302.l9.fatigue.20nov02

Upload: eddy-fadley

Post on 18-Oct-2015

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

fatigue failure analysis

TRANSCRIPT

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    1/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    1

    Microstructure-Properties: II

    Fatigue27-302

    Lecture 9

    Fall, 2002

    Prof. A. D. Rollett

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    2/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    2

    Materials Tetrahedron

    Microstructure Properties

    ProcessingPerformance

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    3/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    3

    Objective

    The objective of this lecture is to explain thephenomenon of fatigue and also to show howresistance to fatigue failure depends onmicrostructure.

    For 27-302, Fall 2002: this slide set containsmore material than can be covered in thetime available. Slides that contain material

    over and above that expected for this courseare marked *.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    4/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    4

    References

    Mechanical Behavior of Materials (2000), T. H.Courtney, McGraw-Hill, Boston.

    Phase transformations in metals and alloys, D.A.Porter, & K.E. Easterling, Chapman & Hall.

    Materials Principles & Practice, ButterworthHeinemann, Edited by C. Newey & G. Weaver.

    Mechanical Metallurgy, McGrawHill, G.E. Dieter, 3rdEd.

    Light Alloys (1996), I.J. Polmear, Wiley, 3rd Ed. Hull, D. and D. J. Bacon (1984). Introduction to

    Dislocations. Oxford, UK, Pergamon.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    5/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    5

    Notationsa := Alternating stresssm := Mean stressR := Stress ratioe := strain

    Nf := number of cycles to failureA := Amplitude ratioepl:= Plastic strain amplitudeeel:= Elastic strain amplitudeK:= Proportionality constant, cyclic stress-strain

    n:= Exponent in cyclic stress-strainc:= Exponent in Coffin-Manson Eq.;

    also, crack length

    E:= Youngs modulusb:= exponent in Basquin Eq.

    m:= exponent in Paris LawK:= Stress intensity

    K:= Stress intensity amplitude

    a:= crack length

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    6/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    6

    Fatigue

    Fatigue is the name given to failure in response toalternating loads (as opposed to monotonicstraining).

    Instead of measuring the resistance to fatigue

    failure through an upper limit to strain (as inductility), the typical measure of fatigue resistanceis expressed in terms of numbers of cycles tofailure. For a given number of cycles (required in

    an application), sometimes the stress (that can besafely endured by the material) is specified.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    7/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    7

    Fatigue: general characteristics

    Primary design criterion in rotating parts. Fatigue as a name for the phenomenon based on the

    notion of a material becoming tired, i.e. failing at

    less than its nominal strength.

    Cyclical strain (stress) leads to fatigue failure. Occurs in metals and polymers but rarely in

    ceramics.

    Also an issue for static parts, e.g. bridges.

    Cyclic loading stress limit

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    8/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    8

    Fatigue:general characteristics

    Most applications of structural materials involve cyclicloading; any net tensile stress leads to fatigue.

    Fatigue failure surfaces have three characteristicfeatures:[see next slide, also Courtney figs. 12.1, 12.2]

    A (near-)surface defect as the origin of the crack Striations corresponding to slow, intermittent crack growth

    Dull, fibrous brittle fracture surface (rapid growth).

    Life of structural components generally limited by

    cyclic loading, not static strength. Most environmental factors shorten life.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    9/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    9

    S-N Curves

    S-N [stress-number of cycles to failure] curve defineslocus of cycles-to-failure for given cyclic stress.

    Rotating-beam fatigue test is standard; alsoalternating tension-compression.

    Plot stress versus thelog(number of cyclesto failure), log(Nf).[see next slide,also Courtney figs. 12.8, 12.9]

    For frequencies < 200Hz,metals are insensitive tofrequency; fatigue life inpolymers is frequency

    dependent.

    [Hertzberg]

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    10/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    10

    Fatigue testing, S-N curve

    [Dieter]

    Note the presence of a

    fatigue limit in manysteels and its absence

    in aluminum alloys.

    log Nf

    sa

    smean 1

    smean 2

    smean 3

    smean 3

    > smean 2

    > smean 1

    The greater the number ofcycles in the loading history,the smaller the stress thatthe material can withstand

    without failure.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    11/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    11

    Endurance Limits

    Some materials exhibit endurance limits, i.e.a stress below which the life is infinite:[fig. 12.8] Steels typically show an endurance limit, = 40% of

    yield; this is typically associated with the presence

    of a solute (carbon, nitrogen) that pinesdislocations and prevents dislocation motion atsmall displacements or strains (which is apparentin an upper yield point).

    Aluminum alloys do not show endurance limits;

    this is related to the absence of dislocation-pinningsolutes.

    At large Nf, the lifetime is dominated by nucleation. Therefore strengthening the surface (shot peening) is

    beneficial to delay crack nucleation and extend life.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    12/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    12

    Fatigue fracture

    surface

    [Hertzberg]

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    13/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    13

    Fatigue crack stages

    Stage 1

    Stage 2[Dieter]

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    14/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    14

    Fatigue Crack Propagation

    Crack Nucleation stress intensification at crack tip.

    Stress intensity crack propagation (growth);- stage I growth on shear planes (45),

    strong influence of microstructure[Courtney: fig.12.3a]- stage II growth normal to tensile load (90)

    weak influence of microstructure[Courtney: fig.12.3b].

    Crack propagation catastrophic, or ductile failure

    at crack length dependent on boundary conditions,fracture toughness.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    15/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    15

    Fatigue Crack Nucleation

    Flaws, cracks, voids can all act as crack nucleationsites, especially at the surface.

    Therefore, smooth surfaces increase the time tonucleation; notches, stress risers decrease fatigue

    life. Dislocation activity (slip) can also nucleate fatigue

    cracks.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    16/52

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    17/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    17

    Slip steps

    and thestress-strain

    loop

    D i Phil h D T l

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    18/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    18Design Philosophy: Damage Tolerant

    Design

    S-N (stress-cycles) curves = basic characterization. Old Design Philosophy = Infinite Life design: accept

    empirical information about fatigue life (S-N curves);apply a (large!) safety factor; retire components or

    assemblies at the pre-set life limit, e.g. Nf=107

    . *Crack Growth Rate characterization ->

    *Modern Design Philosophy (Air Force, not Navycarriers!) = Damage Tolerant design: accept

    presence of cracks in components. Determine lifebased on prediction of crack growth rate.

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    19/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    19

    Definitions: Stress Ratios

    Alternating Stress Mean stress sm= (smax+smin)/2.

    Pure sine wave Mean stress=0.

    Stress ratio R = smax/smin.

    For sm= 0, R=-1

    Amplitude ratio A = (1-R)/(1+R).

    Statistical approach shows significantdistribution in Nffor given stress.

    See Courtney fig. 12.6; also following slide.

    sa

    20

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    20/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    20

    Alternating Stress Diagrams

    [Dieter]

    21

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    21/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    21

    Mean Stress

    Alternating stress sa= (smax-smin)/2. Raising the mean stress (sm)decreases Nf. [see slide 19,

    also Courtney fig. 12.9]

    Various relations between R = 0 limit and the ultimate

    (or yield) stress are known as Soderberg (linear toyield stress), Goodman (linear to ultimate) andGerber (parabolic to ultimate). [Courtney, fig. 12.10, problem12.3]

    sa

    smean

    tensile strength

    endurance limit at zero mean stress

    sa sfat 1 smean

    tensile strength

    22

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    22/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    22

    Cyclic strain vs. cyclic stress

    Cyclic strain control complements cyclicstress characterization: applicable to thermalfatigue, or fixed displacement conditions.

    Cyclic stress-strain testing defined by acontrolled strain range, epl. [see next slide,Courtney, figs. 12.24,12.25]

    Soft, annealed metals tend to harden;

    strengthened metals tend to soften. Thus, many materials tend towards a fixed

    cycle, i.e. constant stress, strain amplitudes.

    23

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    23/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    23

    Cyclic stress-strain curve

    [Courtney]

    Large number of cycles typically needed to reach

    asymptotic hysteresis loop (~100). Softening or hardening possible.[fig. 12.26]

    24

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    24/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    24

    Cyclic stress-strain

    Wavy-slip materials

    generally reach asymptotein cyclic stress-strain:planar slip materials (e.g.brass) exhibit historydependence.

    Cyclic stress-strain curvedefined by the extrema,i.e. the tips of the

    hysteresis loops. [Courtneyfig. 12.27]

    Cyclic stress-strain curvestend to lie below those formonotonic tensile tests.

    Polymers tend to soften incyclic straining.

    [Courtney]

    25

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    25/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    25

    Cyclic Strain Control

    Strain is a more logical independent variablefor characterization of fatigue.[fig. 12.11]

    Define an elastic strain rangeas eel= s/E.

    Define a plastic strain range, epl.

    Typically observe a change in slope betweenthe elastic and plastic regimes. [fig. 12.12]

    Low cycle fatigue (small Nf) dominated by

    plastic strain: high cycle fatigue (large Nf)dominated by elastic strain.

    26

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    26/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    26

    Strain control

    of fatigue

    [Courtney]

    27

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    27/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    27

    Cyclic Strain control: low cycle

    Constitutive relationfor cyclic stress-strain:

    n 0.1-0.2

    Fatigue life: Coffin Manson relation:

    ef~ true fracture strain; close to tensileductility

    c -0.5 to -0.7

    c= -1/(1+5n); large nlonger life.

    s K e n

    ep2

    e f 2Nfc

    28

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    28/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    28

    Cyclic Strain control: high cycle

    For elastic-dominated strainsat high cycles, adaptBasquins equation:

    Intercept on strain axis of extrapolatedelastic line = sf/E.

    High cycle = elastic strain control:slope (in elastic regime) = b = -

    n/(1+5n) [Courtney, fig. 12.13] The high cycle fatigue strength, sf,

    scales with the yield stress high

    strength good in high-cycle

    saEee2

    sf 2N b

    29

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    29/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    29

    Strain amplitude - cycles

    [Courtney]

    30

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    30/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    30

    Total strain (plastic+elastic)life

    Low cycle = plastic control: slope = c Add the elastic and plastic strains.

    Cross-over between elastic and plastic control istypically at Nf= 10

    3cycles.

    Ductility useful for low-cycle; strength for high cycle

    Examples of Maraging steel for high cycleendurance, annealed 4340 for low cycle fatiguestrength.

    2 eel

    2 epl

    2 s f

    E2Nfb e f 2Nfc

    31

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    31/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    31

    Fatigue Crack Propagation

    Crack Length := a.Number of cycles :=NCrack Growth Rate := da/dNAmplitude of Stress Intensity := K = sc.

    Define three stages of crack growth, I, II and III,in a plot of da/dNversus K.

    Stage II crack growth: application of linear elastic fracturemechanics.

    Can consider the crack growth rate to be related to the appliedstress intensity.

    Crack growth rate somewhat insensitive to R (if R

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    32/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    32

    Fatigue Crack Propagation

    Three stages of crackgrowth, I, II and III.

    Stage I: transition to afinite crack growth ratefrom no propagationbelow a threshold value

    of K. Stage II: power law

    dependence of crackgrowth rate on K.

    Stage III: acceleration

    of growth rate with K,approachingcatastrophic fracture.

    da/dN

    KKth

    Kc

    I

    IIIII

    33

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    33/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    33

    *Paris Law

    Paris Law:

    m ~ 3 (steel); m ~ 4 (aluminum).

    Crack nucleation ignored! Threshold ~ Stage I

    The threshold represents an endurancelimit.

    For ceramics, threshold is close to KIC.

    Crack growth rate increases with R(forR>0).[fig. 12.18a]

    dc

    dN A(K)m

    34

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    34/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Striations- mechanism

    Striations occur by development of slip bandsin each cycle, followed by tip blunting,followed by closure.

    Can integrate the growth rate to obtain cyclesas related to cyclic stress-strain behavior. [Eqs.12.6-12.8]

    NII dcA

    m s cmc0cfNII dc

    dc / dNc0

    cf

    35

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    35/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Striations, contd.

    Provided that m>2 and is constant, can integrate.

    If the initial crack length is much less than the finallength, c0

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    36/52

    37

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    37/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Geometrical effects

    Notches decrease fatigue life through stressconcentration.

    Increasing specimen size lowers fatigue life.

    Surface roughness lowers life, again through stressconcentration.

    Moderate compressive stress at the surfaceincreases life (shot peening); it is harder to nucleate acrack when the local stress state opposes crackopening.

    Corrosive environment lowers life; corrosion eitherincreases the rate at which material is removed fromthe crack tip and/or it produces material on the cracksurfaces that forces the crack open (e.g. oxidation).

    Failure mechanisms

    38

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    38/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Microstructure-Fatigue Relationships

    What are the important issues in microstructure-fatigue relationships?

    Answer: three major factors.

    1: geometry of the specimen (previous slide); anything on thesurface that is a site of stress concentration will promotecrack formation (shorten the time required for nucleation ofcracks).

    2: defects in the material; anything inside the material that canreduce the stress and/or strain required to nucleate a crack(shorten the time required for nucleation of cracks).

    3: dislocation slip characteristics; if dislocation glide is confinedto particular slip planes (called planar slip) then dislocationscan pile up at any grain boundary or phase boundary. Thehead of the pile-up is a stress concentration which caninitiate a crack.

    39

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    39/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Microstructure affects Crack Nucleation

    The main effect ofmicrostructure (defects,surface treatment, etc.)is almost all in the lowstress intensity regime,i.e. Stage I. Defects,

    for example, make iteasier to nucleate acrack, which translatesinto a lower thresholdfor crack propagation(Kth).

    Microstructure alsoaffects fracturetoughness andtherefore Stage III.

    da/dN

    KKth

    Kc

    I

    IIIII

    40

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    40/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Defects in Materials

    Descriptions of defects in materials at the sophomore levelfocuses, appropriately on intrinsic defects (vacancies,dislocations). For the materials engineer, however, defectsinclude extrinsic defects such as voids, inclusions, grainboundary films, and other types of undesirable second phases.

    Voids are introduced either by gas evolution in solidification or

    by incomplete sintering in powder consolidation. Inclusions are second phases entrained in a material during

    solidification. In metals, inclusions are generally oxides from thesurface of the metal melt, or a slag.

    Grain boundary films are common in ceramics as glassy filmsfrom impurities.

    In aluminum alloys, there is a hierachy of names for secondphase particles; inclusions are unwanted oxides (e.g. Al2O3);dispersoids are intermetallic particles that, once precipitated, arethermodynamically stable (e.g. AlFeSi compounds);precipitatesare intermetallic particles that can be dissolved or precipiated

    depending on temperature (e.g. AlCu compounds).

    41

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    41/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Metallurgical Control: fine particles

    Tendency to localization of flow is deleterious to theinitiation of fatigue cracks, e.g. Al-7050 with non-shearable vs. shearable precipitates (Stage I in ada/dN plot). Also Al-Cu-Mg with shearableprecipitates but non-shearable dispersoids, vs. onlyshearable ppts.

    graph courtesy of J.

    Staley, Alcoa

    42

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    42/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Coarse particle effect on fatigue

    Inclusions nucleate cracks cleanliness (w.r.t.coarse particles) improves fatigue life, e.g. 7475improved by lower Fe+Si compared to 7075:0.12Fe in 7475, compared to 0.5Fe in 7075;

    0.1Si in 7475, compared to 0.4Si in 7075.

    graph courtesy of J.

    Staley, Alcoa

    43

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    43/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Alloy steel heat treatment

    Increasing hardness tends to raise the endurancelimit for high cycle fatigue. This is largely a functionof the resistance to fatigue crack formation (Stage I ina plot of da/dN).

    [Dieter]

    Mobile solutes that pin

    dislocations fatigue

    limit, e.g. carbon in steel

    44

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    44/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Casting porosity affects fatigue

    Casting tends to result in porosity. Pores are effective sites fornucleation of fatigue cracks. Castings thus tend to have lowerfatigue resistance (as measured by S-N curves) than wroughtmaterials.

    Casting technologies, such as squeeze casting, that reduce porosity

    tend to eliminate this difference.

    [Polmear]

    Gravity castversus

    squeeze cast

    versus

    wroughtAl-7010

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    45/52

    46

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    46/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Design Considerations

    If crack growth rates are normalized by the elasticmodulus, then material dependence is mostlyremoved! [Courtney fig. 12.20]

    Can distinguish between intrinsic fatigue[use Eq.

    12.4 for combined elastic, plastic strain range] forsmall crack sizes and extrinsic fatigue[use Eq. 12.6for crack growth rate controlled] at longer cracklengths. [fig. 12.21.]

    Inspection of design charts, fig. 12.22, shows thatceramics sensitive to crack propagation (highendurance limit in relation to fatigue threshold).

    47

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    47/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Design Considerations: 2

    Metals show a higher fatigue threshold inrelation to their endurance limit. PMMA andMg are at the lower end of the toughnessrange in their class. [Courtney fig. 12.22]

    Also interesting to compare fracturetoughness with fatigue threshold. [Courtney fig.12.23]

    Note that ceramics are almost on ratio=1 line,whereas metals tend to lie well below, i.e.fatigue is more significant criterion.

    48

    *F ti

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    48/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Fatigue

    property map

    [Courtney]

    49

    *Fatigue

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    49/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Fatigue

    property map

    [Courtney]

    50

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    50/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Variable Stress/Strain Histories

    When the stress/strain history isstochastically varying, a rule for combiningportions of fatigue life is needed.

    Palmgren-Miner Rule is useful: ni is the

    number of cycles at each stress level, and Nfiis the failure point for that stress.[Ex. Problem 12.2]

    ni

    Nfi1

    i* Courtneys Eq. 12.9 is confusing; he has Nfin the numerator also

    51

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    51/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    *Fatigue in Polymers

    Many differences from metals Cyclic stress-strain behavior often exhibits

    softening; also affected by visco-elasticeffects; crazing in the tensile portion

    produces asymmetries, figs. 12.34, 12.25.

    S-N curves exhibit three regions, with steeplydecreasing region II, fig. 12.31.

    Nearness to Tgresults in strong temperaturesensitivity, fig. 12.42

    52

  • 5/27/2018 302.L9.fatigue.20Nov02

    52/52

    Objective

    Crack

    Initiation

    S-N

    curves

    Cyclic

    stress-strn

    Crack

    Propagate

    Microstr.

    effects

    Design

    Fatigue: summary

    Critical to practical use of structural materials. Fatigue affects most structural components,

    even apparently statically loaded ones.

    Well characterized empirically.

    Connection between dislocation behavior andfatigue life offers exciting researchopportunities, i.e. physically based models

    are lacking!