john w. nielsen- gammon texas state...

Post on 08-Mar-2018

228 Views

Category:

Documents

3 Downloads

Preview:

Click to see full reader

TRANSCRIPT

Weather and Climate Extremes

John W. Nielsen-Gammon Texas State Climatologist

What’s a Weather or Climate Extreme?

What’s a Weather or Climate Extreme?

• Something unusual • Something high-impact

Why Do People Care About Weather or Climate Extremes?

Why Do People Care About Weather or Climate Extremes?

• Something unusual • Something high-impact

40

-10

40

-10

80

0

1989

80

0

1949

80

0

1930

80

0

1899

40

-10

40

-10

115

90

9.05

Weekly number of flood reports through November

0

5

10

15

20

25

20

25

30

35

15

10 5

0

0

1

World record: 21.93” in 2h 45m, Woodward

Ranch, D’Hanis, Texas

Extreme Weather and Climate Change

The Four Pillars of Attribution of Trends to Climate Change

The greater the number of solid pillars, the greater the scientific confidence that cause and effect has been identified

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The ‘pillar’ slides are adapted from the 2016 NAS report on extreme event attribution, except that I added my own judgment on coastal flooding because the NAS report did not address it.

The Four Pillars

Solid observed

trend

The Four Pillars

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

The Four Pillars

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

The Four Pillars

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

IPCC SREX

National Centers for Environmental Information

IPCC SREX

National Centers for Environmental Information

IPCC SREX

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

Climate change turned a 96°F day into a 100°F day

National Centers for Environmental Information

Climate change turned a 96°F day into a 100°F day

Climate change turned a 4°F above normal day into an 8°F above normal day

National Centers for Environmental Information

Climate change turned a 96°F day into a 100°F day

Climate change turned a 4°F above normal day into an 8°F above normal day

Climate change increased the odds of at least 100°F from 1:50 to 1:7

National Centers for Environmental Information

Texas Precip thru 2016: +8.5%

The Four Pillars

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

Texas Rainfall

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

✔ ✖

Texas Rainfall

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

✔ ✖ ✖

Texas Rainfall

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

✔ ✖ ✖ ✔

Texas Very Heavy Rainfall

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

✔ ✔ ✔

What makes rainfall different from very heavy rainfall?

IPCC AR5, WG1, Fig. 2.8

56 (50,62)

Tweaked from:

Presenter
Presentation Notes
I find that treating IR radiation as net radiation eliminates many opportunities for misunderstandings and misconceptions, including all that ‘back-radiation’ nonsense and the erroneous idea that the key effect of greenhouse gases on surface temperature comes through downwelling radiation. Overarching concept here: heat from the Sun flows mainly to the Earth’s surface. Heat escaping from the Earth comes mainly from the atmosphere (primarily the troposphere). Heat flows from the Earth’s surface to the troposphere, closing the loop. This is why the troposphere generally gets cooler with altitude, and the rate of cooling with altitude is mostly set by thermodynamics. (The stratosphere gains heat mainly from direct absorption of sunlight, so its temperature isn’t interconnected with what’s happening at ground level.)

The Faucet

• Warmer air can carry more water = bigger pipe + 7% per °C

• The effect of weather patterns = turning the handle

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Thermodynamic vs. dynamic influences of climate change

The Faucet

• The size of the pipe matters most when the faucet is wide open

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Extreme rainfall is dominated by the thermodynamic influence. This is confirmed by observed magnitude of changes in extreme rainfall amounts.

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Based on spatial precipitation analyses, so underlying data is county-average daily precip, not point precip. Shown is literally the smoothed annual odds of a “one-year” rainfall event, but just explain that “1” is the expected long-term value assuming no trend. Note that the two counties south of Harris (Galveston and Brazoria) have a negative trend. Harris County has the largest positive trend but it seems to be a local outlier (Also, other big cities in Texas don’t have large positive trends.)

Statewide Extreme Rainfall Analysis

• For each county & each year: – Find stations with nearly-complete data – Pick the one with longest period of record

• Stitch together daily precipitation into one long time series

• Find events exceeding threshold • Sort chronologically, find date of middle event

Time

Time

Time

Events less frequent Events more frequent

Time

Events less frequent Events more frequent

new frequency old frequency

length of first period length of second period =

*about once every 5000 days

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Presumably most of the spatial variation is due to the lack of statistical robustness in extreme rainfall statistics. In other words, one shouldn’t expect extreme rainfall in Harris County to continue increasing at an unusually rapid rate…indeed, a rebound to a temporarily flat trend is much more likely. But there’s a clear underlying upward trend. This is unpublished research, but peer-reviewed research does find an overall upward trend of similar magnitude for the south-central United States.

Probable Maximum Precipitation

• The maximum amount of precipitation physically possible for a given basin over a given duration

• Used for critical infrastructure design – Dams – Nuclear power plants

Hurricanes

National Centers for Environmental Information

Problems with Smaller-Scale Extreme Weather Phenomena

• Lack of stability in data record • Low signal-to-noise ratio • No direct information from climate models

National Centers for Environmental Information

Smaller-Scale Extreme Weather Phenomena

Solid observed

trend

Known reason for

change

Good modeling

ability

No outside

influences

✖ ✖ ?

Problems with Smaller-Scale Extreme Weather Phenomena

• Low signal-to-noise ratio – Natural (and random) variability drives

individual events and clusters – Small trends have large monetary impact – Once clear trend is detectable, it’s too late

National Centers for Environmental Information

Hurricanes: The Balance of Evidence

• Increase in peak intensity (1.5 pillars) • Decrease in frequency (1 pillar)

– …but spatially variable (1.5 pillars)

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

National Centers for Environmental Information

Change in hurricane frequency

National Centers for Environmental Information

Summary

• Extreme weather – Extremely unusual – Extremely impactful

• Texas gets extremes • Climate change affects extremes

– Not always worse – Often very hard to tell

Contact Information

• John W. Nielsen-Gammon • n-g@tamu.edu • 979-862-2248 • http://climatexas.tamu.edu • http://climatechangenationalforum.org • http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov

top related