trauma and detention why doctors are needed pétur hauksson, warsaw, 13 dec 2011

Trauma and detention

Why doctors are needed

Pétur Hauksson, Warsaw, 13 Dec 2011

Why doctors are needed

For 1. assessing the trauma

and 2. assess the health care services'

approach to and treatment of that trauma

Pétur Hauksson, Warsaw, 13 Dec 2011

Doctors are needed

for

assessing the trauma

Pétur Hauksson, Warsaw, 13 Dec 2011

Psychological consequences

vs

mental health consequences

of trauma/torture

(and trauma without traceable consequences)

Aetiology

risk factors

symptoms

diagnosis

prognosis

treatment

What are we doing?

Medicalizing a human tragedy

A western diagnostic system imposed on “normal” responses to extreme trauma

Post-traumatic stress syndrome (PTSD)

Torture syndrome?

Depression, anxiety disorders, psychosis, substance abuse, neuropsychological

impairment, personality disorders

Dual loyalty of the prison doctor

IndependenceConfidentialityEffectiveness

Trust

Presence of officers during examinations?

Impunity for perpetrators

- a factor in PTSD

Therefore, impunity should be of concern to doctors

Degrading treatment

such as:

isolationovercrowding

impoverished regimelack of outdoor exercise

inhuman material conditions

Degrading treatment

Why oppose?Because it is a

Medical problemor Human Rights Violation?

Message to the authorities

from NPMs with a doctor

and without a doctor e.g. regarding health consequences

of ill-treatment- What about the “consequences” of

degrading treatment?i.e. of being subject to a

violation of human rights. Is a doctor needed for that?

Judicial importance of the NPM's / doctor's statements on health consequences

of ill treatment

e.g. when the ill treatment is accepted and generally used by the same judiciary,

arguments must be strong and persuasive.

We ask prison doctors to not only describe medical findings in the records,

but ALSO the victim's explanation and any allegations there might be,

AND the doctor's opinion on the compatibility of the allegations and the

medical findings.

The same should be expected from the NPMs' doctors

If the NPMs come across a case of injury or physical consequences of suspected ill-

treatment, there must be a way to determine the compatibility.

Non-medical monitors should at a minimum be able to describe physical signs of

possible ill-treatment in detail in order to get an opinion on them from an outside doctor (IMAP?) and ask for their opinion, including

of the compatibility with any allegations.

What about possible mental health consequences of ill-treatment?

Can non-medical monitors be expected to describe the psychiatric signs and

symptoms that might have resulted from ill-treatment?

Is it also possible to describe this in detail and ask the opinion of an outside

psychiatrist?Answer: Yes, to a certain degree.

Health care services

Assessing the quality and quantity of the provision of health care,

including the capability of the services to deal with trauma

properly, confidentially, independently and effectively,

in order to have a preventive effect

Independence from prison management. Under MoJ or MoH?

Staff recruitment.

Doctor-patient relationship

sufficient trust, allowing a preventive role

of health care staff

FacilitiesEquipment

Availability of proper medication

Participation of health care staff in ill-treatment?

E.g. assessing wether the victim can tolerate more ill-treatment

Assessing capacity for isolation

- not conducive to formation of a doctor-patient relationship

The doctor-patient relationship

Why the big fuss?

What can NPMs without doctors do then?

Can they assess mental health consequences of torture/ill-treatment?

Can they assess health care services in prisons?

Many policy matters are not merely medical issues

e.g. prevention of health consequences of ill-treatment.

Is this degrading treatment or not? Who decides?

Limits of the role of the doctor

Others may be more qualified e.g. in assessing whether conditions are degrading

or treatment is adequate

Is a doctor needed?

Depends on the doctor