all one-loop nmhv gluon amplitudes in n = 1 symaochirov/talks/cern2013.pdf · mhv nmhv n = 4 sym...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes
in N = 1 SYM
based on arXiv:1311.1491 [hep-th]
Alexander OchirovIPhT, CEA-Saclay, France
Presented atCERN Theory DivisionNovember 29, 2013
![Page 2: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Amplitudes
p1
p2
p3 p4
p5
. . .
pn
![Page 3: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Amplitudes
p1
p2
p3 p4
p5
. . .
pn
◮ basic objects in QFT
![Page 4: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Amplitudes
p1
p2
p3 p4
p5
. . .
pn
◮ basic objects in QFT
◮ measurable at experiment
![Page 5: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Amplitudes
p1
p2
p3 p4
p5
. . .
pn
◮ basic objects in QFT
◮ measurable at experiment
◮ calculable analytically
![Page 6: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Known one-loop amplitudes
One-loop gluon amplitudes known analytically:
MHV NMHV
N = 4 SYM n-point byBern,Dixon,Dunbar,Kosower
’94 [1] n-point by Bern,Dixon,Kosower
’04 [2]
N = 1 SYM n-point byBern,Dixon,Dunbar,Kosower
’94 [3] 6-point byBritto,Buchbinder,Cachazo,Feng
’05 [4]
7-point by Bjerrum-Bohr,Dunbar,Perkins
’07 [5]
and Dunbar,Perkins,Warrick
’09 [6],
n-point by AO’13
QCD n-point byBedford,Brandhuber,Spence,Travaglini
’04 [7] 6-point by Britto,Feng,Mastrolia
’06 [8]
andBerger,Bern,Dixon,Forde,Kosower
’06 [9] and Xiao,Yang,Zhu
’06 [10]
![Page 7: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Content
1. Setup: NMHV amplitudes in N = 1 SYM at one loop
2. Method: spinor integration
3. Cut construction
4. Results
5. Conclusion and outlook
![Page 8: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Yang-Mills theories
Particle content:
helicity 1 1/2 0 −1/2 −1
N = 4 SYM 1 4 6 4 1
N = 1 SYM 1 1 0 1 1
QCD 1 0 0 0 1
![Page 9: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Yang-Mills theories at one loop
helicity 1 1/2 0 −1/2 −1
N = 4 SYM 1 4 6 4 1N = 1 SYM 1 1 0 1 1QCD 1 0 0 0 1
![Page 10: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Yang-Mills theories at one loop
helicity 1 1/2 0 −1/2 −1
N = 4 SYM 1 4 6 4 1N = 1 SYM 1 1 0 1 1QCD 1 0 0 0 1
A1-loopQCD = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 4A1-loopN=1 chiral + 2A1-loop
N=0 scalar (1)
![Page 11: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Yang-Mills theories at one loop
helicity 1 1/2 0 −1/2 −1
N = 4 SYM 1 4 6 4 1N = 1 SYM 1 1 0 1 1QCD 1 0 0 0 1
A1-loopQCD = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 4A1-loopN=1 chiral + 2A1-loop
N=0 scalar (1)
A1-loopN=1 SYM = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 3A1-loopN=1 chiral (2)
![Page 12: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Yang-Mills theories at one loop
helicity 1 1/2 0 −1/2 −1
N = 4 SYM 1 4 6 4 1N = 1 SYM 1 1 0 1 1QCD 1 0 0 0 1
A1-loopQCD = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 4A1-loopN=1 chiral + 2A1-loop
N=0 scalar (1)
A1-loopN=1 SYM = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 3A1-loopN=1 chiral (2)
N = 1 chiral 0 1 2 1 0N = 0 scalar 0 0 1 0 0
![Page 13: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus
![Page 14: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
![Page 15: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus
![Page 16: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
![Page 17: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses
![Page 18: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses — MHV (Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
![Page 19: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses — MHV (Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ Three minuses
![Page 20: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses — MHV (Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ Three minuses — NMHV (Next-to-Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ . . . k minuses
![Page 21: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses — MHV (Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ Three minuses — NMHV (Next-to-Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ . . . k minuses — Nk−2MHV
![Page 22: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses — MHV (Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ Three minuses — NMHV (Next-to-Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ . . . k minuses — Nk−2MHV
ANMHV5 =
(
AMHV5
)∗
![Page 23: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Helicity configurations in SYM
◮ All helicities plus — zero by SUSY
◮ One minus — zero by SUSY
◮ Two minuses — MHV (Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ Three minuses — NMHV (Next-to-Maximally-Helicity-Violating)
◮ . . . k minuses — Nk−2MHV
ANMHV5 =
(
AMHV5
)∗
NMHV important 6+ ext. particles
![Page 24: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
N = 1 SYM at one loop
A1-loopN=1 SYM = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 3A1-loopN=1 chiral (3)
A1-loopN=2 SYM = A1-loop
N=4 SYM − 2A1-loopN=1 chiral (4)
A1-loop = µ2ǫ(
∑
Cbox I4 +∑
Ctri I3 +∑
Cbub I2 +R)
, (5)
from susy power-counting R = 0.
![Page 25: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
UV and IR behavior
In = (−1)n+1(4π)d2 i
∫
ddl1(2π)d
1
l21(l1 −K1)2 . . . (l1 −Kn−1)2(6)
Britto,Buchbinder,Cachazo,Feng
’05 [4]: two-mass and one-mass triangles O( 1ǫ2)
cancel divergences inside boxes⇒ finite boxes and only three-mass triangles
A1-loopN=1 chiral =
1
ǫ
∑
Cbub +O(1) =1
(4π)d2 ǫ
Atree +O(1) (7)
∑
Cbub =1
(4π)d2
Atree (8)
![Page 26: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
NMHV three-mass triangles
already known thanks toBjerrum-Bohr,Dunbar,Perkins
’07 [5]
(s3+1)+. . .m−
1
. . .
s+1
(s1+1)+ . . . m−2 . . . s+2
(s2+1)+
. . .
m−3. . .
s+3
![Page 27: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Method: spinor integration
Thanks to Britto, Feng et al.
Cut =∑
h1,h2
∫
d4l1 δ(l21)δ(l
22)A(−lh̄1
1 , . . . , lh22 )A(−lh̄2
2 , . . . , lh11 ) (9)
lµ1 =K2
2
〈λ| γµ|λ̃]
〈λ|K|λ̃], lµ2 = −
1
2
〈λ|K|γµ|K|λ̃]
〈λ|K|λ̃]
⇒
∫
d4l1 δ(l21)δ(l
22) = −
K2
4
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃]
〈λ|K|λ̃]2(10)
⇒ Cut =
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃] Ispinor(λ, λ̃) (11)
![Page 28: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Spinor integration: complex analysis in disguise
λ = λp + zλq, λ̃ = λ̃p + z̄λ̃q (12)
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃] = −(p+ q)2∫
dz ∧ dz̄ (13)
⇒ Cauchy’s integral theorem (Mastrolia’09 [11]):
∫∫
D
dz ∧ dz̄∂f
∂z̄(z, z̄) = −
∮
∂D
dz f(z, z̄) + 2πi∑
zi∈D
Resz=zi
f(z, z̄)
(14)
Simple pole 〈λ|ζ〉: Resλ=ζ
1
〈ζ|λ〉
N(λ, λ̃)
D(λ, λ̃)=
N(ζ, ζ̃)
D(ζ, ζ̃)
![Page 29: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Spinor integration: residue extraction rules
Simple pole 〈λ|ζ〉:
Resλ=ζ
1
〈ζ|λ〉
N(λ, λ̃)
D(λ, λ̃)=
N(ζ, ζ̃)
D(ζ, ζ̃)= −Res
λ=ζ
1
〈λ|ζ〉
N(λ, λ̃)
D(λ, λ̃)(15)
Multiple pole 〈λ|ζ〉k:
Resλ=ζ
1
〈ζ|λ〉kN(λ, λ̃)
D(λ, λ̃)=
1
〈η|ζ〉k−1
{
1
(k − 1)!
d(k−1)
dt(k−1)
N(ζ − tη, ζ̃)
D(ζ − tη, ζ̃)
}∣
∣
∣
∣
t=0
(16)
Composite pole 〈λ|K|q]:
〈ζ| = [q|K| |ζ〉 = −|K|q]
[ζ̃| = −〈q|K| |ζ̃] = |K|q〉(17)
![Page 30: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Spinor integration: bubble coefficients
Cut =
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃] Ispinor
Cbub=4
(4π)d2 i
∑
residues
1
(n−k)!
d(n−k)
ds(n−k)
1
sln
(
1 + s〈λ|q|λ̃]
〈λ|K|λ̃]
)
×
[
Ispinor〈λ|K|λ̃]n−k+2
〈λ|K|q|λ〉
∣
∣
∣
∣
|λ̃]=|K+sq|λ〉
]∣
∣
∣
∣
s=0
(18)
(n − k) is the difference between the numbers of λ-factors in the numerator and the
denominator of Ispinor, excluding the homogeneity-restoring factor 〈λ|K|λ̃]n−k+2
![Page 31: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Spinor integration: propagators rewritten
(l1 −Ki)2 = K2 〈λ|Qi|λ̃]
〈λ|K|λ̃], (19)
Qµi (Ki,K) = −Kµ
i +K2
i
K2Kµ (20)
![Page 32: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Spinor integration: triangle coefficients
Cut =
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃] Ispinor
Ctrii =
2
(4π)d2 i
1
(K2(xi+ − xi−)2)n−k+1
×1
(n−k+1)!
d(n−k+1)
dt(n−k+1)Ispinor 〈λ|Qi|λ̃] 〈λ|K|λ̃]n−k+2
{∣
∣
∣
∣ λ=λi+−tλi
−
λ̃=xi+λ̃i
−−txi−λ̃i
+
+
∣
∣
∣
∣ λ=λi−−tλi
+
λ̃=xi−λ̃i
+−txi+λ̃i
−
}∣
∣
∣
∣
t=0
,
(21)
P i±(Ki,K) = Qi + xi±K, (22)
xi± =−K ·Qi ±
√
(K ·Qi)2 −K2Q2i
K2. (23)
![Page 33: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Spinor integration: box coefficients
Cut =
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃] Ispinor
Cboxij = −
2K2
(4π)d2 iIspinor 〈λ|Qi|λ̃] 〈λ|Qj |λ̃]
{∣
∣
∣
∣λ=λij+
λ̃=λ̃ij−
+
∣
∣
∣
∣λ=λij−
λ̃=λ̃ij+
}
,
(24)
P ij± (Ki,Kj ,K) = Qi + xij±Qj, (25)
xij± =−Qi ·Qj ±
√
(Qi ·Qj)2 −Q2iQ
2j
Q2j
. (26)
![Page 34: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Simplest NMHV bubbles: MHV-MHV
l11−
. . .
p+
. . .
k− l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−
. . .
n+
∑
h1,h2
A1A2 =(−1)ki[l1p]
2[l2p]2
[l11][12] . . . [k−1|k][kl2][l2l1]
×i 〈l1m〉2 〈l2m〉2
〈l2|k+1〉 〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉 〈nl1〉 〈l1l2〉
×
(
−[l1p] 〈l1m〉
[l2p] 〈l2m〉+ 2−
[l2p] 〈l2m〉
[l1p] 〈l1m〉
)
(27)
![Page 35: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Simplest NMHV bubbles: MHV-MHV
∑
h1,h2
A1A2 =(−1)k 〈m|P1k|p]
2
P 21k[12] . . . [k−1|k] 〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉
×〈l1m〉 〈l2m〉 [l1p][l2p]
〈l1n〉 〈l2|k+1〉 [l11][l2k]
≡F
P 21k
〈l1m〉 〈l2m〉 [l1p][l2p]
〈l1n〉 〈l2|k+1〉 [l11][l2k]
=F
P 21k
〈l1m〉 〈l1|P1k|p] 〈m|P1k|l1][pl1]
〈l1n〉 〈l1|P1k|k] 〈k+1|P1k|l1][1l1]
(28)
Cut(P1k) =−F
4
∫
λ̃=λ̄
〈λdλ〉 [λ̃dλ̃]
〈λ|P1k|λ̃]2〈λ|m〉 〈λ|P1k|p] 〈m|P1k|λ̃][p|λ̃]
〈λ|n〉 〈λ|P1k|k] 〈k+1|P1k|λ̃][1|λ̃].
(29)
![Page 36: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Simplest NMHV bubbles: MHV-MHV
Cbub,P1kN=1 chiral =−
F
(4π)d2 i
∑
residues
1
sln
(
1 + s〈λ|q|λ̃]
〈λ|P1k|λ̃]
)
×
{
〈λ|m〉 〈λ|P1k|p] 〈m|P1k|λ̃][p|λ̃]
〈λ|n〉 〈λ|P1k|k] 〈k+1|P1k|λ̃][1|λ̃]
×1
〈λ|P1k|q|λ〉
∣
∣
∣
∣
|λ̃]=|P1k+s q|λ〉
}∣
∣
∣
∣
s=0
(30)
Cbub,P1kN=1 chiral =
F
(4π)d2 i
∑
residues
[q|λ̃]
〈λ|P1k|λ̃]
×〈λ|m〉2 〈λ|P1k|p]
2
〈λ|k+1〉 〈λ|n〉 〈λ|P1k|1] 〈λ|P1k|k] 〈λ|P1k|q]
(31)
![Page 37: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Simplest NMHV bubbles: MHV-MHV
Cbub,P1kN=1 chiral =
(−1)k
(4π)d2 i
〈m|P1k|p]2
[12] . . . [k−1|k] 〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉
×
{
〈m|k+1〉2 〈k+1|P1k|p]2[k+1|q]
〈k+1|n〉 〈k+1|P1k|1] 〈k+1|P1k|k] 〈k+1|P1k|k+1] 〈k+1|P1k|q]
+〈mn〉2 〈n|P1k|p]
2[nq]
〈n|k+1〉 〈n|P1k|1] 〈n|P1k|k] 〈n|P1k|n] 〈n|P1k|q]
+1
P 21k
(
[1p]2
[1k][1q]
〈m|P1k|1]2 〈1|P1k|q]
〈1|P1k|1] 〈k+1|P1k|1] 〈n|P1k|1]
+[kp]2
[k1][kq]
〈m|P1k|k]2 〈k|P1k|q]
〈k|P1k|k] 〈k+1|P1k|k] 〈n|P1k|k]
+[pq]2
[1q][kq]
〈m|P1k|q]2
〈k+1|P1k|q] 〈n|P1k|q]
)}
.
(32)
![Page 38: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
N = 1 chiral bubble formula
only simple poles:
CbubN=1 chiral = −
K2
(4π)d2 i
∑
residues
[λ̃|q]
〈λ|K|λ̃] 〈λ|K|q]
[
∑
h1,h2
A1A2
∣
∣
∣
∣
|λ̃]=|K|λ〉
]
.
(33)
a close analogue found byElvang,Huang,Peng
’11 [12]
![Page 39: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Cut construction: NMHV double cut
l11+. . .
m−1
. . .m−
2
. . . k+ l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−3
. . .
n+
![Page 40: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Two-mass-easy quadruple cut
l11+. . .
m−1
. . .m−
2
. . .k+ l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−3
. . .
n+
⇒
l11+. . .m−
1
. . .m−
2
. . .k+l2
(k+1)+l3 (k+2)+. . . m−
3
. . .
(n−1)+
l4
n+
![Page 41: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
NMHV super-amplitude in N = 4 SYM
fromDrummond,Henn,Korchemsky,Sokatchev
’08 [13]
ANMHVn = AMHV
n
r+n−3∑
s=r+2
r+n−1∑
t=s+2
Rrst, (34)
R = {r + 1, . . . , s− 1}
S = {s, . . . , t− 1}
T = {t, . . . , r − 1}
R S
Tr
s
t
r+1
r−1
s−1
t−1
Rrst =−〈s−1|s〉 〈t−1|t〉
P 2S 〈s−1|PS |PT |r〉 〈s|PS |PT |r〉 〈t−1|PS |PR|r〉 〈t|PS |PR|r〉
(35)
![Page 42: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
NMHV amplitudes
GGT package byDixon,Henn,Plefka,Schuster
’10 [14]:
Atree(1+g ,+. . ., a−g ,
+. . ., b−g ,+. . ., n−
g )
=i
〈12〉 〈23〉 . . . 〈n1〉
n−3∑
s=2
n−1∑
t=s+2
RnstD4nst;ab, (36a)
Atree(1+g ,+. . ., a−A
Λ , +. . ., b+BCDΛ , +. . ., c−g ,
+. . ., n−g )
=iǫABCD
〈12〉 〈23〉 . . . 〈n1〉
n−3∑
s=2
n−1∑
t=s+2
RnstD3nst;acDnst;bc, (36b)
Atree(1+g ,+. . ., aAB
S , +. . ., bCDS , +. . ., c−g ,
+. . ., n−g )
=iǫABCD
〈12〉 〈23〉 . . . 〈n1〉
n−3∑
s=2
n−1∑
t=s+2
RnstD2nst;acD
2nst;bc, (36c)
![Page 43: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Double cut expression
l11+. . .
m−1
. . .m−
2
. . .k+ l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−3
. . .
n+
∑
h1,h2
A1A2 =i 〈−l2|m3〉
2 〈l1|m3〉2
〈−l2|k+1〉 〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉 〈n|l1〉 〈l1|−l2〉
×i
〈−l1|1〉 〈12〉 . . . 〈k−1|k〉 〈k|l2〉 〈l2|−l1〉
×m1−3∑
s=m1+2
m1−1∑
t=s+2
Rm1stD2m1st;m2(−l1)
D2m1st;m2l2
×
(
〈−l2|m3〉Dm1st;m2(−l1)
〈l1|m3〉Dm1st;m2l2
+ 2 +〈l1|m3〉Dm1st;m2l2
〈−l2|m3〉Dm1st;m2(−l1)
)
(37)
![Page 44: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Double cut expression
l11+. . .
m−1
. . .m−
2
. . .k+ l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−3
. . .
n+
∑
h1,h2
A1A2 = −1
〈12〉 . . . 〈k−1|k〉 〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉
×〈l1|m3〉 〈m3| −l2〉
〈l1|1〉 〈l1|n〉 〈l1|l2〉2 〈k|l2〉 〈k+1|l2〉
×m1−3∑
s=m1+2
m1−1∑
t=s+2
Rm1stDm1st;m2(−l1)Dm1st;m2l2
×(
〈−l2|m3〉Dm1st;m2(−l1) + 〈l1|m3〉Dm1st;m2l2
)2
(38)
![Page 45: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
The factor which defines the non-zero cases for s and t
Dm1st;m2l2
=
〈m1|l2〉 〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|Ps,t−1|m2〉 if {s, t} ∈ A
−P 2s,t−1 〈m1|m2〉 〈m1|l2〉 if {s, t} ∈ B
〈m2|l2〉(
〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|l1] 〈l1|m1〉 − 〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|P1,m1−1|m1〉)
if {s, t} ∈ C
− 〈m1|m2〉(
〈m1|l1〉 [l1|Ps,k |l2〉 − 〈m1|P1,m1−1|Ps,k|l2〉)
if {s, t} ∈ D
〈m2|l2〉 〈m1|Pt,m1−1|Pm1+1,s−1|m1〉 if {s, t} ∈ E
− 〈m1|m2〉 〈m1|Pt,m1−1|Pt,s−1|l2〉 if {s, t} ∈ F
0 otherwise,
(39)
![Page 46: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Non-zero cases for s and t
A : s ∈ {m1+2, . . . ,m2}, t ∈ {m2+1, . . . , l2} (40a)
B : s ∈ {m2+1, . . . , k−1}, t ∈ {m2+3, . . . , l2} (40b)
C : s ∈ {m1+2, . . . ,m2}, t = −l1 (40c)
D : s ∈ {m2+1, . . . , k}, t = −l1 (40d)
E : s ∈ {m1+2, . . . ,m2}, t ∈ {1, . . . ,m1−1} (40e)
F : s ∈ {m2+1, . . . , l2}, t ∈ {1, . . . ,m1−1}. (40f)
![Page 47: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Cases in s and tm1+4 . . . m2+1m2
m2
m1+2
m2+1
.
.
.
m2+2 m2+3 . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
k l2 −l1 1 m1−1
m1−3
1
−l1
l2
k
k−1
k−2
ts
A
B
C
D
E
F
![Page 48: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Results: Frame formulas for generic bubbles and
2me-boxes
Cbub,P1kN=1 chiral(m
−1 ,m
−2 ∈{1, . . . , k},m−
3 ∈ {k+1, . . . ,n})
=∑
{s,t}∈A
Rs,tA +
∑
{s,t}∈B
Rs,tB +
∑
{s,t=−l1}∈C
RsC
+∑
{s,t=−l1}∈D
RsD +
∑
{s,t}∈E
Rs,tE +
∑
{s,t}∈F
Rs,tF
(41)
Cbox,2meN=1 chiral(m
−1 ,m
−2 ∈{1, . . . , k},m−
3 ∈ {k+1, . . . , n})
=∑
{s,t}∈A
Cbox,s,tA +
∑
{s,t}∈B
Cbox,s,tB +
∑
{s,t=−l1}∈C
Cbox,sC
+∑
{s,t=−l1}∈D
Cbox,sD +
∑
{s,t}∈E
Cbox,s,tE +
∑
{s,t}∈F
Cbox,s,tF
(42)
![Page 49: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Example: simpler bubbles
only case F contributes to:
l11+
. . .
(k−2)+
(k−1)−
k− l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−
. . .
n+
![Page 50: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Simpler bubble coefficients
l11+
. . .(k−2)+(k−1)−
k− l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−
. . .
n+
Cbub,P1kN=1 chiral
=P 21k
(4π)d2 i
∑
residues
[q|λ̃]
〈λ|P1k|λ̃]
{
F1〈λ|m〉2 〈λ|P1k|P1,k−1|k−1〉
〈λ|k+1〉 〈λ|n〉 〈λ|P1k|k] 〈λ|P1k|q]
+k−2∑
t=2
Ft 〈t−1|t〉
〈t−1|Pt,k|k]
〈λ|m〉2 〈λ|Pt,k|Pt,k−1|k−1〉
〈λ|1〉 〈λ|k+1〉 〈λ|n〉 〈λ|P1k|q]
}
,
(43)
Ft =〈m|Pt,k|Pt,k−1|k−1〉2
P 2t,k−1P
2t,k 〈t|Pt,k|k]
(44)
![Page 51: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Results: simpler bubble coefficients
Cbub,P1kN=1 chiral =
1
(4π)d2 i
1
〈12〉 . . . 〈k−2|k−1〉 〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉
×
{ k−2∑
t=2
⟨
m|Pt,k|Pt,k−1|k−1⟩2
〈t−1|t〉
P 2t,kP
2t,k−1 〈t−1|Pt,k|k] 〈t|Pt,k|k]
(
〈m|P1k |k+1|m〉⟨
k+1|Pt,k|Pt,k−1|k−1⟩
〈k+1|1〉 〈k+1|n〉 〈k+1|P1k|k+1]
+〈m|P1k|1|m〉
⟨
1|Pt,k|Pt,k−1|k−1⟩
〈1n〉 〈1|k+1〉 〈1|P1k|1]+
〈m|P1k|n|m〉⟨
n|Pt,k|Pt,k−1|k−1⟩
〈n1〉 〈n|k+1〉 〈n|P1k|n]
)
+
⟨
m|P1k|P1,k−1|k−1⟩2
P 21kP
21,k−1 〈1|P1k|k]
(
〈m|P1k|k+1|m〉⟨
k+1|P1k|P1,k−1|k−1⟩
〈k+1|n〉 〈k+1|P1k|k] 〈k+1|P1k|k+1]
+〈m|P1k|n|m〉
⟨
n|P1k|P1,k−1|k−1⟩
〈n|k+1〉 〈n|P1k|k] 〈n|P1k |n]+
P 21k 〈m|P1k|k|m〉 〈k−1|P1k|k]
〈n|P1k |k] 〈k+1|P1k|k] 〈k|P1k|k]
)}
(45)
![Page 52: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Massive poles
l1· · · 1+m−1
. . .(i−1)+
i+. . .m−
2· · · k+ l2 (k+1)+
. . .
m−3
. . .
n+
(l1 − P1,i)2 = P 2
1k
〈λ|Qi|λ̃]
〈λ|P1k|λ̃](46)
〈λ|Qi|P1k|λ〉 = −
⟨
λ|λi+
⟩
[λ̃i+|λ̃
i−]⟨
λi−|λ⟩
xi+ − xi−(47)
Resλ=λi
±
F (λ, λ̃)
〈λ|P1k|λ̃] 〈λ|Qi|P1k|λ〉= −
F (λi±, λ̃
i±)
4(
(P1,i−1 · Pi,k)2 − P 21,i−1P
2i,k
)
(48)
![Page 53: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Results: sample contribution
for s ∈ {m1+3, . . . , m2}, t = −l1
RsC
=−P21k
(4π)d2 i
〈s−1|s〉
〈12〉 . . . 〈k−1|k〉〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉
{
F sC(λ1, λ̃1)
〈1|k〉〈1|k+1〉〈1|n〉+
F sC(λk, λ̃k)
〈k|1〉〈k|k+1〉〈k|n〉
+F sC(λk+1, λ̃k+1)
〈k+1|1〉〈k+1|k〉〈k+1|n〉+
F sC(λn, λ̃n)
〈n|1〉〈n|k〉〈n|k+1〉+
〈m1|P1k|q]2 〈m2|P1k|q]2 〈m3|P1k|q]2
P41k
〈1|P1k|q] 〈k|P1k|q] 〈k+1|P1k|q] 〈n|P1k|q]
×〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|q]
2
[q|P1,s−1|Ps,k|q] 〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|P1,s−1|P1k|q] 〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|Ps,k|P1k|q]
×(
P21k 〈m3|m1〉 〈m2|P1k|q] 〈m1|Pm1,s−1|q] + 〈m1|m2〉 〈m3|P1k|q] 〈m1|Pm1,s−1|Ps,k|P1k|q]
)2
/(
(
〈m1|s−1〉 [q|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|q] + 〈m1|P1k|q] 〈s−1|Pm1+1,s−2|q]
)
×(
〈m1|s〉 [q|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|q] + 〈m1|P1k|q] 〈s|Pm1+1,s−1|q]
)
)
+MsC(λ
+s , λ̃
+s ) + M
sC(λ
−
s , λ̃−
s )
}
,
FsC(λ, λ̃) =
〈λ|m1〉2 〈λ|m2〉
2 〈λ|m3〉2⟨
λ|P1k|Pm1+1,s−1|m1
⟩2[λ̃|q]
⟨
λ|P1,s−1|Ps,k|λ⟩
⟨
λ|P1,s−1|Pm1+1,s−1|m1
⟩ ⟨
λ|Ps,k|Pm1+1,s−1|m1
⟩
〈λ|P1k|λ̃] 〈λ|P1k|q]
×(
〈λ|m2〉 〈m3|m1〉⟨
m1|Pm1+1,s−1|P1k|λ⟩
+ 〈λ|m3〉 〈m1|m2〉⟨
m1|Pm1+1,s−1|Ps,k|λ⟩
)2
/(
(
〈m1|s−1〉⟨
λ|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|λ
⟩
+ 〈λ|m1〉⟨
λ|P1k|Pm1+1,s−2|s−1⟩
)
(
〈m1|s〉⟨
λ|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|λ
⟩
+ 〈λ|m1〉⟨
λ|P1k|Pm1+1,s−1|s⟩
)
)
![Page 54: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Results: sample contribution
for s ∈ {m1+3, . . . , m2}, t = −l1
RsC
=−P21k
(4π)d2 i
〈s−1|s〉
〈12〉 . . . 〈k−1|k〉〈k+1|k+2〉 . . . 〈n−1|n〉
{
F sC(λ1, λ̃1)
〈1|k〉〈1|k+1〉〈1|n〉+
F sC(λk, λ̃k)
〈k|1〉〈k|k+1〉〈k|n〉
+F sC(λk+1, λ̃k+1)
〈k+1|1〉〈k+1|k〉〈k+1|n〉+
F sC(λn, λ̃n)
〈n|1〉〈n|k〉〈n|k+1〉+
〈m1|P1k|q]2 〈m2|P1k|q]2 〈m3|P1k|q]2
P41k
〈1|P1k|q] 〈k|P1k|q] 〈k+1|P1k|q] 〈n|P1k|q]
×〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|q]
2
[q|P1,s−1|Ps,k|q] 〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|P1,s−1|P1k|q] 〈m1|Pm1+1,s−1|Ps,k|P1k|q]
×(
P21k 〈m3|m1〉 〈m2|P1k|q] 〈m1|Pm1,s−1|q] + 〈m1|m2〉 〈m3|P1k|q] 〈m1|Pm1,s−1|Ps,k|P1k|q]
)2
/(
(
〈m1|s−1〉 [q|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|q] + 〈m1|P1k|q] 〈s−1|Pm1+1,s−2|q]
)
×(
〈m1|s〉 [q|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|q] + 〈m1|P1k|q] 〈s|Pm1+1,s−1|q]
)
)
+MsC(λ
+s , λ̃
+s ) + M
sC(λ
−
s , λ̃−
s )
}
,
MsC(λ, λ̃) = −
1
4((P1,s−1 · Ps,k)2 − P2
1,s−1P2s,k
))
×〈λ|m1〉
2 〈λ|m2〉2 〈λ|m3〉
2⟨
λ|P1k|Pm1+1,s−1,m1
⟩2[λ̃|q]
〈λ|1〉 〈λ|k〉 〈λ|k+1〉 〈λ|n〉⟨
λ|P1,s−1|Pm1+1,s−1|m1
⟩ ⟨
λ|Ps,k|Pm1+1,s−1|m1
⟩
〈λ|P1k|q]
×(
〈λ|m2〉 〈m3|m1〉⟨
m1|Pm1+1,s−1|P1k|λ⟩
+ 〈λ|m3〉 〈m1|m2〉⟨
m1|Pm1+1,s−1|Ps,k|λ⟩
)2
/(
(
〈m1|s−1〉⟨
λ|P1,m1|Pm1+1,k|λ
⟩
+ 〈λ|m1〉⟨
λ|P1k|Pm1+1,s−2|s−1⟩
)
(
⟨ ⟩ ⟨ ⟩
)
)
![Page 55: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Checks
1. Check the sum of all bubbles through for 6,7 and 8 points:
∑
Cbub =1
(4π)d2
Atree
2. NGluon byBadger,Biedermann,Uwer
’10 [15]
Numerical data kindly produced by Simon Badger:gluon, fermion and scalar loop contributions for 6-25 ext. gluonsA(1−, 2−, 3+, 4−, 5+, 6+, . . . , n+) andA(1−, 2+, 3−, 4+, 5+, 6−, . . . , n+).Agreement up to 13 digits for 8 points and 12 digits for 17points.
![Page 56: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Conclusions
1. New one-loop amplitudes are known analytically for all n.
2. Good tree formulas ⇒ new loop results.
3. NMHV in N = 1 SYM: untrivial both in helicities and susy.
4. Mathematica files are distributed:N1chiralAll.nb, Ammppmppp.nb.
5. Everybody is invited to play!
![Page 57: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Outlook: one-loop recursion
+ −
7+
l1
1−
2−3+l2 4̂−
5̂+
6+P̂5,6
=
7+
l1
1−
2−3+l2
4−
5+
6+
![Page 58: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Thank you for listening!
![Page 59: All one-loop NMHV gluon amplitudes in N = 1 SYMaochirov/talks/CERN2013.pdf · MHV NMHV N = 4 SYM n-point by Bern,Dixon, Dunbar, Kosower ’94 [1] n-point by Bern, Dixon, Kosower ’04](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060221/5f0748a47e708231d41c38a5/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
References
Z. Bern, L. J. Dixon, D. C. Dunbar, and D. A. Kosower Nucl. Phys. B425 (1994) 217–260.
Z. Bern, L. J. Dixon, and D. A. Kosower Phys.Rev. D72 (2005) 045014.
Z. Bern, L. J. Dixon, D. C. Dunbar, and D. A. Kosower Nucl.Phys. B435 (1995) 59–101.
R. Britto, E. Buchbinder, F. Cachazo, and B. Feng Phys.Rev. D72 (2005) 065012.
N. Bjerrum-Bohr, D. C. Dunbar, and W. B. Perkins JHEP 0804 (2008) 038.
D. C. Dunbar, W. B. Perkins, and E. Warrick JHEP 0906 (2009) 056.
J. Bedford, A. Brandhuber, B. J. Spence, and G. Travaglini Nucl.Phys. B712 (2005) 59–85.
R. Britto, B. Feng, and P. Mastrolia Phys. Rev. D73 (2006) 105004.
C. F. Berger, Z. Bern, L. J. Dixon, D. Forde, and D. A. Kosower Phys.Rev. D75 (2007) 016006.
Z. Xiao, G. Yang, and C.-J. Zhu Nucl.Phys. B758 (2006) 53–89.
P. Mastrolia Phys. Lett. B678 (2009) 246–249.
H. Elvang, Y.-t. Huang, and C. Peng JHEP 1109 (2011) 031.
J. Drummond, J. Henn, G. Korchemsky, and E. Sokatchev Nucl.Phys. B869 (2013) 452–492.
L. J. Dixon, J. M. Henn, J. Plefka, and T. Schuster JHEP 1101 (2011) 035.
S. Badger, B. Biedermann, and P. Uwer Comput.Phys.Commun. 182 (2011) 1674–1692.