breach of undertaking attracts contempt of court (read the judgment)

8/20/2019 Breach of Undertaking attracts Contempt of Court (Read the Judgment)

1/22

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

CONTEMPT PETITION (C) NO. 277 OF 2012

IN

SLP (C) No.26541 o 2005

THE !OARD OF TRUSTEESOF THE PORT OF MUM!AI ...PETITIONER

V"#$%$

NI&HIL N. GUPTA ' ANR. ...RESPONDENTS

J U D G M E N T

R. BANUMATHI, J.

T$ Co*+",-+ P"++o* $ /""* " / +" !o# o

T#%$+""$ o +" Po#+ o M%,/ ("#"*+"# #""##" +o $ 3Po#+

T#%$+) o $ +" o#* #"$-o*"*+ * SLP(C) No.26541 o

2005 *$+ +" #"$-o*"*+$89o*+",*o#$ o# $o/"* +"

o#"# o +$ Co%#+ +" 27.01.2006 "#"/ +$ Co%#+ "

$,$$* +" $-"9 ":" -"++o* #*+" o*" "#$ +," +o

1


2/22

+" #"$-o*"*+$ "#"* +o :9+" +" -#",$"$ $%/;"9+ +o +"

%*"#+


3/22

!"*9 o S, C%$"$ Co%#+ + !o,/ :" o#"# +"

05.12.200@. T" #"$-o*"*+ $ -#""##" #+ P"++o*(C)

No.47222004 /"o#" +" !o,/ H Co%#+ * +" H

Co%#+ $ $,$$" +" #+ -"++o* / * o#"# +"

[email protected]. T" #"$-o*"*+$ :" -#""##" $-"9 ":"

-"++o* /"o#" +$ Co%#+ 9 $ $,$$" / +$ Co%#+ o*

27.01.2006. Ho":"# +$ Co%#+ $ 99"-+" +" #"$-o*"*+$

-#"# +o :" o*" "# +," #o, +" +" o +" o#"# .".

27.01.2006. T" $ o#"# #"$ $ %*"#8

“Heard.The special leave petitio is dis!issed.Ho"ever, the co#sel appeari$ %or the petitioer

pra&s %or so!e ti!e to vacate the pre!ises i '#estio.Havi$ heard the leared (olicitor )eeral appeari$

%or the caveator*respodet, oe &ear+s ti!e is $rated to

the petitioer to vacate the pre!ises i '#estio s#-ectto its %ili$ the #s#al #dertai$ to this e%%ect i this/o#rt "ithi %o#r "ees %ro! toda&.0

P%#$%*+ +o +" o#"# +" 27.01.2006 +" #"$-o*"*+

No.18N


4/22

20.07.2010 /"o#" S, C%$"$ Co%#+ * *o+9" $ $$%"

+o +" #"$-o*"*+$. T" / o +" Co%#+ P.A. Go" ," *

++",-+ +o $"#:" o* +" #"$-o*"*+$ /%+ + $ o%* ++

9o*+",*o#$ :" 9*" +"# #"$$"$. T"#"+"# +#9"

+" / o*+ +" O9" I*$-"9+o# :$+" +" *"

#"$$"$ * o%* +" 9o*+",*o#$ o9"$ "#" *o+ ":"*

o9+" * +" -#",$"$ * "*9" +" *o+9" 9o% *o+ /"

$"#:" %-o* +" #"$-o*"*+$.

4. A"* % $o/""*9" o +$ Co%#+$ O#"#

+" 27.01.2006 -"++o*"# $ " +$ Co*+",-+ P"++o*

9o*+"** ++ *$-+" o $-"99 %*"#+


5/22

5. P"# 9o*+# +" #"$-o*"*+ No.18N


6/22

#"*+. I+ $ #%" ++ +" +# -#+"$ o "#" * 9+%

-o$$"$$o* "#" *o+ ,-"" * +" $%+.

6. O*/" o +" -"++o*"# $ + $ $++" ++

/"9%$" o 9*" o +" #"$$"$ o +" #"$-o*"*+$ 9o%

*o+ ":"* $"#:" *o+9" o* +", * +" ""9%+o* -"++o*. O*

24.0>.2012 +$ Co%#+ #"9+" +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ +o "-"+"

+" "#* * $-o$" o +" ""9%+o* -#o9""*$. "* +"

,++"# 9," %- o# "#* o* 10.10.2014 "#*" 9o%*$" o#

-"++o*"# $%/,++" ++ *$-+" o #"9+o* :"* / +$ Co%#+

o* 24.0>.2012 +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ $ *o+ /""* /" +o ,


7/22

7. L"#*" S"*o# Co%*$" o# -"++o*"# %#" ++ *

+"#,$ o +" o#"# -$$" / +$ Co%#+ * SLP (C)

No.265412005 +" 27.01.2006 +" #"$-o*"*+89o,-*

$ o/" +o "-o$+ +" "*+#" ##"#$ o #"*+ * $%/,++"

++ +" #"$-o*"*+ No.2 $ *o+ "-o$+" o# - #"*+ +o +"

"9#""8o"# * +" #"$-o*"*+$ :" *o+ 9o,-" + ":"*

++ -#+ o +" #"9+o* * $++" ++ $ o* @0.11.2010

$%, o R$.>2@7=5>.11 $ -/" +o +" "9#""8o"# o* +"

-#*9-"$ o* * Jamshed Hormusji Wadia vs. Board of

Trustees, Port of Mumbai and Anr., (2004) @ SCC 214. O* ++

$%/,$$o* M#. S, D:* "#*" S"*o# Co%*$" o# +"

#"$-o*"*+$ $%/,++" ++ $%/;"9+ +o +" * o%+9o," o

+"$" -#o9""*$ +" 9o*+",*o#$ $ "-o$+ +" ,o%*+ o

R$.>2@7=5>.11 /"o#" +$ Co%#+ +* "+ ""


8/22

9+% -$9 -o$$"$$o* o +" -o+ o * * /%* *

++ $o," +# -#+"$ #" * 9+% -$9 -o$$"$$o* o +"

"$" -#o-"#+ * +"#"o#" +" "9#"" 9**o+ /" ""9%+".

O* ++ $%/,$$o* / * o#"# +" 10.10.2014 +$ Co%#+

$ #"9+" +" #"$-o*"*+$ +o " * +$ Co%#+ $+ o +"

o99%-*+$ * +" $-%+" -#o-"#+ 9 $ " / +"

#"$-o*"*+$ +"# o*.

=. T" 9o%#+ ""#9$* 9o*+",-+ ;%#$9+o* $

-#,# 9o*9"#*" + +" ?%"$+o* o 9o*+%,9o%$ 9o*%9+

o +" -#+ o $ "" +o :" 9o,,++" "%+ *

9o,-* + +" #"9+o*$ * +" ;%,"*+ o# o#"#. V"

Union of India & Ors. s. !ubedar "evass# P, 2006 (1) SCC

61@K. I+ $ ":"*+ #o, +" ,+"# o* #"9o# ++ +" $-%+"

/"+""* +" -#+"$ /""* ;%9+" * ++*"

*+ * + $ *o+ o-"* +o +" #"$-o*"*+$ +o o /"o* +"

o#"#$. A$ *o+9" "#"# "* +$ Co%#+ $,$$" +"

$-"9 ":" -"++o* / o#"# +" 27.01.2006 +"

#"$-o*"*+$ "#"* (-"++o*"# * +" $-"9 ":" -"++o*) "#"

#*+" o*" "# +," +o :9+" +" -#",$"$ * ?%"$+o*

$%/;"9+ +o +$ * %$% %*"#+


9/22

""


10/22

:+ * +" Co*+",-+ P"++o* +" #"$-o*"*+$ +"

/"*"+ o " :9" * " $o +" #"$-o*"*+$ #" *o+

;%$+" * +


11/22

+$ Co%#+ #*+" +," +o +" #"$-o*"*+$ o# * 9o%*+"#

:+. T"#"+"# Co*+",-+ P"++o* * 9," %- o#

"#* o* [email protected]=.201@.

1@. I* +" ,"*" o* 17.04.201@ * +" E"9%+o*

A--9+o* No. 5672010 * LE ' C S%+ No. @554>1 o 1=7>

S# G%-+ D#"9+o# o +" $"9o* #"$-o*"*+ 9o,-* "

9o%*+"# :+ (A**"%#" A81 -" No$. 1@78142) $++*

++ +" +# -#+"$ #" * o99%-+o* o +" /%* * ++

+" " $%+ /"* S%+ No. 456= o 2004 *$+ M$

Jo#, D":-#$ ' O#$. o# ":9+o* * #"$-"9+ o +"

-o#+o* o +" /%* 9o*$+#%9+" o* +" $%+ -#o-"#+ * +"

$ $%+ $ -"** o# +#. I* +" $ 9o%*+"# :+ + $

$o :"##" ++ +" $ "$$""$ M$. Jo#, D":-#$

* o+"#$ #" * o99%-+o* o ,o#" +* o +"

9o*$+#%9+" /%* * +" "$$""$ $%/8"+ +" o+"#

-#",$"$ +o +" +# -#+"$ o #" * 9+% -o$$"$$o* o

+" #",** -o#+o* * +" #o%* oo# #$+ oo# * $"9o*

oo#. I* "# :+ S# G%-+ %#+"# :"##" ++ +"

-"++o*"#!o# o T#%$+""$ o +" Po#+ o M%,/ (o# $o#+

3Po#+ T#%$+) *":"# " $%+ o# ,*+o# *;%*9+o* o#

11


12/22

:9+* * ** o:"# o /%* * $-+" o +" 9+ ++

+"#" $ /%* #" * "$+"*9" -#o# +o * o +"

":9+o* $%+ *$+ +" #"$-o*"*+$ * +"#"o#" +o%+

"9#"" o# ,*+o# *;%*9+o* o# #",** -#+ o +"

/%* +" /%* 9**o+ /" #",o:" * +" "9#"" $

*""9%+/".

14. U-o* 9o*$"#+o* o +" $ o/;"9+o*$ * $o

9o*+"*+o* o +" Po#+ T#%$+ +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ Co%#+ o

S, C%$"$ o !o,/ -$$" "+" o#"# +"

10.11.2014 (A**"%#" A85 -" No$. 146814>) * #"9+"

$$%*9" o -o$$"$$o* ##*+ %*"# O#"# I R%" @5 CPC

* #"$-"9+ o +" $%+ -#",$"$. T" $ o#"# #"$ $ %*"#8

.T" ""**+$ :" $-"99 %*"#+


13/22

15. I,,"+" +* 9o%-" o $ .". o*

14.11.2014 S# G%-+ D#"9+o# o +" $"9o* #"$-o*"*+

Co,-* " -"++o* /"o#" +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ +o $+ +"

o#"# +" 10.11.2014 (A**"%#" A86 -" No$. 14=8150)

$++* ++ +" ;%,"*+ "/+o#$ #" *+"** +o -#""#

#":$o* *$+ +" o#"# +" 10.11.2014 -$$" / +"

""9%+* 9o%#+. O* ++ --9+o* :" o#"# +"

15.11.2014 (A**"%#" A87 -" No$. 1518152) ""9%+* 9o%#+

$+" +$ o* o#"# o ":"# o -o$$"$$o* +" 10.11.2014.

T" $ o#"# #"$ $ %*"# 8

@. H"# /o+ -#+"$. P"#%$" #"9o# * -#o9""*.Co*$"#* +" 9+$ + $ *o+" ++ o* 10.11.2014 -o$$"$$o*##*+ * #"$-"9+ o $%+ -#",$"$ $ $$%" %*"# O#"# 21R%" @5 o C.P.C. T" ""**+ *+"*" +o 9"*" $o#"# o# * R":$o* /"o#" A--" Co%#+. T" $-%+"*:o:" * +$ ,++"# $ * #"$-"9+ o -o$$"$$o* o ,,o:/"-#o-"#+. T"#"o#" + $ *"9"$$# +o :" +" #"$o*/" +,"+o ""**+ +o 9"*" $ o#"# /"o#" --" 9o%#+. H"*9"o# +" *+"#"$+ o ;%$+9" ""9%+o* o -o$$"$$o* ##*+ $$+" o# @0 $.

16. I+ $ #"":*+ +o *o+" ++ * +" ,"*" o*

10.10.2014 "* +" Co*+",-+ P"++o* 9," %- o# "#*

/"o#" +$ Co%#+ "#*" S"*o# Co%*$" o# +" -"++o*"#Po#+

T#%$+ $%/,++" ++ +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ $ *o+ /""* /" +o

,


14/22

$ *o+ /""* 9o8o-"#+* * $ /""* :o* *o+9" $$%"

+o +. P"# 9o*+# "#*" S"*o# Co%*$" o# +" #"$-o*"*+$

$%/,++" ++ +" ;%,"*+ "/+o# 9o,-* $ /""*

--"#* * +" ""9%+* -"++o* * $ % #"-#"$"*+" /

9o%*$" * + * #+" " %*"#+oo< o* /" o +"

#"$-o*"*+$ ++ ;%,"*+8"/+o# Co,-* o% "*+"#

--"#*9" /"o#" +" ""9%+* 9o%#+. !$" o* +"

$%/,$$o*$ " #"9+" +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ +o "-"+" +"

""9%+o* o +" "9#"" -$$" * :o%# o +" -"++o*"#8"9#""

o"# * $%/,+ #"-o#+ +o +$ Co%#+ /"o#" +" *"+ +" o

"#*. F%#+"# +" #"$-o*"*+$ "#" #"9+" +o "-o$+

$%, o R$.>2@7=5>.118 /"o#" +$ Co%#+ * +" "#"

$o #"9+" +o #",* -#"$"*+ * +$ Co%#+ o* +" *"+ +" o

"#* .". o* 11.12.2014.

17. I+ $ + ++ ;%*9+%#" o* #"* +" $"#o%$*"$$

o +" $+%+o* +" $"9o* #"$-o*"*+ " -"++o* o*

24.11.2014 (A**"%#" A8> P" No$. 15@8155) /"o#" +"

""9%+* 9o%#+ -#* o# +#* +" --9+o* o# $+

* $o o# :9+* +" $+ o#"# +" 15.11.2014 -$$"

/ +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ o* +"# o* --9+o*. T" #$+

14


15/22

#"$-o*"*+ "#"* $o%+ +o +# +" $+ --9+o*

%*"# +" -#"+"+ ++ +" $ --9+o* $ ," under a

mis+on+etion and ithout +onsent of -i(hi* uta, a +o/dire+tor

of +oman#0. ! -"#%$ o +" #"9o#$ + $ $""* ++ * "#

:+ " * +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ (A**"%#" A81 -" No$.

1@78142) S# G%-+ $*" +" :+ $++* ++ $" $

+" D#"9+o# o +" ;%,"*+8"/+o# 9o,-* * ++ $" $

%+o#" +o " +" #"- :+ o*/" o +"

;%,"*+8"/+o# 9o,-*. " + $ *o+


16/22

o/+** * /"*"+ $o% *o+ /" /#"9" %. T"

#"$-o*"*+$ 9**o+ /" /$o:" o +" %*"#+


17/22

$ o#"# #"$-o*"*+$ :" " $+ o +o$" o99%-*+$ $

%*"#8

(r.No.

Na!e o% Teat Portio o% B#ildi$ occ#pied

1. M$ Jo#, D":-#$(-#+*"#$- #,)

M;o# -o#+o* o #o%* oo#--#o. 2500 $?. ""+ o 9#-"+ #"

2. C.&. I*%$+#"$ P:+. L+. R",*"# -o#+o* o +" #o%*oo# --#o. 700 $?. +. * "*+#"1$+ oo#("9"-+ +"##9" #oo, * o9"9/*) ,"$%#* --#o. 1500 $?.""+

@. G%+, &. !#+ 1$+ oo# +"##9" #oo, * o9"

9/* ,"$%#* /o%+ @50 $?. ""+4. F, o L+" !9*$*

R+O*" #oo, o --#o. 150 $?. +. o*+" 2* oo# * -#+ o o-"*+"##9"

5. J+- &, 200 $?. ""+ * #" #oo, o* +"#o%* oo# o +" /%*

6. H# S* #$.5) S,+. R;"$# !9* S* R+ >2 #$.6) S# &,"$ S* D":"*# R+ 20 #$.7) S,+. N* R;% Doo,* 2> #$.>) S,+. M*;% &%$ S* R* 70 #$.=) S# P#,o !#, P+ 5@ #$.

17


18/22

21. I* +" #"- :+ " / #$+ #"$-o*"*+8N


19/22

o# +# o $+ -"++o* " * +" ""9%+* 9o%#+

(A**"%#" A8> -" No$. 15@8155) 9 $ " / S#

G%+, $* !#+ A:o9+" o# +" #"$-o*"*+$. T"

o#"# +" 25.11.2014 o +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ (A**"%#" A8=

-" No$. 15>815=) + $ $""* ++ M$ !#+ ' Co. $ +"

:o9+" o# +" ;%,"*+ "/+o#. G%+, $* !#+ o

$ $++" +o /" *o+"# o/$+#%9+o*$+ $ *o*" o+"# +* +"

:o9+" o# +" #"$-o*"*+$.

2@. A +" o/$+#%9+o*$+$ :" " o/;"9+o*$ /"o#"

+" ""9%+* 9o%#+ 9o*+"** ++ +" "9#"" $ *""9%+/"

$ +"#" $ *o #"9+o* +o #",o:" +" "$+* /%* * *

+" /$"*9" o * $%9 #"9+o* +" o/$+#%9+o*$+$ 9**o+

/" #",o:". I* +" ,o*+ o J%*" 2015 o*" V; C,*

G%-+ D#"9+o# o M$ C.&. I*%$+#"$ P:+. L+. " :+ o

o/;"9+o* /"o#" +" ""9%+* 9o%#+ * +" o/;"9+o*$ / o+"#

o/$+#%9+o*$+$ #" o* +" $," *"$. " , %$"% #""# +o

+" #"":*+ :"#,"*+$ * +" $ :+8

6. I $ ++ +" P*+$ o* +" /$$ o "9#"" o/+*"

*$+ +" ""**+$ o# :9*+ $+" 9* *o+ #",o:" +"

O/$+#%9+o*$+ #o, +" /%* $ +"#" $ *o #"9+o* o#

"++* -o$$"$$o* o /%* * +" "9#"" *$+ +" -"#$o*$

o #" *o+ -#+"$ +o +" $%+.

19


20/22

7. I $ ++ +" P*+$ #" *o+ o*"#$ o +" /%*.

T" O/$+#%9+o*$+$ #" * -o$$"$$o* o +" /%* * +"#

o* #+. E:"* P*+$ 9, o*"#$- o /%* o* +"

/$$ o +" "9#"" -$$" * #"$-"9+ o :9*+ $+" +"* +"

"9#"" -$$" %*"# S"9+o* 41 o P#"$"*9 S, C%$"$ A9+

/"9o," *% * :o * +" $," 9* *o+ /" ""9%+"

*$+ +" O/$+#%9+o*$+ $ +" /%* * 9 " #"

o99%-* $ 9o:"#" / R"*+ A9+ * +" "9#"" -$$" *$+

+" D""**+$ 9* *o+ /" ""9%+" *$+ %$. H"*9" +"

"9#"" -$$" * :o%# o P*+$ $ " *: * 9*

*o+ /" ""9%+".

24. I+ $ -"#+*"*+ +o *o+" ++ + +" +," "* +"

$-"9 ":" -"++o* $ $,$$" :* +," +o +"

#"$-o*"*+$ +o :9+" +" #"$-o*"*+$ *":"# #$" +" -"

++ +" +# -#+"$ #" * o99%-+o* o +" -#",$"$ *

++ +" 9**o+ /" #",o:" #o, +" /%*. I+ $ #"":*+ +o

*o+" ++ * +" "$" "" + $ 9"# ,"*+o*" ++ + +"

"-#+o* o# $oo*"# "+"#,*+o* o +"#, o +" "$" +"

"$$"" $ #",o:" +" /%* $+** o* +" ",$" *$

* +" ":"*+ ?%"+ ":"# %-+o +" T#%$+""$ +" $ ",$"

-#",$"$ +o"+"# + /%* +"#"o* * oo 9o*+o*. I*

+"#,$ o +" "$" * $o $ -"# +"# %*"#+


21/22

25. T" #"$-o*"*+$ o "#" +" "$$""$ "#" o"

+o 9o*+*%" * +" ",$" -#",$"$. I+ $ *o+


22/22

() T" Co,,$$o*"# o Po9" M%,/ $ #"9+" +o

#"*"# $$$+*9" +o +" / * ""9%+o* o +"

##*+ o -o$$"$$o* * "*$%#" ++ +" :9*+

-o$$"$$o* o +" "*+#" -#",$"$ $ *" o:"# +o +"

-"++o*"# Po#+ T#%$+.() O/$+#%9+o*$+$ $ 9o8o-"#+" * +" ""9%+o* o

+" ##*+ o -o$$"$$o*. O/$+#%9+o*$+$ #" + /"#+

+o --#o9 +$ Co%#+ o# #"#"$$ o +"# #":*9"$

*.

27. T" ""9%+* 9o%#+ $ $%/,+ #"-o#+ +o +$

Co%#+. L$+ +" Co*+",-+ P"++o* +"# +#"" ,o*+$.

J.

(T.S. THA&UR)

J.

(V. GOPALA GODA)

J.

(R. !ANUMATHI)

N" D"BA%%$+ 25 2015

breach of undertaking attracts contempt of court (read the judgment)

Documents