a suggestive research of lesson study methodology for ......keywords : lesson study, evidence,...
TRANSCRIPT
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
0
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program
è¡šçŽ
A Suggestive Research of Lesson Study
Methodology for Teacherâs Deeper Reflection
by Using Lesson Analysis as Evidence:
Cooperative Process between Researchers and
Practitioners
Yasutaka Kizuka,Mizuki Hoshi,Yuta Arii,
and Ichitaro Matsumura
The University of Tokyo
April, 2020
No. 33
æ±äº¬å€§åŠå€§åŠé¢æè²åŠç 究ç§éå± åŠæ ¡æè²é«åºŠåã»å¹ææ€èšŒã»ã³ã¿ãŒ
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education
The University of Tokyo
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
1
æåž«ã®æ·±ãçå¯ãä¿ãææ¥ç 究æ¹æ³ã®ææ¡
âææ¥åæããšããã³ã¹ãšããæåž«ãšç 究è ã®ååçå¯â
æšå¡ èªè²Ž ã»æ çåžã»æäº åªå€ªã»æŸæ äžå€ªæ(æ±äº¬å€§åŠ)
A Suggestive Research of Lesson Study Methodology for Teacherâs Deeper
Reflection by Using Lesson Analysis as Evidence:
Cooperative Process between Researchers and Practitioners
Yasutaka Kizuka,Mizuki Hoshi,Yuta Arii and Ichitaro Matsumura
Authorâs note
Yasutaka Kizuka is a PhD StudentïŒGraduate School of EducationïŒThe University of Tokyo.
Mizuki Hoshi is a PhD StudentïŒGraduate School of EducationïŒThe University of Tokyo.
Yuta Arii is a Master StudentïŒGraduate School of EducationïŒThe University of Tokyo.
Ichitaro Matsumura is a Master StudentïŒGraduate School of EducationïŒThe University of Tokyo.
This research was supported by a grantïŒYong Scholar Training Program from Center for Advanced School
Education and Evidence-Based Research (CASEER)ïŒGraduate School of EducationïŒ The University of
Tokyo.
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
2
Abstract
This research aims to investigate how educational researchers can support the reflective practices of the teachers.
The authors conducted research on two teachers of civics of two different junior high schools. The process of the
research was as follows: (i) pre-interview: asking the teachers their learning experiences in initial teacher education
and current practical issues, (ii)analysis: unit-long lesson observations and their analysis being based on the student
learning in the context of social studies in order to publish alternative idea of the units themselves and their goals,
(iii) post-interview: cooperative interviews between the practitioners and the authors by using the analysis as the
evidence, and finally (iv) reflection analysis: focusing on how the teachers changed their values and beliefs.
According to the pre-interview, both of the teachers faced two difficulties; unit-long lesson design and the eyes to
understand their students. After our cooperative reflections, both of the teachers started to reconsider not only the
observed lessons and units but also their daily practices by focusing on constructions and the design of their units.
They also started to realize the importance of paying attention to their studentsâ voices in the lesson context. The
authors conclude that these two changes are considered to be made by (A) analyzing their practical and somewhat
tacit actions in academic ways with their backgrounds in mind and (B) analyzing their practices and studentsâ
learning in the context of social studies.
Keywords : Lesson study, Evidence, Lesson analysis, Reflection, Newly qualified teachers
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
3
æåž«ã®æ·±ãçå¯ãä¿ãææ¥ç 究æ¹æ³ã®ææ¡ âææ¥åæããšããã³ã¹ãšããæåž«ãšç 究è ã®ååçå¯â
1 åé¡ãšç®ç
è¿å¹ŽïŒæè²ç 究ã«ããããšããã³ã¹ã«é¢ã
ãè°è«ãçãã«è¡ããïŒæè²ç 究ãšæè²å®è·µãš
ã®é¢ä¿ãåãããŠããïŒe.g., Elliott 2001ïŒ
å³¶ç° 2008ïŒãäž¡è ã®é¢ä¿ãèããéã« Schön ã®
è°è«ãåèãšãªããSchönïŒ1983ïŒã¯ïŒæè¡çç
éè ãšçå¯çå®è·µè ãšãã 2ã€ã®å°éè·ã¢ãã«
ãæ瀺ããŠãããæè²ãšããä»äºã¯æè²ç®çã»
ç®æšèªäœãè«äºçã§ããïŒæãåŠã¶ããã»ã¹ã¯
äžç¢ºå®æ§ã®é«ãå¶ã¿ã§ããããïŒæåž«ã¯çå¯ç
å®è·µå®¶ãšããå°éè·åãããŒã¹ã«æããããŠã
ãïŒç³äº 2015ïŒãã€ãŸãïŒç 究è ãåºç€ãšãªã
ç¥èãäœãåºãå®è·µè ã¯ãã®ç¥èãå¿çšãããš
ããé¢ä¿ã§ã¯ãªãïŒå°é家ã§ããæåž«ãæã€çµ
éšã®èç©ã«ãã身ã«ã€ããç¥ã«äŸæ ããªãã
ãïŒè€éã§äžç¢ºå®ã«å€åãç¶ããçŸå®ç¶æ³ã«å¿
ããŠå®è·µã®éçšã§èªãã®è¡çºãã®ãã®ãåå³ã
ã€ã€æ°ããªç¥ãçã¿åºããŠããååšãšæããã
ãŠããããšããã³ã¹ã«åºã¥ãæè²ïŒevidence-
based educationïŒãå«ã°ããæšä»ã«ãããŠïŒç
å¯çå®è·µå®¶ã§ããæåž«ãæ¯ããæè²ç 究ãšãšã
ãã³ã¹ãšã®é¢ä¿æ§ã®åšãæ¹ã暡玢ããããšã¯å«
ç·ã®èª²é¡ã§ããã
1.1 çå¯çå®è·µã«ãããæåž«ã®åŠç¿
æ¥æ¬ã«ãããæåž«ã®åŠç¿ç 究ã¯ãã 30 幎è¿
ãã®éïŒSchönïŒ1983ïŒã«ãã£ãŠç€ºããããç
å¯ããéµæŠå¿µãšäœçœ®ã¥ããŠç 究ãç©ã¿éããŠã
ãããããïŒçå¯ããããšèªäœãç®çãšããã®
ã§ã¯ãªãïŒã©ã®ãããªææ¥ç 究æ³ããæ·±ããç
å¯ãä¿ãã®ããåãå¿ èŠãããïŒå§«é 2019ïŒã
ãæ·±ããçå¯ãšã¯ïŒåã©ãã®åŠç¿ã«å¯Ÿããè©äŸ¡
ãææ¥æ¹åã®æç«ãŠã®æ€èšã«çãŸãã ãã§ã¯ãª
ãïŒææ¥äžã«èµ·ããäºè±¡ã®æå³ã䟡å€ãé¢ä¿æ§
ã®äžã§åãããšãïŒæåž«èªèº«ã®æã€äŸ¡å€èŠ³ãä¿¡
念ããåãçŽãããšã§ããïŒç§ç° 1996ïŒãæåž«
èªèº«ã®æã€äŸ¡å€èŠ³ã信念ã¯ïŒææ¥ã®æ§æ³ã»å®
æœã»çå¯ãšããåãã§ãŒãºã«ãããå€æã®åŠ¥åœ
æ§ãèŠå®ããŠããïŒç³äº 2017ïŒããã®ããïŒæ·±
ãçå¯ãè¡ãå°é家ãšããŠã®å€æã®è³ªãé«ãã
ããšãã©ã®å¹Žä»£ã®æåž«ã«ãæ±ããããã
åæ¬ïŒ2010ïŒã¯ïŒäºåŸæ€èšäŒã«ãããæåž«
ã®åŠç¿éçšãéèªèšé²åã³åçåºæ¿ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥
ãŒã«ããããŒã¿ããæ€èšããŠããããã®çµæïŒ
ææ¥è ã¯èªèº«ã®ææ¥æå³ãåªä»ã«ããŠä»è ã®çº
èšã解éããŠããããšãæããã«ãªã£ãããŸ
ãïŒäºå®®ãïŒ2019ïŒã¯ïŒäºåŸæ€èšäŒã«ãããŠæ·±
ãçå¯ãä¿ãããããã®æ¡ä»¶ãæ€èšããŠããã
ãã®çµæïŒâ æ宀ã®äžã§çèµ·ããåã©ãã®ãã¡
ã®åŠã³ã®ãå€æ§æ§ããæåž«ã®æããšåã ã®åã©
ãã®åŠã³ã®ããºã¬ããæãã工倫ãææ¥å芳ã®
éã«è¡ãå¿ èŠãããããšïŒâ¡ææ¥è èªèº«ãšã¯ç°
ãªãåã©ãã®ã¿ãšããææè¡çºã®ç解ã»è§£éã
åè°äŒã®äžã§æèµ·ãããããã«ïŒææ¥è èªèº«ã
ææ¥ãããã«ããã£ãŠïŒèªãã®ææ¥æ§æ³ãææ
解éãæ確ã«ãïŒææ¥è ã®å®è·µçç¥èãæ瀺ã
ãããšãšãã 2ã€ã®æ¡ä»¶ãæãæïŒæ·±ãçå¯ã
çã¿åºãå¯èœæ§ããããšææããŠãããããªã
ã¡ãæ·±ããçå¯ãä¿ãã«ã¯ïŒææ¥è èªèº«ã®ææ¥
æå³ã課é¡æèãæ確åããäžã§ïŒåã©ãã®åŠ
ã³ã®å€æ§æ§ãæåž«ã®æããšåã©ãã®åŠã³ã®ãºã¬
ãæ€èšããããšãå¿ èŠã§ããããšãæããã«ã
ããŠããŠããã
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
4
1.2 1.2.çå¯çå®è·µãæ¯ããæè²ç 究è ã®åœ¹å²
ç³äºïŒ2015ïŒã¯ïŒãææã«åºã¥ãæè²
ïŒoutcome-based educationïŒãã®èãã«åºã¥ã
ããšããã³ã¹ã«åºã¥ãæè²ãã®ãªã«ã¿ããã£ã
ãšããŠïŒå®è·µè ãäž»äœãšãªãïŒå®è·µãã®ãã®ã®
æ¹åïŒããã³ïŒå®è·µè ã®å®è·µçèªèè«ãè±ãã«
ãªãé«ãŸãããšãç®çã«è¡ãå®è·µç 究ã®éèŠæ§
ãææããŠããããããŠïŒæè·ã®ç¥èåºç€ã®äž
軞ãšãªãããæè²åŠç 究ã¯ïŒå®è·µçå€æã®çµ
æïŒããŸããã£ãæ¹æ³ïŒç®çã»æ段é¢ä¿ïŒãäž
è¬åãã以äžã«ïŒçŸå Žã®æåž«ãã¡ã®äžç¢ºå®ãªæ
è²çå€æã®ããã»ã¹ãå åŽãã察象åãããã®
ã§ããå¿ èŠããããšææããŠãããã€ãŸãïŒæ
åž«ã®å°é家ãšããŠã®å€æãé«ããããšã«å¯äžã
ãæè²ç 究ã®åšãæ¹ãæ±ããããŠãããšèãã
ããããã
Schön ã®åé¡æ起以éïŒã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã»ãªãµãŒ
ãïŒæšå£ 2010ïŒããã¶ã€ã³ç 究ïŒé è€ã»çå·
2015ïŒãªã©ç 究è ãæè²å®è·µã«ç©æ¥µçã«é¢ãã
ç 究ææ³ãçšããææ¥ç 究æ¹æ³è«ãçŸå Žã®æåž«
ãèªåŸçã«è¡ã£ãŠããææ¥ç 究ãããæå¹ã«ã
ãããã®æ¹æ³è«ïŒå·å£ã 2018ïŒãææ¡ãããŠã
ãŠããããããŠïŒãããã®ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒåã©ãã®
åŠç¿éçšããšããã³ã¹ãšããææ¥ç 究ãè¡ãã
ãšã®éèŠæ§ãæããã«ãããŠããŠããïŒe.g.,æ±
éã 2018ïŒã
ãããïŒã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã»ãªãµãŒãã®ææ³ãçšã
ãç 究ãçŸå Žã®æåž«ãè¡ãææ¥ç 究æ¹æ³è«ã«å¯Ÿ
ããææ¡ã§ã¯ïŒå®è·µçãªåé¡ã®è§£æ±ºãäž»ãªç®ç
ãšãããŠããããïŒç 究è ãææ¥ç 究ã«é¢ãã
ååçå¯ããäžã§åŠè¡çãªç¥èŠãæåž«ã®çå¯ã«
ã©ã®ãããªåœ±é¿ãäžããŠããã®ãã¯æ€èšãããŠ
ããªãããŸãïŒãã¶ã€ã³ç 究ã®ææ³ãçšããæ
æ¥ç 究æ¹æ³è«ã®ææ¡ãè¡ã£ãŠããé è€ã»çå·
ïŒ2015ïŒã§ã¯ïŒåŠç¿ç§åŠã®ç¥èŠãææ¥ç 究ã«çµ
ã¿èŸŒãã§ã¯ãããïŒæåž«ãžã®åœ±é¿ãšããŠå¹ŽåºŠæ«
ã®ã¢ã³ã±ãŒãã«ããå¹ææ€èšŒããããŠããªãã
ãïŒçå¯ãžã®åœ±é¿ã¯æ€èšãããŠããªãã
ãã®ããã«æè²å®è·µã«ç©æ¥µçã«é¢ããå è¡ç
究ã«ãããŠã¯ïŒåŠè¡çãªå°éæ§ãæã€ç 究è ã
é¢ããããšã§æåž«ã®çå¯ã«äžãã圱é¿ãæ€èšã
ãŠããç 究ã¯ç®¡èŠã®éããªãã以äžã®å è¡ç 究
ã®å°éç¹ãšèª²é¡ãèžãŸãïŒæ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒä»¥äžã«
瀺ãããã«â æåž«ã®çŸåšã®åé¡æèãææ¥å®è·µ
åã«ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒèª¿æ»ãè¡ãïŒâ¡ãããèžãŸã
ãŠææ¥ã®èŠ³å¯ãªãã³ã«ææ¥åæãè¡ããâ¢ãã
ãŠïŒãã®çµæãååæåž«ã«æ瀺ããããšã§ãæ·±
ããçå¯ãä¿ãããšãåºæ¥ãã®ããæ€èšããã
ãã®ããã«ïŒæåž«ã®çå¯ã«æè²ç 究ã»æè²ç 究
è ãšåœŒããæ瀺ãããšããã³ã¹ã圱é¿ãäžãã
èŠå ãæããã«ããããšãéããŠïŒçå¯çå®è·µ
ãæ¯ããæè²ç 究ã»ç 究è ã®åšãæ¹ãåãããš
ãç®çãšããã
2 2.ç 究æ¹æ³
2.1 2.1.ç 究ååè
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒäžåŠæ ¡ 3幎çã®å ¬æ°åéïŒå
å ã«çç®ãïŒïŒäººã®æåž«ã察象ãšããŠææ¥ã®å
äžèŠ³å¯ãªãã³ã«ææ¥ååŸã®æåž«ãžã®ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥
ãŒãè¡ã£ãã
æåž«ã®æé·ã»åŠç¿ã«é¢ããå è¡ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒå ¥
è·åŸã®å®è·µç¥åœ¢æã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠããïŒæå¡é€æ
課çšãšçŸè·æè²ã®æ¥ç¶ã¯ã»ãšãã©åãããŠããª
ãïŒe.g.,è€æ£®ã»ç°äž 2017ïŒããããïŒå®è·µç¥ã®
圢æã¯æå¡é€æ課çšããçŸè·æè²ã«ãããŠé£ç¶
çã«è¡ããããã®ã§ããããïŒæå¡é€æ課çšãš
çŸè·æè²ã®æ¥ç¶ãèžãŸããæåž«ã®åŠç¿ãçå¯ã®
ããæ¹ãæ€èšããå¿ èŠãããïŒè€å 2019ïŒãã
ãã§ïŒæå¡é€æ課çšãåæ¥ããŠéããªãè¥ææ
åž«ïŒåãæ¬ç 究ã§ã¯å¯Ÿè±¡ãšããã
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
5
ç 究ååè ã®æåž«ã¯ïŒæå¡é€æ課çšã«ãããŠ
瀟äŒç§æè²ã®ãŒãã«æå±ãïŒãŒã掻åå ã®ã¿ãª
ããæ°éæè²å£äœã®ç 究äŒçã«ãããŠïŒæš¡æ¬æ
æ¥ãç 究çºè¡šãè¡ãªã£ãŠãããã€ãŸãïŒãã®ïŒ
人ã®æåž«ã¯è¥æãªããïŒå ¥è·åã«ææ¥èŠ³ãã«ãª
ãã¥ã©ã 芳ãããçšåºŠåœ¢æããŠãããšèããã
ãã
2.2 ç 究æ¹æ³
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒåäžèŠ³å¯ãšååæåž«ã«å¯Ÿããå
æ§é åã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒãè¡ã£ããã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒ
ã¯ïŒåå ååŸã®ïŒåºŠå®æœãããåå å®æœåã®ã€
ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã¯ïŒæåž«ã®åŠç¿ç 究ã®ç¥èŠãè€å
ïŒ2019ïŒã®ææãèžãŸãïŒäž»ã«ç 究ååè ã§ã
ãæåž«ã®æå¡é€ææã«ãããçµéšãåœè©²åå ã®
ããããæ åœããåŠçŽã®æ§åïŒçŸåšæ±ããŠãã
ææ¥å®è·µäžã®èª²é¡ãå°ãããå®æœæéã¯çŽ 1æ
éã§ãã£ããåå åŸã®ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã§ã¯ïŒãŸã
äºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã§èãåã£ã課é¡æèãèæ ®
ã«å ¥ããäžã§çè ããååæåž«èªèº«ã®ææ¥ãå
æãããã®ããšããã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ã説æãè¡
ã£ãããããŠïŒãããèžãŸãïŒåœè©²åå ã®å®è·µ
ãå床æ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠããã£ããå®æœæéã¯çŽ 1æ
éã§ãã£ãããŸãïŒç 究è ãæåž«ã«ãšããã³ã¹
ãæ瀺ããéã«ã¯ïŒå®è·µã«å¯Ÿããç解ã®ä»æ¹ã«
å¯ãæ·»ãåŸèŽããããã§ïŒæšªã®é¢ä¿ïŒïŒç°ãªãèŠ
æ¹ã解éãæ瀺ããïŒå¯Ÿé¢é¢ä¿ïŒãšããããã«
察話ããããšã§å®è·µè ãèªèº«ã®å®è·µã察象åã
ãããšãã§ãããšããææïŒåæã»å岡 2008ïŒ
ãèžãŸãïŒäžæ¹çã«æ瀺ãæå°ããã®ã§ã¯ãª
ãïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã§èãåã£ãå 容ãçµã³
ä»ããŠããããšãå£é ã§ãè£è¶³ããªãããšãã
ã³ã¹ãšããŠææ¥åæãæ瀺ãïŒãã®åŸã«å床å®
è·µãæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠãããããã«ããã
åäžèŠ³å¯ãè¡ãéã«ã¯ïŒãããªãïŒå°äœ¿çš
ãïŒææ¥ã®å šäœã俯ç°çã«æ®åœ±ãããã®ãšïŒç
åŸã®åŠç¿éçšãæããããã«ç¹å®ã®çåŸïŒã°ã«
ãŒãã®æŽ»åãèšé²ãããã®ã«åããã
2.3 ãšããã³ã¹ãšããææ¥åæã®æ¹æ³
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒæç§æè²ç 究ïŒç€ŸäŒç§ïŒïŒã«ãªã
ã¥ã©ã ç 究ãå°éãšãã第äºèè ãšç¬¬åèè ã
äžå¿ã«åæãæ åœãããåæã®èŠç¹ãšããŠã¯ïŒ
å è¡ç 究ã®ç¥èŠïŒå·å£ã 2018ïŒãèžãŸãïŒäž»ã«
çåŸã®åŠç¿éçšã«çŠç¹ãåœãŠãªããïŒæž¡éš
ïŒ2015ïŒãææãã瀟äŒç§æè²ç 究è ç¬èªã®æ
æ¥ã®åæèŠç¹ïŒïŒïŒæåž«ã®çããæèããããš
ïŒïŒïŒæåž«ã®æå°æè¡ãçåŸã®æäœãšãã£ãã
ã¯ããªéšåã ãã§ã¯ãªãåå å šäœã®ãã¯ããªæµ
ããæèããããšïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒïŒã瀟äŒç§æè²ã®ç®
æšã«ç §ãããŠæ矩ãããã®ãå€æããããšã® 3
ç¹ãåèã«åæããã
ãšããã³ã¹ã«ã¯ä»¥äžã®ïŒç¹ãå«ãŸããã
â ïŒåå ã®å šäœæ§é
â¡ïŒçåŸã®åŠç¿éçšïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãŠ
æåž«ãèªã£ãå°é£æãé¡èã«çŸããŠããå Žé¢æ°
ã¶æãæœåºïŒãåãããããã³ã«ããŒã¿
â¢ïŒâ¡ã®è§£é
â£ïŒâ¢ãèžãŸãåå ãéããèå¯ãšä»£æ¡ã®æ
瀺ã
äºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã®éã«ã¯ïŒä»¥äžã®æ§æãšãª
ã£ãŠããææ¥åæããšããã³ã¹ãšããŠçŽåªäœã§
æ瀺ããã
2.4 ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã®åææ¹æ³
åŸãããã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒããŒã¿ã¯ãã¹ãŠéèªå
ããããã®äžã§ Aæè«ïŒBæè«ãšãã«ä»¥äžã®æ
é ã«ãã£ãŠåæãè¡ã£ãã第äžã« Aæè«ããã³
Bæè«ãçè ãã®ææ¥åæã«ãã£ãŠã©ã®ãããª
å€å®¹ãçããããã®ãã«ã€ããŠãããã瀺ãã
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
6
第äºã«ãã®å€å®¹ã«é¢é£ããäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã®
èªããå ·äœçã«åŒçšãïŒå€å®¹åã®æ§åãæãã
第äžã«åæã«ãããŠçè ãã芳å¯å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªã£ã
ææ¥ãã©ã®ããã«æãïŒãšããã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺
ããã®ããšããç¹ã«ã€ããŠæ瀺ãïŒæåŸã«äºåŸ
ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãããå ·äœçãªèªãã®åæã
ãïŒæåž«ã®å€å®¹ãæããAæè«ïŒBæè«ã®ããã
ãã«ã€ããŠä»¥äžã®æé ã«ãã£ãŠåæãè¡ã£ã
åŸïŒåçµæãèžãŸãããããã®å€å®¹ãä¿ãããš
ãæ¯ããŠããèæ¯ã«ã€ããŠèå¯ãè¡ãããªãïŒ
ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒãåŒçšããéã¯ïŒèªãã®å 容ã«çŠ
ç¹åããããããã®ãŒãããããŒãããªã©ã®çº
話ã¯é€ããŠããããŸãïŒèªãã®åæã解éã®æ
äžã«ãããŠæåž«ã®èªããçŽæ¥çã«åŒçšããå Žå
ã¯ã ããçšããããšãšãïŒèªãã®åŒçšã«ãã
ãçè ãã®è£è¶³ã¯ïŒ ïŒã§è¡šãã
3 3.çµæãšèå¯
3.1 Aæè«ã®äºäŸ
æ¬ç 究ã«ããã Aæè«ã®å€å®¹ã¯ïŒç¬¬äžã«èªèº«
ã®åã©ãç解ãåãçŽããããšïŒç¬¬äºã«èªèº«ã®
å®æŠã«ãããåå æ§é ã®èª²é¡ãæŽæ°ããããšïŒ
ãæããããšãã§ããã
3.1.1 çæ³ã®ææ¥ãšçŸåšã®ææ¥å®è·µäžã®èª²é¡
Aæè«ã¯é«æ ¡åœæã®æ¥æ¬å²ã®æåž«ã®è©±ãå
容ãé¢çœãã£ãçµéšããïŒãé¢çœããšãäŒããã
æåž«ã«ãªãããã£ããšèªã£ãŠãããããã倧åŠ
ã«å ¥åŠçŽåŸã® 1幎çã®åŸæã«åè¬ãã瀟äŒç§ã®
ææ¥ã®äžã§æ åœæå¡ããããªãè埳倪åãæã
ãã®ãããšããåããæããããããããšãå¥
æ©ãšããŠïŒåã«åã©ãã掻çºã«åããŠããææ¥
ãè¯ãææ¥ãªã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒææ¥ã®ããããããš
ã«è°è«ããããšã®éèŠæ§ãåŠãã ãšèªã£ãŠã
ãïŒèªèº«ã®ææ¥èŠ³ã倧åŠå ¥åŠåŸã«å€åããããš
ãèªã£ãŠããã
Aæè«ã¯ïŒäžè¿°ã®ãããªæå¡é€ææã«åœ¢æ
ãããææ¥ã®ããæ¹ãç®æããŠãããïŒå ¥è·åŸ
ã¯å®éã«å®è·µã§ããªããšããã®ã£ããã«èª²é¡ã
æããŠããã以äžã¯ãã®ããšãè¡šããŠããèªã
ã§ããã
æŒ ç¶ãšãããã®ïŒçè«ïŒãé¢çœããæããŠã
ãŸã£ãã®ã§ïŒæè²å®ç¿ãšãä»ããããªãã§ãã
ã©ïŒãããå ·äœçã«äœããã®ïŒææ¥ïŒãã€ãã£
ããïŒãã®ãããèŠåŽãããã§ããããã£ã±èª
åã®æããããªãã®ã¯ã€ãããªãã®ã§ããªãã§
ããã©ïŒããŸã ã«ãã®æŒ ç¶ãšãããã®ãããã®
ã§ïŒäœãããã«ïŒææ¥ãïŒè¿ã¥ããããšã¯æã£
ãŠãã¯æã£ãŠããã©ã£ãã§ãã®èãæ¹ãšããŠã
ããã§ãããã
Aæè«ã¯ïŒæå¡é€ææã«åŠãã ïŒåãããæ
æ¥ãäœããšãããææ¥ããããã£ãŠäœããã ã
ãšããè¬çŸ©ãå°è±¡çãªãã®ãšããŠæ¯ãè¿ãïŒèª
身ã®å®è·µã®çæ³ãšããŠãããäžæ¹ã§ãã®çæ³ã
å ·äœçãªææ¥ãšããŠæ§é åããããšãã§ããªã
ããšã«èª²é¡ãæããŠããããããŠèªèº«ã®çŸåšã®
å®è·µãèžãŸãïŒç®æãããææ¥ã®ããæ¹ã以äž
ã®ããã«èªã£ãŠããã
ã¡ã€ã³ã¯ãšã¹ãã§ã³ããã£ãŠïŒææ¥ã§ïŒãã®
ãšãã«ïŒåœããåãªãã§ããã©ïŒåã©ããã¡
ãïŒãããããã ã£ããèããŠãããããªã£
ãŠãã©ãããŠãä»ãã£ãŠãææ¥ã ãšïŒäŸãã°æ
ç§æžã«å šéšïŒçãããã£ããã ãšãïŒå¡ŸïŒè¡ã£
ãŠãåã ã£ããïŒäœãšãªããããªæãã§ããã£
ãŠïŒåãã£ãŠããŸããã§ãããã ããããã§ã¯
ãªããŠïŒãªããé©ããšããããã¡ãã£ãšãã£
ãŠïŒç¥ã£ãŠè¯ãã£ããªã£ãŠæãããããªææ¥ïŒ
ç¹ã«ãããåºæ¬çã«ã¯ïŒäŒè©±ãããªãããªãã
åŠã³ãããã°ãããªãšã¯æã£ãŠãããã§ãã
ã©ã
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
7
Aæè«ã®æ±ããææ¥å®è·µäžã®å°é£æã¯ïŒå ·äœ
çã«ä»¥äž 2ç¹æããããã
â åã©ãã®èŠåãæ¹
Aæè«ã¯å¯Ÿè©±çãªææ¥ãç®æããããšèãã
äžæ¹ã§ïŒå®éã®ææ¥ã§ã¯ãããã£ãé©ãããª
ãïŒå¡Ÿã«è¡ã£ãŠããåã©ãã«ãšã£ãŠæ°é®®å³ãã
ãææ¥ã«ãªã£ãŠããªããšèªã£ãŠããããããŠå¯Ÿ
話çãªå®è·µã®åãçµã¿ãè¡ãããšããŠãïŒãåã
ãåããçããªãã®ã§ïŒå¯Ÿè©±ãšãããïŒãã ã®
åãã£ãŠãåãšã®ãããšãã«ãªã£ã¡ããããšèª
ã£ãŠããããã®èªãããïŒAæè«ã¯èªèº«ã®äžã§
åæãšãããåãã£ãŠãåããšãåãã£ãŠããª
ãåãã®æ çµã¿ã¯ãããïŒåã©ãã®åŠç¿éçšã
çåãéã«ïŒãã®èæ¯ãææ¥ã®æèã®äžã§æã
ãããŠããªãããšã Aæè«ã®å®è·µäžã®æ ¹æ¬çãª
課é¡ã§ããèããããã
â¡åå ã®äžè²«æ§ã®æ¬ åŠ
Aæè«ã¯æå¡é€æåœæã«ïŒåå ã貫ãåãã®
éèŠæ§ã«ã€ããŠåŠãã ãšèªèããŠãããããã
çŸåšã¯å®è·µã«ãããŠå®çŸã§ããŠãããïŒã1æ
éïŒ1æéã§ã¶ã€åããã®ææ¥ã«ãªã£ãŠããŸã£
ãŠãããšïŒãã®ãã©ããããèªã£ãŠããããã®
èªãããã¯ïŒåå ã貫ãåããèšå®ããåå ã
å ·äœçã«äœæããããšã«èª²é¡ãæ±ããŠããæ§å
ãããããããAæè«ã¯ïŒæå¡é€æåœæã«åŠã
ã æœè±¡çãªçè«ãå ·äœçãªå®è·µã«ããããšã«å°
é£ãæ±ããŠããïŒè§£æ±ºçãèŠåºãããšãã§ãã
ã«ããã
ãŸãïŒèªãã®ææ¥ãæ¯ãè¿ãäºã¯ãããæ¬åœ
ã«ãªãããšèšãããã®ããææ¥ã倱æãããšæ
ãããšãã«ã¯ïŒãããã»ããšå€±æãããã§çµã
ã£ããŠããŸãïŒçµäºçŽåŸã«æ¯ãè¿ãããšãã§ã
ãŠããªããšèªã£ãŠãããå®éïŒæå¡é€ææã«ã
ããŠãããã®åãããããšãïŒãã®åãããã
ãã«ããã£ããšããã®ã¯ããã£ããšãããïŒã
ãé·æçãªã¹ãã³ã§ã®æ¯ãè¿ãã¯è¡ã£ãŠããªã
ã£ããšèªã£ãŠããããã®ããšããïŒçæ³ãšçŸå®
ã®äžã§æŒ ç¶ãšèªèº«ã®å®è·µã«ã€ããŠäžå®ã®æ¯ãè¿
ããè¡ã課é¡ãèªèããŠãããïŒãããããæ
æ¥ã«ãããåãã®æ¹åã¬ãã«ã«çãŸãïŒåå ã®
å šäœã®äžã§åã©ãã®åŠã³ãæãææ¥ãæ¯ãè¿ã
ããšãåºæ¥ãŠããªãããšã課é¡ã§ãããšèãã
ããã
3.1.2 ææ¥åæ
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒãç§ãã¡ã®ç掻ãšçŠç¥ããšããå
å ïŒå šïŒæéïŒãåæ察象ãšãããAæè«ã¯ïŒ
çåŸãçŸè¡ã®ç€ŸäŒå¶åºŠãç¥ãã ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒã
ã®èæ¯ãç解ãïŒå°æ¥ã®å¶åºŠèšèšãèããŠãã
ãããšãçããšããŠããïŒåå ã以äžã®ããã«
æ§æããŠãããåå ååã¯å¹Žéãéçšä¿éºãªã©
ã®çŸè¡ã®ç€ŸäŒä¿éå¶åºŠãç¥ãïŒãã®èª²é¡ãšèæ¯
ã«ãã瀟äŒç¶æ³ãç解ããæ§æãšãªã£ãŠããã
åå åŸåã¯ïŒæ°ããªç€ŸäŒä¿éã®ããæ¹ãšããŠã
ãŒã·ãã¯ã€ã³ã«ã ïŒä»¥äžïŒBIïŒã®å¶åºŠãç¥ãïŒ
BIãèªçããèæ¯ã«ãã瀟äŒç¶æ³ãç解ãïŒæ
åŸã«çŸè¡ã®ç€ŸäŒä¿éå¶åºŠãš BIã®ã©ã¡ããåªããŠ
ããããè°è«ããæ§æãšãªã£ãŠãããçè ã
ã¯ïŒAæè«ãå®æœããåå ã®æ§é ããå¶åºŠãã«
é¢ããå 容ãšã瀟äŒç¶æ³ãã«é¢ããå 容ãšãã
ïŒã€ã®èŠç¹ããæŽçãè¡ãïŒçåŸã®åŠã³ã®å®æ
ãèžãŸããŠãã®åé¡ç¹ãèå¯ãããå ·äœçã«
ã¯ïŒ2æéç®ã®åŸåã§çŸåšã®ç€ŸäŒä¿éãå¶åºŠã
ã®åé¡ç¹ãèå¯ããããã«ã瀟äŒç¶æ³ããèå¯
ãããæµãããïŒ3æéç®ã®åé ã§ã¯åã³ BIã®
ãå¶åºŠãã®è©±ãå±éããŠããŸã£ãããã« BIãå¿
èŠãšãããçŸåšïŒãããŠå°æ¥ã®ã瀟äŒç¶æ³ãã
çåŸãã¡ãé£ç¶ããŠèããããšãã§ããªãã£ã
ããšãææããããã®ããã§ïŒä»£æ¡ãšããŠã¯ 2
æéç®åŸåãã 3æéã®ååã«ãããŠçŸè¡ã®ç€Ÿ
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
8
äŒä¿éå¶åºŠïŒBIã®èæ¯ã«ããã瀟äŒç¶æ³ãã«ã€
ããŠçåŸãã¡ã«èå¯ããïŒçŸåšãšå°æ¥ã®ç€ŸäŒã«
察ããèªèãç解ãæ·±ããŠãã㧠BIã®ãå¶åºŠã
ã説æããããšã§ 4æéç®ã®èšè«ããå¶åºŠã察
ãå¶åºŠãã«çµå§ããããšãªãïŒã瀟äŒç¶æ³ãããµ
ãŸããäžã§ãå¶åºŠãã«ã€ããŠèšè«ããããšãã§
ã Aæè«ãç®æãåŠç¿æŽ»åãå±éãããããã«
ãªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšããããšãæ瀺ããã
3.1.3 äºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒ
äºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãããŠïŒAæè«ã¯ïŒä»å
æ瀺ããåæã«å¯ŸããŠä»¥äžã®ãããªææ³ãèªã£
ãŠããã
ãããŸã§èŠããããšãªãã®ã§ïŒåã©ããã¡ã
äžèªäžå¥ïŒäœïŒèšã£ãŠããã£ãŠïŒãªããªãåã
ããªãã®ã§ïŒãããããšããã§åãã£ãŠãªãã
ã ãšãïŒãããïŒã¡ãã£ãšé¢çœããªãšæã£ãŠèŠ
ãŠãŸããã
ãã®äžã§ïŒãããã³ã«ãšããŠæäŸãããåã©
ãã Aæè«ã®è«è©±ã®ã¿ãªããïŒãã®è«è©±ãæ¬å
å ã®äžã§ã©ã®ãããªæå³ãæã€ã®ããšãã芳ç¹
ããã®åæãæ瀺ããããšã§ïŒä»¥äžã®ïŒç¹ã«ã
ããŠäŸ¡å€èŠ³ã»ä¿¡å¿µãå€å®¹ãããŠããã
â åã©ãã®ç解ã«ã€ããŠã®åãçŽã
Aæè«ã¯ææ¥ã®äžã§åã©ãã®çºèšããå·¡åã
ãŠèããŠããããšãããïŒããã§ã®èŠåããšç
åŸããèããŠãããšïŒçµæ§ã®ã£ãããããã
ãªããšåæãæ瀺ããããšã§æ°ã¥ããŠããã
æçµçã«åºãŠããçãã¯ïŒèããŠããã§ãã
ã©ïŒãããŸã§ã®ããã»ã¹ãšãããã§ããããã©
ãããããšãèžã¿èŸŒãã§ïŒæçµçãªçŽåŸã«è³ã£
ãã®ãã£ãŠããã®ã¯ïŒåãããªãã®ã§ã
Aæè«ã¯éåžžã®ææ¥ã«ãããŠåã©ããã¡ã®çº
èšã«ã€ããŠãããŸãããã»ã¹ã¯æèããŠããª
ããããïŒæçµçãªå Žé¢ã§ã®çåŸã®çºèšãåºæº
ã«å€æããŠããããããŠïŒããã®ã¯ã©ã¹ã®äžã§
ã¯ïŒãŸãïŒåãã£ãŠãã»ããªã¯ããªãã§ãã
ã©ïŒãŸã èœãšã蟌ããŠãªãããšããçåŸã®åºæ
åãæãïŒææ¥å 容ã«ã€ããŠç解ããŠãããšè
ããŠããåã©ãã®ææ¥äžã®è«è©±ããæ°ä»ããåŸ
ãŠããããã®ããšã¯ïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãã
ãŠèªã£ãŠãããåãã£ãŠããåããšãåãã£ãŠ
ããªãåãã®åé¡ãåã©ãã®åŠç¿éçšãå¯èŠå
ãããè«è©±ãããšã«ããææ¥åæã®æ瀺ã«ãã£
ãŠåŽ©ããããšã瀺ããŠãããšèãããããããª
ãã¡äºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ããããåãã£ãŠãã
åãšã®ãããšãã«ãªã£ãŠããããšããèªèº«ã®æ
æ¥ã«å¯ŸããèªèãåãçŽãããããšãæå³ããŠ
ãããšèããããšãã§ããã
â¡èªèº«ã®å®è·µã«ãããåå æ§é ã®åãçŽã
瀟äŒïŒå°åé«éœ¢åã®è©±ãããã°ïŒå¿ ç¶çã«é
æ£èŠéçšãšãïŒå ±åãã®è©±ãšãã«ãªã£ãŠããã£
ãŠããã®ã¯ïŒçµå±ïŒ3æéç®ã§ãã£ãããšãšäž
ç·ã®ããšãªã®ã§ãããããïŒãããããµããªæµ
ãã§ïŒç€ŸäŒçèæ¯ããïŒããïŒããŒã·ãã¯ã€ã³
ã«ã ãåºããŠããïŒã®ã»ãããã£ã±ããã£ãã
ããã®ããªã£ãŠããããããªãïŒããŒã·ãã¯ã€
ã³ã«ã ããŒãŒãã£ãŠåºãŠããŠãã®ã§ïŒä»åã¯ã
ãããã£ãç¹ã§ã¯éåžžã«åããã¥ããã
Aæè«ã¯ããŒã·ãã¯ã€ã³ã«ã ã«ã€ããŠåã©ã
ãããæ·±ãæèããããã«ã¯ïŒ1æéã®ææ¥å
容ã®æ¹åã ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒåå å šäœã®äžã§äœãã©
ã®é åºã§èããŠããã®ãããã®ãïŒåå æ§æã
æèããããšã®éèŠæ§ãèªèããŠããã
ãŸãïŒãä»ã®ææ¥ã§ãïŒåºæ¬çã«åããããªæ§
é ã®ã¯ããã§ãããšïŒèªãã®ä»ã®å®è·µã«ãããŠ
ãåæ§ã®åŸåãèŠãããå¯èœæ§ãããããšã«æ
èãåãïŒããããã£ãç®ç·ã§èªåã®ææ¥ãèŠçŽ
ãããïŒããã¡ãã£ãšè¯ããªãã®ããªãïŒãæé
ãèžãã§ãã£ããèããã°ïŒããã¡ãã£ãšåå
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
9
ããã£ã±ïŒãããšããïŒå ¥ãæ¿ããããšãïŒãª
ãããªããšïŒä»åã®æ°ã¥ããèªèº«ã®ææ¥å®è·µã«
ãããä»ã®åå ãææ¥ã€ããŠãå ±éããŠãããš
èªèããŠããã
Aæè«ã¯ïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã®éã«ïŒãåå ã
貫ãåãããšããäžè²«æ§ãæããåå æ§é ãæ
èã§ããŠããªãããšã課é¡ãšããŠæããŠããã
ããã«å¯ŸããŠçè ãã¯ïŒåæ察象ãšããåå ã«
ã¯ãå¶åºŠããšã瀟äŒèæ¯ããšããæ§é ããã£ã
ããšãæ瀺ããããããïŒAæè«ã®ããããšã
ãããã«çåŸãçŸè¡ã®ç€ŸäŒå¶åºŠãç¥ãã ãã§ã¯
ãªãïŒãã®èæ¯ãç解ãïŒå°æ¥ã®å¶åºŠèšèšãè
ããŠãããããšãç®æãããã«ã¯ïŒåå æ§é ã
çµã¿æ¿ããå¿ èŠãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšãã代æ¡
ãçåŸã®åŠç¿éçšã«ãããèºããèžãŸãæ瀺ã
ãããã®ããšã§ïŒAæè«ã¯ïŒä»åç 究察象ãšãª
ã£ãåå ã®ã¿ãªããïŒã»ãã®åå ã«ãããŠãèª
èŠããŠããªãåå æ§é ãååšããå¯èœæ§ããã
ããšãèªèããŠãããä»åã®ãšããã³ã¹ã®æ瀺
ã«ãã£ãŠïŒAæè«ã¯åœè©²åå ã«é¢ããæ¹åã®ã
ãæ¹ã ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒæå¡é€æ段éããæ±ããŠã
ãèªèº«ã®çè«ãšå®è·µã«å¯Ÿããå°é£æãåãçŽ
ãïŒèªèº«ã®ãã®ä»ã®ææ¥å®è·µã®æèãšçµã³ã€ã
ãªãã䟡å€èŠ³ã信念ãå€å®¹ãããŠããã
Aæè«ã®äºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ããããããã®
èªãããã¯ïŒãšããã³ã¹ãšããŠææ¥åæãæ瀺
ããããšã§ïŒæ®æ®µã®å®è·µã®äžã§æ±ããŠããå®è·µ
ã«å¯Ÿããæ·±ãçå¯ãä¿ããŠããããšã瀺ãããŠ
ãããAæè«ã¯ãšããã³ã¹ã®æ瀺ã«ãã£ãŠèªèº«
ããããŸã§æ±ããŠãããšèããŠããå°é£æãå
ãçŽãïŒæ°ããªèŠç¹ã§èªãã®å®è·µãæãçŽããŠ
ããããŸãïŒãããŸã§æ±ããŠãããåãã£ãŠã
ãåããåãã£ãŠããªãåããšããæãæ¹ãæ¹
ãïŒçºèšã«å°ããŸã§ã®ããã»ã¹ã§ãåãã£ãŠã
ãåãã«ãåãã£ãŠããªãéšåããã£ãããšã«
æ°ã¥ããŠããã
以äžïŒç¹ã®åæããïŒAæè«ã«ãšã£ãŠãšãã
ã³ã¹ãšããŠææ¥åæãæ瀺ããããšã¯ïŒåã©ã
ãèŠåãã«é¢ããŠçºèšã®çµæããèæ ®ã«å ¥ããŠ
ããªãã¬ãã«ã§ã®çå¯ããïŒåã©ããææ¥ã®äž
ã§ã©ã®ãããªåŠç¿éçšãçµãŠçºèšããŠããã®ã
ãšãã£ãããšã«ãŸã§ç®ãåããã¬ãã«ã§çå¯ã
ãããšã®å¿ èŠæ§ãèªèããããã«ãªã£ããšèã
ãããããããŠïŒä»åã®åå ã«çãŸããä»ã®æ
æ¥ã«ãããŠãé¡äŒŒã®åŸåãèŠãããå¯èœæ§ã«ã
èšåãïŒãããŸã§ã®èªåèªèº«ã®å®è·µãåãçŽã
ãŠããããã®ããã« Aæè«ã«ãšã£ãŠåæã®æ瀺
ã¯ïŒèªèº«ã®ææ¥ãåã©ãã«å¯Ÿããç解ã«æ°ããª
èŠç¹ãä»äžãïŒããå®è·µã®æèã§ã®çå¯ãä¿ã
ããšãå¯èœã«ãããšèããããã
3.2 Bæè«ã®äºäŸ
æ¬ç 究ã«ããã Bæè«ã®å€å®¹ã¯ïŒç¬¬äžã«åå
ã¬ãã«ã§ã®ææ¥æ¹åã®èŠç¹ã®ç²åŸããªãããã
ãšïŒç¬¬äºã«åã©ãã®åãããªãã®èæ¯ã«æ°ã¥ã
ãããšïŒãæããããšãã§ããã
3.2.1 çæ³ã®ææ¥ãšçŸåšã®ææ¥å®è·µäžã®èª²é¡
Bæè«ã¯æå¡é€ææã«ïŒåéã«ç¹åãããã
ã瀟äŒç§å šè¬ã«ãããŠãæããç®çãšãïŒãªã
ã§ããæããã®ããšãïŒææ¥ãããããäœãã
ãããšæããŠãããå ·äœçã«å®è·µã®ããšã«ã€ã
ãŠèãã¯ãããã®ã¯å°±è·ã決ãŸã£ã 4幎çã§ã
ã£ãããããŠä»ã§ãïŒãèªåããã£ãŠããããš
ãïŒããããè©Šè¡é¯èª€ããªãããã£ãŠãããšïŒ
ææ¥ã¥ããã®é£ãããèªã£ãŠãããææ¥ã«ãã
ãŠã¯äžæ¹çã«èãã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒçåŸã«ã1åïŒ2
åã¯äœãåãããŠããããããšããããšãæè
ããªããïŒæ§ã ãªèŠæ¹ãå ±æããäžã§çåŸèªã
ãè¡åããããšãã§ããããã«ãªã£ãŠã»ãããš
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
10
ããé¡ããæã£ãŠããããã®ããïŒãåšãã«ãã
人ãã¡ãšè©±ããŠãããã¿ãããªã®ã¯æ¯åææ¥ã®
äžã«å ¥ãããããšå¿ããããšãšãã«ïŒè³æã¥ã
ãã®æ®µéã§çåŸãèå³ããã£ãŠäž»äœçã«èªãã
ãšãã§ããããèããŠããã
Bæè«ã¯å®è·µäžã®èª²é¡ãšããŠïŒå ãèŠéãã
ãšã®é£ãããæããŠããã
å ïŒèŠéããŠããã®ãæ¬åœã«èŠæãªãã§ãã
ãïŒç§ããªã®ã§ïŒå€§äœã©ã®èŸºãã§ã©ããŸã§ã£ãŠ
ããïŒãã©ãïŒãªããªãä»ããã®ãèŠæãªã®
ã§ããããããã¡ããããŸãã§ããããã«ãªã
ãããªãŒã£ãŠããã
ãã®å ·äœãšããŠïŒä»¥äžã® 2 ç¹ãçŸåšã®èª²é¡ãš
ããŠæããŠããã
â åã©ãã®èŠåããžã®å°é£
Bæè«ã¯èªèº«ã®èŠç¹ãéå®çã§ããããšã
èªèããŠããããããŠä»åã®å ±åç 究ãéããŠ
ãç§ã®èŠæ¹ãåºããŠã»ããããšèããŠãããã
ããŠïŒä»¥åèªèº«ã®ææ¥ã倧åŠçå芳ãã«æ¥ã
éïŒæ®æ®µã¯ããã¢ãããŒã·ã§ã³äžããããïŒãã
ãããããšãå²ãšè€ãããããæºéæå°ã«ããã
çåŸã®å£°ããã«ã€ããŠããªãã§äœãæžããŠãªã
çåŸã®æè¡ã£ãŠïŒäœãèšããªããã§ããããšæ
æãããããšã§ãèšã£ãæ¹ããããã ãªã£ãŠã
ãã®ã«æ°ã¥ããããšïŒå ·äœçãªãšããœãŒããåŒ
çšããªããèŠæ¹ãåºãããšã¯ã©ãããããšã§ã
ããšæããŠããã®ãã«ã€ããŠèª¬æããã
â¡åå ã®äžè²«æ§ã®æ¬ åŠ
äžè¿°ããâ ãšé¢é£ããŠïŒBæè«ã¯æ¥ããïŒ1
æéåäœã§ææ¥ã®æ¯ãè¿ããè¡ããšãããçŸåš
ã¯ïŒ3ã¯ã©ã¹ãæ åœããŠããïŒåãå 容ã 3ã¯
ã©ã¹ã§è¡ãããïŒã1åçµãã£ãç¬éã«åçãã
ãããšãç¹°ãè¿ããªããïŒãã¡ãã£ãšã§ãé¢çœã
ãããããšèããŠãããããããªããïŒåå ã
éããŠãæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠã¿ãã£ãŠããšãæ£çŽãã£
ãŠããããïŒçåŸãåå ãéããŠãæé·ããã
ã©ããã£ãŠããã®ã¯ãããŸãèŠãŠãããªãããŸ
ãïŒç 究ææ¥ã«ãããŠææ¥åŸã«èªè©ãè¡ãããš
ã¯ãããšãããïŒãç 究ææ¥ã§ã¯èªåã¯ãããã
æå³ã§ãããŸããã¿ãããªã®ãæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠå
ãããšïŒç 究ææ¥ãšããäžã€ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªãææ¥
ã«ã€ããŠã®ã¿ãæ¯ãè¿ãè¡çºã«çãŸã£ãŠãããš
èªèããŠããããã®ããšã¯ïŒåå å šäœã®äžã§æ¬
æã®ææ¥å®è·µãäœçœ®ã¥ããããšã«å¯Ÿãã課é¡ã
Bæè«ã瀺ããŠãããšèããããã
ãããâ ïŒâ¡ã«ç€ºãããããã«ïŒBæè«ã¯
ãããŸã§æèããŠããªãã£ãäœãæžããŠããªã
çåŸã«å¯Ÿããæ¯æŽã®ããæ¹ã®å¿ èŠæ§ã«æ°ã¥ããŠ
ãããã®ã®ïŒãã®ãããªæ¯æŽãäœã®ããã«è¡ã
ã®ãïŒãªããã®ãããªç¶æ³ãçããŠããã®ããš
ãã£ãå ·äœçãªææ¥ãåå ã®æèã®äžã§æãã
ããšã課é¡ãšãªã£ãŠããããŸãïŒãããããã
ããïŒãããããæ¹ãæãŸããããšããæ³ãã¯æ
ããŠããäžæ¹ã§ïŒ1æéã®å®è·µãåå å šäœã®äž
ã§äœçœ®ä»ããããšãäœçœ®ä»ããããšãäœçœ®ä»ã
ãããšãäœçœ®ä»ããããšã«èª²é¡ãæã£ãŠããã
3.2.2 ææ¥åæ
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒãç§ãã¡ã®ç掻ãšçµæžããšããå
å ïŒå šïŒæéïŒã察象ãšãããæ¬åå ã¯æç§æž
èŠéãïŒããŒãžã§ïŒæéã®ææ¥ãæ§æãããŠã
ããBæè«ã¯çåŸã«ç€ŸäŒäºè±¡ãèããããããš
ã§çåŸã®ç©ã®èŠæ¹ãèŠéãåºããããšãçããš
ããŠããããïŒãåçºäºæ åŸã®çŠå³¶ã®éèã®å€æ®µ
ã¯äžãããïŒäžãããããå°å£²åºã®å£²ãäžãã¯ã©
ã®ããã«æšç§»ããŠãããããªã©ã®åããèšå®
ãïŒè³æãããšã«ç€ŸäŒäºè±¡ãèå¯ãã掻åãçµ
ã¿èŸŒãŸããŠãããçè ãã¯ïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒ
㧠Bæè«ãèªã£ãå°é£æãèžãŸããŠïŒçåŸã®æŽ»
åãã¯ã©ã¹å šäœã§å ±æããéã®æåž«ãšçåŸã®çž
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
11
äºäœçšã®å Žé¢ã§ïŒæåž«ãçåŸã®çºèšã®æå³ã解
éããããŠããªãããšïŒæ£çã®çåŸãäžå¿ã«æ
æ¥ãå±éããŠããããšã«çç®ãïŒãã®ç¹ãäžå¿
ã«åæãè¡ã£ãããããã®èŠå ãšããŠïŒæŽ»ååŸ
ã«å šäœã§å ±æããæéãäžè¶³ããŠããããšãè
ããããããïŒäžåå ã«çµã¿èŸŒã掻åã粟éžã
ãããšã代æ¡ãšããŠæ瀺ããã
3.2.3 äºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒ
äºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãããŠïŒBæè«ã¯ä»å
æ瀺ããåæã«å¯ŸããŠä»¥äžã®ãããªææ³ãèªã£
ãŠããã
çåŸãã©ãããæèããŠïŒã©ãããã¹ã£ãŠã
ã®ãã£ãŠãããšãããšãèŠããŠïŒããïŒã¡ãã
ãšè³æã«é 匵ã£ãŠåãçµãã§ããªã£ãŠãããšã
ããèŠããã®ã¯è¯ãã£ããªãšæããŸããã
ãããŠïŒãšããã³ã¹ãšããŠææ¥åæãæ瀺
ããããšã§ïŒä»¥äž 2ç¹ã«ãããŠäŸ¡å€èŠ³ã»ä¿¡å¿µã
å€å®¹ãããŠããã
â åã©ãã®åãããªãã®èæ¯ãžã®æ°ã¥ã
åã©ãã®èŠåãã«ã€ããŠïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒ
ã§ã¯ãã®åã©ããæžããŠãããïŒãããã¯æžã
ãŠããªãããšããçµæã®äœçžæããŠããããã
ãïŒææ¥åæãæ瀺ããããšã§ïŒãããããã®å
ãã¡ãïŒãã®éèŠã»äŸçµŠã®ã©ã£ã¡ãå¢ããæžã
ã£ãŠãããšãããšãïŒããšã¯ããããã©ã£ã¡ã
éèŠã§ïŒã©ã£ã¡ãäŸçµŠã§ãšãïŒéèŠã£ãŠè²·ãæ
ã ã£ãïŒå£²ãæã ã£ãïŒã¿ãããªãšããã«ãªã£
ãããããšãããŸã§ç解ããïŒããŠãããã£ãŠ
ãšã¡ãã£ãšæªãããšæããã§ãããããšïŒåã©
ãã®çºèšã«ã€ããŠææ¥ã®æèãèæ¯ãèæ ®ããŠ
æ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠããããã®ããšã¯åã«å ·äœçãªææ¥
å Žé¢ãæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠããããïŒãšããããšã«çãŸ
ããïŒãããããªãæžãããšãã§ããŠããªãã®
ã ãããïŒãšããåããå é¢åãããŠãããšè
ããããšãã§ãããåæ§ã«ïŒããåã©ããéèŠ
ãšäŸçµŠæ²ç·ã®ææ¥ã®éã«ïŒçºèšããå 容ãã¯ã©
ã¹ã«å ±æããŠããªãã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšããçè ã
ã®åæã«å¯ŸããŠïŒBæè«ã¯èæ¯ã«ãã®åã©ãã®
çºèšã«å¯Ÿãã Bæè«ãªãã®è§£éããã£ããšæ¯ã
è¿ã£ãŠããããããŠïŒãã®çåŸã®ãçºèšã®æå³
ãããã¡ãã詳ããèããŠãããã°ããã£ãã
ãšïŒå®éã®çºèšãšãã®çºèšã«å¯Ÿããèªèº«ã®è§£é
ã®ãºã¬ããã£ãã®ãã©ããã確èªããå¿ èŠãã
ã£ããšæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠããã
äºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãããèªãã§ã¯ïŒãèšè¿°
ã§ããŠããªãçåŸã«å¯Ÿããèªèº«ã®å£°ããããªã
ã£ãããšãã£ã客芳çãªäºå®ã®çµæãæ¯ãè¿ã
ã«çãŸãïŒå£°ãããããªãããšã§ã©ã®ãããªå
é¡ãããã®ãã¯æããããŠããªãã£ãããã
ãïŒåã©ãã®çºèšã«ãããèæ¯ãæèãææ¥ã®
äžã«äœçœ®ã¥ããåæãæ瀺ããããšã§ïŒãããŸ
ã§ã®åã©ãã«å¯ŸããèŠåãã®ããæ¹ãææ¥äžã«
ãããæ¯æŽã®ããæ¹ãåãçŽããŠããã
â¡åå ã¬ãã«ã§ã®ææ¥æ¹åã®èŠç¹ã®ç²åŸ
Bæè«ã¯ïŒåå å šäœã®äžã§ 1 æéã®ææ¥å®è·µ
ãäœçœ®ã¥ãæ¯ãè¿ãããšã«èª²é¡ãæã£ãŠããã
ææ¥ã®åæã«ãããŠçè ãã¯ïŒäžã€ã®çã«çç®
ãïŒããã§ã®çºè©±ãããšã«åå ã«ãããåã©ã
ã®åŠç¿éçšãåæããããããŠïŒåå ãéããŠ
1æéã®äžã«å€ãã®èª²é¡ãèšå®ããŠããããšã«
ãã£ãŠæ£çãäžå¿ã«ææ¥ãå±éããããšã«é¥ã
å¯èœæ§ãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããšããããšã代æ¡ãš
ããŠæ瀺ããããã®æ瀺ãåããŠïŒBæè«ã¯æ
æ¥ã«å¯Ÿãã課é¡ãšããŠãééã£ãéšåã«å¯ŸããŠ
ã®ãã©ãŒã«ã¹ãããç解ã§ããŠããªãã£ããã
ãåã«å¯Ÿãããã©ããŒããäžååã§ãã£ãããš
ãæããäžã§ïŒä»åŸã¯åŠç¿ã掻åã粟éžããã
å¿ èŠæ§ãèªèããŠããããŸãïŒåã«ç解ã§ããŠ
ããªãåã©ãã«å¯ŸããŠãµããŒãã§ããŠããªãã£
ããšããäºå®ãæ¯ãè¿ãã®ã¿ãªããïŒä»åŸã掻
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
12
åã粟éžããããšãã解決çãããã®ã§ã¯ãªã
ããšããæ¯ãè¿ããè¡ã£ãŠããããšã¯ïŒåã«æ
æ¥ã®ãããã³ã«ãæ瀺ããã ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒãã®
çºèšã®æå³ãçè ãåæããŠæ瀺ããããã§ã
ããšèããããã
以äžã® 2ç¹ã®åæããïŒå ·äœçãªææ¥ã«ã
ããè«è©±ã®æå³ãåæããææ¥åæããšããã³
ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ããããšã«ãã£ãŠ Bæè«ããããŸ
ã§æ±ããŠãã䟡å€èŠ³ã信念ãæºãã¶ãåãçŽã
ããšã«ã€ãªãã£ããšèãããããBæè«ã«ãšã£
ãŠæ¬åæã¯ïŒèªèº«ã®ææ¥ã«ã€ããŠããªãããšã
ãèŠç¹ããã®åãçŽããå¯èœã«ããå¹æããã£
ããšèããããã
4 ç·åèå¯
æ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒçå¯çå®è·µãæ¯ããæè²ç 究ã»
æè²ç 究è ã®åœ¹å²ãæ€èšããããïŒä»¥äž 3ã€ã®
æé ã«ãã£ãŠïŒåŠè¡çãªå°éæ§ãæã€ç 究è ã
é¢ããããšã§ãæ·±ããçå¯ãä¿ãããšãã§ãã
ã®ããæ€èšããŠããã
â ææ¥å®è·µåã®ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã§çŸåšã®èª²é¡æ
èãèŽãåãã
â¡äºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒãèžãŸãïŒææ¥ã®èŠ³å¯ãª
ãã³ã«ææ¥åæãè¡ãã
â¢ææ¥åæããšããã³ã¹ãšããŠååæåž«ã«æ
瀺ãïŒå床ææ¥å®è·µãæ¯ãè¿ã£ãŠãããã
ãŸãïŒææ¥åæãè¡ãéã«ã¯ïŒçåŸã®åŠç¿é
çšã察象ã«ãã®è«è©±ã«ãããæå³ãææ¥å®è·µã®
æèã®äžã§æ€èšãïŒåå å šäœã®æ§é ããããã«
é¢ããæ¹åæ¡ãæ瀺ããã
Aæè«ã Bæè«ãïŒäºåã®ã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ã
ããŠèªã£ãŠããå°é£æã¯ææ¥äžã«ãããåã©ã
ã®çºèšã®èæ¯ãæèãèŠåãããšãªãïŒçµæã®
ã¿ã«çŠç¹åãããèŠåãã§ããããšã§ãã£ãã
ãã®ãããªå°é£æã«å¯ŸããŠïŒçè ããæåž«ã®æ
å°æè¡ãçåŸã®æäœãšãã£ããã¯ããªéšåã ã
ã§ã¯ãªãåå å šäœã®ãã¯ããªæµããæèããå
æããšããã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ãäºåŸã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒ
ãšããŠã®ååçå¯ãè¡ã£ãããšã§ïŒä»¥äžã®ïŒç¹
ã®ãããªå€å®¹ãèŠåããããã
â åã©ãç解ã®åãçŽã
Aæè«ã Bæè«ãïŒèªèº«ãæ±ããŠããåã©
ãã«å¯Ÿããç解ããšããã³ã¹ã®æ瀺ã«ãã£ãŠå
ãçŽãããããšãèªã£ãŠãããäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥
ãŒã«ãããŠèªãããåã©ãç解ã¯ãåãã£ãŠã
ãåããåãã£ãŠããªãåããšãã£ãïŒãã®èæ¯
ã«ãŸã§èžã¿èŸŒãŸãªããã®ã§ãã£ãããšããã³ã¹
ã®æ瀺ãšååçå¯ã«ãã£ãŠïŒåãã£ãŠãããšç
解ããŠããåã©ãã§ãããã»ã¹ã®éäžã§åãã£
ãŠããªãå Žé¢ãèŠãããããšïŒAæè«ïŒïŒåã©ã
ã®è¡çºãçºèšã®èæ¯ã«èããããå¯èœæ§ïŒBæ
è«ïŒãšããïŒããææ¥ã®æèãè¡çºã®èæ¯ãèž
ãŸããã¬ãã«ã§ã®çå¯ãè¡ãããšãã§ããŠã
ãã
â¡ ææ¥ãæããèŠç¹ã®è¡šåº
Aæè«ã Bæè«ãïŒäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ã
ããŠã¯ææ¥äœããææ¥ã®æ¯ãè¿ããè¡ãéã«ïŒ
åå æ§é ãæèã㊠1æéã®ææ¥ãæããããš
ãã§ããŠããªããšãã課é¡ãæã£ãŠããããšã
æãããšãªã£ãããããïŒææ¥åæããšããã³
ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ãååçå¯ãè¡ãããšã«ãã£ãŠïŒ
以äžã®ãããªæ°ä»ããåŸãŠãããAæè«ã¯ïŒèª
身ã®ææ¥å®è·µã«ãããåå æ§æãèªèŠãïŒãã®
èŠç¹ã§ä»ã®ææ¥å®è·µãæããå¿ èŠããããšèªè
ããŠãããBæè«ã¯ïŒåå ãéããããããæ
確ã«ãããããšã§ãåŠç¿æŽ»åã®ç²Ÿéžããããäž
寧ãªåã©ããžã®é¢ããè¡ãå¿ èŠæ§ãèªèããŠã
ããããªãã¡ïŒAæè«ã Bæè«ãïŒãšãã«åå
æ§æãšããç¹ã«èª²é¡ãæ±ããŠãããïŒååçå¯
ãéããŠèªèº«ã®åå ã«å¯ŸããèŠæ¹ãåã«ãã€ãª
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
13
ãã£ãŠããªãããšããã ãã§ãªãïŒ1æéã«ã
ããå ·äœçãªåŠç¿æŽ»åã®åšãæ¹ãšåå æ§æäžã®
åé¡ãé¢é£ããŠãããšããããšã瀺åããèªã
ãè¡ã£ãŠããã
以äžã® 2ç¹ã«å ±éããç¹åŸŽãšããŠïŒ(i)ãã
ãŸã§ã®ãçµæã«ç®ãåããèŠåããããããïŒ
ãããææ¥ã®æèãèæ¯ãèæ ®ããèŠåããã®
å¿ èŠæ§ãèªèããããã«ãªã£ãããšã«å ããŠïŒ
ïŒiiïŒ1æéã®ææ¥ã®äžã§åã©ãã®åŠç¿ãæã
ãã®ã§ã¯ãªãïŒåå ãéããèŠç¹ã§æããããš
ã®éèŠæ§ãèªèããããã«ãªã£ãŠããããšãæ
ããããã
ããã(i)ïŒ(ii)ã®å€å®¹ãå¯èœã«ããèæ¯ãš
ããŠïŒä»¥äž 2 ç¹ãèããããã第äžã«çè ãã
ç 究ååè ã®èæ¯ãèžãŸããäžã§ïŒå ·äœçãªèŠ³
å¯å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªã£ãå®è·µãåŠè¡çãªç¥èŠãã䟡å€ã¥
ããããšã§ãããäºåã€ã³ã¿ãã¥ãŒã«ãããŠ
ã¯ïŒæåž«ã®æå¡é€ææããçŸåšã«è³ããŸã§ã®ãš
ããœãŒããå°ãïŒååæåž«ã®æã€äŸ¡å€èŠ³ã信念
ãèžãŸããäžã§èŠ³å¯ããå®è·µãåŠè¡çãªç¥èŠã
æã£ãŠäŸ¡å€ã¥ããããšãè©Šã¿ãããã®ããšã§ïŒ1
æéã®ææ¥æ¹åã«ãšã©ãŸããïŒèªåèªèº«ã®ææ¥
å®è·µå šè¬ã«åœ±é¿ããŠãã䟡å€èŠ³ã信念ãåãçŽ
ãããšã«ã€ãªãã£ãŠãããšèããããã第äº
ã«ïŒææ¥åæããšããã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ããéïŒ
åã©ãã®åŠç¿éçšãæç§ã®èŠç¹ããåæããšã
ãã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ããããšãæããããããã
ãŸã§ã®ã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã»ãªãµãŒããªã©ãå«ãæåž«ã®
åŠç¿ã«é¢ããå è¡ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒææ¥äžã«ãããå
ã©ãã®çºèšãæç§ã®ææ¥ãšããŠã¿ããšãã«ã©ã®
ãããªæå³ãããã®ããäžå¿çãªäž»é¡ãšããŠæ
ããããŠããªãã£ãããããïŒæ¬ç 究ã§ã¯ïŒé
èªèšé²ãããšã«ïŒåã©ãã®çºèšãæç§ã®æèã
ãåæãïŒãšããã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ããããã®ã
ããªãšããã³ã¹ã®åšãæ¹ã¯ïŒçå¯çå®è·µãæ¯ã
ãæè²ç 究ã»ç 究è ã®åšãæ¹ã«ã瀺åãäžãã
ãã®ã§ãããšèããããã
ä»¥äž 2ç¹ã®èŠç¹ãå«ã¿ååæåž«ãšã®ååçå¯
ãè¡ã£ãããšãïŒé€ææã§åŠãã§ããæç§æè²
ã®çè«ãšå®éã®åŠæ ¡çŸå Žã§ã®ææã»åŠç¿éçšã
çµã³ã€ãïŒæ¹ããŠèªèº«ã®äŸ¡å€èŠ³ã信念ãåãçŽ
ãããšã«ã€ãªãã£ãŠãããšèããããã
æ¬ç 究ã«ãããéçã課é¡ã¯ä»¥äžïŒç¹æã
ãããã
第äžã«ïŒä»åã¯ãããŸã§ã 1ã€ã®åå ãéã
ãå®è·µè ãšã®ååçå¯ã«çãŸã£ãŠããããã®ã
ãïŒç 究ååè ã§ããæåž«ãšåŒãç¶ãååçå¯
ãè¡ã£ãå ŽåïŒã©ã®ãããªå€å®¹ãçããã®ãæ€
èšãè¡ãå¿ èŠããããé·æéã«ãããååçå¯
ãè¡ãããšã§ïŒãã®çå¯ãå®è·µè ã«ãšã£ãŠæåž«
ãšããŠã®æŽå²ã®äžéšãšãªãïŒãã®äžã§ããæ¹å€
çã«èªãã®å®è·µãçå¯ã§ããããã«ãªãããšã
æåŸ ãããã
第äºã«ïŒãšããã³ã¹ãšããŠæ瀺ããææ¥å
æãåå ã¬ãã«ã§ã®ãã®ã«ãšã©ãŸã£ãŠããç¹ã§
ããã該åœæç§ã«ãããŠæ åœæåž«ãç®æãç®æš
ã«ç §ãããŠïŒã«ãªãã¥ã©ã å šäœã®äžã§åå ã 1
æéã®ææ¥ã«ãããåã©ãã®åŠç¿éçšãäœçœ®ã¥
ããããã®ããæè²å 容ç 究ã®ç¥èŠãèžãŸããŠ
åæããããšã§ïŒæåž«ã®æã€äŸ¡å€ã信念ã®ã¬ã
ã«ã§ã®æ·±ãçå¯ãä¿ãããšèããããã
第äžã«ä»å ¥å¹æã®æ¯èŒå¯èœæ§ã«ã€ããŠã§ã
ãã1æéããšã®æåž«ã®çå¯ããšããã³ã¹æ瀺
åã«æåž«ã«åå ãéããçå¯ãè¡ã£ãŠãããïŒ
ãã®äžã§ãšããã³ã¹ãæ瀺ããå Žåã®çå¯ã®å€
容ã®æ¯èŒãïŒãšããã³ã¹ãæ瀺ããæåž«ãšããª
ãæåž«ã§ã®æ¯èŒã«ããïŒç 究è ãå®è·µã«é¢ãã
ããšåœ±é¿ããã粟緻ã«æ€èšã§ãããšèããã
ãã
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
14
åèæç®
ç§ç°åä»£çŸ (1996)ãæåž«æè²ã«ããã ãç
å¯ã æŠå¿µã®å±é--åççå®è·µå®¶ãè²ãŠãæåž«æ
è²ãããã£ãŠ ããæè²åŠå¹Žå ± 5ãïŒpp.451-467.
ElliottïŒJ. (2001) Making evidenceâbased
practice educational. British educational
research journalïŒ 27(5)ïŒpp.555-574.
é è€è²ç·ïŒçå·åŒåŠïŒ2015ïŒããã¶ã€ã³ç 究ã
çšãããšããã³ã¹ã«åºã¥ãææ¥ç 究ã®å®è·µãšæ
æ¡ããæ¥æ¬æè²æ ¡åŠäŒè«æèªã39(3)ïŒpp.221-
233.
è€æ±åº·åœŠïŒ2018ïŒãæè²å®è·µç 究ã«ããããäº
å®ããšã¯äœããæ¥æ¬æè²æ¹æ³åŠäŒïŒç·šïŒãæè²å®
è·µã®ç¶æ¿ãšæè²æ¹æ³åŠã®èª²é¡ãïŒpp.68-81.
è€åé¡ (2019)ãåä»»æ (3 幎ç®) æåž«ã®å®è·µ
ç¥ã®åœ¢æ: çŠå±±åžç«å€§åŠæè²åŠéšåæ¥çã察象
ãšããäºäŸç 究ããçŠå±±åžç«å€§åŠæè²åŠéšç 究çŽ
èŠã 7, pp.103-116.
æšå£è¡ (2010) ãææ¥ç 究ã®æ°ããæ¹åæ§--
åççå®è·µå®¶ã«ããã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã»ãªãµãŒããšæ
å掻çšãã åºå³¶å€§åŠå€§åŠé¢æè²åŠç 究ç§çŽèŠ 第
äžéš åŠç¿éçºé¢é£é åã59ïŒpp.21-30.
姫éå®æ²»ïŒ2019ïŒãææ¥ç 究ã®æŽå²ãååŽé倫
ïŒç£ä¿®ïŒãææ¥ç 究ã®ããã³ãã£ã¢ãããã«ãŽã¡
æžæ¿ïŒ pp.16-30
æ± éç¯ç·ïŒç³åå ïŒé«éŠå©·ïŒçŠå æ£åïŒå±±å£
å®åžïŒ åæžãããïŒè¿è€ç§æš¹ïŒå°Ÿè€éåïŒå ç
æ³°èŒïŒèæŸé匥ïŒå±±æ¬çšïŒåå·ååïŒé©æ ä»ïŒ
ç¥é幞éïŒå·å£åºçŸ(2018)ãèšè°æŽ»åã«çç®ã
ãäžåŠæ ¡ç€ŸäŒç§å°çææ¥ç 究: 瀟äŒèªèãšåžæ°
çè³è³ªã®äžäœçãªè²æãç®æããŠããæ¥æ¬äœè²å€§
åŠå€§åŠé¢æè²åŠç 究ç§çŽèŠã 1(1)ïŒpp.95-111.
ç³äºè±çïŒ2015ïŒãæè²å®è·µã®è«çããããšã
ãã³ã¹ã«åºã¥ãæè²ããåãçŽãããæè²åŠç
究ã82(2)ïŒpp.30-42.
ç³äºè±çïŒ2017ïŒãæ¥æ¬ã«ãããæåž«ã®å®è·µç
究ã®æåãç³äºè±çïŒç·šïŒãã¢ã¯ãã£ãã»ã©ãŒã
ã³ã°ãè¶ ããŠãããç 究ãããæåž«ãžãæ¥æ¬æš
æºïŒpp.10-23.
å·å£åºçŸïŒåæžãããïŒè¿è€ç§æš¹ïŒå°Ÿè€é
åïŒé«éŠå©·ïŒçŠå æ£åïŒå±±å£å®åžïŒå çæ³°èŒïŒ
èæŸé匥ïŒå±±æ¬çšïŒåå·ååïŒç¥é幞éïŒé©æ
ä»ïŒæ± éç¯ç· (2018)ãæç§ã®æ§é ã«åºã¥ããå°
åŠæ ¡ç€ŸäŒç§ææ¥ç 究: ç¥èã®æ§é å³ãšæŠå¿µçæ
çµã¿ãçšããŠããåŠæ ¡æè²å®è·µåŠç 究ã 24ïŒ
pp.83-92.
äºå®®è¡äžïŒå°è°·è£äºéïŒäžå±±å幞ïŒäžè¥¿å€§ïŒ
ä¹ ä¿æ人ïŒè¥¿ååéŠèïŒ2019ïŒãçå¯ãä¿ãææ¥
ç 究ã®åšãæ¹ã«ã€ããŠã®å®è·µçç 究ããåæ山倧
åŠæè·å€§åŠé¢çŽèŠåŠæ ¡æè²å®è·µç 究ã3ïŒpp.81-
89.
åæ¬ç¯€å² (2010)ã ææ¥ç 究ã®äºåŸåè°äŒã«
ãããæåž«ã®çå¯éçšã®æ€èš-ææ¥è ãšéææ¥è
ã®çå¯éçšã®ç¹åŸŽã«çç®ããŠããæåž«åŠç 究ã 8
(9)ïŒ pp.27-37.
SchönïŒD.ïŒ1983ïŒThe Reflective
Practitioner: How Professional Think in
ActionïŒBasic Books. æ³æ²¢æäžã»äžèŒªå¥äº
ïŒèš³ïŒïŒ2007ïŒãçå¯çå®è·µãšã¯äœããïŒé³³æžæ¿.
島ç°åž (2008)ã ã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã»ãªãµãŒãã«ã
ãææ¥ç 究ã«é¢ããæ¹æ³è«çèå¯--ãã®æ矩ãš
課é¡ããä¿¡å·å€§åŠæè²åŠéšçŽèŠã121ïŒpp.91-
102.
è€æ£®è£æ¢ïŒç°äžæ³ïŒ2017ïŒãå ¥è·æã«ãããäž
åŠæ ¡ç€ŸäŒç§æåž«ã®è·èœçºéã«é¢ããç 究ããåºå³¶
çµæžå€§åŠç 究è«éã40(2)ïŒpp.43-51.
æž¡éšç«ä¹ïŒ2016ïŒãæãåœã®ããã©ã³ç€ŸäŒç§æ
åž«ã®ææ¥åæã«èŠãããã³ã¬ã¯ããã¹ïŒæè²åŠ
è ã»ããã©ã³æåž« 7人ã®ææ¥æ¹è©ã«èŠãããå
æèŠç¹ã®éãããããæ±äº¬åŠèžå€§åŠçŽèŠ.人æ瀟
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
15
äŒç§åŠç³»ãâ ¡(67)ïŒpp.1-33.
åæéŠã»å岡æ¶åïŒ2008ïŒãèªãã®å Žã«ããã
ä¿è²è ãšç 究è ã®é¢ä¿ããä¿è²åŠç 究ã46(2)ïŒ
pp.12-21.
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
Working Paper Series in Young Scholar Training Program No.33 April, 2020
16
è£è¡šçŽ
Copyright © 2010-2020 Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
æ±äº¬å€§åŠå€§åŠé¢æè²åŠç 究ç§éå±åŠæ ¡æè²é«åºŠåã»å¹ææ€èšŒã»ã³ã¿ãŒ
Center for Advanced School Education and Evidence-Based Research,
Graduate School of Education, The University of Tokyo
WEBSITE (æ¥æ¬èª): http://www.schoolexcellence.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp/
WEBSITE (English): htttp://www.schoolexcellence.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp/en/