1 h c a l hf cable plant options hf cable plant options december 22, 2010 t. shaw

1

H C A L

HF Cable Plant Options

HF Cable Plant Options

December 22, 2010T. Shaw

2

H C A L

Existing RoBox24 PMTs/RoBox

Signal & Reference signals sent on aPair of Coax for each PMT

72 RoBox in system

3

H C A L

Current HF FE Module Front Panel

Each FE module reads out 6 QIEs.

4

H C A L

HF Cable Upgrade

Current plans• Multi-anode readout -> Fit 2x

or 4x channels/cabling into available space; no degradation in performance

• Use same FE modulesSome kind of patch

panel/connector adapter near FE crates to convert new cabling to present connectors.

5

H C A L

Cabling Selection

4 cable schemes are under review1. VPLSP cables; 24-pair, low skew, 100 ohm

differential impedance2. Samtec 50 ohm High Isolation Cable; 50 ohm

coax3. Tyco Z-Pack HM-ZD cables; using 26 AWG

coax; highly customizable 4. Doubling of current cables(probably only

plausible with a doubling of channels)

6

H C A L

Samtec V-Port Cables

We have (qty) 3 5-meter cables in hand!

7

H C A L

Testing Samtec VPLSP

8

H C A L

Testing Samtec VPLSP

9

H C A L

Testing Samtec VPLSP

10

H C A L

Samtec V-port Pros/Cons

Pros• Overall shield• Rugged construction

Cons• Large reflection when we try to use it in

common mode terminated to 50 ohms

Conclusion• Probably do not want to use this

11

H C A L

Samtec 50 ohm coax cable assemblies

We have (qty) 3 5-meter cables in hand!

12

H C A L

Testing Samtec 50ohm Hi-Isolation Cables

13

H C A L

Testing Samtec 50ohm Hi-Isolation Cables

14

H C A L

Testing Samtec 50ohm Hi-Isolation Cables

15

H C A L

Samtec Hi-Iso Pros/Cons

Pros• Cable almost as good as what we are using in

terms of transmission/reflection• Smaller footprint than what we use now (~50%

smaller)• Fairly rugged connector

Cons• No overall shield; can explore custom shield

with vendor, but it will not be incorporated into connector

16

H C A L

Tyco Electronics Z-Pack connector line offers dense cable assemblies

We have some long 26AWG coax samples in hand!

17

H C A L

Testing Tyco Coax w/ SMA connectors

18

H C A L

Testing Tyco Coax w/ SMA connectors

19

H C A L

Testing Tyco Coax w/ SMA connectors

20

H C A L

Testing Tyco Coax w/ SMA & Hm-Zd connectors

21

H C A L

Testing Tyco Coax w/ SMA & Hm-Zd connectors

22

H C A L

Testing Tyco Coax w/ SMA & Hm-Zd connectors

23

H C A L

Tyco z-Pack Pros/ConsPros

• Cable performance close to what we have now• Density allows a large number of conductors in a given

space

Cons• Density of connectors will provide challenge routing

from connector to QIEs• Density may contribute to crosstalk (need to look at

this)• No Overall shield; vendor will work with us, but the

overall shield is not incorporated into the connector• Connectors are NOT rugged; I think they could be used,

but with care!

24

H C A L

Spec’s of current Cable

25

H C A L

Current D-shell Cables

26

H C A L

Testing D-shell Cable

27

H C A L

Testing D-shell Cable

28

H C A L

Testing D-shell Cable

29

H C A L

D-shell Pros/Cons

Pros• Best cable performance• Overall shield incorporated into design• Rugged, proven design• No special adapters needed for input to

current FE Electronics BoardsCons

• Large footprint, could increase density by loading all 8 instead of 6 positions.

• Probably only allows for two-anode readout!

30

H C A L

Main trunk cable costs(does not include adapters or cabling inside

RoBox)

Cable Type#channels/cable

#cables required for two anode readout

#cables required for four anode readout

cost of cable

cost of connector

Total for 2 anode readout

Total for 4 anode readout

#channels for two anode readout 72 RoBox * 24 PMT * 2CH

#channels for two anode readout 72 RoBox * 24 PMT * 4CH

Samtec VPLSP 12 288 576 $278 $80,064 $160,128 3456 691224-pair -> 12 Sig/Refconnectors $10 $5,760 $11,520

$85,824 $171,648

Samtec Hi-Isolation 4 864 1728 $245 $211,680 $423,360connectors $10 $17,280 $34,560

$228,960 $457,920

AMP HM-Zdconnectors

HF Cables now in use 3 1152 2304 $78 $89,856 $179,712price from 2004

$25 $57,600 $115,200$147,456 $294,912

***NOTE if we re-use cables, can save half the cost $.

HF Cables now in use 4 864 1728 $104 $89,856 $179,712price from 2004

$25 $43,200 $86,400$133,056 $266,112

***NOTE If we remake, we could load up all 8 position instead of 6

NOTE - SPARES ADD 20%

31

H C A L

Conclusions

Recommendations• 2 Anode readout

Buy d-sub cables similar to what we have now, but stuff all 8 coax positions

• 4 Anode readoutPursue the Tyco Z-pack cable solution.Second option could be Samtec’s Hi-isolation

cables