deficit and new values in the linguis2c market for small ... · deficit and new values in the...

Deficitandnewvaluesinthelinguis2cmarketforsmalllanguages

JuliaSallabankSOASUniversityofLondon

JonathanKasstanQueenMaryUniversityLondon

COSTNewSpeakersWAC2016,UniversitätHamburg,12-14May

DRAFT–PLEASEDONOTCITEWITHOUTPERMISSIONToappearinpress.

Presenta2onoutline

•  Comparisonofcontexts•  IdeologicalchallengesfacedbynewspeakersofGiernesieiandFrancoprovençal

•  Tradi2onalvs.newlinguis2cmarkets•  Towardsanewanaly2calframework

•  Guernsey(ChannelIs.)•  Semi-autonomousBri2shdependency

•  Indigenouslanguage:Giernesiei(Norman,oïl)

•  Only100-200fluentna2vespeakers?Mainlyaged80+

•  Only6proficientspeakersunder60?(youngest48)

Twosmall,‘severelyendangered’languages:Giernesiei

3

Francoprovençal

(Bert et al. 2009: 14) (Hall 1949: 2)

Francoprovençal

‘Le francoprovençal tout court n’existe pas’ (Helmut Lüdtke 1971: 69). [In short, Francoprovençal does not exist].

‘Le nouveau groupe proposé [...] n'offre aucune unité géographique’ (Meyer 1875: 295). [This newly proposed dialect grouping […] does not form a discrete unit].

i) Does it actually exist?

‘Ce nom est […] un peu trompeur, car il semble suggérer qu’il s’agit d’une langue mixte’ (Walter 2003: vii). [This name is somewhat misleading, for it seems to suggest a hybrid language].

iii) A confusing name

‘Le francoprovençal existe-t-il?’ (Tuaillon 2007: 9) [Does Francoprovençal exist?]

‘[Le francoprovençal n’a] jamais fait l’objet d’une conscience linguistique commune’ (Matthey and Meune 2012: 108) [Francoprovençal has never been associated with a coherent linguistic identity]

ii) No linguistic identity?

Linguis2cmarkets

•  Bourdieudevelopedtheconceptoffieldsormarkets(e.g.1991)–  Notonlywithregardtolanguage

•  Economiccapital:money,assets•  Culturalcapital:knowledge,skills,educa2on,tastes•  Symboliccapital:pres2ge,creden2als•  Oneformofcapitalmaybeconvertedintoanother

–  e.g.pres2gewaysofspeakingfacilitateknowledgeacquisi2onandeconomicadvantage

•  Fundamentallinkbetweenac2onsandinterests

Damnediftheydo,anddamnediftheydon’t

•  Newspeakersofsmall,highlyendangeredlanguagesfindthemselvesinadouble-bind

•  Older/na2vespeakersexpressadesireforyoungerpeopletolearnsuchlanguages

•  Thereisincreasingdesireamongyoungerpeopleforlanguagerevitalisa2on

•  Butnewspeakersaremarginalisedbyself-appointedgate-keeperstotradi2onallinguis2cmarkets– Na2vespeakersactasgate-keeperstolinguis2cmarketswhere‘authen2clanguage’(Coupland2003:419)iscarefullymonitoredandmaintained

Commonissuesre:GiernesieiandFrancoprovençal

•  Ownership(powerinthelinguis2cmarket)– Newspeakersbeingrobbedoflanguageopportuni2es

•  Authen2city,legi2macy•  Status(language~dialect?)andglohonyms•  Cri2cismanddiscouragement•  Mythofnoearliernewspeakers•  Lackofopportuni2estoprac2se•  Insufficientaccesstoinput•  Differentstrategiesamongnewspeakers-acceptauthorityorrebel?

Legi2macy,authen2cityandauthorityinsmalllanguages

•  Na2ve-speakerism–  “languageguardians”upholdtradi2onalwaysofspeaking–  maintenanceoftradi2onalpower(elders=authori2es)–  “LotsofpeopleseeGiernesieiasanostalgicthingandalmostasasecretsocietyorclubwithanaudiblemembershipcardtobelongtothecommunity”–prospec)venewspeaker,M,40s(SallabankandMarquisinpress)

•  Linguis2cvariantsproducedbynewspeakersarecri2cised(delegi2mised)andrejected–  “Wedon’tlikepeoplewhospeakourpatoisbadlyweprefertospeakwithrealpatoisspeakersandtospeakeitherFrenchorourrealpatois,butnottomassacrethepatois”–Swissna2vespeaker,M,80+(Kasstaninpress)

Tradi2onallinguis2cmarketsforsmalllanguages

•  Tradi2onal(na2ve)speakershaveaccesstoheritagelanguagesassymboliccapital

•  InGuernsey,Englishwasusedforu2litarianeventssuchascommercialandofficialtransac2ons;Frenchwasusedforreligion,hashighstatus;Giernesieifulfilledapha2coraffec2verole;nowanostalgicone.Francoprovençalasa“languedelaterre”

•  Impactonlanguagedevelopment– Giernesiei/Francoprovençalassociatedwiththepast–  lexicalmodernisa2onetc.isnotfelttobeapriority

‘Alterna2ve’marketvalues

•  Therehavebeensomeahemptsto(re)definemarketvalueswhichvaloriseminority/heritagelanguages:

1.  Schiffman:‘asortoflinguis2cblack-market’(2002:98)

–  waysthatofficialmarketsareunderminedorresisted–  analogoustoLabov’s(1972)‘covertpres2ge’orsolidarity-

drivenvaluesinlinguis2cpsychology–  nofurtherdetails/developmentontheidea

2.  ‘Linguis2cEmancipa2on’(Huss&Lindgreneds.2011)–  ‘condi2onsthatmustbepresentforagivenunderprivileged

languagetomoveupwardsonanimaginedhierarchicalscaleoflanguages’(Bull2013:33)

–  ‘toimaginedifferent,moreorlessparallellinguis2cmarkets,e.g.global…,na2onal…and,inaddi2on,severallinguis2csubmarkets’(Bull2013:44)

‘Linguis2csub-markets’

•  Partofminoritysociolinguis2chabitusisthetradi2onaldeficitideologyaboutminoritylanguages

•  Blackmarketvaluesandemancipa2onexplainrevalorisa2onandmaintenanceoflow-statusvarie2es

•  Buttheydonotcaterforthedifferingvalue-systemsoftradi2onalvs.newspeakers

•  Inourcontexts,anotherpartofhabitusisideologiesoflegi2macyandthedominanceofna2ve-speakermodels

‘Linguis2csub-markets’

•  Ineffectnewspeakersarecrea2ngasub-marketofalinguis2csub-market:–  revitalisa2on(Giernesiei);–  reclama2on(Francoprovençal);– Parallelwithmarke2ngtheory:micro-marketsforlocaleconomies

•  Whileprospec2venewspeakersaresocialisedintotheseideologies,somearealsowillingtochallengeassump2onsinordertomakethelanguagestheirown

Newmarketvalues?•  Refusinggate-keeper‘authen2city’•  Alterna2veglohonyms•  Symboliclanguageuseisbecominganincreasinglyimportantforumfor‘preserving’GuernesiaisandFrancoprovencal–  Performance,song,‘heritage’/‘cultural’events

•  Iden2ty-construc2on(personalandpoli2cal)–  Indexicality(Silverstein2003)

•  Commodifica2onoflocallanguage–  Placebrandingandpoli2calagendas–  Linguis2clandscape

•  Most(ifnotall)ofthesearearguablyexamplesofpost-vernacularlanguageuse(orconcepts)

Challengingauthorityinlinguis2cmarkets

•  Post-vernacularlanguageusedoesnotchallengena2ve-speakerism–  Itreproducesandperpetuatestheno2onthatnewspeakerswillnever/can’tbecomelegi2mate(fullyfluent/accurate)speakers

•  Mudeshavebeeniden2fiedasafeatureofnewspeakers–  ‘acri2caljunctureinthelifecyclewhereaspeakerchangeslinguis2cprac2ceinfavourofthetargetlanguage’(Walsh&O’Rourke2014:68)

–  Commitmenttospeakingthelanguage–  Newspeakersadoptlanguageasanewcurrency

•  ‘ac2velydefiningthesociolinguis2clandscapeintheirownterms’(Jaffe2015:38)

Poten2alsourcesofauthority(power)ina‘newlinguis2cmarket’

•  Languageknowledgethroughformallessons•  Exper2segainedthroughlinguis2cstudiesandlanguage

documenta2on•  Involvementinlanguagepolicyandplanning

–  Bothtop-downandbohom-uparenas•  Commitmentdemonstratedthroughac2vism(linguis2c,

poli2cal?)•  Neworthographicproposalsandprac2ces•  Languagedevelopment:terminology,newspeakervarie2es•  ‘wecanunderstandthenewcommunica2veorderasa

future-orientedflexible,vacilla2ngandchangeablephenomenonratherthanasta2c,frozenandrigidstatebasedonheritageonly’(WalshandO’Rourke2015:2)

Someconclusions…

•  Lookingforpoten2alnewmarketvalues–  to‘havelocallanguagesandculturescon2nueinwhateverformtheymaytake’(Goodfellow2009:21)

•  OvercomingideologicalchallengesfacedbynewspeakersofRMLs:–  authen2city,ownership,(il)legi2macy

•  Challenging‘post-vernacularity’asagoal–  Impliesterminaldecline–  Pessimis2candinsul2ngviewofnewspeakerabili2es

•  Newkindsofmarketvalues,‘currencies’orlinguis2ccapitalfor‘newspeakercommuni2es’–whatmighttheselooklike?

ReferencesBert,M.,Costa,J.&Mar2n,J.B.(2009).ÉtudeFORA:FrancoprovençaletoccitanenRhône-Alpes.ÉtudePilotéeparl’Ins2tutPierre

Gardehe.UniversitéCatholiquedeLyon.Bourdieu,P.(1991).LanguageandSymbolicPower.Cambridge:PolityPress.Bull,T.(2013).‘Linguis2cemancipa2onandthelinguis2cmarketplace’,Sociolinguis)cStudies7/1-2:33-55.Coupland,N.(2003).‘Sociolinguis2cauthen2ci2es’,JournalofSociolinguis)cs7(3),417-431.Goodfellow,A.-M.(2009).Introduc2on.In:A.-M.Goodfellow(ed.),SpeakingofEndangeredLanguages:IssuesinRevitaliza)on.

Newcastle:CambridgeScholars,1-22.Hall,R.A.,Jr.(1949).‘Thelinguis2cPosi2onofFranco-Provencal’,Language:Linguis)csocietyofAmerica,25,1,pp.1-14.HelmutLüdtke,M.(1971).Rapport.In:Z.Marzys(ed.),Colloquededialectologiefrancoprovençal.ActesducolloquedeNeuchâtel,

23-27Septembre1969.Neuchâtel:Droz,pp.69-74.Huss,L.andLindgren,A.-R.(2011)‘Introduc2on:defininglanguageemancipa2on’,Interna)onalJournaloftheSociologyofLanguage

209:1–16.Kasstan,J.(inpress).‘Contes2ngauthen2cityamongspeakersofacontestedlanguage:onemergingnewspeakersofFrancoprovençal’,

JournalofMul)lingual&Mul)culturalDevelopment.Jaffe,A.(2015).‘Definingthenewspeaker:theore2calperspec2vesandlearnertrajectories’,Interna)onalJournaloftheSociologyof

Language,231,21-44.Labov,W.(1972).Sociolinguis)cPaWerns.Philadelphia:UniversityofPhiladelphiaPress.Mahhey,M.andMeune,M.(2012).‘Anthologiedetextesromandsenfrancoprovençal’,Revuetransatlan)qued’étudessuisses,2,

107-122.Meyer,P.(1875).‘Un2tledreview’,Romania,4,pp.293-296.Pivot,B.(2014).Revitalisa2ondeslanguespostvernaculaires:lefrancoprovençalenRhône-AlpesetleramaauNicaragua.Unpublished

PhDThesis.UniversitéLumière-Lyon2.Sallabank,J.&Y.Marquis.(inpress).‘Wedon’tsayitlikethat’.In:C.Smith-Christmas&M.Hornsby(eds.),IdeologiesofNew

Speakers.Basingstoke:PalgraveMacmillan.Schiffman,H.(2002).Frenchlanguagepolicy:centralism,Orwelliandirigisme,oreconomicdeterminism?inLi,W.,J.-M.Dewaele,A.

Housen(eds):Opportuni)esandChallengesofBilingualism.Berlin:MoutondeGruyter,pp.89-104.Silverstein,M.(2003).‘Indexicalorderandthedialec2csofsociallife’,LanguageandCommunica)on,23,193–229.Tuaillon,G.(2007).LeFrancoprovençal.TomePremier.AostaValley:MusumeciÉditeur.Walsh,John&O’Rourke,Bernadehe(2014).BecominganewspeakerofIrish:linguis2cmudesthroughoutthelifecycle.Digithum16:

57-73.----(2015).‘Linguis2cmudesandnewspeakersofIrish’,COOPERATIONResearchEzine,1,2-14.Zulato,A.,Kasstan,J.&N.Nagy(forthcoming).‘AnoverviewofFrancoprovençalinEuropeandNorthAmerica’,Interna)onalJournalof

theSociologyofLanguage.