minutes of the tenth meeting of the state level expert
Post on 01-Jan-2022
1 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Name of the members who were present in the meeting are as follows:
1. Prof. (Dr.) Sudarshan Neogi Chairman, SEAC2. Dr. Kalyan Rudra Member, SEAC3. Dr. Satya Kinkar Pal Member, SEAC4. Dr. Arunkanti Biswas Member, SEAC5. Prof.(Dr.) S.R. Raychaudhuri Member, SEAC6. Dr. Amitava Roy Member, SEAC7. Dr. Anita Chattopadhyay Gupta Member, SEAC8. Prof. Bhabatosh Biswas Member, SEAC9. Prof. Jayanta Bhattacharya Member, SEAC10. Sri P. K. Sarkar Secretary, SEAC & Member Secretary, WBPCB
In the beginning of the 88th meeting of SEAC, which was held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Bidhan Nagar, the Secretary, SEAC welcome all the members. After introductory session, two cases were discussed under 'Miscellaneous' section. Eleven applicants were requested to make their presentation before the committee. Ten applicants appeared before the SEAC for technical presentation on their respective project proposal. Fourteen cases were placed for reconsideration.
SESSION I
A. Miscellaneous Section :
1. Proposed IT Park by M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. at Jl. No. 35, Mouza – Gangapur, Kolkata Information Technology Park (KITP), Bantala, PS – Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. – 24 Parganas (South).
SEAC has recommended EC in the 67th meeting held on 21.05.2012 for M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. SEIAA has sent a letter to SEAC on 16.08.2012 requesting to study the water balance in CLC area.
The above matter was discussed in the 71st meeting held on 24.09.2012, 73rd meeting held on 30.11.2012 & 75th meeting held on 30.01.2013 and SEAC had requested Director, SWID, GoWB to provide opinion on the status of water availability based on latest water census in the concerned area.
The above issue was discussed in the 77th SEAC meeting held on 26.03.2013 and the committee has issued a reminder letter to the SWID for providing opinion as per latest water census of the area and this case has been kept pending due to nonavailability of opinion of SWID.
SEAC has received a letter dated 25.04.2013 issued by the Director, SWID regarding EC application in respect to applicants namely M/s Phoenix Software Ltd., M/s Dhunseri Petrochem and Tea Ltd., and M/s Cognizant Technology Solutions India (P) Ltd. at KITP Bantala mentioning that M/s. Dalmiya & Co. should apply in prescribed form at the office of the Geologist & Member Secretary, DLA of South 24 Parganas & necessary permission in this regard will be provided by DLA, South 24 parganas as per provisions under GWAct duly approved by SLA and Technical Subcommittee.
Page 1 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. submitted a letter to the Member Secretary, WBPCB on 03.10.2013 informing that M/s M L Dalmiya has already applied to SWID for installation of an additional tubewell as recommended by SWID.
The case was considered in the 79th meeting held on 28.12.2013 and the committee recommended to forward the case to SEIAA for necessary action.
SEIAA referred the proposal back to SEAC mentioning that it is not conclusive whether M/s. ML Dalmiya & Co. Ltd. had obtained necessary permission for abstracting ground water for subsequent distribution of water to the project proponent.
M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd. submitted a letter on 12.06.2014 to SEAC that M/s. ML Dalmiya & Co. Ltd. has obtained necessary permission from SWID for abstracting ground water of 90m3/hrs. @ 10 hrs./day.
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was placed for information in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC discussed the project proposal & submission of the project proponent and recommended to forward the submission (permission for abstraction of ground water issued by SWID in favor of M/s M.L Dalmia & Co.) of the project proponent to the SEIAA for consideration.
2. Proposed application for amendment of Environmental Clearance from 3x135 MW CFBC based boiler to 3x150 MW PF based boiler by M/s. India Power Corporation (Haldia) Ltd. at Jl. No. – 94, Mouza – Kismatshibrampur, Jl. No. – 170, Mouza – Tentulberia, Jl. No. – 147, Mouza – Sovarampur, Jl. No. – 146, Mouza – Kashbere, PS – Bhabanipur, Haldia, Dist. – Purba Medinipur, West Bengal.
The proponent earlier applied for environmental clearance on 31.12.2008 for the proposed Coal based Thermal Power Plant (3x135 MW) at Haldia for the captive energy requirement of Bhaskar Silicon Ltd. for the proposed Poly Silicon Solar PV project. The proponent obtained EC from SEIAA on 12.04.2010.
The proponent has again applied for environmental clearance on 20.04.2011 for 450 MW TPP instead of 405 MW TPP. Earlier proposal was for AFBC Boiler, present proposal is for PF Boiler.
The SEAC has considered the project proposal in the 57th meeting held on 25.07.2011. SEAC decided that since CEPI related moratorium in Haldia is still in force the SEAC is not in a position to consider the case and accordingly informed to SEIAA dated 27.07.2011.
Accordingly, SEIAA informed the project proponent on 11.08.2011 that this proposal which involve expansion in capacity cannot be processed at a state level.
The project proponent has again requested vide their letters dated 26.12.2013 to consider the proposal in the SEAC meeting since moratorium imposed by MoEF has been lifted for Haldia industrial clusters in West Bengal.
The case was put up for consideration in the 80th SEAC meeting held on 18.01.2014. The SEAC after detailed discussion recommended to forward the case to the SEIAA for taking necessary action as moratorium imposed by MoEF has been lifted for Haldia industrial clusters in West Bengal still Haldia industrial cluster is considered as Critically Polluted Areas and attract general conditions as per
Page 2 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
EIA Notification, 2006 and its amendment thereafter. Member Secretary, WBPCB and Secretary, SEAC, WB also sent a letter to MoEF seeking opinion in this regard.
SEAC, WB received a letter from MoEF vide D.O no. J13015/16/2014IA.I dated 27.06.2014 regarding EC application of the project proponent. The SEAC discussed and reviewed the project proposal in light with the letter issued by MoEF, in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. During the meeting SEAC recommended that above mentioned proposal including Form I and other relevant documents as submitted by the project proponent are to be forwarded to MoEF for consideration of the project.
SESSION II
B. Note on Technical presentations
Industry Sector:
1. ToR presentation for the proposed expansion of 1x4 MT induction furnace by M/s. Steel Crackers Pvt. Ltd. at J.L no.14, MouzaBighati, Vill Dhobapukur, P.SBhadreshwar, DistHooghly, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of 1x4 MT induction furnace in the existing plant.
The existing and the proposed facilities are as follows :
Installations Existing Capacity Proposed CapacityInduction Furnace 2x5 T
Billet/Ingot 42,000 TPA1x4T
Billet/Ingot 16800 TPA
Chronology of the event:
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are :
i. Location of the Site – J.L no.14, Mouza – Bighati, Vill – Dhobapukur, P.SBhadreshwar, DistHooghly, West Bengal.
ii. Land Area – Existing 5.615 acresiii. Production Capacity – ExistingBillet/Ingot 42,000 TPA, Expansion: Billet/Ingot 16800 TPAiv. No. of working days per annum – 300 daysv. Emission Sources 1x4 T induction furnacevi. Air Pollution Control System –Bag filter will be installed with IF, RMH sectionvii. Water Requirement – 4 KLD (sourceGW)viii. Wastewater treatment – Industrial Recycle & Zero discharge, Domestic Septic tank.ix. Power Source – 3 MW, WBPDCLx. Solid waste Slag used for land filling/road construction
Name of the Environmental Consultant: M/s. Envirotech East Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After carefully considering the submission by the project proponent and presentation, SEAC recommended ToR (Annexure – I) for preparing draft EIA/EMP reports.
Page 3 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
2. ToR presentation of proposed expansion of the Cement Grinding Unit of M/s. Pristine Cement (P) Ltd., at Jl. No. – 15, Dag No. – 636, 637, 638, 639, 646, 650 and 650/780, Vill. & PO – Suryapur, Mouza – Navarand, Tehsil – Barrackpore, Sewli Gram Panchayat, Khardah Barasat Road, Dist. – 24 Parganas (N), Pin – 700121, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of a Cement Grinding unit for manufacturing Portland Slag Cement (200 TPD / 60000 TPA) and Portland Pozzolona Cement (100 TPD / 30000 TPA). It is noted that clinker will not be manufactured at the site. The manufacturing process will involve grinding of Cement Clinker with Slag / Flyash and Gypsum. The proponent has earlier obtained EC from SEIAA and NOC from WBPCB for installation of a Cement Grinding unit with Oil fired Slag drier for manufacturing Portland Slag Cement (50 TPD / 14400 TPA). However, the proponent has now proposed to install Coal fired Slag Drier.
Chronology of the event :
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are :
i. Location of the Site Jl. No. – 15, Dag No. – 636, 637, 638, 639, 646, 650 and 650/780, Vill. & PO – Suryapur, Mouza Navarand, Tehsil Barrackpore, Sewli Gram Panchayat, Khardah Barasat Road, Dist. – 24 Parganas (N), Pin – 700121, West Bengal.
ii. Land Area – 1.653 acres (earlier 1.16 acres). iii. Raw Materials Clinker, Slag, Flyash, Gypsum, Coal for Slag Drier.iv. Additional Production Capacity Portland Slag Cement (200 TPD / 60000 TPA) and Portland
Pozzolona Cement (100 TPD / 30000 TPA). v. Emission Sources Raw Material Handling Section, Transfer Points, Ball Mills (1x200 TPD and
1x100 TPD), Cement Silo, Packing Section etc. to be provided with high efficiency Bag Filters and Coal fired Slag Drier.
vi. Air Pollution Control System – Bag Filters with stack of height 30m from GL shall be provided at Raw Material Handling Section, Transfer Points, Ball Mills (1x200 TPD and 1x100 TPD), Cement Silo, Packing Section etc. Wet Cyclone with stack of height 30m from GL. should be provided for Coal fired Slag Drier, as proposed.
vii. Total Water requirement – 10 KLD, Ground water.viii. Total Power requirement – 500 KVA, WBSEB.ix. Backup Power – DG Set (1x100 KVA).
The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After carefully considering the submission by the project proponent and presentation, SEAC recommended ToR (Annexure – II) for preparing draft EIA/EMP reports.
Page 4 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
3. ToR presentation of proposed standalone cement grinding unit of capacity1.5 MTPA and CPP 10 MW of M/s. Emami Cement Ltd. at Raghunathpur Industrial Park, Mouza—Durmut, Raghunathpur, DistPurulia, Pin 713336, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for installation of a stand alone Cement Grinding unit (1.5 MTPA) with Coal fired TPP 10 MW. It is noted that clinker will not be manufactured at the site. The manufacturing process will involve grinding of Cement Clinker with fly ash and Gypsum.
Chronology of the event :
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are :
i. Location of the Site – Raghunathpur Steel & allied industrial Park, Mouza Durmut, Raghunathpur, Dist – Purulia.
ii. Land Area – 26.305 Ha / 65 acre. iii. Green area 8.68 Ha (33% of land area)iv. Raw Materials Requirement – Clinker 877500 LTPA, Fly ash 247500 LTPA, Gypsum 750000
LTPA, Slag300000 LTPA, Coal 80000 LTPA v. Production Capacity – Cement Grinding Unit 1.5 MTPA & CPP10 MW.vi. No. of working days per annum – 300 days.vii. Emission Sources – CFBC Boiler. viii. Air Pollution Control System – Individual pulse jet bag filter & ESP for CFBC boiler. ix. Water Requirement – 550 KLD, Source – Ground water / DVC. x. Wastewater – Domestic wastewater will be treated through STP, Process waste water to be
treated in ETP.xi. Power Source – 11 MW, DVC/ CPP.xii. Back up Power – DG set 1x500 KVA
Name of the Environmental consultant M/s. JM EnviroNet Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After carefully considering the submission by the project proponent and presentation, SEAC recommended ToR (Annexure – III) for preparing draft EIA/EMP reports.
4. ToR presentation for proposed expansion of 2x12 T Induction Furnace by M/s. Shree Parasnath ReRolling Mills Ltd. at 3511(P) & 4010 (P), JL No. 85, Touzi No. 1, Khatian No. 93, Mouza – Gopinathpur, Dist – Burdwan, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of 2x12 T Induction Furnace at the existing unit at 3511(P) & 4010 (P), JL No. 85, Touzi No. 1, Khatian No. 93, Mouza – Gopinathpur, Dist – Burdwan.
The existing and the proposed facilities are as follows :
Installations Existing Capacity Proposed CapacityInduction Furnace
2x7 T with CCM MS billets48000 TPA
2x12 T Billet 95040 TPA
Rolled products 155000 TPA rolling mill, 50000 TPA ladle refining furnace
Page 5 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Chronology of the event :
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are :
i. Location of the Site – 3511(P) & 4010 (P), JL No. 85, Touzi No. 1, Khatian No. 93, Mouza – Gopinathpur, Dist – Burdwan,
ii. Land Area – Existing – 7.6 acres, Green belt (proposed)2.8 acres, total10.4 acresiii. Raw Materials – Sponge Iron 64836 TPA, Scrap16809 TPA, Pig Iron – 20672 TPA, Silico
Manganese – 2088 TPAiv. Production Capacity – ExistingBillet/Ingot 48000 TPA, Expansion: Billet/Ingot 95040 TPAv. No. of working days per annum – 300 daysvi. Air Pollution Control System –Bag filter will be installed with IFvii. Water Requirement – 35KLD (existing21 KLD, additional14 KLD) (sourceDPL)viii. Wastewater treatment – Zero discharge Domestic effluent after treatment in Septic tank is
disposed to soak pit. Induction furnace slag will be utilized in road / area / land development.ix. Power Source – 25 MW(existing13 MW,additional12 MW) source DPLx. Back up Power – existing DG set1x125 KVA, Proposed2x250 KVAxi. Solid waste Slag 8968 TPA used for land filling/road construction.
Name of the Environmental Consultant: M/s. Environ India. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After carefully considering the submission by the project proponent and presentation, SEAC recommended ToR (Annexure – IV) for preparing draft EIA/EMP reports.
5. Proposed Upardanga Granite Mine project by M/s. Todi Minerals Pvt. Ltd. at Upardanga Granite Block, Mouza – Talsankara, JL No. 163, Plot No. 3310, PS – Raghunathpur, Dist – Purulia, PIN – 723 133, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for mechanized mining of granite of 1 ha. Lease area for 5 years. Total gross Granite 8730 m3 volume. The granite blocks from the granite deposit in the form of Hilock will be extracted and further upto 10 mtr. depth below the surface will also be extracted.
Chronology of the event :
Salient features of the proposed project are :
1) Location of the Site – Mouza – Talsankara, JL No. 163, Plot No. 3310, PS – Raghunathpur, Dist – Purulia, PIN – 723 133, West Bengal.
2) Total Lease Area – 1 ha.3) Greenbelt – 33% of the land area. Tree Plantation – 490 nos.4) Manpower – 25 nos.5) Production Capacity – year wise gross volume – 1st year – 715 m3, 2nd year – 2036 m3, 3rd year –
1985 m3, 4th year – 2011 m3, 5th year – 1983 m3.6) Water Requirement – To be drawn from shallow tube well.7) Solid Waste – granite waste – 2620 m3. 8) Backup Power – 82.5 KVA DG set.
Page 6 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. The project proponent vide letter dated 26.06.2014 requested SEAC to allow them to make a proper presentation in the next SEAC meeting.
6. Proposed modernization of existing Ductile Iron Pipe Plant by M/s. Rashmi Metaliks Ltd. at Vill. Gokulpur, PO Shyamraipur, PS – Kharagpur, Dist. – Paschim Medinipur, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for modernization of existing Ductile Iron Pipe Plant without changing any production capacity at the existing unit at Vill Gokulpur, PO Shyamraipur, PS – Kharagpur, Dist. – Paschim Medinipur.
Chronology of the event :
M/s. Rashmi Metaliks Ltd. has obtained EC from SEIAA on 09.10.2009 for expansion project for installation of Ductile Iron Pipe Plant of capacity 2,00,000 TPA. Now, they have applied for modernization of existing plant without changing any production capacity.
Salient features of the proposed modernization project are:
Sl. No.
Permission for Installation of
Machineries throughEnvironmental
Clearance
No. of Units& Capacity as
Per ‘EC’
Proposed Additional Machineries
Total Machinerywith Capacity after
EC Amendment
1. Induction Furnaces with 5 crucibles
2 X 8 MT with 5 Crucibles
2 X 8 MT with 5 Crucibles where 1 crucible is standby i.e. 4 Nos. are operational at a time
10 Nos. crucibles where 8 Nos. will be running at a time and 2 nos. will be standby
2. Centrifugal Casting Machine
8 X 5 TPH 2 X 5 TPH 10 X 5 TPH
3. Magnesium Converter 2 X 18 TPH 2 X 18 TPH
4. Core Making Machines 2 Nos. 2 Nos.
5. Annealing Furnace 2 X 30 TPH 2 X 30 TPH
6. Zinc Coating Machines 4 X 10 TPH 4 X 10 TPH
7. Hydraulic Pressure Testing Machine
2 Nos. 2 Nos. 4 Nos.
8. Cement Mortar Lining 2 X 15 TPH 2 X 15 TPH 4 X 15 TPH
9. Bitumen Coating Machine with Preheating & Post Heating furnaces.
2 X 15 TPH 2 X 15 TPH
Page 7 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Sl. No.
Permission for Installation of
Machineries throughEnvironmental
Clearance
No. of Units& Capacity as
Per ‘EC’
Proposed Additional Machineries
Total Machinerywith Capacity after
EC Amendment
10. Mould Grinding and Arc welding machines
3 Nos. 3 Nos.
11. Finishing unit 8 nos. 8 Nos.
12. Sand Driers 2Nos. 2 Nos. (BF Gas used as a Fuel).
The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC scrutinized the documents submitted by the unit. During the presentation the committee noted there is gross mismatch in the information provided in the Form I submitted to SEIAA as compared to the presentation. SEAC also noted that the proposed Environmental Clearance application is not a modernisation project as submitted.
Therefore the committee recommended that project proponent should submit their Environmental Clearance application afresh for further consideration.
Construction Sector:
1. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Bikas Chandra Sinha & Ors. at 59 B.T Road, P.SChitpur, Ward no. 4 under KMC, Kolkata – 700 002, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 159 flats (1 block of B+G+21 storied having two towers connected at basement, Gr. & 1st floor level) with club and community facilities.
Chronology of the event :
Salient features of the proposed expansion project are –
Land Area : 7103.74 sq.m
Expected Population : 895 (residents795, visitors80 and service staff20 persons)
Total Water requirement : 146 KLD (KMC supply)
Fresh Water requirement : 102 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 97 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Treated Wastewater : 87 KLD
Treated wastewater recycled : 60 KLD(to be used in toilet flushing,landscaping, car washing
etc.)
Treated wastewater discharged : 27 KLD (to be discharged to KMC sewer line)
Page 8 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Solid waste disposal : 0.46 TPD (to be disposed off through KMC)
Total Builtup Area : 26781.45 sq.m
Ground Coverage : 2171.18 sq.m (30.561% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 1738.27 sq.m (24.47% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 1486.058 sq.m (20.8% of land area)
Other Green area : 1632.57 sq.m (22.98% of land area)
Service area : 75.13 sq.m (1.06% of land area)
No. of solar street lights proposed : 11 nos.
Total No. of plantation proposed : 110 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 247 nos.(Open106, Covered at ground floor77, Basement64)
Total Power requirement : 700 KW
Backup Power : 2x150 KVA
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th SEAC meeting held on 28.06.2014. After carefully considering the proposal and presentation, the SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
2. Proposed Office Building by M/s. Madgul Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. at C.S Plot no 306(P), 306/222(P), Jl. No. – 35, Mouza – Gangapur, PS – Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. – 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of the Office Building having 1 block of G+11 storied building mostly IT and general office spaces along with retail facilities.
Chronology of the event :
Salient The above proposal has been considered in the 78th SEAC meeting held on 08.05.2013. During the 78th SEAC meeting, committee recommended for delisting the project due to nonsubmission of relevant documents for more than six months as asked by SEAC.
As per fresh EC application dated 19.05.2014, salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 7972.31 sq.m
Expected Population : Office employee 1700 , retail employee60, service staff 60, visitors200 persons, food court100 capacity
Total Water requirement : 140KLD
Fresh water requirement : 65 KLD (Source groundwater)
Page 9 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Total Wastewater generated : 74 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Treated Wastewater : 70 KLD
Treated wastewater recycled : 70 KLD
Treated wastewater discharged : Nil
Solid waste disposal : 0.70 TPD
Total Builtup Area : 27769.51 sq.m
Ground Coverage : 3179.98 sqm. (39.89 % of land area)
Total Paved Area : 1990.11 sqm. (24.96% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 1951.51 sqm. (24.96 % of land area)
Total green area including soft area
: 890.78 sq.m (11.17% of land area)
Total No. of plantation proposed : 120 nos.
No. of solar street light : 10 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : Covered car156 nos.,Open car20 nos., Open bus10 nos.
Total Power requirement : 3000 KW
Backup Power : DG Sets2x1250 KVA & 1x750 KVA
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th SEAC meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC scrutinized the documents submitted by the unit. During the presentation the committee recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:
1. Source and availability of fresh water intake for the proposed project, along with necessary permission.
2. Detailed solid waste management plan for disposal of inorganic and organic waste.
3. Revised rain water harvesting proposal excluding recharging.
4. At least 2% of total project cost should be dedicated for CSR activities. Time bound financial commitment in this regard to be submitted.
It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary clarification/information.
3. Proposed Residential Complex by M/s. Fortune Park Housing Projects (P) Limited at 168 Krishnanagar Road, Vill. – Paschim Khilkapur, L.R Khatian no.1772, J.L no.6, Mouza – Moynagadi, PS Barasat, Dist. 24 Parganas (N).
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 819 flats (13nos. G+11 storied buildings and 1no. G+7 storied building) and Club cum Community Building (G+2 storied).
Page 10 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Chronology of the event:
The above proposal has been considered in the 87th SEAC meeting held on 11.06.2014.
As per fresh EC application dated 27.03.2014, salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 5.841 acres (23641.5 sqm.)
Expected Population : 4100 (fixed), 510 (floating)
Total Water requirement : 710 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 632 KLD (Source Groundwater)
Wastewater generated : 500 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 70 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged : 380 KLD (to be discharged through panchayat drain after treatment in STP)
Solid waste disposal : 2.35 tonnes per day (to be disposed through o be disposed off through local panchayat & in house compost treatment facility )
Total Builtup Area : 79987.76 sqm.
Ground Coverage * Building Ground Coverage
* Cantilever projection
: 7167.01 sqm. (30.32% of land area) : 6931.06 sqm. (29.32% of land area): 235 sqm. (1% of land area)
Exclusive tree plantation Area : 5574.97 sqm. (23.58% of land area)
Other Soft Area : 5796.23 sqm. (24.52% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 5139.23 sqm. (22.58% of land area)
No. of plantations proposed : 350 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 597 (covered –325, open 272)
Total Power requirement : 3000 KW, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (4x250 KVA)
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th SEAC meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC scrutinized the documents submitted by the unit. During the presentation the committee recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:
1. Detailed proposal for disposal of inorganic solid waste.
2. Since the area is an arsenic prone zone, proposal for removal of arsenic from ground water which will be used for domestic consumption need to be submitted.
3. Proposal for sewage treatment based on aerobic treatment method.
It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary clarification.
Page 11 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
4. Proposed construction of Residential Cum Commercial Complex by M/s. Rasika Merchandise Pvt. Ltd. at Mouza – AriadahaKamarhati, JL no. – 01, Dag nos. – 36423647, 36493655, Khatian nos. – 11331135, 1038 &1897; Premises no. 26, B.T.Road, Municipal Holding no. – F15, Ward no. 8, Kamarhati Municipality under PS – Belghoria, Dist – 24Pgs (N,) West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of Block – 1: Part 1, 2 – G+19, Part 3, 4 – G+18 (Club/Community Hall, Gymnasium in Part 3); Block 1 has a common basement. Block – 2: B+G+17, residential use – 2nd to 14th floor, commercial use Ground and 1st floor (Total flats 377).
Chronology of the event:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Total (Phase 1 +Phase 2)
Land Area 18060.37 sqm (as per deed), 16948.31 sqm (as per physical survey)
Expected Population 500 (during construction), 3140 (operation) (permanent – 1885, temporary 1255)
Number of stories This is a proposal for construction of Block – 1 (B+G+3): Part 1, 2, 3 & 4 – G+3; Block 1 has a common basement & Block – 2 (B+G+2) in Phase 1. In Phase 2 : Block 1, 2 – 16 floors added; Part 3, 4 – 15 floors added; Club/ Community Hall/Gymnasium in Part 3. Block 2: 17 floors added; residential use – 2nd to 14th floor, commercial use – Ground & 1st floor. Total no. of flats – 377 (Phase I – 55, Phase II 322)
Total Water requirement 395 KLD (Source – Kamarhati Municipality)
Fresh water requirement 235 KLD
Total Wastewater generated 263 KLD
Treated Wastewater recycled 160 KLD (landscaping, car washing, HVAC)
Treated Wastewater discharged 103 KLD
Solid waste disposal 100 kg/day (construction phase), 1500 kg/day (operation phase)
Total Builtup Area 60747.83 sqm (Phase I – 17288.48 sqm, Phase II – 43459.35 sqm)
Ground Coverage 4684.88 sqm (27.64%)
Water Body (beyond basement) 2185.57 sqm (12.90%)
Road/Paved area (beyond basement) 3300.71 sqm (19.48%)
Exclusive Tree Plantation area 3745.84 sqm (22.10%)
Semipaved are (beyond basement) 859.44 sqm (5.07%)
Page 12 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Total (Phase 1 +Phase 2)
Open parking area (beyond basement)
990.80 sqm (5.85%)
Services and utilities 538.28 sqm (3.18%)
Basement 643.27 sqm (3.80%)
No. of plantation proposed 255 nos.
No. of Solar Street lights proposed 31 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed 334 (Open – 98, Covered – 236: basement – 137, ground floor 99 )
Total Power requirement 3000 KVA (CESC)
Backup Power 3X750 KVA DG sets
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Envirotech East Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th SEAC meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC scrutinized the documents submitted by the unit. During the presentation the committee recommended that the project proponent should submit the following:
1. Design of rain water recharging based on water table data of the locality.
2. Detailed solid waste management plan including inhouse mechanical composting plant for biodegradable part of the solid waste generated.
3. At least 2% of total project cost should be dedicated for CSR activities. Time bound financial commitment in this regard to be submitted.
It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary clarification.
5. Proposed Residential cum Office Complex “NBCC Square” by M/s. National Buildings Construction Corporation Ltd. at Plot no111F/2, Action areaIII, New Town, Dist. – 24 Pgs(N), West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential cum Office complex 2B+G+15 storied building.
Chronology of the event:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 20235 sq.m
Expected Population : 3211 persons (residents336, Office staff2365, visitor510 )
Total Water requirement : 278 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 136 KLD (WBHIDCO supply)
Wastewater generated : 143 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Page 13 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Wastewater recycled : 142 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged : Zero discharge
Solid waste disposal : 0.582 tonnes per day (to be disposed off through municipal authority & in house MSW treatment facility )
Total Builtup Area : 65728.38 sq.m
Ground Coverage : 4933. 39 sqm. (24.38% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 5058.75 sq.m (25% of land area)
Tree Plantation Area : 7205.1 sqm. (35.6 % of land area)
Other green area : 2715.61 sq.m (13.42% of land area)
Artificial water body : 178.70 sq.m (0.88% of land area)
Total No. of Trees provided : 510 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 635 nos. car ( open 80) parking & 11 nos. bus parking .
No. of solar street light : 30 nos.
Total Power requirement : 4949 KVA
Backup Power : DG Sets 2x750 KVA)
Name of Environmental Consultant is M/s. Perfact Enviro Solutions Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for consideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After carefully considering the proposal and presentation, the SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
C. Reconsideration Proposals :Fourteen reconsideration proposals were placed in the meeting.
Industry Sector :
1. Proposed expansion of black stone mine of 30600 TPA by M/s. Md. Bazar Stone Crusher Mine at Mouza – Nischintpur, PS – Md. Bazar, JL No. 37, Plot No. 68, 75, 76, 78, 80, 84, 85, 86, 87, 108, 109, 110, 111, 113, 115, 116 in part 8183, 112, 114 in full, Vill – Patharchal, Rampurhat, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of stone quarry / mining of capacity 30600 ton/year of lease area 9.0 acres in Mouza – Nischintpur, PS – Md. Bazar, JL No. 37, Plot No. 68, 75, 76, 78, 80, 84, 85, 86, 87, 108, 109, 110, 111, 113, 115, 116 in part 8183, 112, 114 in full, Vill – Patharchal, Rampurhat, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal. The quarry shall be semimechanised with down hole blasting and with shovel dumper combination. Mining will be carried out with the help of heavy earth moving machineries for digging, excavation and removal of stone in conjunction with deep hole drilling and blasting. No abstraction of water is required. Requirement of water is 5 KLD will be available from borewells.
Page 14 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Existing DG set of 1x250 KVA. Power shall be sourced through WBSEDCL. 10 HP pump will be used for mining drainage during rainy season. Such mine water will be taken into a settling tank for sedimentation of suspended solid particle. After proper settling the clear water will be used for dust suppression and watering of plantation. Over burden and mineral reject generated during mining will be utilised for back filling at end of the life of the mining.
Chronology of the event :
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 84th SEAC meeting held on 01.04.2014. During the presentation the committee recommended that the unit should submit reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500m radius of their existing lease hold area, authenticated by the appropriate authority.
The project proponent submitted on 16.06.2014 the reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500 m radius for the existing lease hold area prepared by approved Mine Planner of Mining Department, GoWB.
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
2. Proposed expansion of 20033 TPA Black Stone Mining project by M/s. Aryans Stone Quarry at Vill – Jamkandar, Mouza Tarachua, PS Rampurhat, PO – Kastogora, Jl No. 36, Plot No. 3943(P), 3944, 3945, 3946(P), Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of stone quarry / mining of capacity 20033 ton/year of lease area 3.62 acres in Vill – Jamkandar, Mouza Tarachua, PS Rampurhat, PO – Kastogora, Jl No. 36, Plot No. 3943(P), 3944, 3945, 3946(P), Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal. The quarry shall be semimechanised with down hole blasting and with shovel dumper combination. Mining will be carried out with the help of heavy earth moving machineries for digging, excavation and removal of stone in conjunction with deep hole drilling and blasting. No abstraction of water is required. Requirement of water is 5 KLD will be available from borewells. Existing DG set of 1x250 KVA. Power shall be sourced through WBSEDCL. 2.5 KLD waste water shall be generated and it will be disposed through soak pit. 5 HP pump will be used for mining drainage during rainy season. Such mine water will be taken into a settling tank for sedimentation of suspended solid particle. After proper settling the clear water will be used for dust suppression and watering of plantation. Over burden and mineral reject generated during mining will be utilised for back filling at end of the life of the mining.
Chronology of the event :
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 84th SEAC meeting held on 01.04.2014. During the presentation the committee recommended that the unit should submit reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500m radius of their existing lease hold area, authenticated by the appropriate authority.
The project proponent submitted on 16.06.2014 the reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500 m radius for the existing lease hold area prepared by approved Mine Planner of Mining Department, GoWB.
Page 15 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
3. Proposed expansion of black stone mine of 30000 TPA of Black Stone by M/s. Jayanti Stone Quarry at POJagarpur, PSMd. Bazar, JL No. 37 Dag No. 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 96, 100, 103, 609 & JL No. 36, Dag No. 1(P), 2(P), 3(P), 4(P), 5(P), 9(P), Vill Talbandh, Mouza Nischintapur & Dewanganj, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of stone quarry / mining of capacity 30000 ton/year of lease area 5.72 acres in POJagarpur, PSMd. Bazar, JL No. 37 Dag No. 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 96, 100, 103, 609 & JL No. 36, Dag No. 1(P), 2(P), 3(P), 4(P), 5(P), 9(P), Vill Talbandh, Mouza Nischintapur & Dewanganj, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal. The quarry shall be semimechanised with down hole blasting and with shovel dumper combination. Mining will be carried out with the help of heavy earth moving machineries for digging, excavation and removal of stone in conjunction with deep hole drilling and blasting. No abstraction of water is required. Requirement of water is 5 KLD will be available from borewells. Existing DG set of 1x250 KVA. Power shall be sourced through WBSEDCL. 2.5 KLD waste water shall be generated and it will be disposed through soak pit.10 HP pump will be used for mining drainage during rainy season. Such mine water will be taken into a settling tank for sedimentation of suspended solid particle. After proper settling the clear water will be used for dust suppression and watering of plantation. Over burden and mineral reject generated during mining will be utilised for back filling at end of the life of the mining.
Chronology of the event :
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 84th SEAC meeting held on 01.04.2014. During the presentation the committee recommended that the unit should submit reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500m radius of their existing lease hold area, authenticated by the appropriate authority.
The project proponent submitted on 16.06.2014 the reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500 m radius for the existing lease hold area prepared by approved Mine Planner of Mining Department, GoWB.
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
4. Proposed expansion of Mining of 57000 TPA of Black Stone by M/s. Khan Stone Quarry at Mouza Nischintpur, Vill – Patharchal, JL No. 37, Plot No. 1025, 29, 30, 10/678, 10/699 to 10/702, PO Harisingha, PS Md. Bazar, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of stone quarry / mining of capacity 57000 ton/year of lease area 9.75 acres in Mouza Nischintpur, Vill – Patharchal, JL No. 37, Plot No. 1025, 29, 30, 10/678, 10/699 to 10/702, PO Harisingha, PS Md. Bazar, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal. The quarry shall be semimechanised with down hole blasting and with shovel dumper combination. Mining will be carried out with the help of heavy earth moving machineries for digging, excavation and removal of stone in
Page 16 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
conjunction with deep hole drilling and blasting. No abstraction of water is required. Requirement of water is 3 KLD will be available from borewells. Existing DG set of 1x250 KVA. Power shall be sourced through WBSEDCL. 10 HP pump will be used for mining drainage during rainy season. Such mine water will be taken into a settling tank for sedimentation of suspended solid particle. After proper settling the clear water will be used for dust suppression and watering of plantation. Over burden and mineral reject generated during mining will be utilised for back filling at end of the life of the mining.
Chronology of the event :
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 84th SEAC meeting held on 01.04.2014. During the presentation the committee recommended that the unit should submit reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500m radius of their existing lease hold area, authenticated by the appropriate authority.
The project proponent submitted on 16.06.2014 the reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500 m radius for the existing lease hold area prepared by approved Mine Planner of Mining Department, GoWB.
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
5. Proposed expansion of 58924 MTPA of Black Stone Mine by M/s. Kamal Stone Quarry at PO Nischintapur, Jagatpur, Mouza Dewanganj, Vill Talbandh, PS MD Bazar, JL No. 36, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for expansion of stone quarry / mining of capacity 58924 ton/year of lease area 11.70 acres in PO Nischintapur, Jagatpur, Mouza Dewanganj, Vill Talbandh, PS MD Bazar, JL No. 36, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal. The quarry shall be semimechanised with down hole blasting and with shovel dumper combination. Mining will be carried out with the help of heavy earth moving machineries for digging, excavation and removal of stone in conjunction with deep hole drilling and blasting. No abstraction of water is required. Requirement of water is 5 KLD will be available from borewells. Existing DG set of 1x250 KVA. Power shall be sourced through WBSEDCL. 4.0 KLD waste water shall be generated and it will be disposed through soak pit. 10 HP pump will be used for mining drainage during rainy season. Such mine water will be taken into a settling tank for sedimentation of suspended solid particle. After proper settling the clear water will be used for dust suppression and watering of plantation. Over burden and mineral reject generated during mining will be utilised for back filling at end of the life of the mining.
Chronology of the event:
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 84th SEAC meeting held on 01.04.2014. During the presentation the committee recommended that the unit should submit reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500m radius of their existing lease hold area, authenticated by the appropriate authority.
The project proponent submitted on 16.06.2014 the reconciled and updated status map showing existing mining activities within 500 m radius for the existing lease hold area prepared by approved Mine Planner of Mining Department, GoWB.
Page 17 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
6. expansion project for enhancement of production of Unsaturated Polyester Resins by M/s. Strongbonds Polyseal Pvt. Ltd. at Plot No. – 26/C, 26/D/1 & 26/D/2, Kalyani Industrial Estate Phase I, Block – D, Dist. – Nadia, Pin – 741235, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is an expansion proposal for enhancement of production capacity of Unsaturated Polyester Resins (UPR) by 690 TPA. The proposed plant will be located adjacent to the existing plant at Kalyani Industrial Estate. During the 52nd SEAC meeting it has been understood by SEAC that the proposed expansion work has been started before obtaining environmental clearance. The PP has given an undertaking that they will not continue any work for expansion project before getting all statutory clearances to SEAC on 13.10.11
Chronology of the event:
The case was recommended by SEAC in the 60th SEAC meeting held on 24.10.2011 with condition that the effluent as well as kettle wash water should be suitably treated in ETP to meet environmental standards. The effluent should be reused within the plant as much as possible and only the excess flow is to be discharged after compliance with the environmental standards. Effluent treatment plant should be monitored on a regular basis.
The Member Secretary, SEIAA noted that there is a lack of clarity regarding effluent treatment unit (both existing as well as proposed unit) and returned the case to SEAC with a request to get the clarification on effluent treatment from the project proponent.
The case was placed in the 63rd SEAC meeting held on 31.01.2012 and the committee has sought observation from WBPCB regarding the present status of effluent treatment plant.
The unit was inspected by Board officials on 02.04.2012 and it was observed that the process does not require any water. Water is byproduct generated due to polymerization process which is collected in a container for pH correction by caustic soda and then evaporated in an evaporator and released through a stack of ht. 24 m from ground level.
The unit has submitted a letter dated 03.05.2012 mentioning that earlier the unit had biological effluent treatment plant for treatment of water generated from the process. However, the unit has failed to maintain the anaerobic bacteria, in most cases it died and instead controlling the oxygen deficiencies it was actually increasing the BOD and COD level. Therefore, the unit has installed evaporator by discarding the ETP.
The unit has also proposed to install higher capacity evaporator for the expansion project and mentioned that as the polymerization reaction is hydrophobic in nature, no water is used to clean the reactor. Styrene Monomer which is used as raw material and is also a solvent for the product is used for cleaning.
The solid waste remaining after evaporation is sent to WBWML, Haldia and unit has obtained hazardous waste authorization from WBPCB for existing plant.
The SEAC has reviewed the letter of the project proponent submitted on 07.05.2012 in the 67th
meeting held on 25.04.2012 and made the following recommendations. Subsequent response dated 28.02.2013 from the unit is given below :
Page 18 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Recommendations / Directions of the Committee dated 29.05.2012
Response of the Proponent dated 28.02.2013
1. A detailed proposal for Effluent Treatment Plant.
1. The project proponent mentioned that the wastewater from the reaction chamber is slightly acidic in nature. Such acidic effluent is initially neutralized using caustic. Neutralized effluent is then put into an evaporator (functioning at more than 100°C). Water vapour from the evaporator is released to the atmosphere through a piping system (comprising of SS and FRP pipes). Wastewater treatment flow sheet submitted in this regard.
2. Analysis report of stack gas emitted from the evaporator especially with respect to composition of volatile substances for the existing plant.
2. The unit has submitted Chromatogram Plot of organic compounds present in flue gas. The unit has also submitted list of organic compounds identified by GC/MS analysis.The proponent mentioned that Sludge generated in the evaporator is hazardous in nature. Such sludge is being handed over to West Bengal Waste Management Ltd. for ultimate disposal which is accomplished by incineration at WBWML’s own facility. The unit has also submitted application for renewal of Hazardous Waste Authorization to WBPCB, Authorization was valid upto 30.04.2012.
The SEAC has reviewed the letter submitted by the pp on 28.02.2013 in the 77th meeting held on 26.03.2013. The SEAC has recommended that a detailed proposal for effluent treatment plant to be submitted.
The unit has submitted the detailed proposal for effluent treatment plant along with the flow diagram on 14.05.2013. The proposed ETP shall comprise of the following: Reaction Chamber, Settling Chamber, Sand Filter Bed, Collection pit, Carbon Bed, Biological Chamber followed by another Carbon Bed.
The SEAC has reviewed the letter submitted by the project proponent on 14.05.2013 in the 79th
meeting held on 28.12.2013. The SEAC has recommended that project proponent should submit waste water characteristics and schematic of the proposed wastewater treatment system with influent and effluent data. SEAC also noted that the unit has already started construction and accordingly forwarded to SEIAA for necessary action.
SEIAA requested SEAC to verify the current ground possession whether they have stopped expansion work as per their undertaking on 25.03.2014.
The project proponent submitted letter on 05.05.2014 schematic of the proposed waste water treatment system along with influent and effluent data.
WBPCB has conducted an inspection on 15.05.2014 and observe that activity related to expansion unit not yet completed and no activity related to expansion work was going on.
The SEAC has reviewed the reply of the project proponent dated 05.05.2014 in the 87th meeting held on 11.06.2014 and recommended that the project proponent should submit the proposal for effluent
Page 19 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
treatment plant indicating dimensional details and inlet / outlet characteristics of effluent generated from the process.
The project proponent has submitted dimensional schematic diagram of proposed ETP through their letter dated 26.06.2014.
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. During the meeting, SEAC noted that no expansion work is being done at present as observed during inspection carried by WBPCB officials on 15.05.2014 and recommended to forward the proposal for effluent treatment plant as submitted by the project proponent on 26.06.2014 to SEIAA for consideration.
Construction Sector :
1. Proposed Residential Complex “UTALIKA” by M/s. Bengal Ambuja Housing Development Ltd. at Premises No. 405, Borough – 12, Jl No. 21, Mukundapur, KMC Ward No. 109, PS – Purba Jadavpur, Kolkata – 700 078, Dist. 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for residential project comprising of 5 nos. towers G+25 storied, 1 tower 2B+G+21, podium G+3 and podium G and having 1088 flats for residential purpose, 72 nos. office, 72 nos. service apartments Retail units, Club and other amenities.
Chronology of the event:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance in the 74th SEAC meeting held on 20.12.2012.
The proponent submitted the copy of the Master Plan and building plans sanctioned by Kolkata Municipal Corporation on 19.06.2014. The features of the proposed modified project are as follows –
As per SCEC issued on 16.01.2013
As per sanctioned plan submitted on 19.06.2014
Land Area : 81682.48 sqm. : 81682.48 sqm.
No. of building blocks : 5 nos. G+25, 1no. 2B+G+21, HIG podium G+3, LIG podium G, 72 nos. of offices, 72 nos. of service apartments, retail units
: 5 nos. G+25, 1no. 2B+G+19, HIG podium G+3, LIG podium G, 72 nos. of offices, no service apartments, retail units 14 numbers
No. of flats : 1088 1084 (HIG539, LIG422, MIG123)
Expected Population : 2645 – HIG, 2795 – LIG, 3947 – Home Office, Service Apartment, Retail, Club and others
: 2695 – HIG, 2110 – LIG, 615 – MIG, 1014 –Office, 917 – Retail, 2100 – Club, Service and other floating guest
Total Water requirement : 1456.4 KLD (Operation stage) : 980 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 849.75 KLD (KMC supply) : 568 KLD (KMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 1075.4 KLD (to be treated in STP)
: 840 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Page 20 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
As per SCEC issued on 16.01.2013
As per sanctioned plan submitted on 19.06.2014
Wastewater recycled : 606.66 KLD : 412 KLD
Wastewater discharged and place of discharge
: 414.94 KLD (to Municipal drain) : 336 KLD (to Municipal drain)
Solid waste disposal : 3563.9 kg / day : 3486 kg / day (garbage compactor will be installed)
Total Builtup Area : 301540.32 sqm. : 300925.649 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 27494.77 sqm. (33.66% of land area)
:26233.178 sq.m (34.579% of existing boundary area consider for FAR) 26233.178 sqm. (32.11% of total land area as per deed)
Internal Road Area : 10005.94 sqm. (12.25% of land area)
: 12417.7 sqm. (15.2% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area
: 21173.50 sqm. (25.92% of land area)
: 16423.21 sqm. (20.10% of land area)
Nos. of trees planted : 1450 nos. : 1200 nos. big trees and 716 numbers medium and small trees
Water body : 23008.27 sqm. (28.17% of land area)
: 23008.27 sqm. (28.17% of land area)
No. of Parking spaces proposed
: 1950 cars (covered) : 1751 nos. [1700 cars (covered) & 51 (open)]
Total Power requirement : 15200 KVA, CESC : 12050 KVA, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (4x2000 KVA, 2x1600 KVA and 1x500 KVA)
: DG Sets (1x320 KVA, 1x415 KVA, 1x1600 KVA and 4x2000 KVA)
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Ghosh, Bose & Associates Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC reviewed the documents submitted by the proponent and recommended that project proponent should submit the following:
1. Revised master plan based on the sanctioned building plan showing exclusive tree plantation area, total paved area, other green area, open car parking area etc.
2. Details of plantation list as recommended by ZSI in their report .3. Proposal for in house mechanized compost plant for disposal of organic solid waste in
addition to the compactor as sanctioned by KMC.4. Modified water balance statement along with necessary break up/calculations.5. Proposal for compliance of the recommendation made in the report ”Rapid assessment to
document Migratory Birds” prepared by ZSI.
It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary clarification.
Page 21 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
2. Proposed Residential Complex “IDEAL GRAND” by M/s. Vijai Shree Ltd. at Plot No. 456, G. T. Road (South), JL No. 1, Mouza & PS – Shibpur, Howrah Municipal Corporation Ward No. 36, PIN – 711 102, Dist – Howrah, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of a Residential Complex having 384 flats (4 blocks of B+G+16 storied buildings) and Club House.
Chronology of the event:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance in the 76th SEAC meeting held on 19.02.2013.
The proponent submitted on the copy of the Master Plan and building plans sanctioned by Howrah Municipal Corporation on 22.04.2014. The features of the proposed project are as follows –
As per SCEC issued on 13.03.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted on 22.04.2014
Land Area : 18731.42 sqm. : 18731.42 sqm.
Building Profile : 4 blocks of B+G+16 storied buildings
: 4 blocks of B+G+16 storied buildings
Expected Population : 1996 persons : 1996 persons
Total Water requirement : 343 KLD (Operation stage) : 343 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 198 KLD (HMC supply) : 198 KLD (HMC supply)
Wastewater generated : 238.4KLD (to be treated in STP) : 238.4KLD (to be treated in STP)
Wastewater recycled : 144.8 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
: 144.8 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
Wastewater discharged : 81.7 KLD (to be discharged to HMC drain after treatment in STP)
: 81.7 KLD (to be discharged to HMC drain after treatment in STP)
Solid waste disposal : 1.16 tonnes per day (to be disposed off through local authority)
: 1.16 tonnes per day (to be disposed off through local authority)
Total Builtup Area : 50211.12 sqm. (including parking)
: 50367.32 sqm. (including parking)
Ground Coverage without basement
: 3330.64 sqm. (17.78% of land area)
: 3368.85 sqm. (17.99% of land area)
Ground Coverage including basement
: : 9127.93 sq.m (48.73% of land area)
Total Hardscape Area : 4635.98 sqm. (24.75% of land area)
: 4678.76 sqm. (24.75% of land area)
Total Green Area : 10764.8 sqm. (57.47% of land area)
: 11022.02 sqm. (58.84% of land area)
Page 22 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
As per SCEC issued on 13.03.2013 As per sanctioned plan submitted on 22.04.2014
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area
: 4105.72 sqm. (21.92% of land area)
: 4105.72 sqm. (21.92% of land area)
Min. No. of plantation proposed
: 290 nos. : 290 nos.
No. of Parking spaces proposed
: 357 nos. (covered – 332, open –25) : 447 nos. (covered – 333, open at ground –114)
Min. No. of solar street lights proposed
: 35 nos. : 35 nos.
Total Power requirement : 1602.78 KW, CESC : 1602.78 KW, CESC
Backup Power : DG Sets (2x320 KVA) : DG Sets (2x320 KVA)
SEAC has reviewed the reply of the project proponent submitted on 22.04.2014 in the 86th meeting held on 08.05.2014 and recommended that the unit should submit the detailed proposal for inhouse solid waste management facility along with provisions for mechanized composting facility for biodegradable waste.
The project proponent submitted on 09.06.2014 the proposal for inhouse mechanized composting facility.
Name of the Environmental Consultant M/s. Ghosh Bose & Associates Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
3. Proposed Residential Complex "Aqua View" by M/s. Aquaview Projects Pvt. Ltd. (Previously M/s. Ideal Canopy Project Pvt. Ltd.) at RS dag no. 489, 490, 492, JL No. 18, Mouza – Mahishbathan, RS dag no. 852, 918, JL No. 19, Mouza – Thakdari, Bidhannagar Municipality Ward No. 1, PO – Mahisbathan, PS – Electronic Complex, Sector – V, Kolkata – 700 102, Dist – 24 Parganas (North), West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of Residential Complex having 650 flats (4 blocks of B+G+19 storied buildings and 2 blocks of B+G+18 storied buildings) alongwith Club (1no. B+G).
Chronology of the event:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) stipulated the conditions for Environmental Clearance in the 67th SEAC meeting held on 21.05.2012.
The proponent submitted on the copy of the Master Plan and building plans sanctioned by Bidhannagar Municipality on 17.04.2014. The modified features of the proposed project are as follows
As per SCEC dated 22.06.2012 As per sanctioned building plan submitted on 17.04.2014
Land Area : 24615.38 sqm. : 24615.38 sqm.
Page 23 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
As per SCEC dated 22.06.2012 As per sanctioned building plan submitted on 17.04.2014
Expected Population : 3485 (Residents + Club) : 3485 (Residents + Club)
Total Water requirement : 526.962 KLD : 526.962 KLD
Fresh Water requirement : 432.142 KLD : 432.142 KLD
Wastewater generated : 411.564 KLD : 411.564 KLD
Wastewater recycled : 94.82 KLD : 94.82 KLD
Wastewater discharged : 316.744 KLD : 316.744 KLD
Solid waste disposal : 2.0 tonne per day (to be disposed off through municipal authority)
: 2.0 tonne per day (to be disposed off through municipal authority)
Total Builtup Area : 92475.72 sqm. : 87671.23 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 5678.89 (23.07% of land area) : 5678.89 (23.07% of land area)
Total Paved Area : 6137.87 sqm. (24.94% of land area)
: 6137.87 sqm. (24.94% of land area)
Landscaped Green Area : 12507.11 sqm. (50.81 % of land area)
: 12507.11 sqm. (50.81 % of land area)
Swimming Pool : 291.52 sqm. (1.18% of land area) : 291.52 sqm. (1.18% of land area)
No. of plantations proposed : 376 : 376
No. of Parking spaces proposed
: 532(Covered522,open10) : 540(Covered522,open18)
Total Power requirement : 2.9 MW, WBSEDCL : 2.9 MW, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (7x160 KVA) : DG Sets (7x160 KVA)
SEAC has reviewed the reply of the project proponent submitted on 07.05.2014 in the 86th meeting held on 08.05.2014 and recommended that the unit should submit the detailed proposal for inhouse solid waste management facility along with provisions for mechanized composting facility for biodegradable waste.
The project proponent submitted on 09.06.2014 the proposal for inhouse mechanized composting facility.
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration, the committee recommended the project for Environmental Clearance.
Page 24 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
4. Proposed Residential and Commercial Complex by M/s. P. P. S. Progressive Pvt. Ltd. & Others at JL No. 2, Mouza – Dabgram, Siliguri Municipal Ward No. 42, Sevoke Road, PO – Bhaktinagar, Dist – Jalpaiguri, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for construction of Residential cum Commercial Complex (10 nos. of G+4 storied residential blocks and 1 block of 4 storied commercial building). Residential Complex has 236 nos. flats.
Chronology of the event:
Salient features of the proposed project are –
Land Area : 18580.65 sq.m
Expected Population : Residents 1180, Others196. Cafeteria 30 seats
Total Water requirement : 202 KLD (Operation stage)
Fresh Water requirement : 156KLD (SourceGround water)
Wastewater generated : 125 KLD (to be treated in STP)
Treated wastewater recycled : 40 KLD (to be reused after treatment in STP)
Treated wastewater discharged : 73 KLD (to be discharged to SMC drain )
Solid waste disposal : 0.7 tonnes per day (to be disposed off through SMC)
Total Builtup Area : 36525.63 sqm.
Ground Coverage : 7606.30 sqm. (40.93% of land area)
Total paved Area : 4475.77 sqm. (24.08% of land area)
Service Area : 953.93 sqm. (4.40% of land area)
Exclusive Tree Plantation Area : 6164.76 sqm. (33.17% of land area)
Min. No. of plantation proposed : 264 nos. (Existing44 nos, proposed220 nos)
No. of Parking spaces proposed : 235 (covered)
No. of solar street lights proposed : 24 nos. (solar operated LED light) along with solar panel for water heating
Total Power requirement : 1000 KVA, WBSEDCL
Backup Power : DG Sets (2x250 KVA &1x125 KVA)
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 75th SEAC meeting held on 30.01.2013 and after scrutinizing the documents submitted by the unit, the committee recommended that the unit should submit the clearance from the Chief Wildlife Warden as per the provisions of EIA Notification 2006 because of the proximity of the site to the boundaries of the Mahananda Wildlife Sanctuary.
The project proponent submitted the clearance of the Chief Wildlife Warden on 04.06.2014.
Page 25 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration the SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
5. Proposed Integrated Industrial Township by M/s. Kanchan Janga Integrated Infrastructure Development Pvt. Ltd. (A Joint Venture Company of M/s. Shristi Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. & M/s. West Bengal Industrial Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd.) at Fatapukur, Jl. No. – 9, Mouza – Chhat Gujrimari, Jl. No. – 10, Mouza – Kismat Sukani, PS – Rajganj, Dist. – Jalpaiguri, West Bengal.
Activity:
This is a proposal for development of an Integrated Industrial Township. The proposed Township shall include small scale & green category industries; Retail, Hotel and Social Infrastructure like School, Educational Institutes, Nursing Home, Health Care Centre etc. Further, Residential apartments along with individual plots are also proposed.
Chronology of the event:
ToR for conducting EIA studies has been accorded by SEAC during 63rd SEAC meeting held on 31.01.2012.
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 80th SEAC meeting held on 18.01.2014. The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the 80th SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 27.03.2014 from the unit is given below
Recommendations / Directions of the Committee dated 03.02.2014
Response of the Proponent on 27.03.2014
1. Details of industrial activities mentioning nos. of units, CETP etc. to be undertaken within the project.
1. Submitted
2. Provision of waste water treatment facility and recycle of treated waste water to minimise fresh water consumption.
2. Submitted
3. Details of sewage and storm water drainage system. 3. Submitted
4. Long term solid waste management plan including disposal of industrial waste.
4. Submitted
5. Details of proper sludge disposal facility. 5. Submitted
6. Details of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) with financial commitment as discussed during the said meeting Details of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) with financial commitment as discussed during the said meeting.
6. The proponent mentioned that the CSR commitment will be Rs. 120 lakhs.
The SEAC reviewed the letter of the project proponent submitted on 11.03.2014 in 85th SEAC meeting held on 21.04.2014. The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the 85th SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 12.06.2014 from the unit is given below :
Page 26 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Recommendations / Directions of the Committee dated 21.05.2014
Response of the Proponent on 12.06.2014
1) Details of Sewage and Storm water drainageRunoff calculation is very conservative. Such high rainfall area will have higher instantaneous load. The design should be for maximum intensity rainfall (please see rainfall history of the area) for a period of 2 hours.
1) Submitted
2) Long term solid waste management planSolid waste generation values are very conservative and much less than usual. The approximate solid waste system should have a capacity of 15 TPD as against 9 TPD (to be spread proportionally to all users). Similarly all calculations should change. Details of engineered land fill site should be provided.
2) Submitted
3) Sludge disposalThe scheme is sketchy. A nominal sludge disposal plan considering the nature of the industry and their likely capacity should be prepared and be given to the SEAC with the commitments to run the treatment plants if necessary.
3) Submitted
4) CSRThe CSR amount should be as per the prevailing norms. CSR should be spent also on the labor rest rooms, crèche, creating Selfhelp groups (SHGs), pre and post natal children and mother care, etc.
4) Submitted
Name of the Environmental Consultant M/s Voyants Solutions Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration the SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
6. Proposed construction of a Residential Complex by M/s Bengal DCL Housing Development Co. Ltd. at Plot no. AA II D, Block – 10 (Premises no. 010709), Action area II D New Town, Rajarhat, Dist – 24 Pgs (N), Kolkata.
Activity
This is a proposal for construction of a residential complex comprising of Block LIG: G+4 – 06 nos., Block MIG: G+9 – 01 no, Block HIG: G+9 – 5 nos., Club: G+2 – 1 no, Neighbourhood Centre (HIG): G+2 – 1 no.
Chronology of the event:
The unit presented their proposal before SEAC on 82nd SEAC meeting held on 08.03.2014. The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC), West Bengal, made the following recommendations in the 82nd SEAC meeting and subsequent response submitted on 12.06.2014 from the unit is given below :
Recommendations / Directions of the Committee dated 21.03.2014
Response of the Proponent on 12.06.2014
1. Proposal of waste water treatment facility and recycle of treated waste water to
1. Project proponent has submitted proposal for STP of capacity of 56 KLD to treat partial
Page 27 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Recommendations / Directions of the Committee dated 21.03.2014
Response of the Proponent on 12.06.2014
reduce fresh water consumption. waste water. Remaining waste water will be directly discharged to WBHIDCO drain.
2. Proposal for onsite compost plant for treatment of biodegradable fraction of MSW and earmarked the location of the compost plant and STP in the conceptual plan.
2. Submitted
3. Proposal for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) atleast 2% of project cost to be formulated based on specific needs of the locality.
3. The proponent has submitted revised Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) plan with adequate financial commitment of Rs. 20 lakhs.
The name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Centre for Sustainable Development. The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC reviewed the reply of proponent and recommended that no untreated waste water shall be discharged outside of the premises and project proponent should design STP accordingly. It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary clarification.
7. Proposed Township project (PHASE – IA) by M/s. Kolkata West International City Pvt. Ltd. at Mouza – Kona, Baltikuri, Bankura, Pakuria, Tentulkuli, Khalia & Salap, PO & PS – Domjur, Dist – Howrah, West Bengal.
Activity
This is a proposal for development of a Township with 9000 dwelling units, commercial facilities and other infrastructural facilities. The proposed development shall comprise of 5 phases.
Chronology of the event:
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has granted Provisional Environmental Clearance for the proposed Township project in the 7th meeting held on 26.07.2007. The proponent mentioned that the proposed development shall comprise of 5 phases.
Subsequently, the proponent obtained Environmental Clearance from the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority, West Bengal for PHASE – I of the proposed project on 11.11.2008 and amendment of the said Environmental Clearance from the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority, West Bengal for PHASE – I of the proposed project on 04.02.2010.
The proponent has submitted vide letter dated 08.09.2011, sanctioned plan for PHASE – IA along with key plan sanctioned by KMDA, comparative statement and other documents.
The case was placed in the 59th SEAC meeting held on 20.09.2011 and the SEAC noted that the total project area is 390.165 acres. The project proponent earlier obtained Environmental Clearance from the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority, West Bengal for PHASE – I comprising of 89.174 acres. Now the unit applied for PHASE – IA which is only 4.283 acres. The SEAC requested the project proponent vide letter dated 30.09.2011 to consider the project in an integrated manner and also to explain the reasons for reverting to the proposal for sending the sewage to the KMW STP instead of augmenting the capacity of the STP at the project site in a modular form. The SEAC also
Page 28 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
desired to review the compliance status of the PHASE – I for which Environmental Clearance has already been granted.
The proponent has submitted their reply on 22.11.2011. The proponent has mentioned that as per development agreement with KMDA, the sewer line is to be connected to KMW & SA STP at Kona. However, Kona STP was too far from PHASE – I development and development planning for finalisation of the route of the sewer line could not be done for PHASE I. Hence, construction of STP of 650 KLD was considered for PHASE – I. If it is not feasible to connect the sewer line for PHASE – IA, the capacity of the existing STP will be enhanced.
The progress status of PHASE – I as mentioned by the proponent is as follows:
Total no. of units as per
EC
Total No. of units as per sanctioned
plan.
Completed unit
CC obtained
CC applied ConsenttoOperate obtained
ConsenttoOperate
to be applied shortly
910 907 370 269 101 179 191
The comparative statement for PHASE – I and PHASE – IA as mentioned by the proponent is given below :
Salient Features As per Provisional EC
Phase I (EC Obtained) Phase IA (EC Applied for)
Land Area 390.165 acres 89.174 acres 4.283 acres (17272.98 sqm.)
Expected Population 45000 4550 (as per the EC)4535 (as mentioned by the proponent)
2324
Water requirement (Operation stage)
10000 KLD 690 KLD 335 KLD
Wastewater generated
7500 KLD 518 KLD (as per the amended EC)513 KLD (as mentioned by the proponent)
262 KLD
Firefighting Water demand
700 KL 200 KL 300 KL
Solid waste disposal 24.99 TPD 2.53 TPD (as per the EC)2.52 TPD (as mentioned by the proponent)
1.12 TPD
Total Builtup Area Not mentioned 165202.4 sqm. 52736.43 sqm.
Ground Coverage 167.77 acres 18.2 acres 0.967 acres (3913.55 sqm.), 22.578%
Landscaped area with waterbody
128.76 acres 22.85 acres 1.019 acres (23.792%)
Waterbody 3.7 acres NIL NIL
Page 29 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Salient Features As per Provisional EC
Phase I (EC Obtained) Phase IA (EC Applied for)
Road & Pathway 93.64 acres 21.4 acres 1.648 acres (53.63%)
No. of Car Parking spaces proposed
33000 nos. 1811 nos. 210 nos.
Power requirement 32 MVA 4.5 MVA 1.9 MVA
Backup Power DG Sets (3x625 KVA, 10x750KVA & 6x1010 KVA)
DG Sets (2x65 KVA) DG Sets (2x380 KVA)
The subsequent submissions by the project proponent were placed before the SEAC in the 61st SEAC meeting held on 29.11.2011, 63rd meeting held on 31.01.2012, 64th SEAC meeting held on 16.02.2012, 66th meeting held on 25.04.2012, 69th meeting held on 25.07.2012 and 73rd meeting held on 30.11.2012.
Now the project proponent has submitted on 27.05.2014 mentioning that KMDA has assured supply of treated water as per the agreement from Padmapukur water Treatment Plant by the end of December, 2015 and another letter was submitted on 10.06.2014 along with copy of application for sinking of bore well.
The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. The SEAC reviewed the reply of proponent and recommended that project proponent should submit permission for abstraction of ground water/ concurrence regarding availability of water from the competent authority as per requirement for Phase I and Phase IA also. It has been decided that the case shall be further considered only after submission of the necessary clarification.
8. Proposed Residential Complex “IDEAL EXOTICA” by M/s. Ideal Real Estates Pvt. Ltd. at 21, Pramatha Choudhury Sarani, KMC Ward No. 81, PS – New Alipore, Kolkata – 700 053.
Activity
This is a proposal for construction of Residential Complex having 158 flats (5 blocks of 2B+G+21 storied buildings) and club house.
Chronology of the event:
The During the presentation in the 59th meeting held on 20.09.2011, the SEAC has observed that this housing project has been proposed in a site which is likely to be contaminated due to past industrial activity. The SEAC directed vide letter dated 10.10.2011 that the project proponent should first assess the level and type of remediation required, prepare specific site remediation plan and get the site remediated properly. The project proponent should also obtain necessary approval from West Bengal Pollution Control Board after remediation. The SEAC decided that this case would be considered only after the above actions are satisfactorily executed.
The proponent submitted their reply on 21.11.2011. The proponent has submitted the test results conducted by National Test House for nickel content only. The project proponent has mentioned that since the nickel content at site is 10 times lower than the threshold limit, no remediation is necessary.
The State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) has considered the submission of the project proponent dated 21.11.2011 in the 61st meeting held on 29.11.2011. The committee requested the
Page 30 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
project proponent to assess the level of contamination in the proposed site by a competent agency like NEERI and address all the issues raised in the previous letter dated 10.10.2011.
The project proponent again submitted a reply on 30.01.2012 mentioning that they have obtained test result through National Test House, a Govt. of India organisation, it is observed from their report that nickel content was determined to be 0.05% by mass. The threshold limit for nickel as per Hazardous Waste (Management & Handling) Rules is 5000 mg/kg which is equivalent to 0.5% by mass. As the nickel content is 10 times lower than the threshold limit no remediation measures are deemed necessary.
The project proponent has submitted a reply along with the test report of NEERI on 21.03.2013. They also mentioned that the nickel content in soil at the above mentioned site is 68.12 mg/kg. by mass. The threshold limit of nickel as per the Soil Guideline Values (Environment Agency 2009) for land use for residential use is 130 mg/kg and the Soil guideline Values for Nickel as per India Standards is 75150 mg/kg. Therefore, the nickel content at their proposed site is 55% lower than the threshold limit, hence there will be no harmful effect.
During the 78th meeting held on 08.05.2013 SEAC opined that opinion of Waste Management Cell, WBPCB to be obtained on the report provided by the project proponent.
The SEAC considered the submission by the proponent and remarks of the WMC, WBPCB in the 79th
meeting held on 28.12.2013 and recommended that the project proponent should submit the report after incorporating necessary modifications as suggested by the WMC, WBPCB.
The project proponent submitted on 11.03.2014 the modified report incorporated by NEERI.
The modified report was considered in the 83rd SEAC meeting held on 25.03.2014 and after careful consideration the SEAC recommended to refer the case to the Waste Management Cell, WBPCB for opinion on the revised report submitted by the project proponent.
WBPCB reviewed the revised report and provided their comments.
The name of the Environmental Consultant is M/s. Ghosh Bose & Associates Pvt. Ltd. The case was put up for reconsideration in the 88th meeting held on 28.06.2014. After careful consideration of all the documents, SEAC recommended stipulated conditions for environmental clearance for the project.
Summaries of above decisions are also provided in Table1.
Page 31 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
Table1 : List of the projects which were placed before the SEAC in the eighty eighth meeting held on 28.06.2014 at 11:00 hrs. and the Summary Decisions thereof:
A Miscellaneous cases
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. M/s. Dhunseri Petrochem & Tea Ltd.
Proposed IT Park at Jl. No. 35, Mouza – Gangapur, Kolkata Information Technology Park (KITP), Bantala, PS – Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. – 24 Parganas (South).
To be referred to SEIAA for consideration
2. M/s. India Power Corporation (Haldia) Ltd.
Proposed change in configuration from 3x135 MW to 3x150 MW Coal Fired Thermal Power Plant at Haldia, Dist – Purba Medinipur, West Bengal.
All relevant documents to be referred to SEIAA for onward
transmission to MoEF
B Cases placed for presentation
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. M/s. Steel Crackers Pvt. Ltd.
ToR presentation for the proposed expansion of 1x4 MT induction furnace at J.L no.14,MouzaBighati, Vill – Dhobapukur, P.SBhadreshwar, DistHooghly, West Bengal.
Recommended Terms of Reference
2. M/s. Pristine Cement (P) Ltd.,
ToR presentation of proposed expansion of the Cement Grinding Unit at Jl. No. – 15, Dag No. – 636, 637, 638, 639, 646, 650 and 650/780, Vill. & PO – Suryapur, Mouza – Navarand, Tehsil Barrackpore, Sewli Gram Panchayat, Khardah Barasat Road, Dist. – 24 Parganas (N), Pin – 700121, West Bengal.
Recommended Terms of Reference
3. M/s. Emami Cement Ltd.
ToR presentation of proposed standalone cement grinding unit of capacity1.5 MTPA and CPP 10 MW at Raghunathpur Industrial Park, Mouza—Durmut, Raghunathpur, DistPurulia, Pin 713336, West Bengal.
Recommended Terms of Reference
4. M/s. Shree Parasnath ReRolling Mills Ltd.
Proposed expansion of 2x12 T Induction Furnace at 3511(P) & 4010 (P), JL No. 85, Touzi No. 1, Khatian No.
Recommended Terms of Reference
Page 32 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
B Cases placed for presentation
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
93, Mouza – Gopinathpur, Dist – Burdwan, West Bengal.
5. M/s. Todi Minerals Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Upardanga Granite Mine project at Upardanga Granite Block, Mouza – Talsankara, JL No. 163, Plot No. 3310, PS – Raghunathpur, Dist – Purulia, PIN – 723 133, West Bengal.
Absent
6. M/s. Rashmi Metaliks Ltd.
Proposed modernization of existing Ductile Iron Pipe Plant at Vill. Gokulpur, PO Shyamraipur, PS – Kharagpur, Dist. – Paschim Medinipur, West Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
7. M/s. Bikas Chandra Sinha & Ors.
Proposed Residential Complex at 59 B.T Road, P.SChitpur, Ward no. 4 under KMC, Kolkata – 700 002, West Bengal.
Recommended stipulated conditions for Environmental
Clearance
8. M/s. Madgul Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Office Building at C.S Plot no 306(P), 306/222(P), Jl. No. – 35, Mouza – Gangapur, PS – Kolkata Leather Complex, Dist. – 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal.
Asked for additional submission
9. M/s. Fortune Park Housing Projects (P) Limited
Proposed Residential Complex at 168 Krishnanagar Road, Vill. – Paschim Khilkapur, L.R Khatian no.1772, J.L no. 6, Mouza – Moynagadi, PS – Barasat, Dist. 24 Parganas (N).
Asked for additional submission
10. M/s. Rasika Merchandise Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed construction of Residential Cum Commercial Complex at Mouza – AriadahaKamarhati, JL no. – 01, Dag nos. – 36423647, 36493655, Khatian nos. – 11331135, 1038 &1897; Premises no. 26, B. T. Road, Municipal Holding no. – F15, Ward no. 8, Kamarhati Municipality under PS – Belghoria, Dist – 24Pgs (N,) West Bengal.
Asked for additional submission
11. M/s. National Buildings Construction Corporation Ltd.
Residential cum Office Complex “NBCC Square” at Plot no111F/2, Action areaIII, New Town, Dist. – 24 Pgs(N), West Bengal.
Recommended stipulated conditions for Environmental
Clearance
Page 33 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
C Cases placed for consideration of Environment Clearance
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
1. M/s. Md. Bazar Stone Crusher Mine
Stone Crusher & Co. Ltd.
Proposed expansion of black stone mine of 30600 TPA at Mouza – Nischintpur, PS – Md. Bazar, JL No. 37, Vill – Patharchal, Rampurhat, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
2. M/s. Aryans Stone Quarry
Proposed expansion of 20033 TPA Black Stone Mining project at Vill – Jamkandar, Mouza Tarachua, PS Rampurhat, Jl No. 36, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
3. M/s. Jayanti Stone Quarry
Proposed expansion of black stone mine of 30000 TPA of Black Stone at POJagarpur, PSMd. Bazar, JL No. 37 & 36, Vill Talbandh, Mouza Nischintapur & Dewanganj, Suri, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
4. M/s. Khan Stone Quarry
Proposed expansion of Mining of 57000 TPA of Black Stone at Mouza Nischintpur, JL No. 37, PO Harisingha, PS Md. Bazar, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
5. M/s. Kamal Stone Quarry
Proposed expansion of 58924 MTPA of Black Stone Mine at PO Nischintapur, Jagatpur, Mouza Dewanganj, Vill Talbandh, PS MD Bazar, JL No. 36, Dist – Birbhum, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
6. M/s. Strongbonds Polyseal Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed expansion project for enhancement of production of Unsaturated Polyester Resins at Plot No. – 26/C, 26/D/1 & 26/D/2, Kalyani Industrial Estate Phase I, Block – D, Dist. – Nadia, Pin – 741235, West Bengal.
Detailed proposal of ETP submitted by project proponent
to be referred to SEIAA
7. M/s. Bengal Ambuja Housing Development Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex “UTALIKA” at Premises No. 405, Borough – 12, Jl No. 21, Mukundapur, KMC Ward No. 109, PS – Purba Jadavpur, Kolkata – 700 078, Dist. 24 Parganas (South), West Bengal.
Asked for Additional Submission
Page 34 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
C Cases placed for consideration of Environment Clearance
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
8. M/s. Vijai Shree Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex “IDEAL GRAND” at Plot No. 456, G. T. Road (South), JL No. 1, Mouza & PS – Shibpur, Howrah Municipal Corporation Ward No. 36, PIN – 711 102, Dist – Howrah, West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
9. M/s. Aquaview Projects Pvt. Ltd. (Previously M/s. Ideal Canopy Project Pvt. Ltd.)
Proposed Residential Complex "Aqua View" at RS dag no. 489, 490, 492, JL No. 18, Mouza – Mahishbathan, RS dag no. 852, 918, JL No. 19, Mouza – Thakdari, Bidhannagar Municipality Ward No. 1, PO – Mahisbathan, PS – Electronic Complex, Sector – V, Kolkata – 700 102, Dist – 24 Parganas (North), West Bengal.
Recommended for Environmental Clearance
10. M/s. P. P. S. Progressive Pvt. Ltd. & Others
Proposed Residential and Commercial Complex at JL No. 2, Mouza – Dabgram, Siliguri Municipal Ward No. 42, Sevoke Road, PO – Bhaktinagar, Dist – Jalpaiguri, West Bengal.
Recommended stipulated conditions for Environmental
Clearance
11. M/s. Kanchan Janga Integrated Infrastructure Development Pvt. Ltd. (A Joint Venture Company of M/s. Shristi Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. & M/s. West Bengal Industrial Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd.)
Proposed Integrated Industrial Township at Fatapukur, Jl. No. – 9, Mouza – Chhat Gujrimari, Jl. No. – 10, Mouza – Kismat Sukani, PS – Rajganj, Dist. – Jalpaiguri, West Bengal.
Recommended stipulated conditions for Environmental
Clearance
12. M/s Bengal DCL Housing Development Co. Ltd.
Proposed construction of a Residential Complex at Plot no. AA II D, Block – 10 (Premises no. 010709), Action area II D New Town, Rajarhat, Dist – 24 Pgs (N), Kolkata.
Asked for additional submission
13. M/s. Kolkata West International City Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Township project (PHASE – IA) at Mouza – Kona, Baltikuri, Bankura, Pakuria, Tentulkuli, Khalia & Salap, PO & PS – Domjur, Dist – Howrah, West Bengal.
Asked for additional submission
Page 35 of 36
Minutes of the eighty eighth meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal held on 28.06.2014 at 11:30 hrs. at the Conference Room, Paribesh Bhawan, Salt Lake.
___________________________________________________________________
C Cases placed for consideration of Environment Clearance
Sl. No.
Name of the unit & Project address Summary Decision
14. M/s. Ideal Real Estates Pvt. Ltd.
Proposed Residential Complex “IDEAL EXOTICA” at 21, Pramatha Choudhury Sarani, KMC Ward No. 81, PS – New Alipore, Kolkata – 700 053.
Recommended stipulated conditions for Environmental
Clearance
The meeting ended with a note of thanks to the Chair.
Sd/ Sd/
(Prof. (Dr.) Sudarshan Neogi)Chairman
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Prof. (Dr.) Swadesh Ranjan Raychaudhuri)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Dr. Kalyan Rudra)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Dr. Amitava Roy)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Dr. Satya Kinkar Pal)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Prof. Jayanta Bhattacharya)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Dr. Arunkanti Biswas)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Dr. Anita Chattopadhyay Gupta)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Sd/
(Prof. Bhabatosh Biswas)Member
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
(P. K. Sarkar)Secretary
State Expert Appraisal Committee, West Bengal
Page 36 of 36
top related