case studies undp: fishers’ association of the rural community of mangagoulack (apcrm),...

Upload: undpenvironment

Post on 14-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    1/12

    Equator Initiative Case StudiesLocal sustainable development solutions for people, nature, and resilient communities

    Senegal

    FISHERS ASSOCIATION OFTHE RURAL COMMUNITY OFMANGAGOULACK (APCRM)

    Empowered live

    Resilient nation

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    2/12

    UNDP EQUATOR INITIATIVE CASE STUDY SERIES

    Local and indigenous communities across the world are advancing innovative sustainable development solutions that wo

    or people and or nature. Few publications or case studies tell the ull story o how such initiatives evolve, the breadth

    their impacts, or how they change over time. Fewer still have undertaken to tell these stories with community practition

    themselves guiding the narrative.

    To mark its 10-year anniversary, the Equator Initiative aims to ll this gap. The ollowing case study is one in a growing ser

    that details the work o Equator Prize winners vetted and peer-reviewed best practices in community-based environmenconservation and sustainable livelihoods. These cases are intended to inspire the policy dialogue needed to take local succ

    to scale, to improve the global knowledge base on local environment and development solutions, and to serve as models

    replication. Case studies are best viewed and understood with reerence to The Power o Local Action: Lessons rom 10 Years

    the Equator Prize, a compendium o lessons learned and policy guidance that draws rom the case material.

    Click on the map to visit the Equator Initiatives searchable case study database.

    EditorsEditor-in-chie: Joseph CorcoranManaging Editor: Oliver Hughes

    Contributing Editors: Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Erin Lewis, Whitney Wilding

    Contributing WritersEdayatu Abieodun Lamptey, Erin Atwell, Jonathan Clay, Joseph Corcoran, Sean Cox, Larissa Currado, David Godrey, Sarah Gordon,

    Oliver Hughes, Wen-Juan Jiang, Sonal Kanabar, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Rachael Lader, Erin Lewis, Jona Liebl, Mengning Ma

    Mary McGraw, Brandon Payne, Juliana Quaresma, Peter Schecter, Martin Sommerschuh, Whitney Wilding

    DesignSean Cox, Oliver Hughes, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Amy Korngiebel, Kimberly Koserowski, Erin Lewis, John Mulqueen, Loren

    de la Parra, Brandon Payne, Mariajos Satizbal G.

    AcknowledgementsThe Equator Initiative acknowledges with gratitude the Fishers Association o the Rural Community o Mangagoulack (APCRM) and

    guidance and inputs o the ICCA Consortium. All photo credits courtesy o APCRM. Maps courtesy o CIA World Factbook and Wikiped

    except or map o Kawawana management plan (p. 7), courtesy o APCRM.

    Suggested CitationUnited Nations Development Programme. 2013. Fishers Association o the Rual Community o Mangagoulack (APCRM), Senegal. Equa

    Initiative Case Study Series. New York, NY.

    http://c/Users/user/AppData/Local/Adobe/InDesign/Version%209.0/en_US/Caches/InDesign%20ClipboardScrap1.pdfhttp://c/Users/user/AppData/Local/Adobe/InDesign/Version%209.0/en_US/Caches/InDesign%20ClipboardScrap1.pdfhttp://c/Users/user/AppData/Local/Adobe/InDesign/Version%209.0/en_US/Caches/InDesign%20ClipboardScrap1.pdfhttp://c/Users/user/AppData/Local/Adobe/InDesign/Version%209.0/en_US/Caches/InDesign%20ClipboardScrap1.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=casestudysearch&Itemid=858
  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    3/12

    PROJECT SUMMARYThe Fishers Association o the Rural Community oMangagoulack established by shers rom eight villages incentral Casamance manages a community conserved areawith the aim o improving local incomes, strengthening oodsecurity and sovereignty, and protecting biodiversity. Theassociation was started in response to declining sh catchesand in recognition o the need or a community-drivenresource management plan. The tropical estuary ecosystemis now managed through a zoning system based on thetraditional zoning practice.

    Once a month, shers work on behal o the association,dedicating the sale o their catch towards conservationand surveillance needs. Monitoring shows a 100 per centincrease in sh abundance and signicant improvements inmarine biodiversity since the initiative began. Women in thecommunity have ormed an association o shellsh collectors,creating a similar set o rules or management and extraction.The larger association was the rst o its kind in Senegal,unique in engaging local and regional governments to legallyrecognize community shing rights.

    KEY FACTS

    EQUATOR PRIZE WINNER: 2012

    FOUNDED: 2008

    LOCATION: The Ziguinchor region of Casamance

    BENEFICIARIES: Mangagoulacks 12,000 residents

    BIODIVERSITY: Community-conserved marine area

    3

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Background and Context 4

    Key Activities and Innovations 6

    Biodiversity Impacts 8

    Socioeconomic Impacts 8

    Policy Impacts 9

    Sustainability 10

    Replication 11

    Partners 11

    ASSOCIATION DES PCHEURS DE LA COMMUNAUTRURALE DE MANGAGOULACK (APCRM)Sngal

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    4/12

    4

    he Fishers Association o the Rural Community o Mangagoulack

    Association des Pcheurs de la Communaut Rurale de Mangagoulack

    APCRM) was established by local shermen in 2008. The association

    ncludes members rom all eight villages o the municipality o

    Mangagoulack, in the Ziguinchor region o Casamance, the area o

    enegal that extends south o The Gambia. These villages Tandouk,

    Diatok, Boutegol, Elana, Bod, Boutem, Aniam and Mangagoulack

    tsel have a combined population o 12,000 people.

    he initiative was ormed in response to a number o interrelated

    nvironmental, social and economic challenges that collectively

    ecessitated greater reconciliation o local livelihoods and proper

    nvironmental stewardship. The agreed upon intervention was

    he establishment o a community conserved area, where no-takesones would allow or the regeneration o marine biodiversity.

    reviously declining sh populations rebounded quickly, resulting

    n a greater abundance o diversity o marine lie in the area. The

    ssociation has also applied itsel to the restoration o degraded

    ce-growing land through the repair and reconstruction o miles o

    raditional anti-salinization dykes. Together, these activities have had

    ositive impacts on local ood security, biodiversity and community

    wellbeing.

    A tradition o innovative resource management

    he communities o Mangagoulack and surrounding villages are

    mainly Diola (or Jola) people, and are characterized by a tradition otrong social and community bonds. The local landscape is a tropical

    stuarine system o winding inlets (locally called bolons or bolongs)

    nd mangrove orests that, in the past, was home to a diverse array

    marine species. The natural resources o these waterways were

    raditionally protected by sophisticated local customs that dictated

    where members o each village could sh, and traditional practices

    hat invoked etishes (sacred objects or charms) to ensure that

    cological limits were respected. Traditionally, this system worked

    emarkably well, allowing the biodiversity o the bolongs to ourish

    while enabling local communities to meet their subsistence shing

    eeds.

    Gradually, however, local sheries began to decline, as tradit

    natural resource management techniques were neglected

    shers rom other coastal areas o Senegal equipped with ar la

    and more powerul boats than local shermen, who typically wo

    wooden pirogues with no engines began shing indiscriminat

    what was regarded as open-access water. The decline in the qua

    and quality o sh catch impacted local livelihoods and ood sec

    Additionally, the coastal areas where people used to cultivate

    were also declining in productivity due to the degradation o

    ingenious system o dams, built in ancient times, but which

    allen into disrepair. The result was that two o the main local sou

    o ood shing and rice cultivation were severely threatened

    In 2008, the shers association o Mangagoulack decided to addthe situation by establishing a community-conserved area to a

    sh stocks to regenerate and lay the oundation or more sustain

    management o the waterways. The process o establishing

    community-conserved area took several years; during this

    the association initiated a number o complementary initiat

    including mangrove reorestation and banning destructive s

    practices. APCRM has led a campaign against the local us

    monolament nets, burning them where they are ound. T

    nets are cheap and are typically used, quickly damaged, and

    abandoned in shallow coastal areas, where they remain or y

    creating destructive traps or sh and other marine mammals.

    Kawawana community-conserved area

    The community-conserved area was named Kawawana an acro

    or the Diola expression Kapooye Waolal Wata Nanang, meaning

    patrimony, or us all to preserve. Kawawana is remarkable in th

    was conceived, developed and implemented exclusively by the

    shermen themselves. Where external actors were approa

    as in the case o the Centre or Sustainable Development

    Environment (CENESTA), an Iranian NGO it was to request un

    or meetings to consult the wider community on the proposed

    At community meetings, local people identied a number o thr

    Primary among them was the challenge o unregulated, open a

    Background and Context

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    5/12

    55

    shing. A second was the harvesting o marine resources by migrant

    shermen rom northern Senegal who used tiny mesh nets to

    atch shrimp, with devastating efects on sh stocks. Because these

    migrant shermen operated under a national licence, however,

    heir activity was legal and they could not be prosecuted. A third

    dentied threat was the perceived loss o community cohesion as

    result o acculturation and the penetration o oreign values and

    estyles. It was elt that this had degraded local Diola culture, which

    s characterised by community solidarity and respectul interactionwith nature. The community enthusiastically endorsed Kawawana as

    means o simultaneously addressing all o these threats.

    Kawawana was ocially established ater a year o patient diplomatic

    manoeuvring and negotiation between government ocials and

    he leaders o the association. Eventually, APCRM was able to secure

    overnment approval or their plan, which granted the eight villages

    he right to manage their local waterways and claim exclusive

    ustomary shing rights in a small portion o what was previously

    pen access water. The rst step involved securing the approval

    the Mangagoulack Municipality, which endorsed Kawawana

    n the basis o Senegals Decentralisation Law, which assigns to

    he municipal authority responsibility over natural resources in

    errestrial environments. The law had never beore been applied

    n a coastal environment, but the extrapolation ultimately proved

    uccessul. In June 2010, ater extensive lobbying and discussions,

    Kawawana was endorsed by the Regional Council o Casamance and

    y the Regional Governor himsel.

    Kawawana spans nearly 10,000 hectares and is managed directly

    y APCRM. To draw a clear distinction between their community-

    onserved area and the Community Marine Protected Areas (Aires

    Marines Protges Communautaires - AMPCs) that already existed

    n Senegal, the Association named Kawawana an Indigenous

    Heritage and Community Area (Aire du Patrimoine Autochtone etCommunautaire APAC). AMPCs are declared by the state and

    managed by a government-appointed ocial. Local communities

    re rarely involved in their governance, and at best, tolerate them.

    Kawawana bears little resemblance to this model, having b

    conceived, developed and implemented by the local commu

    and in its combination o modern conservation methods

    traditional knowledge and practices.

    Governance and institutional structure

    The Mangagoulack association is at the heart o the Kawaw

    governance system and collaborates closely with muniauthorities and Senegals Fisheries Department. Kawaw

    governance structure consists o ve levels:

    i. the APCRM General Assembly

    ii. the APCRM Bureau

    iii. the Council o the Rural Municipality

    iv. a Scientic Advisory Committee

    v. the Council o Elders

    The General Assembly approves decisions and ensures that mem

    and the Bureau comply with rules. It elects the members o

    Bureau, collects ecological monitoring reports and dissemin

    inormation. The Bureau ormulates technical proposals, t

    decisions and supervises monitoring teams. In turn, the Co

    approves technical proposals and, in consultation with the s

    representative o the Fisheries Department, takes decis

    concerning Kawawana.

    The Scientic Advisory Committee provides guidance on Kawaw

    governance and management processes, helps with analys

    monitoring data, and assists in promoting the Kawawana initiat

    national and international events. The Council o Elders is activ

    an ad-hoc basis as mediator and arbiter when conicts arise. It

    advises on governance issues. Everybody working or Kawaw

    does so on a voluntary basis, evidence o the communitys supor the initiative. Financial resources and external support are so

    only or specic activities on a case-by-case basis.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    6/12

    6

    Key Activities and Innovations

    he ocially designated Kawawana community-conserved

    rea comprises 9,665 ha o bolongs and coastal mangroves and

    overs about two-thirds o the coastal area o the Mangangoulack

    Municipality. Its management plan restricts shing access and

    shing methods in what was previously an open access area, and

    ncludes regulations designed to take into account the needs o

    ocal communities. The management plan is designed to cater to

    he subsistence needs o the local communities rather than those

    o commercial shers, and includes the reintroduction o several

    ncient resource management customs that had gradually become

    eglected. An example includes rules prohibiting entry into sacred

    bolongs that harbour rich biodiversity. Fetishes typically placed on

    ignposts are also used to demarcate each zone within Kawawanand encourage compliance.

    Kawawana management plan

    he management plan designates three distinct areas within

    Kawawana, colour-coded red, orange and yellow. The Red ZoneBolon de Mitij) encompasses a sacred area that serves as a reuge

    or marine lie. Here, harvesting o any resource including sh,

    hellsh and wood is prohibited. The Red Zone is marked by etishes

    enoting its sacred status. This practice is ully in line with the Diola

    radition, whereby each village maintained at least one sacred grove.

    he tradition had previously been degraded by the introduction o

    aws allowing ree access to coastal areas. Kawawanas managementplan reinstates this practice, re-establishing the Bolon de Mitij as a

    o-entry, no-shing zone.

    he Orange Zones (Bolons des Villages) are dedicated to shing or

    ocal consumption and market and may only be shed by the local

    illagers to meet their own needs. Within this zone, each o the eight

    illages has their own bolong where village rules and restrictions

    re enorced. The catch rom these sites must be used within the

    illage as its purpose is to meet local ood security needs. The market

    price o the sh caught here is agreed locally, and it is signicantly

    lower than the price the same sh could etch in the markets o

    regional capital. Foreign shermen may only access these bol

    i invited by a resident and housed in the community. Finally

    Yellow Zone (Bolon de Tandouk) is open to all but regulations re

    the equipment and methods that may be used. For example

    engines or monolament nets are allowed.

    The system o colour coded zones is communicated via

    signs located at strategic transit points. Each sign displays a ph

    number that shermen may call or clarication o the rules. Fet

    are placed at all strategic points, signalling special rules. Toge

    these rules make Kawawana a welcoming environment or a r

    o marine species. Today, rare humpbacked dolphins, manacrocodiles and other coastal sh and shellsh have returne

    large number; so much so that local shermen are concerned a

    human-wildlie conict. Dolphins damage their nets and croco

    can be dangerous, sometimes threatening the saety and liv

    shermen. Mitigating these emerging conicts remains a pr

    work area or APCRM.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    7/12

    7

    urveillance and enorcement are carried out by a 24-person team

    volunteers who work in groups o six. For the rst three months o

    he initiative, surveillance was carried out 24 hours a day, but this was

    educed to regular spot checks as shermen became accustomed to

    he new system. The community has the power to enact sanctions

    when the rules are breached. The severity o the sanctions depends

    n the nature o the transgression. In the Red Zone, sanctions are

    norced directly with no warning given, while in the Yellow Zone,

    warning is issued with sanctions ollowing the second breach.

    anctions include seizure o catches and conscation o property,

    which is returned upon payment o a ne. Fines are used to und

    APCRM activities, including ecological monitoring and surveillance.

    When shermen are ound using monolament nets, the nets are

    urned on the spot with no warnings issued. Within the Orange

    one, each village enorces its own rules within its own bolong.

    o supplement the income rom nes collected, local shermen

    sh collectively once a month with the proceeds rom the sale o

    heir catch going to APCRM to pay or expenses such as uel or

    Kawawanas surveillance boat.

    Women Shellfsh Collectors Association

    he success o Kawawana inspired the women o Mangagoulack,

    who traditionally collect shellsh, to establish an association o their

    own and develop collective rules to protect shellsh stocks. Like

    rules enacted in Kawawana, the women reinstated local custom

    rules that had traditionally been well respected but had allen

    disuse. Their rules include a recovery period o three months e

    year during which shellsh are not collected, in order to allow

    population to regenerate ully.

    Restoring degraded land

    Bolstered by the success o the community-conserved area,

    communities o Mangagoulack and the surrounding region obta

    support rom the UNDP-implemented GEF Small Grants Program

    (SGP) to undertake a programme o land restoration to pro

    their rice cultivation rom encroaching seawater (likely to wo

    with sea-level rise) and help prevent urther land degradation.

    community collectively restored ve traditional dams that were

    by their ancestors to keep seawater out o rice elds. The result

    been the recovery o hundreds o hectares o previously salin

    land that has the potential to produce many tons o rice per yea

    part o this initiative, the local committees established in each vi

    also keep up their reorestation and mangrove restoration proj

    planting Rhizophora mangrove specimens in strategic areas.

    Fig. 1: Kawawana management plan

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    8/12

    8

    Impacts

    BIODIVERSITY IMPACTS

    The inlets and mangroves o Mangagoulacks estuarine landscape

    harbour a diverse array o marine wildlie including manatees,

    humpbacked dolphin and a beautiul range o sh and shellsh.

    Kawawanas management plan has re-established many o the

    raditional customs that protected these resources, or example,

    einstating the tradition o sacred groves where shing is prohibited,

    nd invoking etishes to encourage compliance with zoning and

    egulations. The result has been the creation o a reuge or aquatic

    e in the Red Zone, and a quieter, saer, more unctionally robust

    ecosystem or wildlie throughout Kawawana.

    Ecological monitoring and results

    With assistance rom partner organisations, APCRM has developed

    robust system o ecological monitoring to track the success

    o Kawawana in allowing populations o key marine species to

    egenerate. The monitoring system combines the traditional

    ecological knowledge o local shermen with more modern

    monitoring methods. O the 80 sh species that have been identied

    n Casamance, over 70 are designated with specic common names

    nd shermen maintain detailed knowledge o their traits, breeding

    nd migration habits, and position in the ood chain. Mangagoulacks

    shermen have combined this knowledge base with training in the

    use o computers and spreadsheet sotware to develop a soundmethodology or recording the impacts o Kawawana in terms o the

    ecovery o sheries, general biodiversity and broad socioeconomic

    hange. Despite having very limited ormal education, the shermen

    have mastered the monitoring techniques and their results are

    ounter-checked by the initiatives Scientic Advisory Committee.

    A notably valuable aspect o APCRMs monitoring is that they have

    established a baseline against which the results o the Kawawana

    nitiative can be compared. Such baseline measurements are

    elatively rare in West Arica.

    Monitoring data show that the return to traditional reso

    management methods has ended the decline o marine reso

    around Mangagoulack and neighbouring villages. Fish cat

    have more than doubled compared to baseline levels, sugge

    a signicant increase in sh populations at the site. Monito

    also indicates promising improvements in sh biodiversity

    more sh species being observed. The ban on motors has

    a positive impact on dolphin and seabird populations. Mig

    shers rom northern Senegal were previously a major cause o

    stock depletion: obtaining the right to manage their local co

    environment has played an instrumental role in allowing the

    to recover by allowing local communities to expel oreign sh

    they do not abide by regulations. The Bolon de Mitijor Red Zonshown particularly impressive recovery.

    In addition to the direct impacts o the community-conserved

    on sh stocks and biodiversity, the land restoration progra

    instigated by the community involved the recovery and replan

    o mangrove orests that provide a vital haven or sh, shellsh

    other marine lie. In addition, the land restoration programme

    protected the quality and ertility o cropland by restoring dams

    exclude saltwater.

    SOCIOECONOMIC IMPACTS

    Food security

    The primary impetus behind the APCRM initiative was to re

    the ood security o Mangagoulack and neighbouring commun

    ater it was threatened by declining sh stocks and the incu

    o seawater into rice elds. This motive is reected in Kawawa

    management plan, which is designed to ensure that the need

    local communities are met. Each village has exclusive access

    village bolong which may be shed only or local consump

    and local markets. All sh caught within these village bolongs

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    9/12

    be consumed locally. Local diets and incomes are improving as a

    esult, and the regulations to allow sh stocks to regenerate have

    esulted in a doubling o sh catches. The quality o sh caught is

    also getting better, translating into important dietary improvements

    n communities where sh is the primary source o protein. The

    eaction o local people is that the good lie is back, a claim backed

    up by monitoring results. Food security has been bolstered urther

    by the restoration o traditional dams to protect rice-growing land

    rom the incursion o seawater. This efort resulted in the restorationo hundreds o hectares o previously degraded land that has the

    potential to produce many tons o rice per year.

    Tackling migration and emigration

    Another persistent concern in Mangagoulack and the surrounding

    egion has been the loss o local youth who migrate to large cities

    uch as Dakar or emigrate to Europe in search o better livelihood

    prospects. Migration and emigration o young people is a widespread

    ssue in Senegal and a central goal o the initiative was to develop

    ustainable local livelihood options or the youth o Mangagoulack

    o that they would remain in their communities. Kawawana has

    evitalised local sheries, thereby preserving traditional livelihoods

    and providing improved economic opportunities or local youth.

    nvolvement o women

    The Kawawana initiative has had an empowering efect on the

    women o Mangagoulack, who were inspired by the success o the

    community-conserved area to establish their own association o

    woman shellsh harvesters. The womens association established

    heir own collective rules which include a yearly repose period o

    hree months during which no shellsh are harvested to allow

    tocks to regenerate. Women were also directly involved in the

    establishment o Kawawana, as the approval o local elder womenhad to be obtained beore APCRM could proceed to seek the

    approval o the municipality and the Regional Council and Governor.

    Elder women are central to the Kawawana management plan, as it is

    hey who place the etishes on signposts that are used to demarcate

    he red, orange and yellow zones. This step is crucial, as among Diola

    people, etishes are highly respected. Many women also benetted

    directly alongside men rom the success o Kawawana in particular,

    he many women who make their livings as buyers and sellers o sh

    and have seen their incomes grow as a result o increased catches.

    Community cohesion

    An overarching socioeconomic benet o the associationsKawawana initiative is that it has strengthened community cohesion

    and enhanced solidarity within and between the neighbouring

    communities around Mangagoulack, based on their shared success

    n protecting their local coastal resources. Conicts have become

    ess requent and Kawawana is a source o local pride. Further, the

    uccess o Kawawana opened up the community to urther collective

    action, as evidenced by their subsequent eforts to collectively

    estore degraded dams to protect rice-growing land.

    POLICY IMPACTS

    The communities o Mangagoulack and the surrounding are

    a precedent in Senegal as the rst group to secure exclusive ri

    to govern and manage a coastal conserved area. This achievem

    came ater a long and convoluted advocacy and negotia

    efort. In 2008, APCRM convinced the local Rural Municipali

    endorse the community-conserved area on the basis o Sene

    Decentralisation Law, which assigns responsibility and authover natural resources in terrestrial environments. APC

    application marked a departure rom the norm, as this law

    never previously been applied to coastal resources. It was, how

    eventually accepted. It was not until more than a year later, in 2

    ater much lobbying and discussion, that APCRM nally rece

    the endorsement o the Regional Council and the Governo

    Casamance or the establishment o Kawawana. This set a prece

    or the return o collective shing rights and natural reso

    management rights to the community level.

    As important as this change was to the communitie

    Mangagoulack, allowing them to proceed with their plan to esta

    a protected area and build the capacity o some o their membe

    auxiliary shery ocers, it also set a national precedent. Its pote

    consequences all along the coast o Senegal and West Arica

    monumental. Several other communities have expressed intere

    ollowing in Mangagoulacks ootsteps and applying to take co

    o their local environment and resources, and some have be

    the arduous process o organization. Senegals national p

    on protected areas in general is currently under discussion

    revision expected, and the case o Kawawana is likely to be take

    an example o potential innovations. A study o legal options o

    governance o protected areas in the country that took Kawaw

    case as a key example, meanwhile, has been developed o

    Secretariat o the UN Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) anow available online.

    9

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    10/12

    10

    Sustainability and Replication

    SUSTAINABILITYhe sustainability o APCRM and the Kawawana initiative are a

    unction o both the support and buy-in o local communities and

    he support o the government or the continuation o the initiative.

    Financial stability

    Currently, neither APCRM nor the Kawawana initiative relies on

    ny ongoing nancial support rom external partners or donors.

    upport has been received in the past or specic needs, including a

    rant rom SGP to und the restoration o degraded dams and rice-

    rowing land. Otherwise, APCRM seeks unding only to meet specic

    eeds. The initiatives ongoing sources o unding include nesevied when regulations are broken, and the proceeds o a monthly

    ollective shing day when local shers donate the proceeds o

    heir catch to und the association. These cover expenses related to

    urveillance and ecological monitoring. Additional costs are kept

    ow by the willingness o community members to donate their time

    n a voluntary basis to take part in surveillance and monitoring. All

    members o the initiatives various councils and associations also

    onate their time on a voluntary basis. The association has made

    forts to develop a stable source o income to cover ongoing

    xpenses like uel costs but have yet to nd a suitable source. A

    icycle renting business was attempted or a short time, but, while

    rotable, came to an end due to the short lie span o bicycles in the

    ocal environment.

    ocal support and autonomy

    Community support is the root o Kawawanas success. The

    ommunity-conserved area was conceived, developed and

    mplemented by the local shermen themselves. This community

    eadership and precedent o collective action are crucial to the

    ustainability o Kawawana, as the initiative depends on local

    ompliance, enthusiasm and voluntary contributions o time.

    Given the success o the initiative to date in providing tangible

    mprovements to ood security and local incomes, it is unlikely that

    local enthusiasm or the community-conserved area will wane ishort term. Community members volunteer their time to unde

    monitoring and surveillance, and local shers sh collectively

    a month, donating the proceeds o their catch to pay or ue

    Kawawanas surveillance boat. This voluntary donation o

    and efort is evidence o the communitys strong support o

    initiative. The emerging problem o human-wildlie conict p

    a potential threat to this level o local support, however, and

    require new approaches to mitigating the impact o wildlie on

    shing livelihoods.

    Government backing

    Government support or the initiative lends a high degrelegitimacy to the community-conserved area and the enorcem

    o community regulations. Volunteers responsible or surveill

    and enorcement are now sworn into their roles by the Fish

    Department and the police orce. The Regional Council has

    actively encouraged other rural municipalities to take note o

    Kawawana approach and to account or it in their developm

    planning. This suggests a high degree o institutional support o

    model.

    Social resilience

    The initiative as a whole has rendered the communitie

    Mangagoulack and neighbouring villages more secure and resirebuilding much o the social cohesion that had been grad

    diminishing with widespread cultural changes and emigra

    Kawawanas success demonstrated to the community their abili

    collectively address threats and achieve success. This is evidence

    the act that the success o the community-conserved area spu

    the community to address the degradation o their rice-growing

    by instigating a project to restore traditional dikes that had bec

    degraded. The bonds and cohesion that have been develo

    through the Kawawana initiative will strengthen the resilience o

    community to ace uture challenges.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    11/12

    1111

    REPLICATION

    he success o APCRMs Kawawana community-conserved area has

    nspired other communities in Senegal and beyond to replicate their

    forts. Not only has the initiative provided inspiration, it has also

    et an important legal precedent to assist other communities with

    imilar aspirations. Their case was the rst instance in which Senegals

    Decentralisation Law was invoked to return shing rights andatural resource management responsibility o a coastal ecosystem

    o the community level. This is likely to have proound implications

    or coastal communities throughout Senegal. In act, the success o

    Kawawana has spurred the Regional Council to recommend to all

    ural municipalities in Casamance that they examine the case o

    Kawawana in order to adopt the model in their local development

    nd investment plans.

    he association has also invested a great deal o time in explaining

    heir model via local radio stations throughout Ziguinchor Region.

    Communities in Senegal as well as in neighbouring Guinea Bissau

    ave approached APCRM or advice on establishing their own

    onserved areas. The rst to approach were coastal villages, but it

    s worth noting that APCRM has also been approached by an inland

    ommunity seeking advice on managing its local orest. Several

    existing marine protected areas in the region are conside

    improving the governance and management o their prog

    based on lessons taken rom the Kawawana model. It is clear

    APCRM and Kawawana have a signicant role to play as a m

    and a source o advice and expertise in community-based na

    resource management.

    PARTNERSAn important aspect o Kawawana is the degree to which

    community acted autonomously in initiating the process, develo

    the idea and implementing the protected area. The decisio

    pursue this course came entirely rom local shermen with

    backing o their community. Only aterwards did they approac

    external NGO to seek assistance in carrying out consultations

    the community, and subsequently received nancial assist

    in organising two large community-wide meetings. Since

    beginning, APCRM and the community have maintained

    control o the initiative. Although external support rom part

    is important to the initiative, it tends to be sought out only to

    specic needs.

    The UNDP-implemented GEF Small Grants Programme prov

    support or two meetings that were held in 2008 in orde

    consult community members about the plan to establi

    community-conserved area. This assistance was obtained thro

    the intermediary CENESTA, an Iranian NGO. GEF-SGP also un

    three technical advisors who supported the establishment o

    Kawawana ecological monitoring system. Between 2009 and 2

    Mangagoulack benetted rom an SGP grant o approximately

    46,000 or the implementation o the communitys project to re

    their rice-growing land.

    The Fiba Foundation has provided specic assistance on a num

    o occasions, including providing the nancial resources to purc

    o a wooden canoe, a small engine or surveillance operations,

    in 2011, a motorbike or the transportation o staf. The Internat

    Union or Conservation o Nature (IUCN) provided tech

    support or ecological monitoring and community marine sh

    management.

    There is currently no ongoing partner support to Kawawana

    APCRM has reached out to and maintained contact with a num

    o networks that support their work, including the ICCA Consor

    (a global association supporting indigenous peoples and

    communities that collectively govern and conserve their territoand the Regional Network o Marine Protected Areas in West A

    (Rseau Rgional dAires Marines Protges en Arique de lOue

    RAMPAO). The ICCA Consortium staf provides technical suppo

    APCRM as requested, and has nanced the radio programmes

    visits by shermen rom Mangagoulack to other communities

    wish to replicate their model.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: FISHERS ASSOCIATION OF THE RURAL COMMUNITY OF MANGAGOULACK (APCRM), Senegal

    12/12

    Click the thumbnails below to read more case studies like this:

    Equator Initiative

    Environment and Energy GroupUnited Nations Development Programme (UNDP)

    304 East 45th Street, 6th Floor

    New York, NY 10017

    Tel: +1 646 781-4023

    www.equatorinitiative.org

    UNDP partners with people at all levels o society to help build nations that can withstand crisis, and drive and sustain

    kind o growth that improves the quality o lie or everyone. On the ground in 177 countries and territories, we ofer glo

    perspective and local insight to help empower lives and build resilient nations.

    The Equator Initiative brings together the United Nations, governments, civil society, businesses and grassroots organizati

    o recognize and advance local sustainable development solutions or people, nature and resilient communities.

    2013 by Equator Initiative

    All rights reserved

    FURTHER REFERENCE

    APCRM Equator Initiative prole page: http://www.equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=winner_

    detail&id=74&Itemid=683

    More inormation about APCRMs community conserved area, Kawawana, on rareplanet.org: http://www.rareplanet.org/en/solutio

    search-entry/kawawana%E2%80%94-real-community-conserved-area-coastal-and-marine-environment-casaman

    http://www.equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=winner_detail&id=74&Itemid=683http://www.equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=winner_detail&id=74&Itemid=683http://www.rareplanet.org/en/solution-search-entry/kawawana%E2%80%94-real-community-conserved-area-coastal-and-marine-environment-casamanhttp://www.rareplanet.org/en/solution-search-entry/kawawana%E2%80%94-real-community-conserved-area-coastal-and-marine-environment-casamanhttp://www.rareplanet.org/en/solution-search-entry/kawawana%E2%80%94-real-community-conserved-area-coastal-and-marine-environment-casamanhttp://www.rareplanet.org/en/solution-search-entry/kawawana%E2%80%94-real-community-conserved-area-coastal-and-marine-environment-casamanhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=winner_detail&id=74&Itemid=683http://www.equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=winner_detail&id=74&Itemid=683http://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348160544.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/winners/137/casestudy/case_1370356545.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348161880.pdf