8/2/2019 A Question of Eligibility Comparison Chapter 2

1/2

From Chapter 2 of A Question of Eligibility,Published March 2012

From Wheres the Birth Certificate?, PublishedMay 2011and Corsi article from January 2011 -http://www.jeromecorsi.com/article.php?id=23

A search of the Polks Directory of Honolulu for

1961-1962 indicates that 6085 KalanianaoleHighway was being rented by the grandparents,Madelyn L. Dunham, listed as a loan interviewerand escrow agent at the Bank of Hawaii andStanley A. Dunham, listed as a manager with PrattFurniture.

In a separate listing, Ann S. Obama, Obamasmother, is identified as a student living at the 6085Kalanianaole Highway address; Barack H. Obama,her husband, is listed as a student living at aseparate address, own apartment at 625 11

th

Avenue, closer to the University of Hawaii atManoa, not at 6085 Kalanianaole Highway, with his

wife and in-laws, and supposedly his son.

Investigators concludedin that:

- Neither newspaper had an editor thathandled birth announcements;

- Both newspapers merely printed birthannouncements, directly as received, from

information published in Department ofHawaii vital statistics announcements;

- Hawaiian hospitals did not report tonewspapers any birth announcementinformation;

- Neither newspaper independently checkedthe truthfulness or accuracy of birthannouncement information published bythe newspapers from Hawaii Department ofHealth vital statistics records.

---

Then, on Jan. 18, 2011, the Honolulu StarAdvertiserreported an interview with Hawaii Gov.Neil Abercrombie in which Abercrombies answerssuggested a long-form, hospital-generated birthcertificate for Barack Obama may not exist withinthe vital records maintained by the HawaiiDepartment of Health.

A search of the Polks Directory of Honolulufor

1961-1962 indicates(see Exhibit 41, page 175) that6085 Kalanianaole Highway was being rented bythe grandparents, Madelyn L. Dunham, listed as aloan interviewer and escrow agent at the Bank ofHawaii and Stanley A. Dunham, listed as amanager with Pratt Furniture.

In a separate listing (Exhibit 42, page 175), StanleyAnn Obama, Obamas mother, is identified as astudent living at the 6085 Kalanianaole Highwayaddress; Barack H. Obama, her husband, islisted as a student living at a separate address,anapartment at 625 11

thAvenue.

There is no Polk directory listing of Barack ObamaSr. living at 6085 Kalanianaole Highway, with hiswife and in-laws.

WND interviews with the two Hawaiiannewspapers revealed that:

- Neither newspaper had an editor thathandled birth announcements;

- Both newspapers merely printed birthannouncements, directly as received, from

information published in Hawaii DOH vitalstatistics announcements;

- Hawaiian hospitals did not report tonewspapers any birth announcementinformation; Hawaiian Certifications of LiveBirth do not typically list hospital of birth orattending physician;

- Neither newspaper independently checkedthe truthfulness or accuracy of birthannouncement information published bythe newspapers from Hawaii DOH vitalstatistics records.

---

On Tuesday, the Honolulu Star Advertiserhttp://www.staradvertiser.com/editorials/20110118_This_is_a_collaborative_endeavor.htmlprinted an interview with Hawaii Gov. NeilAbercrombie that suggested a long-form, hospital-generated birth certificate for Barack Obamamay not exist within the vital records maintained bythe Hawaii Department of Health

8/2/2019 A Question of Eligibility Comparison Chapter 2

2/2

Toward the end of the interview with the HonoluluStar Advertiser, the newspaper asked Abercrombiethe following: "Q: You stirred up quite a controversywith your comments regarding birthers and yourplan to release more information regarding

President Barack Obama's birth certificate. How isthat coming?"

In responding, Abercrombie acknowledged that thebirth certificate issue will have "politicalimplications" for the presidential election in 2012"that we simply cannot have."

In suggesting he was still intent on producing morebirth records on Obama from the HawaiiDepartment of Health vital records vault,Abercrombie told the newspaper there was arecording of the Obama birth in the State Archivesthat Abercrombie wants to make public.

Interestingly, Abercrombie did not report to thenewspaper that he or the Hawaii Department ofHealth had found Obama's long-form, hospital-generated birth certificate.

Instead, all Abercrombie suggested hisinvestigations had found to date was anunspecified listing or notation ofObama's birth that someone had made in the StateArchives.

"It was actually written I am told, this is what our

investigation is showing, it actually exists in thearchives, written down ..." Abercrombie said.

For seemingly the first time, Abercrombie was veryfrank in his public comments to acknowledge thatpresidential politics motivated his search forObama birth records, implying that failure toresolve the questions that persist unanswered bythe president about his birth records and nativitystory may damage Obama's chance for re-election.

"If there is a political agenda [regarding Obama'sbirth certificate], then there is nothing I can do

about that, nor can the president," Abercrombiesaid.

Toward the end of the interview with the HonoluluStar Advertiser, the newspaper asked Abercrombiethe following: "Q: You stirred up quite a controversywith your comments regarding birthers and yourplan to release more information regarding

President Barack Obama's birth certificate. How isthat coming?"

In responding, Abercrombie acknowledged that thebirth certificate issue will have "politicalimplications" for the presidential election in 2012"that we simply cannot have."

In suggesting he was still intent on producing morebirth records on Obama from the HawaiiDepartment of Health vital records vault,Abercrombie told the newspaper there was arecording of the Obama birth in the State Archivesthat Abercrombie wants to make public.

Interestingly, Abercrombie did not report to thenewspaper that he or the Hawaii Department ofHealth had found Obama's long-form, hospital-generated birth certificate; all Abercrombiesuggested his investigations had found to date wasan unspecified listing or notation of Obama's birththat someone had made in the State Archives.

"It was actually written I am told, this is what our

investigation is showing, it actually exists in thearchives, written down ..." Abercrombie said.

For seemingly the first time, Abercrombie was veryfrank in his public comments to acknowledge thatpresidential politics motivated his search forObama birth records, implying that failure toresolve the questions that persist unanswered bythe president about his birth records and nativitystory may damage Obama's chance for re-election.

"If there is a political agenda [regarding Obama'sbirth certificate], then there is nothing I can do

about that, nor can the president," he said.