can simplicity improve 2017 diving safety? seminar2014 before lovoy simplification. n. today....
TRANSCRIPT
Can Simplicity Improve Diving Safety?This presentation was part of TechnipFMC presentation about the evolution in diving and dealing with human behavioral issues.
Terje LøvøyCEO Lovoy [email protected]
Based on lesson learned from 20 SMS - Safety Management System (SMS) improvement projects in shipping, oil and gas.
Bergen International Diving Seminar 2017
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
| 2
ClearComplex
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Mortality and complications reduced by 42%
Biggest breakthrough since doctors started washing their hands
Could we transfer the concept to other industries?
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
| 4
Problem:Safety Management Systems (SMS) have become too big, too complex and lost sight of the end user.
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
| 5
Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla!Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla!!! Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla!!Bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla blabla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla blabla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla blabla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla! Bla bla bla bla bla bla!!!
Windbag
Procedures are like peoplesome talk a lot but say littleThe
Bergen
Inter
natio
nal D
iving S
emina
r 201
7
1218 = 2
3 Commence Start=
Text is like math, we can present the same complex or simple
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Complex ClearGive consideration toDuring the period ofA number ofGive the recognition toIs concerned withBecause of the fact that
20 words 6 words
70 % reduction
Solution: Simplify
ConsiderDuringSomeRecognizeConcernsSince
From Lovoy simple word dictionary www.lovoy.infoThe
Bergen
Inter
natio
nal D
iving S
emina
r 201
7
48.939 words 17.235 words
65% reduction
NAVIGATION2014 Before Lovoy simplification Today
Example from Teekay who implemented this on approx. 200 vessels. (Shared with permission from Teekay).Numerous shipping companies have similar examples. For example Eidesvik with 11 vessels, Bernhard Schulte Ship Management and V.Shipsmanaging hundreds of vessels.
Typical Before and After ExampleTank ship navigation procedures and checklists from berth to berth
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
User FeedbackTypical survey answers
• Difficult language
• Must read several times
• Difficult to find what you need
• Not following workflows
• Must transfer knowledge verbally
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
The biggest problem:Spaghetti structureThe
Bergen
Inter
natio
nal D
iving S
emina
r 201
7
Old spaghetti prose text procedure
New step procedure
Untangle Spaghetti Methods
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Checklists
Procedures
Common problem: Poor connection between checklists and procedures
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Good Connection Between Procedures and Checklists
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Structure Style Layout
Operational – Proactive – Risk Based
Good Tools Are Half the Job
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Resources and Case Studieswww.lovoy.info
Terje Løvøy+47 [email protected]
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
New TechnologyOld cockpit New cockpit
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
New Technology and Training
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Avoid Simulator Abuse
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
• Before˗ Only technical skills˗ Stress training
• Today˗ Non technical and technical skills˗ Build confidence˗ Not too much unanticipated events training
• Must have good training procedures and plans
Airline Simulator Training Experiences
Training Plan
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017
Sources and References
Links:• New Teekay Nav Procedures (Video)• User-Friendly Procedures are Used More (Video)• BSM Navigation Procedures (Video)• Simple Word Dictionary
References:• Preventing Complications: The Preflight Checklist, European Urology Focus 2:1, 60-62, Arvid Steinar
Haugen, August Bakke, Terje Lovoy, Eirik Søfteland, Bergen 2016• Proactive Aviation Safety Systems How other industries use aviation concepts, IUMI International
Union of Marine Insurance, Terje Lovoy, Genova 2016• Simplicity Improves Diving Safety, IMCA Making Waves, Terje Lovoy, London 2016
By Terje Lovoy - [email protected]
The Berg
en In
terna
tiona
l Divin
g Sem
inar 2
017