brand trade mark protection in a new digital age - iaf.nu - ipta presentation.pdf · .brand trade...
TRANSCRIPT
.brandTrade Mark Protection in a New
Digital Age
Adrian KinderisChief Executive Officer
AusRegistry International
IPTA Seminar, Sydney
26th October 2010
Agenda
• Speaker Profile
• Introduction to new gTLDs
• Top Level Protection
• Second Level Protection
• ICANN Trade Mark Protection Evolution
• The Application
• The Options
• The Benefits
• Next Steps
• Questions
Adrian Kinderis
• Co-Founder & CEO of AusRegistry Group
– AusRegistry – operator of the .au ccTLD since 2002
– AusRegistry International – Domain Name Registry Services Provider
• Member of the Generic Names Supporting Organisation (GNSO) Council within ICANN since 2007
• Contributor to the “birth” of the new gTLD program
• Veteran of the internet community
What are TLDs? (Top-Level Domain Names)
21 gTLDs, including
• .com
• .org
• .net
• .info
• .biz
• .asia
• .edu
• .gov
• .jobs
• .mobi
• .museum
• .travel
example.com
Generic TLD (gTLD)
What are TLDs? (Top-Level Domain Names)
248 ccTLDs, including
• .au
• .nz
• .uk
• .fr
• .de
• .it
• .ru
• .jp
• .cn
• .hk
• .id
• .in
• .kh
example.com.au
Country Code TLD (ccTLD)
ICANN
• Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers
• Not-For-Profit Public Benefit Organisation
• Foundational principle to promote choice and competition while ensuring Internet security and stability.
1988-1998
• First gTLDs open for registration
• .com .edu .gov .mil .org .net .int
2001-2002
• Second round of gTLDs released
• .aero .biz .coop .info .museum .name .pro
2004
• Third round of gTLDs released
• .asia .cat .jobs .mobi .tel .travel
New gTLD Program
• In 2005, GNSO initiated policy development process for the introduction of new gTLDs
• The policy was completed by the GNSO in 2007, and adopted by ICANN's Board in June 2008
• In 2010, ICANN Board expected to sign off on new gTLD program
The Future
Geographic TLDs.sydney
.london
Generic TLDs.web
.home
Community TLDs.redcross
.scouts
Corporate TLDs.anz
.ibm
21 gTLDs.com
.net
248 ccTLDs.au
.nz
The Future
21 gTLDs.com
.net
248 ccTLDs.한국어
.简体中文版
Geographic TLDs
. Сидней.الكشافة
Generic TLDs.لعب
. финансы
Community TLDs.简体中文版
.كرة المضرب
Corporate TLDs.بيبسي
. מחשב
Internationalised Domain Names (IDNs)
Trade Mark Protection
• The internet addressing system allows for 3 levels of domain names:
– www.good.example.com
• These levels are broken down as follows:
– Top Level = .com
– Second Level = example .com
– Third Level = good.example.com
Current Situation
• Top Level
– No Trade Mark protection requirement• No gTLDs that infringe
• Generic Words
• Second Level
– Significant issues• WIPO
• Third Level
– Currently no level of protection
Protection at the Top Level
• The application to ICANN consists of questions to determine reputable operation of the gTLD:
– Proof of good standing
– Background information on Directors, Officers, Partners and Shareholders• Must indicate if been involved in cybersquatting or domain name
related abuse
– Applicants must describe proposed policies and procedures to minimise abusive registrations and negative activity• Safeguards and complaint handling policies
• Description of takedown or suspension systems
Protection at the Top Level
• Public review of Applications– ICANN will post applications for 45 days for public comment and a
summary will be provided to evaluators to conduct their own analysis
• Formal objection process– Will open once applications are published
– Likely open for 5 months
– Objections lodged with dispute resolution service providers (DRSPs)
– 4 types of objections• String contention
• Community
• Morality & Public Order
• Legal Rights
Risks at the Top level
• Multiple organisations can apply for the same or similar name provided the use of the name is consistent with Trade Mark law– E.g. an apple growing organisation can apply for .apple as long as it is not
used in the context of selling computers
• A community group with the same name will be given precedence (community priority)
• If multiple organisations apply and both meet all criteria then an auction will be used to select an organisation to operate the TLD
• Once a name is approved then a confusingly similar name would not be allowed – E.g. if .com exists, .kom may not be allowed
No-one else applies for your brand
Another eligible organisation applies for your brand
Another ineligibleorganisation applies for your brand
Apply for .brand You will acquire .brand providing no valid objections are provided by the community
There would be an auction between all eligible parties providing no valid objections are provided by the community
You will need to object against the other applicant and win or risk that applicant obtaining your .brand
Do not apply for .brand Your .brand is not allocated by ICANN and unclear when/if available again
Another eligible organisation will win your .brand and own it forever
You will need to object against the other applicant and win or risk that applicant obtaining your .brand
Top Level Summary
Irrespective of size or reach of trademarks, ‘eligible’ means anyone with any trademark or legal right to the mark in any country, jurisdiction or industry
Protection at the Second level• A new gTLD must provide pre-launch rights protection
mechanisms (RPMs) that cover either:
– Sunrise Period• Provides Trade Mark holders with a first right to register
• Trade Mark Clearinghouse – central database to store authenticated information for all new gTLD registries
• Substantive evaluation will occur either at registration or at validation and is required on absolute grounds AND use of the mark
– Trade Mark Claims Service• Provides information to a potential registrant of Trade Mark rights
that exist on the particular name
• Trade Mark holders have no additional right over non Trade Mark
holders
Protection at the Second Level• Uniform Rapid Suspension (URS)
– The URS gives a trademark holder the ability to make a complaint around a Domain Name that infringes on its trademark
– The registrant of the domain is notified and the URS provider will advise the Registry to have the domain locked within 24 hours, however it remains online and still viewable
– The registrant has 14 days to respond with their defense
– If appeal upheld, name is suspended for the duration of its registration
– If appeal dismissed, name is unlocked and returns to it’s normal state
– Then determination of eligibility is made purely on the materials submitted by both parties – no hearing will take place
• Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) – existing policy
– Results in cancellation of the domain or transfer of the domain name to the complainant
Other Rights Protection Mechanisms
• Post-delegation
– Trade Mark Post-Delegation Dispute Resolution Procedure (PDDRP)• Used to manage situations where a new gTLD operator violates
trademarks at the top level after being allocated the gTLD, or is encouraging systemic cyber-squatting within the gTLD
– Registry Restrictions Dispute Resolution Procedure (RRDRP)• Intended for use where a community-based restricted gTLD registry
operator was not meeting its obligations to police the registration and use of domains within the restrictions stated in the terms of its gTLD registry agreement
Objection Fees
• Dispute Resolution Filing Fee
– A non refundable filing fee of USD1,000 – USD5,000 must accompany
any formal objection or objection response
• Additional Fees
– Additional fees are then payable directly to the applicable dispute
resolution service provider
– Any appeals process would incur a fee payable by the appellant
Risks at the Second Level
• Process required by Trade Mark holders:
– Review each of the new gTLDs
– Decide whether they are related or unrelated to the brand
– On related gTLDs, assess the risk and rate in relation to level of restriction and likely take up
– Analyse the risk rating for each new gTLD and decide protection in order of importance to the brand and company
No-one else registers your brand name
Another eligible person/organisation registers your brand
Another ineligibleperson/organisation registers your brand
Protect your brand in other gTLDs
You will acquire your brand domain name
If they have legal rights then you will lose the opportunity to own that domain name
You will need file a URS or UDRP against the registrant and win or risk them owning your brand Domain Name
Do not protect your brand in other gTLDs
Your brand domain name will remain unregistered
Another eligible organisation will successfully register your brand name
You will need file a URS or UDRP against the registrant and win or risk them owning your brand Domain Name
Second Level Summary
ICANN & Trade Mark Protection
• In the first Draft Applicant Guidebook (DAG):– Trade Mark protection was limited to simple legal rights objections and
the current UDRP process
• In the second version of the DAG:– Extended the protection to unregistered marks
• In the third version of the DAG:– Protection extended to eligibility and the PDDRP process
• In the fourth version of the DAG:– Saw the inclusion of the Trade Mark Clearing House, the URS System and
other RPMs
Implementation Recommendation Team (IRT)• In 2009, ICANN assembled a group of experienced Trade Mark
protection specialists who examined and discussed the ideas such as:– IP Clearinghouse
– Globally Protected Trade Marks List
– URS
– Post delegation dispute mechanisms
– Other Rights Protection Mechanisms
– Whois requirements for new gTLDs
– String confusion
Latest Information
In October 2010, The World Trademark Review published these finding of its exclusive survey:
Almost 50% of Trade Mark Lawyers surveyed believe that new gTLDs
are a “good business opportunity
Over 50% of those surveyed support
the Uniform Rapid Suspension System
(URS)
Application process
• Each new gTLD application will be subject to:
– US$185,000 application fee
– 50 questions requiring detailed answers in relation to:• Technical capability – IPv6, DNSSEC, etc
• Financial capability
• Business Operations
– Rigorous external review by industry experts
– Substantial financial resources needed for operation
– Financial guarantees
The Options - Summary
Top Level Protection Second Level Protection
Apply offensively for your .brand and maximise the opportunity
Monitor the new gTLD program
Don’t apply for your .brand and avoid the program altogether
Develop internal strategy as to the most relevant new gTLDs to register your Trade
Mark in
Apply defensively for your .brand simply to protect your Trade Mark
Register your Trade Mark in all new gTLDs
Avoid the program altogether
The Benefits• Customers
Engage with your Customers and increase stickiness by offering personalised content and targeted loyalty programs
• FutureProtect your brand, create an identity and change the game forever with a new gTLD
• SecurityWith a .brand TLD you have the keys to the car and you can drive it how you like,
anytime you like and anywhere you like.
• MarketingIt will change the way we all access and utilise the web whilst driving recall and
efficiency of marketing message
johnsmith.telstra
my.myer
secure.westpac
tigerwoods.nike