Chapter 3Free Cash Flow Valuation

Intro to Free Cash Flows

If applied to dividends, the DCF model is the dividend discount model (DDM) from Chapter 2.

Chapter 3 extends DCF analysis to value a firm and the firm’s equity securities by valuing its free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) and free cash flow to equity (FCFE).

Intro to Free Cash Flows

Dividends are the cash flows actually paid to stockholders

Free cash flows are the cash flows available for distribution.

Applied to dividends, the DCF model is the discounted dividend approach or dividend discount model (DDM). This chapter extends DCF analysis to value a firm and the firm’s equity securities by valuing its free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) and free cash flow to equity (FCFE).

Intro to Free Cash Flows

Analysts like to use free cash flow valuation models (FCFF or FCFE) whenever one or more of the following conditions are present: the firm is not dividend paying, the firm is dividend paying but dividends differ

significantly from the firm’s capacity to pay dividends, free cash flows align with profitability within a

reasonable forecast period with which the analyst is comfortable, or

the investor takes a control perspective.

Intro to Free Cash Flows

Common equity can be valued by either directly using FCFE or indirectly by first computing the value of

the firm using a FCFF model and subtracting the value of non-common stock capital (usually debt and preferred stock) to arrive at the value of equity.

Defining Free Cash Flow

Free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) is the cash flow available to the firm’s suppliers of capital after all operating expenses have been paid and necessary investments in working capital and fixed capital have been made.

FCFF is the cash flow from operations minus capital expenditures. To calculate FCFF, differing equations may be used depending on what accounting information is available. The firm’s suppliers of capital include common stockholders, bondholders, and, sometimes, preferred stockholders.

Defining Free Cash Flow

Free cash flow to equity (FCFE) is the cash flow available to the firm’s common equity holders after all operating expenses, interest and principal payments have been paid, and necessary investments in working and fixed capital have been made.

FCFE is the cash flow from operations minus

capital expenditures minus payments to (and plus receipts from) debtholders.

1

FCFFFirm Value

(1 WACC)t

tt

Valuing FCFF

The FCFF valuation approach estimates the value of the firm as the present value of future FCFF discounted at the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)

Discounting FCFF at the WACC gives the total value of all of the firm’s capital. The value of equity is the value of the firm minus the market value of the firm’s debt

Valuing FCFF

Equity Value = Firm Value – Market Value of Debt

Dividing the total value of equity by the number of outstanding shares gives the value per share.

Calculating a WACC

The cost of capital is the required rate of return that investors should demand for a cash flow stream like that generated by the firm. The cost of capital is often considered the opportunity cost of the suppliers of capital.

Calculating a WACC

If the suppliers of capital are creditors and stockholders, the required rates of return for debt and equity are the after-tax required rates of return for the firm under current market conditions. The weights that are used are the proportions of the total market value of the firm that are from each source, debt and equity.

MV(debt) and MV(equity) are the current market values of debt and equity, not their book or accounting values. The weights will sum to 1.0.

ed requityMVdebtMV

equityMVrateTaxr

equityMVdebtMV

debtMVWACC

)()(

)()1(

)()(

)(

Valuing FCFE

The value of equity can also be found by discounting FCFE at the required rate of return on equity (r):

Since FCFE is the cash flow remaining for equity holders after all other claims have been satisfied, discounting FCFE by r (the required rate of return on equity) gives the value of the firm’s equity.

Dividing the total value of equity by the number of outstanding shares gives the value per share.

1

FCFEEquity Value

(1 )tt

t r

Single-stage constant-growth FCFF valuation model

FCFF in any period is equal to FCFF in the previous period times (1 + g): FCFFt = FCFFt–1 (1 + g).

The value of the firm if FCFF is growing at a constant rate is

Subtracting the market value of debt from the firm value gives the value of equity.

01 FCFF (1 )FCFFFirm Value

WACC WACC

g

g g

Single-stage, constant-growth FCFE valuation model

FCFE in any period will be equal to FCFE in the preceding period times (1 + g): FCFEt = FCFEt–1 (1 + g).

The value of equity if FCFE is growing at a constant rate is

The discount rate is r, the required return on equity. The growth rate of FCFF and the growth rate of FCFE are frequently not equivalent.

01 FCFE (1 )FCFEEquity Value

g

r g r g

Computing FCFF from Net Income

Free cash flow to the firm (FCFF) is the cash flow available to the firm’s suppliers of capital after all operating expenses (including taxes) have been paid and operating investments have been made. The firm’s suppliers of capital include creditors and bondholders and common stockholders (and occasionally preferred stockholders that we will ignore until later). Free cash flow to the firm is:

FCFF = Net income available to common shareholdersPlus: Net Non-Cash ChargesPlus: Interest Expense times (1 – Tax rate)Less: Investment in Fixed CapitalLess: Investment in Working Capital

Computing FCFF from Net Income

This equation can be written more compactly as FCFF = NI + NCC + Int(1 – Tax rate) – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

Computing FCFF from CFO

To estimate FCFF by starting with cash flow from operations (CFO), we must recognize the treatment of interest paid. If, as the case with U.S. GAAP, the after-tax interest was taken out of net income and out of CFO, after-tax interest must be added back in order to get FCFF. So free cash flow to the firm, estimated from CFO, is

FCFF = Cash Flow from OperationsPlus: Interest Expense times (1 – Tax rate)Less: Investment in Fixed Capital

Computing FCFF from CFO

Or you can write the equation as:

FCFF = CFO + Int(1 – Tax rate) – Inv(FC)

Non-cash charges

The best place to find historical non-cash charges is to review the firm’s statement of cash flows.

Some common non-cash charges and the adjustments to net income to get cash flow are:

Non-Cash Item Adjustment to NI to arrive at CF Depreciation Added Back Amortization of intangibles Added Back Restructuring Charges (expense) Added Back Restructuring Charges (income resulting from reversal)

Subtracted

Losses Added Back Gains Subtracted Amortization of long-term bond discounts Added Back Amortization of long-term bond premium Subtracted Deferred taxes Warrants special attention

Non-cash charges

Deferred taxes result from a difference in timing of reporting income and expenses on the company’s tax return. The income tax expense deducted in arriving at net income for financial reporting purposes is not the same as the amount of cash taxes paid. Over time these differences between book and taxable income should offset each other and have no impact on aggregate cash flows. In this case, no adjustment would be necessary for deferred taxes.

Non-cash charges

If the analyst’s purpose is forecasting and he seeks to identify the persistent components of FCFF, then it is not appropriate to add back deferred tax changes that are expected to reverse in the near future. In some circumstances, however, a company may be able to persistently defer taxes until a much later date. If a company is growing and has the ability to indefinitely defer tax liability, an analyst adjustment (add-back) is warranted. An acquirer must be aware, however, that these taxes may be payable at some time in the future.

Finding FCFE from FCFF

Free cash flow to equity is cash flow available to equity holders only. It is therefore necessary to reduce FCFF by interest paid to debtholders and to add any net increase in borrowing (subtract any net decrease in borrowing).

FCFE = Free cash flow to the firmLess: Interest Expense times (1 – Tax rate)Plus: Net Borrowing

OrFCFE = FCFF – Int(1 – Tax rate) + Net borrowing

Finding FCFE from NI or CFO

Subtracting after-tax interest and adding back net borrowing from the FCFF equations gives us the FCFE from NI or CFO:

FCFE = NI + NCC – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

+ Net borrowing

FCFE = CFO – Inv(FC) + Net borrowing

Finding FCFF from EBIT

FCFF and FCFE are most frequently calculated from a starting basis of NI or CFO. Two other starting points are EBIT or EBITDA.

To show the relation between EBIT and FCFF, let us start with the FCFF equation and assume that the non-cash charge (NCC) is depreciation (Dep):FCFF = NI + Dep + Int(1 – Tax rate)

– Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

Finding FCFF from EBIT

Net income (NI) can be expressed as NI = (EBIT – Int)(1 – Tax rate) = EBIT(1 – Tax rate) –

Int(1 – Tax rate)

If this equation for NI is substituted for NI in Equation 3-7, we have

FCFF = EBIT (1 – Tax rate) + Dep – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

To get FCFF from EBIT, multiply EBIT times (1 – Tax rate), add back depreciation, and then subtract the investments in fixed capital and working capital.

Finding FCFF from EBITDA

To show the relation between FCFF from EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization), use the formula for FCFF:FCFF = NI + Dep + Int(1 – Tax rate) – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

Net income can be expressed asNI = (EBITDA – Dep – Int)(1 – Tax rate) NI = EBITDA(1 – Tax rate) – Dep(1 – Tax rate) – Int(1 – Tax rate)

Finding FCFF from EBITDA

Substituting this for NI in the FCFF equation results inFCFF = EBITDA(1 – Tax rate) + Dep(Tax rate) – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

To get FCFF from EBITDA, multiply EBITDA times (1 – Tax rate), add back depreciation times the tax rate, and then subtract the investments in fixed capital and working capital

Forecasting free cash flows

Computing FCFF and FCFE based upon historical accounting data is straightforward. Often times, this data is then used directly in a single-stage DCF valuation model.

On other occasions, the analyst desires to forecast future FCFF or FCFE directly. In this case, the analyst must forecast the individual components of free cash flow. This section extends our previous presentation on computing FCFF and FCFE to the more complex task of forecasting FCFF and FCFE. We present FCFF and FCFE valuation models in the next section.

Forecasting free cash flows

Given that we have a variety of ways in which to derive free cash flow on a historical basis, it should come as no surprise that there are several methods of forecasting free cash flow.

One approach is to compute historical free cash flow and apply some constant growth rate. This approach would be appropriate if free cash flow for the firm tended to grow at a constant rate and if historical relationships between free cash flow and fundamental factors were expected to be maintained.

Forecasting FCFF

One approach recognizes that capital expenditures have two components; those expenditures necessary to maintain existing capacity (fixed capital replacement) and those incremental expenditures necessary for growth. When forecasting, the former are likely to be related to the current level of sales, while the latter are likely to be related to the forecast of sales growth.

Forecasting FCFF

When forecasting FCFE, analysts often simplify the estimation of FCFF and FCFE. Equation 3-7 can be restated as

FCFF = NI + Int (1 – Tax rate)– (Capital spending – Depreciation) – Inv(WC)

which is equivalent to FCFF = EBIT (1 – Tax rate)

– (Capital spending – Depreciation) – Inv(WC) The components of FCFF in these equations are

often forecasted in relation to sales.

Forecasting FCFE

If the firm finances a fixed percentage of its capital spending and investments in working capital with debt, the calculation of FCFE is simplified. Let DR be the debt ratio, debt as a percentage of assets. In this case, FCFE can be written as

FCFE = NI – (1 – DR)(Capital Spending – Depreciation) – (1 – DR)Inv(WC)

When building FCFE valuation models, the logic, that debt financing is used to finance a constant fraction of investments, is very useful. This equation is pretty common.

What about dividends and stock repurchases?

To find FCFF or FCFE, ignore dividends and stock repurchases. Recall two formulas for FCFF and FCFE,

FCFF = NI + NCC + Int(1 – Tax rate) – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC)

FCFE = NI + NCC – Inv(FC) – Inv(WC) + Net borrowingNotice that dividends and other stock transactions are absent from the formulas. The reason is that FCFF and FCFE are the cash flows available to investors or to stockholders, while dividends and share repurchases are uses of these cash flows. Transactions between the firm and its shareholders (through cash dividends, share repurchases and share issuances) do not affect free cash flow.

What about dividends and stock repurchases?

Leverage changes, such as using more debt financing, would have some impact because they would increase the interest tax shelter (reducing corporate taxes because of the tax deductibility of interest) and reduce the cash flow available to equity. In the longer run, however, investing and financing decisions made today will affect future cash flows.

Preferred stock in the capital structure

Including preferred stock as a third source of capital can cause the analyst to add terms to the equations for FCFF and FCFE for the dividends paid on preferred stock and for the issuance or repurchase of preferred shares.

Instead of including those terms in all of the equations, we chose to leave preferred stock out since it exists only for a minority of corporations. For those companies that do have preferred stock, the effects of preferred stock can be incorporated with good judgment. For example, when we are calculating FCFF starting with Net income available to common, Preferred dividends paid would have to be added to the cash flows to obtain FCFF.

Preferred stock in the capital structure

When we are calculating FCFE starting with Net income available to common, if Preferred dividends were already subtracted when arriving at Net income available to common, no further adjustment for Preferred dividends is required. However, issuing (redeeming) preferred stock increases (decreases) the cash flow available to common stockholders, so this term would be added in.

In many respects, the existence of preferred stock in the capital structure has many of the same effects as the existence of debt, except that preferred stock dividends paid are not tax deductible unlike interest payments on debt.

Two-stage FCF models

FCF models are much more complex than DDMs because the analyst usually estimates sales, profitability, investments, financing costs, and new financing to find FCFF or FCFE.

In two-stage FCF models, the growth rate in the second stage is a long-run sustainable growth rate. For a declining industry, the second stage growth rate could be slightly below the GDP growth rate. For an industry that will grow in the future (relative to the overall economy), the second stage growth rate could still be slightly greater than the GDP growth rate.

Two-stage FCF models

The two most popular versions of the two-stage FCFF and FCFE models are: the growth rate is constant (or given) in stage one,

and then it drops to the long-run sustainable rate in stage two.

the growth rates are declining in stage one, reaching the sustainable rate at the beginning of stage two. This latter model is like the H model for dividend valuation.

Two-stage FCF models

The growth rates can be applied to different variables. The growth rate could be the growth rate for FCFF or FCFE, or the growth rate for income (such as net income), or the growth rate could be the growth rate for sales. If the growth rate were for net income, the changes in FCFF or FCFE would also depend on investments in operating assets and financing of these investments. When the growth rate in income declines, such as between stage one and stage two, investments in operating assets will probably decline at the same time. If the growth rate is for sales, changes in net profit margins as well as investments in operating assets and financing policies will determine FCFF and FCFE.

Two-stage FCF models

A general expression for the two-stage FCFF valuation model is

The summation gives the present value of the first n years’ FCFF. The terminal value of the FCFF from year n+1 onward is FCFFn+1 / (WACC – g), which is discounted at the WACC for n periods. Subtracting the value of outstanding debt gives the value of equity. The value per share is then found by dividing the total value of equity by the number of outstanding shares.

1

1

FCFF FCFF 1Firm Value= +

(WACC- )(1+WACC) (1+WACC)

nt n

t nt g

Two-stage FCF models

The general expression for the two-stage FCFE valuation model is

The summation is the present value of the first n years’ FCFE, and the terminal value of FCFEn+1 / (r – g) is discounted at the required rate of return on equity for n years. The value per share is found by dividing the total value of equity by the number of outstanding shares.

1

1

FCFE FCFE 1Equity

(1 ) (1 )

nt nt n

t r gr r

Nonoperating assets and firm value

Analysts usually segregate operating and non-operating assets when they value a firm.

Many non-operating assets are financial assets that can be directly valued by observing their market prices. It is unnecessary to use a valuation model when the market value can be observed reliably.

Non-operating assets that are not contributing operating income to the firm could be sold. The liquidation value of these non-performing assets could then be added to the value of the performing assets.

Nonoperating assets and firm value

Finally, if non-operating assets are not segregated, the cash flows from these assets could be combined with the cash flows of the operating assets, often making it difficult to find the cash flows of the operating assets. For example, interest and dividend income and capital gains from an investment portfolio could mask the fact that the company’s operating profitability is poor. The value of the firm should be the value of its operating and non-operating assets: Value of firm = Value of operating assets

+ Value of non-operating assets.

Nonoperating assets and firm value

When calculating FCFF or FCFE, investments in working capital do not include any investments in cash and marketable securities. The value of cash and marketable securities should be added to the value of the firm’s operating assets to find the total firm value.

Some companies have substantial non-current investments in stocks and bonds that are not operating subsidiaries but financial investments. These should be reflected at their current market value. Based on accounting conventions, those securities reported at book values should be revalued to market values.

Nonoperating assets and firm value

Finally, many corporations have overfunded or underfunded pension plans. The excess pension fund assets should be added to the value of the firm’s operating assets. Likewise, an underfunded pension plan should result in an appropriate subtraction from the value of operating assets.

Nonoperating assets example

Virginia Mak is estimating the value of Charleson Partners, a non-publicly traded Canadian food wholesaler. Mak has assembled the following information for her appraisal.

The firm’s operating assets generated a FCFF of CD35 million in the year just ended. A perpetual growth rate of 5% is expected for FCFF.

The weighted average cost of capital is 11%. Charleson Partners has non-operating assets of

CD12 million of cash and short-term marketable securities CD105 million in a diversified portfolio of common stocks and

bonds Pension fund assets of CD75 million and pension fund liabilities

of CD58 million. Charleson has total debts (notes and bonds payable) with an

estimated market value of CD 108 million. There are 8,250,000 outstanding shares.

Nonoperating assets example

The value of the operating assets (in million CD) is

The value of the non-operating assets is:Cash and short-term investments CD 12 millionStock and bond portfolio CD 105 millionPension fund surplus (75 – 58) CD 17 millionTotal non-operating assets: CD 134 million

The total value of the firm is Value of operating assets + Value of non-operating assets = 385 + 134 = CD 519 million.

The value of equity is the total value of the firm less the market value of its debt obligations, or 519 – 108 = CD 411 million.

Finally, the value per share is CD 411 million / 8,250,000 shares = CD 49.82.

0FCFF (1 ) 22(1.05) 23.1Value(Operating) CD 385

WACC 0.11 0.05 0.06

g

g

Cash & Equivalents / Market value

Cash and Equivalents

December 2001

Stock

Cash and Equivalents ($ millions)

Total Market Value of Equity ($ millions)

Cash and Equivalents as a Percentage of Market Value

Royal PTT Nederland NV (NYSE: KPN) 3,374 4,462 75.6% Fiat S.p.A. (NYSE: FIA) 2,157 5,077 42.5% Solectron Corp. (NYSE: SLR) 2,553 7,314 29.5% Wal-Mart Stores (NYSE: WMT) 2,033 263,637 0.7% Intel Corp. (Nasdaq NMS: INTC) 10,326 217,819 4.7% Nokia Corp. (NYSE: NOK) 1,327 103,415 1.3%

Proust Company (#5)

Proust Company has free cash flow to the firm of $1.7 billion and free cash flow to equity of $1.3 billion. Proust’s weighted average cost of capital is 11 percent and its required rate of return for equity is 13 percent. FCFF is expected to grow forever at 7 percent and FCFE is expected to grow forever at 7.5 percent. Proust has debt outstanding of $15 billion.

A. What is the total value of Proust’s equity using the FCFF valuation approach?

B. What is the total value of Proust’s equity using the FCFE valuation approach?

Proust Company solution

A. The Firm Value is the present value of FCFF discounted at the weighted average cost of capital (WACC), or

The market value of equity is the value of the firm minus the value of debt:

Equity = 45.475 – 15 = $30.475 billion.B. Using the FCFE valuation approach, the present value of

FCFE, discounted at the required rate of return on equity, is

The value of equity using this approach is $25.409 billion.

475.4504.0

819.1

07.011.0

)07.1(7.1)1(01

gWACC

gFCFF

gWACC

FCFFFirm

409.25055.0

3975.1

075.013.0

)075.1(3.1)1(01

gr

gFCFE

gr

FCFEPV

Taiwan Semiconductor (#6)

In 2001, Quinton Johnston is evaluating Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd, (NYSE: TSM) headquartered in Hsinchu, ROC, Taiwan. In 2001, the company is unprofitable. Furthermore, TSM pays no dividends on common shares. So, Johnston is going to value TSM using his forecasts of free cash flow to equity. Johnston is going to use the following assumptions.

17.0 billion outstanding shares Sales will be $5.5 billion in 2002, increasing at 28 percent annually for the next four years (through

2006). Net income will be 32 percent of sales Investments in fixed assets will be 35 percent of sales, investments in working capital will be 6 percent

of sales, and depreciation will be 9 percent of sales. 20 percent of the investment in assets will be financed with debt. Interest expenses will be only 2 percent of sales. The tax rate will be 10 percent. TSM’s beta is 2.1, the risk-free government bond rate is 6.4 percent, and the market risk premium is

5.0 percent. At the end of 2006, TSM will sell for 18 times earnings.

What is the value of one ordinary share of Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd?

Taiwan Semiconductor solution

The required rate of return found with the CAPM is:

r = E(Ri) = RF + bi[E(RM) – RF] = 6.4% + 2.1 (5.0%) = 16.9%.

The table below shows the values of Sales, Net income, Capital expenditures less Depreciation, and Investments in working capital. The free cash flow to equity is equal to net income less the investments financed with equity, which is:

FCFE = Net income – (1 – DR)(Capital expenditures – Depreciation)– (1 – DR)(Investment in working capital)

Since 20 percent of new investments are financed with debt, 80 percent of the investments are financed with equity, reducing FCFE by 80 percent of (Capital expenditures – Depreciation) and 80 percent of the investment in working capital.

Taiwan Semiconductor solution

All data in $ billions 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 Sales (growing at 28%) 5.500 7.040 9.011 11.534 14.764 Net Income = 32% of sales 1.760 2.253 2.884 3.691 4.724 Capex – Dep = (35% – 9%) × Sales 1.430 1.830 2.343 2.999 3.839 Inv(WC) = (6% of Sales) 0.330 0.422 0.541 0.692 0.886 0.80 × [Capex – Dep + Inv(WC)] 1.408 1.802 2.307 2.953 3.780 FCFE = NI–0.80×[Capex–Dep+Inv(WC)] 0.352 0.451 0.577 0.738 0.945 PV of FCFE discounted at 16.9% 0.301 0.330 0.361 0.395 0.433 Terminal stock value 85.040 PV of Terminal value discounted at 16.9% 38.954 Total PV of first five years’ FCFE 1.820 Total value of firm 40.774

Taiwan Semiconductor solution

The terminal stock value is 18.0 times the earnings in year 2006, or 18 × 4.724 = $85.04 billion.

The present value of the terminal value ($38.95 billion) plus the present value of the first five years’ FCFE ($1.82 billion) is $40.77 billion.

Since there are 17 billion outstanding shares, the value per share is $2.398.

BHP Billiton Ltd. (#9)

Watson Dunn is planning to value BHP Billiton Ltd. using a single-stage free cash flow to the firm approach. BHP Billiton, headquartered in Melbourne Australia, is a provider of a variety of industrial metals and minerals. The financial information Dunn has assembled for his valuation is:

1,852 million shares outstanding market value of debt is $3.192 billion free cash flow to the firm is currently $1.559 billion equity beta is 0.90, the market risk premium is 5.5 percent, and

the risk-free discount rate is 5.5 percent before-tax cost of debt is 7.0 percent tax rate is 40 percent for purposes of calculating the WACC, assume the firm is

financed 25 percent debt FCFF growth rate is 4 percent

BHP Billiton Ltd.

Using Dunn’s information, calculate:

A.The weighted average cost of capital

B.Value of the firm

C. Total market value of equity

D. Value per share

BHP Billiton Ltd. solution

A. The required return on equity is

r = E(Ri) = RF + bi[E(RM) – RF] = 5.5% + 0.90(5.5%) = 10.45%

The weighted average cost of capital isWACC = 0.25(7.0%)(1 – 0.40) + 0.75(10.45%) = 8.89%

B. Firm Value = FCFF0(1 +g) / (WACC – g)Firm Value = 1.1559(1.04) / (0.0889 – 0.04) = $24.583 billion

C. Equity Value = Firm Value – Market Value of DebtEquity Value = 24.583 – 3.192 = $21.391 billion

D. Value per share = Equity Value / Number of SharesValue per share = 21.391 / 1.852 = $11.55.

Alcan, Inc (#11)

An aggressive financial planner who claims to have a superior method for picking undervalued stocks is courting one of your clients. The planner claims that the best way to find the value of a stock is to divide EBITDA by the risk-free bond rate. The planner is urging your client to invest in Alcan, Inc. (NYSE: AL). Alcan is the parent of a group of companies engaged in all aspects of the aluminum business. The planner says that Alcan’s EBITDA of $1,580 million divided by the long-term government bond rate of 7 percent gives a total value of $22,571 million. Since there are 318 million outstanding shares, this gives a value per share of $70.98. Shares of Alcan, Inc. are currently trading for $36.50, and the planner wants your client to make a large investment in Alcan through him.

Alcan, Inc. (#11)

A. Provide your client with an alternative valuation of Alcan based on a two-stage FCFE valuation approach. Use the following assumptions:

Net income is currently $600 million. Net income will grow by 20 percent annually for the next three years.

The net investment in operating assets (capital expenditures less depreciation plus investment in working capital) will be $1,150 million next year and grow at 15 percent for the following two years.

Forty percent of the net investment in operating assets will be financed with net new debt financing.

Alcan’s beta is 1.3, the risk-free bond rate is 7 percent, and the market risk premium is 4 percent. After three years, the growth rate of net income will be 8 percent and the net investment in

operating assets (Capital expenditures minus Depreciation plus Increase in working capital) each year will drop to 30 percent of net income. Debt financing will continue to fund 40 percent of the net investment in operating assets.

There are 318 million outstanding shares.Find the value per share of Alcan.B. Criticize the valuation approach that the aggressive financial planner used.

Alcan, Inc. solution

A. Using the CAPM, the required rate of return for Alcan is: r = E(Ri) = RF + bi[E(RM) – RF] = 7% + 1.3(4%) = 12.2%.

To estimate FCFE, use the relationFCFE = Net income – (1 – DR)(Capex – Depreciation)

– (1 – DR)(Invest in WC)

The table below shows net income, which grows at 20 percent annually for years 1, 2, and 3, and then at 8 percent for year 4. Investments (Capex – Depreciation + Investment in WC) are 1,150 in year 1 and grow at 15 percent annually for years 2 and 3. Debt financing is 40 percent of this investment. FCFE is NI – investments + financing. Finally, the present value of FCFE for years 1, 2, and 3 is found by discounting at 12.2 percent.

Alcan, Inc. solution

The value of FCFE after year 3 is found using the constant growth model:

The present value of P3 discounted at 12.2 percent is $15,477.64 million. The total value of equity, the present value of the first three years’ FCFE plus the present value of P3, is $15,648.36 million. Dividing by the number of outstanding shares (318 million) gives a price per share of $49.21. For the first three years, Alcan has a small FCFE because of the high investments it is making during the high growth phase.

Year 1 2 3 4 Net income 720.00 864.00 1,036.80 1,119.74 Investment in operating assets 1,150.00 1,322.50 1,520.88 335.92 New debt financing 460.00 529.00 608.35 134.37 Free cash flow to equity 30.00 70.50 124.28 918.19 PV of FCFE discounted at 12.2% 26.74 56.00 87.98

21,861.67$08.0122.0

19.91843

gr

FCFEP

Alcan, Inc. solution

The planner’s estimate of the share value of $70.98 is much higher than the FCFE model estimate of $49.21. There are several reasons for the differing estimates.

First, taxes and interest expenses, which were $254 and $78 million, have a prior claim to the company’s cash flow and should be taken out. These cash flows are not available to equity holders.

Second, EBITDA does not account for the company’s reinvestments in operating assets. By distributing depreciation charges (which were $561 million), the planner is essentially liquidating the firm over time, much less accounting for the net investments that the firm is making over time.

Alcan, Inc. solution

Third, EBITDA does not account for the firm’s capital structure. Using EBITDA to represent a benefit to stockholders (as opposed to stockholders and bondholders combined) is a mistake. Finally, dividing EBITDA by the bond rate commits major errors, as well. The risk-free bond rate is an inappropriate discount rate for risky equity cash flows. The required rate of return on the firm’s equity should be used. Dividing by a fixed rate also assumes erroneously that the cash flow stream is a fixed perpetuity. EBITDA cannot be a perpetual stream because, if it were distributed, the stream would eventually decline to zero (because of no capital investments). Alcan is actually a growing company, so assuming it to be a non-growing perpetuity is a mistake.

Bron (#12)

Bron has earnings per share of $3.00 in 2002 and expects earnings per share to increase by 21 percent in 2003. Earnings per share are going to grow at a decreasing rate for the following five years, as shown in the table below. In 2008, the growth rate will be 6 percent and is expected to stay at that rate thereafter. Net capital expenditures (Capital expenditures minus depreciation) will be $5.00 per share in 2002, and then follow the pattern predicted in the table. In 2008, net capital expenditures are expected to be $1.50, and then to grow at 6 percent annually after that. The investment in working capital parallels the increase in net capital expenditures and is predicted to equal 25 percent of net capital expenditures each year. In 2008, investment in working capital will be $0.375 and is predicted to grow at 6 percent thereafter. Bron will use debt financing to fund 40 percent of net capital expenditures and 40 percent of the investment in working capital.Year 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008Growth rate eps 21% 18% 15% 12% 9% 6%Net capex per share5.00 5.00 4.50 4.00 3.50 1.50

The required rate of return for Bron is 12 percent. Find the value per share using a two-stage FCFE valuation approach.

Bron solution

FCFE is shown in this table:

Year 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Growth rate for earnings per share 21% 18% 15% 12% 9% 6% Earnings per share 3.630 4.283 4.926 5.517 6.014 6.374 Capital expenditure per share 5.000 5.000 4.500 4.000 3.500 1.500 Investment in WC per share 1.250 1.250 1.125 1.000 0.875 0.375 New debt financing = 40% of [Capex + Inv(WC)] 2.500 2.500 2.250 2.000 1.750 0.750 FCFE = NI – Capex – Inv(WC) + New debt financing –0.120 0.533 1.551 2.517 3.389 5.249 PV of FCFE discounted at 12% –0.107 0.425 1.104 1.600 1.923

Bron solution

The present values of FCFE from 2003 through 2007 are given in the bottom row of the table. The sum of these five present values is $4.944. Since the FCFE from 2008 onward will be growing at a constant 6 percent, the constant growth model can be used to value these cash flows.

The present value of this stream is $87.483 / (1.12)5 = $49.640. The value per share is the value of the first five FCFE (2003 through

2007) plus the present value of the FCFE after 2007, or $4.944 + $49.640 = $54.58.

483.87$06.012.0

249.520082007

gr

FCFEP