anuj angirish
Post on 03-Apr-2018
226 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
1/39
1
FACTOR BEHIND THE SUCCESS OF PETRO RETAIL
OUTLET IN INDIA
Dissertation Project Report
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the
Award of the degree of
IINNTTGG..BBBBAA++MMBBAA((OOIILL AANNDD GGAASS))
By
ANUJ ANGIRISH
Under the guidance of
Dr. Atul Razdan
COMES, UPES
University of Petroleum and Energy Studies,
Dehradun
2012
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
2/39
2
UNIVERSITY OF PETROLEUM &ENERGY STUDIES
DISSERTATION REPORT
ON
FACTOR BEHIND THE SUCCESS OF PETRO RETAIL OUTLET IN
INDIA
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF
Dr. Atul Razdan
College of Management and Economic Studies
SUBMITTED BY:
Anuj Angirish
R430209008
INTEGRATED BBA +MBA (O&G)
Semester VI
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
3/39
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First and foremost, I would like to express gratitude to my Institution, University of Petroleum &
Energy Studies for providing me a magnificent opportunity in the form of this dissertation to
work and learn.
I would like to express gratitude to Dr. Atul Razdan for sharing the journey of conceptualizing
and developing all the ideas. He stood in times of difficulty and despite of his busy schedule
devoted a major chunk of his time towards this project. He has been a part of all the activitiesand duly guided the project to its destination. I am indebted for his endeavour in making this
project a success. He has truly fulfilled
his role as a guide.
I would also like to acknowledge the help and support extended by all my friends whose names
could not be mentioned here. They all have been very co-operative and provided impetus to this
project. Without their help this project would not have reached its destination. I express mygratitude for their suggestions
and help they extended to this project.
I will not miss the opportunity of expressing thankfulness towards all my teachers and the faculty
of University of Petroleum & Energy Studies for sharing their knowledge, which provided
necessary ingredients to this project.
Date:
Signature
Place:
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
4/39
4
INDEX
S.NO. CHAPTER PAGE
Nos.
1. INTRODUCTION 1-42. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5-63. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 74. RESEARCH OBJECTIVE 8-95. LITERATURE REVIEW 10-136. FINDINGS 14-437. QUESTIONNAIRE 44-458. CONCLUSIONS 46-489. REFERENCES 49
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
5/39
5
INTRODUTION
Indian Petroleum Sector
Over the years India Petroleum Industry has played an influential part in triggering the speedy expansion
of the country's economy by contributing 15% in the total GDP. Further to this, petroleum exports gave
new dimension to foreign exchange earnings in India.
Expansion of Indian petroleum retail market is triggered by the growth in automobile sales that resulted in
major foreign investments. The growth is estimated to sustain and the market is likely to expand further
by 20 million every year till 2030, placing India at the world map in terms of being the biggest
automobile market.
The business environment in India has undergone a significant change in the past few years, and
nowhere is it as pronounced as in the petroleum sector. Increase in refining capacity has
transformed India from a net importer to a net exporter of petroleum products. Petroleum
marketing has been decontrolled leading to entry of new domestic and international players into
the market. Government have provided operational freedom to the government oil companies in
a host of areas including determining their own market share, freedom to prepare and implement
their market plans , selection of dealers etc. We are also moving towards a market determined
pricing regime in letter and spirit. This liberalized scenario is making the sector intensely
competitive, and the oil companies, especially those in the public sector would need to adopt a
more customer focused approach to the retail end of their business.
Factors leading to success of petrol retail outlets
To gain a sustainable advantage, a retailer needs to understand and satisfy both the apparent and
the latent needs of the customer. This principle holds true in petroleum retailing too. All our
efforts in exploration and production, refining, distribution and marketing and finally culminate
at retail point after moving through a long complicated supply chain.
Some of the major factors over which success of a petro retail outlet:
a) Quality (no fuel adulteration)
b) Value added servicesc) Generating higher volumesd) Reaching the subserviced arease) Prompt servicesf) Convenience to reach the storeg) Good ambience etc
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
6/39
6
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Indian retail industry can be segmented in different segments viz. cosmetics, footwear,
sanitary products, entertainment etc. The downstream petroleum retailing is one of the largest
segments of the Indian retail industry and the petro-retail sector is one of the most organized
sectors of the retail industry
India had deregulated the petroleum retail sector in 2002 by dismantling APM and enabling newplayers to enter the market. The entry of private players like Reliance, Essar, Shell, NRL, and
many more have increased the competition by means of the quality of fuel and the non fuelofferings at their retail outlets
With a market determined pricing mechanism in place, prices will be lowered, which would
reduce the margins from fuel products. In such circumstances, the petroleum retailers will needto have differentiated value propositions to improve revenues. It will require customer centric
approach and building of a strong brand equity and identity. Non-fuel products tender
higher margins as compared to petroleum products and enable companies to sustain themselves,
especially during times when oil prices are high. However, it is to be kept in mind that petroleumretailing is a retailing of petroleum product and service, with differentiation possible in either or
both areas
Now, it is not all about offering fuel only at the petrol stations. The new look petrol pumps, apart
from dispensing fuels; now offer the best of retail chains providing a value added service to busy
consumers. This trend is in circulation in the international markets and the big petrol stationconvenience stores earn more than 30 to 40 per cent of their profits from the non-fuel activities.
The range of value added services is all beneath one roof. The new-look petrol pumps are now
the more advanced multi-purpose dispenser petrol-pumps. The petrol pumps are computerized,
thus reducing waiting time which not only ensures accuracy, but also saves a lot of time forcustomers and avoids misconception and arguments. The study gives a comprehensive overview
of petroleum industry in India, the way it has evolved through shackles of time and its current
status with respect to companies, regulations and customers. The study tracks the origin and the
journey of industry till date. It has also focused on the kind of services expected by consumers,which are being provided on retail outlets and which can be provided on outlets. These services
will cumulatively increase the revenue realization as well as optimal utilization of land available
on an outlet.There are various talks of the emerging retail boom in India, "with one modern store for every
400,000 population" at present. Among the factors that are driving this boom are convenience of
shopping, store accessibility, quality of products, loyalty programs and product assortment. Froma broader economic perspective, the diffusion of supermarkets can be conceptualized as a system
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
7/39
7
of demand by consumers for supermarket services, and their supply in developing countries. Gas
retail sector is not far away.
The Indian Petroleum retailing industry is today poised to make giant strides both in
terms of new forecourt retailing opportunities and superior customer offerings at the retail outlet.
With the emergence of organized retailing in the country and a growing demand from
consumers for a superior shopping experience, Convenience Retailing has emerged as a key
business area for petroleum companies given their wide retail presence, existing customer baseand strategically located sites. Convenience need gaps have been felt in various fields and
research has shown that the urban consumer today seeks convenience in shopping for their basic
requirements so that their precious time is reserved for more fruitful pursuits. Petrol retail outletsprovide the right framework for setting up convenience retail chains where the consumer has the
opportunity of combining shopping with the fuelling occasion.
Petrol stations are widely recognized to be one of the highest traffic aggregators and retail
majors like hypermarkets such as Sainsbury, Tesco and Carrefour have added motor fuels intheir basket of services for the convenience of their customers. Hence alongwith strategic
locations, the availability of footfall in the petrol retail outlets give petroleum retail companiesthe competitive advantage. Worldwide, petrol station convenience stores have developed into a
serious business in itself with companies like Shell, Caltex, BP running their convenience store
chains very profitably. All of them have deployed best retail practices in their stores and offer awide range of services including laundry, postal services, courier services, fast food etc.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
8/39
8
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
1. To highlight and analyse various factors responsible for the success of petro
retail outlets.
2. To find the factors that drive in customers into the retail outlet.
3. To know whether the customer is expecting anything more from the services
in outlets.
4. To find respondents reason for refueling in the particular retail outlet.
5. To know the importance loyalty program and additional services effect on
customer.6. To know the customer service satisfaction from the respondents.
7. To know the respondents opinion on the performance of their outlets.
8. To help the petroleum companies in knowing what are the factors which
factors would help driving more customers to their petrol pumps.
9. To analyze what are the factors which may help in marketing a petrol pump
better.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
9/39
9
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The type of research done to present this project is mainly descriptive type of research. Major
purpose of description research is the description of state of affairs as they exist at present. The
data used in this research is both PRIMARY DATA which include direct interview of owner and
customers. A part from this my study also contains few traces of SECONDARY DATA (also
known as desk research) involves the summary, collation and/or synthesis of existing research
Secondary research can come from either internal or external source.
3.1 Research Design
The formidable problem that follows the task of defining the research problem is the preparation
of the design of the research project, popularly known as "research design".
The methodology that will be undertaken to study the present study and to fulfil the above stated
aims and objective would be:-
Descriptive research studies are those studies that are used to describe the characteristics of a
particular individual or group.
3.2 Data Source
Primary source:-
Questionnaire and interviews.
A questionnaire will be created which will be subjected to 30 people to know whether the
questionnaire is suitable.
Secondary source:-
Magazine, Newspaper and Internet websites.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
10/39
10
3.3 Sampling Plan:-
A mixture of contact and convenience type of sampling will be used in this kind of research. The
survey is to be conducted at retail outlets in NOIDA. The city has been chosen as per
convenience and to get a better picture about the different strategies used for petro retailing
outlet.
Asample size of 250 (50 people per station) at 5 stations were interviewed by preparing aquestionnaire.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
11/39
11
LITERATURE REVIEW
Price uniformity and competition in retail gasoline market
Andrew Eckert1, Douglas S. West
Theories of price uniformity in a market
The competitive market model
A competitive market model of retail gasoline pricing has been adopted in a variety of
Canadian industry and government studies. This adoption is based on the belief that retail
gasoline markets in Canada satisfy the following assumptions:
(1) Consumers are mobile and can, at low or zero cost, check gasoline prices charged at different
stations in the same geographic market,
(2) Gasoline stations post their prices so that rival stations can check each others prices at low or
zero cost,
(3) Individual gasoline stations set their own prices, and
(4) Gasoline stations act as though they are undifferentiated firms competing in a spacelessworld.
Because these assumptions eliminate all spatial product differentiation and costly consumersearch, it has been predicted that retail gasoline prices (for the same type of gasoline)
will be the same everywhere in the market, irrespective of location, proximity to competitors,
or the characteristics of the retailers. In addition, it has been predicted that the retailprice of gasoline established in a market is a competitively determined price. The empirical
analysis carried out in this paper focuses on the first prediction of the competitive market
model.The competitive market model as stated may appear to be easy to reject: if all prices in
the market are not the same, then the model is rejected. However, rejection of the model on this
basis would not be sufficient to persuade its proponents that alternative models better explain
retail gasoline station pricing. What is required is the specification of an econometric model
that contains variables that the competitive model suggests should not affect the probabilitythat a station charges the market price.. In the absence of a clear rejection of the competitive
market model as the explanation for retail gasoline pricing, antitrust policy decisions will
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
12/39
12
continue to be guided by the belief that retail gasoline markets are competitive, and anti-
competitive conduct in these markets cannot succeed.
Brands
Brands are controlled for by using two dummy variables: Majoritequals one if the stationsells a major brand of gasoline (i.e. Esso, Shell, Petro-Canada, Chevron, Husky-Mohawk)
and equals zero otherwise. Arc Temp itequals one if a station sells ARCO or Tempo brand
gasoline and equals zero otherwise. Majors have a greater incentive to set the tacitly collusive
price, so one would expect their stations to have a higher probability of matching the modeprice than either other brands or ARCOTempo. Conditional on characteristics, INC would
not predict brand specific differences in the probability of matching.
Contracts
Whether or not a station sets the mode price could depend on whether it is the station
dealer who sets the stations price or the supplier, which will depend on contractual
arrangements.At company operated stations and stations with commissioned dealers, the supplier
owns the station and sets the price. At lessee operated stations and branded independents,
the station operator or dealer sets the price.
While we were unable to obtain the contract type used by each major brand station,sufficient information was available to construct a proxy; the variable contract itequals one if
the station is a major brand station that is predicted to have pricing power at the supplier level
and zero otherwise.While the competitive model would suggest that contract type does not affect the
probability of setting the mode price, both tacit collusion and INC models would predict positive
coefficients on contract.
Distances
The competitive model predicts that the distance of a station from its competitor should
not affect whether the station matches the mode price. First, in the competitive model,
commuting makes consumers aware of prices at many stations. Second, either the transportationcosts faced by consumers in buying gasoline are zero or they do not vary by station choice
station that has nominal price control may in fact have little real control over its price. If lessees
and branded independents know that the supplier has a preference for uniform brand pricing,then a stations persistent
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
13/39
13
deviation from the suppliers price could result in loss of a facility lease or of the suppliers
brand banner. It could also result in a loss of price support from the supplier. The British
Columbia Inquiry into Gasoline Pricing (1996), found that major companies will protect retailingmargins at branded stations by lowering wholesale prices to match decreases in retail prices
during price wars, but only if the retailer did not start the price war. since a commuter passes
many stations along her commute.Under the tacit collusion hypothesis, distances may have an effect on the probability ofmatching. A greater distance of a station from one that is not setting the tacitly collusive price
should have a positive impact on the probability of matching since the closer a station is to a firm
that is undercutting, the more likely the station will need to match the undercut to maintainmarket share. On the other hand, the closer a tacitly colluding firms station is to a tacitly
colluding station owned by a different firm, the greater the likelihood of setting the market mode
price in order to prevent the breakdown of tacitly collusive pricing. An INC model would predict
that the greater the distance a station is located from its competitors, the greater the likelihood ofcharging a higher price. In this context, a higher price would be the mode price or a price above.
The effects of distance will be controlled through the variables maj dist it ,Arc Tempdist it , and
odistit .
Distances are measured in kilometers with maj distit
measuring the distance of a stationfrom the nearest major brand station of a different brand. Similarly, Arc Tempdist itmeasures
the distance to the nearest competing ARCO or Tempo station, and odist itmeasures the distance
to the nearest other brand station. The coefficients on these distance
variables are allowed to differ according to whether the station from which distance is beingmeasured is either a major brand, ARCO/Tempo, or other brand, for a total of nine
distance coefficients.
Traffic flows
The competitive model would predict that stations that are not on roads that are a part of
the commuter network would charge the same prices as stations on the major roads. If firms
are behaving in a tacitly collusive fashion, whether or not the station is on a major roadmay determine the likelihood that the station matches the mode price. For tacit collusion to
be sustainable, mode pricing is most important at stations whose prices are easily observed
and for whom undercutting would attract the largest market share from rival firms. AnINC model would also predict whether a station being on a major road should affect the
probability that the station matches the mode price; stations on major roads would be less
likely to match because station locations on major roads should result in more intensive
competition between stations.
To control for this effect, the variable roaditis defined to equal one if the station is located
on a major road and zero otherwise. A station is classified as being on a major road if the
Vancouver Street Atlas, published by MapArt, indicates that the road is either a major arteryor a highway. As with the distance variables, separate road variables are defined for whether
the station is a major brand, ARCO or Tempo, or other brand.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
14/39
14
Degree of local market concentration and competition
The competitive market model predicts that neither the number of nearby competing
stations nor the extent to which local competition is dominated by the majors will have
any impact on the probability of matching. Under the tacit collusion hypothesis, one would
expect the tacitly collusive price to be set more frequently in areas dominated by the majorsand where there is a smaller number of local competitors. To determine whether the intensity
of local competition or dominance by the majors matters, the variable stations itis defined to
measure the number of other stations within a 2 km radius of stationi. This variable couldhave either a positive or negative coefficient under the tacit collusion hypothesis depending
on whether localized competition is dominated by major brand stations or not. An INC
model would suggest a negative sign for this coefficient. The variable maj share itis defined
to measure the fraction of stations in station is municipality that bears the brand name ofone of the five major brands.12 An INC model yields the same positive sign prediction as
the tacit collusion model for the coefficient of this variable.
Income
The competitive market model would predict that a demographic characteristic such as
income will have no impact on a stores probability of matching the mode price. If, however,firms are engaged in tacit collusion or INC, the level of income of consumers located close to a
particular station could have an impact on the price set by the station. Higher income households
may face higher search costs or may have a higher willingness to pay. Therefore, one mightexpect that the mode price is more frequently set in neighborhoods with high incomes.
To control for income, the average household income of the census tract in which each station is
located is obtained from 1996 census data. In cases in which a station is located on the border of
two census tracts, the average of the two census tract incomes is used. The variable inc dum it
equals one if the station is in a tract with income higher than the average across all tracts in the
sample and zero otherwise. This variable allows for a potential threshold effect as opposed to
simply including income
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
15/39
15
Changing the rules of fuel retailing
The article by Archana Chaudhary provides the factors that affect fuel retailing in India. It says
that this RIL-owned petrol pump has been around for more than seven months, but the Reliance
sign still takes the Indian driver by surprise. Ditto with the attention-grabbing deep crimsonEssar Oil signage quietly lining interior roads along the West coast.
Do these ROs (retail outlets) make any difference to customers? Mr Ketan Vakharia, a Navi
Mumbai businessman,who has been buying fuel at RIL's flagship RO, for the past six monthsbelieves that the brand is new to retail business and hence away from the adulteration networks.
Reliance has a computerised system for fuel delivery - complete with GPS-fitted trucks. The
trucks carrying fuel from the company's Jamnagar refinery to the retail outlet and the
underground fuel tanks are sealed with special Finnish Abloy locks worth Rs 2,500 each, says asenior Reliance official. Tanks and fuel dispensing units are all connected to a mother computer,
which keeps a tab on fuel volumes.
There is an obvious emphasis on standardisation at all outlets (almost all Reliance ROs are
company-owned-company-operated) with uniformed attendants wielding computer-linked hand-
held devices, operating imported Japanese pumps.
Issues in the deregulation of the oil and gas sector
This research paper by R.K Narang addresses the factors affecting fuel retailing. It says that
Under the APM, all entities are assured a minimum return on their investments. While the
ONGC (Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited) and OIL (Oil India Limited) are allowed areturn of 15% on employed capital, the downstream companies get 12% (post tax) on their net
worth. Though there are incentives for exceeding the norms laid down by the OCC (Oil
Coordination Committee), it is widely accepted that the system neither fosters innovation nor
offers any significant incentive for efficiency. Some of the criticisms of the system are
enumerated below.It puts a low premium on innovation and efficiency.
It leads to non-optimal investment decisions that are not inconformity with market dynamics.
Since the government controls product prices, political forces exert pressure on price levels. In
the electricity sector, this has led to non-viability of most state electricity boards and in the oilsector, the result was an oil pool account deficit of 150 billion rupees. With an oilgross
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
16/39
16
domestic product elasticity of more than unity, India has been one of the worlds fastest growing
oil markets
FINDINGS
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
17/39
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
18/39
18
1.2 Government Controlled Companies:
OIL, ONGC, IOC, BPCL, HPCL and GAIL. CPCL, BRPL and IBP are now the subsidiaries ofIndian Oil Corporation whereas,. KRL and NRL have become subsidiaries of Bharat Petroleum
Corporation Ltd..
1.3 Joint Sector Companies:
MRPL was the joint venture of Aditya Birla Group and Hindustan Petroleum. However, ONGChas bought the stake of the Aditya Birla Group making it a completely public sector company.
1.4 Private Sector Companies:
Reliance Petroleum Ltd. (RPL), Gujarat Gas, Essar Oil Ltd., etc
Retailing has been the most vigorous and eye-catching sector of last decade.
Retailing industry has been present since ages in our country; it is only recently that it has
witnessed so much vitality. The impetus to retailing in India has been due to the increased
purchasing power of buyers (especially post-liberalization), increase in product variety and
availability, and increase in economies of scale, with the aid of modern supply and distributions
systems. The retail sales are at their peak and new technologies are enhancing retail productivity
CHAPTER 4
FACTORS LEADING TO SUCCESS OF A PETROL RETAIL OUTLET
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
19/39
19
There are galaxies of factors that lead to the success of a retail outlet. There are differentapproaches followed by various retail outlets. Some follow the customer centric approach while
others may follow the profit maximization approach.
In case of a petrol retail outlet some of the major factors over which success of the retail outletdepends are:
a) Qualityb) Value added servicesc) Generating higher volumesd) Reaching the subserviced arease) Convenience to reach the store(location factor)f) Availability of loyalty programmes
1. QualityThe customer, for whatever reasons, has little faith in the quality of product dispensed throughpetrol pumps. While his demands are high, his expectations remain low. Bereft of choice, he is
satisfied as long as he gets an unadulterated product. Our oil companies interpret quality to mean
no adulteration.
2. Value added servicesHere, we will have a glimpse of some of the facilities which are expected by a customer andcan be offered to them on an outlet:
ATM (Automated Teller Machine or Any Time Money)An ATM is the most expected facility at an outlet. Almost every customer now has a debit/credit
card and he/she expects an ATM at the outlet.
Benefits from implementing an ATM:-a) Customer will get an additional facility along will fuel and it will help to draw more
customers.
b) Increase in revenues due to the lease rent from the bank.
Quick care point :-A mechanic who can quickly give a service to the concern vehicle and also he can do theair check. In the quick care point, various lubricants and coolant can be displayed with thepurpose of advertisements as well as enhancing customer awareness. The facility of tyre
puncture should also be offered. This will further enhance the revenue of company.
Windscreen cleaning facility
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
20/39
20
A cleaning man can wipe the windscreen of four wheelers and front or body of the two-wheelers
while customer is getting his/her vehicle fuelled. This will augment the customers perception of
brand as well as organization. An extra attendant can serve for the role of cleaner.
Free health check-upIn the outlet some free health check up camps can be organized by the company doctor. This willillustrate the responsibility of the organization towards the society. Some of the camps which canbe organized may include the Pulse-polio camp and AIDS awareness camps.
INDE-PAYIt is e- recharge machine which will provide a recharge of six different telecommunications
companies along with the railway reservations
The facilities offered by Inde - pay machine are as follows:
Recharge Vouchers (mobile top-ups)
Flight tickets
Rail tickets
Utility Bill-Pay Cinema tickets
Budget Hotels
ContestsThe benefits of Inde - pay machine to the end user are:
Alternate revenue stream
High ROI
Major Value added services under one single terminal
With the purchase of the terminal in addition to the value added services, PCO and POSthe retailer gets the following
IRCTC authorized e-ticketing agent certificate
Airline ticketing (IATA sub-agent license)
The end user will be able to accept payments in cash, credit card and cash card
3) generating higher sales volumes
A good petrol pump that aims to provide comfortable and convenient service to the customers
requires as high an investment as Rs. 50 to 75 lakhs. Depending upon the location and the
number and quality of services, the investment levels could go up to Rs. 1.5 crores. However, the
per pump throughput has been declining and hovers around 160 180 KL/month. The
profitability, may even the sustainability, of the retail business at such high investment and lowvolumes needs to be addressed. Paradoxically, even in such a scenario, the oil companies have
launched a very ambitious, and at times reckless, programme of network expansion. Obviously
the assessment of the market growth made by the oil companies indicates high potential in
future. However, my view is that companies should target to generate higher volumes per retail
outlet rather than concentrating only on increasing the numbers.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
21/39
21
4) reaching the subserviced areas
Rural agricultural market has a large untapped potential for diesel sales, and the oil companies
should make efforts to develop these markets. It is not a correct position that social obligationsof the PSUs adversely affect their commercial interests. If non essential consumer goods like soft
drinks and cosmetics can penetrate the far flung rural markets, why cant the essential mass
consumption petroleum products?
5) location factors
The location of the retail store plays a very important role in its success. It is an integral and
crucial part of the retail strategy. It includes how easy or convenient it is for a customer to reach
the retail outlet. A customer would generally prefer a petrol pump that is near to his residence oron his daily travelling route.
6) Availability of loyalty programs
Loyalty programs are structured marketing efforts that reward, and therefore encourage, loyal
buying behavior -behavior which is potentially beneficial to the firm. In marketing generally and
in retailing more specifically, a loyalty card, rewards card, points card, advantage card, or club
card is a plastic or paper card, visually similar to a credit card or debit card that identifies thecard holder as a member in a loyalty program.
Petrol retail outlets offer a no. of loyalty programs to its customers.
For example:The XTRAPOWER Fleet Card program by IOCL is a complete smart card-based fleet
management solution for fleet operators and corporate for cashless purchase of fuel & lubricants
from designated retail outlets (petrol pumps) of Indian Oil through flexible pre-paid and creditfacilities. The fleet card also offers an exciting rewards programme and unique benefits likepersonal accident insurance cover and vehicle tracking facilities.
CHAPTER 4
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
22/39
22
INDIA AS A NON FUEL RETAILING DESTINATION
1INTRODUCTION
Till a few years ago, petroleum retailing in India was a staid and dreary business. Cars, buses and
two wheelers drove in, got the vehicles fuelled, paid cash, and drove out. The environmentstarted changing when Shell did a makeover of some petrol pumps as part of the economic
reform process. Improved signage, use of credit cards, and carwashes soon became an integral
part of the petroleum retail outlets. Earlier petrol stations were merely used for selling fuel; nowthey are quickly getting converted into multi-facility joints. The idea, common enough in
countries like Singapore and Malaysiais to buy fuel, and shop alongside.
In last few years, opportunities in petro retailing have risen in two key areas:
Sale of Value Added Fuels Branded Fuels
Value added products and servicesNon Fuel products and services
The Indian Petroleum retailing industry is today poised to make giant strides both in terms of
new forecourt retailing opportunities and superior customer offerings at the retail outlet. With theonset of the post APM deregulated scenario, the spirit of competitiveness amongst the petroleum
companies augurs well for the consumer with each of the companies adopting innovative ways to
capture a larger part of the consumers mind share.
With the emergence of organised retailing in the country and a growing demand from consumers
for a superior shopping experience, Convenience Retailing has emerged as a key business areafor petroleum companies given their wide retail presence, existing customer base andstrategically located sites. Convenience need gaps have been felt in various fields and research
has shown that the urban consumer today seeks convenience in shopping for their basic
requirements so that their precious time is reserved for more fruitful pursuits. Petrol retail outletsprovide the right framework for setting up convenience retail chains where the consumer has the
opportunity of combining shopping with the fuelling occasion.
Petrol stations are widely recognized to be one of the highest traffic aggregators and retail majors
like hypermarkets such as Sainsbury, Tesco and Carrefour have added motor fuels in their basket
of services for the convenience of their customers All of them have deployed best retail practices
in their stores and offer a wide range of services including laundry, postal services, courierservices, fast food etc.
India as a Non Fuel Retailing Destination
The Indian Petro retailing industry is now poised to make huge tread both in terms of new
forecourt retailing opportunities and better offerings for the customer at the retail outlet. With the
onset of the deregulated scenario, the character of competitiveness among the petroleum
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
23/39
23
companies augur well for the consumer with each of the companies espousing innovative ways
to capture larger part of the consumers mind.
The emergence of organized retailing and a growing demand from consumers for asuperior shopping experience has made Convenience Retailing a key business area for petroleum
companies due to their wider presence at strategically located sites and the existing mammoth
customer base.
Convenience need gaps have been felt in various fields and research shows that the urban
consumer today seeks convenience in shopping for their basic requirements so that
their precious time is reserved for more productive activities. Petrol retail outlets provide anexcellent framework for setting up convenience retail chains. Here, the consumer enjoys dual
occasion of, opportunity of combining shopping with the fuelling. Hence, along with the
strategic locations, the number of footfall in the petrol retail outlets gives petroleum retailcompanies the competitive advantage. Worldwide, petrol station convenience stores have
developed into a serious business in itself with companies like BP, Shell, Exxon running their
convenience store chains profitably. All of them have deployed best retail practices in their
stores and offer a wide range of services including laundry, postalservices, courier services, fast food etc.
Options for Non-Fuel Offerings
To deliver the many conveniences and services, various oil marketing companies have associated
with leading brands and companies like ICICI Bank, Coca Cola India, Fed Ex, Caf Coffee Day,Western Union Money Transfer, US Pizza, Barista, Dominos Pizza, Skypak, etc. The facilities
on a particular outlet would depend upon the purchasing power of the people. The facilities like
Caf Coffee Day, Barista, Dominos Pizza, US pizza, Crossword, Skypak, etc and other
expensive outlets may not work everywhere. Apart from them there are many other facilitieswhich can be offered to draw more and more customers, thereby increasing profitability and
level of customer satisfaction.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
24/39
24
CHAPTER 5
COMPARISON OF 5 PETROL RETAIL OUTLETS
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
25/39
25
R K Service Station
Sector 41
DSC Road, Sector-41, Noida
01202575099
more..
Jain Packers and Movers
Sector 12
Z-Block Market, Near 12-12 Red Light, Sector 12, Noida
01203104166
more..
A S Aircool
Sector 22
Shop-1, Sector-22, Main Road, Noida
9711763486
more..
Bhardwaj Hospital
Sector 29
Near Ganga Shopping Complex, Sector 29, Noida
01202450111
more..
Anjali Tours and Travels Pvt Ltd
Sector 18
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
26/39
26
307, P-3 Krishna Apra Plaza, Sector 18, Noida
01204332220
more..
During my visit I spoke to the owners of 5 petrol pumps in Noida and also interviewed a sample
of 250 people (50 people per station) at each stations by preparing a questionnaire.
During this visit i drew a comparison between the two retail outlets and the customers visiting
these outlets. There is a common trend that customers give more weightage to a few factors than
others like:
1. Convenience to reach the store
2. Prompt services
3. On daily travelling rout
4. No adulteration in the fuel etc.
Based on this comparison I have prepared a set of pie charts that will explain the factors that lead
to the success of a retail outlet which are given in the next chapter
CHAPTER 5
ANALYSIS THE FACTOR BEHIND THE SUCCESS OF RETAIL OUTLET
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
27/39
27
DATA TABULATION
1: No. of consumers who prefer going to a particular petrol pump.
Preferences No. of Respondents % of respondents
Yes 145 58%
No 105 42%
During the survey, it was found that 58% people prefer going to a particular retail outlet due to
several reasons like a particular retail outlet is near to their residence or they like the behavior of
pump attendants or they have trust regarding Q&Q on a particular retail outlet, etc. Rest 42%prefers RO whichever is on their way.
2: Reasons for preferring particular petrol pump.
1
58%
2
42%
1.No. of consumers who prefer going to a particular
petrol pump.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
28/39
28
Preferences No. of Respondents
Near to Residence 24
Prompt Services 30
Acceptance of fleet/ loyalty cards 16
Good Ambience 50
On daily travelling route 40
No fuel adulteration 60
Availability of Free Air Service 20
No queing 10
From the above graph we can see that maximum people prefer going to a particular retail outlet
because they have trust that there is no fuel adulteration, rest go because they like the ambience
there or they feel that services are good, etc.
2430
16
50 4060
20 10
2. Reasons for preferring a particular retail outlet
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
29/39
29
3: . Do you prefer any other services to be provided in the petrol station.
Preferences No. of Respondents % of Respondents
1.Yes 147 58.62%
2. No 113 41.38%
When customers were asked that are they guided as they enter the retail outlet, it was found that
approx 59% of customers were guided rest 41% think they are not. Some people dont even
notice that someone is guiding them in, they overlook the Marshal.
1
58.62%
2
41.38%
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
30/39
30
4: Trust upon the Fuel Quality & Quantity purchased by you at Fuel Station
of your Choice
81%
10.25%
4.37% 4.38%
Yes No Doesnt Matter Dont Notice
Preferences
No. of Respondents % of Respondents
Yes 202 81%
No 26 10.25%
Doesnt Matter 10 4.37%
Dont Notice 11 4.38%
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
31/39
31
4.38% of customers are in hurry always so they never noticed the uniform of pump attendants.
4.37% of total customer doesnt mind whether pump attendants are in uniform or not, 10% of the
customers say that pump attendants are sometimes in proper uniform sometimes not and the rest
81% of the customers say that yes, it does matter to them if the pump attendants are in uniform
as their uniform separates them from the general crowd on retail outlets which helps them to
understand with whom they have to talk.
5 Do you find any difference in the Quality of Fuel at different Fuel Stations?.
Preferences No. of Respondents % of Respondents
Yes 214 85.87%
No 35 14.13%
85.87%
14.13%
Yes No
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
32/39
32
14.13% of the customers are not satisfied with the attitude and services of the pump attendants
and rest 86% of the customers are satisfied with the behavior and services of the pump attendants
6: Services that attract customers to a particular petrol pump.
Preferences No. of Respondents
Air filling 40
Wind Screen Cleaning 41
ATM 38
Pollution Check 45
Drinking Water 43
Toilets 26
Departmental Store 6
Free vehicle Check- up 8
Puncture Repair 2
Wheel Balancing and
Wheel Alignment
1
40
4138 45 43
26
6 8 2
1
6: Services that attract customers to a particularretail outlet.
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
33/39
33
QUESTIONNAIRE
Name: ___________________
Age: __________
Designation and company name: __________________
Date: __________
Q1. Do you prefer going to a particular petrol pump?
1. Yes
2. No
3. Sometimes
Q2. What are your reasons for preferring a particular petrol pump?
1. Near to residence
2. Prompt services
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
34/39
34
3. Acceptance of fleet or loyalty cards
4. Good ambience
5. On daily travelling route
6. No fuel adulteration
7. Availability of Free Air Service
8. No queuing
Q3. Do you prefer any other services to be provided in the petrol station?
1. Yes
2. No
3. Dont notice
Q4. : Do you have trust upon the Fuel Quality & Quantity purchased by you at Fuel Station of
your Choice?
1. Yes
2. No
3. Doesnt matter
4. Dont notice
Q5. Do you find any difference in the Quality of Fuel at different Fuel Stations?
1. Yes
2. No
Q6. What are the services that attract you to a particular petrol pump?
1. Air filling
2. Wind screen cleaning
3. ATM
4. Pollution check
5. Drinking water
6. Toilets7. Departmental store
8. Free vehicle check up
9. Puncture repair
10.Wheel balancing and alignment
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
35/39
35
CONCLUSION
Retailing is the most active and attractive sector of the last decade. While the retailing industry
itself has been present through history in our country, it is only the recent past that has witnessed
so much dynamism. It's the latest bandwagon that has witnessed hordes of players leaping onto
it. While international retail store chains have caught the fancy of many travelers abroad, the
action was missing from the Indian business scene, at least till recently. The emergence of
retailing in India has more to do with the increasing purchasing power of buyers, specially post-
liberalization, increase in product variety, and the increasing economies of scale, with the aid of
modern supply and distribution management solutions.
A definition of retailing is essential in order to be in a position to assess the impact of retailing
and its future potential. The current retailing revolution has been provided an impetus from
multiple sources. These `revolutionaries' include many conventional stores upgrading themselves
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
36/39
36
to modern retailing, companies in competitive environments entering the market directly to
ensure exclusive visibility for their products and professional chain stores coming up to meet the
need of the manufacturers who do not fall into either of the above categories. Attractiveness,
accessibility and affordability seem to be the key offerings of the retailing chain.
Retailing is a technology-intensive industry. Successful retailers today work closely with their
vendors to predict consumer demand, shorten lead times, reduce inventory holding and thereby,
save cost. Wal-Mart pioneered the concept of building a competitive advantage through
distribution and information systems in the retailing industry. They introduced two innovative
logistics techniques - cross-docking and electronic data interchange. Today, online systems link
point-of-sales terminals to the main office where detailed analyses on sales by item,
classification, stores or vendor are carried out online. Besides vendors, the focus of the retailing
sector is to develop the link with the consumer. `Data Warehousing' is an established concept in
the advanced nations. With the help of `database retailing', information on existing and potential
customers is tracked. Besides knowing what was purchased and by whom, information on softer
issues such as demographics and psychographics is captured.
We are at a time when gaining a customers' trust is critical. It is a daily process, on purpose. It is
a time to maximize potential, ethically and to deal with conflict and problems, with credibility.
The petroleum retailers are also not left behind. Forecourt retailing is yet to emerge in a big way
in India. But with renewed thrust from the oil companies, the concept is poised for the next stage
of evolution. The concept of forecourt retailing at petrol stations is not new. It began in the 1980s
when British Petroleum launched its first convenience store. In India, where consumer interface
was recognized as a key factor, the concept was taken up in the late 1990s by Indian Oil
Corporation, which started its multi-purpose distribution centers at petrol pumps in semi-urban
and rural areas. The concept has been in vogue ever since. But recently it shot into limelight with
oil companies trying to milk this revenue stream for more moolah.
The oil marketing companies need to clearly identify customer needs and establish a strong
corporate brand targeting select customer bases. The companies need to drive product and
service offerings at retail outlets based on identified customer needs. They should develop cost-
effective retail outlets, upgrade existing assets for better throughput and customer service. They
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
37/39
37
should orient their distribution pattern and logistics in tune with demand in target markets and
develop superior franchisee selection and training systems along with appropriate risk-reward
mechanisms to drive performance.
In this respect, the oil companies have been coming up continuously with various initiatives to
differentiate themselves from other competitors and attract customers. They have come up with
various loyalty programs, cash card payment solutions, convenience stores, ancillary services,
food outlets, various other value added service at the retail outlets to give the customers value for
their money. Although the above matter to a large extent in bringing people to a retail outlet, the
main drivers include convenient location, branded fuels and assurance of quality and quantity.
Thus the companies should look for network expansion, supply chain optimization, steps towards
anti adulteration measures and aggressive branding strategies,etc. to give the consumers the best
they can.
Oil companies have made sporadic attempts at exploring non fuel retail(NFR)
opportunities in IndiaCar Wash, ATMs, Co Branded Credit Cards, Cyber Cafes, Convenience
Stores, Food Outlets, etc. Though one-off success stories have been reported no cohesive
strategy has emerged as yet on the NFR front. With the third largest distribution network (after
post offices and FMCG outlets ) there is a lot of untapped potential left for exploring in this
arena. The next few years should see all Oil Marketing Companies experimenting in this field.
Moreover, Gas Retailers can take British Gas as an example of effective Gas retailing, the
methods they have adopted, such as convenience to customer of paying bills online, the home
care scheme; with one call customers can update each and every one of their British Gasaccounts, from gas to burglar alarm support.
Ultimately,
-
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
38/39
38
Its the customer who will emerge as the winner. The company who identifies its
customers and his needs and provides satisfactory services will emerge as the leader
REFERENCES
Websiteswww.iocl.com,www.bharatpetroleum.com,www.hindustanpetroleum.com,
www.ril.com,www.dgh.org,www.essar.com,www.shellindia.com,
www.indiainfoline.com/businessschool/archives/marketingstrategiescurrentlyfollowed
Address by Mr.S.C. Tripathi, Secretary, Ministry Of Petroleum & Natural Gas,
Government of India at Petrotech 2005, January 17-18, 2005 , New Delhi.
Presentation by Dr. C. Srinivasan, Chairman, A.T. Kearney India at Petrotech 2003, 10th
January.
Business Worldissue dated February 15th, 2005. Petroleum Retail Stuck in Pipeline.
The Hindu Business Line Reliance , Essar changing the rules of fuel retailing, Tuesday,
July 20, 2004, Archana Chaudhary.
The Hindu Business Line Strategy ReportIndian Oil & Gas Industry 2004, Chemtech,
December 31, 2003.
TERI, Background paper issues in the deregulation of the Oil & Gas sector, New Delhi,
R.K.Narang, Ardhendu Sen and Leena Srivastava.
http://www.iocl.com/http://www.iocl.com/http://www.iocl.com/http://www.bharatpetroleum.com/http://www.bharatpetroleum.com/http://www.bharatpetroleum.com/http://www.hindustanpetroleum.com/http://www.hindustanpetroleum.com/http://www.hindustanpetroleum.com/http://www.ril.com/http://www.ril.com/http://www.dgh.org/http://www.dgh.org/http://www.dgh.org/http://www.essar.com/http://www.essar.com/http://www.essar.com/http://www.shellindia.com/http://www.shellindia.com/http://www.shellindia.com/http://www.indiainfoline.com/businessschool/archives/marketingstrategiescurrentlyfollowedhttp://www.indiainfoline.com/businessschool/archives/marketingstrategiescurrentlyfollowedhttp://www.indiainfoline.com/businessschool/archives/marketingstrategiescurrentlyfollowedhttp://www.shellindia.com/http://www.essar.com/http://www.dgh.org/http://www.ril.com/http://www.hindustanpetroleum.com/http://www.bharatpetroleum.com/http://www.iocl.com/ -
7/28/2019 Anuj Angirish
39/39
Presentation by Hemant D.P., Country Manager, Sales, FEDEX Express, India at
Petrotech 2003, 10th
January 2003.
Petro Retailing book (basic reference material) Published by UPES, Dehradun , 2004
Research methodology (basic reference material), Published by UPES, Dehradun , 2004
www.businessline.com
www.timesofindia.com
www.economictimes.com
www.hindustantimes.com
www.infraline.com
http://www.businessline.com/http://www.businessline.com/http://www.timesofindia.com/http://www.timesofindia.com/http://www.economictimes.com/http://www.economictimes.com/http://www.hindustantimes.com/http://www.hindustantimes.com/http://www.infraline.com/http://www.infraline.com/http://www.infraline.com/http://www.hindustantimes.com/http://www.economictimes.com/http://www.timesofindia.com/http://www.businessline.com/
top related