4th assignment transpo
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
1/72
4thAssignment
4th Assignment................................................................................................................................1
1. Compania Maritima v. Insurance Co...........................................................................................23. H.E. Heacock Co. v. Macondray and Co...................................................................................13
4. Eastern Shipping ines v. IAC..................................................................................................1!". Sea#and Service v. IAC..............................................................................................................2$
!. Maersk ine v. CA.....................................................................................................................3%
%. Cathay &aci'ic v. CA..................................................................................................................4$(. a Ma##orca v. )e *esus............................................................................................................."1
1+. ara v. ,a#encia......................................................................................................................."!
11. )ang-a v. CA..........................................................................................................................$1
12. China Air#ines v. CA................................................................................................................$!
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
2/72
1. Compania Maritima v. Insurance Co.
EN BANC[G.R. No. L-18965. October 30, 1964.]COMPA!A MAR!"!MA, #et$t$o%er, &'. !N()RANCE COMPAN* O+ NOR" AMER!CA,re'#o%e%t.
R/e $%2'% /or #et$t$o%er.Oet, G$bb' Oet /or re'#o%e%t.(*LLAB)(1. CON"RAC" O+ CARR!AGE EN CON"RAC" COMPLE"E LOA!NG O+ CARGO ONCARR!ER7( BARGE PREPARA"OR* "O LOA!NG ON (!P. ere te '$##er e$&ere tecr2o to te crr$er % te tter too: #o''e''$o% tereo/ b; #c$%2 $t o% $2ter or br2e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
3/72
J+!NAL E("!NA"!ONH Bo'to%J"ere/ter, te t?o oe br2e' e/t Mceo7' ?r/ % #roceee to %
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
4/72
J+!NAL E("!NA"!ONH Bo'to%.J"e /ct tt te crr$er 'e%t $t' $2ter' /ree o/ cr2e to t:e te e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
5/72
J"e $b$$t; o/ te crr$er ' co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
6/72
te 'oe' o/ % '=b't$t=te te tter $% e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
7/72
2. Samar Mining Co. v. Nordeutscher Lloyd(ECON !!(!ON[G.R. No. L-@863. October @3, 1984.](AMAR M!N!NG COMPAN*, !NC., #$%t$//-##eee, &'. NORE)"(CER LLO* % C.+.(ARP COMPAN*, !NC., e/e%%t'-##e%t'.P. e Oc
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
8/72
4. !. !. L!AB!L!"* O+ COMMON CARR!ER( LA( APPL!CABLE "EREON. "e$b$$t; o/ te co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
9/72
)#o% rr$& o/ te /ore'$ &e''e t te #ort o/ M%$, te /ore
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
10/72
o#erte b; t$' crr$er ' be co%'$ere 'oe; te /or?r$%2 2e%t o/ te '$##er %?$to=t %; oter re'#o%'$b$$t; ?t'oe&er e&e% to=2 te /re$2t /or te ?oe tr%'#ort' bee% coecte b; $e >>>
"e crr$er or
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
11/72
JArt$ce 138. "e e>tror$%r; $b$$t; o/ te co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
12/72
"e recor' /$ to re&e #roo/ o/ %e2$2e%ce, ece$t or /r= co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
13/72
3. .!. eacoc" Co. v. Macondray and Co.
#$%t$//-##e%t, &'. MACONRA* COMPAN*, !NC., e/e%%t-##e%t.+$'er e$tt /or #$%t$// % ##e%t.o/'o%, o/'o% (c?r:o#/ /or e/e%%t % ##e%t.
(*LLAB)(1. COMMON CARR!ER B!LL O+ LA!NG ("!P)LA"!ON( REGAR!NG L!AB!L!"* O+CARR!ER +OR LO(( O+ OR AMAGE "O CARGO AL!!"* O+ ()C ("!P)LA"!ON(. "ree:$%' o/ 't$#=t$o% &e o/te% bee%
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
14/72
J1. !t $' cee500 #er /re$2t to%, or, $% #ro#ort$o% /or %; #rt o/ to%, =%e'' te &=e be e>#re'';'tte ere$% % &ore< /re$2t #$ tereo%.JJ9. A'o, tt $% te e&e%t o/ c$
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
15/72
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
16/72
e/e%%t7' $b$$t;. !t $' $//$c=t to reco%c$e te< ?$to=t o$%2 &$oe%ce to te %2=2e='e % re$%2 e>ce#t$o%' % co%$t$o%' $%to te =%ert:$%2 co%t$%e $% c='e 9 ttre %ot tere. "$' be$%2 te c'e, te b$ o/ $%2 $% =e't$o% 'o= be $%ter#rete 2$%'tte e/e%%t crr$er, ?$c re? '$ co%trct. JA ?r$tte% co%trct 'o=, $% c'e o/ o=bt,be $%ter#rete 2$%'t te #rt; ?o ' r?% te co%trct.J K6 R. C. L., 854. !t $' ?e-:%o?% #r$%c$#e o/ co%'tr=ct$o% tt
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
17/72
4. !astern Shipping Lines v. IAC
+!R(" !!(!ON[G.R. No. 69044. M; @9, 198.]EA("ERN (!PP!NG L!NE(, !NC., #et$t$o%er, &'. !N"ERME!A"E APPELLA"E CO)R" %
EELOPMEN" !N()RANCE ()RE"* CORPORA"!ON, re'#o%e%t'.[G.R. No. 148. M; @9, 198.]EA("ERN (!PP!NG L!NE(, !NC., #et$t$o%er, &'. "E N!((!N +!RE AN MAR!NE !N()RANCECO., % OA +!RE MAR!NE !N()RANCE CO., L"., re'#o%e%t'. E C ! ( ! O NMELENC!O-ERRERA, #H
"e'e t?o c'e', bot /or te reco&er; o/ te &=e o/ cr2o $%'=r%ce, ro'e /ro< te '
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
18/72
Goo' b; (e Act KCOG(A % tt ?e% te o'' b; /$re $' e'tb$'e, te b=re% o/#ro&$%2 %e2$2e%ce o/ te &e''e $' '$/te to te cr2o '$##er.O% (e#te
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
19/72
=%e'' c='e b; $2t%$%2 11 or b; oter %t=r $''ter or c$erc$'e =e $$2e%ce to #re&e%t or
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
20/72
O% te )( 500 Per Pc:2e L$ct; te $b$tJAJ, % te c%2e rte o/ [email protected] to )(1, ?o= be P@86,160, orJ
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
21/72
e /$% %o re&er'$be error. "e 1@8 crto%' % %ot te t?o K@ co%t$%er' 'o= beco%'$ere ' te '$##$%2 =%$t.!% M$t'=$ Co., Lt. &'. A#ort L$%e', !%c. 636 + @ 80 K1981, te co%'$2%ee' o/t$% $%2ot' % te '$##er o/ /oor co&er$%2 bro=2t ct$o% 2$%'t te &e''e o?%er %o#ertor to reco&er /or o'' o/ $%2ot' % /oor co&er$%2, ?$c bee% '$##e $% &e''e-'=##$e co%t$%er'. "e ).(. $'tr$ct Co=rt /or te (o=ter% $'tr$ct o/ Ne? *or: re%ere
F=2
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
22/72
KA#$% te ='e o/ te e't$>> >>> >>>J!%ee, '$%ce /ter No&e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
23/72
te b'$' o/ te e&$e%ce =ce. t =e #roce'' bor' $' b'o=te c: o/ o##ort=%$t;to be er. @4O% te A?r o/ Attor%e;7' +ee'HPet$t$o%er Crr$er =e't$o%' te ?r o/ ttor%e;7' /ee'. !% bot c'e', re'#o%e%t Co=rt//$r
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
24/72
"e t?o co%t$%er' ?ere e$&ere b; te '$##er to te crr$er re; 'ee /or '$#
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
25/72
19. JA co%t$%er $' #er
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
26/72
#. Sealand Service v. IAC
+!R(" !!(!ON[G.R. No. 5118. A=2='t 31, 198.](EA-LAN (ER!CE, !NC., #et$t$o%er, &'. !N"ERME!A"E APPELLA"E CO)R" % PA)L!NOC)E, o$%2 b='$%e'' =%er te %
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
27/72
tt e $%&o:e' te #ro&$'$o%' o/ '$ Coe 2o&er%$%2 te ob$2t$o%' o/ co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
28/72
crr$2e o/ 2oo' b; 'e to % /ro< P$$##$%e #ort' $% /ore$2% tre b; Co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
29/72
'$ 't$#=t$o% $' F='t % re'o%be $' r2=be /ro< te /ct tt $t ecoe' Art. 150 $t'e/$% #ro&$$%2 $
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
30/72
+=rter
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
31/72
. C$&$ C'e No. @0810. 8. Roo, #. @1. 9. AC-G.R. C No. 06150.10. Roo, #. 1@, @[email protected]. 90 P$. 836, 845-846 'ee 'o A#re'' Co. &'. Nt$&$, 46 P$. @0 %Poe%$> A''=r%ce Co., Lt. &'. )%$te (tte' L$%e', @@ (CRA 65.
1@. Art. 153, C$&$ Coe.13. Art. 166, C$&$ Coe (' % Co. &'. Pc$/$c M$ (te
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
32/72
$. Alitalia v. IAC+!R(" !!(!ON[G.R. No. 19@9. ece
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
33/72
% =
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
34/72
b; %; 2e%t o/ te crr$er ct$%2 ?$t$% te 'co#e o/ $' e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
35/72
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
36/72
15. !., #. 91.16. += t$teH JCo%&e%t$o% /or te )%$/$ct$o% o/ Cert$% R=e' Ret$%2 to !%ter%t$o%Crr$2e b; A$r '$2%e t r'?, October 1@, 19@9J KLe2=e o/ Nt$o%' "ret; (er$e',co [1946-198@] c$t$%2 13 Le2=e o/ Nt$o%' "ret$e'(er$e' 11. "e r'? Co%&e%t$o% ?'
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
37/72
33. ==et &. P% A
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
38/72
%. Maers" Line v. CA
"!R !!(!ON[G.R. No. 9461. M; 1, 1993.]MAER(D L!NE, #et$t$o%er, &'. CO)R" O+ APPEAL( AN E+REN . CA("!LLO, o$%2 b='$%e''
=%er te %
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
39/72
ere', e 2$&e' $' co%'e%t KM2e% M%=/ct=r$%2 Mr:et$%2 Cor#ort$o% &. Co=rt o/A##e', et ., @01 (CRA 10@ [1991]. !% M2e%, K'=#r, ?e r=eH J!t $' o%2 't%$%2
F=r$'#r=e%t$ r=e tt b$ o/ $%2 o#erte' bot ' rece$#t % ' co%trct. !t $' rece$#t /or te 2oo' '$##e % co%trct to tr%'#ort % e$&er te '
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
40/72
$%&o$ce, cert$/$ct$o% /ro< te $''=er o/ te etter o/ cre$t % te Me
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
41/72
e%;$%2 tt $t co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
42/72
!!Jeter or %ot re'#o%e%t C't$o $' e%t$te to >>>JRe te /o=rt ''$2%e errorH A##e%t Mer': L$%e7' $%'$'te%ce tt ##eee ' %o c='eo/ ct$o% 2$%'t $t % ##e%t E$ L$; bec='e te '$#
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
43/72
O% te oter %, #r$&te re'#o%e%t c$
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
44/72
!% (=o, r. &. Co=rt o/ A##e' K@0 (CRA 498 [199@] t$' Co=rt eHJ"e o/t-re#ete r=e re2r$%2 crr$er7' $b$$t; /or e; $' tt $% te b'e%ce o/ '#ec$ co%trct, crr$er $' %ot % $%'=rer 2$%'t e; $% tr%'#ortt$o% o/ 2oo'. e% co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
45/72
%e2$2e%ce o% te #rt o/ te #et$t$o%er
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
46/72
&. Cathay 'aci(ic v. CA
+!R(" !!(!ON[G.R. No. 60501. Mrc 5, 1993.]CA"A* PAC!+!C A!RA*(, L", #et$t$o%er, &'. CO)R" O+ APPEAL( % "OMA( L.
ALCAN"ARA, re'#o%e%t'.($2=$o%-Re;%, Mo%tec$o O%2'$:o % "o
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
47/72
$b$$t;. "e r'? Co%&e%t$o% ecre' te crr$er $be /or
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
48/72
''$'t%ce /ro< CA"A*7' e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
49/72
Ct; Pc$/$c.J CA"A*7' e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
50/72
/or e>e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
51/72
). La Mallorca v. *e +esus
EN BANC[G.R. No. L-@1486. M; 14, 1966.]LA MALLORCA % PAMPANGA B)( COMPAN*, #et$t$o%er', &'. ALEN"!N E E()(, MANOLO
"OLEN"!NO % CO)R" O+ APPEAL(, re'#o%e%t'.M%=e O. C% /or #et$t$o%er'.($>to ". A%to%$o /or re'#o%e%t'.(*LLAB)(1. AMAGE(, ACC!EN" CA)(E B* MECAN!CAL E+EC" L!AB!L!"* O+ ONER O+E!CLE. ere te c='e o/ te bo?o=t ?$c c='e te cc$e%t ?' :%o?% $% ttte $%%er t=be o/ te e/t /ro%t t$re ?' #re''e bet?ee% te $%%er c$rce o/ te e/t ?ee %te r$< ?$c '$##e o=t o/ te ?ee,
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
52/72
"e% 2$% bot tr$ co=rt % te Co=rt o/ A##e' /o=% ' /ct tt te b=' ?'r=%%$%2 =$te /'t $
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
53/72
e$ct $% ##eee7' co
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
54/72
2$&e% te r$&er te c='to
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
55/72
!% te #re'e%t c'e, te /ter ret=r%e to te b=' to 2et o%e o/ $' b222e' ?$c ?' %ot=%oe ?e% te; $2te /ro< te b='. R=e, te c$ tt 'e ?', erc$'e te J=t
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
56/72
Co%ce#c$o%, C. ., .B.L., Re;e', $o%, Re2, .P. Be%2o%, $&r, (%ce % C'tro, ., co%c=r.M:$%t, ., co%c=r' $% te re'=t.+oot%ote' 1. Or
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
57/72
1,. Lara v. -alencia
EN BANC[G.R. No. L-990. =%e 30, 1958.]LO)RE( . LARA, E" AL., #$%t$//'-##e%t', &'. BR!G!O R. ALENC!A, e/e%%t-
##e%t.C't$o, Cer&%te', Occe%, Lo%o, Mo%t%, C=%%%, ($'o% C't$o % E$2$o G.L2tror$%r;
$$2e%ce ' re=$re b; o=r ?. KArt$ce' 155 % 156, %e? C$&$ Coe.
@. !. L!AB!L!"* O+ CARR!ER PA((ENGER( !N)R* ON !( ON NEGL!GENCE. A#''e%2er ;' =r$%2 ?$c e co%trcte
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
58/72
rr%2e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
59/72
JNo ebe #erer'e e &$'t e eco, =e o' %e2oc$o' e e>#ortc$o% e troo' ee>> >>>JE &$Fe e Cotbto &o %o e'
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
60/72
#o'$t$o%. !%ee te ? #ro&$e' tt JA #''e%2er
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
61/72
11. *anga v. CA
(ECON !!(!ON[G.R. No. 9558@. October , 1991.]ANGA "RAN(POR"A"!ON CO., !NC. % "EOORE LAR!ABAL ; MALECAN,#et$t$o%er', &'. CO)R" O+ APPEAL(, !NOCENC!A C)!AMA", EM!L!A C)!AMA" BANO*,
+ERNANO C)!AMA", MARR!E"A C)!AMA", NORMA C)!AMA", AN"E C)!AMA",(AM)EL C)!AMA" % L!GA*A C)!AMA", e$r' o/ te te Per$to C=$
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
62/72
re#ete; e tt $% % ct$o% b'e o% co%trct o/ crr$2e, te co=rt %ee %ot #re'' /$%$%2 o/ /=t or %e2$2e%ce o% te #rt o/ te crr$er $% orer to o $tre'#o%'$be to #; te erc$'ee>tror$%r; $$2e%ce ' #re'cr$be $% Art$ce' 133 % 155 o/ te C$&$ Coe.. !. !. !. AC")AL OR COMPEN(A"OR* AMAGE( R)LE !N E"ERM!N!NG "EAMO)N" "EREO+. $t re'#ect to te ?r o/
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
63/72
re'#o%e%t co=rt erre $% re&er'$%2 te ec$'$o% o/ te tr$ co=rt % $% /$%$%2 #et$t$o%er'%e2$2e%t % $be /or te ce#t$o%', o%e o/ ?$c $' ?e% te /$%$%2' o/ te ##ete co=rt re co%trr; to to'e o/te tr$ co=rt, $% ?$c c'e ree>
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
64/72
S t ##e%e ?e% ;o= e$&ere t$' #''e%2er t t$' #rt$c=r #ce $%Le#%toA e% ?e rece te #ce, #''e%2er $2te % ! '$2%e
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
65/72
!t ' 'o bee% re#ete; e tt $% % ct$o% b'e o% co%trct o/ crr$2e, te co=rt%ee %ot #re'' /$%$%2 o/ /=t or %e2$2e%ce o% te #rt o/ te crr$er $% orer too $t re'#o%'$be to #; te tror$%r; $$2e%ce ?$t =e re2r /or te c$rc=
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
66/72
ERE+ORE, '=bFect to te bo&e $cb Gr2e, !%c., 10@ P$. 48@ K195 Bt%2' "r%'#ortt$o%Co. &'. C2=$
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
67/72
12. China Airlines v. CA
(ECON !!(!ON[G.R. No. 45985. M; 18, 1990.]C!NA A!R L!NE(, L"., #et$t$o%er, &'. CO)R" O+ APPEAL(, O(E PAG(!B!GAN, P!L!PP!NE A!R
L!NE(, !NC. % ROBER"O E(P!R!"), re'#o%e%t'.[G.R. No. 46036. M; 18, 1990.]P!L!PP!NE A!R L!NE(, !NC. % ROBER"O E(P!R!"), #et$t$o%er', &'. CO)R" O+ APPEAL(, O(EPAG(!B!GAN % C!NA A!R L!NE(, L"., re'#o%e%t'.B2o' Pere L? O//$ce' /or #et$t$o%er C$% A$r L$%e', Lt.($2=$o% Re;%, Mo%tec$o O%2'$:o /or #et$t$o%er' $% G.R. No. 46036.(;=$ L? O//$ce' /or o'e P2'$b$2%. E C ! ( ! O NREGALAO, #H
"e'e co%'o$te #et$t$o%' 'ee: te re&$e? o/ te ec$'$o% o/ re'#o%e%t co=rt $% CA-G.R.No. 530@3-R e%t$te Jo'e E. P2'$b$2%, P$%t$//-A##e%t, &'. P$$##$%e A$r L$%e', !%c. %Roberto E'#$r$t=, e/e%%t'-A##e%t' C$% A$r L$%e', Lt., e/e%%t-A##eee,J 1 te$'#o'$t$&e #ort$o% o/ ?$c ecre'H
JERE+ORE, e>ce#t /or
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
68/72
cco
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
69/72
're $% te error co>>JA '$
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
70/72
O% te oter %, $% G.R. No. L-46036, re'#o%e%t P2'$b$2% c$ 7A7 'oe; % e>c='$&e; b; re'o% o/ 2ro'' $%coc='be %e2$2e%ce
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
71/72
e>c='$&e; re'#o%'$be /or '=c error % tere/or te co%c='$o% beco
-
8/13/2019 4th Assignment Transpo
72/72
c='e b; te$r e