case study using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/disasters/cs-vca...3 introduction this...

20
Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool in Rwanda Case study

Upload: others

Post on 02-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Using the vulnerability andcapacity assessmenttool in Rwanda

Cas

e stu

dy

Page 2: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

2003International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent SocietiesPO Box 372CH-1211 Geneva 19SwitzerlandTelephone: +41 22 730 4222Telefax: +41 22 733 0395Telex: 412 133 FRC CHE-mail: [email protected] site: www.ifrc.org

© International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies

Any part of this report may be cited, copied, translated into other languages or adapted to meet local needs without prior permission from theInternational Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, provided that the source is clearly stated.

The maps used do not imply the expression of any opinion on the part of the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies orNational Societies concerning the legal status of a territory or of its authorities.

AcknowledgementsThe International Federation is gratefulto the staff and volunteers of theRwandan Red Cross and to the com-munity residents for openly sharingtheir reflections and experiences.

Page 3: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Contents

Introduction _______________________________________________________________ 3Overview of the Rwandan context _____________________________________________ 3

1. VCA - initial arrangements _________________________________________ 4Learning from neighbouring countries _________________________________________ 4Defining priorities and orientation _____________________________________________ 4

2. The national VCA ____________________________________________________ 4A questionnaire is prepared and used _________________________________________ 4The questionnaire method - lessons learned _____________________________________ 5Disaster response____________________________________________________________ 5

3. The local VCA ________________________________________________________ 5Objectives of the local VCA __________________________________________________ 6On-site cooperation _________________________________________________________ 6Choice of sectors____________________________________________________________ 6The method ________________________________________________________________ 7Groupwork ________________________________________________________________ 7The elderly ________________________________________________________________ 7The women _______________________________________________________________ 7Young people ______________________________________________________________ 8The results__________________________________________________________________ 9

Conclusion ________________________________________________________________ 10Understanding of the VCA ___________________________________________________ 10The VCA and the long-term approach _________________________________________ 10Sharing knowledge__________________________________________________________ 10Adapting to the local socio-cultural context _____________________________________ 10Developing partnerships______________________________________________________ 10Planning and the reduction of risks of vulnerability ______________________________ 11

Annex 1____________________________________________________________________ 12Rwandan Red Cross – Action plan from November 2001 to June 2002

Annex 2____________________________________________________________________ 16Example of the national VCA questionnaire

1

Page 4: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies2

Mpigi

Masakakaak

Rakaiii

KaseseKaseseK

MbararaBBushenyhenyi

Kampalaa

I

LakeLake

UUMMM

BBBAA

U G A N D AU G A N D AU GG

0 km 10050 150 200 km

Page 5: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

3

IntroductionThis case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability andcapacity assessment (VCA) tool. Devised in the 1990’s by the Federation and included in Strategy2010, the VCA is a participative means of obtaining an overview of the risks and capacities existingin a country at the national and local levels.

The aim of this study is to describe the approach adopted by the Rwandan Red Cross and to sharethe lessons it learned from that experience with other National Societies.

The contextRwanda, which has 8.1 million inhabitants and apopulation density of 305 inhabitants per squarekilometre, is one of Africa’s most populous countries.Most households consist of small farms that consumemuch of what they grow.

Many problems within Rwandan society, particularlythose associated with health, food insecurity andhumanitarian values, are inherently linked withpoverty. Moreover, the genocide has had a deeppsychological impact on the Rwandan people.

As in most developing countries, many of thediseases that are commonplace in Rwanda, such asAIDS, malaria, acute respiratory infections,diarrhoea, malnutrition, tuberculosis and vaccine-preventable illnesses, have preventable causes.

Generally speaking, information, education,communication, basic health care for the sick, thesupply of drinking water and sanitation play asignificant role in the prevention and managementof most of the illnesses occurring in the country.When disease strikes, it spreads rapidly unless swiftaction is taken.

Page 6: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

1. VCA - the initial arrangements

For two years, the National Society worked with a Federation delegate to draw up a disasterpreparedness and response plan. This programme, which can be consulted on the Federation’sInternet site (www.ifrc.org), comprises over 20 points relating to institutional capacity that theNational Society must take into account and adapt to the situation in the country. One of thosepoints is the implementation of the VCA programme.

The Rwandan Red Cross decided to launch the VCA process following the 1999 famine, which wasparticularly severe in Bugesera and Umutara provinces. The aim was to identify those parts of thecountry most vulnerable to disaster and on that basis to design projects to mitigate the effects ofdisasters in cooperation with the local communities and authorities.

Rwanda was able to undertake several disaster preparedness activities, including the VCA, thanks tothe financial support provided by the United Kingdom’s Department for InternationalDevelopment (DFID) to National Societies in the region (Rwanda, Ethiopia and Sudan).

Learning from neighbouring countriesTo start with, the Rwandan Red Cross sent five officials to Uganda for one week. The Ugandan RedCross had been using the VCA tool for several years and was able to to share its experience with itsneighbours. During their visit, the Rwandan Red Cross officials obtained information on VCA tech-niques and approaches. The administrator of the Ugandan Red Cross, who had been recently trans-ferred to Nairobi, provided technical support in terms of the VCA process.

Defining priorities and orientationsThe Rwandan Red Cross then organized a workshop for all the disaster-preparedness officers of theNational Societies of Rwanda, Ethiopia and Sudan and the regional office in Nairobi. The participantsdiscussed the obstacles encountered in implementing the programme, chiefly the deadlines imposed.The three National Societies therefore decided to review the programme planning together and tofocus on key activities in the following 15 months.

The workshop was also attended by representatives of the Ministry of Health, Social Affairs, andLand-Use Planning, the cooperation delegate of the International Committee of the Red Cross(ICRC), the DFID technical coordinator in Geneva and the British Red Cross technical adviser.

2. The national VCA A questionnaire is prepared and usedFollowing the workshop, a working group drew up a questionnaire covering health, climate risksand local infrastructure (number of schools, number of hospitals and health facilities, receptionfacilities, sources of water). The questionnaire (see annex) was then translated from French intoKinyarwanda.

In order to facilitate the distribution of the questionnaire nationwide, the Rwandan Red Cross hadto provide its district volunteers with training. The training process was headed by the regionalofficer in Nairobi who, as a staff member seconded by the Ugandan Red Cross, was familiar withthe VCA method.

At the same time, the disaster preparedness coordinator and the head of the relief service from theRwandan Red Cross travelled throughout the country, training three members in each provincialcommittee and one member in each district committee.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies4

Page 7: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Each committee had to be familiar with the VCA and the questionnaire method, especially when itcame to data collection.

In all, 62 of Rwanda’s 92 districts were involved in collecting information nationwide.

The questionnaire method - the lessons learnedThe study of the data collected through the questionnaire was rapidly put to good use when thevolcano erupted in Goma. Both the National Society and the government were able to easilyidentify pockets of vulnerability and to plan a response on the basis of the data collected. Thequestionnaire was also sent to the international and local organizations working in the country,thereby fostering enhanced cooperation between all stakeholders.

However, an analysis of the shortcomings of the questionnaire method in the conduct of a VCAbrings to light the following points:

1. Only 56 per cent of the 62 districts surveyed replied. There may be several reasons for this rela-tively low response rate:- lack of time, the volunteers concerned having to work in the fields;- the remoteness of certain places;- lack of means (for example, of transportation).

2. The method used to compile and sort the data transmitted to headquarters was not effectivefor the purposes of the analysis. For example, it would have been very useful to train person-nel in the use of computer spreadsheets.

3. Food insecurity is one of the country’s biggest problems, a point that was obviously highligh-ted in the questionnaire and that perhaps automatically steered the action of the Rwandan RedCross away from other serious potential risks (such as epidemics and weather phenomena).

4. While assessment by means of a questionnaire is only one part of conducting a VCA, it never-theless requires a substantial investment in terms of time and human resources.

Disaster responseWhile the Rwandan Red Cross was conducting the VCA, it had to launch several disaster reliefoperations, specifically in October and November 2001 when the Gisenyi region was hit by torrentialrainfall and landslides, and on 17 January 2002 when a volcano erupted, destroying part of the townof Goma. In the latter case, the Rwandan Red Cross was obliged to mobilize all of its availableresources to come to the aid of the inhabitants of Goma and the neighbouring town of Gisenyi.

These operations seriously disrupted the schedule initially established for the risk-reductionprogramme, resulting in a number of delays.

3. The local VCA Following the national VCA, the decision was made to conduct a more detailed VCA in one ofRwanda’s most vulnerable districts and to give the National Society the possibility of cooperatingwith the local communities, not only in identifying the principal risks but also in drawing upappropriate mitigation projects.

The district of Karaba was chosen on the basis of several criteria:■ dynamic regional and local committees;■ backing from the local authorities;■ recurring problems of food insecurity;■ presence and support of other non-governmental organsations (NGOs);■ backing of the community.

Rwanda: Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool 5

Page 8: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Objectives of the local VCA■ To detect the problems faced by the local people in their everyday lives.■ To classify those problems by order of priority, so as to determine which are the causes of food

insecurity.■ To propose sustainable solutions to the community.■ To make an effective contribution to the establishment of a district development plan.

On-site cooperationIn cooperation with the mayor of Karaba district, 26 provincial committee volunteers who would act asfacilitators in meetings with the communities took part in a six-day course of training covering thefollowing main points:

■ introduction to disaster management at community level;■ introduction to the VCA;■ progression of vulnerability;■ risk evaluation;■ capacity evaluation;■ techniques and tools for conducting a VCA;■ introduction to the participative method;■ tools of the participative method.

The VCA project coordinator travelledwidely throughout the district in order toenhance his understanding of the distancesthe volunteers would have to cover, toidentify the best places for meetings, and tofamiliarize himself with the environment andthe provincial committee. The Rwandan RedCross headquarters regularly informed theDirector General for Land-Use Planning, theEnvironment and Habitat, who is in chargeof the Prime Minister’s Disaster ManagementOffice, of the progress being made in theVCA process.

Choice of sectorsThe Rwandan Red Cross limited the local VCA to 13 out of 26 sectors, or half of Karaba district.

The sectors were chosen so as to be representative of the entire district from the geographical,economic and social points of view. The availability of the people to be interviewed was also takeninto account.

For the purposes of the VCA, interviews were conducted with a sample of 60 people per sector whowere called the “working group” and were representative of the groups in the community namely:

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies6

The local population is regularly beingasked questions by organizations wantingto set up programmes. The problem is thatthese surveys rarely produce concreteresults or benefits, and as a result, somelocal people no longer want toparticipate.

Page 9: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

■ 20 members of the basic structural organization, including 10 women;■ 10 members of the basic organizational structure among young people;■ 30 resource people: educated people, the elderly, community representatives.

The survey lasted two weeks. The participants spent one or several days each in total, depending ontheir availability.

The method

In order to collect all the information required, the topics of discussion were shared out as follows:■ the elderly worked on the sector’s history, with special emphasis on problems relating to food

security;■ the women’s representatives focussed on the seasonal calendar and the daily routine;■ the young people produced a map of the sector showing community development achievements.

Groupwork

The elderlyThe key to the community’s collective past is held by the elderly, who can pass on their experiencesand specifically explain what they did during periods of food shortage.

The following questions were asked:■ What years stand out in the district’s history (drought, famine)?■ How did the communities organize themselves during those years (sharing of food, use of food

stocks)?■ Were some sectors more seriously affected than others? Why?

Three examples are illustrative of the data collected:■ In the past, when times were hard young people married earlier than usual in order to have a

plot of land they could farm and to be able to eat one meal a day, which they could not do ifthey stayed with their parents.

■ A district cleric took steps to buy, at a fixed price, the farmers’ surplus production in times ofplenty. If the following harvest was also good, he sold his stocks to merchants. If, however, lackof rain gave rise to famine, he sold all or part of their harvest back to the farmers at the sameprice, thus easing the effects of the famine. He also explained the need to save with a view tohaving something put aside when times were hard.

■ Prior to the ethnic conflicts of 1959 to 1994, the large numbers of livestock meant that thesoil was easily fertilised, making it less acidic. Those herds had been decimated by various eth-nic conflicts and the environment had suffered as a result.

From this groupwork, the Rwandan Red Cross obtained an understanding not only of how faminehad affected the district but also of people’s coping mechanisms (for example, eating seed or sellingthe tiles from the roof of their house).

It is important to note that many of the people interviewed underscored the shortage of livestock asa major source of concern.

The womenWomen are a true pillar of Rwandan society. They are the ones who usually tend the fields and takecare of the crops and the family’s children. In addition, the genocide made many women householdheads. Some of them are widows, others have their husbands in jail. Women therefore know a greatdeal about their land and the daily difficulties and obstacles that they face.

Rwanda: Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool 7

Page 10: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

The group of women started by drawing up a seasonal calendar of work, in order to share theircollective experience. It was thus possible to determine, in the light of the rainy seasons that markthe crop cycle in Rwanda, during which period women sowed their seeds, what they sowed and why.

To do this, the women drew a large circle on the ground and divided it into 12 months. They placeddifferent vegetables and cereals in the calendar, depending on when they were sown. It became clearthat certain species were not at all cultivated in the region.

The discussion focused on the legumes, roots and cereals that the women’s group had placed on thecalendar and what were the best crops to grow.

For example, several sources had said that the district had the perfect soil for growing coffee and thatmillions of coffee plants had once grown there. This is no longer the case.

The discussion with the women’s group revealed that production had slowed after several dry seasonsand, above all, that without washing stations the coffee beans could not be properly treated and soldat the current market price. And yet, the income generated from coffee production was far higherthan that obtained from growing vegetables, for example.

Young peopleThe elderly and the women worked on the vulnerabilities. With the young people, the RwandanRed Cross broached the issue of capacities.

Capacity is used here to refer to the achievements and existinginfrastructure in the district, in terms of communitydevelopment.

First, the group of young people and the volunteers dividedbetween them the 13 sectors taking part in the local VCA.

Then, for two weeks, usually on foot, the young people travelledthroughout the sectors to meet with the locals and draw up adetailed map of the local infrastructure. They noted in particular:■ the number of bridges and what state they were in;■ the number of hospitals, schools and health facilities and their

capacities;■ the number of standpipes, their quality and capacities;■ the community programmes carried out and their effects.

This information was recorded on a map of the region and usedrapidly to assess the capacities of each sector. It was thenforwarded to the working group at headquarters for more in-depth analysis. The latter’s conclusions will be used to draw upprogrammes adapted to the communities in the Karaba region.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies8

“We had never thought in this way about how we live and grow food, wehad never taken the time to visit our neighbours, even if they didn’t livenearby, to ask them. When, why and how do you do that? We grow thisvariety rather than that one because…”.

Page 11: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

VCA resultsOnce the data had been compiled, Rwandan Red Cross section coordinators and local authoritieslisted the problems encountered in the sectors selected by order of priority. That order of prioritieswas then taken to be representative of the entire district.

The results of the analysis and the definition of priorities show that the five main causes of foodinsecurity in the district are:

1. low numbers of livestock;2. the absence of income and jobs outside the agricultural sector;3. very poor knowledge about how to start income-generating projects;4. undeveloped marshland (75% unused);5. disease (malaria, AIDS, worm infections).

Using data provided by World Vision and SNV (the Foundation of Netherlands Volunteers), theRwandan Red Cross supplemented its analysis and drew up tables of production and livestock inKaraba district.

Rwanda: Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool 9

Agricultural productionPlant Number of tonnes

per hectareBanana 2.3Cocoyams 4.0Beans 0.9Maize 1.0Manioc 9.0Sweet potatoes 8.0Peas 0.7Potatoes 12.0Soya 0.8Sorghum 1.2

LivestockSpecies Number

Cattle 12,223Goats 12,608Pigs 5,849Poultry 12,932Rabbits 6,710Sheep 5,696

Page 12: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Conclusion Proper understanding of the VCA Before launching the VCA exercise, the objectives have to be clearly defined so that the participantsare not forced to learn by trial and error and can identify the strengths and weaknesses of theexercise, the opportunities it affords and the resources that have to be mobilized to conduct it.

The Rwandan Red Cross had reflected on the following points:■ risk-assessment programmes carried out by the government and other partners (NGO’s,

associations etc.);■ its capacity to conduct the VCA exercise;■ the internal and external VCA competences available;■ the means available to follow up the VCA results.

The VCA and the long-term approachThe VCA is a reliable, sustainable development-oriented approach for any National Society wishingto undertake long-term activities. It is a very useful tool for identifying a region’s risks, needs andcapacity for proper planning.

Sharing knowledgeThe Rwandan Red Cross has genuinely learned from others:

■ the exchange of experiences during the visit by Rwandan Red Cross officials to Uganda gavethe Society the impetus to conduct the VCA exercise;

■ partnerships with those on the spot, in particular World Food Programme (WFP), WorldVision and SNV, and the support of the Nairobi delegation fostered the exchange of infor-mation and experience;

■ headquarters officials, the volunteers in all the country’s provinces and the authorities ofKaraba district, all took part in VCA training.

Adapting to the local socio-cultural context It is essential to involve the community in which the VCA is being conducted. Volunteers from thecommunities were a key factor in encouraging the local population take part in the VCA process.

Developing partnershipsBefore embarking on the VCA exercise, local partners have to be targeted in accordance withanticipated needs. The Rwandan Red Cross contacted the local organizations that had an experienceof the participatory rural appraisal (PRA) method.

The WFP, for its part, has acquired substantial experience of assessment by means of its vulnerabilitymapping approach.

The support of local political and administrative structures played a key role in mobilizing thecommunities as well as material and human support.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies10

Page 13: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Planning and reduction of risks of vulnerabilityThe VCA helps to identify not just needs but also solutions.

Through this approach, all the stakeholders in one community seek solutions to the problemsposed, then analyse the possibilities for mobilizing internal and external resources.

One of the biggest challenges when conducting a VCA is to go beyond a mere study and tocommunicate the information to the communities, the authorities and the National Societyvolunteers. All those involved want to know what will be done once the assessment is concluded,and the people expect concrete help.

The Rwandan Red Cross and Karaba district must now unite their efforts to find the financialmeans to respond to the priority needs identified by the communities in Karaba.

Rwanda: Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool 11

Page 14: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Annex 1

Rwandan Red CrossAction plan, November 2001 - June 2002

Objective: to strengthen the Rwandan Red Cross (RRC) disaster preparedness, response andmitigation capacities.

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies12

Activities

Conduct 12 seminars with12 provincial committeesand partners to discuss theNational Society draft DPpolicy/plan (180 peopletargeted).

Conduct a nationalworkshop for the 38people in charge ofexamining the revisedNational Society DPpolicy.

Submit the NationalSociety draft DP policy tothe Board for approval.

Organize a workshop withthe government of Rwandaand the stakeholders tofurther the process for anational governmental DPpolicy.

Examine the data collectedand the follow-up activitiesconducted by otherorganizations to avoidoverlap.

In each of the threeprovinces (prefectures)designate two provincialfocal points for disaster-preparedness activities.

Indicators

Report on the 12provincial meetings.

Feedback on the draftDP policy.

The national workshopreport andrecommendations areincorporated into thedraft policy.

National Society DPpolicy/plan approved.

Report of theworkshop.

Report available inNovember 2001.

The list of focal pointsis available; contactshave been made.

Outcome

The members,personnel andvolunteers helpformulate the policyand thereby have asense of ownership.

The final NationalSociety draft DPpolicy is submittedto the Board forapproval.

A National SocietyDP policy/plan.

The RRC Board ofDirectors negotiatesa formal agreementwith the governmentdefining the role ofthe Rwandan RedCross in thenational disaster–mitigation policyand framework.

Information is avail-able on the activi-ties of other institu-tions.

Six provincial focalpoints have beenappointed.

Timeframe

November -December2001

December2001

First quarter2002

First quarter2002

Mid-November

November

Financialsupport

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

Objective

1. To draw up a disaster-preparedness (DP)plan/policy and to help formulate a nationalgovernment disastermanagementpolicy/framework.

2. To promote foodsecurity in the three“high-risk”provinces byestablishing acommunity-basedearly warningsystem.

Page 15: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Rwanda: Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool 13

Activities

Procure and install 4 faxmachines in Gisenyi,Kibungo and Gikongorodistrict regional sectionsand at the headquarterscoordination office.

Procure and distributethree motorcycles and 30bicycles in Gisenyi,Kibungo and Gikongoroprovinces (1 motorcycleand 10 bicycles perprovince).

Procure and install acomputer for the person incharge of the disaster-preparedness programmeat headquarters.

Prepare a reporting systemfor the section committeesand focal points reportingregularly to Kigali.

Training: hold a two-dayworkshop to trainprovincial focal points andregional coordinators inthe system’s use and basicreporting skills.

Collect and analyse dataon the means ofsubsistence and householdeconomics in Kibuye,Kibungo and Gikongoroprovinces and draw upinternal reports.

Bimonthly bulletin drawnup by the person in chargeof DP in Kigali. Informationto be transmitted to all keyplayers (Red CrossMovement, government,UN system, NGOs) and toall sections in a monthlypublication.

Indicators

Procurement requests;means available.

Procurement requests;means available.

Procurement request;means available.

The system is availableand accepted byNational Society seniormanagement.

Report of theworkshop.

The information isavailable fordissemination. Monthlyreports to the person incharge of DP.

Publication of regularbulletins.

Outcome

The four faxes havebeen bought andinstalled and areoperational.

Improved means oftransport for datacollection in theprovinces.

Enhanced data pro-cessing and prepa-ration of reports.

System preparedfor December2001.

The six focal pointsand the coordina-tors are trained inthe system’s usestarting in January2001.

The information isregularly receivedfrom the field.

Early warning indi-cators.

Publication of a bi-monthly bulletin.

Timeframe

November

December2001 -January2002

December2001

December2001

January2002

Ongoing asof February2002

February-May 2002

Financialsupport

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

Objective

Page 16: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies14

Activities

VCA training for 25employees and volunteers.

Train 20 communityvolunteers (Karaba,Gikongoro district) andconduct a VCA to identifythe risk level in thecommunity.

Prepare a risk-reductionproject on the basis of the VCA results.

Conduct or undertake aVCA (using existingquestionnaires) to identifyhigh-risk areas andproduce emergency plansfor foreseeable disasters.

On the basis of the VCAresults, draw upemergency plans in theevent of floods/landslides,political disturbances/population movements(displaced persons,refugees) in co-operationwith other partners.Incorporate the NationalSociety’s plans and thoseof other partners.

Draw up an operationalhandbook/guidelines.

Cooperate and form anetwork with the ICRC, the Federation, thegovernment, UN agenciesand other NGOs.

Conduct three regionaladvanced courses on DP(3 days per region) for160 volunteers.

Indicators

Report on the training.

Report on the training.

Report on the VCAimplementation.

The project proposal isavailable.

VCA report.

National and regionalemergency plans in theevent offloods/landslides andpoliticalunrest/populationmovements have beenproduced.

The handbook isavailable and has beendistributed tovolunteers.

Monthly reports on thenumber oforganizations visitedand minutes ofmeetings.

Reports on the training.

Outcome

25 employees andvolunteers are ableto apply VCAtechniques.

Assistance to thevulnerablecommunity isplanned on thebasis of the VCAresults.

Project proposal.

A risk map ofRwanda has beenprepared.

Each of the fourregions has its ownemergency plan.

Links have beenestablishedbetween two RRCnational emergencyplans and existingUN agencies,government, ICRCor NGO plans.

Operationalhandbook/guidelines.

Good workingrelations withpartners.

Qualified volunteersand employeesmake up regionalresponse teams.

Timeframe

November2001

December2001 -January2002

March-April2002

December2001-January2002

February-May 2002

January-April 2002

Ongoinguntil endMay 2002

February-March 2002

Financialsupport

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

DFID

Objective

3. To mitigate theeffects of a disasterin a vulnerablecommunity inGikongoro provinceby means of acommunity-baseddisaster-management project(risk reductionmeasures).

4. To conduct anationwide VCAand draw upemergency disasterresponse plans.

Page 17: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Rwanda: Using the vulnerability and capacity assessment tool 15

Activities

Conduct 4 regionaltraining courses on DP for80 volunteers in provincesprone to conflict - Kibuye,Byumba, Butare andRuhengeri (20 volunteersper province).

Exchange visits withneighbouring sections ofthe Uganda Red CrossSociety (12 volunteers fromGisenyi, Ruhengeri andUmutara provinces visitKisoro and Kabale districtsin Uganda).

Emergency stocks andfunds.

Construct a DP house inGisenyi.

Indicators

Reports on the training.

Report on the visit.

Basic stocks and fundsare available torespond to seasonaldisasters.

DP house built inGisenyi.

Outcome

Heightenedawareness of howto use emergencyplans.

Rapid response.

Rapid response.

Timeframe

February2002

Ongoing

March-December2002

Financialsupport

ICRC

DFID

PNS

Italian RedCross andSingaporeRed CrossSociety

Objective

Page 18: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

Annex 2International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies16

Example national VCA questionnaireSample questions on vulnerabilities

SLOW ONSET WEATHER DISASTERS:What slow onset weather disasters have been commonplace in your region in the past five years?

1. DROUGHT YES NO If yes, answer the following questions,❍ ❍ if no, go directly to the next point.

CauseAt what time of the year?Number of incidents Number of families affectedNumber of people hospitalized Number of deaths registered

1. FAMINE YES NO If yes, answer the following questions,❍ ❍ if no, go directly to the next point.

CauseAt what time of the year?Number of incidents Number of families affectedNumber of people hospitalized Number of deaths registered

Sample questions on capacities:

HEALTH FACILITIES 1. Are there any health centres YES NO If yes, answer the following questions,

in your district? ❍ ❍ if no, go directly to the next point.

How many? CapacityLocation

1. Are there any hospitals YES NO If yes, answer the following questions,in your district? ❍ ❍ if no, go directly to the next point.

How many? CapacityLocation

WATER AND SANITATION

1. Are there sources of water YES NO If yes, answer the following questions,in your district? ❍ ❍ if no, go directly to the next point.

How many? Average distance to travelLocation

Page 19: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

The Fundamental Principlesof the International Red Crossand Red Crescent MovementHumanityThe International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, born of adesire to bring assistance without discrimination to the wounded on thebattlefield, endeavours, in its international and national capacity, toprevent and alleviate human suffering wherever it may be found. Itspurpose is to protect life and health and to ensure respect for the humanbeing. It promotes mutual understanding, friendship, cooperation andlasting peace amongst all peoples.

ImpartialityIt makes no discrimination as to nationality, race, religious beliefs, class orpolitical opinions. It endeavours to relieve the suffering of individuals,being guided solely by their needs, and to give priority to the most urgentcases of distress.

NeutralityIn order to enjoy the confidence of all, the Movement may not take sidesin hostilities or engage in controversies of a political, racial, religious orideological nature.

IndependenceThe Movement is independent. The National Societies, while auxiliariesin the humanitarian services of their governments and subject to the lawsof their respective countries, must always maintain their autonomy sothat they may be able at all times to act in accordance with the principlesof the Movement.

Voluntary ServiceIt is a voluntary relief movement not prompted in any manner by desirefor gain.

UnityThere can be only one Red Cross or Red Crescent Society in any onecountry. It must be open to all. It must carry on its humanitarian workthroughout its territory.

UniversalityThe International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, in which allsocieties have equal status and share equal responsibilities and duties inhelping each other, is worldwide.

Page 20: Case study Using the vulnerability and capacity … studies/Disasters/cs-vca...3 Introduction This case study recounts the experience of the Rwandan Red Cross with the vulnerability

5090

0 0

8/20

03

E 50

0

The International Federation of Red Cross and Red CrescentSocieties promotes thehumanitarian activities of National Societies amongvulnerable people.

By coordinating international disaster relief and encouragingdevelopment support it seeks to prevent and alleviate human suffering.

The Federation, the NationalSocieties and the InternationalCommittee of the Red Crosstogether constitute the International Red Cross and Red CrescentMovement.