alternative transportation fuels maria tome, p.e. state of hawaii department of business, economic...
TRANSCRIPT
Alternative Alternative Transportation FuelsTransportation Fuels
Maria Tome, P.E.Maria Tome, P.E.
State of HawaiiState of HawaiiDepartment of Business, Economic Development, and Department of Business, Economic Development, and
TourismTourismStrategic Industries DivisionStrategic Industries Division
22
OverviewOverview
Hawaii's Transportation Fuel Demand Hawaii's Transportation Fuel Demand Alternative Fuels Alternative Fuels Alternative Fueled VehiclesAlternative Fueled Vehicles IncentivesIncentives
33
Hawaii's Gasoline UseHawaii's Gasoline Use
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
5001
98
3
19
85
19
87
19
89
19
91
19
93
19
95
19
97
19
99
20
01
20
03
Year
Mil
lio
ns
of
Ga
llo
ns
MauiCounty
Kauai
Hawaii
Oahu
44
Gasoline Demand per YearGasoline Demand per YearActual (1983-2003) and Projected (2004-2015)Actual (1983-2003) and Projected (2004-2015)
0
100
200
300
400
500
6001
98
3
19
85
19
87
19
89
19
91
19
93
19
95
19
97
19
99
20
01
20
03
20
05
20
07
20
09
20
11
20
13
20
15
Year
Mil
lio
ns
of
Gal
lon
s
Maui CountyKauaiHawaiiOahu
actual projected
55
Alternative FuelsAlternative Fuels
Alcohol Fuels Alcohol Fuels EthanolEthanol MethanolMethanol
BiodieselBiodiesel ElectricityElectricity HydrogenHydrogen LPGLPG Natural Gas (CNG, LNG)Natural Gas (CNG, LNG) Others under development (P-series, diesohol)Others under development (P-series, diesohol)
66
Most Significant Most Significant
Alternative Fuels for Hawaii Alternative Fuels for Hawaii
Alcohol Fuels Alcohol Fuels EthanolEthanol MethanolMethanol
BiodieselBiodiesel Hydrogen / Fuel Cell / ElectricityHydrogen / Fuel Cell / Electricity LPGLPG Natural Gas (CNG, LNG)Natural Gas (CNG, LNG) Others under development (P-series, e-Others under development (P-series, e-
diesel)diesel)
√
√
Blending to begin in 2006; flex-fuel vehicles in use
Potentially significant; under development
If LNG available, this could change
√
30 years of local use but facing challenges
√
77
Most Significant Most Significant
Alternative Fuels for Hawaii Alternative Fuels for Hawaii
EthanolEthanol
LPG (Propane)LPG (Propane)
BiodieselBiodiesel
Hydrogen / Fuel Cell / Hydrogen / Fuel Cell / ElectricityElectricity
88
Fuel EthanolFuel Ethanol
Ethanol is also Ethanol is also known as ethyl known as ethyl alcohol. It’s the alcohol. It’s the alcohol in beer, alcohol in beer, wine, rum, vodka, wine, rum, vodka, etc.etc.
Ethanol was used Ethanol was used to fuel some of the to fuel some of the first automobiles.first automobiles.
99
Fuel EthanolFuel Ethanol
On the Mainland, independent gasoline On the Mainland, independent gasoline stations were generally first to offer gasoline stations were generally first to offer gasoline with up to 10% ethanol (E10; formerly known with up to 10% ethanol (E10; formerly known as gasohol). as gasohol).
1970s-1980s: Used as a 1970s-1980s: Used as a gasoline gasoline extenderextender
1980s: An 1980s: An octane boosteroctane booster (raises octane (raises octane 2-3 points)2-3 points)
1990s: Used as an 1990s: Used as an oxygenateoxygenate for clean for clean airair(Adds oxygen & reduces emissions of (Adds oxygen & reduces emissions of carbon monoxide)carbon monoxide)
1010
Projected US Ethanol DemandProjected US Ethanol Demand
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
1980 1990 2000 2010
BN
GL
N
BN GLN = billion gallons
1111
Fuel EthanolFuel Ethanol
Today, ethanol-blended gasoline is Today, ethanol-blended gasoline is available in most states. available in most states.
All of Minnesota's gasoline contains All of Minnesota's gasoline contains 10% ethanol10% ethanol Minneapolis/Saint Paul, 1995Minneapolis/Saint Paul, 1995 Statewide, 1997Statewide, 1997
California, New York, and Connecticut California, New York, and Connecticut switched completely at the end of switched completely at the end of 2003 and are now using ethanol rather 2003 and are now using ethanol rather than MTBE.than MTBE.
1212
States With 10 or More Years States With 10 or More Years of Fuel Ethanol Useof Fuel Ethanol Use
States With 10 or More Years of Use of Gasoline / Ethanol Blends
02468
1012141618202224
Ala
ba
ma
Ala
sk
aA
rizo
na
Ark
an
sa
sC
alif
orn
iaC
olo
rad
oC
on
ne
cti
cu
tD
ist.
of
Co
l.F
lori
da
Ge
org
iaId
ah
oIll
ino
isIn
dia
na
Iow
aK
an
sa
sK
en
tuc
ky
Lo
uis
ian
aM
ary
lan
dM
ich
iga
nM
inn
es
ota
Mis
so
uri
Mo
nta
na
Ne
bra
sk
aN
ev
ad
aN
ew
Je
rse
yN
ew
Me
xic
oN
ew
Yo
rkN
ort
hN
ort
hO
hio
Ore
go
nP
en
ns
ylv
an
So
uth
So
uth
Te
nn
es
se
eT
ex
as
Uta
hV
irg
inia
Wa
sh
ing
ton
W. V
irg
inia
Wis
co
ns
in
Ye
ars
1313
Ethanol could be produced in Hawaii Ethanol could be produced in Hawaii at a large scale (up to 90 million gallons per at a large scale (up to 90 million gallons per year) andyear) andat a competitive cost ($1.25 -$1.30 per gallon).at a competitive cost ($1.25 -$1.30 per gallon).
Waste biomass is better used for electricityWaste biomass is better used for electricityproduction than for ethanol production, since production than for ethanol production, since Hawaii's electricity is relatively expensive. Hawaii's electricity is relatively expensive.
Ethanol blending provides cost advantagesEthanol blending provides cost advantagesto blenders.to blenders.
The production of ethanol and generation The production of ethanol and generation of power of power from sugarcane is recommended.from sugarcane is recommended.
Hawaii’s Ethanol PotentialHawaii’s Ethanol Potentialfrom Stillwater Reportfrom Stillwater Report
1414
Biomass to Ethanol… or Electricity?Biomass to Ethanol… or Electricity?
2200 t/dayLignocellulose
to Ethanol69.3 MMGPY
$192 MM
Biomass100%
11.55 x 1012 Btu/yr$23 MM @ $30/ton
Waste Heat46.8%
Ethanol48.7%
$86 MM @ $1.28/gln
Power4.5%
$9 MM @ $0.06/kWh
2200 t/dayLignocellulose
to Power120 MW$90 MM
Waste Heat71.6%
Power28.4%
$57 MM @ $0.06/kWh
Biomass100%
11.55 x 1012 Btu/yr$23 MM @ $30/ton
Gross Margin $72 MM – $22 MM Fixed & Variable Operating = $50 MMEBITDA/Capital = 0.26
Gross Margin $34 MM – $6 MM Fixed & Variable Operating = $28 MMEBITDA/Capital = 0.31
2200 t/dayLignocellulose
to Ethanol69.3 MMGPY
$192 MM
Biomass100%
11.55 x 1012 Btu/yr$23 MM @ $30/ton
Waste Heat46.8%
Ethanol48.7%
$86 MM @ $1.28/gln
Power4.5%
$9 MM @ $0.06/kWh
2200 t/dayLignocellulose
to Power120 MW$90 MM
Waste Heat71.6%
Power28.4%
$57 MM @ $0.06/kWh
Biomass100%
11.55 x 1012 Btu/yr$23 MM @ $30/ton
Gross Margin $72 MM – $22 MM Fixed & Variable Operating = $50 MMEBITDA/Capital = 0.26
Gross Margin $34 MM – $6 MM Fixed & Variable Operating = $28 MMEBITDA/Capital = 0.31
EBITDA = Earnings Before Income Tax, Depreciation and Amortization
1515
Why no fuel ethanol in Hawaii?Why no fuel ethanol in Hawaii?
According to ASTM specification D4814, Hawaii According to ASTM specification D4814, Hawaii gasoline may not have a RVP (Reid vapor pressure) gasoline may not have a RVP (Reid vapor pressure) greater than 11.5 pounds per square inch (psi).greater than 11.5 pounds per square inch (psi).
Gasoline testing report in 1989 showed that vapor Gasoline testing report in 1989 showed that vapor pressures ranged from 9.7 to 11.4 psi.pressures ranged from 9.7 to 11.4 psi.
Adding ethanol to gasoline near the 11.5 psi limit Adding ethanol to gasoline near the 11.5 psi limit would result in fuel that did not conform to would result in fuel that did not conform to specifications.specifications.
To successfully blend ethanol in Hawaii, a suitable To successfully blend ethanol in Hawaii, a suitable blendstock is needed.blendstock is needed.
Bottom line: in Hawaii, refiner participation is Bottom line: in Hawaii, refiner participation is necessary.necessary.
1616
10.0
10.5
11.0
11.5
12.0
12.5
13.0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Vol % Ethanol
RV
P (
psi
)
RVP = Reid Vapor Pressure.
Vapor PressureVapor Pressure
Hawaii’s gasoline (including ethanol blends)
must have an RVP of
11.5 or less.
Lower curve: If gasoline with an RVP of 10.3 psi has ethanol added to it, the blend will have an acceptable RVP.
Upper curve: If gasoline with an RVP of 11.5 psi has ethanol added to it, the blend will have a (too) high RVP.
1717
For each gallon of ethanol, local refiners For each gallon of ethanol, local refiners will lose market share and be required to will lose market share and be required to modify operations and construct facilities. modify operations and construct facilities.
Such cost increases are offset… the price Such cost increases are offset… the price per gallon at the rack will not increase.per gallon at the rack will not increase.
The evaluation of the production of Ethyl The evaluation of the production of Ethyl Tertiary Butyl Ether (ETBE) using locally Tertiary Butyl Ether (ETBE) using locally produced ethanol and isobutylene from the produced ethanol and isobutylene from the local refineries is recommended.local refineries is recommended.
Considerations & Considerations & RecommendationsRecommendationsfrom Stillwater Reportfrom Stillwater Report
1818
Hawaii Gasoline to Contain 10% Hawaii Gasoline to Contain 10% EthanolEthanol
Beginning in April of 2006, at least 85 out of every 100 Beginning in April of 2006, at least 85 out of every 100 gallons of gasoline sold in the State for use in motor vehicles gallons of gasoline sold in the State for use in motor vehicles shall contain 10% ethanol by volume. shall contain 10% ethanol by volume. HRS HRS §486J(10), HAR 15-35§486J(10), HAR 15-35
-
100,000,000
200,000,000
300,000,000
400,000,000
500,000,000
600,000,0001
98
3
19
86
19
89
19
92
19
95
19
98
20
01
20
04
20
07
20
10
20
13
GA
LL
ON
S
ETHANOL DEMAND*
GASOLINE DEMAND*
* If all gasoline blended with ethanol
1919
Ethanol-based Alternative Fuel: Ethanol-based Alternative Fuel: E85E85
Gasoline with ethanol is still gasoline. It's not an Gasoline with ethanol is still gasoline. It's not an alternative fuel.alternative fuel.
An increasing number of new vehicles can use An increasing number of new vehicles can use E85E85 (15% gasoline, 85% ethanol), which (15% gasoline, 85% ethanol), which isis an alternative an alternative fuel.fuel.
2121
Onroad Alternative Fuel and Onroad Alternative Fuel and Hybrid Vehicles in the U.S., Hybrid Vehicles in the U.S.,
20032003Fuel Type Light Duty Medium Duty Heavy Duty Grand
Total Total Total TotalCompressed Natural Gas (CNG) 2,229 2,705 1,188 6,122Electric (EVC) 12,382 12 1 12,395Ethanol, 85 Percent (E85) 859,261 0 0 859,261Gasoline/Diesel-Electric Hybrid 50,357 0 175 50,532Hydrogen (HYD) 6 0 0 6Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) 20 0 91 111Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG) 180 1,650 281 2,111TOTAL 924,435 4,367 1,736 930,538
4 million on the road in the U.S.
2222
Energy Energy Policy Act of Policy Act of 1992 1992 (EPACT) (EPACT) alternative alternative fueled fueled vehicle vehicle (AFV) (AFV) purchase purchase requirementrequirements s
State, Federal, and Fuel Provider State, Federal, and Fuel Provider Fleets are Required to Purchase Fleets are Required to Purchase
AFVsAFVs
Model Year
Federal Fleets
State Fleets
Fuel Providers
1997 25% 10% 50%
1998 33% 15% 70%
1999 50% 25% 90%
2000 75% 50% 90%
2001+ 75% 75% 90%
2424
Produced Produced locally (Maui & locally (Maui & Oahu) from Oahu) from used cooking used cooking oiloil
Can also be Can also be produced from produced from oilseed cropsoilseed crops
For use in For use in diesel enginesdiesel engines
BiodieselBiodiesel
2525
BiodieselBiodiesel Can be used pure or blended with regular diesel. Can be used pure or blended with regular diesel.
B100=100% biodiesel; B100=100% biodiesel; B20 = 20% biodiesel, 80% petro diesel; B20 = 20% biodiesel, 80% petro diesel; B5 = 5% biodiesel, 95% petro diesel;B5 = 5% biodiesel, 95% petro diesel; B2* = 2% B2* = 2% biodiesel, 98% petro diesel;biodiesel, 98% petro diesel;
Can be added to regular diesel to improve cetane Can be added to regular diesel to improve cetane rating and reduce engine wear.rating and reduce engine wear.
Burns cleaner; produces less soot, smoke, and Burns cleaner; produces less soot, smoke, and cancer-causing emissions than diesel; smells cancer-causing emissions than diesel; smells different.different.
* Minnesota has a * Minnesota has a B2 mandate, triggered by 2 B2 mandate, triggered by 2 requirements:requirements:1) 8 million gallons of biodiesel production capacity; 1) 8 million gallons of biodiesel production capacity; ANDAND2) No earlier than June 30, 2005. 2) No earlier than June 30, 2005.
2626
BiodieselBiodiesel#2 DIESEL #1 DIESEL BIODIESEL
Specifications Specifications Test results
CETANE NUMBER (min) 40 40 61.2
FLASH POINT, °C (min) 60 38 >130
CLOUD POINT, °C (max) 10 10 3
SULFUR, ppm (max) 500 500 4.6
Wear Test Results #2 DIESEL #1 DIESEL BIODIESEL
High Frequency Reciprocating Rig (HFRR) Scar, microns
536 671 314
PROPERTY
2727
BiodieselBiodieselPercent
Biodiesel Number 2 Diesel Number 1 Diesel
0.0% 536 671
0.4% 481 649
1.0% 321 500
2.0% 322 355
20.0% 314 318
100.0% 314 314
HFRR Scar (microns)*
*Lower numbers are better. Below 460 is recommended by Fuel Injection Equipment (FIE) manufacturers
2828
Biodiesel EmissionsBiodiesel Emissions
http://www.epa.gov/otaq/models/analysis/biodsl/p02001.pdf
3030
IncentivesIncentives Federal ethanol credit: 51Federal ethanol credit: 51¢ per gallon provided to blender¢ per gallon provided to blender
Federal biodiesel credit: Federal biodiesel credit: $.50 or $1.00 per gallon to producer$.50 or $1.00 per gallon to producer
Federal small ethanol producer credit: 10¢/gallon to Federal small ethanol producer credit: 10¢/gallon to producerproducer
Federal Commodity Credit Corp: credits for new production Federal Commodity Credit Corp: credits for new production of ethanol and biodiesel (amounts vary; approx. $100 million of ethanol and biodiesel (amounts vary; approx. $100 million nationwide)nationwide)
State credit for ethanol facility: up to $4.5 million per facility State credit for ethanol facility: up to $4.5 million per facility
State highway taxes reduced for alternate fuelsState highway taxes reduced for alternate fuels
State 4% retail excise tax exemption for gasoline with 10% State 4% retail excise tax exemption for gasoline with 10% ethanolethanol
Electric vehicles with special license plates are allowed free Electric vehicles with special license plates are allowed free parking at meters; HOV accessparking at meters; HOV access
Counties provide highway tax reductions or exemptions for Counties provide highway tax reductions or exemptions for alternative fuelsalternative fuels
3131
Sum of State & County Sum of State & County Highway Taxes (cents per Highway Taxes (cents per
gallon)gallon)County Gasoline Ethanol LPG Biodiesel Diesel
Honolulu 32.5 4.8 10.6 12.3 32.5
Maui 34.0 6.2 9.5 4.0 34.0
Hawaii 24.8 3.7 8.1 6.2 24.8
Kauai 29.0 4.3 9.5 4.0 29.0
3232
SummarySummary
Transportation Fuel Demand is Projected to Transportation Fuel Demand is Projected to IncreaseIncrease
Alternative Fuels and Vehicles are AvailableAlternative Fuels and Vehicles are Available EthanolEthanol LPGLPG BiodieselBiodiesel Hydrogen / Hydrogen /
Fuel Cell / Fuel Cell / ElectricityElectricity
Incentives are AvailableIncentives are Available
3333
Internet ResourcesInternet Resources
Alternative Fuels Data CenterAlternative Fuels Data Center (national)(national) www.eere.energy.gov/afdc www.eere.energy.gov/afdc
Hawaii's Ethanol ProgramHawaii's Ethanol Program new-fuel.com new-fuel.com
BiodieselBiodiesel www.biodiesel.org www.biodiesel.org
Hawaii State Energy OfficeHawaii State Energy Office www.hawaii.gov/dbedt/ert/ www.hawaii.gov/dbedt/ert/