en16309 - methodology social performance assessment (comprehensive presentation)

EN16309

Sustainability of construction works – Assessment of the social performance of buildings – Methodology

CEN TC 350 WG5

1http://www.hamans.com

GENERAL PROCEDURE

THE SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT OF BUILDINGS

EN15643-part 3: framework standard

EN16309:

Assessment of social performance of buildings —

Methods Methodology

English Version

Sustainability of construction works — Assessment of buildings —Part 3: Framework for the assessment of social performance

EUROPEAN STANDARD

NORME EUROPÉENNE

EUROPÄISCHE NORM

EN 15643-3

January 2012

ICS 91.040.01

Contribution des ouvrages de construction audéveloppement durable - Évaluation des bâtiments - Partie

3: Cadre méthodologique pour l'évaluation de la performance sociale

Nachhaltigkeit von Bauwerken - Bewertung derNachhaltigkeit von Gebäuden - Teil 3:

Rahmenbedingungen für die Bewertung der sozialenQualität

EN16309 :

within the framework EN15643-3 the standard

EN16309 provides the methodology for

“measuring” the social performance of buildings

CEN TC350 standards

for sustainability assessment

• not for

designing an object

• for assessing the

performance of

a designed

an existing building

practice however:

it turns out to work like good help in designing

not meant for

Assessment requires first:

• a good DESCRIPTION

of the object of assessment

• specifying the SCENARIOS

for all life cycle stages

and “processes”

object of assessment

THE CONCEPT OF THE SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT

Applying to all the standards of the sustainability assessment:

Environmental, Social and Economic assessment

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

+Functional Requirements to the building

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

Environmental, Social, Economic Requirements to the building

Technical Requirements to the building

Concept of Sustainability Assessment

Functional Equivalent:

Technical and Functional Requirements

Sustainability Assessment

Designed Solution or Existing Building

technical

characteristicsfunctionality

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

the assessed indicators on

declared technical and functional performances

of the assessed object

functional equivalent

communication of:

ENV, SOC, ECON demands from

clients brief and/or regulations

Concept of the

sustainability assessment

EN16309. fig 1

Client demand

Rules and Regulations

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

technical

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

communication of:

demandclient’s brief

regulations

Concept of the

EN16309. fig 1

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

technical

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

communication of:

demand

supply

client’s brief

regulations

architect’s or

designer’s

solution

Concept of the

EN16309. fig 1

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

technical

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

communication of:

DESCRIPTION

EN16309. fig 1

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

technical

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

communication of:

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

technical

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

communication of:

DESCRIPTION

EN16309. fig 1

BUILDING LIFE CYCLE INFORMATION

INFORMATION MODULE

Benefits and loads beyond the

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

B 6 Operational Energy use

A5 B 7 Operational Water use

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

BEYOND

THE BUILDING LIFE CYCLE

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

PROCESSUSE STAGE END OF LIFE STAGE

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

BUILDING ASSESSMENT INFORMATION

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

USE STAGE

before-use stages are

excluded from the

social performance

assessment

after-use stages are

excluded from the

social performance

assessment

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

USE STAGE

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

ENV SOC ECON

assessed object

Client's brief,

requirements

Regulations

Requirements

technical

ECON------------

SOC------------

ENV------------

communication of:

Building (design) description

USE STAGE

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

USE STAGE

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

Scenariosspecifications of

“processes”

USE STAGE

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

USE STAGE

Scenarios for the

information modules are

building and building-use

specific.

The standard only provides

rules for specifying

scenarios.

Aspects of social performance of a building

• Accessibility

• Health and Comfort

• Safety and Security

• Adaptability

• Impact on the neighbourhood

per aspect

one or more indicators

EN 15643-3

The checklist approach

• aspects and indicators of social performance are difficult to quantify in figures

• therefore a checklist approach is chosen

The checklist approach

• aspects and indicators of social performance are difficult to quantify in figures

• therefore a checklist approach is chosen

reporting in a checklist per indicator provides relevant information on the building’s:

• conditions of the scenario

• descriptions of measures provided

• the level of measures where possible

What is assessed?

Use stage

“USE” = “what impact has the building on the user ?”

e.g. :

• ease of access for the building user

• health and comfort for the building user

• safety and security for the building user

• …………..

Use stage

e.g. :

• …………..

“normal” use over the life time of the building

Use stage

e.g. :

• …………..

“normal” use over the life time of the building

but also “what impact has the building on the user”

during ……

maintenance activities, repair works, refurbishments,

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

Use stage

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

Use stage

The assessment is structured per information module:

• describe “the impact of the building on the user” during normal use – B1

• describe “the impact of the building on the user” during maintenance – B2

• describe “the impact of the building on the user” during repair – B3

• etc. ……………………

Scenarios

• The building assessment requires the specification of scenarios

– A performance declaration without specifying the scenarios is useless.

• Scenarios for the information modules are building and building-use specific.

• The standard provides only rules for specifying scenarios.

• Scenarios are specified per information module:

– for the “normal use” in information module B1

– for the “maintenance works” in information module B2

– for the “repair works” in information module B3

– etc. ……………………

description and specifications of the scenario for B1 are part

of the building’s social performance assessment

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

functional specification of the building =

scenario for B1

technical & functional

performance of the

building in use

technical specification =

description measures

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

Use stage

Scenarios to be specified for the “services” B2 – B7

Scenarios depend on type and pattern of use and on

the functional and technical design of the building

HOW IS “SOCIAL PERFORMANCE”

MEASURED AND DESCRIBED?

categories, aspects and indicators

Aspects of social performance of the building

the building

facilitating its useoperating processes serving and/or maintaining

the required functionalities of the building

Distinguish:

• aspects related to the building fabric (building characteristics)

• user- and control systems related aspects (interaction in operation)

building-related aspects for the fabric

Accessibility

Accessibility for people with specific needs

Access to building services

Thermal characteristics

Health & Comfort

Characteristics of visual comfort

Acoustic characteristics

Characteristics of indoor air quality

Spatial characteristics

Adaptability

Safety and Security

Resistance to climate change

Accidental actions (earthquake, explosions,

fire and traffic impacts

Personal safety and security against intruders

and vandalism

Security against interruptions of utility supply

Impact on neighbourhood

Glare/overshadowing

Emissions

Shocks / vibrations

Accessibility

Accessibility for people with specific needs

Access to building services

Health & Comfort

clause: 7.2.3

clause: 7.2.2

EN16309

clause: 7.4.3.1

clause: 7.4.2.1

EN16309

clause: 7.4.4

clause: 7.4.5.1

clause: 7.4.6

Adaptability

Safety and Security

Resistance to climate change

Accidental actions (earthquake, explosions,

fire and traffic impacts

Personal safety and security against intruders

and vandalism

Security against interruptions of utility supply

Glare/overshadowing

Emissions

Shocks / vibrations

clause: 7.7.4

clause: 7.7.2

EN16309

clause: 7.5.2

clause: 7.3

clause: 7.5.3

clause: 7.5.4

clause: 7.5.5

clause: 7.7.3

clause: 7.7.5

user- and control system-related aspects relevant for the operation of the building

Thermal comfort

Health & Comfort

Visual comfort

Indoor air quality

Safety and Security

Security against intruders and vandalism

Emissions

clause: 7.4.5.2

clause: 7.4.3.2

clause: 7.4.2.2EN16309

Thermal comfort

Health & Comfort

Visual comfort

Indoor air quality

EN16309

clause: 7.7.4.1

Safety and Security

Security against intruders and vandalism

Emissions

EN16309

clause: 7.5.3

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

USE STAGE

system boundary

B2 B3 B4 B5

BEYOND

A1 - 3 A4 - 5 B1 - 7 C1 - 4

PRODUCT

CONSTRUCTION

rial S

nsport

Manufa

nsport

Constr

uction -

llation p

rocess

Deconstr

uction

nsport

cessin

reuse,

recovery

ecyclin

Reuse -

Recovery -

Recycling -

potential

A1-A3R

tenance

Repair

SOCIAL PERFORMANCE

USE STAGE

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

performance of the

building in use

health comfort

accessibility

safety security

adaptability

impact neighbourhood

Use stage

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

performance of the

building in use

health comfort

accessibility

safety security

adaptability

building characteristics

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

performance of the

building in use

health comfort

safety security

interaction in operation

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

accessibility

safety security

adaptability

health comfort

safety security

user- and control system-related aspects

all operational “services”

deliver/secure the “functional & operational” performance

however: how do these “services” impact the use (B1) of the building?

Example

for example:

the level of thermal comfort in using the building

providing thermal comfort

USE STAGE Information module : B1

Information module : B6

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

Use stage

health comfort

and with the defined scenario to B1

building USE

• type of activities in the room• type of users ( e.g. activities, clothing)

• operative temperature

• humidity

• air velocity and distribution

clause: 7.4.5.2

clause: 7.4.3.2

clause: 7.4.2.2EN16309

Thermal comfort

Health & Comfort

Visual comfort

Indoor air quality

in the information module:

supply side specified comfort

indicators – comfort scenario

demand side specified

framework conditions for comfort

Specifications of the scenario for B1 are part of the building’s social

performance

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

specification of the scenario for B1:

• for the building overall

• detailed for specified rooms, part of the building

• e.g. energy performance acc. EPBD or equiv. National rules

• setting of room temperatures, humidity, ventilation,….. hours/day/week

• constancy of comfort temperature, etc.

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

Use stage

health comfort

building characteristics:

description

due to / in spite of, the building characteristics

there may be a need for energy to maintain the

specified comfort level

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

Use stage

health comfort

Thermal comfort

Health & Comfort

Visual comfort

Indoor air quality

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

Use stage

health comfort

Health & Comfort

Thermal comfort

Health & Comfort

Visual comfort

Indoor air quality

B2 B3 B4 B5 B6 B7

health comfort

Use stage

health comfort

Health & Comfort

Thermal comfort

Health & Comfort

Assessment of information module B6: (impact on the

user when “heating”, “air conditioning”, etc.) :

- e.g. continuous or interval conditioning causing drafts,

noise, temperature fluctuations, etc.

Assessment in a checklist approach per information module

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

Step 5

Step 6

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Intended Useclause 4

Specification of the

Object of

Assessment

Functional Equivalent

Reference Study Period

System Boundary

Object of Assessment

clause 5

Scenarios for the

Building Use StageObject of Assessment – Time related characteristics

Scenarios for the information modules B1 and B2 – B7clause 6

Evaluating aspects

and indicatorsChecklist

clause 7, 8

Annex B

Reporting and

Communication

General information

The Assessment Result

Data sourcesclause 9

Verification Verification clause 10

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Object of

Assessment

System Boundary

clause 5

Scenarios for the

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Object of

Assessment

System Boundary

clause 5

Scenarios for the

Evaluating aspects

clause 7, 8

Annex B

Step 4 Evaluating aspects

clause 7, 8

Annex B

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Object of

Assessment

System Boundary

clause 5

Scenarios for the

social building-performance indicators

clause 7, 8

Annex B

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Object of

Assessment

System Boundary

clause 5

Scenarios for the

health comfort

accessibility

safety security

adaptability

health comfort

safety security

clause 7, 8

Annex B

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Object of

Assessment

System Boundary

clause 5

Scenarios for the

health comfort

accessibility

safety security

adaptability

health comfort

safety security

Follow the methodology in clause

7.2-7.7

Is there a regional,

national or European

requirement

a client requirement

Is the aspect relevant for

the design of the object of

assessment?

assessment

of aspect

assessment of

aspect

is the indicator

assessed ?

Specify the minimum requirement

and/or give details of client’s

requirement

Describe

measures

that have

been taken

Justify

INAJustify

Report obtained

performance

and references

Report

Mark as

relevant)

Have measures

been taken

exceeding the

requirement ?

7.2-7.7

Report obtained

performance

and references

Report

for all aspects- all indicators

Report obtained

performance

and references

Describe

measures

that have

been taken

Guided by a checklist Evaluating indicators per information module B1-B7

7.2-7.7

Is there a regional,

national or European

requirement

a client requirement

Is the aspect relevant for

the design of the object of

assessment?

assessment

of aspect

assessment of

aspect

is the indicator

assessed ?

Specify the minimum requirement

and/or give details of client’s

requirement

Describe

measures

that have

been taken

Justify

INAJustify

Report obtained

performance

and references

Report

Mark as

relevant)

Have measures

been taken

exceeding the

requirement ?

7.2-7.7

Report obtained

performance

and references

Report

for all aspects- all indicators

Report obtained

performance

and references

Describe

measures

that have

been taken

Fig.3 EN16309

Report in a checkliste.g. for B1

Annex A - Table for Module A 1: checklist on the social indicators for the information module

"Use stage"

Module B1 a b c d e f

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

indicators for the aspect related to

social performance as listed in Table 1 in clause 7.1

the indicators 1-16 are building-related aspects for the fabric

the indicators 17-21 are user- and control system-related aspects relevant for the operation of the building

Is the aspect

relevant for the design of

the object of assessment ?

(yes/no)

Is there a national-

regional or European

requirement applicable ?

(yes/no)

If yes - give

reference to the relevant regulation)

Specify the minimum

requirement according the prevailing

regulation or if not regulated give details

of any requirements made in the clients

Have measures

been taken for exceeding the

requirements given in c)

yes/no)

Give value for indicator or

briefly specify measures taken to achieve the

stated performance ?

Give Reference to

relevant documentation to support e)

Aspect Accessibility, see 7.2

1. Accessibility for people with specific needs (see 7.2.2)

2. Access to building services see 7.2.3

Aspect Adaptability, see 7.3

3. Adaptability

Aspect Health and comfort, see 7.4

4. Thermal characteristics, see 7.4.2.1

5. Characteristics of indoor air quality, see 7.4.3.1

6. Acoustic characteristics,

see 7.4.4

7. Characteristics of visual comfort,

see 7.4.5.1

8. Spatial characteristics,

see 7.4.6

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"Module B1 a b c d e f

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

the indicators 18-22 are user- and control system-related aspects

relevant for the operation of the building

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

Impacts on neighbourhood, see 7.5

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

10. Emissions, see 7.5.3

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

3. Adaptability

6. Acoustic characteristics, see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise,

see 7.5.2

11. Glare/overshadowing, see 7.5.4

12. shocks / vibrations, see 7.5.5

Aspect Safety and security, see 7.7

13. Resistance to climate change, see

14. Accidental actions (earthquake,

explosions, fire and traffic impacts), see 7.7.3

15. Personal safety and security against intruders and vandalism,

see 7.7.4

16. Security against interruptions of utility supply, see 7.7.5

17. Thermal comfort, see 7.4.2.2

18. Indoor air quality, see 7.4.3.2

19. Visual comfort,

see 7.4.5.2

20. Emissions,

see 7.5.3.1

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise,

see 7.5.2

see 7.7.4

19. Visual comfort,

see 7.4.5.2

20. Emissions,

see 7.5.3.1

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise,

see 7.5.2

see 7.7.4

19. Visual comfort,

see 7.4.5.2

20. Emissions,

see 7.5.3.1

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

"Use stage"

Clause

7.2 – 7.7

Is the aspect

(yes/no)

If yes - give

Specify the minimum

Have measures

yes/no)

Give Reference to

3. Adaptability

see 7.4.4

see 7.4.5.1

see 7.4.6

9. Noise, see 7.5.2

summarizing the steps in the assessment

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

Step 5

Step 6

Identify Purpose of

the Assessment

Object of

Assessment

System Boundary

clause 5

Scenarios for the

Evaluating aspects

clause 7, 8

Annex B

Reporting and

Communication

General information

The Assessment Result

Data sourcesclause 9

Verification Verification clause 10

esc@hamans.com

www.hamans.com

en16309 - methodology social performance assessment (comprehensive presentation)

object of assessment

buildingtechnical requirements

economic requirements

functional performances

buildingclients brief

performance ofa

framework standarden16309

framework en15643

Engineering

developing a comprehensive methodology for bpr projects...

a comprehensive smart methodology for museum …

from 3d to gis. a comprehensive methodology for recording

an automated methodology for a comprehensive definition of

earned value management and telecom projects success · evm...

comprehensive aircraft preliminary design … ·...

costing green: a comprehensive cost database and budgeting...

comprehensive gas turbine combustion modeling methodology

a comprehensive methodology for computational fluid

positioning the cen tc350 standards and en16309: social...

a comprehensive validation methodology for sparse

s measurement system (sms) methodology · this report...

fao land cover mapping methodology, tools and standards...

comprehensive full-chip methodology to verify … full-chip...

a comprehensive diagnosis methodology for complex hybrid...

4cs employee opinion comprehensive analysis report · 4cs...

comprehensive design methodology of input- and output-split...

a comprehensive methodology to analyze the impact …

a comprehensive methodology for assessing biomechanical...

practical use of the glasgow coma scale - a comprehensive...