module 1 - 7 point form 106
Post on 02-Mar-2018
219 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
1/106
Project Management Module 1
1.0 Introduction ......................................................................................................... 1
1.1.2 Projects and other production systems .......................................................... 1
1.1.3 Characteristics of a project ........................................................................... 1
1.2. What is Project Management? ............................................................................ 2
1.2.3 Basic Project Management Structures........................................................... 2
1.2.3.1 Internal Project Management ................................................................. 2
1.3.2 External Project Management .......................................................................... 3
1.3 Characteristics of Project Management ............................................................... 3
1.3.2 Multiple Objectives ....................................................................................... 3
1.3.3 International Co-Operation and Standards ................................................... 3
1.3.4 Multi Industry ............................................................................................... 3
1.3.5 Generic Benchmarks ..................................................................................... 3
1.3.6 Specific Provisions ........................................................................................ 41.3.7 Project Life Cycle ......................................................................................... 4
1.4 Potential Benefits and Challenges of Project Management .................................. 4
1.4.2 Potential Benefits .......................................................................................... 4
1.4.3 Potential Challenges ..................................................................................... 4
1.0 Introduction
1.1.2 Projects and other production systems Production systems can be classified into three broad categories
o Mass production e.g. cars
o Batch production e.g. chemicals
o Project (non-repetitive) production e.g. IT
Mass production is capitally intensive, highly mechanistic & little
management intervention once system running satisfactorily
Batch production unlikely to be continual high demand, typically organised
around functional groupings
Project one off change e.g. improving batch or mass production efficiency
Programme may contain many projects e.g. customer service improvement
programme
1.1.3 Characteristics of a project
Single, definable purpose, product or result
Usually has defined constraints or targets
Uses skills & talents from multiple professions and organisations
It is unique, unfamiliar and temporary
It is part of a process to achieve a goal
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
2/106
It is part of an interlinked process
It is generally of secondary importance to the company, exceptions are pure
R&D
It is relatively complex
Skills required include:
o
Financial awarenesso Marketing appreciation
o Technical knowledge
o Planning skills
o Strategic Awareness
o Quality Management
1.2. What is Project Management? It is about achieving time, cost and quality targets, within the general
context of overall strategic and tactical client requirements, by using
project resources Cost vs. Time vs. Quality, pick two
Industrial Projects have become more complex and hence so has project
management
1.2.3 Basic Project Management Structures
1.2.3.1 Internal Project Management
Most common form, project team operates within the firm
Most companies are organised around functional groupso Advantages specialisation
o Disadvantages compartmentalised and rigid
Project teams can operate across these functional groups
Project team members then have project and functional responsibilities
Characteristics
o Single designated person (PM) acts independently and outside formal
functional authority structure
o PM has equal authority to functional managers over shared resources
o PM acts as single leader
o Projects normally require several functional specialists to work
together
o
PM has to negotiate with functional heads for resourceso People can originate from any level with the organisation
o Project structures generally require the assistance of standard support
functions such as HR and IT
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
3/106
1.3.2 External Project Management
External PM is appointed on a consultancy basis and acts as external agent on
behalf of client, has external resources for project group
Characteristics
o External system is more flexible than the internal system
o Communication has to be across organisational boundary, this may be
a problem
o Team allegiance is lower
o PM has direct authority of his team, functional structure of firm does
not matter
o Greater requirement for risk transfer and contractual control
o No built in knowledge of firm
1.3 Characteristics of Project Management
1.3.2 Multiple Objectives Typically these objectives fall into the categories of cost, quality and time
Cost Quality curve shows how quality improves as cost improves (usually).
Where you want to be on a curve can depend on factors like:
o Market price of goods
o Guaranties and warranties in place
o Cost of replacement
o True cost of defective workmanship
Project Management is concerned with ensuring the project success criteria aremet within the changing constraints of the time,cost,quality continuum
1.3.3 International Co-Operation and Standards
PMs code of practice and body of knowledge are based on international rather
than national practice, i.e. a project manager in one country should be able to
practice his art in another
The international body is the International Project Management Association(IPMA)
1.3.4 Multi Industry
PM not specific to one industry
1.3.5 Generic Benchmarks
There are standards that are not industry specific
o British BS6079
o International ISO10006
and standards that are:
o Prince2: controlled environment industries & government
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
4/106
1.3.6 Specific Provisions
Traditionally PMs were selected from functional specialists within anorganisation
Modern concept of project management includes the professional project
manager
1.3.7 Project Life Cycle
Traditionally consultants have only advised on 1 or 2 sections of an overall
project this leads to problems of lack of co-ordination
Project managers now give advice to clients on all stages of the project
Life cycles include:o Inception the basic proposal for work
o Feasibility establish the validity of the proposal from all persepctives
o Prototype
o
Full Design Development once protoype has been adjustedo Tendering and contractual arrangements can be a mixture of in house
and external
o Manufacturing
o Commisionning all aspects of switching the system on
o Operation actively used for the purpose for which it was designed
o Decommisionning process by which it is switched off
o Removal & Recycling
1.4 Potential Benefits and Challenges of Project
Management
1.4.2 Potential Benefits
Increased concentration on a specific objective
More efficient use of resources
Accountability
Healthy competition between functional and project units
Reduced disruption of functional operations
Enhanced visibility of strategy implementation
Improved team spirit and innovation
Improved management skills
1.4.3 Potential Challenges
Key staff taken away from functional units
Competition for resources
Conflicting orders
Powerful functional manager can deprive project of resources
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
5/106
Project sponsor is necessary go between for project manager and functionalmanager
Staff need to be flexible
Project staff may find it difficult to re-adjust to functional units
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
6/106
Module 2 Individual and Team issues
2.2 The Project Manager ........................................................................................... 7
2.2.2 Selecting the Project Manager ...................................................................... 7
2.2.2.2 The concept of the PM ............................................................................ 7
2.2.2.3 Central Position of the PM ..................................................................... 7
2.2.2.4 Role of the PM ....................................................................................... 82.2.2.5 Selecting the Project Manager ............................................................... 9
2.2.3 Some Essential PM requirements .................................................................. 9
2.2.3.1 Introduction ........................................................................................... 9
2.2.3.2 Planning ................................................................................................ 9
2.2.3.3 Authorising .......................................................................................... 10
2.2.3.4. Team organising ................................................................................. 10
2.2.3.5 Controlling .......................................................................................... 11
2.2.3.6 Directing .............................................................................................. 11
2.2.3.7 Team Building ...................................................................................... 12
2.2.3.8 Leadership ........................................................................................... 12
2.2.3.9 Lifecycle Leadership ............................................................................ 13
2.3 Project Team ..................................................................................................... 13
2.3.2 Project teams within functional organisations ......................................... 13
2.3.3 Team multi-disciplinary and heterogeneity Issues ....................................... 14
2.3.4. Group and team processes ......................................................................... 14
2.3.5 Project team performance ........................................................................... 14
2.4 Project Team Staffing Profile and Operation ..................................................... 15
2.4.2 Project Team Staffing ................................................................................. 15
2.4.3 Project Team Profile ................................................................................... 15
2.4.3.1 Project Team Mix ................................................................................. 15
2.4.3.2 Uniqueness of project team .................................................................. 15
2.4.4 Project Team Operation .............................................................................. 16
2.5 Project Team Evaluation ................................................................................... 16
2.5.2 Project Life Cycles ...................................................................................... 16
2.5.3 Project Change control and management ................................................... 16
2.5.4 Project Team evaluation ............................................................................. 16
2.5.5. Groupthink ................................................................................................ 17
2.6 Project team motivation ..................................................................................... 17
2.6.2 McGregor and Maslow ............................................................................... 17
2.6.3 Equity Theory and Expectancy Theory ........................................................ 17
2.6.3.1 Equity Theory ....................................................................................... 172.6.3.2 Expectancy Theory ............................................................................... 18
2.7 Project Team Communications .......................................................................... 18
2.7.2 Project Communication .............................................................................. 18
2.7.3 Formal and Informal communications ........................................................ 18
2.7.4 Internal and External communications ......... .......... ......... .......... .......... ........ 18
2.8 Project Team Stress ........................................................................................... 19
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
7/106
2.8.2 Origins and Symptoms of Team Member stress ........................................... 19
2.8.3 Stress Management ..................................................................................... 19
2.8.3.1 Individual Stress Management ............................................................. 19
2.8.3.2 Project Team Stress ............................................................................. 19
2.9 Conflict Identification and Resolution ................................................................ 20
2.9.2 Sources of conflict ....................................................................................... 202.9.3 Conflict Characteristics .............................................................................. 20
2.9.4 Approaches to Conflict ............................................................................... 20
2.9.5 Conflict management .................................................................................. 20
2.2 The Project Manager
2.2.2 Selecting the Project Manager
2.2.2.2 The concept of the PM
PMs are sometime permanent specialists or external consultants
The role is similar to CEO or General Manager
PM usually responsible to Project Sponsor
Different kind of projects call for different types of PM
Projects tend to be run outside the traditional top down hierarchy of thecompany
His role is temporary and without the power of functional managers
They have the authority to make project decisions but dont have authority to
order people to carry out the work which results from these decisions The PM must depend on other forms of influence to persuade functional
managers to agree with them
o Competency
o Professionalism
o Reputation
o Skill
o Inter personal skills
o Alliances
If these dont work, go to the Project Sponsor, so the PS needs to be senior
2.2.2.3 Central Position of the PM Key ability is to be able to focus on issues in detail while not losing sight of
the project as a whole
PM occupies a central position relating to communications between the
various people and organizations involved
Needs both the intellect to devise the project strategy and the diligence toensure that the actions are taken, both to the required standards and on time
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
8/106
2.2.2.4 Role of the PM
Primary requirements of the role are:
o Planning project activities, schedules and budget
o Organising and selecting project team
o Interfacing with client, the organisation and all interested parties
o Negotiating with suppliers and clients
o
Managing the project resourceso Monitoring and controlling the project status
o Identifying issues and problems
o Finding solutions
o Resolving conflicts
These requirements have to be carried out within the overall success criteria of
the project, including:
o Within agreed time limits
o Within agreed cost limit
o To at least minimum specified quality level
o To the satisfaction of the client
o
In compliance with the strategic plano
Within agreed scope
Scope is what is and is not part of project
Project scope creep is a killer, need to manager it using interface management
managing the organisational interfaces
Personal, Managerial and Leadership skills
In terms of personal skills, the PM should:o Be flexible and adaptable
o Be able to concentrate on more than one thing at a time
o Demonstrate initiative
o Be persuasive
o
Good communicatoro Balance multiple objectives
o Be prepared to generalize rather than always specialise
o Good planner and implementer
o Good time manager
o Good negotiator and influencer
o Be diplomatic
Technical and Business Skills
Technical skills help a PM understand the detailed components of a project
Harder characteristics include
o Understanding how to setup a team and run it
o
The ability to develop complex time and cost plans and achieve them
o Understanding of contracts, procurement and purchasing
o Active interest in training and development
o Understanding of the technology that is central to project success
o Ability to translate business strategy into project objectives
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
9/106
2.2.2.5 Selecting the Project Manager
Best person is a functional manager with project management skills
knowledge of industry & organisation
Problem is losing a good functional manager, should not do both PM and fnc
management at same time
Could use an external consultant, but they have learning curve
Specialist project managers are best main issue is technical competence
2.2.3 Some Essential PM requirements
2.2.3.1 Introduction
Primary functions
o Project planning
o Authorising
o Team organising
o
Controllingo Directing
o Team building
o Leadership
o Life cycle leadership
2.2.3.2 Planning
Most critical phase of project as mistakes made here are most expensive to
rectify if they are not discovered until later phases
Organisational and resourcing issues planning covers activities and their
sequence Technical planning required for
o Time planning & control
o Cost planning & control
o Quality management
Also need to plan and establish individual/team authority and communication
relationships
Use Task Responsibility Matrix (TRM) to define authority linkages. TRMshows
o Key milestones
o Individual important activities
o General responsibilities
o
Specific responsibilitieso Dates
Responsibilities include:
o Approval
o Preparation
o Checking
o Making and input
o Authorising
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
10/106
Typical TRM
Person A Person B Person C
Inception Report O,I C A
Feasibility Report O,I I A
Outline Proposals O,I I A
Scheme Designreport
I O,I O,C,A
I = Input
C= Checking report
A = authorising contents before submission to client
O = Organising reports
2.2.3.3 Authorising
Interested in authority from two perspectives:o Sufficient authority to get job done
o How much authority to delegate
Authority is not the same as power
Authority is the type of ability to control and direct that is delegated from
higher levels
Power is given to an individual by subordinates at lower levels
For example, PM and functional manager have the same authority, but
functional leader has more power, given to him by subordinates
PM has to enter authority negotiations with functional manager
2.2.3.4. Team organizing PM responsible for organising how work is to be executed
To create organisational structures, PM must understand politics of the
organisation & the stakeholders
Organisational structures fall into the following categories
o Classic Theory: people involved are components of a production
process, producing the goals of the org. Often used in large scale
manufacturing
o Empirical Theory: basic similarities between the systems and processes
adopted by organisations. If enough observations and sample data are
taken, the process can be identified & indeed predicted. E.g. train
operating organisations tend towards the same systems and procedureso Behavioural Theory: two main schools
Human relations school: suggests there are intrinsic links
between the behaviour of individuals and the behaviour of the
organisation, need to match the two e.g. total quality
management
Social system school: as social characteristics of the
organisation change, so to must those of individuals. Changes
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
11/106
may go beyond attitudes and objectives they may involve
working practices e.g. smoking ban in workplace
o Decision theory: organisations can be observed and modelled and
models can be used to predict organisational efficiency in other
organisations
o System management theory: break up an organisation into a series of
linked systems, each with inputs, some form of processing and outputs Managers that subscribe to any of the above theories will be resistant to the
imposition of any systems derived from any other theory e.g. using classical
theory in an ad agency
PMs tend to favor more analytical - decision and system theories
PM needs to review available resources and pick appropriate org structure
At the first meeting, the following are agreed:
o Individual responsibilities
o Project organisational breakdown structure (OBS)
o Project Task responsibility matrix (TRM)
o Communication links
o Authority links
o
Information configuration management system
o Project programme
2.2.3.5 Controlling
PM responsible for
o Establishing desired targets for performance
o Measuring actual performance against targets
o Initiating corrective action where the actual performance deviates too
far from that desired
Controlling is a four stage process:
o
Targeting targets can be set for individuals or the group and shouldbe in line with overall success and failure criteria for project
o Measuring can be formal (earned value analysis) or informal
(appreciation or evaluation)
o Evaluating identifying where progress is not being made in
accordance with the overall project plan & consideration of corrective
action. Variance analysis looks at difference between planned and
actual events i.e. its retrospective. Should also use a forecasting
system, telling the PM where planned actions are likely to result in
poor performance
o Correcting Evaluation identifies where problems are occurring,
correcting phase identifies why problems are occurring, how to correct
them and monitors if they are being corrected (second level varianceanalysis)
2.2.3.6 Directing
1 This is the process involved in converting organizational goals into reality
using organizational and project resources
2 Activities include:
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
12/106
o Setting up the project team
o Team training and development
o Supervision
o Individual and team motivation
o Co-ordination
2.2.3.7 Team Building
1 Process of taking a series of individuals from different functional groups andwelding them into a unified project team
2 This is an ongoing thing, not just at start, although the start is most critical
3 Ten sections to any good team building process:
o Individual and team commitment: sharing aims and objectives of
project. This is easier when its an internal rather than external team.
Use reward system or external factors
o Developing team spirit: this is a measure of motivation
o Obtaining project resources: often a problem when the success of a
team means it grows. Mix of skills also criticalo Establishment of clear goalsand successes and failure criteria: stops
people moving the goalposts, strategic changes must be relayed to
team and project objectives re-established. Criteria must be
quantifiable
o Formalisation of visible senior management support
o Demonstration of effective program leadership
o Development of open formal and informal communications. Good
communications is a motivator. People take ownership
o Application of reward and retribution systems: good performers are
recognised and rewarded
o Identification and management of conflict: not just between people
but between incompatible design and cost information. Some conflict
is necessary
o Development of heterogeneity control and cohesiveness
2.2.3.8 Leadership
Traits include:
1 Decision making capability
2 Problem solving
3 Ability to integrate new team members
4 Inter personal skills
5
Ability to identify and manage conflict6 Communications skills
7 Interface management skills: with upper management, functional heads and
project team
8 Factor balancing skill: constant tradeoffs
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
13/106
2.2.3.9 Lifecycle Leadership
Project leadership is unique because requirements vary over time
1 Project teams last only until project is completed and hence there is little time
to gain knowledge of the project and team
2 Project manager concerned with complete lifecycle rather than just the
individual stage. So he must apply different leadership skills and styles
depending on the stage3 Lifecycle leadership is only relevant when one person leads team(s) through
entire lifecycle
4 Task oriented leadership relates to tasks themselves and the mechanics of the
process
5 People oriented leadership relates to leadership of individuals and how they
work as a team
Phase Characteristic Task People Effect
1 Inception Hi Lo Telling2 Development Hi Hi Persuading
3 Stablisation Lo Hi Participating
4 Maturity Lo Lo Delegating
1
Phase 1: similar to new employees joining a company, they want to be told
what to do as there is much confusion
2
Phase 2: system not yet evolved, so high task leadership. Growing trust
and so growing people leadership
3
Phase 3: Stabilised team and output secure. Manager moves to higher level
motivational factors (e.g. Maslows hierarchy)
4
Phase 4: team can be left alone to do project
2.3 Project Team
2.3.2 Project teams within functional organisations
1 Most projects are carried out within traditional organisations designed along
functional lines e.g. repackaging product is a marketing project
2 Some projects are run across functional areas e.g. installing a new finance
system
3 Some pure project organizations may be setup external to a parent company
4 Advantage of running projects with operating project teams within functional
organizations:o Structure provides flexibility
o Employees given new skills and experiences
o Team and cross functional attitude is improved
o Experts can share expertise across organisation
o Experts working together produce new synergies
o Employees in project can still follow primary career path
o New career paths open
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
14/106
o Less costly than using external consultants
5 Disadvantages
o Function has to continue to operate as normal despite resource
depletion
o Functional managers sometimes put weak people on projects
o May be difficult to adapt
o Project manager has difficulty making his project the priority
o Communications problems between projects and functional
organizations
o Motivation may be a problem
2.3.3 Team multi-disciplinary and heterogeneity Issues
1 The Project manager must blend functional specialists together
2 Sentience is the tendency for individuals to identify with their own
professional background3 Interdependency is when teams depend on inputs from more than one person
4 Specilaism adds to sentience which can lead to a communications problem
5 Integration is the process of defining responsibilities and control
6 The greater the range of team members characteristics and background, the
less the chance of overall bias or sentience, but higher conflict
7 Homogenous = one type
8 Heterogeneous = many types
2.3.4. Group and team processes1 Groups are collection of individuals who work together in pursuance of a
common objective
2
Teams are a collection of individuals who work under direction of a team
leader in pursuance of a common objective
3
Team = subset of Group
4 An organisation has many groups, formal and informal
5
Informal groups meet because of social reasons
6 Project Managers must be aware of all types of groups in an organisation
7
Groups are better than individuals at problem solving because
o they brainstorm more effectively
o consider a wide range of factors
o develop an enhanced logic flow
o generate more original ideaso consider a wider range of consequences
o solve problems quicker and more accurately
2.3.5 Project team performance
8 Factors which effect team performance the most are:
o Heterogeneity - the more, the better problem sovling but the more
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
15/106
conflict
o Cohesiveness - how much team members want to be members and how
well personal goals are aligned to team goals
2.4 Project Team Staffing Profile and Operation
2.4.2 Project Team Staffing
A balance of skills and experience is sought
Normally project manager will assemble a schedule of resources requiredand submit to senior management
Factors taken into account include
o Availability of resources - short and long term, internal vs.
external
o Ability
o Continuity requirements
o team working skills
o
special skills Successfully staffing means:
o Staffing is voluntary
o Staffing is in relation to value of project
o Less formal than functional teams
o PMs lead by example
o Teams are flexible and responsive
o Teams interface across all boundaries
o Teams innovate and evolve
o Functional managers receive recognition
o Conflict can be good during staffing
2.4.3 Project Team Profile
2.4.3.1 Project Team Mix
Think about team in the widest terms, including clients, subcontractors,stakeholders
The Project Office provides a focus
2.4.3.2 Uniqueness of project team
No set skills profile for an effective project team There are three project management positions that need to be filled: Project
Manager (acts as MD), Project Planner (acts as Operations Manager) and
Project Controller (CFO)
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
16/106
2.4.4 Project Team OperationKey areas are:
Establish measurable objectives: identify which stakeholders will decide ifproject is a success and work with them to define success
Stakeholder management: perception by them is critical, develop mentors and
get quality resources
Establish & plan for SMART targets at different levels with different people,
plan for risk and use milestones
Plan and establish processes: the environment and relationships should be
planned for (morale). Clear but flexible rules applied
Leadership: constant improving of team & rewards
Membership and identity: credibility, active membership
Communication systems: meetings are important, formal and informal,
actionable
Team separation: rely on the ability of other member to keep in regular contact
Teams in general: regular face to face meetings, performance measures,
completion criteria, commitments and responsibility
2.5 Project Team Evaluation
2.5.2 Project Life Cycles
Inception
Feasibility
Preliminary R&D
Manufacture of prototype
Development and testing of prototype
Second stage R&D Final trials
Production
Commissioning
Use
Decommissioning
Recycling
2.5.3 Project Change control and management
Very important
2.5.4 Project Team evaluation
Forming: team meets, objectives set, rules established, everyone knows their
responsibilities and objectives
Storming: establish cohesiveness, maybe conflict at this stage
Norming: establishing team standards
Performing
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
17/106
2.5.5. Groupthink
Happens when group of individuals become highly motivated towards a set ofbeliefs
Inconsistencies can cause problems
Groups emerging beliefs and aims replace their own
Symptoms include
o Absolute commitment to project
o Lack of respect for competitors
o Intolerance of dissenters
o Fear that something is wrong but censor themselves
o Self delusion, positive filter
o Selective reporting
2.6 Project team motivation
2.6.2 McGregor and Maslow
McGregor:
Theory X: operatives are lazy and need to be led
Theory Y: operatives want to work and find work stimulating
Most operational systems fall between the two
Functional managers are more X, Project managers are more Y
Maslow hierarchy of needs
Self actualisation (freedom to make the best of one's talents)
Esteem
Belongingness Safety
Physiology (Food/Water)
Hierarchy should be considered from the following perspectives:
Relative importance of needs, varies from project to project
Time based requirements, higher the level, the more time it takes to achieve it
Unsatisfied needs can cause resentment
Complex needs: higher level are more subjective and so more complex
Anticipation: fulfilled needs are no longer a motivation
2.6.3 Equity Theory and Expectancy Theory
2.6.3.1 Equity Theory
Based on the perceptions of individuals in relation to what they do and who
they are
Employees compare these and the level of effort to achieve them and that
defines level of motivation
If you perceive inequality you can:
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
18/106
o seek promotion
o seek increased reward level
o make a lesser contribution
o increase other inputs (shift work to colleagues)
2.6.3.2 Expectancy Theory People are motivated to achieve goals they believe will give them the rewards
they desire
People can be motivated provided the successful completion of the project can
be linked to their own personal goals
2.7 Project Team Communications
2.7.2 Project Communication
Process by which the Project Manager sends out information, directives and
objectives and monitors actual performance Depends partly on quantity and quality of face to face meetings
2.7.3 Formal and Informal communications
Organisations naturally develop barriers to communication
Various section of the organisation that are defined by functional and power
boundaries are called operation boundaries
Formal lines of communication are setup so project stakeholders get whatever
information they need and vice versa
A good communications system monitors and records the flow of information
Danger that formal communications become choked with volumes ofrelatively low value information, problem made worse by email and MS
Project
Formal communications include
o frequently distributed reports to predefined list
o regular project meetings
o project memos
o project noticeboard, newsletter and project away days
Informal communications revolve around the grapevine: hard to control but
can be influenced by
o lunch and dinner appointments
o telephone conversations
o
coffee breakso evening in bar
o social events
2.7.4 Internal and External communications
Project communication is either internal to project members or external to allother people
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
19/106
Good internal communication relies on people's willingness to communicateand disseminate openly
Good external communications is the opposite: requires absolute control overdissemination of information
One person should be responsible for all external communication
2.8 Project Team Stress
2.8.2 Origins and Symptoms of Team Member stressTypical reasons for stress
o Conflict between project and functional duties
o Working to strict time, cost and quality limits
o Team's short life span
o Projects tend to be relatively complex
o Operating within a changing environment
Stress leads to a loss in productivity and efficiency Stress types
o personal - from within the team member
o work - from work environment, usually linked to workload
o environmental stress - originates from outside both individual and
workplace e.g. fear of unemployment
Symptoms
Physiological - blood pressure
Phychological - sleep problems
Behavioural - loss of energy
2.8.3 Stress Management
2.8.3.1 Individual Stress Management
Poor diet
Lack of exercise
Physiological awareness and control
communication
Holidays
2.8.3.2 Project Team Stress Deregulation e.g. flexi time
Reasonableness
Fairness - balancing the workload
Open mindedness
Flexibility
Approachableness
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
20/106
2.9 Conflict Identification and Resolution
2.9.2 Sources of conflict
Onerous resource constraints
Pressure to increase speed / reduce costs
pressure to meet deadlines
personality clashes
functional vs project
misunderstanding requirements
incorrect or late communications
perception of inequalities
underlying resentment
2.9.3 Conflict Characteristics
more multi disciplined the team, the more the conflict
positive conflict is good
the lower the project managers power and authority, the higher the conflict
the lower the degree of specified and quantifiable objectives, the greater the
conflict
lower communications and accountability means more conflict
more change means more conflict
lower prestige of project means more conflict
2.9.4 Approaches to Conflict
must monitor and manage divergences of opinion
conflict highest during active phases of project, reduces at the beginning andend
Questions to ask
o why is conflict occurring
o what is the source of conflict e.g. are objective inconsistent?
o what is the potential impact to project
o can conflict be reduced or eliminated
o could conflict be foreseen and can we avoid it in future
2.9.5 Conflict management conflict avoidance: used if matter is not important enough or there is no
acceptable solution
conflict absorption: accept it and try to minimize
conflict resolution imposition: where there is no alternative, no consultation or
negotiation e.g. unemployment
negotiated conflict resolution
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
21/106
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
22/106
Module 3 - Risk
3.2 Background to risk .................................................................................................. 23
3.2.2 Concept of Risk ................................................................................................. 23
3.2.3 The Human Cognitive Process .......................................................................... 24
3.2.3.1 Pattern Recognition and Attention.............................................................. 243.2.3.2 Bounded Rationality ................................................................................... 24
3.2.3.4 Intuition and bias ....................................................................................... 24
3.2.3.5 The Decision Model ................................................................................... 24
3.3 Risk Handling .......................................................................................................... 25
3.3.2 Approaches to risk handling ............................................................................. 25
3.3.3 Risk Assessment and Control ............................................................................ 25
3.3.3.1 Elements of Risk assessment ....................................................................... 25
3.3.3.2 Elements of Risk Control ............................................................................ 25
3.3.3.3 Risk Identification ...................................................................................... 26
3.3.4 Project and Strategic Risks ............................................................................... 26
3.4 Types of Risk ........................................................................................................... 26
3.4.1 Generic Risk Headings ..................................................................................... 26
3.4.2 Market and Static Risk ...................................................................................... 26
3.4.3 External and Internal Risk ................................................................................ 26
3.4.3.1 External Risk (cannot be controlled) .......................................................... 26
3.4.3.2 Internal Risk (can be controlled) ................................................................ 27
3.4.4 Predictable and Unpredictable risks ................................................................. 27
3.5. Risk conditions and decision making....................................................................... 27
3.5.1 Conditions of Certainty ..................................................................................... 27
3.5.2 Decisions made under conditions of risk ........................................................... 27
3.5.3 Decision made under conditions of uncertainty ................................................. 27
3.5.3.1 Hurwicz Criteria ........................................................................................ 28
3.2.3.2 Wald Criterion ........................................................................................... 28
3.5.3.3 Savage Criterion ........................................................................................ 28
3.5.4.3.4 Laplace Criterion .................................................................................... 28
3.5.4 Rules for risk taking based on certainty risk and uncertainty ........... ........... ....... 29
3.5.5 Need for risk management strategy ................................................................... 29
3.6 The concept of Risk Management ............................................................................. 29
3.6.2 Risk Identification ............................................................................................. 30
3.6.2.1 Brainstorming ............................................................................................ 30
3.6.3 Risk Classification ............................................................................................ 303.6.4. Risk Analysis .................................................................................................... 30
3.6.4.1 Risk Analysis table ..................................................................................... 31
3.6.4.3 Risk Drivers Map ....................................................................................... 31
3.6.4.4 Risk Map .................................................................................................... 31
3.6.4.5 Risk grid .................................................................................................... 31
3.6.5 Risk Attitude ..................................................................................................... 31
3.6.6 Risk Response ................................................................................................... 32
3.6.6.1 Response Considerations ........................................................................... 32
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
23/106
3.6.6.2 Response Options ....................................................................................... 32
3.6.7 Risk control, policy and reporting ..................................................................... 33
3.7 Risk, Contracts and Procurement ............................................................................ 33
3.7.2 Basic Contract theory ....................................................................................... 33
3.7.3 Procurement ..................................................................................................... 34
3.7.4 Characteristics of Contracts ............................................................................. 343.7.4.1 Controllable and uncontrollable costs ........................................................ 34
3.7.4.2 Express and implied terms.......................................................................... 34
3.7.5 Transfer of risk in contracts .............................................................................. 35
3.7.6 Variation orders and change notices ................................................................. 35
3.7.7. Claims risk ....................................................................................................... 35
3.2 Background to risk
3.2.2 Concept of Risk1 Risk management evolved in the 50s with the design of nuclear reactors2 Risk is a measurement of the probability and consequence of not achieving a
specific project goal
3 First level equation for risk:
o Risk = function (event, uncertainty, consequences)
4 Two different events may carry the same risk, depending upon theiruncertainty and consequences
5 Second level equation is used when uncertainty is difficult to measure
o Risk = function (event, hazard, safeguard)
6 Something or lack of something = event. An event causes a risky situation7 Hazard = source of danger8 Safeguard = mitigation or defence against hazard9 Risk acts as a barrier to the development of an effective strategy10Risk management means that risk can be controlled and a certain strategy can
be pursued
11Exposure is a measure of the vulnerability of parts of the organisation to riskimpacts
12An organisations sensitivity to risk is a function ofo Significance (severity) of enterprises exposure
o Likelihood of different events occurring
o
Firms ability to manage implications13 Sensitivity = function(significance, likelihood, manageability)14Effective Risk Exploitation (EFE) is when an organisation makes use of assets
not normally measured on its P&L e.g. IP
15 Positive or negative changes in key variables are a source of risk16 General facts about risks
o World is uncertain
o Sometimes risks can be eliminated
o Risk is a function of opportunity
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
24/106
o Risk is an ally, if seized can lead to competitive advantage
o Risk management providers a range of analytical tools
17Risk management operates at all levels within an organisation18 Companies have to take risks19No risk management system is infallible
3.2.3 The Human Cognitive Process
3.2.3.1 Pattern Recognition and Attention
1 The decision making process is largely dependant on perceived risks andrewards
2 The human cognitive process involveso Pattern recognition: have I seen this before?
o Attention: this filters out unwanted information so only info relevant to
the decision remains
o Memory: short term memory stores the basic pattern recognition
information. Once filtered, its stored in long term memory to be usedagain
3.2.3.2 Bounded Rationality
1) A person will generally opt for rational behaviour within constraints2) Risk forecasting is
o Built on experience
o As much subjective as objective
o Possible to model it in complex maths
o Best evaluated using a combination of modelling and subject
approaches
o Extrapolate from past data to predict future events
3) Important to accurate forecasting:
o Accurate data
o Time limit, longer the time the more inaccurate
o Cost
o Vision, trying to envisage what the future will look like
3.2.3.4 Intuition and bias
1 Intuition is a combination of experience and extrapolations forward2 Bias is the tendency to misinterpret data because of a person's aims or
outcome preferences
3.2.3.5 The Decision Model
The analysis and synthesis of a problem from a four stage process:
Framing: avoid working on the wrong problem, the various
components of the problem are evaluated
Formulation: provides the formal model based on the problem
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
25/106
o alternatives available
o relationship between possible decisions and outcome
o preferences of decision maker
Evaluation: establish a ranking order of options
Appraisal: sensitivity of decision and effects on risk
3.3 Risk Handling
3.3.2 Approaches to risk handling
Bunker approach : try to be ready for anything.
o very expensive initial estimate
o only applicable to high tech, high significance work
Ostrich approach: opposite to bunker
Gut reaction: should be last resort
Aggressive
3.3.3 Risk Assessment and Control
Risk Assessment is part of risk analysis
Risk Analysis = determining the probability of risky events occurring and
their potential consequences and a monitoring and control process
Risk handling = how we deal with the risks
Risk control = risk analysis + risk handling + feedback to future strategies
Risk Management = Risk Assessment + Risk control
3.3.3.1 Elements of Risk assessment Risk assessment = Identify, analyse, classify and prioritise risk
process is iterative
steps are
o Identify risk
o Analyse risk
o Classify risk
o Prioritise risk
Likelihood of occurrence: Rabbits Lions
Mice Shark
Potential of occurring->
3.3.3.2 Elements of Risk Control
Risk control is a process by which actual and planned risk are measured andvariances between them acts as a basis for corrective action
must consider project constraints
activities on critical path are especially scrutinised
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
26/106
3.3.3.3 Risk Identification
Risk will have a source and an effect
Control requirements will vary according to the relative importance of an
activity
'Project could overrun' is not a risk
'Task A is underestimated' is a risk
3.3.4 Project and Strategic Risks
Project Risks are limited to Project
Strategic risks are more difficult to manage because they're more long term
and more complex & difficult to model
Most strategies allow for a variance envelope, up to which no action is taken.
Margin must diminish as project nears completion
3.4 Types of Risk
3.4.1 Generic Risk Headings
Strategic risk e.g. market, economic environment
Operational risk : the process, people in project teams
Financial risk : market, credit and capital structure
Knowledge risk: IT and KM issues
Catastrophic risk: cannot be predicted
All of the above are linked
3.4.2 Market and Static Risk
Some risks can have positive or negative outcomes and are dynamic e.g.
shares
Others are only negative e.g. insurance
Market risk is dynamic and concerned with potential losses and gains to the
organisation.
Market Business Risk (MBR) is when the company trades with its assets:
spreads risks throughout all of the company
Market Financial Risks arise from gearing ration and effects equity holders
only
Static Risk e.g. insurance, can be controlled or reduced whereas market risks
are always there
3.4.3 External and Internal Risk
3.4.3.1 External Risk (cannot be controlled)
Competition Risk
Market demand
Innovation
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
27/106
Exposure e.g. gearing
Shareholder risk eg. if shareholder confidence declines, may be difficult to
raise capital
Political risk
Statute risk
Impact - some companies can handle big hits
3.4.3.2 Internal Risk (can be controlled)
Operational
Financial
Management e.g. outsourcing
IT
3.4.4 Predictable and Unpredictable risks
Predictable are 'known unknown'
Unpredictable are 'unknown unknown'
change in project priority is an example of a dynamic internal unpredictable
risk
3.5. Risk conditions and decision making Risk assessment and control are tools for decision making
Three main conditions under which decisions can be made
o conditions of certainty
o conditions of risk: reasonable probability of a event occurring &
assessment can be made (predictable risk)
o
condition of uncertainty (unpredictable risk)
3.5.1 Conditions of Certainty
you know exactly what the outcome is for a range of strategies under a range
of different conditions
3.5.2 Decisions made under conditions of risk
In general, higher profits mean high risk
in the absence of a dominant strategy a probability is assigned to each state of
nature
3.5.3 Decision made under conditions of uncertainty
essential in this case to identify sources of uncertainty that relate to each of
the firms exposures (risk assessment)
source of uncertainty
o external
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
28/106
o internal
o decision drive (information) e.g. new market analysis
Its not possible to predict what will happen i.e. what state of nature will apply
3.5.3.1 Hurwicz Criteria
Also known as the Maximax criterion: decision maker seeks to maximizeprofits
N1 (probability= 25%) N2 (prob=25%) N3(prob=50%)
S1 100M 80M 60M
S2 150M 100M 80M
S3 200M 160M -100M
S= Strategies, N = events
Decision maker here would go for strategy S3 becuase it gives the maximum
profit (200)
He would ignore the fact that S3 is risky : max loss -100M
3.2.3.2 Wald Criterion
Also known as Maximin
Only considers minimum profits (not losses)
He would go for S2, as its worst case still yields 80M
3.5.3.3 Savage Criterion
Also known as Minimax
Minimise maximum regret for each strategy
For N1:
S1 regret = 200 -100 = 100
S2 regret = 200 -150 = 50
S3 regret = 200 -200 = 0
Regret table
N1 (probability= 25%) N2 (prob=25%) N3(prob=50%)
TOTAL
S1 100M 80M 20M 200
S2 50M 20M 0M 110
S3 0M 0M 180M 180
S2 has least regret and hence S2 is chosen
3.5.4.3.4 Laplace Criterion
Tries to convert uncertainty decision making to risk decision making using
subjective possibilities
objective possibilities are based on long term frequencies of occurrence
subject possibilities are based on degree of belief of decision maker
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
29/106
usually you compare the uncertain risk to a hypothetical risk and compare up
with an approximate possibilities
in the example, he just averages the payoffs for each strategy
3.5.4 Rules for risk taking based on certainty risk and
uncertainty Uncertainty
o how much money can we afford to lose
o what level of risk are we willing to take
o what level of risk outcome can we absorb
General
o analyse risks carefully
o plan as much as possible
o always have a plan B
o Dont accept risks for spurious reasons
o never risk more than you can afford to lose
o
allow for bias and groupthink Hazard and safeguard
o take risks in non critical areas
o reduce risk profile where possible
o dont confuse risk taking with boldness
Philosophical
o cannot avoid risk so accept
o risk = opportunity
o use risk to make money
3.5.5 Need for risk management strategy
Every area for outsourcing and risk transfer has been explored
Risk management should be seen as a collective corporate strategy
Total Strategic Risk Management (TRSM) is better suited to strategic planning
rather than tactical response
3.6 The concept of Risk Management Most risk management systems consist of 5 distinct areas
o risk identification
o risk classification
o risk analysis
o
risk attitude
o risk response
A Risk Management system should be
o practical
o realistic
o compliant
o cost effective
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
30/106
3.6.2 Risk Identification
This is about finding out all risks likely to impact on a given project and
exploring linkages between them, risks like:
Project risk: time & cost limits
Technical risk: R&D risk
Production risk: downtime Engineering risk: maintenance
Classifications of risk
Internal: these can be identified by breaking the project down into separate
work packages using Work Breakdown Structure (WBS)
External
Project: overlap internal and external, they are a feature of this specific
project e.g. the specific project team
It is important that identification process is concerned with risk source rather
than effect
Objective risk = based on experience Subjective risk = based on current knowledge e.g. Pert analysis
3.6.2.1 Brainstorming
Primary method for risk identification
Two phases: creative & evaluation
3.6.3 Risk Classification
Portfolio theory considers risk classification from a financial point of view
Three level classificationo risk type: static (insurable) or market (business)
o risk extent: environment, sector, company, project
o risk impact: hi, lo or medium
3.6.4. Risk Analysis
Identification of all feasible options and data relating to various risks and
analysis of outcomes of any decision
Step 1: evaluate all options: look deeper into identified risks
Step 2: consider the risk attitude of decision maker
Step 3: consider the characteristics of the risks eg. controllable?outcomes?
Step 4: establish measurement system e.g. qualitative or quantitative
Step 5: interpret results of measurement system
Step 6: make decision as to which risks to retain, which to transfer to
other parties and what risk profile is acceptable
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
31/106
3.6.4.1 Risk Analysis table
A risk analysis should comprise of a simple numerical analysis
Soil Type Probability Cost Probable Cost Time Probable
Time
Dry 0.2 1 0.20 2 0.4
Average 0.3 3 0.90 10 3Wet 0.5 5 2.50 20 10
TOTALS 3.60 13.4
3.6.4.2 Risk Factor Checklists
1=High, 5 = Low
Risk Description Probability Impact
---------------- ----------- --------
Design Problems 3 5Project Team gets VD 2 2
3.6.4.3 Risk Drivers Map
Usually derived from the SWOT analysis
3.6.4.4 Risk Map
Put isolated risks on an axis of impact vs. probability of occurrence
Risks can move within the risk map over time
you can have an 'actual' and a 'target' risk map
may be zones rather points that mark a risk where either impact and/or
probability is not exactly known
3.6.4.5 Risk grid
Alternative to risk map
Severity
Probability LO Medium High
Lo Retain Retain Insure
Medium Retain Insure Insure
High Insure Cease Cease
3.6.5 Risk Attitude
Risk evaluation is subjective and hence perceived level of risk depends upon
attitude of risk taker
Depends on company and personality of risk taker
Professions can be plotted
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
32/106
Plot of jobs on graph of Creativity vs. Risk
FACT: Teams take riskier decisions the longer they are together
3.6.6 Risk Response
3.6.6.1 Response Considerations Response depends upon
o nature of risk
o detail of the risk analysis
o attitude of risk taker
Risk response centres on risk distribution
The contract is the tool by which risk is allocated and distributed
The distribution of risk depends on
o is the outcome of project worth the risk?
o who has greatest risk control? e.g. suppliers controls delivery risk
o who has the greatest risk liability? Usually in legal systems the onus is
on the party who would be least effected by it occurring e.g. employerliable for employee
o what incentive does each party have? Usually both parties share at
least some risk
3.6.6.2 Response Options
Risk retention eg. not insuring household contents and hoping nothing goes
wrong. Perhaps you can retain some risk and transfer other e.g. 5% defect
rate on widgets
Risk reduction by:
o education/training
o
physical protection to reduce likelihood of loss [design to be robust]o systems for contingency
o physical protection to people and property
Risk reduction matrix:
Risk How to reduce probability How to reduce impact
-------------- --------------------------- --------------------------
......
Risk Transfer
o insurance is an option
o contractual clauses
Factors when considering insuranceo insurability of risk (eg. is data available)
o cost of premium
o maximum probable loss
o likely cost of loss (including replacement)
o likely cost of paying for loss if uninsured
Risks can be transferred through damage clauses within contracts
Non insurable risks can be transferred to contractors
Risk avoidance = refusal to take risks
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
33/106
Further information can be gathered
3.6.7 Risk control, policy and reporting
Risk Control = using information learnt now on a project at a later stage of
project
Risk impact + probabilities change over time and so need to be monitored
A risk handbook documents risk experiences
Risk reports could include
o risk maps with variances
o listing of risk drivers
o risks and KPIs
o progress reports
A risk policy doc contains
o risk holders and risk strategies for high probability and high impact
risks
o overall aims and objectives of risk management strategy
o
accountability e.g. task responsibility matrix (TRM)o formalised reporting channels
o risk tolerances
o authorisation
3.7 Risk, Contracts and Procurement Contract defines rights, dues, obligations and liabilities of each party
3.7.2 Basic Contract theory Companies compete for work using bids or tenders
These bids and tenders depend upon wording of the contract
Contract normally include
o signature block and project title
o definition of contract terms and scope
o information and facilities provided by client
o project approvals e.g. milestones
o payment systems e.g. when and how much
o specification of product/service being provided
o general conditions
o specific conditions
o
provision for changeso form of tender
o dispute resolution e.g. bad contract, insolvency
o bonds and warranties
For a contract to exist there must be
o offer and acceptance
o consideration i.e. exchange of something, usually money
o Capacity ie. ability to perform obligations
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
34/106
o legal relations - contract must be legal
o communication - offeror must be aware
Alternatives to successfully performing the contract are
o breach
o frustration - contract cannot be performed even though both parties
want to
o
recission - error or misunderstanding in original contracto rectification - badly worded contract
o void e.g. legal goods
o termination
o determination - one party seeks reimbursement from the other
3.7.3 Procurement
process by which goods and services are acquired
good procurement -> good suppliers -> good performance
procurement can be strategic or project procurement can have lifecycle phases:
o objective: establishing objectives of procurement process and contract
terms
o exposure: sourcing vendors
o alternatives: comparing vendors
o documentation: preparation of contracts and definition
o tendering : vendors invited to bid
o award: bids scrutinised
o contract administration: monitor T&C's to ensure they are satisfied
3.7.4 Characteristics of Contracts
3.7.4.1 Controllable and uncontrollable costs
these effect overall level of risk in contract
fundamental contract risks are
o adequacy of design: latent (hidden) and patent (obvious) defects
o project eventual cost: cost overrun risk could be born by client and/or
contractor
o safety and indemnification for accidents
o third party insurance
o fire/flood etc.
o completion deadlines
3.7.4.2 Express and implied terms
Fundamental risks are expressed by express terms
Liabilities (eg. reasonable duty of care) are generally covered by implied
terms
There are contractual situations (e.g. professional services) where you cannot
cover everything in express terms
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
35/106
most consultants/professional have professional indemnity insurance
3.7.5 Transfer of risk in contracts
The greater transfer of risk, the greater the cost of the contract
Indemnity clauses transfer specific risk for specific events onto a named party
3.7.6 Variation orders and change notices
There allow for changes in a contract without invalidating it
Must be fair to both parties
3.7.7. Claims risk
If a delay or change occurs a party might seek reimbursement from the party
that caused it
Contracts will often list items that are classified as client risk e.g. feature
creep
Contractor could claim direct loss and expense and/or more time
client usually liable for fire/flood/acts of God
contractor usually liable for his employees/harmful chemicals etc.
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
36/106
Module 4: Project Management
Organisation Structures and Standards
4.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 364.2. Organisation Theory and structures ....................................................................... 37
4.2.2 The Project within an existing organisation ...................................................... 37
4.2.2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................... 37
4.2.2.2 Functional structure ................................................................................... 37
4.2.2.3 Pure Project Structure ............................................................................... 37
4.2.2.4 Matrix Structure ......................................................................................... 38
4.2.2.5 Mixed or hybrid structure ........................................................................... 39
4.2.3 The Project external to the existing organisation .............................................. 39
4.2.3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................... 39
4.2.3.2 External (executive) project management structure .................................... 39
4.2.4 Criterion for selecting organisation structure ................................................... 41
4.2.4.1 Broad Considerations ................................................................................ 414.2.4.2 Project Objectives and choice of organisational structure .......................... 41
4.3 Examples of Organisation Structure ........................................................................ 41
4.3.2 Example of an internal project management structure ...................................... 42
4.4 Project Management Standards ............................................................................... 42
4.4.2 The APM and the APM body of knowledge ....................................................... 42
4.4.2.1 Aims ........................................................................................................... 42
4.4.2.2 The APM body of knowledge profile ........................................................... 42
4.4.3 BS6079 ............................................................................................................. 43
4.4.4. Prince 2 ........................................................................................................... 43
4.4.4.1 Introduction ................................................................................................... 43
4.4.4.2 PRINCE2 Methodology .................................................................................. 43
4.1 Introduction The org structure defines the arrangement of resources within the
organisation
An org breakdown structure (OBS) is a map showing main components or
organisation and how they relate to each other
A project managers task is to look at existing org structures, look at the
required project structure and modifying both to produce the optimal project
structure
Project teams can beo wholly internal to organisation
o wholly external to organisation
o partly internal but with external specialist support
Organisation structures can be
functional based
pure project based e.g. R&D
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
37/106
matrix structure - functional group exist but project teams are formed
across functional boundaries
internal project teams eg. local govt
external project teams e.g. ad agencies
4.2. Organisation Theory and structures
4.2.2 The Project within an existing organisation
4.2.2.1 Introduction
The decision of internal vs. external depends on
size of project relative to organisation
relative status and importance of project
resources available
strategic fit with strategic objectives of company
4.2.2.2 Functional structure
In larger organisations self contained non matrixed projects can exist within
a particular functional group
These are usually incremental improvement projects
Advantages
clear reporting
clear authority
simpler
uses specialist knowledge
Disadvantages
inflexible
projects within functional group tend to be viewed as of secondary
importance
cross functional activities are discouraged
career is tied to functional rather than project
projects become islands in group
only OK for continuous programs of work
greater degree of central support required
main problem is operational islands = semi independent sub groups
project and matrix structures remove these islands by forming horizontal and
vertical lines of authority and communication
4.2.2.3 Pure Project Structure
Could be a self contained project within a group
used when project are difficult to plan and resources required are uncertain
at its simplest, project manager picks from a pool of specialist resources that
get returned to the pool when project is complete (e.g. consultancy company)
pure project structure differs from functional organisation projects in that the
latter are internal for benefit of organisation itself whereas former are more
visible e.g. new drug development
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
38/106
pure project structures may be completely separate from parent company e.g.
joint venture
Advantages
flexibility
encourages innovation
operational: can be dynamically adjusted
project manager has total control of project, not sharing resource withthe functional manager
clear reporting
communications lines shorter
authority contained within project
team members have no functional loyalties
support requirements are smaller
easier to use external consultants in this structure
can have a series of projects forming a program-> more efficiencies
Disadvantages
several projects at same time => duplication of work
initial operating costs can be high
central authority required
may be a padding of resources
unhealthy competition e.g. cutting corners
lack of long term commitment
difficult to compare project performance due to different nature
prolonged absence from their functional group may blunt a team
members specialist knowledge
4.2.2.4 Matrix Structure
pure functional and pure project structures represent different ends of the
spectrum matrix is a compromise, also known as internal or non-executive project
management structure
usually technical decisions on the project are responsibility of functional
group
Resourcing, scheduling and cost decisions made by project manager
matrix structures can be strong e.g. long-term projects that veer more
towards pure project structures
Internal project management systems have the following key characteristics:
functional boundaries - vertical
organisationl islands - same horizontal level but different functions and
so dont communicate
project sponsor - conflict resolving and monitors project
Project management chair: PS
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
39/106
Time recording and cost centre charging
Good points of matrix project management system
self contained unit
access to functional units
flexible and adaptable
links with functional groups means project remains in sync with corporate
and functonal objectivesgood innovation
Weaknesses
difficulties balancing project vs functional
confused reporting to two bosses
project management job is more complex
project sponsor requirements adds complexity
4.2.2.5 Mixed or hybrid structure
combination of functional and project structures e.g. new product project
based in marketing but requires R&D input
4.2.3 The Project external to the existing organisation
4.2.3.1 Introduction
Surrogacy is the extent to which clients want to delegate control/authority to
running a project
Risk transfer is also an important issue in external project management
4.2.3.2 External (executive) project management structure
'Executive' because project management has total control, no negotiation
with functional managers
Suits smaller organisations
Formal interface body acts as gateway between organisation and external
organisation project manager
A legal contract might be drawn up and monitored
Characteristics
o multidisplinarian/shared loyalty group characteristics -> sentience
and differentiation
o fee structure - consultants bid to be part of an external project team.
The timing could be at
completion of pre contract work (e.g. analysis) completion of post contract work (e.g. implementation)
completion of final account (e.g. completion)
o fees could be per hour or % of work to be done
External contractual linkages
o risk increases with more external dependency
o contract take these forms
completion contract - one off payments on completion
term contracts : long term
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
40/106
service level agreements
o contracts are priced by
completion contracts
negotiated contracts
o contracts can be
fixed price
cost or cost plus: profit fixedreimbursement: expenses plus fees
target price: target + fee+ incentive
o contract types:
standard: reasonable risk allocation, recourse cover all eventualities
professional services contract: mostly implied terms, fees and dates
covered, related to professional standards
supply contract: specify goods and delivery dates
pro forma contracts: monopoly situation, onus on the client e.g. ESB
Contractual links include
o Client to PM and other team members
o Client to main contractor
o Client to service authorities i.e. supply agreements
o Client to nominated sub contractors and suppliers: sub contractor
nominated to main contractor
o Client to local authority e.g. safety & regulatory issues
External non contractual linkages
o Authority links: client = head of authority
o Communication links: change control procedures
o Having client bypass project manger and communicate directly with team
is a bad idea: scope creep
Advantages of external project management
o Flexibleo Dynamic
o External specialist bring in new ideas
o If there is no internal knowledge you can use external
o Quick to setup
o Quick to disband
o Internal risks avoided e.g. having key people missing
Disadavantages:
o Expensive
o No loyalty
o Recourse can be difficult
o New control structures necessaryo Rigid and controlled communications required
o Legal people get involved
o Risk profile changes
o Complex project management
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
41/106
4.2.4 Criterion for selecting organisation structure
4.2.4.1 Broad Considerations
o Authority
o Communication
o
Knowledge transfer
o Loyalty
o Technology e.g. matrix use IT to innovate
o Cost: functional is high cost and inflexible
o Co-ordination: functional has a low degree of co-ordination required
o Support functions: functional require lots of support
4.2.4.2 Project Objectives and choice of organisational structure
A Functional organisation structure is suitable when
o Workload is constant and doesnt vary mucho Projects are required infrequently
o Well developed support structure exist
o Informal communications not required
o Where functional objectives are the main concern
A Matrix structure is suitable when
o Dynamic workload
o Project frequently required
o R&D frequently required
o Centralised support present or outsourced
o Split authority ok
o Informal communications oko Projects are of secondary importance but still significant
o Projects are small to medium sized
o Fast response not required
Pure project structure is suitable when
o Workload varies a lot
o Projects are frequent
o Lots of R&D
o Little centralised support
o Authority can be devolved to project managers
o Projects are primary concern
o Projects are largeo Fast response time required
4.3 Examples of Organisation Structure
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
42/106
4.3.2 Example of an internal project management structureSetting up a new engineering project management course
Step 1: Appoint a project manager and team. The choice depends on
o Priority of new course
o General availability and workload
o Existing commitments
o University policy
Step 2: structure: maybe matrix across engineering, management and science?
Step 3: external consultants? Yes, if its a highly specialised subject area. It may
involve the setting up an interface via the Legal Services group within the
university
Step 4: setup formal and informal links within the internal project team, university
admin, external consultant and project sponsor
4.3.3 Example of an external project management structureManaging external training courses
Step 1 : the clients legal services setup contracts with external service providersStep 2: Draw up pro-forma professional services agreements describing syllabus
and details, fees and expenses
4.4 Project Management StandardsAPM is the Association for Project Management: body of knowledge
BS 6079: standards for practice based on APM approaches
Prince 2: stand alone methodology (Project management ina Controlled
Envrionment), its an alternative to BS 6079
Numerous industry specific adaptations of these generic standards
4.4.2 The APM and the APM body of knowledge
4.4.2.1 Aims
o Act as the first point of contact
o Lead the development of professionalism
o Champion interest representation: lobby govts etc.
o Establish standards of qualifications
o Establish national branches
o Establish practices and procedures for training
4.4.2.2 The APM body of knowledge profile
Lists five areas project managers must have academic qualifications and
experience in:
o Project management e.,g. project lifecycle and environment
o Organisation and people e.g. leadership and communications
o Techniques and procedures e.g. scheduling and estimating
o General management e.g. finance and law
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
43/106
o Value management i.e. aims and objectives of client
Project manager should be concerned about the long term use of the system
being built
4.4.3 BS6079 British guide to Project management
Strategic Project Plan (SPP) is the most important part of BS6079
Establishes a generic project plan that is applied to all projects
Main sections of SPP defined in BS 6079 include:
o Preliminaries: title page, description of project, contents list, defines who
has access to what
o Project aims and objectives: objectives relate to time, cost, quality and a
range of other objectives. may also be sub objectives e.g. health and
safety, environment
o Subject specific sections: information presented in standard format.
scheduling and cost control, project history Contributors to the SPP include:
o design engineers
o cost consultants
o legal consultants
o client (aims and objectives)
o project manager (communication and co-ordination systems)
o external statutory bodies
4.4.4. Prince 2
4.4.4.1 Introduction
Its an alternative to BS 6079
Originally used for government IT projects
4.4.4.2 PRINCE2 Methodology
Based on the process model of a project - breaking project down into
component processes
Each process is then defined in terms of its key inputs and outputs and in
terms of the aims and objectives of each process
Prince 2 is driven by the project business case Main advantages
o offers a standardized project structure with a clear start, middle and
end
o allows regular and detailed reviews of actual vs. planned progress
o allows regular and detailed reviews of actual vs. business case
o identifies and makes use of flexible decision points
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
44/106
o identifies and allows automatic control of any deviations from project
plan
o ensures timing and involvement of all stakeholders and management is
optimized
o encourages good communication channels
-
7/26/2019 Module 1 - 7 Point Form 106
45/106
Module 5 : Project Time Planning and Control
5.1 The Concept of Project Time Planning and Control ................................................................. 46
5.1.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 46
5.1.2 Aim and Objectives of the planning process ...................................................................... 46
5.1.3 Project Time Planning and control and the Generic Project Plan ..................................... 47
5.1.4 Project Time Planning and the Project Life Cycle ............................................................. 47
5.2 The Process of Project Time Planning ..................................................................................... 48
5.2.1 Factors Affecting the Time Planning Process .................................................................... 48
5.2.1.2 Sources of Time Planning Data .................................................................................. 48
5.2.1.3 Project Uniqueness .................................................................................................... 48
5.2.1.4 People Issues ............................................................................................................. 48
5.2.1.5 Complexity ................................................................................................................. 48
5.2.1.6 Uncerta
top related