achieving high performance in an era of climate change - accenture … · 2010-09-09 · accenture...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change
![Page 2: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
�
Contents
Foreword........................................................................................... .1
Executive.Summary....................................................................... .�
Introduction..................................................................................... .4
1..How.climate.change.is.transforming.the.business.landscape.......................................................................................... .6
�..Current.business.responses.to.climate.change.................11
3..Constraints.on.action............................................................... 16
4..Regulatory.actions.favored.by.today’s..business.executives....................................................................... �1
5..Conclusion:..Meeting.the.business.challenges.of.climate.change...........30
Appendix—Country.Stories..........................................................34
Statistical.Appendix...................................................................... 41
References....................................................................................... 45
![Page 3: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
1
Foreword
News.coverage.about.climate.change.seems.to.increase.almost.daily.as.scientists,.governments,.consumers,.journalists.and.the.general.public.share.views.on.the.issue.and.its.potential.implications.
As.one.of.the.world’s.leading.management.consulting,.technology.and.outsourcing.companies,.Accenture.has.been.tracking.the.complex.scientific.and.political.discussions.surrounding.climate.change.and.various.proposals.for.responding.to.the.threat..We.also.have.the.ongoing.opportunity.to.exchange.views.and.ideas.about.climate.change.with.our.clients.and.other.business,.government.and.industry.leaders..What.comes.across.most.in.these.discussions.is.a.high.level.of.uncertainty—about.the.specific.ways.in.which.climate.change.will.affect.nations.and.businesses,.about.the.impact.of.regulation.and.global.cooperation,.and.also.about.the.opportunities.that.climate.change.presents.to.forward-thinking.businesses.that.want.to.get.out.in.front.of.the.
Mark.Foster.Group.Chief.Executive.Management.Consulting.&.Integrated.Markets.Accenture
issue..Despite.this.uncertainty,.and.regardless.of.individual.views.on.the.science.behind.climate.change,.one.thing.is.clear:.the.global.business.environment.is.in.the.midst.of.dramatic.change.caused,.in.part,.by.shifting.consumer.behavior,.media.scrutiny.and.new.public.policies—all.in.light.of.heightened.global.awareness.of.climate.change..Businesses.that.expect.to.achieve.and.sustain.high.performance.must.accelerate.their.responses.to.these.shifting.attitudes.and.behaviors..The.early.movers.here.hold.an.incalculable.advantage.
The.need.for.rapid.action.is.even.more.pressing.in.a.world.where.the.character.of.globalization.has.also.changed..In.what.Accenture.calls.the.“multi-polar.world,”.economic.power.is.becoming.more.dispersed.among.both.developed.and.emerging.nations..That,.in.turn,.means.that.awareness.and.cooperation.among.nations.are.also.increasing..As.in.the.classic.example.of.the.“butterfly.effect”.from.chaos.theory—how.a.butterfly.beating.its.wings.in.Beijing.can.eventually.affect.weather.patterns.in.North.America—every.action.taken.by.a.business.anywhere.is.likely.to.be.felt.everywhere..
At.a.time.of.intense.media.coverage.on.climate.change,.hard.facts.and.statistics.are.increasingly.vital..For.that.reason,.Accenture.has.conducted.a.wide-ranging.research.study.based.on.surveys.of.more.than.500.business.executives.around.the.world.in.both.developed.and.emerging.markets..What.is.the.prevailing.attitude.among.leading.executives.about.climate.change?.What.kinds.of.responses.are.under.way.or.being.considered?.In.what.ways.are.some.companies.gaining.competitive.advantage.over.their.rivals.through.unique.actions.and.strategies?.These.are.some.of.the.questions.we.have.sought.to.answer..
This.report.provides.businesses.with.a.view.of.some.specific.actions.to.consider.in.order.to.achieve.high.performance.in.this.changing.political,.economic.and.business.environment..Our.research.and.
experience.suggest.that.many.kinds.of.responses.are.possible:.looking.afresh.at.supply.chain.strategies;.considering.the.role.that.new.technologies.can.play;.capitalizing.on.opportunities.in.adjacent.markets.for.“green”.goods.and.services;.and.inculcating.a.broader.sense.of.sustainable.business.among.employees.through.performance.rewards.and.metrics..This.report.should.also.provide.essential.reading.for.policymakers.wanting.to.understand.the.impacts.of.climate.change.on.businesses,.as.well.as.how.leading.companies.perceive.the.challenges.of.climate.change.and.the.associated.regulation.that.will.continue.to.develop.
Those.who.follow.the.ongoing.discussions.about.climate.change.know.that.no.one.has.all.the.answers..However,.it.is.vital.to.understand.the.central.questions,.as.well.as.to.encourage.discussion.about.potential.solutions..The.most.compelling.conclusion.arising.from.our.research.is.that.businesses.have.to.be.more.proactive..Time.is.of.the.essence..Attitudes.are.changing.at.a.startling.pace,.and.businesses.need.to.keep.up—or,.better,.get.out.ahead.
Mark.Foster.Group.Chief.Executive..Management.Consulting..&.Integrated.Markets..Accenture
![Page 4: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
�
Business attitudes toward climate change•.Business.executives.around.the.globe.increasingly.see.climate.change.as.a.major.issue.they.must.address.if.they.are.to.achieve.and.sustain.high.performance.into.the.future..
•.Forty-five.percent.of.all.respondents.said.that.climate.change.was.currently.a.major.issue.for.their.business..
•.A.much.higher.proportion—59.percent—believe.that.climate.change.will.be.a.major.issue.for.them.within.five.years.
•.At.the.same.time,.climate.change.is.not.high.on.the.list.of.strategic.priorities.for.many.companies..Only.5.percent.of.survey.respondents.named.climate.change.as.their.top.strategic.priority..In.no.region.of.the.world.did.that.number.rise.above.8.percent..Just.11.percent.of.businesses.stated.that.climate.change.figures.as.their.second.or.third.strategic.priority.
Direct and indirect impacts•.It.is.vital.that.businesses.develop.a.more.nuanced.understanding.of.the.impacts.that.climate.change.is.having.on.their.industries..The.direct.environmental.impact.of.climate.change.on.a.business.is.only.one.piece.of.the.puzzle..Other.critical.pieces.involve.indirect.
impacts:.the.attitudes.and.behaviors.of.a.range.of.stakeholders.that.includes.government,.consumers,.shareholders,.employees,.suppliers.and.the.media.
Current business responses to climate change •.While.businesses.may.feel.a.responsibility.to.respond.to.climate.change,.they.do.not.feel.well.positioned.to.do.so..About.two-thirds.of.all.respondents.stated.that.they.feel.a.responsibility.to.help.manage.the.impact.of.climate.change,.but.only.4�.percent.said.they.actually.feel.well.positioned.to.do.so..
•.Consequently,.business.responses.to.climate.change.tend.to.be.fragmented.across.a.range.of.piecemeal.activities..More.than.four-fifths.of.businesses.surveyed.are.currently.undertaking.initiatives.relating.to.climate.change,.yet.more.than.half.of.those.businesses.have.only.one.or.two.initiatives.in.place..
•.The.most.frequently.mentioned.activities.relate.to.reducing.or.managing.carbon-related.activities:.deploying.technologies.to.improve.energy.efficiency.(named.by.53.percent.of.respondents),.measuring.carbon.footprints.(39.percent).or.increasing.the.use.of.renewable.energy.(3�.percent)..More.comprehensive.and.holistic.practices.
such.as.reconfiguring.supply.chains.are.less.common.at.present,.with.only.17.percent.of.businesses.undertaking.such.initiatives..
•.Nearly.one-fifth.(19.percent).of.companies.are.doing.nothing.in.response.to.climate.change,.reflecting.in.part.an.under-appreciation.of.the.business.opportunities.presented.to.companies.by.climate.change..For.example,.67.percent.of.the.executives.surveyed.see.climate.change.as.a.necessary.cost,.compared.with.just.39.percent.who.see.it.bringing.new.business.opportunities..
Constraints on action•.More.than.half.of.the.businesses.(53.percent).surveyed.are.struggling.to.understand.the.implications.of.climate.change..However,.there.are.significant.variations.across.markets..For.example,.only.�8.percent.of.German.businesses.are.struggling.to.understand.the.implications..
•.Competing.strategic.priorities.mean.that.climate.change.may.receive.less.attention.than.other.business.imperatives..Climate.change.ranked.as.only.the.eighth.strategic.priority.for.businesses,.named.by.only.16.percent.of.respondents—lagging.behind.sales.growth.(47.percent),.cost.reduction.(46.percent),.developing.new.products.and.services.(45.percent),.the.war.for.talent.(39.percent),.growth.in.emerging.markets.(�9.percent),.innovation.(�8.percent).and.technology.(18.percent)..
•.Internal.challenges.also.exist.when.it.comes.to.implementing.climate-change-related.initiatives.within.a.business..The.three.most.commonly.cited.internal.challenges.were.introducing.new.technologies.(�5.percent),.changing.internal.behavior.(�4.percent).and.coping.with.new.regulations.(�0.percent)..
•.Uncertainty.around.the.shape.and.future.direction.of.climate.change.legislation.means.that.many.businesses.do.not.feel.in.a.position.to.place.significant.strategic.bets.on.climate-change-related.initiatives..
Executive SummaryDemands are increasing on businesses to do their part to respond to the threat of climate change based on their influential position within the global community. But what, exactly, are the impacts of climate change on businesses? What are some specific steps businesses can take to respond to both the threats and opportunities presented by climate change? To support a fact-based discussion of the business impact of climate change, Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United Kingdom and the United States. The resulting analysis examines both the impact of climate change on global businesses and the responses that leading companies are taking to achieve and sustain high performance in the face of profound global change.
![Page 5: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
3
Regulatory actions favored by businesses•.Government.was.the.most.commonly.mentioned.stakeholder.in.terms.of.its.influence.on.a.business’s.response.to.climate.change,.named.by.65.percent.of.respondents,.followed.by.consumers.(41.percent).and.shareholders.(36.percent)..
•.Sixty-three.percent.of.businesses.see.a.balance.between.market-driven.and.government-driven.responses.to.climate.change.as.being.most.effective..Where.regulation.is.introduced,.businesses.would.also.prefer.to.see.a.collaborative.approach:.46.percent.favor.co-regulation,.such.as.codes.of.practice.backed.by.government.but.enforced.by.industry..
•.Businesses.expect.a.combination.of.incentives.and.enforcement.policies.in.response.to.climate.change..Low-carbon/renewables.incentives.(named.by.74.percent.of.respondents).and.targets.to.reduce.carbon.emissions.(65.percent).were.seen.as.the.most.likely.regulatory.measures..Taxes.on.energy.use.are.also.expected,.with.54.percent.of.businesses.citing.them.as.likely..
•.Businesses.are.looking.for.regulatory.flexibility.that.reflects.the.different.business.environments.of.different.industries,.but.they.are.also.looking.for.a.degree.of.geographic.harmonization..In.particular,.the.communications.and.high-tech.sector.and.financial.services.companies.favor.flexibility.between.industries.as.they.might.not.wish.to.be.saddled.with.the.more.stringent.measures.to.which.more.energy-intensive.users.might.be.subjected..
•.Despite.the.importance.of.governments.in.setting.the.climate-change.agenda,.most.businesses.are.inadequately.involved.in.shaping.the.regulatory.agenda..Only.36.percent.of.companies.surveyed.had.taken.steps.to.shape.regulatory.policies.relating.to.climate.change..However,.that.number.rises.to.49.percent.for.very.large.companies.and.to.54.percent.in.the.natural.resources.industries,.where.climate.change.is.more.front-of-mind.and.closely.regulated..
How businesses can meet the challenge•.There.are.a.number.of.steps.that.businesses.should.take.if.they.are.to.position.themselves.to.achieve.high.performance.in.a.carbon-constrained.world..These.actions.fall.within.the.scope.of.the.three.critical.areas.that.Accenture.has.identified.as.the.building.blocks.of.high.performance:.market.focus.and.position;.distinctive.capabilities;.and.performance.anatomy..These.building.blocks.are.part.of.Accenture’s.research.into.High.Performance.Business,.which.is.based.on.an.extensive.analysis.of.6,000.companies.around.the.world.
Market focus and position—Business strategy decisions regarding where and when to compete•.Conduct.a.stakeholder.analysis:.Businesses.need.to.understand.the.key.sources.of.influence.shaping.the.climate.change.agenda,.such.as.government.and.consumers,.and.engage.them.accordingly..
•.Develop.“green”.products.and.services:.Businesses.should.assess.how.existing.and.new.products.can.meet.the.demands.of.increasingly.environmentally.conscious.consumers.and.also.satisfy.related.regulation.in.this.area..
•.Enhance.brand:.Businesses.should.consider.how.they.can.use.robust.environmental.credentials.to.reposition.their.brand.and.differentiate.themselves.from.their.competitors..
Distinctive capabilities—Hard-to-replicate capabilities that define how businesses compete•.Track.external.developments:.Businesses.need.to.ensure.they.are.able.to.monitor.closely.developments.in.the.political,.economic,.social.and.technological.arenas.and.take.action.accordingly.
•.Optimize.supply.chains:.Businesses.should.explore.the.extent.to.which.the.reworking.of.their.supply.chain.can.be.an.important.source.of.cost.savings.as.well.as.reducing.their.impact.on.the.environment.
•.Use.smart.technologies:.Businesses.should.seek.to.deploy.“green”.technologies.(e.g.,.green.data.centers,.which.use.less.energy).as.a.source.of.cost.reduction.as.well.as.competitive.advantage,.both.through.enhanced.reputation.and.more.efficient.delivery.of.services..
Performance anatomy—Common mindsets relating to culture, leadership and the workforce•.Ensure.senior.support:.Businesses.must.ensure.that.the.environmental.agenda.is.owned.at.a.senior.level.and.underpinned.by.regular.communication.on.progress.
•.Drive.human.performance:.Businesses.should.seek.to.refine.performance-management.regimes.so.that.they.reward.activities.that.support.the.organization’s.environmental.agenda..
•.Create.a.culture.of.carbon-consciousness:.Businesses.need.to.engender.the.right.set.of.cultural.mindsets.within.the.organization,.which.can.underpin.and.strengthen.new.processes.and.activities.
![Page 6: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Introduction
4
![Page 7: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
5
22%
51%
27%
US$50-100m
US$100m-US$1bn
US$1bn+
47%
8%
24%
6%10% 5%
Other
Financial Services
C&I
C&HT
Resources
Government
To.develop.a.richer.understanding.of.the.new.context.for.business.engendered.by.climate.change,.and.to.identify.some.of.the.new.paths.to.high.performance.being.forged.by.representative.industry.leaders,.Accenture.commissioned.Opinion.Leader.Research.to.conduct.an.anonymous.survey.of.the.attitudes.of.business.leaders.to.climate.change..Telephone.interviews,.administered.via.an.in-depth.questionnaire,.were.conducted.with.C-level.executives.from.504.companies,.with.fieldwork.completed.in.�007..All.respondents.had.influence.on.(and.had.some.responsibility.for.implementing).the.corporate.strategy.of.their.organizations.
The.companies.interviewed.were.located.in.six.countries—China,.Germany,.India,.Japan,.the.United.Kingdom.and.the.United.States—and.each.had.annual.revenues.of.at.least.US$50.million.(see.Figure.1)..The.survey.sample.included.both.local.and.global.companies,.varying.from.small.(fewer.than.�00.employees).to.major.(more.than.10,000.employees)..Respondents.were.distributed.across.a.broad.spectrum.of.industries.(see.Figure.�),.broken.down.into.five.broad.industry.sectors:.
•.Communications.and.high-tech.(C&HT):.Electronics.and.high-tech;.communications;.media.and.entertainment..
•.Consumer.and.industrial.(C&I):.Consumer.goods.(manufacturing.and.retail);.pharmaceuticals.and.medical.products;.health.services;.industrial.equipment;.automotive;.freight.and.logistics;.transportation.and.travel.services..
•.Financial.services:.Banking;.insurance;.capital.markets..
•.Government:.Defense;.education;.postal.services;.revenue;.public.services.
Figure 2: Industry breakdown of survey respondents1
Figure 1: Company size of survey respondents (by revenue)
•.Resources:.Chemicals;.energy;.forest.products;.metals.and.mining;.utilities..
Drawing.on.the.primary.data.collected.in.this.survey,.and.supported.by.extensive.secondary.research,.this.report.covers.five.primary.sections:.
•.Chapter.1.discusses.the.new.business.context.created.by.climate.change,.looking.in.particular.at.the.role.of.different.stakeholders.in.shaping.the.agenda..
•.Chapter.�.explores.how.businesses.are.responding.to.climate.change..
•.Chapter.3.looks.at.the.key.constraints.on.future.actions.by.businesses.in.response.to.climate.change.
•.Chapter.4.focuses.on.government.regulation.as.a.key.driver.and.presents.findings.on.what.businesses.want.to.see.out.of.the.regulatory.environment.with.regard.to.climate.change.
•.Chapter.5.makes.a.number.of.recommendations.about.how.businesses.can.meet.the.challenge.of.climate.change.and.position.themselves.to.achieve.high.performance..
Additionally,.we.provide.six.snapshots.of.business.attitudes.and.responses.in.the.countries.that.are.the.focus.of.this.study..An.appendix.to.the.main.study.provides.some.detailed.statistical.data.and.findings.from.our.survey.
![Page 8: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
How climate change is transforming the business landscape
1
6
![Page 9: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
7
Sustained.business.success.over.economic.cycles.and.across.changes.in.executive.leadership—something.Accenture.calls.“high.performance”—is.no.accident..Our.High.Performance.Business.research.initiative.has.shown.that.high-performance.businesses.differentiate.themselves.through.three.essential.building.blocks..First,.they.have.remarkable.clarity.when.it.comes.to.their.market.focus.and.position—the.“where.and.when.to.compete”.aspects.of.business.strategy..Second,.high.performers.are.also.committed.to.creating.and.evolving.a.set.of.distinctive,.hard-to-replicate.capabilities.that.satisfy.multiple.stakeholders.(especially.customers).while.supporting.the.most.effective.utilization.of.assets..Third,.achieving.high.performance.depends.on.a.company’s.culture.or.what.we.refer.to.as.its.“performance.anatomy”—the.mindsets.that.result.in.effective.leadership.and.in.the.optimal.impact.of.talent.on.business.performance.
However,.a.company’s.ability.to.put.in.place.these.building.blocks.and.achieve.high.performance.is.being.challenged.dramatically.by.global.conditions.over.which.no.single.company.has.control..Climate.change—a.rise.in.global.temperatures.caused.at.least.in.part.by.human.activity—is.having.profound.impacts.on.shareholder.value..
A significant number of executives see climate change as a major issueOur.research.findings.suggest.that.business.executives.increasingly.see.climate.change.as.a.major.issue.they.must.face.if.they.are.to.sustain.high.performance.into.the.future..As.shown.in.Figure.3,.45.percent.of.all.respondents.said.that.climate.change.was.currently.a.major.issue.for.their.business..A.much.higher.proportion—59.percent—believe.that.climate.change.will.become.a.major.issue.for.them.within.five.years..These.numbers.reflect.the.fact.that.a.majority.of.business.leaders.recognize.that.climate-change-related.activity—especially.legislation—is.going.to.increase.significantly,.forcing.the.issue.on.to.the.corporate.radar.
Significant.differences.among.global.regions.are.evident..Businesses.in.the.United.Kingdom.are.the.most.likely.to.see.climate.change.as.a.major.issue.now..This.may.reflect.the.high.degree.of.media.attention.focused.on.the.issue.of.climate.change.since.the.�006.publication.of.government.advisor.Nicholas.Stern’s.report.on.the.economics.of.climate.change.�.German.businesses.appear.to.attach.less.priority.to.dealing.with.climate.change.than.do.their.counterparts.in.the.United.Kingdom.or.India..However,.Germany.has.a.longer.tradition.of.focusing.on.environmental.issues,.so.this.finding.might.mean.simply.that.German.businesspeople.no.longer.perceive.climate.change.as.a.new.issue.
We.also.saw.striking.differences.among.the.emerging.economies..For.example,.an.awareness.of.the.business.impacts.of.climate.change.appears.higher.among.Indian.businesses.than.among.companies.in.China..Yet.other.trends.and.research.findings.point.to.the.complexity.of.assessing.the.level.of.climate-change.awareness.among.businesses..For.example,.recent.Chinese.investments.in.green.technology.suggest.that.at.least.some.companies.in.this.rapidly.developing.nation.are.taking.forward-looking.positions.3.
Just as climate change may transform parts of our planet, so it is transforming the business landscape—the context and presumptions by which businesses typically operate today. This transformation is a result of both the direct impacts of climate change on business operations, as well as its indirect effects—experienced as the changing attitudes, preferences and behaviors of a varied set of stakeholders who are critical to achieving and sustaining high performance. Many business leaders feel a profound responsibility to do their part to respond to the pressing global challenge represented by climate change. But apart from this sense of societal obligation, business leaders must also be attuned to how climate change is altering the dynamics of markets, competition and profitability.
Figure 3: Climate change is a major issue for my business (% by market)
Germany
US
Japan
India
UK
All
0 25 50 75 100
China
Within five yearsNow
![Page 10: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
8
Furthermore,.additional.research.conducted.by.Accenture.into.end-consumer.perceptions.of.climate.change.points.to.a.disconnect.between.consumers.and.businesses..Our.findings.showed.that.97.percent.of.consumers.in.China.are.concerned.about.climate.change,.compared.with.a.global.average.of.85.percent.4.Inevitably,.those.consumer.attitudes.will.be.reflected.back.into.corporate.attitudes..
Executives forecast climate change to be increasingly important over time
Across.most.of.the.industries.and.regions.surveyed—with.China.being.a.significant.exception—more.businesses.believe.that.climate.change.will.be.a.major.issue.in.five.years.than.it.is.today..Eighty.percent.of.UK.businesses.believe.this.to.be.the.case,.followed.by.India.with.70.percent.and.the.United.States.with.6�.percent..Only.�0.percent.of.Chinese.companies.agreed..The.biggest.increase.in.perceived.significance.of.climate.change.from.the.present.to.five.years.out.is.in.the.United.States.(39.percent.currently.and.6�.percent.in.five.years)..This.may.reflect.the.extent.to.which.legislation,.particularly.driven.by.states.like.California,.is.beginning.to.force.an.
awareness.of.climate.change.higher.up.on.the.US.corporate.agenda..
Perceptions differ among various industriesJust.as.differences.exist.among.regions.and.markets,.they.are.also.evident.across.industries.(see.Figure.4)..Only.30.percent.of.executives.working.in.communications.and.high-tech.(C&HT).sectors,.for.example,.said.that.climate.change.is.currently.a.major.issue.for.their.businesses..Looking.ahead.five.years,.the.figure.does.not.increase.significantly..This.finding.may.reflect.the.fact.that.companies.in.the.C&HT.sector.are.less.directly.dependent.on.natural.resources..Accenture.believes,.however,.that.industries.such.as.C&HT.may.under-appreciate.the.technological.opportunities.that.could.be.derived.from.climate-change-related.activities..For.example,.many.consumers.see.telecommuting.as.an.opportunity.to.reduce.reliance.on.non-renewable.resources,.so.C&HT.companies.have.considerable.potential.to.leverage.associated.technologies.such.as.teleconferencing.to.their.advantage.
In.the.resources.industries.(i.e.,.utilities,.energy.and.extractive),.where.environmental.impact.is.more.a.part.of.everyone’s.consciousness,.
more.than.half.(5�.percent).of.the.executives.surveyed.cited.climate.change.as.a.major.issue.for.their.businesses..That.number.grows.to.67.percent.when.looking.ahead.five.years..Financial.services.executives.also.demonstrated.a.relatively.high.awareness.of.climate.change.as.a.major.issue.for.them..This.finding.may.reflect.an.awareness.among.these.executives.of.the.future.financial.risks.and.opportunities.for.sectors.such.as.the.insurance.industry.stemming.from.more.severe.weather.conditions.
Direct and indirect impactsAccenture.believes.that.many.of.the.differences.reflected.in.the.survey.numbers—varying.levels.of.appreciation.of.the.effects.of.climate.change.on.business.operations—are.rooted.in.the.difference.between.direct.and.indirect.impacts.of.climate.change..
In.terms.of.direct.impacts,.a.rise.in.average.global.temperatures.can.lead.to.clear.cause-and-effect.relationships.in.many.industries—agriculture,.food.products,.tourism.and.many.others..Some.of.these.effects.are.potentially.threatening.to.sustainable.high.performance:.changing.climatic.conditions,.for.example,.may.directly.influence.patterns.of.future.costs.and.benefits..Yet.these.effects.may.also.drive.new.forms.of.innovation—for.example,.drought-resistant.crops.in.agriculture.and.food.processing,.or.new.financial.products.in.the.insurance.industry.to.mitigate.environmental.risk.
Many.industries.will.feel.less.of.a.direct.impact.from.climate.change..But.none.will.be.immune.from.its.indirect.impacts..Indeed,.Accenture.believes.that.it.is.the.indirect.impacts.of.climate.change.that.will.have.the.greatest.influence.over.future.business.strategy..The.following.are.the.most.significant.stakeholders.whose.actions.in.light.of.climate.change.are.likely.to.have.most.influence.on.the.business.community.(see.Figure.5).
Figure 4: Climate change is a major issue for my business (% by industry)
C&HT
C&I
FinancialServices
Resources
Within five yearsNow
0 25 50 75 100
![Page 11: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
9
Figure 5: Stakeholders viewed as most influential on a company’s response to climate change (%)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Government
Consumers
Shareholders
Employees
Members of the public
Suppliers
Media
Other
Advocacy groups
Non-governmental organizations
GovernmentExecutive.respondents.to.the.Accenture.survey.believe.that.government.will.play.a.critical.role.in.shaping.the.business.environment.relating.to.climate.change..Survey.results.showed.that.65.percent.of.respondents.cited.government.(both.national.and.local).as.the.most.significant.stakeholder.influencing.future.business.responses.to.climate.change..Government.policies.and.regulations.introduced.in.response.to.concerns.about.climate.change.have.the.potential.to.radically.alter.market.incentives.and.opportunities.for.profit..Chapter.4.provides.a.detailed.description.of.various.regulatory.mechanisms.that.may.come.into.play.here,.but.these.include:
•.“Cap-and-trade”.systems,.whereby.a.cap.is.imposed.on.overall.CO�.emissions,.with.participating.companies.free.to.trade.an.allocated.allowance.with.other.carbon.producers.
•.Subsidies,.which.reduce.market.prices.for.activities.that.in.some.way.contribute.to.lower.CO�.emissions..
•.“Green”.taxes,.which.aim.to.adjust.patterns.of.consumption.and.production.by.reflecting.the.additional.costs.associated.with.CO�.emissions..
Around.the.world,.the.pace.of.new.regulations.related.to.climate.change.has.already.been.rapid..For.example,.the.European.Union.Emissions.Trading.Scheme,.introduced.in.�005,.covers.40.to.50.percent.of.Europe’s.CO�.emissions.and.is.changing.the.face.of.business.activity.for.a.large.number.of.energy-intensive.industries.in.Europe..In.the.United.States,.support.for.legislation.in.states.such.as.California.seems.to.be.growing,.with.federal.legislation.potentially.not.too.far.away..
The.advent.of.new.regulatory.regimes.will.cause.two.fundamental.shifts.in.the.economics.of.doing.
business.in.many.industries..First,.regardless.of.the.specific.mechanism.used.to.limit.carbon.emissions,.most.schemes.have.in.common.the.creation.of.a.scarcity.value.of.carbon—a.price.that.will.need.to.be.factored.into.future.production.and.consumption.decisions..Second,.climate.change.regulation.will.have.an.international.character..That.means.that.a.multinational.corporation.may.be.faced.with.a.tapestry.of.different.regulatory.regimes.across.which.to.operate,.creating.challenges.in.terms.of.cost.structures.and.business.flexibility.
Regulation.is.likely.to.affect.different.industries.in.different.ways..For.example,.subsidies.for.biofuels.will.present.new.manufacturing.opportunities.for.the.automobile.industry.and.could.advance.the.market.for.new.farming.technologies..Conversely,.those.subsidies.could.also.shrink.the.land.available.for.conventional.crops,.affecting.prices.for.agribusiness.
![Page 12: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
10
and.food.processing..Incentives.for.the.use.of.energy-efficient.buildings.will.expand.the.market.for.eco-friendly.building.materials,.appliances.and.insulation.and.create.a.new.market.for.the.assessment.of.energy.efficiency..Emissions.trading.schemes,.which.set.limits.to.carbon.emissions.below.free-market.levels.so.that.they.can.be.valued.and.traded,.will.alter.the.balance.of.competitive.advantage.toward.more.efficient.producers.and.could.potentially.create.new.financial.markets.in.carbon-related.derivatives.
ConsumersConsumers.are.seen.by.our.executive.respondents.as.the.second.most.important.group.exerting.an.indirect.influence.on.the.response.of.businesses.to.climate.change..Changing.consumer.preferences.in.light.of.environmental.concerns.can.be.seen.in.trends.such.as.wider.demand.for.energy-efficient.products,.processes.and.services;.requests.for.better.information.about.environmental.impacts.of.products.and.services;.and.increased.adoption.of.energy-efficient.(or.“green”).technologies..The.Accenture.survey.of.end-consumers.mentioned.earlier.suggests.that.consumers.are.willing.to.translate.concern.over.the.environment.into.tangible.action.by.making.purchasing.decisions.according.to.a.company’s.track.record.on.environmental.impacts.5.
Environmental.responsibility.is.quickly.becoming.an.important.factor.in.a.buyer’s.decision.to.purchase.a.particular.product.or.service,.and.this.trend.will.only.accelerate..Businesses.need.to.be.proactive.with.strategies.that.can.exploit.this.shift.in.consumer.preferences.to.gain.competitive.advantage.and.advance.themselves.toward.sustainable.high.performance..
ShareholdersInvestor.decisions.about.the.allocation.of.capital.are.also.increasingly.informed.by.environmental.considerations..In.a.survey.conducted.by.the.US.National.Marketing.Institute,.50.percent.of.Americans.said.they.would.be.more.likely.to.buy.the.stock.of.a.company.with.more.environment-friendly.operations.6.Investor.interest.in.so-called.“ethical.mutual.funds”.has.mushroomed.in.recent.years..The.United.Kingdom.alone.has.more.than.60.such.funds,.with.a.total.of.£3.3.billion.(US$6.1.billion).of.capital.under.management.in.�005,.an.84.percent.increase.in.value.since.�000.7.
In.addition.to.the.ethical.investment.sector,.major.institutional.investors.such.as.pension.and.mutual.funds.are.increasingly.looking.at.a.company’s.environmental.performance.and.its.ability.to.respond.to.environmental.trends.as.key.factors.in.making.investment.decisions..One.recent.study.found.that.companies.that.exemplify.strong.competitive.positioning.combined.with.leadership.in.environmental,.social.and.governance.characteristics.outperformed.average.stock.market.returns.by.�5.percent.8
EmployeesA.company’s.environmental.performance.and.strategies.are.also.influencing.its.ability.to.recruit.and.retain.talent..One.study.found.that.75.percent.of.MBA.students.from.top.schools.would.be.willing.to.accept.a.pay.cut.of.between.10.and.�0.percent.in.order.to.work.for.a.company.they.regarded.as.socially.responsible—a.perception.that.is.linked.at.least.in.part.to.a.company’s.attitudes.and.actions.with.regard.to.climate.change.and.other.environmental.issues.9
In.summary,.climate.change.is.becoming.more.than.just.an.environmental.issue..It.is.now.playing.out.across.a.range.of.dimensions,.from.political.and.social.to.economic.and.technological..In.this.way,.climate.change.is.emerging.as.a.key.determinant.of.the.potential.of.today’s.companies.to.create.long-term.value.and.sustain.high.performance..A.number.of.important.stakeholders.are.shaping.the.business.landscape.because.of.climate.change.issues..The.exact.science.of.climate.change.should.matter.less.to.businesses.than.the.perceptions.and.behaviors.of.these.increasingly.powerful.stakeholders—especially.the.regulatory.responses.of.legislators.and.the.purchasing.patterns.of.consumers..Companies.that.are.attuned.to.these.shifts.and.that.respond.in.a.timely.and.proactive.manner.will.advance.toward.sustained.high.performance.faster.than.their.competitors.
![Page 13: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Current business responses to climate change
2
11
![Page 14: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
1�
Although.our.survey.points.to.positive.news.about.executive.awareness.of.the.impacts.of.climate.change,.this.awareness.is.not.wholly.reflected.in.the.actions.that.businesses.are.taking...
Climate change is not yet a strategic business priorityOur.research.reveals.a.significant.gap.between.executive.awareness.of.environmental.issues.and.corporate.willingness.to.approach.climate.change.as.a.strategic.priority.(see.Figure.6).
Only.5.percent.of.survey.respondents.named.climate.change.as.their.first.strategic.priority..In.no.region.of.the.world.that.we.surveyed.did.that.proportion.rise.above.8.percent,.and.no.Chinese.company.named.climate.change.as.its.first.strategic.priority..Although.one.might.well.imagine.that.more.immediate.concerns.such.as.sales.growth.and.new.product.development.would.rank.as.the.top.strategic.priority,.the.numbers.did.not.rise.significantly.even.when.executives.were.asked.about.their.second.and.third.priorities..Across.all.countries.represented.in.our.research,.11.percent.of.businesses.stated.that.climate.change.figured.as.their.second.or.third.strategic.priority..This.gap.between.awareness.of.the.issue.of.climate.change.and.the.willingness.to.take.action.should.serve.as.a.warning.sign.for.any.company.seeking.sustainable.high.performance.today..Seizing.competitive.advantage.based.on.an.effective.response.to.climate.change.will.require.dedicated.resources,.innovative.thinking.and.concerted.strategic.action..
Analysis.of.responses.by.industry.(see.Figure.7).shows.that.financial.services.and.resources.companies.appear.to.place.greater.strategic.priority.on.climate.change.than.do.communications.and.high-tech.(C&HT).or.consumer.and.industrial.(C&I).companies..This.finding.most.likely.reflects.the.unique.business.environment.of.resources.companies.that.have.a.concern.over.direct.emissions,.and.of.financial.services.
Figure 6: Climate change is a strategic priority for my business (% by market)
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
China
All
First strategic priority
Second or third strategic priority
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Figure 7: Climate change is a strategic priority for my business (% by industry)
C&HT
C&I
Financial Services
Resources
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
First strategic priority
Second or third strategic priority
Figure 8: Perceptions of corporate responsibility and positioning to act on climate change (%)
100
80
60
40
20
0
Average global levels
China Germany India Japan UnitedKingdom
UnitedStates
My business has a responsibility to help manage the impact of climate change
My business is well positioned to deal with climate change
![Page 15: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
13
Figure 9: Types of climate change initiatives currently being undertaken (%)
Technologiesto improveenergyefficiency
Measuring/ reducing carbon footprint
Increasing use of renewable energy
Carbon offsetting strategy
Internal policy formulation
Employee training
New products & services
Consumer information
Supply chain reconfiguration
NoneOther
0
20
40
60
companies.that.see.the.significant.opportunities.represented.by.environment-conscious.investment.funds.and.the.direct.impact.that.more.severe.weather.conditions.could.have.on.insurance.markets..
Many businesses feel a responsibility to act but do not feel well positioned to do soWhen.it.comes.to.climate.change,.even.the.most.well-intentioned.businesses.might.not.have.the.leverage.or.positioning.to.have.an.impact..As.Figure.8.opposite.shows,.despite.feeling.a.pronounced.sense.of.responsibility,.many.businesses.do.not.feel.well.positioned.to.deal.with.climate.change..German.businesses.see.themselves.as.better.situated.than.most.others.to.respond.to.climate.change,.perhaps.reflecting.a.perception.of.being.at.the.forefront.of.environment-conscious.technologies.and.innovations..Indian.companies.also.feel.relatively.confident.about.their.ability.to.act.on.climate.change,.possibly.an.indication.of.the.pervasive.entrepreneurial.spirit.and.optimism.in.today’s.dynamic.Indian.economy..Chinese.companies.feel.the.least.well.positioned.to.deal.with.climate.change—a.sign,.perhaps,.of.the.scale.of.the.huge.environmental.challenges.that.China.faces.in.the.
future..In.total,.two-thirds.(67.percent).of.businesses.feel.they.have.a.role.to.play.in.tackling.climate.change,.but.only.4�.percent.feel.well.positioned.to.fulfill.that.role.
Business initiatives in response to climate change are generally spread across a broad range of activities, risking fragmentationThe.emergence.of.climate.change.as.a.major.issue.for.business.is.already.generating.a.broad.range.of.different.initiatives.(see.Figure.9),.varying.to.some.extent.by.industry.and.type.of.organization..Overall,.a.little.more.than.four-fifths.of.businesses.surveyed.currently.have.initiatives.in.place.relating.to.climate.change..The.most.frequently.mentioned.activities.typically.involve.reducing.or.managing.carbon-related.activities,.including:.
•.Deploying.technologies.such.as.smart.metering.or.energy-efficient.buildings.to.improve.energy.efficiency.(mentioned.by.53.percent.of.respondents).
•.Measuring.an.organization’s.carbon.usage—its.“carbon.footprint”.(39.percent).
•.Increasing.the.use.of.renewable.energy.sources.(3�.percent)..
A.smaller.proportion.of.companies.report.initiatives.in.the.area.of.internal.policy.formulation.(�8.percent).and.employee.training.and.communication.(�7.percent)..When.it.comes.to.more.comprehensive.activities.that.are.likely.to.create.substantial.efficiencies.or.new.business.opportunities,.fewer.companies.are.taking.action..For.example,.less.then.one.quarter.of.companies.are.creating.new.products.and.services.in.response.to.climate.change,.and.only.17.percent.are.looking.to.reconfigure.their.supply.chains..Both.activities,.Accenture.believes,.represent.areas.where.significant.value.can.be.realized.
Several.differences.emerge.among.the.industries.surveyed..New.products.and.services.are.more.likely.to.be.introduced.by.companies.in.the.resources.and.financial.services.industries.(with.�9.percent.and.30.percent,.respectively).than.their.counterparts.in.other.industries..C&HT.companies.are.generally.less.likely.to.be.undertaking.climate-change-related.initiatives,.with.38.percent.undertaking.none.at.all..The.most.common.initiative.for.the.C&HT.sector.is.in.relation.to.energy-efficiency.technologies,.mentioned.by.45.percent.of.those.companies..A.C&I.or.resources.company.is.more.likely.than.one.in.the.other.
![Page 16: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
14
industries.to.look.at.measuring.its.carbon.footprint..
In.short,.although.it.is.clear.from.our.research.that.businesses.are.pursuing.a.range.of.initiatives.in.response.to.climate.change,.there.is.little.evidence.of.an.enterprise-wide.or.holistic.approach..In.fact,.our.analysis.highlights.significant.fragmentation.in.business.responses..Almost.half.of.those.businesses.undertaking.any.initiatives.have.only.one.or.two.in.place..
On.the.other.hand,.where.more.fundamental.initiatives.are.underway,.there.is.evidence.that.a.more.holistic.approach.is.possible..For.example,.of.those.who.are.reconfiguring.their.supply.chains.in.response.to.climate.change,.more.than.80.percent.are.also.looking.at.four.or.more.other.initiatives..For.those.pursuing.more.limited.approaches—such.as.simply.improving.their.energy.efficiency—that.number.drops.to.just.over.40.percent.and.includes.16.
percent.who.are.doing.only.that..As.climate.change.moves.further.up.the.strategic.agenda.of.more.businesses,.we.would.expect.to.see.companies.take.a.more.holistic.approach.that.takes.into.account.all.aspects.of.business.operations..
Companies are too rarely considering the business opportunities represented by climate change As.shown.in.Figure.9,.about.one-fifth.of.the.companies.in.our.survey.have.no.climate.change.initiatives.under.way.at.all..This.finding.can.perhaps.be.best.explained.by.another.research.finding:.that,.across.the.board,.executives.look.at.climate.change.more.as.something.that.will.increase.the.cost.of.doing.business,.rather.than.something.that.can.open.up.new.opportunities..
Figure.10.shows.that.only.39.percent.of.businesses.see.climate.change.as.something.that.can.present.them.with.new.business.opportunities..
Two-thirds.(67.percent).consider.climate.change.to.be.a.necessary.cost,.rather.than.something.that.can.spur.potential.development..The.story.is.slightly.different.in.emerging.economies..In.China,.46.percent.of.companies.see.climate.change.as.presenting.new.opportunities—as.do.5�.percent.of.companies.in.India..
Figure 10: Perceptions of the costs and business opportunities of climate change (%)
IndiaGermany UnitedKingdom
UnitedStates
JapanAll
100
80
60
40
20
0China
Climate change will increase the cost of doing business
Climate change will open up many new opportunities for mybusiness
![Page 17: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
One.of.the.largest.financial.institutions.in.the.world,.UK-headquartered.HSBC.considers.climate.change.to.be.the.single.largest.environmental.challenge.of.this.century..HSBC.is.a.comparatively.low.emitter.of.CO�,.with.its.major.direct.impacts.on.atmospheric.carbon.concentrations.coming.from.electricity,.natural.gas.and.fuel.oil.consumption.to.power.and.heat.its.buildings.and.to.support.employee.travel..Through.a.three-point.Carbon.Management.Plan—reduce.energy.use,.buy.green.electricity.where.possible,.and.offset.remaining.emissions—in.October.�005.HSBC.became.the.world’s.first.major.bank.to.become.
carbon-neutral..HSBC.estimated.its.carbon.dioxide.emissions.for.the.last.three.months.of.�005.would.be.170,000.tons.and.invested.in.carbon.offset.projects.in.New.Zealand,.Australia,.India.and.Germany.at.a.total.cost.of.US$750,000.
HSBC.is.also.actively.encouraging.its.customers.to.reduce.their.own.impact.on.the.environment..For.the.month.of.January.�007,.the.bank.offered.a.special.promotion—which.it.called.a.“Green.Sale”—on.a.range.of.its.most.popular.products.and.services.for.personal.and.business.customers,.including.car.and.home.insurance,.loans,.credit.card.services,.business.start-up.
services.and.savings.accounts..For.every.Green.Sale.product.or.service.bought.in.the.United.Kingdom,.HSBC.contributed.£�.(about.US$4).to.a.group.of.environmental.organizations..
Case Study: HSBC
One.of.the.most.successful.car.companies.today,.Toyota.is.also.an.industry.leader.in.the.battle.against.climate.change..Its.approach.to.climate.change.is.a.story.of.innovation.and.market.anticipation,.perhaps.best.represented.by.its.first.mass-produced.hybrid.car.(the.Prius).in.Japan.in.1997..The.company’s.expanding.line-up.of.hybrid.vehicles.is.testimony.to.a.commitment.to.hybrid.technology.it.made.more.than.15.years.ago,.long.before.climate.change.came.on.to.most.companies’.radars..Since.the.Prius.was.introduced.into.the.North.American.market.in.�000,.Toyota.has.sold.more.than.400,000.hybrids,.and.demand.
is.still.outstripping.supply..By.late.�006,.Toyota.hybrid.drivers.in.the.United.States.were.estimated.to.have.saved.more.than.178.million.gallons.of.gasoline.and.1.6.million.tons.of.CO�.emissions..The.company.is.currently.developing.the.technology.behind.plug-in.cars.that.will.run.solely.on.electricity..
Case Study: Toyota
15
![Page 18: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
3Constraints on action
16
![Page 19: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
17
While.many.business.executives.feel.a.responsibility.to.respond.to.the.threat.of.climate.change,.they.often.do.not.feel.able.to.take.action.in.a.coherent.or.comprehensive.fashion..Our.survey.findings.point.to.a.number.of.constraints.experienced.by.the.typical.company.today.when.it.comes.to.taking.action.in.response.to.climate.change..
Difficulty understanding a complex and fluid issue More.than.half.of.businesses.said.that.they.are.struggling.to.understand.the.implications.of.climate.change.on.their.industry.and.business.(see.Figure.11)..This.finding.may.reflect.uncertainty.about.the.future.regulatory.environment.in.different.markets..Businesses.may.lack.clear.indications.about.the.type.or.strength.of.regulations.under.which.they.may.be.required.to.operate..For.example,.in.the.United.Kingdom.a.group.of.companies,.including.BT.and.United.Utilities,.has.published.an.open.letter.to.the.prime.
Figure 11: Proportion of survey respondents agreeing with the statement: “Businesses are struggling to understand the implications of climate change”
Agree
53%
24%
23%
Disagree
Neither agree nor disagree
![Page 20: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
18
minister.calling.for.clarity.around.a.common.carbon.reporting.standard.10.Conflicting.scientific.viewpoints.on.the.impacts.of.climate.change.may.also.add.to.this.sense.of.uncertainty,.compounded.by.intense.and.often.inconsistent.media.coverage.
Competing business prioritiesFigure.1�.shows.that.while.businesses.may.generally.agree.that.climate.change.is.a.major.issue,.it.tends.to.receive.less.attention.when.set.against.more.immediate.business.imperatives..Asked.to.name.their.most.pressing.strategic.priorities,.executives.named.sales.growth.(47.percent.of.respondents),.cost.reduction.(46.percent).and.developing.new.products.and.services.(45.percent).well.ahead.of.climate.change,.cited.by.just.16.percent.of.respondents.
One.challenge.is.to.develop.a.more.nuanced.understanding.of.how.climate.change.relates.to—and.shapes—many.of.these.other.business.priorities..For.example,.cost.reduction—the.second.most.important.business.priority.according.to.survey.respondents—is.increasingly.intertwined.with.climate.change.issues..An.oil.price.close.to.or.exceeding.US$100.per.barrel.is.forcing.businesses.to.assess.how.to.cut.costs.related.to.energy.usage..Alternative.energies.such.as.wind.and.solar,.once.viewed.as.uncompetitive,.are.starting.to.become.viable.options..The.potential.for.future.profits.in.biofuels.is.slightly.less.positive.due.to.rising.commodity.prices.in.raw.materials..However,.notwithstanding.this.trend,.alternative.energy.sources.will.eventually.constitute.a.significant.means.of.cost.reduction..The.German.Association.of.the.Biofuels.Industry,.for.example,.calculates.that.oil.prices.need.to.rise.to.US$1�0.per.barrel—a.figure.that.is.no.longer.unrealistic—to.make.
biofuels.competitive.11.If.such.a.scenario.were.coupled.with.a.fall.in.the.production.costs.of.biofuels—due.to.lower.prices.of.wheat.and.maize—biofuels.would.become.increasingly.economic.relative.to.other.fuel.sources..This.is.just.one.example.of.how.climate.change.increasingly.influences.other.business.priorities.
Internal business challengesAssessing.the.business.impacts.of.climate.change.is.a.difficult.task—but.actually.implementing.actions.within.an.organization.is.even.more.challenging..Figure.13.opposite.shows.those.areas.where.businesses.perceive.the.greatest.internal.challenges..Twenty-five.percent.of.respondents.considered.the.introduction.of.new.technologies.to.be.the.primary.challenge..This.finding.may.reflect.insufficient.experience.with.green.technologies.and.inadequate.understanding.of.what.they.can.offer.relative.to.business.requirements..Changing.internal.behaviors.was.the.second.
Figure 12: Strategic concerns named by businesses as a top-three priority (%)
12%
9%
13%
16%
18%
28%
29%
39%
45%
46%
47%
Other
Increasing the level of capital allocation
Regulation
Climate change
Technology
Innovation
Growth in emerging markets
War for talent
Developing new products and services
Cost reduction
Sales growth
![Page 21: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
19
most.pressing.internal.challenge,.named.by.�4.percent.of.respondents..This.finding.underscores.the.fact.that.preparing.organizations.for.a.future.that.requires.heightened.awareness.of.carbon.consumption.is.as.much.about.engendering.the.right.culture.as.it.is.about.implementing.the.right.systems.and.processes..Twenty.percent.of.executives.surveyed.also.shared.a.concern.about.coping.with.new.regulation,.pointing.to.the.key.role.played.by.regulators.and.to.the.uncertainty.surrounding.future.regulatory.environments..
Disparate but powerful stakeholdersAs.discussed.in.Chapter.1,.multiple.stakeholder.views.on.climate.change.are.critical.in.shaping.the.business.response.to.climate.change..How.businesses.deal.with.their.stakeholders.over.the.issue.of.climate.change.can.have.serious.repercussions.for.profits,.image.and.the.overall.pursuit.of.high.performance..In.our.survey,.65.
percent.of.executives.mentioned.government.(national.and.local).as.the.most.influential.stakeholder.in.terms.of.their.company’s.response.to.climate.change..Governments.are,.of.course,.in.charge.of.regulation.and.therefore.the.most.influential.player.in.setting.the.rules.of.the.game..As.such,.businesses.need.to.have.a.clear.understanding.of.likely.future.legislation.and.should.be.seeking.to.inform.and.shape.that.legislation.wherever.possible..However,.at.present,.uncertainty.over.future.regulation.is.hampering.business.in.its.desire.to.take.concrete.action,.as.we.show.in.Chapter.4.
Figure 13: Top challenges facing businesses in responding to climate change (%)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Updating performance metrics
Re-engineering internal business processes and systems
Managing stakeholder expectations
Coping with new regulations
Changing internal behaviors
Introducing new technologies
![Page 22: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
The.Tata.Group.is.a.good.example.of.how.a.corporate.entity.can.make.the.challenge.of.climate.change.integral.to.its.processes..An.Indian.conglomerate.comprising.over.100.companies.that.operate.in.seven.sectors,.from.cars.to.chemicals,.software.to.steel,.the.group.has.made.the.preservation.and.regeneration.of.the.environment.an.intrinsic.part.of.its.culture.of.corporate.sustainability.
Coordinating.and.directing.the.climate-change.efforts.of.the.Group’s.companies.is.Tata.Quality.Management.Services,.a.central.organization.that.draws.on.the.experience.and.expertise.of.senior.Tata.leaders..The.broad.concept.is.to.develop.a.
common.approach.to.the.critical.environmental.challenges.confronting.the.Group’s.businesses,.and.formulate.policies.that.can.deal.effectively.with.vital.issues.such.as.climate.change....
The.Tata.Group’s.approach.to.climate.change.has.made.it.stand.out.among.its.peers..In.our.survey.of.companies.across.India,.a.significant.number.cited.Tata.as.an.organization.that.is.a.leader.in.dealing.with.the.challenges.presented.by.climate.change.
Case Study: The Tata Group
�0
![Page 23: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Regulatory actions favored by today’s business executives
4
�1
![Page 24: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
��
combination.of.market-driven.and.regulatory.measures,.although.the.degree.of.preference.varies.by.country.and.sector.
•.A.consensus.exists.among.business.leaders.that.future.regulation.related.to.climate.change.should.be.relatively.harmonized.across.different.countries.to.reduce.the.costs.of.compliance—but.at.the.same.time.should.be.more.flexibly.applied.in.different.industries.to.reflect.the.unique.conditions.existing.in.those.sectors.
•.By.standing.back.and.not.proactively.engaging.in.discussions.related.to.legislation,.businesses.risk.letting.others.set.the.regulatory.agenda.for.them..Only.a.small.percentage.of.businesses.are.working.with.other.organizations.or.taking.active.steps.to.help.shape.regulatory.policies.in.the.area.of.climate.change.
Figure 14: Most effective regulatory environment for responding to climate change (all respondents)
Balance between the two
18%
17% 63%
2%
Mainly government-driven
Mainly market-driven
Don’t know
Climate.change.is.now.the.subject.of.intense.political.debate.in.many.countries,.spurring.a.raft.of.regulatory.proposals.at.both.the.national.and.international.levels..However,.many.aspects.of.the.future.legislative.environment.have.yet.to.be.settled..Businesses.clearly.feel.a.sense.of.uncertainty.and.are.seeking.long-term.signals.about.where.and.how.to.invest..For.example,.the.European.Corporate.Leaders.on.Climate.Change.group.has.said.that.“to.promote.the.necessary.step-change.in.investments.in.low-carbon.goods.and.services,.a.strong.and.clear.policy.framework.that.creates.long-term.value.for.carbon.emissions.reductions.is.required.”1�.That.view.has.been.echoed.by.the.US.Climate.Action.Partnership,.which.has.written:.“Policies.are.needed.to.realize.the.full.potential.of.energy.efficiency.as.a.high.priority.energy.resource.and.a.cost-effective.means.of.reducing.greenhouse.gas.emissions.”13
These.concerns.expressed.by.the.business.community.highlight.a.fundamental.tension.surrounding.the.regulatory.framework.for.addressing.climate.change:.Businesses.are.reluctant.to.make.big.investments.in.climate-change-related.initiatives.until.the.form.and.scope.of.future.regulation.becomes.clearer..At.the.same.time,.policymakers.are.reluctant.to.push.ahead.with.particular.forms.of.regulation.until.more.is.known.about.the.impact.of.climate.change.and.regulation.on.business.competitiveness.
Given.this.complex.interplay.between.future.regulation.and.business.investment,.it.becomes.important.to.understand.how.businesses.view.the.evolving.regulatory.landscape.and.the.ways.in.which.they.are.responding.to.it..Our.research.and.analysis.highlight.the.following.key.findings:
•.Business.leaders.believe.that.climate.change.will.be.tackled.most.effectively.through.a.
![Page 25: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
�3
UnitedKingdom
UnitedStates
0
20
40
60
80
100
China Germany India Japan Mainly market-driven
Mainly government-driven
Balance between the two
Figure 15: Most effective regulatory environment to respond to climate change (% by market)
Different businesses favor market-driven or government-driven responsesAn.important.issue.for.policymakers.when.addressing.climate.change.is.whether.to.pursue.government-driven.responses.(e.g.,.standards,.emissions.controls.and.limits).or.market-based.approaches.(e.g.,.taxes.and.subsidies,.provision.of.consumer.information.on.the.environmental.impact.of.specific.products,.and.new.technologies)..Our.survey.shows.that.the.majority.of.business.leaders.(63.percent).favor.a.balance.between.market-driven.and.government-driven.initiatives.as.the.most.effective.means.of.responding.to.climate.change.(see.Figure.14.opposite)..The.remainder.of.respondents.are.fairly.evenly.divided.in.calling.for.either.mainly.government-driven.or.mainly.market-driven.approaches..
The.preference.for.a.combination.of.approaches.increases.to.some.degree.with.organizational.size..Sixty-seven.percent.of.businesses.
with.revenues.between.US$100.million.and.US$1.billion.favor.a.combined.approach,.while.only.54.percent.of.companies.in.the.US$50.million.to.US$100.million.category.favor.that.approach..This.difference.could.be.a.reflection.of.organizational.culture:.smaller.organizations.lean.toward.greater.autonomy,.while.larger.businesses.recognize.the.value.of.collaboration..
Some.marked.differences.are.also.evident.across.countries,.perhaps.reflecting.different.national.circumstances.and.regulatory.traditions.(see.Figure.15)..Business.leaders.in.the.United.Kingdom.are.more.likely.than.their.counterparts.elsewhere.to.favor.a.combination.of.market-driven.and.government-driven.intervention..Chinese.business.leaders.were.more.likely.to.believe.that.responses.to.climate.change.should.be.mainly.instigated.by.the.government.rather.than.market-driven.(4�.percent.versus.16.percent).
The.general.preference.of.businesses.for.approaches.that.involve.collaboration.between.government.and.industry.also.extends.to.the.way.in.which.future.regulation.might.operate..Where.regulation.is.introduced,.46.percent.of.survey.respondents.would.prefer.co-regulation,.such.as.codes.of.practice.backed.by.government.but.enforced.by.industry..The.remainder.of.those.surveyed.were.split.between.those.preferring.self-regulation.(�6.percent).and.those.favoring.government-led.regulation.(�8.percent)..Some.differences.exist.by.industry—for.example,.business.leaders.in.consumer.and.industrial.companies.are.more.likely.than.those.in.the.resources.sectors.to.favor.co-regulation.(49.percent.versus.35.percent)..This.could.reflect.the.fact.that.consumer.and.industrial.companies.are.generally.less.closely.regulated.than.resources.companies,.for.whom.government-led.regulation.is.often.the.norm.
![Page 26: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
�4
Executives expect a range of potential regulatory measures to be consideredA.wide.array.of.regulatory.instruments.have.been.put.forward.by.various.governments.in.response.to.the.issue.of.climate.change.(see.panel.at.the.end.of.this.chapter)..Some.of.these.regulatory.approaches,.such.as.taxes.and.subsidies,.aim.to.internalize.the.impact.of.emissions.by.altering.market.incentives.to.producers..Others.involve.more.direct.regulation.and.control.of.emissions..Some,.such.as.emissions.trading.schemes,.involve.both.market.and.regulatory.elements..
Our.survey.shows.a.consensus.of.expectation.among.business.leaders.that.renewable.energy.incentives.and.carbon.targets.will.form.part.of.the.policy.response.to.climate.change,.with.an.average.of.74.percent.and.65.percent,.respectively,.saying.that.these.kinds.of.measures.are.likely.to.be.implemented.in.their.countries..Other.types.of.policies.are.also.widely.expected,.but.to.a.lesser.degree..
These.include.increased.provision.of.information.to.consumers.through.measures.such.as.labeling.(named.by.58.percent.of.respondents),.taxes.on.energy-intensive.products.(54.percent),.and.carbon.trading.schemes.(46.percent)..In.a.situation.where.the.evolution.of.the.regulatory.environment.remains.very.uncertain,.the.message.seems.to.be.that.businesses.are.expecting.most.policy.options.to.be.on.the.table..
Again,.national.differences.are.apparent.(see.Figure.16)..US.executives.are.more.likely.to.expect.market-based.measures.such.as.incentives.and.consumer.information.than.to.expect.the.introduction.of.carbon.taxes.or.targets.to.reduce.emissions..Business.leaders.from.China,.Germany.and.the.United.Kingdom.are.more.likely.than.their.counterparts.elsewhere.to.expect.the.implementation.of.carbon.taxes..In.the.example.of.Germany.and.the.United.Kingdom,.this.is.likely.to.reflect.the.proactive.stance.that.their.respective.governments.have.
taken.in.this.area..For.example,.the.UK.Climate.Change.Bill.proposes.to.introduce.a.clear,.long-term.framework.in.which.the.United.Kingdom.can.reduce.CO�.emissions.and.ensure.that.steps.are.taken.to.adapt.to.climate.change.impacts.14.Furthermore,.the.United.Kingdom’s.Green.Fiscal.Commission,.launched.in.�007,.will.be.conducting.independent.research.into.environmental.tax.reform.and.its.implications.15
Even.if.the.future.regulatory.environment.were.more.predictable,.the.impact.of.legislation.on.business.would.not.be.easy.to.quantify..Figure.17.shows.that.future.regulatory.measures.are.expected.to.have.only.a.moderate.impact..This.may.reflect.executives’.optimism.about.the.ability.of.businesses.to.adapt.to.regulatory.constraints.or.it.may.simply.indicate.the.difficulty.in.identifying.the.impact.of.schemes.whose.form.and.scope.remain.uncertain.
Taxes.on.energy-intensive.products.and.services,.incentives.to.use.
![Page 27: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
�5
Figure 16: Perceived likelihood of various regulatory measures being implemented (% by market)
United Kingdom
Low-carbon/renewablesincentives
Targets toreduce carbonemissions
Consumerinformation(e.g., labeling)
Tax on energyuse
Carbontrading
0
25
50
75
100
JapanChina India United StatesGermany
Figure 17: Expected impact on businesses if various measures were implemented (1= no impact; 4 = big impact)
Low-carbon/renewablesincentives
Targets toreduce carbonemissions
Consumerinformation(e.g., labeling)
Tax on energyuse
Carbontrading
United KingdomJapanChina India United StatesGermany United KingdomJapanChina India United StatesGermany
1
2
3
4
![Page 28: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
�6
renewable.energy,.and.targets.to.reduce.energy.emissions.are.more.likely.to.be.seen.as.having.a.big.impact.on.business.than.are.consumer.information.and.carbon-trading.schemes..In.general,.business.leaders.from.developed.economies.such.as.the.United.Kingdom,.Germany.and.Japan.were.more.likely.to.see.such.measures.having.an.impact.on.their.business.while.Chinese.businesses.were.inclined.to.ascribe.little.impact.to.these.measures.
Businesses seek both international consistency and industry flexibilityBy.its.very.nature,.climate.change.is.a.global.issue,.leading.to.calls.for.more.consistent.and.coordinated.policy.approaches.at.the.international.level..These.concerns.are.echoed.in.our.survey.of.business.leaders,.who.expressed.a.preference.for.regulation.to.be.more.harmonized.across.different.countries..This.reflects.the.fact.that.many.of.these.businesses.
operate.across.multiple.countries.and.a.concern.that.a.proliferation.of.different.national.regimes.and.standards.will.lead.to.extra.complexity.and.impose.additional.costs.of.doing.business..
At.the.same.time,.the.implications.of.climate.change.are.often.radically.different.across.industries..Energy-intensive.users.such.as.manufacturers.or.resource.companies.will.necessarily.have.a.different.view.of.climate.change.than.less.energy-intensive.industries,.such.as.services..The.different.concerns.of.different.industries.were.borne.out.by.our.survey,.with.a.majority.of.business.leaders.saying.that.future.climate-change.regulation.should.be.flexible.across.different.industries.to.allow.for.variations.in.industry.conditions.and.circumstances.(see.Figure.18.opposite)..Such.flexibility.was.particularly.favored.by.C&HT.and.financial.services.companies,.which.might.not.wish.to.be.saddled.with.the.more.stringent.measures.to.which.energy-
intensive.users.might.be.subject..The.message.is.that.businesses.want.regulation.that.is.flexible.by.industry.but.more.consistent.across.international.boundaries.
Most businesses are inadequately involved in shaping regulationGiven.the.high.stakes.involved.when.it.comes.to.future.regulation.and.its.impact.on.the.ability.of.businesses.to.achieve.high.performance.in.the.face.of.climate.change,.it.is.surprising.that.relatively.few.companies.are.taking.active.steps.to.work.with.other.stakeholders.to.inform.and.shape.the.regulatory.debate..Only.36.percent.of.the.companies.we.surveyed.had.taken.steps.to.help.shape.regulatory.policies.in.this.area;.that.number.rises.to.49.percent.for.very.large.companies.and.to.54.percent.for.companies.in.the.resources.industries.(see.Figure.19.opposite),.where.regulation.is.a.more.front-of-mind.issue..Interestingly,.companies.that.
![Page 29: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
�7
Figure 19: Survey respondents who say their businesses are involved in shaping regulatory policies (% by industry)
Resources FinancialServices
C&IC&HT0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Figure 18: Preference for regulatory flexibility versus harmonization across industries (% by industry)
Financial Services C&IC&HT
More flexible More harmonized
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Resources All
perceive.themselves.as.innovators.in.respect.of.their.responses.to.climate.change.are.more.likely.to.seek.to.shape.regulation.than.those.that.perceive.themselves.to.be.followers.(5�.percent.versus.�8.percent).
More.than.one-third.(37.percent).of.businesses.are.not.working.with.any.external.organization.on.the.business.implications.of.climate.change..Of.those.who.are,.the.most.frequently-mentioned.collaborators.are.industry.bodies.(40.percent),.government.departments.(34.percent).and.suppliers.(�9.percent)..Again,.self-perceived.innovators.are.much.more.likely.than.followers.to.be.working.with.external.organizations—80.percent.versus.53.percent.
![Page 30: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Different.legislative.bodies.have.proposed.a.variety.of.regulatory.mechanisms.to.reduce.the.impact.of.carbon.emissions..These.regulations.fall.broadly.into.the.following.categories:.carbon.taxes;.subsidies/incentives;.“command-and-control”.approaches.(quantitative.restrictions);.emissions.trading.schemes;.standards;.and.information.provision..
•.Tax-based.instruments.aim.to.adjust.market.prices.of.consumption.and.production.activities.to.reflect.the.additional.social.costs.associated.with.CO�.emissions..Taxes.can.be.revenue-positive,.bringing.in.additional.money.to.the.public.purse,.which.could.be.channeled.toward.environmental.programs..Alternatively,.taxes.can.be.revenue-neutral,.with.the.revenue.from.carbon.taxes.used.to.reduce.taxes.levied.elsewhere..Carbon.taxes.are.in.place.in.Sweden,.Finland,.Norway.and.the.Netherlands,.but.proposals.to.introduce.them.elsewhere.(e.g.,.
in.New.Zealand.and.the.United.States).have.largely.stagnated..However,.the.launch.of.the.Carbon.Tax.Center.in.the.United.States,.and.government.advisor.Nicholas.Stern’s.backing.of.carbon.taxes.in.the.United.Kingdom,.have.put.carbon.taxes.back.on.the.agenda.as.a.credible.possibility.
•.Subsidies.and.incentives.work.in.the.opposite.direction.from.the.taxation.approach.by.aiming.to.reduce.market.prices.for.activities.that.contribute.in.some.way.to.reduced.CO�.emissions..Approaches.here.can.include.subsidies.for.substitute.goods.or.services.with.a.lower.carbon.footprint.than.alternatives.(e.g.,.public.transport.as.a.substitute.for.private.transport),.or.incentives.for.the.development.and.use.of.new.technologies.that.reduce.carbon.emissions.(e.g.,.energy-efficient.materials.for.buildings.and.housing,.next-generation.biofuels.and.solar.fuel.cells)..“Hidden”.subsidies.(such.as.tax.breaks).often.exist.for.fossil.
fuels..Eliminating.these.subsidies.would.redress.the.balance.of.fossil.versus.renewable.energy.in.the.market.but.probably.would.not.be.a.long-term.stand-alone.solution.
•.“Command-and-control”.approaches.to.regulation.usually.involve.some.form.of.quantitative.restriction.such.as.quotas.on.CO�.emissions.or.mandating.the.use.of.specific.energy.sources.or.technologies..In.practice,.quantitative.restrictions.are.usually.combined.with.some.form.of.arrangement.to.allow.firms.to.trade.individual.carbon.allowances.in.a.“cap-and-trade”.scheme.(discussed.below).
•.“Cap-and-trade”.schemes,.also.known.as.emissions.trading.schemes,.are.the.most.globally.significant.mechanisms.in.place,.forming.the.basis.of.the.United.Nations’.Kyoto.protocol—an.addition.to.the.original.United.Nations.Framework.Convention.on.Climate.Change..Under.such.
Regulatory options for reducing greenhouse gas emissions
�8
![Page 31: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
schemes.a.cap.is.imposed.on.overall.CO�.emissions,.with.those.companies.covered.by.the.scheme.(usually.in.energy-intensive.industries).allocated.an.individual.carbon.allowance,.which.can.be.traded.with.other.producers..The.lower.the.overall.cap.on.emissions,.the.higher.the.price.at.which.carbon.allowances.will.be.traded.(other.things.being.equal)..Emissions.trading.schemes.have.several.benefits.from.the.point.of.view.of.both.businesses.and.policymakers:.
-.They.are.economically.efficient.in.the.sense.that.businesses.that.can.generate.more.profit.per.unit.of.CO�.emissions.will.have.incentives.to.buy.allowances.from.less-productive.firms.
-.They.provide.price.signals.to.companies.to.help.guide.investment.decisions.
-.They.offer.industry.more.flexibility.in.meeting.CO�.limits.than.do.traditional.regulations.or.controls.
-.They.provide.more.certainty.with.respect.to.overall.limits.on.carbon.emissions.16....
The.most.well-known.cap-and-trade.scheme.is.the.European.Union.Emissions.Trading.Scheme,.introduced.in.�005.and.covering.around.40.to.50.percent.of.CO�.emissions.and.10,500.installations.across.the.European.Union..Phase.II,.set.to.run.from.�008.to.�01�,.will.include.tighter.caps.on.emissions.to.ensure.a.positive.price.for.carbon.and.may.bring.additional.gases.and.sectors.within.its.scope..
Legislators.in.the.United.States.are.considering.a.variety.of.cap-and-trade.schemes.with.several.schemes.at.the.state.level.already.in.existence,.such.as.the.US.Regional.Greenhouse.Gas.Initiative.and.the.(voluntary).Chicago.Climate.Exchange.17.Countries.including.New.Zealand,.Norway.and.Switzerland.are.also.developing.emissions-trading.schemes.18
With.correct.pricing.and.target.levels,.cap-and-trade.schemes.can.be.very.effective,.but.they.
are.subject.to.several.practical.difficulties..One.issue.is.whether.carbon.allocations.or.permits.should.be.awarded.free.to.producers.on.a.“grandfather.rights”.basis,.taking.into.account.existing.production.patterns,.or.whether.they.should.be.auctioned.to.the.highest.bidder,.providing.opportunities.for.new.producers.to.bid.for.allocations.and.generating.revenues.for.the.government..Regional.or.international.schemes.may.offer.greater.certainty.and.consistency.for.companies.operating.across.borders,.but.they.bring.the.additional.problem.of.finding.agreement.on.the.appropriate.division.of.carbon.allocations.by.nation..Developing.countries.will.want.allocations.that.reflect.their.future.growth.aspirations,.whereas.industrialized.nations.will.want.allocations.that.at.least.in.part.reflect.their.existing.levels.of.income.and.consumption..
•.Standards.can.also.play.a.role.in.increasing.efficiency.and.the.use.of.renewable.energy.sources..Standards.have.been.used.effectively.in.Europe.to.regulate.and.reduce.emissions.from.cars.and.have.been.used.in.Japan.more.broadly.to.enable.that.nation.to.become.the.most.energy-efficient.developed.country..However,.standards.do.not.always.work.precisely.as.intended..An.example.is.the.Corporate.Average.Fuel.Economy.(CAFE).legislation.introduced.in.the.United.States.in.1975,.which.imposed.mandatory.fuel.economy.requirements.on.cars.in.an.effort.to.encourage.consumers.to.buy.more-efficient.vehicles..The.effect.on.fuel.consumption.was.limited,.however,.largely.because.consumers.traded.up.to.larger.vehicles.such.as.light.trucks.and.because.the.reduction.in.fuel.costs.per.mile.lowered.the.cost.of.motoring.and.encouraged.owners.to.use.their.vehicles.more.than.before..Consequently,.in.�007,.Congress.passed.legislation.to.introduce.more-stringent.fuel.economy.standards.on.cars.and.light.trucks.by.around.�0�0.
•.Finally,.information.provision.can.play.a.role.in.helping.consumers.and.industrial.users.make.more.informed.purchasing.decisions.by.highlighting.the.energy.efficiency.or.carbon.footprint.of.different.products.and.services..Examples.would.include.energy-efficiency.labeling.of.electrical.appliances.and.labeling.of.food.items.to.show.their.carbon.footprint.
�9
![Page 32: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
5Conclusion: Meeting the business challenges of climate change
30
![Page 33: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
31
Accenture.defines.a.high-performance.business.as.one.that.outperforms.its.peers.consistently.over.the.long.term..Our.experience.in.working.with.clients—and.our.High.Performance.Business.research,.which.covers.more.than.6,000.companies—establishes.that.high-performance.businesses.differentiate.themselves.by.balancing,.aligning.and.renewing.three.essential.building.blocks.of.high.performance:
•.Market.focus.and.position—business.strategy.decisions.regarding.where.and.when.to.compete.
•.Distinctive.capabilities—hard-to-replicate.capabilities.that.define.how.businesses.compete.
•.Performance.anatomy—common.mindsets.relating.to.culture,.leadership.and.the.workforce.
While.the.environmental.context.in.which.businesses.are.operating.is.changing.rapidly,.there.are.nevertheless.a.number.of.steps.that.they.can.take.within.each.of.these.building.blocks.to.position.themselves.better.to.achieve.high.performance.in.an.era.of.climate.change..
Market focus and positionConduct.a.stakeholder.analysis:.Identify.and.gauge.the.key.sources.of.influence.on.your.company,.focusing.in.particular.on.the.views.of.the.government.as.well.as.consumers..As.part.of.this.analysis,.engage.with.the.regulatory.body.that.sets.the.environmental.agenda.and.help.to.shape.the.discussion.about.legislation..Governments.run.the.
risk.of.being.caught.in.a.situation.whereby.both.regulators.and.businesses.are.looking.to.each.other.to.make.the.first.move..Businesses.should.play.their.part.in.pre-empting.this.understandably.cautious.approach.and.should.articulate.a.clear.view.of.how.legislation.can.help.businesses.manage.the.impacts.of.climate.change..
Develop.environmentally.conscious,.or.“green,”.products.and.services:.Assess.how.existing.and.new.products.can.be.tailored.to.meet.consumer—and.potentially.regulatory—demands.for.reduced.environmental.impact..For.example,.as.part.of.a.wider.plan.to.reduce.energy.consumption,.the.UK.retailer.Marks.&.Spencer.is.selling.a.line.of.clothes.manufactured.with.polyester.from.recycled.bottles.19
Brand.repositioning:.Leverage.environmental.achievements.to.enhance.your.organizational.brand.and.position.your.business.more.firmly.within.the.sphere.of.environmental.responsibility..A.positive.reputation,.based.on.sound.credentials,.can.be.both.an.important.means.of.differentiation.as.well.as.a.method.to.enhance.competitive.advantage..However,.with.raised.expectations.comes.increased.scrutiny.of.performance...
Distinctive capabilitiesTrack.external.developments:.Monitor.changes.in.the.political,.economic,.social.and.technological.arenas.and.assess.those.developments.on.a.regular.basis.to.determine.whether.action.is.necessary.in.light.of.their.implications..Step-changes.
in.the.environmental.agenda.will.occur.only.through.a.confluence.of.political,.economic,.social.and.technological.factors..For.example,.the.potential.of.a.technological.development,.such.as.plug-in.electric.cars.or.hydrogen.fuels,.may.only.be.fully.realized.once.regulatory.support.(in.the.form.of.incentives).makes.widespread.take-up.economically.attractive.to.consumers..Until.all.of.those.factors.align,.change.will.most.likely.be.incremental.at.best..As.part.of.this,.businesses.should.generate.scenarios.around.what.core.operations.and.relations.with.consumers.look.like.in.a.future,.“carbon-constrained”.world..This.can.help.identify.implications.that.might.not.yet.have.been.identified.(see.panel.overleaf,.“Scenario.�0�0”)..
Optimize.supply.chains:.Ensuring.that.a.supply.chain.is.as.efficient.and.environment-friendly.as.possible—perhaps.the.next.frontier.of.managing.climate.change.impacts—offers.the.potential.for.significant.returns..At.the.same.time,.it.requires.concerted.effort.within.a.company’s.own.operations.but.principally.across.the.activities.of.other.companies.operating.in.the.supply.chain..For.example,.an.internal.survey.conducted.at.a.major.UK.newspaper.publisher.found.that.80.percent.of.its.carbon.footprint.was.added.by.processes.and.raw.materials.used.by.other.companies.in.the.supply.chain..This.shows.the.potential.value.to.be.gained.from.a.collaborative.supply.chain.approach.�0..
Deploy.smart.technologies:.Investments.in.new,.more.environmentally-conscious.technologies.such.as.green.data.centers.(which.use.less.energy).are.increasingly.a.source.of.cost.reduction.as.well.as.competitive.advantage..These.technologies.offer.the.promise.of.both.enhanced.reputation.and.more.efficient.delivery.of.services..In.the.utilities.sector,.for.example,.smart.meters.can.provide.real-time.information.to.domestic.consumers.about.the.cost.of.their.energy.use.and.about.areas.of.wastage..This.
Achieving high performance in an era of climate change requires businesses to take a holistic approach that spans the breadth of their value chain as well as the depth of their operating models. Managing the impacts of climate change is as much about effective strategy and culture change as it is about implementing supporting systems and processes. If companies can effectively integrate strategy, people, processes and technology in the pursuit of initiatives that respond to climate change, the result can be a powerful tool of long-term value creation.
![Page 34: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
It.is.the.year.�0�0..The.past.decade.has.seen.the.introduction.of.a.set.of.trends,.ideas.and.actions.in.relation.to.climate.change.that.have.coalesced.to.form.a.very.different.context.for.business.from.that.of.�008..What.does.this.world.look.like.and.what.are.businesses.and.policymakers.doing.differently.to.achieve.high.performance.in.this.altered.landscape?
The.first.thing.that.is.noticeable.is.that.businesses.rarely.talk.any.longer.about.specific.“environmental”.or.“green”.initiatives..In.very.much.the.same.way.that.eCommerce.ceased.to.exist.as.a.discrete.concept.once.it.became.an.everyday.part.of.business,.carbon.strategies.are.now.typically.infused.across.the.entire.organization,.from.manufacturing.and.research,.through.distribution.and.retail,.to.supply.chain.and.finance..Sustainability—encompassing.financial,.geopolitical.and.environment-related.risks.to.the.enterprise—is.the.name.of.the.game.and.is.now.seen.as.a.key.driver.of.high.performance..In.many.organizations.sustainability.is.now.a.central.tenet.underpinning.HR.training.and.processes,.as.well.as.organizational.culture.and.values..Of.course,.not.every.business.has.embraced.such.thinking.or.been.quick.enough.to.respond..Indeed,.those.that.failed.to.respond.to.the.changing.global.environment.in.a.timely.manner.are.typically.struggling.to.recover.lost.ground.
Such.a.shift.did.not.occur.by.accident,.but.through.a.combination.of.regulation,.stakeholder.preferences,.and.business.action..Businesses.have.continued.to.do.what.they.have.always.sought.to.do—maximize.shareholder.value—but.that.goal.is.now.contextualized.within.a.new.set.of.regulatory.constraints.and.stakeholder.concerns..Government.policies.and.regulations.have.been.instrumental.in.providing.the.initial.impulse.to.action..Some.
legislation.occasionally.encountered.stiff.business.resistance,.but.other.regulatory.measures.were.often.introduced.at.the.behest.of.coalitions.of.business.interests.concerned.that.continuing.regulatory.uncertainty.would.act.as.a.barrier.to.increased.investment.and.innovation..
From.�008.onwards.the.regulatory.framework.regarding.climate.change.increasingly.began.to.take.shape,.framed.by.national.preferences.and.economic.models..Some.countries.favored.direct.intervention.in.markets,.such.as.standard-setting.and.controls.on.emissions..Others.opted.for.more.market-based.mechanisms.such.as.taxes.and.subsidies.to.shift.consumption.to.less.carbon-intensive.activities.and.to.stimulate.innovation..Businesses.operating.across.borders.had.to.become.increasingly.adept.at.navigating.a.maze.of.different.regulatory.regimes,.though.there.was.some.limited.convergence.of.cross-border.regulations.under.pressure.from.businesses.wanting.a.level.playing.field.for.international.competition..
Hybrid.mechanisms.such.as.carbon.cap-and-trade.schemes.have.become.increasingly.common,.with.carbon.allocations.progressively.tightened.over.time.to.meet.international.emissions.targets.and.to.encourage.carbon-efficient.production.via.a.progressively.higher.price.of.carbon..Initially.established.on.a.local,.national.or.(as.in.the.European.Union).regional.basis,.these.schemes.have.grown.in.scope.and.scale..Today,.in.�0�0,.they.are.gradually.meshing.together.into.larger.regional.and.even.international.systems..This.development.has.yielded.a.significant.improvement.in.the.liquidity.of.carbon.emission.markets,.as.well.as.a.variety.of.secondary.markets.in.carbon-related.derivatives.and.options.to.help.businesses.hedge.and.manage.climate-change-related.risks.
Businesses.have.responded.in.a.variety.of.ways.to.the.new.competitive.context.wrought.by.regulation.and.changing.stakeholder.preferences.surrounding.climate.change..Some.businesses.have.limited.their.efforts.to.compliance.strategies,.working.to.anticipate.changes.in.the.regulatory.landscape.and.mitigate.future.risks.through.options.and.hedging.mechanisms..Others.have.gone.further,.harnessing.the.new.context.as.a.force.for.innovation.within.their.businesses—new.product.adaptations.and.business.models,.for.example..A.much.smaller.number.have.assumed.a.leadership.position.as.flagship.sustainable.businesses,.moving.beyond.compliance.and.innovation.to.reshape.the.competitive.context,.often.entering.adjacent.markets.or.creating.entirely.new.ones..The.actions.of.these.leading.companies.have.influenced.the.nature.of.regulation..At.the.same.time,.regulation.has.become.less.relevant.to.them,.because.the.market.increasingly.provides.technological.and.commercial.solutions.to.the.constraints.imposed.by.a.carbon-conscious.world..
In.fact,.technology.now.underpins.many.of.the.mechanisms.and.services.that.have.been.designed.to.reduce.emissions.or.manage.carbon-related.activities.more.efficiently..City.planners.now.talk.about.the.“smart.municipality,”.where.information.technology.and.advanced.urban.planning.techniques.are.combined.to.ensure.the.optimum.flows.of.energy.and.traffic.within.the.city.area..In.the.electricity.industry,.innovations.such.as.smart.metering.and.micro.combined-heat-and-power—which.allows.households.and.small.businesses.to.generate.electricity.as.a.byproduct.of.heating.and.then.sell.their.surplus.power.to.the.grid—are.now.commonplace..Information.technology.is.also.reducing.the.carbon.impact.of.automobile.traffic.through.traffic.management.systems.within.larger.metropolitan.areas..
Scenario 2020: One vision of a carbon-conscious future
3�
![Page 35: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
33
technology.can.help.to.reduce.overall.energy.consumption.as.well.as.provide.a.significant.business.opportunity.to.appropriately-incentivized.service.providers..
Performance anatomyEnsure.senior-level.ownership:.Setting.the.agenda.from.the.top.is.important.if.businesses.are.to.manage.the.impact.of.climate.change.in.a.coherent.and.proactive.way..Environmentally.based.initiatives.need.to.receive.senior-level.sponsorship.as.well.as.visible.signs.of.support.and.regular.communications.on.progress.
Drive.human.performance:.Companies.that.will.be.most.effective.in.achieving.high.performance.in.an.era.of.climate.change.will.be.those.that.distribute.environmental.responsibility.and.decision-making.throughout.their.organizations,.down.to.the.lowest.appropriate.level.but.guided.by.strong.leadership..Managing.the.performance.of.people.effectively.in.light.of.climate.change.will.require.companies.to.refine.their.employee.performance.measures.to.reward.activities.and.innovations.that.promote.the.organization’s.environmental.agenda.and.credentials.
Create.a.culture.of.carbon.consciousness:.Managing.the.business.impacts.of.climate.change.in.the.pursuit.of.high.performance.requires.companies.to.adopt.more.effective.collective.thinking..Ensuring.that.the.appropriate.organizational.mindsets.are.held.by.all.employees.will.support.the.more.operational.responses.that.businesses.need.to.take.and.will.help.them.make.more.informed.decisions.on.future.options..While.variations.among.industries.may.exist,.the.mindsets.needed.to.achieve.high.performance.in.an.era.of.climate.change.can.broadly.be.summarized.as.follows:
•.Carbon.impacts.are.not.an.overhead—they.need.to.be.factored.into.every.stage.of.the.value.chain,.just.as.any.other.type.of.expenditure.would.be..
Only.then.will.an.attentiveness.to.climate.change.become.a.routine.facet.of.everyday.business..
•.The.customer.is.always.right..An.executive’s.opinion.about.the.science.of.climate.change.is.secondary.to.consumer.perceptions.and.governmental.action..If.the.perceived.impacts.of.climate.change.are.important.to.governments.and.consumers,.they.should.be.important.to.a.business..
•.Employees.should.be.empowered..Environmental.stewardship.is.an.increasingly.powerful.motivator.behind.recruitment.decisions.and.subsequent.employee.performance..High.levels.of.engagement.among.employees.regarding.environmental.issues.should.be.harnessed,.so.that.climate.change.issues.become.an.integral.way.of.doing.business,.rather.than.a.corporate.overhead.undertaken.by.a.discrete.element.within.the.organization..
•.Higher.stretch.goals.should.be.set..Businesses.are.already.falling.into.the.trap.of.under-appreciating.the.business.opportunities.presented.by.climate.change..Undertaking.more.forward-looking.and.wide-ranging.innovations.could.help.businesses.examine.a.broader.range.of.strategic.opportunities.open.to.them..
The.journey.toward.high.performance.in.an.era.of.climate.change.is.unlikely.to.be.straightforward..Shifting.regulation,.changing.consumer.behaviors.and.new.technologies.are.just.some.of.the.factors.that.are.changing.the.environment.in.which.businesses.are.operating..Being.able.to.track.and.preempt.these.developments.will.give.businesses.significant.competitive.advantage..
Businesses.need.to.be.proactive.in.developing.the.capabilities.needed.to.succeed.in.an.era.of.climate.change..If.they.can.develop.the.right.cultural.mindsets—strengthened.by.organizational.processes.and.approaches—they.will.be.well.placed.to.achieve.high.performance.in.the.carbon-constrained.world.of.the.future.
![Page 36: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Appendix— Country Stories
34
![Page 37: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
35
China
Summary:.Mindful.of.not.slowing.economic.growth.and.looking.to.the.government.to.take.a.lead.in.combating.climate.change.
Emerging.economies.have.experienced.substantial.economic.growth.fueled.by.overall.growth.in.energy.consumption,.and.China.is.no.exception..China’s.huge.economy.and.large.manufacturing.sector.mean.that.heavy.use.of.fossil.fuels.will.continue..Currently,.for.example,.a.new.coal-fired.power.station.opens.in.China.every.10.days.�1.However,.there.are.now.serious.efforts.around.the.country.to.promote.and.expand.renewable.energy..For.example,.Beijing.now.has.one.of.the.largest.fleets.of.compressed.natural.gas.(CNG).buses.in.the.world,.with.more.than.�,000.CNG.engines.��.At.the.Asia-Pacific.Economic.Cooperation.summit.in.September.�007,.China.increased.its.international.visibility.in.the.climate.change.arena.as.leaders.signed.an.agreement.on.tackling.climate.change,.though.without.binding.commitments.�3.
The.Chinese.business.leaders.interviewed.in.our.survey.generally.did.not.cite.climate.change.as.a.top.strategic.priority,.with.only.�.percent.placing.it.among.their.top.three..Sixty-six.percent.of.those.surveyed.are.currently.taking.no.action.in.response.to.climate.change.(see.Figure.�0),.and.70.percent.have.no.plans.to.do.so.within.the.next.five.years...
Nearly.half.of.Chinese.businesses.are.struggling.to.understand.the.implications.of.climate.change.and.are.therefore.looking.to.the.government.to.shape.and.formulate.any.response.in.the.short-.and.medium-term..The.majority.of.businesses.prefer.a.government-led.approach.to.regulation.(see.Figure.�1),.and.the.general.feeling.among.those.surveyed.is.that.the.most.positive.approach.to.climate.change.will.be.either.
wholly.or.partially.government-driven..In.this.vein,.66.percent.believe.that.implementation.of.a.green.tax.is.likely,.and.84.percent.believe.that.government-funded.incentives.to.use.renewable.energy.or.low.carbon.energy.are.likely.
It.is.here.that.China.has.the.potential.to.leapfrog.other.countries.in.alternative.solutions..Indeed,.it.has.already.made.significant.steps.in.becoming.one.of.the.world’s.leading.users.of.solar.energy,.particularly.in.water.heating..Cities.such.as.Rizhao.in.Shandong.province,.where.about.99.percent.
of.city-center.residents.use.solar.energy.for.water.heating,.provide.a.model.of.urban.development.that.can.be.rolled.out.across.China,.supported.by.the.government..In.�005,.the.use.of.solar.hot.water.in.China.exceeded.that.of.the.rest.of.the.world.combined.and.led.to.a.small.offset.of.carbon.emissions.�4
Figure 20: Businesses with no current climate change initiatives underway (%)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
All
Figure 21: Businesses preferring a government-led approach to regulation (%)
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
All
![Page 38: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
36
Germany
Summary:.Confident.of.its.lead.in.response.to.climate.change.and.focused.on.aggressive.emissions.targets..
Holder.of.the.European.Union.presidency.in.the.first.half.of.�007.and.the.G8.Summit.presidency.throughout.�007,.Germany.has.been.well.placed.to.set.the.international.agenda.on.climate.change..Chancellor.Angela.Merkel’s.tough.stance.on.energy.security.and.climate.change.as.the.top.two.priorities.for.Germany’s.EU.presidency.stems.from.a.position.of.strength:.Germany.is.well.on.the.way.to.achieving.the.proposed.EU.target.of.�0.percent.of.primary.energy.coming.from.renewable.sources.by.�0�0.
The.actions.of.German.businesses.seem.to.mirror.their.government’s.environmental.message:.6.percent.cited.climate.change.as.their.top.strategic.priority,.17.percent.listed.it.in.their.top.three,.and.a.majority.see.it.as.continuing.to.be.a.major.issue.over.the.next.five.years..Across.a.range.of.survey.findings,.German.businesses.seem.to.demonstrate.a.certain.confidence.that.they.are.well.ahead.of.their.international.counterparts.in.this.area.
This.confidence.is.well.founded,.with.a.number.of.notable.successes..In.�00�,.three.years.ahead.of.schedule,.DB.(German.Railways).achieved.its.aim.of.reducing.energy.consumption.to.one-quarter.of.1990.levels.and.has.already.set.aggressive.new.targets.of.a.further.15.to.�0.percent.reduction.by.�0�0.�5.This.focus.on.efficiency.is.supported.by.our.survey.findings,.which.showed.that.61.percent.of.companies.are.currently.undertaking.initiatives.in.technologies.to.improve.energy.efficiency.
German.progress.in.creating.new.technologies.that.capitalize.on.climate.change.is.supported.by.generous.government.funding..The.
Federal.Research.Ministry.intends.to.intensify.research.activities.that.focus.on.new.technologies.and.manufacturing.opportunities.arising.from.climate.change.by.providing.€�34.million.(US$345.million).over.the.next.10.years.�6.This.emphasis.is.already.reaping.rewards:.a.third.of.all.solar.cells.and.almost.half.of.all.wind.turbines.in.the.world.are.produced.in.Germany.�7.Our.survey.respondents.identified.developing.new.energy.saving/renewable.products.and.the.development.of.new.technologies.as.the.future.top.business.opportunities.presented.by.climate.change..
While.it.is.clear.that.the.German.government.is.a.keen.advocate.of.action.on.climate.change,.German.businesses.actually.cited.shareholders.as.the.most.influential.stakeholder.in.their.response.to.climate.change.(see.Figure.��)..Businesses.are.also.looking.elsewhere.for.inspiration,.with.a.high.proportion.(78.percent).currently.working.with.one.or.more.external.organizations.to.address.the.issue.(see.Figure.�3).
All
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Figure 22: Businesses citing shareholders as influential in the corporate response to climate change (%)
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
None
Other
NGOs/ environmental groups
research institutions/academia
Consultants
Suppliers
Government
Industry bodies
Germany Survey average
Figure 23: German businesses working with external partners on climate change (%)
![Page 39: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
37
India
Summary:.Interested.in.the.potential.of.new.technologies.and.adopting.a.tough.international.stance.on.climate.change.
Like.China,.India.faces.considerable.pressure.on.environmental.issues.due.to.rapid.industrialization,.urbanization,.and.economic.development..With.its.large.and.growing.population,.the.economy.is.closely.tied.to.its.natural-resource.base..
The.Indian.government.has.begun.to.take.action..India.already.has.one.of.the.world’s.largest.renewable.energy.programs,.with.approximately.6.percent.of.its.electricity.transmission.grid.capacity.based.on.renewables—compared.with.less.than.1.percent.in.China.and.around.�.percent.in.the.United.States.�8.But.with.the.average.Indian.citizen.producing.one-tenth.of.the.carbon.emissions.of.the.average.European.and.one-twentieth.of.the.average.American,�9.and.with.roughly.one.quarter.of.India’s.population.living.below.the.poverty.line,.seeking.a.balance.between.economic.growth.and.energy.use.will.not.be.easy.30.
Among.the.businesses.surveyed,.only.4.percent.mentioned.climate.change.as.their.top.strategic.priority,.and.just.1�.percent.mentioned.it.at.all..However,.70.percent.foresee.that.climate.change.will.be.a.major.issue.for.their.business.in.the.next.five.years..
India.is.certainly.interested.in.the.new.technologies.that.may.be.developed.in.response.to.climate.change.and.in.gaining.competitive.finance.for.clean.technologies.through.the.world.trading.system.in.carbon.emissions..This.market.is.worth.approximately.US$�.billion.annually.in.the.developing. Survey averageIndia
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Major issue now Major issue in next five years
Top three strategic priority
Figure 24: Businesses advocating new technology as a key to dealing with climate change (%)
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
All
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Figure 25: Indian businesses viewing climate change as a major issue now; in five years; a top three strategic priority (%)
world.31.Seventy-two.percent.of.our.survey.respondents.in.India.are.keen.on.technologies.to.improve.energy.efficiency.and.8�.percent.said.they.believe.that.new.technologies.provide.the.key.to.dealing.with.climate.change.(see.Figure.�4)..Accordingly,.more.than.half.said.that.climate.change.would.offer.them.many.new.business.opportunities..
India.is.perhaps.uniquely.vulnerable.among.the.rapidly.industrializing.nations.to.the.impact.of.possible.changing.weather.patterns.(food.security,.flooding.and.rising.sea.levels,.increased.breeding.grounds.for.malarial.mosquitoes)..Awareness.of.climate.change.issues.is.therefore.critical,.and.it.is.a.message.that.business.seems.to.be.heeding.(see.Figure.�5)..
![Page 40: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
38
Japan
Summary:.Already.highly.energy-efficient.and.confident.in.the.new.technologies.associated.with.combating.climate.change.
Over.the.last.two.decades.Japan.has.positioned.itself.as.one.of.the.leading.nations.in.tackling.climate.change..Despite.its.high.global.ranking.in.terms.of.total.energy.consumption.and.its.well-publicized.struggle.to.meet.its.Kyoto.emissions.reduction.targets,.Japan.has.a.low.per-capita.energy.consumption.level.and.is.one.of.the.least.energy-intensive.countries.in.the.developed.world.3�.Emissions.in.Japan.are.expected.to.increase.only.by.0.1.percent.per.year.from.�004.to.�030,.reflecting.the.overall.maturity.of.Japan’s.energy.infrastructure.33.This.energy.efficiency.is.due.largely.to.government-mandated.energy-savings.initiatives.and.strong.environmental.policies.encouraging.the.adoption.of.new,.efficient.technologies.
This.strong.governmental.role.is.reflected.in.the.fact.that.about.a.third.of.businesses.cited.government.as.the.prime.influence.on.their.response.to.climate.change.(see.Figure.�6)..This.influence.has.evidently.been.real:.95.percent.of.all.Japanese.businesses.surveyed.had.at.least.one.climate.change.initiative.in.place—the.highest.proportion.of.any.country.represented.in.our.study..Almost.half.have.taken.steps.to.measure.or.reduce.their.carbon.footprint,.and.more.than.one-third.are.involved.in.carbon.offsetting...
The.combined.strength.of.businesses.and.government.has.also.been.witnessed.in.the.Japanese.Voluntary.Emissions.Trading.Scheme.(JVETS),.which.was.established.in.May.�005.and.now.has.89.participants.34.By.subsidizing.the.cost.of.reduction,.this.voluntary.scheme.provides.economic.incentives.to.companies.that.achieve.self-determined.emission.reduction.targets...
Innovation.and.technology.are.themes.that.run.through.Japanese.business.
Figure 26: Businesses that consider government to be the prime influence on their response to climate change (%)
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
All
Figure 27: Businesses seeing new commercial opportunities from climate change and identifying themselves as innovators (%)
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
Identify themselves as innovators See new business opportunities
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
All
culture,.and.its.responses.to.climate.change.prove.no.exception..Forty-one.percent.of.Japanese.businesses.consider.themselves.to.be.innovators.compared.with.their.peers.and.39.percent.think.that.climate.change.will.open.up.many.new.opportunities.(see.Figure.�7)..Eighty-one.percent.think.new.technologies.provide.the.key.to.dealing.with.climate.change..This.sense.of.forward-looking.innovation.has.already.helped.Japan.position.itself.as.one.of.the.world’s.preeminent.exporters.of.new.technology,.with.its.automotive.industry.taking.the.lead.in.developing.hybrid.and.alternative-energy-powered.cars.
Looking.to.the.future,.Japan.has.announced.the.“Invitation.to.Cool.Earth.50”.initiative,.which.proposes.a.global.target.of.cutting.emissions.by.half.from.�007.levels.by.�050.35.Climate.change.will.be.high.on.the.agenda.of.the.G8.summit.in.�008,.which.Japan.will.host..Being.prepared.to.tackle.climate.change.is.critical.to.Japan,.owing.partly.to.its.vulnerability.to.changing.weather.patterns.and.partly.to.the.business.opportunities.that.climate.change.might.present.
![Page 41: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
39
United Kingdom
Summary:.Confident.it.is.ahead.of.the.curve.on.climate.change.but.still.seeking.greater.clarity.and.direction.on.future.regulation.
Climate.change.is.high.on.the.agenda.for.all.political.parties.in.the.United.Kingdom..Tough.targets.have.been.proposed—60.percent.reduction.in.emissions.from.1990.levels.by.�050—and.a.strong.leadership.role.on.climate.change.within.the.European.Union.has.been.established..Businesses.in.the.United.Kingdom.have,.for.the.most.part,.backed.this.position,.seeming.to.agree.that.“investment.in.preventing.[climate.change].now.will.pay.us.back.many.times”.(Tony.Blair,.former.UK.prime.minister,.�007).36.
As.shown.in.Figure.�8,.more.than.one-quarter.of.all.UK.businesses.consider.climate.change.to.be.a.top-three.strategic.priority—far.higher.than.any.other.market—and.80.percent.believe.it.will.be.a.major.issue.for.their.businesses.within.the.next.five.years..A.very.low.proportion.consider.climate.change.to.be.over-hyped,.and.85.percent.feel.they.have.a.responsibility.to.help.tackle.its.implications..A.clear.picture.is.building.of.UK.businesses.being.concerned.with.the.issue,.and.our.survey.suggests.that.they.are.taking.an.active.approach..Almost.nine.out.of.10.businesses.have.some.climate-change-related.initiative.in.place,.with.more.than.half.having.taken.steps.to.measure.or.reduce.their.carbon.footprint..UK.businesses.see.themselves.as.ahead.of.the.curve,.with.45.percent.considering.themselves.to.be.innovators.in.this.field.
Driving.these.businesses.to.act.are.government.(mentioned.by.53.percent.of.respondents),.consumers.(39.percent),.shareholders.(36.percent).and.employees.(3�.percent)..Businesses.are.looking.to.the.government.to.provide.a.clear.long-term.regulatory.framework.within.which.to.develop.policy.and.
Figure 28: Businesses that view climate change as a strategic priority (%)
First strategic Priority Second or third strategic priority
All
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Figure 29: Respondents agreeing with the statement: “Businesses struggling to understand the implications of climate change” (%)
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
All
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
implement.initiatives.to.tackle.the.implications.of.climate.change..The.UK’s.Corporate.Leaders.Group.on.Climate.Change.believes.that.“there.is.an.urgent.need.to.develop.new.and.longer-term.policies.for.tackling.climate.change.”37
However,.the.picture.is.not.entirely.positive..UK.businesses.see.a.number.of.challenges.ahead,.with.“changing.internal.behaviors”.the.most.frequently.cited..Businesses.do.not.fully.understand.all.of.the.implications.of.climate.change.(see.Figure.�9),.with.only.14.percent.feeling.they.had.a.clear.view.on.this..
UK.businesses.are.keen.to.act.and.committed.to.working.with.their.customers.and.the.government..At.the.moment,.though,.they.do.not.have.the.clarity.they.need.to.make.big.investment.decisions..
![Page 42: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
40
United States
Summary:.Building.up.a.critical.mass.of.state.legislation.and.increasingly.active.in.addressing.climate.change.
Individual.US.states.have,.to.date,.been.foremost.in.driving.innovative.responses.to.climate.change..California,.Florida.and.a.corridor.of.northeastern.states.in.particular.have.been.in.the.vanguard..The.key.issue.for.the.United.States.is.whether.this.groundswell.of.state-led.initiatives.will.gather.enough.strength.to.tip.the.balance.toward.establishing.a.federal.framework..
In.January.�007.the.Edison.Electric.Institute.(the.US.trade.association.for.shareholder-owned.electricity.companies).called.for.regulation.on.carbon.emissions—although.stopped.short.of.asking.for.them.to.be.made.mandatory.38.At.the.same.time,.10.blue-chip.companies,.in.cooperation.with.four.leading.NGOs,.formed.the.United.States.Climate.Change.Action.Partnership.and.called.for.“strong”.federal.action.to.combat.climate.change.39.In.looking.for.this.clear.direction,.US.businesses.hope.to.see.a.collaborative.approach.between.industry.and.government;.6�.percent.of.US.respondents.said.they.wanted.to.see.a.balance.between.market-.and.government-driven.approaches..
The.appetite.for.clear.government.direction.is.almost.certainly.a.response.to.business.concerns.about.different.approaches.developing.across.the.United.States,.which.are.much.harder.to.manage.than.a.nationwide.system..Thirty-three.percent.of.those.surveyed.said.that.coping.with.new.regulation.was.the.greatest.challenge.posed.by.climate.change.(see.Figure.30).
US.businesses.feel.a.strong.sense.of.responsibility.to.help.manage.the.impact.of.climate.change.(see.Figure.31).and.in.many.areas.their.outlook.is.positive..Seventy-eight.percent.of.US.respondents.thought.that.incentives.
(financial.or.non-financial).to.use.renewable.energy.were.more.likely.than.taxation..Furthermore,.US.businesses.have.not.been.slow.to.recognize.the.potential.for.increased.energy.efficiency.through.new.technologies:.Sixty-seven.percent.of.respondents.were.taking.up.new.technologies.to.improve.energy.efficiency.and.6�.percent.said.they.believed.that.new.technologies.provide.the.key.to.dealing.with.climate.change.
Figure 30: Businesses that view “coping with new regulations” to be a significant challenge in responding to climate change (%)
Most important challenge Second most important challenge
China
India
US
Germany
Japan
UK
All
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Figure 31: US businesses agreeing with the statement: “My business has a responsibility to help manage the impact of climate change” (%)
Agree
59%21%
20%
Disagree
Neither agree nor disagree
![Page 43: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
All China Germany India Japan UK US
Awareness & concernWhat.are.the.top.three.strategic.priorities.for.your.business.out.of.the.following.list?.(%).War.for.Talent. 39 68 �0 �6 74 14 35
Increasing.the.level.of.capital.allocation 9 1� 4 6 7 10 1�
Developing.new.products.and.services. 45 4� 47 60 47 39 43
Growth.in.emerging.markets. �9 44 38 4� 15 34 15
Climate.Change. 16 � 17 1� 13 �6 18
Innovation �8 34 38 3� 14 �4 �8
Technology 18 �8 �0 30 9 8 �4
Sales.growth. 47 �6 48 46 46 55 47
Cost.reduction 46 34 53 40 6� 37 41
Regulation. 13 10 6 6 11 16 �4
Do.you.agree/disagree.that.climate.change.is.currently.a.major.issue.for.your.business?.(%)Strongly.agree 19 � 17 �6 17 �5 ��
Agree �6 �� �� �8 33 35 17
Neither.agree.nor.disagree �8 �0 33 �4 30 �8 �5
Disagree 18 48 18 14 13 10 16
Strongly.disagree 9 8 11 6 6 � 19
Do.you.agree/disagree.that.climate.change.will.become.a.major.issue.for.your.business.in.the.next.five.years?.(%).Strongly.agree �3 4 18 3� 18 34 �5
Agree. 36 16 36 38 37 46 37
Neither.agree.nor.disagree 18 �� �5 16 �3 11 16
Disagree 14 50 10 8 15 7 8
Strongly.disagree 7 8 8 4 6 � 14
Action & initiativesWhat.initiatives.are.currently.undertaken.by.the.company.relating.to.climate.change?.(%)New.products.and.services �4 6 5 64 11 30 41
Consumer.information. 19 � �� 44 � �5 �8
Supply.chain.reconfiguration. 17 � 13 30 8 �8 �5
Technologies.to.improve.energy.efficiency. 53 4 61 7� 50 51 67
Increasing.the.use.of.renewable.energy.sources. 3� � 4� 3� �� 33 47
Measuring.and/or.reducing.your.CO�.footprint. 39 6 36 36 47 55 36
Internal.policy.formulation. �8 0 �8 48 11 34 46
Carbon.offset.strategy. �9 6 30 40 34 �1 36
Employee.training/.communications.strategy. �7 � 3� 66 9 33 �8Other.initiatives. 10 16 7 0 3 �1 10
Statistical Appendix
41
![Page 44: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
All China Germany India Japan UK US
DriversWhat.is.the.most.significant.challenge.facing.your.business.in.response.to.climate.change?.(%)Changing.internal.behaviors. �4 �4 14 3� �3 4� 17
Re-engineering.internal..business.processes.and.systems 9 16 7 18 7 6 6Introducing.new.technologies �5 30 41 3� 19 17 17
Updating.performance.metrics 4 4 � � 5 0 10
Coping.with.new.regulations �0 4 17 10 31 15 33
Managing.stakeholder.expectations..(e.g.,.consumers,.shareholders.etc.) 15 16 18 6 15 15 15Others 1 0 � 0 0 1 0
Which.of.your.stakeholders.are.influential.in.terms.of.your.company’s.response.to.climate.change?.(total.mentions)Shareholders. 36 36 60 �� �0 36 30
Employees �� � 13 �0 30 3� �5
Suppliers 9 8 4 8 18 10 5
Consumers 41 �8 35 50 4� 39 44
National.government 47 56 44 58 51 47 41
Local.government 18 36 7 �4 �1 6 �6
Media 4 1� 5 � 3 � �
NGOs � 0 � � 3 3 �
Members.of.the.public.at.large. 13 6 �4 1� 8 7 15
Advocacy.groups 3 � 3 � � 0 8
Other.(please.specify). 3 10 � 0 � 9 1
Regulatory environmentHow.likely.is.it.that.tax.on.high-energy.products.and.services.will.be.implemented.in.your.country?.(%)Very.likely �0 30 36 14 5 �6 13
Likely 34 36 �7 34 50 30 �4
Neither.likely.nor.unlikely �1 �0 18 �6 �� 14 �9
Not.likely 14 10 9 16 18 11 �0
Not.at.all.likely 6 4 4 10 5 � 1�
Already.in.existence 5 0 6 0 0 15 1
How.likely.is.it.that.incentives.to.use.renewable.energy/low.carbon.technology.will.be.implemented.in..your.country?.(%).Very.likely 3� 46 �5 34 34 �5 38
Likely 4� 38 36 44 55 35 40
Neither.likely.nor.unlikely 1� 4 19 1� 4 �0 11
Not.likely 5 � 6 4 � 11 4
Not.at.all.likely 1 0 � 4 1 � 0
Already.in.existence 7 10 13 � 4 6 7
4�
![Page 45: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
All China Germany India Japan UK US
How.likely.is.it.that.consumer.information.schemes.will.be.implemented.in.your.country?.(%).Very.likely �5 �4 �8 �� �� �5 �6
Likely 33 3� �0 46 41 �7 38
Neither.likely.nor.unlikely �� �0 �4 16 �5 �4 �0
Not.likely 9 10 17 4 5 9 9
Not.at.all.likely 3 � 5 4 � � 3
Already.in.existence 7 1� 7 8 5 11 3
How.likely.is.it.that.cap-and-trade.schemes.will.be.implemented.in.your.country?.(%)Very.likely 19 �8 15 �8 17 17 17
Likely �7 50 �� 1� 30 �5 �9
Neither.likely.nor.unlikely �� 4 18 �6 31 �0 �8
Not.likely 13 10 11 18 10 17 16
Not.at.all.likely 5 � 6 10 5 0 7
Already.in.existence 13 6 �9 6 7 19 3
How.likely.is.it.that.targets.to.reduce.carbon.emissions/carbon.content.will.be.implemented.in.your.country?.(%)Very.likely �6 �8 19 �8 30 33 ��
Likely 39 5� �9 4� 4� 31 4�
Neither.likely.nor.unlikely 17 14 �6 16 8 18 19
Not.likely 7 � 1� 8 5 3 8
Not.at.all.likely � � 3 4 0 0 5
Already.in.existence 9 � 11 � 15 15 3
GeneralTo.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.Climate.change.will.revolutionize.my.industry.over.the.next..five.years.(%).Strongly.agree 6 0 4 � 3 14 7
Agree. 17 4 10 38 16 �5 10
Neither.agree.nor.disagree 30 16 �8 �6 38 �7 36
Disagree �5 48 �4 �4 �8 �4 14
Strongly.disagree �3 3� 34 10 15 10 33
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.Climate.change.will.increase.the.cost.of.doing.business.(%)Strongly.agree �0 6 �1 16 �� �5 �6
Agree 47 5� 50 64 56 3� 35
Neither.agree.nor.disagree 17 18 19 6 13 30 13
Disagree 1� �0 7 10 5 13 �0
Strongly.disagree 4 4 4 4 4 0 6
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.Climate.change.will.open.up.many.new.opportunities.for..my.business.(%)Strongly.agree 10 8 9 6 8 10 1�
Agree �9 38 �1 46 31 �3 �6
Neither.agree.nor.disagree �6 �0 30 18 �7 �8 �5
Disagree �� 30 �0 �4 �4 �6 16
Strongly.disagree 14 4 �1 6 10 13 �1
43
![Page 46: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
All China Germany India Japan UK US
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.My.business.is.well.positioned.to.deal.with.climate.change.(%)Strongly.agree 1� � 18 4 8 10 19
Agree 30 1� 4� 48 �� 30 19
Neither.agree.nor.disagree 31 �0 �8 34 3� 4� �9
Disagree 19 50 8 10 �9 14 �0
Strongly.disagree 8 16 4 4 9 4 13
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.Climate.Change.is.over-hyped.(%)Strongly.agree. 7 0 7 0 � 9 17
Agree. 13 �0 1� �� 11 5 18
Neither.agree.nor.disagree �0 �4 15 �0 30 16 17
Disagree 34 4� �5 48 4� 38 �0
Strongly.disagree �6 14 4� 10 15 30 �8
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.Business.is.failing.to.take.a.lead.on.climate.change.(%)Strongly.agree 6 8 3 � 10 6 8
Agree. 3� 54 19 40 37 �� 3�
Neither.agree.nor.disagree �8 10 33 �0 31 34 �7
Disagree �5 �4 �9 30 �0 31 �1
Strongly.disagree 8 4 16 8 � 5 11
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.New.technology.provides.the.key.to.dealing.with.climate.change.(%)Strongly.agree 19 4 30 16 �0 1� �0
Agree. 49 58 44 66 61 35 4�
Neither.agree.nor.disagree �� 18 16 1� 18 36 �8
Disagree 8 16 7 6 1 1� 8
Strongly.disagree � 4 3 0 0 5 �
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.Businesses.are.struggling.to.understand.the.implications.of..climate.change.(%)Strongly.agree 13 0 10 4 8 19 �6
Agree. 40 44 18 50 41 44 5�
Neither.agree.nor.disagree �4 �� �5 18 36 �4 11
Disagree 17 �8 34 �� 11 14 4
Strongly.disagree 6 6 14 6 4 0 7
To.what.extent.do.you.agree.with.the.statement:.My.business.has.a.responsibility.to.help.manage.the.impact.of..climate.change.(%)Strongly.agree �4 16 �0 8 �5 41 �7
Agree. 43 56 34 70 39 44 3�
Neither.agree.nor.disagree 19 1� �� 10 �6 14 �0
Disagree 9 8 19 10 8 0 10
Strongly.disagree 5 8 6 � � 1 11
44
![Page 47: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
45
References1. For.subsequent.industry.analyses,.
government.agencies.have.been.excluded.from.the.findings.to.reflect.better.the.business.response.to.climate.change.
�..The.Stern.Review.on.the.Economics.of.Climate.Change,.�006.
3..The.Economist,.“Green.Shoots,”.January.19,.�007.
4. Accenture.end-consumer.survey.on.climate.change,.�007..
5.. Ibid,.p.16..6..US.National.Marketing.Institute.
report,.�005.7..Ethical.Investment.Research.Services.
(EIRIS),.December.�005,.www.gaeia.co.uk.
8..Goldman.Sachs.Research,.“Introducing.GS.Sustain,”.June.��,.�007.
9..Net.Impact.report,.�006..10..The.Financial.Times,.“Aldersgate.
group.open.letter.to.Gordon.Brown,”.November.13,.�007,.p.17..
11..Der.Spiegel,.“Ökobranche.jubelt.über.hohen.Ölpreis,”.November.6,.�007.
1�..Corporate.Leaders.on.Climate.Change,.“Letter.to.President.Barroso,”.November.�7,.�006.
13.United.States.Climate.Action.Partnership.(USCAP),.“A.call.for.action,”.�007,.p.10.
14..UK.Department.for.Environment.Food.and.Rural.Affairs.(DEFRA).website,.“UK.Legislation:.taking.the.Climate.Change.Bill.forward,”.November.��,.�007,.www.defra.gov.uk.
15.Green.Fiscal.Commission.website,.www.greenfiscalcommission.org.uk..
16.The.discussion.of.emissions.trading.schemes.in.this.section.draws.on.a.presentation.by.the.United.Kingdom.Department.for.the.Environment,.Food.and.Rural.Affairs.(DEFRA),.European.Union.Emissions.Trading.Scheme,.July.16,.�007..
17..Stern.Review,.op..cit.,.p.311.and.p.3�9..
18..Ministry.for.the.Environment,.New.Zealand,.“How.a.New.Zealand.Emissions.Trading.Scheme.will.work,”.September.�007;.International.Energy.Agency,.Climate.Change.Policy.Database;.Aftenposten,.“Norway.claims.tough.CO�.scheme,”.March.8,.�007.
19..Marks.&.Spencer.website,.www.marksandspencer.com..
�0.The.Carbon.Trust,.“Carbon.footprints.in.the.supply.chain:.the.next.step.for.business,”.November.�006,.p.15..
�1.International.Energy.Agency,.World.Energy.Outlook,.�007.
��.Ecoworld,.“Hydrogen.Power.in.China:.Will.Fuel.Cells.Ever.Be.Clean,.Cheap,.Efficient?,”.October.15,.�004.
�3..Environmental.News.Network,.“India.and.China.sign.deal.to.stabilize.greenhouse.gases,”.November.1�,.�007.
�4..New.Scientist,.“The.Sun.King,”.November.�007,.p..54;.Renewable.Energy.Policy.Network.for.the.�1st.Century,.Renewables.Global.Status.Report.�006.Update..
�5..Responding.to.Climate.Change.(RTCC),.Transport.and.climate.change,.International.Union.of.Railways.(UIC),.�007.
�6..German.Embassy.Washington.website,.“Merkel:.Joint.Action.Needed.to.Counteract.Climate.Change,”.April.10,.�007,.www.germany.info..
�7..German.Embassy.Canberra.website,.“Economy.News:.Green.Champions,”.March.�007,.www.germanembassy.org.au.
�8..SciDevNet,.“India’s.pragmatic.approach.to.climate.change,”.August.31,.�006.
�9..Centre.for.Social.Markets,.“Climate.Change—Why.India.needs.to.take.leadership,”.August.�007,.p.8.
30.Central.Intelligence.Agency.(CIA),.The.World.Factbook,.�007.
31..Guardian.Unlimited,.”Stern.tackles.climate.change.for.India,”.January.18,.�007.
3�..National.Council.for.Science.and.the.Environment,.Energy.Profile.of.Japan,.December.�006.
33..United.States.Energy.Information.Administration,.International.Energy.Outlook.�007,.May.�007...
34..Reuters,.“Factbox:.Carbon.trading.schemes.around.the.world,”.June.1,.�007;.Ministry.of.the.Environment,.Japan,.Presentation.on.Japan’s.Voluntary.Emission.Trading.Scheme.(JVETS),.January.17,.�007.
35..”Invitation.to.“Cool.Earth.50”.-.3.proposals,.3.principles,”.speech.by.prime.minister.Shinzo.Abe,.May.�4,.�007.
36..UK.prime.minister.Tony.Blair’s.comments.at.the.launch.of.the.Stern.Review,.October.�006.
37..Corporate.Leaders.Group.on.Climate.Change.website,.�007,..www.cpi.cam.ac.uk..
38..Edison.Electric.Group,.“Electric.perspectives,”.May/June.�00�..
39.United.States.Climate.Action.Partnership.website,.www.us-cap.org.
![Page 48: Achieving High Performance in an Era of Climate Change - Accenture … · 2010-09-09 · Accenture surveyed more than 500 business leaders from China, Germany, India, Japan, the United](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042123/5e9ed8492d30de2924231f6b/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
ACC8080
Copyright.©.�008.Accenture.All.rights.reserved..Accenture,.its.logo,.and..High.Performance.Delivered.are.trademarks.of.Accenture..
Core Project TeamTim Cooper, Alice Pearl, Mark Purdy, Matthew Robinson and Livia von Roetteken.
Senior Executive SponsorMark Spelman
We.would.also.like.to.thank.the.following.individuals.for.their.contributions.to.this.study:..Lucy.Atkinson,.Jo.Brown,.Gib.Bulloch,.Kit.Burdess,.Jonathan.Burton,..Ladan.Davarzani,.Olivia.Donnelly,.Henry.Egan,.John.Glen,.Iain.Griffiths,.Donald.Hamilton,.Jill.Huntley,.Nijma.Khan,.Adetola.Kunle-Hassan,.Peter.Lacy,.Saskia.Merriman,.Sarah.Michell,.Lauren.Miller,.Craig.Mindrum,.Paul.Nunes,.Andrew.Pincott,.Jeffrey.Playford,.Evis.Sakaj,.Becky.Sternberg.and.Oscar.Vasco..
For.more.information.visit:.www.accenture.com/[email protected]
To.find.out.more.about.how.Accenture.can.help.companies.develop.sustainability.strategies.that.enable.high.performance,[email protected]
Accenture Policy & Corporate Affairs
This.study.was.produced.by.Accenture.Policy.&.Corporate.Affairs..The.group.is.Accenture’s.macroeconomic.and.geopolitical.think.tank,.analyzing.key.trends.and.their.implications.for.business.leaders.and.policymakers..The.group.uses.a.combination.of.primary.and.secondary.research,.strategic.analysis,.scenario.planning.and.ongoing.dialogue.and.debate.with.senior.executives,.clients.and.outside.experts..The.views.and.opinions.expressed.in.this.publication.are.meant.to.stimulate.thought.and.discussion..These.ideas.should.not.be.viewed.as.professional.advice.
About Accenture
Accenture.is.a.global.management.consulting,.technology.services.and.outsourcing.company..Combining.unparalleled.experience,.comprehensive.capabilities.across.all.industries.and.business.functions,.and.extensive.research.on.the.world’s.most.successful.companies,.Accenture.collaborates.with.clients.to.help.them.become.high-performance.businesses.and.governments..With.more.than.175,000.people.in.49.countries,.the.company.generated.net.revenues.of.US$19.70.billion.for.the.fiscal.year.ended.August.31,.�007..Its.home.page.is.www.accenture.com..