getting voices heard researching poverty with young people, reflections from a facilitator. fiona...

‘Getting Voices Heard’ Researching poverty with young people, reflections

from a facilitator. Fiona McHardy : Community Research Officer

Overview

The research through the Evidence Participation and Change (EPiC) project based at Poverty Alliance explored the issues of transitions post school.

This project was conducted with young people through a community research approach.

Background

Its overall aim is to support people with experience of poverty, grassroots community and voluntary organisations to influence the development of anti-poverty policy within Scotland.

Project breakdown

Partnerships project with Stirling Council Youth Services in 2010 -2011.

Research undertook a community research approach.

Research objectives

The research objectives were to:

Provide an understanding of young people’s views and experiences on opportunities available to them locally within regeneration areas.

Contribute to understanding perceptions and experiences of the service provision available within regeneration areas.

Highlight best practice in service delivery and provide policy recommendations.

Training Programme

As Israel et al (1998 ) argues that participatory models embed co learning and expertise within communities.

Learning is a duel process and one that builds upon the strengths and resources within a community. This project recognised the young researchers as co -partners within the research process and drew upon their perspective.

Training Programme

Bennett and Roberts (2004 p 13)argue that although trust is often seen as a by product of a participatory research projects, it crucial to the effectiveness of participatory processes.

France (2000 p3 ) highlights the importance of participation structures with flexibility to allow for young people to be able to leave and return to the project and the need to embed support responsive to the needs of young researchers.

Research Approach

Peer to peer interviews. Community surveying. Stakeholder interviews.

Nieuwehuys (2004 p210) argues that it is critical that participatory approaches reflect that knowledge construction as a form of power and participatory approaches should allow for alternative methods in the research process.

Research Approach

McKendrick and McHardy (2011) discuss the importance of skills sets and support required for achieve research goals.

Bennett & Roberts (2004 p 10) discuss how participatory research processes result in greater feelings of ownership of the research

Research Approach

Bennett & Roberts (2004 p 57 ) discuss the importance of research as a part of a broader process to build networks and partnerships.

Research Approach

Welford (2011) discusses how participatory approaches are shaped by the context they operate.

Bennett and Roberts (2004) argue that by adopting participatory approaches the research process is refined making the research process more accessible.

Key findings

Accessing support that was accessible and tailored to their needs was seen as vital to an effective transition.

Barriers that affected opportunities included financial ones such as low pay and transports costs.

Experiences of services accessed for support showed the importance of services being ‘youth friendly’ particularly for more disengaged young people.

Research and Policy

Knowledge of challenges faced. Targeting of service provision. Resourcing of project. Need for effective engagement and dialogue.

References Bennett, F. , Roberts, M. (2004) From input to influence: participatory approaches toresearch and inquiry into Poverty York : Joseph Rowntree Foundation

Chambers, R. (1999) Participatory Methods of Poverty Measurement[Online] [Accessed: 1/2/2012].

Clark, J. (2004) Participatory research with children and young people: philosophy,possibilities and perils, [online] [Accessed: 1/2/2012].

Nieuwenhuys , O. (2004) ‘Participatory Action Research in the Majority World’ in FraserS Lewis, V. Ding , S . Kellet , M , Robinson, C. (eds) (2004) Doing Research with Children and Young People London: Sage .

References France, A. (2000) Youth Researching Youth: The Triumph and Success Peer

ResearchProject, Joseph Rowntree Foundation: York

Israel, B; Schultz, A; Parker A, Becker A. (1998). ‘Review of Community-Based

Research:Assessing Partnership Approaches to Improve Public Health’. Annual Review of

Public Health 19: 173-202.

Kirby, P. (2004) A Guide to Actively Involving Young People in Research: For researchers,

research commissioners, and managers, Involve :

References Kelly, P. (2011) in ‘Poverty and Participation: progress in Scotland’ in McKendrick, J;Mooney, G; Dickie, J and Kelly, P (eds). (2011). Poverty in Scotland 2011: Towards aMore Equal Scotland?, London: Child Poverty Action Group.

McKendrick, J. McHardy, F. (2011) Learning Point 61 Involving children and young people as active research participants in community regeneration and tackling poverty in Scotland. Available at

http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/Doc/94257/0113610.pdf

Schäfer N, Yarwood, R. (nd ) Involving young people as researchers : uncovering multiple power relations among youth. [online] [Accessed: 1/2/2012].13

Welford , S. (2011) ‘ The Poverty Alliance Evidence Participation and Change Project ,Putting Participation into Practice in Scotland’ in EAPN (2011) Breaking Barriers Driving Change Case Studies of Building Participation Of People Experiencing Poverty. Brussels: European Anti Poverty Network.

Contact details

Fiona McHardy Fiona.mchardy@povertyalliance.org 0141 353 0440 The Poverty Alliance 162 Buchanan Street Glasgow

G1 2LL