appellate tribunal mumbai - mahaonline appeals... · l9lo9lt9 before the maharashtra real estate...

13
L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti & Anr' v/s. M/s. Ruchi PriYa DeveloPers Pvt' Ltd' 2) APPeal No. AT0O6OO0OO0OO0171 Mr. Izharulhaq Siddiki v/s. M/s. K.D. Builders 3) Appeal No. AT006000000000097 Mr. Mahendra DaYaram Bhanushali v/s. M/s. Link Promoters & Poker Enterprises 4) Appeal No. AT005OOO0OOO0O262 Mustafa Firoz Tinwala v/s. M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS 5) Appeal No. ATOO6000O00O0O254 Mustafa Firoz Tinwala v/s. M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS 5) Appeal No. ATOO5OOOOO0O1O387 M/s. APZ RealtY v/s. Kiran Prasad 7) Appeal No. AT0050000O0010382 Pinnacle Vastunirman v/s. Sunil S. Dharmadhikari 1

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

L9lO9lt9

BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE

APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI

1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149

Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti & Anr'v/s.

M/s. Ruchi PriYa DeveloPers Pvt' Ltd'

2) APPeal No. AT0O6OO0OO0OO0171

Mr. Izharulhaq Siddikiv/s.

M/s. K.D. Builders

3) Appeal No. AT006000000000097

Mr. Mahendra DaYaram Bhanushaliv/s.

M/s. Link Promoters & Poker Enterprises

4) Appeal No. AT005OOO0OOO0O262

Mustafa Firoz Tinwalav/s.

M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS

5) Appeal No. ATOO6000O00O0O254

Mustafa Firoz Tinwalav/s.

M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS

5) Appeal No. ATOO5OOOOO0O1O387M/s. APZ RealtY

v/s.Kiran Prasad

7) Appeal No. AT0050000O0010382

Pinnacle Vastunirmanv/s.

Sunil S. Dharmadhikari

1

Page 2: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

19/09h9

8) Appeal No. AT006000000010463

Atif Gesawatv/s.

Mass Enclave

9) Appeal No. ATO05O00OO0O10498YughalChelani

v/s.K.D. Lite DeveloPers

1o) Apoeal No, ATOO6O00OO001053OSony Nijesh

v/s.Mrs. Pradnya Nikhil Sable

11) Appeal No. ATO06O0OOOOO1O546Mr. Hemendra MaPara

v/s.Kutubuddin H. Lokhandwala

12) Aooeal No. AT0O6O0OOO0O1O591M/s. Marvel Realtors & Developers Ltd.

v/s.Mr. Wtthal M. Jadhav & Anr.

Ao lNo. 6 oooo10585M/s. Akshar Space P/t.Ltd.

v/s.Mr. Shrikant Muthineni

t4) AD lNo. ATOO6 000010613Bhavan Valji Baruadia

v/s.M/s. Rohan DeveloPers M.Ltd.

Ao lNo. s00 000010747Mr. Sagar Pravinbhai Patel

v/s.M/s. Twin Star Infrastructure

16) Appeal No. AT0O5000OOO01O835M/s. Renaissance Indus Infra Pvt.Ltd.

v/s.Mr. Pafth Bharat Suchak

2

13)

1s)

Page 3: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

19/09179

r7) Appeal No. AT005000000010869Mr. Hemendra MaPara

v/s.Mr. Kochikar Pai

18) Appeal No. ATO05O0O0OO01O966M/s. Spire Associates

v/s.Mr. Ghevarchand Ganeshmal Dhumavat

19) Apoea! No. ATOO500OOO001O98OMr. Mukesh Kailash Singh

v/s.M/s. Lodha Developers

20) Aooeal o. ATO06O0OO0 10804

21) Apoeal No. ATOO60O0O0OO1O809Mr. Kailas Patil

v/s.Mr. Hemant Varade

22) Aooeal No. ATOO600OOO0010811Mr. Kailas Patil

v/s.MadhaviNaik

23) Aopeal No. ATOO6O0OOOO01O81OMr. Kailas Patil

v/s.Mr. RahulP. Kadam

24) AooealNo. ATOO5O0O0 10875Mr. Vinit Methi

v/s.Indiabulls Park 4

Mrs. KnjalKariav/s.

Mr. Jayant Mehta

Mr. Kailas Patilv/s.

Mr. Raju Bana

2s) Appea! No. AT0O6O0OOO0011106

3

Page 4: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

19109179

26) Appeal No. ATOO60OOOOOO21146M/s. VidhiRealtors

v/s.Asad Anwar Khatau

27) Aopeal No. AT0O600OOO0O21152M/s. VidhiRealtors

v/s.Sainath Rakumar Sarode & Ors.

28) Appeal No. ATO060OO0OO021174M/s. Ravi DeveloPments

v/s.Mr. Arun P. Veer

S. Karthikeyan & Anr.v/s.

M/s. Whispering Towers

30) Ao INo. ATOO 5000000011 o27Mr. Yogesh Shivalkar

v/s.M/s. Housing Development & Infrastructure Ltd.

31) Appeal No. ATOO6OOO0OOO212O3M/s. Monarch & QureshiBuilders

v/s.Mr. Arif Lussanwala

Mr. Vivekanand K. Gaonkarv/s.

M/s. Neptune Ventures & Developers Pvt. Ltd.

M/s. AnmolAlliancev/s.

Prabha Kannan34) Aopea! No. AT006000000021206

M/s. Monarch & QureshiBuildersv/s.

Shikha Sharma

4

29) Apoeal No. AT0O6000000O21178

32) Apoeal No. AT0O6000000021222

33) Appeal No. AT005000O00021223

Page 5: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

79/09/19

35) Aooeal No. ATOO60O0OOOO21241Mr. Yogesh Jadhav

v/s.Mr. Sanjay Chintala

36) Ao I No. AT006ooooooo2l 242Mr. Yogesh Jadhav

v/s.Mr. Virendra Pandare

37) Aooeal No. AT0O6O0O0O0O21246M/s. Shantee Housing & Anr.

v/s.Mr. Naeem Abdul Sattar Shaikh

38) Aooeal No. AT006000000021268M/s. Maruelsigma Homes Pvt.Ltd.

v/s.Mrs. Kamakshi L. Matai

3e) AD I No. ATOO 50000000 1198Mr. Ashish Jain

v/s.M/s. Lucina Land DeveloPment Ltd.

40) Appeal No. ATOO6OO000OO21357Mr. Sunil Daga & Anr.

v/s.Larsen and Turbo

4t) Aopeal No. ATOO6OO0O ooo2L249Mr. Thomas Verghese

v/s.Mr. Ravi Developments

42) Ap I No. ATOO 60000000 L4L6Mr. Madhusudanan Menon

v/s.M/s. Ravi Developments

43) Appeal No. ATOO600O00OO21448M/s. Build Tech Group

v/s.Mr. Anjum Abdul Deraiya

5

Page 6: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

79/09/!9

M/s. M.K. Sheltersv/s.

Mrs. Aisha Abdul Deraiya & Anr.

4s) Aopeal No. AT0O5000000021486M/s. Dhan International

v/s.Kishore Thakural

46) Aooeal o. ATOO6O0OOO 21496Mr. Himanshu B. Rajure

v/s.M/s. Wshwakarma DeveloPers

47) Appeal No. AT006000000021403M/s. Om DeveloPers-Projed Green

v/s.Mr. Abhay Shrirangwar

Aooea I No. ATO050000000315 o548)Mr. Mahesh Nalawade

v/s.Mr. Vaibhav V. Balwantkar

4e) Aooeal No. ATOO6O0OO 00031512Mr. Kailash Patil

v/s.Mr. Naresh Patil & Ors.

50) Appeal No. AT0O6O0OOO0031515Mr. leetendra Pathak

v/s.M/s. D.S.Kulkarni DeveloPers Ltd.

s1) AopealNo. ATO050OO0 031518Mr. SuneelR. Hoshing

v/s.M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

Mr. Iulanik S. Hoshingv/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni DeveloPers Ltd.

6

44) Aopea! No. AT0050000O0021468

s2) Apoeal No. ATOO6OOOOOOO31519

Page 7: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

191091\9

s3) Aopeal No. AT006000000031520

Mr. Shreyas G. Prabhudesaiv/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

Mr. Ameya Nawathev/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

55) Aooeal No. AT0O6O00OOOO31522

Mr. Mayur Vasant Somwanshv/s.

M/s. D.S.Kulkarni Developers Ltd.

(None for the pafties)

CORAM INDIRA JAIN J. CHAIRPERSONS.S. SANDHU, MEMBER (A)

19TH SEPTEMBER, 2019.

Called.

Perused office submissions dated 19.8.2019 and mail

dated 17th July, 2019 forwarded to the respective parties in

the above appeals. From the date of filing online appeal

as shown in the chart below, it is apparent that appellants

have failed to submit hard copies since long despite

individual mail notices and notice on website.

Hence all the 55 (fifty five) online appeals stand dismissed

for failure to submit hard copies.

7

*.

54) Apoeal No. AT006000000021455

DATE :

Page 8: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

L9/09179

CHART

Sr. No. Appeal No. AppellanUsV/s.

Respondent

Date of filingOnlineAppeal

1 AT006000000,000149MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800006008

Mr. Sharnala SureshBaheti & Anr.V/s.M/s. Iluchi PriyaDevelopers Pvt Ltd.

22.03.2018

2. AT 71

MahaRERA Reg No

P51 800008606

Mr. Izharulhaq SiddikiV/s.M/s. K D Builders 05.04.2018

3. AT006009000000097MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800005290

Mr. Mahendra DayaramBhanushaliV/s.M/s. Link Promoters &Poker Ilnterprises

04.05.2018

4. AT006000000000262MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 90001 0592

Mustafir F iroz'l'inwalaV/s.M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS

05.05.2018

5. AT006900000000254MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 90001 0592

Mustai{a Firoz TinwalaV/s.M/s. Adarsh Nagar CHS 22.05.2018

b. AT00500000001 0387MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 00000942

Mls. APZ RealtyV/s.Kiran Prasad 06.06.2018

7 ATo059o00oo01 0382MahaRERA Reg No.

P52100A04125

Pinnacle VastutritmanV/s.Sunil S. Dharmaclhikari 08.06.2018

8. AT00600000001 0463MahaRERA Reg No.

P518000',!0794

Atif GesawatV/s.Mass Enclave 09.07.2018

9. AT00600000001 0498MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800004525

Yughal ClhelaniV/s.M/s. K D LiteDevelopers

24.07.2018

10, AT00600000001 0530MahaRERA Reg No.

P517A0U2252

Sony Nif esh

V/s.Mrs. Pradnya NikhilSable

09.08.2018

8

Page 9: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

Le/09/Ls

11 AT006000000010546MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800005482

Mr. Flemendra MaPara

V/s.Kutubudciin H.Lokhandwala

25.08.2018

AT00500000001 0591

MahaRERA Reg No.

P521A0001627

M/s. Marvel Realtors &Developers Ltd.V/s.Mr. Vitthal M Jadhav &Anr.

03.09.2018

13. AT00600000001 0585MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700003889

M/s. Akshar Space Pl't.Ltd.V/s.Mr. Shrikant Muthineni

04,09.2018

14. AT00600000001 061 3

MahaRERA Reg No.

P5190000'1899

Bhavan Valji BarvadiaV/s.M/s. Rohan DevelopersPvt Ltd

15. AT0050000000f 0747MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 00009509

Mr. Sagar PravirtbhaiPatelV/s.Ms. Twin Starlnfi'astructure

20.10.2018

16. AT00600000001 0835MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 70001 3956

M/s. Renaissance IndusInl'ra Pvt [.tdVis.Mr. Parth BharatSuchak

11 11.2018

17. AT00600000001 0869MahaRERA Reg No.P51 800005482

Mr. Hemendra MaparaV/s.Mr. Kochikar Pai 24.11.2018

18. AT00500000001 0966MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 0001 1 908

M/s. Spire AssociatesV/s.Mr. GhevarchandGaneshmal l)humavat

04.01,2019

19. AT00500000001 0980MahaRERA Reg No.P52100000174

Mr. Mukesh KailashSinghVls.M/s. I-odha Developer

15.01,2019

20. AT00600000001 0804MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Mr. Raju Bana 27.01.2019

21 AT006000000010809MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Ir4r. Hernant Varade 28.01.2019

9

.Y

12.

14.09.2018

Page 10: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

19/0slL9

22. AT00600000001081 1

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Madhavi Naik 28.01.2019

23. AT00600000001 081 0

MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 700006977

Mr. Kailas PatilV/s.Mr. Rahul P. Kadam 28.01.2019

24. AT0060000001 0875MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 900000467

M/r. Vinit MethiV/s.Indiabulls Park 4 01.02.2019

25. AT00600000001 1 1 06MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 0479

Mrs. Kinial KariaV/s.Mr. Jayant Mehta 13.02.2019

26. AT006000000021 146MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800007949

M/s. Vidhi RealtorsV/s.Asad Anwar Khatau 27.02.2019

27 AT006000000021 1 52MahaRERA Reg No.

P5'1800007949

M/s. Vidhi realtorsV/s.Sainath RajkurnarSarode & Ors.

27.02.2019

28. AT006000000021 174MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 1407

M/s. ItaviDevelopmentsV/s.Mr. Arun P. Veer

27.02.2019

29. AT006000000021 178MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800007809

S Karthikeyan & AnrV/s.M/s. WhisperingTowers

28.02.2019

30. AT00600000001 1027MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800007809

Mr. Yogesh ShivalkarV/s.M/s. HousingDevelopment &Inliastructure Ltd.

28.02.2019

31 AT006000000021 203MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 80001 0967

M/s. Monarch &Qureshi BuildersV/s.Mr. Aril'Lussanwala

09.03.2019

32. AT006000000021 222MahaRERA Reg No.

P990000001 09

Mr. Vivekanand K.GaonkarV/s.M/s. Neptune Ventures& f)evelopers Pvt Ltd

12.03.2019

v10

Page 11: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

19/091t9

33. AT006000000021 223MahaRERA Reg No.P51 800004209

M/s. Anmol AllianceV/s.Prabha Kannan 13.03.2019

34. AT006000000021 206MahaRERA Reg No.P51 80001 0967

M/s. Monarch &Qureshi BuildersV/s.Shikha Sharma

15.03.2019

35. ATO 241MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800008680

Mr. Yogesh.ladhavV/s.Mr. Saniay Chintala 18.03.2019

36. AT00600000002{ 242MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800008680

Mr. Yogesh.IadhavV/s.Mr. Virendra Pandare 18,03.2019

37 AT006000000021 246MahaRERA Reg No.P99000001441

M/s. Shantee Housing& Anr.V/s.Mr. Naeem AbdulSattar Shaikh

19.03.2019

38. AT005000000021 268MahaRERA Reg No.P52100001711

M/s. Marvel SigmaHornes Pvt LtdV/s.Mrs. Kamakshi L. Matai

26.03.2019

39 AT006000000021 198MahaRERA Reg No.P52000002658

Mr. Ashish JainV/s.M/s. Lucina LandI)evelopment Ltd

27.03.2019

40 AT006000000021 367MahaRERA Reg No.P51 800003307

Mr. Sunil Daga & Anr:.V/s.Larsen and Turbo 05.04.2019

41. AT006000000021 249MahaRERA Reg No.P51740007276

Mr. I'homas VergheseV/s.M/s. RaviI)eveloprnents

12.04.2019

42. AT006000000021 41 6MahaRERA Reg No.P517A0007276

Madhusudanan MenonV/s.M/s. Ravil)evelopnrents

13.04,2019

43. AT006000000021448MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800009965

M/s. Build'l'ech GroupV/s.Mr. Aniunr AbdulDcraiya

25.04.2019Y

1.1.

Page 12: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

t9/09/ts

44. AT006000000021468MahaRERA Reg No.P51 800009965

M/s. MK SheltersV/s.Mrs. Aisha AbclulDeraiya & Anr.

10.05.2019

45. AT006000000021486MahaRERA Reg No.

P51 800001 637

M/s. Dhan IntemationalPvt LtdV/s.Kishore 'l'hakural

20.05.2019

46. AT005000000021496MahaRERA Reg No.P52700003997

Mr. Himanshu B.RajureV/s.M/s. VishwakarmaI)evelopers

27.05.2019

47 AT005000000021403MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 00005869

M/s. OM Developers-Project GreenV/s.Mr. Abhay Shrirangwar

28.05.2019

48. AT005000000031 505MahaRERA Reg No.

P52 1 00002331

Mr. Mahesh NalawadeV/s.Mr. Vaibhav V.Balwantkar

30.05.2019

49. AT006000000031 51 2

MahaRERA Reg NoP51 700006977

Mr. Kailash PatilV/s.Mr. Naresh Patil & Ors 31.05.2019

50 AT005000000031 51 5MahaRERA Reg No.P52100005158

Mr. Jeetendra PathakV/s.M/s. D S KulkamiDevelopers Ltd.

02.06.2019

51 AT005000000031 51 8MahaRERA Reg No.P52100005158

Mr. Suneel R. HoshingV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

52. AT005000000031 51 9

MahaRERA Reg No.P521 000051 58

Mr. Manik S. HoshingV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

Y

12

Page 13: APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI - MahaOnline appeals... · L9lO9lt9 BEFORE THE MAHARASHTRA REAL ESTATE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI 1) APPeal No. AT006000000000149 Mr. Shamala Suresh Baheti

t9l09lt9

53. AT005000000031 520MahaRERA Reg No.P521 000051 58

Mr. Shreyas G.PrabhudesaiV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

54, AT005000000021455MahaRERA Reg No.P521 000051 58

Mr. Arncya NawatheV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

03.06.2019

55. AT005000000031 522MahaRERA Reg No.

P521 000051 58

Mr. Mayur VasantSomwanshV/s.M/s. D S KulkarniDevelopers Ltd.

04.06,2019

(rrrror#irarN r)(s

ed(f{,8-26,28-57-Online appeals dismi$ed for non submission of hard copi6).

13