it’s risky out there

1

It’s risky out there

High risk sectorAccidents – falling from heightsMSD – heavy lifting, movements, repetitive workChemical exposureStress

But construction is also …- work of high quality- giving opportunities to use skills- autonomy- interacting with fellow workers- etc.

2

OHS of migrant workers– who cares?

By Ulrik Spannow, EWHN 2006

3

Migration is not new• Construction has always

been trans-national• For instance:

- Originally, the Danish carpenters were taught by the Germans

- Constructing the bridge between DK and Sweden included workers from 13 countries

• The construction labour market is an open one

4

European project• Trade union study on

migrant workers• Initiated by the European

Trade Union Institute For Research, Education and Health & Safety

• Objectives:1) To collect best practices in the OHS activities related to MW 2) To publish a brochure on TU initiatives & setting out guidelines for the future

• Time schedule: 2007

5

The Danish case on MW

• Lack of scientific based evidence• But plenty of experiences• What are your experiences?

6

Migrant workers in DK

Country of origin?PolandLithuaniaLatvia & EstoniaGermanySweden Etc.

7

Active work permits, const

Active work-permits for persons from new EU-countries (all sectors)

Source: Labour Market Administration (Arbejdsmarkedsstyrelsen)

957621449378240173128834Total

111110000Slovenia

4581044320Czech Republic

98101196540Slovakia

111210986520Estonia

1366863320Hungary

45271918119650Latvia

19512810294522724141Lithuania

67943429322714911882543Poland

2006Q22006Q12005Q42005Q32005Q22005Q12004Q42004Q32004Q2

Source: Labour Market Administration (Arbejdsmarkedsstyrelsen)

957621449378240173128834Total

111110000Slovenia

4581044320Czech Republic

98101196540Slovakia

111210986520Estonia

1366863320Hungary

45271918119650Latvia

19512810294522724141Lithuania

67943429322714911882543Poland

2006Q22006Q12005Q42005Q32005Q22005Q12004Q42004Q32004Q2

8

Danish situationIn DK: 12-15.000 workers from the new EU countries, since EU25

• Steeply increasing numbers in 2006

• MW have an impact on the Danish construction labour market

• MW are a big issue of the TU, in order to avoid social dumping

9

• MW are less aware of the risks at work

• MW worry less about OHS

• Migrant workers are more exposed to accidents and MSD than the national workers

• Poor housing & welfare conditions

• MW is a vulnerable group

• MW rarely contact the Danish Trade unions

• How come?

MW OHS, experiences

10

MW OHS, experiences

MW plays a double role:On top of being more exposed to OHS risks…MW also affect the OHS situation of the fellow (national) construction workers, due to language problems and different “safety cultures”

11

“Foreign companies are often less serious than domestic ones”

Reasons?• They stay for a short period of time• They are more focused on short term profits• They become aware of the rules after signing a contract

ControllingThe foreign companies often try to avoid the attention of the authorities. By this they are harder to control.

Foreign companies

12

Reactions of the inspectorate given to foreign construction companies in DK:8 in 2003; 15 in 2004; 73 in 2005; 166 in the first 9 months of 2006• 10% of the cases involving reactions did involve MW – due to recent inspection in construction• The labour inspectorate has tabled brochures on OHS, in German, Polish & Lithuanian

Labour inspection

13

Reflections - 1What is the situation like in your country?

• OHS of MW?• OHS in foreign companies? Any examples?

14

Reflections - 2Strategies for improvements

• What can be done, while we are waiting for the Governments and labour inspectors to take action?

• What can the migrant workers do on their own?

• What can the trade unions do?- host TU?- TU in the country of origin?

15

Reflections - 3How to make

improvements?

• EU15 contractors are said to provide a better OHS standard at sites, when contracting in the new members states? Do you agree?

• Is it possible to keep the new OHS standard, when the foreign contractors are leaving?

• Possible ways keep improvements?

16

“OHS is an lever to increase organising and TU influence”

Correct?OHS 1. A matter of workers’ interest

- and their families2. Easy to improve3. Accepted in society4. A matter of law:

Employer obligation Risk assessment etc.

5. Gives access to the workers- via active workers as safety reps

OHS: A tool for organising?