assignment 1 - journal done

Upload: ggleichgesinnten

Post on 09-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    1/15

    Automation & Robotic

    Assignment 1-Journal

    (Automation in Constuction)

    A development of next

    generation intelligent

    construction liftcar toolkit for

    vertical material movementmanagement

    Name : Mohamad Aliff Mohd Sahimi

    ID : 7697

  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    2/15

    A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical

    material movement management

    Chang-Yeon Cho a,1, Soonwook Kwon c,, Tae-Hong Shin b,2, Sangyoon Chin c,3, Yea-Sang Kim c,3

    a Korea Institute of Construction Technology, Goyang 411-712, South Koreab Samsung SDS., Seoul 135-918, South Koreac Dept. of Civil, Architectural, and Environmental System Engineering, Sungkyunkwan Univ., Suwon 400-746, South Korea

    a b s t r a c ta r t i c l e i n f o

    Article history:Accepted 3 May 2010

    Available online xxxx

    Keywords:

    Construction lift

    Material management

    USN

    RFID

    Wireless sensing

    Material movement

    High-rise construction sites, especially those situated in spatially-constrained urban areas, have difficultiesin timely delivery of materials. IT-driven management techniques can be further benefited from state-of-the-

    art devices such as Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) tags and Ubiquitous Sensor Networks (USN), which

    have resulted in notable achievements in automated logistics management at the construction sites.

    Based on those achievements, this research develops USN hardware toolkits for hoists, which aims to

    automate the vertical material delivery by sensing the material information and routing it automatically to

    the right place. The gathered information from the sensors can also be used for monitoring the overall status.

    To support the system, a hoist-mountable intelligent toolkit was developed. Its feasibility test was conducted

    by applying the implemented system to a test bed and then analyzing efficiency of the system and the

    toolkit.

    2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

    1. Introduction

    Unlike other industries where single standard manufacturing

    process can be applied to a batch of production items, each

    construction project requires its own production process highly

    customized to individual project characteristics. As a result, each

    construction project has a unique, flexible logistics process for

    procurement of materials [4]. Therefore, planning of a supply chain

    management system should be flexible, which would accommodate

    highly variable project environment, from large-scale urban renovation

    to high-rise building construction [3].

    In such environment, where only limited number of material

    lifting equipments are available, careful planning for the operation

    of the equipments is needed for efficient logistics management

    in construction site [13,19]. According to the precedent re-

    search [1,2,6], it was indicated that the efficiency of the lifting

    equipments varies with regards to the building height, and that

    planning of the material lifting affects the overall duration of the

    construction; furthermore, increased building height would lead to

    exponential increase of the information to be managed such as

    scheduling and cost, let alone the increased material quantity.

    Especially in construction sites in spatially-constrained urban

    areas, planning and managing the logistics of the materials directlyaffect the construction schedule and the cost; if a problem breaks

    out, it would trigger cascading problems in other parts in the

    project which would result in production delays and cost overrun.

    Many techniques such as Six Sigma, JIT (just-in-time production),

    Lean Construction have been applied to the area in order to

    improve its efficiency; however, the industry demands automated

    system for the management tasks, which have progressed rather

    slowly [1,2].

    This paper describes the development of an intelligent lift car,

    which is a part of the multi-year national research project in

    development of the intelligent construction logistics system. The

    system under development utilizes remote sensing and communi-

    cation technologies such as RFID (Radio Frequency Identification)

    and USN (Ubiquitous Sensor Network) to capture the information of

    material movement and to manage it in an intelligent manner. A

    toolkit (which consists of various sensors and wireless communi-

    cation modules) has been developed to convert existing lift cars into

    the intelligent ones easily. The new lift car is designed to increase

    the efficiency of vertical transportation, which is crucial for

    successful on-site logistics, and to improve information manage-

    ment related to it. Several field tests were conducted to assess the

    capability of the new lift car. Overall goal of the development effort

    is to propose a new alternative for the next generation construction

    sites where many parts of their jobs are automated and intelligently

    controlled.

    Fig. 1 illustrates overall procedure of our research work.

    Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Corresponding author. Tel.: +82 31 299 7578; fax: +82 31 290 7570.

    E-mail address: [email protected] (S. Kwon).1 Tel.: +82 31 910 0284; fax: +82 31 910 0114.2 Tel.: +82 2 3429 2114.3 Tel.: +82 31 299 7578; fax: +82 31 290 7570.

    AUTCON-01145; No of Pages 14

    0926-5805/$ see front matter 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

    doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

    Automation in Construction

    j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w. e l s e v i e r. c o m / l o c a t e / a u t c o n

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008mailto:[email protected]://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/09265805http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/09265805http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008mailto:[email protected]://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    3/15

    2. As-is construction supply chain management (CSCM)

    2.1. Precedent researches in CSCM

    This section reviews precedent researches in the construction

    supply chain management area we surveyed, which can be summa-

    rized as the followingparagraphs. An earlier version of this survey can

    also be seen in [1,2]. According to our survey, those past researches

    fall in one of the following categories:fi

    rst, enhancement of thelogistics management including application of new management

    theories; second, improvement of the material procurement; third

    (the last), adoption of new technology.

    For the third category (adoption of new technology), it was

    observed that the barcode-based systems were being replaced with

    RFID-based ones, and that development of the management system

    also reflected the transition for instance, utilization of the wireless

    communication and development of decision support models based

    on the new technology. When we narrow the scope down to vertical

    material movement (e.g., lift cars and cranes), the related researches

    may fall into the following categories:finding optimal arrangement of

    tower cranes [11,12], load distribution between the vertical move-

    ment equipments (for tower cranes, lift cars, and both) (Jung, 2004;

    [3,14]), and support system for the equipments [13,19].

    In [1,2], efficiency of high-speed construction lifts was analyzed.

    According to it, the time needed for single lift operation can be

    calculated as below:

    Time needed for a single lift=favg: lifting height m = lifting speed m =min

    2 round trip g + extra time needed for loading; unloading; etc:

    Cho also argued that reduction of the extra time would be the best

    tactic for improving efficiency of the lifting operation, if the

    mechanical performance was steady. It was also found that,

    considering their importance, there were surprisingly few researches

    on automated systems for monitoring movement of the construction

    materials via the lifting equipments as a part of the construction

    supply chain management.

    2.2. Precedent researches using RFID/USN technologies in CSCM

    Effi

    cientmanagement of the supplychains for constructionmaterialsis becoming more important as large-scale, high-rise projects are being

    common. Around the world, many research activities on this area are

    currently going on; among them, various practical approaches utilizing

    RFID/USN technology, which can prevent time consuming chores and

    potential mistakes in information handling by automatingmany parts of

    the CSCM process, have been introduced.

    In this section, precedent researches on application of the RFID/USN

    technology are reviewed.

    Among the state-of-the-arts, [15] showed a practical approach in

    engineered component tracking using RFID; in [16], a convergent

    approach that combines RFID with GPS (Global Positioning System)

    and wireless communication technology was proposed. Automated

    detection of the material location is another key research theme:

    [9,10,17,18] proposed computational models for localization of the

    RFID-tagged materials stored in a stockyard; also, attempts to use

    the tracking information for managerial operations such as produc-

    tivity analysis [7] and for progress management [5,8] have been

    made.

    2.3. Concept of next generation vertical transportation (and logistics)

    management

    Our research described in this paper aims to develop a construc-

    tion lift car toolkit-based on RFID/USN technology, to support vertical

    Fig. 1. Research procedures.

    2 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    4/15

    movement of the construction materials and works depending on

    them. The background researches of its development made by the

    authors were the development of the intelligent CSCM process [5]

    identification mechanism for inter-equipment material movement

    [4], and efficiency analysis of various construction lift types [1,2].

    In thecontext of our research, the term next generation intelligent

    CSCM automation system refers to the CSCMenvironment envisioned

    by the authors where RFID/USN technology is widely used for optimal

    management of the supply chain in construction projects frommaterial factories to construction sites, especially for large-scale

    projects such as high-rise buildings [4].

    The system will monitor overall flow of the construction materials

    from a production line to their destinations in a construction site and

    will be able to track current location of each material in real-time.

    Fig. 2 illustrates the concept of the vertical CSCM, which is the main

    objective of this research.

    The intelligent CSCM for vertical transportation of the construction

    materials consists of the following parts: a lift car equipped with RFID

    readers and necessary wireless communication functionality; an RFID

    reader-equipped intelligent mover (IM) that will load/unload the

    RFID-tagged materials to the lift car; a CSCM logistics management

    server that will provide the destination and quantity information of

    the transported material to the lift car; and a monitoring system

    which is responsible for the tracking current status of the material in

    real-time [1,2].

    At the construction site, whether given material is delivered to the

    right place in right time can be monitored in real-time via project

    management information system (PMIS); also, work progress

    compared to construction schedule can be determined from the

    monitored information. These aspects allow confidence in construction

    management as well as improved efficiency in CSCM.

    In this paper, we would like to propose a prototype of the

    intelligent construction lift, based on an easily-deployable toolkit

    which provides RFID reading capability and necessary wireless

    communication capability.

    3. Next generation intelligent construction liftcar

    toolkit architecture

    3.1. Performance requirements for the toolkit

    There are two categories for performance requirements of the new

    construction lift car with respect to the intelligent CSCM context:

    software requirements and hardware ones.

    For the lift car hardware (especially for the CSCM support), it must

    fulfill the following requirements:

    First, the RFID/USN functionality should be portable so that the

    functionality can be transferred to new hardware (such as an

    elevator) when the lift car is no more needed and therefore to be

    removed; a toolkit system which integrates the required function-

    alities seems desirable for satisfying this requirement.

    Second, the hardware should be weather-proof because construction

    sites are inherently exposed to adverse weather conditions.

    Third, for the communication capability, it mustsupportmid-to-long

    range communication, for both wired and wireless one, in order to

    contact with thelogisticsmanagement serverand other servers such

    as PMIS.

    Fig. 2. Concept of intelligent vertical CSCM.

    3C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    5/15

    Fig. 3. 3-Tier based system architecture of toolkit software.

    Fig. 4. Information model of toolkit software.

    4 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    6/15

    Fourth, it must provide short-range wireless communication capa-

    bility also for communicating with other intelligent equipments (for

    instance, an intelligent mover) and handheld devices such as PDA.

    Fifth, it must befriendly to the fieldusersat the construction site in

    terms of usability.

    Sixth, it should provide backup power (e.g. batteries) in case the

    fixed power service fails.

    Seventh, there must exist RFID readers and antennas for

    identification of RFID tags.

    For the software embedded to the toolkit, its requirements can be

    summarized as below:

    First, it must allow its users to access the loading information via

    touch screen display; also, if any event breaks out during the

    process of loading, it must be able to display theevent in real-time.

    Second, initial loading plans stored in the PMIS must be relayed to

    the onboard computer in the toolkit so that the intelligent lift car

    system can be operated as planned. This functional requirement

    can be implemented using web service for the PMIS and its proxy

    running on the toolkit's control computer.

    Third, overall software must be configured as three-tier system

    architecture so that plug-and-play concept of the toolkit can be

    implemented easily.

    Fourth, if something went wrong during the loading process,

    details of the problem must be logged to the systemand notifiedto

    the responsible personnel.

    Fifth, end result of the loading process must be reported to the

    logistics management server from the toolkit's control computer

    via asynchronous web service.

    3.2. Toolkit software design

    In order to operate properly, the control computer (based on an

    industrial PC) must be able to communicate with other systems such

    as the logistics management server and the PMIS; the latter system

    will have the actual plan of the material movement. As mentioned

    above, the toolkit system's control software is configured to have the

    Fig. 5. Illustration of the intelligent lift toolkit concept for elevator and intelligent lift.

    Fig. 6. Setting up embedded control module.

    5C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    7/15

    3-tier architecture as the configuration provides flexibility and

    extensibility, which suit well for our toolkit-based approach (Fig. 3).

    Fig. 4 shows the information items regarding the operation of the

    intelligent lift. This information model diagram follows the UML

    (Unified Modeling Language) notation, which illustrates the relation-

    ships between the toolkit and other related systems regarding the

    information exchange among them.

    3.3. Toolkit hardware design

    Fig.5 summarizes tasks theintelligentlift toolkit is supposed to do,

    which is based on the hardware requirements listed earlier.

    Figs. 6 and 7 show a prototype toolkit we designed for the tasks

    sorted out in Fig. 5. Fig. 6 shows the design of the control module that

    contains the embedded computer.

    Because construction lifts typically have two doors one for entry

    (loading) and the other for exit (unloading), two separate RFID

    readers are used for each door. For the control computer, we used an

    industrial PC with integrated touch screen display. The display is

    ergonomically mounted at 120 cm from the floor deck for comfort of

    the human operators.

    To provide emergency power service in case main power service

    fails, a lead-acid battery pack is installed with a power inverter to

    provide AC power to the toolkit.

    Fig. 7 shows the console-section design of the toolkit.

    3.4. Toolkit software design

    Fig. 8 shows a UML activity diagram of the information exchange

    process during the intelligent lift operation. The PMIS provide the as-

    planned loading information to the control PC of the intelligent lift car

    via Web service; similarly, the logistics management server accepts the

    result information from the control PC of the lift via Web service too. In

    this manner, the planning information and the information of actual lift

    operation can be managed in a single intelligent CSCM framework.

    4. Manufacturing and test result analysis

    4.1. Manufacturing and test plan

    To evaluate the feasibility of our intelligent lift car toolkit, we built

    a working prototype system and then conducted performance tests

    against it. The following sub-sections describe the detail of the tests.

    4.1.1. Manufacturing toolkit

    Our prototype system consists of the toolkit hardware and its

    control software. Table 1 lists the hardware specification of our

    intelligent construction lift car toolkit.

    Fig.9 shows thepicture of ourtoolkit apparatus anddescriptionof its

    components. The entire toolkit is hosted in a single cabinet enclosure,

    which also has two RFID readers and one battery pack inside.

    4.1.2. Toolkit test plansWith the prototype toolkit, we have conducted three tests in total.

    Table 2 gives a brief description of each test.

    The first one was a pilot test for evaluating the performance of the

    individual components. It evaluated the RFID readers (for their

    identification ranges with various tag positions) and communication

    modules including Zigbee and wireless internet over CDMA cellular

    telephony network.

    Fig. 7. Detailed design of the intelligent lift toolkit on console section.

    6 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    8/15

    Thesecond test wasmade against the assembled toolkit prototype,

    which comprised tests of eight RFID antennas for measuring

    identification performance, tests of short-range data communication

    between the intelligent equipments, tests of wireless internet services

    using CDMA and Wibro modules, and tests of the backup battery

    measuring its service time.

    The third one was the field test of the toolkit installed to the lift

    hardware with the system software we developed. To assess the real-

    world performance of the prototype, the test evaluated functionality

    of the system software and its interoperability with external systemssuch as the intelligent logistics server and the PMIS.

    4.2. Toolkit performance tests

    4.2.1. Pilot type test

    The pilot test was conducted against the individual component of

    the toolkit to see whether it met our functional requirements. It

    comprised three sub-tests and each one is described as follows:

    First, identification range and S/N ratio of the RFID antennas

    Second, short-range communication test using Zigbee

    Third, operation of the wireless communication module.

    Fig. 10 illustrates test settings and various test conditions.

    The result from the first test can be summarized as follows:

    First, inside the construction lift car which was made of steel,

    short-range communication using Zigbee within 5 m was stable

    and noise-free.

    Second, when a door of the lift car was closed, the RFID tags of the

    materials outside the lift car were not identified; when the door

    opened more than 1 m width, tags on the materials located within

    5 m were able to be identified; when the door was fully open, the

    range extended to 8 m.

    Third, wireless internet access was attempted using a CDMA/Wibro

    dual-mode modem for accessing external PMIS; 10 tests were

    conducted, all of them were successful. Based on this result, a

    Fig. 8. Process model of toolkit software.

    Table 1

    Specification of toolkit hardware.

    Hardware Specification

    1 CDMA/WiBro 900 Mhz/1.8 GHz

    2 Zigbee 2.4 Ghz

    3 RFID reader 900 Mhz

    4 RFID tags Passive tag

    5 Battery pack D.C 12 V

    6 Industrial computer CPU Intel Pentium 4 2 Ghz

    7 Touch screen monitor 12 in TFT LCD

    7C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    9/15

    decisionwas made to usethe technology forcommunicating with the

    PMIS.

    4.2.2. Prototype test

    The second test mainly evaluated the performance of the toolkit

    hardware, which was developed based on the result from the earlier

    pilot test.

    The test evaluated the following items:

    First, identification ratio with respect to various antenna types

    Second, changes in identification ratio with varying locations of the

    antennas

    Third, changes in identification ratio with adjustment of the antenna

    gain.

    Fig. 11 illustrates the field condition for the test.

    From the figure, dashed line around the material box and the

    construction worker represent the entrance area to the lift car whichwasmade of steel meshes. Thetest used passive-type tags attached on

    two different places top of the material box and side of it.

    For the first test item (identification ratio over various antenna

    types), which was conducted to determine the best antenna type for

    our toolkit, the antennas were placed on sidewall of the lift car, which

    was 130 cm above the floor deck and 30 cm away from the entrance

    door horizontally. A receiver antenna and a transmitter one were

    installed symmetrically to the sidewall so that they can face each

    other.4

    The test result was summarized in Fig. 12.

    For the second test item (identification ratio over varying antenna

    locations), we used the circular type antenna, as it performed better

    than the linear type in the previous test. For this test, two antenna

    pairs (each pair consisted of a receiver and a transmitter5) were first

    placed at 2.65 m above the floor deck (highest location), and was

    gradually lowered at 30 cm intervals as measurements were made for

    each height setting. The test result is shown in Fig. 13.

    Also, we tested different pair locations: symmetric locations of

    RXTX pair versus asymmetric locations, which result is shown in

    Fig. 14.

    As a result, there was no observable difference in the identification

    performance over different antenna heights; on the other hand,

    location of the tag on the material box did cause the difference,

    especially for top mounted vs. side mounted for right side vs. left

    side, the latter performed better.

    For the last item (identification performance over varying antenna

    gains), we started from the maximum gain (zero value) and gradually

    reduced the gain by 30 (the numeric value actually increased) until

    the number reaches 255 (the minimum gain).

    Fig. 15 shows the display screen of the control computer during

    the test. Its test result showed that the antenna gain only marginally

    affect the identification performance.

    4.2.3. Field testFinally, we conducted the field test of our toolkit for evaluation of

    its feasibility in the context of the intelligent CSCM environment, with

    the system software developed for it.

    The field test took place in the settings illustrated in Fig. 16.

    The scenario for this test, for measuring feasibility of the toolkit for

    vertical logistics management process under the intelligent CSCM

    environment, is described as follows:

    We first loaded four material boxes to the intelligent mover (IM),

    which was developed in our earlier research [4]. Each box was

    attached with a 900 Mhz passive RFID tag, and their information4 An RFID antenna can play two roles: a transmitter (TX) which sends off radio

    signals to the RFID tag so that the tag can generate electrical power to send off its ID

    information by induction; and a receiver (RX) which receives the radio signal from the

    tag. These roles are interchangeable on a single antenna.

    Fig. 9. Developing an intelligent lift toolkit.

    Table 2

    Test type definition.

    Tests Test purpose

    1 Pilot test Toolkit device performance test

    2 Pro to type te st Toolkit perf or man ce t est

    3 Field t est Too lkit +PMI S communication perf or mance t est

    5 In Fig. 13, when the left-side antenna acted as RX, the right-side one would act as

    TX, and vice versa. The RFID reader decided which one would be the RX.

    8 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    10/15

    was picked up by the IM to be sent to the toolkit via the Zigbee

    communication. The toolkit, which had already received the

    shipping list from the intelligent logistics server, displayed the

    destination floor on its touch screen and controlled the lift car to

    move to the floor. When the lift car arrived, the IM moved out of

    the lift car with the tagged box, and then the toolkit reports the

    updated state, including the ID of the IM, the material, and the

    floor and the materials were unloaded, to the intelligent logistics

    server wirelessly.

    Fig. 17 shows snapshots taken during the field test with

    annotations.

    The test result conformed well with our scenario: we conducted

    three tests,and allof them exceeded ourperformancerequirements

    for RFID identification ratio, successful communication ratio with the

    intelligent movers, and successful communication ratio with the

    intelligent logistics management server.

    4.3. Test result analysis

    From reviewing the tests we conducted, their test results can be

    summarized as follows:

    Thefirstpilot test wasintendedto seewhetherdevelopment of the

    intelligent lift car system, was feasible; the test proved that

    development of the system was feasible using available

    components.

    For the second test (against the prototype hardware), it was

    intended to evaluate our design of the intelligent lift toolkit in

    terms of its RFID identification performance, to see whether it was

    deployable to actual construction sites where radio signal was easily

    disrupted by various obstacles. The test result showed that the

    hardware had enough performance to be used in such environment.

    Finally, the third test sets up a scenario of the intelligent CSCM

    process, and evaluated the system's performance within the

    scenario. Also, the test evaluated whether the system could

    interoperate with other equipments (e.g. the intelligent mover)

    andremote systems such as theintelligentlogistics server. Thetest

    result confirmed that the tested system performed well and couldbe deployed to the real-world construction sites.

    5. Conclusion

    In this paper, we discussed our research in development of the

    intelligent construction lift toolkit, as part of our ongoing research in

    thenext generation CSCM system. We built theprototype hardware of

    the toolkit and its system software also. Using the prototype, we

    evaluated its performance and verified its feasibility through multiple

    performance tests. From these research activities, we have reached

    the following conclusion:

    First, the RFID technology can be applied to construction sites even

    though they have adverse conditions in terms of radio signal

    Fig. 10. Pilot test layout and test conditions.

    9C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    11/15

    transmission due to various signal-blocking obstacles. This finding

    allows automated recognition of the logistic items using the

    technology.

    Second, short-range data communication between the intelligent

    equipments using Zigbee is feasible at the construction sites.

    Third, application of long range data communication using

    wireless internet technology such as CDMA/Wibro to construction

    sites is also feasible (presumably in urban areas where its

    infrastructure is well established) for communication with remote

    systems such as theintelligentlogistics serverand thePMIS, which

    allows real-time information exchange.

    Fourth, our toolkit-based approach allows easy deployment of the

    system to both construction lift cars and elevators.

    Therefore, the intelligent vertical CSCM toolkit developed can be

    transferred to elevators when they are installed to the building under

    construction and they replace the lift cars, so the management system

    can persist even after the lifts are removed.

    In the future, as demonstrated with our prototype system, the

    RFID/USN technology, which is technologically more superior than

    conventional barcodes, will enable more advanced construction

    project management once they are widely used in the CSCM area.

    Fig. 12. Result of antenna type recognition test.

    Fig. 11. Prototype test layout.

    10 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    12/15

    Fig. 14. Result of RXTX test.

    Fig. 13. Result of RX =TX test.

    11C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    13/15

    Fig. 16. Field test conditions.

    Fig. 15. RFID antenna detection range sensibility test.

    12 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    14/15

    We hope this research will contribute to the transformation of theconstruction industry from labor-intensive to a more systematic and

    information-centered one.

    Acknowledgements

    This work was supported by the KoreanInstitute of Construction &

    Transportation Technology Evaluation and Planning (KICTEP) with

    the program number of 06-Unified and Advanced Construction

    Technology Program-D16.

    References

    [1] C. Cho, T. Shin, S. Kwon, S. Chin, Y. Kim, J. Lee, A development of next generationintelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical material movement management,

    Conference Proceeding of ICCEM, 2009.

    [2] C. Cho, S. Kwon, J. Lee, S. You, S. Chin, Y. Kim, Basic study of smart roboticconstruction lift for increasing resource lifting efficiency in high-rise buildingconstruction, Conference Proceeding of ISARC, 2009.

    [3] S. Shin, Hoist scheduling chart and lifting load leveling method for applying JIT inconstruction, Journal of AIK 25 (2) (2009).

    [4] S. Kwon, A development of mechanism on supply chain information recognitionamong intelligentequipment for USN basedconstruction supplychain managementprocess, Conference Proceeding of KICEM, 2008.

    [5] S. Chin, S. Yoon, C. Choi, C. Cho, RFID+ 4D CAD for Progress Management ofStructural Steel Works in High-Rise Buildings, vol. 22, No. 2, 2008, pp. 74 89.

    [6] J. Lee, et al.,Procurementmanagement impacton scheduling, Journal of AIK23 (12)(2007) 143.

    [7] Y. Su, L. Liu, Real-time construction operation tracking from resource positions,Computing in Engineering 2007 (2007) 200207.

    [8] S. Chin, S. Yoon, Y. Kim, J. Ryu, C. Choi, C. Cho, Realtime 4d Cad+ Rfid forproject progress management, Construction Research Congress 2005 (2005)110.

    [9] J. Song, T. Carl, H. Carlos, Tracking the location of materials on construction jobsites, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management 132 (9) (September 1

    2006) 911

    918.

    Fig. 17. Toolkit scenario field test.

    13C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx

    Please cite this article as: C.-Y. Cho, et al., A development of next generation intelligent construction liftcar toolkit for vertical materialmovement management, Automation in Construction (2010), doi:10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.07.008
  • 8/8/2019 Assignment 1 - Journal DOne

    15/15

    [10] J. Song, T. Carl, C. Carlos, L. Katherine, Locatingmaterials on constructionsite usingproximitytechniques, ConstructionResearchCongress 2005Paper No 7641,2005,pp. 110.

    [11] H. Chae, M. Jang, H. Lee, Developing the tower cranes planning process in high-rise building project, Conference Proceeding of KICEM (2) (2001) 387395.

    [12] J. Park, H. Lee, C. Hyun, K. Koo, A location model for tower cranes of high-risebuilding construction, Conference Proceeding of KICEM (4) (2003) 614617.

    [13] B. Ahn, J. Kim, N. Jee, Planningan optimized horizontal move forfinishing materialin high-rise building construction, Journals of AIK 17 (8) (2001) 119131.

    [14] Y. Jung, E. Kim, H. Seo, C. Kim, A Study of the high-rise buildings lift-upmanagement: though division of loading factors of equipment materials,

    Conference Proceeding of KICEM (5) (2004) 539

    553.[15] D. Bin, Z. Xiaoning, J. Li, Rfid-based vehicle key parts tracking system, The EighthInternational Conference of Chinese Logistics and Transportation Professionals,2008, pp. 21772184.

    [16] Y. Ouyang, R. Xu, The convergence of Rfid with Wi-Fi and on the applications inlogistics system, International Conference on Transportation Engineering 2007(ICTE 2007), 2007, pp. 41244130.

    [17] D. Torrent, C. Caldas, Field experiments of an automated materials identificationand localization model, Computing in Engineering 2007, 2007, pp. 689696.

    [18] D. Torrent, C. Caldas, Methodology for automating the identification andlocalization of construction components on industrial projects, Journal ofComputing in Civil Engineering 23 (1) (2009) 313.

    [19] B. Ahn, A vertical movement plan for labors in high rise building constructionusing discrete event simulation, Journal fo KICEM 5 (1) (2004) 4754.

    14 C.-Y. Cho et al. / Automation in Construction xxx (2010) xxxxxx