bnl stores

6
Scanned by CamScanner 9 B 1 2 B 0 2 7 B N L S T O R E S P a u C n z w o a h s C S O u n o h o p o v o n o P o u s o V n u h R a d c o s o e y o p o v d e m a e a o c a s d s c u s s o n T h e a h o s d o o n e n d o a o o o o c v o o n o o e v o h a n d n g o a m o n o g e e u a o n T h e a u h o s m a y h a v e d g u e d c o n o s n d o h o d o y n g o m a o n o p o o c c o n o n y T s P u b c a o n m a y n o b o t m n s m . i l o d p h o o c o p o d d g e d o o h o w e e p o d u c e d n a n y o m o b y a n y m e a n s w h o u h e p e m s s o n o h o c o p y g h h o d e R e p o d u c o n o h m a o a n o c o v e e d u n d e a u h o z a o n b y a n y e p o d u c o n g h s o g a n z a o n T o o d e c o p e s o e q u e s p o m s o n o e p o d u c e m a o a s c o n a c v e y P u b s h n g v e y B u s n e s s S c h W e s e n U n v e s y L o n d o n O n a o C a n a d a N C o p y g h © F R c h a a E n S c h o o o ß s n o s s F o u n d a o n V e o n 2 0 1 0 4 2 n h c s p n g o r 2 0 0 P a C m z w a s a b u s n s s s u d e n w h o h a d u s s a r d a n a c c o u n n g c o u r s e A s a n n r o d u c o y a s s g n m e n h s p r o e s s o r h a d g v e n h c e a c h s u d e n h c a s k o f a n a y z n g h e n a n c a s a e m e n s o r a c o m p a n y o f h c r c h o o s n g F o r h s a n a y s s C r u z s e e c e d B N L S o r s b e c a u s e w a s o n e o f h s h v o r e p a c e s o s h o p + o w e v e r r e c e n y h c h a d r e a d n h c b u s n e s s p r e s s h a B N L s s o c k h a d f a e n d a m a c a y d r o p p n g f r o m a h g h o f $ 0 0 p c s h a e o e s s h a n $ o d e s p e h c a c h a h c o m p a n y w a s k n o w n o p a y o u r e a v e y c o n s a n d v d e n d s o s s h a r e h o d e r s B N L w a s a n e s a b s h e d M d w s e m r e a e r h a h a d b e e n n b u s n e s s o r o v e r 4 0 y e a r s n r e c e n m e s m a n a g e m n h a d u n d e r a k e n a s e r e s o f n e w b u s n e s s s r a e g e s o n e o f w h c h w a s o e x p a n d h e n u m b e r o f B N L s n e w s u p e r c e n e r s o r e s w h e p h a s n g o u h e r a d o n a d s c o u n s o r s T h e s u p e r c e n e r s o r e s c a r r e d a g r e a e r s e e c o n o f d u r a b e g o o d s s u c h a s a p p a n c e s a n d f u r n i t u r e n o d e r t o e n c e c u s o m e r s o p u r c h a s e h e s e m o r x p e n s v e e m s B N L h a d s a r e d o r i n g s o r e c r e d o s c u s o m e r s E a c h n d v d u a s o r e m a n a g e r w a s r e s p o n s b e o r a u h o r z n g h e o p n n g o f s o r e c r e d a c c o u n s a n d u m a y h a d h e f n a s a y a s o w h e h e r c r e a w o u d b e g r a n e d o a c u s o m e r S o r e m a n a g e r s w e r e p a d a n a n n u a b o n u s / a s e d o n n e n c o m e f o r h e r r e s p e c v e s o r e a n d w e r e k n o w n f o r b e n g q u e e n e n n g r a n n g c r e d t n o r d e r o n c r e a s e n e t n c o m e f o r h e y e a r a n d h e r e o e h e s z e o l h e r b o n u s C r u z w o n d r e d w h e h e r h e s e n e w s a e g e s w e r e r e s p o n s b e o r h e d e c n e n B N L s s h a r e p r c e w h c h h h a d r e a d a b o u t T o c o e c h e f n a n c a s a e m e n t n o r m a t o n h a h e r e q u n d o c o m p e e h s a s s g n m e n h e w e n * o h e b u s n e s s c h o o l b r a y o b a n e d B N L s b a a n c e s h e e s s a e m e n s o f n c o m e a n d s a e m e n t [ o f c a s h f o w s o r h e f s c a y e a r s e n d m g 2 0 0 2 w o u g h 2 0 0 7 H o w e v e r f o r 2 0 0 8 o 2 0 0 h w a s a b e t o o b a n n c o m e h e b a a n c e s h e e s s t a t e m e n s o f c o m e b u n o s a e m e n s o f c a s h f o w s ( s e e E x h b 1 2 a n d 3 ) T h s c a s e h a s b e e n w H e p e a o n a n d p e s p e c v e s p e s e n e d n h s c a s e a @ 1 d

Upload: roger

Post on 06-Feb-2016

26 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Accounting

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: BNL Stores

Scanned by CamScanner

9B1

2B027

BNL STORES

Pau

Cn

z

wo

a

h

s

C

SO

un

o

ho

po

v

on

o

P

o

us

o

Vn

uh

Ra

dc

o

soe

y

op

ov

de

ma

e

a

o

c

a

s

d

scuss

on

The

a

ho

s

do

o

n

end

o

a

o

o

o

oc

vo

o

no

oe

vo

hand

ng

o

a

monoge

e

ua

on

The

au

ho

s

may

have

d

gu

ed

co

n

os

ndo

ho

do

y

ng

o

ma

on

o

p

o

oc

con

on

y

T

s

Pu

b

ca

on

may

no

bo

tmnsm.ilod

pho

ocop

od

d

g

ed

o

o

ho

w

e

ep

oduce

d

n

any

o

mo

by

any

means

w

hou

he

pe

mss

on o

ho copy

gh

ho

de

Rep

oduc

on o

h

ma

o

a

no

cove

ed un

de

au

ho

za

on

by any

ep

oduc

on

gh

s

o

gan

za

on

To

o

de

copes

o

eques

po

ms

on

o

ep

oduce

ma

o

a

s

con

ac

vey

Pu

b

sh

ng

vey

Bus

ness

Sch

Wes

e

n

Un

ve

s

y

London

On

a

o

Cana

da

N

Copy

gh

©FRc

ha

aEnSc

hoo

o

ß

s

noss

Foun

da

on

Ve

on

20104

2

n

hc sp

ng

or

20

0

Pa

Cmz was

a

bus

n

ss

s

uden

who

ha

d

us

s

ar

d an

accoun

ng

course

As

an

n

ro

duc

o

y ass

gnmen

h

s pro

essor

had g

ven

hc eac

h

s

uden

hc

as

k o

f ana

yz

ng

he

nanc

a

s

a

emen

s o

r

a

company

of

hc

r

choos

ng

For

h

s ana

ys

s

C

ruz se

ec

ed BNL S

or

s

because

was one o

f

h

s

hvor

e p

aces

o s

hop

+owever

recen

y

hc

ha

d

rea

d

n

hc

bus

ness

press

ha

BNL

s s

oc

k h

ad f

a

en

d

ama

ca

y

dropp

ng

from a

h

gh

of

$

00 pc

s

ha

e

o

ess

han

$

o

d

esp

e

hc

ac

ha

h

company was

known

o pay ou

re

a

ve

y

cons

an

d

v

den

ds

o

s

share

ho

ders

BNL was an es

ab

sh

ed Mdw

s

emre

a

er

ha

ha

d

been

n

bus

ness

or

over

40 years

n

recen

mes

managem

n

h

ad un

der

ak

en a ser

es o

f

new

bus

ness s

ra

eg

es

one o

f

wh

ch was

o expan

d

he num

ber

of BNL

s new supercen

er s

ores

w

h

e p

has

ng ou

he

ra

d

ona

d

scoun

s

or

s

The supercen

er

s

ores carr

ed a grea

er se

ec

on o

f

dura

b

e goo

ds

suc

h

as app

ances an

d furniture

n o

der

to en

ce

cus

omers

o purc

hase

hese

mor

xpens

ve

ems

BNLha

d

s

ar

ed

oring

s

ore cre

d

o

s cus

omers

Eac

h

nd

v

dua

s

ore manager

was respons

b

e

or au

hor

z

ng

he op

n

ng o

f

s

ore cre

d

accoun

s an

d

u

ma

y

ha

d

he

f

na

say as

o w

he

her cre

a wou

d be gran

ed

o a cus

omer

S

ore managers were

pa

d

an annua

bonus

/ase

d on ne

ncome

for

he

r respec

ve s

ore

an

d were

known

for

be

ng qu

e

en

en

n gran

ng cre

d

t

n or

der

o

ncrease ne

t

ncome

for

he year an

d

here

o

e

he s

ze o

l

he

r

bonus

Cruz won

d

re

d

whe

her

hese

news

a

eg

es

were

respons

b

e

or

he

dec

ne

n

BNL

s

sh

are

pr

ce

wh

ch

h

ha

d

rea

d a

bou

t

To co

ec

he

f

nanc

a

s

a

emen

t

n

orma

t

on

ha

he requ

nd

o comp

e

e

h

s

ass

gnmen

he wen

*

o

he

bus

ness

chool

bray

o

b

a

ne

d BNL

s

ba

ance s

hee

s

s

a

emen

s o

f

ncome

an

d

s

a

emen

t[

ofcas

h f

ows

or

he

f

sca

years en

dmg

2002

woug

h 2007

However

for

2008

o

20

0

h

was a

b

eto

ob

a

n

ncome

he

ba

ance

shee

s

s

ta

temen

s

of

come

bu

no

s

a

emen

s o

f

cas

h f

ows

(see

Ex

h

b

1

2

an

d

3)

Ths case

has

been w

H

e

p

e

a

on an

d

pe

spec

ves

p

esen

ed

n

h

s

case

a

@

1

d

Page 2: BNL Stores

Scanned by CamScanner

P a g e 2 9 B 1 2 B 0 2 7

A r m e d w i t h th e s e f i n a n c ia l s t a t e m e n t s a n d t h e i n f o r m a t i o n h e h a d l ( : a r n e d i n t h c c o u r s e t h u s f a r,

C r u z

c a lc u l a t e d t h « : f o l l o w i n g f i n a n c ia l r a t i o s (s e (: E x h ib i t 4 )

Q u e s t i o n

C a l c u l a t « : t h c 10 r a t i o s d o n c : i n E x h ib i t 4 f o r e a c h y e a r f r o m 2 0 0 8 t o 20 10 D o y o u n o t i c e a n y t r e n d s ?

W h a t i n s i g h t s d o t h e s e t r e n d s p r o v id e i n t o t h« : o p e r a t io n s o f B N L ?

Q u e s t i o n 2

F o l lo w in g t h c f o r m a t g i v e n i n E x h ib i t 3, p r c : p a r e s t a t i : m e n t s o r c a s h n o w s f o r B N L fo r e a c h y e a r f r o m

2 0 0 8 t o 2 0 10 P l e a s e u s e t h c f o l l o w i n g f i gu r e s f o r th c a dd i t io n s t o p r o p e r ty , p l a n t a n d (: q u i p m e n t :

2 0 0 8 2 0 09 2 0 10

(In c r e a s e ) o r d e c r e a s e in - p la n t a n d e q u ip m e n t (17 7 9 m (154, 7 (9W

Q u e s t i o n 3

w Da t d o t h e c a s h f l o w s t a t e m e n t s s h o w W ha t d o e s th i s m e a n f o r t h e fu t u r e v i a b i l i t y o f th c f i m n ? H o w

h e lp f u l i s t h i s a n a ly s i s in u n de r s t a n d in g t he c o m p a n y'

s s t o c k p r i c e p e r f o r m a n c e ?

Page 3: BNL Stores

Scanned by CamScanner

Page 4: BNL Stores

Scanned by CamScanner

Page 5: BNL Stores

Scanned by CamScanner

Page 6: BNL Stores

Scanned by CamScanner