2004 second preliminary report (bur.)
Post on 30-May-2018
230 views
TRANSCRIPT
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 1/208
1
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
mt & bn
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 2/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
2
The Ad hoc Commission On
Depayin Massacre (Burma) Let's join hands together in promoting global justice by facilitating the efforts of people in Burma
to seek justice for Depayin Massacre.
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'kwd,t}udrf y%mr tpD&ifcHpm
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'kwd,t}udrf y%mr tpD&ifcHpm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 3/208
3
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
T'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpmwGif azmfjyxm;aomtcsuftvufrsm;/ wifjycsuf
rsm;/ ok H;oyfcsufrsm;tm;vk H;onf 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif. rlyk difjzpfonf? ok dŒ &mwGif trSefw&m; azmfxkwfa&;twGuf TtpD&ifcHpmuk d vk dtyfovk d uk d;um;tok H;jyKEk difygonf? xkwfE+wf tok H;jyKvk donf htzJ GŒ tpnf;rsm;/ yk*~Kdvfrsm;taejzif hrl aumfr&SifxHrS cGif hjyKcsuf&,l&ef jzpfygonf?
yk HES dyfrSwfwrf;
yxrt}udrf
tkyfa& ( 2000 )
2003 ckESpf 'DZifbmv
xkwfa0olxkwfa0olxkwfa0olxkwfa0olxkwfa0ol
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
rsufESmzk H;ESifh tjyiftqifrsufESmzk H;ESif h tjyiftqifrsufESmzk H;ESifh tjyiftqifrsufESmzk H;ESif h tjyiftqifrsufESmzkH;ESif h tjyiftqif
armifawmuf/ bkdndrf;
twGif;yef;csD
bkdndrf;
rlyk difcGif h
qufoG,f&ef
email address: [email protected] Box ( 29 ) Hua Mark Post Office 71240, Bangkok, Thailand
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 4/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
4
aus;Zl;wifv$m --------------------------------------------- ( 5 )( 5 )( 5 )( 5 )( 5 )
ed'gef; --------------------------------------------- ( 7 )( 7 )( 7 )( 7 )( 7 )
tcef; ( 1 ) a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tay: 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_rwd kifrD
ppftm%myd kifrsm;. zdES dyfcsKyfcs,fr_rsm;/wd kufcd kufr_rsm;ESif htouftE W&m,fxdcd kufapEd kifonf txdt=urf;zufcJ hjcif;rsm; -------------------- ( 13 )( 13 )( 13 )( 13 )( 13 )
tcef; ( 2 ) 'DyJ,if;c&D;pOfrwd kifrD aemufqH k;c&D;pOfjzpfaom ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOftwGif; aESmif h,SufcH&r_rsm; ------------------ ( 22 )( 22 )( 22 )( 22 )( 22 )
tcef; ( 3 ) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_jzpfpOf -------------------------------- ( 34 )( 34 )( 34 )( 34 )( 34 )
tcef; ( 4 ) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ tay:aumfr&Sif. y%mroH k;oyfwifjycsuf ----------- ( 42 )( 42 )( 42 )( 42 )( 42 )
tcef; ( 5 ) rsufjrifoufaorsm;.xGufcsufrsm; ------------------------- ( 53 )( 53 )( 53 )( 53 )( 53 )
tcef; ( 6 ) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_eSif hywfoufI jynfwGif;jynfyrSwkef hjyefajymqd kcsufrsm; ------------------------- ( 103 )( 103 )( 103 )( 103 )( 103 )
tcef; ( 7 ) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHrSK ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&SifrSxkwfjyefcJ honf h yef=um;csufrsm; ------------------------- ( 119 )( 119 )( 119 )( 119 )( 119 )
rmwdum
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 5/208
5
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
aemufqufwJ Grsm;
(1) "gwfyH krsm;/'%f&m&olrsm;/ vlaysmuf/aoqH k;olrsm;ESif h armfawmf,mOf pm&if;rsm; --------------------------- ( 130 )( 130 )( 130 )( 130 )( 130 )
(2) trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf.xkwfjyefa=unmcsufrsm; ---------------------------------------- ( 140 )( 140 )( 140 )( 140 )( 140 )
(3) a':atmifqef;pk=unf. owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JESif h2003 ckESpf arv(29)&ufae@n rk H±Gmòrd @wGif ajym=um;onf hrdef @cGef; ---------------- ( 154 )( 154 )( 154 )( 154 )( 154 )
(4) etz . owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jrl&if;rsm; -------------------------------- ( 169 )( 169 )( 169 )( 169 )( 169 )
(5) aZmfaZmfatmif/ ud kausmfvGif/ rE Wav;wk dif; trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyf
tzJ G @0if trsKd;orD;wOD;wd k @. Ed kifiHwum toHv$if hXmersm;ESif hqufoG,far;jref;csufrsm; -------------------------------------- ( 178 )( 178 )( 178 )( 178 )( 178 )
(6) &efukefwk dif;/ urm±Gwfòrd @e,f trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyf tzJ G @0ifuk dpk d;oef;. oufaoxGufqk dcsuf ---------------------------------- ( 192 )( 192 )( 192 )( 192 )( 192 )
(7) 2003 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (18)&ufaeŒwGif usif;yaom(58)}udrfajrmuf ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcHrS
jrefrmEk difiH. vlŒtcGif hta&;tajctaeESif h pyfvsOf;IcsrSwfaom qk H;jzwfcsufrsm; -- ( 201 )( 201 )( 201 )( 201 )( 201 )
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 6/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
6
aus;Zl;wifv$m
'DyJ,if; vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif h pyfvsOf;I aumfr&Siftaejzif h jynfwGif;rS vlyk*~Kdvfoufaorsm;uk d vufcH&,lEk dif&efóud;yrf;jcif;/ oufaocHtaxmuftxm;rsm; &,lpkaqmif;jcif;/ aumfr&Sif±k H; zGif hvSpfjcif;/ oufaorsm;uk d ulnD
apmif ha&Smufjcif;/ jynfwGif; jynfyok d @ jzpf&yftrSefrsm;jzef @csdjcif;ESif h jynfwGif; jynfyrS tquftoG,fESif h tultnDrsm;uk d &SmazG&,ljcif;rsm; tygt0if aumfr&Sif.vkyfief;rsm;aqmif±Guf&mwGif tpp t&m&mvk dtyfonfrsm;uk d0k dif;0ef;ulnDyh Hyk d;um vufwJ Gvkyfaqmifay;=uaom atmufazmfjyyg tzJ G @tpnf;rsm;/ vlyk*~Kdvfrsm;tm; aus;Zl;Oyum& txl;wif&S dyga=umif;ESif h ‚if;wk d @. tultnDESif h yl;aygif;aqmif±Gufr_ ryg&S dbJ ukvor*~rS qk H;jzwfcsufusvmonf h &v'ftygt0if T 'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpmuk d xkwfjyefEk difonf htqif hxd a&muf&S d&ef rjzpfEk difyga=umif; aumfr&Siftaejzif h rSwfwrf;wiftyfygonf?
(1) jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEk difiH trsKd;om;!Gef @aygif;tpk d;&rS wm0ef&S daomyk*~Kdvfrsm;ESif h jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEk difiHtrsKd;om;aumifpDrS tzJ G @0iftzJ G @tpnf;rsm;/ acgif;aqmifrsm;/
(2) jrefrmEk difiHa&S @aersm;aumifpDrS Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;ESif h 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I Oya'a&;&mt&vnf;aumif;/ vl @tcGif hta&;tajccHt&vnf;aumif;/ 0k dif;0ef;t}uHay;um vufwJ Gyl;aygif;aqmif±Gufay;=uaom Ek difiHwumrS vl @tcGif hta&;tzJ G @tpnf;rsm;/ Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;/
(3) jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEk difiHtrsKd;om;aumifpD. Ek difiHa&;tHwkr_aumfrwD(4) owif;tcsuftvufrsm;0k dif;0ef;pkaqmif;+yD; ukvor*~ok d @ wk dif=um;pmrsm; ay;yk d @tultnDawmif;cH
cJ h=uaom jynfwGif;rS v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,frsm;/ jynfaxmifpkwk dif;&if;om;vlrsKd;rsm; 'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyftygt0if 'DyJ,if; vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I pk Hprf;ppfaq;azmfxkwfay;&ef 0k dif;0ef;awmif;qk day;=uaom jynfwGif;ESif he,fpyfa'orsm;rS wk dif;&if;om;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ tjcm; Ek difiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm;/ trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyfrS
vli,frsm;/(5) owif;ESif hrSwfwrf;"gwfyk Hrsm; ay;yk d @ulnDaom 'Drk dua&pDESif hzG H @òzd;wk d;wufa&;tiftm;pk trsKd;om;'Drk d
ua&pDtzJ G @csKyf (vGwfajrmufe,fajr)ESif h 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_usL;vGefjcif;cH&olrsm;. pm&if;jyKpk&mwGif tultnDay;aom Ek difiHa&;tusOf;om;rsm; ulnDapmif ha&Smufa&;toif; (jrefrmEk difiH)/ xk d @tjyif wefzk d;rjzwfEk difaomowif;tcsuftvufrsm;ESif h rSwfwrf;"gwfyk Hrsm; &SmazGpkaqmif;ay;yk d @&mwGifvnf;aumif;/ rsufjrifoufaorsm;ac: xkwf&mwGifvnf;aumif;/ &J0H @ajymifajrmufpGm pGef @pm;ulnDcJ h=uonf h jrefrmjynfwGif;rS trnfemr xkwfazmfjcif;rjyKEk difaomyk*~Kdvfrsm;uk d aumfr&SifrS av;pm;pGm aus;Zl;wif&S d rSwfwrf;wif*k%fjyKyga=umif; azmdjytyfygonf?
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 7/208
7
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 8/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
8
(1) OD;cifausmf[ef/obmywdtzG J @0if/
a&eHacsmif;jrdK he,ftrSwf(2) v$wfawmf ud k,fpm;;vS,f/
jynfol @v$wfawmfudk,fpm;vS,frsm;tzG J @(tzG J @0if)
(2) OD;ausmfausmf/tzG J @acgif;aqmif/ Ed kifiHa&;tHwkr_aumfrwD/
OuUX/'Drd kua&pDESif h zG H @òzd;wd k;wufa&;tiftm;pk (NDD)
jynfaxmifpkjrefrmed kifiH trsKd;om;aumifpDjynfaxmifpkjrefrmedkifiH trsKd;om;aumifpDjynfaxmifpkjrefrmed kifiH trsKd;om;aumifpDjynfaxmifpkjrefrmedkifiH trsKd;om;aumifpDjynfaxmifpkjrefrmed kifiH trsKd;om;aumifpD jrefrmed kifiHa&S haersm;aumifpDjrefrmed kifiHa&S haersm;aumifpDjrefrmed kifiHa&S haersm;aumifpDjrefrmed kifiHa&S haersm;aumifpDjrefrmedkifiHa&S haersm;aumifpD
(1) OD;atmifxl;M.A. (Human Rights) R. L.
taxGaxG twGif;a&;rSL;
(2) OD;rif;vGifOD; (LL.B)
tzG J @acgif;aqmifOya' taxmuftuljyKÏme/
ed'gef;
jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,frsm;tzJ G @ (jrefrmEk difiH)/ trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDwyfaygif;pk/ jrefrmjynf 'Drk du&ufwpfr[mrdwftzJ G @csKyfESif h trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyf (vGwfajrmufe,fajr)wk d @yg0ifonh f tus,fjyef @qH k;aom'Drk dua&pDtiftm;pkjzpfonf h jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD onf vGwfvyfonh f a&S @aetzJ G @tpnf;wckjzpfaom jrefrmEd kifiHa&S @aersm;aumifpDjrefrmEd kifiHa&S @aersm;aumifpDjrefrmEd kifiHa&S @aersm;aumifpDjrefrmEd kifiHa&S @aersm;aumifpDjrefrmEd kifiHa&S @aersm;aumifpDESif h yl;aygif;I/ arv(30)&ufae@wGif ppfud kif;wd kif;/a&$bd kc&d kif/ 'DyJ,if;òrd @e,f usnf&Gm teD;Y jzpfyGm;cJ honf h vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_rsm;ESif h ywfoufI jzpf&yfrSefrsm;tm; azmfxkwfoGm;Ek dif&ef“'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif”'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif”'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif”'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif”'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif”uk d atmufyg uk d,fpm;vS,frsm;jzif h 2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv(25)&ufae@wGif zJ G @pnf;ch Jygonf?
aumfr&Sifonf jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD. Ed kifiHa&;t&wm0efcHr_ESif h/ jrefrmEd kifiHa&S @aersm;aumifpD. Oya'yd kif;qd kif&mt& taxmuftuljyKr_wd k hud ktajccHI vufawG @vkyfief;pOfrsm;ud k vGwfvyfpGmqH k;jzwfaqmif&GufcGif h&S daom aumfr&Sif jzpfygonf?
aumfr&Sif. tcef;u¾aumfr&Sif. tcef;u¾aumfr&Sif. tcef;u¾aumfr&Sif. tcef;u¾aumfr&Sif. tcef;u¾
“ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif ”onf/ jynfwGif; tcsif;jzpfyGm;&mae&mod k h oGm;a&mufum wm0ef&S daom tm%myd kifrsm;tygt0if r_cif;eSif houfqd kifaom oufaorsm;tm;vH k;ud k awG @qH kar;jref;+yD;xGufcsufrsm;eSif houfaocHcsufrsm; jynf hjynf hpH kpH kpkaqmif;ed kifaom tcGif htm%m&S donf h aumfr&Sif}uD;w&yf r[kwfyg? Taumfr&SifrSm 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;twGuf trSefw&m;ud k jynf hjynf h00azmfxkwf+yD; wm0ef&S dolrsm;tm;
xd kufonf htm;av#mfpGm ta&;,laqmif&GufEk difrnf htajctaew&yfay:aygufvma&;twGuf wwfpGrf;or# 0d kif;0ef;aqmif&Gufaeonf h ,m,D aumfr&Sifw&yfom jzpfygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 9/208
9
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm; &,ljcif;
aumfr&SifrS 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;wGif ud k,fwd kifawG @}uHKcHpm;cJ h&onf h rsufjrifoufaorsm;tm;vufcH&mwGif/‚if;oufaorsm;. aemufcHud k,fa&;tcsuftvufrsm;/ v_yf&Sm;aqmif&Gufr_rsm;/ yg0ifywfoufr_rsm; ponfwd k @ESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfwGif;&S d rdrdwd k @. ,H k=unf&onf htquftoG,frsm;xH qufoG,fpH kprf;+yD;/ y%mr twnfjyK csuf &,l+yD;rS/ trSefwu,f rsufjrifoufao [kwfEk dif/ r[kwfed kifud k avhvmoH k;oyfygonf? Tonfud kvkyfaqmif&mY tcuftcJrsm;eSif h rsm;pGmóuHawG h&ygonf? xd k @aemufoufaorsm;tm; wOD;csif; oD;jcm;awG @qH kumtcsif;jzpf&yfESif hywfoufI ar;jref;ppfaq;jcif;rjyKrD/ tcsif;jzpf&yfwGif trSefwu,f yg0ifcJ hr_ &S d r&S d/ y%mrar;jref;ppfaq;+yD;rS ‚if;rsufjrifoufaorsm;. uwdopPmjyK tppfcHxGufqd kcsufrsm;ud k &,lygonf? Tr# pepfwus}udK;yrf;aqmif&Gufygaomfvnf; aumfr&Sif. vkyfief;pOfrsm;wGif tm;enf;csufrsm; tenf;ESif htrsm; &S ded kifygonf? tcsdK@oufaoxGufcsufrsm;ud k txyfxyfppfaq;+yD;aemufyd kif;wGif tcd kiftrmtwnfjyKEd kif&ef vd ktyfaeao;aoma=umif htjiif;yGm;zG,f rjzpfap&efaumfr&Siftaejzif h toH k;rjyKao;bJ ,m,DcsefvSyfxm;r_rsm;vnf;
&S dygonf? T tpD&ifcHpmwGif tqd kygxGufqd kcsufrsm;ud k xnf hoGif;azmfjyxm;jcif; r&S dao;yg?
'kwd, y%mr tpD&ifcHpm
rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifrS 2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (4)&ufae@wGif rsufjrifoufao[k vufcHed kifbG,f&S dol (4)OD;xHrSxGufcsufrsm;&&S dcJ h+yD;aemuf/ y%mrtpD&ifcHpmwapmifud k t*Fvdyfbmomjzif h taqmwv#if jyKpkxkwfjyefcJ hygonf? ,if;uJ hod k @ oufaorsm;tvH ktavmuf&onftxd rapmif hqd kif;yJ xkwfjyefcJ hjcif;rSm rdrd wd k @&&S dxm;onh ftwnfjyKcsufrsm;ud k Ed kifiHwumtod kif;t0ef;ESif h trsm;jynfolwd k @taejzif h apmpD;pGmod&S dxm;Ed kifapvd konf h&nf&G,fcsufa=umif hjzpfygonf? oufaorsm; aemufxyfa&muf&S dvmygu yd krd kjynf hpH konf h tcsuftvufrsm;jzif h
jznf hpGuf+yD; xkwfjyefoGm;&ef &nf&G,fxm;cJ h&m ,cktcsdeftxd aumfr&SifrS pdppfvufcHxm;aom rsufjrifoufao(7)OD;. xGufqd kcsufrsm;ESif h yd krd kjynf hpH konf h tcsuftvufrsm;aygif;pyfI T'kwd, y%mr tpD&ifcHpmud kjrefrmbmomjzif h xyfrH xkwfjyefvd kufjcif;jzpfygonf? aumfr&SifrSm yd krd kcd kifvH kaom oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;eSif h oufaocHtaxmuftxm;rsm;ud k qufvufpkaqmif;aeqJjzpf+yD; &&S dvmygu yd kIjynf hpH kaom tpD&ifcHpmrsm;ud k qufvuf fxkwfjyefoGm;ed kif&ef &nf&G,fygonf?
ppftkyfpkrS usL;vGefcJ haom &mZ0wfr+rsm;eSif h vGwfjidrf;cGif h ( Impunity )
ppftkyfpkvufatmuf jrefrmEd kifiHwGif w&m;Oya'pd k;rd k;r_ r&S dbJ ppftkyfpk Oya'rJ hjyKor# jynfolrsm;cg;pnf;cHcJ h&onfrSm ESpfaygif;(40)ausmfvmcJ h+yD jzpfygonf? ppftkyfpk pwi ftm%modrf;cJ honf h 1962 ckESpf/ Zlvd kif(7)&ufae@ ta&;awmfyH k}uD;wGif/ &efukefwuUod kvfausmif;om; tajrmuftrsm; aoG;ajruscJ h&ygonf? ppftkyfpkrS,ck'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;wGif/ aoqH k;ol(4)OD;/ '%f&m&ol(48)OD;om&S da=umif;xkwfjyefouJ hod k @yif/ xd kpOfu (15)OD;omaoqH k;+yD;/ (27)OD;'%f&m&&S dcJ honf[kom xkwfjyefa=unmcJ hygonf? tvm;wlyif 1988 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(9) &ufae@/ ppfud kif;&Jpcef;a&S @ ypfcwfr_wGif/ tjypfrJ hjynfol &m*%ef;tcsdL@ aoqH k;cJ h&onfud k/ (31)OD;aoqH k;+yD;/(31)OD;'%f&m&cJ honf[k rsm;pGmavsmhenf;apvS suf xkwfjyefcJ hygonf? tqd kyg &mZ0wfr_}uD;rsm;Y wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud k rnfod k hrS s ta&;,ljcif;rsdK;vnf; r&S dcJ hyg?
1988 ckESpf/ rwfv (13)&ufae@ zkef;armfusqH k;cJ h&r_wGifvnf; [efjypH kprf;a&;aumfr&Sifw&yf zG J @pnf;ay;cJ h+yD;/wm0ef&S dolrsm;tm; xda&mufpGmta&;,lcJ hjcif; r&S dcJ hyg? 1988 ckESpf/ rwfv (18)&ufae@wGif tcsKyfum;twGif;rS
vl(41)OD; toufr&_Ed kifbJ rGef;=uyfaoqH k;cJ h&onf h tr_wGifvnf; tvm;wlyifjzpfygonf? TaoqH k;ol '%f&m& olrsm;rSm Oya't&ukpm;r_ wpH kw&mcHpm;cJ h&jcif; r&S dcJ hyg? wm0ef&S donf h jynfol @&JwyfzG J @t=uD;tuJ. jynfolrsm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 10/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
10
od k @ &Sif;vif;wifjycsufud kyif r=um;cJ h&yg? &Srf;eSif h tjcm;wd kif;&if;oltrsdL;orD;uav;rsm;tay: rk'def;r_usL;vGefcJ hr_rsm;ud kvnf; ajymifajymifwif;wif;jiif;qd kxm;cJ h+yD; &mZ0wfom;rsm;tm;,aehwd kif wpH kw&m ta&;,ljcif;r&S dao;yg? 1962 ckeSpf ppftm%modrf;+yD; aemufyd kif;rSpI }uD;rm;aom&mZ0wfr_ usL;vGefcJ holrsm;onf q,fpkeSpf
aygif;tawmf=um vGwfjidrf;cGif h&ae=uqJjzpfygonf?
'DyJ,if; vkyf}uHr+}uD;. xl;jcm;r+
,ck 'DyJ,if;udpPrSm ,cifppftkyfpk usL;vGefcJ haom &mZ0wfr_rsm;eSif h rwlbJ xl;jcm;ygonf? tb,fa=umif hqd kaomf &Spfav;vH k; umvtwGif;uuJ hod k @ qlylr_jzpfatmif v_ H @aqmfzefwnf;+yD;rS ,if;ud kta=umif;jyum ypfcwfeS drfeif;cJ hjcif;rsdL; r[kwfbJ omref +idrfoufaeaomtajctaerSmyif aoG;at;at;eSif h vkyf=uHr_jzpfygonf? vlolta&muftaygufenf;aom awmawmifa'orsm;wGif vltcGif hta&; csdL;azgufr_rsm; usL;vGefcJ hjcif;rsdL; r[kwfbJwurB mvH k;u apmif h=unf haeonf htcsdefrSmyif ajymifajymifwif;wif;/ ay:ay:xifxif usL;vGefcJ hjcif;jzpfonf?
omref jynfolrsm;ud k usL;vGefjcif;rsdL;yif r[kwfbJ urB mod +idrf;csrf;a&; Ed kA,fqk&Siftygt0if a&G;aumufyG JtEk dif& Ek difiHa&;ygwDacgif;aqmifrsm;ud k qef @usifusL;vGefjcif;jzpfonf? Tjypfr_}uD;wGifvnf; txufazmfjyyg &mZ0wfr_}uD;rsm;rSmuJ hod k @ vGwf+idrf;cGif h&aeOD;rnfqd kygu usL;vGefcH&olrsm;twGufomru vl @tzG J @tpnf;w&yfvH k;twGufyg w&m;r#wr_ qH k;&S HL;jcif;ru qH k;±_ H;aeOD;rnfjzpfonf? t"duwm0ef&S daom ppftkyfpk.vuf0,fod k @ w&m;0ifvlowfvd kifpif xyfrHcsD;jr‡if hay;tyfvd kufouJ hod k @ jzpfaeygrnf? vl @tzG J htpnf;wckvH k;rSm tkyfpd k;olppftkyfpkud kjym;jym;0yfa=umuf&onf h tajctaeok d @ rkcsa&muf&S dawmhrnfjzpfonf? ppfrSefaomtrsKd;om; jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;ud k rnfok d @r# ajrmfrSef;Ek difawmhrnf r[kwf? tESpfpfom&ESif h jynf hpH kaom +idrf;csrf;r_ud kvnf; wnfaqmuf&ef jzpfEk difrnf r[kwfawmhyg?
od k @jzpfygI rdrdwd k @aumfr&Siftaejzif h tjzpftysuftrSefrsm;ud k tcd kiftrmavhvmpH kprf;um ed kifiHom;wOD;jcif;pDb0 vH k+cHKr_&S dapa&;/ vufeuftm;ud k; Oya'rJ ht=urf;zufr_rsm; yaysmufa&;ESif h w&m;Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;wd k @twGuf/pGrf;pGrf;wrHaqmif&Gufv#uf&S daom tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ yk*~ dKvfrsm;ESif hvufwG Jum tedrf hqH k;tm;jzif h Tjypfr_}uD;eSif hpyfvsOf;I trSefw&m;ay:aygufvmap&ef ud k,fpGrf;/ ^m%fpGrf;&S dor# }udK;yrf;oGm;rnf jzpfygonf?
aumfr&Sif. tm;enf;csufESif h tm;omcsufrsm;
xd kod k @aqmif&Guf&mwGif rdrdwd k @aumfr&Siftaejzif h tcuftcJESif huef @owfr_tcsdK@&S da=umif; 0efcHvd kygonf?tcif;jzpfyGm;&mae&mod k @ ud k,fwd kifoGm;a&muf avhvmpH kprf;ppfaq;r_ rjyKEd kifjcif; rsufjrifoufaorsm;tm;vH k;ESif h rawG @qH k rppfar;Ed kifjcif;/ oufaocHypPnf;rsm;tm; oGm;a&mufI &SmazGpkaqmif;r_ rjyKed kifjcif; ponfwd k @
jzpfygonf? od k @&mwGif wcsdefwnf;Y rdrdwd k @rSm jrefrmed kifiH. e,fpyfa'owae&mwGif tajcpd kufaqmif&GufEk difojzif h jynfwGif;rSjynfolrsm;. yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_rsm;ud k txd kuftav#muf&&S djcif;/ jynfwGif;jynfy&S d Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;/ tzG J @tpnf;rsm;rS acgif;aqmifrsm;ESif htzG J @0ifrsm;/ a'ocHjynfolrsm;. yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_&&S djcif;/ Ed kifiHwumESif hxdawG @qufpyfEd kifjcif; ponf h tm;omcsufrsm;vnf; &S dygonf?
oufaocHcsufrsm;
aumfr&Siftaejzih f vkyf=uHr_jzpfyGm;&mwGif&S daecJ honf h/ rsufjrifoufaorsm;teuf (6)OD;. xGufcsufrsm;uk dvufcH+yD; ,ck y%mrtpD&ifcHpmwGif azmfjyxm;ygonf? usef xGufqd kcsufrsm;ud k qufvufpdppfqJjzpfonf?
xk d @tjyif vkyf}uHr_jzpfyGm;onh fae&mwGif &d Saech Jonh f tjcm;rsufjrifoufao(2)OD;. xGufqk dcsufrsm;uk dvnf;/,k H=unfpdwfcs&aom owif;&if;jrpfrsm;rSwqih f aumfr&SifuvufcH&&d Sch Jygonf? aumfr&Sifu tqk dyg rsufjrif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 11/208
11
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
oufao pkpkaygif; (8)OD;.xGufqk dcsufrsm;uk d/ TtpD&ifcHpmwGif t"du ud k;um;wifjyxm;onf? rsufjrifouf
aorsm;uk d awG @qk Hch Jonh f tzJ G @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;/ xdcd kuf'%f &m&olrsm;/ zrf;qD;xdrf;odrf;cHxm;&olrsm;tm;oGm;a&mufawG @qk Hch Jonh faqGrsKd;rsm;/ rdwfaqGrsm; ponf h yk*~ dKvfrsm;u/ a&'D,k dowif;Xmersm;ok d @ qufoG,fajymjycsufrsm;uk dvnf; axmufcHoufaocHcsuf 11111 rsm;tjzpf aumfr&Sifu rSwfwrf;wifxm;onf? tqd kyg oufaocHcsuf tm;vH k;tay:wGif tajccHpkpnf;I T tpD&ifcHpmud k jyKpkygonf?
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+}uD;eSif h pyfvsOf;I xm;&S doif haom oabmxm;
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;onf wzG J h/ wygwD/ yk*~ dKvfwOD;wa,mufESif hom oufqd kifaomudpP r[kwfyg? wwd kif;wjynfvH k; wd kif;&if;om;jynfolw&yfvH k;eSif h oufqd kifaom udpPjzpfygonf? ppftkyfpktaejzif h ‚if;wd k @. Ek difiHa&;
tm%mud k xdyg;Ek difrnf[k oHo,&S dol rnfolud krqd k Ek difiHawmft=urf;zuf0g'22222 ud k toH k;csum &uf&ufpufpufajcr_ef;oGm;rnf[k wEk difiHvH k; wurB mvH k;ud k twdtvif; +cdrf;ajcmufvd kufjcif;yif jzpfonf? 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;eSif hpyfvsOf;I ppftkyfpktwGif;rS pDpOfn$ef=um;aom yk*~ dKvfrsm;/ wm0ef&S daom tm%myd kifrsm;/ 'DyJ,if;vlowfuGif;twGif;Y ud k,fxdvufa&muf owfjzwf&ufpufr_ usL;vGefolrsm;ud k wpH kw&mta&;,ljcif; rjyKEk difv#if aoqH k;/aysmufqH k;/ '%f&m&/ b0ysufpD; xdcd kufepfemqH k;±_ H;=u&oltm;vH k;twGuf w&m;r#wr_ vH k;0 qH k;±_ H;ygrnf? xk d @tjyif'Drd kua& pDta&;eSif h wd kif;&if;om;rsm;. ud k,fyd kifjyXmef;cGif h tcGif hta&;twGuf v_yf&Sm;óud;yrf;aer_rsm;rSmvnf;wEk difiHvH k;wGif csnf heJ @oGm;rnf rkcsjzpfonf? vlxktrsm;pk}uD;taejzif h ppftkyfpk. rw&m;zdES dyftkyfcsKyfr_ud k qef @usifwGef;vSef&ef aeSmif haES;oGm;rnf jzpfonf? Oya'pd k;rd k;a&; vH k;0csLyf+idrf;oGm;+yD; Ek difiHawmft=urf;zuf0g'uom
v$rf;rd k;}uD;pd k;oGm;rnfjzpfonf? ppftkyfpkeSif h Ek difiHa&;t&awG @qH kaqG;aEG;um trsdL;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&; wnfaqmufEd kifrnf[laom ar#mfrSef;csufrSmvnf; oJxJa&oGefomjzpfaeygrnf? tusKd;quftjzpf rsufarSmuf wGifvnf;aumif;/ tem*wfwGifvnf;aumif; Ek difiHom;wOD;csif;pDwd kif;twGuf b0vH k+cHKr_/ vGwfvyfr_ESif h +idrf;csrf;r_rsm; uif;rJ hoGm;rnfjzpfonf? od k @jzpfI 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif h pyfvsOf;I trSefw&m;ud kazmfxkwfum wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud k xd kufonh ftm;avsmfpGm ta&;,laqmif&GufEk difa&;rSm vl @tzG J @tpnf;w&yfvH k;. wm0efjzpfvmygawmhonf?
ta&;,laqmif&Gufr+ tm;enf;jcif;ESif h t-urf;zufr+oHo&m
Tr#}uD;rm;aom vkyfief;}uD;ud k jynfolvlxktrsm;pk}uD;eSif h Ek difiHa&;ygwD tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ 'Drd kua&pDta&;wufºuGvSKyf&Sm;olrsm;/ Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;ud kazmfaqmifvd kaom jynfwGif;jynfyrS Oya'qd kif&mynm&Sifrsm;ESif h trSefw&m;ud k jrwfed k;aomtiftm;pkrsm;/ vl @tcGif hta&;ud k vd kvm;awmif;qd kwd kufyG J0ifv#uf&S d=uaom wOD;csif; jynfolrsm; tzG J @tpnf;rsm; ponfwd k @u xda&mufxufjruf pGmyl;aygif;qmif&Gufjcif; rjyKv#if tqd kyg&nfrSef;csufatmifjrif&ef rvG,fyg? 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uH r_}uD;ud k zH k;uG,fESif h&ef etz rS zefwD;ay;aom Ed kifiHa&;vrf;a=umif;rsm;tay: wkef @jyefjcif; ( Reaction ) vkyfief;rsm;ud kom vd ktyfonfxuf yd kIvkyfaqmifae=urnfqd kv#if 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;rSm 1962 ckeSpf aemufyd kif;rS pI usL;vGefcJ honf h jypfr_}uD;rsm;uJ hod k @ wajz;ajz;arS ;rS def aysmufuG,foGm;Ek difrnf h tajctae&S dygonf? ,if;od k @jzpfv#if rnfok d @aom awG @qH kaqG;aEG;r_rsm;jyKonfjzpfap/ ppftkyfpkonf‚if;wd k @ud k twd kuftcHjyKvm+yD[k oHo,&S daom rnfonh fEk difiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm;/ vl htcGif hta&; v_yf&Sm;wufºuG
olrsm;ud k rqd k 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_xufyd krd kI qd k;0g;aom t=urf;zufr_}uD;rsKd;ud k xyfrHusL; vGefOD;rnf rkcsjzpfonf?,if;ok d @jzif h jrefrmEk difiHonf t=urf;zufr_oHo&mxJYom xyfumxyfum vnfywfaeOD;rnf jzpfonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 12/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
12
aumfr&Sif. óud;yrf;r+rsm;
aumfr&Siftaejzif h vkyfyd kifcGif h/ vltiftm;/ twwfynm/ ±kyf0wKyx0D taetxm; tuef @towfrsm;
tygt0if tcuftcJaygif;pH kt=um;rSyif pwifzG J @pnf;cJ honf h ZGefv (25)&ufae@rSpI (6)wm umvtwGif;atmufygwd k @ud k aqmif&Gufed kifcJ hygonf?
(1) jynfwGif;rS Ek difiHa&; tiftm;pkrsm; vl @tcGif hta&;v_yf&Sm;wufºuGolrsm;. tultnDjzif h&ed kiforS saomrsufjrifoufaorsm;udk pkaqmif;cJ h/ pkaqmif;qJjzpfonf? ‚if; oufaorsm;tm;xdef;odrf;apmifha&SmufumwwfpGrf;or#tultnDrsm; ay;tyfxm;qJjzpfonf?
(2) ed kifiHwum vl @tcGif hta&; tzG J @tpnf;}uD;rsm;/ Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;od k @csOf;uyfum tultnD t=uH^m%feSif h yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_ud k awmif;cHcJ h/ awmif;cHqJ jzpfonf? 'Drd kua&pDeSif h vl @tcGif hta&;ud k vd kvm;jrwfEk d;aom jynfya&muf ed kifiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm;/ acgif;aqmifrsm;/ jrefrmed kifiHom;rsm;ud kqufoG,farwWm&yfcHum'DyJ,if;udpPud k txl;jyKaqmif&Gufrnf h vSKyf&Sm;r_tzG J
hrsm; ( Depayin Campaign Committee) zG J @pnf;aqmif
&Guf=uyg&ef arwWm&yfcH cJ honf? od k h&mwGif ta=umif;a=umif;a=umif h ,cktcsdeftxd *syefEk difiH wEk difiHwGifomzG J hpnf;aqmif&Gufvmed kifa=umif; awG @&S d&onf?
(3) jynfaxmifpkjrefrmed kifiH trsKd;om;aumifpDeSif h trsKd;om;!Gef @aygif;tpd k;&wd k @. tultnDjzif h rsufjrifoufaorsm;tm; xd kif;Ek difiH txufv$wfawmfESif h tar&duefjynfaxmifpkuGef*&ufok d @apv$wfum 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yf}uD;eSif h pyfvsOf;I Ek difiHwumrS yd krd kod&S dvmatmif oufaoxGufqk d xkwfazmfed kifcJ honf?
(4) 2003 ckeSpf Zlvd kif v (4)&ufae@wGif t*Fvdyfbmomjzif h yxrt}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpmud kvnf;aumif;/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ (6)vjynf hajrmufonf h ed k0ifbmv (30) &ufae@wGif jrefrmbmomjzif h 'kwd,t}udrfy%mr tpD&ifcHpmud kvnf;aumif;/ jyKpkxkwfjyefEk dif fcJ honf?
(5) jrefrmEk difiH vltcGif hta&;qd kif&m ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f rpPwm yDnJ±k d;xHok d @ 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfeSif hpyfvsOf;I oufaocHtaxmuftxm;rsm;eSif h wuG jynf hjynf hpH kpH k wifjyed kifcJ honf? Ed k0ifbmv (12)&ufae@wGifrpPwm yDnJ&d k;rS (58)}udrfajrmuf urB mhukvor*~ taxGaxG nDvmcHod k @ jrefrmEd kifiH vl @tcGif hta&;tajctaersm;ESif hpyfvsOf;+yD; ‚if;.pH kprf;awG @&S dcsufrsm;ud k tpD&ifcHwifjy&mY 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_jzpf&yf}uD;ud k t"duxm; rD;armif;xd k;wifjyoGm;cJ honf htjyif atmufygtwd kif; oH k;oyfcJ honf?
“tpd k;& tm%myd kifrsm;u yl;aygif;=uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdL;r[kwf&if 'DyJ ,if; jzpf&yfjzpfyGm;ed kifp&m r&S dbl;tpd k;& tm%myd kifrsm;u yl;aygif;=uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdL;r[kwf&if 'DyJ ,if; jzpf&yfjzpfyGm;ed kifp&m r&S dbl;tpd k;& tm%myd kifrsm;u yl;aygif;=uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdL;r[kwf&if 'DyJ ,if; jzpf&yfjzpfyGm;ed kifp&m r&S dbl;tpd k;& tm%myd kifrsm;u yl;aygif;=uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdL;r[kwf&if 'DyJ ,if; jzpf&yfjzpfyGm;ed kifp&m r&S dbl;tpd k;& tm%myd kifrsm;u yl;aygif;=uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdL;r[kwf&if 'DyJ ,if; jzpf&yfjzpfyGm;ed kifp&m r&S dbl;qd kwJ htcsufudk oH k;oyfed kifzk d @ cdkifvH kwJ @ ta=umif;taxmuftxm; oufaocHcsuf&S dae+yDvd k husaemf ajymedkifqd kwJ htcsufud k oH k;oyfed kifzkd @ cd kifvH kwJ @ ta=umif;taxmuftxm; oufaocHcsuf&S dae+yDvd k husaemf ajymed kifqd kwJ htcsufudk oH k;oyfed kifzk d @ cdkifvH kwJ @ ta=umif;taxmuftxm; oufaocHcsuf&S dae+yDvd k husaemf ajymedkifqd kwJ htcsufud k oH k;oyfed kifzkd @ cd kifvH kwJ @ ta=umif;taxmuftxm; oufaocHcsuf&S dae+yDvd k husaemf ajymed kifqd kwJ htcsufud k oHk;oyfedkifzk d @ cd kifvHkwJ @ ta=umif;taxmuftxm; oufaocHcsuf&S dae+yDvdk husaemf ajymed kifw,f?w,f?w,f?w,f?w,f?
I can say that there is a prima facie evidence that the Depayin incident could not have
happened without the connivance of State agents.
arwW m&yfcHjcif;
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif h pyfvsOf;I tjzpfrSefazmfxkwfEk difa&;ESif h wm0ef&S dolrsm;tm; wpk Hw&mta&;,laqmif±GufEk difa&;twGuf jynfolvlxktrsm;pk}uD;ESif h Ek difiHa&;ygwDtzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ 'Drd kua&pDta&; wufºuGv_yf&Sm;olrsm;/ Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;ud kazmfaqmifvd kaom jynfwGif;jynfyrS Oya'qd kif&mynm&Sifrsm;ESif h tiftm;pkrsm;/ vl @tcGif hta&;ud k vd kvm;awmif;qd kwd kufyG J0ifv#uf&S d=uaom wOD;csif;jynfolrsm; tzG J @tpnf;rsm; ponfwk d @u xda&mufxufjrufpGm yl;aygif;qmif&Guf&ef arwWm&yfcHygonf? ok d @r[kwfv#if Tr#}uD;rm;aom vkyfief;}uD; xajrmufatmifjrif&ef rvG,fulyg?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 13/208
13
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
trSeftwd kif; wifjy&v#if jzpfyGm;cJ haom r_cif;}uD;. twd kif;twmy%mreSif h ed kif;,SOfygu jynfwGif;rSjzpfapEk difiHwumrSjzpfap/ ,cktcsdeftxd 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;twGuf ta&;,lyl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_rSm rsm;pGmenf;yg;
aeygonf? aumfr&Siftaejzif h 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfESif h pyfvsOf;I trSefw&m;azmfxkwfEk difa&;twGuf tuef @towftcuftcJrsm;=um;rS wwfpGrf;or# óud;yrf;cJ hygonf? tusKd;quftaejzif h Ek d0ifbmv(18)&ufae@wGif usif;yaom (58)}udrfajrmuf ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcHwGif atmufygtwk dif; qk H;jzwfcsufcsrSwfI ukvor*~rSetztm; awmif;qk dvk duf+yD jzpfonf?
“ar(30)&ufae@Y jzpfyGm;cJ haom 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfESif hpyfvsOf;I Ek difiHwumESif hyl;aygif;umvGwfvyfaompk Hprf;r_rsm;uk d jynf hpk HpGmjyKvkyfoGm;&ef”
tqk dygawmif;qkdcsuftwkdif; vufawG@jzpfvm+yD; 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yf}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I wm0ef&Sdolrsm;tm;
wpk Hw&mxda&mufpGm ta&;,laqmif±GufEk dif&efrSmrl Ek difiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm;u OD;aqmifum tm;vk H;0k dif;0ef;óud;yrf;=urSom jzpfEk difygrnf? ,if; &nfrSef;csufatmifjrifEk difa&;twGuf 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;wGif xdcd kufcHpm;cJ h=u&olrsm;/ tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ 1990 arv a&G;aumufyG JwGif a&G;cs,fwifajr‡mufjcif;cH&aom v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;/ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csLyfrS wm0ef&S dolrsm;/ wd kif;&if;om;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;eSif hpyfvsOf;I w&m;r#wr_ 0d kif;0ef;&SmazGvd konf h jynfwGif; jynfyrS yk*~ dKvfrsm;tm;vH k; yl;aygif;vufwG J aqmif&GufoGm;=u&efaumfr&SifrS tav;teufarwWm&yfcHygonf?
,if;od k @ yl ;aygif;vufwG Jaqmif&Gufr_ yd krd ktm;aumif;vmapa&;twGufvnf;aumif;/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;eSif h pyfvsOf;I tjynf htpH k r[kwfao;aomfjim;vnf; wpH kw&maomtwd kif;twmtxd trSefw&m;ud k azmfxkwfcGif h&ap&ef vnf;aumif;/ &nf&G,fum Ty%mrtpD&ifcHpmud k a&;om;jyKpkxkwfa0wifjy&jcif; jzpfygonf?
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm;( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm;( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm;( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm;( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )
11111? Corroborated Evidence
22222? State Terrorism
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 14/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
14
tcef;(1)
a':atmifqef;pk-unfESifh tzGJŒcsKyftzGJŒ0ifrsm;tay: 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ rwd kifrD
ppftm%myd kifrsm;. zdESdyfcsKyfcs,fr+rsm;/ wd kufcd kufr+rsm;ESif h
touftEW&m,fxdcd kufapEd kifonftxd t-urf;zufcJ hjcif;rsm;
2002 ckESpf/ arv (6)&ufae@wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf (19)v=umaetdrftus,fcsKyfrSvGwfajrmufvmcJ h+yD;aemuf/ pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm; oGm;a&mufcJ hygonf?
aetdrftus,fcsKyfrS,ckw}udrfvGwfajrmufvmr_rSm c|if;csufjzif h r[kwfbJ oGm;a&mufvd konf hae&mod k @ vGwfvyfpGm oGm;vmEd kifcGif h¶S da=umif; etzrS oabmwlxm;cJ honf?
aetdrftus,fcsKyfrSvGwfajrmufvm+yD;aemuf &efukefwd kif;twGif;pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf ² ² ²
(1) 17-5-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefajrmufyd kif;c¶d kif/ a¶$jynfomòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?(2) 22-5-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefta¶S @yd kif;c¶d kif/ a'gyH kòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?(3) 24-5-02 &ufae@wGif &efukeftaemufyd kif;c¶d kif/ urm¶GwfòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?
(4) 31-5-02 &ufae@wGif &efukeftaemufyd kif;c¶d kif/ =unf hjrifwd kifòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?(5) 12-6-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefta¶S @yd kif;c¶d kif/ omauwòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?(6) 16-7-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefajrmufyd kif;c¶d kif/ r*Fvm'H kòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;ESif h vSnf;ul;òrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf
¶H k;?(7) 30-8-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefawmifyd kif;c¶d kif/ 'vòrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;/ aumhrª;òrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;ESif h uGrf;+cH
ukef;òrdŒe,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?(8) 19-9-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefta¶S @yd kif;c¶d kif/ wmarGòrd @e,ftzG J @csKyf¶H k;?(9) 4-10-02 &ufae@wGif &efukefta¶S @yd kif;c¶d kif/ oCFef;u|ef;òrdŒe,f tzG J @csKyf¶H k;wd k @od k @oGm;a&mufcJ honf h
c&D;pOfrsm;twGif;/ jynfolvlxk.vd _ufvd _ufvS JvS JwcJeufaxmufcHr_ud k&¶S dcJ honf?
wdkif;ESif hjynfe,frsm;odk @oGm;a&mufcJhonfhpnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf ² ² ²wd kif;ESifhjynfe,frsm;od k@oGm;a&mufcJ honf hpnf;¶Hk;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf ² ² ²wdkif;ESif hjynfe,frsm;odk @oGm;a&mufcJhonfhpnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf ² ² ²wd kif;ESifhjynfe,frsm;od k@oGm;a&mufcJ honf hpnf;¶Hk;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf ² ² ²wd kif;ESif hjynfe,frsm;od k @oGm;a&mufcJ honf hpnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf ² ² ²
(1) 14-6-02 &ufae@rS 15-6-02 &ufae@txd rGefjynfe,f/ omrn? (omrnawmifq&mawmf -tbd"Z t*~r[mo'<rRaZmwdu b'N E W0de,tm; oGm;a&mufzl;ajrmf=unf!k d )
(2) 22-6-02 &ufae@rS 29-6-02 &ufae@txd rE Wav;wd kif;/ rauG;wd kif;twGif;(16)òrdŒe,f?(3) 14-7-02 &ufae@rS 17-7-02 &ufae@txd yJcl;wd kif;twGif;(14)òrdŒe,f?(4) 20-7-02 &ufae@rS 23-7-02 &ufae@txd rGefjynfe,fESif hu&ifjynfe,ftwGif;(12)òrdŒe,f/?
(5) 13-11-02 &ufae@rS 27-11-02 &ufae@txd &Srf;jynfe,ftwGif;(17)òrdŒe,f?(6) 16-12-02 &ufae@rS 24-12-02 &ufae@txd &cd kifjynfe,f/ rauG;wd kif;ESif h{&m0wDwd kif;twGif;(15)
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 15/208
15
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
òrdŒe,f?(7) 3-4-03 &ufae@rS 13-4-03 &ufae@txd rauG;wd kif;ESif hcsif;jynfe,ftwGif;(21)òrdŒe,f?(8) 6-5-03 &ufae@rS 30-5-03 &ufae@txd rE Wav;wd kif;/ ppfud kif;wd kif;/ ucsifjynfe,f/ ¶Srf;jynfe,ft
wGif; (28)òrdŒe,f ponfjzif h wk dif;ESif hjynfe,f (12)ck&S d pkpkaygif; (125)òrdŒe,fok d @ oGm;a&mufcJ honf?azmfjyyg pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif; jynfolrsm;.axmufcHtm;ay;r_ wpxuf wp wd k;wuf&¶S d vmcJ honf henf;wl/ tm%myd kifrsm;. enf;trsdK;rsdK;jzif haESmif h,Suf[ef @wm;r_rsm; wpxuf wp wd k;wufrsm;jym;vmonfud k awG @}uHKcJ h&onf?
tm%myd kifrsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftay: aESmif h,Suf[ef @wm;cJ honfrSm ,ckrS r[kwfyg? 1988 ckESpfwGif tjypfrJ hjynfol&maygif;rsm;pGmtm;ypfcwfowfjzwfacsr_ef;+yD; tm%modrf;,lcJ honf h tm%myd kif(ppftkyfpk)rsm;onf/ rv$ JomI Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;zG J @pnf;cGif hay;cJ haomfvnf;/ Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;.vGwfvyfpGmpnf;¶H k;v_yf¶Sm;cGif hud k tpOft+rJ enf;rsdK;pH kjzif hydwfyif[ef @wm;cJ honf? Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;taejzif hjynfolvlxk=um;wGif pnf;¶H k;a&;vkyf=u&&m/ tm%myd kifrsm;rS jynfolrsm;ud kenf;rsdK;pHkjzif h+cdrf;ajcmufxm;+yD;Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;ESi f hxdawG @qufqHr_ rjyKEd kifatmif [ef @wm;ydwfyifxm;cJ honf?
1988 ckESpf
1988 ckESpf/ pufwifbmv (27)&ufae@wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf zG J @pnf;cJ h+yD;/ pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;tjzpf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @ wd kif;ESif hjynfe,frsm;od k @ oGm;a&mufcJ h&m/ tm%myd kifrsm;.aESif h,Sufr_trsdK;rsdK; }uHKawG @cJ h&onf?
1988 ckESpf/ 'DZifbmv (14)&ufae@rS (18)&ufae@txdoGm;a&mufcJ honf h rGefjynfe,fpnf;¶H k;a&; c&D;pOftwGif; aomif;ESif hcsDonf hjynfolrsm;u}udKqd kaxmufcHcJ h=uygonf? tm%myd kifrsm;u pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOftwGif;aESmif h,Suf[ef @wm;r_wpH kw&m rjyKcJ haomfvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @ rGefjynfe,f pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D; jyefvmonf hae@rSpI rGefjynfe,ftwGif;rStzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; trdef @trSwf-2§88 ud kcsdK;azmufonf[k qd kumzrf;qD;xdef;odrf;r_rsm; jyKvkyfcJ honf?
1989 ckESpf
tqd k;qH k;rSm {&m0wDwd kif; pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif;jzpfonf? 1989 ckESpf/ Zefe0g&Dv(14)&ufae@rS (25)&ufae@txdESif h 1989 ckESpf/ {+yDv(4)&ufae@rS (6)&ufae@txd oGm;a&mufcJ honf hc&D;pOfrsm;wGif/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @ rvma&mufrD}udKwifI {&m0wDwd kif;twGif;¶S djynfolvlxktm;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @vmv#if r}udK&/ tdrfwGif;rStdrfjyif rxGuf&/ vuf rjy&/ usef;rmygap rajym& ponfjzif h wm;jrpf[ef @wm; +cdrf;ajcmufxm;cJ honf? tcsdK@ae&mrsm;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @ a&mufvmcJ hv#if +yHK; rjy&[kyif wm;jrpfcJ honf?
{&m0wDwd kif; +idrf0yfydjym;r_wnfaqmufa&;tzG J @(w-0-w)OuUX Ad kvfrª;csKyfjrif hatmifrS a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @0ifrsm;. pnf;¶H k;a&;c&D;pOftwGif;wGif ppfwyftm; 'Drd kua&pDtiftm;pkrsm;ud kajcmufvSef @&ef/ ajcr_ef;&eftoH k;jyKcJ honfud k xif¶Sm;pGmawG @&ygonf? vH k+cHKa&;ta=umif;jyI jynfolrsm;. 'Drd kua&pDtcGif hta&;rsm;tm;qef @usifjcif;/ 'Drd kua&pDv_yf¶Sm;r_tm; wd kufcd k kufjcif;rsm;jyKvkyfcJ honf?
1989 ckESpf/ {+yDv (5)&ufae@ "EkjzLòrd @Y a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @tm; aoewf jzif h ypfcwfEd SrfESif;rnfjyK onftxd jzpfcJ honf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 16/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
16
yxrt}udrfrSm a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @ anmifwkef;òrd @/ "EkjzLòrd @ESif hteD;tem;aus;&Gmrsm;od k @/ {+yDv(4)&ufae@rS (6)&ufae@txd (3)&uf=um pnf;&k k H;a&;c&D;oGm;a&mufcJ hygonf? 5-4-89 &ufae@ eHeuf (9)em&D(30)rdepftcsdefcef @wGif/ "EkjzLòrd @ trsd K;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf&k H;Y òrd @e,fpnf;&k H;a&;rª;rsm;ESif h em&D0ufcef @ awG @qH kI
aqG;aEG;cJ h+yD;/ tazsmufòrd @od k @c&D;quf&ef tzJ G @csKyf&k H;teD;&d S &efrsdK;atmifqdyfurf;od k @ vrf;av#mufvmcJ honf?a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzJ G @0iftcsdK@ ‘acwfvd kuf’wnf;cd k&dyfomteD;&d S vrf;qH kod k @a&mufumeD;wGif vltkyf.aemufbuf ud kuf(100)ausmfcef @rS toHcsJ @pufwyfqifxm;aomum;jzif hvd kufygvmaom (r-0-w)tzJ G @0ifrsm;onf “qlyl&ef&nf&G,fcsufjzif h pDwef;vrf;av#mufjcif;qENjyjcif;rsm; vH k;0 rðy&efESif h od k @r[kwfygu xda&mufpGm ypfcwf&Sif;vif;ES drfeif;&rnfjzpfa=umif;”ponfjzif h[pfatmfowday;cJ honf?
aemufbufrSaeI “usnfxd k;”[ktrdef @ay;onf? xd k @aemuf yxrt}udrf owday;onf/ 'kwd,t}udrfowday;onf/ wwd,t}udrf owday;onf[k toHcsJ @pufjzif hajymum/ppfom;rsm;tm; 'l;axmufapI a': atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @tm; csdef&G,f&eftrdef @ay;cJ honf? od k @aomf trSefwu,f ypfcwfcJ hr_ rjyKjzpfcJ hojzif hom toufraocJ hjcif;jzpfonf?
'kwd,t}udrfrSm 5-4-89 &ufae@wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @ tazsmuf/ qum}uD;aus;&Gmrsm;od k @0ifa&muf+yD; aemufqH k;pcef;jzpfonf h vufyefyifaus;&Gmod k @ 0ifa&mufI jyefvnfxGufcGmvm&m "EkjzLqdyfurf;od k @ nae(6)em&DtcsdefwGif qd kufa&mufcJ hygonf? tzJ G @csKyf&k H; wnf&d S&mod k @ tzJ G @0ifrsm; at;csrf;pGmajcvsifjyefvmcJ h+yD; aps;teD; r[mAE<Kvvrf;twGif;od k @0ifa&mufcJ h&maps;ydwfcsdefjzpfI vrf;&Sif;ae+yD; rnfonf hv_yf&Sm;r_r# r&d SbJ at;aq;+idrfoufvsuf&S donf?
a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @ r[mAE< Kvvrf;ESif h pmwd kufvrf;qH krS ay(300)cef @twGif;od k @a&mufonf htcg*spfum;wpfpD; vrf;xdyfod k @&kwfw&ufxd k;qd kufvm+yD; um;ay:rS&Jabmf(6)OD;ESif h Ad kvf}uD;wOD;qif;vmI &Jabmf(4)OD;u 'l;axmufIvnf;aumif;/ ESpfOD;u rwfwwf&yfIvnf;aumif; ypfcwf&eftoif h taetxm;ðyvkyfcJ honf?
‚if;tzJ G @tm;tkyfcsKyfol Ad kvf}uD;u a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; “qENjyonf htaetxm;jzif h rcsDwufygESif h/vrf;ud kydwfqd k @jcif; rðyvkyfygESih f”ponfjzif hvnf;aumif;/ “yxrt}udrf owday;aeygw,f”[lIvnf;aumif;atmf[pfajymqd konf?
a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS tzJ G @0ifrsm;tm; vrf;ab;wbufwcsufod k @cJ GIav#muf&efajymqd k&m ‚if;wd k @uvrf;wbufwcsufod k @qif;I av#muf=uonf? ‚if;Ad kvf}uD;u“vrf;ab;uav#mufv#ifvnf; ypf&rSmyJ”[ka':atmifqef;pk=unftm; ajymonf htcg/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS wOD;wnf;vrf;v,fod k @xGufum/ aoewfjzif hcsdef¶G,faeonf h &Jabmfav;OD;t=um;rS jzwfausmfav#mufoGm;cJ honf?
xd ktcd kuf Ad kvfrª;ESpfOD; tzJ G@csKyfvli,frsm;aemufrS &kwfw&ufajy;wufvm=u+yD;/ “AdkvfjrifhOD;/ rvkyfeJ @/
rvkyfeJ @”atmf[pfwm;jrpfcJ honf? xd k @aemuf&Jabmfrsm;tm;usnf&Sif;&ef csufjcif;yif ,if;Ad kvfrª;wd k @u trdef @ay;+yD;usnf&Sif;apcJ hojzif hom a':atmifqef;pk=unf toufraocJ hjcif;jzpfonf?Ad kvf}uD;jrif hOD;qd kolu a'gojzif h ol.ykcH k;ay:wGif wyfqifxm;aom&mxl;tqif hwHqdyfrsm;ud k qJ GòzwfI
“'Dvd kqd k&if 'gawGbmvkyf&rSmvJ”[k txuft&m¶S drsm;tm;jyefajymcJ honf/ “rif;ta&;,l cH&r,f”[k Ad kvfrª;wOD;u owday;&m/ Ad kvf}uD;jrif hOD;u“cifAsm;wd k @ ,lcsif,l/ óudufwmvkyf”[kjyefajym cJ honftxdjzpfcJ honf?
1996 ckESpf
a':atmifqef;pk=unf.+cH0if;twGif; (4-1-96) ae@wGif (47)ESpfajrmuf vGwfvyfa&;ae@tcrf;tem;usif;ycJ honf? tqk dygtcrf;tem;wGif t+idrf hjzif h ujyajzmfajzcJ h=uonf h OD;ygygav;/ OD;vlaZmf/ OD;axG;ESif h OD;atmifpk d;wk d @tm; rE Wav;ok d @ jyefta&mufwGif tm%myk difrsm;u zrf;qD;+yD; w&m;pJ Gqk dcJ honf? xk dtr_wGif oufaocH&ef
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 17/208
17
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
rE Wav;ok d @oGm;a&mufrnf h a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @ &efukefblwm}uD;ok d @a&muf&S dpOf tm%myk difrsm;rS a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @ pD;eif;vk dufygrnf h&xm;wJ Gtm; pufyk dif;qk dif&mcsKd @,Gif;r_&S donf[kta=umif;jyI tqk dyg&xm;wJ Guk djzKwfxm;+yD; wm;qD;aESmif h,SufcJ honf?
Ed kifiHawmf+idrf0yfydjym;r_wnfaqmufa&;tzG J @. &xm;yd k @aqmifa&;0ef}uD;Xme/ 0ef}uD;wOD;jzpfol OD;0if;pdefonf jynfaxmifpk}uH @ck difa&;ESif hzG H @òzd;a&;toif;wGif A[d ktwGif;a&;rª;tjzpf wm0efxrf;aqmifae&oljzpf+yD;/ ,if;yk*~ dKvfonf 1-11-96 &ufae@ESif h 3-11-96 &ufae@rsm;wGif xk dtzG J @twGuf pnf;¶k H;a&;uGif;qif;&mY ajym=um;cJ honf hpum;rsm;rSm/tvGefw&m ao;odrf,kwf!H hvSonf? xk dajym=um;cJ ho!f hpum;rsm;uk d trd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf oufqk dif&mtzG J @cG Jrsm;u A[d kXmecsKyfok d @ay;yk d @xm;o!f h tpD&ifcHpmrsm;twd kif; jyefvnfa&;om;+yD;/Ek difiHawmf+idrf0yfydjym;r_wnfaqmufa&;tzGJ @ OuUÏvnf;jzpf+yD;/ jynfaxmifpk}uH @cdkifa&;ESif h zGH @òzd d;a&;toif;.em,u}uD;vnf; jzpfo!h f Ad kvfcsKyfrª;}uD;oef;a¶$xH 20-12-96 &ufpG JygpmtrSwf 179§ pnf;(jidrf)§96 jzif htzG J @csKyf OuUX OD;atmifa¶$rS ta=umif;=um;cJ honf?
jzpfpOfrSm 1-11-96 &ufae@ (14;00)em&Dtcsdefcef @wGif/ tif;awmfòrd @rS(1)rk difcef @a0;aom/ v,fjyifaus;&Gmrlvwef;ausmif;0ef;twGif;ðyvkyfaom &Gmvk H;u|wf}uH @§zG H @toif;0if tqk dðyv$may;tyfyG Jtcrf;tem;wGif/ &xm;yd k @aqmifa&;0ef}uD;Xme 0ef}uD; OD;0if;pdefrS wufa&mufvm=uaom aus;&Gmvlxktm;pum;ajym=um;&mY/ a': atmifqef;pk=unftm; yk*~ dKvfa&;t& xk d;ESufwk dufck dufcJ honf? 0ef}uD; OD;0if;pdefajympum;rsm;rSm jynfwGif;Ed kifiHa&; rwnfr+idrfjzpfatmifvkyfaeol a':pk=unfuk d okwfoif &Sif;vif;ypf&rnfjzpfa=umif;/ okwfoif&Sif;vif;ypf& rnfud k em;vnf=uovm;/ okwfoif&Sif;vif;ypf&r,fqk dwm owfypf&r,fvk d @qd kvk dwmjzpfa=umif;/ (wqufwnf;) atmifqef;pk=unfud k owf&Jovm;/ (Tpum;uk dy&dowftm; 5-6 cgavmuf a'gow}uD;qufar;)/
a':pk=unfud k owfypf&r,f[kajyma=umif;/ avmufpyDumjzif hajym=um;aom txufygpum;rsm;ud k ud k,fwk difwufa&muf=uolrsm;tjyif/ a'ocHaus;&GmvlxkESif h&Gmbkef;}uD;ausmif;rS &[ef;oHCmrsm;yif=um;odcJ h&onf?
}uH @§zG H @twGif;a&;r–; 0ef}uD;OD;0if;pdefonf 2-11-96 &ufae@nyd kif;wGif uomc¶d kif }uH @§zG H @ taqmuftOD;wGif/ uomc¶d kif}uH @§zG H @tvkyftr_aqmifrsm;/ Xmeqk dif&m0efxrf;t}uD;tuJrsm;tm; ac:,lawG @qk HI “=o0g'cH,lyG J” usif;yðyvkyfcJ honf? 3-11-96 &ufae@ eHeufyd kif;wGif uomòrd @e,f odrftif;aus;&Gm “&Gmvk H;u|wf}uH @§zG H @tqk dðyv$may;tyfyG J”wGifa[majymaom 0ef}uD;.pum;rsm;rSm/ a':atmifqef;pk=unf.ud k,fa&; ta=umif;t&mrsm;ud krrSefruefazmfjyajymqk donf htjyif/ “atmifqef; pk=unfud kowf&Jvm;”[k (3)}udrf(3)cg ar;jref;
wk difwnfatmf[pfay;cJ honf?0ef}uD;OD;0if;pdefonf xk dae@eHeuf(11)em&DwGifuomòrd @e,f/ tif;&Gmok d @a&muf&S dvm+yD;/ “&Gm;vk H;u|wf }uH @§zG H @tqk dðyv$may;tyfyG J”ok d @wufa&mufrdef @cGef;ajym=um;ygonf? tqk dygvlxktpnf;ta0;Y 0ef}uD;. a[majymcsufrsm;rSm a':atmifqef;pk=unf.ud k,fa&;&mZ0ifud k r[kwfrrSefaom/ odrfzsif;aompum;&yfrsm;jzif h vlxkud kt,k HoGif;a[majymcJ honf? xd k @aemuf “olrud kwk dif;jynfrSz,f&Sm;jypf&r,f/ okwfoifypf&r,f”[k (3)}udrfwk difatmf[pfaºuG;a=umfcJ honf? okwfoifw,fqk dwmowfypf&r,f[k qk dvk da=umif;xyfrHt"dy` g,fzGif hqk dajymqk dcJ honf?owf&J=uovm;[kok H;}udrfatmf[pfar;jref;cJ honf? tqk dyga[majymcsufrsm;ESif h pum;tok H;tE_ef;rsm;twd kif;yif uomc¶d kif/ tif;awmfòrd @e,f/ v,fjyif aus;&GmwGifusif;yðyvkyfonf h vlxktpnf;ta0;wGif vl(ig;axmif) cef @a&S @wGifa[majymoGm;cJ ha=umif; =um;odcJ h&ygonf? 0ef}uD;OD;0if;pdeftaejzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unftay: Yvnf;aumif;/ trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J @csKyfESif hywfoufIvnf;aumif;/ tpOfojzif h rrSefruefajymqk dr _r sm;ud k ðyvky fvsuf& S daeonf ud kawG @&onf? 1995 ckE Sp f / uomc¶d ki f (24)em&D r D;vif;a&;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 18/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
18
tcrf;tem;usif;ypOfuvnf;/ rdef @cGef;ajym qk d&mwGif “trsdK;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J @ csKyfESif h vl vlcsif;/ 'kwf 'kwfcsif;/ 'g; 'g;csif;¶d kufoif h&if¶k duf&rSm
jzpfa=umif;” xnf hoGif;ajymqk doGm;cJ hjcif;rsm;&S dcJ honf?0ef}uD;wOD;taejzifh a':atmifqef;pk
=unftm; vkyf}uHowfjzwf&ef v_H@aqmfcsufrsm;/ yk*~ dKvfa&; xdyg;ykwfcwfcsufrsm; ponfwk d @rSm owif;pmrD'D,mrsm;wGif ruawmhbJ e,fvSnf hwd kufcd kufajymqd kvmonftxd ajAmif usus vkyfaqmifvmcJhonf? OD;0if;pdefu ajym=um;onf hpum;&yfrSm tvGefw&mjyif;xefvS+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; toufqkH;¶_ H;ap&efyif v_ H @aqmfxm;onfud kawG @&onf?
1996 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(9)&ufae@wGif/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf acgif;aqmifrsm;jzpf=uaom 'kwd,OuUXrsm;jzpf=uonf h OD;wifOD;/ OD;=unfarmifESif h taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.um;wef;ud k vl&rf;um;(200)cef @wd k @uvH kòcHa&;wm0ef,lae=uonf h tm%myd kiftzG J @tpnf;toD;oD; rSyk*~ dKvfrsm;a&S @wGifyif wu,f hrif;rJ hwd kif;jynfyrm/ vlud kaoapEd kifavmufaomvufeufrsdK;pH kjzif h/ &ufpuf=urf;=uKwf pGm0d kif;0ef;I t=urf;zufwd kufcd kufcJ h=uonf? xd kod k @wd kufcd kufr_onftzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;. touftE W&m,fud k xdcd kufapEd kifavmuf
onf htjyif acgif;aqmifrsm;pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm; ysufpD;oGm;cJ honf?
1998 ckESpf
1998 ckESpf/ ZGefv(25)&ufae@wGif/ wuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;¶S d a':atmifqef;pk=unf.aetdrfY vli,frsm;tm;A[kokwwd k;yGm;ap&efESifhynmay;&ef ESpfywfw}udrf jyKvkyfae=ujzpfaompmzwf0d kif;od k@ vma&muf=uonfhtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifvli,frsm;tm; 24-6-98 &ufae@uwnf;u+cJwGif;od k @0ifa&muf&eftwGuf +cH0if;rSaxmuf vSrf;a&;rsm;xH }udKwiftrnfpm&if;ay;xm;cJhygv#uf +cH0if;.t0iftxGufud k ppfaq;avh¶SdaomvHk+cHKa&;*dwfrS
tm%myd kifrsm;.vH k+cHKa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;u0ifcGif hrjyKcJ hojzif h/ OD;wifOD;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @rS +cHjyifxGufIpepfwus}udKqd kac:aqmifvmcJ honfwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. aetdrfteD; rlvwef;ausmif;a¶S @od k @ a&mufonf htcg vH k+cHKa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;u “bmacgif;aqmifvJ/ ¶d kufuGm”/ “acgif;aqmifawGbmawGem;rvnfbl;/ tJ'Dacgif;aqmifyg±k duf”[ktrdef @ay;+yD; teD;¶d S ukuU dKud kif;/ opfud kif;/ eHygwfwkwfrsm;jzif h oJoJrJrJ 0ifa&muf¶d kufESufcJ hojzif h/ tzG J @csKyf0ifvli,f(4)OD; OD;acgif;ESif htjcm;ae&mrsm;wGif jyif;xefpGm'%f&m&¶S dcJ h+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftenf;i,f'%f&m&¶S dch J onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.touftE W&m,fud kxdcd kufapEd kifonftxd ðyvkyfcJ hjcif;jzpfonf?
1998 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(7)&ufae@ eHeuf(08;50)em&Dcef @wGif yJcl;wk dif;/ rif;vSðrd @e,f rJqENe,f trSwf(2)rSjynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f a':vSvSrd k;xHod k @ tzG J @csKyfOuUX OD;atmifa¶$/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @ armfawmf,mOfjzif hoGm;a&mufcJ honf hc&D;pOfwGif eHeuf(09;30) em&Dcef @Y &efukef-rEWav;vrf;¶S d
1996 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (9)&ufaeŒ u
etz tm%myk difrsm; vk HòcHa&;,lxm;onf h-um;rS
vl&rf;um;wpk wk dufck dufr+a-umif h
a':atmifqef;pk-unf pD;eif;vkdufygvmaom um;xdck dufysufpD;cJ h&pOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 19/208
19
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
axmuf}uH @ppfaq;a&;*dwfod k @a&mufonf htcg armfawmf,mOfud k &yfxm;apcJ honf/ (10)rdepfcef @&yfxm;+yD;aemuf
qufvufxGufcGmcJ honf htcg arSmfbD+rdK@txGufwGif tm%myd kifwd k @u xyfrHwm;qD;cJ honf? qufvufxGufcGmcJ hjyef&m (10;20)em&Dcef @tcsdef rd kifwd kif(40)rd kif (1)zmvH k¶S d a¶$jr,maus;¶GmteD;wGifta&mufwGif tm%myd kifrsm;u qufvufxGufcGmI r&atmif f wm;qD;xm;cJ honf? xd kae&mwGifyif &Jwyf&if;(3)pcef;csxm;cJ honf?qufvufrxGufcGmEd kifawmhonf h twGuf tzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm; xd kae&mwGifyif farmfwmf,mOfay: YwnvH k;aecJ h&onf? 8-7-98 &uf ae@eHeuf(07;30)em&DwGif tm%myd kifrsm;u a':vSvSrd k;tm; tzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;xHod k@ac:vmcJh=uonf? tm%myd kifrsm;u a':vSvSrd k;tm; 10-7-98 &ufae@ nae(15;00)em&Dta&muftzG J @csKyf¶H k;od k @ yd k @aqmifay;&efoabmwlnDcJ hojzif h xd kae@(08;20)em&Dcef @wGif tzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;jyefvmcJ h=uonf?
1998 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(20)&ufae@ eHeuf(09;10)em&Dcef @wGif {&m0wDwk dif;/ yef;waemf+rdK@e,fod k @ tzG J @csKyftaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h {&m0wDwd kif;pnf;¶H k;a&;aumfrwD OuUXESif h A[d k tvkyftr_aqmif tzG J @0ifwOD;jzpfol OD;vSazwd k @ armfawmf,mOfjzif hc&D;xGufcJ h=u&mwGif anmifwkef;òrd @rS ta¶S @buf (15)rd kifcef @tuGm tnmpkESif hyefwd kif¶GmteD;od k @ eHeuf(11;55)em&Dcef @wGifa&muf¶S dpOf tm%myd kifrsm;uvrf;ydwfqd k @wm;qD;cJ honf? yef;waemf +rdK@e,frJqENe,ftrSwf(1)rS jynfol @ v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f a'gufwm wifrif;xGÉftm; ae@vnf(14;10)em&Dcef @wGif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf¶Sd&modk @ tm%myk difrsm;uac:aqmifvmay;ojzif h tm%myd kifrsm;.oabmwlnDcsuft& ‚if;tm; &efukefod k @ ac:vm+yD;jyefvmcJ h=uonf?
1998 ckESpf/ Zkvk difv (24)&ufae@wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf ESif h {&m0wDwk dif; pnf;±k H;a&;tzJ GŒ OuUÏESif hA[k dtvkyftr_aqmif tzJ G @0ifwOD;jzpfol OD;vSazwk d @ {&m0wDwk dif;twGif;rS jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f
1998 ckESpfu {&m0wDwk dif; ykodrfòrdŒ ok dŒ toGm; &efukefwk dif; xef;wyifòrdŒe,f/ yefwk dif±G m (tnmpk)wGif
a':atmifqef;pk-unfESif htzJ GŒ etz tm%myk difwk dŒ . wm;qD;jcif;cHae&pOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 20/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
20
rsm;tm; &mZ0wfjypfr_ usL;vGefavh&S dolrsm;twGufom tok H;jyK avh&S daomajccsKyfESif h cH0eftufOya't& ta&;,lxm;jcif;cH& onf h ‚if;uk d,fpm;vS,frsm;ESif h ‚if;wk d @.rdom;pkrsm;tm; tm;ay;
pum;ajym=um;&ef {&m0wDwk dif; ykodrfòrd @ok d @ armfawmf,mOfjzif hoGm;a&mufcJhonf? anmifwkef;òrd@ta&S@buf(15)cef@tuGmtnmpk±GmwHwm;teD;wGif tm%mykdifrsm;u oHql;óud;rsm;oJtdwfrsm;csxm;I wm;qD;ydwfqk d @cJ honf?
(6)&uf=um wm;qD;ydwfqk d @xm;+yD; Zlvk difv(29)&ufae@nwGif ,cif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.+cHwGif wm0efus t&m&S djzpfcJhol trSwf(12)axmufvSrf;a&;wyfrS Akdvfrª;ol& (=unf;§18242)ESif h tiftm;(50)cef @&S dvk HòcHa&; wyfzJ G @0ifrsm; tqk dyg a': atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @tm; wm;qD;xm;&mae&mok d @ a&muf&S dvm+yD; (6)&uf =um wm;qD;ydwfqkd@cHxm;&ojzifh tpmESifhaomufa&jywfojzif h tm;tifcsdenf hpGm um;xJwGif vJavsmif;aeonf h a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; um;wGif;0ifa&muft=urf;zuf tEk diftxufjyKcsKyfaESmif+yD; twif;t"rR aetdrfok d @ jyefyk d @cJ honf?
1998 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(12)&ufae@ eHeuf(10;15)em&DwGiftzG J @csKyftaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf/ A[d k tvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0ifESif h {&m0wDwd kif; pnf;¶H k;a&;tzG J @ OuUX OD;vSazwd k @ 24-7-98 &ufae@u c&D;oGm;a&mufcJ h&mwGif udpP+yD;jywfjcif; r¶S daoma=umif h {&m
0wDwk dif;/ ykodrf+rdK@e,fod k @ trsm;jynfolwd k @toH k;jyKonf h c&D;vrf;twd kif;at;csrf;wnf+idrfpGm armfawmf,mOfjzif hc&D;xGufcJh=uonfwGif ,cifu wm;qDjcif;cHcJh=u&onfh xef;wyif+rdK@e,f/ yefwdkif¶Gm(tnmpk)teD;wGiftm%myd kifrsm;rS xyfrHwm;qD;cJ h=uonf? xd kod k @ ydwfyifwm;qD;jcif;cHae&pOftwGif; tpmESif ha&vH kavmufr_r¶S dojzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf.usef;rma&;tajctae wpxufwp yd krd kqd k;¶Gm;vmcJ honf? 21-8-98 &ufae@wGif tm%myd kifrsm;.cGif hjyKcsuf&ojzif h rdom;pkq&m0efrS oGm;a&mufppfaq;&m pd k;&drfzG,f&mtajctaeod k @a&mufaea=umif; ppfaq;awG @¶S dcJ h&+kyD;/ 24-8-98 &ufae@wGiftm%myd kifrsm;uxyfrHcGif hjyKojzif h rdom;pkq&m0efrSoGm;a&mufppfaq;=unf h&m txl;pd k;&drf&onf htaetxm;od k @a&muf¶S daea=umif; ppfaq;awG @¶S dcJ h&onf? trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h 'Drd kua&pDa&;vd kvm;=uonf h trsm;jynfoltm;vH k;wd k @u 'Drd kua&pDa&;
qufvufvkyfaqmifEd kif&eftwGuf a':atmifqef;pk=unfjyefvm&ef qENjyif;jypGm¶S dae=uojzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS 'Drd kua&pDtiftm;pkrsm;ESif htwl 'Drd kua&pDa&; qufvufaqmif¶Guf&efjyefvmcJ h&m 24-8-98 &ufae@(15;20) em&DwGif aetdrfod k @ jyefvnfa&muf¶S d vmcJ honf? tm%myd kifrsm;urw&m;ydwfyifwm;qD;xm;onfrSm(13)&uf =umjrif hcJ honf?
2000 jynfhESpf
trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 'kwd,OuUX OD;wifOD;/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf/ &efukefwd kif; pnf;¶H k;a&;aumfrwD OuUX OD;pd k;jrif h/ &efukefwd kif; pnf;¶H k;a&;tzG J @0if a'gufwmrsdK;atmifESif h ,mOfarmif;(2)OD;tygt0if tzG J @csKyfvli,f(16)OD;wd k @ 2000jynf hESpf/ =o*kwfv(24)&uf ae@/ eHeuf(09;00)em&Dcef @wGif &efukefwzufurf; 'vòrd @rSwqif h &efukefwd kif;/ uGrf;+cHukef;òrd @ESif h aumhrª;òrd @rsm;od k @ pnf;¶H k;a&;udpPrsm;aqmif¶Guf&ef
tm%myk difwk dŒ u
a':atmifqef;pk-unftm;
t-urf;zuf ac:aqmifvmojzifh
&&S dcJ haom'%f&mrsm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 21/208
21
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;rS trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ GŒ csKyf A[k dXmecsKyftm; 0ifa&mufpD;eif;I aomhrsm;±k dufcsKd;_yD;±k H;aowW mrsm;tm; csKd ;zsufar$aES mufoG m;pOf
&efukefòrd @ yef ;qd k;wef; eef;oDwmqdyfurf;rS c&D;xGufcGm&efpDpOfcJ h&m/ tm%myd kifwd k @u yef;qd k;wef;qdyfurf;wGif(1)em&DcG Jcef @ ydwfqd k @xm;+yD;rS 'vod k @ ul;Ed kifcJ honf?
'vòrd @od k @a&muf+yD;aemuf óudwifapmif haeaom tzG J @csKyfum; (2)pD;jzif h uGrf;+cHukef;òrd @od k @ c&D ;xGufcJ honf?
'v+rdK@jyify (3)rd kifcef @tuGm¶d S usefppfom;&yfuGufteD;wGif um;rsm;tm;ydwfqd k @+yD;/ &Jrª;rsdK;vGifu qufvufoGm;cGif h rjyKEd kifa=umif;ESif h &efukefod k @jyefvSnf h&efajymqd kcJ honf? OD;wifOD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @tzG J @u jyefvSnf hjcif; rjyKojzif h/ ppftm%m&Sifrsm;uarmfawmfum;(2)pD;tm; rI vrf;r}uD;ab; wGif¶d Saom v,fuGif;rsm;t=um; ajrvrf;ay:od k @ yd k @aqmifcJ honf?
OD;wifOD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @u uGrf;+cHukef;+rdK@od k @ oGm;Ed kifonftxdapmif h&eftcd kiftrm&yfwnf+yD;xd kae&mwGif wJxd k;IaecJ h=uonf? tm%myd kifrsm;utaESmif ht,SuftrsdK;rsdK;ay;cJ honf h=um;rS oEM dXmefcd kifrmpGmjzif h qufvuf&yfwnfaecJ h&mrS (9)&ufajrmufae@jzpfonf h 2000 jynf hESpf/ pufwifbmv (1)&ufae@ n (11;15)tcsdefwGif &Jrª;csKyfatmifEG,f/ &Jrª;rsdK;vGifESif h ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;tzG J @rS Ad kvfrª;ol&(c)aepd k;(=unf;-18242) /Ad kvfrª;awZwd k @ yg0if aom vltiftm;(200 rS 400)cef @¶d Sonf h vH k+cHKa&;wyfzG J @rsm;u OD;wifOD;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @tzG J @ &yfem;onf hae&mod k @ 0ifa&mufpD;eif;+yD; tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; twif;t"rR &efukefod k @jyefyd k @cJ honf?
xd kod k @ 0ifa&mufpD;eif;&mwGif vli,ftcsdK@ud k t=urf;zuf¶d kufESufcJ h+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; trsdK;orD;(6)OD;u twif;t=uyfcsKyfaESmifI ppftm%m¶Sifwd k @u ‚if ;wd k @.armfawmf,mOfjzif h wuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;aetdrfod k @ yd k @aqmifcJ honf? OD;wifOD;tm;vnf; twif;t"rRcsKyfaESmifac:aqmifcJ h+yD; aetdrfod k @a&mufonf htcgwGifum;ay:rS =urf;wrf;pGmqG JcscJ honf?
ppftm%m¶Sifwd k @u OD;wifOD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @tm; t=urf;zufIaetdrfjyefyd k @cJ h¶H kr#ru xd knwGifyif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ A[d kXmecsKyf¶H k;ud k0ifa&mufodrf;yd kufcJ honf? aemufwae@wGif tzG J @csKyf A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0ifrsm; tm;vH k;ud k tus,fcsKyfjzif h xdef;odrf;cJ honf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 22/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
22
2000 jynfhESpf/ pufwifbmv(2)&ufae@wGif Adkvfrª;}uD;oef;xGef; (=unf;§12013) OD;aqmifonf h
ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;rStrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ A[d kXmecsKyfud k 0ifa&muf pD;eif;I tcef;wHcg;aomhrsm;tm;vH k;ud k±k dufcsdK;+yD;/ bD±k d aomhrsm;/aowWmaomhrsm; ud k csdK;zsufI ¶H k;pmzd kifwG Jrsm;/ pm¶Gufpmwrf;rsm;ud k ar$aESmuf ¶SmazGumodrf;qnf;,laqmif oGm;cJ honf?
2000 jynfhESpf/ pufwif bmv(14)&ufae@ eHeuf(9) em&DtcsdefwGif tzG J @csKyf OuUX OD;atmifa¶$tm;etz twGif; a&;rª; (1)'kwd,Ad kvfcsKyf}uD;cifnGef @u zdwfac:I/ A[d ktvkyf tr_aqmiftzG J @0if vl}uD;rsm;tm;vH k;jyefvnfvGwfajrmuf+yDjzpfa=umif;ESif h/ tzG J @csKyf A[d kXmecsKyf¶H k;ud kvnf; jyefvnfzGif hvSpfEd kif+yD jzpf a=umif; ajymqd kcJ honf?
2000 jynf hESpf/ pufwifbmv (21)&ufae@wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf 'kwd, OuUX OD;wifOD;/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @/ tzG J @csKyfv_yf¶Sm;r_ r¶S dEd kif&ef ydwfyifwm;qD;r_rsm;/ tzG J @csKyf¶H k;rsm;tm; rw&m;ydwfapjcif;/ tzG J @csKyf¶H k;qd kif;bkwfrsm;tm;rw&m;jzKwfcsapjcif;rsm;ud k oGm;a&mufpH kprf;&eftwGuf
nae&xm;jzif h rE Wav;od k @oGm;&efpDpOfcJ hygonf? rE Wav;od k @oGm;&ef &efukefblwm}uD;od k @ oGm;a&mufcJ h&m/ vufrSwfukefaeonf[k r[kwfrrSefta=umif;jyI vufrSwfa&mif;ray;ojzif h/ &xm;xGufcsdeftxd apmif;qd kif;cJ h=u+yD; vufrSwfr&ojzif h aemufae@ eHeuf&xm;jzif hvd kuf&ef qufvufapmif hqd kif;aecJ honfud k twif;t"rRzrf;qD;Ivli,frsm;ud kxdef;odrf;cJ h+yD;/ vl}uD;rsm;tm; aetdrfod k @t"rRjyefyd k @cJ honf? wqufwnf; pufwifbmv (22)&ufae@rS pI A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftm;vH k; tm; aetdrfjyifyod k @ xGufcGif hrjyKbJ tus,fcsKyfcsxm;cJ honf?
azmfjyyg tm%myd kifrsm;.tjyKtrl/ tajymtqd kESif hvkyf&yfrsm;ud kaxmuf¶_jcif;tm;jzif h/ tm%myd kifrsm;taejzif h Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;ESif h Ek difiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ (txl;ojzif htrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf). vGwfvyfpGmpnf;¶H k;v_yf¶Sm;cGif htay: t+rJuef @owfydwfyif[ef @wm;aESmif h,SufcJ h+yD;/ jynfolvlxk rxd
awG @Ed kifap&ef enf;vrf;rsdK;pH ktoH k;jyKcJ honf hjyif a': atmifqef;pk=unf. touftE W&m,fxdcd kufatmif ,cifuwnf;u }uH¶G,fcJ ha=umif; txift¶Sm;awG @&onf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 23/208
23
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tcef;( 2 )
'DyJ,if;c&D;pOfrwd kifrD aemufqkH;c&D;pOfjzpfaom
ucsifjynfe,f pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOftwGif; aES mif h,SufcH&r+rsm;
2003 ckESpf/ arv(6)&ufae@rS pwifcJ haom a':atmifqef;pk=unf. ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfwavsmufwGifatmufygtwk dif; aESmif h,Sufr_rsm;uk d óuHawG @cJ h&onf? 2003 ckESpf/ arv(8)&ufae@ a&$bd kòrd @wGif òrd @e,f¶H k;qd kif;bkwfwifrnf hae&monf v,f,majrESif hrvGwfuif;[kta=umif;jyI tm%myd kifrsm;rS cGif hrjyKbJ aESmif h,SufcJ honf? a&$bd kòrd @wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pD tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; óudqd kjcif; rjyK&ef a'ocHjynfolvlxkud ktm%myd kifrsm;u wm;jrpfydwfyifxm;aomfvnf; jynfolvlxku wcJeufaxmufcHóudqd kcJ h=uonf?
xd kod k @jynfolvlxk.axmufcHr_ud k etzppftkyfpkrSjrifawG @onf htcg arv(9)&ufae@wGif aumvif;òrd @rSpwifI =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k qef @usifqENjyap&ef pDrHaqmif&GufcJ honf?
arv(9)&ufae@ nae(6)em&Dcef @wGif aumvif;òrd @&S d txufwef;ausmif;a&S @wGif=uHcd kifzG H @jzdK;a&; tzG J @0ifrsm;u
“jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u”[lonf hqd kif;bkwfrsm;axmifxm;+yD; aºuG;a=umfoHrsm;jzif hatmf[pfqENjyaESmif h,SufcJ honf? 11111
arv(10)&ufae@ tif;awmfòrd @t0if eef @oJaus;&Gmod k @ n(9)em&Dtcsdefcef @wGifa&muf&S dcJ h&m ppfud kif;wd kif;rH k&Gm c±k dif/ =uH @zG H @twGif;a&;rª; OD;aX;atmifOD;pD;onf h tiftm;(70)cef @&S d}uH @zG H @rsm;u tpdrf;a&mifydwfpay:wGifpmvH k;tjzLjzif h “jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u”[laom pmwrf;rsm;csdwfqG J+yD; qef @
2003 ckESpf arv(11)&ufaeŒ aeŒvnf(12)em&DwGif uomòrdŒ t0if*dwfod kŒ a&muf&S d&m
}uHŒzG HŒ tzG JŒ 0ifrsm;. [efŒ wm;aES mif h,Sufr+rsm;ud k óuHawGŒ &pOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 24/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
24
usifaESmif h,Sufonfud k=uHKawG @&onf?22222 a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS a'ocHjynfolvlxkESif h tm;ay;axmufcHolrsm;udkrdef @cGef;ajym=um;aepOf =uH @cd kifzGH @jzdK;a&;tzG J@0ifrsm;u teD;uyf ±k kef;&if;qefcyfjzpfatmifvkyfaqmifcJ honf htwGuf t"du&k%f;jzpfvkeD;yg; tajctaeqd k;&Gm;cJ honf? vH kxdef;rsm;u xdef;xdef;odrf;vkyf&rnf htpm; rod
usdK;u|H =unh faecJ h=uonf?33333
arv(11)&ufae@ ae@vnf(12)em&DwGif uomòrd @t0if*dwfod k @a&muf&S d&m tiftm;(150)cef @&S d =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;. [ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufr_rsm;ud k=uHKawG @&onf? 44444 uomc±k dif at;csrf;om,ma&;aumifpD OuUX 'k-Ad kvfrª;=uD;jrif hEd kifud k,fwd kifa&muf&S dvmum a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; “0ef;od kjrdK@wGif =uH @zG H @ tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; ykwfcyfajym=um;ojzif h,ckuJ hod k @jyKvkyf&jcif;jzpfa=umif;/ aemifwGifxd kuJ hod k @rajymawmhyg[k uwday;ygu ‚if;.vlrsm;ud kjyefac:oGm;rnfjzpfa=umif;” vma&mufajym=um;cJ honf? 55555 a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS “usr 0ef;od kwGifajym=um;cJ honf hpum;rsm;onf tjzpfrSefud kajymjcif;omjzpfa=umif;/ usr. ,ckc&D;pOfonf txuftm%myk difrsm;u nd ‡E_ dif;/ today;xm;jyD; jzpfa=umif;/ Ad kvfrª;=uD;wd k @zufuvlawGud k vrf;z,fay;zd k @ajymyg/ rdrdwd k @zufrS vli,frsm;ud k usr wm0ef,la=umif; jyefvnfajym=um;cJ honf”? 66666 =uH @cd kifzG H @jzdK;a&;tzG J @0ifrsm;u qufroGm;&ef ydwfyif[ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufaeonfudk wm0ef&S dol tm%mydkifrsm;u=um;0ifjzefajzaqmif&Gufay;&rnf htpm; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;jyefvSnf hoGm;&ef ajym=um;cJ honf? 77777
arv(12)&ufae@n(8)em&DcG Jcef @wGif rd k;aumif;òrd @e,f/ ref&Gufaus;&Gmt0if vrf;xdyfwGif tiftm; (100)cef @&S d =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;.aESmif h,Sufr_ud k=uHKawG @cJ h&onf? arv(13)&ufae@ zm;uef @òrd @od k @ ra&mufrD erf hrppfaus;&Gmt0ifwGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u “jynfytm;ud k;ykqdef&d k;/ tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u” pmom;yg&S donf hqd kif;bkwfi,frsm;ud kifaqmifI toHwdwf qENjyaESmif h,Sufonfud k=uHKawG @ &onf? 88888
arv(15)&ufae@ eHeuf(4)em&DcG Jcef @wGif erRwD;vrf;twd kif;xGufcGmvm&m aumif;&m &Gmta&mufwGif=uH @zG H @ tzG J @0ifrsm;u “jynfytm;ud k;ykqdef&d k;-tvd kr&S d” “tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm; tvd kr&S d” “wd k;wufr_zsufqD;ol-
tvd k r&S d” “wnf+idrfat;csrf;a&;ud kzsufqD;ol tvd kr&S d” ponf hqd kif;bkwfrsm;ud k ud kifaqmifIqENjyaESmif h,SufcJ honf? 99999
2003 ckESpf arv(12)&ufaeŒ n(8)em&DcG JcefŒ wGif rd k;aumif;òrdŒ e,f/ ref&Gufaus;&G mt0if vrf;xdyfwGif
tiftm; (100)cefŒ &S d }uHŒ zG HŒ tzG JŒ 0ifrsm;u pmwrf;rsm;ukdifaqmifI atmf[pfaESmif h,Sufae-upOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 25/208
25
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
2003 ckESpf arv(15)&ufaeŒ eHeuf(4)em&DcG JcefŒ erRwD;vrf;twd kif;xGufcG mvm&maumif;&m &G mta&muf }uHŒ zG HŒ tzG JŒ 0ifrsm;u qd kif;bkwfrsm; udkifaqmifI qENjyaES mifh,SufaepOf
arv(16)&uf eHeuf(6)em&Dcef @wGif jrpf}uD;em;+rdK@od k @qufvufxGufcGmvm&m/ eHeuf(8)em&Dcef @wGif jrpf}uD;em;+rdK@t0if eef;auG @wHwm;teD;wGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0if(300)cef @u vrf;ab;0J,mrS “jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ jynfe,fat;csrf;om,ma&;ud kaESmif h,SufzsufqD;olrsm;tm;-qef @usif=u/” “trsdK;omoem cd k;,lzsufqD;olrsm;tm;-qef @usif=u/ acsr_ef;=u”[k yd kpwmrsm;ESif ht0wfezl;pnf;rsm;ud k ud kifaqmifv#ufoGm;rnf hvrf;wGif ydwfqd k @[ef @wm; qlylaESmif h,SufcJ honf? 1010101010 qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;ESif h rvSrf;rurf;wGif t"du&k%f;ES drfeif;a&; vH kxdef;&Jwyfom;rsm;tm; 'kwf'd kif;rsm;ud kifaqmif+yD; toif hapmif hqd kif;ae=uonfud kawG @&onf? 1111111111 av;*Grsm;/ pufbD;oH k;
abmrsm;/ avmufpmvH k;rsm;/ "g;wd krsm; ud kud kifaqmifv#uf qlylaESmif h,Sufaeonfud k vH kjcHKa&;rsm;u rnfod k @r#[ef @wm;jcif; r&S dcJ hay/ 1212121212
arv(18)&uf eHeuf(9)em&Dcef @wGif 0d kif;armfòrd @od k @c&D;qufvufxGufcGmcJ h&m 0d kif;armf+rdK@t0if aemifwmav&GmewfpifteD;rS =uH @zG H @tiftm;(200)cef @u uef @uGuf&_wfcsaESmif h,SufcJ h=uonf/ 2003 ckESpf/ arv(19)&uf
0d kif;armfòrdŒ t0if aemifwmavaus;&G mewfpifteD;}uHŒ zG HŒ tiftm;(200)cefŒ uefŒ uGuf&+wfcsaES mif h,Sufae-upOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 26/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
26
eHeuf(9)em&Dcef @wGif Aef;armfòrd @od k @ c&D;qufvufxGufcGmvm&m/ nae(5)em&DcG Jtcsdef w&kwfEd kifiHESif h uyfv#uf&S donf h rd k;armuf+rdK@e,f/ v,f*sm;,rf&Gmod k @a&muf&S donf? etz ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(8)rS Ad kvfrª;wifatmif=unfESif h axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(21)rS Ad kvfrª;rif;vGifOD; wd k @u wm;jrpfcJ hojzif h vd kifZmaus;&Gmod k @ c&D; rqufjzpfawmhbJ Aef;armf+rdK@od k @ jyefvnfxGufcGmcJ h&onf?
2003 ckESpf/ arv (20)&ufAef;armf+rdK@t0ifoH k;rd kif&Gmod k @ eHeuf(3)em&DwGifa&muf&S dcJ honf/ xd kaus;&GmwGifwkwf/ "g;rsm;ud kifaqmifxm;ol =uH @cd kifzG H @+zdK;a&;tzG J @0if(300)ausmfcef @u vd kifpifeHygwfjym; rygaomum;rsm;ESif hqd kifu,frsm;ud ktoH k;jyK+yD;/ Oya'ud kajAmifususcsdK;azmufI uef @uGufqENjy aESmif h,SufcJ honf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfud kifaqmifonf h AG D'D,d kuifr&mud kyif vk,l&efóud;pm;cJ honf? Aef;armfòrd @&S d pnfyifom,maps;ud kvnf; vltrsm; tjym; rpka0Ed kifap&ef tm%myd kifrsm;uydwfxm;cJ honf? 1313131313 tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud k =uH @cd kifzG H @+zdK;a&;u wkwf/ "g;rsm;ud kifaqmif+yD; vufeufud kift=urf; zuf[ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufonfud k tm%myd kifrsm;u rnfod k @r# wm;qD;[ef @wm;jcif;rjyKay? 1414141414
2003 ckESpf/ arv (21)&ufeHeuf(8)em&DomomwGif a&$ulòrd @rS jyefvnfxGufcGmcJ h&m rd k;rdwf+rdK@od k @ n(8)em&DcG JwGif a&muf&S donf/ rd k;rdwfòrd @rS rbdrf;òrd @od k @toGm;wGif a'ocHtm%myd kifrsm;jzpfonf h rbdrf;òrd @e,f &JwyfzG J @/pcef;rª; &Jtkyf0if;aX;ESif h v0uOD;pD;rª; OD;pd kif;jrif hodef;wd k @u rbdrf;zufod k @ul;rnf h a&$vDjrpfurf;ab;&S djrpfqH k aus;&Gmul;wd k @qdyfurf;rS pufavSyd kif&Sifrsm;tm; tif*sifpufrsm;jzKwfxm;&ef/ &,u OuUXrSwqif h trdef @ay;xm;cJ honf? 1515151515 xd k @a=umif h rbdrf;òrd @od k @ c&D;qufxGufEd kifjcif;r&S dcJ hay? 1616161616
2003 ckESpf/ arv(22)&ufae@ nae(4)em&DcG Jcef @wGif rd k;ukwfòrd @od k @ pwif0ifa&mufonf? 2003 ckESpf/ arv(25)&uf rd k;ukwfòrd @rS =uyfjyif+rdK@rod k @0ifa&muf+yD; qufvufxGufcGmcJ h&m uoJtkyfpk/ bd kukef;&yfta&mufwGif
rEWav;wk dif;±k H;a&SŒ rS apmifhqk dif;óudqk dae-uonf h jynfolvlxk}uD;tm;
a':atmifqef;pk-unf rdefŒ cGef;ajym-um;aepOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 27/208
27
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tiftm;(400)ausmfcef@&S d =uH@zG H@rsm;.uef @uGufqENjyaESmifh,Sufjcif;ud kcHcJh&onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tm;uef @uGufqENjy&ef =uHzG H @tzG J @. twGif;a&;rª;rsm;uvlpkaqmif;&mwGif wtdrfwa,muf rvmrae&/ tu,fI rvma&mufygu vufyHvS um;vrf;azgufvkyfa&;wGif vkyftm;
ay;rsm;tjzpf apcd kif;cH&rnfjzpfa=umif;ajymqd kI t"rRvlpkaqmif;cJ honfud kawG @&onf?1717171717
xd kod k @ t"rRqif hac: jcif; cHxm;&olrsm;xJwGif jrefrmpm rzwfwwfonf h wd kif;&if;om;rsm;vnf;yg&S dcJ honf? =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u xd kolrsm;ud k a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;óudqd k&efa&;om;xm;aom pmom;rsm;ygonf h qd kif;bkwfrsm;jzpfa=umif; ajym=um;cJ honf? tcsdK@rSm qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud k txufatmufajymif;jyefud kifaqmifxm;onfud kvnf;awG @&S d&onf?1818181818 a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;u tjzpfrSefud kajym=um;onf htcg ud kifaqmifxm;onf hqd kif;bkwfrsm;ud k ta0;od k @v$if hypfI a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;axmufcHa=umif;jyocJ honf? 1919191919
nae(3)em&Dausmfcef @wGif oydwfusif;+rdK@e,f/ (7)rd kif&Gmxdyfta&mufwGif trsdK;om;ESif htrsdK;orD;rsm; tygt0if tiftm;(1000)ausmfcef @&S d}uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;.aESmif h,Sufjcif;ud k xyfrHcHcJ h&jyef onf// 2020202020 =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;pD;eif;vmaomum;rsm;ESif h ‚if;wd k @ud kapmif ha&Smufvd kufygvmaom ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;pD;eif;vmonf hum;wef;rsm;tm; enf;rsdK;pH kjzif haESmif h,Sufjcif;ud k }uHKawG @& onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu qef @usifqENjyolrsm;ESif h a'ocH&Gmom;rsm;ud k (15)rdepfcef @ E_wfcGef;qufrdef @cGef;a[majymygonf? xd kod k @a[majymaepOftwGif; =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u enf;rsdK;pH kjzif h [ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufjcif;ud kjyKrlvkyfaqmifcJ h=uonf? =uH @zG H @rsm;u qef @usifqENjy&efac:aqmifvmolrsm;onf a':atmifqef;pk=unf. rdef @cGef;ud k em;axmif+yD;aemuf ‚if;wd k @ud kifaqmif vmonf hqd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kypfcs+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; axmuf
a':atmifqef;pk-unfrdefŒ cGef;uk d em;axmifae-uaom rEWav;wk dif;±k H;a&SŒrS jynfolvlxk}uD;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 28/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
28
cHóudqd kr_rsm;jyKvkyfcJ h=uonf? 2121212121 w&Gmvsif tenf;qH k;(4)OD;rS(20)OD;txd &,urS rvmrae& twif;t"rRqif hac:ojzif h vma&muf&a=umif; a'ocHaus;&Gmol&Gmom;rsm;ujyefvnfajymjyygonf? }udKqd kolrsm;ud kyifa':atmifqef;pk}unftm;}udKqd kv#if axmif(7)ESpfcsrnf[k &yfuGufat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @òzd;a&;aumifpDrsm;u w&m;vGef +cdrf;ajcmufxm;}uonf// vl(200)cef @ud k t&ufwd kufIvnf;aumif;/ aiGay;Ivnf;aumif;ac:,lcJ h=uonf[k}um;od&onf// 2222222222
arv(25)&uf nae(7;00)em&Dcef @wGif/ pOf hul;òrd @e,f/ pOf hul;òrd @teD; usnfawmufaygufaus;&GmESif h EG,f&H kaus;&Gmta&mufwGif qD'ifum;(11)pD;/ 'd kifem(4)pD;/ [d kif;vyf'f(15)pD;wGifpD;eif;vd kufygolrsm;ESif h a'ocH}uH @cd kifzG H @jzdK;a&; pkpkaygif;tiftm;(500)ausmfcef @&S d =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;. aESmif h,Sufjcif;ud k xyfrH}uHKawG @cJ h&onf/ 4if;wd k @ud ktr&yl&/ rwW&m/ ausmufqnf/ rE Wav;wd k @rSac:vmonf[k }um;od&onf// xd k @tjyif EG,f&H kaus;&Gm (a&$wGif;)rStvkyform;rsm;(usif;om;)ud k w&ufvd kufygqENjyv#if xrif;auí;/ t&uft0wdkufonfhtjyif ae@wGufvkyftm;ctjzpf (500)rS(1000)xday;Iac:aqmifcJ ha=umif;od&S d&onf? 2323232323 tcsdK@aom&Gmom;rsm;ud k “wtdrfwa,muf rvd kufrae&/ rvd kufygu vufyefvS um;vrf;azgufae&mwGifvkyftm;ay;(2)&ufcd kif;cH&rnf”[kjcdrf;ajcmufac:vma=umif;=um;od&onf// ‚if;wd k @onf 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;um“ukvm;r,m; tvk dr&d S/ jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k; tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm;-tvd kr&d S”[kaºuG;a=umfatmf[pfum ±d kufykwf&efpjcif;ud k =uHK awG @&ygonf? tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;.,mOfwef;rsm;twGif;od k @ ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;.tultnDjzif h tqd kygaESmif h,Sufonf hvlrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm;u twif;armif;ESif0ifa&mufaESmif h,Suf=uygonf? usnfawmuf
ayguf&Gm ta&muf/ toHcsJ @pufrsm;wyfqifxm;onf h armfawmf,mOftrSwf 2c§4363/ 5u§1899/ 2u§3726'd kifemum;rsm;ESif h/ 7u§6643/ b§7358 [d kif;vyf'fum;rsm;onf/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; }udKqd konf h
rk d;ukwfc&D;pOfrS rEWav;òrdŒ okdŒ a&muf&S dvmaom a':atmifqef;pk-unfESif htzJ GŒ tm;
vrf;wav#muf vk dufygtumtuG,fay;cJ h-uonf h oHCmawmfrsm;ESif h óudqkdae-uaom
rEWav;òrdŒ rSjynfolvlxk}uD;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 29/208
29
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vlxkrsm;t=um;ok d @ “z,f&if z,f/ rz,f&if ud k,f htavmif;ud k,faumuf”“z,f&if z,f/ rz,f&if ud k,f htavmif;udk,faumuf”“z,f&if z,f/ rz,f&if ud k,f htavmif;ud k,faumuf”“z,f&if z,f/ rz,f&if ud k,f htavmif;udk,faumuf”“z,f&if z,f/ rz,f&if ud k,f htavmif;ud k,faumuf”qd k+yD;/ w&=urf; xd k;0ifarmif;ESif=uonf// vlxkrSm vrf;ab;ajr}uD;ay:rSomae+yD;}udKqd k=uaomfvnf;/ um;rwd kufrdap&ef xGufajy;=u&onf//tqd kygvl&rf;um;rsm;rSm oHjym;rsm;ud kwD;+yD;/ wkwf/ "g;vufeufrsm;/ av;*Grsm; ud kifaqmifxm;}uonf// 2424242424
tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;pD;eif;vmonf hum;rsm;ESif h,SOfrd+yDqd kygu ud kifaqmifxm;onf h'kwfrsm;ESif h xd k;rwwf/
&d kufrwwfjyKvkyf=uonf htjyif &kef @&if;=urf;wrf;onf hpum;rsm;jzif h ajymqd k&efpjcif;ud kvnf; =uHKawG @cJ h&ygonf?a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;ykwfcwfI “ukvm;ud k tm;uk d;csifovm;”pojzif h &efvd konf h pum;rsm;ajymqd konfudk xd kae&mwGif(3)em&Dausmfr#cHchJ&onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud kvnf; cJrsm;jzif hxk=uonf//rE Wav;rSvd kufvmaom vli,ftzG J @rS armifxGef;xGef;0if;rSm cJrSefIacgif;aygufoGm;cJ honf// 2525252525
usnfawmufaygufaus;&GmwGif=uHKawG @&onf htjzpftysufESif hywfoufI a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rH k&GmjrdK@od k @a&mufonf htcg jynfolvlxktm;ajym=um;onf hrdef @cGef;wGif ² ² ²
“=uH hcd kifzG H @òzd k;a&;tzG J @u w&m;Oya'eJ @rnDwJ hudpPawGud kvkyfaeygw,fqd kayr,f hvnf; tm%myd kif awGu
ta&;r,lbl;? ta&;r,lawmh tm%myd kifawGuolwd k @vufrSm&d Sw,fqd kwJ hoabmxm;eJ @ usrwd k @uvnf; bmrSrwkef @jyefbl;qd kwmud kodaeawmh/ 'D=uH hcd kifzG H @òzd;a&;tzG J @uvnf; wpxufwp yd k+yD;awmhqd k;vmw,f? usrwd k @'D rwW&mud k/ pOf hul;ud kvmwJ htcgrSm usnfaxmufayguf&GmrSmusawmh wkwfawG/ "m;awG/ avmufav;*GawGeJ @ usrwd k @&J @tzG J @awGud k usrwd k @ud k axmufcHwJ holawGud k&rf;um;vmwJ htxdjzpfvmw,f” [kxkwfazmfajym=um;cJ honf?
2003 ckESpf/ arv (26)&uf rwW&m+rdK@e,fod k @a&muf&S donf/ nae(5)em&Dcef @ ykodrf}uD;+rdK@e,f/ ykodrfav;&Gmod k @ ta&mufwGif tiftm; (600)ausmf&S daESmif h,Sufolrsm;ESif hxyfrH=uHKawG @&+yD; nae(6;15) em&Dcef @wGifrE Wav;wd kif; pnf;&H k;a&;tzG J @&H k;od k @jyefvnfa&muf&S dcJ honf? xd kae@n (7)em&DcG J(8)em&Dcef @wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.rdef @cGef;ud kem;axmif&ef trSwf(78-79)vrf;}um;wGiftoif hapmif hqd kif;ae=uonf h jynfolvlxktwGif;od k @ ,mOfxdef;&J.tultnDjzif h ,mOftrSwf 5u-8175'd kifem,mOf(1)pD; twif;t"rR 0ifa&mufwd kuf&efóud;pm;&mrS jynfolvlxku cJjzif hjyefvnfypfaygufojzif h xd kum;.a&S @avumrSef uG JcJ h&onf? 2626262626
a':atmifqef;pk-unf rdefŒ cGef;ajymaepOf rEWav; wk dif;±k H;a&SŒ &S d jynfolvlxktwGif;
,mOfxdef;&J tultnDjzif h twif;t"rR 0ifwd kuf&efóud;pm;&mrS
jynfolvlxku cJjzifhjyefvnfypfaygufojzif h a&SŒ avumrSefuJ GcJ h&aom 5u = 8175 'd kifem,mOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 30/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
30
ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOfwav#mufaES mifh,SufcH&r+rsm;tay:
aumfr&Sif.awGŒ&S dcsufrsm;
a':atmifqef;pk=unf.ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&Hk;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif; aESmifh,SufcH&r_rsm;ESifh ywfoufIaumfr&Sifuatmufygtwd kif;awG @&S dcJ honf?
jynfaxmifpk}uHŒcd kifzGHŒ jzdK;a&;toif;}uD;. yg0ifywfoufr+
ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOftwGif;/ aumvif;+rdK@e,frSpwifI a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;uOD;aqmifI aESmif h,SufcJ hjcif;jzpfonf? xd k @a=umif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. xkwfjyefausnmcsufrsm;ESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. ajyma&;qk dcGif h&S dol OD;vGif.jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif h awG @qH kar;jref;onf htpDtpOfrsm;wGif =uHzG H @toif;u OD;aqmifyg0ifywfoufr_rsm; &S da=umif;ud k twdtvif; tpOfwpd kufxkwfazmfajym=um;cJ hjcif;jzpfonf f?
jynfaxmifpk=uH @cd kifzG H @jzdK;a&;toif;}uD;taejzif h xd kod k @aESmif h,Sufr_rsm;wGif ‚if;wd k @ ryg0ifa=umif; twdtvif;jiif;qd kxm;jcif;/ wpH kw&mjyefvnfajz&Sif;xm;jcif; r&S dyg/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; qef @usifonf hvkyfief;rsm;ud k
twm;tqD;r&S d vkyfaqmifEd kifap&ef =uH @zG @HtzG J @0ifrsm;tm;tm%myd kifrsm;u wzufwvrf;rStm;ay;ulnDr_rsm;jyKvkyfcJ honf[k a':atmifqef;pk=unfuajym=um;jcif;ud kvnf; etz tm%myd kifrsm;taejzif h jyefvnf&Sif;vif;jcif; rjyKcJ hyg?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 31/208
31
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
qefŒusifqENjy aESmifh,Sufolrsm;. taetxm;
a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud k uef @uGufqENjyolrsm;onf ezl;pnf;
pmwrf;rsm;ud k òrd @t0ifae&mrsm;/ ausmif;rsm;.a&S @wGif ajymifajymifwif;wif;csdwfqG JI qENjyqef @usifjcif;jzpf&mxd kod k @ csdwfqG JqENjyEd kif&efoufqd kif&mtm%myd kifrsm;.cGif hjyKcsuf&,l+yD;rSom vkyfaqmifEd kifrnf hudpP&yfjzpfygonf?tm%myd kifrsm;.oabmwlnDr_jzif haqmif&Gufonf htwGuf ‚if;wd k @taejzif hqef @usifqENjy&mwGif ta=umuftvef @r&S dbJ &Jwif;pGmjzif h ud k,fxdvufa&muf usL;vGefqef @usifqENjyvmjcif;jzpfonfud kvnf; txift&Sm;awG@&S dEd kifygonf? xd kod k @qef@usifqENjy&mwGif tm%myd kifrsm;udk,fwd kifu tm;ay;ulnD}uD;=uyfcJ ha=umif;ud katmufygtcsufrsm;t& awG @&d S&onf?
(u) a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud k qef@usifqENjyrnf holrsm;tm;armfawmf,mOfrsm;jzif hyd k @aqmif&mwGif ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;/ jynfol @&JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;u apmif ha&Smufvd kufygjcif;/
(c) qef @usifqENjyaepOftwGif; &kef;&if;qefcwfr_rsm; jzpfyGm;onftxdjzpfaeaomfvnf; [ef @wm;ajymqd kr_ rjyKjcif;/(*) a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; qef @usifqENjyonf hae&mrsm;
ud ka&G;cs,f&mwGif òrd @tjyif vloluif;a0;onf hae&mrsm;jzpfaejcif;/ xd kae&mrsm;od k @ qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;ud kum;rsm;jzif h yd k @aqmifay;jcif;/
(C) ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOfwGif etzESif h+idrf;csrf;a&;&,lxm;onf h ucsifvufeufud kiftzG J @tpnf;ESif h awG @qH k&ef oGm;a&mufpOf etz ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(8)rS Ad kvfrª;wifatmif=unfESif h axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(21)rSAd kvfrª; rif;vGifOD;wd k @u wm;jrpfcJ hjcif;/
(i) jynfaxmifpk=uH @cd kifa&;ESif hzG@HjzdK;a&;toif;}uD;ESif h r,u/ &,ursm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;
óudqd kjcif; rjyK&efESif h }udKqd kyguaxmif'%fcsrSwfjcif;cH&rnfjzpfa=umif; jynfolvlxktm;jcdrf;ajcmuf ajymqd kcJ hjcif;/(p) a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud kqef @usifqENjy&ef a'ocHjynfol
vlxktm; =uH @zG H @twGif;a&;rª;rsm;/ &yfuGufat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif hzG @HòzdK;a&;aumifpDOuUXrsm;u wtdrfwa,mufrvmrae& twif;t"rRqif hac:I vlpkaqmif;cJ hjcif;?
(q) a':atmifqef;pk=unf.ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOftwGif; tcsdK@aomòrdK@rsm;wGif nOf @eufonftxd qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;u toif hapmif hqd kif;ae=ujcif;/
Oyrmtm;jzif h-
1? arv(10)&ufae@tif;awmfòrd @t0if&S d eef @oJaus;&Gmod k @ n(9)em&Dn(9)em&Dn(9)em&Dn(9)em&Dn(9)em&Dcef @wGifa&muf&S d&m =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u qENjy&efapmif hqd kif;ae=uonf?
2? arv(12)&ufae@n(8)em&DcGJcefn(8)em&DcG Jcefn(8)em&DcGJcefn(8)em&DcG Jcefn(8)em&DcG Jcef @wGif rd k;umif;òrd @e,f/ ref&Gufaus;&Gm/ &Gmt0ifvrf;xdyfwGif tiftm;(100)cef @&S d=uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;. aESmih f,Sufr_ud k=uHKawG @cJ h&onf?
3? arv(15)&ufae@eHeuf(4)em&DcG Jcef@eHeuf(4)em&DcG Jcef @eHeuf(4)em&DcG Jcef@eHeuf(4)em&DcG Jcef @eHeuf(4)em&DcG Jcef @wGif erRwD;vrf;twd kif;xGufcGmvm&m aumif;&m&Gm ta&mufwGif=uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;.aESmif h,Sufr_ud k=uHKawG @&onf?
4? arv(16)&uf eHeuf(6)em&Dcef@eHeuf(6)em&Dcef @eHeuf(6)em&Dcef@eHeuf(6)em&Dcef @eHeuf(6)em&Dcef @wGif jrpf}uD;em;òrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmvm&m/ eHeuf (8)em&Dcef @wGifjrpf}uD;em;òrd @t0if eef;auG @wHwm;teD;wGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0if(300). qef @usifqENjy aESmif h,Sufr_ud k&ifqd kif&onf?
5? arv(20)&ufAef;armfòrd @t0if oH k;rd kif&Gmod k @ eHeuf(3)em&DeHeuf(3)em&DeHeuf(3)em&DeHeuf(3)em&DeHeuf(3)em&DwGifa&muf&S dcJ honf xd kaus;&GmwGif wkwf/ "g;rsm;ud kifaqmifxm;ol =uH @cd kifzG H @+zdK;a&;tzG J @0if(300)ausmfcef hu vk difpifrJ hum;rsm;/ qd kifu,frsm;ud karmif;ESifI Oya'ud kajAmifususcsdK;azmufI uef @uGufqENjyaESmif h,SufcJ honf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 32/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
32
6? arv(25)&uf n (7;00) em&Dcefn (7;00) em&Dcefn (7;00) em&Dcefn (7;00) em&Dcefn (7;00) em&Dcef @wGif/ pOf hul;òrd @e,f/ pOf hul;òrd @teD; usnfawmufaygufaus;&GmESif hEG,f&H kaus;&Gmta&mufwGif qD'ifum;(11)pD;/ 'd kifem(4)pD;/ [d kif;vyf'f(15)pD;wGif pD;eif;vd kufygolrsm;ESif h a'ocH}uH @cd kifzG H @òzd;a&;pkpkaygif;tiftm; (500)ausmfcef @&S d=uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm; .aESmif h,Sufjcif;ud k xyfrH&ifqd kif}uHKawG @cJ h&
onf?a':atmifqef;pk=unf.ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfwavsmufwGif a&$bd kòrd @e,frSty usef òrd @e,frsm;wGifqef @usifqENjyaESmif h,Sufr_rsm;jzif h&ifqd kif=uHKawG @cJ h&onf? xl;jcm;onf htcsuftaejzif h tcsdK@òrd @e,frsm;wGifnOf @eufae+yDjzpfaomfvnf; qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;u òrd @t0ifaus;&Gmrsm;wGif apmif hqd kif;aeonf hudpPrsm;rSm oabm&d k;jzif hapmif hqd kif;aejcif; r[kwfa=umif;ud k aumfr&Siftaejzif hoH k;oyfawG @&S d&onf?
(Z) a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;qef@usifqENjyrnfholrsm; pD;eif;vdkufygvmonfhum;rsm;udkapmifh=uyfvd kufygvmonf h ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;u pepfwusarmif;ESifaeonf h a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;rsm; taetxm;ysufoGm;ap&efaESmif h,Suf&mwGif 0d kif;0ef;yH @yd k;ulnDay;cJ honf? 2727272727
a':atmifqef;pk=unf. ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&Hk;a&;c&D;pOftwGif; etzppftkyfpk. tm%mydkifrsm;ua':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud k =uHzG H @toif;0ifrsm;u qENjy[ef @wm;aESmif h,SufEd kif&ef ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;/ jynfol @&JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;/ t"du&k%f;ES drfeif;onf hvH kxdef;wyfrsm;ESif h ppfwyft&m&S d}uD;rsm;ud k,fwd kif pDpOfnGef=um;vkyfaqmifcJ honfud k txufaz: jyyg tcsuftvufrsm;t& xif&Sm;pGmawG @&S d& onf?
( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )
1? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm ZGefv(1)&ufae@ pm-92? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm ZGefv(1)&ufae@ pm-9/ESif h ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?3? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpf/ arv(27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)4? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/armif&ifr_ dif;aqmif;yg;?5? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/armif&ifr_ dif;aqmif;yg;?
6? tzG J @csKyftzG J @0if/ teD;uyfvH kjcHKa&;wm0ef,lcJ hol ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?7? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpfarv(27)&ufae@/&ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)8? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/armif&ifr_ dif;aqmif;yg;ESif h ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?9? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/armif&ifr_ dif;aqmif;yg;?10? jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/armif&ifr_ dif;aqmif;yg;/11? ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?12? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpf/ arv(27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)13? ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?14? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpf/ arv(27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)
15? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpf/ arv(27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)16? ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 33/208
33
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
17? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpf/ arv(27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)18? a':nGef @nGef @. oufaoxGufqd kcsuf19? a':nGef @nGef @.xGufqd kcsufESif h jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif hjynfwGif;rS tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifwOD;tm;awG @qH k
ar;jref;jcif;?20? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. 2003 ckESpf/ arv(27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyga=unmcsuftrSwf-6(5§03)?21? a':nGef @nGef @wd k @. oufaoxGufcsuf?22? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf . 2003 ckESpf/ arv (27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyg a=unmcsuftrSwf 6 (5§03)?
23? jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifwOD;ESif h awG @qH kar;jref;csufrsm;?
24? jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifwOD;ESif hawG @qH kar;jref;csufrsm;?25? a':nGef @nGef @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf . 2003 ckESpf/ arv (27)&ufae@
&ufpG Jyg a=unmcsuftrSwf 6 (5§03)?26? a':nGef @nGef @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufESif h jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/ ZGefv(1)&ufae@27? a':nGef @nGef @ESif h ud krif;odef;wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 34/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
34
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 35/208
35
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tcef;( 3 )
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHowfjzwfr+jzpfpOf
2000 ckESpf/ arv (6)&ufae@wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfonf aetdrftus,fcsKyfcsxm;cH&jcif;rS jyefvnfvGwfajrmufvm+yD;aemuf (11) &ufae@ ZGefv 2002 rS pwifI 13-4 -2003 txd jrefrmEd kifiHw0Srf; wk dif;ESif hjynfe,f (12)ck&S d òrd @e,faygif; (235)òrd @e,fod k @ c&D;vSnf hvnfcJ honf?
2003 ckESpf/ arv (6) &ufae@rSpwifI rEWav;wd kif;/ ppfud kif;wd kif;/ ucsifjynfe,f/ &Srf;jynfe,frsm;od k @vSnf hvnfI tzG J @csKyf&H k;rsm; jyefvnfzGif hvSpfay;jcif;/ qd kif;bkwfwifjcif;wk d @ jyKvkyfcJ honf? arv (29)&ufae@wGifrE Wav;/ rH k&Gmc&D;pOfud k pwifcJ hygonf? xd kuJ hod k @ txufjrefrmjynfc&D;pOfud koGm;vm&eftwGuf Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif hzG @Hòzd;a&;aumifpD/ òrd @e,f a&G;aumufyG Jaumfr&Sifwd k @ESif h óudwif oabmwlcGif hjyKcsufrsm; &,l+yD;rS txufygc&D;pOfrsm;ud k pwifcJ hjcif;jzpfygonf?
rE Wav;òrd @rS arv(29)&ufae@ eHeufyd kif;wGif tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm; . armfawmf,mOf(7)pD;ESif h rE Wav;òrd @aejynfolvlxkrsm;u vd kufvHyd k @aqmifonf h armfawmf,mOfrsm;/ armfawmfqd kifu,ftpD; (20)ausmfESif h jynfolvl
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 36/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
36
xktygt0if tiftm;(100)ausmfjzif h (38)vrf;taemufbufwnf hwnf h(84)vrf; awmifbufrS pwifI ppfud kif;od k @ OD;wnfxGufcGmcJ hygonf? a&S @ajy;vH kjcHKa&;tjzpf ud kEd kifEd kif/ ud katmifatmifESif h tzG J @csKyf/ rE Wav;wd kif; tzG J @0ifuk drsKd;rif;wd k @u um;wpD ;jzif h óudwifxGufcGm+yD; ,if;um;.aemufrS a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @0ifrsm;. um;
rsm; vk dufygvmcJ hygonf? ppfud kif;wHwm;ud k eHeuf (10)em&Dcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ h&m/ ppfud kif;wHwm;tvGef ppfud kif;òrd @t0if vrf;ab;0J/,mwGif =uH @cd kifzG @Hòzda&;tzG J @0ifrsm;/ tiftm;(200)cef @u “=uH @cd kifzG @HjzdK;a&;tm; raxmufcHolrsm; tvd kr&S d” [lonf h qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;+yD; E_wfrSvnf; xd kpmom; rsm;twd kif; aºuG;a=umfqENjyatmf[pfaeonfud k pwif=uHKawG @&onf? xd kolrsm;ud kausmfvGefvmonf htcg ppfud kif;òrd @&S d jynfolvlxktiftm;2000 ausmfwd k @u “a':atmifqef;pk=unf usef;rmygap”/ “bbOD;wifOD; usef;rmygap/” [k qkrGefaumif;rsm;awmif;I jynfolvlxk.qENud k xkwfazmfjyo+yD; v_ dufvS JpGm=udKqd kcJ h=uonf? 11111
ppfud kif;òrd @rS jrif;rlòrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmvm&m jrif;rlòrd @od k @ ae@vnf (12) em&Dcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ hygonf?xdkod k @ oGm;vmonf hc&D;wavsmufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.,mOfwef;aemufrS ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;/ ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;vd kufygI "gwfyH k&d kufjcif;/ AG D'D,d kuifr&mjzif h rSwfwrf;wifjcif; ponfwd k @ud k jyKvkyf=uygonf? 22222 jrif;rlòrd @od k @a&muf&S donf htcg tzG J @cskKyf jrif;rlòrd @e,f&H k; qd kif;bkwfwif+yD;/ vli,ftzG J @ zG J @pnf;a&;wd k @ud ktxufjrefrmEd kifiHvli,fzG J@pnf;a&;wm0efcH/ v,fa0;òrd @e,f trSwf(1)rJqENe,frS vGwfawmfud k,fpm;vS,fud kwifxGÉfOD;u OD;aqmifI jrif;rlòrd @e,f vli,ftzG J @ud k zJ G @pnf;ay;cJ hygonf?xd ktcsdefwGif jrif;rlòrd @e,f/ tzG J @csKyf&H k;.tjyifzufwGif um;(5)pD;ud kawG @&S d&+yD; xk dum;rsm;ay:wGif &JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;/ t&HrD;owf wyfzG J @0ifrsm;/ jynfol @pGrf;tm;&SiftzG J @0ifrsm;/ òrd @e,f at;csrf;om,ma&;ESih f zH G @+zdK;a&;aumifpDtzG J @0ifrsm;/ =uh HzG H @ toif;0ifrsm; ponfwk d @uk dawG @&onf? um;wpD;ay:wGif jynfol @pGrf;tm;&Sif [laom pmvk H;ud k ydwfp tjzLay:wGif tpdrf;a&mifjzif h a&;om;xm;onf? jrif;rlòrd @rS jyefvnfxGufcGmonf htcg a':atmifqef;pk=unf. ,mOfwef;rsm; aemufrS txufaz: jyygum;(5)pD;onf a&yd k;pm;aus;&Gmtxd vd kufygcJ honfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? 33333
jrif;rlòrd @rS rH k&Gmòrd @od k @ nae (3) em&DausmfwGif pwifxGufcGmcJ h&m jrif;rlòrd @ESif hacsmif;OD;od k @ ra&mufrD a&yd k;pm;aus;&GmteD;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;tm; wd kufcd kufaESmif h,Suf&ef pDrHxm;r_rsm;ud k a&S @ajy;vH kòcHa&;tjzpf wm0ef,lxm;onf h ud katmifatmifESif h ud kEd kifEd kifwd k @u pwifjrifawG @cJ honf? qef @usifqENjy&ef apmif hqd kif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 37/208
37
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
aeolrsm;onf æ “jynfytm;udk; ykqdef&dk;/ tqd k;jrif 0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u”/ “jynfwGif;jynfy tzsuform;rsm;tm;“jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqdk;jrif 0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u”/ “jynfwGif;jynfy tzsuform;rsm;tm;“jynfytm;udk; ykqdef&dk;/ tqd k;jrif 0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u”/ “jynfwGif;jynfy tzsuform;rsm;tm;“jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqdk;jrif 0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u”/ “jynfwGif;jynfy tzsuform;rsm;tm;“jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqd k;jrif 0g'Drsm;tm; qef@usif=u”/ “jynfwGif;jynfy tzsuform;rsm;tm;
bH k&efoltjzpf owfrSwfacsr_ef;=u”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHud k Ed kifiHwumrS tultnDay;jcif;ud k ydwfyifaeoltm; tvd kbH k&efoltjzpf owfrSwfacsr_ef;=u”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHud k Ed kifiHwumrS tultnDay;jcif;ud k ydwfyifaeoltm; tvd kbH k&efoltjzpf owfrSwfacsr_ef;=u”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHud k Ed kifiHwumrS tultnDay;jcif;ud k ydwfyifaeoltm; tvd kbH k&efoltjzpf owfrSwfacsr_ef;=u”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHud k Ed kifiHwumrS tultnDay;jcif;ud k ydwfyifaeoltm; tvd kbH k&efoltjzpf owfrSwfacsr_ef;=u”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHud k Ed kifiHwumrS tultnDay;jcif;ud k ydwfyifaeoltm; tvd k
r&S d”/ “wnf+idrfat;csrf;r_ud k vdkvm;onf”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHod k @ urB mvSnf h c&D;oGm;rsm;rvmatmif ydwfyifaer&S d”/ “wnf+idrfat;csrf;r_ud k vd kvm;onf”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHodk @ urB mvSnf h c&D;oGm;rsm;rvmatmif ydwfyifaer&S d”/ “wnf+idrfat;csrf;r_ud k vdkvm;onf”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHod k @ urB mvSnf h c&D;oGm;rsm;rvmatmif ydwfyifaer&S d”/ “wnf+idrfat;csrf;r_ud k vd kvm;onf”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHodk @ urB mvSnf h c&D;oGm;rsm;rvmatmif ydwfyifaer&Sd”/ “wnf+idrfat;csrf;r_ud k vd kvm;onf”/ “jrefrmEdkifiHod k@ urBmvSnfh c&D;oGm;rsm;rvmatmif ydwfyifaeolrsm;tm; tvd k r&S d”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHtm; &if;ES D;jr‡KyfES Hr_rsm; rvmatmif ydwfyifaeolrsm;tm; tvd k r&Sd”/olrsm;tm; tvd k r&Sd”/ “jrefrmEdkifiHtm; &if;ESD;jr‡KyfES Hr_rsm; rvmatmif ydwfyifaeolrsm;tm; tvd k r&S d”/olrsm;tm; tvd k r&S d”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHtm; &if;ES D;jr‡KyfES Hr_rsm; rvmatmif ydwfyifaeolrsm;tm; tvd k r&Sd”/olrsm;tm; tvd k r&Sd”/ “jrefrmEdkifiHtm; &if;ESD;jr‡KyfES Hr_rsm; rvmatmif ydwfyifaeolrsm;tm; tvd k r&S d”/olrsm;tm; tvd k r&S d”/ “jrefrmEd kifiHtm; &if;ES D;jr‡KyfESHr_rsm; rvmatmif ydwfyifaeolrsm;tm; tvdk r&S d”/“vdk&moH k; 'Drd kua&pD tvd k r&Sd”“vd k&moH k; 'Drdkua&pD tvd k r&S d”“vdk&moH k; 'Drd kua&pD tvd k r&Sd”“vd k&moH k; 'Drdkua&pD tvd k r&S d”“vd k&moH k; 'Drd kua&pD tvd k r&S d” ponf h pmom;rsm; yg0ifonf h qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud k ud kifaqmifIvnf;aumif;/a=uG;a=umfoHrsm;jzif h atmf[pfIvnf;aumif; qef @usif qENjycJ h=uonf? 44444 xd kod k @qef @usif qENjy=uonf h olrsm;onfjrif;rlESif h rH k&Gmvrf;c&D;wavsmuf vrf;r}uD;ay:wGifwnf&S daeonf h aus;&Gmrsm;rS aus;&Gmol/ aus;&Gmom;rsm; r[kwf=uay// tb,fa=umif hqd kaomf xd k a&yd k;pm;aus;&GmESif h teD;w0d kufwGif vrf;r}uD;ud k ar;wifvsufwnf&S daeonf h aus;&Gmrsm; r&S day? xd kae&mwGif qef @usifqENjyrnf h trsdK;orD;rsm;/ trsdK;om;rsm;ESif h ‚if;wd k @ud kifaqmifxm;onf h qd kif;bkwfrsm;/ xd kolrsm;ud kwifaqmifvmonf h hum;rsm;ud kawG @&S d &ygonf? xd kum;rsm;ud kapmif h=uyfvd kufygvmonf h ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;/ &J0efxrf;rsm;/ ppfwyfrS Ad kvfr_;=uD;tqif h&S dolrsm;/ vH kxdef; (t"du&k%f;Ed Srfeif;a&;wyfzJ G @)um;rsm;/ ppfum;rsm;/ wyfrawmfwyfxdef;um;rsm;/ vrf;ab; 0J,mrS xaemif;yif/ wrmyifrsm;. aemufuG,f&S d csHKykwfrsm;ud k tumtuG,f,lI tm%myk difwk d @.um;rsm; &yfwef @xm;onfuk d awG @&onf?vrf;ab;0J,mwGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;u‘rH k&Gm-ref;/ csif;wGif;om;’ ponh f c&D;onfwifvd kif;um;rsm;ud k tok H;jyK=uonf? cef @rSef;ajc armfawmf ,mOftpD;(30)cef @ud k xd kae&mwGifjrifawG @&onf?xd kae&mwGif teD;uyf}uD;=uyfaeolrSm ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOfwavsmuf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; vd kufvHaESmif h,SufcJ honf h OD;aX;atmifqd koljzpfygonf? azmfjyyg qENjyqef @usifrnh folrsm;ESif hawG @qH konf htcg owif;ESih fjyef=um;a&;tzJ G @wm0efcHjzpfol ud kodef;pd k;u"gwfyH k&d kuf,l+yD;/ ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu AG D'D,d kuifr&mjzif h rSwfwrf;wifum ud kjrif hausmfu toHzrf;,lrSwfwrf;wifch Jygonf? 55555
apmif hóudaeonf hvlrsm;.teD;w0d kuf vrf;r}uD;wavsmufwGif vrf;cif;ausmufrsm;ud k vrf;jyif&ef r[kwfbJta=umif;rJ htoif hpkyH kxm;onfud kvJawG @&S d&ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef; jrif;rlòrd @rS xGufcGmvm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 38/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
38
onf htcsdefwGif rH k&Gmòrd @rS rE Wav;òrd @od k @ajy;qG Jaeonf h c&D;onfwif vd kif;um;rsm;ud k&yfem;xm;&ef oufqd kif&mtm%myd kifrsm;u trdef @xkwfwm;jrpfxm;jcif;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; vma&mufóudqd k=urnf h rH k&Gmòrd @cHvlxktm; rH k&Gmòrd @rS xGufcGmjcif; rjyK&ef wm;jrpf ydwfyifxm;jcif; ponfwd k @rSm a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud k[ef @wm;aESmif h,Suf&ef tm%myd kifrsm;.pHepfwus óudwifpDpOfr_rsm;yif jzpfonf? od k @aomfvnf;acsmif;OD;òrd @ESif h rH k&Gmòrd @rsm;rSvma&mufóudqd k=uonf h jynfolvlxk. tiftm;rsm;jym;aeonf htwGuf etz.
pDpOfn$ef=um;r_rsm;jzif hvkyfaqmifaeonf h =uH @zG H @tzG J @taejzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; t=urf;zuf&d kufESuf&ef raqmif&GufEd kifcJ hay?
rH k&Gmòrd @od k @ nae(6)em&DwGif qd kufa&muf&m/ rH k&Gmòrd @olòrd @om;rsm;/ a'ocHjynfolvlxkrsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; v_ dufvS JpGmóudqd k=uonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @ rH k&Gmòrd @od k @ a&muf&S dcsdefwGif tm%myd kifrsm;u rH k&Gmòrd @ wòrd @vH k;tm; v#yfppfrD;rsm;jzwfawmufxm;aomfvnf; rH k&Gmòrd @aejynfolvlxku za,mif;wd kifrsm;xGef;n‡ dI “a':atmifqef;pk=unf usef;rmygap/ bbOD;wifOD; usef;rmygap” pojzif h aºuG;a=umfqkawmif;arwWmyd k @o+yD;/ aomif;aomif; jzjz óudqd k=uygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu vma&mufc&D;OD;óudqd konf h rH k&Gmòrd @&S d jynfolvlxkud k rdepf(40)cef @ rdef @cGef;ajym=um;cJ honf? xd kn(9) em&DcG J wGifa':atmifqef;
pk=unfu rH k&Gmòrd @e,f&H k; jyefvnfzGif hvSpfyG JESif h qd kif;bkwfwiftcrf;tem;rsm; jyKvkyfcJ hygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @e,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ òrd @e,fvli,fvkyfief;tzG J @zG J @pnf;a&;ud k n(12) em&DrS (2)em&Dtxd rH k&Gmòrd @e,f rJqENe,ftrSwf(1) jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f Ad kvfr_;a[mif; OD;=unfpd k;.aetdrf (pdefr#m;pwd k;)Y jyKvkyf+yD;xd ktdrfwGif wnwm ntdyf&yfem;cJ hygonf6?
arv(30)&ufae@eHeufyk dif;wGif rH k&Gmòrd @&S d aZmwduausmif;q&mawmftm; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h OD;wifOD;wd k @ 0ifa&mufzl;ar#mfcJ honf? xd k @aemuf OuU Hawm&ausmif;od k @ 0ifa&mufzl;ajrmf&efpDpOfxm;aomfvnf;/ tpDtpOfud kzsufI eHeuf(10)em&Dcef @wGif rH k&Gmòrd @/ òrd @ywfvrf;rSwqif h bkwvifòrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? ZD;awmaus;&GmteD;&S d taemufajrmufwd kif; ppfXmecsKyfteD;od k @a&muf&S donf htcg ppfwyftm%myd kifrsm;u a':atmif
qef;pk=unfESif htzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm; pDeif;vd kufygonf h,mOfrsm;ESif h rH k&Gmòrd @rSvd kufvHyd k @aqmifonf h ,mOfrsm;ud k&yfwef @wm;qD;+yD; rH k&GmrSvd kufvHyd k @onf holrsm;ud k bkwvifòrd @txdom vd kufygcGif hjyKcJ hygonf? a':atmifqef;pk
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 39/208
39
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
=unfESif h tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm; bkwvifòrd @od k @ a&muf&S donf htcg bkwvifòrd @e,f/ tzG J @csKyf&H k; zGif hvSpfyG JESif h qd kif;bkwfwifyG J usif;y+yD;/ tzG J @csKyfvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k aqmif&GufcJ honf? rH k&GmrS vd kufygyd k @aqmifonf h,mOfrsm;/qd kifu,frsm;u bkwvifòrd @rS rH k&Gmod k @jyefvnfxGufcGm oGm;=uonf? xd kod k @xGufcGmoGm;onf holrsm; taemufajrmufwd kif;
ppfXmecsKyfteD;&S d ZD;awmaus;&Gmod k @a&muf&S donf htcg toif hapmif hqd kif;aeonf h&Jrsm;. &d kufESufzrf;qD;jcif;ud k cH=u&onf? xd kowif;ud k a':atmifqef;pk=unf =um;odonf htcg xk dae&mod k @ ppfuk dif;wk dif; OuUX OD;bmbm.um;jzif hvd kufoGm;&ef bkwvifòrd @e,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf OuUX OD;atmifqef;ESif h OD;xGef;òrdif (0ufvufòrd @e,f/ jynfol @vGwfawmf ud k,fpm;vS,f/ppfud kif;wd kif;pnf;&H k;a&;r_;) wd k @tm; oGm;a&mufajz&Sif;&ef a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS ajym=um;cJ honf?
bkwvifòrd @rS pwifI vufwGifvufywfrsm;ywfxm;onf hbkef;}uD;rsm;/ =uH @zH G @tzG J @0ifrsm;/ jynfol @pGrf;tm;&Sifrsm; tygt0ifvltrsm;tjym;ud k wifaqmifxm;onf hum;rsm;tm; rH k&GmrS bkwvifòrd @t0if ("gwfqDa&mif;onf h ae&mrsm;)wGif pwif awG @&S d&ygonf? 77777
xd k @a=umif h a&S @ajy;vH kjcHKa&;tjzpfoGm;aeonf h ud kEd kifEd kif/ ud katmifatmifESif hud krsdK;rif;wd k @tm; owd 0d&d,&S d&ef/ tif;awmfòrd @e,f/ vGwfawmfud k,fpm;vS,fjzpfol OD;apmv_ difESif h óudwifnS dEd _if;vkyfaqmif&efESif h tu,fIum;jzih f vma&mufta=umif; r=um;Ek difygu qd kifu,fjzif hta=umif;=um;Ed kif&ef ud kwifxGÉfOD;u ud kausmfatmifud k wqufwnf; wm0efay;cJ hygonf?
nae( 4) em&D rdepf (30)cef @tcsdefwGif bkwvifòrd @rS 'DyJ,if;òrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? xd d kod k @xGufcGmvm&m pd kifjyif&Gmod k @ta&mufwGif zrf;qD;xdrf;odrf;jcif;cHxm;&aom vGwfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f OD;0if;jrif hatmif.aetdrfod k @ 0ifa&mufI a':atmifqef;pk=unfu ‚if;.rdom;pk0ifrsm;/ a'ocHtzJ G @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ud ktm;ay;pum;ajym=um;cJ honf?
ar(30)&ufae@ eHeufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;oGm;a&mufrnf h 'DyJ,if; c&D;pOf
twGuf vrf;c&D;vH kòcHa&;ud k pH kprf;&efxGufcGmoGm;onf h OD;0if;jrif hatmif.om;jzpfolESif h ‚if;.qd kifu,ftm;tm%myd kifrsm;u 'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;wGif tus,fcsKyfjzif hóudwifI zrf;qD;xm;cJ honf? 88888 'DyJ,if;òrd @od k @ ra&mufrDpd kifjyif}uD;wGif ,mOfwef; a&S @ajy;vH kjcHKa&;tjzpf apvGwfxm;onf h um; jyefvnf a&mufvmjcif; r&S donf htwGufarmfawmfqd kifu,frsm;ud k pH kprf;&ef xyfrHapvGwfcJ hygonf? od k @aomf xd k armfawmfqd kifu,frsm;vnf; jyefvnfa&muf&S dvmjcif; r&S dyg? 99999
xk d @aemuf qufvufxGufcGmvm&m tcsif;jzpfyGm;onf h usnf&Gmod k @n(8)em&Dcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ hygonf?'DyJ,if;òrd @od k @a&muf&ef (2) rd kifcef @omvd kygonf? usnf&Gmod k @a&mufonf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzJ G @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; &Gmol&Gmom;rsm;uvma&mufóudqd k=uonf? tcif;jzpfyGm;onf htcsdefwGif 'kwd,OuUX
OD;wifOD; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h awmif;athpftrsdK;tpm; ,mOftrSwf7u§56617u§56617u§56617u§56617u§5661 u a&S @qH k;wGif&S daeygonf?xd kum;.aemufwGif rE Wav;wd kif;rS OD;ud kud kav;armif;ESifonf h [d kif;vyfum;jzpfygonf? xd kum;.aemufwGifa':atmifqef;pk=unfpD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h um;trSwft§5415jzpf+yD; xd kum;.aemufwGif (aps;csdKrS) OD;xGef;0if;eSif h OD;cifarmifaomif;wd k @ yg0ifonh fum; vk dufygvmonf? pwkwajrmufum;rSm teD;uyfvH kjcHKa&; wm0ef,lxm;onf h rE Wav;òrd @e,f/ vli,ftzG J @0ifrsm;.um; ([d kif;vuf trsdK;tpm;/ tpdrf;a&mif) jzpfygonf? ‚if;um;.aemufwGif pOf hud kifòrd @e,f/ rJqENe,ftrSwf (2)rSv$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f a'gufwmvSpd k;nGef @.um; (qefeDtjzLa&mif) vd kufygvmonf? xd kum;rsm;. aemufwGif tzG J @csKyftzJ G @0ifrsm;.um;rsm; tpDt&D vd kufyg vm=uonf?
usnf&GmrS ud kuf(100)cef @ ausmfvGefvmonf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h armf
awmf,mOfud k bkef;}uD;(2)yg;u a&@S SrSydwfqd k @+yD; &yfwef @cd kif;ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif tzJ G @csKyf A[k dvli,ftzJ G @ vk HòcHa&;wm0efcH ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu armfawmfum;ay:rSqif;I tusdK;ta=umif;ud kar;jref;avsmufxm;&m xd k bkef;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 40/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
40
}uD;u“igwd k @apmif haewm =um+yD/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k rdef @cGef;ajymcd kif;yg”[k ajymqd kygonf/ xd ktcg ud kxGef;aZmfaZmf u tcsdefr&ojzih f rdef @cGef;ajymEd kifrnf r[kwfa=umif; &Sif;jyav#mufxm;ygonf// 1010101010
xd kod k @&Sif;jyaepOf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @csKyf tzGJ @0ifrsm;/ vd kufvHyd k @aqmifonf h jynfolvlxk.
armfawmf,mOfrsm;aemufrSvd kufygvmonf h vltjynf h wifaqmifxm;aom 'd kifemum;rsm;ESif h ta0;ajy;c&D;onfwif um;rsm;ay:rS vlrsm;u ‘jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm; tvd kr&S d[k’ t}udrf}udrfatmf[pf+yD;um;rsm;ay:rSqif;vm=uonf? xd ktcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf ESif htzG J@csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; vma&mufóudqd k=uonf h usnf&GmrS &Gmom;rsm;u ‘'d k @jynfolvlxkuvnf; rif;wd k @ud k tvd k r&d S’ [k wkef @jyef aºuG;a=umf=uygonf? 1111111111 xd ktcg =uh HzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;/ tca=u;aiGay;I iSm;&rf;xm;onf holrsm;/ bkef;}uD; twkrsm;u “rif;wd k @bmajymwm vJ” [kqd k+yD; um;rsm;ay:wGif toif h,laqmifvmonf h oHc|efrsm;/ oH'kwfrsm;/ 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;/opfom;'kwfrsm; ud kifaqmifI um;ay:rSqif;vm+yD;/ &Gmol&Gmom;rsm; ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf tygt0ifum;ay:rS tzG J @csKyf tzGJ @0ifrsm;/ t&yfom;rsm;ud k twif;t"rR0ifa&mufI pHepfwus &d kufESuf=uonf? 1212121212
xd k @a=umif h usnf&GmrSa':atmifqef;pk=unftm; vma&mufóudqd k=uonf hjynfolvlxkrSm ajcOD;wnf h&mud k xGufajy;wdrf;a&Smif=u&onf? &kwfw&ufaemufrS0ifa&mufI wd kufcd kufjcif;ud kcH&onf htwGuf,mOfwef;.aemufqH k;wGif vd kuf fygvmonf holrsm;rSm trsm;tjym; tjyif;txef&d kufESufjcif;cH=u&onf?
vufywfrsm;ywfxm;onf hbkef;}uD;twkrsm;/ vufywftjzLywfxm;onf h t&yf0wfESif hvlrsm;u xd kod k @tqufrjywf&dkufESufaepOf E_wfrSvnf; “trsdK;zsufrawG/ ukvm;udk vifawmfcsifwJholawG/ ukvm;udkvifrvkyfcif igwd k @ud k t&ifvifvkyf” ponf h &kef @&if;=urf;wrf;aompum;rsm;jzif h }udrf;0g;cJ honf? '%f&mjzif hvJaeonf h trsdK;orD;rsm;. tzG J @csKyfwlnD0wfpH k yifeD&ifzH k;tusôrsm;/ a,mxrDrsm;ud k qG Jc|wfjcif;/ qHyifud k vufjzif h&pfywfqkyfud kifI uwW&mvrf;ESif h rsufESmtm;qG Jaqmif hjcif; wd k @ud k touftE W&m,fxdck dufaponftxd ,kwfrm&d kif;pd kif;pGm jyKrlaqmif&GufcJ hygonf// 1313131313 xd k @tjyif '%f&m&olrsm;. qG Jóud;rsm;/ em;uyfrsm;/ aiGa=u;rsm;ud kvnf;
twif;t"rR vk,uf,liifcJ hygonf? 1414141414
,mOfwef;rsm;.aemufrSvd kufvmonf h t=urf;zuf&d kufESufolrsm;onf a':atmifqef;pk=unf pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h armfawmf,mOf.0Jbufjcrf;ud k t"duxd k;azmuf&d kufESufcJ h=uonf? xk d @a=umih f armfawmf,mOfab;wGif txyfxyf vufjcif;qufI um&Hay;xm;onf h vuf0Jbufjcrf;rS vk H+cKHa&;wm0ef,lxm;olrsm;jzpfonf htzG J @csKyf A[d kvli,fvk HjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;/ rE Wav;rSvd kufygvmonf h vH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h rH k&Gmòrd @rS vd kufygvmonf h vli,ftzG J @0ifrsm;/ pD;yGm;a&;wuUod kvfausmif;om;rsm; trsm;tjym; tjyif;txef xdcd kuf'%f&m &&S dcJ honf? 1515151515 OD;acgif;ud k raorcsif; tjyif;txef±k dufESufonf htwGuf rE Wav;wd kif;/ (taemufawmifòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf
pnf;&H k;a&;r_;) wOD;jzpfolud kodef;wd k;at;/ rE Wav;wd kif;tzG J @csKyfrS "gwfyH kq&m ud kwifarmifOD;/ ,mOfarmif;jzpfol ud kpef;jrif h(ac: )ud k&m*sL;wd k @rSm xd kae&mwGifyif yG Jcsif;jyD;aoqH k;cJ h&onf? 1616161616
xd kod k @ t=urf ;zufvkyf=uHowfjzwfaeonf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;onf t=urf;zuf 0d kif;0ef;&d kufESufaeonf h=um;rS twif;jzwfausmfarmif;xGufcJ h&onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfvd kufygonf hum; armif;xGufoGm;jyD;aemuf qnfajrmif;0if;teD;od k @ta&mufwGif vrf;ab;0J/,mrS toif hapmif hqd kif;aeonf h vl(4000)cef @u usnf&GmrS xGufajy;vGwfajrmufvmolrsm;tm; qnfajrmif;0if;a&S @rSqD;óudI xyfrH t=urf;zuf &d kufESuf=ujyefonf? 1717171717 xd ktcsdefwGif“xGuf/ wd kuf” qd konf h trdef @ay;oHESif htwl toif hapmif hqd kif;aeaom 'd kifemESpfpD;ua':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @pD;vmonf hum;ud k rsufESmcsif;qd kifrS 0ifwd kuf&ef qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;rS armif;xGufvmygonf? xd k 'd kifemum;(2)pD;ud ka&Smifwdrf;jyD; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.um;u oHql;óud;wef;(3)ckud k quf
wd kuf 0ifwd kuf+yD; ausmfjzwfxGufoGm;ygonf? xd kod k @ wd kufxGufoGm;csdefrSmyif “ypf” [k trdef @ay;onf h toHESif htwl (10)csuf (15)csuf qufwk dufypfcwfcJ honf? 1818181818 od k @aomf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h a'gufwm vSpd k;nGef @wd k @
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 41/208
41
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm;onf ‚if;wd k @tm; 0ifa&mufwd kufcd kufonf h 'd kifemum;(2)pD; ESif hvkyf=uHowfjzwfrnf hvltkyf}uD;ud k twif;jzwfausmfumtoufpGef @armif;ESifcJ hojzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;onf a&OD;òrd @t0iftxd‚if;/ a'gufwm vSpd k;nGef @.um;onf 'DyJ,if;jrdK@ e,faq;&H kod k @‚if;a&muf&S dcJ hjyD;/ toufab; tE W&m,frS
vGwfajrmufcJ honf?rE Wav;wkdif;/pnf;&Hk;a&;r_;jzpfola':0if;jrjr pD;eif;vd kufygvmonfhum;rSm um;csif;0ifa&mufwdkuf&efusnf&GmteD;&S d qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;rS armif;xGufvmonf h 'd kifemum;(2)pD;udka&Smifwdrf;&if; vrf;ab;&S dukuU dKyiftm; 0ifa&mufwd kufrdonf @twGuf a':0if;jrjrrSm vuf(2)zufusdK;onftxd '%f&mjyif;xefpGm&&S dcJ honf?
xd kod k @ &kef;&if;qefcwfjzpfaepOf a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; armif;xGufoGm;+yD;aemuf tzG J @csKyf 'kwd,OuUÏOD;wifOD; vd kufygvmonf h armfawmf,mOfud kvnf; t=urf;zufolrsm;u twif;t"rR0ifa&muf&d kufESuf=uygonf? xd kae&mwGif OD;wifOD;ESif htwl&S dae=uonf h OD;wifatmifatmif/ tygt0if(5)OD;ud k &JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;u tcsif;jzpf usnf&GmteD;rSzrf;qD;jyD; 'DyJ,if;òrd @e,f&Jpcef;od k @ nwGif;csif;ac:aqmifoGm;ygonf? ud kwifxGËfOD;/ ud kawZEd kif/ud kvSOD;ESif h tjcm; tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tm;arv(31)&ufae@eHeuf usnf&Gm teD;wGifa&$bd kc&d kif(c,u)OuUXjzpfolOD;pD;onf h vH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;u zrf;qD;cJ h+yD; 'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;od k @ yd k @aqmifcJ honf? 1919191919 xd kolrsm;ud k ZGefv(1)&ufae@wGif a&$bd kaxmifod k @ yd k @aqmifcJ honf?
xd kod k @0d kif;0ef;I t=urf;zufvkyf=uHowfjzwf&d kufESuf=uolrsm;onf e,fajrtvd kuf a'oqd kif&m =uH @cf d kifzG H @òzd;a&;tzG J @rsm;u tca=u;aiGjzif hiSm;&rf;xm;olrsm;jzpf+yD; pkpkaygif; tiftm;(5000)cef @ 2020202020 &S dygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tjyif vma&mufóudqd k=uonf h a'ocHjynfolvlxktm; pHepfwus óudwifjyifqifI (3)em&Dausmfr# aoap&eft=uHjzif h t=urf;zuf &d kufESufacsr_ef;cJ hjcif; jzpfonf?
n (11)em&Dausmfcef @wGif xd kae&mod k @ 'd kifemum;(4)pD;jzif h 'd kif;rsm;/ wkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf h &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;/ jynfol @pGrf;tm;&Sifrsm;2121212121 (*0)cef @ESif h xd kum;rsm;.aemufwGif yg*sJ&d k;um;ESif h qifwlonf hum;(2)pD; a&muf&S dvmonf? xd kum;(2)pD;ay:rS t&m&S d(2)OD;qif;vm+yD; t=urf;zuf&d kufESufowfjzwfonf hae&muf k d vSnf hvnf=unf h&_ppfaq;onf? &JwyfzJ G @0if(80)cef @u '%f&m&olrsm;/ tavmif;rsm;ud k ‚if;wd k @pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h 'd kifemum;rsm;ay:od k @ tr_ dufypfouJ hod k @ ypfwifI wifaqmifoGm;ygonf? tcsif;jzpfyGm;&mwGif usef&S dcJ honf h,mOfrsm;teuf [d kif;vyfum;(2)pD;ud k v,fuGif;twGif;od k @wGef;csjyD; wdrf;arSmufonf hyH kpHESif hqifwlap&ef jyifqif=uonf?,mOfwef;twGif;rS tjcm; [d kif;vyfum;(2)pD;ud kvnf; acgif;csif;qd kifI wd kufonf htaetxm;od k @ ajymif;a&G @
jyifqif+yD;rS AG D'D,d kjzif hrSwfwrf;wifjcif;/ "gwfyH krsm;&d kuf,ljcif;wd k @ud k jyKvkyfcJ hygonf?2222222222
ysufpD;aeonf @um;rsm;teuftcsdK@ud k a&OD;òrd @bufod k @wGef;Io,faqmifoGm;onfud kvnf; rsufjrifoufaotcsdK@u awG @&S dcJ honf? 2323232323
'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_}uD;.jzpfpOfud k ud k,fwd kifjrifawG @cJ h&onf h rsufjrifoufaorsm;/ &d kufESufjcif;cH&onf holrsm;. xkwfazmfajymqd kcsufrsm;t& rH k&Gmòrd @e,f=uH @cd kifzG H @jzdK;a&;toif;twGif;a&;rª; OD;aX;atmif 2424242424ESif h a&$bd kc&d kif(c,u) OuUXjzpfol 'kwd,Ad kvfrª;}uD;oef;[ef 2525252525 tygt0if a'oqd kif&m tm%myd kifrsm;u pHepfwusóudwifpDpOfvkyfaqmifcJ ha=umif; ay:aygufonf? tm%myd kifrsm;. yHyd k;ulnDr_a=umif ht=urf;zuf&d kufESufolrsm;u twif h&JpGmjzif h&d kufESufjcif;/ aiGa=u;ESif hvuf0wf&wemrsm;tm; vk,ufjcif;/trsdK;orD;rsm;.t0wftpm;rsm;ud k vlrqefpGm qkwf+zJjcif;/c|wfypfjcif;wd k @ud k vkyfaqmifcJ h=uonf? tjypfrJ husnf&Gmol&Gmom;rsm;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k &d kufESufpOf tumtuG,fay;cJ honf htzG J @csKyfvli,f teD;uyfvH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;/ rE Wav;rS
vli,ftzG J @0ifrsm;/ ESif hrH k&Gmòrd @rS pD;yGm;a&;wuUod kvfausmif;om;rsm;/ rH k&Gm vli,ftzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;onf jyif;xefpGmjzif h pHepfwus&d kufESufjcif;ud k cHcJ h&onf?tcsdK@rSm &d kufESufjcif;cH&onf htwGuf toufaoqH k;cJ h&onf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 42/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
42
tcsdK@rSmrl &&Sdonfh'%f&mrsm;a=umifh rlv&kyfqif; ysuf,Gif;cJh&onf? xdkodk@vlom;csif;pmemr_uif;pGmjzifhtòid;w}uD;&d kufESuf&jcif;onf a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; wcJeufaxmufcHonf h jynfolvlxk. tiftm;ud kòzdcG Jjcif;jzpfouJ hod k @ tjcm;aomjynfolvlxkwd k @ud kvnf; tm%myd kifrsm;taejzif h ‚if;wd k @. tm%mwnf+rJa&;
ud k xdyg;vmygurnfuJ hod k @vkyfaqmifrnfjzpfa=umif;ud k pHerlemjy jcdrf;ajcmufvk dufjcif; jzpfa=umif;awG @&S d&onf?
( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )
(1) 0Àarmif/ a':nGef @nGef @/ud krif;odef;/ud kcifOD;/ud kzd k;aZmfwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(2) a':nGef @nGef @/ud k Ed kifEd kifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(3) a':nGef @nGef @/ud kEd kifEd kif/ud katmifatmif/ ud kcifOD;/ud kzd k;aZmfwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(4) a':nGef @nGef @/ud krif;odef;/ud kcifOD;/ud kzd k;aZmf/ud kEd kifEd kif/ud katmifatmifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(5) ud kcifOD;/ud kEd kifEd kifESif hud katmifatmifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(6) a':nGef @nGef @/ud krif;odef;/ud kcifOD;/ud kEd kifEd kifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(7) ud kEd kifEd kifESif hud katmifatmifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?(8) ud kcifOD;. oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?(9) xd kolrsm;ud kusnf&GmteD; qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;&S d a':atmifqef;pk=unf,mOfwef;tm; t=urf;zuf&d kuf
ESuf&ef toif hapmif hqd kif;aeonf holrsm;u zrf;qD;xm;cJ hygonf?(10) 0Àarmif/ ud kcifOD;/ ud krif;odef;ESif ha':nGefnGef @wd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(11) 0Àarmif/ ud krif;odef;ESif ha':nGefnGef @wd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/
(12) 0Àarmif/ ud kcifOD;/ ud krif;odef;ESif ha':nGefnGef @wd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/
(13) 0Àarmif/a':nGef @nGef @ESif hud krif;odef;wd k @. xGufqd kcsufrsm;/(14) 0Àarmif/ud kcifOD;wd k @. tppfcHcsuf(15) 0Àarmif/ud kcifOD;ESif hud krif;odef;wd k @.xGufqd kcsufrsm;/(16) a':nGef @nGef @/ud krif;odef;/wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(17) 0Àarmif/armifzd k;aZmf/ ud kcifOD;wd k @.xGufqd kcsufrsm;/(18) ud kEd kifEd kifESif hud katmifatmifwd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?
(19) 0Àarmif.xGufqd kcsuf/ jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif hawG @qH kar;jref;csuf/ aumfr&SifrSqufvufpH kprf;&mxd kpOfu a&$bd kc&d kif(c,u)OuUX jzpfolrSm 'kwd,Ad kvfrª;=uD;oef;[efjzpfa=umif; pH kprf;od&S d&onf?(20) jrefrmhtvif;owif;pm/ ZGefv(1)&uf2003 ckESpf/ arv(31)&ufae@ etz .owif;pm&Sif;yG J/(21) aZmfaZmfatmifESif hawG @qH kar;jref;cef;wGifajymjycsuf?(22) aZmfaZmfatmifESif hawG @qH kar;jref;cef;wGifajymjycsuf?(23) aZmfaZmfatmif ESif hjynfyowif;Xmersm;.awG @qH kar;jref;cef;wGifajymjycsuf?/ jynfwGif;rSaumfr&Sif
od k @ wd kuf&d kufay;yd k @onf h owif;tcsuftvufrsm;/
(24) ud kcifOD;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf
(25) jynfwGif;rSaumfr&SifxHwd kuf&d kufay;yd k @onf howif;tcsuftvufrsm;/ jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif h awG @qH kar;jref;csufrsm;/
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 43/208
43
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tcef; ( 4 )
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+tay: aumfr&Sif. y%mr oH k;oyfwifjycsuf
a':atmifqef;pk=unf aetdrftus,fcsKyfxdef;odrf;cH&jcif;rS vGwfajrmufvm+yD;aemuf/ wk dif;ESif h jynfe,ftES H @pnf;&k H;a&;c&D;xGuf&mwGif jynfaxmifpk=uH @cd kifa&;ESif hzG H @jzdK;a&;toif;(=uH @zG H @)/ jynfol @pGrf;tm;&Sif/ &JwyfzJ G @/ a'oqd kif&m tm%myd kifrsm;/ ppfaxmufvSrf;a&; ponfwd k @u enf;rsKd;pk Hjzih f taESmih ft,Sufay;cJ honfud kawG @cJ h&onf?csif;jynfe,f/ &cd kifjynfe,fc&D;pOfrsm;wGif aESmih f,Sufr_rsm; pwifðyvkyfvmcJ honf// xk d @aemuf ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOfwGif vlud kaoapEd kifonf hvufeufrsm;ud k ajAmifususud kifwG,fum aESmif h,SufcJ honf? ,ckaemufqk H; ppfuk dif;wd kif; bkwvifrS 'DyJ,if;od k @toGm;wGif aESmif h,Sufonf htqif hrSausmfvGefI t=urf;zufowfjzwfacsr_ef;onf htqif hod k @ a&mufvmcJ honf?
etz ppftkyfpkonf ar(30)'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ud k pepfwusóudwif=uHpnf/ jyifqifusL;vGefcJhjcif;jzpfa=umif; aumfr&Siftaejzif h atmufygtcsuftvufrsm;t& oH k;oyfawG @&S d&onf?
1? óudwifoifwef;ay;jcif;
a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; uef @uGufqef @usifqENjy&ef vd ktyfonf h vltiftm;ud k ppfud kif;wd kif;/ a&$bd kc&d kifrS òrd @e,f(8)òrd @e,f/ rH k&Gmc&d kif&S d òrd @e,frsm;rS =uH @zG H @twGif;a&;rª;rsm;urdrdwd k @òrd @e,frsm;twGif;&S d =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ESih f jynfolvlxkud kpkaqmif;ay;cJ h=u&onf? 11111xd kod k @ vltiftm; pkaqmif;&mwGif tca=u;aiGrsm;ay;jcif;jzif hvnf;aumif;/ twif;t"rRjcdrf;ajcmuft=uyfud kifIvnf;aumif; pkaqmif;cJ h=uonf? 22222
pkaqmif;&&S dcJ holrsm;tm; oufqd kif&mòrd @e,frsm;tvd kuf ppfud kif;òrd @/ txufwef;ausmif;trSwf(2)/ rk H&Gmòrd @/txufwef;ausmif;trSwf(2)ESih f trSwf(3)ausmif;rsm;/ taemufajrmufwd kif;ppfXmecsKyf0if;/ 'DyJ,if;òrd @/ txufwef;ausmif; ponf hae&mrsm;wGifpkpnf;xm;&S dum/ vlpkvla0;ud kt=urf;zuf&d kufESuf òzdcG Jacsr_ef;enf;oifwef;rsm;pHepfwusay;cJ honf? 33333
xd kuJ hod k @ oifwef;yd k @csr_ESif hywfoufI tvm;wltawG @t=uHKud k&efukefwd kif;/ urm&Gwfòrd @e,f vli,fwm0efcHjzpfo lud kpd k;oef;u atmufygtwd kif;jyefvnfajymjycJ honf?
“1996 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv (1)&ufae@up+yD; jynfxJa&;Xme¶H k;csKyf rsufapmif;xd k;rSm&S dwJ h or0g,r ukefpnfjyyG Jcef;r aemufzufu wk dufopf}uD;xJrSm }uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifawGud k txl;oifwef;awGay;ygw,f? vlawG/ um;awGuk d
b,fvd k ¶d kufESuf&r,fqd kwmutp oif=um;ay;xm;w,fvd k @vnf;od&ygw,f/ vufa&G;pifac:,lxm;wJ h }uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifawGuk d w&ufv#if xrif;au|;t+yD; usyf(200)pD ay;xm;w,fvd k @vnf; od&S d&ygw,f”
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 44/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
44
2? ud kifaqmiftoH k;jyKonfhvufeufrsm;
a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; 'DyJ,if;òrd @teD; usnf&GmY vkyf=uHowfjzwfacsr_ef;&mwGifud kifaqmiftoH k;jyKch J=uonf h 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;/ 0g;c|efrsm;/ ESpfwpfvufrt&G,ftpm;&d S opfom;yd kif;rsm; pojzih f
t=urf;zuf&d kufESufolrsm;tm;vH k; ud kifaqmifonf h vufeufrsm;yk HpHwlnDae=uonfud k awG @&S d&onf? xd k @tjyifvufeufrsm;ud ktoH k;jyK&d kufESufonf h enf;pepfrsm; (OD;acgif;ESif hcg;tqpf rsm;ud kpHepfwus&d kufESufjcif;)vnf;xyfwl lnDaeonfud k awG @&S d&onf? xd kvufeufrsm;ud k =uHzG H @twGif;a&;rª;rsm;u oufqd kif&mòrd @@e,f/ aus;&Gmrsm;&S djynfolvlxkrsm;tm; jyKvkyfapcd kif;cJ honf?
3? tcsdefumvESifh owfuGif;jyifqifr+
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_onf arv(30)&ufae@ n(8)em&D0ef;usifwGif pwifjzpfyGm;+yD;/ n(11)em&DcG J (12)em&Dcef @wGif +yD;qH k;cJ honf? 44444 tcsif;jzpfae@onf uqkefvuG,fae@jzpfI ywf0ef;usifud k &Sif;vif;oJuG JpGm rjrifawG @Ed kif
ap&ef óudwifpDpOfcJ hjcif;jzpfonf?usnf&Gmod k @ ra&mufrD armfawmfum;vrf;wqpfcsdK;auG @wGif um;ud k&yfwef @&efpDrHIwm;qD;cJ hjcif;/ oHql;óud;
(3)xyfjzif h vrf;ud kydwfqd k @um&Hxm;jcif;/ vufeufud kifppfom;rsm;ESif h&JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;ud k qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;wyfpG Jae&m,lxm;jcif;/ vrf;ab;0J,mwd k @wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;tm; &d kufESufrnf holrsm;ud kpepfwusóudwifae&mcsxm;cJ honf? &d kufESufrnf holrsm;taejzif h ywf0ef;usifud k aumif;pGmjrifEd kifap&eftwGufqvd kufrD;rsm;ud k toif hjyifqifxm;jcif;/ &d kufESufowfjzwfrnfholrsm;.aemufrS armfawmfum;rsm;ud k pepfwuswef;pDI &yfwef @um um;a&S @rD;}uD;rsm;ud kxd k;ay;Ed kif&ef pDpOfcJ honf ud kawG @&S d&onf? 55555
&d kufESufrnf holrsm;ud k wae&mwnf;wGifpkpnf;xm;&S dI pepfwus&d kufESuf+yD;/ vsifjrefpGmvlpkcG J azsmufzsuf
Ed kifjcif;onf tm%myd kifrsm;yg0ifywfoufr_&S drSom vG,fulpGmvkyfaqmifEd kifrnfjzpfonf? tcsif;jzpfonf h usnf&GmESif hteD;qH k;jzpfonf h &Gmopf&Gm/ usnf&GmESif hqnfajrmif;0if;wd k @wGifaexd kifvkyfud kifpm;aomuf=uonf hvlOD;a& onf(1000)0ef;usifxuf ryd kyg?
a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @. ,mOfwef; usnf&Gmod k @ra&mufrD a&S @ajy;vH kjcHKa&;tjzpf ,mOftrSwf "§801ud k pD;eif;vd kufygcJ honf h vl @abmifopf'Drd ku&ufwpfygwDrS ud katmifatmifESif hud kEd kifEd kifwd k @ESpfOD; tqd kygqnfajrmif;0if;twGif; zrf;qD;cHxm;&+yD;jzpfygonf? xd kolrsm;ud k zrf;qD;onf htcsdefonf nae (5;30)em&DwGifjzpfaoma=umih f zrf;qD;olrsm;ESif h ywf0ef;usiftaetxm;ud k tao;pdyfjrifawG @cJ h&onf? 66666
4? wd kufcd kufacsr+ef;onf h enf;pHepfrsm;?
a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;rsm;aemufrS vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm;ay:wGif &d kufESufacsr_ef;rnf h olrsm;onf OD;acgif;ud kt"duxm;I &d kufESufonfud kawG @&S d&onf? toufrao/ owdrvpfbJ '%f&m&I nnf;nL aeolrsm;tm; vl(4)(5)a,mufu0d kif;I wòydifwnf;/ pHepfwus0d kif;0ef;&d kufESufcJ honf? 77777 &d kufESufrnf holrsm;tcsif;csif; vlrrSm;Ed kifap&eftwGuf vufwGif tjzLa&mift0wfprsm;ywfxm;I cG Jjcm;xm;onf? 88888 um;rsm;ay: wGif pD;eif;vd kufygvmolrsm;tm; &d kufESufolrsm;u um;ay:rSqif;vsifqif;/ rqif;vsif um;ud k rD;&_ d @ypfrnf[k+cdrf;ajcmufajymqd k+yD;/ um;atmufod k @qif;vmolrsm;ud k toif hapmif haeolrsm;u 0d kif;I&d kufESufcJ honf? 99999 um;rsm;ay:r Sqif;rvmonf hvlrsm;ud k um;atmufod k @qG JcsI tjyif;txef&d kufESufcJ h=uonf? 1010101010 um;atmufod k @qG Jcs&d kufESuf+yD;aemuf tzG J @csKyf. wlnD0wfpH krsm;ud k twif;t"rRc|wf,ljcif;/ vuf0wfvufpm;rsm;ud k vk,ljcif;
wd k @ud kjyKvkyfcJ honf? 1111111111
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 45/208
45
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
5? tm%myd kifrsm;ud k,fwd kif f yg0ifywfoufr+
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;wGiftm%myd kifrsm;.yg0ifywfoufr_ESif hywfoufI atmufygtwd k fif;awG @&S d&onf?(1) tcsif;jzpfyGm;onf hae@wGif rE Wav;ESif hrH k&Gmt=um;ajy;qG Jonf h c&D;onfwifvd kif;um;rsm;ud k tm%m
yd kifrsm;u xGufcGmcGif hrjyKbJ ydwfyifxm;cJ honf?1212121212
(2) a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @tm; rk H&GmrS bkwviftxdvd kufvHyk d @aqmif+yD; jyefvm=uonf h qk difu,ftpD;(70§80)cef @tm; rk H&Gmòrd @ESif hbkwvifòrd @t=um; ZD;awmaus;&GmteD;&S d(erc) ppfXmecsKyf0if;teD;wGif ppfwyfESif h &Jrsm;uzrf;qD;cJ honf// 1313131313 xd kod k @zrf;qD;jcif;cH&olrsm;ud kulnD&ef rH k&Gmòrd @rS xyfrHvd kufygvm=uolrsm;ud kvnf;xd kae&mwGif xyfrHzrf;qD;vk dufonf htwGuf xd kae@ nae(4;30)cef @wGif rH k&Gmòrd @twGif;qlylr_rsm; pwifjzpfyGm;cJ honf// xd ktajctaeud k bkwvifwGifa&muf&S daeonf h a':atmifqef;pk=unfod&S d+yD;/ bkwvifòrd @e,ftzJ G @csKyfOuUX OD;atmifqef;ESif h ppfud kif;wd kif;tzJ G @csKyf twGif;a&;rª;OD;xGef;+rdKifwd k @tm;apv$wfch J&m oGm;a&mufajz&Sif;olrsm;xd kae&m wGifyifzrf;qD;jcif; cHcJ h=u&onf? tm%myd kifrsm;u,if;od k @zrf;qD;cJ hjcif;rsm;rSm 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_usL;vGefrnf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;Yvltiftm;ta&twGufavsmhenf;ap&ef jzpfonf?
(3) ar(30)&ufae@u bkwvifòrd @wGif ud krsdK;Ed kif(rEWav;wd kif;pnf;&H k;a&;wm0efcH)ESif h ud koufxGef; (OD;wifOD;.um;armif;ESifol)/ ud kEd kifEd kif(vl @abmifopf'Drd ku&ufwpfygwD)wd k @ rH k&Gmbkwvif vrf;c&D;tajctaeud k &efukef&S dtzG J @csKyfA[k dod k @ w,fvDzkef;qufta=umif;=um;&ef bkwvifòrd @e,f/ qufoG,fa&;&H k;od k @oGm;a&mufcJ h&m xd k&H k;rS0efxrf;wOD;u w,fvDzkef;vd kif;rsm;jzwfawmufcHxm;&onf htwGuf ‚if;wd k @yif rnfonf hòrd @ud kr#qufoG,f Ir&a=umif; ajym=um;cJ honf? 1414141414
,if;tcsufud k=unf hjcif;tm;jzif h tcsif;jzpfonf hae@ vkyf=uHr_usL;vGefrnf htcsdefwGif bkwvifòrd @rS qufoG,fonf h w,fvDzkef;vd kif;rsm;ud k tm%myd kifrsm;utpDtpOf&S d&S djzif hóudwif jzwfawmufxm;cJ ha=umif; awG @&onf?a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef; bkwvifòrd @ud kjzwfoGm;+yD;aemuf jy\em wpH kw&m=uHKawG @&vsif bkwvifrS
wqif h jyifyod k @qufoG,fta=umif;=um;jcif; rjyKEd kif&efjzpfonf[k oH k;oyf&onf?(4) usnf&GmteD;&S dbkef;}uD;ausmif;rsm;ud k a'oqk dif&mtm%myd kiftzG J @tpnf;rsm;u a':atmifqef;pk
=unfESif h tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;a&muf&S dvmygu oGm;a&mufóudqd kjcif; rjyK&/ tultnD ray;&/ jy\em wpH kw&mjzpfyguvnf; xGufrvm&pojzih f bkef;}uD;ausmif;tcsdK@tm; +cdrf;ajcmufIvnf;aumif;/ tjcm;bkef;=uD;ausmif;tcsdK@tm; v_zG,fypPnf;rsm;qufuyfum ajzmif;zsavsmufxm;I óudwifwm;jrpfcJ honf// xd kod k @wm;jrpfxm;onf htwGuf jy\emwpH kw&mjzpfyGm;ygu tultnDr&Ed kifa=umif;/ um;vrf;rsm;ud kvnf; ydwfxm;vd kuf+yDjzpfonf htwGuf rnfonf hòrd @&Gmrsm;ud krS qufoG,fIr&a=umif; bkef;awmf}uD;wyg;rS rdef@=um;cJ honf? 1515151515
tm%myd kifrsm;u ,if;od k @vkyfaqmifjcif;rSm vkyf=uHr_usL;vGefonf htcsdefwGif rsufjrifoufaorsm; r&S dap&efESif h
a':atmifqef;pk=unf,mOfwef;tm; tultnDay;rnh ftiftm;rsm;a&muf&S d rvmap&ef pepfwus óudwifpDpOfxm;jcif;jzpfonf?(5) tcif;jzpfyGm;onf hae&mod k @ a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;rsm;a&mufrvmrD qd kifu,fESif h um;
rsm;jzif h a&S @ajy;tjzpf óudwifxGufcGmvm=uolrsm;tm; ppfwyfESif h&Jrsm;yg0ifonf h tm%myd kifrsm;u usnf&GmteD;&S d qnfajrmif;0if;wGifóudwifzrf;qD;cJ honf?
“xd kae&mwGif oHql;óud;wef; ud k;ck csxm;onf? wwef;vsif(3) ckE_ef;jzih f (3)wef;csxm;+yD;/ vrf;uk dydwfqd k @xm;onf? xd kod k @ydwfqd k @xm;ojzih f um;ud k t&S defav#mhvd kuf&onf? xk dtcg oHql;óud;wefrsm;.aemufwGifwkwf/ 'dkif;rsm;udkifaqmifxm;aom &JwyfzJG @0iftiftm;(30)cef@udkawG @&onf?tusôtjzL0wfxm;onfh vlwa,muf a&mufvm+yD; ‘b,foGm; rvd k @vJ’[kar;ygonf? rdrdwd k @uvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih f twlvmjcif;jzpfa=umif; &Sif;jyonf? xd ktcg ‚if;u ppfabmif;bDESih fpGyfus,ftusô0wfxm;aom touf(50)cef @t&G,f&S dolwOD;xHoGm;I ‘Ad kvfrª;/ 'g a':atmifqef;pk=unfeJ @ ygvmwJ hum;’[k owif;yd k @ygonf? xd kolu‘at;/ txJxnf hvd kuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 46/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
46
[k jyefajymygonf? xk d Ak dvfrSL;qk dolrSm tenf;i, f0+zdK;+yD;/ pGyfus,ftusô0wfqifxm;ojzih f &mxl;trSwftom;ESif h wHqdyfud k rjrifawG @&yg”1616161616 &d kufESufolrsm;taejzif h ywf0ef;usifud k &Sif;vif;pGmjrifEd kifap&eftwGufvnf;qvd kufrD;rsm;ud ktoif hwyfqifxm;jcif;/ &d kufESufowfjzwfrnf holrsm;.aemufrS armfawmfum;rsm; ud kpepfwus
wef;pDI&yfwef @um um;a&S @ rD ;}uD;rsm;ud kxd k;ay;Ed kif&ef pDpOfcJ honfud kawG @&S d&onf?1717171717
xd kod k @acsr_ef; rnf holrsm;tm;}uD;=uyfuGyfuJaeolrsm;rSm ppfwyfrS Ad kvfr_;tqif h&S dolwOD; 1818181818 ESif h 'DyJ,if;òrd @e,f&JwyfzG J @rS pcef;r_; OD;pdef0if;wd k @jzpfonf? 1919191919
(6) qnfajrmif;0if;twGif; ae&mcswyfpG Jxm;onf h&Jrsm;tm; }uD;=uyfaeolrSm 'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;rS pcef;rª;OD;pdef0if;jzpfa=umif; awG @&S d&onf? qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;jcif;cHxm;&olrsm;xJwGif 'DyJ,if;jrdK@e,f/jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f OD;bd karmif;vnf;yg0ifonf? 2020202020 usnf&GmteD;wGifwd kufcd kufcH&+yD;aemuf tcsif;jzpfae&mrS xd k;azgufarmif;xGufvmaom a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;onf oHql;óud;wef; oH k;wef;ud k wd kuf+yD;jzwfausmfarmif;ESifoGm;cJ honf? xd ktcsdefwGif 'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;rS ª;jzpfolOD;pdef0if;u OD;bd karmif;tygt0if zrf;qD;xd fef;odrf;jcif;cHxm;&olrsm;tm; ² ² ²
“OD;bd karmif;tygt0if tm;vH k;=um;=u/ jrif=uwJ htwd kif;yJaemf/ cifAsm;wd k @ud k uHz,foGm;w,fvd k @ rSwfxm;vd kufyg/ a&S @av#muf+yD; uHaumif;ygap”2121212121 [k ajym=um;cJ honf?
(7) aemufrSvd kufvmum &d kufESufowfjzwfrnf holrsm;tm; o,faqmifvmonf hum;}uD;rsm;ud k rH k&Gm&S dtaemufajrmufwd kif; ppfXmecsLyf0if;twGif; xm;&S djcif;/ ,if;um;rsm;udktoH k;jyKI vlaotavmif;rsm;udka&$ @ajymif;&mYpDrHcef @cG JolrSm Ad kvf}uD;wOD;jzpfjcif; paomtcsufrsm;rSm tm%myd kifrsm; yg0ifywfoufa=umif;xif&Sm;onf? xd kudpPESif hywfoufI ,mOftrSwf 2c§1962 ukefwifum;. ,mOfaemufvd kufwOD;jzpfol ud kausmfvGifu jynfyowif;Xmetm; atmufygtwd kif;ajym=um;cJ honf?
“eDqef;,l'D NISSAN-UD um;trSwf 2 c§1962 rSm pyg,f,m vkyfygw,f// *dwfzH k;eHygwfu &efukef 681229 yg// usaemfwd k @um;u &efukef-rH k&Gm ukefpnf yd k @aqmifa&;ud kt"du vkyfygw,f//
28-5-03 &ufae@avmufu pjyD;awmh rH k&GmrSm acsmqG JcH&ygw,f// erc u qG Jwmyg?tm;vH k; (10)bD;um; (10)pD;yg// um; tm;vH k; erc 0if;xJrSmae&ygw,f// arv(30)&ufae@rSmawmh erc 0if;xJuae Ad kvf}uD;qd kwJ holu a&S @cef;rSmxd kifygw,f// olu t&yf0wfeJ @yg?um;ay:rSm qufoG,fa&;pufawGvJ wifvmwmawG @&ygw,f? aemufcef;rSmawmh oCFef;
0wf/ vl0wf tm;vH k;ta,muf(50)avmufwufygw,f// um;ud k wmvywf trd k;eJ @zH k;um+yD;rS p xGufcd kif;ygw,f// n (7;00) em&DausmfavmufrSm erc 0if;xJae p xGufwmyg?'DyJ,if;/ a&OD;bufud k armif;cd kif;ygw,f//
'DyJ,if; ra&mufcif (2)rd kif/ (3)rd kif tvd kavmufrSm vlawG &kef;&if;qefcwfeJ @ &d kufyG J}uD;wckudkawG@&ygw,f? a&S@cef;u Adkvf}uD;qdkolu um;rD;eJ@xdk;cdkif;xm;+yD;/ aemufcef;uvlawGud k qif;cd kif;+yD; tJ'DvltkyfxJ 0if&d kufcd kif;ygw,f// um;ay:rSmawmh usaemf&,f/ ud kndK &,f/ Ad kvf}uD;qd kol&,f oH k;a,mufyJ usefcJ hygw,f// jrif&wmuawmh tjyif;txef t+idK;w}uD;eJ @ &d kufaewmrsdK; jrifawG @ae&ygw,f//awmfawmfajcmufjcm;zd k @aumif;ygw,f// 'grsdK;rawG @bl;/ róuHzl;ygbl;// wzufowf&d kufaeyH kygbJ//
t&d kufcH&wJ hvlawGvnf; vJwJ holvJ/ ajy;wJ holajy;/ atmfwJ holuatmfeJ @ aoG;&l;aoG;wef;jzpfae=uwm awG @&ygw,f// vJaewJ hol wcsdK@ud k r xkwfvm+yD; usaemfwd k @um;em;rSm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 47/208
47
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vmyH kxm;ygw,f// r vmwJ holawGud k b,folb,f0gawmh rodygbl;// usaemf hum;ay: ygvmwJ h olawGbJxifygw,f//
um;acgif;cef;xJu Ad kvf}uD;qd kwJ holuawmh “[kwfuJ h Ad kvfcsKyf/ [kwfuJ h/ [kwfuJ h” qd k+yD;
zkef; wvH k;eJ @ajymaewm awG @&ygw,f? c%aeawmh um;ab;u vlaoyH kud k um;ay: wifzk d @usaemf hud k cd kif;ygw,f// a&S @rSm&d kufaewJ h vltkyfxJud kvnf; ajcmufvH k;jyL;eJ @ (3/ 4)csuf vSrf;ypfvd kufao;w,f?
vlaoawGvm;/ arhajrmae=uovm;awmh rodbl;/ tm;vH k;uawmh aoG;awG&$ JepfaewmygyJ// usaemfud k,f wd kif xrf;wif&wmyg/ um;aemufcef;xJud kaygh// tm;vH k;(17)a,mufwdwdyJ? wifvd k @vnf;+yD;a&m um;ud k aemufa=umif; jyefvSnf harmif;cd kif;ygw,f// um;ay:uoCFef;0wfawG/ vl0wfawGawmh jyefyg rvmygbl;?
wjcm; acsmqG JcHxm;&wJ h (10) bD;um;awGvnf; 'D &d kufyG J}uD;ud kvmwm awG @&ygw,f?olwd k @ bmvkyf&ovJawmh rodygbl;// usaemfwd k @vnf; um;armif;vmvd kufwm tvH k&Gma&mufawmh um;&yfcd kif;+yD; aemufcef;u tavmif;(17)avmif;ud katmufcs+yD; vrf;ab;rSmyH kcd kif;ygw,f// Ad kvf}uD;qd kwJ holucd kif;wmyg// +yD;awmh um;ud k erc 0if;xJ jyefarmif;cd kif;ygw,f?
0if;xJrSm pm;yG JaomufyG JawG tqifoif hjyifxm;+yD;/ usaemfwd k @ud k0ifpm;cd kif;ygw,f//+yD;awmh wa,mufud k aiG(30000)usyfpD ay;ygw,f/
usaemfwd k @ pm;aomufaewkef; usaemfwd k @um;ud k wjcm;vlwa,muf armif;oGm; wmawG @&ygw,f// Ad kvf}uD; qd kwJ holu “'Dem;wifyg/ pdwfrylygeJ @” vd k @ajymygw,f//
um;u aemufae@ arv (31)&ufnaeavmufrS jyefa&mufvmygw,f// um;uk d ZGefv(1)&ufae@ reufusrS a&aq;+yD; qGrf;uyf&ygw,f// tvH kvrf;ab;csxm;cJ hwJ h tavmif;
(17)avmif;ud k bmvkyfovJawmh rodygbl;? ajymoH=um;wmawmh rD;&_ d @ypfw,fqd kvm;yJ?tck *dwfjyefxd k;+yD;/ vd kif;jyefqG Jaeygw,f” 2222222222
6?trdefŒay;pepfrsm;
tcsif;jzpfyGm;aeonf htcsdefwGif qufoG,fa&;pum;ajympufrsm;jzif h trdef @ay;n$ef=um;r_rsm; ðyvkyfcJ h onf?“a'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a&OD;ayguf wef @qnfaygufudk ydwf/“a'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a&OD;ayguf wef@qnfaygufud k ydwf/“a'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a&OD;ayguf wef @qnfaygufudk ydwf/“a'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a&OD;ayguf wef@qnfaygufud k ydwf/“a'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a&OD;ayguf wef @qnfaygufud k ydwf/pufuav; toif hjyif/ vd ktyfv#if fypf”pufuav; toif hjyif/ vd ktyfv#iffypf”pufuav; toif hjyif/ vd ktyfv#if fypf”pufuav; toif hjyif/ vd ktyfv#iffypf”pufuav; toifhjyif/ vd ktyfv#if fypf”
“atmifcdkifatmifEd kif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvdkvJ/ yd k@+yD;+yDvm;”“atmifcd kifatmifEd kif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ yd k @+yD;+yDvm;”“atmifcdkifatmifEd kif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvdkvJ/ yd k@+yD;+yDvm;”“atmifcd kifatmifEd kif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ yd k @+yD;+yDvm;”“atmifcd kifatmifEdkif b,fvdkvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ ydk @+yD;+yDvm;”2323232323
æ pojzif h wd kuf&d kuf!$ef=um;ajymqd kaeonfud k rsufjrifoufaorsm;u=um;odcJ h&onf? t=urf;zuf &d kufESufolrsm;ud k pepfwus&d kufESuf&eftrdef @ay;&mwGif “a&tzGJ @ wuf rD;tzG J @ wuf”“a&tzG J@ wuf rD;tzG J@ wuf”“a&tzGJ @ wuf rD;tzG J @ wuf”“a&tzG J@ wuf rD;tzG J@ wuf”“a&tzG J @ wuf rD;tzGJ @ wuf”[ktrdef @ay; cJ h+yD;aemuf/&d kufESuf+yD;csdefwGif “a&tzG J @ jyefr,f/ rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f ”“a&tzG J @ jyefr,f/ rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f ”“a&tzG J @ jyefr,f/ rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f ”“a&tzG J @ jyefr,f/ rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f ”“a&tzG J @ jyefr,f/ rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f ”pojzif htrdef @ay;cJ honf? xd ktrdef @ay;pepfonf wyfrawmfom;rsm;ESif h &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;omvsif tok H;ðyajymqd konf h pum;0Sufrsm;jzpfonf?
7? vkyf}uHrnfhol vklOD;a& (5000)cefŒud k pDpOfae&mcsxm;jcif;
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ud k pepfwusóudwifpDpOfaqmif&GufcJ h&mwGif toH k;jyKcJ honf hvltiftm;ud k etz. arv(31)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JwGif xkwfaz:ajymqd kcsufrsm;t& a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfud k raxmufcHol (5000)cef @u uef @uGufqENjy&mrSjzpfay:vmonf h t"du&k%f;tjzpfEd kifiHwumod k @wifjyajymqd kcJ honf? 2424242424 bkwvifòrd @rStxGufwGif c&D;onfwifum;rsm;twGif; =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;/ jynfol @pGrf;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 48/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
48
tm;&Sifrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm;wGif vlOD;a&(500)cef @ESif h erc 0if;twGif;rS vd kufygvmonf h (10)bD;um;rsm; (10)pD; wpD;vsifvl(50)E_ef;ESif h vl(500) pkpkaygif;vltiftm;(1000)cef @u 2525252525 a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @. ,mOfwef;aemufr Svd kufygcJ hygonf? 'DyJ,if;òrd @teD; vkyf=uHowfjzwf&efjyifqifxm;aom usnf&GmtvGef
qnfajrmif;0if;a&S @wGif vltiftm;(4000)cef @tm; óudwifae&mcsxm;cJ honfud k rsufjrifoufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;t& aumfr&SifrS od&S dcJ h&onf? 2626262626
a':atmifqef;pk=unf. ucsifjynfe,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfwavsmuf qef @usifqENjyuef @uGufolrsm;wGiftrsdK;orD;rsm;ESih ftrsdK;om;rsm; ae&mwd kif;wGifyg0ifcJ honfud kawG @&onf? od k @aomf 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_wGifrl t=urf;zufowfjzwfvkyf=uHrnf holrsm;onf trsdK;om;rsm;csnf;omjzpfonfrSm xl;jcm;onf htcsufw&yfjzpfonf? uef @uGufqENjy&H kr#omrubJ t+yD;owfvkyf=uHacsr_ef;&ef &nf&G,fxm;ojzif h trsdK;orD;rsm;ud k ac:,ljcif; rjyKcJ ha=umif; aumfr&SifuoH k;oyfawG @&S d&onf?
8 ? oufaotaxmuftxm;rsm;ud k azsmufzsufjcif;ESif h jyKjyifzefwD;jcif;
vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf usnf&GmteD;jzpfyGm;cJ honf h ta&;tcif;wGifoufaocHypPnf;rsm;tjzpfusef&pfcJ honf hum;rsm;/ armfawmfqd kifu,frsm;/ tjyif;txefxdcd kuf'%f&m&olrsm;/ aoqH k;olrsm;ud k nwGif;csif;yif ppfwyfESif hjynfol @&JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;u um;rsm;jzif ho,f,lI azsmufzsufypfcJ honf? t"du&k%f;jzpfonf hyH kpHtjzpfzefwD;Ed kif&ef bkwvifòrd @rStxGuf a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.,mOfwef;aemufrS t=urf;zuf&d kufESufolrsm;pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;ud kvnf; ‚if;wd k @ud k,fwd kifyif jyefvnfI rD;&_ d @zsufpD;cJ honf? 2727272727
t=urf;zuf&d kufESufr_rsm; +yD;onf htcsdef n(11)em&DcG Jcef @wGif tcsif;jzpfae&mod k @ ppfwyfESif h &JwyfzG J @t&m&S drsm; um;rsm;jzif ha&muf&S dvmonf? 2828282828 tcsif;jzpfae&mrsm;wGifusef&S dcJ honf h armfawmfum;rsm;teuf um;(4)pD;ud k ae&mtaetxm;rsm;a&$ @ajymif;I AG D'D,d kuifr&mjzif h rSwfwrf;wifonf// 2929292929
,cktcsdeftxd ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_=uD;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h axmufcHonf hjynfolrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygoGm;onf h armfawmf,mOfrsm;/ armfawmfqd kifu,frsm;ud k etz wm0ef&S dolrsm;u ,ae@wd kif azsmufzsufxm;qJjzpfonf?
9? rsufjrifoufaorsm;ESifh '%f&m&olrsm;tm;zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;xm;jcif;
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ud k ud k,fwd kifóuHawG @cJ h&aom rsufjrifoufaorsm;ESif h '%f&m&&S dcJ holrsm;ud k zrf;qD;cJ honf? tcsif;jzpfae&mrS xGufajy;vGwfajrmufoGm;onf holrsm;ud kvnf; vd kufvHzrf;qD;r_rsm; jyKvkyfcJ honf? vkyf=uHr_}uD;wGif '%f&mjyif;xefolrsm;ud k rH k&Gmòrd @&S d aq;wyfqG,ftrSwf(7)od k @ yd k @aqmif+yD;/ '%f&m rjyif;xefolrsm;ud k
a&$bd kaxmifod k @ yd k @aqmifcJ honf? qnfajrmif;0if;a&S @wGif zrf;qD;xm;onf hol (44)OD;ud k arv(31)&ufae@eHeufwGifa&$bd kaxmifod k @ yd k @aqmifcJ honf? a&$bd kaxmifwGifzrf;qD;csKyfaESmifjcif;cHxm;&olrsm;ud k wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(20)rS Ad kvf}uD;vif;aZmfuH OD;pD;onf htzG J @u ppfa=uma&;rsm;jyKvkyfcJ honf? 3030303030 a&$bd kaxmifwGif (12)&ufOya'ESifhtnDr[kwfbJ zrf;qD;csKyfaESmifxm;+yD; aemuf ar(30)'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESifhpyfvsOf;I zrf;qD;cHxm;&olrsm;teufrS trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if r[kwfolrsm;ud k jyefvnfvGwfay;cJ honf? xd kod k @jyefvnfvGwfay;rnf holrsm;ud k a&$bd kaxmifAl;0wGif axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(20)rSwyf&if;rª;qd kolu 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESih fywfoufI rnfol @ud kr#jyefvnfrajym&efESif h xd kod k @ajymqd kygu Ed kifiHwumowif;Xmersm;u toH k;csoGm;rnfjzpfa=umif;/ wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;uvnf; jyefvnfta&;,lrnfjzpfa=umif;wd k @ud k ud k,fwd kifvma&mufajymqd kI owday;jcdrf;ajcmufcJ honf? 3131313131
axmifrsm;wGifzrf;qD;csKyfaESmifcH&aom rsufjrifoufaorsm;ESif h'%f&m&olrsm;tm; &Ju pH kprf;ppfaq;jcif;r&S dbJ wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;uom wd kuf&d kufud kifwG,fppfaq;+yD; qufvufcsKyfaESmifxm;cJ honf? aemufyd kif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 49/208
49
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
wGif ta&;}uD;aomoufaorsm;rSvG JI usef oufaorsm;ud kjyefvnfv$wfay;&mwGifvnf; wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;.rsufarSmufwGif 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_jzpfpOfrsm;ud k jyefvnfxkwfazmfajymqd kjcif; rjyK&ef cH0efvufrSwfa&;xd k;cd kif;+yD;rSom jyefvnfv$wfay;cJ honf? ,if;wd k @rSm 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I tjzpfrSefud k
zH k;uG,fxm;Ed kif&ef tm%myd kifrsm;.vkyfaqmifcsufrsm;jzpfonf? ,cktcsdeftxd ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ESif hpyfvsOf;I a&$bd k/ uav;ESif hcE W D;tusOf;axmifrsm;wGifzrf;qD;xdef;odrf;csKyfaESmifxm;jcif;cH&olrsm;ud k jypfr_qd kif&mOya'jzif haomfvnf;aumif;/ txl; Oya'rsm;jzif haomfvnf;aumif;ta&;,lxm;onf[k etz u twd tvif;xkwfazmfajymqd kjcif; r&S dao;onfud kvnf; awG @&S d&onf?
xd k @tjyifta&;=uD;aomtcsufrSm 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_jzpfyGm;onf hae@rS pI (6)vjynf hajrmufonf htcsdeftxdjypfr_usL;vGefcJ hol (5000)teuf wOD;wa,mufud kr#ud kaomfvnf;aumif;/ ‚if;vl(5000)ud k trdef @ay; pDpOfnGef=um;cJ hol[k,lq&onf h wm0ef&S dtm%myd kif wOD;wa,mufud kr#aomfvnf;aumif;/ zrf;qD;jcif;/ ppfaq;ta&;,ljcif; vH k;0 r&S dao;acs// ,if;od k @ ta&;,lr_ wpH kw&mjyKvkyfcJ hvsif tjzpfrSefay:aygufvmrnfud kpd k;&drfI etztm%myd kifrsm;u zH k;uG,f&efóud;pm;r_rsm;jzpfa=umif; aumfr&SifrS oH k;oyfonf?
ed*H k;csKyfoH k;oyfcsuf
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;onf arv(30)&ufae@n(8)em&DwGif pwif+yD; n(11)em&DcG J(12)em&Dcef @wGif +yD;qH k;cJ honf? vkyf=uHr_jzpfyGm;+yD; (16)em&Dt=um arv(31)&ufae@nae(4)em&DrSmyif etzonf owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jac:,lI a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; axmufcHolrsm;ESif h qef @usifolrsm;t}um; jzpfyGm;aomyÉdyuQtjzpf urB mod k @ &Sif;vif;wifjycJ honf? tenf;qH k; vl(5000)ausmfyg0ifcJ haomjzpf&yf}uD; twGif; aoolao/ '%f&m&ol&/xGufajy;olajy;ESif h&SKwf&Sufcwfaeonf htcsdefwGif em&Dtenf;i,fr#twGif;ppfaq;+yD; ed*H k;csLyfoH k;oyfcsufwck
xkwfEd kif&efrSm rnfr#t&nftcsif;ESif hjynf hpH kI tawG @t=uHK&if husufaom pH kprf;ppfaq;a&;rSL;rsm; yg0ifppfaq;onfjzpfap vH k;0 rjzpfed kifyg? etzonf }udKwifjyifqifxm;aomtcsuftvufrsm; vufxJwGif toif h&S daeojzih fom ,if;uJ hod k @ csufjcif;owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG J ac:,l&Sif;jyEd kifjcif;jzpfonf? xif&Sm;aomtcsufrSm vkyf=uHr_}uD;jzpf+yD; +yD;jcif; arv(31)&ufae@eHufwGifzrf;qD;I a&$bd kaxmifod k @yd k @vd kufaom '%f&m&olrsm;ESif h rsufjrifoufao pkpkaygif;(146)OD;tm; etz axmufvSrf;a&;rsm;u ZGefv(1)&ufae@wGifrS pwif"gwfyH krsm;&d kuf,l=u+yD;ZGef fv (2)&ufae@ eHuf(9)em&D tcsdefa&mufrSom oufaowOD;csif;pDud k yxrqH k; pwif ppfaq;ed kifcJ honf? 2323232323
xd ktcsdef frSm etz. owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jusif;ytjyD; w&ufcG Jr#t=umyif&S daecJ hjyDjzpfonf?yd kIxif&Sm;aomtcsufrSm vkyf=uHr_jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf ,ae@tcsdeftxd (6)vwmumv =umvmcJ h+yDjzpf
aomfvnf; rnfonf hpH kprf;ppfaq;rSKrS xyfrH rjyKvkyfonf htjyif rnfonh fed*H k;csLyfawG @&S dcsuf topfud kr# xkwfjyefa=ujimed kifjcif; r&S dawmhyg? tb,fa=umif hqd kaomf“oHvsufawmf,lonf h olcd k;ud kv”oHvsufawmf,lonf h olcd k;ud kv”oHvsufawmf,lonf h olcd k;ud kv”oHvsufawmf,lonf h olcd k;ud kv”oHvsufawmf,lonf h olcd k;ud kv” [lI jrefrmqd k&dk;pum;wckwGif yg&S dcJ honf htwd kif; 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ud k pepfwusóudwif=uHpnfusL;vGefolrSm etz ud k,fwd kifjzpfaeojzif hrnfonh fpH kprf;ppfaq;r_ud kr# xyfrHjyKvkyfp&m rvd kawmhaoma=umif hyifjzpfonf? Ttcef;.txufwGif wifjyxm;cJ hjyD;aom tcsuftvuftaxmuftxm;rsm;t&vnf; y%mr pH kprf;ppfaq;awG @&S dcsufrsm;t& w&m;cHrSmetz omjzpfa=umif; xif&Sm;ay:vGifaeay+yD?
Tae&mwGif etzonf Tr#}uD;rm;aom&mZ0wfr_}uD;ud k tb,fa=umif h rnfod k @aomOD;wnfcsufjzif h&uf&ufpufpufusL;vGefjcif;jzpfygoenf;? a':atmifqef;pk=unfuJ hod k @ urB mausmfEd kA,f+idrf;csrf;a&;qk&Sifud kyifqef @usifI wurB mvH k;.a&S @arSmufY tb,fa=umif hajymifajymifwif;wif; jypfr_usL;vGefcJ hjcif; jzpfygoenf;?
etztm; qENpG Jt+iKd; tmCmwrsm;jzif h vG,fvif hwulpGyfpG Jvd kaomoabmrsdL;ud ka&Smifv$ Jum aumfr&Sifonf ,sxmblwusus tcsuftvufrsm;tay:wGifomtajccHI tajzwckxkwfed kif&ef }udK;pm;cJ hygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 50/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
50
xd ktcg jzpfed kifajc(2)&yfud k awG @&ygonf?yxrw&yfrSm etzonf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csLyf. vlxkpnf;&H k;a&;vkyfief;
rsm; &yfwef @oGm;atmif ajcmufvSef @vd konf hoabmjzif homusL;vGef&mrS vufvGefoGm;=u+yD; vlaygif;tajrmuftrsm; aoa=uoGm;=ujcif;jzpfed kifonf?'kwd,w&yfrSm a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h OD;wifOD;wd k @tm; taovkyf=uHum trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pD tzG J @csLyf
w&yfvH k;ud k tjywfajcr_ef;vd konf hoabmjzif h usL;vGefjcif;vnf;jzpfEk difonf? jzpfEk difajc yxrw&yfud k OD;pGmoH k;oyfygonf? trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J@csLyf. vlxkpnf;&H k;a&;vkyfief;rsm;&yfwef @oGm; atmifajcmufvSef @&H koufoufomqd kv#if ² ² ²
(1) Tr#}uD;rm;aomvltiftm;udk toHk;jyKp&m rvdk? a':atmifqef;pk=unf,mOfwef;xuf ESpfqoH k;qru rsm;jym;aom vlwaxmifcef @r#ud komtoH k;jyKv#if atmifjrifed kifygonf?
(2) pepfwusjyKvkyfxm;onf h vlud kaoaped kifavmufaomvufeufrsm;ud k toH k;jyKp&m rvd k? vrf;ab;wGif tvG,fwul&ed kifaom ausmufcJrsm;/ wkwfrsm;jzif hom ypfayguf+cdrf;ajcmufed kifonf?
(3) v#dK@0SufoauFwrsm;/ vufywfrsm;/ qufoG,fa&;pepfrsm;toH k;jyKI jypfrSKusL;vGefrnf h olrsm;tm;pepfwusavhusif hay;+yD; qkwf wuf jyKvkyfumwd kufcd kuf&ef rvd k? vltkyfvd kuf v$wfay;umtvG,fwul&efp+yD;&kef;&if;qefcwfr_jzpfatmifjyKum +cdrf;ajcmufed kifonf?
(4) tm%myd kifrsm;. vufeufud kiftzG J @tpnf;rsm;jzpfaom ppfwyf/ &J ponfrsm;rS wm0ef&S dolrsm; ud k,fwd kif }uD;=uyfaqmif&Guf&ef rvd k? }uH hzG H @ tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif homv$wfay;+yD; jy\emjzpfatmifvkyfed kifonf?
(5) etz tm%myd kifrsm;ud k,fwd kif }udKwif}uHpnf+yD; pepfwususL;vGefaomjypfrSK}uD; r[kwfv#if xdrf0SufzH k;uG,fxm;&ef rvd k? Ek difiHwumtygt0if r,H kouFmjzpfonf hyk*d ~Kvfrsm;/ tzG J @tpnf; rsm;ud k ay:ay:xifxifvm
a&mufavhvmppfaq;cGif hay;ed kifonf? +cdrf;ajcmufaESmif h,Suf&H kom wm0efay;xm;cJ haomfvnf; ,if;xufyd kIvltajrmuftrsm;ud kaoapcJ honftxd jypfrSKusL;vGefcJjhcif;rsdK;jzpfvsif xd kolrsm;ud kazmfxkwfta&;,led kifonf?
od k @&mwGif etz.vkyfaqmifcsufrsm;onf txufygtcsufrsm;ESif h vH k;0qef @usifaea=umif; atmufygtwd kif; awG @&onf?
(1) rnfod k @wd kufcd kufajcr_ef;&rnfud k pepfwus=udKwifoifwef;rsm;ay;cJ honf?(2) vlud kaoaped kifavmufonftxd t&G,ftpm;twd kif;twmyrm%&S daom vufeufrsm;ud k toif hjyif
qif ud kifaqmiftoH k;jyKaponf?
(4) wdkufcd kufajcr_ef;onf h enf;pepf/ tcsdefumv/ owfuGif;rsm;ud k pepfwusa&G;cs,fum qufoG,fa&;ypPnf;rsm;/ um;}uD;rsm;ESif h qvd kufrD;uJ hod k @taxmuftuljyKypPnf;rsm;ud ktoH k;jyKI tifESif htm;ESif h usL;vGefcJ honf?
(5) Ad kvfrSL;/ Ad kvf}uD;tqif h&S daom wyfrawmfrSwm0ef&S dolrsm;/ pcef;rSL;tqif h&S daom&JwyfzG J @rSL;rsm;ud kyifjypfr_usL;vGefrnf holrsm;tm; wd kuf&d kufuGyfuJapI ppfqifa&;}uD;wckozG,f vkyfaqmifcJ honf?
(6) jypfr_usL;vGefrnf holrsm;tm; ppfud kif;wd kif;twGif; a'otoD;oD;rS vlOD;a&(5000) cef @r#&&S datmifpepfwuspkaqmif;/ jzef @cG Jr_rsm;jyKvkyfcJ honf?
(7) jypfr_ rusL;vGefcif owif;rxGufatmif ydwfqd k hcJ hrSKrsm;/ jypfrSKusL;vGef+yD;aemuf oufaocHypPnf;ESif htavmif; azsmufzsufr_rsm;/ oufaocHxGufqd krnf holrsm;tm; jcdrf;ajcmufwm;qD;/ zrf;qD;xm;r_ rsm;rSm jypfr_}uD;
wckvH k; vH k;0 tpte rxGufap&ef}udK;yrf;r_rsm;jzpfa=umif;awG @&onf?(&) a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;axmufcHolrsm;ESif h qef @usifolrsm;t=um;jzpfyGm;aom yÉdyuQ[lI toif h
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 51/208
51
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
jyifqifxm;+yD;aom ta=umif;jycsuf&S daeonf? ,if;yÉdyuQtwGif; a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k qef @usifolrsm;u&d kufeSuf=u&m vufvGefIuG,fvGefoGm;cJ h+yD[k ta=umif;jyEk difonf?
txufygtcsufrsm;ud k axmuf&_I etzonf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdL;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @ csKyf.
vlxkpnf;&H k;a&;vkyfief;rsm;&yfwef @oGm;atmif ajcmufvSef @vd konf hoabmjzif hom 'DyJ,if;t=urf;zufr_}uD;ud kusL;vGefcJ honf[laomtcsufud k Ty%mrtpD&ifcHpmwifonf htqif hrSmyif aumfr&Siftaejzif h vufcHEk difbG,fr&S dacs? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h OD;wifOD;wd k @tm;taovkyf}uHI trsdL;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csLyfud k tjywfajcr_ef;vd konf hoabmjzif h usL;vGefcJ honf h&mZ0wfr_}uD;jzpfonf[k oH k;oyfonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; t"duOD;wnfvkyf=uHcJ honf h }udK;yrf;r_rsm;tjzpf atmufygtwd kif; tqif h oH k;qif hud kawG @&S d&onf?
(1) jyif;xefpGm&d kufESufwd kufcd kufr_a=umif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k 0d kif;&HumuG,fv#uf vH kòcHa&;wm0ef,lxm;=uonf h vli,ftajrmuftrsm;rSm twH k;t&H k;vJusukefus+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unfxd kifaeonf hum;. aemufrSefud kyif xd k;azgufcJ h=u+yD;jzpfonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;armif;ol ud kausmfpd k;vif;rS ‚if;.ud k,fyd kifqH k;jzwfcsufjzif h xd k;azgufarmif;xGufed kifIom yxrowfuGif;ae&mrS vGwfajrmufoGm;cJ hjcif;jzpfonf?
(2) xd kod k @xd k;azgufxGufvmaom a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k 'd kifemum;(2)pD;jzif h twif;0ifa&mufwd kufcd kuf&ef qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;rS tm%myd kifrsm;u trdef @ay;cJ h&m xd kum;(2)pD;ud k wdrf;a&Smifed kifcJ honf htjyif}udKwifwm;qD;xm;onf hoHql;}udK;(3)wef;ud kyg xd k;azmufjzwfausmfarmif;ESifEk difcJ hojzif hom 'kwd,owfuGif;ae&mrS vGwfajrmufvmcJ hjcif;jzpfonf?
(3) ¶d kufESufwd kufcd kufvkyf}uHonf ht=um;rS vGwfajrmufoGm;onf hum;rsm;ud k ydwfqd k @zrf;qD;&ef/ vd ktyfygu ypfcwfzrf;qD;&ef qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;&S d Ad kvfrª;wOD;u OD;aqmifn$ef=um;aecJ honf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; xd k;azmufjzwfausmf armif;ESifxGufoGm;onf htcsdefwGif qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;rS ypfrdef hay;oHrsm;ESif h
aoewfoHrsm;ud k=um;cJh&onf h oufaorsm;&S donf? od k @jzpfI a':atmifqef;pk=unfrSm tqd kygypfcwfr_rsm;t=um;rS vGwfajrmufvmcJ honf[k ,lqed kifonf?
od k @jzpfI etzonf a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k vkyf=uHEk difavmufonftxd pOf;pm;pDpOfcJ hjcif;rSm tb,fa=umif henf;[k qufvufoH k;oyf&ef vd ktyfvmygonf? rvkyf=uHv#if rjzpfEk difawmhonf htajctae a&muf&S dae+yD/a':atmifqef;pk=unf toufxif&Sm;&S dae+yD; Ek difiHa&;vkyfief;rsm;qufvufvkyfaqmifEk difaeao;v#if rdrdwd k @tm%mwnfjrJa&;rSm vH k;0 tmrcHcsuf r&S dawmh[k etzu ¶_jrifvmyH k&onf? t}uD;tus,fpd k;&drfvmyH k&onf?,if;od k @ pd k;&drf&onf haemufcHta=umif;rSm etzonf vufawG @wGif wd kif;jynfud kv$rf;rd k;tkyfcsLyf&mY tcuftcJaygif;pH kESif h awG @}uHKae&onf?
tajccHjynfolvlxk. pD;yGm;a&;/ vlr_a&;jyoemrsm;ud k vH k;0 r&Sif;ed kif? vlxkw&yfvH k;rSm wae@xuf wae@t=uyftwnf;rsm; yd kIawG @vmae&onf? tdrfeD;csif;ek difiHrsm;jzpfaom w&kyf/ tdEN d,ESif h xd kif; ek difiHwd k @xHrS wpH kw&m tultnDrsm;&&Sdaeaomfvnf; wdkif;jynf.pD;yGm;a&;OD;armhvmaponftxd tajymif;tvJvkyfEkdifavmufatmif r&&S dcJ h? b%fjyoemrsm;jzpfyGm;cJ h+yD;aemuf aiGrJrsm;jzif husm;uefaeojzif hom pD;yGm;a&;òydvJ roGm;cJ haomfvnf; Oya'pd k;rd k;a&; r&S daoma=umif h Ek difiHjcm;rS&if;ES D;jrKyfES Honf h ukr%Dtajrmuftrsm; qkwfcGmoGm;r_rsm;tygt0if pD;yGm;a&;t=uyftwnf;rSm }uD;rm;onfxuf }uD;rm;vmaecJ honf?
wd kif;&if;om;vufeufud kiftzG J @tpnf;tawmfrsm;rsm;ESif h typftcwf&yfpJa&;vkyfxm;+yD;aemuf +idrf;csrf;a&;&ae+yD[k etzrSaºuG;ausmfaeaomfvnf; ‚if;tzG J @tpnf;rsm;ud k,fwd kifu Ek difiHa&;t& rnfonf hoabmwlnDcsufr# r&ao;acs? etzESif h typftcyf&yfpJa&;rvkyfbJ qufvufwd kufyG J0ifaeonf h wd kif;&if;om;vufeufud kif
tzG J @tpnf;tawmfrsm;rsm;vnf; &S daeao;onf? xd k @tjyif jynfwGif;rS Ed kifiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm;/ v_yf&Sm;wufºuGolrsm;/ jynfolrsm;. trSefw&m;ud k &J0H @pGmxkwfazmfajymqd kr_rsm;rSm +yD;cJ honf hwESpfausmftcsdefumvwGif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 52/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
52
t&S def&vma=umif;awG @&onf? jynfywGifa&muf¶S dae=uaom 'Drd kua&pDa&;tiftm;pkrsm;ESif h wd kif;&if;om; tiftm;pkrsm;. óud;yrf;r_rsm;a=umif hvnf; etz. rw&m;tkyfcsLyfr_rsm;ud k urB mu wjznf;jznf;yd kIyd kIodvmaeonf? tar&duef/ uae'g/ t*Fvef/ Oa&myor*~/ *syefpaom 'Drd kua&pDed kifiH}uD;rsm;. zdtm;rSmvnf; wjznf;
jznf; wd k;wufvmaeonf? od k @jzpfI etzonf Ek difiHa&;t&vnf; xGufayguf&Sm&cufonf htajctaeod k @ wjznf;jznf; a&mufvmv#uf¶S donf? TwGif ‚if;wd k @ qufvuftm%mwnfjrJa&;twGuf pd k;&drfr_rsm;&S dvmrnfrSm taotcsmjzpfonf?
Tod k @aom aemufcHtajctaersm;atmufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfrSOD;aqmifI wd kif;ESif hjynfe,f toD;oD;od k @ pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;xGufcJ h&m r,H kEk difp&maumif;avmufatmifyif atmifjrifr_rsm;&vmonf? c&D;pOfwck+yD;wck vlxkaxmufcHr_yk dIyd kI&vmcJ honf? etz tm%myd kifrsm;/ =uH hzG H @rsm;. [ef @wm;aESmuf,Sufr_rsm;t=um;rSyif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @tm; axmifaomif;csDaomjynfolrsm;u vd _ufvd _ufvS JvS Jóudqd k=uonf? txufjrefrmjynfpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;rSm tatmifjrifqH k;jzpfonf? vlyifv,f}uD;wr# tm;aumif;vSaomvlxk}uD;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdL;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csLyftm; axmufcHa=umif;jzif h vrf;rrsm;ay:od k @ ajymif ajymifwif;wif;xGuf+yD; vufckwf=obmrsm; aomif;aomif;nHay;Ijyo=uonf? vlxk'Da&vd _if;wHydk;}uD;onf wjznf;jznf;ºuGwufvmcJ honf? txufjrefrmjynfrSwqifh atmufjrefrmEd kifiHw0Srf;vH k;odk @ul;pufysH @ES H @um etz. tkyfcsLyfr_ud k ud kifv_yfawmhrnf htaetxm;od k @ OD;wnfvmcJ honf?
Tod k @aomtajctaeatmufwGif etzonf aemufqH k;vufeufud komxkwfoH k;&awmhonf? ,if;rSmEk difiHawmft=urf;zufr_ (State Terrorism)ud k usif hoH k;+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @tm; t=urf;zufajcr_ef;IwjynfvH k;Y ta=umufw&m;}uD;}uD;rm;rm;jzpfay:atmif zefwD;um etz tm%mwnfjrJa&;ud k rjzpfraequfvufwnfaqmufoGm;&efjzpfonf? ,if;rSm 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ud k etz usL;vGef&onf htajccHta=umif;jzpfonf[k aumfr&SifrS oH k;oyfonf?
wcsdefwnf;wGif 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I ,cktcsdeftxd aumfr&SifrS vufvSrf;rrDojzif h rodEd kifao;aom ta=umif;tcsufrsm;pGm &S daeqJjzpfonf?'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_=uD;ud k etz. xdyfyd kif;acgif;aqmifrsm;xJrSrnfol. wd kuf&d kuftrdef @ay;n$ef=um;csuft& usL;vGefcJ honf/ rnfod k @aom r[mAsL[mpD rHcsufcsrSwfI usL;vGefcJ honf/ vufawG @owfuGif;wGif ±k dufESufowfjzwfr_usL;vGef&ef rnfolrsm; rnfod k @rnfyH k cG Ja0wm0ef,lcJ h=uonf?tavmif;rsm;ud k rnfonf hae&mrsm;wGif rnfod k @ rnfyH k azsmufzsufxm;cJ honf pojzif h aumfr&SifrS razmfxkwfEd kifaomta=umif;tcsufrsm;pGm&S daeqJjzpfonf?
od k @&mwGif Ty%mrtpD&ifcHpmY pkpnf;wifjyxm;aom rsufjrifoufaoxGufcsufrsm; tjcm;taxmuftxm;rsm;/ ywf0ef;usiftajctaersm;ud koH k;oyfum 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;wGif etz.wm0ef&S dr_rSmrl jiif;uG,f
r&atmif ay:vGifvsuf&S donf? tao;pdyftcsuftvufrsm; yd krd kIwdusjynf hpH kpGm od&S dazmfxkwfEd kif&efrSmrl tcsif;jzpfae&mud k oGm;a&muf=unf h&_ppfaq;um rsufjrifoufaorsm;/ cHpm;cJ h&onf h um,uH&Sifrsm;/ wm0ef&S detztm%myd kifrsm;ud k Ed kifiHwumrS todtrSwfjyKvufcHEd kifaom t&nftcsif;ESif h jynf hpH kIvGwfvyfaom pH kprf;a&;aumfr&Sifw&yfrS tcsdef,lumppfaq;=um;em+yD;rSom jynf hpH kaomtpD&ifcHpmud k ed*H k;csKyfoH k;oyfcsufESif htwlwifoGif;Ed kifrnf jzpfayonf?
( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )
(1) jynfwGif;rS aumfr&Sifod k @wd kuf&d kufay;yd k @aomowif;tcsuftvufrsm;/
(2) trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. arv (27)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyg a=unmcsuftrSwf/6(5§03)ESif h jynfwGif;rSaumfr&Sifod k @ay;yd k @onf h owif;tcsuftvufrsm;? toHv$if hXmersm;ESif hqufoG,fajym=um;csufrsm;?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 53/208
53
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
(3) 0ÀarmifESif h armifzd k;aZmf(c) armifaZmfwd k @. oufaotjzpftppfcHcsufrsm;ESif howif;Xmersm;od k @xkwfazmfajym=um; csufrsm;?
(4) arv(31)&ufae@wGifjyKvkyfonf h etz.owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JESih f rsufjrifoufaorsm;.xGufqd kcsufrsm;?
(5) ud katmifatmifESif h ud kEd kifEd kifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(6) ud kEk difEd kifESif h ud katmifatmifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(7) a':nGef @nGef @ESif h ud krif;odef;wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/ jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif hawG @qH kar;jref;csuf
rsm;?(8) aZmfaZmfatmif/ 0Àarmif/ ud krif;odef;/ a':nGef @nGef @/ ud kcifOD;wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?
(9) a':nGef @nGef @ESif hud krif;odef;wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(10) a':nGef @nGef @. jynfyowif;Xmersm;od k @jyefvnfajymjycsufrsm;?(11) 0Àarmif/a':nGef @nGef @/ rif;odef;/ wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(12) ud kEd kifEd kif/ ud katmifatmif/ armifzd k;aZmf(c)armifaZmfwd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(13) ud kEd kifEd kif.oufaoxGuf qd kcsuf?(14) ud kEd kifEd kif.oufaoxGuf qd kcsuf?(15) armifzd k;aZmf(c) armifaZmf ESif hud krif;odef;wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(16) ud kEd kifEd kifESif hud katmifatmifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?
(17) ud katmifatmifESif h ud kEd kifEd kifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/ jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif hawG @qH k ar;jref;csufrsm;?
(18) aumfr&Sifod k @ jynfwGif;rSwd kuf&d kufay;yd k @onf howif;tcsuftvufrsm;t& a&$bd kc&d kif(c,u)OuUXjzpfol Ad kvfr_;=uD;oef;[ef [kod&S d&onf/ aumfr&Siftaejzif htwnfjyKEd kif&efqufvufpH kprf;qJjzpfonf?
(19) ud kEd kifEd kif/ ud katmifatmif/wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/(20) ud kEd kifEd kif.xGufqd kcsuf?(21) ud kEd kifEd kif.xGufqd kcsuf?(22) ud kausmfvGifjynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif hqufoG,fajym=um;csuf?(23) ud kEd kifEd kifESif hud katmifatmifwd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(24) ZGefv(1)&ufae@xkwfjrefrmhtvif;owif;pmyg/ ar(31)&ufae@nae(4)em&DwGifjyKvkyfonf hetz.
owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG J?(25) ud kausmfvGif.jynfyowif;Xmersm;ESif hawG @qH kar;jref;csufrsm;?(26) ud kEd kifEd kif/ ud katmifatmif/ ud kzd k;aZmf ESif h0Àarmifwd k @. oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(27) ud krif;odef; ESif ha':nGef @nGef @wd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(28) ud kaZmfaZmfatmif/.jynfyowif;XmeESif hawG @qH kar;jref;csufESif h ud krif;odef;.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?(29) ud kaZmfaZmfatmif. jynfyowif;XmeESif hawG @qH kar;jref;csuf?(30) ud kEd kifEd kif/ESif h ud katmifatmif wd k @. tppfcHcsufrsm;/ ud kaZmfaZmfatmifESif h awG @qH kar;jref;csufrsm;/
(31) ud kEd kifEd kifESif hud katmifatmifwd k @.oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;?(32) ud kEd kifEd kif.oufaoxGufqd kcsuf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 54/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
54
tcef; ( 5 )
(1) uk dcifOD;(2) 0Àarmif
(3) a':!Gef @!Gef @(4) uk drif;odef;
(5) armifzk d;aZmf (ac: ) armifaZmf
(6) uk datmifatmif(7) uk dEk difEk dif
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+}uD;ukd jrifawGŒcJh&onfh
rsufjrifoufaorsm;. xGufqkdcsufrsm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 55/208
55
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
r&rf;ukef;òrdŒe,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG JŒcsKyf (òrdŒe,fpnf;&H k;a&;tzGJŒ0if)
ud kcifOD;. uwdopPmjyKxGufqd kcsuf
trnftrnftrnftrnftrnf uk dcifODukdcifODuk dcifODukdcifODuk dcifOD;touf (37)ESpfarG;ae@ouU&mZf 3-9-1966tztrnf OD;vSxGef;trdtrnf a':cifpk
rSwfyk HwiftrSwf trf0k dif*sD 163 815vlrsKd; jrefrmbmom Ak'<bmomynmt&nftcsif; tXrwef;ae&yfvdyfpm trSwf (71 )/ ol&vrf; / ( 9 )&yfuGuf/ r&rf;ukef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefwk dif;
usaemfarmifcifOD;onf 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_ESif hpyfvsOf;I uwdopPmjyKxGufqd konfrSm æ
1? rdrd.trnfrSm cifOD;jzpf+yD;/ zcifOD;vSxGef;ESif hrdcif a':cifpk wd k @rS rauG;wd kif;/ òrdifòrd @e,f/ vuf,ufraus;&Gm Y 1966 ckESpf pufwifbmv(3)&ufae@wGif arG;zGm;cJ hygonf?
18-3-88 aom=umae@wGif &efukefòrd @/ odrf}uD;aps;(pD)&H ka&S @wGif qENjy/ qlylr_rsm;jzpfyGm;+yD; tm%myk difrsm;u zrf;qD;I tif;pdeftusOf;axmifwGif (3)veD;yg; xdef;odrf;jcif;cHch J&onf? 1-6-88 ae@wGif jyefvnfvGwfajrmufcJ hygonf//
trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J @csKyf pwifxlaxmifonh f 27-9-88 rSpI tzG J @csKyfok d @ 0ifa&mufcJ hygonf? tzG J @0iftrSwf(2401247)+zif h tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if jzpfvmcJ hygonf? xk d @aemuf tzG J @csKyf òrd @e,fvli,f/ b¾ma&;rSL;wm0ef/1990 jy!f hESpf ygwDpk H'Drk dua&pDtaxGaxGa±G;aumufyG JumvwGif r&rf;ukef;òrd @e,f/ tzJ G @csKyf/ a&G;aumufyJ G atmif
Ek difa&;aumfrwDwGif owif;ESih f jyef=um;a&;/ vk H+cKHa&;wm0ef ponh f wm0efrsm;uk d yl;wG Jxrf;aqmifcJ hygonf//2? 10-7-95 tzJ G @csKyf/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf aetdrftus,fcsKyfrS jyefvnfvGwfajrmufvm+yD;aemuf/ r&rf;ukef;òrd @e,f/ tzJ G @csKyf/ qufoG,fa&;zdwf=um;a&;vli,ftzJ G @ (vli,fvkyfief;tzJ G @)wm0efcH(3)tjzpf wm0efay;tyf+cif; cHcJ h&ygonf? &efukefwd kif;/ qufoG,fzdwf=um;a&;vli,ftzJ G @. vrf;n$efr_jzif h tzG J @csKyf. Ek difiHa&;vkyfief;/ pnf;&k H;a&;vkyfief;/ tzJ G @twGif;vk H+cKHa&;vkyfief;rsm;uk d vkyfuk difcJ honf? 9-9-98 ae@wGif tzJ G @csKyf. jynfol @v$wfawmfac:,la&; vkyfief;pOfwGif yg0ifaqmif&GufcJ hojzif h tm%myk difrsm;u&JrGefwyfòrd @/ wyfr(11)/ c-r-&(215)wGif xdef;odrf;cJ hygonf//
21-12-98ae@wGif jyefvnfvGwfajrmufcJ h+yD; r&rf;ukef;òrd @e,f/ tzJ G @csKyf/ pnf;±k H;a&;tzG J @/ wG Jzuf twGif;a&;rª;tjzpf 2002ckESpftxd wm0efxrf;aqmifcJ honf? xk d @aemuf òrd @e,fpnf;±k H;a&;tzG J @0iftjzpf qufvuf
wm0efxrf;aqmifcJ hygonf?24- 8- 2000 ae@ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf. &efukefwk dif;/ wG Haw;òrd @e,f vli,f
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 56/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
56
vkyfief;tzG J @ zG J @pnf;a&;c&D;pOfwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. teD;uyfvk H+cKHa&;wm0ef&d SolwOD;taejzif h vk dufygch Jonf? tm%myk difrsm;u xk dc&D;pOftm; aESmih f,Suf[ef @wm;cJ honf? &JwyfzG J @ &Jrª;csKyf atmifEG,f/ 'k &Jrª;}uD;rsKd;vGifwk d @u rdrdwk d @tm; 'vòrd @/ usefppfom;&yfuGuf±S d v,fuGif;jyifwGif 1-9- 2000 ae@txd rw&m; wm;qD;
ydwfyifch Jonf? 1-9-2000 ae@/ (11;45)em&D tcsdefcef @wGif rdrdwk d @tm; twif;t"rRa&wGifESpfI/vufxdyfcwf+yD;zrf;qD;ch Jonf?xk d @aemuftrSwf(54) wuUok dvf&dyfomvrf;/ &efukefòrd @&d S taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. aetdrfok d @ yk d @aqmif+yD; rdrdwk d @tm; tus,fcsKyfcsxm;ch Jonf// 14-9-2000 ae@wGif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif htwltus,fcsKyfrS v$wfa+rmufcJ hygonf//
3? 21- 9-2000ae@ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL; a':atmifqef;pk=unf. Ek difiHa&;vkyfief;pOfwckjzpfonh frE Wav;wk dif;/ vli,fvkyfief;tzG J @ zG J @pnf;a&;c&D;pOfwGif rdrdESih f uk dat;xGef; (A[k dvli,f-taxmuftuljyKtzJ G @/tzG J @0if)wk d @u um;eHygwf 7u§ 5661 jzif h a&S @ajy;vk H+cKHa&;wm0ef,l&ef 19-9-2000ae@wGif&efukefrS óudwifxGufcGmch Jonf? xd kae@n (12; 00)em&DtcsdefY &efukefòrd @jyif&d S axmuf=uH @ppfaq;a&;*dwfwGif ppftm%myk difrsm;.
zrf;qD;xdef f;odrf;jcif;ud k cHcJ h&ygonf//rdrdwk d @ (2)OD;tm; A[k daxmufvSrf;a&;wyf/ ppfa=uma&;Xme (a&=unftk dif)wGif ,m,D xdef;odrf;ch Jonf?
tzJ G @csKyf A[k dtvkyftrlaqmiftzG J @0ifrsm; vGwfajrmufcsdefwGif rdrdwk d @vnf; jyefvnfvGwfajrmufvmcJ hygonf?xk d @aemuf tzG J @csKyf. Ek difiHa&;vkyfief; pOfrsm;tm; qufIwm0ef,lcJ hygonf? 6-5-2002 ae@wGif ppftm%myk difrsm;u tzG J @csKyf/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; aetdrftus,fcsKyfcsxm;jcif;rS jyefvnfv$wfay;cJ h+yD;aemuf rdrdonf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. vk H+cKHa&;wm0efrsm;ud k atmufygtwk dif; xrf;aqmifcJ hygonf//
(1) omrn c&D;pOf 14-6-2002 rS 15-6-2002(2) rauG;wk dif;/ rE Wav;wk dif;c&D;pOf 20-6-2002 r 29-6-2002(3) rGef+ynfe,fc&D;pOf 20-7-2002 rS 23-7-2002(4) yJcl;wk dif;taemuf+crf;c&D;pOf 13-7-2002 rS 17-7-2002(5) ±Srf;+ynfe,fc&D;pOf 13-11-2002 rS 27-11-2002(6) &ck difjynfe,f/{&m0wDwk dif;c&D;pOf 16-12-2002 rS 24-12-2002
a':atmifqef;pk-unf. &efukefwkdif;/ wG Haw;òrdŒe,f vli,f vkyfief;tzG JŒ zG JŒ pnf;a&;c&D;pOfuk d
'vòrdŒ usefppfom;&yfuGuf±S d v,fuGif;jyifwGif 24=8= 200 &ufaeŒ rS 1=9= 2000 aeŒ txd
etz tm%myk difwk dŒ rw&m; wm;qD;ydwfyifch JpOfu
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 57/208
57
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
(7) csif;+ynfe,fc&D;pOf 3-4-2003 rS 13-4-2003(8) yJcl;wk dif;/ yJcl;òrd @e,f y¾dw&mr awm&y&d,wW d pmoifwk duftvSLc&D;pOf(9) ucsif+ynfe,f/ ppfuk dif;wk dif;/ rE Wav;wk dif;c&D;pOfrsm;
xk d @jyif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. aetdrf+cH0if;vk H+cKHa&;/ &efukefwk dif;twGif;c&D;pOfrsm;wGif teD;uyfvk H+cKHa&;ponh fwm0efrsm;uk d xrf;aqmifcJ hygonf//
4? 6-5-2003 eHeuf(5)em&DwGif ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOf pwif&ef a':atmifqef;pk=unf. aetdrfjcHtwGif;rS xGufcGmcJ h=uygonf// a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;. um;a&S @cef;wGif ,mOfarmif; ud krsKd;nGef @ (rE W av;)ESif htwlud kxGef;aZmfaZmf/ tv,fcef;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfvk dufygch Jonf? aemufcef;wGif rdrdESih ftwl ud krif;vGif/ud krd k;aZmf/ ud koef;xGef;/ ud krsdK;!Gef @/ ud koufxGef;/ ud kwd k;vGifwk d @ vd kufygvmonf? arv (6)&ufae@ n(12)em&Dcef @wGif rE Wav;ok d @ a&muf&d Sch Jonf?
OD;wifOD; awmif;athpfum;wGif rE Wav;wd kif;rS OD;atmifpk d;(,mOfarmif;)/ A[k dvli,fvkyfief;tzJ G @. jyef=um;a&;tzG J @0ifrsm;jzpfonh f ud kodef;pd k;/ ud kjrif hausmfwd k @ vd kufygvmcJ hygonf?
OD;pdef0if; (yJcl;wd kif;/tif;waumfòrd @e,f pnf;&H k;a&; aumfrwD)armif;ESifonf h 'd kifemum;wGif OD;vSrif;/ OD;xGef;jrif h/ ud katmifxl;/ ud kausmfZif0if;wd k @ vd kufyg vmonf?
5? ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOftwGif; vrf;c&D;wavsmufwGif atmufygtwd kif;aESmih f,SufcHch J&onf?10-5-2003&ufae@/ n(9)em&Dcef @wGif ppfud kif;wd kif;/tif;awmfòrd @od k @a&muf&S dygonf? tif;awmfòrd @t0if
wGif ppfud kif;wd kif;/ rH k&Gmc¶d kif}uH hzH G @twGif;a&;rª;jzpfonf h OD;aX;atmifOD;pD;onf h tiftm;(70)rS(100)t=um;&S d}uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u rdrdwd k @ud k atmf[pfIqENjycJ h=uygonf? wkwfc|ef/ 0g;&if;wkwf/ ausmufcJponh f vufeufrsm;ud k
atmufwGif toih fcsxm;+yD; qENjyaejcif;jzpfonf? xd kawG @&S dcsufrsm;ud k tzJ G @csKyf. jyef=um;a&;tzJ G @u AG D'D,d k/"gwfyH krsm;jzih f&k duful;I rSwfwrf;wifxm;ygonf?
11-5-2003 &ufae@ tif;awmfrS uom+rdK@od k @xGufcGmch Jonf? uomok d @ ra&mufrD (2)rd kifcef @tvd kwGifrH k&Gmc&d kif/ }uH hzH G @twGif;a&;rª;jzpfol OD;aX;atmifacgif;aqmifonh f }uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;/ tca=u;aiGay;I ac:xm;olrsm;ud k rdrdwd k @ awG @&ygonf?tif;awmfwGif awG @&ouJ hod k @ rdrdwd k @tm; qef @usifqENjy=urnf h vlta&twGuf(500)cef @ teD;wGif wkwfrsm;/ ausmufcJrsm;ud k awG @&S dcJ h&ygonf//
rH k&Gmc&d kif/ =uH hzG H @toif;/ twGif;a&;rª;jzpfol OD;aX;atmifonf c&d kifat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @òzd;a&;aumifpDOuUX(c,u) Ad kvfrª;}uD; jrif hEd kifud kyif *¶krpd kuf/ tav;rxm;a=umif; rdrdwd k @ jrifawG @&ygonf? c¶d kif(c,u)
Ad kvfrª;}uD;jzpfolu “aX;atmif/ rif;wd k @tvkyf rif;wd k @vkyf=u? 'D {nf honfjzpfwJ h a':atmifqef;pk=unfvnf;olwd k @vrf; olwd k @ oGm;vdrf hr,f”[kajymqd k+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; c¶d kif Ad kvfrª;}uD;uk d,fwk difvma&mufIawmif;yefonfudk rdrdwd k@jrifawG@&ygonf? =uHhzGH@twGif;a&;r_;jzpfol OD;aX;atmifu “olwdk @ t&ifoGm;&rSusaemfwd k @oGm;r,f” pojzih f tjyeftvSefajymqk dae=uonf ud kvnf; rdrdwd k @ud k,fwd kif =um;odcJ h&ygonf?
rdrdwd k @tzG J @0ifrsm; uomòrd @od k @ a&muf&S d+yD;aemuf/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih f uomrS tzJ G @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;awG @qH k=uonf? n (8)em&Dausmfcef @wGif rdrdwk d @ jyefvnfxGufcGm=u&m OD;aX;atmifu uom+rdK@ txufwef;ausmif;a&S @wGif &yfwef @apmih fqk dif;aeonf? ausmif;0if;xJwGif OD;aX;atmif OD;pD;onf h =uh HzG H @tzG J @0if (1000)ausmfcef @u rD;yH kyG JjyKvkyfae=uonf? rdrdwd k @,mOfwef;jzwfoGm;cd kufwGif ‚if;wk d @u ‘igwd k @ atmif +yD/ atmif+yD’[k [pfatmfaºuG;a=umf=uonfud k rdrdwk d @,mOfwef;wGif twlvd kufygvmolrsm; =um;od/ óuHawG @cJ h&ygonf? xk dae@ ae@vnfu ‚if;wd k @ud k,fwd kifvkyfaqmifcJ honf hvkyf&yfrsm;ESih fywfoufI rD;yH kyG Jusif;ypOf/ wkwf/ wkwfc|ef ponh f vufeufrsm;uk duk difajr‡mufum ‘igwd k @ atmif+yD/ atmif+yD’ [k aºuG;a=umfae=uygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 58/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
58
arv(13)&ufae@ zm;uef @òrd @od k @ra&mufrD erf @rppfaus;&Gm t0ifwGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u “jynfytm;ud k;ykqdef&d k;/tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;tm; qef @usif=u” pmom;yg&S donf hqd kif;bkwfi,frsm; ud kifaqmifI toHwdwfqENjyaESmif h,Sufonfud k óuHawG @&ygonf?
arv (16)&uf eHeuf(6)em&Dcef @wGif jrpf}uD;em;òrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmvm&m/ eHeuf(8)em&Dcef @wGif jrpf}uD;em;òrd @t0if eef;auG @wHwm;teD;wGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0if(300)cef @u vrf;ab;0J,mrS“jynfytm; ud k;ykqdef&d k;/jynfe,fat;csrf;om,ma&;udkaESmif h,SufzsufqD;olrsm;tm;qef@usif=u/”“trsKd;omoem cd k;,lzsufqD;olrsm;tm;qef @usif=u/acsr_ef;=u”[k yd kpwmrsm;ESif h t0wfezl;pnf;rsm;ud kud kifaqmifv#uf oGm;rnf hvrf;wGif ydwfqd k @ [ef @wm; qlylaESmif h,SufcJ honf? qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;ESif h rvSrf;rurf;wGif t"du&k%f;ES drfeif;a&; vH kxdef;&Jwyfom;rsm;tm; 'kwf 'd kif;rsm;ud kifaqmif+yD; toif hapmif hqd kif;ae=uonfud k awG @&onf?
2003 ckESpf/ arv (20)&uf Aef;armf+rdK@t0if oH k;rd kif&Gmod k @ eHeuf(3)em&DwGifa&muf&S dcJ honf? xd kaus;&GmwGifwkwf/ "g;rsm;ud kifaqmifxm;ol =uH @cd kifzG H @+zdK;a&;tzG J @0if (300)ausmfcef @u vd kifpifeHygwfjym; rygaom um;rsm;ESif h qd kifu,frsm;ud ktoH k;jyK+yD;/ Oya'ud kajAmifususcsdK;azmufI uef @uGufqENjyaESmif h,SufcJ honf? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS ud kxGef;aZmfaZmf ud kifaqmifonf h AG D'D,d kuifr&mud kyif vk,l&ef óud;pm;cJ honf?
6? rdrdwd k @armfawmf,mOfwef;&d S um;rsm;ay:wGif rnfonf hvufeufr# ,laqmifch Jjcif; r&S dyg? c&D;a0;oGm;& onf htwGuf vrf;c&D;wGif "gwfqDtcuftcJ r&S dap&ef/ (16)*gvHqef @onf h "gwfqDyH k; wyH k; wifaqmifvmygonf/c&D;pOfwavsmuf teD;uyfvH kòcHa&;,lxm;ol vli,frsm;xJwGif xk dyk H;uk d rnfolr# wa,mufwnf; o,frEd kifjcif;r&d Syg? xd k @a=umif h tqk dyg (16)*gvHyH k;ud k óud;uGif;pGyf+yD; vl(2)a,mufrI qDjznh fEd kifap&eftwGuf vk dtyfonh fESpf wvuRt&G,f opfom;wkwfwacsmif;ud k aqmifxm;ygonf// xd kudpPud k teD;uyfvH kjcHKa&; wm0ef,lxm;ol
vli,frsm;tm;vH k; od=uygonf?ucsifjynfe,f-rEWav;wk dif;-ppfud kif;wk dif;c&D;pOfwGif 'DyJ,if;vlowfyG J}uD;yH kpHrsdK;uJ hod k @ wk dufck dufr_rsKd;uk d óuH
awG @ch J&ygonf? rEWav;wd kif;/ pOf hul;òrd @e,f/ usnfawmufaygufaus;&GmESif h EG,f¶H kaus;&Gmrsm;wGif tm%myd kifrsm;yl;aygif;yg0ifaom =urf;=urf;wrf;wrf; [ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufjcif;ud k óuHawG @cJ h&ygonf? n (8) em&DcG JESif h (9)em&Dcef @wGif }uH hzG H @tzG J @rsm; pDeif;vd kufygvmonf h 'd kifemum; (3)pD;/ [d kif;vyfum; (4)pD;/ pkpkaygif; um;(7)pD;cef @urdrdwd k @,mOfwef;/ txl;ojzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih f rdrdwd k @vk dufygvmonf hum;ud k 0J,mrSn‡yfum/wd kufvkeD;yg;jzpfonftxd aESmih f,Sufch Jonf? xk dum;rsm;ay:wGif ygvmolrsm;u wkwf/ 0g;c|ef/ ausmufcJ ponh fvufeufrsm;jzih f rdrdwd k @.um;ud k xkESufrnf h hyH ko¾efjyKvkyfI ajcmufvSef @onfud kvnf;}uKHawG @&ygonf? pOf hul;òrd @t0if
wGif xd kum;rsm;ay:rS avmufav;cGjzih f ypfcwfwk dufck dufojzif h rdrdwk d @bufrS rE Wav;wd kif;/ tzJ G @csKyftzJ G @0if vli,f(1)OD; '%f&m&&S dcJ hygonf? xd k @a=umif h 'kwd, OuUX OD;wifOD;u pOf hul;òrd @ &Jpcef;wGif tr_zGif hwd kif=um;cJ hygonf?
7? 29-5-2003 ckae@wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf/ 'k-OuUX OD;wifOD; wk d @acgif;aqmifonh f rdrdwk d @tzG J @onfrE Wav;wd kif;¶H k;rS rH k&Gmc&D;pOfud k pwifxGufcGmcJ hygonf? ppfud kif;òrd @od k @ (10)em&DcG Jcef @wGif a&muf&S donf? ppfud kif;wHwm;xdyfwGif OD;aX;atmif OD;pD;onf h =uH @cd kifzG H @òzda&;tzG J @0if tiftm; (150)cef @u qd kif;bkwfrsm; ud kifaqmifjyD;/[pfatmfqENjyaeonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? rdrdwd k @ESif htwlvd kufygvmonf h,mOfwef;twGif;rS armfawmf,mOfrsm;u rnfod k @r# wk H @jyefjcif; rjyKcJ hyg/ xd ktcsdefwGif rdrdonf a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;aemufcef;wGif vd kufygvmygonf? (12)em&DcG Jcef @wGif jrif;rlòrd @od k @ a&muf&S dcJ hyg onf? ud kwifxGÉfOD;(v,fa0;òrd @e,f/ trSwf(1)rJqENe,f
v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f/ txufjrefrmjynf vli,fjyefvnfzG J @pnf;a&;wm0efcH) OD;aqmif+yD; òrd @e,f vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;vkyfief;rsm; vkyfaqmifcJ hygonf? xk dzJ G @pnf;a&;wGif tcrf;tem;rª;tjzpf uk dawZEd kifu aqmif &Gufygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 59/208
59
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vrf;ab; 0J ,mrS xaemif;yif/ wrmyifrsm;. aemufuG,f&S d csHKykwfrsm;ud k tumtuG,f,lI
tm%myk difwk dŒ .um;rsm; &yfwefŒ xm;_yD; vrf;jyif&ef r[kwfbJ ta-umif;rJ h pkykHxm;aom ausmufyk Huk d awGŒjrif&pOf
xd kod k @aqmif &GufaepOf jrif; rl òrd @e,f/ tzG J @csKyf&H k; tjyifzufwGif um;(5)pD;ud k awG @&S d&ygonf? xk dum;rsm;ay:wGif&JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;/ t&HrD;owf wyfzG J @0ifrsm;/ jynfol @pGrf; tm;&SiftzG J @0ifrsm;/ òrd @e,f at;csrf;om,ma&;ESih f zH G @+zdK;a&;aumifpDtzG J @0ifrsm;/ =uh HzG H @ toif;0ifrsm; ponfwk d @uk d awG @&onf? um;wpD;ay: wGif jynfol @pGrf;tm;&Sif
[l aompmvk H;ud k ydwfp tjzL ay:wGif tpdrf;a&mifjzif h a&; om;xm;onf?jrif;rlòrd @rS jyefvnfxGufcGmonf htcg rdrdwd k @. ,mOfwef;aemufrS txufazmfjyyg um;(5)pD;vd kufygcJ honfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? nae(3)em&DcG Jcef @wGif rdrdwd k @ a&yd k;pm;aus;&GmteD;od k @a&muf&S dcJ hygonf? a&yd k;pm;od k @ a&mufonf htcg vrf;ab; 0J,mrS xaemif;yif/ wrmyifrsm;. aemufuG,f&S d csHKykwfrsm;ud ktumtuG,f,lI &yfwef @xm;onfh tm%mykdifwk [email protected];rsm;ukdawG@&onf? vHkxdef; (t"du&k%f;EdSrfeif;a&;wyfzJ G @)um;rsm;/ ppfum;rsm;/wyfrawmf wyfxdef;um;rsm;/ ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;. armfawmf,mOfrsm;ud kawG @&S d&ygonf? xd k @tjyif vrf;ab;0J,mwGif =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;uk d awG @&onf? ‚if;wk d @ u ‘rH k&Gm-ref;/ csif;wGif;om;’ ponh fc&D;onfwifvd kif;um;rsm;ud k tok H;jyK=uonf? cef @rSef;ajc armfawmf,mOf tpD;(30)cef @ &S dygonf?
xd kae&mwGif trsKd;om;/ trsKd;orD; cef @rSef;ajc vltiftm; (500)cef @ud k jrifawG @&ygonf? ‚if;wk d @ teD ;wGifwkwf/ vrf;cif;ausmuf ponfwk d @uk d toif hpkyH kxm;&S d+yD;/ &efjyKrnf htaetxm;ud k awG @&S d&ygonf? xd kae&mwGifteD;uyf}uD;=uyfaeolrSm ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOfwavsmuf rdrdwd k @tm;vd kufvHaESmif h,SufcJ honf h OD;aX;atmifqd kolyifjzpfygonf? rdrdwd k @.um;onf azmfjyyg qENjyqef @usifrnh folrsm;ESif h awG @qH konf htcg owif;ESih fjyef=um;a&;tzJ G @ wm0efcHjzpfol ud kodef;pd k;u "gwfyH k&d kuf,l+yD;/ ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu AG D'D,d kuifr&mjzif h rSwfwrf;wifum/ud kjrif hausmfu toHzrf;,l+yD; rSwfwrf;wifch Jygonf?
a&yd k;pm;aus;&Gmud kjzwfonf htcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @.um;a&S @wGif 'kwd, OuUX OD;wifOD; vk dufygvmonf hum;tygt0if um;(3)pD;cef @ &S dygonf? a&yd k;pm;ok d @ rd k;csKyfonh ftcsdefrS a&mufrnfqd kygu 'DyJ,if;wGifjzpfyGm;ch Jonh fvlowfyG J}uD;uh Jok d @ wk dufck dufr_jyKvkyf&ef pDpOfxm;onf hyH kpHrsKd; jzpfygonf? a&yd k;pm;aus;&GmwGif rdrdwd k @tm; axmuf
cHonf h jynfolvlxk}uD;ud kjrifonf htcg qef @usifqENjy/ wk dufck dufrnf holrsm; xdwfvef @oGm;ygonf? a&yd k;pm;od k @a&muf&S doGm;onf htcsdefrSm ae@tcsdefjzpfonf? xk d @a=umih f qef @usif qENjyrnf holrsm; taejzif h vkyf=uHwk dufck duf&ef
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 60/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
60
tcGif hta&; r&cJ hay?acsmif;OD;rS rH k&Gmod k @n(9)em&DcG Jcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ hygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @/ tzG J @csKyf qd kif;bkwfwifyG JwGif 'k wd,OuUX
jzpfol OD;wifOD;u ‘atmifjrifjcif;*gxm’ &Gwfqd k+yD;aemuf a':atmifqef;pk=unfu jynfolvlxk}uD;tm; rdef @cGef;
ajym=um;ygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @e,f/ tzJ G @csKyf vli,ftzJ G @ zG J @pnf;a&;ud k pdefr#m;pwd k;wGifjyKvkyf&m ar(30)&ufae@/ eHeuf(2)em&DwGif atmifjrifpGm zG J @pnf;ay;cJ honf?
8? arv(30)&ufae@/ eHeuf (10)em&D0ef;usifwGif aZmwduausmif;od k @oGm;a&mufI q&mawmftm; 0wfjyK +yD;/ jynfolvlxktm;E_wfqufI rdef @cGef;ajym=um;cJ honf? xd k @aemuf bkwvifòrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf?rH k&Gmòrd @rS qd kifu,frsm;ESif hum;rsm;uvnf; bkwvifòrd @txd vd kufygyd k @aqmif=uonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? bkwvifòrd @od f k @ ae@vnfrGef;wnf hcsdefwGif qd kufa&mufcJ honf? bkwvifòrd @ tzG J @csKyf qd kif;bkwfwifyJ GjyKvkyf+yD;/ òrd @e,fpnf;&H k;a&;tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h awG @qH kcJ hygonf? jynfolvlxkud k E_wfcGef;qufpum;ajym=um;I acwWtem;,lygonf?bkwvifòrd @rS nae (3)em&Dausmfcef @wGifxGufvmcJ h&m pd kifjyif}uD;&Gmod k @ nae(5)em&Dausmfcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ hygonf? pd kifjyif}uD;&Gm&d S zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;jcif;cHxm;&onf h OD;0if;jrif hatmif.aetdrfok d @ oGm;a&mufum a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h OD;wifOD;u rdom;pktzG J @0ifrsm;uk d tm;ay;pum;ajym=um;ygonf? xk d @aemuf jynfolvlxktm;rdef @cGef;ajym=um;+yD;/ n(7)em&Dcef @wGif pd kifjyif}uD;rS 'DyJ,if;òrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf?
9? n(7)em&DcG Jcef @wGif usnf&GmteD;od k @a&muf&S dcJ hygonf?vrf;r}uD;ay:wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;axmufcHóudqd kaeonf h jynfolvlxk}uD;uk d pwifawG @&S d&ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu apmih fóudaeolrsm;ay;tyfonh f yef;pnf;rsm;ud kvufcH&,lonf?um;ud kajz;nif;pGm qufvufarmif;ESifvmch J=uygonf? apmih fóudaeonf h vltkyf}uD;twGif;rS nmbufvufarmif;wGif teDa&mift0wfp ywfxm;onh f bkef;}uD;(2)yg;uvnf;
rdrdwd k @.um;aemufrS vd kufvmygonf// xd k @aemuf twefi,f0onf h bkef;}uD;(1)yg;u rdrdwd k @.,mOfud k a&S @rSydwfIwm;vd kufygonf? “rif;wd k @aumifawG/ igwd k @wm;aewmawmif *&krpd kufwJ hoabmvm;” [k ,mOfarmif;jzpfoltm; ajymqd kygonf/ xd k @aemuf bkef;}uD;uyif “jynfolvlxkud k rdef @cGef;enf;enf;avmuf ajymay;yg’ [k ajymonf htcg ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu rdrdwd k @a&S @qufoGm;&rnf hc&D; &S dao;onf htwGuf awmif;yefyga=umif; xd kbkef;=uD;(2)yg;ud kavsmufxm;ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfu “OD;Zif;vlawGud k pkvd kufyg/ wynf hawmfr q,frdepfavmufawmh vlawGud k E_wfqufpum;ajymygr,f” [k ajymvk dufonf? xk dcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @,mOfwef;}uD;.aemufrSuyfvsufvd kufygvmonf h }uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm; tygt0if ‚if;wd k @ac:aqmifvmonf hvlrsm;u usnf&Gmol &Gmom;rsm;ud k pwif¶d kufESufae+yDjzpfa=umif; rE Wav;wd kif;rSvd kufygvmonf h vH kjcHKa&;vli,fwOD;u rdrdwd k @ud k vma&muf
owday; ta=umif;=um;ygonf? rdrdwd k @u a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; oGm;a&mufta=umif;=um;ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu rdrdwk d @,mOfwef;tm; wm;qD;onf hbkef;}uD;ESpfyg;ud k “wynf hawmfwd k @ud k &d kufESufae+yD/ OD;Zif;wd k @ wm0ef,lwm;jrpfay;ygOD;” [kajymonf htcg xd kOD;Zif;ESpfyg; aysmufjcif;rvS aysmufuG,foGm;ygonf? rdrdwd k @.,mOf wk dufck dufcH&csdefwGif xk dbkef;}uD;ESpfyg;ud k rawG @&awmhyg?
10? usnf&GmrS vma&muf}udKqd konf h jynfolvlxkud k¶d kufESuf+yD;csdefwGif ,mOfwef;wGifyg0ifonh f rE Wav;wd kif;/ tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifwk d @. um;rsm;/ rH k&GmrSvd kufyd k @onf h um;rsm;tm; pwif¶d kufESufaeonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf?0ifa&muf&d kufESufonf holrsm;.aemufrS um;a&S @rD;rsm;xd k;ay;xm;onf htwGuf aumif;rGefpGm jrifae&ygonf?0ifa&muf&d kufESufonf hvltiftm; rsm;jym;vSonf htwGuf ta&twGuf rnfr#&d Srnfuk d rcef @rSef;Ed kifyg? yxrOD;pGm
rdrdwd k @.,mOfwef;ud k ausmufcJrsm;jzif h pwifypfaygufygonf? cJjzif h ypfayguf+yD;aemuf 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;/ 0g;qpfydwfrsm;/ opfom;wkwfrsm;/ 0g;c|efrsm;jzif h 0ifa&muf&d kufESuf=uygonf? rdrdwd k @.,mOfrsm;ay:wGif vk dufygvm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 61/208
61
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
olrsm;u um;rsm;ay:rSqif;+yD; xGufajy;=u&mwGif tcsdK@vnf; vGwfajrmuf+yD;/ tcsdK@rSm rajy;Ed kifojzif h xd kae&mwGifyif jyif;xefpGm &d kufESufjcif;cH&onfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? ,mOfwef;aemufqH k;rSum;rsm;rSm yxrOD;pGm &kwfw&uf trSwfrxif&d kufESufjcif;cH&onf? xk d @a=umih f xk dum;rsm;ay:wGif txdtcd kuf/ taotaysmuf yd krk drsm;jym;
ygonf? rdrd.rsufpda&S @wGifyif trsKd;orD;rsm;vnf;&d kufESufcH&onfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? jyif;jyif;xefxef &d kufESufcH&olrsm;rSm rE Wav;wd kif;rSvd kufygvmonf h vli,frsm;ESif h vH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;/ rH k&GmrSvd kufygvmonf h ausmif;om;rsm;/ rH k&Gmòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf/ tzG J @0ifrsm; jzpf=uonf? &d kufESufolrsm;u “eifwd k @ ukvm;r,m; awmfawmf awmfcsifaewJ h aumifrawG” [kajymqd k+yD;/ rd kufrd kuf¶d kif;¶d kif;qJqd kum ¶d kufESuf=uonfud k rdrdud k,fwd kifjrifawG @=um;odch J&ygonf?t=urf;zuf&d kufESufolrsm;ua':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k pwif wk dufck dufcsdefwGif aemufwGifvk dufygvmaomum;rsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k rnfod k @r# ausmfwufI r&awmhyg? a&S @aemuf ydwfrdaepOf 0k dif;0ef;&k dufESufcH=u&ojzih f taotaysmufESif h xdcd kuf'%f&m&ol vGefpGmrsm;jym;ygonf?
11? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. um;a&S @wGif&S daeonf h OD;wifOD;u um;ay:rSqif;vm+yD; xk dae&mrSxGufcGm&efvma&mufajymqk dygonf? ,cifu OD;wifOD;onf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih fpum;ajymqk donh ftcg ‘a':atmifqef;pk=unf’ [k ac:avh&d Sygonf? 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_}uD; pwifjzpfyGm;onf h xk dtcsdefwGif OD;wifOD;u“ighorD;&,f/ 'if;wd k @ tajctaeu raumif ;awmhbl; orD;av;&,f? orD;av;um; xGufygawmh”“ighorD;&,f/ 'if;wd k @ tajctaeu raumif ;awmhbl; orD;av;&,f? orD;av;um; xGufygawmh”“ighorD;&,f/ 'if;wd k @ tajctaeu raumif ;awmhbl; orD;av;&,f? orD;av;um; xGufygawmh”“ighorD;&,f/ 'if;wd k @ tajctaeu raumif ;awmhbl; orD;av;&,f? orD;av;um; xGufygawmh”“ighorD;&,f/ 'if;wd k @ tajctaeu raumif ;awmhbl; orD;av;&,f? orD;av;um; xGufygawmh” [k u¶k%moHjzif h vma&mufajymqk donfud k ,ae@xd rdrd. em;xJwGif =um;a,mifaeygonf?
a':atmifqef;pk=unfu“bbæusr&J @aemufrSm &Gmol&Gmom;awG/ jynfolawG/ tzG J@0ifawG t¶d kufcHbbæusr&J @aemufrSm &Gmol&Gmom;awG/ jynfolawG/ tzG J @0ifawG t¶dkufcHbbæusr&J @aemufrSm &Gmol&Gmom;awG/ jynfolawG/ tzG J@0ifawG t¶d kufcHbbæusr&J @aemufrSm &Gmol&Gmom;awG/ jynfolawG/ tzG J @0ifawG t¶dkufcHbbæusr&J @aemufrSm &Gmol&Gmom;awG/ jynfolawG/ tzGJ @0ifawG t¶d kufcHae&+yD/ usr 'Dvd kxGufoGm;&ufyghrvm;ae&+yD/ usr 'Dvd kxGufoGm;&ufyghrvm;ae&+yD/ usr 'Dvd kxGufoGm;&ufyghrvm;ae&+yD/ usr 'Dvd kxGufoGm;&ufyghrvm;ae&+yD/ usr 'Dvd kxGufoGm;&ufyghrvm;” [k jyefvnfI wkef @jyefajym=um;ygonf? OD;wifOD;onf a':atmifqef;pk=unfuk d rnfok d @r# ajzmif;zsIr&onf h htqH k;wGif ol.um;&S d&mod k @ jyefvSnf hoGm;ygonf?
12? xd ktcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @um;teD;od k @ t=urf;zufvkyf=uHowfjzwf &d kufESufrnf holrsm; a&muf&S dvm+yD;/
a':atmifqef;pk=unf. um;aemufyd kif;ud k pwif ¶d kufESufzsufqD;ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ay:wGifteD;uyfvH kjcHKa&;tjzpfvd kufygvmonf h vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;jzpfaom ud krd k;aomf / ud krif;vGif/ ud koef;xGef;/ud kwd k;vGif/ ud krsdK;!Gef @/ ud koufxGef;ESih f rdrdwd k @u um;a&S @cef;ud k k wzufwcsufpDwGif 0d kif;&Hvd kufygonf? rdrdu a':atmif
a':atmifqef;pk-unf. um;uk d A[k dvli,f teD;uyfvk HòcHa&;tzJGŒ 0ifrsm;u umuG,fxm;pOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 62/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
62
qef;pk=unf. nmbufab; a&S @wnf hwnf h&S dum;acgif;xdyfwGif ae&m,lygonf? &d kufESufolrsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfxd kifaeonf hum;. b,fbufjcrf;ud k tjyif;txef pwifIwk dufck duf&d kufESufygonf? um;ud k 0ef;&Hxm;onf hvli,frsm;jzpfaomrdrdwk d @ud kvnf; pwif¶d kufESufae+yD jzpfonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf xd kifaeonf h
b,fbufjcrf;&S d um;rSefrsm;uG JoGm;onfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. nmbuf vufarmif;'%f&m&&S doGm;onfud kvnf; um;acgif;cef;wGif rD;zGif hxm;onf htwGuf rdrduk d,fwk difjrifawG @&ygonf? wqufwnf;wGif a&S @ nmzufjcrf;rS ,mOfarmif;ol ud kausmfpd k;vif;tm; pwif¶d kufESufygonf? rdrdonf um;a&S @ nmzufjcrf;wGif&S daeI ud kausmfpd k;vif;ESif h teD;uyfqH k; jzpfygonf? ud kausmfpd k;vif;. nmbufvufxdcd kuf'%f&m&+yD;aoG;rsm;jzmxGufaeygonf? rdrdudk¶dkufonf htcg b,fvufjzif hcHvdkufojzifh ywfxm;onfhvufywfem&DuG JoGm;ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif ,mOfarmif;jzpfol ud kausmfpd k;vif;u “tefwD hud k xdoGm;+yD/ xdoGm;+yD” [k atmfvd kufygonf? um;jywif;aygufrSefuJ Grsm;a=umih f a':atmifqef;pk=unf. b,fbufycH k; xdck dufuG J&SoGm;jcif;jzpfonf?
rE Wav;wd kif;vli,fjzpfonf h ud koD[ acgif;uG JoGm;+yD;/ &efukefrS ygvmonf h teD;uyf vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifxJrSud kwd k;vGif/ ud krd k;aomfwd k @ (2)OD ;vnf; aemufausmESif hOD;acgif;wd k @wGif¶d kufESufcH&ygonf? uk doef;xGef;vnf; jyif;xefpGm'%f&m&ygonf? um;aemufcef;wGif 0d kif;¶d kufonf htcg wkwfc|efrsm;jzif h 0d kif;0ef;xd k;ESuf+yD;/ &d kufESuf=ujcif;jzpfonf htwGuf '%f&mjyif;xefjcif;jzpfonf? ud koef;xGef;onf c&D;pOfrsm;wGifvk dufygch J+yD;/ rnfonf hae&mok d @a&mufonfjzpfap um;ay:rS vH k;0rqif;yg? ‚if;.wm0efrSm um;ay:&S dypPnf;rsm;ud k apmif ha&Smufxdef;odrf;a&;jzpfygonf? ud kwd k;vGifrSm acgif;ud kjyif;xefpGmt¶d kufcH&onf htwGuf rsufESmay: wGif aoG;rsm;jzmusaeonfud kjrifawG @vk duf&ygonf?
vGwfvyfa&; Adokum}uD; Ad kvfcsKyfatmifqef;.orD;/ Ed kbJvf+idrf;csrf;a&;qk&Sif a':atmifqef; pk=unf ud kyif,ckuJ hod k @ ¶d kufESufowfjzwfaev#if rdrdwd k @uh Jok d @ omreftn=wwa,mufud kvnf; aoonftxd &d kufESufrnfrSm aocsmygonf? &Sif;&Sif;ajym&vsif xd kuJ hod k @ t=urf;zuf¶d kufcHae&csdefwGif rdrdwGif a=umufpdwfrsm;0ifvmonf?
a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;teD;rS cGmI “tefwD armif;ajy;ygawmh? ud kausmfpd k;vif; armif;ygawmh/ 'Dae&muxGufygawmh” [k toHukefatmf[pfI owday;ygonf?
rdrdESif htwl usefonf hvli,frsm;uvnf; um;xGuf&ef atmf[pf=uonf? r=umrDwGif ud kausmfpd k;vif;uum;ud k armif;xGufoGm;ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu trdef @ay;I armif ;xGufoGm;jcif; r[kwfyg? 'DyJ,if;vlowfyG J}uD;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf rnfol @a=umif h touftE W&m,frS vGwfajrmufoGm;oenf;[kar;vsifud kausmfpd k;vif;a=umif h touftE W&m,fu vGwfajrmufjcif;jzpfonf[k rdrdu ajz&ygrnf?
a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; armif;xGufoGm;onf htcg ,cifu rdrdwd k @.um;a&S @wGif&S daeonf h rE Wav;wd kif;/ tzJ G @csKyfrS OD;ud kud kav;armif;ESifonf h [d kif;vyfum;ay:od k @wufajy;ygonf? OD;ud kud kav;.um; tcif;jzpf
onh fae&mrS xGufajy;armif;ESifvm+yD; r=umrD rdrdwd k @.a&S @rS óudwifxGufajy;oGm;onf h qd kifu,ftkyfpku aemufok d @ jyefvSnf hvmonf? ‚if;wk d @u “a&S @rSmvnf; qD;¶d kuf+yD;/ owfjzwfae=ujyef+yD/ a&S @ud k armif;rajy;eJ @”[k ajymqd konf htwGuf OD;ud kud kav;u um;ud k xd kae&mwGif &yfxm;vd kufonf? a&S @ok d @qufajy;vsif t&d kufcH&I aornf/aemufzufok d @ jyefvSnf hajy;vsifvnf; t&d kufcH&rSm =udrf;aoonf/ xd k @a=umif h rdrdwd k @. nmbufwGif&S daeonf hv,fuGif;rsm;xJod k @ qif;ajy;cJ hygonf?
13? ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHowfjzwfyG J}uD;onf tifrwefrSyif xdwfvef @wkefv_yfzG,f aumif;ygonf? rdrd.rsufpda&S @Y aoG ;td kifxJwGif vJonf hvlu vJaeonf? vJae&mrS tm;wif;I ¶kef;uef+yD; xonf htcg wGifvnf;xyfrH ¶d kufESufcH&onf? vGefpGm aoG;ysufzG,f/ pdwfajcmufjcm;zG,fjzpfygonf? tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if trsKd;orD;tcsKd @rSm
tusôrsm; tc|wfcH&=u&onf? “ukvm;r,m; awmfawmf awmfcsifwJ haumifrawG/ eifwd k @aowm at;w,f”[k qJqd kjcif;/ ¶d kufESufjcif;rsm;uk d cH&ygonf? rdrdonf pum;tyk drsm; ajymqk daejcif; r[kwfyg? rsufjrifawG @óuH
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 63/208
63
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
=um;odch J&onfud k jyefvnf ajymjyjcif;om jzpfygonf? t=urf;zuf&d kufESufjcif; cH&onf htwGuf toufqH k;&H _;olvGefpGm rsm;jym;ygonf? aoqH k;aeonf hvl/ '%f&mjzif hvJaeol/ aoG;tdkifxJwGif ar@arsmaeolta&twGuf
tenf;qH k; (100)xuf ryk d[kqk dv#ifvnf; (100)xuf avsmhvdrf hrnf r[kwf[k cef @rSef;&ygonf? [d kif;vyfum;ay:rS rdrdqif;ajy;+yD; v,fuGif;xJod k @a&mufonf htcg rH k&Gmòrd @rS tzJ G @csKyfvli,ftzJ G @ wm0efcH(2) ud kud kvGiftygt0if rH k&GmrS vli,ftzG J @0if(7)OD;/ rE Wav;taemufawmifòrd @e,frS vli,fwOD;uk dvnf; awG @&onf? rdrdtygt0if vli,f(9)OD;onf tcif;jzpfonf h hae&mrS v,fuGif;rsm;ud kjzwfausmfI wem&Dcef @ ajy;v$m;cJ h&ygonf?xGufajy;+yD; armyef;Item;,laecsdefwGif 'DyJ,if; òrd @zufrS rD;armif;rsm;xd k;onfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? xd k @aemufppfum;rsm; armif;xGufoGm;onfud kvnf; jrifawG @&ygonf? wcsdefwnf;rSmyif yk'fr 144 n rxGuf&trdef @xkwfjyefa=umif; toHcsJ @pufjzif h atmf[pfa=unmaeoHrsm;ud k=um;&ygonf? wqufwnf;rSmyif aoewfypfoHtenf;qH k; (8)csuf/ (10)csufcef @ud k =um;&ygonf?
14? ar(30)&uf wnvH k; bkwvifòrd @teD;&S d v,fuGif;rsm;xJwGif ykef;atmif;IaecJ h=u&onf? arv(31)
&uf eHeuf t¶k%fwuf (4)em&Dcef @wGif rdrdwd k @(9)OD;onf v,fuGif;xJ&S d v,fwJav;wGif tultnDawmif;=uonf? tqd kyg v,fwJrSvlwOD;u rdrdwd k @tm; ebJvSaus;&Gmod k @ vd kufvHyd k @aqmifygonf? ebJvSaus;&GmrS ysHusaus;&Gm/ &GmOD;bkef;}uD;ausmif;ok d @a&mufygonf? bkef;}uD;ausmif;wGif 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_a=umif h '%f&m& onf hvl (12)a,mufcef @ óudwifa&muf&S daeygonf? xd kolrsm;xJwGif pum;ajymEd kifol (4)a,mufcef @&S d+yD; usefvlrsm;uvnf; '%f&m&xm;+yD; tajctae raumif;yg? ppfud kif;wd kif; ajrmifòrde,frSESpfa,mufrSm '%f&mjyif;xefI tonf;toef jzpfaeygonf? pum;vnf; rajymEd kifawmhyg/ atmhtefrl;a0ae+yD; OD;acgif;ESif hausmrsm;wGif'%f&mrsm;pGm &&d Sxm;ygonf? '%f&m&onf holrsm;ud k k vmppfaq;rnf[k ajymqd konf htoH=um;ojzif h xd kae&mwGif acwWr#em;ae+yD; ysHus&GmrS pd kifjyif}uD;od k @vrf;av#mufxGufcJ h&m pd kifjyif}uD;&S d a':atmifqef;pk=unf aemufqH k;
&yfem;cJ honf htdrfok d @ ae@vnf(12)em&Dcef @wGif rdrdESif h ud kud kvGifwd k @a&muf&S dcJ hygonf? OD;0if;jrif hatmif. om;jzpfolu ar(30)&ufae@ eHeufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;oGm;a&mufrnf h 'DyJ,if;c&D;pOftwGuf vrf;c&D;vH kðcH ka&;ud k pH kprf;&ef xGufcGmoGm;pOf ‚if;.qd kifu,fESif htwl tm%myd kifrsm;u'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;wGiftus,fcsKyfjzif h óudwifIzrf;qD;xm;cJ ha=umif; rdrdtm;jyefvnfajymjyI bkwvifòrd @txd vd kufygyd k @aqmifay;cJ honf? ud kud kvGifu ysHus&GmrS vlemrsm;tm;oGm;a&mufI =unf hOD;rnf[kajymqd kum pd kifjyif}uD;wGifaecJ hygonf?arv(31)&ufae@nwGif bkwvifòrd @e,fteD;&S d v,fuGif;twGif; ntdyfcJ hygonf? ZGefv(1)&ufrS (4)&ufae@txdbkwvifòrd @teD;&S d bkef;}uD;ausmif;wGif acwWwnf;cd kykef;atmif;aecJ hygonf? armfawmfum;vrf;rsm; ydwfxm;onf htwGuf ZGefv(4)&ufae@ um;vrf;rsm; jyefzGif honf htcgrS rE Wav;od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? rdrd.
aetdrfod k @ rjyefbJ a&Smifwdrf;ykef;atmif;aexd kifcJ h&mrS 2003ckESpf/ atmufwd kbmv(28)&ufae@wGif xd kif;-jrefrme,fpyfwae&mod k @ a&muf&S dcJ hygonf?
txufyg trSwfpOf (1) rS (14) txdyg&S daom ta=umif;t&mrsm;ud k rnfolr# rw&m; =oZmv$rf;rd k;jcif;/+cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ aoG;aqmifjzm;a,mif;jcif;/ vdrfvnfvSnf hjzm;jcif; r&S dbJrdrd. vGwfvyfonf hoabmqENt& xkwfazmfajym=um;jcif;jzpf+yD;/ trSwfpOf(1)rS (14) xdyg&S donf h ta=umif;t&mrsm;onf rdrdud k,fwd kifawG @/ ud k,fwd kifjrif/ ud k,fwd kifodonf h ta=umif;t&mrsm; jzpfa=umif; 0efcHuwdjyKygonf?
ud kcifOD;ud kcifOD;ud kcifOD;ud kcifOD;udkcifOD;
2003 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (24)&uf2003 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (24)&uf2003 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (24)&uf2003 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (24)&uf2003 ckESpf/ Ekd0ifbmv (24)&uf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 64/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
64
0Àarmif. uwdopPmjyK xGufqd kcsuf0Àarmif. uwdopPmjyK xGufqd kcsuf0Àarmif. uwdopPmjyK xGufqd kcsuf0Àarmif. uwdopPmjyK xGufqd kcsuf0Àarmif. uwdopPmjyK xGufqdkcsuf
trnf// // 0Àarmifrdbtrnf? // OD;ausmfarmif/ a':wif0if;Ed kifiHom;pDppfa&;trSwf? ? 9§rcp Ed kif 003840arG;ouU&mZf? ? 16-3-1977ae&yfvdyfpm? ? xGefwH k;òrd @opf/ csrf;jrompnf/
rE Wav;òrd @
usaemfarmif0Àarmifu 'DyJ,if; ta&;tcif;ESif hywfoufI uwdopPmjyKxGufqd konfrSm æ
1// usaemfonf rE Wav;/ csrf;jrompnfòrd @e,f xGefwH k;&yfuGufwGif aexd kif+yD;/ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/rE Wav;wk dif;/ vli,ftzG J @0iftjzpf av#mufxm;olwOD;jzpfygonf? usaemfwd d k @. tzG J @0iftjzpfav#mufv$mud ktrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ 'kwd, OuUXjzpfol OD;wifOD;u tzG J @csKyftzG J @0iftjzpf vufcHxm;a=umif; OD;wifOD;ud k,fwd kifu rdrdwd k @tm;ajym=um;ygonf? tzG J @0ifu'fjym;rsm;ud k avmavmq,fq,f tajctaet&yf&yfa=umif hrnfol @ud krS csray;Ed kifao;a=umif; &Sif;vif;ajymjyygonf? ygwD. vkyfief;pOfrsm;ud k qufvuftaumiftxnf
azmfvkyfaqmifoGm;&efajym=um;onf// usaemfonf xGefwH k;&yfuGuf vli,frsm;.a&G;cs,fcef @xm;csuft& xGefwH k;òrd @e,f vli,fpnf;&H k;a&;wm0efud k ,lxm;&oljzpfygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 65/208
65
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
2? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. txufjrefrmjynf pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfwGif rE Wav;wd kif;/ tzG J @csKyf. wm0efay;csuft& vli,fvH kjcHKa&;wm0efjzif hvd kufygoGm;&ygonf? vH kjcHKa&;wm0efqd konfrSm c&D;pOfwavsmuf vrf;c&D;wGiftE W&m,f rusa&mufEdkifap&ef teD;uyfwm0ef,laqmif&Gufay;&onf? rE Wav;wdkif;/ pOfhud kifòrd@e,f
trSwf(2)rJqENe,frS v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f a'gufwmvSpd k;nGef@tm; rE Wav;wd kif; pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif; vH kjcHKa&;wm0ef,lay;&ef a':atmifqef;pk=unfu wm0efay;cJ honf? xd k @a=umif h a'gufwmvSpd k;nGef @urE Wav;òrd @e,frsm;jzpfaom ta&S @awmif/ taemufawmif/ taemufajrmufESif h ta&S @ajrmufòrd @e,frsm;rS vli,ftzG J @rsm;tm; a':atmifqef;pk=unf. pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif; t&HvH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;tjzpf wm0ef,lvd kufygaqmif&Gufay;&ef òrd @e,ftzG J @rsm;ud k xyfqif hwm0efay;tyfcJ hygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. vH kjcHKa&;twGuf &efukefrS A[d kvli,f(17)OD;vd kufygcJ honf? um;rsm;&yfem;pOf vH kjcHKa&;wm0ef&d Sol A[d kvli,frsm;uwxyfum&H+yD;/ t&HvH kjcHKa&; vli,frsm;u wxyf pojzih f xyfqif hIum&Hay;&onf?
3/ c&D;pOf rpcifuwnf;u =uH hzG H @òr@de,f±k H;rsm;wGif 0g;&if;wkwf wyfzJ G @rsm;zJ G @+yD; &-,-u OuUX u wyf&if;rª; tjzpfzJ G @pnf;um oifwef;ay;ae=uonf[k usaemfwd k @=um;od&onf// tqk dyg oifwef;om;rsm;twGuf&duQmuk d &yfuGufrsm;twGif; tjcm;ta=umif;jycsufrsm;jzih f t"rR qif hqd kcJ honfuk dvnf; usaemfwd k @ =um;odcJ h&onf?xk d @a=umif h usaemfwd k @c&D;pOf pxGufonh ftcsdefrSpI tm%myk difrsm;ESih fxdyfwd kufawG @Ed kifonh f tjyKtrl/ tajymtqd krsm;ud k vk H;0 a&SmifusOf=u&ef a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rSm=um;xm;onf//
4? arv(29)&ufae@/ eHeuf(9)em&Dcef @wGif rE Wav; (38)vrf;taemufrS (84)vrf;twk dif; um;rsm;/qd kifu,frsm;jzif h pwifxGufcGmcJ hygonf? rdrdwd k @.um;wGif rdrdwd k @ESif htwl a'gufwmvSpd k;nGef @/ ud kat;0if;/ ud k0À/rE Wav; taemufajrmufòrd @e,f/ òrd @e,fpnf;&k H;a&;r_; OD;vSoef;/ ud katmifud k/ a':cifat;jrif h/ a':nGef @nGef @/ ud kodef;
aZmfwd k @twl vd kufygcJ h=uonf? ,mOfwef;.a&S @ajy;tjzpf um;wpD;ud k óudwifapvGwfxm;onf? rdrdwd k @,mOfrsm;u aemufrSvd kufygcJ honf?
5? eHeuf (10) em&DcG G Jcef @wGif ppfud kif;òrd @od k @ a&muf&S dcJ honf? ppfud kif;wHwm;tvGef òrd @t0ifauG @wGif vrf;.b,fnmESpfzufpvH k;wGif vltiftm; (600)cef @uk d awG @&onf? ‘}uH hcd kifzG H @jzdK;a&;tzJ G @tm; raxmufcHolrsm; tvd kr&d S’ [ka&;xm;aomqd kif;bkwfrsm;ud k ud kifaqmif+yD; yg;pyfrSvnf; xd kpmom;rsm;twd kif; atmf[pfae=uonf?xd kolrsm;.aemufzuf rvSrf;rurf;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;óudqd kaeaomjynfolrsm;uk d awG @&onf? jynfolrsm;u tifESif htm;ESif h vd _ufvd _ufvS JvS Jóudqd kaxmufcH=uonf? usaemfwd k @uvnf; 0rf;omtm;&jyefvnf E_wfquf
cJ h=uonf? “a':atmifqef;pk=unf usef;rmygap/ bb OD;wifOD; usef;rmygap”[k vlxku aºuG;a=umfóudqd konh ftcgusaemfwd k @uvnf; “jynfolvlxk}uD; usef;rmygap” pojzif h jyefvnf+yD;qkawmif;arwWmyd k @ay;=uonf? ppfud kif;òrd @wGif;od k @ r0ifawmhbJ jrif;rlòrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ honf?
6? jrif;rlòrd @od k @ ae@(12)em&Dcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ honf? jrif;rlwGif òrd @e,ftzG J @csKyf&H k;ud k a':atmifqef;pk=unfu qd kif;bkwfwif zGif hvSpfay;cJ honf? xd k @aemuf txufjrefrmEd kifiH vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;wm0efcH ud kwifxGÉfOD;u jrif;rlòrd @e,f tzJ G @csKyfvli,ftzG J @ud k zG J @pnf;ay;cJ honf?
7? rGef;vG J 3em&Dcef @wGif rH k&Gm+rdK@od k @qufvufxGufcGmcJ h&m vrf;c&D;wGif rH k&Gmòrd @@rSvma&mufI c&D;OD;jyKonf h
qd kifu,frsm;/ armfawmfum;rsm; wajz;ajz;rsm;jym;vmonf? armfawmf,mOfrsm; pHepfwusESif harmif;ESifvmcJ h&mrH k&Gmòrd @t0ifod k @ nae (6)em&Dcef @wGif pwifa&muf&S dcJ honf? rH k&Gmod k @ a&muf&S donf htcg a':atmifqef;pk=unf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 66/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
66
tm; vma&mufqd konf holrsm;jym;vSojzif h òrd @vnf&S d em&Dpifod k @ n (9) em&DcG Jcef @wGifrS a&muf&S dcJ honf? rH k&GmwGifa':atmifqef;pk=unfu (45)rdepfcef @ rH k&Gmòrd @rdòrd @zrsm;ESif hjynfolvlxktm; rdef @cGef;ajym=um;cJ h+yD;/ wnwm &yfem;cJ h=uonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfonf v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,fwOD;.aetdrfwGif ntdyfwnf;cd k+yD; usef tzG J @0if
rsm;taejzif h oif hawmfonf hae&mrsm;wGif pDpOfwnf;cd k=uonf?
*? arv (30)&ufae@ eHeuf(10)em&DcG JwGif rH k&GmrS bkwvifòrd @od k @ pwifxGufcGmcJ honf? rk H&Gmòrd @rS txGufwGif'kwd,OuUX OD;wifOD;tygt0if/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h usaemfwd k @tzJ G @0ifrsm;onf aZmwdu bkef;}uD;ausmif;od k @ 0ifa&mufzl;ar#mfcJ honf// xd k @aemuf OuU Hawm&ausmif;od k @ 0ifa&mufzl;ar#mf&ef pDpOfxm;aomfvnf; q&mawmfr&S donf htwGuf bkwvifòrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf?
c&D;pwifxGufcGmpOf rH k&Gmòrd @vlxku armfawmf,mOf (10)pD;/ armfawmfqd kifu,f tpD; (150)cef @jzih f h vd kufygyd k @aqmif=uonf? bkwvifòrd @od k @ a&mufonf htcg bkwvifòrd @ òrd @e,ftzG J @csKyf &H k;zGif hyG JESif h qd kif;bkwfwifyG Jusif;y+yD;/
bkwvifòrd @e,f vli,ftzG J @ud k zG J @pnf;cJ honf? nae (4)em&D/ rdepf (30)cef @wGifbkwvifòrd @rS 'DyJ,if;òrd @od k @ xGufcGmcJ honf?xk dod k @xGufcGmvm&m pd kifjyif&Gmod k @ta&mufwGif zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;jcif;cHxm;&aom v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f OD;0if;jrif hatmif. aetdrfod k @0ifa&mufI a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rdom;pkESif htzG J @0ifrsm;uk d tm;ay;pum;ajym=um;cJ honf? 'DyJ,if;od k @ ra&mufrD a&S @ajy;tjzpfapv$wfxm;onf hum; jyefvnfa&mufvmjcif; r&S donf htwGuf armfawmfqd kifu,frsm;ud kpH kprf;&ef xyfrHapvGwfcJ honf? od k @aomf xd karmfawmfqd kifu,frsm;vnf; jyefvnf a&muf&S dvmjcif; r&S dyg?
9? xd k @od k @qufvufxGufcGmvm&m tcif;jzpfyGm;onf h pk difjyifESif h 'DyJ,if;t=um; usnf&GmteD;od k @ a&muf&S dcsdefwGif n (8;00)em&Dcef @&d S+yDjzpfonf? xd ktcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ESih f usaemfwd k @.um;t=um;wGiftjcm; armfawmf,mOf(2)pD;omjcm;ygonf? 'kwd,OuUX OD;wifOD; pD;vmonf hum;ua&@Sqk H;wGif&S d+yD;/'kwd,um;rSm a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; jzpfygonf? tv,fwGif (aps;csKdrS) OD;xGef;0if;ESif hOD;cifarmifaomif;wd k @vd kufygvmonf hum; &S daeonf? pwkwajrmufum;rSm usaemfwd k @um; ([d kif;vuftrsKd;tpm; tpdrf;a&mif)jzpfonf? rdrdwd k @.aemufwGif pOf hud kifòrd @e,f v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f a'gufwmvSpd k;!Gef @.um; (qefeDtjzLa&mif)jzpfonf? xd kum;.aemufwGif A[d kvli,ftzG J @.um; ([d kif;vuftjzLa&mif)/ xd kum;aemufwGif tzG J @csKyftzJ G @0ifrsm;.um;rsm; vd kufygvm=uonf?
usnf&GmrS ud kuf(100) cef @ ausmfvGefvmonf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. armfawmf,mOfud k bkef;}uD;(2)yg;u a&S @rSydwfqd k @+yD;wm;ygonf? ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu armfawmfum;ay:rS qif;ItusdK;ta=umif;ar;onf htcg xd kbkef;}uD;u “igwd k @apmif haewm=um+yD a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k rdef @cGef;ajymcd kif;ay;yg”[k ajymonf?ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfu tcsdef r&ojzih f rdef @cGef; rajymEd kifyg[k jyefvnf&Sif;jyygonf// xd kod k @&Sif;jypOf rk H&GmbufrSvd kuf
vmonh f 'd kifemum; (2)pD;/ axmfvm*sDum; (2)pD D; pkpkaygif;(4)pD;ay:rS vlrsm;u ‘jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;/ tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm; tvd kr&S d[k’ t}udrf}udrfatmf[pf+yD; um;ay:rS qif;vm=uonf?
xd ktcg usnf&GmrS &Gmom;rsm;uvnf; ‘'d k @jynfolvlxkuvnf; rif;wd k @ud k tvd kr&d S’ [k jyefatmf=uonf f?um;ay:wGifygvm=uaom =uh HzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;/ taygif;tygrsm;u ‘rif;wd k @ bmajymwmvJ ’[kqd k+yD; toif h,laqmifvmaom oHc|ef/ oHwkwf/ 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;/ opfom;'kwfrsm;ud k ud kifaqmifI qif;vm+yD; twif;t"rR0ifa&mufxd k;ESuf/ wd kufcd kuf=uonfud k usaemfwd k @ pdwfrcsrf;ompGmESif hjrifawG @=u&onf? xd ktcsdefwGif 'd kifemum;wpif;uvnf; awG @&mvlrsm;ud k vk dufvHwk dufck dufaeaoma=umif h usnf&GmrSvma&mufqd k=uonf h jynfolrsm;u ajcOD;wnf h&mok d @ xGufajy;=u&onf? a':pkum;ud kwm;+yD; w&m;a[mcd kif;onf h bkef;}uD;(2)yg;tm; wm;jrpfay;&ef
ajymonf h tcg ‘igwd k @ bmwwfEd kifrSmvJ/ rif;wd k @vnf; armif;csif&if armif;awmh’ [k ajymaecsdefrSmyif usaemfwd k @um;rsm;uk d pwifI ±k dufESufae=ujyDjzpfonf//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 67/208
67
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
10? usaemfu a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;. nmbufjcrf;wGif wm0ef,lxm;onf? xd ktcsdefwGif vH kjcHKa&;wm0ef,lxm;olrsm;. tajctaeud kajym&vsif usaemfu a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;. nmzufud k,fxnfESif huyfaeonf f? aemufwGif rnfolr# r&S dyg/ ab;wd kuftaexm;jzif h usaemfwd k @pDwef;I&yfae=uonf? um;u
vrf;.nmbufjcrf;wGif uyf&yfxm;jcif;jzpfI xd knmbufwGif wOD;p ESpfOD;pom &d Sonf? vufywfteD wawmifqpftxdywfxm;onf h bkef;}uD;ESpfyg;u usaemfwd k @um;wGif uyfvsuf&yfaeonf? um;wm;onf h bkef;}uD;(2)yg; r[kwfyg? xd ktcsdefwGif aemufwGif&S dor#um;rsm;ud k ‚if;wd k @vlrsm;tm;vk H; 0d kif;&d kufaeonf? usaemfwd k @ua': atmifqef;pk=unfum;. b,fzufab;wGif usaemfwd k @ vH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0iftm;vH k; ESpfxyfoH k;xyf um&Hay;xm;onf?
0if&d kufonhf =uH@zGH @tzGJ @0ifrsm;ESifhtca=u;aiGjzif hiSm;vmolrsm;tm;vkH; rl;,pfae=uonf? rHk&GmrSxGufvmpOfuyif ‚if;wd k @um;rsm;ay:wGif wd kifuDjywfrsm;jzif h t&uftjynf ho,fvm+yD; pdwf}udKufaomufcGif hjyKxm;onf[k od&onf? xd k @a=umif h rdrdwd k @,mOfrsm;tm; 0ifa&muf&d kufESufonf htcg vlrqefpGm&d kufESuf+yD;/ E_wfrSvnf;rif;wd k @u“ukvm;r taocHwyfawGvm;/ uJ 'gqd kvnf;ao=u/ ao=u” [kqd kum 0d kif;±k duf=uonf? vlrsm;onf hzufud k t"duxm;&d kufojzif h/ vlenf;onh f um;.nmzufjcrf;wGif&d Saom usaemfwk d @ t&d kuf rcH&yg? wzufjcrf;rSvlrsm; vJusoGm;onf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;rSefud k 0d kif;&d kufolrsm;u ±k dufcG Jvd kufygonf?um;rSef uG JoGm;onf htcg 'kwfrsm;jzif h um;twGif;od k @ aqmif hxd k;=uonf? xd ktcsdefwGif usefonf h usaemfwd k @u‘a':pk ajy;awmh/ ajy;awmh’[k atmfajym=uonf? xd kum;xJwGif ,mOfarmif;jzpfol ud kausmfpd k;vif;/ ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @ (3)OD;wnf;om &S dygonf?
aemufwGif&S daom OD;wifOD;.um;ud k 0d kif;±k duf+yD; xd kolrsm;u OD;wifOD;ud k qG Jac:oGm;onf? xd ktcsdefwGifOD;wifOD;.OD;acgif;wGif '%f&m&&S dxm;onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfonf um;xJrS rxGufojzif h t&d kufrcH& jcif;jzpf+yD;/ um;xJu xGufv#if &d kufonf holrsm;u tao&d kuf=urnfjzpfonf? tb,fa=umif hqd kaomf 0d kif;±k dufol
rsm;u vGefpGmrl;,pfaeaoma=umih fjzpfonf? t&ufrl;onf hyk HpH r[kwfbJ/ aq;rl;aeonf hyk HpHjzpfygonf? vlawGtm;vk H; &kwf&kwfoJoJjzpfaecsdefwGif &d kufESufaeolrsm; a':pkum;teD;od @ka&mufvm+yD; tvk H;t&if;ESih ftiftm;ok H;±k dufESuf=uonf? usaemfwd k @ wkef @jyefr_ r&d Saoma=umif h yd kI±k duf=u owf=uonf[kxifygonf//
wwd,um; ([d kif;vyftpdrf;a&mif)ay:wGif ygvmonf htrsdK;orD;rsm;ud kvnf; xrD/ tusF Drsm;qG Jc|wf+yD;&d kufonf? t&d kufcH&aoma=umif h aoG;tvl;vl;ESif hvJusoGm;onf htcg vJaeolawGtay:rS um;,m;wufcGI/qHyifud kvufjzih f&pfcsnf+yD; acgif;uk dausmufvrf;ESih f tpGrf;ukef ud kifaqmif h=uonf? vlrqefpGmjzif h yufyufpufpuf vkyfaeonfud kawG @&onf// vJusaeonf htrsdK;orD; (oE Wmpd k;/ 'kwd,ESpfausmif;ol)xHrS em;uyfud kvnf;twif;c|wf,laeonfud k usaemfud k,fwd kif jrifawG @ae&ygonf? ‚if;wd k @yg;pyfuvnf; ‘ukvm;ud k vifawmfcsifwh J
[mrawG ao=uprf;/ ukvm; t&if igwd k @u eifwd k @ud k vifvkyfypfr,f? igwd k @uawmh vrf;awGazmuf/ vrf;awGjyif/wHwm;awGjyifeJ @ eifwd k @u ukvm;ud k vifawmfcsif=uwm/ ao=uprf;/ ao=uprf;’[kqd k+yD; r=um;0H hremom&d kif;pd kif;,kwfrmonf hpum;vH k;rsm;jzif hajymqd k+yD; &uf&ufpufpuf taoowf=uonf? aemufwGif &yfxm;onf hum;rsm;rSvnf; um;a&S @rD;}uD;rsm;xd k;ay;xm;aoma=umif h usaemfwd k @taeESif h tjzpftysuftm;vk H;ud k jrifae& ygonf? aoG;tvl;vl;ESif hvJusaeolrsm;ud k vlrqefpGmjzif h rnmrwm &d kufESufaeonfud k jrif&onf hjrifuGif;onfusaemhrsufpdxJrS tckcsdeftxd rxGufawmhyg?
11? a':atmifqef;pk=unfpD;vmonf hum; xGufoGm;+yD;aemuf usaemfwd k @vnf; xGufajy;=uonf? tcsKd @qd kifu,frsm;jzif hxGufajy;=uonf? ajcvsifxGufajy;=uolrsm;wGif usaemf/ OD;Zif;wyg;tygt0if (3)a,muf
jzpfonf// cyfa0;a0;od k @ajy;+yD;onf htcg usaemfwd k @ qufrajy;Ed kifawmhyg// xd ktcsdefrSmyif aemufrSum;wpD;armif;vmonfud kawG @ojzif h usaemfwd k @ wm;vd kufonf// usaemfwd k @tzG J @xJrS um;jzpfaeonf f// xd kum;.pufacgif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 68/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
68
ay:o@d k usaemfwd k @ (3)a,mufpvk H; wufvd kuf=uonf? xd kum;rSm a&S ho@d k odyfrarmif;vd kuf&yg? }uh HzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif htaygif;tygwpk a&S @rSóudapmif haeonf? xd ka&S @wGifyif qd kifu,frsm; tpD;av;q,f ig;q,fcef @ t&d kufcHae&onf?usaemfwd k @vnf; um;ud kaemufqkwf+yD;armif;ajy;ch J&onf// usaemfwd k @ yxrt&d kufcH&onf hae&mESif h ‚if;wd k @óud
apmif haeonf hae&mrSm um;jzif h (10)rdepfcef @armif;&ygonf// ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;ud kvnf; jrifae&ygonf// a&S @ok d @ajy;vnf; rvGwf/ aemufok d@jyefvSnf hajy;yguvnf; rvGwfEd kifonfhtajctaejzpfonfhtwGuf vrf;eab;wGifjrif&onf h vrf;cG J[kxif&onf hae&mok d @ usaemfwd k @um; qif;csvd kuf&ygonf? od k @aomf vrf;r[kwfbJ acsmufjzpfaeygonf? um;rSm AGufxJok d @epfoGm;ojzif h f/ vltm;vk H;qif;I wGef;onf htcg yxr tenf;i,fa&G @oGm;onf?a&S @em;a&mufonf htcg bD;u csdKif hxJu|HoGm;ygonf? xd ktcg wGef;I r&awmhyg// xrif; rpm;&ao;aoma=umif hvnf;aumif;/ vd kufowfI ajy;&aoma=umif hvnf;aumif;/ yifyef;+yD; um; rwGef;Ed kifawmhyg?
um;ay:wGif vl (18)a,mufce@fygonf? xd kolrsm;rSm txufArmjynf vli,fwm0efcH ud kwifxGÉfOD;/ 'kwm0efcH ud krsKd;Ek dif/ wG Jbufwm0efcH ud kvSOD;/ A[d kvli,f ud kodef;pd k;wd k @tygt0if vk HjcKHa&; wm0ef,l&efygvmonf hrE Wav;rSvli,ftzG J @0ifrsm; jzpfonf// um;ud k vSnf hr=unf hed k kifawmhbJ usaemfwd k @tm;vk H; ab;vGwf&mo@d k xGufajy;=uygonf// uHaumif;ojzif h usaemfwd k @ajy;onf hae&mrSm jcHKykwf}uD;jzpfaeygonf// xd kod k @xGufajy;=uonf htcgud kwifxGÉfOD;ESif h ud krsKd;Ek difwd k @ usaemfwd k @ESif htwl rygvmawmhyg// usaemfwd k @ajy;onf hae&mwGif yxr xGufajy;olrsm;ESif hawG @&onf// tm;vH k;aygif; qd kifu,f(49)pD;ESih f vlaygif; (97)a,mufud k jyefqH kawG @&onf? jyefawG @=uolrsm;rSm rH k&GmESif h ppfud kif;wd k @rS rdrdwd k @ ,mOfwef;ESif htwl vd kufygvm=uonf h ausmif;om;ausmif;olrsm;jzpf=uonf?eHeufrd k;vif;onf h tcg a&wGuf=unf hI od&jcif;jzpfonf?
xd kolrsm;xJwGif }uh HzG H h @u cd kif;Iqd k+yD; usaemfwd k @ud k&d kufonf htzJ G @xJu (2)a,mufygvmonf? usaemfwd k @u ar;aoma=umif h ‚if;wd k @ajymjyjcif; r[kwfyg/ ‚if;wk d @ud k,fwd kif zGif hajymjcif;jzpfonf? ‘usaemfwd k @u woufeJ @wud k,f 'grd sK;vnf; rvkyfch Jzl;bl;? vkyfvnf; rvkyf&ufvd k @ tud kwd k @eJ @a&m+yD; ajy;vmwm yg’ [kajymjyygonf?
12// arv(31)&ufae@eHeuf (5;00)em&DwGif qd kifu,frsm;/ vlrsm;ud ka&wGufI tm;vk H; vrf;ray:od k @ wufoGm;=uonf// qd kifu,frsm;ud k vrf;ay: rwuf&efwm;aomfvnf; ZGwfwufoGm;=uonf// usaemfESif hud kcspf&ifwd k @xd kae&mwGifae&pfch J+yD; vrf;ay:wufonf f htzJ G @xJwGif ud kvSOD;ygoGm;onf? vrf;ay:a&mufonf hqd kifu,frsm;ud k&Jum;u aoewfjzif hypfIwm;qD;onfud k usaemfwd k @vSrf;jrifae&onf? xd ktcsdefwGifaoewfoH (7)csuf=um;& onf// xd kod k @aom tjzpftysuftm;vk H;ud kjrif&olrSm oE Wmpd k;jzpf+yD; olru nuyifa&Smifwdrf;&if; vrf;ESif hrvSrf;rurf;&S d opfyifay:wGif&d Saejcif;jzpfI reufyd kif;wGif jzpfysufcJ honf hudpP&yftm;vk H;ud k opfyifay:rSjrifawG @ae&onf?oE Wmpd k;ESif h ud k&ifav; (3)yg; um;vrf;ray:wuf&efjyifqifaecsdefwGif usaemfvSrf;ac:onf htwGuf vrf;ray:
rwufbJ usaemfwd k @qDud k jyefvmygonf// roE Wmpd k;rSm rE Wav;uyif usaemfwd k @ESif hum;wpD;xJwGif twlvd kufvmoljzpf+yD;/ rE Wav;wuUod kvf/ 'kwd,ESpfausmif;oljzpfonf? rE Wav;uyifvd kufvm=uonf h trsdK;orD;tm;vH k; ta,muf(20) cef @&S dygonf? vljyefpk=uonf htcg yk H @yk H @ESif hcifrrxGef;wd k @ygonf hum; vk H;0aysmufqk H;ae+yD;/usefonf htrsdK;orD;rsm;vnf; rnfonh fae&mok d @a&mufaerSef; rod=uawmhyg//
13? usaemfwd k @u um;vrf ;ray: rwufawmhbJ v,fuGif;twd kif;av#mufvmcJ h&m ,if;awG&Gmod k @ a&muf&S dcJ honf? xd k&Gmol&Gmom;rsm;u xrif;au|;onf htwGuf xrif;pm;+yD; acwWem;cJ hygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif tjyifrSjyefvmonf huav;i,fwOD;u &Gmvl}uD;u pk Hprf;ar;jref;aeonf[kajymqk dojzih f usaemfwd k @ xd k&GmrS jyefvnfxGufcGmcJ hygonf? tcsdeftm;jzif h rdepf(30)cef @ av#muf +yD;onf htcg a'ocHaus;&Gmom;(6)OD;ud kawG @&S d&onf? xd kolrsm;u
‚if;wd k @.v,fuGif;rsm;od k @ ac:aqmifoGm;+yD; wnwm apmif ha&Smufxm;onf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 69/208
69
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
14? ZGefv (1) &ufae@ eHeuf (5)em&DtcsdefwGif ntdyfwnf;cd konf hv,fuGif;rS pwif xGufcGmcJ honf?vrf;c&D;wGif awG @&onf h v,form;rsm;xHrS rdrd.ucsifvk HcsnfESif htusôtjzLud k vJvS,f0wfqifch J&onf? a&$bd kòrd @e,f qiftif;aus;&Gmtxd &Gmom;wa,mufu vd kufyd k @ay;ygonf? (15)rd kifce@ftxd xd k&Gmom;u vd kufyd k @+yD;qiftif;a&mufonftxd &Gmrsm;uk djzwfI vrf;av#mufch J&ygonf? qiftif;rSa&$bd d kod k @ um;pD;+yD;/ a&$bd d kodk @a&mufonf htcg todrdwfaqGtdrfY acwWc% wnf;cd kygonf// a&$bd kwGif&S daepOf 'DyJ,if;&d kufyG JrS jyefvmonf h
vl(8)a,mufESif h awG @&ygonf f? ‚if;wd k @u tvkyfr&d SI&SmaecsdefwGif vlwa,mufu tvkyfay;rnfqd k+yD; =uH hzG @H&k H;od k @ac:oGm;a=umif;/ ae@wGuftaejzif h wae@ud k aiG(800)usyfay;rnf/ xrif;au|;rnf/ t&ufwd kufrnfjzpfa=umif;/vlwpkud k 0d kif;&d kufay;&rnfjzpfa=umif;/ xd k&k H;xJrSvl}uD;rsm;ud k a=umufI [kwfuh Jyg[k ‚if;wd k @taejzif h uwday;ch Ja=umif; ajymjyonf? t&ufwd kufonfud k pd kifjyifrSmuwnf;uyif usaemfwd k @ jrifawG @cJ h&ygonf//
a&Gbd krS rE Wav;od k @ armfawmfum;jzif h rGef;vG J (1)em&Dcef @wGif xGufcGmcJ h&m rE Wav;od k @ nae (3)em&DcG Jcef @wGifa&muf&S dcJ hygonf?
usaemfonf txufyg trSwfpOf (1) rS (14)txdyg&S daom ta=umif;t&mrsm;ud k rnfolr# rw&m;=oZmv$rf;rd k;jcif;/ +cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ aoG;aqmifjzm;a,mif;jcif;/ vdrfvnfvSnf hjzm;jcif; r&S dbJ rdrd. vGwfvyfonf hoabmqENt& xkwfazmfajym=um;jcif;jzpf+yD;/ trSwfpOf(1)rS (14)xdyg&S donf h ta=umif;t&mrsm;onfrdrdud k,fwd kifawG @/ ud k,fwd kifjrif/ ud k,fwd kifodonf h ta=umif;t&mrsm; jzpfa=umif; 0efcHuwdjyKygonf?
0Àarmif0Àarmif0Àarmif0Àarmif0Àarmif2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (30) &uf2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (30) &uf2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (30) &uf2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (30) &uf2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (30) &uf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 70/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
70
a':nGefŒ nGefŒ. uwdopP mjyKxGufqd kcsuf
trnf a':!Gef @!Gef @/touf (51) ESpf/vlrsdK; jrefrm/Zmwd arjrdK@
ud k;uG,fonf hbmom Ak'<bmom/cifyGef;trnf OD;atmifEd kifOD;/ rE Wav;+rdK@?tvkyftud kif rS Dcd kae&yfvdyfpm tES dyfawmf&yf/ 75§1/ pusif0/eef;awmfa&S @/rEWav;jrdK@
usr a':nGef @nGef honf arv(30)&ufae@wGifjzpfyGm;cJ honf h 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hywfoufI uwdopPmjyK xGuf qd konfrSm æ
1? usronf trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG @JcsKyfod k @/ 1989 ckESpfwGif0ifa&mufcJ h+yD; rE Wav;/ taemufajrmufòrd @e,fwGif/ pnf;&k H;a&;rª;wm0efxrf;aqmifch Jygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. txufjrefrmjynf pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfwGif rd k;ukwfrStjyef rE Wav;rS oGm;a&mufóudqd k=uonf htzJ G @wGif usrvnf; wOD;tygt0ifjzpfygonf?wm0eft&vd kufygjcif; r[kwfyg/ tzJ G @0ifrsm;ud kom vd kufygcGif hjyKjcif;jzpfaomfvnf;/ 1990 ckESpfwGiftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf a&G;aumufyG JatmifEd kifa&;twGuf rd kif (180)txd ajcvsifav#mufI &rnf;oif;/ jypDtxd(1)vESif h&uf(20)txd pnf;&H k;a&;qif;cJ holjzpfonf htwGuf usrtm;taemufajrmufòrd @e,frSoGm;a&mufóudqd konf hum;ESif htwl vd kufygcGif hjyKcJ hjcif;jzpfygonf?
2? rd k;ukwfod k @oGm;onf h usrwk d @. taemufajrmufòrd @e,fum;wGif atmifol/ OD;cspfwif/ a':aX;/ rmrmcd sK/
usrESif h vli,ftzG J @0ifrsm; (10)OD;cef @vd kufygcJ hygonf? usnfawmufaygufaus;&GmteD;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;u 'd kifemum;(14)pif;cef @&S dum;rsm;ay:wGif pD;eif;vd kufygvm+yD; 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;um usrwd k@tm;“ukvm;r,m; tvk dr&d S/ jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k;tqdk;jrif 0g'Drsm;tm;tvd kr&d S”[kqd kum &d kufykwf&efpjcif;ud k=uHKawG @&ygonf? jynfolrsm;ESif h usrwd k @.,mOfwef;rsm;twGif;od k @ ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;.tultnDjzif h tqd kygaESmif h,Sufolrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm;u twif;armif;ESif 0ifa&mufvmygonf? usrwd k @.um;rsm;ESif h ,SOfrd+yDqd kygu ud kifaqmifxm;onf h'kwfrsm;jzif h xd k;rwwf/ &d kufrwwf vkyf=uonf htjyif &kef @&if;=urf;wrf;onf hpum;rsm;jzif h ajymqd kjcif;ud kvnf; usrwd k @cHcJ h&ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif hywfoufI “ukvm;ud k tm;uk d;csifovm;”pojzif h &efvd konf hpum;rsm;ud kajymygonf? xd kod k @ &efpajymqd k
onfud k (3)em&Dausmfr# cHch J&ygonf? jynfolrsm;uvnf;a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;teD;od k @ E_wfqufóudqd k=u&efa&mufvmonf htcg tqd kygum;ay:ygolrsm;ESif hum;rsm;u jynfolvlxkESif ha':atmifqef;pk=unf rawG @qH kEd kifap
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 71/208
71
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
&ef enf;rsdK;pH kjzif h t"rRaESmif h,Suf=uygonf? xd kod k @aESmif h,Sufonf htwGuf rE Wav;rSvd kufygvmonf h rdrdwd k @.trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifvli,fwOD; xdcd kuf'%f&m&cJ hygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu xd kod k @ tzG J @0ifwOD; aoG;ajrus &onf hudpPtwGuf oufqd kif &m&Jpcef;wGifwd kifcsufzGif hch Jonf [k usrwd k @ud k ajymjyygonf?
‘jynfolawG vrf;ay:uz,f=uyg/ um;vm+yD/ cifAsm;wd k @uk dwd kufrdrSm pd k;vk d @/aocsif;qd k;eJ @ aoukefr,f’[kajymonf htcsdefwGif usrwk d @ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS ,leDazmif;0wfqifxm;onf hvli,frsm;u vrf;rab;rSaeI jynfolrsm;.a&S @rS vufrsm;ud kwG JI vrf;ud kwm;ay;vd kufygonf? xd kod k @ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrSvli,frsm;uwm;ay;vk dufojzif h vrf;jcm;ay;vd kufouJ hod k @jzpfoGm;+yD; óudqd kae=uonf hjynfolrsm; pnf;urf;wusjzpfoGm;ygonf// xd ktcsdefwGif ‘vrf;pnf;urf;ud k em;vnfyg/ pnf;rh Jurf;rh J roGm;ygeJ @/ jynfolawGaemufqkwfyg’qd konfrsm;ud k ta=umif;r&S dbJ avmfpyDumwyfqifxm;onf hum;rsm;ay:rS ZGwfatmfaeygonf? a': atmifqef;pk=unfu qD;óudaeonf hjynfolvlxkud k rdef @cGef;ajym&mwGif “usr tck=unf haewh JtcsdefrSm bmum;rSvmwm rawG @ygbl;/ usr pum;ajymrSmrd k @vd k @ oufoufrh Japmfum;wmyJ/ vlr_a&;t&/ wa,mufe@Jwa,mufem;vnfr_&d S&if aumif;ygw,f/ rae@uvnf; usrwd k @tzJ G @uvli,fwOD; xdcd kufrdwJ htwGufaoG;ajruscJ h&w,f/usr tr_zGif hch Jygw,f/ tr_zGif hwh JtwGuf aiG(50)usyfay;&w,f? tr_u wa,mufu aewa,mufud k owfwh Jtr_/ aemufwr_uvnf; vlwOD;u vlwOD;ud k owfwh Jtr_/ (2)r_pvk H;[m vlowfr_yJjzpfw,f// 'Dvlowfr_ud kawmh tjypfay;+yD;/ aemuf vlowfr_ud ktjypfray;&if tJ'g rrSefuefwh JOya'yJ/ tJ'DOya'ud k usrwk @dacszsuf&r,f/aemifvmaemufom;orD;awGud k 'D rrSefuefwJ h Oya'u rxdyg;ap&bl;? tc kusrzGif hch Jwh Jtr_ud k b,fvd kpD&ifcsufcsrvJqd kwmud k &Sifwd k @em;axmifaeyg”[k xd kae@u a':atmifqef;pk=unfajymonf hrdef @cGef;xJwGif xnf hoGif; ajym=um;cJ hygonf?
3? usrwd k @ qufoGm;onf htcg rwW&mud ka&mufygonf/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rwW&mòrd @e,f trsdK;om;
'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud kaqmif&Gufygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif 'd kifemum;wpD;a&muf&S dvm+yD; avmfpyDumESif hatmfI aESmif h,Sufjcif;ud k &ifqd kif&ygonf? xd ktcsdefrSmyif uGrf;,ma&mif;onf hvli,fwOD;u 'DbufuxGuf&if‘a&xGufprf;teD;wGif 'kwfrsm;/'g;rsm;ESif hapmif haea=umif; ’ usrwd k @ud kvmajymjyygonf? usrvnf; wqufwnf;v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f y'krRm OD;armifarmifoef;(&rnf;oif;)ESif h vli,facgif;aqmifjzpfolud kwifxGÉfOD;(v,fa0;)wd k @ud k today; ta=umif;=um;vd kufygonf?
ud kwifxGÉfOD;u vk HjcHKa&;tajctae odyfraumif;onf htwGuf aemufxyf vmóudyg&ef rE Wav;wd kif;&H k;od k @ta=umif;=um;tultnDawmif;cHygonf? oHCmawmfrsm;u vnf;vrf;c&D;wGif vH kjcHKa&;twGufpdk;&drfIrE Wav;xd vd kufygyd k @aqmifay;ygonf? rd k;ukwfrS rE Wav;c&D;pOfwavsmuf usrwd k @twGuf vk HjcKHa&; bmrSr&d S
yg? tb,fa=umif hqd kaomf usrwd k @rd k;ukwfòrd @od k @ óudqd ka&;c&D; puwnf;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfrS nGef=um;csufay;xm;+yD;jzpfygonf? “&ef rvd k&bl;/ rp &bl;/ jzpfvm&ifacgif;ik H @cHvd kuf”pojzif hajymxm;onf htwGufusrwd k @ jyefvSefajymcGif hvnf; r&d Syg/ &efvd konf hrsufvk H;ESif hyif r=unf h&[k usrwd k @ud k ajymjyxm;ygonf? rE Wav;rSxyfrHac:vd kufonf h vk HjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm; xyfrHa&mufvm+yD;aemuf usrwd k @onf rE Wav;+rdK@ud kywfI rE Wav;wd kif;trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&k H;od k @ n(6)em&DcG J (7)em&Dcef @wGifa&muf&d Sygonf? rE Wav;òrd @ trsd K;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&H k;od k @a&mufonf htcg toif hapmif hóudae=uonf hvlxk}uD;tm; a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rdef @cGef;ajym=um;ygonf? xd kod k @ rdef @cGef;ajymaeonf htcsdefwGif ,mOfxdef;&JESif h &Jrsm;uvltkyfrsm;twGif;od k @armfawmf,mOf(2)pif;ud k t"rRarmif;ESifI 0ifcd kif;onfud kawG @&ygonf?arv(28)&ufae@wGif rE Wav;wd kif;&H k;od k @ oGm;a&mufvnfywf&if; pum;ajymqd konf htcg OuUX OD;bd kZH/ OD;uHxGef;/ OD;ud k}uD;/ OD;wifatmif/ armifarmifoef;wk d @u usrtm;
a':atmifqef;pk=unf. rH k&Gmc&D;pOfwGif twlvd kufygoGm;&efajymygonf? ud k,f hpm;&dwfESif hud k,f um;iSm;IoGm;&jcif;jzpfonf htwGuf aiGa&;a=u;a&;udpPud kvnf; usr.rdom;pkESif hjyefwd kifyif&ygonf//armfawmf,mOfiSm;&ef
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 72/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
72
twGuf ukefusrnf hum;iSm;cud k ulnDaeaomolrsm;u pkaygif;ulnDaomfvnf; tjcm;vd ktyfonf haiGa=u;ud kud k,fwd kifjznf h+yD; pDpOf&jcif;jzpfygonf? ud k,f hxrif;ud k,fpm;&rnfjzpfonf htwGuf iwfcsifiwfrnf/ cifyGef;jzpfoluusrud k xd kc&D;pOfwGif vd kufygoGm;&efoabmwlcGif hjyKygonf?
4? xd k @a=umif h arv(29)&ufae@wGif rE Wav;/ rH k&Gmòrd @e,fpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfud k a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih ftwlvd kufygcJ hygonf? rE Wav;r SpIvd kufygvmaom rE Wav;wd kif; trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;.um;rsm;rSm (11)pif;cef @ &S dygonf? qd kifu,frsm;tygt0if ppfud kif;wHwm;ud ka&muf&S donf htcsdefwGif ppfud kif;òrd @t0ifY a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; qef @usifqENjy&efapmif hqd kif;aeolrsm;u qd kif;bkwf frsm;ud kifaqmifxm;+yD;toHwdwf uef @uGufqENjyaeonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? ppfud kif;rS qufvufxGufcGmvm&m jrif;rlòrd @od k @a&muf&S dygonf? jrif;rlòrd @wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf qd kif;bkwfwif+yD; trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. jrif;rlòrd @e,fvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k vkyfaqmifygonf? xd ktcsdefrSpI usrwd k @um;rsm;.aemufrS qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;.x&yfum;rsm; pwifvdkufygvmonfudkjrifawG@&ygonf? jrif;rlrStxGuf vrf;c&D;wavsmufwGifrnfonfhtaESmif ht,Sufud krS rawG @&yg? rH k&Gmòrd @od k @ra&mufrD a&yd k;pm;&Gmod k @a&mufonf htcg 'd kifemum;rsm;ESif h c&D;onfwifum; ajrmufrsm;pGmud kjrifawG @&ygonf? um;wd kif;wGif ,mOfxdef;&JESif h &Jrsm;vd kufygvmygonf? a&yd k;pm;&Gmod k @ta&mufwGif vltiftm;(200)(300)cef @ESif h um;u(13)pD;r#&S donf h vltkyf}uD;ud kawG @&ygonf? xd kae&mwGifqd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf htrsKd;orD;rsm;u usrwd k @.,mOfrsm;tm; pwiftaESmif ht,Suf ay;=uygonf?rk H&Gmòrd @t0ifud knae(6)em&Dcef @wGifa&muf&S dygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @wGif;&S d trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&H k;od k @ n (10)em&DtcsdefwGif a&muf&S dygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @rSjynfolrsm;u vd _ufvS JpGmjzif h wcJeufóudqd k=uygonf? tcsKd @tzGm;tk d}uD;rsm;u “Ak dvfcsKyforD;av; b,frSmvJ/ Ak dvfcsKyforD;av; jyygOD;/ um;&yfygOD;” [kqd kum yef;rsm;ay;I óudqd k=uygonf? óudqd k=uonf holrsm;rSm rH k&Gmòrd @ESif hteD;w0d kufrSjzpfjyD; eHeufuwnf;uapmif hae=uonf[kod&ygonf?rH k&Gmòrd @wGifa':atmifqef;pk=unfrS rH k&Gmjynfolvlxktm;rdef @cGef;ajym=um;+yD;aemuf n(1)em&Dcef @wGif trsdK;om;
'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k pdefr#m;pwd k;wGif f jyKvkyfygonf?
29=5=2003 &ufaeŒ rk H±G mtoG m; acsmif;OD;òrdŒe,f/ a&yd k;pm;aus;&G mteD;
tiftm;(300)cefŒ &S dvltkyf}uD;u qd kif;bkwfrsm; ud kifaqmifI atmf[pfqJqd k aES mif h,SufaepOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 73/208
73
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
5? arv (30)&ufae@ eHeuf(6)em&Dcef @wGif um;rsm; pxGuf&efjyifqifygonf? eHeuf(9)em&Dcef @wGifrH k&Gmòrd @cHvlxktm; a':atmifqef;pk=unfu E_wfqufpum;ajymqd k+yD; xGufcGmvmygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @rS bkwvifòrd @od k @txGufwGif aZmwdu(*sKd;jzL)bkef;awmf}uD;ausmif;ud k 0ifIuefawmhygonf? rk H&GmrS pxGufonf htcsdefwGif
usrwd k @. um;ay:wGif usrESif htwl tjcm;vl(15)OD;cef @ vd kufyg vmyg onf? atmifuk d/ wifarmifav;/ OD;oG,f/OD;cspfwif/ odef;atmifav;/ 0Àarmif / rE Wav;/ xGefwH k;&yfuGufrS (a':atmifqef;pk=unf.vH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0if)/trsKd;orD;rsm;jzpfaom usr/a':cifat;jrih f/tao;av;(c)oE Wmpd k;ESif h tjcm; trnfrrSwfrdonf htzG J @0if topfrsm;yg0ifygonf? usrwd k @um;.aemufwGif vd kufygvmonf hum;ay:wGif rH k&Gmòrd @rS uk d&ifav;rsm;ESif h bkef;}uD;pkpkaygif;(13)yg;cef @ vd kufygvmonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? bkwvifod k @a&mufonf htcg t&yfom;c&D;onfwifum;rsm; oGm;vmae=uonfud k vk H;0 rawG @&awmhyg// xd krSwqif h pk difjyif&Gmod k @a&mufygonf// v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,fwOD;.aetdrfwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfu 0ifa&muftm;ay;pum;ajym+yD; acwWtem;,lyg onf?
6? pk difjyifrS n(7)em&Dcef @wGif pwifxGufcGmvmygonf? taESmif ht,Suf rawG @&ao;yg/ ,ck tcsif;jzpfyGm;onf husnf&Gmuk d rdepf(20)cef @omarmif;ESif&ygonf// usnf&Gmuk da&mufonf htcg óudqk d=uonf h ywf0ef;usif&Gmrsm;rS &Gmol&Gmom;rsm;ESif h usnf&Gmol&Gmom;rsm;ud kawG @&ygonf?a':atmifqef;pk=unf. um;u usrwd k @.um;a&S @od k @ ausmfwufarmif;ESifoGm;ojzif h usrwd k @um;.aemufwGif um;(2)pD;om usef&d Sygawmhonf? usrwk d @um;wef;ESif htwlvd kufygvmonf h qk difu,form;wOD;u ‘aemufrSm &Gmom;awGuk d &k dufae+yD’[k vmI ta=umif;=um;ojzif h usrwk @d.um;vnf; &yfvk dufygonf// usrwd [email protected];ay:wGif twlvdkufygvmonfh 0Àarmif(xGefwH k;&yfuGufvli,fvH kjcHKa&;tzG J @)ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf. vH kjcHKa&;wm0ef,lxm;onf h A[d kvli,fvH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;ua':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; &S donf hae&mod k @ oGm;ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif usrwk d @um;ay:rSm vli,f(5)OD;cef @om usefygonf? usrvnf; um;ay:rSqif;+yD; aemufod k @=unf hvk dufonf htcg &Gmom;rsm;uk d um;rD;rsm;xk d;+yD; &k dufaeonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? um;rsm;rSm ajrmufbufukdvSnh fxm;+yD; usnf&GmrSmvnf; ajrmuf
bufwGif &d Sygonf// xd kod k @armfawmf,mOfwef;rsm;tm; pwif&d kufaeonf htcsdefwGif 'kwd,OuUXjzpfol (OD;wifOD;)u a':atmifqef;pk=unf&S daeonf hum;xH vli,f(2)a,mufESif htwloGm;onfud k aemufqH k;jrifawG @&ygonf?
7? aemufrSvd kufvm+yD; &d kufonf holrsm;a&mufvmonf htcsdefwGif usrwd k @.um;ay:wGif usef&S daeolrsm;tm;vk H; um;ay:wGifacgif;csif;qd kifI0yfae&ygonf? tb OD;cspfwifu rdef;r(3)OD;tay:wGif 0rf;vsm;xk d; arSmufay;xm;ygonf? &d kufESufolrsm;u rdef;r(3)a,mufuk d (4)cg&k dufvsif tb OD;cspfwifyJ (4)csufcH&ygonf? xd k @a=umif h &d kufESufolrsm;u tb OD;cspfwifud k um;ay:u qG Jxkwfvk dufygonf? OD;cspfwif.atmufwGif&S daeaomusrwd k @ ud k,fvk H;ay:vmrS/ usrtusôud k qG J+zJvk duf+yD; cg;ud k tkwfcJjzif h xkygonf? usrwd k @ trsd K;orD;rsm;taejzif h
yifeDtusô&ifzH k;wxnfud kom 0wfqifcJ hygonf? tcsdK@ trsdK;om;rsm;rSm yifeDwd kufyk Htusôtc|wfcH&vsifvnf;/atmufwGif &SyftusôtjzLusefaeao;onf? wd kufyk Htusô r0wfxm;olrsm;rSm ud k,fwk H;vk H;usefonftxd yifeDtusôrsm;ud k qkwfjzJjypfygonf? xd kuJ hod k @ &d kufESufaepOf usrud k 0g;qpfjzif h(2)csufcef @&k dufygonf? xd kod k @ &d kufESuf+yD;onf htcg ‚if;wd k @u um;ay:od k @wufvm+yD;/ c&D;aqmiftdwfrsm;ud kqG J,l/ trsKd;orD;tcsKd @.qG Jóud;rsm;ud k jzwf,l=uygonf?
8? usrwd k @tm; um;ay:rSqG Jcs+yD; atmufa&mufonf htcsdefwGif tusôuk dqG Jc|wfcH&jcif;jzpfygonf? trsdK;orD;rsm;tm;vH k;. yifeDtuF sDrsm; ausmzufrSpkwf+yJukefojzif h usrwk d @trsdK;orD;rsm;tm;vH k; xrD&ifvsm;rsm;jzif hae&ygonf? usr.tusôrSm aemufzufwGifpkwf+yJjcif;jzpf+yD; tusô.a&S @zufjcrf;rSm ru|wfao;yg? usrud k&k dufonf holrsm;wGif bkef;}uD;ESpfyg; yg0ifygonf? vli,fydefydefaumifav;wOD;u &Syftuô stjzL0wfqifxm;+yD; OD;xkyf
ud k aemufjyefaqmif;xm;jyD; ykqd k;ud k pvG,fod kif;xm;ygonf? usrwd k @.um;ay:rS vltm;vH k;ud k um;atmufod k @qG Jcsygonf? ajcaxmufrS qG Jcsjcif;cH&onf holrsm;onf um;vrf;ray:od k @ rsufESmjzif @ðywfusonf htcg atmufrS
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 74/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
74
toif hapmif haeolrsm;u ud kifaqmifxm;onf h 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;jzif h wqufwnf;0d kif;&k duf=uygonf? usrud k um;ay:rS qG Jcsonf htcgwGif OD;acgif;ud kud kifqG J+yD; um;atmufod k @csjcif;jzpfonf htwGuf um;ay:rS ab;wd kuftaetxm;jzif h usr ðywfusvmygonf?usr. b,fzufausmwjcrf;vk H; uwW&mvrf;ESif hyGwfwd kufrdojzif h yGef;yJ h
pkwfjywfukefygonf? um;atmufod k @ usonf hae&mrS usr.qHyifud kqG JI '&Gwfwd kufqG Jac:oGm;+yD; usr.acgif;ud kvrf;rESif h qG Jud kifIaqmif hygonf? xd kod k @qG Jaqmif haepOf &d kufESufaeolrsm;xJrS wOD;u usrud k ‘ukvm;r,m;jzpfcsifwmvm;/ ukvm;r,m;ud k tm;ud k;wmvm;/ igwd k @u wHwm;awGaqmuf/ vrf;awGazmufaewmud k/eifwd k @ eif;vmwmr[kwfvm;/ igwd k @azmufxm;wJ hvrf;rSm eifwd k @pD;vmwm/ armif;vmwm r[kwfvm;/ 'gawGrodbl;vm;’ [kajymqd k+yD; usrud k 0g;c|efjzif hxk d;ygonf? rsufESmESif hrsufvH k;ud kawmh rxdyg? xd k @aemuf 'Daumifr'D yifeDtusôyJrufaew,f [kqd kum usr.tuô sud kqG Jc|wfojzif h usru vH kcsnfud k uAsmuoD qG Jwifvd kuf& ygonf? wqufwnf;rSmyif usr0wfqifxm;onf hxrDud kvnf; atmufrSqG Jc|wfygonf? xrDrSm aoG;rsm;ayae+yD; aoG;pD;rsm;jzif h pD;uyfaeonf htwGuf xrDud krl c|wfIr&yg/ usrvnf; xrDuk d csdKif;ESpfzufjzif h n‡yf+yD;xrD&ifvsm;xm;&ygonf? xd k @aemuf usrtm; 0g;&if;wkwfjzif h&k dufygonf? usr owdrar@ciftcsdefwGif vlaoaeonf hum;ud k vSrf;jrif&ygonf? usrESif h um;wpD;wnf;twlvd kufygvmonf h roEWmpd k;uf d k ‘'grdef;rvm;/a,musfm;vm;’[kajymqd kum tusôc|wfae/ ¶d kufaeonf htoHrsm;ud k =um;&ygonf? olrtm; ¶d kufaeonfud kusr odaeygonf? um;ay:wGif ygvm olrsm;xHrS qG Jóud;ðzwf,ljcif;/ yd kufqHrsm;ud kvk,ljcif;rsm;ud k &d kufESufolrsm;u ðyvkyfaeonfud k usr jrifawG @ae&ygonf? xd kod k @&d kufESufaepOf vlwOD;a&mufvmjyD; awmf=uawmh[k ajymqd kum a&rD;/ a&rD;qd konf h oauFwrsm;ud kajym+yD; olwd k @pD;vmonf hum;rsm;jzif h jyefvnfxGufoGm;=uonfud k awG @&ygonf? ‚if;wf d k @xGufoGm;+yD;aemuf em&D0ufcef @xd tarSmifxJ wGifjidrfae&ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif &GmxJrSbkef;}uD;wyg;ESif h vl(5)OD;cef @ a&mufvmygonf? usrud k ac:yg[kajymaomfvnf; usrud kayG @,lvd kufonf htcsdefwGif arhajrmoGm;onf htwGuf usrud k jyefcsxm;cJ hygonf// ac:roGm;yg?
9// ud krif;odef;ESif ha':=unf=unfjrif hwd k @.toHrsm;ud k =um;&ojzif h usrvnf;owdjyef&vmygonf? rdrdpD;vmonfhum;ay:rS awG@onfhtuôswxnfud kaumuf0wf+yD; ‘usrvJ vd kufr,f’[k atmf[pfajymonfhtwGuf &Gmom;wOD;u usrud kum;ay:uqD;ayG @+yD; um;atmufod k @csay;ygonf?usrwd k @pD;vmonf hum;. um;acgif;ay:wGif um;armif;ol ukvm;av;pef;jrif h rSm b,fzufrsufvH k;xGufjyD; aoaeonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf?olu tiSm;um;armif;orm;omjzpf+yD; tzG @J0if r[kwfyg? usrwd k @. ab;ywf0ef;usifuk d =unf honf htcg(25)ay/ay(50)cef @ wGif&S daom v,fuGif;rsm;xJwGif vlrsm; =unf hraumif;atmif wk H;vk H;yufvufvJaejyD; emusifojzif hnnf;nLaeolrsm;udk awG@&ygonf? usrESifhtwlxGufajy;vmonfh a':=unf=unfjrifhu “&dkufwJhvlawG
jyefvm&if xyf+yD;aoukefvdrf hr,f vmjyefpd k @” [kajymonf htwGuf usrwd k @ &Gmbufud kxGufoGm;=uygonf?usrvnf; owdr&wcsuf&wcsufESif h bkef;}uD;ausmif;ay:ud k rnfod k @a&mufvmonfud k rodawmhyg? ausmif;od k @a&mufonf htcgwGif ausmif;xd kifbkef;}uD;u ‘axmfvm*sDum; iS g;w,f/ AdaE<mq&mvnf; &Smcd kif;w,f/b,folrSrvd kuf&J=ubl;/ bmvkyf&rSef; rodvd k @ xd kifaewm’ [kajymygonf? usr/ a':=unf=unfjrif h/armifrif;odef;(3)OD;ESif hrH k&GmrS ausmif;om;av;wOD; aygif;(4)OD;ud k bkef;}uD;ausmif;wGifaumif;rGefpGmxm;ygonf? bkef;}uD;ausmif;utcsif;jzpfyGm;onf hae&mESif h (1)rd kifcef @a0;ygonf? (3)em&DcG Jcef @wGif bkef;+uD;a&mufvmjyD;‘'umr}uD; cifAsm;wk d @ud k'DrSmrxm;&Jawmhbl;/ ajy;awmh’[kqk d+yD; vrf;p&dwfaiG (1700)vmay;ygonf? usrwk d @ ygvmonf haiGrsm;rSmusrwd k @ &d kufESufcH&onf htcsdefwGif ygvmonf haiGrsm;ud k&d kufESufolrsm;u vk,loGm;ojzif h usrwd k @wGif aiGr&S dawmhyg?
10// bkef;}uD;ausmif;rS blwmod k @ eHeuf(3)em&DcG JwGif pwifxGufcGmvm&m eHeuf(5)em&DcJ GwGif usnf&Gmblwm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 75/208
75
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
&H kod k @ a&muf&S dygonf? blwmESif h bkef;}uD;ausmif;rSm (3)rd kifcJ Gcef @a0;a=umif;ud k vd kufyk d @onf h OD;Zif;u ajymjyIod&ygonf// (8)em&DxGufonf h&xm;jzif h tifeft,fvf'DrS (3)OD;ESif h rk H&GmjrdK@rS vli,fwOD; twlrH k&GmjrdK@od k @jyefvd kufch Jygonf? &xm;u(12)em&DcG JwGif rk H&Gmod k @a&mufygonf? usr. 'l;ESif haygifwd k @tm; &k dufxm;onf h'%f&mrsm; a=umif hrH k&Gmòrd @od k @a&mufonf htcg rv_yfEk difawmhyg? xd k @a=umif h qk dufum;pD;+yD; bkef;}uD;ausmif;ud koGm;&ygonf? vli,fav;wOD;rSm rk H&Gma&mufuwnf;u ‚if;aexd kifonf h&Gmod k @ jyefajy;ygonf? usrESif htwl armifrif;odef;/ r=unfjrif h(3)OD;om bkef;}uD;ausmif;wGifusef&pfcJ hygonf? bkef;}uD;ausmif;wGifaexd kifaepOfumvrsm;twGif; t0wftpm;rsm;vJvS,f&ef ryg&SdonfhhtwGuf wynfhawmfwk d@udk t0wftpm;tvSLcHay;yg&ef bkef;}uD;udk awmif;yefavsmufxm;&ygonf? xd kausmif;wGif (2)&ufcef @ae+yD;onf haemuf ud kvSoef;ESif h rcifat;jrif hwd k @(2)OD;vnf;xd k bkef;}uD;ausmif;ud k xyfrHa&mufvmygonf? usrud k q&m0efwOD;uvmI aq;0g;ukoay;ojzif h oufomvm+yD; xd kif;jrefrm e,fpyfwae&mud k =o*kwfv( 19 )&ufae@wGif a&muf&S dcJ hygonf?
txufyg trSwfpOf (1)rS (10) txd yg&S donf hta=umif;t&mrsm;onf rdrdud k,fwd kifawG @/ ud k,fwd kifjrif/ud k,fwd kifodonf h ta=umif;t&mrsm;jzpf+yD;/ ,ckuJ hod k @ xkwfazmfajym=um;&ef rnfolr# rw&m;=oZmv$rf;rd k;jcif;/+cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ aoG;aqmifjzm;a,mif;jcif;/ vdrfvnfvSnf hjzm;jcif; r&S dbJ rdrd. vGwfvyfonf hoabmqENt& xkwfazmfajym=um;jcif;jzpfa=umif; 0efcHuwdjyK vufrSwfa&;xd k;ygonf?
a':nGef @nGef@a':nGef@nGef@a':nGef @nGef@a':nGef@nGef@a':nGef @nGef @2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (20)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (20)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (20)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (20)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (20)&uf/
29=5=2003 &ufaeŒ rk H±G mtoG m; acsmif;OD;òrdŒ e,f/ a&ydk;pm;aus;&G mteD;
tiftm;(300)cefŒ &S dvltkyf}uD;u qd kif;bkwfrsm; ud kifaqmifI atmf[pfqJqd k aES mif h,SufaepOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 76/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
76
ud krif;odef; ( rEWav; taemufawmifòrdŒ e,f )
vli,fwG Jzufwm0efcH (3). uwdopPmjyKxGufqd kcsuf
trnf ud krif;odef;tztrnf OD;wifatmiftrdtrnf a':trm=unftvkyftud kif yef;ykESif h ausmufvkyfief;arG;ouU&mZf 1970ckESpf/ {+yDv/ 2 &uf
trsdK;om;rSwfyH kwiftrSwf 9§ rew (Ed kif) 018041
usaemf rif;odef;onf arv(30)&ufae@wGifjzpfyGm;cJ honf h 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hywfoufI uwdopPmjyK xGufqd konfrSm æ
1? usaemf.trnf armifrif;odef; Ed kifiHom;pDppfa&;u'f (9§ rew(Ed kif)008041) ud kifaqmifolonfzcifjzpfol OD;wifatmifESif h rdcifjzpfol a':trm=unfwd k @rS 1970 ckESpf{+yDv (2) &ufae@wGifarG;zGm;cJ hygonf?yef;ykESif hausmufvkyfief;ud k toufarG;0rf;ausmif;vkyfief;tjzpf vkyfud kif+yD; rE Wav;/ taemufawmifòrd @e,fwGif
rdbrsm;ESif htwl aexd kifygonf? usaemfonf 2000jynh fESpf/ vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;wGif2000 jynf hESpf/ {+yDv/ tzG J @0ifpjzpfonf htcsdefrS pI vuf&S dumvtxd/ rEWav; taemufawmif fòrd @e,f/ vli,fwm0efcH/ wG Jbuf(3)tjzpfwav#mufvH k; wm0ef,lxm;ygonf? 2000 jynf hESpf/ arv (19)&ufrS 2001 ckESpf/ rwfv(31)&uftxd taemufawmif+rdK@e,f vli,fzG J @pnf;r_twGuf rE Wav;td k;bd kaxmifwGif zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;jcif;cHcJ h&ygonf?
2? rE Wav;rH k&Gmc&D;pOfwGifòrd @e,ftvdkuf vrf;c&D;vH kjcHKa&;wm0ef,l&ygonf? usaemfonf taemufawmifòrd @e,f vH kjcHKa&;wm0efcHtjzpf a&S @ajy;taeESif hvd kuf fygcJ h&jcif;jzpfonf? rE Wav;u pxGufI ppfud kif; wHwm;ud kausmfonfESif h }uH hzG H @tzG J @0if vltkyfpk wpkud kawG @&ygonf? ‚if;wd k @u “jynfytm;ud k;ykqdef¶d k; tvd kr&S d d / vd k&moH k;
'Drd kua&pD tvd kr&S d” ponf hqd kif;bkwfrsm;ud k ud kif+yD;&yfwef @apmif hqd kif;aeonfud k usaemfwd k @ jrifawG @&ygonf?jrif;rlòrd @ud k a&mufonf htcgwGif jrif;rljrdK@e,f vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;vkyfygonf? vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;vkyfaeonf htcsdefwGifjrif;rlòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf&H k;.tjyifY avmfpyDum(2)vH k;wyfxm;onf h }uH hzG H @.'d kifemum;wpD; &yfaeonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? xd kum;ay:wGif pD;eif;vd kufygvmolrsm;u um;acgifrd k;ay:ESif h um;xJwGif tjynf hyg &S donfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;um;rsm;vnf; rdrdwd k @.,mOfwef;rsm;aemufrS vd kufygvmonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? axmufvSrf;a&;um;rsm;.teD;wGif Van & Publica um; awmfawmfrsm;rsm;ud kvnf; jrifawG @&ygonf?jrif;rlòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf0if;.a&S @wGif um;wpD;ay:rS AG D'D,d kuifr&mjzif h vloH k;OD;/ wa,mufycH k;ay: wa,mufwifIususee¶d kuful;aeonfud k usaemfwd k @jrifawG @&ygonf? usefonf hum;rsm;ay:rSvnf; trsdK;rsdK;vSnf hywfI "gwfyH k
ESif h AG D'D,d k&d kuful;aeonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf?
3? rH k&Gmòrd @od k @0ifonf htcsdefrSm ae0ifvk+yDjzpfygonf? ‘rH k&Gmòrd @rS óudqd kyg.’qd konf h qd kif;bkwfud k (6)em&D
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 77/208
77
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
0ef;usifcef @wGif a&muf&S dygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @e,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf &H k;od k @ n (9)em&DausmfwGif a&muf&S dygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @rSm rD; jzwfxm;jcif;cH&onf htwGuf za,mif;wd kifrsm;ud kifaqmifI apmif hóudae=uonf h jynfolvlxku“a':atmifqef;pk=unf usef;rmygap/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf usef;rmygap”qd konf h/ aºuG;a=umfoHrsm;
jzif @ rdrdwd k @tzG J @0ifrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h,mOfrsm;ud k v_ dufvS JpGmóudqd k=uygonf? odef;csDonf h jynfolvlxkuwvrf;vH k;jynf hóudqd k=uonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? qd kifu,frsm;ud k rsufpdwqH k;jrifawG @ae&ygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @wGiftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf qd kif;bkwfwifyG Jvkyf+yD; tzG J @csKyfvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud kvnf; rH k&Gmòrd @&S d pdefr#m;pwd k;wGifnwGif;csif; ðyvkyfcJ hygonf?
4? arv (30)&ufae@wGif usaemfwd k @ rH k&Gmòrd @rSxGufvm+yD;aemuf bkwvifud ka&muf&S d+yD;/ bkwvifòrd @e,fvli,fzG J @pnf;a&; aqmif&Gufygonf? rdrdwd k @.um;wef;rsm;teD;wGif wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;rS um;rsm;/ =uH @zG @HtzG J @0ifrsm;.um;rsm; tjrJwrf;vd kufygapmif h=unf haeonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? bkwvifòrd @e,f vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k vkyfaqmif+yD;/ naeyd kif;wGif bkwvifrSxGufcGmcJ hygonf? pd kifjyif&S d trsdK;om;'Drd ka&pDtzG J @csKyf¶H k;od k @0ifa&muf+yD;óudqd kae=uonf hjynfolvlxktm; a':atmifqef;pk=unfu E_wfcGef;qufpum; ajym=um;ygonf? óudqd kaeonf hjynfolvlxktm;E_wfquf+yD; usaemfwd k @,mOfwef;onf 'DyJ,if; c&D;pOfud k qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf?
5? usnf&Gmud k n(8)em&Dcef @wGifa&muf&S dygonf? usnf&GmrSvlxku xGuf+yD; usaemfwd k @um;wef;ud k óudqd k=uygonf// usnf&GmrS ud kuf(300)cef @xGufvmonf htcsdef usaemfwd k @um;.aemufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @ pD ;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum; jzpfygonf?usaemfwd k @.um;rSm vH kjcHKa&;um;taejzif h c&D;pOfwavsmuf t+rJwrf;vd kufygcJ h&+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @um;. a&S @ (4)pD;ajrmufjzpfygonf? vlrsm; &kwf&kwfoJoJjzpfaeonf htcsdefwGif usaemfwd k @pD;eif;vmonf hum;a&S @od k @ a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;u ausmfwufvmygonf? usaemfwd k @
um;.a&S @wGif tr&yl&OD;vSjrif h.um; jzpfygonf? xd ktcsdefwGifbkef;}uD;(2)yg;ESif h vl(2)a,muf(3)a,mufua':atmifqef;pk=unf pD;eif;vd kufygvmaomum;ud kwm;ojzif h &yfvd kufonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGifvH kjcHKa&;,lrnf hvli,frsm; a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;teD;od k @oGm;&ef um;ay:wGifvd kufygvmonf h vl}uD;rsm;u ajymygonf? usaemfwd k @ um;teD;od k @a&mufonf htcg bkef;}uD;u ‘w&m;a[may;yg/ w&m;a[m+yD;rS 'DuoGm;&r,f’[k ajymaeonfud k=um;&ygonf? xd ktcg a':pkum;ay:wGifygonf h vli,fwm0efcH ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfuqif;+yD; “t&Sifbk&m;/wynf hawmfwd k @ tcsdefr&onf htwGuf oGm;cGif hðyyg/ a&S @rSmvnf; c&D;qufp&mawG &S dygao;
vkyf}uHr+jzpfyGm;yk Htm; rsufjrifoufaowk dŒ .ajymqkdcsuft& yk H-urf;a&;qJ G azmfjycsuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 78/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
78
w,f”[kavsmufxm;ygonf? ‘rif;wd k @oGm;vd k @ r&bl;/ oGm;cGif h ray;Ed kifbl;/ w&m;a[m+yD;rS oGm;&r,f’[k ajymygonf? vl(2)a,mufuvnf;/ ‘a[haumif/rif;wd k @ ajym+yD;rS oGm;&r,f’[k &efvd konf hyH kpHjzif h0ifI ajymqd kygonf?bkef;}uD;u ‘a[haumifawG/ rif;wd k @ tomae/ ighbmom igajymr,f’[kqd kum ol @vlrsm;ud kolxdef;+yD; ‘igwd k @vlawG
aemufrSm vmae+yD? apmif h+yD; w&m;a[may;yg/ a[m+yD;rSyJ oGm;&r,f? 'DrSmyJ w&m;a[may;yg’ [k xyfrHajymqd kygonf// a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k wm;vd kufonf htwGuf/ um;ay:rS tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifvli,frsm;ESif husaemfwd k @ rE Wav;rS vH kjcHKa&; wm0ef ,lxm;onf h h vli,frsm;tm;vH k; a':atmifqef;pk=unf. um;teD;od k @a&muf&S dvmygonf? xd k @a=umif h bkef;}uD;uajymqd konh fpum;rsm;ud k =um;ae&jcif;jzpfygonf? wqufwnf;wGiftzG J @csKyfum;rsm;ay:rS vlrsm;uvnf; ud k,f hum;ay: ud k,fwuf um;xGufrnf[kajymonf htwGuf rdrdwd k @pD;vmonf hum;rsm;ay:ud k jyefIwufygonf? usaemfwd k @um;ay:ud ka&mufonfESif hwòydifeuf tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;.,mOfwef;aemufrS vd kufvmonf h um;wef;onf um;a&S @rD;rsm;ud kxd k;I òydifwlqd kuf&mufvmygonf?
6// wqufwnf;rSmyif xd kum;rsm;ay:rSvlrsm;qif;vm+yD; awG @or#vltm;vH k;ud k wef;pD+yD; pwif¶d kufygonf?usnf&GmrS vma&muf=udKqd k=uonf h&Gmvlxkuvnf; xd ktcsdefwGif rjyefao;yg? armfawmfum;rsm;. a&S @rD;xd k;xm;onf htwGuf ¶d kufESufaeonfud kjrifawG @ae&ygonf? &GmvlxkuemusifI atmf[pfaeonf htoHrsm;ud kvnf;usaemfwd k @ =um;ae&ygonf? awG @or#vltm;vk H;ud k odrf;usHK;I¶d kufESufjcif;jzpfygonf? t&d kufcH&onf holrsm;xJwGif vl}uD;/ vli,frsm;/ tbd k;}uD;/ tbGm;}uD;rsm;ESif h uav;rsm;utp &d kufESufjcif;ud kcH&ygonf? xd kod k @&d kufESufcH&onf htwGuf &Gmom;rsm;rSmusnf&GmxJod k @ xGufajy;oGm;=uonfud kvnf; jrifawG @&ygonf?
7? xd ktcsdefwGif &d kufESufolrsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;vd kufyd k @=uonh f qd kifu,frsm;ESif h usaemfwk d @.um;rsm;ud k pwif ¶d kufESufygonf? usaemfwd k @tm;&d kufESufonf holrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonh f um;rsm;rSm bkwvifrS pxGuf
onfhtcsdefrS pI usaemfwd k @.,mOfwrf;aemufwGif avmfpyDum(2)vH k;wyfqifxm;onfh }uH hzGH @um;wpD;uOD;aqmif+yD; vd kufygvmonf hum;rsm;jzpfygonf? um;wef;rsm;ud k rsufpdwqH k; jrifae&onf h twGuf um;pD;a& rnfr#&S donfud k twdtus rajymEd kifyg? xd kum;rsm;ay:rSqif;vmonf h bkef;}uD;rsm;u OD;aqmifI usaemfwd k @.um;rsm;ESif @ qd kifu,fpD;vmolrsm;ud k pwif&d kufESuf=uygonf? bkef;}uD;rsm;. nmbufvufwGif vufywftjzL rsm;ywfxm;+yD; ‘ukvm;r,m; vkyfcsifwJ h[mawG’ [k qJqd k}udrf;armif;+yD; vlrqefpGm pwif ¶d kufESufjcif;jzpfygonf? &d kufonf holrsm; usaemfwd k @um;teD;od k @ a&mufonf htcsdefwGif usaemf xd kifcsvd kufygonf? rdrd.ab;wGifrwfwyf&yfaeolrsm;t¶d kufcH&ygonf? acgif;rsm;ud ktrsm;qH k; t"duxm; ¶d kufonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? ‚if;wd k @¶d kufESuf&mwGiftoH k;jyKonf hvufeufrsm;rSm opfom;vH k;/ ESpfwvufrwkwf/ 0g;&if;wkwfESif h oHc|efwkwfrsm; jzpfonf
ud k awG @ae&ygonf? 0d kif;¶d kufonf htwGuf um;ay:rS&yfaeolrsm; rdrdtay:od k @vJòyd+yD; usvmygonf? ‚if;wd k @.cE<mud k,frSxGufvmonf haoG;rsm; rdrdyg;pyfxJ0ifvmonfud k axG;xkwfvd k @ r&Ed kifonftxd rdrd.ud k,fay:wGifydaeygonf? xd kod k @ydaeonf htcsdefwGif &d kufaeonf holrsm;xJrSwa,mufu ‘a&S @rSm ukvm;rum; &S dw,f/ ukvm;rum;ud k oGm;¶d kuf/ ukvm;rud k aoatmifowf/ ukvm;r aorSjzpfrSm’[katmf [pftrdef @ay;aeonf htoHud kvnf; =um;ae&ygonf? usaemfwd k @um;ay:rS t&d kufcH&onf hvlrsm;uvnf; emusifonf htwGuf“trav;a=umufyg+yDAs/ aoyg+yDAs”[laom nnf;nLaeonf htoHrsm;ud k=um;vsif ‘[m 'Daumif raoao;bl;/¶d kuf¶d kuf’ [kqd k+yD; xyfrH0d kif;¶d kufygonf? rdrdwd k @vnf;aemufqH k;wGif rnnf;nL&J/ ratmf&J =uawmhyg? tcsdK@vnf;owdarhoGm;=uygonff? tcsdK@vnf; aooGm;onf[k,lq&ygonf? xd k@tjyif raobJ '%f&mjyif;xef Itenf;i,fv_yfaeonfud kjrifvsif ‘[m raoao;bl; ¶d kuf ¶d kuf’ [kqd k+yD; xyfrHpkòyH+yD; 0d kif;¶d kufygonf? xd kod k @
¶d kufonf htcgwGif t¶d kufcH&onf h vlay:ud k wOD; wa,mufwnf;u wkwfwacsmif;wnf;jzif h ¶d kufjcif; r[kwfbJwkwfrsm; pkòyH+yD;&d kufaeonfud kawG @& ygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 79/208
79
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
8? xd kod k @t&d kufcHae&onf htcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @.um;ay:wGif vl}uD;/vli,f tm;vH k;(15)OD;cef @ pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf? rdrdwd k @um;.a&S @cef;wGif um;armif;olrSmaps;csdKvlr_taxmuftuljyKtzG J @rS ud kxGef;0if;jzpf+yD; ‚if;ESif h
twl OD;cifarmifaomif;(taemufawmifòrd @e,fpnf;)/ OD;wk d;(tzG J @0if)wd k @(3)OD; pD;eif;vd kufygvmygonf// um;aemufcef;wGif ud k&Jrif;aZm/f wG Jzufwm0efcH(1)/ ud kaZmfaZmfatmif wG Jbufwm0efcH(2)/ usaemfu wG Jbufwm0efcH(3)/ ud kausmfrsdK;ol/ ud krsdK;wif h/ ud k0Àatmif/ OD;wifjrif h/ OD;wifarmifOD;(aoqH k;ol "gwfyH kq&m)/ ud kodef;wk d;at; (aoqH k;ol taemufawmifjrdK@e,fpnf;)wd k @ESif htwl trsdK;orD;tzG J @0ifrsm;xJrS òrd @e,fpnf; rsm;jzpf=uonf ha':wifjrif h/a':=unf=unfjrif hESif h rcifjr0if;wd k @ vd kufygvmygonf? rE Wav;taemufawmifòrd @e,f vli,fvkyfief;tzG J @xJrS usefonf h vli,f(2)OD;ud k usaemf emrnf rrSwfrdawmhyg?
9? xd kod k @¶d kufaeonf htcsdefwGif um;a&S @rD;rsm;ud k aemufbufrS tcsdefjynf hxd k;xm;onfud kjrifawG @&ygonf/&d kufESufolrsm;u yg;pyfrSvnf;qJqd k+yD; &d kufESufjcif;jzpfonf htwGuf toHrsm;ud kvJ=um;ae&ygonf? yifeDtuô s0wfonf h trsdK;orD;rsm;.tuô srsm;ud k qG Jc|wfygonf? ‚if;wd k @0wfqifxm;onf h qG Jóud;rsm;ud kvnf; qG Jðzwfygonf? yd kufqHtdwf/ c&D;aqmiftdwf ponf hypPnf;rsm;ud kvnf; tukef,lonfud kawG @&ygonf? yg;pyfrSvnf;‘igwd k @ vrf ;awGazmufw,f/ wHwm;awGaqmufw,f/ eifwd k @ 'gud kawmh taumif;rjrifbl;vm;/ eifwd k @ atmifqef;pk=unfu bmvkyfay;wkef;/ ukvm;r,m;u bmvkyfay;wkef;/ ukvm;r,m; jzpfcsifwmyJodw,f/ usefwm eifwd k @bmodwkef;’[k }udrf;armif;ajymqd k+yD; tqufrjywf ¶d kufESufoHrsm;ud kvnf; =um;&ygonf? rdef;cav; tcsdK@u ‘tuô sud k usrwd k @ c|wfay;yghrnf’[k awmif;yefajymqd kaomfvnf; r&yg/ twif;t"rR qG Jc|wfonf ud k cH=u&ygonf?usaemfpD;vmonf h um;ay:wGif jzpfaeonf htwGuf ,ckuJ hod k @ jrifae=um;ae&jcif;jzpfygonf?
10? ‚if;wd k @ ¶d kuf+yD; +yD;csif; rdrdwd k @,mOf fwef;.um;rsm;ay:wGif ygvmolrsm;tm;vH k;rSm '%f&mrsm; jyif;xefpGm&&S d=uygonf ? owdarhaeonf hvltm;vH k;onf um;ay:rSm/ vrf;ay:rSm jyef @}uJae=uonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf?tcsdK@olrsm;ud k um;ay:rSm&S dpOf ¶d kuf&onfud ktm;r&ao;onf htwGuf um;atmufo@d k qG Jcs+yD; ausmufvrf;jzif hwd kufonf htjyif wkwfrsm;ESif h 0d kif;¶d kuf fESuf=uonfud k vnf; jrifawG @&ygonf? xd kod k @&d kufESufaeonf htcsdefwGifbkef;}uD;rsm;u ta&S @awmifòrd @e,frS um;tjzLav;wpD;ud k vrf;ab;csdKif hxJod k @wGef;csvd kufygonf? rdrdwd k @pD;vmonf hum;ud kvnf; wGef;cs&efjyifqifygonf? um;rSm *D,m!yfaeonf htwGuf um;orm; OD;xGef;0if;ud k *D,mðzwfcd kif;ygonf? OD;xGef;0if;u “wynf hawmfum;orm; r[kwfygbl;/ um;orm; a&S @rSmoGm;yg+yD/ aomhvnf; ol,loGm;ygw,f/ wynf hawmf um;vnf; rarmif;wwfygbl;”[kjyefajzygonf? um;orm; ud kxGef;0if;ud d k awmfawmfav;
¶d kufESufcJ honf htwGuf eH&d k;ESif h vufusdK;oGm;onfud kvnf; jrifawG @ae&ygonf?
11? ‚if;wd k @u um;wef;wav#muf rnfolawGv_yfaeao;onf/ rnfolawG toHxGufaeao;onfwd k @ud kvSnf hvnf=unf h&_+yD; tm;vH k;rv_yfawmhbl;[k ‚if;wd k @ pdwfcs&+yDxifonf htcsdefwGif acgif;aqmif[k ,lq&onf hvlwa,mufu “a&rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f/ a&rD;tzG J @ jyefr,f” [k tm;vH k;ud k trdef @ay;I jyefvSnf hoGm;=uygonf?xd kod k @xGufcGmoGm;onh ftcsdefwGif avmfpyDum(2)ckwyfqifxm;onf h 'd kifemum;wpD;tm; rD;¶d _ @oGm;ygonf?tqd kygum;rSm c&D;pOfwav#mufvH k; usaemfwd k @aemufrSvd kufI apmif h=unf h&ef }uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h 'd kifemum;jzpfygonf? rdrdwd k @tzG J @csKyfrSvlrsm;u rnfod k @r# vufwk H @jyefEd kifjcif; r&S dyg? xd k @a=umif h ‚if;wd k @um;ud k ‚if;wd k @ud k,fwd kif rD;¶d _ @onf[k ajym&jcif;jzpfygonf? &Gmol &Gmom;rsm;rSmvnf; 'a&maomyg;ESif h ud k,f h
toufud k,fvk+yD; xGufajy;&onf htwGuf ‚if;wd k @pD;vmonf hum;ud k ‚if;wd k @ud k,fwd kif "gwfqDavmif;+yD; rD;¶d _ @oGm;jcif; jzpfygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 80/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
80
12? xd kod k @jzpf+yD;aemuf rdrdpD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;ay:wGif ygvmolrsm;teuf aoolESif h tjyif;txef'%f&m&ol (10)OD;0ef;usifcef @&S dygonf// twdtusaoqH k;onf[kod&olrsm;rSm ud kodef;wd k;at;ESif h ud kwifarmifOD;
wd k @jzpfygonf? '%f&mtjyif;txef&olrsm; tenf;qH k; (5)OD; (6)OD;cef @&S dygonf? tcsdK@aomolrsm;rSm rnfod k @r#ar;I r&onf htjyif/ v_yf&Sm;onfud kvnf; rjrifawG @&yg? (10)em&Dcef @wGif &d kufESufolrsm; jyefoGm;=uygonf?rdrdwd k @vnf; '%f&m&ojzif hnnf;nLaeolrsm;tm; wwfEd kifor#ðypkukoay;=uygonf? od k @aomf rnfonf h aq;0g;r# ygrvmonf htwGuf '%f&m&onf holrsm;ud kxnf hay;&ef aq;r&S dyg? um;vrf;ab; aeomxd kifom&S donf hae&m/ vrf;edrf hav#m&S daomae&mrsm;wGif vJ Scd kif;xm;&ygonf?
Oyrm æ ud kxGef;0if;qd kvsif vufusdK;oGm;onf htwGuf vufud k vH k;0txdrcHEk difyg? emusifonf htwGufnnf;nLatmf[pfaeygonf? rdrdwd k @vnf; rdrdwd k @.tuô sESif h vufpnf;yH kpHjyKvkyfay;+yD; tdyfcd kif;xm;&ygonf?vrf;eab;wGifvnf; arSmifaeonf htwGuf toHrsm;ud k=um;ae&+yD; vlud krl rjrif&yg? “u,fygOD;/ u,fygOD;”pojzif h atmf[pf tultnDawmif;aeonf htoHrsm;ud k usaemf=um;ae&ygonf?
13? &d kufESufolrsm;jyefoGm;+yD;aemuf &GmrS vlrsm;ESif hbkef;}uD;(1)yg;u tcif;jzpfonf hae&mud k vm=unf hygonf? usaemfu '%f&mr&oljzpfonf htwGuf OD;aqmif+yD; “&Gmu tud k}uD;wd k @/ usaemfwd k @vlawGud k u,fyg/aq;cef;yk d @ay;yg/ usaemfwd k @vlawGud k ulnD=uyg”[k ajymygonf? bkef;}uD;ud kjrifonf htcgwGif “t&Sifbk&m;wynf hawmfwd k @ud k u,fyg/ wynf hawmfwd k @vlawGud k aq;¶H kyd k @ay;yg”[k ajymonf htcg “[ æ rif;wd k @vlawGuaoae+yD”[k bkef;}uD;uajymvsuf vuf!d k;xd k;jyonf hae&mud k rdrd=unf hvd kufonf htcg taemufajrmufòrd @e,frSum;ud karmif;onf h ud k&m*sL; (ac: )pef;jrif h rsufvH k;wzufxGuf+yD; ZufusdK;yufvufvefusaeonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? rdrdu “t&Sifbk&m; ajymwmrSefygw,f/ 'g aowJ h vlyg/ raoao;wJ hol arhaewJ hvlawG&S dygw,f/ u,fEd kif
oavmuf u,fay;ygbk&m;” [k bkef;}uD;ud kavsmufxm;ygonf?
14? &Gmom;rsm;vnf; rdrdwd k @teD;o@d k ruyf&J/ ru,f&J=uyg// v,fuGif;xJrS '%f&m&ol ltcsdK@uvnf; “u,f=u yg/ usaemf raoao;ygbl;/ u,f=uyg” qd k+yD; atmf[pftultnDawmif;oHud k=um;&onf htcg “tud k}uD;wd k @[d krSm æ [d krSmoGm;+yD; vkyfay;yg”[k rdrduajym&m &Gmom;wa,mufESpfa,mufu v,fuGif;xJrS um;vrf;ab;o@d k o,f,lvmay;ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif &GmcHbkef;}uD;u “uJæ 'gqd k&ifvnf; wum}uD;wd k @&GmrSm xa&mfvm*sDawmh &S dw,f/ oGm;iSm;=unf hr,f” qd k+yD; &Gmud kjyefoGm;ygonf? tcsdK@ &Gmom;rsm;uvnf; ru,f&Jbl;[kqd k+yD;bkef;}uD;ESif htwl jyefvd kufoGm;=uygonf? rdrdwd k @ um;wef;wGifygolrsm;teuf toufraoolrsm;/ vrf;ud k
yif óud;pm;av#mufae&olrsm;ESif h '%f&m&olwcsdK@ud k rdrdu ‘'Dajrmif;av;ud k ausmf+yD;awmh v,fuGif;xJ oGm;ae=uyg’[k qd k+yD; v,fuGif;xJod k @ v$wfvd kufygonf? toufaoqk H;ol/owdarhaeolrsm;uvG JI tm;vH k; v,fuGif;xJ a&mufoGm;=uygonf?
15? usaemf/ a':=unf=unfjrif h/ a':!Gef @!Gef @ESif h rH k&Gmòrd @cH aumifav;wa,muf/ usaemfwd k @(4)OD; vlemawGud kxm;cJ h+yD; aq;ukay;rnf holud k&SmazG&ef &GmxJud koGm;ygonf? ‘aq;ukay;r,f holu vd kuf+yD; aq;uk&JrSm r[kwfbl;’ [k vrf;rSmawG @&onf h&Gmom;rsm;uajymygonf? xd k @a=umif hrdrdwd k @u bkef;}uD;ausmif;od k @yd k @ay;&ef ajymonf htwGuf bkef;=uD;ausmif;o@d k vd kufyd k @ay;rnf[k ajymqd k+yD; usaemfwd k @(4)OD; tm; bkef;}uD;ausmif;od k @ac:oGm;ygonf? &Gmt0if bkef;}uD;ausmif;od k @a&mufonf htcg ‘t&Sifbk&m; wynf hawmfwd k @vlawGud k aq;xnf hay;csifvd k @
yg’[kavsmufxm;ygonf//bkef;}uD;rSm apmapmu xa&mfvm*sDiSm;&efajymoGm;onf hbkef;}uD; jzpfaeygonf?‘at;æwum}uD;wd k @ud ku uHqd k;wm xa&mfvm*sDu iSm;r&vd k @bkef;}uD;vnf; bmrS rvkyfwwfyJ ud k,f hausmif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 81/208
81
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
rSm ud k,fjyefae&w,f’[k bkef;}uD;uajymygonf? awm&aqmufwnfaom bkef;=uD;ausmif; jzpfonf htwGufausmif;wGif rnfonf haq;0g;r# r&S dyg? rdrdu ‘wynf hawmfwd k @vlawGud k oGm;u,fvd kufOD;r,fbk&m;’[k qd konf h
tcg/‘[ rif; oGm;u,fraeeJ @/ rif;wa,mufwnf; rif;u,fvd k @ tusd K;xl;rSm r[kwfbl;’[kajymygonf? rdrduvnf; ‘wynf hawmf vlawGtay: opPmrJ hovd kjzpfr,f’[kqd k+yD; ZGwfoGm;rnfvkyfonf htcg v,fuGif;xJrS jzwf+yD;oGm;&ef ajymygonf?
16? t&d kufcH&onf hae&mud ka&mufonf htcg um;wpD;u acsmufxJud kusae+yD; 'd kifemum;wpD;vJ rD;avmifaeygonf? qd kifu,frsm;vnf; jyef @}uJae+yD; &d kufESufcH&onf htwGuf rnfonf hqd kifu,frS taumif; rusef&pfyg? rdrdwk d @tzG J @rSvlrsm;vnf; aoqk H;aeolrsm;ESif howdvpf+yD; '%f&mjzif hvJaeolrsm;ud kawG @&ygonf? rdrdvnf;bkef;}uD;ausmif;od k @ vSnf h jyefvmcJ hygonf?
17? n(11)em&DwGif a&S @uaoewfoH (10)csuf/ (11)csufcef @ =um;&ygonf? (12)em&D(45)rdepfwGif ppfwyf/&J/ rD;owf/pGrf;tm;&SiftzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h =uH hzG H @tzG J @rsm;a&mufvmygonf? ¶d k;¶d k;t&yf0wfrsm;0wfxm;onf htwGuf}uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;[k ajym&jcif;jzpfygonf? vrf;ray:wGif usef&pfaomum;(4)pD;teuf ta&S @awmifòrd @e,f rSum;tjzL ESif h taemufajrmufòrd @e,frS um;ud k acgif;csif;qd kifwk dufrdI vrf;ab;acsmufxJod k @ wdrf;arSmufusaeonf hyH kpHuJ hod k @ zefwD;I jyifqifaeonfud k usaemfjrifawG @&ygonf? v,fuGif;ywf0ef;usifw0d kuftm; "gwfyH k¶d kufjyD;/AG D'D,d kuifr&mESif h rSwfwrf;wif ¶d kuful;=uygonf? um;rsm;ud ka&$ @/ tavmif ;awGo,f/ rSwfwrf;rSwf&mawGvkyfponfjzif h jyKvkyfjyD;aemuf (1)em&D(45)rdepfwGif ‚if;wd k @jyefoGm;=uygonf? rdrdwd k @um;. a&S @@rS tr&yl&òrd @e,fOuUXOD;vSjrif h.um; t0ga&mifav;ud k (2)em&D(5)rdepfrSm 'DyJ,if;bufwGef;oGm;+yD; um;ud k,fxnfrsm;ud k cGm,l
aeonfhtoHrsm;ud k =um;ae&ygonf? tcsif;jzpfonf hae&mwGifusef&pfcJhonf hum; (3)pD;jzpfygonf// xd kod k@bkef;=uD;ausmif;teD; v,fuGif;tpyfu apmif h=unf haeonf htcsdefwGif usaemfeJ @twl h rH k&Gm wuUod kvf 'kwd,ESpfrSvli,fausmif;om;wOD;vnf; &S daeygonf? olwd k @a&mufvmonf htcsdefESif h jyefonf htcsdefrsm;ud kod&S dEd kif&ef em&Dud k"gwfrD;ESif h xd k;=unf h+yD;rS usaemfu pm&Gufjzif h a&;rSwfxm;jcif;jzpfygonf?
18? arv(31)&ufae@ eHeuf (4)em&Dausmf/ (5)em&Dcef @wGif &GmrSvlrsm; tdyf,m rxrD usaemfwd k @ xd kbkef;=uD;ausmif;rS xGufvmcJ hygonf? vrf;p&dwf (1700d)ud k q&mawmf}uD;u ay;vd kufygonf? (8)em&D/ (5)rdepf &xm;jzif hrH k&Gmòrd @od k @ jyefvnfxGufcGmcJ hygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @wGif ( 3-4)&ufaeygonf? (2)&ufajrmufonf hae@wGif taemuf
ajrmufòrd @e,frS OD;vSoef;ESif h a':cifat;jrif hwd k @ESpfa,muf xyfrH a&muf&S dvmygonf?
txufyg trSwfpOf (1)rS (18)txdyg&S donf h ta=umif;t&mrsm;onf rdrdud k,fwd kifawG @/ ud k,fwd kifjrif/ud k,fwd kifodonf h ta=umif;t&mrsm; jzpf+yD; ,ckuJ hod k @xkwfazmfajym=um;&ef rnfolur# rw&m; =oZmv$rf;rd k;jcif;/ +cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ aoG;aqmifjzm;a,mif;jcif;/ vdrfvnfvSnf hjzm;jcif;r&S dbJ rdrd. vGwfvyfonf h oabmqENt& xkwfazmfajym=um;jcif;jzpfa=umif; 0efcHuwdjyKygonf?
ud krif;odef;ud krif;odef;ud krif;odef;ud krif;odef;udkrif;odef;
2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (12)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (12)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (12)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (12)&uf/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (12)&uf/
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 82/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
82
armifzd k;aZmf (c) armifaZmf. uwdopPmjyKxGufqd kcsuf
trnf? ? armifzd k;aZmftouf? ? 23 ESpfae&yf? ? jr&nfeENmòrd @opf/
bb(4)&yfuGuf/ rE Wav;jrdK@?tvkyftud kif? ? ta&mif;t0,frdb? ? OD;oef;armif - a': jrusifEd kifiHom;pDppfa&;trSwf ? rre(Ed kif) 139877
usaemf armifzd k;aZmfarv 30 &ufae@wGifjzpfyGm;onh f 'DyJ,if;òrd @teD;&S d usnf&GmwGifjzpfysufcJ honh fudpP&yfrsm;
ESif h ywfoufIuwdopPmjyKxGufqd konfrSm æ
1? usaemf.trnfrSm armifzd k;aZmftouf(23)ESpfjzpfygonf? Ed kifiHom;pDppfa&;u'fjym;trSwf rre(Ed kif)139877 ud kud kifaqmif+yD; rdbESpfyg;rSm OD;oef;armifESif ha': jrusifwd k @jzpfygonf? rE Wav;òrd @/ jr&nfeENmòrd @opf/bb(4)&yfuGufwGifaexd kif+yD; ta&mif;t0,fvkyfief;jzif htoufarG;0rf;ausmif;jyKygonf? usaemfonf ,cifuEd kifiHa&;ygwDudpPESif h rywfoufcJ hzl;yg? a':atmifqef;pk=unf rE Wav;c&D;pOf rvma&mufrD (2) ywftvd kwGifrStrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ tzG J @0iftjzpfavsmufxm;cJ hygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf rE Wav;òrd @wGifaexd kifpOftwGif; nbufvH kjcHKa&;wm0eftjzpf (2)n wm0ef,l&ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfonf rE Wav;òrd @od k @ (26)&ufae@wGifa&muf&S d+yD;/ aemufae@ ar(27)&ufae@wGif wHwm;OD;od k @oGm;a&mufcJ hygonf? wHwm;OD; c&D;pOfwGifrdrdESif htwl vH kjcHKa&;wm0ef,l&olrsm; rSm ud k0if;=unf/ ud kzkef;jrif haZmf/ ud k0Àarmif/ ud kat;0if;/ ud k&Jrif;pef;/OD;jrif h/ ud kpd k;wd k @ jzpfygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 83/208
83
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
2? (29)&ufae@ arv 2003 rE Wav;rS rH k&Gmc&D;pOfwGiftaemufawmifòrd @e,frS aZmfaZmfatmif/ ud kwifatmifjrif h/ OD;axG;wd k @ESif htwl vd kufygcJ hygonf?xd kc&D;pOfwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. vH kjcHKa&;wm0efud kawmhr,l&yg? rE Wav;wd kif;&H k;rS armfawmf,mOftcuftcJa=umif h wòrd @e,fvsif (2)OD;ud kom vH kjcHKa&;wm0efESif h vd kufyg
cGif hjyKygonf?od k @aomf rdrd.pm;&dwfESif h rdrdvd kufygEd kifa=umif; wm0ef&S dolrsm;u&Sif;jyygonf? xd k @a=umif h tcsdK@olrsm;onfud k,f htpDtpOfESif hud k,f vd kufyg=uygonf? rE Wav;ESif h rH k&Gmc&D;pOfwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. t"duvH kòcHa&;wm0efud k trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ A[d kvli,ftzG J @0ifrsm;u wm0ef,lygonf?
3? rE Wav;òrd @rS vd kufygyd k @aqmifonf h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h jynfolvlxktm;vH k;pkpkaygif; qd kifu,fESif hum;(20)(30)pD;cef @ &S dygonf?usaemfpD;eif;vd kufygonf hum;rSm qefeDtrsdK;tpm; ypfuyfjzpfygonf? rE Wav;òrd @rS ppfud kif;od k @oGm;onf h vrf;c&D;wavsmufwGif yxryd kif;Y bmrS xl;jcm;r_ r&S dyg//od k @aomfppfud kif;wHwm;ud kausmfvGefonf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf tvd kr&S d qd konf h atmf[pfoHrsm;ESif htwlvl(100)ausmfcef @&S donf hvltkyf}uD;ud k pwifawG @&ygonf? ppfud kif;òrd @rS jrif;rlòrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf?jrif;rlòrd @ud k (12)em&Dausmfcef @wGif a&muf&S dygonf? jrif;rlòrd @wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf jrif;rlòrd @e,f &H k;zGif hyG J/qd kif;bkwfwifyG JESif h vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;wd k @ud kaqmif&GufcJ hygonf? jrif;rlòrd @rS nae(3)em&Dcef @wGif qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? acsmif;OD;od k @ ra&mufrD a&yd k;pm;aus;&GmteD;wGif vl(170) (180)cef @&S donf h vltkyf}uD;u qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmif+yD; &yfapmif h ae=uonfud kawG @jrif&ygonf? xd kvltkyf}uD;u pwifIatmf[pfqJqd k+yD; qd kif;bkwfrsm;jzif hum;twGif;od k @ xd k;oGif;&efp=uygonf? xd kolwd k @ud kifaqmifxm;onf hqd kif;bkwfrsm;wGif “jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&k d;/
NLDtvd kr&S d” ponf @pmwrf;rsm; a&;om;xm;onfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? xd ktcg rdrdwd k @tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h twlygvmonf h jrif;rlòrd @ESif h rH k&GmrSvma&mufóudqd konf h &[ef;oHCmrsm;u xd kod k @ rjyKvkyf&ef arwWm&yfcHwm;jrpfcJ hygonf? od k @aomfvnf; qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf holrsm;u em;raxmifbJ yd krd kI&efvd konf h tjyKtrlrsm;ud k pwifjyKvkyfvmygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif &Jum;rsm;/wm0ef&S dolrsm;u vrf;.vuf0J zufjcHKrsm;.=um;wGif &S d
ae=uygonf? oHCmrsm;ESif hxd kolrsm; pum;rsm;aeonfud k0ifa&mufwm;qD;jcif; r&S dbJ vspfvsL&_I=unf hae=uygonf? xd ktcgbkef;}uD;rsm;u ajymqd kr&onf holrsm;tm; vufoD;ESif hvd kufxd k;ygonf? xd ktcg qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf holrsm;u aemufod k @ vSnf hjyefoGm;onfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? xd kod k @jzpfyGm;onf hae&mwGif aus;&Gmol&Gmom;rsm;ESif h jynfolvlxkwd k @ r&S d=uyg? qufvufI xGufcGmvm&m atmf[pfqENjyolrsm;u ‚if;wd k @.um;rsm;jzif h rdrdwd k @.,mOfwef;rsm;aemufrS qufvufvd kufygvmcJ hygonf?
4? jrif;rlESif hrH k&Gm vrf;ckvwf&S d trnfrod&Gmw&GmwGif a'ocHjynfolvlxkrsm;tm;a':atmifqef;pk=unfa&muf&S dvmygu xGufIóudqd kjcif; rjyK&eftrdef @xkwfxm;onfud k &Gmol&Gmom;rsm;uajymjyIod&ygonf? xd k&Gm
wGifa':atmifqef;pk=unftm; qef @usifqENjy&ef pepfwuswef;pD+yD;apmif haeonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? xd kpDwef;aeonh folrsm;.aemufwGif &J(2)OD; &J0wfpH kjzif h &yfIapmif h=unf haeygonf?&Gm0ifvrf;wGif ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;ud kvnf;jrifawG @& ygonf? &Gmom;rsm;tm; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; vrf;ay:xGufIóudqd k jcif;rjyK&ef trdef @xkwfxm;aomfvnf; &Gmol&Gmom;rsm;urvd kufembJ &GmvH k;u|wfxGufI óudqd k=uygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif a'ocH&Gmol&Gmom;rsm;/ &[ef;oHCmrsm; tiftm;rsm;onf htwGuf atmf[pfqENjyjcif;rjyKbJ qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud katmufod k @csIacgif;iH k @um&yfae=uygonf? vufckyfwD;tm;ay;onf h a'ocHjynfolvlxkud k rdrdwd k @. um;wef;aemufod k @ vd kufvmonf hum;rsm;ay:rS AG D'D,d kuifr&mjzif h rSwfwrf;wifjcif;/ "gwfyH k&d kufjcif;rsm; jyKvkyfaeonfud k rdrdwd k @ jrifawG @&ygonf?
5? acsmif;OD;rS rH k&Gmòrd @od k @t0ifwGif vma&mufóudqd k=uonf @ rH k&Gmòrd @rSqd kifu,ftpD; (200) (300)cef @ud k
awG @&ygonf? xd k qd kifu,frsm;/ um;rsm;onf ol @vrf;ESif hol armif;ESif=uygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @wGif tm%myd kifrsm;uwòrd @vH k; rD;rsm;jzwfawmufxm;onf htwGuf usaemfwd k @tzG J @ud k vlxk}uD;u za,mif;wd kifrD;rsm;xGef;nS d+yD; óudqd k
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 84/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
84
=u ygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @od k @ nae (6)em&Dcef @wGif a&muf&S dcJ hygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @wGif nbuf (10)em&DcG J (11) em&Dcef @wGifrH k&Gmòrd @e,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&H k; zGif hvSpfyG JESif h qd kif;bkwfwifyG Jud k jyKvkyfcJ hygonf?
6/ arv (30) &ufae@ eHeuf(9)em&Dcef @wGif rH k&Gmòrd @&S d aZmwdubkef;awmf}uD;ausmif;od k @ 0ifa&mufIq&mawmftm; zl;ajrmfaomfvnf; q&mawmfr&S dojzif h rzl;awG @&yg // xd k @a=umif h rdrdwd k @onf bkwvifòrd @od k @qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? rdrdwd k @.,mOfrsm; rH k&Gmòrd @rS rxGufcGmrD rdrdwd k @.um; vuf0JzufY rE Wav;/rH k&Gmc&D;onfwifum;('d kifem)ay:wGif xrif;xkyfrsm;toif h,laqmifxm;+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;ESif h ftwl &Jpcef;r_;wOD;vnf; twl&S daeonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @ay:&S d ausmif;q&mwOD;.ajymjycsuft& a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pD tzG J @csKyftm; qef @usifqENjyvsif xrif;au|;/pm;&dwf+idrf; wae@ aiG(500)usyf xkwfay;a=umif; od&S d&ygonf?
7? rH k&Gmòrd @rStxGufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;. um;(12)pD;cef @ &S dygonf?rdrdwk d @.um;aemufwGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0if trsKd;orD;tzG J @0ifrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygonf hum;jzpf+yD; xd kum;.OD;cef;wGif a':0if;jrjrESif h aemufcef;wGif a,musfm;/rdef;r(12)OD;cef @vd kufygvm=uygonf?aemufqH k;um;wGif &[ef;oHCmawmfrsm;/ ud k&ifrsm; pD;eif;vd kufygvmygonf?
8? rH k&GmrSxGufvmonf htcg xl;jcm;csufrsm; r&S dao;yg? bkwvifòrd @od k @ a&mufonf htcgwGif bkwvifòrd @e,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ qd kif;bkwfwifyG JESif hvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k usif;ycJ hygonf? xd krSwqif h nae (6)em&Dcef @wGif pd kifjyifod k @qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? pd kifjyifwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf rdepf(30)cef @ rdef @cGef;ajymygonf? xd k @aemuf pd kifjyifrS 'DyJ,if;òrd @od k @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf// xd ktcsdefwGif usaemfwk d @um;.a&S @wGif um;(9)
pD; aemufwGif(2)pD;&S dygonf? xd k @aemuf ysHus&GmteD;od k @a&mufonf htcgwGif vlta,muf(40)cef @ pDeif; vd kufygEd kifonf h rSefvH kum; tpD;(20)cef @ usaemfwd k @um;wef;rsm;.aemuf rvSrf;rurf;rS vd kufygvmonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? xd kod k @armif;ESifvmpOf usnf&GmteD;od k @ta&mufwGif bkef;}uD;(2)yg;u a':atmifqef;pk=unf pD;eif;vd kufygvmaomum;ud k wm;I rdef @cGef;ajymay;&efawmif;qd kygonf// xd ktcg A[d kvli,fvH kjcHKa&;tzG J @wm0efcHu tcsdefr&ojzifh rdef@cGef;rajymEdkifonfudkcGifhvGwfyg&efarwWm&yfcHav#mufxm;onfudkjrifawG@&ygonf//xd kaemufum;ud k a&S @od k @tenf;i,farmif;ESifoGm;ygonf?xd ktcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @,mOfrsm;.aemuf rvSrf;rurf;rSvd kufygvmonf h qef @usifqENjyolrsm;u a'ocHvlxktm; toif h,laqmifvmonf h 'kwfrsm;/ oHc|efrsm;/ oHwkwfrsm;/ 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;jzif h pwif&d kufESufygonf//
9? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ tzG J @0ifrsm;pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h um;rsm;ud k&yfwef @xm;&ef ajym=um;ygonf? xd kod k @&d kufESufaeonf htcsdefwGifa'ocH&Gmom;rsm;xJrS (3)(4)OD;cef @ u‘a':pku,fygOD; æ usaemfwd k @&Gmom;awG t&d kufcHae&+yD’[k atmf[pftultnDawmif;um rdrdwd k @.um;rsm;&yfxm;onf hae&modk @ a&muf&Sdvmygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif a'gufwmvSpd k;nGef@u vma&mufóudqd kaeonf h bkef;}uD;(2)yg;ud ktultnDawmif;&m bkef;=uD;rsm;u rjzpfEd kifa=umif; jyefvnfajym=um; ygonf? tb,fa=umif hqd kaomfxd kae@ ae@vnfwGif usnf&GmteD;&S dbkef;=uD;ausmif;rsm;ud k a'oqk dif&m tm%myd kiftzG J @tpnf;rsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/tzG J @0ifrsm; a&muf&S dvmygu oGm;a&mufóudqd kjcif; rjyK&/ tultnDray;&/ jy\em wpH kw&mjzpfyguvnf; xGufrvm&[k tcsdK@ bkef;}uD;ausmif;rsm;tm+cdrf;ajcmufI‚if;/ tcsdK@bkef;}uD;ausmif;rsm;tm; v_zG,fypPnf;rsm; qufuyfrnf[kajymqd kI‚if;/ óudwifvma&mufwm;jrpfcJ honf//
xd kod k @wm;jrpfxm;onf htwGuf tultnD r&Ed kifa=umif;/ qufoG,fa&;vrf;rsm;ud kvnf;ydwfxm;vd kuf+yD jzpfa=umif; xd kbkef;}uD;u jyefvnf ajymjyygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 85/208
85
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
xd kod k @a'ocH&Gmom;rsm;tm;&d kufESufaeonfud k AG D'D,d kjzif hrSwfwrf;wif&ef rdrdwd k @ESif htwlvd kufygvmonf hqd kifu,frsm;u pDwef;IrD;rsm;xd k;ay;ygonf? xd kqd kifu,frD;rsm;.atmufwGif 'kwfrsm;/0g;&if;wkwfrsm;/ oH'kwfrsm;/oHc|efrsm;ud kud kifajr‡mufum atmf[pfaeonf hvlrsm;ud krD;a&mifjzif hjrifawG @&ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif c&mr_wf
tcsufay;oH=um;&+yD; xd kolrsm; nmoHay;um vufywfteDywfxm;onf hbkef;}uD;rsm;uOD;aqmifI ajy;wufvmonfuk d jrifawG @&ygonf? xd kod k @ajy;wufvmonfud k &kwfw&ufjrifawG @&I tH H htm;oif haecsdefwGif rdrdwd k @,mOfwef;.aemufqH k;um;jzpfaom &[ef;oHCmrsm;ESif h ud k&ifrsm;pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;tm; yxrqH k;pwifI t=urf;zuf &d kufESuf=uygonf?
10? xd k @aemuf a':0if;jrjrwd k @pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf h trsdK;orD;rsm;.um;ud k qufwd kufqd kovd k 0ifa&muf&d kufESuf=uonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? xd kod k @jzpfaeonf htcsdefwGif um;ay:wGifygvmolrsm;teuf tcsdK@u ,mcif;xJod k @‚if; tcsdK@u um;vrf;ray:od k @wufI‚if; xGufajy;=uygonf? xd kod k @vlrsm; OD;wnf&mrJ h xGufajy;onf htcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @.armfawmf,mOfwef;ESif htwl a':atmifqef;pk=unfpD;eif;vd kufygvmaom um;rSmvnf;xGufajy;=uonf hvltkyfrsm;.aemufwGif usef&pfcJ hygonf?
wqufwnf;rSmyif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k &d kufae+yDjzpfa=umif; atmf[pfajymoHrsm;=um;&ojzif ha&S @od k @a&mufaeonf hvltkyfrSm aemufzufod k @ wzef jyefIvSnf hvmygonf?a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; teD;od k @ta&mufwGif um;rSm 0d kif;&d kufaeonf h vlrsm;=um;rS twif;armif;xGufvmonf ud kjrifawG @&ygonf? um;ay: wGif A[d kvli,fvH kjcHKa&;tzG J @0ifrsm; (*)OD; (9)OD;cef @u armf awmfum;.abmifrsm;ay:wGif rwfwyf&yfvsuf rsufESmcsif;qd kif vufcsif;qufI tumtuG,fay;vd kufygoGm;onfud kjrifawG @vd kuf&ygonf?a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;aemufrS rdrdwd k @tzG J @0ifrsm;.um;rsm;uvnf; wqufwnf;vd kufygarmif;ESifvmojzif h xGufajy;=uonf holrsm;onf rD&mum;rsm;ay:od k @wufI pD;eif;vd kufygcJ h=uygonf? um;ay:wGif vlrsm;jynf haeojzif h rdrdwOD;wnf;
um;trd k;ay:od k @wufI pD;eif;cJ hygonf// um;armif;xGuf+yD; (10) rdepfcef @t=umwGif rdrdwd k @.armfawmfum;toHrsm;a=umif h vrf;ab; 0J,m v,fuGif;rsm;xJ&S d pHepfwustoif h&yfwef @apmif hqd kif;aeonf hum;rsm;rS um;a&S @rD;rsm;ud k òydifwlzGif hvd kufygonf? rdrdrSm um;acgifrd k;ay:wGif&S daeonf htwGuf v,fuGif;twGif; toif hapmif hqd kif;aeonf h vlOD;a& cef @rSef;ajc (1000) eD;yg;cef @ud k um;rD;a&mifrsm;.a&S @wGif 'kwfrsm;/ oH'kwfrsm;/ 0g;&if;wkwfrsm;/oHc|efrsm;ud kifaqmif+yD; apmif haeonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? xd kapmif hqd kif;aeonf holrsm;.=um;od k @ a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; a&muf&S doGm;onf htcsdefwGif toif hapmif haeolrsm;u ‚if;wd k @ud kifaqmifxm;onf h 'kwfrsm;/ tkwfcJrsm;/ avmufav;cGrsm;/oH'kwfrsm;jzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf.armfawmfum;ud k ypfayguf=uygonf? vufvSrf;rDonf holrsm;uvnf; um;ud k 0d kif;I&d kufESuf=uygonf?
11? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.armfawmfum;u vltkyf}uD;tm; vGefoGm;onf htcsdefwGif rdrdwd k @pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;rSm t=urf;zuf&d kufESuf&ef toif hapmif haeonf hvltkyftwGif;od k @ pwif0ifa&mufonf htcsdef jzpfygonf? rdrdwd k @um;rSm vltkyftwGif;od k @ t&S defjzif harmif;ESif0ifa&muf&efóud;pm;pOf 'd kifemum;wpD;u rdrdwd k @.um;tm; 0ifa&mufwk dufygonf? xd ktcg rdrdwd k @.um;u xd k 0ifwd kufonf hum;ud kwdrf;a&SmifpOf vrf;eab;od k @us+yD; toif hapmif haeonf hvltkyf.a&S @od k @ a&muf&S doGm;ygonf? um;a&Smifwdrf;onf htcsdefwGif rdrdrSm um;acgifrd k;ay:rS ckefqif;vd kufygonf? rdrdwd k @.um; vrf;eab;rS vrf;ay:od k @ twif;jyefvnfarmif;ESifwufonf htcsdefwGifrdrdvnf; um;.aemufcef;ud k ab;rSum&Hxm;onf hwef;rsm;ud k tm;jyKI aemufcef;twGif;od k @ jyef0ifa&mufEd kifcJ hygonf? xd kod k @ um;ay:od k @jyefwufEd kif&efóud;yrf;pOf ab;rSypfvd kufonf h'kwfyd kif; rdrd.ausmukef;tm; xdrSef
cJ hygonf? armfawmfum;eab;wGifcsnfxm;onf h rd k;umrsm;tm;cs+yD; armfawmfum;ud k qufvufarmif;ESifcJ h=uygonf? um;ay:wGifyg&S donf holrsm;onf vltkyf=um;twGif; (2)rdepfcef @0d kif;I&d kufESufjcif;ud k cHcJ h&ygonf? um;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 86/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
86
aemufcef;wGifygvmolrsm; =urf;jyifwGif 0rf;vsm;arSmufae=uojzif h tay:qH k;rSvlrsm;om xdcd kufr_&S dcJ hygonf?rdepftenf;i,farmif;ESif+yD;aemuf 'DyJ,if; aq;&H kod k @a&muf&S dcJ hygonf?
12? xd kod k @ toif hapmif hqd kif;aeonf hvltkyf}uD;rS t=urf;zufwd kufcd kufr_rsm;ud k rdrdwd k @ trsd K;om;'Drd kua&pD
tzG J @csKyf/ tzG J @0ifvli,frsm;taejzif h vufwkef @jyefI &d kufESufcJ hjcif; rjyKcJ hyg//a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rdrdwd k @ vli,ftzG J @0ifrsm;tm; trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. wlnD0wfpH kjzpfaom tusôtjzLESif h ucsifvH kcsnf0wfqifxm;vsifbmbJvkyfvkyf jyefvnfvufwH @k rjyef&bl;/ acgif;iH k @cH=uyg[krSm =um;xm;ygonf?
13? rdrdwd k @pD;vmonf h a'gufwmvSpd k;nGef;.um; 'DyJ,if;aq;&H kod k @a&mufonf htcgwGif ud kpd k; (vufarmif;/'l;/ajcaxmuf)/ ud kjrif hOD;(acgif;uG J)/ rH k&GmrSausmif;om;wpfa,muf(trnfrod)acgif;uG J/ &efuif;bkef}uD;ausmif;rSt&Sifynm'Dyu(acgif;ESif hwHawmifuG J)/ rH k&GmjrdK@rSvk dufygvmonf htrnfrod/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if(2)OD; (OD;acgif;wGif'%f&m&)/ tcsif;jzpfae&mrSxGufajy;vmonf h pd kifjyif&GmrSud krif;atmifESif h rE Wav;taemuf
awmifrS (1)OD;wd k @jzpfygonf? rE Wav;taemufawmifòrd @e,frS(1)OD;rSm '%f&m rjyif;xefojzif h tjyifvlemtjzpfukoay;ygonf? usefolrsm;tm;vH k; '%f&mjyif;xefojzif htwGif;vlemtjzpf vufcHukoay;cJ hygonf? xd knwGifyif a'gufwmvSpd k;nGefrSm 'DyJ,if;aq;&H krS a&Smifwdrf;oGm;cJ hygonf?
14? usaemfwd k @ xd kaq;&k HwGif aq;ukor_cH,laepOf (2)&ufajrmufonh fae@ arv (31)&ufae@ wGif ,mOfxdef;&J(2)OD;a&muf&S dvm+yD; um;armif;ol OD;aomif;nGef @tm;ac:aqmifoGm;ygonf?xd k @aemufpcef;r_K;ESif h &J(1)OD;qd kifu,fjzif ha&muf&S dvmygonf? xd kod k @a&muf&S dvmonf htcsdefwGif òrd @e,faq;&H k wm0efcHq&m0efxHrS twGif;vlemrsm;tjzpf vufcHukoay;olrsm;.trnfpm&if;ud k vma&muf,loGm;ygonf? vlemrsm;ud kvnf; trnf
pm&if;ESif h wd kufqd kifppfaq;+yD; vlemrsm;.ae&yfvdyfpmrsm;ud k a&;rSwfoGm;ygonf? ud kpd k;u vlempm&if;rsm;aumuf,ljyD;onf htcsdefwGif usaemf htm; ‘rif;ygw,fqd kwmud k olwd k @ rodbl;/ 'd k @(8)a,mufud kawmh pm&if;,loGm;+yD’ rif;ajy;+yD; wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud kowif;ay;yd k @&ef ajymygonf? xd kae@nae (5)em&DcG Jcef @wGif pcef;r_;(1)OD;ESif h&Jwyfom; (5)OD; um;jzif haq;&H kod k @jyefvnfa&muf&S dvmygonf? vlempm&if;wGifyg&S donf holtm;vH k;ud k zrf;qD;ac:aqmifoGm;ygonf?
15? aq;&H kwGif(2 )ntdyf/ 2 &ufaecJ h+yD;/ 'DyJ,if;blwmod k @ ZGefv (1)&ufae@ eHeuf (3)em&DwGif aq;&H krSrdwfaqGwOD;ESif h xGufcGmvmygonf? 'DyJ,if;blwmod k @ta&mufwGif rdrdESif h tazmfvd kufygolwd k @onf &xm;vufrSwf0,f+yD; rH k&Gmòrd @od k @ xGufcGmcJ hygonf? eHeuf(10)em&DwGif rH k&Gmud ka&muf&S d&m rEWav;ok d @qufoGm;&ef
vd kif;um; vd kufpH kprf;ygonf? um;vd kif;rsm;ud karv (30)&ufae@rSpI (10)&uf=umcef @ydwfxm;+yD; rH k&Gmòrd @wGifvnf; n rxGuf& trdef @xkwfjyefxm;ygonf? ZGefv(2)&ufae@ nae(6)em&DwGif rE Wav;od k @ jyefvnfa&muf&S dcJ hygonf?
txufwGifazmfjyyg&S daom trSwfpOf(1)rS (15) ygtcsuftvufrsm;/ ta=umif;t&mrsm;onf ud k,fwd kifod/ud k,fwd kifjrif/ ud k,fwd kif=uHKawG @cJ h&aomtjzpftysufrsm;jzpfa=umif;ESif h xd kod k @xkwfaz:mfajym=um;&ef rdrd.vGwfvyfonf hoabmqENt& ajym=um;jcif;jzpfa=umif;ud k 0efcHuwdjyKygonf?
armifzdk;aZmfarmifzd k;aZmfarmifzdk;aZmfarmifzd k;aZmfarmifzd k;aZmf2003 ckESpf/ Zlvk dif (3)&ufaeŒ2003 ckESpf/ Zlvkdif (3)&ufaeŒ2003 ckESpf/ Zlvk dif (3)&ufaeŒ2003 ckESpf/ Zlvkdif (3)&ufaeŒ2003 ckESpf/ Zlvk dif (3)&ufaeŒ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 87/208
87
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vlŒabmifopf'Drd ku&ufwpfygwD0if
ud katmifatmif(c) atmifqef;0if;. uwdopP mjyKxGufqd kcsuf
trnf atmifatmif (c) atmifqef;0if;/rdbtrnfu OD;armifuk d/ a':wifOD;/
arG;ouU&mZf 1965 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (19)&uf/ynmt&nftcsif; 0dZ… mbG J @ (jrefrmpm)/ae&yfvdyfpm (19)vrf;/ atmifajromZH/
taemufajrmufòrd @e,f/ rEWav;òrd @?
usaemf ud katmifatmif(c)atmifqef;0if;onf arv(30)&ufae@Y usnf&GmteD;wGifjzpfyGm;cJ honf h 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hywfoufI uwdopPmjyKxGufqd konfrSm æ
1? usaemh femrnf atmifatmif(c)atmifqef;0if;jzpf+yD; zcifjzpfol OD;armifud kESif h rdcifjzpfol a':wifOD;wd k @u 1965ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(19)&ufae@wGif arG;zGm;cJ hygonf? rE Wav;wuUod kvfrS jrefrmpmt"duESif h ausmif;+yD;cJ hygonf// ae&yfvdyfpmrSm (19)vrf;/ atmifajromZH&yfuGuf/ atmifajromZHòrd @e,f (ac: ) taemufajrmufòrd @e,f/
rE Wav;òrd @jzpfygonf?
2? usaemftaejzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unf. txufjrefrmjynfpnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfwGif rwW&mrS pwif+yD;a&S @ajy;vH kjcHKa&;taejzif h vd kufygaqmif&GufcJ hygonf? arv(2*)&ufae@nwGif rE Wav; tzG J @csKyfwd kif;&H k;ok d @ a&muf&S d f+yD; ud kwifxGÉfOD;/ ud krsdK;ed kif/ OD;wifatmifatmifwd k @ESih f awG @qk Hygonf? xd ktcgwGif ud kwifxGÉfOD; (v,fa0;jrdK@e,fv$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f)u usaemfESif h ud kEd kifEd kifwd k @tm; 'DyJ,if; c&D;pOfwGif yg0ifulnD&efajymygonf? usaemfwd k @tm; ¶d k;¶d k;omreft0wfpm;rsm; 0wfqif+yD;/ oD;oef @um;wpD;jzif h oGm;apvk donf? xd kum;ay:wGif tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k rwifaqmifapvk dyg? tultnDawmif;onf htwGuf usaemfwd k @uvJ oabmwlnD+yD; vd kufjzpfoGm;jcif;jzpfygonf?
3? ,mOfarmif;jzpfol ud kEd kifEd kif/ rdwfaqGwOD;ESif htwl usaemfwd k @oH k;a,muf acgif;cef;wGif twlwuGpD;eif;cJ hygonf? arv(29)&ufae@ eHeuf(8)em&D0ef;usifwGif rE Wav;rS pwifxGufcGmcJ hygonf? ppfud kif;ok d @a&mufonf htcgtaESmif ht,Suf rawG @@&yg? a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.,mOfwef; jrif;rlòrd @ok d @ a&mufvmonf htcg jrif;rlòrd @e,f/tzG J @csKyf vli,fzG J @pnf;a&; vkyfaqmifygonf? zG J @pnf;I+yD;cgeD;wGif jrif;rlrS usaemfwd k @ qufvufxGufcGmch Jonf?jrif;rlòrd @rStxGuf a&yd k;pm;aus;&GmwGif vltkyfpk wpfckuk d awG @&onf? rSefvH kum;tygt0if 'd kifemum;(3) (4)pD;cef @ &S d+yD; apmif haeonf hvltkyf}uD;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.,mOfwef;tm; qENjy&ef jyifqifapmif hqd kif;ae=uonf? usaemfwd k @um;tm;jrifonf htcg a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;[kxifI qENjy&ef jyifqif=uonf? usaemfwd k @.aemufwGif rnfonh fum;r# rygvmojzih f ‚if;wd k @ aemufqkwfoGm;onf? puUef @yd kif;r# xyfrH
armif;ESifvd kufonf htcg xd kvltkyfteD;em;wGif ,leDazmif;0wf oH k; av;OD;ud kawG @&onf? ppf,leDazmif;jzif h Ad kvfrª;tqif h(1)OD;/ &J0wfpH k0wfxm;olwOD;ESif htwl ,mOfxdef;&Jud kyg jrifawG @&onf? armfawmf,mOf toGm;tvmrsm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 88/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
88
ud k ydwfxm;onf hyH kpHrsdK;jzpfaeonf? xd kae&mud kausmfjzwf+yD; rvSrf;rurf;wGif usaemfwd k @.um;ud k&yfvd kufygonf?xd k @aemuf usaemfwd k @oH k;OD; wd kifyif=uonf? usaemfwd k @u “ 'Dae&mrSmt=urf;zufr_awG jzpfEd kifw,f// ae&muwqpfcsdK;auG @jzpfaewmrd k @ owfuGif;vd kjzpfaew,f? 'Dvd kjrifawG @&wJ htajctaeud k tzG J @csKyfum;awG a&mufrvm
cif b,fvd kta=umif;rvJ ”pojzih fwd kifyif pOf;pm;=uygonf?
4? xdktcsdefwGif rH k&GmbufrSvmóud=uonf h qd kifu,frsm;a&mufvmygonf? (10)pD; (15)pD;cef @yxrwokwftjzpf a&mufvmygonf// usaemfwd k @u qd kifu,frsm;tm; wm;vk duf+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @tm;qef @usifqENjy&ef apmif hqk difaeaom vlrsm;tm; awG @&a=umif;/ vufxJwGifvnf; qd kif;bkwfrsm;uk difxm;a=umif;/vrf;uk dvnf; ydwfxm;a=umif; ajymjyvd kufygonf// ‚if;wd k @uvnf; usaemfwd k @ESih ftwl xyfrHa&mufvmrnh folrsm;uk d &yfapmif hae=uonf// usaemfu xyfrHa&mufvmrnf holta&twGufuk d rk H&GmrS qd kifu,fESif ha&mufvmolrsm;ud k ar;ygonf? ‚if;wd k @.aemufwGif um;ESif hqd kifu,ftrsm;tjym; rH k&GmrSxGufvm=uojzih f acwWapmif hyg[kajymjzih f ‚if;wd k @ESif htwl (15)rdepfcef @ xyfrHapmif hqk dif;ch Jonf// xd ktcsdefwGif qd kifu,frsm;a&muf&S dvmygonf? vltiftm; rsm;vmojzih f tvsiftjrefoGm;=u&ef xyfrHa&mufvmolrsm;ud kajymjyonf? qd kifu,f(100)eD;yg; armif;xGufoGm;onf? wm;qD;r_ r&S dojzih f qENjyrnh folrsm; apmif hqd kif;aeonf hae&mud k ausmfjzwfoGm;Ek difch Jonf?xd ktcsdefwGif qd kifu,frsm; xyfrHa&muf&S dvmonf htwGuf usaemfpD;vmonh fum;ay:rSqif;+yD; qd kifu,fwpD;ay:wGif acwWvd kufygoGm;onf? a&yd k;pm;ok d @a&mufonf htcsdefwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih ftwl vd kufygvmaom ,mOfwef;ay:rSvlrsm;u urB mra=uoDcsif;qd kae=uonf? qENjy&efapmif hqd kif;ae=uolrsm;bufrS atmf[pfoHrsm;uk d r=um;&awmhyg//
5? usaemfvnf; um;qDok d @ qd kifu,ftkyfpkESih ftwl jyefvk dufvmonf? um;ay:ok d @ jyefwuf+yD;aemuf
c&D;qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif rH k&GmrS vma&mufóudqd k=uonf h qd kifu,frsm;/um;rsm; rsm;jym;vmonf htwGuf ajz;ajz;omarmif;ESifch J&onf? rH k&Gmòrd @t0if&d S &Gmrsm;uvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @. ,mOfwef;ud k v_ dufvJpGmóudqd k=uonf? rH k&Gmok d @ (6)em&Dausmfcef @wGif a&muf&S dygonf? óudae=uonf holrsm;ud k tH hrcef;awG @&ygonf? Ed kifiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;tm; óudqd k=u&mwGif rH k&Gmòrd @.óudqk dr_tm; rnfonh fae&ma'orS rDrnfrxifyg? rH k&Gmwòrd @vH k; rD;jzwfxm;onh ftwGuf za,mif;wd kifrsm;xGef;+yD; óudqd k=uonf? qd kifu,fta&mif;qk difwckuvnf; qd kifu,frD;rsm; vrf;ay:ok d @xk d;ay;x;m;onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rlv pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;ay:rSqif;I tjcm; um;wpD;ay:od k @ ajymif;IpD;+yD; rH k&Gmòrd @vlxkud k E_wfqufonf? rH k&Gmòrd @e,f tzJ G @csKyf&H k;ud k n(9)em&Dausmfcef @wGifa&muf&S d+yD;/ òrd @e,ftzG J @csKyf&k H; qd kif;bkwfwifyG Jud kjyKvkyf ygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @cHvlxkud kvnf;
a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rdef @cGef;ajymygonf? xd knwGifyif rH k&Gmòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k jyKvkyfygonf?usaemfwd k @u bkef;}uD;ausmif;wGif oGm;a&mufwnf;ck dygonf?
6? arv(30)&ufae@eHeufwGif usaemfwd k @ rH k&GmrSxGufvmygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu aZmwduausmif; q&mawmftm; 0ifa&mufzl;ajrmfygonf? OuU Hawm&ausmif;ud k xyfrH0ifa&muf&eftpDpOf&S daomfvnf;r0ifjzpfawmhyg? rH k&Gmòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifvli,ftrsdK;orD;rsm;u OuU Hawm&bkef;}uD;ausmif;txd usaemfwd k @um;ESif htwl vd kufygvmcJ honf? OuU Hawm& bkef;}uD;ausmif;ok d @ r0ifbJ awmufav#mufarmif;vmonf htwGufvli,ftrsdK;orD;rsm; bkwvifòrd @txdygvmonf? rGef;vG J(2)em&Dcef @wGif bkwvifok d @a&mufygonf? bkwvifok d @a&mufonf htcg tzG J @csKyfvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k vkyfygonf/ nae(4)em&Dcef @wGif vli,fzG J @pnf;a&;+yD;qk H;ygonf?
ud kausmfatmif (taemufajrmufòrd @e,ftwGif;a&;rª;)u qd kifu,fjzif h a&S @rSóudwifoGm;ESif hojzih f ‚if;ESif hvk dufoGm;&ef ud kwifxGÉfOD;u usaemfwd k @tm;ajymygonf/ xd k @a=umif h(4)em&D0ef;usifcef @wGif usaemfwd k @ bkwvifrS pwif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 89/208
89
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
xGufvmcJ hygonf? pd kifjyif}uD;od k @a&mufonf htcg a'ocHvlxku v_ dufvS JpGmóudqd k&ef jyif fqifae=uonf/ a&S @vrf;c&D;tajctaeud k ar;jref;aomtcgwGif vrf;a=umif;&Sif;onf[kajymonf htwGuf usaemfwd k@ qufvufIxGufcJ hygonf? vrf;c&D;wavsmufwGif wzufrSvmonh fc&D;onfwifum;rsm; rawG @&jcif;rSm xl;jcm;aea=umif;
usaemfu ud kEd kifEd kiftm;ajymygonf? qufxGufvmonf htcg a&yd k;pm;&GmwGifawG @cJ h&aom qENjyaESmif h,Sufrnf hvltkyfuh Jok d @ vltkyfwtkyfud k awG @&ygonf// xk dvltkyfrSm a&yd k;pm;wGif awG @cJ h&aomvltkyfxuf vlta&twGuf fyd krk drsm;jym;onf// tcsdK@u qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf? ‚if;wk d @tm; ausmfvGefvm+yD;aemuf pd kufysdK;a&;0if;(aemifwGif qnfajrmif;0if; [k od&onf h ae&m)ok d @ usaemfwd k @um; a&mufvmygonf?
7? xd kae&mwGif oHql;óud;wef; (9)ck csxm;onf? wwef;vsif (3)ckE_ef;jzih f (3)wef; csxm;+yD; vrf;uk dydwfqd k @xm;onf? xd kod k @ ydwfqd k @xm;ojzih f um;ud k t&S defav#mhvd kuf&onf? xk dtcg oHql;óud;wef;rsm;.aemufwGifwkwf/ 'd kif;rsm;ud kifaqmifxm;aom &JwyfzJ G @0iftiftm;(30)cef @ud k awG @&onf? tusôtjzL0wfxm;onf h vl
wa,muf a&mufvm+yD; “b,foGm;rvd k @vJ” [kar;ygonf? usaemfwd k @uvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih ftwlvmjcif;jzpfa=umif; &Sif;jyonf? xd ktcg ‚if;u ppfabmif;bDESih f pGyfus,ftusô0wfxm;aom touf (50)cef @t&G,f&S dolwOD;xH oGm;I “ Ad kvfrª;/ 'g a':atmifqef;pk=unfeJ @ ygvmwJ hum;” [k owif;yd k @ygonf? xd kolu“at; txJxnf hvdkuf” [k jyefajymygonf? xk d Ak dvfrª;qk dolrSm tenf;i,f0òzd;+yD;/ pGyfus,ftusô0wfqifxm;ojzih f &mxl;trSwftom;ESif hwHqdyfud k rjrifawG @&yg?
usaemfwd k @. nmzufab;wGif yvyfpwpfcH krsm;ay:wGif xd kifaeonf h oHCmawmfrsm;ud k vSrf;jrif&onf?Ad kvfrª;[k tac:cH&olu oHCmawmfrsm;xHoGm;I “a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @um;vm&if vrf;zGif hay;rSm ygbk&m;/tck 'DrSmapmif haewJ hvlpku rauseyfa=umif; atmf=urSmyg” [kqk donf? usaemfwd k @ud krl wkwfuk difaqmifxm;aom &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;u 0if;xJok d @0if&ef ck dif;ygonf? um;armif;ol ud kEd kifEd kifu um;acgif;ud k 0if;jyifbufok d @acgif;wnfvd kuf&m ‚if;wd k @u ¶d kufESufrnf h[efjyifygonf// um;ud k aemufqkwfI taqmufOD;&S donf h0if;xJod k @um;ud k armif;0ifvd kufygonf? um;&yfonfESif h wkwfud kifaqmifxm;onf h &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;ajy;vm+yD; um;ud k0d kif;vd kufojzih f usaemfwd k @vnf; um;atmufok d @qif;&ef r0h H&Jawmhyg? xd k @aemuf &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;u qif;&ef trdef @ay;onh ftcgrS um;ay:rSqif;vd kufonf// cE<muk d,fwGif &SmazG&ef vufuk d tay:ok d @ ajr‡mufcd kif;ygonf? xk d @aemufusaemfwd k @.a&S @wGif um;ud k&SmazG+yD; 0if;taemufzufwGif&S daom taqmuftOD;teD;ok d @ ac:aqmifoGm;onf?
taqmufOD;teD;wGif c&D;oGm;trsdK;orD;tcsdK@xd kifaeonf? xd ktaqmufOD;a&S @jrufcif;jyifwGif ykcH k;wGif=u,fESpfyGif hwyfxm;aom &Jt&m&d SwOD;ud k jrifawG @&onf? ‚if;onf 'DyJ,if; &Jpcefrª;[k aemufyk dif;wGif jyefvnfod&onf? usaemfwd k @. ae&yfvdyfpmrsm;ud k,l+yD; pD;vmonf hum;eHygwfud kvnf; rSwfom;xm;ygonf// xk d @aemuf
taqmuftOD;twGif;&S d tcef;xJod k @xnf hvd kuf&m tcef;xJwGif 'DyJ,if;òrd @e,f v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,fjzpfolOD;bd karmif/ uomòrd @e,f v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f OD;jrif=hunf/ tif;awmfòrd @e,f v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f OD;apmvd _if pojzih f (6)OD;(7)OD;cef @uk dawG @&onf? tm;vH k;uk d vufxdyfcwfxm;onf? usaemfwd k @tm;csKyfaESmifxm;onf h tcef;ab;wGif t&yfom;c&D;onfrsm;ud k csKyfaESmifxm;onf[k od&S d&onf/
8? c%t=umwGif 0if;xJok d @ qd kifu,farmif;0ifvmaom ud kausmfatmiftm;awG @&onf? ud kausmfatmiftm; csufcsif; óud;jzif hcsnfygonf? wqufwnf;wGifyif usaemfwd k @tm;vnf; wG J+yD;csnfygonf? ud kausmfatmifa&mufvmrS ,cifu zrf;xm;olrsm;ESif h pwif pum;ajymjzpfygonf// arSmif&DysKd;pwGif usaemfwd k @ud k tcef;av;
twGif;rSxkwfI 'd kifemum;ay:od k @ ajymif;+yD;wifygonf// (7) em&D0ef;usifcef @jzpfonf? usaemfwd k @tm; wifaqmifxm;onh f 'd kifemum;ab;wGif &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;u ae&m,lapmif hqk dif;aeygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 90/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
90
9? n(8)em&D0ef;usifcef @wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @.,mOfwef;rS rD;a&mifrsm;ud k pwifjrif&onf?usaemfwd k @0ifvmonf h 0ifayguf.vrf;rbufok d @ um;rD;rsm;xd k;xm;onf? vrf;ray:ok d @ opfyifrsm;ay:rSvnf;qvd k k kufrD;rsm; xd k;ay;xm;onfud kvnf; jrifawG @&onf? 0if;twGif;&S d 'd kifemum;rsm;unf; um;vrf;ay:od k @ rD;
rsm; xd k;xm;onf? qlnHaom vloHrsm;ud kvnf; =um;ae&onf? xd ktcsdefwGifa':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @. ,mOfwef; a&muf&S dvmonf? usaemfwd k @ud kzrf;qD;xm;onf h hae&mrS ay(300)cef @ uGma0;rnf[kxifygonf? rnfonf htwm;tqD;rS r&S dbJ uGif;jyifuJ hod k @ jzpfaeonf htwGuf tm;vH k;ud k &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif; vSrf;jrifae&ygonf?
10? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;u a&S @qH k;rSjzpfrnf[k xifygonf/ tb,fa=umif hqd kaomf xk dum;rSmzd k;0D;vf (4WD) jzpfonf htwGuf um;a&S @rD;a&mifu tjcm;um;rD;a&mifrsm;xuf jrif hygonf/ “um;awmha&mufvm+yD/ bma=umih f&yfaeovJ rodbl;” [k tzrf;cHxm;&oltcsif;csif; wD;wk d;ajymjzpf=uonf? jy\emjzpfaoma=umih f n‡ dE_ dif;ae=uonf[k tcsKd @u,lq=uonf? wcsdefwnf;rSmyif vrf;ab;0J,mwGif apmif hqd kif;aeolbufrsm;xHrS trdef @ay;aeonf htoHrsm;ud k =um;&onf? “vrf;ay: rwufeJ @/ vrf;ay:u qif;=uyg” pojzih ftrdef @ay;oHrsm;vnf; =um;&onf? apmif hqk dif;aeolrsm; v_yfv_yf&G&GjzpfoHrsm;=um;&onf? atmf[pfoHrsm;uk drl r=um;&ao;yg? a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @um; &yfwef @aeonfrSm(15)rdepfcef @=umrnf xifygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif armfawmfum;rD;vH k; tenf;i,fa&G @vmonf htwGuf um;xGufvm+yD[k rdrdwd k @tcsif;csif; ajymaepOf [pfatmfoHrsm;=um;&+yD;/ “xk xk xk/ ypf/ owf owf”“xk xk xk/ ypf/ owf owf”“xk xk xk/ ypf/ owf owf”“xk xk xk/ ypf/ owf owf”“xk xk xk/ ypf/ owf owf” qd konf h toHrsm;ud k pwif=um;&onf?
11? a':atmifqef;pk=unfpD;vmonf hum;u a&S @qH k;rS t&S defjyif;jyif;jzih f armif;vmonfud k jrifawG @ &onf?usaemfwd k @ESif h rsufESmcsif;qd kifwGif&S daeonf h 0ifaygufvrf;ray:rS oHql;óud;tqD;twm;rsm;ud k wd kufcd kufrdonh ftoHrsm;ud kvnf; wqufwnf; =um;&ygonf? xd ktcsdefwGif aoewfoH (10)csufcef @ =um;&ygonf?
xd kuJ hod k @jzpfaecsdefwGif OD;bd karmifESif h&if;ES D;onf h 'DyJ,if;òrd @e,f &Jpcef;rª; OD;pdef0if;qd kol usaemfwd k @um;teD;ok d @
a':atmifqef;pk-unf vk dufygvmaomum;uk darmif;ol uk dausmfpk d;vif; t&S defjyif;jyif;ESif h armif;xGufpOf
tm%myk difwk dŒ ydwfqkdŒ xm;aom oHql;óud; (3)xyfuk d ykH-urf;jzifh azmfjycsuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 91/208
91
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
a&mufvm+yD; “uJ OD;bd karmif/ cifAsm;jrifwJ h =um;wJ htwd kif;yJaemf/ cifAsm;wd k @ trsm;}uD; uHaumif;ygw,f/ uHoDygw,f” [k ajymygonf? wqufwnf;rSmyif usaemfwd k @um;.teD;Y pum;ajympufESif h qufoG,fajymqk doHrsm;ud kvnf; =um;&ygonf? “a'0wifvS &xm;+yD? a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;w,f” xk dtoHrsm;uk d ¶kwfw&uf em;
rvnfyg? “a'0wifvSqd kwm OD;wifOD;ud kajymwm/ OD;wifOD;ud k zrf;xm;w,f? a'0pH&Sm;qd kwm a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kajymwm a':atmifqef;pk=unf vGwfoGm;+yD” [k ud kEd kifEd kifu aemufyd kif;wGif &Sif;jyonf?
12? ra&S;raESmif;wGif 0if;xJod k @zrf;qD;ac:aqmifvmaomvlrsm;ud k jrifawG @&onf? nnf;nLoHrsm;ud k=um;&+yD; r=umrD ‚if;wd k @um;. aemufrD;zGif hvd kufonf htcg usaemf.rdwfaqGjzpfol OD;atmifpd k;.orD;/ tjcm; trsKd;orD;i,frsm;/ '%f&m&onf holrsm;ud k jrifawG @&onf? atmifol0if;.acgif;wGif aoG;rsm;&$ Jepfae+yD;/ '%f&m}uD;us,fygonf? usaemfwd k @vnf; '%f&m &vmolrsm;uk d wwfEk difoa&G @ jyKpkay;ygonf? &moDOwktvGefylojzih f,yfcwfay;&onf// xd k @aemuf rH k&GmrS bkwviftxdygvmonf h rH k&Gmatmif&Sif.orD;jzpfol usaemfwd k @.um;ay:ud ka&mufvmonf? “&ufpufw,f/ acgif;awGud kyg ¶d kufwm” [kajymqd kum pdwfacsmufcsm;+yD; wkefv_yfaeonf// acgif;wGif jyif;jyif;xefxef '%f&m r&aomfvnf; cg;wGif f¶d kufcH&onf h '%f&memusifI nnf;nLae=uonf?
13? rd k;vif;umeD;cef @wGif usaemfwd k @um;ay:rS '%f&m&xm;olrsm;ud k aq;¶H kyd k @rnfqd kum usaemfwk d @.ab;wGif&d Saomum;ay:o@d k ajymif;a&$ @vk dufonf? xk dum;onf eHeufvif;tm;}uD;tcsdefcef @wGif usnf&GmteD;&S d qnfajrmif;0if;twGif;rS xGufoGm;onf?
usaemfwd k @ud k wifaqmifxm;onf hum;onf eHeuf(6) em&Dcef @wGif qnfajrmif;0if;xJrS xGufvmygonf?um;ay:wGif OD;Zif; OD;aZmwdu/ OD;apmvd _if/ OD;bd karmif/ ud kausmfatmif/ OD;jrif h=unf/ aZmfxGef;/ aZmfjrif h/ ud kEd kifEd kif/
rsdK;rif;/ usaemf/ ud kpdefvd _if/ oef;xGef;OD;/ rH k&Gmatmif&Sif.orD;jzpfoltjyif wd k;wd k;0if; qd konf h rH k&Gmòrd @rS trsdK;orD;wOD;ESif h oufxGef;OD;qd kaom ausmif;om;av;wd k @vd kufygvmygonf? emrnftm;vk H;ud k rrSwfrdawmhyg// usaemfwd k @tm;wifaqmifvmonh fum; 0if;ayguftxGufY vltjynf h wifaqmifxm;onf h 'd kifemum;rsm; tpD;(50)cef @uk dawG @&ygonf? ud kausmfatmifu vSrf;=unf honf h htcg xd kum;ay:rSvlwOD; u “rif;wd k @ 'Davmuf vufoHajymifwm rrSwfao;bl;vm;/ bm=unf hwmvJuG/ aooGm;csifvd k @vm;”[k vSrf;ajymoHud k=um;&ygonf? tvkyfudpPrsm;+yD;qk H;I jyef&efjyifqifaeonf hyH kpHud k jrifawG @&ygonf?
14? usaemfwd k @ud k a&OD;rSjzwfI a&$bd kaxmifod k @ yd k @vd kufygonf? a&$bk daxmifud k usaemfwd k @ tapmqH k; a&muf
&S djcif;jzpfonf? usaemfwd k @um;wGif trsdK;orD;(2)OD; ygvmonf? rk H&Gmatmif&Sif.orD;ESif h wd k;wd k;0if; wd k @jzpfygonf?a&$bd kaxmifAl;0wGif tjcm;um;ay:rS +zdK;jrjrpd k;ESif h trnfrodtrsdK;orD;wOD;ud k usaemfawG @&ygonf? zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;cH&olrsm;wGif rH k&Gmòrd @rS yd krsm;ygonf? um;ay:rS ygvmoltukefvH k;uk d a&$bd kaxmif atmufxyfrS tcef;xJwGif xm;vd kufonf? omref tcsKyfom;rsm;ud k wcef;vsif(70)/(80)cef @pDxm;onf[k ajymygonf? ae@vnfyd kif;wGif usaemfwd k @tm;vH k; tay:xyfod k @ajymif;&onf? tay:xyfwGifvnf; tjcm; tusOf;om;rsm;ESif h a&mxm;ygonf? ZGefv(1)&ufae@ ae@vnfyd kif;wGif nDnDatmif tygt0if tjcm;vli,frsm;ud k awG @&jyD; ud kwifxGÉfOD;ud krlrawG @&ao;yg?
15? (10)&ufcef @t=umwGif tr&yl&òrd @e,f OuUX OD;vSjrif h/ taemufajrmufòrd @e,f (atmifajromZHòrd @e,f)
rS ud kodef;atmifav; polwk d @a&mufvmonf? ud kodef;atmifav;.OD;acgif;wGif jyif;xefaom'%f&m (3)ck awG @&onf? wae&mwGif(6)csufESif h tjcm;wae&mwGif(4)csuf csKyfxm;onf? ezl;rS'%f&mrSm csKyfrxm;onf h twGuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 92/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
92
tuG Jvd kufjzpfaeonf? erc aq;wyfqG,frS a&muf&d Svmjcif;jzpfonf? yxrwGif ‚if;wd k @u erc aq;±k HrS v$wfay;vd kuf+yD[k xifae=uonf? aq;¶k HrS um;ay:od k @ ajymif;a&$ @wifonf htcsdefwGif omreft&yfom;rsm;omyg&S donf?aq;¶k Htjyifbufod k @ a&mufonf htcsdefwGif t&yfom;rsm;u um;ay:rSqif;+yD;aemuf &JwyfzJ G @0ifrsm;wufvm+yD;
usaemfwd k @&S daeonf ha&$bd kaxmifok d @ yd k @vd kufjcif;jzpfa=umif; jyefajymjyonf?
16? ZGefv(2)&ufae@wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ESif h twlygoGm;onf h vli,frsm;jzpfaom ud kxGef;aZmfaZmf/ um;armif;ol ud kausmfpd k;vif;/ ud kxGef;jrif h/ oufxGef;/ ud krif;vGif f/ ud kawZEd kif ponf hvli,frsm; a&$bd kaxmifod k @ a&muf&S dvmonf? ud kwifxGÉfOD;wd k @ESif h jyefvnfawG @qH konf htcgwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. tajctaeud k ar;=unf hygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum; a&S @rSef ruG Jaomfvnf; ab;rSefrsm;uG JoGm;+yD; um;twGif;ok d @ wkwfESpfacsmif;a&mufvma=umif;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unf.vnfyif;wGif rSefprsm;xd&Sonf htwGuf '%f&mtenf;i,f &&S doGm;onf[k usaemfwd k @tm; jyefvnfajymjyonf?
17? ZGefv(1)&ufae@wGif wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;u usaemfwk d @tm; ppfa=uma&; pwifjyKvkyfonf?wm0ef,lppfaq;olrSm Ad kvf}uD;vif;aZmfuHjzpf+yD; usaemfwd k @. ud k,fa&;&mZ0ifESif h ,ck ta&;tcif;wGif yg0ifywfoufonf htcsufrsm;ud k ar;ygonf? ZGefv(8)&ufae@ aemufyd kif; usaemfwd k @tm; jyefvnfv$wfay;cgeD; ok H;/av;/ ig;&uf tvd kwGif &efukefrSv$wfonf[kqd k+yD; vlwOD;a&mufvmonf? ppfaxmufvSrf;a&;[k rajymyg?“cifAsm;wd k @ ta,muf(50)vGwfajrmufa&;twGuf vm+yD;vkyfay;&wm” [k ‚if;u qk donf? xd kolu usnf&GmteD;wGif jzpfysufcJ honf hta=umif;t&mrsm;ud k b,fol @ud kr# rajym&ef/ rdom;pk0ifrsm;uk dyif rajym&ef wm;jrpfonf? usaemfwd k @ud kvnf; a&$bd kaxmifwGifaecJ h&jcif;ESih fywfoufI rajym&ef xyfrHwm;jrpfonf// “ywf0ef;usifuar;&if c&D;oGm;w,fvd k @om jyefajymyg”[kqk donf? a&$bd kaxmifwGif zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;xm;csdefwGif touf
(14)ESpft&G,f oufxGef;OD; qd konf h rH k&GmrS ausmif;om;wOD;/ ud k&if(5)yg;ESif h OD;yÍif;(3)yg; tygt0if pkpkaygif;(120)eD;yg;cef @&S donf? zrf;qD;cHxm;&onf h ud k&ifESif h OD;yÍif;rsm;ud k axmift0wftpm;rsm;xkwfay;I vl0wfvJaponf?
18? ZGefv(9)&ufae@wGif rk H&Gmòrd @ txufwef;ausmif;om;rsm;/ wuUod kvfausmif;om;rsm;tygt0if (25)a,mufuk d vGwfay;onf? ZGefv(12)&ufae@wGif usaemfwd k @ (21)a,mufud kv$wfay;onf? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm; r[kwfonf htwGuf v$wfay;vd kufjcif;jzpfonf// xd kod k @ v$wfay;onf htcgwGif wa,mufv#ifpm&Gufw&GufuspD ay;ygonf? ed kifiHawmf.txl;vsKd @0Sufcsufjzpfonf htwGuf xd kudpPud k rayguf=um;ap&ef/
ayguf=um;ygu xyfrHta&;,ljcif;cH&rnf pojzif h tusOf;csKyfyg&S donf? usaemfwd k @u wm0ef,lvd kufemrnfjzpfa=umif; ppfud kif;wd kif;axmufvSrf;a&; wyf&if;(20)wyf&if;rª;.a&S @wGif tqifoif h vufES dyfpuf±k dufay;xm;onf hxk dpm&Gufud k vufrSwfa&;xd k;ay;cJ h&onf?
19? a&$bdkaxmifAl;0wGif txufvl}uD;rsm;u pmemaxmufxm;+yD; ,ckuJ hod k @ vGwfay;vd kufjcif; jzpfa=umif;/ rnfonh ftjypfr# r&d Sonf htwGuf v$wfay;vk dufjcif;jzpfa=umif;ajymjyonf? ,ckuJ hod k @ zrf ;qD;cH&onf hudpPud k jyefvnfajym=um;ygu jyifyowif;Xmersm;. tok H;csjcif;uk d cH&vdrf hrnf[kajymonf? xd k @aemuf a'gufwm vSpd k;!Gef @ pD;vmonf hum;uk darmif;ESifol OD;aomif;!Ge@f/h a':0if;jrjr pD;eif;vd kufygvmonf hum;ud karmif;olOD;pdef&D/ ud krsdK;rif;/ ud kEd kifEd kifESif h usaemfwk d @(5) OD;tm; acsmqG Jvmonf h c&D;onfwif'd kifemum;ESih f vd kufyd k @onf?
20? um;a&S @cef;wGif axmufvSrf;a&;rS Ad kvf}uD;vif;aZmfuHESif hwOD;/ vufeuftjynf htpH k ud kifaqmifxm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 93/208
93
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
onf h &JwyfzG J @0if(6) OD; (7)OD;cef @vd kufygvm+yD; ppfud kif;òrd @ axmufvSrf;a&;wyfqG,f&k H;ok d @a&mufvmonf? xd kae&mwGif acwWxm;+yD; axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(1)od k @ ta=umif ;=um;onf? usaemfwd k @tm; axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(1)rS Ad kvf}uD; tqif h&S dolESif h tjcm;(4)OD;xHok d @ vG Jajymif;ay; vd kufonf? emrnfrsm;ud k usaemf rodyg?
usaemfwd k @tm; zd k;0D;vfum;jzih f axmufvSrf;a&;(1)ok d @ac:oGm;onf? axmufvSrf;a&;(1)wGif ud k,fa&;&mZ
0if xyfrHa&;&onf? xd k @aemuf ,ckjzpfcJ honfrsm;uk d rnfol @ud kr#rS rajymygqd konf h pum;&yfrsm;yg0ifaompm&GufwGif vufrSwfxd k;&onf? xd k @aemuf "gwfyk H&k duf+yD; r,u OuUXESif h/ &,u OuUXtm;ac:,l+yD; usaemfwd k @ud ktaemufajrmufòrd @e,f e,fajrcHaxmufvSrf;a&;xHod k @ v$ Jajymif;vk dufonf? ‚if;wk d @ESif htwl tdrfta&muf jyefvnfvd kufyd k @ygonf? naeyk dif; tdrfok d @a&mufonf htcg tdrfwGif &,u/ r,uOuUrsm;ESif htwl "gwfyk H(2)yH k&d kuf& onf? rdom;pkESif h wG J&d kuf&jcif;jzpfonf? xk difaeaom usaemfESif h usaemf h.tpfraemufwGif ‚if;wk d @rwfwyf&yfaeonh fyk Huk d &d kufjcif;jzpfonf? aetdrfok d @ aumif;rGefpGm jyefyd k @a=umif; taxmuftxm;tjzpfrSwfwrf;,l+yD;/usaemh ftrjzpfolu tkyfxdef;oltjzpf xk dok d @jyefyd k @jcif;uk d od&d Syga=umif; vufrSwfxd k;ay;&onf? usaemfwd k @ (2)zG J @aygif; (46)a,muf vGwfvmjcif;jzpfonf htwGuf a&$bd kaxmifwGif pkpkaygif; (60-70)cef @ qufvufxdef;odrf;cH
xm;&qJjzpfonf? ud kausmfatmif/ ud k0if;cd kifESif h ud kodef;atmifav;wd k @ jyefvnfvGwfajrmufvmyg+yD[k od&S d&ygonf?
txufyg trSwfpOf (1) rS (20) txdyg&S donf hta=umif;t&mrsm; onf rdrdud k,fwd kifawG @/ ud k,fwd kifjrif/ud k,fwd kifodonf h ta=umif;t&mrsm;jzpf+yD; ,ckuJ hod k @xkwfaz:ajym=um;&ef rnfolr# rw&m; =oZmv$rf;rd k;jcif;/+cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ aoG;aqmifjzm;a,mif;jcif;/ vdrfvnfvSnf hjzm;jcif; r&S dbJ rdrd. vGwfvyfonf hoabmqENt& xkwfazmfajym=um;jcif;jzpfa=umif; 0efcHuwdjyK vufrSwfa&;xd k;ygonf?
udkatmifatmif?ud katmifatmif?udkatmifatmif?ud katmifatmif?udkatmifatmif?2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (28)&uf (wevFmae@)?2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (28)&uf (wevFmae@)?2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (28)&uf (wevFmae@)?2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (28)&uf (wevFmae@)?2003 ckESpf/ Zlvdkifv (28)&uf (wevFmae@)?
&efukef&S d tar&duefoH±k H;wm0ef&S dolwk dŒ vkyf}uHr+jzpfyG m;&mae&muk d oG m;a&muf±k duful;xm;onf h "gwfyk H
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 94/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
94
vlŒabmifopf'Drd ku&ufwpfygwDrSud kEd kifEd kif (c) ud kodef;Ed kif. uwdopP mjyKxGufqd kcsuf
trnf ud kEd kifEd kif (c) ud kodef;Ed kifarG;ouU&mZf 16 - 5 - 1969
rdbtrnf OD;cifud k - a':oef;/ynmt&nftcsif; 0dZ… mbG J @ (yx0D)/tvkyftud kif ta&mif;t0,f/ae&yfvdyfpm atmifajromZHòrd @e,f/ rE Wav;òrd @?
usaemfud kEd kifEd kif (c) ud kodef;Ed kifonf arv(30)&ufae@wGifjzpfyGm;cJ honf h 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hywfoufIuwdopPmjyKxGufqd kvk donfrSm ² ² ²
1? usaemf ud kEd kifEd kif (Ed kifiHom;rSwfyk HwifeHygwf/ 9§rer(Ed kif)-051359)onf zcifjzpfol OD;cifud kESif h/ rdcifjzpfol a':oef;wd k @rS 16 - 5 - 1969 ae@wGif arG;zGm;cJ hygonf? rEWav;wuUod kvfrS yx0Dbmomt"duESif hbG J @&&S d+yD;/ ta&mif;t0,f fvkyfief;ESif h toufarG;0rf;ausmif;jyKI/ rE Wav;wk dif;/ atmifajromZHòrd @e,fwGif aexd kifygonf? &Spfav;vk H;vlxktk HºuGr_wGif ausmif;om;xkESif htwl ausmif;om;or*~wGif/ xd kufoif honf hae&mrS yg0ifv_yf&Sm;+yD;/ 1989-ckESpf/ vl @abmifopf'Drd ku&ufwpfygwDay:aygufonf haemufwGif/ ygwD0ifwOD;jzpfvmum/ausmif;om;a&;&maumfrwDESif h vli,fa&;&maumfrwDwGif/ aumfrwD0ifwOD;taejzif h 0ifa&mufwm0efxrf;aqmifcJ hygonf? vl @abmifopf'Drd d ku&wfwpfygwDzsufodrf;cH&+yD;aemuf/ w&m;0if &yfwnfonf hEd kifiHa&;ygwDtaejzif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyfwckwnf;om usefonf htwGuf/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf. vd ktyfcsufrsm;ud k/ ,cifuwnf; uvufwG Jvkyfud kifcJ h=uonf h oli,fcsif;rsm;ESif htwl qufvufv_yf&Sm;+yD;/ t+rJwrf; wwfEd kifor# wm0ef,lyh Hyd k;ulnDcJ hygonf?
2? arv(26)&ufae@ a':atmifqef;pk=unf. rwW&mc&D;pOfrS pwifI/ usaemfESif hud katmifatmif/ qd kifu,fjzif h a&S @ajy;vH kjcHKa&;tjzpf vd kufygulnDcJ h&ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;teD;rS ,SOfoGm;onf htcg/
“om;/ tJ'DrSm qd kifu,fawGuk d [Gef;awG rwD;zd k @/ om;u ajymOD;”/ “rD;awGvnf; rxGef;apeJ @”/ “om;/pnf;urf; &d S&r,faemf”[kajymonf htcg usaemfu“[kwfuh JtefwD &w,f”[k jyefvnfajymqd k+yD;/ vufvSrf;rDor#ud k vd kufvHajymch Jygonf? usaemfwd k @tzJ G @0ifrsm;tm;vk H;ESif h óudqd k=uonf hvlrsm;tm;vk H;u rD;vnf; rxd k;/[Gef;vnf; rwD;=uyg? xd kod k @ c&D;qufvm=upOf a':atmifqef;pk=unf. vk HòcHa&;twGuf vd kufygvmonf h
tzJ G @csKyf tzJ G @0if vli,f(11)OD;u =umeDuHaus;&GmteD;wGif urB mra=uoDcsif;ud k pwifoDqd kygonf? ykodrfav;rS rE Wav;c&D;wavsmuf/ urB mra=uoDcsif;ud k oDqd kvm=u+yD;/ rE Wav;jrdK@/ td k;bd kaxmif.ta&S @bufrSjzwf+yD;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 95/208
95
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
jyefvm=uygonf? td k;bd kaxmifa&SŒod k @a&mufonf htcg óudqd k&efvmonf h tzJ G @wGif yg0ifolrsm;tm;vk H;u/ urB mra=u oDcsif;ESif h axmifwGif;&d S ed kifiHa&;tusOf;om;rsm;ud k tm;ay;onf htaejzif h/ oH+ydKif[pfaºuG;oDqd k=u+yD;jyefvmch J=uygonf? rE Wav;òrd @od k @a&mufonf htcg vlxk}uD;u aomif;aomif;jzjzóudqd konfud kjrifawG @&ygonf?
3? rE Wav;wGif (1)&ufem;ygonf? aemufw&ufwGif rE Wav;(19)vrf;/atmifajromZH±k H;ESif h &wemrO… L bk&m;ok d @ a':atmifqef;pk=unfvmrnfqk dojzih f tacsmarG @qk H;ESif h vlxk.aomif;aomif;jzjzóudqd kr_&&d Sap&efusaemfwd k @ vd kufvHpnf;&k H;+yD; óudqd kzd k @jyifqif=uygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfqd kvsif e*d kuyif jynfolvlxkw&yfvk H; cspfcif+yD; jzpfonf htwGuf/ aomif;aomif;jzjz}udKqd k=uygonf? xd kc&D;pOfwGif taemufajrmufòrd @e,f&k H;a&S @ Y vlxktm; E_wfqufpum; tenf;i,fajymum/ &wemrO… Lbk&m;tm;zl;ar#mf+yD;aemuf wHwm;OD;òrd @e,fod k @oGm;ygonf? wHwm;OD;od k @oGm;onf htcgwGif tzJ G @csKyf tzG J @0iftcsdK@ESif htwl usaemf/ ud katmifatmifwd k @ ESpfa,mufum;jzif hvd kufoGm;ygonf? wHwm;OD;od k @toGm; tr&yl&òrd @od k @a&mufonf htcgwGif a'gufwmaZmfjrif h armif. ZeD;jzpfola':,k,karud k,fwd kifc&D;OD;óudqk d+yD; wHwm;OD;txdvk dufyd k @ygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h ud kwifxGÉf OD;wd k @onfwHwm;OD;òrd @e,f/ vli,fzJ G @pnf;a&;jyKvkyf+yD;onf htcsdefwGif usaemfwd k @vnf;jyefvmygonf? wHwm;OD;òrd @. txifu& yk*~ dKvf}uD;ESpfOD;jzpfaom ud kav;(tif;0*k%f&nf)ESif h OD;=unfatmifwd k @u wHwm;OD;òrd @txGufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kapmif hóud+yD; vk dufvHyd k @aqmifE_wfqufygonf? a'ocHvlxkuvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;&mE_ef;jynf heD;yg; axmufcH=uonf htwGuf vd _ufvd _ufvS JvS J}ud dKqd konfud k usaemfwd k @ud k,fwd kif jrifawG @cJ @&ygonf?
4? rE Wav;od k @jyefvm+yD; aemufwae@ ar(28)&ufae@ nyd kif;wGif rE Wav;wd kif;±k H;od k @ qufqufvmch Jyg&efa':atmifqef;pk=unfu usaemf htm; rSm=um;ygonf? usaemfa&mufoGm;onf htcsdefY rE Wav;wd kif; tzJ G @csKyf&k H;tay:xyf a':atmifqef;pk=unftem;,ltdyfpufonf htcef;a&S @wGif/ud kxGef;aZmfaZmf/ud kwifxGÉfOD;/ a':atmif
qef;pk=unfESif h usaemfwd k @(4)OD; rE Wav;-rH k&Gm a&S @c&D;pOftwGuf aqG;aEG;wd kifyif=uygonf f? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu taESmif ht,Sufay;Ed kifonf hudpPrsm;awG @ygu jyefvnfqufoG,f&ef “om;wd k @ud k vk dufapcsifw,f”[k ajymygonf? ud kwifxGÉfOD;uvnf; usaemf htm; tultnDawmif;ygonf? wqufwnf;rSmyif a':atmifqef;pk=unfu “tefwDwd k @csrSwfxm;wJ h rlawGay:rSm/ ud kwifxGÉfOD;/ uk dxGef;aZmfaZmfe@J om; n‡ dvd kufyg”[k ajymonf? c&D;pOftwGif; taESmih ft,Sufrsm;óuH&rnf/ rnfolu|Hu|H ud k,f hbufu onf;cH+yD;oGm;&rnf/ &d kufvsifvnf; cH&rnf/ owfvsifvnf; ao&rnfqd konf hrl tzJ G @csKyfwGif&d Sonf[k ud kwifxGËfOD;u usaemh fud k &Sif;vif;ajymjyygonf? rE Wav;wk dif;/ (4)òrd @e,frS tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifvli,frsm;ud kvnf; xd kpnf;urf;rsm; ajymjy+yD;jzpfa=umif;od&onf? txufaz: jyygrljzif @ pnf;&H k;a&;c&D;pOfoGm;aejcif;jzpfonf htwGuf xd krlrsm;twd kif; vd kufemapvk donf
[k ajymygonf? a':pkuyif “tzJ G @csKyftzJ G @0if rjzpfwh Jtay:rSm/ 0d kif;0ef;wJ hom;wd k @/ a&S @ajy;tzG J @taeeJ @ tzG J @csKyf&J @wlnD0wfpH kud k0wfzk d @ rvd kygbl;/ om;wd k @ ulnDyg” [k ajymygonf? usaemfu ucsifjynfe,f c&D;pOfwGif rvd kufygEd kifch Jonf htwGuf ,ckwcg usaemfwd k @vd kufrnf[k a':pkud k jyefvnfajymvd kufygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. ,mOfwef;ESif htwl vd kufrnf r[kwfaoma=umif h rdrdwd k @.um;ud k wae&mwGifxm;ch J+yD; “ud kEd kif/ eufjzefreuf(8)em&D'Dud k vmch Jyg” [k uk dwifxGÉfOD;u csdef;qd kvd kufygonf?
5? arv(29)&ufae@ eHeufwGif (38)vrf;ESif hvrf;(80)a'gif hwGif um;uk d&yfxm;cJ h+yD;/ rEWav;wd kif;&k H;od k @oGm;ygonf f? ud katmifatmifu um;ay:wGifaech Jygonf? ud kwifxGÉfOD;ESif h awG @qH k pum;ajymonf htcg/ ‚if;wd k @tzG J @u (9)em&DwGif pxGufrnfjzpfonf htwGuf (8)em&DcG JwGif rdrdwk d @tm; a&S @rSoGm;ESih f&ef ajymygonf? usaemfwd k @
ESif htwl rE Wav;wd kif;/ tzJ G @csKyftzG @J0if oli,fcsif;wOD;tygt0if tm;vH k;(3)OD; a&S @ajy; vH kjcHKa&;um;taejzif hrE Wav;rS pwifxGufvm=uygonf? ppfud kif;òrd @ }udKqd ka&;&k H;ok d @a&mufonf htcg a&S @rSem&D0ufapmxGufjcif;jzpf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 96/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
96
a=umif;/ aemuf wem&Dqd kv#if a':atmifqef;pk=unfa&mufvmrnf[k ajym+yD; jrif;rlòrd @ok d @ qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? ppfud kif;+rdK@rS txGuf vrf;.vuf smbufwGif “trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyfESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; vd _ufvS JpGmóudqd kygonf” [lonf h qd kif;bkwfESif htwl/ tzG J @csKyf/ tzJ G @0ifrsm;ESif h jynfolvlxk}uD;u óudqd ka&;pcef;
zGif hvSpfóudqd k=uonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf?
6? jrif;rlod k @ ra&mufrD/ tkef;awmaus;&GmwGif usaemfwd k @&yf+yD;/ uGrf;,m/ aq;vdyf0,fonf htcsdefwGifqufoG,fa&;ypPnf;rsm;ESif h tvkyf&_yfaeaom axmufvSrf;a&;rsm;uk d [k dufvyfum;tjzL (%§6456)ay:wGifawG @&onf? xd kae&mrSpI axmufvSrf;a&;um;rsm; vk dufygvmonfud k pwif owdjyKrdcJ hjcif;jzpfygonf? od k @aomf rnfonf h taESmih ft,Sufud kr# róuHawG @&ao;yg? jrif ;rlt0if a&mufonftxd/ axmufvSrf;a&;um;rsm;vd kufygvmonfud k d k awG @&ygonf? a':pktm;qef @usifqENjyrnf holrsm;u 'd kifemum;ay:wGif avmfpyDumrsm;wyfqif f+yD;/ jrif;rlòrd @e,f/ tzG J @csKyf &H k;a&S @ vrf;ay:wGif atmf[pfaESmif h,Sufae=uygonf? jrif;rlòrd @e,f&H k;twGif;od k @a':atmifqef;pk=unf0ifoGm;onf htcg a':atmifqef;pk=unf-usef;rmygap/ csrf;omygap/ OuUÏ}uD; OD;wifOD;-usef;rmygap/ csrf;omygap/ touf&mausmf &Snfygap ponf h h qkawmif;arwWmyd k @oHrsm;ESif h óudqd k=uygonf?jynfolvlxk}uD;. óudqd konf h htoHrsm;ud k/ 'd kifemum;ay:rS qef @usifonf h htoHrsm;u rv$rf;ed kifcJ hyg// xd k'd kifemum;onf jrif;rlòrd @e,f tzG J @csKyf&H k;0ef;usifwavsmufwGif vSnf hvnf f+yD;/ aESmif h,Sufae=uonfud k jrifawG @ae&ygonf?jrif;rlòrd @wGif tzG J @csKyfvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;ud k vkyfygonf? usaemfwd k @vnf; &H k;tjyifrSaeI (1)em&D(45)rdepfcef @ apmif h+yD;aemuf jrif;rlòrd @rS xGufvm=uygonf?
7? jrif;rlESif h acsmif;OD;=um;wGif&S daom a&yd k;pm;aus;&Gmok d @ 0ifonf htcgwGif (3)wef,mOf wpD;pmeD;yg;cef @&S donf h vrf;cif;ausmufrsm; vrf;ab; 0J/ ,mwGif (15)yk H/ tyk H(20)cef @ESif htwl/ vltkyf}uD; (1000)cef @ apmif hae
onfud k awG @&ygonf? xd kvlrsm;.vufxJwGifvnf; “jynfytm;ud k; ykqdef&d k; tvd kr&d S” ponf h ‚if;wd k @ tjrJwrf;ud kifaqmifaeus qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf? usaemfwd k @um;u tqk dygvltkyf}uD;ud k ausmfvGefonf htcgt&m&d SAd kvfrª;wa,mufESif h ,mOfxdef;&Jwa,mufu rE Wav;/ rH k&GmoGm;rnf h h,mOfrsm;tm; ydwfqd k @wm;qD;ae=uonfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? usaemfwd k @um;vnf; jyefauG @I r&awmhyg? xd k @a=umif h a&S @ud ka&mufEd kifonftxdarmif;&ygonf? xd kod k @armif;oGm;onf htcg acsmif;OD;rS vma&muf óudqd k=uonf h armfawmfqd kifu,ftpD; (40)(50)cef @ud k pwifawG @&ygonf? vl(100)cef @ yxra&mufvmjcif;jzpf+yD; aemufyd kif;wGif oHCmawmfrsm; ygvmygonf f? usaemfwd k @u a&mufvmolrsm;ud k aemuf wem&DwGif/ Tae&mod k @ a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @ a&mufvmrnf hta=umif;ESif h tE W&m,ftvGefrsm;onf hta=umif;wd k @ud k jrifawG @cJ h&onfrsm;ESif h,SOfI ud k;um;&Sif;jyygonf?
yxr (4) (5)pif;oGm;&ef óud;pm;&mwGif vrf;ydwfxm;IjyefauG @vm=uygonf? xd kod k @ apmif hqk dif;aepOf &maxmifcsD+yD; xyfrHa&mufvmonf h hqdkifu,ftkyfESif hjzwfonf htcgrS xd k,mOfxdef;&JESifh ppf,leDazmif;0wfAd kvfrª;tqif h&S dolwd k @u aemufud kqkwfI vrf;z,fay;vd kufjcif; jzpfygonf f?
8? a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;óudqd k&ef rk H&GmrS vm=uonf hqd kifu,frsm;/ vlrsm;ud k/ rH k&Gmòrd @rSxGufcGif hray;bJydwfxm;onf[k od&ygonf? rk H&GmwuUod kvfESif h aumvdyfrsm;rS ausmif;om;rsm; qd kifu,f(200)ausmf/ (300)cef @‚if;wk d @.ausmif;rsm;a&S @wGif pkI vltkyfpkvd kuf trsm;ESif h pxGuf=uonf htwGuf/ rwm;qD;Ed kifawmhbJ vGwfay;vd kuf&aoma=umif h/ óudqk d=uonf h hvlrsm; axmifESif hcsDIa&mufvmjcif;jzpfa=umif; od&ygonf? rH k&GmrSaeI vma&muf óudqd k=uol vGefpGmrSyif rsm;jym;onf htwGuf um;ud ktjrefarmif;I r&awmhyg/ acgif;aqmifwOD;ud k
,ckuJ hod k @óudqd konfud k usaemfwcgrS rawG @zl;yg/ usaemfwd k @um;u a&S @qk H;wGifjzpfojzih f vmóud=uonf h qd kifu,frsm;ESif htwlwl wjznf;jznf;om oGm;Ed kifawmhonf? &yfa0;rS wul;wu vmóudonf h ouf}uD;&G,ftd krsm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 97/208
97
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vnf;yg0if+yD; t&G,fpk HawG @&ygonf? vlxku/ rk H&Gmòrd @t0ifwGif urB m ra=uoDcsif;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfusef;rmygap/ OuUÏ}uD; OD;wifOD; usef;rmygap pojzif h qkawmif;arwWm yd k @oaºuG;a=umf+yD; óudqd k=uygonf?omreftcsdefwGif (20)/ (25)rdepfarmif;&onf hc&D;ud k nae (5)em&DrS n(9)em&Dausmftxd (4)em&DeD;yg;armif;rS
rk H&Gmòrd @ tzG J @csKyf&k H;ok d @ a&muf&S dygonf?rk H&Gmòrd @wGif rD;rsm;jzwfxm;onf htwGuf za,mif;wd kifrD;rsm; xGef;n‡ d+yD; rH k&Gmvlxku v_ dufvS JpGm óudqd k d k=uygonf? a':pkvnf; 0rf;omyDwdjzpf+yD;/ vlxk.arwWmud k wkef @jyefonf htaejzif h [k dif;vyf ypfuyfum;ud kajymif;pD;+yD;/ aEG;axG;pGmóudqd kE_wfquf=uonf h jynfolvlxkud k jyefvnfE_wfqufygonf? yef;uk H;pGyf=uonfud kvnf; ud k,fwd kifvufcH,lygonf? vma&mufóudqd kolrsm;uk d usaemfwd k @=unf hvd kufonf htcg 0rf;omI id kolrsm;vnf; &d Sonf?
“'d k @ Ad kvfcsKyforD;av;ud k jrifcsifvd kufwm/ b,frvJ jyprf;yg”[k ar;oluar;/ xk djrifuGif;rsdK;ud k usaemfwcgrS rawG @zl;yg/ avhvmodrSwfzl;onh ford kif;wGif róuHzl;atmif jynfolvlxk. axmufcHóudqd kr_ud k a':atmifqef;pk=unf &&S dcJ hjcif;jzpfonf? a':pkud k rk H&Gmòrd @u óudqd kr_a=umif h/ etzu ta&;,ltjypfay;rnfqd kygu rk H&Gmòrd @}uD;tm; axmif0if;cwf+yD;xm;&rnh f tajctaersdK;jzpfygonf? rH k&Gmòrd @e,f&H k;ok d @ a&mufonf htcg vma&mufóudqd k=uonf hvlxkud k OD;wifOD;u/ 'Drd kua&pDatmifjrifa&;qEN}uD; (4)yg; jynfol @ud kqENay;+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfu rdef @cGef;ajymygonf? xk d @aemuf rk H&Gmòrd @rS v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f Ad kvfrª;}uD;a[mif;=unfpd k;. aetdrf/pdefr#m;pwk d;od k @ oGm;a&mufum/ rH k&Gmòrd @e,f/ tzG J @csKyfvli,fzG J @pnf;a&;vkyfaqmif+yD;aemuf xd ktdrfYyif tem;,lygonf? usaemfwd k @u OD;xGef;0if;ESif h zkef;qd k;ausmif;wd kufwGif vd kuftdyfygonf?
9? aemufwae@eHeufwGif aZmwduausmif;wd kufok d @ oGm;rnf/ uk dEd kif a&S @uoGm;ESif @/ vltkyftwGif; ydwfrdaernf[k ud kwifxGÉfOD;u vmajymygonf? aZmwduausmif;wd kufok d @0ifzl;+yD;aemuf OuU Hawm&ausmif;ok d @ quf
oGm;rnf @tcsdefwGif rH k&Gmòrd @e,f tzG J @cskKyftzG @J0iftcsdK@ usaemfwd k @um;ay:wufvmygonf? q&mawmf r&d Sonf htwGuf OuU Hawm&ausmif;ok d @ r0ifjzpfawmhbJ/ òrd @ywfvrf;twd kif; bkwvifok d @ c&D;qufxGufvmcJ h=uonf?bkwvifESif h rk H&Gm=um;wGif vH kòcHa&;wm0ef,lxm;onf h ud kaZmfav;.um; ysufoGm;onf? xk d @a=umih f usaemfwd k @um;u vk HòcH Ha&;tjzpf qufvufwm0ef,lch Jygonf? bkwvifa&mufonftxd jynfolrsm; óudqd k=uonf hae&mrsm;ok d @ a&mufonf htcgwGif vli,frsm;onf usaemfarmif;onh f um;ay:rSqif;+yD;/ a':pkum; eHab;wGifvH kòcHa&;wm0efrsm; vG Jajymif;+yD; ,lcJ h&ygonf? usaemfESif h ud krsdK;Ed kifwd k @u a&mufonf hae&mwd kif;wGif òrd @t0ifòrd @txGufud k vSnf hywfavhvmygonf? xd k @a=umif h bkwvifòrd @ok d @ a&mufonf htcgwGifvnf; vmch Jonf hvrf;ESif hqufvufoGm;rnf h vrf;c&D;.tajctaeud k vd kuf=unf hygonf? bkwvifòrd @t0if&S d "mwfqDqd kifteD;wGif/ um;
twGuf "gwfqDxnh faepOf um;(16)pD;cef @ESif htwl vufarmif;wGif tjzLywfxm;onf hvlrsm;ud k pwifawG @&ygonf? xk d @jyif vufarmif;wGiftjzLywfrsm;ESif h oHCmwzG @Jud kvnf; usaemfjrifawG @&ygonf? owif;yd k @&ef a':pkwd k @xH jyefvmonf htcsdefwGif rH k&GmrSbkwviftxdvd kufyd k @aom qd kifu,f(70) (80)cef @ud k/ ZD;awmaus;&GmwGif oHql;óud;ydwf+yD; zrf;onf hta=umif;/ a':pkxHowif;yd k @ay;&ef rH k&GmrSbkwviftxdvd kufygvmonf h trsdK;orD;i,fwOD;u ajymygonf?
xd k @a=umih f bkwvif&k H;tay:xyfwGif ae@vnfpm pm;aeaom a':pk/ xGef;aZmfaZmfESif h ud kwifxGËfOD;wd k @xHoGm;a&muf+yD; ajymjyygonf? a':pkvnf; pdwfraumif;jzpf+yD;/ bkwvifòrd @e,fOuUX OD;atmifqef;ud k/ xk dudpPvd kuf&Sif;ay;&efajymonf htwGuf/ ppfuk dif;wk dif;OuUX OD;bmbm.um;jzif h vd kufyd k @onf hqd kifu,frsm; zrf;qD;xm;onf hae&mod k @ OD;atmifqef;vd kufoGm;ygonf? wqufwnf;rSmyif vufwGiftjzLywf ywfxm;olwk d @.um;
(15)pD; (16)pD; aemufuvd kufvm+yD; bkwvift0ifwGif apmif haeonfud k jrifawG @cJ h&a=umif; a':pkuk d ajymjyygonf? ud kwifxGËfOD;u “uk dEk dif/ cifAsm;wd k @ tajctaeuk d aoaocsmcsm *&kpd kufyg/ xl;jcm;&if owif;yk d @yg” [k
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 98/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
98
ajymonf? a&S @rSoGm;ESif honf h OD;apmvd _ifESif h qufoG,fay;rnf[k ud kwifxGÉfOD;u ajymygonf?a':pkwd k @u/ bkwvifòrd @e,f tzJ G @csKyfvli,fzJ G @pnf;a&;ud k qufvufvkyfaqmifygonf? OD;odef;azjrif h tkwf*l
a&S @wGif um;jyif&if;ESif h usaemfwk d @em;ae=uygonf? rH k&GmrSvd kufvmonf h tzJ G @csKyf/ tzJ G @0ifrsm;ESif h vma&muf}udKqd k
oltcsdK@ud k vd kufyd k @ay;onf h qd kifu,form;rsm;uvnf;/ ZD;awm&GmwGifzrf;aeonfqd konf h owif;=um;&onf h htwGuf rjyefao;bJ tajctaeud kapmif h=unf haeolrsm;vnf; &S dae=uygonf? usaemfwd k @ em;ae=uonf hae&mok d @ ud kwifxGÉfOD;vd kufvm+yD; “ud ked kif cifAsm;wd k @ jyefvSnf hzk d @ tcuftcJ&S drSm pd k;&drf&vk d @/ud kausmfatmifvnf; aemufuqd kifu,fpD;+yD; t&yf0wfeJ @ vd kufvmvdrf hr,f? cifAsm;wd k @ a&S @u oGm;ESif hvd kufyg/ OD;apmvd _if 'DyJ,if;rSm&S dr,f? vrf;c&D;rSmtcuftcJ&d Swh Jtcg/ ud kausmfatmifeJ @ csdwf+yD;vkyfyg” [kajymygonf? a':pkwd k @ um;wef; rxGufrD em&D0uf (45)rdepfapm+yD; usaemfwd k @ bkwvifu xGufvmcJ hygonf?
10? pd kifjyif}uD;ud ka&mufonf htcg zrf;qD;cHxm;&aomv$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,fOD;0if;jrif hatmif. aetdrfwGif }udKqd ka&;pcef; zGif hxm;ojzif h acwW0ifem;ygonf? pd kifjyif}uD;ESif h bkwvif=um;vrf;c&D;wav#muf&S d aus;&Gmjynfolvlxkrsm;uvnf; a':pkud k vd _ufvd _uf vS JvS Japmif hóudqd kae=u onfud k awG @jrif&ygonf? wem&Dcef @ tem;,l+yD;aemuf OD; apmvd _if 'DyJ,if;ok d @ oGm;ESif h+yD[k usaemfwd k @od&ygonf? usaemf wd k @vnf; OD;apmv_ difESif h qufoG,f&rnf jzpfonf htwGuf pd kifjyif}uD;rS qufvufxGufcGmcJ hygonf? pd kifjyif}uD;rS twef=um um;armif;oGm;+yD;aemuftcsif;jzpf onf hae&mod k @ a&mufonh ftcg oHql;óud;rsm; (3)xyfumxm;+yD;/ vrf;ab;0J,mwGifvnf; vl(4000)ausmf (5000)cef @ud k jrifawG @&ygonf? vltkyf}uD;ESif h oHql;óud;rSm odyfra0;yg/ vltkyfqk H;onfESif h oHql;óud;umxm;aomae&mok d @ a&mufygonf? vuf smbufrSvltkyfu enf;+yD;/ vuf0JbufrSvltkyfu yd krsm;onfud kvnf;owdxm;rdygonf? xd kae&mwGif apmif haeonf hvlrsm;onf bkwvift0ifwGifawG @cJ honf h vlrsm;uJ hod k @ b,fbufvufwGif tm;vk H;t0wf jzLywfxm;+yD;/ tcsdK@u qd kif;bkwfrsm; ud kifxm;=uygonf? Tae&mwGif wck xl;jcm;
onfrSm trsdK;om;rsm;ud komawG @&+yD;/ trsdK; orD;rsm; ryg0ifyg? usaemfwd k @vnf; um;ud k qufarmif;ESifvmonf?um&Hxm;onf h oHql;óud;wef;rsm;ud kausmfvGef+yD; qufxGufI&vsif OD;apmvd _ifESif h xyfrHpDpOfrnf[kpOf;pm;xm;ygonf?oHql;óud;rsm;jzif h wm;xm;onf hae&mwGif um;ud k&yfvd kuf&yg onf? t&yf0wfESif hvl (3) OD; usaemfwd k @ um;teD;ud k a&mufvm+yD;/ wa,mufu b,fvJ[k ar;ygonf? usaemfu 'DyJ,if;ud koGm;rSm[k jyefvnf ajz=um;vd kufygonf? um;xJrS uk datmifatmifu a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif hvmonf[k ajzvk dufygonf? xd kod k @ajymqd k+yD;aemuf usaemfvnf; um;atmufuk d qif;vd kufygonf?
11? xd ktcsdefwGift&yf redrf h rjrih f/ cyf00/ rsufck H;tenf;i,fxl+yD; rsufESmwif;wif;ESih fvlwa,mufu
xd kifcH kwGif xd kifaeonf hbkef;}uD;rsm;ud k vuftkyfcsD+yD; “'Dvrf;uae a':pk=unftzJ G @oGm;r,f/ 'DrSm apmif haewJ hvltkyfu a':pk=unfwd k @a&mufvm&if olwd k @ rauseyfwmawGuk datmfr,f/qENjyr,f/ 'DrSm apmif haewJ hvltkyfeJ @/a':atmifqef;pk=unfeJ @ygvmwh J buf u oHCmawGeJ @ jy\emwuf&if/ bkef;}uD;wd k @u rsufESmjyzd k @ ygyJ” [kajymyg onf? ‚if;onf tay:wGif pGyfus,f tusô0wfxm;+yD;/ atmufwGif ppfabmif;bD0wfxm; um/ &_;zdeyfpD;xm;ygonf? ‚if;u bkef;}uD; rsm;uk d usaemf hum;teD;Y ajymaejcif; jzpfI ajymqd konfrsm;tm;vH k;ud k =um;ae&ygonf?usaemfwd k @ud k b,foGm;rSmvJ[k ar;onf holu/ ‚if;uk d “Ad kvfrª;”[kac:vd kuf+yD; a':pk=unfESif htwlvmonf h um;jzpfa=umif;ajymonf htcg xd kAd kvfrª;u “zrf;xnf h xm;vd kuf” [kajymygonf? vrf;.b,fbufwGif&S daom qnfajrmif;Xme0if;}uD;xJod k @ um;ud karmif;0if&ef ajymygonf? usaemfwd k @tm;zrf;qD;olrsm;rSm wkwfrsm;/ 'd kif;rsm;ud kifaqmifxm;onf h &Jrsm;jzpfygonf// cE<muk d,fud k OD;pGm&SmazG+yD;/ xk d @aemuf um;xJud k &Smygonf// usaemfwd k @
.ud k,fa&;tusOf;,l+yD;aemuf/ 0if;xJwGif&S daom taqmuftOD;wckxJok d @ yd k @vd kufygonf? tcef;xJok d @ a&mufonf htcg tzrf;cHxm;&onf h OD;apmvd _if/ OD;jrif h=unf/ OD;bk darmif/ uk daZmfxGef;/ OD;pdefwif ponf h yifeDtusô
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 99/208
99
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
&ifxd k;wHqdyfponf h 0wfpk Hjynh f0wfqifxm;aom tzG @JcsKyf 0if(5)OD;/ t&yf0wfESih f tzJ G @csKyftzJ G @0if(1)OD;/ uk dpdefvif;[kac:aom t&yfom;wOD;wk d @ tzrf;cHxm;&onfud k jrifawG @ &ygonf? tcef;xJod k @ usaemfwd k @(3)OD; a&mufoGm;onf htcg“OD;apmvd _ifygovm;”[k ar;=unh fygonf// yxr rajym&J=uao;yg/ aemufrS OD;apmvd _ifqd kwm olyJ[k ud kaZmfxGef;u jyefvnfajz=um;ygonf? OD;apmvd _ifESif husaemf hud k a':pkwd k @u qufoG,fck dif;vk dufjcif;jzpfI rnfok d @qufvkyf=urnfuk dar;&m “bmrS rvkyfwwfawmhbl;” [k ajymyg onf? c%=umonf htcg usaemfwd k @ESif hqufoG,f&ef
qd kifu,fjzif hvd kufvmonh f taemufajrmufòrd @e,f twGif;a&;rª;jzpfol ud kausmfatmif a&muf&S dvmygonf?
12? ud kausmfatmifud kvnf; ‚if;wd k @u vd ktyfonfrsm;ud kar;+yD;aemuf vufESpfzufud kyl;I óud;jzif h csnfaESmifygonf? usaemfwd k @ud kvnf; ud kausmfatmifESih ftwlwG JI óud;jzif hcsnfxm;ygonf? ud kausmfatmifu óud;csnf&ef rvd ktyfyg[k ajymaomfvnf; r&yg/ arSmif&DysdK;vmonf htcsdefwGif usaemfwd k @tm;csKyfaESmifxm;onf htaqmifav;xJrS xkwf+yD;/ taqmuftOD;ESif h ay(30)cef @wGif&yfxm;onf h c&D;onfwif'd kifemum;ay:od k @ ajymif;+yD; wifygonf? a':pkwd k @.um;rsm; rvmrD tqd kyg0if;}uD;a&S @&d S opfyif}uD;ay:rS qvd kufrD;ESpfvH k;cef @ xd k;ay;xm;ygonf? rD;vH k;}uD;rsm;jzif h vrf;ray:ud k tvif;a&mifrsm;ay;xm;+yD;/ a':pkwd k @tzG J @tm;wd kufcd kufrnf h vrf;.vuf0Jbuf qnfajrmif;0if;xJrS vltkyf}uD;ud k 'd kifemum; (15)pD;cef @u pDwef;+yD;/ aemufausmrS rD;xd k;ay;xm;onfud kjrifae&ygonf?
usaemfwd k @a&muf+yD; (1)em&DcG J cef @t=umwGif usaemfwd k @ESih fay(400)cef @tuGmrS um;rD;a&mifwef;rsm; ay:
vkyf}uHr+jzpfyG m;&mae&mESif h reD;ra0;Y tm%myk difwk dŒ pDpOfxm;onf h
oHql;óud;(3)xyfESif h apmif hqkdif;aeaomvltkyf}uD;uk d yk H-urf;a&;qJ Gazmfjycsuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 100/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
100
vm+yD;/ a':pk.,mOfwef;a&mufvm onfud k jrifawG @&ygonf? qef @usifqENjy&d kufESufrnf hvltkyf}uD;.a&S @tpyfusnf&GmteD;wGif um;wef;}uD; &yfwef @oGm;ygonf? xk dtcsdefwGif OD;aZmwduqd konf hbkef;awmf}uD;wyg;ESif hrk H&GmrS ausmif;om;wOD;u qd kifu,fjzif h vltkyf}uD;a&S @ok d @ a&mufvm+yD; tajctaeud kavhvmaomtcg ‚if;wd k @ud k
vnf; zrf;qD;vd kufygonf? bkef;}uD;ud kawmh bmrSrvkyfyg/ qd kifu,farmif;onf holtm;¶d kufESuf+yD;/ ‚if;wk d @(2)OD;pvH k;ud k usaemfwd k @&d Saeonh fum;xJ xnf hvd kufygonf? xd k @aemuf a':pk.um;ESif h tjcm;um;(2)pD; xGufvmonfud k jrif&ygonf? xk dum;rsm; usaemfwd k @ud k zrf;xm;onf h 0if;a&S @od @k a&mufonf htcg/ apmif haeonf hvltkyfu“rsdK;zsufr/ opPmazmufrud k owf/ rsdK;zsufrud k owf”“rsdK;zsufr/ opPmazmufrudk owf/ rsdK;zsufrud k owf”“rsdK;zsufr/ opPmazmufrud k owf/ rsdK;zsufrud k owf”“rsdK;zsufr/ opPmazmufrudk owf/ rsdK;zsufrud k owf”“rsdK;zsufr/ opPmazmufrud k owf/ rsdK;zsufrudk owf” [kajymqd k+yD; 0if¶d kuf=uygonf? vli,frsm;uvnf;“tarhud k umuG,f=u/ tarhud k umuG,f=u”“tarhud k umuG,f=u/ tarhud k umuG,f=u”“tarhud k umuG,f=u/ tarhud k umuG,f=u”“tarhud k umuG,f=u/ tarhud k umuG,f=u”“tarhud k umuG,f=u/ tarhud k umuG,f=u” qd konf h atmfoHrsm;ESif htwl “tarhud k rxdapeJ @/ umuG,f=u”“tarhud k rxdapeJ @/ umuG,f=u”“tarhud k rxdapeJ @/ umuG,f=u”“tarhud k rxdapeJ @/ umuG,f=u”“tarhud k rxdapeJ @/ umuG,f=u”[k atmf[pfowday;aeonf h toHrsm;ud k =um;ae&ygonf? xd kod k @jzpfaecsdefwGif “xGuf/ wd kuf”“xGuf/ wd kuf”“xGuf/ wd kuf”“xGuf/ wd kuf”“xGuf/ wd kuf” qd konf h trdef @ay;oHESif htwl toif hapmif hqd kif;aeaom 'd kifemESpfpD;u a':pkwd k @pD;vmonf hum;ud k rsufESmcsif;qd kifwd kuf&ef rdrdwd k @tm;zrf;qD;xm;onf h0if;xJrS armif;xGufoGm;ygonf? a':pkwd k @.um;u oHql;óud;wef;(3)ckud k qufwd kuf0ifwd kuf+yD; xGufoGm;ygonf? xd kod k @ wd kufxGufoGm;csdefrSmyif “ypf”“ypf”“ypf”“ypf”“ypf” [k trdef @ay;onf htoHud k=um;&+yD; (10)csuf/(15)csuf qufwk dufypfcwfonh faoewfoHrsm; =um;&ygonf? um;u r&yfbJ qufarmif;oGm;ygonf?
xd ktcsdefwGif usaemfwd k @tm;zrf;qD;xm;onf h 'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;rª; OD;pdef0if;u “JuJ OD;bd karmiftygt0if tm;vH k;=um;=u jrif=uwJ htwd kif;yJ/ cifAsm;wd k @ uHz,foGm;w,f/ uHaumif;w,fvd k @yJ oabmxm;vd kufyg” [k vma&mufajymqk dygonf? ‚if;taejzif h ,ckuJ hod d k @jzpfrnfud k óudwifod&S d+yD;jzpfyH k&ygonf?
13? 0if;a&SŒwGif &d kuf/ ESuf/ owf[k atmf[pfae=ucsdefwGif usaemfwd k @um;ab;wGif pum;ajympufESif hvlwOD; owif;yd k @aeonfud k =um;&onf? “&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;?&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;?&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;?&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;?&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;?” wzufu “&xm;/ &xm;&xm;/ &xm;&xm;/ &xm;&xm;/ &xm;&xm;/ &xm;” [k jyefajymonfud k=um;&jyD; “a'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0wifvS &+yDa'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0wifvS &+yDa'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0wifvS &+yDa'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0wifvS &+yDa'0wifvS &+yD/ a'0wifvS &+yD” “a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/ a'0pH&Sm; vGwfoGm;/” “a&OD;ayguf/a&OD;ayguf/a&OD;ayguf/a&OD;ayguf/a&OD;ayguf/
wef@qnfaygufud k ydwf/ a&OD;ayguf/ wef @qnfaygufudk ydwfwef @qnfaygufudk ydwf/ a&OD;ayguf/ wef@qnfaygufudk ydwfwef@qnfaygufud k ydwf/ a&OD;ayguf/ wef @qnfaygufudk ydwfwef @qnfaygufudk ydwf/ a&OD;ayguf/ wef@qnfaygufudk ydwfwef@qnfaygufudk ydwf/ a&OD;ayguf/ wef@qnfaygufud k ydwf” “pufuav;toif hjyif vk dtyf&if ypfpufuav;toifhjyif vkdtyf&if ypfpufuav;toif hjyif vk dtyf&if ypfpufuav;toifhjyif vkdtyf&if ypfpufuav;toifhjyif vkdtyf&if ypf” [kqufvufowif;yd k @aeonf h toHrsm;ud kvnf; =um;&ygonf?
a':pkum; armif;oGm;csdefwGif qnfajrmif;0if;a&S @Yvnf; a':pkum;wef;wGifygvmolrsm;ud k ¶d kufESufonf htoHrsm; =um;ae&ygonf? “owf/ taoowf/ rsdK;zsufrud kowf/ ukvm;r,m;jzpfcsifwJ h[mawG owf” ponf htoHrsm;vnf; =um;ae&ygonf? wqufwnf;rSm yif owif;yd k @oHrsm;/ tjyeftvSef ajymqd kaeoHrsm;uk dvnf;=um;&ygonf?
“&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;”“&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;”“&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;”“&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;”“&xm; vm;/ &xm; vm;”[k wzufu ar;ygonf?usaemfwd k @teD;rSm&S daeonf holu “&xm;/ &xm;”“&xm;/ &xm;”“&xm;/ &xm;”“&xm;/ &xm;”“&xm;/ &xm;” [k jyefajzygonf?
“atmifcd kif/ atmifEdkif/ b,fvd kvJ?”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvdkvJ?”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEdkif/ b,fvd kvJ?”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvdkvJ?”“atmifcdkif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvd kvJ?” [k wzufuqufar;&m “¶d kufvd k @ owfvdk @ r+yD;ao;bl;?” “¶d kufvd k @/ owfvdk @ r+yD;ao;bl;?”“¶dkufvdk @ owfvd k @ r+yD;ao;bl;?” “¶d kufvdk @/ owfvd k @ r+yD;ao;bl;?”“¶d kufvd k @ owfvdk @ r+yD;ao;bl;?” “¶d kufvd k @/ owfvdk @ r+yD;ao;bl;?”“¶dkufvdk @ owfvd k @ r+yD;ao;bl;?” “¶d kufvdk @/ owfvd k @ r+yD;ao;bl;?”“¶d kufvd k@ owfvd k @ r+yD;ao;bl;?” “¶d kufvd k @/ owfvd k @ r+yD;ao;bl;?” [k jyefvnfowif;yd k @ygonf?wzufuqufjyD; “aumfr&Sif b,fvdkvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ jyefyd k @+yD;+yDvm;”“aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ jyefyd k@+yD;+yDvm;”“aumfr&Sif b,fvdkvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ jyefyd k @+yD;+yDvm;”“aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ jyefyd k@+yD;+yDvm;”“aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ aumfr&Sif b,fvd kvJ/ jyefyd k @+yD;+yDvm;” [k xyfar;jyefonf?“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”[k jyefvnfajz=um;ygonf?xd k @aemufwGif tcsif;jzpfonf hae&mrSvlrsm;ud k &Jrsm;u&d kufESufjyD; zrf;qD;ac:aqmifvmygonf?trsKd;orD;rsm;uk d ajcaxmufjzif haemufrSuef+yD;/ trsKd;om;rsm;uk d eHygwfwkwfrsm;ESif h¶d kuf+yD; zrf;qD;vmonf
ud k jrifawG @ae&ygonf? tzrf;cH&olrsm;wGif oHCmawmfrsm;vnf; yg0if+yD;/ i,f&G,fonf h hud k&ifrsm;ud k ajcaxmufjzif huef+yD; zrf;qD;ac:aqmifvmonfud k jrifawG @ae&ygonf? zrf;qD;vmolrsm;ud k usaemfwd k @ab;wGif &yfxm;onf h c&D;onfwif'd kifemum; ESpfpif;ay:ud kwifygonf? um;wpD;ud kvl(20)ausmfwifxm;jcif;jzpfI um;(3)pD;ay:
wGif vl(70)cef @&S drnf[k xifygonf?xd ktcsdefwGif qufoG,fa&;pufjzif hwzufrS “atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvd kvJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvd kvJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvd kvJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvd kvJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ b,fvd kvJ” [k ar;oH=um;&jyD;/ 'DbufrS
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 101/208
101
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
jyefajzolu“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ a&cJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ a&cJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ a&cJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ a&cJ”“atmifcd kif/ atmifEd kif/ a&cJ”[k jyefvnfajz=um;ygonf? xd k @aemuf wzufrS“aumfr&Sifb,fvd kvJ/“aumfr&Sifb,fvd kvJ/“aumfr&Sifb,fvd kvJ/“aumfr&Sifb,fvd kvJ/“aumfr&Sifb,fvd kvJ/yd k @+yD;+yDvm;?”yd k @+yD;+yDvm;?”yd k @+yD;+yDvm;?”yd k @+yD;+yDvm;?”yd k @+yD;+yDvm;?” [k xyfar;oHud k =um;&+yD; 'DbufrS “pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f”“pDpOfaew,f/ vkyfaew,f” [k tjyeftvSefajymqd kaeonf htoHrsm;ud k =um;&ygonf?
14? n(12)em&Dcef @wGif cyfvSrf;vSrf;&S d&Gmrsm;rS “'d k @ta&;”“'d k @ta&;”“'d k @ta&;”“'d k @ta&;”“'d k @ta&;” atmfoHrsm; =um;&+yD; wqufwnf;wGif aoewfoHrsm;ud k aemufwae@eHeuf (3)em&Dcef @txd =um;ae&ygonf?
eHeuf (1)em&Dcef @wGif um;(3)pD;ay:rS '%f&m&onf holrsm;ESif h r&olrsm;ud k cG Jxm;vd kufygonf? '%f&mr&olrsm;u um;(2)pD;jzpf+yD; '%f&m&&S dol ( 20 )ausmfcef @uk d tjcm;um;wpD;ay:wGif awG @&ygonf?
eHeuf(5)em&Dcef @wGif usaemfwd k @tm;wifaqmifxm;onf hum;(2)pD; xGufvmonf htcg vm&d kufonf htzG J @rsm;ud k jyefyd k @&efwifaqmifxm;onf h 'd kifemum;rsm;/ rSef fvH kum;rsm;ESif h xd kifcH krygbJ rwfwyf&yfpD;&onf hum;tcsdK@ud k vrf;ab;0J,mwGif jrif hawG @&ygonf? cef @rSef;ajc um;tpD;(100)cef @ &S dygonf?
xd kae&mrSwqif h a&$bd kaxmifok d @ eHeuf(9)em&Dcef @wGif yxrqH k; tokwftaejzif h trsdK;orD;(4)OD; tygt0if/tm;vH k;(44)OD; twla&muf&S doGm;ygonf? trsdK;orD;rsm;rSm òzd;jrjrpd k; touf(16)ESpf/ rH k&Gmatmif&Sif.orD;/wd k;wd k;0if;ESif h trnfrodaemufwOD;jzpfonf? ‚if;wk d @ (4)OD;rSm rH k&GmrSjzpfa=umif; od&ygonf? trsdK;om;(40)teuf oHCmawmfrsm;yg0if+yD; ‚if;wk d @rSm rH k&Gmòrd @ tvH kausmif;wd kufrS OD;aZmwdu/ &efuif;ausmif;wd kufrS OD;^medENqd konf h OD;yÍif;(2)yg;ESif h ud k&if(4)yg; pkpkaygif;(6)yg;jzpfygonf? OD;^medEN. b,fbufvufaumuf0wfwGif a&mifud kif;aeygonf?
15? ZGefv(1)&ufae@wGif a':pkum;armif;ol ud kausmfpd k;vif;ESif htwl/ tjcm;vli,f(7)OD;cef @ usaemfwd k @.atmufxyfok d @a&mufvmygonf? ud kausmfpd k;vif;.nmbufvufwGif '%f&m&xm;onf? usaemf a&csdK;qif;csdef
wGifud kausmfpd k;vif;ESif hawG @Ipum;ajym&onf? usaemfu a':pkbmjzpfao;vJ [kar;&m/ nmbufycH k; t¶d kufcH&Ia&mifaea=umif;/ um;a&S @cef;nmbufwHcg;aygufESif haemufcef;rSrSefjywif;rsm;uG Jum/ a':pk.nmbufvnfyif;wGif rSefuG Jrsm; xd&+yD;/ b,fbufvnfyif;wGifvnf; tenf;i,fxd&SoGm;onf[k ajymygonf? tcsif;jzpfonh fae&mwGif umxm;onf h oHql;óud;rsm;ud f k jzwfausmf+yD;/ n(10)em&DcG Jcef @wGif a&OD;òrd @t0ifok d @a&muf&d SoGm;a=umif;/a':pkESih ftwl um;ay:wGif vli,f(20)cef @ ygvma=umif;/ a&OD;òrd @t0ifvrf;ud k ydwfxm;+yD;/ wzufwGifvnf;aoewfrsm;jzif h csdefxm;onf h&J(10)a,mufcef @ apmif haea=umif;/ arv(31)&ufae@reufoH k;em&Dcef @wGif ppfwyfa&muf&S dvm+yD;/ a&OD;wyfe,fxJod k @ zrf;qD;ac:aqmifoGm;a=umif; tcsif;jzpfae&mwGif a':pk.um;0d kif;&d kufcH&pOfum;twGif;od k @ 0ifvmonf h wkwf(2)acsmif;ESif h cJwvHk; a&OD;txdygvma=umif; pojzih f ar(30)&ufae@u
jzpfysufcJ honf h udpPrsm;ud k usaemf @tm;jyefvnf&Sif;jyygonf?
16? 2003cESpfZGefv (1)&ufae hnae(4) em&Dcef @wGif axmufvSrf;a&;wyf&if;(20)rS SAd kvf}uD;vif;aZmfuHOD;pD;aom (10)OD;cef @yg0ifonh ftzG J @u usaemftygt0if arv(31)&ufae@eHufwGifzrf;qD;Ia&$bd kaxmifod k @ yd k @vd kufaom '%f&m&olrsm;eSif h rsufjrifoufaopkpkaygif;(146)OD;tm; etz axmufvSrf;a&;rsm;u pwifI"gwfyH krsm;&d kuf,l=u+yD; ZGef fv (2) &ufae@ eHuf (9) em&DrS pwifum zrf;qD;jcif;cHxm;&olwOD;csif;pDud k ppfa=uma&; pwi jyKvkyfygonf? ZGefv(2)&ufae@wGif tzJ G @csKyf/ A[d kvli,frsm;jzpfaom ud kxGef;aZmfaZmf/ ud kxGef;jrif h/ud koufxGef;/ uk drif;vGif/ ud koef;xGef;/ ud kjrif hausmf/ ud kwd k k;vGif/ ud kaygufayguf/ ud krsdK;!Gef @/ pkpkaygif;(9)a,mufusaemfwd k @ tzrf;cHxm;&onf h a&$bd kaxmifod k @ a&mufvmygonf? ud kwd k;vGiftm; acgif;uG Jonf h'%f&mjzif h jrifawG @
&ygonf?ppfa=uma&;+yD;I tcef;ajymif;xm;onf htcg ud kwifxGÉfOD;ESif h tzG J @csKyfvli,frsm;tm;xm;&d Sonf h tcef;od k @
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 102/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
102
usaemfwd k @ a&mufoGm;ygonf? ud kwifxGÉfOD;u jyefvnfajymjyonfrSm ar(31) &ufae@/ eHeuf(7)em&Dcef @wGif/,refae@nu ‚if;wd k @pD;vmaomum;rsm;&S donf h tcsif;jzpfae&mod k @jyefvm=u&m qnfajrmif;0if;teD;wGif toif hapmif hqd kif;ae=uaom ppfwyfESif h&Jwd k @.zrf;qD;jcif;ud k cHch J&onf?xk d @aemuf‚if;wd k @tm; 'DyJ,if; &Jpcef;od k @ yd k @vd kuf
onf[k ajymjyygonf? &Jpcef;wGif tcsif;jzpfyGm;pOf fu zrf;qD;jcif;cH&aom 'kwd, OuUX OD;wifOD;ESif h awG @cJ h& a=umif;/ OD;wifOD;u “ighud k aoatmif owf/ igrao&if rif;wd k @udkighud k aoatmif owf/ igrao&if rif;wdk @ud kighud k aoatmif owf/ igrao&if rif;wd k @udkighud k aoatmif owf/ igrao&if rif;wdk @ud kighud k aoatmif owf/ igrao&if rif;wd k@ud k igud k,fwd kif cH k&Hk;wifr,figudk,fwd kif cH k&H k;wifr,figud k,fwd kif cH k&Hk;wifr,figudk,fwd kif cH k&H k;wifr,figud k,fwd kif cHk&H k;wifr,f” [k tqufrjywfajymqd kaea=umif; / ud kwifxGÉfOD;ESif h vli,frsm;tm;vH k;ud k 'DyJ,if; &Jpcef;rS a&$bd kaxmifod k @yd k @&ef pDpOfaeonf htcsdefwGif“uav;awGud k b,fac:+yD; bmvkyfrSmvJ/ igeJ @ twlxm;/ 'grS r[kwf&if igvnf; olwdk @eJ @ vd kufr,fuav;awGudk b,fac:+yD; bmvkyfrSmvJ/ igeJ@ twlxm;/ 'grSr[kwf&if igvnf; olwd k@eJ @ vdkufr,fuav;awGud k b,fac:+yD; bmvkyfrSmvJ/ igeJ @ twlxm;/ 'grS r[kwf&if igvnf; olwdk @eJ @ vd kufr,fuav;awGudk b,fac:+yD; bmvkyfrSmvJ/ igeJ@ twlxm;/ 'grSr[kwf&if igvnf; olwd k@eJ @ vdkufr,fuav;awGud k b,fac:+yD; bmvkyfrSmvJ/ igeJ @ twlxm;/ 'grSr[kwf&if igvnf; olwd k @eJ@ vd kufr,f”pojzih fajymqk dvsuf 'DyJ,if;&Jpcef;Y usefaecJ ha=umif; ud kwifxGÉfOD;u usaemf htm; jyefvnf ajymjyygonf?
uk dwifxGÉfOD;.tcef;ok d @ uk dxGef;aZmfaZmfwk d @tm; acwWxnh foGif;xm;ch Jonf[k od&onf? ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfxHrS odchJ&onfrsm;uk dvnf; uk dwifxGÉfOD;u jyefajymjyygonf? A[d kvli,frsm;ud k zrf;qD;csdefwGif Adkvfrª;uvli,ftm;vH k;ud ka':pkxHrS cG Jxkwf&efóud;pm;&m a':pku vH k;0vufrcHch Ja=umif;/ ‚if;.'%f&mrsm;ud k *&krpd kufbJ/'%f&m&onf hvli,frsm;ud kom pd k;&drf}uD;pGmjzif hwnvH k;jyKpkay;ch Jonf[k ajymjyygonf? A[k dvli,f(9)OD;ud k reufyd kif; (10)em&Dcef @wGif a':pkESif hcG Jxkwf&ef pDpOf&m a':pku tcG J rcHa=umif;/ xk dAd kvfrª;u &d kif;jyaomtoH k;tE_ef;rsm;jzif h“cifAsm;twGuf ESpfa,mufac:xm;vd kuf/ b,fol @ud k ac:rvJ”[k ajymqd kojzif h ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfESif h ud kxGef;jrif hud kac:xm;vd kufonf?
aemufwae@ eHeuf(2)em&Dcef @wGif ud kxGef;aZmfaZmfESif h ud kxGef;jrif hud k acwWc%(15)rdepfcef @[kajymqd k+yD;a':pkESif h xyfrH cG Jxkwfvd kufjyefonf? xd kod k @ (15)rdepf[kajym+yD;aemuf ‚if;wd k @(9)OD;ud k usaemfwd k @ tzrf;cHxm;& onf h a&$bd kaxmifok d @ yd k @vd kufa=umif; ud kwifxGÉfOD;u jyefvnfajymjyygonf? ‚if;wd k @a&$bd k axmifod k @a&mufvmjyD;(2)&ufcef @wGif &efukefrS A[d kvli,f(9)OD;ESif h ud kausmfpd k;vif;wd k @ud k a&$bd kaxmifwGif rawG @&awmhyg/
17? a&$bd kaxmifxJwGif awG @ch J&onh f rH k&Gmòrd @rS wuUod kvfausmif;om;rsm;/ (9)wef;/ (10)wef; ausmif;om;
rsm;rSm '%f&m&onf holrsm;/ r&olrsm;tygt0if pkpkaygif;(30)cef @&S dygonf? ud k&ifwyg;. b,fbufvufwGif"g;ckwfcHxm;&+yD; t¶d k;ud kyif fjrifae&ygonf? tjcm; ud k&ifwyg;rSm b,fbufvufusdK;aeojzih f ausmufywfwD;pnf;xm;onf//
tr&yl&òrd @e,f OuUÏ OD;vSjrif h/ bkwvif òrd @e,ftzG J @0if ud kawmufxGef;OD;/ rE Wav; xGefwH k;òrd @opfrS ud kodef;aZmf/ taemufajrmufòrd @e,frS ud kodef;atmifav;ESif h OD;oG,f ponh f '%f&mjyif;xefonf holrsm; rk H&Gmppfaq;&k HtrSwf (7)rS a&$bd kaxmifod k @ xyfrHa&mufvmygonf?
ppfaq;&H kwGif '%f&mjyif;xefonf htwGuf usef&pfcJ holrsm;rSm a':0if;jrjr(rE Wav;wd kif;pnf;&H k;a&;rª;)/ OD;cspfwif/ tr&yl& OD;vSjrif h.om;jzpfolud kaZmfav; (c)ud kaZmfcifwd k @ jzpfa=umif; a&mufvmolrsm;uajymjyI od&S d&ygonf?
18? ZGefv(9)&ufae@wGif rk H&Gmòrd @rS txufwef;ausmif;om;rsm;ESif h wuUod kvfausmif;om;rsm;tygt0ifpkpkaygif; (25)OD; yxrtzG J @taejzif h vGwfajrmufoGm;onf? ZGefv(12)&ufae@wGif usaemfwd k @(21)OD; vGwfajrmufvmygonf? (2)zG J @aygif; pkpkaygif;(46)OD; vGwfvmygonf? tzG J @csKyf0ifrsm; r[kwfonf htwGuf v$wfay;vd kufjcif;jzpfonf[kxifygonf? xd kod k @v$wfay;&mwGif usaemfwk d @tm; pm&Gufw&GufpDay;ygonf? xd kpm&GufwGifyg&S donf hpmom;rsm;rSm Ed kifiHawmf. txl;v#dK@0Sufcsufjzpfonf htwGuf xd kudpPud k rayguf=um;ap&ef/ tu,fI ayguf=um;ygu xyfrH ta&;,ljcif;cH&rnf pojzif h tusOf;csKyfyg&S dygonf// ppfud kif;wd kif; axmufvSrf;a&;(20)wyf&if;rª;a&S @YvufES dyfpuf&d kufxm;onf h xd kpm&GufwGif wm0ef,lvd kufemrnfjzpfa=umif; usaemfwd k @u 0efcHuwdjyK/vufrSwfa&;xd k;ay;&ygonf? a&$bd kaxmifAl;0wGif axmufvSrf;a&; trSwf(20)wyf&if;rª;ud k,fwd kifu txufvl}uD;rsm;
u pmemaxmufxm;+yD; ,ckuJ hod k @v$wfay;vd kufjcif;jzpfa=umif;/ rnfonh ftjypfr# r&d Sonf htwGuf v$wfay;jcif;jzpfa=umif;/ ,ckuJ hod k @ zrf;qD;cH&onf hudpPud k rnfol @uk dr#jyefrajym&ef rSm=um;vk da=umif;/ ajymygu jyifyowif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 103/208
103
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
Xmersm;. tok H;csjcif;uk d cH&rnfjzpfa=umif; ajymygonf?
19? usaemftygt0if a'gufwmvSpd k;!Gef@ygonfhum;ud karmif;ESifol OD;aomif;!Ge@f/ a':0if;jrjrygaomum;ud karmif;ESifol OD;pdef&D/ ud krsdK;rif;/ ud katmifatmif pkpkaygif; (5)a,muftm; Ad kvf}uD;vif;aZmfuHESif h axmufvSrf;a&;wOD;/ vufeuf tjynf htpH kud kifaqmifxm;onf h &JwyfzG J @0if(6)OD;u acsmqG Jvmonf h c&D;onfwif 'd kifem
um;jzif h ppfud kif;+rdK@&S d axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(20)wyfqG,f&k H;ok d @ yd k @vd kufygonf? wyfqG,f&H k;wGif usaemfwd k @ud kacwWxm;+yD; aemuf f e,fajrcHaxmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(1)rE Wav;od k @ ta=umif ;=um;ygonf? usaemfwd k @ud k Ad kvf}uD;atmifaZmfESif h t&yf0wfESih faxmufvSrf;a&;(4)OD;a&muf&S dvmum vJ $ajymif;vufcH,lygonf? OD;aomif;nGef @ESif hOD;pdef&D wd k @ud k axmufvSrf;a&;trSwf(16)rS vma&mufv$ Jajymif;vufcHoGm;ygonf? usaemfwd k @(3)OD;ud k zd k;0D;vfum;jzif h axmufvSrf;a&;(1)od k @ ac:aqmifoGm;onf? xk d @aemuf "gwfyk H&d kuf,lumud k,fa&;&mZ0ifrsm; jyefvnfa&;ck dif; ygonf? ,ckuh Jok d @ jzpfcJ honf h hudpPud k rnfol @ud kr# jyefvnf rajymygqd konfud k xyfrHIvufrSwfa&;xd k;&ygonf?ud krsdK;rif;ud k tr&XmeD&yfuGuf =uH @cd kifzG @Hòzd;a&; toif;OuUÏu vmI vG Jajymif;vufcHoGm;ygonf? xd k @aemufusaemfwd k @ òrd @e,f. r,u OuUÏESif h &,u OuUÏwd k @ud k ta=umif;=um;ygonf? usaemfwd k @tm; taemufajrmufòrd @e,f/ e,fajrcHaxmufvSrf;a&; OD;vGifOD;qd kolu OD;aqmif+yD; tdrfta&mufjyefvd kufyd k @ygonf?
tdrfa&mufonf htcg usaemfESif hrdom;pktm;vH k;wG JI "gwfyH kwyH k &d kufygonf? xd k @aemuf usaemfESif h usaemf @rdb(2)OD;u xd kifxm;&+yD;/ aemufbufwGif e,fajrcHaxmufvSrf;a&; OD;vGifOD; tygt0if/ &,u(2)OD;ESif h twl"gwfyk H(2)yH k &d kuf&ygonf// xd kod k @ "gwfyH krSwfwrf; taxmuftxm;,l+yD;aomtcg rdom;pkxHok d @ aumif;rGefpGmyk d @ay;onfuk dod&d Sa=umif; usaemf hzcifu vufrSwfa&;xd k;ay;&ygonf? usaemfwd k @ (46)a,mufvGwfvmonf htwGuf a&$bd kaxmifwGif (80)cef @ usef&S daeygonf?
txufyg trSwfpOf (1) rS (19) txd yg&S donf hta=umif;t&mrsm;onf rdrdud k,fwd kifawG @/ ud k,fwd kifjrif/ud k,fwd kifodonf h ta=umif;t&mrsm;jzpf+yD;/ ,ckuJ hod k @ xkwfazmfajym=um;&ef rnfolr# rw&m; =oZmv$rf;rd k;jcif;/
+cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ aoG;aqmifjzm;a,mif;jcif;/ vdrfvnfvSnf hjzm;jcif; r&S dbJ rdrd. vGwfvyfonf h oabmqENt& xkwfazmfajym=um;jcif;jzpfa=umif; 0efcHuwdjyK vufrSwfa&;xd k;ygonf?
ud kEd kifEd kifud kEd kifEd kifud kEd kifEd kifud kEd kifEd kifud kEd kifEdkif2003ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(7)&uf2003ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(7)&uf2003ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(7)&uf2003ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(7)&uf2003ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(7)&uf
ÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐÐ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 104/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
104
tcef;( 6 )
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ESifhywfoufI jynfwGif; jynfy&Sd Ed kifiHa&;tzGJŒtpnf;rsm;/
Ed kifiHwumacgif;aqmifrsm;. wkefŒ jyefajymqd kcsufrsm;
ar(30) 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf Ed kifiHwumrSacgif;aqmifrsm;/ tpd k;&rsm;/ tpd k;& r[kwfonf h tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ jynfwGif;&S d Ed kifiHa&;ygwDtzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ etzESif h ap@pyf+idrf;csrf;a&;vkyfxm;onf h wk dif;&if;om; vufeufud kiftzG G J @tpnf;rsm;/ e,fpyfa'o&S d wd kif;&if;om;vufeufud kiftzG J @tpnf;rsm;ESif h 'Drd kua&pDta&;v_yf&Sm;=uonf htzG J@tpnf;rsm;/ jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHnGef @aygif;tpdk;&/ jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpDwd k @u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;wd kufcd kufcH&r_/ zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;cH&r_ESif h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf.&H k;rsm; csdwfydwfcH&r_rsm;ESih fywfoufI toD;oD;xkwfjyef a=unmcJ honf?
ocifodef;az
jynfwGif;&S d Ed kifiHa&;orm;a[mif;}uD;jzpfol ocifodef;azu jynfyowif;XmeESif hawG @qH kajym=um;&mwGif 'kwd,Ed kifiHa&;vkyf=uH r_jzpfa=umif;/ tm%myd kifrsm;ud k,fwd kifu pDpOfjcif;jzpfa=umif; xkwfazmfajym=um;cJ honf? 11111
owif;pmESifh pma&;q&mr}uD; vlxka':trm
emrnfausmf pma&;q&mr}uD; vlxka':trmuvnf; 'DyJ,if;wGifjzpfyGm;cJ haomudpPESif hywfoufI ukvor*~ ~ vH kjcHKa&;aumifpDwGif aqG;aEG;tajz&Smoif honf[k olr.xifjrifcsufud k xkwfazmfajymqd kcJ honf? 22222
owif;pmt,f'DwmcsKyfa[mif; OD;xdefvif;
ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_}uD;twGuf pH kprf;a&;aumfr&SifzG J @ pH kprf;oif ha=umif;/ ,ck zrf;qD;xm;olrsm;ud kvnf; jyefvnfvGwfay;&efvd ktyfa=umif; Ad kvfwaxmifowif;pm t,f'DwmcsKyfa[mif; OD;xdefvif;uvnf;jynfyowif;XmeESif h awG @qH kar;jref;cef;wGif zGif h[awmif;qd kcJ honf? 33333
&JabmfokH;usdyf0if Ak dvfrª;csKyfa[mif; ausmfaZm
(10-6-2003) ae@wGif vGwfvyfa&;wk dufyJ G0if &Jabmfok H;usdyf0ifwOD;jzpfonf h Ak dvfrª;csKyfa[mif;ausmfaZmu
'DyJ,if;òrd @teD;wGifjzpfyGm;cJ haomjy\emtay:¶_ jrifcsufESif h vuf&S dwyfrawmftay: ‚if;.oabmxm;tjrifrsm;ud k 'Drd ku&ufwpfjrefrmhtoHESif h qufoG,far;jref;cef;wGif æ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 105/208
105
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
“ usaemfwk d @=um;&wJ howif;a&m/ usaemfwk d @ wGufcsufr_t&a&m/ 'g[m a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k óudwifpDpOf+yD; vkyf}uHr_vd k @,lqygw,f? ppfwyfu a':atmifqef;pk=unf
r&S d&if olwk d @ud k b,folrS tmrcH&Jawmhbl;vd k @ ,lq=uyk H&w,f? 'Dvd kvkyf}uHr_[m tvGeft¶kyfqk d;,kwfnH hygw,f? 'guk d usaemf jyif;jyif;xefxef uef @uGufygw,f? bma=umif hvnf;qk dawmh yxrtcsufu NLD [m t=urf;rzufwJ h +idrf;csrf;pGmeJ @'Drk dua&pD &a&;ud k vkyfaqmifaewJ h ygwDjzpfw,f? 1990 ckESpfa&G;aumufyJ GrSmvnf; tjywftowf tEk dif&xm;wJ hygwDjzpfw,f? 'kwd,tcsufu a':atmifqef;pk=unf[m trsKd;om;acgif;aqmifeJ @ wyfrawmfacgif;aqmif Ak dvfcsKyfatmifqef;&J @orD;jzpf+yD; olud k,fwk difvnf; r,drf;r,d kif &Gyf&Gyfc|Hc|HArmjynf 'Drd kua&pD&a&;twGuf a&S @aqmifvkyfaqmifaewJ h trsKd;om;acgif;aqmifjzpfw,f?aemuf OD;wifOD;[mvnf; ol&bJ G @ &xm;wJ h wyfrawmfacgif;aqmifwOD;jzpfw,f? trsKd;om;umuG,fa&;ppfyJ G KMT wk dufyJ GrSm usaemfeJ @twl wk dufcJ hpOfu &cJ hwmjzpfw,f? 'gh
a=umif h trsKd;om;ol&Jaumif;wOD;vnf;jzpfw,f? tck 'Drd kua&pDwk dufyJ GrSmvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfeJ @twl vufwJ Gwk dufyJ G0ifaewJ h trsKd;om;acgif;aqmifwa,mufjzpfw,f? 'gha=umif h 'Dvd kyk*~ dKvfawGeJ @ 'Dvd kygwDrsKd;ud k tðywfwk duf acsr_ef;zk d @vkyfwmjzpfvd k @ usaemf jyif;jyif;xefxefuef @uGuf&jcif;jzpfw,f? usaemf htaeeJ @ a':atmifqef;pk=unftwGufa&m/ OD;wifOD;twGufa&m tvGefpd k;&drfylyefrdw,f? 'g usaemf htjrifygyJ?
Armhwyfrawmfud k 1941 ckESpfu Ak dvfcsKyfatmifqef;acgif;aqmif+yD; usaemfwk d @yg0ifxlaxmifcJhpOfu usaemfwkd@&J@ &nf&G,fcsuf[m ArmhvGwfvyfa&;wkdufyJGtwGufvnf;aumif;/ jynfol @tusKd;aqmif&Gufzk d @vnf;aumif; &nf&G,f+yD; xlaxmifcJ h=uwmyg? aemif
vnf; usaemfwd k @ awmufav#muf 'D&nf&G,fcsuftwk dif; vkyfaqmifcJ h=u w,f? 'gayr,f h,ckaemufqk H;tajctaeuawmh jynfolud k awmufav#mufzdES dyfn‡Of;yrf;¶k Hru tvGef,kwfnH hwJ henf;vrf;rsm;pGmok H;+yD; jynfol @qef @usifa&;awGvkyf/ jynfol @acgif;aqmifawG/ jynfolawGud k vkyf}uHowfjzwf vm=u+yD? 'Dtwk dif; qufoGm;&ifawmh t*Fvdyfacwfu t*FvdyfawG Oya'jyifyuae+yD; jynfolud kzdES dyfzd k @arG;xm;wJ h vrf;rawmfzk d;wkwf vlrk duf*k d%f;vd k jzpfawmhr,f? wk dif;jynf}uD;vnf; acsmufxJusawmhr,f? tckvuf&S d ppfwyfxJ&S d rsKd;cspfjynfcspfyk*~ dKvfrsm; 'Dtwk dif; =unf hrae=uygeJ @? aphpyfaqG;aEG;a&;vrf;ay: jyefa&mufatmif 0k dif;óud;pm;=uyg? usaemf 'D[myJ wk dufwGef;csifygw,f?
wk dif;jynftwGuf tvGefta&;}uD;wJ h vrf;qk Hvrf;cG a&mufaeyg+yD? wvrf;uawmhppfwyfu tm%mud k vuf0g;}uD;tkyfxm;+yD; qufvufzdES dyfowfjzwfwJ hvrf;/ 'Dvrf;ud kppfwyfuqufoGm;&if jynfol @qENud k qef @usif+yD;wmjzpfvd k @ ork dif;tr_ dufyk HxJ pGef @ypfjcif;cH&ygvdrf hr,f? jynfolawGvnf; epfemrSmyg? trsKd;om;nD!$wfa&;ysufjym;+yD; aemufwausmhjynfwGif;ppfud kOD;wnfEk difw,f? aemufwvrf;uawmh ppfwyfu aemufwvSrf;qkwf+yD; aphpyfaqG;aEG;a&;vrf;a=umif;vk duf+yD;/ ukvor*~ qk H;jzwfcsufrsm;eJ @tnD vkyfaqmifoGm;wJ hvrf;/ 'guawmh jynfola&m/ ppfwyfa&m tm;vk H;twGuf tusKd; &S dwJ hvrf; jzpfygw,f?'Dvrf; ESpfvrf;ud ka&G;r,f h tqk H;tjzwfay;r,f holu ppfwyfyJjzpfw,f? 'gha=umif h usaemf
awmif;qd kcsifwmu ppfwyf[m jynfol @tusKd;a&S @¶_wJ h aphpyfaqG;aEG;a&;vrf;ud kvk duf+yD;trsKd;om;nD!$wfa&;ud kwnfaqmufygvd k @ tEl;t!$wf yef=um;vd kygw,f? jynfolvlxk
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 106/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
106
taeeJ @vnf; ppfwyftaeeJ @ aphpyfaqG;aEG;a&;vrf;a=umif;ay: a&mufvmatmif 0k dif;0ef;E_ d;aqmf=uyg? usaemf 'DavmufyJajymcsifygw,f”[k txufygtwd kif; ajym=um;cJ honf?
ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfwGif;&S d Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;/etzESif h vufeufESif h jidrf;csrf;a&; vJvS,fxm;=uonf h wd kif;&if;om;vlrsdK;pktzG J @rsm;tjyif etz ppftkyfpkESif h aphpyfaqG;aEG;a&;jyKvkyfxm;onf h tzG J @rsm;uvnf; toD;oD; a=unmcsufrsm;xkwfjyefI uef @uGufcJ h=uonf?
jynfolŒv$wfawmfukd,fpm;vS,f (70)
jynfwGif;&S d trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;/ 1990 jynf hESpf ygwDpH k'Drd kua&pDa&G;aumufyG JwGif jynfolwd k @ a&G;cs,fwifajr‡mufxm;aom jynfol @ v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,f (70) u Ad kvfcsKyfrª;}uD; oef;a&$xH atmufygtwd kif; wifjyawmif;qd kcJ honf?
(1) trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf 'kwd,OuUÏ OD;wifOD;/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @ESif htwlvd kufygoGm;=uaom tzG J @0iftm;vH k;wd k @ud k tjrefqH k;jyefv$wfay;&ef/
(2) arv (31)&ufae@rS tpðyI aetdrfwGiftus,fcsKyfxm;aom OD;atmifa&$trª;ðyonf h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifvl}uD;rsm;ESif h 'Drd kua&pDtusOf;om;tm;vH k;wd k @ud kvnf; jyefv$wfay;yg&ef/
(3) trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf A[d kESif hjynfe,f/ wd kif;tm;vH k;wd k @wGif csdyfydwfxm;aom ¶H k;cef;rsm;ud k csdyfcGmzGif hvSpfay;yg&ef/
(4) 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;wGif trSefwu,faoqH k;=uol/ '%f&m&&S dol/ zrf;qD;xm;jcif;cH&olrsm;ESif h aysmufqH k;aeolrsm;.pm&if;ud k ðypka=unmay;Ed kif&eftwGuf pH kprf;a&;aumfr&Sif zG J @pnf;azmfxkwfay;yg&ef/
(5) urB m@ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcH. jrefrmEd kifiHESif hywfoufaomqHk;jzwfcsuftwd kif; aqmif&Guf
taumiftxnfazmfay;yg&efESif h Ed kifiHawmf+idrf0yfydjym;r_wnfaqmufa&;tpd k;&. (1990)ckESpfa&G;aumufyG JOya'pnf;rsOf;a=unmcsuft& jynfol @v$wfawmfac:,lzG J @pnf;ay;yg&ef ponf htcsufrsm;ud kwifjyawmif;qd kcJ h=uonf?
trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJGŒcsKyf/ trsKd;orD;tzJGŒ0ifrsm;
trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf trsdK;orD;tzG J @0ifrsm;uvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;tm; tjrefqH k;v$wfay;&efESif h jrefrmjynftES H @tjym;&S d trsKd;tm;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf.csdyfydwfxm;onf h&H k;cef;rsm; jyefvnfzGif hcGif hay;&efwd k @ud k etztm; awmif;qd konf hpmrsm;ay;yd k @cJ honf?
{&m0wDwk dif; (6)òrdŒe,f trsKd;om;'Drkdua&pDtzJGŒcsKyf/ tzJGŒ0ifrsm;{&m0wD wd kif;twGif;&S d trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf {&m0wDwd kif;(6)òrd @e,f/ òrd @e,fpnf;&H k;a&;tzG J @0ifrsm;/
tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if rsm;ESif h jynfolwd k @rS vufrSwfa&;xd k;I ukvor*~tzG J @csKyf vH kjcHKa&;aumifpDrS tjrefqH k;ta&;,laqmif&Gufay;yg &ef atmufygtwd kif; xyfrHwifjyawmif;qd kcJ honf//
(u) trsKd;om;acgif;aqmif a':atmifqef;pk}unfESifh zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;cH Ed kifiHa&;tusOf;om;tm;vHk;c|if;csuf r&S d tjrefqH k;(csufjcif;)v$wfay;&efESif h rw&m;zrf;qD;r_rsm;ud k &yfqd kif;&ef//
(c) t"rR csdyfydwfxm;aom tzG J @csKyf&H k;tm;vH k;ud k tjrefqH k;(csufjcif;)jyefvnfzGif hvSpfay;+yD; vGwfvyfpGmpnf;&H k;v_yf&Sm;cGif hay;&efESif h tjcm; Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;ud kvnf; vGwfvyfpGm pnf;&H k;v_yf&Sm;cGif hay;&ef//
(*) urB mhukvor*~tzG J @}uD;. taxGaxGnDvmcHtoD;oD;u wnDwnGwfwnf; csrSwfvd kufaom 1990jynf hESpfygwDpH k'Drd kua&pDtaxGaxGa&G;aumufyG J&v'fonf 'Drd kua&pDud kjynfolvlxku vd kvm;a=umif; jyovd kufjcif;jzpfonf[laom qH k;jzwfcsufud k taumiftxnfaz:ay;&ef//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 107/208
107
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
(C) arv (30) &ufae@ujzpfyGm;cJ haom “'DyJ,if;t=urf;zufvkyf}uHr_” ta&;tcif;}uD;tm; vGwfvyfaom =um;aepH kprf;ppfaq;a&;tzG J @ zG J @I ppfaq;az:xkwfay;&ef//
{&m0wDwd kif;twGif;&S d ² ² ²{&m0wDwdkif;twGif;&Sd ² ² ²{&m0wDwd kif;twGif;&S d ² ² ²{&m0wDwdkif;twGif;&Sd ² ² ²{&m0wDwd kif;twGif;&S d ² ² ²
usHKaysmfòrd @e,f - 941 OD ;?ausmif;ukef;òrd @e,f - 977 OD;?bd kuav;òrd @e,f - 508 OD ;?yef;waemfòrd @e,f - 66 OD;?armfvòrdifu|ef;òrd @e,f - 198 OD;?ig;od kif;acsmif;òrd @e,f - 286 OD;?
æ pkpkaygif; - (2976)OD;u vufrSwfa&;xdk;xm;aom rl&if;pm&Gufrsm;tm;yl;wGJI ar(30)&ufae@'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ud kvnf; w&m;r#wonf htwd kif; ta&;,laqmif&Gufay;&ef ukvor*~ ~ vH kjcHKa&;aumifpD/ukvor*~ ~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;wk d @xHod k @ wk dif=um;pmrsm;/ arwWm&yfcHonf hpmrsm; ay;yd k @cJ honfud k awG @&S d&onf?
trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ GŒcsKyf (vli,f)
2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(8)&ufae@wGif trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifvli,frsm;uvnf;/ urB mhukvor*~taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyf ud kzDteefxHod k @ ar(30)'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ESif hpyfvsOf;I ta&;,laqmif&Gufay;&efarwWm&yfcHpm ay;yd k @cJ h&mwGif æ
“ygwDtaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfonf r=umrDumvrsm;u ygwDpnf;&k H;a&;vkyfief;pOfESif h ygwD&k H;cef;rsm;zGif hvSpfa&;udpPud k ppftpd k;&. oabmwlcGif hðycsuft& c&D;xGufch J&m jrefrmjynfajrmufyd kif;c&D;pOfwavsmufvk H;wGif jynfolvlxktaygif;wd k @u vrf;ay:xGufI aomif;aomif;jzjz óudqd kE_wfqufch J=uygonf?
2003 ckESpf/ arv(30)&ufae@u ppfud kif;wd kif;/ a&$bk dc&d kif/ 'DyJ,if;ðrd @e,f usnf&GmteD;Y nbuftcsdef0d kif;0ef;ydwfqd k @wk dufcd kufowfjzwfch J&m vlaygif; (70)ausmfaoqk H;ch J+yD; (100)ausmf '%f&m&ch Jygonf? ygwD 'kwd,OuUÏ OD;wifOD;ESif h taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @rSm toufab;rS oDoDuav; vGwfajrmufvmch Jaomfvnf; ,cktcg ppftm%m&Sif.tusOf;axmifrsm;Y tjcm; trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;uh Jod k @yif zrf;qD;csKyfaESmifxm;jcif; cHae&ygonf?
xd k @a=umif @ ar (30)&ufae@ 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;onfum; vltpkvd kuf tðyHvd kufud k ppftm%m&Sif tpd k;& ud k,fwd kifu vkyf}uHowfjzwfaom ord kif;wGifusefrnf h vlowfyJ Gjzpfygonf?
av;pm;cifrif&ygaom urB mhukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfcifAsm;-
u|Ek fyfwd k @ jrefrmEd kifiHonf ppftm%m&Siftpd k;&vufatmufwGif vl @tcGif hta&;ud k t}uD;tus,f csKd;azmufjcif; cHae&onfrSm vk H;0,k HrSm; oHo,jzpfp&m rvd kyg? xk d @a=umif h u|Ef kyfwd k @ trsKd ;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf vli,ftzJ G @0ifrsm;u atmufygudpP&yfrsm;ud k tvsiftjrefaqmif&Gufay;yg&ef awmif;qd kcsufrsm; wifoGif;tyfygonf?
1? urB mhukvor*~tzJ G @csKyf}uD;taejzif h jrefrmEk difiH tm%myd kifppftpd k;&. ar (30) &uf 'DyJ,if; vlowfyJ Gta&;tcif;ESif hywfoufI tjrefqk H; tpD&ifcHpmwifoGif;Ed kif&ef tpd k;&r[kwfaom oD;jcm;vGwfvyfonf h aumf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 108/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
108
r&Sifw&yfud k zJ G @pnf;xlaxmifI pk Hprf;aqmif&Gufay;ap&ef?2? rw&m;zrf;qD;csKyfaESmif tjypfay;xm;aom ausmif;om;/ oHCmESif h Ed kifiHa&;tusOf;om;tm;vk H;ud k
c|if;csuf r&d S tjrefqk H;v$wfay;yg&ef?
3? trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf&k H;cef;rsm;ud k tjrefqk H; jyefzGif hay;a&;/ 1990jynf hESpf ygwDpk Ha&G;aumufyJ G&v'fud k (6)vtwGif; taumiftxnfazmfaqmif&Gufay;rnf h wdusaomvkyfief;pOfud k urB mod k @ a=unmay;&ef?4? ukvor*~vk HðcHa&;aumifpDod k @ jrefrmEd kifiHta&;ESif hywfouf+yD; wifjyaqG;aEG;vsuf ydwfqk d @ta&;,ljcif;
ud k wd k;jr‡if haqmif&GufI jrefrmEd kifiH. ppftm%m&Siftpd k;&ud k,fpm;vS,fud k ukvor*~tzJ G @tpnf;rS z,f&Sm;jcif;ponf h qk H;jzwfcsufrsm;uk d taumiftxnfazmfay;&ef”ponf h tcsufrsm;ud kwifjyawmif;qd kcJ honf?
typftcwf&yfpJxm;onf h tzJ GŒ (7)zJ GŒ
jynfwGif;&S d etzESif h typftcyf&yfpJum +idrf;csrf;a&;,lxm;=uonf h vufeufud kiftzG J @tpnf;rsm;uvnf;ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I æ
typftcwf&yfpJum +idrf;csrf;a&;,lxm;=uaom tzG J@tpnf;rsm;taejzif h ucsifjynfvGwfvyfa&;tzG J @(KIO) u,ef;jynfopfygwD (KNLP)/ u&ifeDvlrsdK;aygif;pH kvGwfajrmufa&;wyfOD; (KNPLF) yavmifjynfe,fvGwfajrmufa&;wyfrawmf (PSLA) // rGefjynfopfygwD (NMSP) / &Srf;jynfe,f+idrf;csrf;a&;aumifpD (SSPC)/&Srf;jynf vlrsdK;aygif;pH kjynfol @vGwfajrmufa&;tzG J @ (SNPLO) wk d @u 2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(1)&ufae@wGif ‚if;wd k @.oabmxm;rsm;ud k xkwfjyefa=unmcJ honf?
jynfwGif; wkdif;&if;om;EkdifiHa&;ygwD (9) zJGŒ
“2003 ckESpf/ arv(30)&ufae@wGifjzpfysufcJ honf h 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;onf rdrdwd k @tcsif;csif; t=urf;zuf
toGifaqmifaom vkyf&yfjzpfaoma=umif h jynfolrsm; toufqH k;¶H _;xdcd kuftemw&jzpfysufcJ h&onf htwGuftxl;yif0rf;enf;a=uuG JjzpfcJ h&ygonf? ,cktajctaewGif urB mhukvor*~tzG J @tpnf;}uD;ESif h Ed kifiHwum tod kif;t0d kif;rsm;rS 0ifa&mufajymqd kvm&onftxd jzpfay:cJ h&r_twGufvnf; rdrdwd k @rS pdwfrcsrf;ajr@jzpf&ygonf” [kazmfjyyg&S donf?
1? r&mjynfol @ygwD2? Zd k;rD; trsdK;om;uGef*&uf3? rGeftrsdK;om; 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf4? csif;trsKd;om; 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf
5? &Srf;wd kif;&if;om;rsm; 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf6? u&iftrsKd;om;rsm; 'Drd kua&pDuGef*&uf7? u,m;jynfe,fvlrsKd;aygif;pH k 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf8? ucsifjynfe,ftrsKd;om;rsm; 'Drd kua&pDuGefz&if h9? u,ef;trsKd;om;rsm;pnf;vH k;a&; 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfwd k @yg0ifonf h wd kif;&if;om;vlrsdK;pk Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;
. jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiH. vuf&S djzpfay:aeaom Ed kifiHa&;tajctaersm;tay: oabmxm;xkwfjyefcsufud k 2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (7)&ufae@wGif xkwfjyefcJ h&m æ
“Ed kifiHawmfESif hjynfoljynfom;rsm;.tusKd;ud kaxmuf¶_aomtm;jzif h rnfonf ht=urf;zufr_rsm;ud krqd kcsufcsif;&yfqd kif;&efwd kufwGef;tyfygonf? t=urf;zufr_rsm;ud k zefwD;olwd k @tm;vnf; u|Ef kyfwd k @ujyif;xefpGm¶_wfcsvd kufygonf? jrefrmhEd kifiHa&;jy\emrsm;ud k Ed kifiHa&;enf;vrf;jzpfonf h awG @qH kaqG;aEG;=ujcif;jzif hom tajz&Smoif hyga=umif;”pojzif h ‚if;wd k @.oabmxm;ud k xkwfjyefcJ honf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 109/208
109
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
jynfaxmifpkwk dif;&if;om;vlrsKd;rsm; 'Drkdua&pDtzJGŒcsKyf
vwfwavmjzpfay:aeaom jrefrmEd kifiHa&;tajctaeay:wGif “jynfaxmifpkwd kif;&if;om;vlrsKd;rsm;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf ” (y-v-'-z) (UNLD) .oabmxm;&yfwnfcsufrl(5)ckESif h Ed kifiHa&;vrf;jyajryH kud k 2003 ckESpf
pufwifbmv (29)&ufae@wGi fxkwfjyefa=unmcJ honf/ ,if;xkwfjyefa=unmcsufwGif 'DyJ,if; vk kyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I oabmxm;&yfwnfcsufrl trSwf(1)tjzpf ta&;w}uD;xm;um atmufygtwd kif;awmif;qd kcJ honf?
(1) 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;ud k w&m;r#wpGm pH kprf;azmfxkwf&ef/
2003 ckESpf/ arv(30)&ufae@u ppfud kif;wd kif;/ 'DyJ,if;+rdK@teD;wGifjzpfyGm;cJ haom ta&;tcif;onf vGefpGm}uD;us,faom Ed kifiHa&;vlowfyG J}uD;jzpfa}umif; ay:vGifxif&Sm;v#uf&S donf/ tm%myd kifrsm;.xkwfazmfa=unmcsuft&/ trsKd;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J @csKyfbufrSpnf;urf;rJ hr_rsm;a=umif h jzpfyGm;&onf[kajz&Sif;aomfvnf;/ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf fbufurl wpfbufrS pepfwus }udKwifpDpOfxm;r_a}umif h[k pGyfpG Jxm;onf//
rnfod k @qd kap wkwf/ "g;/ 0g;c|ef/ av;cG pojzif h vufeufrsdK;pH kud kifaqmifxm;aom vl(1000) ausmfcef @ yg0ifcJ haom vlowfyG J}uD;jzpfI trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf f.aemufvd kufrsm;ESif h }uH @cd kifa&;ESif hzG H @òzd;a&;toif;0ifrsm;=um; jzpfyGm;cJ hjcif;jzpfa=umif; tjiif;ryGm;ay/tm%myd kifrsm;.xkwfazmfa=unmcsuft& vl(4)OD;aoqH k;onf[kqd k+yD; trsKd;om;'Drd kua& pDtzG J @csKyfbufurl vl(100)ausmf aysmufqH k;aoqH k;aeonf[k qd konf//xd k @a=umih fvnf;Tta&;tcif;rSm jynfwGif;a&;oufoufr#[k ,lqjcif;rjyKEd kifawmhbJ a'ota&;/ tjynf
jynfqd kif&mta&;tjzpf/ wurB mvH k;u pdwf0ifpm;vm=u&jcif;jzpfonf//Tr#}uD;us,faomvlowfyG JrsdK;ud k w&m;Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;ESif hvH kjcHKa&;ud k txl;OD;pm;ay;
aom wyfrawmf tpd k;&taejzif h vspfvsL¶_xm;&ef roif hacs// tjrefqH k;ESif h w&m;r#wr_t&S dqH k; azmfxkwf&rnfomjzpfonf// od k @aomf cHbufrSaecJ h=u&aom trsKd;om;'Drd kua& pDtzG J @csKyf fbufrS OD;wifOD;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @tygt0if ygwD0iftrsm;ud kom zrf;qD;csKyfaESmifjcif;/ ygwD&H k;rsm;tydwfcH&jcif;/ acgif;aqmifrsm;tus,fcsKyf cscHae&+yD;/ wyfrawmftpd k;&.=oZmcH jzpfaom =uH @§zG H @ tzG J @0ifrsm;ud krl vH k;0ta&;,ljcif;cH&onf[k rawG @&S d&&mrsm;pGmtH h=o raus eyfzG,f jzpf=u&ayonf//
Tr#}uD;us,faom vltrsm;aoa=uysufpD;cJ h&onf h ta&;tcif;wcktwGuf pH kprf;ppfaq;r_ vd ktyfonfud krl rnfolr# jiif;qd kEd kifrnf r[kwfay// od k @aomf }uH @§zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm; yg0ifywfoufaejcif;a=umif h/ wyfrawmf tpd k;&.=oZmatmufwGif ppfaq;&ef roif hawmfay?urB mhukvor*~tzG J @csKyf}uD;. =oZmcH pH kprf;ppfaq;a&;tzG J @ud k v$ Jtyfppfaq;I trSef w&m;ud kazmfxkwfjcif;omv#iftoif hawmfqH k;jzpfayrnf// od k @aomf xd kod k @trSefw&m;ud k ppfaq;azmfxkwf+yD;aemuf wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud k ta&;,ltjypfay;jcif;vrf;pOfud k rvd kufbJ/ awmiftmz&duwGif usif hoH k;cJ haom trSefw&m;azmfxkwf fa&;ESif h cGif hv$wfa&;vrf;pOfud k vd kufemusif hoH k;oif honf xifygonf? od k @jzif h trSefw&m;ay:aygufvmonfESif htr# Ed kifiHa&;tmCmwrsm;avsmhenf;vm+yD; ESpfbuftiftm;pkrsm;t=um; ,H k}unfr_wnfaqmufa&;. yxrajcvSrf;jzpfvmoif honf? xd ktqif hrS qufI a&S @qufvkyf=u&rnf hvrf;pOfud k azmfxkwfoif honf[koabm&&S dayonf// bmr# rjzpfovd k vspfvsL&_xm;jcif;onf tcsif;csif; oHo,ESif h tmCm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 110/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
110
w rsm;om yGm;rsm;apojzif h vd kufemoif haomvrf;pOf r[kwfay//wyfrawmfrS wm0ef&S dolrsm;onfvnf;aumif;/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. acgif;aqmifrsm;onfvnf;
aumif;/ Ed kifiHESif hvlrsdK;ud k cspfjrwfEd k;}uolrsm;csnf;jzpf&m/ Ttcsufud k av;eufpGm pOf;pm;=uyg&ef yef=um;
tyfygonf”
jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHtrsdK;om;aumifpD ( NCUB )
etz onf ‚if;. t=urf;zufvkyf&yfrsm;ud k tjref&yf+yD;aemuf a':pkESif hwuG zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;xm;onf h NLD acgif;aqmifrsm;/ tzG J ‹0ifrsm;tm; tjref jyefv$wfay;&ef/ NLD ±H k;rsm;ud k tjrefjyefzGif hay;&ef/ NLD tay: &efp wd kufcd kufr_/ vlxktay: &efp wd kufcd kufr_rsm;ud k csufcsif;&yfpJypf&ef 'DyJ,if; ta&;tcif;twGif; aoqH k;r_/'%f&m&&S dr_rsm;/ epfemqH k;±H _;r_rsm;twGuf ppfaq;ta&;,lr_rsm; ðyvkyf&ef/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h NLD ud kvGwfvyfpGm pnf;±H k;v_yf&Sm;cGif hay;&efwd k @ud k 2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv (2)&ufae@wGifa=unmcsufxkwfjyefI awmif;qd kcJ honf?
ABFSU ( FAC )/ ABSDF / DPNS / NDD
ArmEd kifiHvH k;qd kif&m ausmif;om;or*~rsm;tzG J @csKyf(Ed kifiHjcm;a&;&maumfrwD) jrefrmEk difiHvH k;qd kif&m ausmif;om;rsm;'Drk du&ufwpfwyfOD;/ vl @abmifopf'Drd ku&ufwpfygwD/ 'Drd kua&pDESif h zG H @òzd;wd k;wufa&;tiftm;pk wd k @uvnf;ar(30)&ufae@ 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_ESif hpyfvsOf;I ‚if;wd k @.oabmxm;rsm;ud k atmufygtwd kif; xkwfjyef a=unmcJ honf?
“etz ppftkyfpkonf trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL; a':atmifqef;pk=unf tyg
t0if A[d k tvkyftr_aqmifrsm;ESif h tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k zrf;qD;jcif;/ wjynfvH k;&S d trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf±H k;rsm;tydwfcH&jcif;wd k @tay: rdrdwk d @tzG J @tpnf;rsm;taejzif h jyif;xefpGm uef huGuf¶_wfcsvd kufonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf. pnf;¶k H;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif; jzpfysufcJ honfrsm;t& t=urf;zufaESmif h,Sufr_rsm;tm;vk H;onf etzrS vufoyfarG;jrLxm;onf h }uH h§zG H @tzG J @rS jyKvkyfaeonfrSm jiif;r&atmifxif¶Sm;vSonf? ,cif a':atmifqef;pk=unf. pnf;±H k;a&;c&D;pOfrsm;twGif; aESmif h,Sufr_rsm;ud k tqufrjywfjyKvkyfcJ h+yD; ,ck ajrmufyd kif;pnf;¶k H;a&;c&D;pOfY yd krd kqd k;0g;vmcJ honf? etz ppftkyfpk. t=urf;zufr_a=umif hjzpfay:cJ h&aom trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;/ ausmif;om;jynfol/ &[ef;oHCmrsm; aoa=uxdcd kuf'%f&m&r_tm;vk H;onf tm%mud k rw&m;& ,lxm;onf h etz ppftkyfpk.wm0efjzpf+yD; vuf¶S d etz ppftkyfpktaejzif h jynfolrsm;.tusKd;pD;yGm;xuf
‚if;wd k @. tm%mtoufqufa&;twGufom vkyfaqmifrnfqd kaom Zmwd¶kyfud k zGif hvSpfjyovd kufjcif jzpfa=umif;ESif h jrefrmjynfvlrsKd;pH kjynfolw&yfvk H;/ 'Drd kua&pD tiftm;pkrsm;/ wd kif;&if;om;tiftm;pkESif h jrefrmh'Drd kua&pDa&;ud k vd kvm;onf h Ed kifiHwumtzG J @tpnf;rsm;tm; apmfum;csuf/ pdefac:csufvnf; jzpfa=umif;”
ArmjynfuGefjrLepfygwD
'DyJ,if; a&OD; t=urf;zufr_ESif hywfouf+yD; ArmjynfuGefjrLepfygwD A[d kpnf;¶H k;a&;aumfrwD ajyma&;qd kcGif h&S dol. xkwfjyefa=unmcsuf 7§2003ud k (2/ 6/ 2003)&ufae@wGi fxkwfjyefa=unmcJ h&mwGif æ
“rH k&GmESif h teD;w0d kufòrd @rsm;wGifjzpfysufcJ honf h t=urf;zufr_rsm;ESif hywfoufI ormorwfusaom oHCmawmfrsm;/ vlyk*~ dKvfrsm;yg0ifonf h pH kprf;a&;aumfr&Sif tjrefzG J @yg? tpD&ifcHpm tjrefxkwfyg? wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud kta&; ,lyg” [kawmif;qd kcJ honfud kawG @&S d&onf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 111/208
111
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
trsKd;om;'Drkdua&pDtzJGŒcsKyf/ trsKd;om;atmifyJ GaeŒ xkwfjyefa-unmcsuf
2003 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(18)&ufae@wGif usa&mufonf htrsdK;om;atmifyG Jae@wGif trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pD tzG J @csKyfu a=unmcsufwapmifxkwfjyefcJ h&m xd kxkwfjyefcJ honf h a=unmcsufwGif æ
“yxrajcvSrf;taejzif h txdef;odrf;cH tzJ G @csKyfacgif;aqmif a':atmifqef;pk=unf/ OD;wifOD;ESif h aetdrftus,fcsKyfuscHae=u&aom OuUÏ OD;atmifa&$ tygt0if A[k dtvkyftr_aqmiftzJ G @0ifrsm;/ tusOf;uscH tzJ G @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;ESif h Ek difiHt0Srf; tusOf;uscHae=u&aom Ek difiHa&;tusOf;orm;tm;vk H;ud k c|if;csufr&S d tjrefqk H;jyefv$wfay;&ef/ 31-5-03 &ufae@r SpI cwW,m,Dydwfxm;cJ h=uaom trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyf¶k H;rsm; tjrefqk H; jyefzGif ha&;ESif h Ek difiHa&;ygwDrsm; vGwfvyfpGmpnf;¶k H;v_yf&Sm;cGif hðy&ef/Ek difiHt0Srf; w&m;Oya'pd k;rk d;a&; &SifoefxGef;um;a&;/ Oya't&mwGif vlwk dif;vlwk dif; tnDtr#&S dapa&;wk d @ud k wefzk d;xm;av;pm;vd kufema=umif; jynfolvlxkESif hurB mu od&S datmifjyoaomtm;jzif h ar(30) 'DyJ,if;t=urf;zufr_tm; jynfolvlxk,k H=unfvufcHEk dif
aom yk*~ dKvfrsm;yg0ifonf h pk Hprf;a&;aumfr&SifzJ G @+yD; vGwfvyfpGm pk Hprf;ppfaq;cGif hðy&ef ponf htcsufrsm;ud k rvJ GraoG aqmif&Gufay;&efrSm EkdifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESifhzHG @òzd;a&;aumifpD. wm0efomjzpfayonf”[kazmfjyI awmif;qd kcJ h=uonf?
( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmifajcrSwfpkrsm; )
(1) vGwfvyfaomtm&StoHESif h ZGefv(21)&ufawG @qH kar;jref;csuf?(2) vGwfvyfaomtm&StoHESif h ZGefv(25)&ufawG @qH kar;jref;csuf?
(3) vGwfvyfaomtm&StoHESif h ZGefv(9)&ufawG @qH kar;jref;csuf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 112/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
112
tar&duefEkdifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; aumvif;yg0Jvf
jrefrmEd kifiH ppftpd k;&u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tift,fvf'DrS ta&;ygonf hacgif;aqmifrsm;ud k zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;jcif;ESif hywfoufI tar&duef Ed kifiHjcm;a&;Xme0ef}uD; aumvfvif;yg0Jvfu 1-6- 2003ae@wGif usif;yrnf h tm&yf - tar&duef xdyfoD;aqG;aEG;yG Jwufa&muf&ef tD*spftyef;ajzpcef; &Seftm&S dwfud ktoGm; owif;axmufrsm;ud kajym=um;&mwGif æ
“a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k tumtuG,fay;zd k @yJjzpfjzpf/ bma=umif hyJjzpfjzpf vH kòcHa&; ta=umif;jyK+yD; xdef;odrf;xm;jcif;ud k tjcm;Ed kifiHrsm;enf;wl &_wfcsygw,f/ &kwf&kwfoJoJ jzpfvd k @ olrud k tum tuG,fay;wJ htaeeJ hxdef;odrf;xm;wmvd k @ jrefrmtm%myd kifawGu ajymygw,f? 'gqd kvd k @&S d&if a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k csufcsif;v$wfay;vdrf hr,fvd k @ ar#mfvif hygw,f/ tjrefqH k; v$wfay;Ed kifatmifvnf; oHcif;wrefcif;vrf;a=umif;uae jrefrmtpd k;&ud k today;xm;ygw,f” [k owif;Xmersm;tm; ajym=um;cJ honf?
tar&duef EdkifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; aumvif;yg0Jvf. 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I a&;om;xm;onf haqmif;yg;ud k 2003 ckESp/ fZGefv (12)&ufae@xkwf (Wall Street Journal) wGifazmfjycJ h&m æ
“'Drk dua&pDtm; t}udrf}udrfwk dufck dufch J+yD;/ 'Drk dua&pDa&;v_yf&Sm;aeaom ol&Jaumif;rsm;uk d r=umc%zrf;qD;tusOf;csaeaomppftm%m&Sifrsm;tay:wGif usih fok H;aeonh f u|Ef kyfwk d @.rl0g'uk d jyefvnfok H;oyf&eftcsdefusa&mufvm+yD jzpfonf?
arv (30)&ufae@u a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef; wk dufck dufcHch J&+yD;aemufyk dif;wGif owif;tcsuftvufrsm; pkaqmif;Ek dif&ef tar&duefoH&k H;t&m&d Srsm;uk d tcsif;jzpfyGm;onh fae&mok d @ u|Ek fyfwk d @apv$wfch Jonf?‚if;wk d @u ,if;wk dufck dufr_rSm óudwif}uH&G,fxm;jcif;jzpfa=umif; tpD&ifcHch J=uonf? x&yfum;rsm;onf vloluif;&Sif;onh fae&ma&mufonftxd a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;aemufrS vk dufygch J+yD;aemuf/ ydwfqk d @ [ef @wm;ch Jonf? xk d @aemuf x&yfum;ay:rS vl&rf;um;rsm;u 'Drk dua&pDa&; v_yf&Sm;axmufcHolwk d @.armfawmf,mOfrsm;uk d a'gow}uD;wk dufck dufch Jonf? wk dufck dufolrsm;rSm &ufpuf=urf;=uKwfvGef;+yD;/ pepfwus pDpOfwk dufck dufch Jonf/ wk dufck dufcH&olrsm;rSm +idrf;csrf;pGm jyefvnfwkef @jyefch J+yD; ckcHwk dufck dufr_rsm; rjyKvkyfch Jay? jzpfysufch Jonfrsm;ESih fywfoufI jrefrmppftm%myk difwk d @. &Sif;vif;wifjyr_rsm;rSm vk H;0 tajctjrpf r&d Say? etzonf aoqk H;/'%f&m&olta&twGufESih h f ywfoufonh f ,k H=unf&avmufonh ftpD&ifcHr_rsKd; rjyKvkyfEk difch Jay? óudwif=uHpnfxm;onh f t=urf;zufwk dufck dufr_uk d pDpOfn$ef=um;r_ESih h fpyfvsOf;I ppftpk d;&tzJ G @0ifrsm;wGif wm0ef&d Sa=umif;u|Ek fyfwk d @ oH&k H;0efxrf;rsm;u &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif;od&d Sxm;ygonf” [k xkwfazmfa&;om;cJ honf?
xd k @tjyif jrefrmppftpd k;&[m Ed kifiHawmftcsKyftjcmtm%mud k tumtuG,fvkyf+yD; jrefrmEd kifiHom;awG&J htajccH&yd kifcGif hawGud k csdK;azgufaewJ h tpd k;&jzpfw,f/ 'ga=umif h 'Dxufyd k+yD; wif;wif;rmrm ud kifwG,fta&;,loif hw,f/ 'D &ufpuf yufpufwJ h ppftpd k;&[m a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k jyefvnfv$wfay;zd k @ wurB mvH k;u
tvd k&S daew,fqd kwmud kvnf; odzd k @vd ka=umif; ‚if;uyif 17-6-2003 ae@ urfyl;csm;Ed kifiH/ zEGrf;yifwGif usif;yrnf h(Asia Forum) tpnf;ta0;od k @ wufa&muf&eftvmwGif xyfrHajymqd kcJ honf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 113/208
113
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tar&duefEk difiHjcm;a&;Xme ajyma&;qkdcGif h&Sdol zdvpf wD&Dum
2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv(5)&ufae@wGif tar&duefEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef=uD;Xmeu ajyma&;qk dcGih f&d Sol zdvpf wD&Dumuzdvpf wD&Dumuzdvpf wD&Dumuzdvpf wD&Dumuzdvpf wD&Dumu'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I a=unmcsufwapmif xkwfjyefcJ h&m æ
“'DyJ,if; ta&;tcif;jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf &efukefòrd @/ tar&duefoH&k H;rS t&m&d Srsm;onf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESih f c&D;pOfwGifvk dufygoGm;olrsm; arv(30)&ufae@u t=urf;zufwk dufck dufcHch J&onh fae&mok d @ oGm;a&muf=unh f&_avhvm+yD; jyefvmch J=uonf? ‚if;wk d @. avhvmawG @&d Scsuft& a':atmifqef;pk=unf.,mOfwef;onf óudwifjyifqifxm;onh f wk dufck dufr_uk dcHch J&a=umif; od&d S&onf? avhvmawG @&d Sch Jaomtajctaersm;ESih f a'ocHwk d @.tqk dt& xk dwk dufck dufr_uk d tpk d;&u ausmaxmufaemufcHjyKxm;onh f vl&rf;um;rsm;u pDpOfch Jjcif;jzpfonf?tcsif;jzpfyGm;onh fae&mwGifusef&pfch Jaom oJvGefprsm;u vltajrmuftrsm; qk d;qk d;0g;0g;xdck dufEk difonh f wk duf
ck dufr_}uD;rsm; jzpfay:ch Ja=umif; azmfjyaeonf?u|Ef kyfwk d @taejzih f aoqk H;/ '%f&m&/ aysmufqk H;olrsm;pm&if;tjynh ftpk Huk dwifjy&ef Ek difiHawmfat;csrf;om
,ma&;ESih f zH G @òzd;a&;aumifpDtm; wk dufwGef;vk dufonf” pojzif h etz tm; wd kufwGef;awmif;qd kcJ honf?
tar&duefEd kifiHtpd k;&u jrefrmEd kifiH&S d tar&duefoH&H k;tzG J @0ifrsm; tcsif;jzpfyGm;&mae&mod k @apv$wfI pH kprf;&mrS &&S donf h pH kprf;awG @&S dcsufrsm;ud ktajcjyKI 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_onf etz ppftkyfpk ausmaxmufaemufcHay;xm;onf holrsm;u pDpOfaqmif&GufcJ hjcif;jzpfa=umif; Ed kifiHwumod k @ twdtvif;xkwfazmfajymqd kcJ honf? 11111 xd kod k @ajymqd kr_rsm;a=umif h jrefrmEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;OD;0if;atmifESif h 'kwd, Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;jzpfol
OD;cifarmif0if;wd k @onf jrefrmEd kifiHESif h e,fedrdwfjcif;xdpyfaeonf h w&kwfESif h tdEN d,Ed kifiHrsm;/ ta&S @awmiftm&SEd kifiHrsm;/ Oa&myor*~ tzG J @0ifEd kifiHrsm;/tar&duefEd kifiHESif hukvor*~twGif;a&;r_;csKyf ud kzDteefwd k @tm; jzpf&yfrSefud kzk H;uG,fxm;onf h vkyf=uHowif;rsm;jzif h‚if; "gwfyH krsm;jzif hvnf;aumif; wifjy ajymqd k&Sif;vif;cJ h=uonf?
ukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyf. txl;uk d,fpm;vS,f rpPwm &mZmvD tpPar;vf
tar&duefoH&H k;t&m&Sdrsm;. a=unmcsufxGufay:vm+yD;aemuf ukvor*~twGif;a&;r_;csKyf. txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f &mZmvDtpPar;vfu “ a':atmifqef;pk=unf vGwfajrmufzd k @ usaemfwd k @vkyf=u&rSm taotcsmygyJ/ olr[m trsKd;om;acgif;aqmif}uD;jzpfovd k ukvor*~twGif;a&;r_;csKyf&J @a=unmcsufxJrSm azmfjycsuf
t&qd k&ifvJ olr&J @ygwDtwGuf vkyfief;aqmifwmawGaqmif&Gufzd k @ olr &S dae&rSmyg/ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfud k csdyfydwfxm;p&mta=umif; r&S dovd k 'DygwD&J @ta&;ygwJ htzG J @0ifawGud k ydwfavSmifzrf;qD;xm;p&mta=umif;vnf; r&S dygbl;? 'Dvkyf&yf[m w&m;r#wr_ r&S dbl; pojzif hajym=um;cJ honf? 22222 xd kod k @ajymqd k+yD;aemuf ZGefv(6)&ufae@wGif jrefrmEd kifiHod k @ a&muf&S dvmcJ honf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h ZGefv(10) &ufae@wGif awG @qH kcGif h&&S dap&eftwGufyif etz ppftkyfpkESif h t}udrf}udrf aqG;aEG;awmif;qd kcJ h&onf? jrefrmEd kifiHrS rxGufcGmrD tjynfjynfqd kif&mavqdyfwGifjyKvkyfonf h owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JY a':atmifqef;pk=unfonf aumif;rGefpGm&S daea=umif;ESif h xdcd kuf'%f&m&r_ r&S da=umif;/ pdwf"gwfcd kifrmvsufyif&S da=umif; owif;Xmersm;tm; tay:,Hr#om xkwfazmf ajym=um;cJ honf? rav;&Sm;Ed kifiHod k @a&muf&S d+yD;aemuf rav;&Sm;uDeD tifwmeufowif;pmESif h awG @qH kar;jref;&mwGif æ
“a':atmifqef;pk=unfu ar(30)jzpf&yfudk vlrqefwJh&ufpuf,kwfrmr_[k ajymqdk+yD;/ Oya't& w&m;tr#wqH k; qH k;jzwfay;yg&efvnf; wifjyawmif;qd kcJ honf” 33333 [k pwifI xkwfazmfajym=um;vmonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 114/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
114
&mZmvD tpPar;vfonf ar(30) 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h yxrqH k;awG @cGif h&onf h tqif hjrif hukvor*~oHwrefwOD;jzpfonf? rav;&Sm;Ed kifiHod k @ a&muf&S donf htcsdefrSom ,ckuJ hod k @a':atmifqef;pk=un fwd k @.,mOfwef; vkyf=uHwd kufcd kufjcif;cH&a=umif;ud k twdtvif;xkwfazmfajym=um;cJ honf?
xd k @aemuf *syefEd kifiH Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;ESif h awG @qH konf htcgwGif yd krd kIjynf hpH kpGm xyfrHajymqd konf?“a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; &efukefòrd @&S d tusOf;axmifwckxJY tkwfESif haqmufxm;onf hoD;oef @ tcef ;
usOf;av;wGif awG @&S dcJ h&a=umif;/ olrud kxm;onf hae&mrSm vlxkacgif;aqmif/ Ed kifiHacgif;aqmifwa,mufud k xm;&rnf hae&m r[kwfa=umif;ESif h ar(30) 'DyJ,if;t=urf;zufvkyf=uHwd kufcd kufcH&r_rsm;ud k a':atmifqef;pk=unfxHrS ‚if;odcJ h&onf htwd kif; wifjyajymqd kcJ h&m *syefEd kifiHonf jrefrmEd kifiHod k @ay;tyfaeonf h tultnDrsm;ud k&yfqd kif;xm;&ef qH k;jzwfcJ honf? wqufwnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif hEd kifiHa&;tusOf;om;rsm;ud k v$wfay;&efetz ppftkyfpkud k zdtm;ay;Iawmif;qd kcJ honf? rpPwm&mZmvDESif h *syefEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;wd k @onf a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k tjrefqH k; v$wfay;&ef etzppftpd k;&ud k zdtm;ay;&rnfqd konfud k ESpfOD;vH k;uoabmwlnDcJ honf?
xd k @a=umif h vufawG @ta&;,lr_taejzif h jrefrmEd kifiHtwGufay;aeonf h tultnDrsm;ESif h ay;&efjyifqifaeonf hpDrHudef;rsm;tm;vH k; &yfqd kif;xm;rnfjzpfa=umif; *syefEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;. ajymcGif h&yk*~ ~ dKvf rpPwm ud k*sD;&d k; rwfqkrd kwd ku ajym=um;cJ honf” 44444
xkdif; 0ef}uD;csKyf oufqif &S Dem0gx&m
jrefrmEd kifiHESif h e,fedrdwfjcif;xdpyfvsuf&S donf h xd kif;Ed kifiH.0ef}uD;csKyfjzpfol oufqif &S Dem0gx&muvnf;tar&duefEd kifiHESif hxd kif; ESpfEd kifiHyl;wG Jxkwfjyefonf ha=unmcsufwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; tjrefqH k; v$wfay;&ef etz tm; awmif;qd kcJ honf?
tmqD,H
ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_ jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv(18)&ufae@ uarBm'D;,m;EdkifiH/zEGrfyifòrd @wGifusif;yonf h ta&S @awmiftm&Sqd kif&m/ tmqD,HEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;rsm; tpnf;ta0;wGifa':atmifqef;pk=unftm; tjrefqH k;v$wfay;&ef tmqD,H0ef}uD;rsm;u zdtm;ay;awmif;qd kcJ h=uonf? 55555 tmqD,HtzG J @tpnf;ta0;twGif; yxrOD;qH k;t}udrftjzpf tzG J @0ifEd kifiH wEd kifiH. jynfwGif;a&;ud k0ifa&mufpGufzuf+yD; awmif;qd kcJ hjcif;jzpfonf? xd kod k @ tmqD,HtzG J @}uD;. awmif;qd kcsufESif hywfoufI etztm; tmqD,HtzG J @0ifEd kifiH wEd kifiHjzpfvmap&ef axmufcHtm;ay;cJ honf h rav;&Sm; 0ef}uD;csKyf r[moD,mrd k[mrufu “a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k bma=umif h v$wfray;ovJqd kwm pOf;pm;vd k @ud k r&ygbl; / wjcm;Ed kifiHawG ajymqd kwmud k vufrcHwmxuftmqD,HtzG J@0ifEdkifiHawGu a':atmifqef;pk=unfv$wfay;zd k@awmif;qd kwmudkawmh owdjyKoif h+yD; etz.vkyf&yfonf tmqD,HwzG J @vH k;ud k usOf;xJusyfxJ wGef;yd k @aeonf”[k xkwfazmfajym=um;cJ honf? 66666 jrefrmEd kifiH.tajctaeonf jrefrmEd kifiHtwGufomruyJ tmqD,HtzG J @}uD;twGufvnf; qkwf,kwfr_rsm;jzpfa=umif;ud kvnf; puFmyl Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; *sm&mul;rm; u xkwfazmfajymqd kcJ honf? a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; xdef;odrf;xm;jcif;onf ta&S @awmiftm&SEd kifiHrsm;toif;}uD;(tmqD,H). *k%foduQmud k xdcd kufa=umif;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; tjrefqH k;jyefvnfv$wfay;&ef vd ka=umif;ud k rav;&Sm; Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; qm&pf[mrpf t,fvfbmu ZGefv(27)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JwGif ajymqd kcJ honf?
etz. ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_a=umif h jrefrmEd kifiHonf Ed kifiHwum. yd krd k'%fcwfr_rsm;a=umif h
pDyGm;a&; yd krd k=uyfwnf;vmrnfjzpfa=umif;ud k puFmylorwEd kifiH. 0ef}uD;csKyfa[mif;jzpfol vDuGrf,ku owday;ajym=um;cJ honf? 77777 zdvpfyd kifEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; td kyJvfu “etz ppftpd k;&[m a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k v$wf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 115/208
115
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
ay;zd k @ taotcsmajymqd kr_awG r&S dwJ haemufydkif;rSm tmqD,HEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;awGtaeeJ @ vl @tcGifhta&;a=unmpmwrf;wckud k tpjyK a&;qG Jaeyg+yD/ xd kpmwrf;ud k twnf jyKjyXmef;Ed kif&if jrefrmEd kifiHtay: '%fcwf
ta&;,lr_ od k @r[kwf tmqD,HtzG J @xJu xkwfypfzd k @txdawmif OD;wnfoGm;Ed kifygw,f”“a':atmifqef;pk=unf vGwfajrmufvm+yD;&if tmqD,HtaeeJ @ jrefrmEd kifiHrSm +idrf;csrf;pGm Ed kifiHa&;ajymif;vJr_rsm; v#ifjrefpGmjzpfay:vmap&ef jrefrmEd kifiHud k tqif hjrif h tmqD,Hud k,fpm;vS,ftzG J @ wzG J @ apv$wfygvdrf hr,f/tJ'Dud k,fpm;vS,ftzG J @taeeJ @ a':atmifqef;pk=unftygt0if etz ppftpd k;&eJ @ awG @qH kaqG;aEG;wmawGvkyfzd k @tmqD,Hobmywdwm0ef,lr,f h tif'd keD;&Sm;Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; [mqm rd kvm&d kwmu tqd kjyKxm;a=umif;”ajymqd kcJ honf? 88888
ta&S @wDarm Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; a[mfwmuvnf; “jrefrmEd kifiH[m 2006 ckESpf rwd kifcifrSm tckvd k &yfwnfvkyfaqmifwmrsdK;awGuf d k pGef @v$wf&r,fqd kwmeJ @ ywfoufvd k @ tmqD,HEd kifiHawG tonf;toefjzpfae=uw,f?'Dvd krS r[kwf&ifawmh tmqD,HtzG J @wGif;rSm&S dwJ hEd kifiHwd kif;[m awmfawmf hud k rsufESm ysufp&mjzpfr,f? ckawmif
awmfawmfrsufESmysufae&yg+yD/ tmqD,H Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;awG[m jrefrmEd kifiHrSmjzpfysufcJ hwJ h Ed kifiHa&;aemufjyefqG Jr_awGa=umif h t}uD;tus,fpdwfysuf&ygw,f ”
Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; OD;0if;atmifu ar(30) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHowfjzwfr_ESif hpyfvsOf;I tmqD,HEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;rsm;tm; &Sif;vif;wifjyr_ESif hywfouf+yD; “olwd k @ajymjywJ hta=umif;awGu vH k;0,H k=unfEd kifp&m r&S dygbl;/ 'ga=umif hvnf; tmqD,HEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;awGu wnDwnGwfwnf; olrud kv$wfay;zd k @ awmif ;qd kaewmyg? +yD;cJ hwJ h etz&J @vkyf&yf[m tmqD,HwckvH k;&J @*k%foduQmud k n‡Kd;EGrf;apw,fqd kwJ htcsufud k tmqD,Hacgif;aqmiftm;vH k;u oabmwlvufcHcJ h=uw,f? tvGwfoabmnpmpm;yG JrSmvJ 'DudpPud kyJ aqG;aEG;a0zefcJ h+yD;a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k csufcsif;jyefv$wfay;zd k @ tif'd keD;&Sm;eJ @ uarB m'D;,m;Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;awGu awmif;qd kcJ h
wmjzpfa=umif;” 99999 zEGrf;yifòrd @wGifusif;yonf h tmqD,H Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;rsm;tpnf;ta0;wGif jrefrmEd kifiHESif hywfoufI ‚if;.oabmxm;ud k txufyg twk dif; xkwfazmfajymqd kcJ honf?
xd kuJ hod k @ tmqD,HtzG J @0ifEd kifiHrsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unf jyefvnfv$wfay;a&;ESif hpyfvsOf;I tmqD,HtzG J @wzG J @ &efukefòrd @od k @ oGm;a&mufa&;ud k tvSnf hus tmqD,HOuUÏ tif f'd keD;&Sm; Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;u tqd kjyK xm;aomfvnf; etz bufrS wkef @jyefr_ rjyKcJ hyg? 1010101010
ta&S @awmiftm&SEd kifiHrsm;toif;}uD;(tmqD,Htoif;)taejzif h zEGrf;yifòrd @ Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;rsm; tpnf;ta0;wGif ar(30) ta&;tcif;ESif hpyfvsOf;I a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; jyefvnfv$wfay;&ef tjyif;txefawmif;qd kr_rsm; jyKvkyfcJ honf? od k @aomf tif'd keD;&Sm;Ed kifiH bmvDu|ef;wGifusif;yonf h tmqD,H xdyfoD;tpnf;
ta0;wGifrl zEGrf;yifòrd @wGif tmqD,HEd kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;rsm;u csrSwfxm;onf hqH k;jzwfcsufud k qufvuftaumiftxnf razmfaqmifEd kifonfud k awG @&S dcJ h&onf?
ukvor*~ vlŒtcGif hta&;qk dif&m txl;uk d,fpm;vS,f
ukvor*~vl @tcGif hta&;qd kif&m txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f rpPwm ay:vk dqm*sD,d k yDnJ&d k;onf ‚if;. jrefrmEd kifiHod k @qXrajrmufc&D;pOftwGif; 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;rS xGufajy;vGwfajrmufvmonf h rsufjrifoufaorsm;/ tcif;jzpfcsdefwGif ud k,fwd kif&ifqd kifóuHawG @ cJ h&olrsm;ESif h awG @qH kar;jref;cGif h &&S dcJ honf?
2003ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbm (12)&ufae@wGif ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ ay:vk dqm*sD,k dyDnJ&k d;u(58)}udrfajrmuf ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcH/ wwd,aumfrwDod k @ tpD&ifcHpmwifoGif;&mwGif 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uH
owfjzwfr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I atmufygtwd kif; wifjycJ honf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 116/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
116
“rdrd. ,ckc&D;pOfuk d ,cifc&D;pOfrsm;wGifjzpfay:aeaom tajctaersm;ESih f wlnDjcif;r&d Sonh ftcsdefwGif pwifch Jonf? 2003 ckESpf/ rwfvwGif jyKvkyfch Jaom rdrd. aemufqk H;c&D;pOfwGif vl @tcGih fta&;tajctaersm;ESih f trsKd;om;jyefvnfoih fjrwfa&;vkyfief;pOfrsm; odod
omomqkwf,kwfusqif;ch Jonf? 2003 ckESpf/ arv(30)&ufae@Y 'DyJ,if;òrd @wGif ay:aygufch Jaomjzpf&yfonf vl @tcGih fta&; qk d;qk d;0g;0g;csKd;azmufr_rsm; jzpfay:ch J+yD;/ Ek difiHa&;tajc taersm;ESih fvnf; eufeuf&d _if;&d _if; qufEG,fywfoufaeonf?
TtpD&ifcHpm rwd kifrD rdrd. aemufqk H;tpD&ifcHpmwGif arv (30)&ufae@jzpf&yfrsm;uk dwifjych J+yD;jzpfonf? xk dwifjycsufwGif jrefrmtm%myk difwk d @. xkwfjyefajymqk dcsufrsm;/ ,k H=unfpdwfcs&onh f owif;&if;jrpfrsm;uk d uk d;um;I wifjych Jjcif;jzpfonf? xk d @jyif xk dtpD&ifcHpma&;om;pOf&&d Sch Jaom pkaqmif;rdor# owif;tcsuftvufrsm;tay: tajccHI jzpfpOftay: rdrd. y%mroH k;oyfcsufud kvnf; azmfjycJ honf? ,ck c&D;pOfwGif wk dufck dufcHch J&oltcsKd @/rsufjrifoufaotcsKd @wk d @uk d awG @qk Har;jref;Ek difch J+yD;/ ‚if;wk d @xHrS xk djzpf&yfESih fywfoufonh ftcsuftvufrsm;&&d Sch Jonf? xk d @jyif tm%myk difrsm;ESih f a':atmifqef;pk=unfwk d @tm; oGm;a&mufaqG;aEG;jcif;jzih fvnf; tcsuftvufrsm;pGm &&d Sch Jonf? 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfonf tpk d;&tm%myd kifrsm;u =uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdK; r[kwfvsif 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yf jzpfyGm;Ed kifp&m r&S dbl;qd konf htcsufud k vufcHEd kifavmufatmifjrifomonf h oufaocHtaxmuftxm;rsm; &S dae+yD[k rdrdajymEd kifonf?
,ae@tcsdeftxd rdrdavhvmpkaqmif;chJaom taxmuftxm;rsm;u atmufygtwd kif; azmfjyaeonf? 2003 ckESpf/ arv(25)&ufae@ESih f (30)&ufae@t=um; a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; axmufcHóudqk dolta&twGufrsm;jym;vmonf? xk dtcg trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pD
tzJ G @csKyftm; qef @usifolrsm;/ ok d @wnf;r[kwf tpk d;&tm%myk diftzJ G @tpnf;rsm;ESih f wenf;enf;jzih f qufpyfxdawG @aeolrsm;. yg0ifywfoufr_jzih f +cdrf;ajcmufjcif;/ v_ H @aqmfjcif;/ aESmif h,Sufjcif;/ wk dufck dufjcif;/ tEk difusih fapmfum;jcif;ESih f t=urf;zufjcif;rsm; ay:aygufch Jonf?rvk dvm;tyfaom toufqk H;&_ H;epfemjcif;rsm;/ xdcd kuftemw&jzpfr_rsm;ud ka&Smif&Sm;I xk djzpf&yfuk d +idrf;csrf;pGmajz&Sif;jcif; rjyKEk dif[k qk djcif;rSm rdrdtaejzih f ,k H=unf&efcufcJvSonf?
'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfa=umif h 'DyJ,if;jzpfpOftwGif;omru vl @tcGif hta&;e,fy,fwGif 0rf;enf;a=uuG JzG,f&m aemufqufwG J qkwf,kwfepfemr_rsm; jzpfay:cJ h&onf? Ek difiHtES H @&d S tifeft,fvf'D &k H;rsm; tydwfcHch J&onf// a': atmifqef;pk=unf txdef;odrf;cHch J&onf// tzJ G @csKyf A[k d
tvkyftr_aqmiftzJ G @0ifrsm; aetdrftus,fcsKyf uscJ h=uonf? tzJ G @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;/ axmufcHolrsm;/ 'Drk dua&pDESih f vl @tcGih fta&;v_yf&Sm;olrsm;tm; zrf;qD; tusOf;csch Jonf// ‚if;wd k @ud kapmih f=unf hppfaq;r_rsm;/ +cdrf;ajcmufr_rsm; wk d;jrih fvmonf? jypfr_usL;vGefolrsm;tm; w&m;pJ Gqk d&ef xda&mufonh fvkyfaqmifr_rsm; r&d SbJ wk dufck dufr_wGif xdck dufepfemch Jolrsm;om zrf;qD;tusOf;cscHch J&onf?
xk d epfemcsufrsm;uk d jyefvnfajz&Sif;&eftwGuf 2003 ckESpf/ arv(30)&ufae@rS pIxdef;odrf; cHxm;&olrsm;/ aetdrfwGif csKyfaESmifcHxm;&olrsm;tm; c|if;csufr&d S csufcsif;v$wfay;&ef vk dtyfygonf?
xk d @tjyif wd kufcd kufcH&r_rS vGwfajrmufvmolrsm;ESif h jzpfpOftwGif; toufaoqk H;oGm;
olrsm;. rdom;pk0ifrsm;uk dvnf; avsmfa=u;aiGay;&ef pOf;pm;oif hygonf? Ek difiHwum pHcsdefrsm;ESih ftnD tao;pdyfpk Hprf;ppfaq;r_rsm; jyKvkyfoih fygonf? jypfr_usL;vGefolrsm;/ pk Hprf;ppf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 117/208
117
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
aq;r_rS xGufay:vmaom&v'frsm; ponfwk d @uk d trsm;jynfol od&d Sap&efvnf; xkwfjyefa=unmoih fonf?
'DyJ,if;ESih fywfoufonh f jzpf&yfrSefrsm;xGufay:vma&;twGuf yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufol
rsm;uk d vufpm;acsjcif;/ +cdrf;ajcmufjcif; rjyKvkyfyg[laom tmrcHcsufrsm;ay;oih fonf?tzJ G @csKyf&k H;rsm; jyefvnfzGih fvSpfoih fygonf? xk dok d @ jyKvkyfjcif;jzih f jzpf&yfqk d;}uD;wGif&&d Sch Jaom'%f&m'%fcsuftcsKd @uk d ukpm;Ek difrnfjzpfonf?
2002 ckESpf arvESih f 2003 ckESpf/ arvt=um; tcsdefumvuk d jyefvnfavhvm =unh fygu tajctaerSm a&&maocsmr_ r&S daomfvnf; vlxktrsm;pkrSm ar#mfvih fcsuftcsKd @ xm;&d Sch J=uonf? ,k H=unfr_wnfaqmuf&ef tapmyk dif;umv óud;yrf;csufrsm;ESih f ywfoufonh ftcGih ftvrf;rsm; qk H;&_ H;ch Jonf[k rdrdtaejzif h,lqygonf? ESpfzuf tjyeftvSef,H k=unfr_wnfaqmuf&ef jynf hpH kcd kifrmonf h uwdu0wfrsm; uif;rJ honf htwGuf ,H k=unfem;vnfr_wd k;yGm;vm&rnf htpm; wjznf;jznf;,kwfavsmhvmum aemufqH k; 'DyJ,if;udpP jzpf&onf htajctaeod k @ qd kufa&mufcJ honf?
ar(30) jzpf&yfonf jrefrmEk difiHtay: Ek difiHwumtok dif;t0k dif;u tjrifajymif;vJvmap&ef jyXmef;ay;vd kufaom t"dujzpf&yf jzpfvmcJ honf? jrefrmEd kifiHtay: wm;qD; ydwfyifr_rsm; wd k;jr‡if hðyvkyfonftxd Ek difiHwum. jypfwif&_wfcsr_uk d etztaejzih f róuHpzl; tjyif;xefqH k; cHvk duf&onf? xk d @a=umih fvnf; tusdK;quftjzpf etz u 2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfvwGif 0ef}uD;csKyfopfwOD; cef @tyfwm0efay;a=umif; a=unmjcif;/ tcsuf (7)csufyg0ifaomvrf;jyajryk HtpDtpOftm; a=unmjcif; pojzih f wkef @jyefvkyfaqmifch Jonf? xk d vkyfaqmifr_rsm;uk d Ek difiHtcsKd @u todtrSwfjyKch J=uonf?
jrefrmEd kifiH.tem*wfta&;ud k trSefwu,ftav;xm;oltm;vH k; 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfESif hywfoufI oifcef;pm,loif hygonf? ‚if;oifcef;pmrsm;ud k tjrefqH k; tav;xm;vd kufemusif hoH k;oif hygonf? Tjzpf&yfrSm vufpm;aajc wkef @jyefajz&Sif;&rnf h jy\emw&yf r[kwfovd k wzufzufrS &yfwnfI Ed kifiHa&;oabmxm;ay;&rnf h udpPvnf; r[kwfyg?
TjzpfpOftwGif; usL;vGefcJ haom vl @tcGif hta&;csdK;azmufr_rsm;ud k xda&mufpGm ðyjyifukpm;Ed kifrSomv#if 'Drd kua&pDðyjyifajymif;vJa&; vrf;a=umif;ay:ok d @ wd kif;jynfud kyd k @ aqmifay;Ed kifrnf h usif h0wfoduQmqd kif&m vrf;!$efr_ud k &&S dayvdrf hrnf?
TuJ hod k @ ESpfOD;ESpfzuf=um; jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;tcGif htvrf;ud k vufvGwfqH k;¶H _;ygu
wd kif;jynftwGuf qd k;usKd;rsm;om jzpfxGef;vmEd kifayonf? xd k @a=umif h ar(30) jzpf&yfESif hywfoufI rdrdud k vGwfvyfpGmpH kprf;tuJ jzwfcGif hay;&ef etz tpd k;&tm; tqd kðyurf;vSrf;cJ honf? xd kurf;vSrf;csufud k etz wm0ef&S dolrsm;u oabm rwlao;yg? ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
xyfrHzrf;qD;r_rsm; rjyKvkyf&ef rdrdtaejzih f t}udrf}udrfawmif;qk dch Jaomfvnf; 2003ckESpf/ arv(30) &ufae@ rSpI vl(250)cef @ zrf;qD;cHch J&onfqk daomowif;rsm; &&d Sch Jonf?od k @aomf 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfESih fqufEG,f+yD; zrf;qD;cH &olaygif; (153)OD;&d S+yD;/ ‚if;wk d @xJrS (109)
OD; jyefvnfvGwfajrmufvmch Jonf[k etz rS xkwfjyefa=unmcJ honf? xk dtxJwGif 2003ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (9)&ufae@wGif jyefvnfv$wfajrmufvmaom tusOf;om;(8)OD; vnf;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 118/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
118
yg0ifonf? rdrd. owif;&if;jrpfrsm;tm; tjyefjyeftvSefvSefppfaq;+yD; cef @rSef;wGufcsuf=unh f&m qufvufxdef;odrf;cHae&olrsm;rSm etz. w&m;0ifpm&if;Z,m;rsm;xuf ta& twGuf yk drk drsm;jym;vsuf&d Sa=umif; awG @&onf? ‚if;wk d @tm; c|if;csufr&d S/ csufcsif;v$wfay;a&;onf wpk dufrwfrwfawmif;qk daeaom Ek difiHa&;tusOf;om;rsm;tm;vk H; vGwfajrmufa&;ESih f rnfok d @r# roufqk difyg? Ek difiHa&;tusOf;om;[lor# csufcsif;v$wfay;a&;twGuf vGwf+idrf;csrf;omcGih fa=unmay;&ef rdrdu awmif;qk dch Jonf? cd kifrmaom Ek difiHa&;tajymif;tvJrsm;jzpfay: vmap&eftwGuf jy,k*fwcktjzpf awmif;qk dch Jjcif;jzpfonf? jrefrmhEk difiHa&;ork dif;wGif
tcgtm;avsmfpGm vGwf+idrf;csrf;omcGih ftrdef @ xkwfjyefr_rsm;&d Sch Jovd k ,ae@umvwGif ppftpd k;& taejzih f xk dok d @ vkyfaqmifoif hygonf?----------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
arv (30)&ufae@jzpf&yfonf Ek difiHtwGif;&S d yuwdEk difiHa&;taetxm;rSefuk d ,cifuxufyk dI xifxif&Sm;&Sm; azmfxkwfjyovd kuf&m a&mufayonf? ,ae@umvtajctaeonf rnfonf humvESif hr# rwl wrlxl;jcm;+yD; ¶_yfaxG;eufeJvsuf&S d&m jrefrmEk difiHtwGufaqG;aEG;a&;pum;0k dif;wGif awG @qk Hnd ‡E_ dif;I ajyvnfr_&SmazGonh f enf;vrf;rSvJ GI tjcm;enf;
vrf;uk d rdrdtaejzih f rawG @&d Sao;yg? Tok d @aom jrefrmhork dif;tcsKd;tauG@wGif etzESif htrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzJ G @csKyf/ vlrsKd;pkwk dif;&if;om;rsm;tygt0if tjcm;aomEk difiHa&;ygwDrsm;taejzih f Ek difiHtwGuf rnfonh fvrf;a=umif;onf taumif;qk H;jzpfonf/ rnfok d @ oGm;a&mufvk donf ponfwk d @uk d nDnGwfpGm twlwuGqk H;jzwf=u&ygrnf? tjcm; tiftm;pkrsm; yg0ifjcif; r&d Sonh f tkyfpkwpfckwnf;jzif haqmif&Gufygu jrefrm Ek difiHtwGuf a&G;cs,f&rnh fyef;wd kifuk dcsnf;uyfEk dif rnf r[kwfyg? jrefrmEk difiH&d S vlxkw&yfvk H;. vl @tcGih fta&;tajctaewk d;wufr_twGuf vuf&d S jzpfay:aeaom a&S @rwd k; aemuf rqkwfomtajctaeu t[ef @twm;}uD;wck jzpfaeygonf”
,ck c&D;pOfonf ukvor*~. vl @tcGif hta&;qd kif&m txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ ay:vk dqm*sD,d kyDnJ&d k;. qXrt}udrfajrmuf jrefrmjynfc&D;pOf jzpfonf? jrefrmEd kifiH ppf tpd k;&. vl @tcGif hta&;csdK;azgufr_rsm;ud kpH kprf;avhvmI ukvor*~wGif tpD&ifcHwifoGif;&ef wm0ef,l&olvnf;jzpfonf? ,cif c&D;pOfrsm;wGif jrefrmEd kifiH. vl @tcGif hta&;ESif h pyfvsOf;I wifoGif;aom tpD&ifcHpmrsm;onf xda&mufr_ r&S dbJ omrefr#omjzpfI jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;u rcsif hr&JjzpfcJ h&onf?
od k @aomf ,ck qXrt}udrfajrmufc&D;pOfrStjyef 2003 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(12)&ufae@wGif wifoGif;onf htpD&ifcHpmwGifrl 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hywfoufI xda&mufpGmta&;,laqmif&GufEd kifonf h pH kprf;a&;aumf
r&SifzG J @pnf;Ed kifa&;udpPud k tav;teufxm; t}uHjyKwifjycJ honfud k awG @&S d&ygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 119/208
119
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )
(1) ZGefv (12)&uf/ 2003 ckESpfwGif tar&duef Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; aumvif;yg0Jvf. xkwfjyefonf ha=unmcsuf?
(2) ZGefv(5)&ufae@wGif bDbDpDowif;Xmeod k @ ajym=um;csuf?(3) rav;&Sm;uDeD tifwmeufowif;pmESif h awG @qH kar;jref;jcif;?(4) 25-6-2003 &ufae@wGif pDtiftif &kyfjrifoH=um;rS xkwfvGif hcsuf//(5) 15-6-2003 tmpD,H Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;rsm;. xkwfjyefausnmcsuf?(6) 23-6-2003 pwm; tGefvd kif; tifwmeufowif;pmESif h awG @qH kar;jref;cef;(7) Zlvd kifv(6)&ufae@ &ufpG Jyg SPR Strait Time ESif h awG @qH kar;jref;cef;?(8) The Nation News Paper, 21-6-2003 , Radio Free Asia.
(9) zEGrf;yif/ attufzfyD/ 17-6-2003
(10) tif'd keD;&Sm; Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;. ajymcGif h&yk*~ dLvf rpPwm emwmvD0g0g. ajym=um;csuf? 28-6-2003 *sumwmyd k @pf owif;pm/
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 120/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
120
tcef; ( 7 )
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&SifrSxkwfjyefcJhonfh yef-um;csufrsm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 121/208
121
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ jzpfyGm;I oHk;vjynfh+yD;onf hae@wGif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ jzpfyGm;I oHk;vjynfh+yD;onf hae@wGif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ jzpfyGm;I oHk;vjynfh+yD;onf hae@wGif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ jzpfyGm;I oHk;vjynfh+yD;onf hae@wGif'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ jzpfyGm;I oHk;vjynfh+yD;onf hae@wGifjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ed kifiHwumodk @jynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ed kifiHwumodk @jynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ed kifiHwumodk @jynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ed kifiHwumodk @jynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ed kifiHwumodk @
aumfr&Sif. wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHyef=um;csufaumfr&Sif. wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHyef=um;csufaumfr&Sif. wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHyef=um;csufaumfr&Sif. wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHyef=um;csufaumfr&Sif. wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHyef=um;csuf
1? ,ae@onf/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_jzpfyGm;+yD; oH k;v wif;wif;jynf hajrmufonf hae@jzpfonf? 'DyJ,if; vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sifud k/ 2003 ckESpf/ ZGefv(25)&ufae@wGif pwifzG J @pnf;cJ h+yD;/ oufwrf; ESpfvausmfumvtwGif;/ vkyf}uHr_jzpfyGm;pOfu ud k,fwd kifusL;vGefcHcJ h&onf[k xGufqd k=uonf h/ jynfwGif;rS epfemolum,uH&Sif rsufjrifoufao(8)OD;ud k/ vGwfajrmufe,fajra'orsm;od k @ ac:xkwfum/ aumfr&Sifud k,fwd kif pepfwusppfaq;ar;jref; rSwfwrf;wifxm;cJ h+yD;jzpfonf? jynfwGif;rS wd kuf&d kufay;yd k @aom tvm;wloufao(2)OD;. xGufqd kcsufrsm;ud kvnf;/ aumfr&SifrS vufcHxm;+yD;jzpfonf? 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ud k xd kif;txufv$wfawmfrS wqif hurB muodatmif aumfr&Sifu pDpOfxkwfazmfcJ honf? tvm;wl xkwfazmfr_rsdK;ud k tjcm;Ed kifiHrsm;/ v$wfawmfrsm;
wGifvnf; ay:aygufvmEd kifap&ef óud;yrf;v#uf&S donf? Ed kifiHwumvl @tcGif hta&;tzG J @tpnf;rsm;od k @ qufoG,fum/ ‚if;wd k @.tultnDESif h yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_rsm;&&S datmif }udK;yrf;qJjzpfonf? Ed kifiHwumjypfr_qd kif&m w&m;&H k; ay:aygufvmatmif 0d kif;0ef;}udK;yrf;cJ h=uaomtiftm;pkrsm;/ ynm&Sifrsm;. em;vnf pmemaxmufcHr_&&S datmif óud;pm;Ed kifcJ honf?
2? jrefrmEd kifiHta&;ud k ukvor*~ vH kòcHa&;aumifpDrS ta&;,laqmif&Gufvmatmifóud;yrf;&mY/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_rSm vlom;tjzpf touf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_ud k qef @usifusL;vGefaomjypfr_}uD;tjzpf owfrSwfEd kif+yD;Ed kifiHwEd kifiH. tcsLyftjcmtm%m[laom abmifud kausmfvGefI ta&;,laqmif&GufEd kifrnf h taetxm;&S daoma=umih f TrSKcif;}uD;ud k t"duxm; wifoGif;ay;=uyg&ef/ oufqd kifaomEd kifiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ tiftm;pkrsm;/ukvor*~ twGif;a&;rª;csKyf. t}uHay;t&m&S drsm;od k @ tqufrjywfwifjyv#uf &S donf? 2003 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(4)&ufae@wGif/ t*Fvdyfbmomjzif h y%mrtpD&ifcHpmud kwifoGif;cJ honf? yk drd kvufcH&&S dvmaom oufaoxGufqd kcsufrsm;/ taxmuftxm;rsm;tay: tajccHv#uf/ jznf hpGufoH k;oyfr_rsm; jyKvkyfum/ y%mrtpD&ifcHpmud kjrefrmbmomjzif h/ pufwifbmvtwGif; xkwfjyefEd kif&ef óud;yrf;v#uf&S donf? TonfrSm aumfr&Sif.óud;yrf;r_rsm;ud k trsm;jynfol wpH kw&mod&S dEd kif&eftwGuf wifjyjcif;jzpfygonf? Tod k @óud;yrf;cGif h&atmif 0d kif;0ef;tultnDay;=uaom/ um,uH&Sif xdck dufepfemolrsm;/ acgif;aqmifrsm;/ tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ trSefw&m; ay:aygufvmatmif 0d kif;0ef;azmfxkwfay;v#uf&S d=uaom owif;Xmersm;tm; aus;Zl;txl;wif&S dygonf?
3? 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_jzpfyGm;t+yD; aemufwae@rSmyif etzrS owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JjyKvkyf&mY a':atmifqef;
pk=unfESif h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfud k/ vk dvm;axmufcHolrsm;ESif h qef @usifolrsm;t=um;Y jzpfyGm;aom/&kef;&if;qefcwfr_tjzpf &Sif;vif;cJ honf? ,cktcsdeftxdvnf; ,if;od k @ &yfwnf&Sif;vif;aeqJ jzpfonf? tcsdK@aom
The Ad hoc Commission On
Depayin Massacre (Burma) Let's join hands together in promoting global justice by facilitating the efforts of people in Burma
to seek justice for Depayin Massacre.
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 122/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
122
owif;Xmersm;/ owif;axmufrsm;onfyifv#if ,if;od k @aom toH k;tE_ef;rsdK;jzif h wcgw&HoH k;E_ef;ae=uonf?aumfr&Siftaejzif hoH k;oyfwifjyvd konfrSm 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfonf vltkyfpkwckESif h tjcm;wckt=um; a&SmifwcifjzpfyGm;aom &kef;&if;qefcwfr_ 11111 r[kwf/ vltajrmuftrsm;ud k toufqH k;¶H _;apcJ haomvkyf}uHr_}uD;22222 jzpfonf? 'DyJ,if;
&kef;&if;qefcwfjzpfr_ r[kwf/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_33333
twdtusjzpfonf? omrefvlowfr_ r[kwf? pepfwusóudpepfwusóudpepfwusóudpepfwusóudpepfwusóudwifpDpOf+yD;wifpDpOf+yD;wifpDpOf+yD;wifpDpOf+yD;wifpDpOf+yD; 44444 tk HESif h usif;ESif husL;vGefaom &mZ0wfr_}uD;tk HESif h usif;ESif husL;vGefaom &mZ0wfr_}uD;tk HESif h usif;ESif husL;vGefaom &mZ0wfr_}uD;tk HESif h usif;ESif husL;vGefaom &mZ0wfr_}uD;tk HESifh usif;ESif husL;vGefaom &mZ0wfr_}uD; 55555 jzpfonf? usL;vGefcH&ol &m*%ef;tcsdK@ud komru/wEd kifiHvHk;&S d jynfoltm;vH k; xdwfvef@ajcmufjcm;oGm;apcJ honftxd/ oufa&mufr_&S dapcJ h+yD;/ vlom;tjzpfvlom;tjzpfvlom;tjzpfvlom;tjzpfvlom;tjzpftouf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_ud k qef @usifusL;vGefonf h &mZ0wfr_ touf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_udk qef @usifusL;vGefonf h &mZ0wfr_ touf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_ud k qef @usifusL;vGefonf h &mZ0wfr_ touf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_udk qef @usifusL;vGefonf h &mZ0wfr_ touf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_ud k qef @usifusL;vGefonfh &mZ0wfr_ 66666 jzpfonf?
4? aumfr&Siftaejzif h pH kprf;ppfaq;r_ud k pwifonf htcsdefu um,uH&SifusL;vGefcH&ol rsufjrif oufao(4)OD;ud k ppfaq;aomtcg/ usL;vGefolrsm;rSm pkpkaygif;vl(5000)cef @&S da=umif;ESif h/ }uH @zG H @toif;0ifrsm; jzpfEd kifa=umif; xGufqd k=uonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;wef;. aemufwGif/ tjcm;um;rsm;jzif h vd kufygvmaom}uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;rSm vl(1000)cef @&S d+yD;/ vrf;ab;rS ykef;atmif;apmif hqd kif;ae+yD; 0ifa&muf¶d kufESuf=uolOD;a&rSmvl(3000)ausmf (4000)cef @ &S dEd kifa=umif; xGufqd k=uonf? od k @&mwGif tqd kygvl(4000) (5000)tkyf}uD;ud k/pepfwus pDpOfae&mcsxm;n$ef=um;ay;olrsm;rSm rnfolrnf0grsm; jzpfa=umif;/ ‚if;wd k @u xGufqd kEd kifjcif; r&S dacs?qufoG,fa&;pufrsm;ESif h pum;0Sufrsm;toH k;jyKyH kpepfud k avhvmjcif;tm;jzif h/ vufeufud kifwyfzG J @wck ck. }uD;=uyfr_atmufY tqd kyg}uH hzG H @toif;0ifrsm;ESif h/ tjcm; &mZ0wfaumifrsm;usL;vGefcJ haom vkyf}uHr_[lIom oH k;oyf&onf? od k @&mwGif ,ck=o*kwfvtwGif; xyfrHa&muf&S dvmaom rsufjrifoufaorsm;.xGufqd kcsuft&rl/'kwd,owfuGif;ae&mY/ etz ppfwyfrS Ad kvfrª;tqif h&S dolwOD;. OD;aqmifr_atmufY wm0efxrf;aqmifv#uf&S daom/ ,leDazmif;tjynf htpH k0wfqifxm;onf h ppfom;rsm;ESif h &JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;ud k tajrmuftrsm;awG @&S d&a=umif;/‚if;ppfom;rsm;ESif h &Jom;rsm;u a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htzG J @tm;wd kufcd kuf&ef wdwfqdwfpGmapmif hqd kif;ae=u
onf h vl(4000)cef @&S drnf hvltkyf}uD;tm; uGyfuJae=uonfud k awG @&S d&a=umif;xGufqd kxm;=uonf? ,if;xGufqd kcsufrsm;t& 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ud k pepfwuspDpOfn$ef=um; usL;vGefolrSm etzomjzpfa=umif; yd krd kI &Sif;vif;ay:vGifvmayonf?
5? ppf+yD;or#aom oufaotrsm;pk}uD;. xGufqd kcsufrsm;wGif Tr#}uD;rm;aom &mZ0wfr_}uD;ud k azsmufzsufEd kif&ef}udK;pm;aom etz tm%myd kifrsm;.vkyfaqmifcsufrsm;ud k avhvmI&onf? om"utm;jzif h/ armfawmfum;vrf;ay:wGif xifusefcJ haomaoG;rsm;ud k nwGif;csif;a&aq;jcif;/ tavmif;rsm;ud k csufjcif;azsmufzsufypfjcif;/ armfawmfum;csif;wd kufrdonf hyH kpHrsm;jzpfatmif/ acgif;csif;qd kifapv#uf "mwfyH krsm;&d kuf,ljcif;/ eHeuf
vif;aomtcg xGufrajy;Ed kifaom '%f&m&xm;olrsm;ud k tjyif&S daq;&H krsm;od k @ ryd k @bJ/ zrf;qD;I axmifrsm;od k @yd k @jcif;/ usnf&GmESif h&GmeD;csKyfpyfrS rsufjrifoufaojzpfEd kifolrsm;ud k tjcm;ae&mrsm;od k @ twif;t"rR ajymif;a¶$ @apjcif;/ 'DyJ,if;tjzpfqd k;}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I xGufqd kjcif; rjyKyg[/ 0efcHvufrSwfa&;xd k;ap+yD;rS/ zrf;qD;xm;olrsm;tm; axmifrSay;v$wfjcif;/ OD;0if;atmiftm; tmqD,Hacgif;aqmifrsm;xHod k @apv$wf+yD;/ bmr# rjzpfcJ hoa,mifzefwD;xm;aom"mwfyH krsm;ud kjyoum t,H koGif;apjcif;/ typftcwf&yfpJa&;vkyfxm;aom wd kif;&if;om; tzG J @tpnf;rsm;tm; ac:,lt,H koGif; &Sif;vif;r_rsm; vkyfaqmifjcif; ponfwd k @jzpfonf? wzufwGifvnf; etzonfrdrduk d,fwd kif Ed kifiHa&;tajymif;tvJw&yf&yfud k jyKvkyfrnf htoGifrsKd;/ od k @r[kwf Ed kifiHwumrS zdtm;ay;vkyfaqmifr_wckckwGif yl;aygif;yg0ifv#uf/ ,if;tajymif;tvJwGif trSefwu,f yg0ifaqmif&Gufawmhrnf h taetxm;rsKd;ud kjyum/ Ed kifiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ tzG J @tpnf;rsm;tm; tm&H kv$ Jajymif;apv#uf tcsdefqG J+yD;/ 'DyJ,if; vkyf}uH
r_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I/ taxmuftxm;rsm; &SmrawG @awmhbJ/ tcd sef=umvmonfESif htr#S arhaysmufoGm;ap&efzefwD;v#uf&S donf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 123/208
123
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
6? 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;rSm 1990 jynf h/ arva¶G;aumufyG JwGif tEd kif& Ed kifiHa&;ygwDacgif;aqmifrsm;/ ‚if;Ed kifiHa&;ygwDtm; vd kvm;axmufcHonf hjynfolrsm;tay:/ etzrS &ufpufpGm qef @usifusL;vGefonf h &mZ0wfr_}uD;jzpf
onf? 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfv#Of;I/ trSefw&m;ESif h wm0ef&S dr_ud k azmfxkwfta&;,lEd kifjcif; r&S dor#umvywfvH k;/ etzESifh trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyfwd k@t=um;wGif/ ppfrSefaomtrsKd;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;udktdyfruf rufI&Ed kifawmhrnf r[kwfyg? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif htrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfud k/ tjywf qufvufacsr_ef;Ed kifa&;ESif h 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ud k t+yD;wd kifazsmufzsufxm;Ed kifa&;twGufóud;yrf;r_tjzpf/etzonfwd kif;&if;om;acgif;aqmifrsm; tzG J @tpnf;rsm;ud k/ acsmharmhajzmif;zsxm;&ef óud;yrf;v#uf&S donf? wd kif;&if;om;tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ acgif;aqmifrsm;rSwqif h/ awG @qH kaqG;aEG;a&;vrf;a=umif;rsm; zGif hvSpfoGm;rnf[laom/ Ed kifiHa&;rufvH k;ud kjyum tcsdefqG J+yD;/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfv#Of;I/trSefw&m;azmfxkwfay;a&; awmif;qd koHrsm;+idrfoGm;atmif óud;yrf;qJjzpfonf? qufvufóudyrf;rnf h tvm;tvmrsm;vnf; awG @ae&onf?
&? 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;rSm a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf wckwnf;ESif h oufqd kifaomudpP&yfwck r[kwfawmh? wwd kif;jynfvH k;ESif hqd kifaom &ufpufr_}uD;jzpfvmygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfuJ hod k @ urB mh+idrf;csrf;a&;Ed kA,fvfqk&/ urB modxif&Sm;aom yk*~ dKvfwOD;tygt0if/ tjypfrJ hjynfolrsm;ud kyif wurB mvH k;.a&S @arSmufY &ufpufpGm jypfr_usL;vGef&J+yD;/ ,if;od k @usL;vGefr_tay: vl @tzG J @tpnf;u rnfod k @r#ta&;,laqmif¶GufEd kifjcif; r&d S/ vGwf+idrf;cGif h&aernfqd kv#if/ etz tm%myd kifrsm;onf vuf&JZuf&Jjzpfum aemifwGifrnfol @ud k rqd k/ rnfod k @aomEd kifiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm;ud k rqd k/ rnfonf hae&mwGif rqd k/ rnfr# =urf;=uKwfwf&ufpufaomjypfr_rsKd;ud k rqd k/ qufvufusL;vGef&ef 0efav;awmhrnf r[kwfyg? od k @jzpfI/ etzESif h Ed kifiHa&;t&awG @qH kaqG;aEG;+yD;/ trsKd;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;ud k wnfaqmufum 'Drd kua&pDa&;toGiful;ajymif;r_rsm;ud k +idrf;csrf;
aomenf;jzif h azmfaqmifoGm;&ef óud;yrf;r_jzpfpOfwd kif;wGif/ y%mrvd ktyfcsuf 77777 rSm/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I trSefw&m;ESif h wm0ef&S dr_ud k azmfxkwfta&;,laqmif¶Gufay;a&; jzpfoif hygonf?
8? aumfr&Siftaejzif h jynfwGif;jynfyrS 'Drd kua&pDa&;v_yf&Sm;wufºuGol tcsKd @/ vl @tcGif hta&;tzG J @tpnf;tcsKd @/ Ed kifiHa&;tiftm;pktcsdK@ESif h owif;XmetcsdK@wd k @. yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_jzif h wwfEd kifor# óud;pm;v#uf&S daomfvnf;/ ajrmfrSef;oavmuf c&D;ra&muf&S dEd kifao;yg? jynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkESif h Ed kifiHwuma&muf 'Drd kua&pDa&;tiftm;pkrsm;/ wd kif;&if;om;tiftm;pkrsm;. yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_ud k/ ,ckxuf tqrsm;pGm&&S d&ef vd ktyfaeygonf? owif; tcsuftvufrsm;/ oufaoxGufcsufrsm;/ oufaocHcsufrsm;/ ,ckxufyd kI tqrsm;pGm
&&S drSom/ trSefw&m;ud k yd kIjynf hpH kpGmazmfxkwfEd kifygrnf? od k @rSom/ ukvor*~vH kòcHa&;aumifpDod k @ wifoGif;jcif;tygt0if/ Ed kifiHwumwGif xda&mufaomta&;,laqmif&GufrSKrsm; jyKEd kifa&;twGufvnf; enf;vrf;rsm;&Sm}uHEd kifygrnf?
9? aumfr&Siftaejzif h jynfwGif;&S dvlxkw&yfvH k;ESif h Ed kifiHwumod k @/ atmufygtwd kif; yl;aygif; aqmif&Guf=uyg&ef arwWm&yfcHyef=um;ygonf?
(u) xdcd kufepfemaom um,uH&Sifrsm;/ aysmufqH k;v#uf&S dolrsm;twGuf/ rdom;pkrsm;u &J&if hpGmjzif houfqd kif&m &Jpcef;rsm;/ w&m;&k H;rsm;wGif w&m;0iftr_zGif h+yD; wd kif=um;=uyg&ef/ ,if;od k @ qmif&GufEd kifa&;twGuf/Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;/ a&S @aetoif;rsm;rS vd ktyfaomtultnDrsm;ay;=uyg&ef/ wd kifcsufzGif hta&;,laqmif&Guf
&ef&S dv#if/ wd kifcsufrzGif hrD jzpfap/ zGif h+yD;aemuf jzpfap owif;Xmersm;od k @owif;rsm;ay;yd k @=uyg&ef?(c) etz. &Jpcef;/ w&m;&H k;rsm;wGif wd kifcsufzGif h&efr0H h&Jaom/ xdcd kufepfemaom um,uH&Sifrsm;/
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 124/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
124
rsufjrifoufaorsm;on/f rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifxH tao;pdyfxGufqd kcsufrsm; ud k,fwd kifvma&muf ay;tyfjcif;jzif hvnf;aumif;/ tcsKd @ ta&;}uD ;aomoufaorsm;rSm/ rdrdwd k @aumfr&Sif.tultnDjzif h/ Ed kifiHwum Ed kifiHrsm;wGif
oGm;a&mufI/ 'Drd kua&pDEd kifiHrsm;. v$wfawmfrsm;a&S @arSmufwGifvnf;aumif;/ Ed kifiHwumowif;Xmersm;.a&S @arSmufwGifvnf;aumif;/ trSefw&m;ud k wurB mvH k; yd krd kod&S dvmatmif zGif hcsazmfxkwfay;=uyg&ef?
(*) etz. &Jpcef;/ w&m;&H k;rsm;wGifwd kifcsufzGif h&ef r0H h&J/ rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifESif hvufwG J yl;aygif;um/Ed kifiHwumu od&S dvmatmifpGrf;aqmifoGm;Ed kif&efvnf; tcuftcJ&S daom epfemolum,uH&Sifrsm;/ rsufjrifoufaorsm;onf/ jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif;&S d 'Drd kua&pDEd kifiHrsm;rSoH&H k;rsm;/ Ed kifiHwumtzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ Oya'qd kif&mtzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;a&S @arSmufod k @ oGm;a&mufum xGufqd kcsuf tao;pdyfrsm;ud k pmjzif ha&;om;+yD;/rdrd."mwfyH kESif hwuG rSwfwrf;jyKpk vufrSwfa&;xd k;um/ rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifxHta&muf/ enf;rsdK;pH kjzif hyd k @aqmifay;tyf=uyg&ef?
(C) txufygenf;vrf;rsm;twd kif; vkyfaqmif&efyifv#if tcuftcJ&S daom/ epfemol um,uH&Sifrsm;/rsufjrifoufaorsm;onf/ owif;Xmersm;ESif hqufoG,fum/ rdrdwd k @. xGufqd kcsuftjynf htpH kud k toHjzif h ay;tyf=uyg&ef?
(i) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ESif houfqd kifonf h oufaocHtaxmuftxm;/ "gwfyH k/ AG D'D,d k rSwfwrf;/ pm&Gufpmwrf;ESif h tjcm;rSwfwrf;rSwf&mrsm;ud k rdrdwd k @aumfr&Sifvuf0,fod k @a&muf&S donftxd/ enf;vrf;aygif;pH k&Sm}uHIay;yd k @=uyg&ef?
(C) 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfv#Of;I/ trSefw&m;ESif h wm0ef&S dr_ud kazmfxkwfta&;,la&;ud k vd kvm;aom/ jynfwGif; jynfy&S d Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;/ tjcm;ynm&Sifrsm;/ vl @tcGif hta&;tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ tpd k;&rsm;/Ed kifiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ Ed kifiHa&;tzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ vlxktoif;tzG J @rsm;/ 'Drd kua&pDa&; wufºuGvSKyf&Sm;olrsm;onf/ ukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfxH vdyfrlI/ pmjzif ha&;om;ay;ydk @wd kifwef;jcif;/ arwWm&yfcHjcif;tm;jzif h ukvor*~vH kjcHKa&;aumifpDrS/ 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_tay: pH kprf;ppfaq;a&;aumfr&Sifapv$wfEd kifap&efvnf;aumif;/ Ed kifiHwumjypfr_qd kif&mOya'rsm;ESif htnD oif havsmfovd k cH k&H k;rsm;zG J @pnf; ta&;,lvmEd kifap&efvnf;aumif;/ 0d kif;0ef;óud;yrf;ay;=uyg&ef rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifrS av;eufpGm arwWm&yfcHyef=um;tyfygonf?
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_ta&;,laqmif¶Gufa&;aumfr&Sif/2003 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (30)&uf/1365 ckESpf/ awmfovif;vqef; (4)&uf?
For more information, please contact U Aung Htoo, Coordinator, Ad Hoc Commission on Depayin
Massacre. Tel (66) (01) 487 0262 (or) (66) (07) 206 9
( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )( atmufajcrSwfpkrsm; )
1 Riot
2 Massacre
3 Depayin Massacre
4 Premeditated Attack
5 Organized Crime6 Crime Against Humanity
7 Pre-condition
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 125/208
125
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
jrefrmEk difiH vl @tcGif hta&;qdkif&m ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;.jrefrmEk difiH vl @tcGif hta&;qdkif&m ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;.jrefrmEk difiH vl @tcGif hta&;qdkif&m ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;.jrefrmEk difiH vl @tcGif hta&;qdkif&m ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;.jrefrmEk difiH vl @tcGif hta&;qdkif&m ukvor*~ txl;ud k,fpm;vS,f ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;.jrefrmEk difiH c&D;pOfESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfolvlxkod k harwWm&yfcH yef=um;csufjrefrmEk difiH c&D;pOfESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfolvlxkod k harwWm&yfcH yef=um;csufjrefrmEk difiH c&D;pOfESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfolvlxkod k harwWm&yfcH yef=um;csufjrefrmEk difiH c&D;pOfESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfolvlxkod k harwWm&yfcH yef=um;csufjrefrmEk difiH c&D;pOfESif hpyfvsOf;I jynfolvlxkod k harwWm&yfcH yef=um;csuf
1? jrefrmed kifiHY arv(30)&ufae@ 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_}uD;jzpfyGm;+yD;aemuf ig;vausmfr# =umjrif hcJ h+yD jzpfaomf
vnf; etz ppftpd k;&onf wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud k azmfxkwftjypfay;jcif; rjyK&H komru aumfr&Sifw&yf zG J @pnf;apIvlxk wpH kw&mauseyfvufcHatmif o¾meft&yif pH kprf;ppfaq;jcif; tv#Of;r&S dacs? Tr# }uD;rm;aomvkyf}uHr_ud k arv(30)&ufae@ n(12)em&Dcef @wGift+yD;owfusL;vGefcJ h+yD; em&Daygif; (16)em&Dcef ht=um aemuf wae@ naewGifóudwifjyifqifpkaqmif;xm;aom tcsuftvufrsm;ud k ud kifpG JI owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JjyKvkyfjcif;/ etz onf ‚if;&Sif;vif;yG Jyg tcsuftvufrsm;twd kif;om ,ae@tcsdeftxd awmufavsmuf&Sif;vif;aejcif;rsm;rSvG JI rnfod k @r#xl;jcm;wd k;wufvmr_ r&S dajc? TonfrSm 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;Y epfemcHpm;cJ h&olum,uH&Sifrsm;twGuf w&m;r#wr_ud k rsufuG,fjyKjcif;jzpf&H komru vl @tzG J @tpnf;w&yfvH k;. +idrf;csrf;r_/ wnf+idrfr_/ vGwfvyfr_ud k tmrcHcsufay;onf h w&m;Oya' pd k;rd k;a&;tajccHud k ajymifajymifwif;wif; zsufqD;vd kufjcif;jzpfonf?
2? 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_}uD;rSm wd kif;jynftkyfcsLyfa&; ,E W,m;rsm;ud k toH k;jyKI ppftm%myd kifrsm;u ‚if;wd k @a&&Snftm%mwnf+rJa&; &nfrSef;csufjzif h tpDtpOfwus usL;vGefaom t=urf;zufrSK}uD; (State Terror-
ism) jzpfojzif h }uD;rm;+yD; a=umufrufzG,faumif;ayonf? T vkyf}uHr_}uD;eSif hpyfvsOf;I trSefw&m;ud k azmfxkwfum wm0ef&S dolrsm;tm; xd kufonf htm;av#mfpGm ta&;,ljcif; rjyKEk difor#umvywfvH k; ppftm%myd kifrsm;u ‚if;wd k @ tm%mwnfjrJa&;ud k qef @usiftwd kuftcHjyKvmol[k ,lqaom rnfol @ud k rqd k/rnfonf htzG J @tpnf;ud k rqd k 'DyJ,if; vkyf}uHr_xuf yd krd kqd k;&Gm;&ufpufaomt=urf;zufrSKrsm;ud k qufvufusL;vGefum tjyif;txef zdeS dyfawmhrnfrSm taotcsmyif jzpfayonf? od k hjzpfI aemifwGif Tjzpf&yfrsKd; rnfonf htcgwGifr#vl htzG J htpnf;Y xyfrH rjzpfyGm;ap&ef 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;eSif h pyfv#Of;I wurB mvH k;odatmif tjzpfrSefud k
azmfxkwfwifjyum wd kuf&d kuf wm0ef&S dolrsm;tm; ta&;,lcGif h&Ek difapa&;twGuf 0d kif;0ef;óud;yrf;=u&efrSm vlwd kif;rjzpfrae xrf;aqmifoif haomwm0ef jzpfvmygonf?
The Ad hoc Commission On
Depayin Massacre (Burma) Let's join hands together in promoting global justice by facilitating the efforts of people in Burma
to seek justice for Depayin Massacre.
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 126/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
126
3? 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ud k pH kprf;ed kifa&;twGuf urB mhukvor*~tzG J @csKyf}uD;rS vGwfvyfonf h pH kprf;ppfaq;a&;tzG J @ud k apv$wfppfaq;I trSefw&m;ud kazmfxkwfay;&efawmif;qd k=uaom jynfwGif;rS jynfaxmifpkwd kif;
&if;om;vlrsKd;rsm; 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf}uD;ESif h/ v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;/ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;/Ek difiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;ud k rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifrS rSwfwif;wiftyfygonf? od k @&mwGif Tr#ESif h rvH kavmufao;a=umif; wifjyvk dygonf? vlig;axmifcef hu &ufpufpGm usL;vGefcJ h +yD; vl tajrmuftrsm; aoa=u/ b0ysufpD;t}uD;tus,f xdcd kufepfem qH k;±_ H;r_rsm;&S dcJ haomfvnf; vlxkw&yfvH k;eSif h ed kifiHa&;ygwDtzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ vl @tcGif hta&; v_yf&Sm;wufºuGolrsm;. jyefvnfwkef @jyef ta&;,laqmif&Gufr_rSm tm;&avmufbG,f xda&mufr_ r&S dao;yg? ukvor*~ud k,fpm; jrefrmEk difiHESif hpyfv#Of;I vl htcGif hta&; twGuf wm0eft&S dqH k;yk*~ dKvfjzpfaom ygarmuQyifa[;&d k; wywf=umr#vma&mufum vl @tcGif hta&;tajctaersm;ud kavhvmpH kprf;onh ftcsdefwGif atmufygtwd kif; 0d kif;0ef;aqmif&Gufay;=uyg&ef rdrdwd k @aumfr&SifrS tav;teuf arwWm&yfcHwifjytyfygonf?
(u) vmrnh f Ek d0ifbmv (12)&ufae@wGif ukvor*~Y ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;rS jrefrmEk difiH vl @tcGif hta&;tajctaersm;eSif hpyfvsOf;I wifjy&mwGif 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD; ESif hpyfvsOf;I tjynf htpH kwifjycGif h&Ek difa&;twGufrdrdwd k @od&S dxm;aom owif;tcsuftvufrSefor#ud k enf;vrf;rsKd;pH kud ktoH k;jyKI ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;. vuf0,fod k ha&muf&S datmif ay;yd k h=uyg&ef?
(c) ukvor*~ vH kòcHa&;aumifpD taejzif h ‚if;.vkyfyd kifcGif htm%mud ktoH k;jyKv#uf vGwfvyfaompH kprf;ppfaq;a&;aumfr&Sifw&yf zG J hpnf;apv$wfed kifa&;twGuf ygarmuQ yDnJ&d k;rSwqif h ukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csLyfxH wd kuf&d kuf pmjzif ha&;om;ay;yd k hum arwWm&yfcHay;=uyg&ef?
(*) 'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr_}uD;eSif hpyfvsOf;I trSefw&m; azmfxkwfEk dif&ef rdrdwd k @wOD;csif; od k @r[kwf tzG J htpnf;tvk duf óud;yrf;pGrf;aqmifr_rsm;ud k owif;Xmersm;od k hxkwfjyefay;=uyg&ef?
'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHrSK ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHrSK ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHrSK ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHrSK ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHrSK ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&;aumfr&Sifed k0bFmv (1) &uf 2003 ckeSpf
tao;pdyfqufvufod&S dvd kygvS siftao;pdyfqufvufod&SdvdkygvSsiftao;pdyfqufvufod&S dvd kygvS siftao;pdyfqufvufod&SdvdkygvSsiftao;pdyfqufvufod&S dvd kygvS sifaumfr&Sif. Coordinator OD;atmifxl; (66) (01) 487 0262 od k hqufoG,fyg&ef
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 127/208
127
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
The Ad hoc Commission On
Depayin Massacre (Burma) Let's join hands together in promoting global justice by facilitating the efforts of people in Burma
to seek justice for Depayin Massacre.
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ jzpfyGm;I ajcmufvjynfh+yD;onf hae hwGif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ jzpfyGm;I ajcmufvjynfh+yD;onf hae hwGif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ jzpfyGm;I ajcmufvjynfh+yD;onf hae hwGif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ jzpfyGm;I ajcmufvjynfh+yD;onf hae hwGif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ jzpfyGm;I ajcmufvjynfh+yD;onf hae hwGifjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ek difiHwumod k haumfr&Sif.wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHcsufjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ek difiHwumod k haumfr&Sif.wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHcsufjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ek difiHwumod k haumfr&Sif.wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHcsufjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ek difiHwumod k haumfr&Sif.wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHcsufjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;ESif h Ek difiHwumod k haumfr&Sif.wifjycsufESif h arwWm&yfcHcsuf
1? ukvor*~txl;ud k,fpm;vnf ygarmuQ ay:vd kqm*sD,d k yDnJ&d k;onfvl htcGif hta&;tajctaersm; ESif hpyfvsOf;IjrefrmEk difiHod k @ oGm;a&mufpH kprf;+yD;aemuf 2003 ckESpf Ek d0ifbmv(12)&ufae@wGif (58) }udrfajrmuf urB mhukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcH wwd,aumfrDwDod k htpD&ifcHpm wifoGif;&mwGif 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;tay: atmufyguJ @od k @aom ed*H k;csKyfcsufrsKd;ud k jyKvkyfI ,if; jzpf&yf}uD;tm; vGwfvyfpGm pH kprf;ppfaq;r_jyKvkyf&ef vd ktyfa=umif;jzif h wifjyoGm;cJ honf?
“tpd k;&tm%myd kifrsm;u yl;aygif;=uHpnfaqmif&GufwmrsdK; r[kwfv#if 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfjzpfyGm;Ek difp&m r&S dbl;qd konf htcsufud kvufcHEd kifavmufatmifjrifomonf h oufaocHtaxmuftxm;awG &S dae+yDvd k @usaemf ajymEk difw,f”
“ I can say that there is a prima facie evidence that the Depayin incident
could not have happened without the connivance of State agents.”
2? 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ud k usL;vGef&ef óudwifoifwef;yd k @csr_rsm; jyKvkyfjcif;/ vufeufrsm;ud k pepfwusa&G;cs,f ud kifaqmifjcif;/ tcsdefumveSif howfuGif;rsm;ud k pepfwus a&G;cs,fjyifqifum wd kufcd d kufacsrSKef;jcif;/ vuf
eufud kifwyfzG J hrsm;om toH k;jyKavh&S daom trdef hay;enf;pepfrsm;ud k toH k;jyKjcif;/ vkyf=uHrnf hvlOD;a& ig;axmifcef @ud k tuGufusus pDpOfxm;&S dusL;vGefjcif;/ oufaocHtaxmuftxm;rsm;ud k azsmufzsufjcifESif h jyKjyifzefwD;rSKrsm;jyKvkyfjcif;/ rsufjrifoufaorsm;ESif h '%f&m&olrsm;tm; zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;xm;jcif;/owfuGif;ESif h teD;qH k;ae&mwGifAd kvfrª;tqif h&S dol wOD;eSif h 'DyJ,if; &Jpcef;rª;wOD;wd k @ud k,fwd kif vkyf=uHrnf holrsm;tm; }uD;=uyfuGyfuJaeonfud kjrifawG hcJ h&onf h oufaorsm;&S djcif; tp&S daom ta=umif;tcsufrsm;ud k tajccHum 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;rSma':atmifqef;pk=unf tygt0if xd kpOfu twlvd kufygoGm;=uaomtrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;ud ka':atmifqef;pk=unf tygt0if xd kpOfu twlvd kufygoGm;=uaomtrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;ud ka':atmifqef;pk=unf tygt0if xd kpOfu twlvd kufygoGm;=uaomtrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;ud ka':atmifqef;pk=unf tygt0if xd kpOfu twlvd kufygoGm;=uaomtrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;ud ka':atmifqef;pk=unf tygt0if xd kpOfu twlvd kufygoGm;=uaomtrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;ud ktaovkyf=uHum trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J hcsKyf ud k tjywfajcr_ef;vd konf h oabmjzif h pepfwus tpDtpOf&Sd&S dtaovkyf=uHum trsKd;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J hcsKyf udk tjywfajcr_ef;vdkonf h oabmjzif h pepf wus tpDtpOf&S d&S dtaovkyf=uHum trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J hcsKyf ud k tjywfajcr_ef;vd konf h oabmjzif h pepfwus tpDtpOf&Sd&S dtaovkyf=uHum trsKd;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J hcsKyf udk tjywfajcr_ef;vdkonf h oabmjzif h pepf wus tpDtpOf&S d&S dtaovkyf=uHum trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J hcsKyf ud k tjywfajcr_ef;vd konf h oabmjzif h pepfwus tpDtpOf&S d&S dusL;vGefcJhonfh &mZ0wfr_}uD; jzpfonfusL;vGefcJhonfh &mZ0wfr_}uD; jzpfonfusL;vGefcJhonfh &mZ0wfr_}uD; jzpfonfusL;vGefcJhonfh &mZ0wfr_}uD; jzpfonfusL;vGefcJhonfh &mZ0wfr_}uD; jzpfonf [k ig;vausmfr#umvtwGif; rdrdwdk@pHkprf;ppfaq;awG@&Sd&aomowif;tcsuftvufrsm;/ vloufaorsm;.xGufqd kcsufrsm;ud k tajccHum rdrdwd k @aumfr&Siftaejzif h oH k;oyfonf? aumfr&Sif. 'kwd,t}udrf y%mr tpD&ifcHpmud kvnf; r=umrD umvtwGif;rSmyif jynfwGif;&S djynfolrsm;eSif h wurB mvH k;od k hxyfrHjzef @a0um tpD&ifcHwifjyoGm;ygrnf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 128/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
128
3? 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;twGif; aoqH k;/ aysmufqH k;/ '%f&m&/ b0 xdcd kufepfemysufpD;=uonf h yk*~ dKvfOD;a& rSm &0rf'gESif h ,l*d kqvm;AD,m;Ek difiHrsm;rSmuJ hod k h rsm;jym;jcif; r&S daomfvnf; t"duusaom atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k ta=umif;jyKI 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;rSm vlom;tjzpf touf&Sif &yfwnf&Sifoefr_ud k qef @usifonh fjypfr_(Crime Against Humanity) ajrmufed kifa=umif; oH k;oyfawG @&S d&onf?
(u) ajymif;vJvmaom Ed kifiHwumOya'. t"dy` g,fzGif hqd kcsufrsm;t& ppfyG JumvtwGif; usL;vGefonf h ppf&mZ0wfr_rsm;eSif hqufpyfa=umif; jyo&ef rvd kawmhbJ t&yfom;jynfoltajrmuftrsm;ud k qef @usif
usL;vGefonf h jypfr_eSif h tóuH;0ifaejcif;?(The nexus is unnecessary and gross human rights violations in peacetime are as criminal
as those during armed conflict.)
(c) pepfwus óudwifjyifqifum t&yfom;vltkyfpktm; wdwdususypfrSwfxm;I usL;vGefaomjypfr_}uD;jzpfjcif;?
(The second distinguishing feature of crimes against humanity is that they be committed in a
planned, systematic manner insofar as they are directed against a specific 'civilian population' and
not merely random individuals.)
(*) ed kifiHa&; &nfrSef;csufjzif h usL;vGefaom jypfr_}uD;jzpfjcif;?
(For crime against humanity, it must be demonstrated that the defendant targeted the vic-
tims specifically based on their social, political, racial, religious, or other attributes.)
( C) jypfr_usL;vGefcH&onf h vlta&twGufrSm }uD;rm;vSjcif; &S dcsifrS &S drnfjzpfaomfvnf; t&yfom;vlxkw&yfvH k;ud k t}uD;tus,f xdwfvef hajcmufjcm;oGm;ap&ef usL;vGefonf h jypfr_}uD;jzpfjcif;?
( To intimidate the entire 'civilian population')
4? tm%m&Sif tkyfcsKyfr_atmufrS 'Drd kua&pDEk difiHtjzpfod k hEk difiHa&;t& awG @qH kaqG;aEG; oabmwlnDcsufrsm;&,lum toGiful;ajymif;&efóud;yrf;=uaomEk difiHrsm;Y tm%m&Sifrsm;eSif h 'Drd kua&pDEk difiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm; ed kifiHa&;t& rnfod k
hyifoabmwlnD=uonfjzpfap Ed kifiHwum Oya't& atmufyg jypfr_rsm;ud k vGwf+idrf;csrf;omcGif h
ay;yd kifcGif h r&S d/ w&m;Oya'ESif htnD cGif hv$wfcGif h r&S d/ oifykef;acscGif h r&S d/ jypfr_usL;vGef&mY wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud kOya'eSif htnD ta&;,laqmif&Guf=u&rnfjzpfonf?
(1) vlrsKd;wk H;owfjzwfr_ud k tjypfay;jcif;ESif h umuG,fjcif;qd kif&moabmwlnDcsuft& vlrsKd;wkef; owfjzwfr_ (Genocide)
(2) eS dyfpufnOf;yrf;r_ eSif h tjcm;aom&ufpuf=urf;óuwfI vlrqef/ vl h*k%foduQm ud k nd _;EGrf; apaomqufqHr_rsm;ud k qef @usif&ef jypf'%fpD&if&ef oabmwlnDcsuft& eS dyfpufnOf;yrf;r_
(Convention Against Torture)
(3) vlom;tjzpf touf&Sif&yfwnf&SifoefrSKud k qef husifusL;vGefaomjypfr_
(Crime Against Humanity)
(4) (*sDeDAm oabmwlnDcsufud k csdL;azgufusL;vGefaom) ppf&mZ0wfr_ (War Crime)
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 129/208
129
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
r=umao;cifeSpfrsm;twGif; ukvor*~u qDvm&D,Gef; Ek difiHtm; !$ef=um;cJ honf hjzpf&yfrsm;u ,if; tcsufud k oufaocHv#uf&S donf?
5? 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;ESif hpyfvsOf;I wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud k azmfxkwfta&;,l&ef óud;yrf;aqmif&Gufr_rsm;onf(u) rsufarSmufwGifa&m tem*wfumvwGifyg tjypfrJ hEk difiHom;rSefor#ud k Ek difiHtpd k;&u Oya'rJ h
qef @usifusL;vGefrnf h aemufxyf tvm;wljypfr_rsdK; xyfrHjzpfyGm;jcif;r&S dap&ef wm;qD;umuG,fonf hoabma&mufyg onf? (To prevent repeated heinous crimes)
(c) aoqH k;/ aysmufqH k;/ tzrf;tqD;cH&/ b0xdcd kufepfemysufpD;qH k;&_ H;=u&aom tjypfrJ hjynfolrsm;twGuf w&m;r#wr_ &SmazGay;&ma&mufygonf? (Justice for the Victims)
(*) tem*wfvl @tzG J @tpnf;wGif +idrf;csrf;r_/ wnf+idrfr_/ vGwfvyfr_eSif h w&m;r#wr_ud k tmrcHcsuf&&S daprnf h rnfod k @aom wd kif;jynftkyfcsKyfa&;,E W,m;rsm; &S doif honf[laomtcsufrsm;ud k pOf;pm;azmfaqmifvmaped kifygonf? (Institutional Reform)
6? tqd kygta=umif;tcsufrsm;ud k axmufxm;v#uf 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;eSif h pyfvsOf;I aumfr&Siftaejzif hjynfwGif;&S d jynfolvlxkrsm;tm;vH k;eSif h ed kifiHwumod k hatmufygtwd kif;arwWm&yfcH yef=um;tyfygonf?
(u) jrefrmed kifiH 'Drd kua&pDeSif h wd kif;&if;om;tcGif hta&;rsm;twGufóud;yrf;aqmif&Gufv#uf&S d=uaomed kifiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;/ tzG J htpnf;rsm;/ tiftm;pkrsm;rS OD;aqmifum ukvor*~vH kjcHKa&;aumifpDrSaeI'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;eSif h pyfvsOf;+yD; Ek difiHwumpH kprf;ppfaq;a&;aumfr&Sifw&yf apv$wfEk difa&;twGuf óud;yrf;aqmif&Gufay;=uyg&ef?
(c) 'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_}uD;eSif h pyfvsOf;ItrSefw&m;ud k yd krd kjynf hpH kpGm azmfxkwfay;ed kifrnf houfaorsm;/oufaocHtaxmuftxm;rsm;/ owif;tcsuftvufrsm;/ yd krd k&&S da&;Ek difiHwumESif h ukvor*~od k h pepfwuswifjyEk difa&;wk d @twGuf jynfwGif;&S d epfemolum,uH&Sifrsm;/ rsufjrifoufaorsm;/ tcsif;jzpfcsdefwGif &S dae=uaom
jynfolrsm;/ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pD tzG J @csKyfrS tqif hqif haom acgif;aqmifrsm;/ vG $wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;/ Oya'ynm&Sifrsm;/ w&m;r#wr_twGuf v_yf&Sm; wufºuG=uolrsm;onf jynfwGif;&S d Ek difiHwumtzG J @tpnf;rsm;/ jynfwGif;jynfy owif;Xmersm;ESif h yl;aygif;um pkaqmif;ay;yd k @ jzef @a0=uyg&ef?
(*) Ek difiHwum Ed kifiHrsm;Y 'DyJ,if;v_yf&Sm;r_aumfrwD (Depayin Campaign Committee)rsm; zJ G @pnf;aqmif&Gufjcif;tygt0if Ek difiHwumqufoG,fr_uGef,ufrsm;/ jynfwGif;qufoG,fr_uGef,ufrsm; zG J @pnf;wnfaqmufI Ek difiHwum pH kprf;ppfaq;a&;aumfr&Sifw&yfrS 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfrSef}uD; ay:aygufvm+yD; wm0ef&S dolrsm;ud kxd kufonf htm;avsmfpGm ta&;,laqmif&GufvmEk difaponftxd 0d kif;0ef;óud;yrf;=uyg&ef?
'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&; aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&; aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&; aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&; aumfr&Sif'DyJ,if;vkyf=uHr_ta&;,laqmif&Gufa&; aumfr&Sifedk0bFmv (30) &uf 2003 ckeSpfed k0bFmv (30) &uf 2003 ckeSpfedk0bFmv (30) &uf 2003 ckeSpfed k0bFmv (30) &uf 2003 ckeSpfed k0bFmv (30) &uf 2003 ckeSpf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 130/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
130
aemufqufwJ Grsm;
(1) "gwfyH krsm;/'%f&m&olrsm;/ vlaysmuf/aoqH k;olrsm;ESif h armfawmf,mOf pm&if;rsm; --------------------------- ( 130 )( 130 )( 130 )( 130 )( 130 )
(2) trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf.xkwfjyefa=unmcsufrsm; ---------------------------------------- ( 140 )( 140 )( 140 )( 140 )( 140 )
(3) a':atmifqef;pk=unf. owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JESif h2003 ckESpf arv(29)&ufae@n rk H±Gmòrd @wGif ajym=um;onf hrdef @cGef; ---------------- ( 154 )( 154 )( 154 )( 154 )( 154 )
(4) etz . owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jrl&if;rsm; -------------------------------- ( 169 )( 169 )( 169 )( 169 )( 169 )
(5) aZmfaZmfatmif/ ud kausmfvGif/ rE Wav;wk dif; trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyftzJ G @0if trsKd;orD;wOD;wd k @. Ed kifiHwum toHv$if hXmersm;ESif hqufoG,far;jref;csufrsm; -------------------------------------- ( 178 )( 178 )( 178 )( 178 )( 178 )
(6) &efukefwk dif;/ urm±Gwfòrd @e,f trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyf tzJ G @0ifuk dpk d;oef;. oufaoxGufqk dcsuf ---------------------------------- ( 192 )( 192 )( 192 )( 192 )( 192 )
(7) 2003 ckESpf/ Ek d0ifbmv (18)&ufaeŒwGif usif;yaom(58)}udrfajrmuf ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcHrS
jrefrmEk difiH. vlŒtcGif hta&;tajctaeESif h pyfvsOf;IcsrSwfaom qk H;jzwfcsufrsm; -- ( 201 )( 201 )( 201 )( 201 )( 201 )
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 131/208
131
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
a':0if;jrjrrE Wav; (taemufajrmufòrd @e,f)
rE Wav;wk dif; pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0if
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+twGif;Y xdck duf'%f&m& zrf;qD;cH&olrsm;
ol& OD;wifOD;'kwd, OuUÏ
trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKKyf
a':atmifqef;pk=unftaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;
trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ G @csKyf
a':wifjrif h
rE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)pnf;±kH;a&;aumfrwD0if
rcifrrxGef;
rE Wav; (ta&S @ajrmufòrd @e,f)trsKd;orD;tzJ G @0if âââââ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 132/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
132
uk d0if;ck difrE Wav; (taemufajrmufòrd @e,f)
vli,ftzJ G @0if
uk drsKd;Ek difrE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)
rE Wav;wk dif; pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0if
uk dausmfrsKd;ol
rE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)vli,ftzJ G @0if f
uk djrif harmfrE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)
vli,ftzJ G @0if
a'gufwm vSpk d;!Gef @rE Wav;wk dif;/ pOf @uk dif fòrd @e,f
trSwf(1) jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 133/208
133
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
uk dvSOD;
rE Wav; (taemufajrmufòrd @e,f)pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0if
uk drsKd;wif h
rE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)vli,ftzJ G @0if
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+twGif;Y xdck duf'%f&m& zrf;qD;cH&olrsm;
OD;xGef;0if;rE Wav; (aps;csKd f)
OD;cifarmifaomif;
rE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0if
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 134/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
134
armifpk d;
rE Wav; (ta&S @awmifòrd @e,f)xGefwk H;òrd @opf
uk drif;vGifrE Wav; (taemufawmifòrd @e,f)
vli,fpnf;±k H;a&;wm0efcH
OD;wifatmifatmifrE Wav;wk dif; taemufajrmufòrd @e,f
trSwf(1)rJqENe,fajr
jynfol @v$wfawmf uk d,fpm;vS,f
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+twGif;Y xdck duf'%f&m& zrf;qD;cH&olrsm;
uk dausmfausmfrk d;rE Wav; (taemufajrmufòrd @e,f)
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 135/208
135
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+twGif;Y xdck duf'%f&m& zrf;qD;cHcJ h&onf htrsKD;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ GŒ csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL; a':atmifqef;pk-unf.
teD;uyfvk HòcHa&;tzJ GŒ 0ifrsm;xJrS tcsKdŒ
uk dxGef;jrif h&efukefwk dif; (A[ef;òrd @e,f)
twGif;a&;rª;A[k dvk HòcHa&;tzJ G @0if
uk djrif hausmf&efukefwk dif; (wmarGòrd @e,f)
pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0ifA[k dvk HòcHa&;tzJ G @0if
uk dxGef;aZmfaZmf
tzJ G @csKyf A[k dvli,fA[k dvk HòcHa&; wm0efcH
uk dwk d;vGif
vli,fwm0efcH{&m0wDwk dif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 136/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
136
uk dodef;pk d;&efukefwk dif; (&efuif;òrd @e,f)
pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0ifA[k dvk HòcHa&;tzJ G @0if
uk doef;xGef;&efukefwk dif; (urm±Gwfòrd @e,f)
pnf;±k H;a&;aumfrwD0if
A[k dvkHòcHa&;tzJ G @0if
uk drk d;aomf (ac: ) aygufayguf
A[k dvli,f vk HòcHa&;tzJ G @0if
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+twGif;Y xdck duf'%f&m& zrf;qD;cHcJ h&onf htrsKD;om;'Drk dua&pDtzJ GŒ csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL; a':atmifqef;pk-unf.
teD;uyfvk HòcHa&;tzJ GŒ 0ifrsm;xJrS tcsKdŒ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 137/208
137
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ t wG i f ; a o q Hk ; oG m ; = u
ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ t wG i f ; a o q Hk ; oG m ; = u
ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ t wG i f ; a o q Hk ; oG m ; = u
ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ t wG i f ; a o q Hk ; oG m ; = u
ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ t wG i f ; a o q Hk ; oG m ; = u
ol r s m ; ?
p O f ? p O f ? p O f ? p O f ? p O f ? t r n f
t r n f
t r n f
t r n f
t r n f
w m 0 e f w m 0 e f w m 0 e f w m 0 e f w m 0 e f
a e & y f a e & y f a e & y f a e & y f a e & y f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
1 ? O D ; w i f a r m i f O D ;
" g w f y Hk q & m
yG J c s i f ; + y D ; a o q Hk ;
2 ? u dk o d e f ; w dk ; a t ;
yG J c s i f ; + y D ; a o q Hk ;
3 ? u dk p e f ; j r i fh ( c ) & m * s L ;
, m O f a r m i f ;
yG J c s i f ; + y D ; a o q Hk ;
4 ? O D ; xG e f ; a t
m i f a u s m f
a u s m i f ; q & m
r Hk ¶G m
t c i f ; j z p f p O f u & ¶S d c Jh o n fh ' % f & m r s m ; t m ; a q ; 0 g ; uk o
a e p O f p u f w i f b m v q e f ; y dk i f ;
wG i f uG ,
f vG e f
rS w f c s u f ?
? p m & i f ; t & w & m ; 0 i f v dk u f y g oG m ; o
l r s m ; x J rS a o q Hk ; ol p m
& i f ; j z p f y g o n
f ? r EW a v ; rS t c i f ; j z p f a e & m t x d v
r f ; c & D ; w a v # m u f rS v dk u f y g c Jh ol r s m ; /
a ' : a t m i f q
e f ; pk = u n f ES i fh t zG J@ t m ; v m a & m u f q D ; } u d K E_ w f q u f = u o n fh a ' o c H j y n f o
l r s m ; / t c i f ; j z p f yG m ; p O f wG i f t
= u r f ; z u f ¶ dk u f ES u f o w f j z w f c H c Jh & o j z i fh a o q
Hk ; ol
t a j r m u f t
r s m ; ¶S d y g o n f ? r d r d w dk @ a u m f r ¶S i f t a e
j z i fh v u f vS r f ; r r
D o j z i fh t w d t u s p m & i f ; a u m u f ,l & e f t c u f t c J ¶S d y g o n f ? q u f oG , f p Hk p r
f ; a e q J j z p f o j z i fh
w d u s a o c s m
o n fh p m & i f ; r s m ; & ¶S d o n
fh t c g j z n fh pG u f I q
u f v u f p m & i f ; xk w
f j y e f oG m ; r n f j z p f y g o n f ?
uk d o
d e f ; wk d ; a t
;
r EW a v
; ( t a e m u f a w m i f ò r d@ e , f )
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 138/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
138
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ wG i f z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; c H c Jh & ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ wG i f z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; c H c Jh & ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ wG i f z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; c H c Jh & ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ wG i f z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; c H c Jh & ol r s m ; ?
' D y J , i f ; vk y f } u
H r_ wG i f z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; c H c Jh & ol r s m ; ?
p O f ? p O f ? p O f ? p O f ? p O f ? t r n f
t r n f
t r n f
t r n f
t r n f
w m 0 e f
w m 0 e f
w m 0 e f
w m 0 e f
w m 0 e f
a e & y f a e & y f a e & y f a e & y f a e & y f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
rS w f c s u f
1 ?
a ' : a t m i f q e f ; pk = u n f
t a xG a xG t
wG i f ; a & ; rª ;
w uU o
dk v f & d y f o m v r f ; / & e f uk e f + r d K @ ? t c i f ; j z p f yG m ; + y D ; a e m u f
t i f ; p d e f t u s O f ; a x m i f wG i f x d e
f ; o d r f ; x m ; & m
rS p p f a x m u f vS r f ; a & ; p c e f ; w ck wG i f a j y m
i f ; a ¶$ @
c s K y f a ES m i
f x m ; c Jh + y D ; / x d e f ; o d r f ;
x m ; p O f cG J p d w f uk o
r_ c H ,l & e f v dk t
y f v m
o j z i fh t m ¶S a w
m f 0 i f a q ; ¶ Hk wG i f w u f a & m u f
cG J p d w f uk o r_ c H ,l c Jh + y D ; a e m u f , ck t c g
w uU o dk v
f & d y f o m v r f ; a e t d r f wG i f a e
t d r f
t u s , f c s K y f c s x m ; j c i f ; c H a e & y g o
n f ?
2 ?
O D ; oG ,
f
+ r d K @ e , f p n f ;
t a e m u f a j r m u f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
3 ?
O D ; a t m i f u dk
+ r d K @ e , f p n f ;
t a e m u f a j r m u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a
x m i f rS j y e f vG w f
4 ?
u dk o d e f ; a t m i f
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a j r m u f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
5 ?
u dk a t ; 0 i f ;
vl i ,
f
xG e f wk H ; + r d K @ o
p f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
6 ?
u dk p dk ; p dk ;
vl i ,
f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
7 ?
u dk a u s m f a t m i f
t wG i f ; a &
; rª ;
t a e m u f a j r m u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a
x m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
8 ?
u dk a u s m f r s d K ; ol
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a w m i f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 139/208
139
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
9 ? u dk r s d K ; w i fh
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
1 0 ? u dk 0 À a t m i f
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
1 1 ? u dk vS r dk ; 0 i
f ;
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
1 2 ? u dk & J r i f ; a Z m f ( z dk ; a Z m f )
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
1 3 ? r c i f j r 0 i f ;
+ r d K @ e , f p n f ;
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
1 4 ? a ' : w i f j r i fh
+ r d K @ e , f p n f ;
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
1 5 ? u dk a t m i f a t m i f
vl @ a b
m i f o
p f
1 2 - 6 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f / j y n f y xG u f cG m v m
1 6 ? u dk E dk i f E dk i f
vl @ a b
m i f o
p f
1 2 - 6 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f / j y n f y xG u
f cG m v m
1 7 ? u dk r s d K ; r i f ;
vl i , f
t a e m u f a j r m u f
1 2 - 6 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
1 8 ? a ' : 0 i f ; j r j r
w dk i f ; p n f ; t
zG J@ 0 i f
1 3 - 1 0 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f e r
c p p f a q ; ¶ Hk rS a ¶$ b dk a x m i f o dk @ y dk @
1 9 ? O D ; p d e f & D
, m O f a r m i f ;
1 2 - 6 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
2 0 ? O D ; vS O D ;
t wG i f ; a & ;
rª ;
9 - 1 1 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
2 1 ? u dk o e f ; xG e f ; O D ;
vl i ,
f
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
2 2 ? u dk a t m i f E dk i f
vl i ,
f
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
2 3 ? u dk xG e f ; xG e f ; 0 i
f ;
vl i ,
f
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
2 4 ? r c i f r r xG e f ;
vl i ,
f
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
2 5 ? r 0 i f ; t d j z L
vl i , f
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
2 6 ? O D ; vS j r i
fh
O uU X
t r & yl &
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x
m ;
2 7 ? u dk 0 i f ; c dk i f
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a j r m u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
2 8 ? u dk n D n D a t m i f
vl i ,
f
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
2 9 ? u dk a Z , s m xG e f ;
vl i ,
f
t a e m u f a w m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
3 0 ? O D ; & J j r i fh a t m i f
O uU X
t a ¶S @ a j r m
u f
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x
m ;
3 1 ? O D ; b m b m
O uU X
p p f u dk i f ; w dk i f ;
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x
m ;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 140/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
140 3 2 ? O D ; xG e f ; + r d K i f
t wG i f ; a & ;
rª ;
p p f u dk i f ; w dk i f ;
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
3 3 ? O D ; a p m v d_ i f
v$ w
f a w m f u dk , f p m ; vS ,
f
t i f ; a w m f + r d K @ e , f r J q EN e ,
f
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
3 4 ? O D ; j r i fh = u n f
v$ w
f a w m f u dk , f p m ; vS , f
u o m + r d K @ e , f r J q EN e ,
f
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
3 5 ? O D ; xG e f ; a ¶S m i
f
+ r d K @ e , f p n f ;
r Hk ¶G m + r d K @
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x m
i f rS j y e f vG w f
3 6 ? O D ; a t m i f q e f ;
O uU X
bk w v i f
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
3 7 ? O D ; a o m i f ; nG e f@
, m O f a r m i f ;
t a ¶S @ a w
m i f
1 2 - 6 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w f
3 8 ? O D ; j r i fh O D ;
p n f ; t zG J@ 0 i f
t a ¶S @ a w
m i f
2 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x m
i f rS j y e f vG w
f
3 9 ? O D ; o e f ; a X ;
p n f ; t zG J@ 0 i f
t a ¶S @ a w
m i f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
4 0 ? O D ; w i f xG É f O D ;
v$ w f a w m
f u dk , f p m ; vS , f
v , f a 0 ; + r d K @ e , f r J q EN e ,
f
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
4 1 ? u dk w i f v i f ;
vl i , f
t a e m u f a j r m u f
1 8 - 7 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
4 2 ? u dk a u s m f Z i f 0 i f ;
t zG J@ c s K y f vl i ,
f
A [ dk vl i ,
f v Hk + c H K a & ;
a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
4 3 ? u dk a w Z E dk i f
t zG J@ 0 i f
t x u f j r e f r m j y n f vl i ,
f j y e f v n f zG J@ p n f ; a & ;
9 - 1 1 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk
a x m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
4 4 ? O D ; a t m i f p dk ;
w dk i f ; p n f ; t
zG J@ 0 i f
r EW a v
; w dk i f ;
9 - 1 1 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f a ¶$ b dk a x
m i f rS j y e f vG w
f
v m c Jh + y D ; / a e m u f w a e@ wG i f & J p c e f ;
rS
j y e f v n f z r f ; q D ;
4 5 ? ol & -
O D ; w i f O D ;
'k w d , O uU X
t r s d K ; o m ; ' D r dk u a & p D t zG J@ c s K y
f A [ dk t vk y f t
r_ a q m i f t zG J@
u a v ; a x m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x
m ;
4 6 ? O D ; a y g c i f
v$ w
f a w m f u dk , f p m ; vS ,
f
j r i f ; + c H + r d K @ e , f r J q EN e ,
f t rS w f ( 1 ) u a v ; a x m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x
m ;
4 7 ? O D ; w i f a t m i f a t m i f
v$ w
f a w m f u dk , f p m ; vS ,
f
r EW a v
; t a e m u f a j r u f + r d K @ e , f r J q EN e ,
f t rS w f ( 1 ) u a v ; a x m i f Y
z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x m ;
4 8 ? a ' g u f w m - 0 i f ; a t m i f O uU X
c i f O D ; + r d K @ e , f
u a v ; a x m i f Y z r f ; q D ; x d e f ; o d r f ; x
m ;
4 9 ? u dk xG e f ; a Z m f a Z m f
A [ dk vl i , f j y e f v n f zG J@ p n f ; a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS 1 3 - 1 1 - 0 3 & u f a e@ wG i f j y e f vG w
f
5 0 ? u dk xG e f ; j r i
fh
+ r d K @ e , f t w
G i f ; a & ; rª ;
A [ e f ; + r d K @ e , f
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 1 ? u dk w dk ; vG i f
i yk a w
m + r d K @ e , f
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w f a j r m
u f
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 141/208
141
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
5 2 ? u dk a Z m f 0 i f ; xG e f ;
vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
r EW a v
;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 3 ? u dk r s d K ; a Z m f a t m i f
vl i , f t zG J@ 0 i
f
a u m v i f ; + r d K @
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 4 ? u dk r i f ; vG i f
vl i , f t zG J@ 0 i
f
& e f uk e f + r d K @
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w f a j r m
u f
5 5 ? u dk j r i fh a iG
vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
a & e H a c s m i f ; + r d K @
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 6 ? u dk o e f ; xG e f ;
vl i , f t zG J@ 0 i
f
A [ dk vl i ,
f v Hk + c H K a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 7 ? u dk r dk ; a Z m f ( c ) a y g u f a y g u f vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
A [ dk vl i ,
f v Hk + c H K a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 8 ? u dk o e f ; xG e f ;
vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
A [ dk vl i ,
f v Hk + c H K a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
5 9 ? u dk r s d K ; r i f ; ( c ) w i f r s d K ; r i f ; vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
r EW a v
;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
6 0 ? u dk o D [
vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
r EW a v
;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w f a j r m
u f
6 1 ? u dk j r i fh a u s m f
vl i , f t zG J@ 0 i
f
A [ dk vl i ,
f v Hk + c H K a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
6 2 ? u dk a u s m f p dk ; v i f ;
vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
r EW a v
;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
6 3 ? u dk a t m i f a u s m f j r i fh
vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
r EW a v
;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w f a j r m
u f
6 4 ? u dk r s d K ; nG e f@
vl i , f t zG J@ 0 i
f
A [ dk vl i ,
f v Hk + c H K a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
6 5 ? u dk o u f xG e f ; ( c ) uk v
m ; vl i ,
f t zG J@ 0 i
f
A [ dk vl i , f v Hk + c H K a & ;
c EW D ; a x
m i f rS ( 2 / 1 2 / 2 0 0 3 ) wG i f vG w
f a j r m u f
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 142/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
142
trd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrSwf(97§c) taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf(97§c) taemufa&$*Hkwd kifvrf;trSwf(97§c) taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf(97§c) taemufa&$*Hkwd kifvrf;trSwf(97§c) taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;
A[ef;òrd @e,f&efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f&efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f&efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f&efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f&efukefòrd @
a=unmcsuftrSwf- 4 (6§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf- 4 (6§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf- 4 (6§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf- 4 (6§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf- 4 (6§98)
1? trd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J@csKyfonf w&m;0ifrSwfyH kwifI/ w&m;0if&yfwnfaeo!f h Ed kifiHa&;ygwDtzG J@tpnf;jzpfayonf? od k @ygojzif h tzG J @csKyf ----- Ed kifiHa&;ESif hywfoufIvkyfaqmifcsufrsm;onfvnf; w&m;0ifudpPjzpfayonf?
2?vli,frsm;tm;A[kokwwd k;yGm;ap&efESif hynmay;&ef a':atmifqef;pk=unf +cH0if;wGif ESpfywfwpf}udrfðyvkyfaeus pmzwf0d kif;ðyvkyfjcif;ud k 25-6-98 &ufae@wGif pDpOfxm;onf? ‚if;pmzwf0d kif;wGif v$wfawmfud k,fpm;
vS,f(4)OD;tygt0if/ vli,f(48)OD;cef@0ifa&muf&ef/ 24-6-98 &ufae@uwnf;u trnfpm&if;ESifhwuGa':atmifqef;pk=unf+cH0if;rSaxmufvSrf;a&;rsm;ud k/ óudwif----------------------------?
3? 25-6-98 &ufae@vnf(13;00)em&Dcef @Y xd kyk*~ dKvfrsm; oGm;a&muf&mwGifwuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;ay:&S da':atmifqef;pk=unf+cHod k@ t0iftxGufud kppfaq;avh&S daom vH kòcHa&;*dwfrS oufqd kif&mtm%mydkifrsm;.vH kòcHa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;u r0if&efwm;qD;onf? xd kvH kòcHa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;u tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k vltkyfjzif hwGef;xkwf=uonf? xd k @a=umif htzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifrsm;onf urB mat;apwDvrf;ESif hwuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;axmif h&S d rD;yd GKif hteD;od k @pnf;urf;pepfwusjzif h -------a&muf&S doGm;=uonf?
4? TudpPESif hywfoufI 'kwd,OuUX OD;wifOD;ESif h taxGaxGtwGif;a&;r_;a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @od&S d+yD;xd krD;yd GKif hteD;txd oGm;a&muf=uum/ pmzwf0d kif;od k @vmol tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k pepfwusac:aqmifoGm;onf?
5? tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k vH kòcHa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;u tqif hqif hwm;qD;+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unf.tdrfteD;rlvwef;aus mif;a&S @od k @ ta&mufwGif rnfonf h &kef;&if;qefcwfESif hyÉdyujzpfyGm;jcif;vH k; 0r&S dbJ “bmacgif;aqmifvJ &k dufuGm” “acgif;aqmifawG bmawG em;rvnfbl;/ tJ'Dacgif;aqmifyg &d kuf”[k rd kuf&d kif;&d kif;ajym+yD; &d kuf=u&ef/trdef @ay;onf[k=um;od&onf? &d kuf=u&eftrdef @ay;olrSm tom; ðzðzt&yfawmifarmif;armif;--0wfxm;ol(vljrifv#if rSwfrdol)/ t&yf0wf 0wfxm;olwpfOD;jzpfonf[k =um;od&onf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 143/208
143
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
6? xd ktcgvH kòcHa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm;u teD;&S dukuU dKud kif;/ opfud kif;/ eHygwfwkwfrsm;jzif h oJoJrJrJ0ifa&muf&d kufESuf=uonf? pkpkaygif;&d kufESufjcif;ud kcH=u&ojzif h/ tzG J @csKyfvli,f(4)OD;. OD;acgif;ESif htjcm;ae&mrsm;wGif '%f&mrsm;&&S d=uonf[k =um;od&onf? &d kufESufjcif;cH&o!f hae&monf tm%myd kifae&mjzpfI tjcm; rnfolwpfOD;wpfa,mufr# r&S day?
&? xd kowif;ud k&&S dojzif h tzG J @csKyfOuUXESif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0if vli,f(3)OD;wd k @ tcsif;jzpfyGm;&m
ae&mod k @csufjcif;vd kufoGm;=u&m tm%myd kifwd k @u vH kòcHa&;*dwfrSwm;qD;+yD; vH k;0 0ifcGif hrðycJ hay?
8? =um;od&o!f howif;rsm;t& a':atmifqef;pk=unfwGiftenf;i,f'%f&m&&S da=umif;ESif h OD;wifOD;ESif ha':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @onf +cH0if;xJod k @ r0ifbJ/ tcsif;jzpfyGm;onf h 25-6-98&ufae@ (14;00)em&Dcef @rS pI/,ae@ 26-6-98 &ufae@eHeuf(09;00) em&Dcef @txd/ rd k;xJa&xJ xd kae&mYyiftm%myd kifwd k @. vH kòcHa&;wyfzG J @0ifrsm; 0d kif;&Hvsuf&S daeonf?
9? rdrdwd kif;jynfwGifjzpfay:aevsuf&S do!f h Ed kifiHa&;/ pD;yGm;a&;/ vlr_a&;t=uyftwnf;rsm;ud k/ txufyg
uJhodk@&dkufESufjcif;ESifh zrf;qD;jcif;/ tusOf;uscHapjcif;tp&Sdo!fhenf;vrf;rsm;udktoHk;jyKjcif;tm;jzifh vH k;0ajz&Sif;Ed kifrnf r[kwfay?
A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzGJ @trd sK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&efukefòrd @
1360 jy!f hESpf/ ewfawmfvqef;(3)&uf1998 ckESpf/ ZGefv (26)&uf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 144/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
144
trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwdkifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwdkifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;
A[ef;òrd@e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd@e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @
a=unmcsuftrSwf - 18 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 18 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 18 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 18 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 18 (7§98)
1? trsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J @csKyf. taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf/ A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifwOD;ESif h tzG J @ud k/ tm%myd kifrsm;u ,refae@ (29-7-98)&ufae@n (21;50)em&Dcef @wGif/ wm;qD; ydwfyifxm;onf h tnmpkESif h yefwd kif&GmteD;ae&mrS/ vH kòcHa&;wyfzG J @tiftm;ud koH k;I t=urf;zufaomenf;jzif h tEd k fiftxufðycsKyfaESmif+yD;/ armfawmf,mOftwGif;od k @oGwfoGif;v#uf/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. oabmxm; qENvH k;0 rygbJ/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;.aetdrfod k @ twif;t"rRjyefyd k @cJ h=uygonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. armfawmf,mOfud kvnf;/ tm%myd kifwd k @u taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª. cGif hðycsuf r&S dbJ/ ‚if;wd k @bmom armif ;ESifcJ h=uygonf?
2? usef A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifwOD;ESif h tzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if(2)OD;wd k @ud kvnf; tm%myd kifwd k @.armfawmf,mOfrsm;twGif;od k@ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;enf;wl t=urf;zufaomenf;jzifh tEdkiftxufðy cskyfaESmifI/tm%myd kifwd k @uoGwfoGif;=ujyD;/ twif;t"rRac:aqmifvmcJ h=uygonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif htzG J @ud k/tEd kiftxufðyI ac:aqmifvmcJ h=uonf h armfawmf,mOfrsm;toD;oD;xJwGifvnf;/ tm%myd kifwd k @. wm0ef&S dyk*d ~Kvfrsm;ESif h vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;om&S d=uygonf?
3? tm%myd kifwd k @u Tod k @&d kif;jypGmqufqHaqmif&Gufjcif;rsm;onf/ &mZ0wfruif;aom tEd kiftxufðyjcif;/ vufa&mufr_usL;vGefjcif;wd k @jzpfygojzif h trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfu av;av;eufeuf jyif;jyif;xefxefuef @uGuf¶_wfcsvd kufonf?
A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf
&efukefòrd @1360 jynf hESpf/ 0gacgifvqef; (7) &uf/1998 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (30) &uf?
rSwfcsuf?rSwfcsuf?rSwfcsuf?rSwfcsuf?rSwfcsuf? ????? aemufqH k;owif;t&/ yxrwm;qD;cH&onf hae&mrS (4)rd kifcef @uGma0;onf h tnmpkESif hyefwd kif&GmteD;wGif/ 'kwd,t}udrf xyfrHwm;qD;xm;onf[k owif;&&S dygonf? qufvuf jzpfay:vmrnf h tajctaersm;ud kapmif h=unf hI/ tzG J @csKyfu vd ktyfovd kqufvufta&;,l aqmif&GufoGm;rnfjzpfyga=umif;?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 145/208
145
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
trsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J@csKyftrsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J@csKyftrsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J@csKyftrsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J@csKyftrsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG J@csKyftrSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*Hkwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*Hkwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&$*Hkwd kifvrf;
A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd@A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd@A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd@a=unmcsuftrSwf - 20 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 20 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 20 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 20 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 20 (7§98)
1? trsdK;om;'Drdkua&pDtzG [email protected];a&;rSL; a':atmifqef;pk =unfESifh A[dktvkyftr_aqmifwOD;wd k @onf/ at;csrf;wnfjidrfpGmjzif h/ ykodrfòrd @od k @ 24-7-98 &ufae@eHeuf (09;05)em&Dcef @ wGifarmfawm,mOfjzif hc&D;xGufcJ h=uygonf?
2? Tod k @c&D;xGufcJ h&jcif;.&nf&G,fcsufrSm/ vl @b0wGif tvGefw&mtqif htwef;edrf hvSjyD; raumif;qH k;aomtoufarG;0rf;a=umif ;jzifhjypfr_usL;vGefavh&Sdolrsm;twGufom&nf&G,fIjyXmef;xm;aom Oya'jzifh/tzG J @csKyfrS*k%foa&oduQm&S dvSonf h jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;tm;/ vl @*k%foduQmud k wrifoufoufcsdK;ES drf ES drf hcspGmzrf;qD;ta&;,lxm;aoma=umih f xk djynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm; ESif h‚if;wd k @.rdom;pkrsm;ud ktm;ay;pum;ajym=um;&eftwGufjzpfygonf? TonfrSm jrefrmh,Ofaus;r_ xH k;wrf;pOfvmt&vnf;aumif;/tzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;.wm0efESif h0wW&m;rsm;t&vnf;aumif;/ c&D; oGm;=u&jcif;jzpfygonf?
3? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;ESif htzG J @u/ qlylvd kaomqENvH k;0 r&S dbJ at;csrf;wnf+idrfpGmjzif h c&D;xGuf=u&mwGif/ awG @óuHcJ h&aomjzpfpOfrsm;rS t"dutcsufrsm;rSmatmufygtwd kif;jzpfygonf? ‚if;jzpfpOfrsm;rSm oufqd kif&mum,uH&Sifrsm;ud k,fwd kifawG @óuHcHpm;cJ h&aom ajym=um;csufrsm;jzpfygonf?
(1) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;ESif htzG J @tm; 24-7-98 &ufae@eHeuf (10;15)em&Dcef @wGif/ anmifwkef;òrd @.ta&S @buf(15)rd kif/ (24)uDvd krDwmcef @uGma0;onf htnmpk&GmteD;Y tm%myd kifwd k @u oHql;óud;wef;rsm;/ vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;jzif h wm;qD;ydwfqd k @xm;=uonf? vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;jzif h armfawmf,mOfud k0d kif;&Hxm;=uonf?armfawmf,mOfud kteD;&S d acsmif;ul;opfom; wHwm;uav; ay:od k @eHeuf(10;42)em&Dcef @wGif rIvnf;aumif;/wGef;I vnf;aumif;/ a&$ @xm;=uonf?
(2) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;.um;bD; (4)bD;vH k;tm;/ wqif hcHb&dwfrsm;jzif h tm%myd kifwd k @u csKyfxm;vd kufonf? wHwm;xdyfvrf;ay:wGif 4u§9518 'd kifemum;wpD;jzif h ydwfqd k @xm;onf? eHeuf (11;30)cef @wGif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 146/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
146
y§3614 wDtD; - 11 um;}uD;jzif h xyfI ydwfqd k @xm;+yD;/ 'd kifemum;ud k z,fvd kufonf?(3) nae (16;05)em&Dcef @wGif &Jrª;csKyfatmifEG,fESif h 'k-&JrSL;(1)OD;wd k @ a&mufvm+yD; um;wHcg; ud kacgufonf?
um;wHcg;ud ktwif;qG JzGif @onf? tvGef¶k dif;jyonf hyH kpHjzif hðyrlqufqHonf? yJcl;wd kif; rif;vSòrd @ESif h {&m0wDwd kif;
yef;waemfòrd @c&D;pOfrsm;uJ hod k @ csufjcif;tajzxkwfay;Ed kifrnf htqif h&S dol r[kwfonf htjyifqufqHa&;¶k dif;jyr_a=umif htaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;u zGif h ray;cJ hjcif;jzpfonf?(4) ,if;wHwm;av;.aemufwGif oHql;óud;acGrsm;jzif h n(19;10)em&Dcef @Y xyfqif hum&H xm;vd kufonf?
wHwm;xdyfwGif ,leDazgif;0wfvH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;tiftm;jzif hywfqd k @xm;onf? ,if; oHql; óud;acGrsm;ud k 26-7-98 &ufae@wGif tm%myd kifwd k @u oHwrefrsm;/ ppfoHrSL;rsm;eSif h owif;axmufrsm;tm; ac:,ljyocgeD;rSóudwifz,f&Sm;xm;=uonf? vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;onf vnf; ,leDazgif;0wfrS t&yf0wfod k @ajymif;vJxm;=uonf?
(5) 25-7-98 &ufae@eHeuf (08-33)em&Dcef @wGif - 24-7-98 &ufae@u wyfqifxm;cJ haom wqif hcHb&dwfrsm;ud k ðzwfoGm;=uonf? eHeuf (10;52)em&Dcef @wGif armfawmf,mOfa&S @wGif vrf;&Sif;aoma=umif h ykodrfbufod k @armfawmf,mOfud karmif;xGufpOf vrf;v,fYvH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;u xyfrHwm;qD;=ujyefonf? eHeuf(10;54)em&Dcef @wGif vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;u vrf;ay:rS armfawmf,mOfud k acsmif;ul;wHwm;av;ay:od k @ jyefIwGef;a&$ @xm;=uonf?
(6) vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifwOD;ua&oef @bl; wbl;ud k taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif htzG J @tm; 0,fay;onf?xd kvH kòcHa&;tzG J @0iftm; aemufae@rsm;wGif armfawmf,mOfteD;Y wm0efcsxm;jcif; r&S donfud kawG @&onf/
(7) 26-7-98 &ufae@eHeuf (06;52)em&Dcef @wGif armfawmf,mOfud k ykodrfbufod k @ armif;xGufpOf vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;uoHql;óud;acGrsm;jzif hqG JIydwf+yD; wm;qD;=ujyefonf?eHeuf (07;04)em&Dcef @wGif vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;u armfawmf,mOfud k wHwm;ay:od k @wGef;Y a&$ @xm;=ujyefonf?
(8) eHeuf (08;00)em&Dcef @wGif aomufa&oef @bl;oGm;0,f&m tm%myd kifwd k @u “txuftrdef @ t&”
[kqd k+yD; 0,fcGif h rðy=uyg?(9) eHeuf (08;50)em&Dcef @wGif wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;rS Ad kvfrª;&efEd kif[k qd kolu “ tefwD b,foGm;
rvd k @vJ” [kvmar;&m/taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;u“ajccsKyfESif h cH0eftufOya'jzif hzrf;qD;jcif;/ cH0efvufrSwfa&;xd k;ay;&jcif;cHae=u&wJ h {&m0wDwd kif;rS jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,fawGqDoGm;rSm” [k jyefajymcJ hygonf?‚if;jyif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;u “vH kòcHa&; rygvd k @ qufoGm;cGif h rðybl;vd k @ oHwrefawGud kajymwJ hudpP/ vdrfwm”[kvnf; ajymcJ hygonf?
(10)ae@vnf (12;07)em&Dcef @wGif wm0efcsxm;aom,leDazgif;0wfvH kòcHa&;tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k t&yf0wfjzif hajymif;vJ+yD;/ wm;qD;ydwfqd k @r_tm;vH k;ud kvnf; &Sif;vif;xm;ygonf? t&yf0wfjzif h vH kòcHa&;tzG J @0if(2)OD;u taxG
axGtwGif;a&;rSL;.um; xGufEd kifrnf hvrf; wJuav;0Y ydwfIxd kifapmif haeonf?(11)ae@vnf (12;30)em&Dcef @wGif aomufa&oef @0,fcGif hðy&ef 'kwd,t}udrf tm%myd kifwd k @ tm; ajym&mxyfrHwm;qD;+yD; oGm;cGif h rðyyg? ,if;tcsdefrSpI aomufa& r&S dojzif h ae@vnf (13;30)em&Dcef @wGif rd k;&Gmonf htcg xD;jzif ha&cH+yD; aomuf&ygonf?
(12)26-7-98 &ufae@wGif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif h tzG J @Y tpm;tpmESif haomufa&rsm; ukef+yDjzpfItzJ G @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;uay;yd k @jcif;ud kvnf; tm%myd kifwd k @u vufrcHonf htjyif ‚if;wd k @ud k,fwd kifvnf; tpm;taomufrsm;ud k ray;=uyg?
(13)27-7-98 &ufae@ eHeuf(08;55)em&Dcef @wGif Ad kvfrª;&efEd kif[kqd kol xyfrHa&mufvm+yD;/ A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0if OD;vSaztm; “ tefu,ftouf}uD;+yD/ 'Dvd kqufoGm;vd k @ bmr#ta=umif; rxl;ygbl;/Ed kifiHa&;
tawG @tóuH/ jzwfoef;cJ hwJ h Ed kifiHa&;oufwrf;vnf; &S dyg+yD/ aemuf qufvkyfp&m Ed kifiHa&;awGtrsm;}uD;yg/ usaemftckvd kvmajymwm[m tusdK;&S dapcsifvd k @yg”[kajym&m taxGaxGtwGif; a&;rª;;u“ aoG;cG Jpum; vmrajymeJ @
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 147/208
147
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
”[k jyefajymcJ hygonf?(14)ae@vnf(14;25)em&Dcef @wGif/ Ad kvfrª;&efEd kif[kqd kol xyfrHa&mufvmjyD; “ trwd k @/ tefu,fwd k @ &efukefjyef
wm taumif;qH k;jzpfr,f ”[k ajymcJ hygonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;u “ trsm;oGm; vmvd k @&wJ h vrf;c&D;ud k/
wOD;wa,mufusrS roGm; rvm&bl;qd kwm t"dy` g,f r&S dbl; ”[kjyefajymcJ h ygonf? xd ktcg Ad kvfrª;&efEd kifqd kolu“ tJ'gu/a'oqd kif&m tm%myd kifawGu vH kòcHa&;udpPa=umif h vkyfwmyg”[kajym&m/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;uvH kòcHa&;awGygwmyJ/ vm rvdrfeJ @ ”[kjyefajymcJ hygonf? Ad kvfrª;&efEd kifqd kolu “ tr &wJ howif; rSm;aeygw,f/{&m0wDwd kif;rSm tzrf;tqD; vH k;0 r&S dygbl;” [kajymojzif h/ taxGaxG twGif;a&;rSL;u “ 'DrSm {&m0wDwd kif;uvl}uD;ygw,f/ ar;=unf h ”[kajymojzif h {&m0wDwd kif; pnf;&k H;a&;OuUÏu ajccsKyfESif hcH0eftufOya't& tzrf;tqD;cHae=u&aom jynfol@v$wfawmfudk,fpm;vS,[email protected];udk ajymjyvdkufygonf? xdktcgAd kvfrª;&efEd kif[k qd kolu “tJ'gawmhusaemf h rajymeJ @/ a'oqd kif&mawGu vH kòcHa&;t&vkyfwJ hudpPawGygyJ” [kajym&m/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;u “ rw&m;vkyfwm Ed kifiHawmfu pd k;rd k;&rSmaygh/ w&m;Oya'[m wef;wl &nfwljzpf&rSmaygh/ w&m;Oya'qd kwm wckwnf;yJ&S d&rSmyJ/ a'oqd kif&mtm%myd kifawGu vkyfwmud k/ A[d ku ta&;,laqmif&Gufay;Ed kifjcif; r&S dbl;vm;/ A[d ku a'o qd kif&mud kv$rf;rd k;&rSmaygh ”[kjyefajymcJ hygonf?
(15)28-7-98 &ufae@eHeuf(11;00)em&Dcef@wGif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;.q&m0efjzpfol a'gufwmwifrsdK;0if; aq;vmukay;onf? aomufa&jywfaeI vdktyfaeojzif h q&m0ef.awmif;qd kcsuft& yxrt}udrfwGif aomufa&oef @(3)bl; 0,fcGif h&ygonf? 'kwd,t}udrf a&oef @bl;(5)bl;xyfay;&eftwGuf a'gufwmwifrd sK;0if;u jyefcgeD;wGiftm%myd kifwd k @tm; yd kufqH 500d§-usyfay;cJ hygonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; aq;ukor_cH,lrnfud k Ad kvfrª;&efEd kifqd kolu/ uifr&morm;awG ac:vmojzif h/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;u“ Ad kvfrª;&efEd kifqd kolESif h uifr&morm;awG yg&if/ aq;ukocGif h rcHbl;”[kajymrS/ ‚if;wd k @ vd kufrvmbJ vrf;xdyfwJav;Y rwfwyf&yfv#uf aecJ h=uygonf? ,if; ae&mrSaeI ‚if;wd k @u/ taxGaxG twGif;a&;rSL;wd k @aq;ukor_cH,ljcif;ud k "gwfyH k
rsm;/ AD'D,d krsm;¶k duf=uygonf? ae@vnf(13;00)em&Dcef @wGif tm%myd kifwd k @u“ tcsdefaph+yD ”[kajymojzif h a'gufwm wifrsdK;0if; jyefoGm;&ygonf?
(16)eHeuf (11;00)em&Dcef @uwnf;u/ a'gufwmwifrsdK;0if;yd kufqHay;oGm;aom aomufa&oef @(5)bl;ud k nae (16;05)em&Dcef @wGif tm%myd kifwd k @xHrS &&S d=uonf?
(17)29-7-98 &ufae@ae@vnf (12;00)em&Dcef @wGif/ tm%myd kifwd k @.um;jzif h a'gufwifrsdK;0if; aq;ukay;&efa&mufvmonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;twGuf vd ktyfaeaompm;aomufp&mrsm;ESif h t0wftxnfrsm;ud k &Jwyf&if;(9)ppfaq;a&;*dwfrS tm%myd kifwd k @u odrf;qnf; xm;vd kufonf? tm%myd kifwd k @ucGif hðyonf haq;ypPnf;tcsdK@om ,laqmifcGif h&onf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;twGuf t[m&jzpfapaom ADwmriftp&S donf h
aq;ypPnf;rsm;ud k ,laqmifcGif h rðy=uyg? a'gufwm wifrsdK;0if;ESif htwlvk dufygvmaom trsdK;orD;q&m0efa'gufwm òyH;tdrd k. ud k,fcE<mud kvnf; ppfaq;&SmazG+yD; aq;oGm;ukcGif h ray;yg? odrf;qnf;xm;aomypPnf;rsm;ud kvnf; taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;xHrS a'gufwmwifrsdK;0if; jyefvmonf htcgusrSomv#if tm%myd kifwd k @ujyefay;ygonf?
(18)n (17;30)em&Dcef @wGif tzG J @csKyf OuUÏ/ 'k-OuUÏ ESif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifwOD;wd k @ oGm;a&mufawG @qHk=uonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif htzG J@twGuf ygoGm;aomaomufa&oef @ESif h tpm;taomufrsm;ud k/&Jwyf&if;(9)ppfaq;a&;*dwfrS óudwifodrf;qnf;xm;vdkufonf? odrf;qnf;xm;aom ,if;ypPnf;rsm;udktaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;wd k @xHrS OuUÏ wd k @ jyefvm=uonf htcgrSomv#if tm%myd kifwd k @u jyefay;=uonf?
(19) xd kod k @oGm;a&muf=u&jcif;ta=umif;rSm Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif hzG H @òzd;a&;aumifpD. t}uHðy
csufwckud k Ad kvfrª;ol&rSwqif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifwOD;u&&S donf? Tt}uHðycsufud k A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @rsm;tm;vH k; !d ‡Ed _if;aqG;aEG;&ef vd ktyfvmonf? xd k @a=umif h tzG J @csKyfwGif&S dae=uaom A[d ktvkyftr_aqmif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 148/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
148
tzG J @0ifrsm;tm;vH k;taejzif h wm;qD;jcif;cHae&onf h taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmif OD;vSazwd k @xHod k @ oGm;&ef fvd ktyfa=umif;jyefajymcJ honf? Ad kvfrª;ol&u tm;vH k;oGm;&ef roif hygojzif h/ OuUÏ/ 'k-OuUÏESih fA[d ktvkyftr_aqmifwOD;wd k @ aygif ;(3)OD;ud k oGm;cGif hðycJ hygonf? Ed kifiHawmf at;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @ðzd;a&;aumifpD
. t}uHðycsufud k A[d ktvkyf tr_aqmiftzG J @u!d ‡Ed _if;aqG;aEG;=uonf? xd kod k @aqG;aEG;=u+yD; tjcm;t}uHðycsufwckud k Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @òzd;a&;aumifpDESif haqG;aEG;&ef oabmwlnDcJ h=uygonf? ,if;oabmwlnDcsufud k tzG J @csKyfOuUÏu wm0ef,lI qufvufaqmif&Guf&ef A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0ifrsm;tm;vH k;oabmwlnDcJ h=uonf?
(20) OuUÏ/ 'k-OuUÏESif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0if wOD;wd k @onf (19;40)em&Dcef @wGif wm;qD;jcif;cHae&aom taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;wd k @xHrS jyefvnfxGufcGmvm=u&m (21;00)em&Dcef @wGif A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0if OD;vGif.tdrfod k @jyefa&muf=uonf? A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifrsm;. oabmwlnDcsufud k qufvufaqmif&GufEd kifjcif; r&S drD tm%myd kifwd k @u taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ESif h tzG J @tm;/ twif;t"rR0ifa&mufcsKyfaESmifI tEd kifxufðy t=urf;zuf+yD; vufa&mufr_rsm; usL;vGefum twif;t=uyfac:aqmifcJ h=ujcif;jzpfonf?
(21)taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;u vlv$wf+yD;ac:cd kif;I OuUÏ tygt0if A[d ktvkyftr_aqmif tzG J @0if(4)OD;wd k @taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;tm; oGm;a&mufawG @qH k=ujcif;om jzpfygonf?tm%myd kifwd k @u taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;tm; OuUÏ ESif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmifwd k @xH tyfES Hjcif; r[kwfyg?
(22)ac:aqmifvmyH krSm§n(21;10)em&Dcef @wGif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;.jcHY ,cifu wm0efus t&m&S djzpfol Ad kvfrª;ol&wd k @tzG J @ tiftm;(50)cef @jzif h vma&muf=uonf? um;vrf;ay:wGif óudwifpDrHxm;aom um;wef;&Snf}uD; &S daeonf?
(23) tzG J @csKyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;jzpf=uaom ud kxGef;jrif h/ ud knGef @a&$ESif h A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0if OD;vSaz wd k @ud ktpDtpOftvd kuf twif;t"rR0ifqG J+yD; tEd kiftxufðy csKyfaESmif=uum toif hpDpOfxm;onf h armfawmf,mOf
rsm; twGif;od k @ tm%myd kifwd k @u oGwfoGif;=uonf?(24) wcsdefwnf;wGif tpmESif h aomufa&jywfojzif htm;tifcsdeJ @pGm um;xJwGifvJavsmif;aeaom taxG
axGtwGif;a&;rª;tm;/ Ad kvfrª;ol&ESif htzG J @u/ armfawmf,mOftwGif;od k @0ifa&muf=uum t=urf;zufaom enf;jzif htEdkiftxufðycsKyfaESmifI vufa&mufr_rsm;usL;vGef+yD; taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;.oabmqEN vHk;0rygbJtaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. aetdrfodk@ tm;vH k;ud k twif;t"rR jyefydk@cJh=uonf? taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;.armfawmf ,mOfud kvnf;/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; .cGif hðycsuf r&S dbJ oufqd kif&mtm%myd kifwd k @u ‚if ;wk d @bmomtwif;t"rRarmif;ESifcJ h=uonf?
(25) 30-7-98 &ufae@nae (16;00)em&Dcef @wGif/ Ad kvfrª;ol&u A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0if OD;oef;xGef;
tm; “ a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; (15§20)rdepfcef @ arwWm&yfcHajymqd kaomfvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfu(5)rdepfom pum;ajymyg/ reufus&if OD;oef;xGef;xHoGm;ar;yg[k ajymcJ hyga=umif;/'gha=umif h(5)rdepf a&wGufaeoH=um;&aoma=umif h rwwfEdkifawmhI a':atmifqef;pk=unftm;ayG @xl+yD; tjcm; ppfolemðy &Jar(2)a,mufESif h n‡yfxd kifvd kufa=umif;/ 'Dum;ud kvnf; &JabmfawG armif;+yD;awmh a':atmifqef;pk=unftdrfud k jyefyd k @vd kufa=umif; ”[k ajym=um;cJ hygonf?
4? xd k @a=umif h txufygjzpfpOfrsm;ud k pdppfavhvm=unf hv#if/ tm%myd kifwd k @onf æ(u) rw&m; wm;qD;uef@uGufr_/ rw&m; csKyfaESmifxm;r_wd k@udkusL;vGefjcif;/ ,if;od k@usL;vGefjcif;jzif h
xdyfwd kuf&ifqd kifa&;ud k jzpfay:ap&ef wrifoufoufzefwD;aejcif;/(c) &mZ0wf ruif;aom tEd k fiftxufðyr_trsdK;rsdK;/ vufa&mufr_trsdK;rsdK;/ cd k;r_ESif htjcm;jypfr_wd k @ud k usL;vGef
aejcif;/(*) urB mhukvor*~. vlr_tcGif hta&;rsm;qd kif&m urB mht"dXmefðya=unmpmwrf; tyd k'f - 3/ tyd k'f-25
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 149/208
149
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
(1)ponf h vlwOD;wa,mufwGif &oif h&xd kufaom tajccHvl @tcGif hta&;rsm; ud kcsdK;azgufaejcif;/(C) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;ESif htzG J @tm; touftE W&m,fpd k;&drf&onftxd vrf;yef;qufoG,fa&; jzwf
jcif;/ ywf0ef;usifESif htqufjzwfjcif;/ tpm;tpmESif haomufa&wd k @ud kjzwfawmufxm;jcif;/ ,if;od k @jzwfawmuf
jcif;jzif h tiftm;csdenf hap+yD;rS 0ifa&mufI twif;t"rRt=urf;zufES drfESif;jcif;/ q&m0ef.aq;ukor_ r&&S dcJ hygv#if,ckuJ hod k @ t=urf;zufyH kzufenf;rsdK;onf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. touftE W&m,fud kxdcd k kufapEd kifjcif;/
(i) 9-11-96 &ufae@wGifvnf; taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. um;wef;tm; vl&rf;um;wd k @u vH kòcHa&; tzG J @0ifrsm; a&S @wGifyif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. touftE W&m,fud k xdcd kufapEd kifonftxdvnf;aumif;/25-698&ufae@wGifvnf; pmzwf0d kif;od k @vma&muf=uonf h tzG J @csKyftzG J @0ifvli,frsm; tm;tm%myd kifwd k @u wm;qD;&k dufESufjcif;udpPwGif taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. touftE W&m,fud k xdcd kufapEd kifonftxdvnf;aumif;/ ,cifu(2)}udrfðyvkyfcJ h+yD;jzpfI ,ckw}udrfESif hqd kygv#if tm%myd kifwd k @utaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. touftE W&m,fud kxdcd kufapEd kifonftxd t=urf;zufaejcif;rSm pkpkaygif;(3)}udrf&S d+yDjzpf jcif;/
( p) ,ckuJ hod k @ t=urf;zuf+yD;ES drfESif;&ef óudwif}uH&G,fI pDrHaqmif&Gufxm;jcif;/(q) trsdK;orD;rsm;ab;tE W&m,frS umuG,fa&;[k aºuG;a=umfaeaomfvnf;/ vufawG @wGifrl Ed kb,fvf
+idrf;csrf;a&;qk&Sif/ 'Drd kua&pDacgif;aqmif/ tzG J @csKyftaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kyif/ touftE W&m,fxdcd kufapEd kifonftxd w&m;vufvGwf &efðyaejcif; wd k @ud k wdwdususay:vGifxif&Sm;pGm od&S dem;vnfEd kif=urnfjzpfa=umif; a=unmvd kufonf?
&efukefðrd @ ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @
1360 jynf hESpf/ 0gacgifvqef; (11)&uf/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf1998 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (3) &uf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 150/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
150
trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJ @csKyftrSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&G*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&G*H kwdkifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&G*H kwd kifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&G*H kwdkifvrf;trSwf (97§c)/ taemufa&G*H kwd kifvrf;
A[ef;òrd@e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd@e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @A[ef;òrd @e,f/ &efukefòrd @
a=unmcsuftrSwf - 8 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 8 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 8 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 8 (7§98)a=unmcsuftrSwf - 8 (7§98)
1? trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;ESif h {&m0wDwd kif;pnf;&k H;a&;tzG J @. OuUÏESif hA[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @0ifwd k @onf/ ,ae@ 20-7-98 eHeuf (09;10)em&Dcef @wGif/ {&m0wDwd kif;/ yef;waemfòrd @od k @ armfawmf,mOfjzif hc&D;xGufcGmoGm;=uygonf?
2? c&D;xGufjcif;udpPrSm/ *k%foa&oduQm&Sdjynfol@v$wfawmfudk,fpm;vS,frsm;udk/ vl@b0wGiftedrfhusqH k;aomtoufarG;0rf;a=umif;ESif htouf&Sifae=uonf holrsm;ESif homoufqdkifonf h ajccsKyfESif hcH0eftufOya'jzif hta&;,lxm;jyD;/ vl @oduQmud kwrifoufoufcsdK;ES drfedrf hcsjcif;tm;/ tzG J @csKyfuvufrcHEd kifyg ojzif h/yef;waemf&S d jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,fa'gufwmwifrif;xGËfxHod k @oGm;a&mufjyD;tm;ay;&ef jzpfygonf?‚if;onf az: jyygOya'jzif hta&;,ljcif;cH&ae&ygonf?
3? &efukef-ykodrfvrf; a=u;eef;wd kiftrSwf - 106 teD;/ y'ef&GmteD;wGif/ tm%myd kiftzG J @0if vH kxdef;&Jrsm;u/ armfawmf,mOfud kwm;qD;onf[kowif;&&S dygonf? c&D;qufvufroGm;Ed kif&ef yxr/ toif hjyKvkyfxm;onf h ql;oHóud;wef;rsm;jzif h0d kif;umxm;+yD;/ 'kwd,/ Tonfrsm;tpm;/ xef;wH k;[k,lq& aomwH k;rsm;jzif h ,mOf.a&S@/ aemufwdk@wGifcsxm;onf[k=um;od&ygonf? ‚if;jyif ,mOfudkvHkxdef;&Jrsm;u/ 0dkif;xm;onf[k=um;od&ygonf?
4? od k @aomf (11;40)em&Dcef @wGif/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rSL;wd k @armfawmf,mOfrSm anmifwkef;òrd @bufod k @ qufvufxGufcGmoGm;onf[komowif;&&S dygonf?
A[d ktvkyftr_aqmiftzG J @trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&efukefòrd @
1360 jynf hESpf 0gqd kvjynf hausmf (12)&uf1998 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv (20)&uf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 151/208
151
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
&ufpG J- 2003 Zlvd kifv (9)&uf
OuUXEd kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @òzd;a&;aumifpDjrefrmEd kifiH/ &efukefòrd @?
ta=umif;t&m? ? 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;+yD;aemuf ,ae@jrefrmEd kifiHawmf.tusnf;wefaomtajctaeESif hajz&Sif;ay;&efrsm;?
1? 2003ck/ arv (30)&ufnaecif; 'DyJ,if;òrd @ESif husnf&Gmt=um;wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf 'kwd,OuUXOD;wifOD;tygt0if taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k t=urf;zufol wpkwd k @upDpOfwd kufcd kufojzif h aoqH k;olrsm;ESif h'%f&m&&S dolajrmufrsm;pGm&S da=umif;twnfrðyEd kifaomowif;rsm; =um;od&ygonf// Tod k @ r&Sif;rvif;jzpf&onfrSm e,fajrwm0ef&S dolrsm;u xkwfazmfa=unmjcif;rðyonf h twGufjzpf&ygonf?
2? xd k @aemuf txufaz: jyyg trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @acgif;aqmifrsm;ESif htwlvd kufygoGm;=uaom vli,frsm;ESif h tzG J @0ifrsm;ud kvnf; tusOf;cszrf;qD;xdef;odrf;xm;jcif;cHae&onfud k xyfrH=um;od&jyefojzif h/ u|efawmfwd k @ 1990 jynf hESpf ygwDpH k'Drd kua&pDa&G;aumufyG JwGifjynfolwd k @a&G;cs,fwifajr‡mufxm;aom jynfol @ v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;taejzif h 'Drd kua&pDud kvd kvm;+yD;}udrfrD;tH k;ovd kcHpm;ae=u&aom trsm;jynfolwd k @ud k,fpm;atmufygtwd kif; wifjyawmif;qd k&jcif;jzpfygonf?
(1) trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf 'kwd,OuUX OD;wifOD;/ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef; pk=unfwd k @ESif htwlvd kufygoGm;=uaom tzG J @0iftm;vH k;wd k @ud ktjrefqH k;jyefv$wfay;&ef/
(2) arv (31)&ufae@rStpðyI aetdrfwGiftus,fcsKyfxm;aom OD;atmifa&$trª;ðyonf hA[d ktr_ aqmif
vl}uD;rsm;ESif h 'Drd kua&pDtusOf;om;tm;vH k;wd k @ud kvnf; jyefv$wfay;yg&ef/(3) trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf A[d kESif hjynfe,f/ wd kif;tm;vH k;wd k @wGif csdwfydwfxm;aom¶H k;cef;rsm;ud k csdyfcGm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 152/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
152
zGif hvSpfay;yg&ef/(4) 'DyJ,if;ta&;tcif;wGif trSefwu,faoqH k;=uol/ '%f&m&&S dol/ zrf;qD;xm;jcif;cH&olrsm;ESif h aysmu
fqH k;aeolrsm;.pm&if;ud k ðypka=unmay;Ed kif&eftwGuf pH kprf;a&;aumfr&Sif zG J @pnf;azmfxkwfay;yg&ef/(5) urB m@ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcH. jrefrmEdkifiHESif hywfoufaomqHk;jzwfcsuftwdk if;aqmif&Guf
taumiftxnfazmfay;yg&efESif h Ed kifiHawmf+idrf0yfydjym;r_wnfaqmufa&;tpd k;&. (1990)ckESpf a&G;aumufyG JOya'pnf;rsOf;a=unmcsuft& jynfol @v$wfawmfac:,lzG J @pnf;ay;yg&ef/
3? u|efawmfwd k @jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;. wifjyawmif;qd kcsufrsm;onf wpfOD;wpfa,muf/wpfzG J @wpfygwD.tusdK;twGufr[kwfbJ jynfolwpf&yfvH k;.tusdK;pD;yGm;ESif h Ed kifiHawmftpd k;&. 'Drd kua&pD vrf;a=umif;ud k OD;wnfav#mufvSrf;&mwGifacsmarG @tqifajya&;ESif h atmifjrif+yD;ajrmufa&;wd k @ud ka&S @¶_aomtm;jzif hvnf;aumif; (0g) wenf;tm;jzif h trsdK;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwf/ yl;aygif;aqmif&Guf=u&efvd ktyfonf [k,H k=unfaomtm;jzif hvnf;aumif; wifjyawmifqd k&jcif;jzpfygonf?
4? xd k @tjyif Ed kifiHawmfESif hjynfolvlxk.tay:od k @usa&mufvmonf htE W&m,fESif h Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;wnf+idrfr_ud kxdcd kufaprnf htE W&m,frsm;ud kwm;qD;umuG,fay;&efrSm vuf&S dEd kifiHawmftpd k;&tzG J @wGif t"du wm0ef&S douJ hod k @/ u|efawmfwd k @jynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;uvnf; wm0ef&S donf[k(cH,l)cH,lygaoma=umif hvnf;aumif;/ trsdK;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;/ wd kif;&if;om;pnf;vH k;nD!Gwfa&;ESif h acwfrS DzG H @òzd; wd k;wufaom'Drd kua&pDEd kifiHawmfopfwnfaqmufa&;ud k OD;wnfar#mfrSef;aomtm;jzif hvnf;aumif; wifjy&jcif;jzpfa=umif;xyfavmif;azmfjytyfygonf?
av;pm;pGmjzif h ² ² ²
1990 jynf hESpfa¶G;aumufyG JrSa¶G;cs,fwifajr‡mufjcif;cHxm;&onf hjynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;?
( trnfESif hvufrSwfrsm;yl;wG Jv#uf )
“ vufrSwfa&;xd k;=uoljynfol@v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;pm&if;? ”“ vufrSwfa&;xd k;=uoljynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;pm&if;? ”“ vufrSwfa&;xd k;=uoljynfol@v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;pm&if;? ”“ vufrSwfa&;xd k;=uoljynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;pm&if;? ”“ vufrSwfa&;xd k;=uoljynfol @v$wfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;pm&if;? ”
pOfpOfpOfpOfpOf trnftrnftrnftrnftrnf jynfe,f§wd kif;jynfe,f§wdkif;jynfe,f§wd kif;jynfe,f§wdkif;jynfe,f§wd kif; rJqENe,frJqENe,frJqENe,frJqENe,frJqENe,f1? a'gufwm-pdefjrif h {&m0wDwd kif; bdkuav;(2)2? OD;atmif=uif {&m0wDwd kif; ajrmif;jr(1)3? OD;vS=unf {&m0wDwdkif; ykodrfta¶S @(2)4? OD;nGef@vd _if {&m0wDwd kif; ykodrfta¶S @(1)5? OD;nGef@0if; {&m0wDwd kif; a&=unf(1)6? OD;wifacsm {&m0wDwd kif; ykodrftaemuf(1)
7? a'gufwm-aZmfjrif h {&m0wDwd kif; [oFmw(2)8? OD;jrif hodef; {&m0wDwd kif; jrefatmif(2)
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 153/208
153
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
9? OD;wifOD; {&m0wDwd kif; jrefatmif(1)10? a'gufwm-wifrif;xGÉf {&m0wDwd kif; yef;waemf(1)11? OD;ref;nGef @odef; {&m0wDwd kif; yef;waemf(2)
12? OD;wif {&m0wDwd kif; usHKaysmf(1)13? OD;ref;a*smfeD {&m0wDwd kif; usHKaysmf(2)14? a'gufwm-vS0if; {&m0wDwd kif; ausmif;ukef;(2)15? OD;apmvGif {&m0wDwd kif; ausmif;ukef;(1)16? OD;vSjrif h {&m0wDwd kif; rtlyif(2)17? OD;jrifhodef; rauG;wd kif; acsmuf(1)18? OD;cspfwif rauG;wd kif; rif;vS19? OD;pd k;0if; rauG;wd kif; qdyfjzL 20? ocif-cifnGef @ rauG;wd kif; a&eHacsmif;(1)21? OD;atmifqef;jrif h rauG;wd kif; +rdKif(1)22? OD;uHOD; rauG;wd kif; pvif;(2)23? OD;wm rauG;wd kif; pvif;(1)24? OD;ausmf¶Sif; rauG;wd kif; yGifhjzL(1)25? a'gufwm-atmifrd k;ndK rauG;wd kif; yGif hjzL(2)26? OD;ausmfjrif h rauG;wd kif; rauG;(1)27? OD;cspfaxG; rauG;wd kif; +rdK@opf(2)28? OD;atmifpd k; rauG;wd kif; rauG;(2)
29? OD;bd kaxG; rauG;wd kif; ewfarmuf(1)30? OD;[efaZmf rauG;wd kif; qifaygif0J31? OD;jrif hatmif rauG;wd kif; +rdKif(2)32? a'gufwm-=unfrif; rauG;wd kif; yckuUL(1)33? OD;vd _ifat; rauG;wd kif; yckuUL(2)34? OD;atmifjrif hodef; rauG;wd kif; ewfarmuf(2)35? OD;nGef @vd _if rauG;wd kif; atmifvH(1)36? OD;xGef;ºuG,f yJcl;wd kif; anmifav;yif(2)
37? OD;armifat; yJcl;wd kif; om,m0wD(2)38? OD;yd kuf+cHK yJcl;wd kif; a¶$awmif(2)39? a'gufwm-rsdK;0if; yJcl;wd kif; u0(1)40? OD;wifa¶$ yJcl;wd kif; a0g(1)41? OD;pH0if; yJcl;wd kif; om,m0wD(1)42? OD;atmifpd k;jrif h yJcl;wd kif; awmifil(1)43? OD;xGef;atmif yJcl;wd kif; a&wm¶Snf(2)44? OD;aomif;pdef yJcl;wd kif; jynf(2)45? a':vSvSrd k; yJcl;wd kif; rif;vS(2)
46? OD;omarmif yJcl;wd kif; tkwfzd k(2)47? OD;wifOD; yJcl;wd kif; tkwfzd k(1)
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 154/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
154
48? OD;nGef @at; yJcl;wd kif; vufyHwef;(2)49? a':arESif;=unf rE Wav;wd kif; rd k;ukwf(1)50? a':pef;pef; &efukefwd kif; qdyfurf;51? OD;odef;jrif h &efukefwd kif; wmarG(2)
52? OD;armifarmifvwf &efukefwd kif; omauw(1)53? OD;pd k;(c)OD;pd k;wif &efukefwd kif; arSmfbD(1)54? OD;ausmfoGif &efukefwd kif; c&rf;(1)55? OD;vSxGef; &efukefwd kif; =unf hjrifwd kif56? eef;cifaxG;jrif h u&ifjynfe,f bm;tH(3)57? OD;rif;xGef;cspf u&ifjynfe,f bm;tH(2)58? OD;usifodef; u&ifjynfe,f =umtif;qdyf}uD;(2)59? OD;vSarmif u&ifjynfe,f =umtif;qdyf}uD;(1)60? a'gufwm-pdef0if; u&ifjynfe,f qdyf}uD;§caemifwd k61? OD;apmatmif ppfud kif;wd kif; rH k¶Gm(2)62? OD;[Homjrif h ppfud kif;wdkif; bkwvif(1)63? OD;rif;oGif ppfud kif;wd kif; ajrmif(2)64? OD;odef;az ppfud kif;wd kif; uef @bvl(1)65? a':cifpef;vd _if ppfud kif;wd kif; 0ufvuf(2)66? OD;pd k;0if; ppfud kif;wd kif; yJcl;(1)67? OD;nDyk &cd kifjynfe,f *G68? OD;ausmfcd kif &cd kifjynfe,f awmifukwf
69? OD;jrarmif &cd kifjynfe,f &rf;+AJ70? OD;ausmfrif; &cd kifjynfe,f bl;oD;awmif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 155/208
155
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
,ckowif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JrSm +yD;cJ hwJ @wESpftwGif;u jzpf&yfawGuk d jyefvnfok H;oyfrSm jzpfygw,f? usr csif;jynfe,fc&D;pOfeJ @ +yD ;cJ hwJ hwESpftwGif;u wjcm;c&D;pOfawGta}umif;uk dvnf;ajymygr,f?aemufqk H;jzpf&yfjzpfwJ @ usr&J @ csif ;jynfe,fc&D;pOfeJ @ pygr,f? wcsK@djzpf&yfawGuk d usr &Sif;vif;wifjycsifygw,f? bmjzpfvk d @vJ qk dawmh(usr em;vnfwmuk dajym&&if) 'Djzpf&yfawGeJ @ywfoufvk d @ tm%m
yk difawG&J @ xkwfjyefa=unmcsufrsm;[m usrwd k @ odwmawGeJ @ vG Jaevkd@ jzpfygw,f? [kdrSmuyfxm;wJ@ "gwfykHawGuk d=unfh+yD;=u+yDvkd@xifygw,f? tJ'Dyk HawGxJu wcsKd @"gwfyk HawG[m usrwk d @ c&D;oGm;pOfu taESmif @t,SufcH&wJ hudpPeJ @ywfoufvk d @ tm%myk difawG&J @xkwfjyefcsufwckeJ @ qk difygw,f? usefwJ @"mwfyk HawGu usrwk d @ c&D;oGm;pOf vrf;uk d }uH hck difzG H @òzd;a&;tzG J @0ifrsm; (}uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm; jzpfa=umif;uk d olwd k @pD;wJ @um;ay:rSm }uH @zG H @tvHrsm;axmifxm;a=umif;a'ocH jynfolrsm;& J @ajym=um;csuft& usrwk d @od&wm
jzpfygw,f)u ydwfqk d@&ef opfwk H;rsm;eJ@csxm;wmukd jyo aeygw,f? tm%mykdifrsm;u 'Dvkdydwfqkd@r_rsm;r&S dcJ @ygbl;/ jyefjyifaewJ @wHwm;wckem;rSmcsxm;wJ @ opf jym;rsm; om&S dcJ hw,fvk d @ a=unmcsufxkwfjyefcJ @w,fvk d @usrwkd@ em;vnf&ygw,f? jyefjyifaewJ h wHwm;awmfawmfrsm; rsm;ukd usrwk d@ jzwfcJ @&ygw,f? 'gayr,fhtJ'gawGu usrwk d @&J @xD;vif;-ausmufxkvrf; tawG @tóuHeJ @ trsm;}uD ; uGmjcm;ygw,f? owif;axmuf}uD;rsm;"gwfyk HeJ @wuGjrifcJ @}u&wJ @twk dif;yJ opfwk H;rsm;uk d vrf;ay:rSm wrifwum csxm; wm[m wae&mwifruESp fae&mrSmjzp fygw,f? usrwk d @r Sm uHaumif;axmufrpGm opfwk H ;r sm;uk da& $ @E k di fwJ h tiftm;vk Hvk Havmufavmuf&S dcJ @ygw,f? tm%myk difawGu vrf;ay:rSmopfyifawGvS Jxm;cJ @w,fqk d&if a&$ @Ek difygh rvm;vk d @apm'uwufcJ@ygw,f? usrwkd@eJ@ygoGm;wJ@vlawGu awmfawmfrsm;ygw,f? OD;aESmuf&SdwJhvl wa,muf
ESpfa,mufavmufeJ @awmifrS 'Dvk dopfyifawGuk d wenf;enf;eJ @z,f&Sm;Ek difrSmyg? usr &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif;jzpfapcsifwmuawmh 'Dopfwk H;awG[m usrwk d @c&D;pOfuk dt[ef @twm;jzpfapbk d @twGuf wrif wumvrf;ay:rSmcsxm;cJ @w,fqk dwJ h tcsufygyJ? 'DudpPuk d vkyfcJ hwJ hvlpkuk d usrwk d @ aqmrSm aemufwcgawG @cJ h &ygao;w,f? 'geJ @ywfoufvk d @tm%myk difawGua=unmcsufrsm;xkwfcJ @wmuk dvnf; awG @+yD;jzpfygvdrf @r,f?
'D "gwfyk HawGuk d=unf hjcif;tm;jzif h bmjzpfcJ @ovJqk dwmuk d wdwdususodEd kifygvdrf @r,f? olwk d @awG G[m vlpkvla0;eJ @ jy\em&Smzk d @ apmif hae=uwmyg? olwd k @u olwk d @&J @wdyfacGtcsKd @uk d odrf;qnf;+yD; jyefray;vk d @vkyf&wmvk d @qk dygw,f? usrwk d @ aoaocsmcsm&Sif;vif;xm;wJ @ tifeft,fvf'D&J @rluawmh usrwd k k @ud k vGwfvGwf vyfvyf"gwfyH k&d kufEd kifygw,f? ta0;uae AD'D,d k&d kufr,fqd k&ifvnf; usrwd k @ bmrSrvkyfEd kifygbl;? 'gayr,f h usrwd k @&J @ tpnf;
ta0;awG vkyfaewJ hae&m/ jynfolvlxkeJ @awG @qH kwJ hae&mud kawmh0ifa&muf+yD; usrwd k @ud k todray;bJeJ @ AD'D,d k&d kufcGif h ray;ygbl;? "gwfyk H&d kufcsif&if(od k @) AD'D,d k&d kufcsif&if usrwd k @ud k today;&rSmjzpfygw,f? usrwd k @ud k AD'D,d k
trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf.trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J@csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf.trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf.trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J@csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf.trsKd;om;'Drk dua&pDtzG J @csKyf taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª; a':atmifqef;pk=unf.
2003 ckESpf/ {+yDv (23)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yGJ aumufE_wfcsuf2003 ckESpf/ {+yDv (23)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yGJ aumufE_wfcsuf2003 ckESpf/ {+yDv (23)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yGJ aumufE_wfcsuf2003 ckESpf/ {+yDv (23)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yGJ aumufE_wfcsuf2003 ckESpf/ {+yDv (23)&ufae@ owif;pm&Sif;vif;yGJ aumufE_wfcsuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 156/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
156
&d kufcsifw,fqd k&if today;&r,fvd k @ usrwd k @tjrJyJajymcJ hygw,f? wu,fawmh 'g[m tajccH,Ofaus;r_usif h0wfygbJ? txl;ojzif h usrwd k @ y&0%ftwGif;rSm vkyfr,fqd k&ifajym&rSmyg? Oyrm qd k&if usr vufcHEd kif/ rEd kif rar;yJeJ @ 'D&H k;xJ0if+yD; "gwfyH k&d kufwmwd k @/ AD'D,k d&k dufwmwd k @qd kwm[m rvkyfoif hwJ hudpPbJ? usrwd k @ cGif hjyKcsuf r,lbJ
eJ @0if+yD;awmh "gwfyH kwd k @ AD'D,d kwd k @&d kufw,fqd k&if zvifwd k @/ AD'D,d ktacGwd k @ud k odrf;,l+yD; wef&mwefa=u; ay;vd kufygw,f? 'g[m usrwd k @ vkyfaeusyg? ausmufxkrSmjzpfcJ hwmuawmh 'DvlawG[m &efvd kwJ hyH kpHjycJ hygw,f? wm0ef&S dolawGeJ @awG @+yD;awmh wdyfacGudpP&Sif;zk d @/ odrf;xm;wJ hAD'D,d kacGtwGuf wef&mwefa=u;ay;zk d @ usrwd k @bufu óud;pm;cJ hygw,f? 'gayr,f holwd k @bufu vm+yD; rawG @ygbl;? æ usrwd k @ ausmufxkrSm&S daewkef;rSm tJ'DtkyfpkxJuwa,mufu olwd k @uufqufacG jyefray;&if aqmrSmawG @r,fvd k @+cdrf;ajcmufcJ hygw,f? 'Dawmh aqmrSm taESmif ht,Sufay;cJhwm[m olwdk@&J@ tpDtpOft&vkyfcJhwmyg? usrwdk@taeeJ@ b,fawmhrS+cdrf;ajcmufr_a=umifhtav#mhay;jcif;ud k rvkyfcJ hygbl;? 'gayr,f h usrwd k @[m b,fawmhrqd k jy\emwckud kaqG;aEG;+yD; w&m;r#wpGmeJ @ESpfOD;ESpfbufpvH k; vufcHEd kifr,f htajz&Smbd k @ tqifoif h&S daeygw,f? æ 'DtkyfpktaeeJ @ jy\emud kajz&Sif;csifwJ hqENr&S dbl;qd kwm &Sif;aeygw,f? jy\em&Smcsif=uwmjzpfygw,f? olwd k @[m wu,fwrf;jy\emud k at;at;aq;aq;ajz&Sif;csifcJ hw,fqd k&if usrwd k @tzJ G @uv$wfvd kufwJ h OD;[efaZmfeJ @OD;jrif hodef;wd k @ud kvmawGrSmaygh? usrwd k @taeeJ @ emrnfeJ @wuG ajymqd kzk d @&m 0efrav;ygbl;? usrwd k @bmrS r&d k;rom;vkyfcJ hwm r&S dyg? æ olwd k @taeeJ @uawmh olwd k @tkyfpkwm0efcH b,folvJ? olwd k @[m b,ftzJ G @tpnf;uvJqd kwmud k ajymbd k @&m tqif hoif h r&S d=ubl;?olwd k @[m avhvma&;tzJ G @jzpfw,fvd k @yJ ajymw,f? aemuf+yD; aqma&mufwJ htcgusawmh r , u OuUXud k'Dtkyfpk[m b,folawGvJqd kwmpH kprf;ay;zk d @ ajymcJ hygw,f? olwd k @b,folawG (b,ftzJ G @u jzpfw,f) usrwd k @od+yD;om;jzpfayr,f h w&m;0ifodcsifvd k @yg? r , u OuUX (OD;atmifjrif h)u bufvd kufw,fqd kwm xif&Sm;ygw,f? 'Dtkyfpk k[m jynfolxJu/ jynfolawGygyJvd k @ ajymygw,f? usrwd k @awG[mvnf; jynfolxJu/ jynfolawGygbJ? æ 'Dtkyfpk[m aqmu r[kwfygbl;? *ef @a*guae+yD;awmh jy\em&Smzkd @ vmcJ h=uwmyg? usrwd k @
c&D;oGm;vrf;ay: opfwH k;awGcs+yD;ydwfqd k @zk d @ óud;pm;wmvnf; olwd k @yJvd k @xifygw,f? æ
rwlyDrSm usr&J @ teD;uyfvli,ftcsKd @u usrwd k @wnf;cd kwJ htdrf&J @ywf0ef;usifud k&SmazG+yD;/ &lyaA' ausmif f;om;wOD;jzpfwJ h ud katmifatmifqd kolud k &Jpcef;ud ktwif;tusyfac:oGm;cJ hw,fvd k @ tm%myd kifawGu a=ujimcsufxkwfcJ hygw,f? 'DudpPeJ @ywfoufvd k @ usr bmrS rodygbl;? usreJ @ &efukefuygvmwJ hvlawGvnf; bmrS rodygbl;?usrwd k @txJu b,folrS tdrfawGud kav#muf+yD; r&Smygbl/;? 'Dvd k&Smzk d @ tcsdefvnf; r&S dygbl;? aemuf+yD; usrwd k @[mwjcm;vlawG&J @tdrfxJud kvnf; cGif hjyKcsuf r&S dbJeJ @ 0ifrSmr[kwfygbl;? wcsKdvlawGom 'Dvd kvkyfcsifvkyfr,f? usrwd k @uawmh rvkyfygbl;? 'D ud katmifatmif[m ausmif;om;jzpfw,fqd kwmuk d owfowfrSwfrSwftm%myd kifawGu
bmjzpfvd k @ajymcJ hw,fqd kwm[m pOf;pm;p&mjzpfygw,f? usrwd k @eJ @ ausmif;om;awGt=um; jy\emjzpfatmifvkyfcsifvd k @vm;vd k @ pOf;pm;rdw,f? usrwd k @ jrefrmEd kifiHuausmif;om;awG[m rwH k;ygbl;? ausmif;om;trsKd;rsKd;&S dw,fqd kwm od=uygw,f? ausmif;om;jzpfwmeJ @yJ oHo, &S dzG,f&mvkyf&yfrsm;rS uif;r,fvd k @ olwd k @rxifygbl;?ausmif;om;wd kif;[mvnf; 'Drd kua&pDv_yf&Sm;r_ud k axmufcHaewm r[kwfygbl;? 'gud k usrwd k @vufcHygw,f?vlwa,muf[m ausmif;om;qd kwmeJ@ tzJ G @tpnf;tcsKd@twGuf axmufvSrf;a&;vkyfief;awG rvkyfbl;vd k @rajymEd kifygbl;? æ
(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;) jynfolawGud k jcdrf;ajcmufcH&w,fvd k @ajymwm[m b,fvd kenf;awGeJ @ +cdrf;ajcmufcH&wmvJ?(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz) &d k;&d k;av;ygyJ? usrwdk @udk xGufóudr,f/ axmufcHr_jyKr,fqd k&if wenf;enf;eJ @'%fay;cH&r,fvd k@
ajymwmyJ jzpfygw,f? csif;jynfe,f wae&mrSmqd k&if usrwd k @ud kxGufóud&if usnfqHeJ @awG @&r,fvd k @ +cdrf;ajcmufwmawGawmif &S dw,fvd k @od&ygw,f? *ef @a*grSmqd k&if c,u OuUXu jynfolawG usrwd k @ud k axmufcHa=umif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 157/208
157
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
jywmawGud k [ef @wm;zd k @óud;pm;cJ h+yD;/ rdef;uav;wcsKd @ud k um;eJ @vd kufwd kuf+yD; ajcmufvSef @cJ h w,fvd k @od&ygw,f?*ef @a*g c,u OuUXemrnfu aX;OD;jzpfygw,f?
csif;jynfe,frSm taESmif ht,Sufay;cJ hyH kawG[m usrwd k @ &cdkifjynfe,foGm;wkef;u yH kpHawGeJ @ rwlygbl;?csif;jynfe,frSmqd k&if &JawG[m xifwifay:ay: ryg0ifcJ hygbl;? &cd kifjynfe,frSmwkef;uawmh ,leDazmif;0wf&JawGeJ @ ,mOfxdef;&JawGu xifxif&Sm;&Sm;ay:cJ hygw,f? ae&mwumrSm r,uawGuvnf; ygcJ hygw,f? =uufajceDtzJ G @/ rD ;owfwyfzJ G @awGuvnf; ,leDazmif;0wf+yD;ygcJ h=uygw,f? 'Dwpf=udrfrSm &Hzef&HcgrD;owfum;awGeJ @ rD ;owform;awGud kawmh awG @cJ h&ygw,f? 'gayr,f h a,bk,stm;jzif hawmh 0wfpH k0wfxm;olawGud k toH k; rjyKcJ h=uygbl;?æ 'gayr,fh &cdkifjynfe,frSmoHk ;cJhwJhenf;wcsKd@udkawmh oHk;=uygw,f? oDcsif;awG tus,f}uD;zGifhwm?y&dwfawG&Gwfwm/ rD;ab;tEœ &m,fumuG,fa&;owday;csufawG tus,f}uD;zGif hwm? æ *ef @a*grSm usrwd k @ud kvma&mufóudqdkwJhjynfolwcsKd@udk pum;ajymaewkef; toHcsJ@pufwyfqif xm;wJhum;wpD;a&mufvm+yD;aESmif h,Sufzk d @ vkyfcJ hygw,f? 'gayr,f h c%av;omae+yD; jyefxGufoGm;ygw,f? æ jynfolvlxkuawmh awmfawmf+cdrf;ajcmufcH&ygw,f? usrwd k@ud k xGufóudr,f? axmufcHr_jyr,fqd k&if wenf;enf;eJ @ '%fay;cH&r,fqd kwJhoabmeJ @ +cdrf;ajcmufcJ hygw,f? 'gayr,f hvnf; "gwfyH krsm;rSmawG @Ed kifwJ htwd kif;yJ jynfolawGu +cdrf;ajcmufr_awG=um;xJu 'Drd kua&pDv_yf&Sm;r_ud kaxmufcHa=umif; ,H krSm;oHo, r&S dEd kifavmufatmif jyocJ hygw,f? æ
csif;jynfe,frSm c&pf,mefbmom0ifrsm;uk d oG,f0d kufaomenf;rsm;eJ @ taESmif ht,Sufay;w,fqd kwm awG @& ygw,f// 'g[mtifrwefrS 0rf;enf;p&maumif;vSygw,f// usr[m Ak'<bmom0ifwOD;jzpf+yD; Ak'<bmom0ifjzpf&wmud kvnf; *k%f,lygw,f// 'gayr,f h tjcm;bmomud k;uG,folrsm;ud k 'kuQay;w,fqd kwm tifrwef f&Sufp&maumif;w,fvd k @ xifygw,f// æ usrwd k @Ed kifiHrSm tm;vH k; rdrdwd k @ud k;uG,fwJ hbmomtwGuf*k%f,l+yD;/
r,drf;r,d kif bmoma&;vk dufpm;wJ hwcsdefwnf;rSmyJ b,folurS bmomrwlolrsm;ud k aESmif h,Suf'kuQay;jcif;r&S doif hygbl;// csif;jynfe,fol§jynfe,fom;rsm;[m rdrdwd k @qENt& rdrdwd k @,H k=unf&mbmomud k jynf hjynf h00vGwfvyfpGmudk;uG,fyd kifcGifh &Sd&rSmyg// æ usr csif;jynfe,frSm&SdaepOf jynfe,fol jynfe,fom;rsm;taeeJ @tav;teufxm;wJ hudpP/ aemuf(2)ckuawmh vrf;yef;qufoG,fa&; tajctaeeJ @ ynma&;jzpfygw,f// ævrf;yef;qufoG,fa&;qd k;&Gm;r_a=umif h csif;jynfe,ftwGif;rSm c&D;oGm;&efcufcJ+yD; rdrdwd k @b0 &yfwnfr_vnf;yJ cufcJ&ygw,f// csif;jynfe,frSm ysrf;r#jcif; q,fwef;atmifE_ef;[m (10) eJ @(15)&mcd kifE_ef;t=um;rSmyJ &S dw,fvd k @ajym=uygw,f// 'g[m tifrwefedrf huswJ hatmifE_ef;jzpf+yD; csif;jynfe,fol jynfe,fom;rsm;[m 'DudpPud k pd k;&drfylyefr_ &S d=uygw,f// usrvnf; pd k;&drfylyefygw,f// csif;jynfe,foljynfe,fom;rsm;[m &cd kifjynfe,foljynfe,f
om;rsm;eJ @ &Srf;jynfe,foljynfe,fom;rsm;vd kyJ jynfaxmifpkpdwf"gwftm;aumif;=uw,fqd kwm xifxif&Sm;&Sm;jyocJ h=uygw,f// wd kif;&if;om;rsm;[m ArmawGtay:rSm tmCmw rxm;ygbl;// ArmawGu rdrdwd k @tay:rSmqufqHyH keJ@ywfoufvdk@ oHo,awmh&S d=uygw,f// Armvlrsm;pk[m 'gudktodtrSwfjyK+yD; twdwfwkef;uusrwd k @&J hvkyf&yfawGa=umif h wd kif;&if;om;rsm;[m usrwd k @ud k oHo,eJ @jrifw,fqd kwmud k em;vnf&ygr,f// æ
yifvH kpdwf"gwf[m wd kif;&if;om;rsm;&J @pdwfrSm &SifoefaeqJjzpfygw,f// ppfrSefwJ hjynfaxmifpkwckud k vd kvd kvm;vm;axmufcHr,fvd k @ usr,H k=unfygw,f// ppfrSefwJ h'Drd kua&pDjynfaxmifpkrSmqd k&if wu,f hud k wefbd k;&S dr,f hEd k fifiHolEd kifiHom;rsm;jzpfr,fqd kwm usr oHo,r&S dygbl;// wd kif;&if;om;rsm;[m eufeufeJeJ opPmw&m;}uD;rm;+yD;/'DopPmw&m;u rdrdwd k @ud k trSefwu,fumuG,fr_ay;+yD;/ rdrdwd k @&J @ tajccHtcGif hta&;rsm;uk d tmrcHr,f h Ed kifiHwck
twGuf &,lEd kifr,fqd k&if usrwd k @Ed kifiHtwGuf wu,f hud kwefbd k;&S drS Smyg// æ jynfaxmifpkpdwf"gwf[m usrwd k @&J @wd kif;&if;om;rsm;twGif;rSm &SifoefaewJ htwGufa=umif h 'Dpdwf"gwfud k oif hawmfwJ h Ed kifiHa&;pepfeJ @ usrwd k @jynfol
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 158/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
158
tm;vH k;ud k tajccHtcGif hta&;rsm;tmrcHr,f h Ed kifiHawmfzJ G @pnf;tkyfcsKyfyH ktajccHOya'wd k @eJ h jyKpkysKd;axmifay;& ygvdrf hr,f// æ
usrwd k @=uHKawG @&wJ h taESmif ht,SufawGeJ @ywfoufvd k @ odyf+yD;tH h=ow,fvd k @awmh rajymEk difygbl;// ,cifESpf arv(6)&ufae@ usr pjyD;c&D;xGufpOfuwnf;u &Hzef&HcgtaESmif ht,Sufay;wmav;awGeJ @ p+yD;=uHKcJ h& ygw,f// æ =uH @zH G @tzJ G @0ifrsm;eJ @ r,u tcsd K@[m jynfolawGud k+cdrf;ajcmufzk d @ óud ;pm;wmawG/ usrwd k @ud k axmufcHolawGud k taESmif ht,Sufay;wm;av;awG &S dcJ hygw,f// 'Dvd ktajctaeawG[m &cd kifjynfe,fud k oGm;wJ htcgusawmh xifxif&Sm;&Sm;}uD;ud k yd k+yD;qd k;vmcJ hygw,f// æ &cd d kifjynfe,foGm;pOftcgu taESmif h t,Sufay;wmawG[mtm%myd kifrsm;upDpOfw,fvd k @ usrwd k @ rvJ Gra&SmifomoH k;oyfcJ hygw,f// csif;jynfe,frSmvnf; wcsKd @ae&mawGOyrm æ *ef @a*grSmqd k&if aESmif h,Sufr_awGud k tm%myd kifawGupDpOfcJ hw,fqd kwm ,H krSm;oHo, r&S dEd k fifygbl;//ae&mtawmfrsm;rsm;rSm =uH @zH G @eJ @ r,u awGaygif;jyD; aESmif h,SufcJ h/ jynfolvlxkud k jcdrf;ajcmufcJ hygw,f// æ
0ef}uD;wOD;[m =uH @zH G @qd kif;bkwfrsm;ud kav#mufwifcJ hw,fqd kwm awG @&ygw,f// jynfcd kifòzd;&Gm/ jynfcd kifòzd;òrd @e,f pojzif h qd kif;bkwfawGaxmifwmeJ @ywfoufvd k @ usrwd k @ ar;cGef;xkwf&ygvdrf hr,f// =uH hcd kifzH GjzdK;a&;tzJ G @[mbmvJ// Ed kifiHawmftzJ G @wckvm;/ b,fvd ktzJ G @rsKd;u òrd @e,f we,f[m rdrdwd k @eJ @oufqd kifw,f/ rdrdwd k @&J @=oZmtm%matmufrSm &S dw,f/ rdrdwd k @yd kifw,fvd k @ ajymyd kifcGif h&S dovJ// }uH @cd kifzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @[m bmvJ// 'Dvd kqd kif;bkwfawGaxmifbdk @&m olwk d@rSmb,fvd kw&m;0ifvkyfyd kifcGifh &SdovJ// æ 'geJ@,SOf=unfhr,fqdk&if tm%myd kifawG[mbmjzpfvd k @ NLD &H k;awGjyefzGif h+yD; qd kif;bkwfwifwmeJ @ywfouf fvd k @ a&;}uD;cGifus,fvkyf&wmvJ// 'D&H k;awG[m1988§89 uwnf;u zGif hcJ hwmyg// tJ'Dtcsdefwkef;u=uH @zH G @tzJ G @qd kwmawmif r&S dao;ygbl;// æ r=umrDumvu &efukefrSmusif;ywJ h 0efxrf;awGtwGufoifwef;rsm;rSm =uH @zH G @tzJ G @0ifrsm;vnf; ygcJ h=uw,fvd k @od&ygw,f//
=uH hzH G @tzJ G @eJ @ 0efxrf;awGeJ @ b,fvd koufqd kifr_&S dovJ// =uH @zH G @tzJ G @[m tpd k;&eJ @b,fvk dywfoufaeovJ// Ed kifiHawmfeJ @b,fvd kywfoufaeovJ// Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif hzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @eJ @ b,fvd kywfoufaeovJ// 'Dar;cGef;awGud k &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif;tajzay;&ygvdrf hr,f// =uH @zH G @tzJ G @[m vlr_0efxrf;tzJ G @wpfckvd k @ usrwd k @ vufrcHEd kifygbl;//vlr_0efxrf;tzJ G @wpfckyH kpH ray:ygbl;// Ed kifiH&J @vlr_0efxrf;ud dpPrsm; twGufvkyfaew,fv@d kvnf; usrwd k @ rjrifygbl;?+yD;cJ hwJ hwESpftwGif; usrc&D;pOfawGuae aumufcsufqJ GEd kifwmuawmh tm%myd kifawG[m =uH @zG H @tzJ G @ud k NLD
eJ @ NLD ud kaxmufcHolrsm;ud kaESmif h,Sufzk d @ toH k;csaew,fvd k @awmif xifygw,f// 'Dvd kr[kwfbl;qd k&if =uH @zH G @tzJ G @&J @vkyf&yfawGud k rdrdwd k @ raxmufcHbl;qd kwm tm%myd kifawGtaeeJ @jyozk d @ vd kygvdrf hr,f// xd k @twlbJ usrwd k @&J @&cd kifjynfe,feJ @ csif ;jynfe,fc&D;pOfawGrSm a'ocH=uH @zH G @tzJ G @awGOD;aqmifwJ h taESmif ht,SufawGtaemufrS rdrdwd k @
rygbl;qd kwm tm%myd kifawGu xif&Sm;atmif jyo&rSmjzpfygw,f// æ
(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;) a'ocHjynfolawGud k usnfqHeJ @awG @&r,fvd k h+cdrf;ajcmufwm[m b,frSmygvJ//(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz) awmifyd kif; csif;jynfe,f / rwlyD§rif;wyf//(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;) b,folu +cdrf;ajcmufwmvJ//(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz) c , u OuUXvd k h usrwd k hem;vnfygw,f//(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;)(ar;) 'Dvd k+cdrf;ajcmufwmud k 'Da'ocHawGua&mem;axmif=uovm;//(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz)(ajz) wu,fawmh em;raxmif=uygbl;//
(2)ygwf=um&if usr tus,fcsKyfu vGwfvmwm(1)ESpfjynf hygawmhr,f? jyef=unf hr,fqd k&if wd k;wufr_r&S dwmeJ @ywfoufvd k @ usrwd k @tav;teufxm;ygw,f? usr vGwfvmwJ htcsdefwkef;u ,H k=unfr_wnfaqmuf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 159/208
159
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
a&;tqifh +yD;ajrmufoGm;+yD/ 'ghxufyd k+yD;wk d;jrSif hwJ htqif hud k oGm;&r,fvd k @ tm%myd kifawGeJ @ usrt=um;rSmoabmwlnDcsuf,lcJ hygw,f? 'gayr,f h wd k;wufr_&S dcJ hw,fvd k @ usr rxifygbl;? wu,fqd k&if qkwf,kwfr_rsdK;awmifjzpfw,fvd k @ ajymEd kifygw,f? usrwd k @taeeJ @ rjzpfrae Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;tzG J @&J @ apwemeJ @
ywfoufvd k @ ar;cGef;xkwf&awmhr,fvd k @xifygw,f? olwd k @[mwu,fyJ usrwd k @eJ @ oabmwlnDcsuf ,lcsif&J @vm;vd k @ ar;p&mjzpfvmygw,f? usrajymcsifwmu (tef-t,fvf-'D)aomfvnf;aumif;/ e-t-z aomfvnf;aumif; trsdK;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;ud k pdwf0ifpm;onf/ rpm;onfu t"du r[kwfygbl;? vd ktyfcsufut"duyg? usrwd k @Ed kifiHtwGuf trsdK;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;vd ktyfaeygw,f? æ 'gud k e-t-z u oabmaygufzd k @ tcsdefa&mufyg+yD? owif;axmuf}uD;rsm; tck'DrSm&S daewkef;tcgrSm ar;cGef;wpfck xkwfzd k @&mtvGefoif hawmfygw,f?
e-t-z [m bmjzpfvd k @ (tifeft,fvf'D)eJ @ tquftoG,f&S daewJ hta=umif;awGud k Ed kifiHawmf owif;jzef @csda&;XmeawGu xkwfazmf rajymwmvJ// bmjzpfvd k @ olwd k @&J @a=unmcsufawG[m oHwreftod kif;t0d kif;eJ @ Ed kifiHjcm;owif;jzef @csda&;tod kif;t0d kif;ud k OD;wnfae&wmvJ? ² ² ² ² ² olwd k @[m trsd K;om;jyefvnf oif hjrwfa&;eJ @ywfoufvd k @ wu,fyJapwemrSefw,f/ olwd k @[m (e-0-w)tm%modrf;pOfu uwdjyKcJ hwJ hwd kif; wu,fyJ 'DEd kifiHud k'Drd kua&pDpepfod k @ tjrefwufvSrf;apr,f h oabmwlnDcsuf,lcsifw,fqd k&if bmjzpfvd k @ jynfolvlxkud k w&m;0ifajym&rSm 0efav;aewmvJ?
usrwd k @taeeJ @ jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;vd kvm;wJ hta=umif;ud k w&m;0ifajymqd k&rSm 0efrav;ygbl;? usrwd k @[m e-t-z eJ @ em;vnfr_,lxm;wmawGud k azmufzsuf&m ra&mufovd k bmrqd k yGif hyGif hvif;vif; w&m;0ifajymzd k @ tqifoif hyg? tcka&mufaewJ howif;axmuf}uD;rsm; odrSmyg? yxrOD;qH k; usrwd k @eJ @ e-t-z t=um;rSm qufoG,fr_awG&S daea=umif;ud k ESpf(2000)tukefyd kif;u oHwrefrsm;eJ @owif;axmufawGud k xkwfazmfajymcJ h
ygw,f? 'DEd kifiHujynfolawGud k ajymcJ hjcif; r&S dyg? usrwd k @(tef-t,fvf-'D)bufu 'DudpPeJ @ywfoufvd k @ wcGef;rSrajymcJ hygbl;? bmjzpfvd k @vJqd kawmh tJ'Dyxrtqif heJ @ywfoufvd k @ wOD;eJ @wOD;odu|rf;+yD; cd kifrmwJ h ,H k=unfr_wnfaqmufEd kifzd k @twGuf xdrf;odrf;xm;r,fvd k @ em;vnfr_,lxm;wmyg? 'gayr,f h odwJ htwd kif;yJ Ed kifiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD; OD;0if;atmifu (tef-t,fvf-'D)eJ @ (e-t-z)t=um;rSm qufoG,fr_awG&S dcJ hw,fqd kwmud k today;cJ hygw,f? usrwd k @(tef-t,fvf-'D)eJ @ rwd kifyifbJeJ @ 'Dvd kxkwfazmfajymcJ hwmjzpfygw,f? 'gayr,f h usrwd k @taeeJ @'Dvkyf&yfa=umif h ,H k=unfr_wnfaqmufa&;óud;yrf;r_ud k txpftaigh rjzpfapcJ hygbl;? a&;}uD; cGifus,f rvkyfcJ hygbl;?tckvJ a&;}uD;cGifus,f rvkyfcsifygbl;// tJ'gjzpfcJ hw,f? tck +yD;oGm;yg+yD? usrwd k @ ar;cGef; xkwfcsifwmu bmjzpfvd k @'Davmuf}uD; Ed kifiHjcm;owif;XmeawG/ oHwrefawGeJ @ Ed kifiHjcm;tod kif;t0d kif;ud k xkwfazmfajymcsif+yD; 'DEd kifiHu
jynfolawGud kawmh xkwfazmfrajymwmvJ/ 'DEd kifiHujynfolawG[m usrwd k @twGuf yd k+yD;awmh ta&;rygbl;vm;/'DEd kifiHujynfolawG[m avmavmq,f 'DEd kifiHud kOD;aqmifaewJ holawGtwGuf yd k+yD;awmhta&;rygoif hbl;vm;² ² ² ² ²
aemuf xkwfp&mar;cGef;rsm;vnf; &S dygao;w,f? trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;aphr_ óud;yrf;a&;eJ @ ywfoufvd k @qufEG,faewmuawmh ukvor*~twGif;a&;rª;csKyf&J @ ud k,fpm;vS,f rpPwm &mZmvDtpPar;vf jzpfygw,f//(tifeft,fvf'D)eJ @ e-t-z t=um; uGm[r_usOf;ajrmif;zd k @twGuf rpPwm&mZmvD[m wufºuG+yD; tjyKoabmaqmifwJ hu¾rSm yg0ifcJhygw,f// ol@&JhapwemeJ@ jrefrmEdkifiHrSm +idrf;csrf;om,mr_&S d+yD; pD;yGm;a&;/ vlr_a&;/Ed kifiHa&;zG H @òzd;r_od k @ wufvSrf;Ed kifr,f htajctaeud k vd kvm;+yD; ol @&J @apwemoef @pifw,fqd kwmud k usr vH k;0 oHo,
r&S dygbl;// usrwd k @ tef-t,fvf-'Du rpPwm &mZmvDud kaus;Zl;wifygw,f// ,H kvnf;,H k=unf ygw,f// e-t-z u rpPwm &mZmvDud kqufqHyH keJ @ywfoufvd k @ tH htm;oif h&ygw,f// jrefrmEd kifiHrSm trsdK;om; jyefvnf&if=um;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 160/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
160
apha&;vkyfaqmifaewJ h taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;&J @ud k,fpm;vS,ftaeeJ @ ol[m b,ftcsdefrqd k vmcsifwJ htcg'DEd kifiHud k vmyd kifcGif h&S doif hygw,f// æ ol @&J @tvkyfwm0efeJ @ywfoufvd k @ 'DEd kifiHwGif;rSm oloGm;csifwJ hae&mud k oGm;yd kifcGif h&S doif hygw,f// tck 'DrSma&mufaewJ hyk*~ dKvfrsm;[m rESpfu rpPwm &mZmvDvmpOf usrud k awmif}uD;rSm
vma&muf+yD;awG @zd k @udpPeJ @ywfoufvd k @ t[ef @twm;vkyfcJ hwmawGud k od}urSmyg// rpPwm &mZmvDtaeeJ @ usrjrefrm Ed kifiHtwGif;c&D;xGufwJ htcg tajctaeawGb,fvd k&S dvJqd kwm}unf hcsif&if ol @rSm }unf hydkifcGif h&S d&H kru}unfhzdk@wm0efawmif&Sdw,fvdk @ xifygw,f// ,Hk}unfr_wnfaqmufa&;eJ @ jyefvnfoifhjrwfa&;vkyfief;awGb,fvd k&S daew,fqd kwm od&atmifaygh// usrwd k @[m urB mhukvor*~ud kav;pm;&if taxGaxG twGi;fa&;rª;csKyf&J @usrwd k @Ed kifiHrSm jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;jzpfapcsifwJ hqENud k ,H k}unf&if rpPwm &mZmvDud k ol &xd kufwJ h,H k}unfr_/*k%fjyKr_/ av;pm;r_wd k @eJ @ qufqHoif hygw,f// æ jrefrmEd kifiHud k rdrdb,fawmh vmoif hw,fqd kwmud k rpPwm&mZmvDud k,fwd kif qH k;jzwfyd kifcGif h&S doif hygw,f// e-t-z [m wu,fyJ trsKd;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;ud k vd kvm;w,fqd k&if rpPwm &mZmvD olvmcsifwJ htcsdefrSm vmEd kifa&;ud k t[ef @twm; rjyKoif hygbl;?
usr t&ifESpfarv(6)&ufae@u vGwfvmpOftcg a&muf&S daewJ htajctaerS yd k+yD; wd k;wufEd kifzd k @ usrwd k @trsm;}uD; óud;pm;cJ hygw,f? ,H k=unfr_wnfaqmufa&;rS yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufa&;/ aqG;aEG;a&;eJ @ wpfcsdefwnf;jzpf& r,f h jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;tqif hod k @ a&mufzd k @twGuf óud;pm;cJ hygw,f? usrwd k @[m yk*~ dKvfwcsdK@eJ @ tzG J @tpnf;wcsdK@rSwqif h vlom;csif;pmema&;taxmuftulrsm;eJ @ywfoufvd k @ tm%myd kif awGeJ @yl;aygif;aqmif&GufEd kifa&;twGuf óud;pm;cJ hygw,f? e-t-z [m vlom;csif;pmema&;taxmuftulrsm;eJ @ywfoufvd k @ usrwd k @eJ @ yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @&m pdwftm;xufoefr_ r&S dbl;qd kwmud k usrwd k @ &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif; odvmcJ h&ygw,f?
'Dae&mrSm pD;yGm;a&;ydwfqd k @r_awG/ taxmuftuludpPawG/ urB mvSnfhc&D;onfudpPawGeJ @ ywfoufvdk @
ajymcsifygw,f? arv(6)&ufae@ usr vGwfajrmufvm+yD;wJ htcgrSm owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jvkyf+yD; aqG;aEG;r_rsm;rp rcsif; usrwd k @tajccHr_rsm;eJ @ywfoufvd k @ tajymif;tvJ&S drSm r[kwfbl;vd k @ ajymcJ hygw,f// 'D t"dy` g,fuawmh urB mvSnf hc&D;oGm;rsm;udpP/ pD;yGm;a&;ydwfqd k @r_udpP/ taxmuftuludpPawGeJ @ywfoufwJ h usrwd k @rlawGajymif;vJrSm r[kwfbl;qdkwmajymcsifygw,f// usrwdk@(tef-t,fvf-'D)[m pD;yGm;a&;ydwfqdk@r_rsm;vkyfzdk@awmif;qd kaewma=umif h &if}um;apha&; rvd kvm;bl;vd k @ oH k;oyf&r,fvd k @ qd kwJ hvlawGud kajymyg&ap// usrwd k @[mpD;yGm;a&;ydwfqd k @r_rsm; rawmif;qd kcJ hygbl;// 'gayr,f h pD;yGm;a&;ydwfqd k @r_eJ @ywfoufwJ h usrwd k @rlud kvnf; rajymif;cJ hygbl;// xd kenf;wl taxmuftyH heJ @urB mvSnf hc&D;oGm;vkyfief;awGeJ @ywfoufvd k @vnf; usrwd k @rl tajymif;tvJr&S dao;ygbl;// aqG;aEG;yG Jrsm; rp rcsif; 'gawG[m rajymif; rvJwnf&S daeygvdrf hr,f// 'gayrJ h wjcm;ae&mawGrSm
usrwd k @taeeJ @ wwfEd kifor#yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_rSm tqifoif h&S daewJ hu¾awG &S daeygw,f// txl;ojzif h vlom;csif;pmema&;taxmuftulrsm;eJ @ ywfoufvd k @jzpfygw,f// 'gayr,f h tm%myd kifawG[m 'Dvd kudpPawGeJ @ywfoufvd k @ usrwd k @eJ @ yl ;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ wGef @qkwfaewmud kawG @&ygw,f// bmjzpfvd k @ 'Dvd k jzpfae&wmvJqd kwm usrwd k @ar;&ygawmhr,f// usrwd k @&J h apwemud koHo,&S daew,fqd k&if yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufjcif;eJ @ tajz&SmEd kifygw,f//
a&xJ0ifcsifw,fqd k&if a&ud k=unf h&H keJ @ at;vGef;w,f/ ylvGef;w,fvd k @ajymvd k @ r&ygbl ;// a&xJ0if+yD;rSomv#ifylvGef;ovm;/ at;vGef;ovm;qd kwmqH k;jzwf+yD; a&cJxnf hzd k @vd kvm;/ a&aEG;xnf hzd k @vd kvm; pOf;pm; &ygr,f// æuav;wpfa,muf[m a& rcsdK;csifbl;qd k&if a&uat;vGef;w,f/ ylvGef;w,f/ ol[m rnpfywfao;ygbl;/wjcm;vkyfp&m&S dygao;w,f ponfjzif h qifajctrsdK;rsdK;wufrSmjzpfygw,f// wu,fyJ pdwfygwJ holqd k&ifawmh
a&[m odyfat;vGef;/ ylvGef;w,fqd k&ifawmifrS a,musfm;yDyD&ifqd kifzd k @&m tqifoif h jzpfrSmyg// e-t-z[mEd kifiH&J @aumif;usdK;ud k wu,fyJ pdwf0ifpm;w,fqd k&if tef-t,fvf-'DeJ @ yl ;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ txl;ojzif h vlom;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 161/208
161
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
csif;pmemr_qd kif&mtaxmuftyH hawGudpPrSm w&m;0ifyl;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ tqifoif hjzpfygw,f// wd kif;jynfud kvnf; 'Dvd kvkyfaew,fqd kwm &Sif;&Sif;vif;vif;ajymoif hygw,f// bmjzpfvd k @ ud k,f hEd kifiHom;awG rodatmif v#dK@0Sufxm;csif&wmvJ æ usrwdk@[m trsdK;om;jyefvnfoifhjrwfa&;eJ@ywfoufvdkh av;av;eufeufoE<dXmef
csxm;ygw,f// usr 'Dae@ajymwJhtxJrSm tm%mydkifawGeJ@ywfoufwJh ta}umif;ygwma=umifh jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&; rvd kvm;bl;qd kwJ h t"dy` g,f ra&mufygbl;// usrwd k @ud k xdyfwd kuf&ifqd kifwmvd k @ pGyfpG Jaumif;pGyfpG Jygvdrfhr,f// [kwfygw,f/ usrwd k@[m jy\emawGudk&ifqdkifzdk@tqifoifhygyJ// jy\emqdkwm r&ifqdkifvdk @rjzpfygbl;// jy\emawGud kajz&Sif;csif&if&ifqd kif&rSmyg// 'Djy\emawGud k wifjycJ hwmuvnf;&ifqd kif+yD; rajz&Sif;vd k @uawmh jy\emawG[m yd k+yD;qd k;oGm;rSmrd k @ jzpfygw,f//
'DEd kifiH&J @ pD ;yGm;a&;tajctaeeJ @ywfoufvd k @ od =uvdrf hr,fvd k @xifygw,f// b%fvkyfief;tcuftcJ jy\em&J @aemufrSm bm&S dvJqd kwm b,folrS rod}uygbl;// usrc&D;oGm;pOfrSm 'Djy\emeJ @ywfoufvd k @ òrd @toD;oD;uyk*~ dKvfrsm;eJ @ aqG;aEG;cJ hygw,f// tusdK;oufa&mufr_rsm; &S dvm;vd k @ar;cJ hygw,f// qd k;usdK;oufa&mufr_rsm; &S dcJ hw,fvd k @ tajz&ygw,f// awmifolv,form;rsm;ud k aiGpuUL&Sm;yg;vd k @qd k+yD; aps;ES drfay;aew,fvd k @odcJ h&ygw,f// 'gayr,f h &efukefrSmawmh pm;oH k;ukefypPnf;awG aps;usyH k r&ygbl;// 'Dawmh wae&mrSm wckckawmh tifrwefrSm;aeyg+yD?
tajctaeud k tm%myd kifrsm;u wd kif;jynftusdK;vd kvm;w,fqd k&if xdrf;odrf;zd k @tcsdefa&mufjyDvd k @xifygw,f?usr vGwfvmwJ htcsdeftcgu wd kif;jynfeJ @ywfoufvd k @xifjrifcsufawGud k rSefrSefuefuef xif&Sm;apr,fvd k @
ajymcJ hygw,f// jy\emawGud k r&S d[efaqmif+yD; av#mhajymrSm r[kwfayr,f h tm%myd kifawGeJ @ajyvnfr_ud kvnf;wwfEd kifoIóud;pm;+yD; xdrf;odrf;oGm;r,fvd k @ajymcJ hygw,f// tckvnf; usrwd k @[m wu,f hud kyJ etz eJ @ajyvnfr_ vd kcsifygw,f// yk*~ dKvfa&;t& tmCmwqd kwmvnf; vH k;vH k;r&S dygbl;// bmyJ jzpfcJ hjzpfcJ h usrwd k @[m tcsdefra&G;
rdwfaqGjzpfzd k @ jyefvnf&if=um;aphEd kifzd k @ urf;vSrf;&eftqifoif h&S dygw,f// usrwd k @[m tcsdefra&G; yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ tqifoif h&S dayr,f h aESmuf,SufwmawG/ +cdrf;ajcmufwmawGud kawmh cHrSmr[kwfygbl;// 'Dvd kcH&if 'Drd kua&pDta&;eJ @ jynfolvlxk&JhtajctaeawGudk taxmuf tuljyKrSm r[kwfygbl;// æ a'ocHtm%mydkifawGuEd kifiHawmftqif htm%myd kifawG&J @oabmwlcsuf 'grSr[kwf tenf;qH k;awmh em;vnfr_eJ @ cGif hjyKcsuf&S dw,fvd k @rxif&if olwd k @vkyfcJ hwmawGud k vkyf&JrSm r[kwfygbl;// usrwd k @[m ,k H=unfr_wnfaqmufa&; taxmuftuljzpfapr,f h wpfckwnf;aomvrf;jzpfw,fqd k+yD; a'ocHtm%myd kifawGeJ @ }uH @zG H @wd k @vkyfor#ud k cHr,fqd k&if usrwd k @trsm;}uD; rSm;ygvdrf hr,f// taESmif ht,SufawG[m yd k+yD;wd k;vmr,f/ +cdrf;ajcmufr_awG[mvnf; yd kvd k @wd k;vm+yD;tajctae[m yd k+yD;qd k;vmum usrwd k @[m ppfrSefwJ htrsdK;om;&if}um;apha&;rS a0;oxufa0;oGm;rSmyg// e-
t-z [m wu,fyJ trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;vd kvm;w,fqd k&if 'Djy\emawGud k &ifqd kif&ygvdrf hr,f?usrwd k @ c&D ;oGm;pOftcgrSm wcsdK@a'ocHtm%myd kifrsm;&J h vkyfaqmifcsufrsm;ud k etz taeeJ @ &Sif;jyEd kif&ygvd frf hr,f?}uH @cd kifzG @Hòzd;a&;tzG J @taeeJ @vnf; olwd k @vkyfcsif wmawGtm;vH k; vkyfyd kifcGif h bmjzpfvd k @&S dvJqd kwmud k &Sif;jy&ygr,f?usrwd k @ (tef-t,fvf-'D) taeeJ @ usrwd k @tzG J @0ifawGtwGuf wm0ef,lEd kifygw,f//
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? b%fvkyfief;jy\emtcuftcJawG yd k+yD;qd k;vmw,fvd k @qd kwm b,fvd kpD;yGm;a&;eJ @ vlr_a&; oufa&mufr_awG &S dEd kifr,fvd k @xifygovJ//
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? 'Dvd kquf+yD;jzpfaer,fvd k @qd k&ifawmh pD;yGm;a&;jy\emawG wufrSmaygh// pD;yGm;a&;jy\emeJ @ vlr_a&;jy\emawGqd kwm qufEG,faewmyJ// vlawG[m pD;yGm;a&;tcuftcJeJ @ awG @óuH&w,fqd k&if pD;yGm;a&;jy\em
r[kwfbJ vlr_a&;jy\emawGu ygvmygw,f// 'g[mvnf; jy\emawG bmjzpfvd k @&ifqd kifzd k @vd kw,fqd kwmjyaewJ h Oyrmwck jzpfygw,f// jy\emud kajz&Sif;zd k @[m yxr &ifqd kif&ygvdrf hr,f// tckxd 'D tusyftwnf;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 162/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
162
jy\em bmha=umif hjzpfay:vmvJqd kwm usrwd k @ b,folrS rodao;ygbl l;// aumv[mvawGuawmh trsdK;rsdK;aygh// tJ'g[m 'DEd kifiHrSm wm0ef,lr_eJ @ jrifomodomEd kifwJ htajctaeawG r&S dvd k @ygyJ// 'Dvd k bmjzpfvk d @ jzpf&vJqd kwmud k jynfolvlxkawGu ar;Ed kifwJ hol b,folrS r&S dygbl;//
ar; //ar; //ar; //ar; //ar; // =unf h&wm 'ghxuftrsm;}uD; yd kqd k;oGm;Ed kifr,f/ tm*sifwD;em;vd k tajctaersdK;jzpfoGm;Ed kifw,f/vrf;awGay:rSm t}urf;zufr_awGjzpfEd kifwJ h tajctaexd qd k;&Gm;oGm;Ed kifw,fvd k @ xifygovm;//
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? vlawG[m 'kuQcH&wJ htwd kif;twmwcka&muf+yDqd k&if rdrdwd k @&J @ pdwfrauseyfr_awG oufom&m&zd k @twGuf 'grSr[kwf w&m;r#wr_&zd k @twGuf enf;trsdK;rsdK;oH k;wwf=uygw,f// æ tm*sifwD;em;rSm jynfolawGut}urf;zufr_awGjzpfcJ hwm[m jynfolawGtaeeJ @ olwd k @ud k aumif;aumif;rGefrGef r#r#ww rqufqHbl; xifcJ hvd k @jzpfygw,f// w&m;r#wr_&aew,fvd k @ ,H k}unfr_&S dwJ hvlawG[m t}urf;zufavh r&S dygbl;//
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? ydwfqd k @r_awGeJ @ywfoufvd k @ (tD;-,l)eJ @ tar&duefjynfaxmifpku yd k+yD; wif;wif;rmrm vkyfr,fvd k @t&dyfta&mifjyaeygw,f// 'gayrJ h=opa=w;vsuawmh tjyKoabmaqmifwJ hcsOf;uyfr_ud k quf+yD;awmh usif h=uHaeygw,f// 'Dawm htjynfjynfqd kif&m tod kif;t0d kif;rSm =opa=w;vsu b,fvd kae&m a&mufaeygovJ//
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? 'Dar;cGef;[m =opa=w;vswa,mufjzpfwJ h &Sif htaeeJ @ ud k,f hEd kifiHud k jyefar;&rSmjzpfygw,f// &Sifwd k @Ed kifiH[m 'Drd kua&pDEd kifiHyJ// &Sifwd k @tpd k;&ud k ar;=unf hEd kifcGif h&S dwmyJ// ar;cGef;trsm;}uD; ypfar;Ed kifwmyJ// usrwd k @[mvn;f'DtajzawGud kodcsifygw,f// =opa=w;vsu 'Drlud k bmjzpfvd k @usif hoH k;aevJqd kwmud k usrwd k @ odcsifaeygw,f//tck bmawGyJjzpfcJ hjzpfcJ h jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;jzpfajrmufEd kifr,fvd k @ ,lq&atmif olwd k @rSm vsKd @0Sufem;vnfr_&S dxm;vd k @vm;//
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? =opa=w;vs tpd k;&ud k bmrsm; today;csifygovJ//ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? usrwd k @taeeJ @ =opa=w;vstpd k;&ud k xyfwvJvJyJ olwd k @&J hvkyf&yfawGeJ @ywfoufvd k @ oabmrwl
bl;qd kwm today;cJ hygw,f//
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu etz [m trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;ud k pdwf r0ifpm;bl;vd k @ ajymcJ hygw,f? æ etz &J @ wH k @qd kif;r_taemufrSm bmawG&S dovJvd k @ xifyg ovJ?
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? usrajymcJ hwmu oufaotaxmuftxm;awGt& etz [m trsdK;om; jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;rSmtrSefwu,fpdwf0ifpm;yH k r&bl;qd kwmygyJ? &if=um;apha&;ud k pdwfr0ifpm;bl;qd kwm pdwf r0ifpm;wma=umif h
oufoufygyJ? wjcm; pdwfr0ifpm;apcsifp&mta=umif; r&S dEd kifygbl;? vlawGeJ @ywfoufvd k @oHo,awG&S dEd kifygw,f?'gayr,f h &if=um;aphr_ud k vd kvm;Ed kifygw,f? wu,fqd k&if (tef-t,fvf-'D)eJ @ 'Drd kua&pDv_yf&Sm;r_[m +yD;cJ hwJ h(14)ESpftwGif;u jy\emawGeJ @ywfoufvd k @ cH&wJ hbufu &S daew,fqd kwm todtrSwfjyK&ygvdrf hr,f? 'ga=umif husrwd k @taeeJ @ jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;vrf;pOfud k eufeufeJeJqkyfud kifxm;jcif; enf;enf;av;rS rav#mhcJ hygbl; usrwd k @taeeJ @ tm%myd kifawGud k oHo,eJ @=unf hcsifp&mta=umif;awGtrsm;}uD; &S dygw,f? olwd k @ud k owdeJ @&_jrifwmwcsdK@ae&mawGrSm emusnf;r_eJ @&_jrifwmawG &S dEd kifygw,f? 'gayr,f h usrwd k @&J @trsdK;om;&if=um;apha&;ud k vd kvm;csuf[m enf;enf;r Susqif; roGm;Ed kifygbl;? etz taeeJ @ jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;ud k pdwfr0ifpm;bl;qd kvd k @&S d&ifjyefvnf&if=um;apha&;ud k rvd kvm;vd k @yJjzpfrSmyg? wjcm;ta=umif; r&S dEd kifygbl;? trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;twGuf róud;yrf;jcif;[m bm tusdK;tjrwfrSjzpfaprSm r[kwfygbl;? trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;ud k
&,lEd kifr,fqd k&if tjrwfcsnf;ygyJ? ,H k=unfr_wnfaqmufa&;qd kwm b,favmuftcsdef,l&rSmvJ/ 'gud kqG Jaer,fqd k&if vd kwm&J @qef @usifbuf tusdK;oufa&mufr_awG jzpfvmEd kifygw,f?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 163/208
163
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? (tef-t,fvf-'D)taeeJ @ vkyfyH kvkyfenf;yH kpHajymif;zd k @ tcsdefa&muf+yDxifygovm;?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? usrwd k @[m tpOft+rJyJ vkyfyHkvkyfenf;trsdK;rsdK;ud k wpfcsdefwnf;rSmoH k;&ygw,f? vkyfyH kvkyfenf;
wckwnf;&,fvd k @ r&S dygbl;? trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;jzpfajrmufzd k @twGuf vkyfyH kvkyfenf; trsdK;rsdK;oH k;zd k @&m usrwd k @utqifoif hygyJ? trsdK;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;[m jzpfud kjzpf&r,f? jzpfvnf;jzpfajrmufrSmyg? 'gayr,f h Ed kifiHeJ @jynfoltusdK;twGuf tjrefjzpfajrmufzd k @vd kygw,f? æ pD;yGm;a&;tajctae[m qd k;&Gm;aew,f?yd k+yD; qd k;zd k @vJ aocsmoavmufygyJ? aemuf+yD; wjcm;udpPawGvnf;&S dygao;w,f? Oyrm- ynma&;/ usef;rma&;aygh? tckcsdefrSm jrefrmEd kifiHusef;rma&;eJ @ ywfoufvd k @ajym&&if (tdyfcsf-td kif-AG D) at-td kif-'Dtufpf-ta=umif;xnf hrajymvd k @ rjzpfygbl;? (tdyfcsf-td kif-AD G§at-td kif-'Dtufpf) [m 'DEd kifiHrSm v#ifjrefpGmjyef @yGm;aeygw,f?urB mhusef;rma&;tzG J @}uD;uvnf; 'DudpPeJ @ywfoufvdk @ tawmfpdk;&drfylyifae&w,fvdk @ em;vnfxm;ygw,f?jyif;jyif;xefxef ta&;,laqmif&Gufr_ r&S d&if r=umrDtwGif;rSm xdef;rEd kif odrf;r&tqif hud k a&mufoGm;r,fvd k @xifaeygw,f? usrwd k @taeeJ @ vlom;csif;pmemr_udpPrsm; (tdwfcsf-td kif-AD G§at-td kif-'D-tufpf tygt0if )eJ @ywfoufvd k @ tm%myd kifawGeJ @ yl ;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ tqifoif h&S dcJ hygw,f? 'gayr,f h tm%myd kifawGu(tdwfcsf-td kif-AD G§at-td kif-'D-tufpf)eJ @ ywfoufwJ hudpPawGawmif usrwd k @eJ @ yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ rvd kvm;ygbl; æ'ga=umif hrd k @vd k @ tm%myd kifawG&J @apwemeJ @ywfoufvd k @ ar;cGef;xkwf&ygr,f? æ
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? tzGJ@0if pkaqmif;a&;eJ@ywfoufvdk@ +yD;cJhwJhESpftwGif;rSm tajctaeb,fvdk&SdygovJ? usaemfpum;ajymcJ h&wJ hvli,fawGu olwd k @[m pdwfysufvm+yD; (tef-t,fvf-'D)eJ @a0;uGmaew,f? tpd k;&u olwd k @tdwfxJud kyk dufqHxnf hay;&ifyJ auseyfw,fvd k @ajym=uw,f? tzG J @0ifpkaqmif;a&;rSm jy\emawG&S daeygovm;?vli,f awG[m tef-t,fvf-'D eJ @ uif;uGmvmw,fvd k @ xifygovm;?
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? usrtaeeJ @ qef @usifbufjrifygw,f? usrwd k @[m vli,fawG&J @axmufcHr_ud k qxufxrf;yd k; &aeygw,f? 'gha=umif h tck &SifajymcJ hwJ htcsuftvufud k &Sif;jyapcsifygw,f? vli,fawG[m (tef-t,fvf-'D)uae+yD;yd kufqH &Sma&;bufud k a&$ @ajymif;aew,fqd kwJ hrSwfcsufud k bmtay:rSm tajccHxm;ygovJ?
ar;? ? usaemf vrf;ay:rSmav#muf+yD; usaemfeJ @pum;ajymcJ hwJ h vli,fwcsdK@&J @ xif jrifcsufud kar;=unf hwJ htcgolwd k @u yd kufqHwd k @ aw;*Dwwd k @ &S d&if+yD;wmyJ/ (tef-t,fvf-'D)v_yf&Sm;r_ud k owdjyKrdwJ hyH kawmif r&bl;?
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? 'Dvli,fawG[m tpuwnf;u Ed kifiHa&;rSm pdwf0ifpm;yH k r&ygbl;? txl;ojzif h &efukefrSm t*Fvdyfpum;u|rf;u|rf;usifusifajymEd kifwJ h wcsdK@vli,fawG[m wcsdefvH k; aysmfaysmfyg;yg; aecsifwJ h vli,frsdK;/ yd kufqHwd k @/
'pfpfud kwd k @omvd kvm;wJ h vli,frsdK;awGomjzpfrSmyg? 'g[m tH h=op&m r[kwfygbl;? b,frSmrqd k vli,frsm;[m aysmfaysmfyg;yg;aecsif=uygw,f? 'gayr,f h +yD;cJ hwJ hESpftwGif; wu,f htH h=op&mudpPuawmh vli,fawG&J @axmufcHr_ygyJ? ajym&r,fqd k&ifawmh &efukeftjyifuvli,fawG[m &efukefuvli,fawGxufyd k+yD; tajctaeud kowdjyKrdyH k&ygw,f? 'g[m &efukeftjrifrSm pdwfud kpG Jaqmifp&mudpPawGyd kenf;+yD; vuf&S dtajctae&J @ jy\emawGud k yd k+yD;owdjyKrdvd k @ jzpfEd kifygw,f? usrtaeeJ @ &Sif har;cGef;ud k enf;enf;th H=ordygw,f? ud k,f h&J @ aumif;pm;a&;ud kom t+rJpdwf0ifpm;wJ hvli,fawGuawmh Ed kifiHa&;tajctaeawG b,fvd kyJjzpfae jzpfae olwd k @&J haumif;pm;a&;ud kyJ pdwf0ifpm;ae=urSmygyJ? æ
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? aemufqH k;taeeJ @ yDnJ&d k;ud k v#dK@0SuftoHzrf;wJ hudpPeJ @ywfoufvd k @ 'DudpP[m tjynfjynfqd kif&m
tod kif;t0d kif;ay:rSm b,fvd ktusdK;oufa&mufr_&S dcJ hygovJ? 'DudpP[m tajctaeawGud k wqpfcsdK;ajymif;apcJ hw,fvd k @ xifygovm;?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 164/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
164
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? 'DudpPa=umif h wqpfcsdK;ajymif;vJr_jzpfapcJhw,fvd k @qd k&if Ed kifiHwumtod kif;t0d kif;eJ @ywfoufvdk @pdwfysuf&rSmyJ? wu,fawmh'g[m odyftH h=op&mudpPawmh r[kwfygbl;? 'DudpPawGu tm%myd kifawG&J @ apwemeJ @ ywfoufvd k @ ar;cGef;xkwfp&m aemufwcsufjzpfygw,f? æ
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? tm%myd kifawG[m bmjzpfvd k @ trsKd;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;ud k rvd kvm;bl;vd k @ xifygovJ?ajz ? tajymif;tvJ rvd kvm;vd k @jzpfrSmyg? trsKd;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;jzpf+yDqd k&if tajymif;tvJawG
u jzpfvmrSmyg? tajymif;tvJqd kwm vd kvm;onfjzpfap rvd kvm;onf jzpfap a&SmifvJ $vd k @ r&ygbl ; æ 'ga=umif h
rd k @vd k @ b,fvd ktajymif;tvJawG 'DEd kifiHrSm jzpfoif hw,fqd kwm usrwd k @ twltajz&Smzd k @vd kygw,f?
ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ?ar; ? (tef-t,fvf-'D) u (e-t-z) eJ @ vlom;csif;pmemr_taxmuftyh HeJ @ywfoufvd k @ yl ;aygif;aqmif&Gufzd k @ tqifoif h&S dw,fvd k @ajym&mrSm 'Dvkyfief;awGrSm wm0ef&S dr_/ jrifomodomEd kifwJ htajctaeeJ @ vGwfvGwfvyfvyf avhvmoH k;oyfjcif;pwJ h vuQ%mawGeJ @ ud kufnD&r,fqd kwJ h (tef-t,fvf-'D)&J @ tjrifa=umif hvm;?
ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ?ajz ? vlom;csif;pmemwJ htaxmuftyH heJ @ywfoufwJ h usrwd k @&J @rlawGeJ @ ud kufnDvd k @jzpfygw,f? apmapmuusrajymcJ hwJ htwd kif;yJ pD;yGm;a&;ydwfqd k @r_/ taxmuftyH hay;r_/ urB mvSnf hc&D;oGm;vkyfief;rsm; ponfwd k @eJ @ qd kifwJ htajccHr_awGrSm usrwd k @ajymif;vJjcif; r&S dygbl;? vlom;csif; pmemwJ htaxmuftulqd kif&mawGrSm yl;aygif;jcif;[m
usrwd k @&J @tajccHr_awGud k ajymif;vJ&ma&mufrSm r[kwfygbl;? bmjzpfvd k @vJqd kawmh vlom;csif;pmemr_qd kif&mtaxmuftuleJ @ywfoufvd k @&S d&if wm0ef,lr_ jrifomodomEd kifwJ htajctaeeJ @ vGwfvGwfvyfvyf avhvmoH k;oyfjcif;wd k @&S d&r,fqd kwm usrwd k @ t+rJyJajymcJ hwmjzpfygw,f? 'Dae&mrSm tajccHrlrsm;ud k rxdcd kufbJ usrwd k @taeeJ @ jynf hjynf h00 vGwfvGwfvyfvyf yl;aygif;aqmif&GufEd kifygw,f? aemuf+yD; 'Dvd kyl;aygif;aqmif&Gufjcif;[myd k+yD;aumif;rGefwJ h &if=um;apha&;twGuf b,fvd k twlvkyfoGm;Ed kifrvJqd kwmud k tajz&SmEd kifygw,f? yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufa&;vkyfief;[m ppfrSefwJ h trsdK;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;jzpfzd k @twGuf b,fvd knS dEd _if;Ed kifrvJqd kwmud k odEd kifzd k @jzpfygw,f? yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufa&;[m usrwd k @tqifajyEd kifrvm;vd k @ avhvm=unf hwmr[kwfyJ b,fvd ktqifajyatmifvkyfEd kifrvJvdk @ tajz&Smwmjzpfygw,f? wd kif;jynftusdK;twGuf usrwd k @=um;rSm tqifajy
atmifvkyf&ygvdrf hr,f? ÐÐÐÐ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 165/208
165
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
“1947 ckESpfu txufjrefrmEd kifiHrSm pnf;¶k H;a&;c&D;oGm;+yD;wJ haemufrSm azazuae+yD;awmh rk H&Gmud ka&mufcJ hygw,f?tJvd k rk H&Gmud ka&mufwJ htwGuf pnf;¶k H;a&;c&D;uvJenf;enf;yrf;vmwJhtcgusawmh rkH&Gmudka&mufwJhtcgrSm rkH&Gmu(zqyv)tzJ G @csKyfuae+yD;awmh olwk d @taeeJ @ em;em;aeae aexd kifzk d @twGuf pDpOfvd kufygw,f? pDpOfwJ htcgawmh azaz ub,fvd kajymvJqk dawmh rk H&GmuuG,f æ vdrRmw,f æ vd k @ajymw,fwJ h? usrwd k @ajym&rSmu rk H&Gmu vdrRmw,fvd k @ajymr,f htpm; rk H&Gmu cd kifrmw,fvd k @ usr ajymcsifygw,f? (=obm(=obm(=obm(=obm(=obmoHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)
bmjzpfvd k @vJqk dawmh rk H&Gmu 1988 ckESpfeJ @ rxl;bJ rxl;jcm;em;bJ cdkifckdifrmrm&yfwnfaew,f? ydk+yD;awmhawmifrS
ck difrm w,fqk dwm usrwk d @ jrif&ygw,f? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)yd k+yD;ck difrmvmwJ hta=umif;ud k usr pOf;pm;vd kufawmh 'g usr xifwmaemf? usrwk d@ jynfolvlxku
rw&m;wmud k róudufbl;? tEk difusif hwmud k róudufbl;?(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) usrwk d @ud k usrwk d @tzJ G @csKyfud k tck usr'Dpnf;± H k ;a&;ayg haemf / ucsi f jynfe,f/ t"duuawmh ucsi f jynfe,fpnf; ¶ k H ;a&; c& D;pO fayg h ?csif;jynfe,ftxda&mufvmawmh usrwdk@uvJ ppfudkif;wkdif;/rauG;wkdif;/rE Wav;wkdif;rSm 0if+yD; awmhwcsKd @òrd @e,fawGrSm usrwk d @0ifvd kufr,fqk d+yD;awmh qk H;jzwf+yD;awmh c&D;pOfxJrSmxnf hwmjzpfygw,f? tJ'D awmh'D ucsifjynfe,fc&D;pOf p uwnf;uyJ usrwdk@&J@vkyfief;awGudkzsufvdkzsufqD;/ tEkdif hxufpD;eif;eJ@}uH @cd kifa&;zH G @òzd;a&;tzG J @u trsKd ;rsKd;vkyfcJ hygw,f? tJ'Dawmh 'D[mawGud k usrwk d @ trsm;}uD;onf;nnf;cHcJ hygw,f?
qENjywmawmh wu,fawmh vlwk dif;vlwk dif;rSm qENjyyk difcGif h&S d&r,fqk dwm usrwk d @&J @t,ltq usrwd k @&J @,k H=unfcsufyJ? tm%myd kifawGtaeeJ @ wu,fyJ vlwk dif;vlwk dif;rSm qENjyyk difcGif h&S d&r,fqk dwm ,k H=unf&if vlwk dif;vlwk dif;ud k qENjyyd kifcGif hay;&r,f? (rSefygw,f? rSefygw,f? =obmoHrsm;)(rSefygw,f? rSefygw,f? =obmoHrsm;)(rSefygw,f? rSefygw,f? =obmoHrsm;)(rSefygw,f? rSefygw,f? =obmoHrsm;)(rSefygw,f? rSefygw,f? =obmoHrsm;) 'gayr,f hvd k @ txl ;tcGif hta&;taeeJ @}uH @ck difzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @ud k qENjyyk difcGif hay;wmud kawmh xm;vd kufygawmh usrwk d @ 'gud k bmrS odyf+yD;awmhrajymvd kygbl;?'gayr,f h wu,f hrSefuefwJ hqENjyjcif;awmh r[kwfygbl;? wcsKd @jynfolawG twif;t=uyf rvd kufrae&qk d+yD;awmhac:vm+yD;awmh qENjyck dif;wmawGvJ&S dyg w,f?
(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)tJ'gtjyifrSm usrwk d @uvJ bmrSrwkef @jyefygbl;? bmrSrwkef @jyefbl;? usrwk d @taeeJ @ tm%myd kifawGud k
today;w,f? 'Dvd kyJ }uH @ck difzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @ u w&m;Oya'eJ @rnDwJ hudpPawGud k vkyfaeygw,fqk dayr,f hvJ tm%myd kifawGu ta&;r,lbl;? ta&;r,lawmh tm%myd kifawGu olwk d @vufrSm&S dw,fqk dwJ hoabmxm;eJ @ usrwd k @uvJ bmrS rwkef @jyefbl;qk dwmud kodaeawmh 'D }uHck difzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @uvJ wpxufwp yd k+yD;awmhqk d;vmw,f?
jrefrmh'Drk dua&pDacgif;aqmif a':atmifqef;pk-unf
2003 ckESpf/ arv(29)&ufaeŒ nurk H&G mòrdŒ qk dif;bkwfwifyJ GwGif ajym-um;cJ honf h rdefŒ cGef;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 166/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
166
wpxuf wp yd k+yD;awmhqk d;vmw,fqk dwmu usrwk d @ 'D rwW&m ud k pOf hul;uk dvmwJ htcgrSm usnfawmufayguf&GmrSmusawmh wkwfawG/ "m;awG/ avmufav;*GawG eJ @ usrwk d @&JŒtzJ G @awGud k usrwk d @ud k axmufcHwJ holawGud k&rf;um;vmwJ htxdjzpfvmw,f? 'gayr,f h usrwk d @ b,fvd krSrwkef @jyefygbl;? &Jpcef;rSmyJ tr_zGif hvd kufygw,f?
bmjzpfvd k @vJqk dawmh usrwk d @u 'DEk difiHrSm Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;&S dovm; r&S dovm;qk dwm aoaocsmcsmodcsifvd k @?r&S d&ifvJ oufaoeJ @ aoaocsmcsmod&atmif? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) 'Dawmh aemufwae@usawmh rwW&mrSmusawmhxyf+yD;awmh wqif hwk d;+yD;awmh usrwk d @ud k aESmif h,SufwJ htaeeJ @ usrwk d @tzJ G @csKyf¶k H;xJrSm usrwk d @tzJ G @csKyf&J @ y&d0k%ftwGif;xJrSm usrwd k @ vli,fzJ G @pnf;a&;vkyfaecsdefrSm y&dowf tJ'DutzJ G @csKyfu +cHuawmfawmfus,fygw,f?tck 'Duae [d kbuf +cHpnf;¶k d;avmuf&S dr,f? tJ'Dawmhy&dowfuvJ +cHxJrSmyJ&S dw,f? wcsKd @uvJ+cHtjyifrSmvrf;[d kbufrSm&S dw,f? tJ'Dvd ktcsdefrSm 'D }uH @ck difzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @ u um;awGeJ @atmfvH}uD;awGeJ @vm+yD;awmh [d kusrwk d @ud kaESmif h,Suf &efpwJ hoabmeJ @vkyfvmw,f? vkyfvmawmh usrwk d @vJbmrS rvkyfygbl;? 'Dvd kyJ uk d,f h[mud k,fqufvkyfaewkef;/ 'DavmufawmifrS tEk difusif hwmud k=unf hr&wJ h oHCmawmfawGuae+yD;awmh axmfvm*sDeJ @vm+yD;awmh avmufav;*GeJ @ ypfawmhrSyJ 'Dum;awGxGufoGm;w,f? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)
tJ'Dawmh usrwd k @jrifwmuawmh oHCmawmfawGuvJ 'Dvd k wbufowftEk difusif haewmud k =unf hr& awmhvk d @ vkyfwmyJ? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) 'g w&m;r#wr_ r&S dwmud k/ w&m;r#wr_ r&S dwmud kvufrcHEk difvd k @ 'Dvd kvkyfwmyJ?aemuf+yD;awmhvJ usrwk d @tzJ G @csKyftay:rSm u¶k%moufvd k @vkyfwmyJ? wu,f wzufowfcHae&w,fqk d+yD;wmhtJ'Dawmh tckusrwk d @ 'Dud k rk H&Gmud kvmwJ htcgrSmvJ usrwk d @=um;wmayghav? ppfud kif;wk dif;rSm b,fvd k/ }uH @ck difzH G @òzd;a&;tzJ G @awGud k b,fvd kpkaqmif;aew,f? b,fvd kum;}uD;awG b,fESpfpD;eJ @ b,fESpfa,muf ac:vmw,f pojzif hpojzif h tJ vrf;rSmvJawG @ygw,f? um;awGa&m/ qENjywJ hvlawGa&m um;awGuawmfawmfud krsm;w,f? wjcm;vlawGawmh um;ydwfxm;w,fvd k @ajymw,f? um;awGbmawG tck wavmiSm;vd k @r&bl;qk d tm;vk H; (=obm(=obm(=obm(=obm(=obmoHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)? 'gayr,fh tJ'DtzJG @uawmh um;awGawmfawmfrsm;ygw,f? tJ'Dawmh usrwk d@rk H&Gmudk0ifvmawmh
acsmif;OD;u tpayghav/ usrwk d @ acsmif ;OD;u jynfolvlxkua&m/ acsmif;OD;eJ @ rk H&Gm=um;xJu&GmawGu jynfolvlxkua&m wcJeuf usrwk d @ud ktm;ay;axmufcHwm[m 'Dvd k rw&m;vkyfwm/ tEk difusif hwmud k róudufvd k @ axmufcHaewmud kvJ trsm;}uD;ygw,fvd k @ usr 'Dvd kyJ,k H=unfygw,f”
'Dawmh usrwk d @ rk H&Gmud k0ifvmawmh acsmif;OD;u tpayghav/ usrwk d @ acsmif;OD;ujynfolvlxkua&m/acsmif;OD;eJ @rk H&Gm=um;xJu&GmawGu jynfolvlxkua&m wcJeuf usrwk d @ud k tm;ay;axmufcHwm[m 'Dvdkrw&m;vkyfwm/ tEk difusif hwmud k róudufvd k @ axmufcHaewmud kvJ trsm;}uD;ygw,fvd k @ usr 'Dvd kyJ,k H=unfygw,f?(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) usr 'gawGusawmh usr tifrwefrS auseyfygw,f? bmjzpfvd k @vJqk dawmh tajccHtm;jzif husr wd k @jynfolvlxk[m rw&m;wJ hudpPawG róudufbl;/ tEk difusif hwmud k rESpfòrd @bl;? cH&wJ hbufud krS u¶k%m
oufw,fqk dwm 'g tifrwefrSaumif;ygw,f? tJ'Dawmh usrwk d @ 'gqk d&if 'Dvd kpdwf"mwfawGuk dtajccH+yD;awmh'Drd kua&pDEk difiH}uD;wckud kxlaxmif&rSm? trSefw&m;onf tiftm;/ tiftm;onf trSefw&m;r[kwfbl;qk dwJ h,k H=unfcsufeJ @ usrwk d @&J @ 'Drd kua&pDEk difiHawmfud k xlaxmifzd k @vd kygw,f? usrwk d @ 'Drd kua&pDxlaxmifr,fqk d+yD;awmhajymaewm[m w&m;Oya'pd k;rk d;a&; &S dapcsifvd k @/ w&m;r#wjcif; &S dapcsifvk d @/ b,folurS b,fol @ud k w&m;Oya'eJ @ rud kufnDbJeJ @tEk difusif hwmawG/ [d k Ak dvfuswmawG rvkyfEk difbl;? tJ'Dawmh tJ'Dvd ktajctae&S dzk d @twGufusrwk d @[m jynfolvlxkud k tmrcHEk difcsufay;r,f hpepfvd kw,f? pepf[m tifrwefrS ta&;}uD;ygw,f? usrud k&Hzef&Hcgar;ygw,f/ pepfeJ @ tJ vleJ @ rleJ @ b,f[myd k+yD;awmhta&;}uD;vJayghaemf? usru jrifygw,f? (2)ckpvk H;ta&;}uD;w,f? vlawGu b,favmufawmfawmf rlaygh pepfu/ pepfuraumif;bl;qk dvd k @&S d&if 'D raumif;wJ hpepfxJrSm awmfwJ hvlawG/ aumif;wJ hvlawGu EH GxJrSmepfovd kepfaer,f? ¶kef;vd k @r&bl;jzpfaer,faemf? (=obmoH(=obmoH(=obmoH(=obmoH(=obmoH
rsm;)rsm;)rsm;)rsm;)rsm;) usrwk d@ wbufu=unf hvd kufvd k@&S d&ifvJ pepfub,favmuf aumif;aumif; vlawGu raumif;bl;/vlawGu rawmfbl;qk dvd k @&S d&if Ek difiHwEk difiHrSm wk d;wufr_&S dEk difrSmr[kwfbl;? tJ'Dawmh ta&;}uD; wmu pepfu
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 167/208
167
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
rSefzd k @aumif;zk d @vJvd kw,f? vlawGuawmfzd k @ óud; pm;zd k @vJvd kw,f? tJ'Dawmh usrwk d @&JŒjrefrmEk difiHu jynfolvlxk[m 'Dvd kpepfaumif;&wJ htcgrSm Ek difiHwk d;wufzk d @twGuf Ek difiHat;csrf;om,mzk d @twGuf vkyfay;Ek difwJ h/t&nftcsif;&S dwJ h jynfolvlxkvm;qk d usrwk d @ok H;oyfvd kufvd k @&S d&if usrwk d @u 'D t&nftcsif;eJ @jynf hpk Hw,fvd k @ xifw,f?
bmjzpfvd k @ usr 'Dvk dxifvJqk dwm ta=umif;u (2)a=umif;aygh? wa=umif;uawmh t&ifork dif;t&ayghaemf?[d k æ vGwfvyfa&;&+yD;pOf umvacwfwkef;uqk dvd k @&S d&if usrwd k @Ek difiH[m usrwk d @ ta&S @awmiftm&SrSmqk dvd k @&S d&iftwk d;wufqk H;Ek difiHjzpfw,f? 'g wcsdefwcg wkef;u usrwk d @&J @Ek difiHu Ek difiHolEk difiHom;awGu usrwd k @a'orSma&S @ajy;jzpfEk difavmufatmifud k t&nftcsif;&S d&if pepfuae+yD;awmhaumif;vd k @&S d&if 'Dvd kt&nftcsif;awG xyf+yD;awmh jyefray:vmp&mta=umif ; bmrSr&S dbl;? aemufwckuvJ tckacwfrSm usrwk d @jrefrmEk difiHu pD;yGm;a&;tajctaeraumif;wJ htcgusawmh Ek difiH&yfjcm;ud koGm;+yD;awmh rdrdwk d @rdom;pkawGtwGuf/ [k d b0&yfwnfEk difzk d @twGuf yd kufqH&Sm&w,faygh? oGm;+yD;awmhtvkyfvkyf&w,f? yd kufqH&SmwJ htvkyfvkyf&wJ hvlawG awmfawmfrsm;rsm;&S d w,f? usrwk d @Ek difiHrSm? tJ'Dvd k Ek difiH&yfjcm;ud k pGef @ pGef @pm;pm;oGm;+yD;awmh toufarG;0rf;a=umif;twGuftvkyfvkyfwJ h jrefrmEk difiHolEk difiHom;awG[m atmifatmifjrifjrif&S dw,f? trsm;pku awmfawmf hud k atmifjrifw,f? [d k oabFmom;awGqk dvd k @&S d&if jrefrmoabFmom;awGqk dvd k @&S d&if wbufuvnf;*k%f,l&w,f/ wbufuvnf; oem;&w,f/ &ifem&w,f? *k%f,l &w,fqk dwm bmjzpfvk d @vJqk dawmh jrefrmoabFmom;awG[m tvkyfodyfvkyfwmyJqk d+yD;awmh Ek difiHjcm;ukr%D awGu oabmusw,f? jrefrmoabFmom;awGqk dvd k @ &S d&if iSm;csifw,f?olwk d @twGuf oem;p&maumif;w,f/ &ifemp&maumif;w,fqk dwm jrefrmoabFmom;awGu b,favmufcd kif;ck dif; ck dif;vd k @vJ&w,f? vc ES drfay;vd k @&S d&ifvJ,lw,f? jrefrmEk difiHu ol @&J @Ek difiHom;awGud k jyef+yD;awmh rumuG,fbl;qk d+yD;awmh vkyfief;&SifawGu jrefrmoabFmom;awGud k tcGif hta&;,lwmrsKd;awG&S dw,f?(=oomoHrsm;)(=oomoHrsm;)(=oomoHrsm;)(=oomoHrsm;)(=oomoHrsm;)
tJ'Dawmh 'goabFmom;awGwif r[kwfbl;? wjcm;ae&mawGrSmvJ'Dvd kyJ? 'Dawmh pepfurSefvd k @&S dvd k @&S d&ifusrwk d @Ek difiHolEk difiHom;awG rwk d;wufp&m ta=umif;r&S dbl;qk dwm xif&Sm;ygw,f? (=obmoHrsm;(=obmoHrsm;(=obmoHrsm;(=obmoHrsm;(=obmoHrsm;)
'gha=umif h usrwk d @[m 'Dvd k jynfolvlxkud ktcGif hta&;tjynf ht0ay;r,f hpepfwckud k xlaxmifzk d @óud;pm;aewmyg? usrwkd@qk dwm jynfolvlxkudk csrf;omatmifvkyfay;r,fhpepfvdk@ tJ'Dvdkrajymygbl;? tcGifhta&;tjynf ht0ay;r,f hpepf/ tJ'DtcGif hta&;ud k rSefrSefuefuefok H;vd k @&S d&if ZJ G/0D&d,/vk HveJ @vkyfr,fqk dvd k @&S d&if usrwk d @Ek difiH[m csrf;omEk difr,f? at;csrf;Ek difr,f? pnf;vk H;r_[m tifrwefrSta&;}uD;ygw,f? usrwk d @Ek difiH[mjynfaxmifpkyg? wkdif;&if;om;vlrsKd;aygif;pkHeJ@zJG @xm;wJh jynfaxmifpkjzpfygw,f? tJ'ga=umifhrkd@vkd@ at;csrf;r_[mtifrwefrS ta&;}uD;ygw,f? vGwfvyfa&;&+yD;wJ h tcsdefumvu p+yD;awmh jynfwGif;vufeufud kif aomif;usef;r_ awGtrsKd;rsKd;&S dcJ hygw,f? tckqk dvd k @&S d&if typftcwf&yfpJa&;oabmwlnDcsufawG&S dayr,f h typftcwf&yfpJa&;qk dwm +idrf;csrf;a&; r[kwfygbl;? +idrf;csrf;a&;oabmwlnDcsufawGawmh r&S dao;ygbl;? tJ'Dawmh +idrf;csrf;a&;
oabmwlnDcsufawG&S dzk d @ usrwk d @&J @jynfaxmifpktwGif;rSm +idrf;csrf;r_tmrcHzk d @qk dwm Ek difiHa&;enf;vrf;eJ @yJ vkyfvd k @& ygw,f? Ek difiHa&;t& wk dif;&if;om;rsm;tm;vk H;[m oabmwlnD trsm;twGufaumif;usKd;ay;r,f hjynfaxmifpkwckud kxlaxmifr,fqk d+yD;awmh qk H;jzwfcsufcsvd kufwJ htcgrS usrwd k @Ek difiH[m wu,fyJat;csrf; oGm;+yDvd k @owfrSwfEk difrSmyg? tJvd k at;csrf;oGm;+yDqk d&if Ek difiHuvJat;csrf;r,f/ jynfolvlxkuvJ tcGif hta&;awGud k tjynf ht0ay;& r,f? usrwk d @ Ek difiHolEk difiHom;awG ud k,f htpGrf;tpeJ @ ud k,f hud k,f ud kcsrf;omatmif/ ud k,f hwk dif;jynfud kcsrf;omatmifvkyfEk difwJ htcGif hta&;awGtrsm;}uD;&rSmyg? 'Dawmh 'Drd kua&pD[m tcGif hta&;ay;wJ hpepf/ vk HòcHr_ay;wJ hpepf/vGwfvyfr_ay;wJ hpepf/ tJ'D &xm;wJ hvGwfvyfr_eJ @/ vk HòcHr_eJ @tcGif hta&;awGabmiftwGif;rSm jynfolvlxku ud k,f hEk difiHwk d;wufatmif ud k,fóud;pm;&r,f?wk d;wufatmifóud;pm;csifwJ h pdwf "mwf &S d&r,f? óud;pm;csifwJ h t&nftcsif;&S d&r,f? tJ'Dvd k t&nftcsif;awG&S datmifvd k @ Ek difiHawmfu tjynf ht0ulnD&r,f? qk dvd kwmu Ek difiHawmfu
tqif hjrif hwJ hynma&;pepf vlawGrSm&S datmifvkyfay;&r,f? tqif hjrif hwJ hynma&;pepfr&S dbJeJ @ usr wk d @&J @jynfolawG[m wk d;wufrSm r[kwfbl;? (axmufcHoHrsm;)(axmufcHoHrsm;)(axmufcHoHrsm;)(axmufcHoHrsm;)(axmufcHoHrsm;)
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 168/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
168
usr em;vnfw,f/ usrwk d @ausmif;om;awGu tckynma&;pepfeJ @ywfoufvd k @ auseyfr_ r&S dbl;? (axmufcH(axmufcH(axmufcH(axmufcH(axmufcHoHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;) auseyfr_r&S dawmh wbufuae=u!h fvd k @&S d&ifawmh 'g 0rf;enf;p&maumif;wmaygh? usrwk d @&J @vli,fawG[m'Dynma&;pepfeJ @ywfoufvd k @ auseyfr_r&S dbl;?wbufuae=unf hvd k @&S d&ifawmh 'gaumif;wJ hvuQ%myJ? tqif hr&S d
wJ hpepfud k tqif h r&S dbl;vd k @odwm[m tifrwefrSaumif;ygw,f? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)tqif htwef;rrDwJ h ynma&;pepfud k odyf+yD;awmhtxif}uD;aevd k @&S d&if usrwk d @ b,fvd kvkyfwk d;wufrSmvJ?'gav;eJ@auseyfaerSmvm;? tJ'Dawmhusrwkd @vli,fawGu rsufpdyGif hem;yGif hr_&Sdw,f?wcsKd@vli,fawGuawmhud k,f htwGuf ud k,fyJ pOf;pm;w,f? ud k,fat;at;csrf;csrf; aecsifw,f? 'Dvd k [d k tckacwf acwfay:ypPnf;awGok H;csifw,f/ pm;csifw,f/aomufcsifw,f/ aysmfcsifw,f/yg;csifw,f? 'Dvd kvli,fawGawmh 'gawmh usrwk d @Ek difiHwifr[kwfygbl;? Ek difiHwk dif;vd kvd krSm &S dw,faygh? 'gayr,f h usrwk d @vli,ftawmfrsm;rsm;[m Ek difiHa&;pdwf"mwf &S dw,fqk dwm usrawG @&w,f? Ek difiHa&;pdwf"mwf&S dwmvJ b,folrS roifxm;bJeJ @aemf/ tckacwfqk dvd k @&S d&if Ek difiHa&;qk dtm;ay;rSm r[kwfbl;? [d k usrwd k @ vGwfvyfa&;acwfwkef;uqk d&if tJ ocifaygufp axmif(6)vqk d+yD;awmhajcmuf=uw,f? usrwk d @acwfrSmawmh Ek difiHa&;vkyfvd k @ axmif(6)vqk dwm &Dawmif&Dcsifao;w,f? (=obm(=obm(=obm(=obm(=obmoHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)
axmifu ajcmufvqd kvd k @&S d&ifawmh tem;,loGm;w,fvd k @yJ xif&rSmaygh? tJawmh 'DavmufawmifrS Ed kifiHa&;ud k tm; ray;wJ hacwf? Ed kifiHa&;rSm vl}uD;/ vli,fra&G; pdwf r0ifpm;atmifvkyfaewJ hacwf}uD;rSm vli,fawG[mEd kifiHa&;pdwf"mwf&S dvmw,f? vli,fawGu olwd k @ud k,folwd k @ Ed kifiHa&;pdwf"mwf&S drSef;awmif od&JŒvm;awmh rodbl;? 'gayr,f h Ed kifiHa&;pdwf"mwf&S dw,f? usrwd k @ bmvd k @&S dvJ ajymvJqd kwm[m 'DtajctaeawGrSm ajymif;vJ& r,fqd kwmem;vnfw,f? ajymif;vJr_ud k vd kvm;w,f? aemuf+yD;awmhvJ rjzpfoif hwmawGjzpfaewm? rw&m;wJ hudpPawGjzpfaewmud k vH k;0 rauseyfbl;? tJ'ga=umif h usrajymaewm? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) apmapmu usrajymovd kaygh? usrwd k @ud k jynfolvlxkuae+yD;awmh usrwd k @tzG J @csKyf&JŒvkyfief;pOf/ usrwk d @tzG J @csKyf&J @ rlawGud koabmusvd k @
axmufcHwmqd k&ifvJ usrwk d @oabmuswmyJ? tJvd kaxmuf cHr_qd k&if usrwd k @óudqd kw,f? 0rf;omw,f? 'gayr,f h'Drw&m;r_ud k róudufvd k @ usrwd k @ud k axmufcHw,fqk d&if usr yd k+yD;awmhñudufw,f? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) rw&m;r_ud k róudufwJ h Ed kifiHol/ Ed kifiHom;awG[m rdrdwd k @Ed kifiHrSm w&m;Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;twGuf xdxda&mufa&mufvkyfay;Ed kifwJ hEd kifiHolEd kifiHom;awG? w&m;Oya'pdk;rdk;a&;qdkwm[m vlwdkif;vlwdkif;ud k Oya'abmifatmufrSm wef;wlnDwlumuG,fr_ay;xm;+yD;awmh Ed kifiHawmfeJ @ Ed kifiHol Ed kifiHom;awGud kvH kòcHr_ay;wJ h pepfyJ? tckaemufyd kif;rSm usrwd k @ rd k;ukwf/rE Wav;/ acsmif;OD;/rH k&Gm'Dbufyd kif;awG a&mufvmwJ htcgusawmh usr=unf hvd kufwJ htcgusawmh usrwd k @&JŒ jynfolvlxkud k 'Drd kua&pDeJ @ rxd kufwefbl;vd k @ ajymwJ hvlawGu jynfolvlxkeJ @xdawG @r_ vH k;vH k;r&S dbl;xifw,fvd k @ usrxifw,f? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)usrwd k @jynfol[m 'Drd kua&pDeJ @xd kufwefw,fqd kwm usrwd k @,H k=unfw,f? 'gayr,f h
usrwd k @'Drd kua&pD&zd k @qd kwmawmh óud;pm;&rSmyJ? bmrS tvum;r&bl;aemf? vG,fvG,feJ @awmhr&bl;? vG,fvG,feJ @ay; csifvd k @&S d&if ay;wm=umvS+yD? (15)ESpfvH k;vH k;? (&DoHrsm;)(&DoHrsm;)(&DoHrsm;)(&DoHrsm;)(&DoHrsm;)'Dawmh vG,fvG,feJ @ r&wJ hudpPrd k @vd k @ óud;pm;yrf;pm;eJ @vkyf&r,f? usrwd k @tzG J @csKyfu jynfolvlxkud k ay;xm;wJ h
uwdtwk dif; jrefrmEd kifiHrSm 'Drd kua&pDpepfxGef;um;zd k @twGuf/ wnfwH hck difrmzd k @twGuf/ xyf+yD;awmh usrwd k @óud;pm;rSmyJ? &wJ htxd vkyfoGm;rSmyJ? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) atmifjrifr,f ratmifjrifbl;qd kwm ar;p&mta=umif;r&Sdbl;? atmifjrifr,f? 'gayr,f hvJ b,favmufjrefjref atmifjrifr,fqd kwJ har;cGef;u ta&;}uD;w,faemf?bmjzpfvd k @ vJqd kawmh 'Drd kua&pDpepfxGef;um;zd k @ =umavav wd kif;jynfemavavyJ? pD;yGm;a&;u wae@xufwae@usaew,fqd kwm usrwd k @ jynfolvlxktm;vH k;odw,f? ukefaps;E_ef;awGu wufw,f/ pD;yGm;a&;u usw,f? 'g[m tm;vH k;odw,f? 'Dvd ktajctaerSm wk dif;jynfwjynf[m xyf+yD;awmh =um =umaevd k @&S d&if jynfol
vlxk trsm;}uD;'kuQa&mufrSmyJ? 'Davmufqd kawmh usrwk d @ tajymif ;tvJu tjrefvd kw,fqd kwm[m pD;yGm;a&;eJ @Ed kifiHa&;[m cG Jjcm;vd k @ r&bl;? 'D Ed kifiH&JŒpD;yGm;a&;pepf nH hzsif;aewm[m Ek difiHa&;pepf nH @zsif;vd k @yJjzpfw,f? (=obm(=obm(=obm(=obm(=obm
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 169/208
169
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;)oHrsm;) tJ'Dawmh pD;yGm;a&orm;awGqd kwmvJ rdrdwd k @&JŒOya'abmiftwGif;rSm rdrdwd k @&JŒvkyfyd kifcGif hawGeJ @ vH kvH kòcHòcHvkyfyd kifcGif h&S d&r,f? tJ'Dvd k&S dwJ h pepfrSmrS wd kif;jynf[m pD;yGm;a&;t&wd k;wufEd kifrSm? 'Dawmh usrwd k @ 'Drd kua&pDjrefjrefvd kcsifw,f? b,favmufjrefjrefvd kcsifovJqd k? wcsKd @uawmh ajymwmayghaemf/ tcsdef,l&r,f/ bm tcsdef,l
csifvJ (15)ESpfwm awmfavmuf+yDvd k @ usrxifw,f? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) 'gayr,f h usrwk d @u tjrefqk H; 'Drd kua&pD& atmifvd k @ usrwk d @óud;pm;aew,f? 'D óud;pm;wJ hae&mrSm jynfolvlxk&JŒaxmufcHr_[m usrwd k @twGufta&;}uD;qH k;yJ? 'Drd kua&pD&zd k @uawmh usrwd k @ odyf+yD;awmhoHo,jzpfp&mta=umif; r&S dbl;? &ud k &r,f? bmjzpfvd k @vJqd kawmhjynfolvlxk&JŒqENu tJ'DbufrSm&S dw,f? 'DurB m&J @ ord kif;a&pD;a=umif;u 'Drd kua&pDbufrSm&S dw,f? urB mhukvor*~eJ @wuG urB mhEd kifiHtrsm;pku jrefrmEd kifiH&JŒ'Drd kua&pDv_yf&Sm;r_uk d axmufcHw,f/ tm;ay;=uw,f? 'Dawmhusrwdk @[m 'Drd kua&pD&rSm? &wJ htcgusvd k @&S d&if 'Drd kua&pDwnfwH hcd kif+rJatmifvkyfzk d @awmh usruae+yD;awmhrH k&Gmòrd @ol/ òrd @om;rsm;ud k owday;csifw,f? bmjzpfvd k @ usr'Dvd kajymwmvJ qd kawmh rH k&Gmðrd @ol/ ðrd @om;rsm;[musr apmapmuajymovd k cd kifrmw,f/ tiftm;awmif hw,f? ud k,f h&JŒtiftm;ud k rSefrSefuefuefok H;zk d @vd kw,f?'D tiftm;ud k pnf;urf;wuseJ @ rSefrSefuefuefoH k;r,fqd kvd k @&S d&if usrwd k @Ed kifiH[m tjref}uD;wd k;wufvdrf hr,f?'Drd kua&pDpepfrSmtjref}uD;wd k;wufvdrf hr,f? }uD;rm;wJ htiftm;ud k tvG JoH k;pm;vkyfvd k @&S d&ifawmh tE W&m,f&S dwwfygw,f? tJ'ga=umif hrk d @ vd k @ usrwd k @&JŒjynfolvlxk[m 'Drd kua&pD&wJ htcg usvd k @&S d&if ud k,f hwm0efawGud kvJodapcsifw,faemf? 'Drd kua&pDqd kwm tcGif hta&;}uD;yJ r[kwfbl; wm0efvJ&S dw,f? 'Drd kua&pDpepf&Sifoefzd k @qd kwm[m tpOft+rJyJóud;pm;ae=u&w,f? [d k usrwd k @ Ed kifiHolEd kifiHom;awG&J h tm;enf;csufwcku bmvJqd kawmhudpPwckud k p +yD;vd k @qd kvd k @&S d&if/ 'grSr[kwf vkyfief;wckud k p+yD;qd kvd k @&S d&if xdef;odrf;wJ hae&mrSm enf;enf;tm;enf;w,f? Oyrmtm;jzif h vrf;awGaygh? vrf;awGazmuf+yD;awmh 'gayr,f hvrf;awG xdef;odrf;jcif;r&S dvd k @ usefwJ hvrf;awGu ayguf+yJ csKdif hawGjzpfaemf? (=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;)(=obmoHrsm;) 'guawmh trsm;oH k;wJ hvrf;qd kawmh b,folrS*&krpd kufbl;qd kwJ h oabmrsdK;rd k @vk d @vm;awmh rodbl;? tJvd kqd k&if raumif;bl;? usrxyfwvJvJajymygw,f? trsm;yd kifypPnf;ud k
ud k,fyd kifypPnf;xuf wefzd k;xm;&r,f/ av;pm;&r,f? tJ'Dvd k trsm;yd kifypPnf;ud k ud k,fyd kifypPnf;xuf wefzd k;xm;Ed kifwJ hpdwf&S drS usrwd k @ wu,fwd k;wufwJ h'Drd kua&pDpepfjzpfr,f?
aemuf+yD;awmh usrwd k @ud k,fyd kiftdrf,mawGqd k&ifvJ usr wd k @jrefrmvlrsdK;awmfawmfrsm;rsm;[m tdrf yxrp aqmufwkef;u tdrfuvSyoef @&Sif;ae+yD;awmh aemufawmh xdef;odrf;r_ae&mrSm odyfrvkyfcsifbl;? yk dufqHtukefcH+yD;awmh tdrfud k rxdef;odrf;csifbl;? jyifwmqd kwm rvkyfcsifbl;? ysufwmud k qufae aew,f? tJawmh tdrfwtdrf[m (4-5-6)ESpf =umwJ h tcgusawmh tajctaeu odyfrvSawmhbl;? wajz;ajz;ysufpD;,d k,Gif;vmw,f?wu,fqd kvd k @&S d&if tdrfawG[m quf+yD;awmh xdef;odrf;xm;r,fqd kvd k @&S d&if ESpf&mcsD+yD;awmhcHw,f? olwk d @ Oa&myrSmqk dvd k @&S d&if Oa&myEk difiHawGrSm olwk d @ vlrsKd;toD;oD;ayghaemf? olwk d @awG[m tJvd k xdef;odrf;r_ae&mrSmawmh awmf
w,f? [k d; ESpf&maxmifeJ @csD+yD;awmh tJ &yfwnf&S daewJ h taqmufttk HawGawmif olwk d @ aumif;aumif;xdef;odrf;xm;Ek difw,f? tJ'gu olwk d @&J @ "avh/xk H;pH/,Ofaus;r_t& xdef;odrf;r_ae&mrSm awmfw,f? tJ'Dawmh usrwk d @'Drd kua&pDqk d &vd k @&S d&ifvJ 'Drd kua&pD&+yD;¶k HeJ @ r+yD;ao;bl;? 'Drd k ua&pDud kxdef;odrf;&r,f? xdef;odrf;zk d @twGufusrwk d @&if;ES D;&r,f? bm&if;ES D;&rvJqk d&ifawmh pdwf"mwftiftm;&if;ES D;&r,f? vkyftm;&if;ES D;&r,f? pdwf"mwf tiftm;qd kwm 'Drd kua&pDtcGif hta&;awGud k tvG JoH k;pm;rvkyf&bl;? tcGif hta&;awGud k/ vGwfvyfcGif hawGud k rSefrSefuefuefoH k;&r,f? aemuf+yD;awmh 'Drd kua&pDud kxdyg;apr,f hudpPawGud k usrwd k @umuG,f&r,f? aemuf vkyftm;aygh?vkyftm;qd kwm &wJ htcGif hta&;ud k wd kif;jynfcsrf;omzd k @twGuf wk d;wufzk d @twGufoH k;&r,f? tJ usrwd k @ tJvd kpdwf"mwf tiftm;eJ @/vkyftm;eJ @ xdef;odrf;oGm;+yD;awmh cd kifrmoGm;rS 'D pepfw&yfcd kifrmoGm;rS usrwd k @aemifvmaemufom;awGtwGuf usrwd k @rsdK;qufopfawG wquf+yD;wquf usrwd k @[mpdwfcs&+yDvd k @ ajymEk difrSmjzpfyg
w,f? 'Dawmh usrwd k @&JŒvlom;tiftm; pdwf"mwfcd kifrmwJ h rk H&Gmòrd @olòrd @om;rsm;[m 'Drd kua&pDtjrefqH k;&ygapvd k @qkawmif;ygw,f? ÐÐÐÐ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 170/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
170
trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG JŒ cskKyfrS a':atmifqef;pk}unfOD;aqmifjyD;OD;wifOD;tygt0if aemufvd kuftiftm;wpk
at;csrf;wnf_idrfr+&S daeonfŒ òrdŒ &G mtcsKdŒ uk doG m;vm_yD;
vlpkvla0;jzif h qlylr+jzpfatmifv+ HŒ aqmf tqd k;jrif0g'rsm;0ef;&HaeonfŒ a':pk-unfonf tpd k;&bufu tjyKoabmaqmifaomfvnf;
taumif;jrif&ef cufcJae ‚if;.ajymqk da0zefr+rsm;aoG;xk d;v+ HŒ aqmfr+rsm;onf Ed kifiHawmf.wnf_idrfat;csrf;r+ud k
ysufjym;ap a':pk-unfESif htzG JŒ onf a&mufav&mwGifvl kpkvla0;zefwD;_yD; ±kwf±kwfoJoJvkyf±k HomruawmhbJ
armfawmfqk difu,frsm;/ um;rsm; vlrsm;ESif h tkyfpkzG JŒ _yD;oG m;vmr+
wae&mxuf wae&m vGefuJvm
trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS a':pk=unfOD; aqmif+yD; OD;wifOD; tygt0ifaemufvd kuftiftm; wpk jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif; at;csrf;wnf+idrfr_&S daeonf @ òrd @&GmtcsKd @ud kvSnf @vnfvm+yD; vlpkvla0;jzif hqlylr_jzpfatmif v_ @HaqmfcJ hjcif;ESif hywfouf+yD; jynfwGif;/ jynfyowif;pmq&mrsm;ESif hawG @qk HI owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jud k ,ae@nae(4)em&DwGif &efukefòrd @ tif;vsm;vrf;&S d wyfrawmf{nf @a*[mY usif;yonf//
,if; owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jod k @ Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif hzG @Hòzd;a&;aumifpD. jynfol @qufqHa&;ESif howif;jzef @csda&;qd kif&mvkyfief;tzG J @OuUX/ tvkyform;
0ef}uD;Xme 0ef}uD; OD;wif0if;/ jyef=um;a&;0ef}uD;Xme0ef}uD; Ad kvfrª;csKyfausmfqef;/ 'kwd, wyfrawmfaxmufvSrf;a&;rª;csKyf Ad kvfcsKyfausmf0if;/ jynfxJa&;0ef}uD;Xme 'kwd,0ef}uD; Ad kvfrª;csKyf ol&jrif hatmif/jyef=um;a&;0ef}uD;Xme 'kwd,0ef}uD; AdkvfcsKyfatmifodef;/ umuG,fa&;0ef}uD;XmerS wyfrawmft&m&Sd}uD;rsm;/ Xmeqd kif&mt}uD;tuJrsm;/ jyef=um;a&;0ef}uD;Xme owif;ESif hjyef=um;a&;qd kif&m wm0ef&S dol rsm;/usK d' d kowif;XmerS OD;pdef0if;/ Ed ki fiHjcm;owif;axmufrsm;toif;em,u OD;vSaxG;/ OuUX OD;p0fud kifzESif h toif;0ifowif;axmufrsm; zdwf=um;xm;olrsm; wufa&muf}uonf//
owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG JwGif Ed kifiHawmfat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG @Hòzd;a&;aumifpD. jynfolqufqHa&;ESif howif; jzef@csda&;qd kif&mvkyfief;tzGJ @ OuUX/ tvkyform;0ef}uD;Xme 0ef}uD; OD;wif0if;u trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS a':pk=unfOD;aqmif+yD; OD;wifOD;tyg
t0if aemufvdkuftiftm;wpk jrefrmEdkifiHtwGif;at;csrf;wnf+idrfr_&S daeonf @ òrd @&GmtcsKd @ud kvSnf @vnfoGm;vm+yD; vlpkvla0;jzif h qlylr_rsm;jzpfatmif v_ @Haqmf
etz. jynfolŒ qufqHa&;ESif h
owif;jzefŒ csda&;qd kif&m
vkyfief;tzG JŒ OuUX
tvkyform;0ef}uD;Xme 0ef}uD; OD;wif0if;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 171/208
171
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vkyfaqmifcJ hjcif;rsm;ESif h ywfoufI y&k d*sufwmqvd kufjzif h &Sif;vif;ajym=um;&mwGif æ,ae@owif;pmq&m}uD;rsm;tm; trsKd; om; 'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS a':pk=unfOD;aqmif+yD; OD;wifOD; tygt0if
aemufvd kuftiftm;wpfpkonf jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif; at;csrf;wnf+idrfr_&S daeonf @ òrd @&GmtcsKd @ud k vSnf @vnfoGm;
vm+yD; vlpkvla0;awGjzif h qlylr_rsm;jzpfatmifvkyfaeonf @ta=umif;/ ,if;vkyf&yfrsm;a=umif h vlpkvla0;jzif hvrf;ydwfqd k @r_rsm; }uKHawG @vm&+yD; òrd @&Gme,fajrtwGif; at;csrf;rsm; ysufjym;&a=umif;/ xk d @a=umif h pk=unfESif htifeft,fvf'Dudk rauseyfjzifhqef@usifolrsm;ua':pk}unfudkraxmufcHa=umif;qENjy=ua=umif;/Todk@qENjy=u&mrS tpjyKjyD; a':pk}unfud k axmufcHolESif huef @ uGufolt=um; yÉdyuQrsm; jzpfay:cJ honf @ta=umif;/,if;jzpf&yfrsm;ud k tifeft,fvf'Du Ed kifiHwum rD'D,m avmuud ktok H;cs+yD; Ed kifiHawmftpd k;&tay: jypfwifa0zefzdtm;ay;vmatmiftjypfr&S d tjypf&Sm/ jzpfvmonfud k yk H}uD;csJ @onf @0g'jzef @csdr_awGESif h [efcsufnD vkyfaqmifaeonfud k kawG @&onf @ta=umif;/ TudpPrsm;ESif h ywfoufI jzpf&yftrSefud k&Sif;jy&efjzpfa=umif;/ trSefrSm ,ckuJ hod k @ykwfcwfpGyfpG Jr_rsm;ud k tjyef tvSefajz&Sif;ae&onf @tvkyfrsKd; rdrdwd k @rvkyfvd ka=umif;/ od k @aomf ,cktcsdeftcgwGifjzpf&yfrSeftajctaersm;ud kxif&Sm;pGmajymqd k&ef vd ktyfaeonf @twGuf ajymqk d&jkcif; jzpfa=umif;//
a':pk=unfESif h tifeft,fvftzG J @ud k2002ckESpf/arvup+yD;jynfe,fESif hwd kif;rsm;rSm&S donf @ ygwD0ifrsm;ESif hawG @qk H&ef vGwfvyfpGmoGm;vmcGif hjyKcJ ha=umif;/ xk d @a=umif ha':pk=unftaejzif h 11-6-2002&ufae@rS15-6-2002&ufae@ txd rGefjynfe,f/ omrn/ 22-6-2002&ufae@rS29-6-2002&ufae@txdrE Wav;wd kif;/ rauG;wd kif;twGif; (16)òrd @e,f/ 20-7-2002rS 23-7-2002txd rGefjynfe,fESif h u&ifjynfe,ftwGif; (12)òrd @e,f/ 14-7-2002 rS 17-7-202002 txd yJcl;wd kif;twGif; (14)òrd @e,f/ 13-11-2002r/S 27-11-2002 txd &Srf;jynfe,ftwGif; (17)òrd @e,f/ 16-12-2002 rS 24-12-2002 txd &cd kifjynfe,f/ rauG;wd kif;ESif h {&m0wDwd kif; twGif;(15)òrd @e,f/ 3-4-2003 rS 13-4-2003 txd rauG;wd kif;ESif h csif;jynfe,ftwGif; (21)òrd @e,f pojzif h pkpkaygif;(95)òrd @e,f oGm;a&mufcJ ha=umif;/ ,ck c&D;pOfud kar (6)&ufrSp+yD; rE Wav;wd kif;/ ppfud kif;wd kif;/ ucsifjynfe,f/
&Srf;jynfe,f/ ,if;rSwqif h rE Wav;wd kif; rd k;ukwfòrd @od k @ jyefvnf0ifa&muf+yD;/ ,cktcg rE Wav;rSwqif h rk H&Gmbufod k @c&D;qufaejcif;jzpfa=umif;/ Ed kifiHawmft}uD;tuJrsm;uawmh ,ckuJ hod k @ jynfe,f/ wd kif;/ òrd @e,fawGud kvuf awG @a&mufoGm;v#if Ed kifiHawmfa&S S @tem*wftwGuf vrf;cif;ay;xm;onf @ajymif;vJvmaom zG H @òzd;wd k;wufr_ tajctaersm;ud k awG @jrifoGm;v#if rlvu pG Jud kifxm;onf @ tqd k;jrifrl0g'awGajymif;vJoGm;+yD; wd kif;&if;om; jyefvnfpnf;vk H;nDn$wfa&;ud k taxmuftuljyKvmrSmyJ[k ,k H=unfcJ h=ua=umif;/ xk d @a=umif hvnf; yxr apmapmyd kif;u oGm;cJ honf @c&D;pOfrsm;wGif atmifvHòteD;rSm&S donf h 'k&ifuAd kvf jrpfa&wifpDrHudef;/ awmifwGif;}uD;teD;rSm&S donf @ &efy,facsmif;pDrHudef;/ {&m0wDjrpful;wHwm;(rauG;)pDrHudef;/ aygif;avmif;a&tm;v#yfppf pDrHudef;/oHvGifjrpful;wHwm;(armfvòrdif)wnfaqmufa&;pDrHudef;/ 0if;zEk Hqnf wnfaqmufa&;pDrHudef;/ rif;vSòrd@&Sd
o&ufwyif pd kufysKd;a&;pDrHudef;/ aygufacgif;òrd @teD;&S d awmife0if;qnfpDrHudef;/ yef;awmif;òrd @teD;&S d anmifud kif;qnfpDrHudef;ESifh jynfòrd@teD;&Sd ewfarSmf jrpfa&wifpDrHudef;rsm;udk=unf@&_&efzdwfac:+yD; ta&;}uD;yk*~dKvfwa,mufozG,f {nf @cHjyKpk+yD; &Sif;vif;jyocJ hyga=umif;//
rlv pwif+yD;c&D;xGufpOfu c&D;oGm;onf @tcg ESpfzufn‡ dE_ dif;oabmwl+yD;rS oGm;&ef/ vlpkvla0;rsm;ESif hrvd kvm;tyfonf @jy\emrsm; ray:aygufap&ef/ qk dif;bkwfwif&ef oabmwlonf @òrd @e,frsm;wGif òrd @e,f a&G;aumufyG Jaumfr&Sif cGif hjyKcsuf&,l+yD; pnf;urf;wusaqmif&Guf&ef }udKwifoabmwlnDcsufrsm;&,l+yD; aqmif&GufcJhjcif;jzpfa=umif;/ Todk@oGm;vmv_yf&Sm;cJhonf@ c&D;pOfrsm;wGif tifeft,fvf'DygwD wdk;csJ@zGJ@pnf;jcif;/vli,ftzG J @ zG J @pnf;jcif;/ &k H;cef;zGif hjcif; ponf @ygwDpnf;&k H;a&;vkyfief;rsm;jyKvkyfcJ ha=umif;/ xd kr#rubJ vltrsm;ud kvrf;ray:rSmpka0;a&muf&S dvmatmif vkyf,l+yD;tcGif hta&;&v#if &ovd k a[majymr_rsm;jyKvkyfvma=umif;/
bmoma&;taqmufttk H bkef;awmf}uD;ausmif;rsm;ud kyg tok H;csI vlpkvla0;ud kzefwD;+yD; a[majymr_awGud kjyK vkyfvma=umif;/ xd k @tjyif trsm;oligoGm;vmonf @vrf;rsm;/ ta0;ajy;vrf;rsm;ay:wGifvnf; armfawmf,mOf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 172/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
172
rsm;jzif hydwfqd k @+yD; vrf;rv,faumifwGif pm;yG Jck H cs+yD;a[majymvmwmawG @&a=umif;/ ,if;od k @a[majym&mwGifvnf; Ed kifiHawmfrSm vd ktyfcsufrsm;ud k aumif;atmif rnfod k @vkyfrnf/ Ed kifiHawmf}uD;at;csrf;atmifrnfod k @vkyfrnfqdkonf @tjyKoabmaqmifonfrsKd;/ jynfolud kynmay;onf@a[majymcsufrsKd;udkawmh rajymbJ/ EdkifiH
awmftpd k;&.tm;enf;csufud k&Sm+yD; tjypftemtqmrsm;ud k vkyf}uHyk H}uD;csJ @ ajymqd konfu rsm;vma=umif;aemufqk H;jynfolvlxkud k wd kufyG J0if&efv_ @Haqmfajr‡mufay;aeonfud kyJawG@&a=umif;/ c&D;pOfwpfckxufwpfckajymqdkr_rsm;onf Ed kifiHawmftpdk;&ESif h0efxrf;rsm;tay:qef@usifajymqdkr_/ jypfwifajymqdkr_/ jynfolvlxkudkajr‡mufyif hay;r_awGyd krsm;vma=umif;/ ynma&;qd kif&m0efxrf;rsm;tay: pGyfpG Jykwfcwfajymqd d kr_rsm;/ usef;rma&;qd kif&m0ef;xrf;rsm;tay: pGyfpG Jykwfcwfajymqd kr_rsm/ Xmeqd kif&m0efxrf;rsm;/ a'otm%myd kifrsm;ESif h toif;tzG J @tcsKd @tay:pGyfpG Jykwfcwfajymqd kr_rsm;onf owif;rSm;rsm;tay:tajccH+yD; rw&m;ojzifh ajymqd kr_rsm;jzpfaeonfud kawG @&a=umif;/ xd k @a}umif hvnf; jynfoltawmfrsm;rsm;onf a':pk=unftay: rauseyfjzpfay:r_ rsm;vmonfud kawG @&a=umif;/ vlpkvla0;jzih fjyomemjzpfatmif zefwD;r_awGud kvnf; yd krd kjyKvkyfvmonfud kawG @&a=umif;/rdrdwd k @taejzif h bmoGm;awG @&ovJqk dv#if c&D;pOfwGifawG @óuH}um;od&onf @owif;rsm;onf a':pk}unf ud k,fwd kifodwmrsm;&S douJhod k @ udk,fwdkifrodbJ ab;uajymwmrsm;&Sda=umif;/ ‚if;=um;oonfh owif;trsm;pkonfowif;rSm;rsm;jzpfa=umif;/ ud k,f hbufu aumif;owif;usawmh omomxd k;xk d;ajymolrsm; acsufwGef;owif;usawmh}uHzefvkyf}uH+yD; yk H}uD;csJ @/ xd kowif;rsm;ud k e,fuae &efukefud kay;/ &efukefuvnf;owif;rsm;ud k jynfyrD'D,mrsm;ud kjzef @/ jynfyrD'D,mrsm;uvnf; jrefrmtpd k;&ud kepfemaprnf howif;qd kv#if tm;&yg;&v$if h qd konf @pepf}uD;u tifeft,fvf'Dud k 0ef;&Haea=umif;/ tqd k;jrif0g'Drsm;0ef;&Haeonf @ a':pk=unfonf tpd k;&bufu&nfrSef;csufaumif;aumif;jzif h tjyKoabmaqmifaomfvnf; taumif;jrif fvmEd kif&efcufcJaeonfqd kjcif;ud kem;vnfyga=umif;/ xd k @a=umif h a':pk=unfud kvnf; tjypfrwifvd kaomfvnf; ‚if;.ajymqk da0zefr_rsm;/ jynfolrsm;ud k'Drd kua&pDta=umif;jy+yD; aoG;xk d;v_ H @aqmfr_rsm;onf Ed kifiHawmf.wnf+idrfat;csrf;r_ud k xdcd kufysufjym;ap
onfrSm trSefyif jzpfa=umif;/ ,ckaemufqk H;oGm;onf @ ucsif jynfe,f/ ppfud kif;wd kif;/ rE Wav; wd kif;e,fajrc&D;pOfrStjzpftysuftcsKd @ud k qufvufwifjyrnfjzpfa=umif;//
ar (6)&ufwGifa':pk=unfESif htzG J @ ucsif jynfe,fud kc&D;xGuf&ef&S da=umif;ESif h c&D;pOfoGm;&if;òrd @e,ftcsKd @ud kqd kif;bkwfwifoGm;vd ka=umif;ud k rdrdwd k @bufud kar(2)&ufwGif today;ajym}um;vma=umif;// od k @jzif h(4)&ufae@wGifqd kif;bkwfwifEd kifaomòrd @e,ftcsKd @ud k cGif hjyKa=umif;ud k jyef=um;yga=umif; / xd ktcgwGif ppfud kif;wd kif;/ rE Wav;wd kif;ESif h &Srf;jynfe,fxJu aemufxyf (16)òrd @e,f xyfrHcGif hjyKcsufawmif;cHyga=umif; ,if;txJwGif qd kif;bkwf&S djyD;om;òrd @e,ftcsKd @ygaeonfud kawG @&a=umif;/ xk dòrd @e,frsm;cGif hjyKcsufud k b,fvd kenf;ESif hrS tcsdefrDcGif hjyKcsuf&atmif vkyfvd k @ r&yga=umif;/ rdrdwd k @bufrSmvnf; tcuftcJawG&S dyga=umif;/ &k H;ydwf&ufcHaeonfawGvnf;&S da=umif; wm0ef&S d
olt}uD;tuJrsm; c&D;xGufoGm;onfvnf;&S dyga=umif;/ tifeft,fvf'Dbufuay;onf @ pm&if ;qd konfuvnf;òrd @e,ftrnfyJ yg&S da=umif;/ rnfonf @ae&mwGifwifrnf/ rnfol @tdrfjzpfonfqd konf @ vdyfpmawG tcsuftvufawGvnf; ryg&S da=umif;/ Ed kifiHa&;ygwDqd d kif;bkwfwifrnf @ae&m/ taqmufttk HwpfckrSm uif;uif; &Sif;&Sif;jzpfoif hyga=umif;/ omoemhajr/ tpd k;&yd kifaqmufttk H/ pnfyifom,myd kifajr/ v,f-,majr tarGyd kif tjiif;yGm;onf @tdrf/rdom;pk oabmrwlonf @taqmufttk H tp&S daom rvd kvm;tyfonf @&_yfaxG;r_rsm;rS&S doif ha=umif;/ ,if;wd k @&S d/r&S d avhvm&efvd ka=umif;/ xk duJ hod k @tcuftcJrsm;&S dI rwifygESif hOD;[kajym&if tpd k;&uqd kif;bkwfwif&ef udpPawGud kydwfyifaeygonf[k ajymcJ honfrsm;&S da=umif;/ rdrdwd k @bufuawmh awmif;qd kxm;onf @ppfud kif;wd kif;xJu òrd @e,fawGud kyg tcsdefrDqd kif;bkwfrsm;wifEk difatmif c&D;pOfumvtwGif;rSmyJ vd kufvd kufavsmavsmaqmif&Gufay;cJ hyga=umif;/ wpfzufESif hwpfzufem;vnfr_ESih f tjyeftvSefav;pmr_&S dvmatmif rdrdbufu tcuftcJrsm;&S donf @
wd kifatmif ajyvnfapvd konf @oabmESif h vd kufavsmaqmif&Gufay;cJ hwmcsnf;yJ jzpfyga=umif;//a':pk=unfOD;aqmifaom OD;wifOD; tygt0if tifeft,fvf'D aemufvk dufaemufygwpfpk. ucsifjynfe,f
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 173/208
173
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
bufud koGm;a&mufcJ honf @ v_yf&Sm;r_jzpfpOftcsKd @ud kwifjy&v#if ,if;ud k=unf @jcif;tm;jzif h b,fvk d&nf&G,fcsufawGESif h b,fvd kt=uHtpnfawGESif h aqmif&Gufaeonfqd kwm xif&Sm;pGmawG @jrifEd kifyga=umif;// ar(8)&uf rE Wav;rS ppfud kif;wd kif;ud kxGufonf @ tcsdefup+yD; jyomem pygawmha=umif; / ppfud kif;wHwm;up+yD; tifeft,fvf'DygwD
0ifawG[m tvHaxmifxm;onf @qd kifu,ftpD;(20)avmufESif h ,mOfwef;ud kjcH&H+yD; ae@cif;}uD;rSmrD;awGxGef;/[Gef;awGus,favmifpGm wD;+yD; armif;ESif=ua=umif;/ ppfud kif;rS a&$bk da&mufonftxdjzpfa=umif;//'Dvd kvkyfaeonfud k um;xJrSmvd kufygvmaom vl}uD;awGodovm;/ rodbl;vm;awmh usaemfwd k @ rodyg
a=umif;/ od k @aomfvnf; c&D;pOfwpfav#mufvk H; 'Dyk HpHjzif hqd kifu,fawGw0D0DESif h jcH&H+yD;oGm;vmcJ honfud kawG @& a=umif;/ tqd k;qk H;uawmh rd k;rdwfòrd @rS rd k;ukwfud koGm;onf @c&D;pOfrSm pnf;urf;trJ hqk H;jzpfa=umif;/ qd kifu,ftpD;(40)avmufonf ,mOfwef;.a&S @rSm ESpfpif;wG J,Of+yD; vrf;ud kydwfqd k @+yD;armif;ESif=ua=umif;/ qd kifu,fawGESif hjcH&Hxm;onf @,mOfwef;u aemufuvd kufygvma=umif;/ rd k;ukwfòrd @v,faumifud k jzwfoef;+yD; wnf;cd konf @ae&mtxdjzpfa=umif;/ xk d @a=umif h ,mOfoGm;vmr_ vrf;ydwfqk d @r_ awGjzpfcJ h&a=umif; rd k;ukwfrSrE Wav;oGm;onf @c&D;pOfrSmvnf; qdkufu,frsm; pnf;urf;rJhpGmarmif;ESif+yD;vdkufygcJha=umif;/ xkd@a=umifhrdk@ ykodrf}uD;òrd@e,f/ykodrfav;aus;&GmrSm aus;&Gmol rjrwfoif;ol qd konf @ (21)ESpft&G,f rdef;uav;wpfOD;ud k qd kifu,fwpfpD;u0ifwk duf+yD; }udwfeif;oGm;onf @twGuf ajcaxmufrSm '%f&m&&S dcJ ha=umif;//
ar(9)&ufwGif f uef @bvlaumvif;òrd @e,fodk @toGm; pHy,feH @omqd konf @aus;&Gmta&mufrSm AD'D,d k&kyf&Sif±k HxJu &kyf&Sif}unf @xGufvmaomvli,f(20)avmufu a':atmifqef;pk}unf tvd kr&S d[k atmfonfud k}uKHawG @vd kuf&yga=umif;/ xd krSmwif ,mOfwef;ud k&yf+yD; ,mOfwef;ay:rSmygvmaom aemufvd kufaemufyg tifeft,fvf'D vli,fqd kolrsm;u &Gmv,faumifrSm&kef @&if;}urf;wrf;pGm r}um;0H @remaom wpf&Gmvk H;rd k;r$efoGm;atmif qJqd kr_vkyfygawmha=umif; apmapmuvli,fawGud kvnf; cJjzif hvd kufaygufI vli,fawGxGufajy;oGm;=ua=umif;/ nae (6)em&Dcef @aumvif;òrd @ud k0ifonf @tcgrSm txufwef;ausmif;Y jynfaxmifpk}uH @cd kifa&;ESif hzG @Hòzd;
a&;toif;u zGif hvSpfxm;aomaEG&moDoifwef;wck jyifqifxm;&S dyga=umif; xk H;pHtwd kif;jynfol @oabmxm;pmwrf;rsm;vnf; csdwfqG Jjyifqifxm;yga=umif; ,if;ud k ,mOfwef;rSmygvmaom tifeft,fvf'Dvli,fqk dolawGu "mwfyk H awG/ AD'D,d kawG&k duf=uyga=umif;/ ausmif;0if;xJu vli,fESpfa,mufuvnf; "mwfyk Hjyef&k dufawmh,mOfwef;rSmygvmaomtifeft,fvf'D vl li,fawGu 0d kif;0ef;atmf[pf+yD; cJjzif haygufonf @twGuf ausmif;0if;xJuvli,frsm;xGufajy;oGm;cJh&yga=umif; tif;awmfa&mufonf@tcsdefrSm n(9)em&Dausmf+yDjzpfa=umif;a':pk=unfud k raxmufcHonf @ vl (70)avmufu jynfol @oabmxm;aqmifyk'frsm;ud ka&;om;+yD; uef @uGufqENjy=ua=umif;/ od k @aomfvnf; arSmif&dyfxJrSm&S donf @ tifeft,fvf'DawGu cJjzif haygufI aus;&Gmolaus;&Gmom;rsm;jzpf}uaom aX;vGif(c)bd kvGif/ odef;Ek/ oef;OD;/ pd k;jrif hOD;ESif haZmfvGifOD;qd kolwd k @'%f&mrsm;&&S doGm;cJ ha=umif;?
ar(11)&uf uomòrd @ud ka&mufonf @tcgrSmawmh a':pk=unf.c&D;pOfud k qef @usifqENjyolawG tawmfrsm;rsm; &S daeonfud kawG @&a=umif; / ESpfzuftjyeftvSefaºuG;a}umfoHawG atmf[pfr_awGjzpfvmyga=umif; aemufqk H;c&k difat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @òzd;a&;aumifpDOuUX u 0ifa&mufajz&Sif;ay;rS ESpfzufvlpkuG J+yD; tifeft,fvf'D,mOfwef;vnf; vk d&mc&D;ud kqufoGm;Ed kifcJ honfud kawG @&a=umif;/ wpfzufESif hwpfzuf ud k,fxdvufa&mufusL;vGefr_rsm; r&S dcJ ha=umif; / tvm;wl ucsifjynfe,ftwGif; òrd @&GmtcsKd @rSm a':pk=unf.ygwD0ifrsm;u yk Ho¿efrsKd;rsKd;jzif h c&D;OD;óudjyK=uouJ hod k @ qef @usifolrsm;uvnf; uef @uGufr_ud kjyKvkyf=ua=umif;/ ‚if;wk d @.qENoabmxm;ud kum,uH&Sifrsm; odatmifxkwfazmfqENjy=ua=umif;/ od k @aomfvnf; tifeft,fvf'Du ae@pOfESif htr#jynfytoHv$if hXmeawGud kay;aeonf @ a=unmcsufrsm;rSm azmfjyouJ hod k @c&D;pOfud kydwfyif/ wm;qD;/ aeSmif h,Suf[ef @wm;r_vnf; r&SdcJha=umif;,mOfwef;ud k cJjzif haygufjcif;/ wkwfESifh&k dufjcif;/ um;rSefud kvufoD;ESif hxkd;jcif;/
ucsif"m;rsm;jzif h +cdrf;ajcmufjcif;qkdonfrsKd;vnf;r&SdcJha=umif;/ ‚if;wd k@ajymoavmufomjzpfaev#if tifeft,fvf'D ,mOfwef;wpfckvk H; wpfppDa=urGae+yDvm;[kyif xifrda,mifrSm; jzpfEd kifyga=umif;//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 174/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
174
ar(21)&uf rd k;rdwfa&mufoGm;+yD;onf @aemufyd kif;wGif a':pk=unf w&m;a[m&k HomruawmhbJ OD;wifOD;uyg Ed kifiHawmftpd k;&ud kykwfcwfapmfum;onf @ajymqd kcsufawG a'otm%myd kifrsm;ud k Oya'yk'frawG &Gwfqd k+yD; +cdrf;ajcmufajymqd kr_awG jyKvkyfvmcJ ha=umif; ar(25)&ufpOf @ul;òrd @e,f EG,f&k Haus;&GmrSm tifeft,fvf'DygwD
0ifawGu av;cGrsm;jzifhypfcwfaoma=umif h a':pk=unfud kqef@usifqENjy&ef a&mufvmaom vlrsm;xJwGifpOf @ul;òrd @e,f 0g;&k Hukef;&Gmom;ausmfEd kif/ a&mufyif&k d;&Gmom;pef;OD;ESif h bd k;csKdwd k @'%f&mrsm; &oGm;a=umif;ud k od& a=umif;/ tifef t,fvf'Dbufu xkwfjyefajym=um;csufawGrSm ygwD0ifwpfa,muf '%f&m&onf[kqd ka=umif;/rE Wav;jrdK@a&mufonf @tcgrSmwnf;cd konf @ tifeft,fvf'D rE Wav;wd kif;&k H;ud ka&mufvmjyD; vlpkvla0;zefwD;jyD;a[majymyG JjyKvkyfyga=umif; vrf;ydwfqd k @r_rsm;jzpfonf @twGuf vrf;&Sif;ay;yga=umif; ,mOfxdef;&Jrsm;pD;eif; vk dufygvmaom ,mOftrSwf 5u §8175 'd kifem,mOfud k trSwf(78-79)vrf;=um;rSm &yfwef @xm;pOf f tifeft,fvf'DygwD0iftcsKd @u oHwkwfjzih f&k dufonf @twGuf a&S @avumrSef fuG Ja}uysufpD;oGm;cJ hyga=umif; ok d @aomfvnf; tifeft,f 'D bufu owif;xkwfonf @tcg vl=um;xJtwif;armif;vd k @ t&k dufcH&onf[k owif;xkwfcJ honfud kawG @& a=umif;//
a':pk=unfESifhtzG J@onf a&mufav&mwGif vlpkvla0;zef;wD;+yD; &kwf&kwfoJoJvkyf&k HomruawmhbJarmfawmfqd kifu,frsm;/ armfawmfum;rsm;/ vlrsm;ESif htkyfpkzG J @+yD;oGm;vmr_onf wae&mxuf wae&m vGefuJ+yD;vkyfvmonfud kawG @&a=umif;/ rlv &efukefu poGm;pOf um;ok H;pDESif hvl (18)a,mufjzpfa=umif; ar(29)&ufrE Wav;u rk H&Gma&mufonf @tcsdefwGif um;(7)pD;/ qd kif;u,ftpD;(20)ESif h vl (100)ausmf vd kufyg+yD; oGm;cJ ha=umif;/acsmif;OD;rSxGuf+yD; rk H&Gmud ka&mufoGm;onf @tcsdefwGifrl qd kifu,ftpD;(150)/ um;(16)pD;/ vl(300) ausmftkyfpkzG J @+yD; 0ifa&mufa=umif;/ rk H&Gmòrd @wGif;vrf;rrsm;Y (3)em&D=umvSnf @vnfoGm;vm+yD; wnf+idrfat;csrf;aeonf @rk H&Gmòrd @ay: Y qlqlylylvkyfa=umif;/ tqk dygjrifuGif;ud k rSwfwrf;wifaeonf @ "mwfyk Hq&m armifrsKd;jrif hqk dolud k0d kif;0ef;&k dufES dufonf @twGuf acgif;'%f&m&+yD; aq;&k Hwufukor_cH,lcJ h&a=umif;/ ,if;ud kifaqmifonf @ AD'D,d k
uifr&mvnf; zsufqD;cHvd kuf&a=umif;/ a':pk=unfESif htzG J @onf rk H&Gmòrd @ tifeft,fvf'D &k H;qd kif;bkwfud k nwGif;csif;wifvd kufa=umif;/ ESpfzufn‡ dE_ dif;oabmwlxm;onf @pnf;urf;csufESif htnD òrd @e,fygwDpk HtaxGaxGa&G;aumufyG Jaumfr &Sifuk daomfvnf;aumif;/ òrd @e,fat;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h zG H @òzd;a&;aumifpDud kaomfvnf;aumif;today;cGif hawmif;jcif;rjyKbJ qef @usifaqmif&GufoGm;a=umif;//
ar(30)&uf (12)em&Dtcsdefcef @wGif rk H&GmrS bkwvifud kxGufa=umif;/ armfawmf,mOf (15)pD;ud k qd kifu,ftpD; (100)cef @ua&S @aemuf0J,m jcH&H+yD;oGm;cJ ha=umif;/ bkwvifòrd @t0ifwGif qd kifu,frsm;rD;xGef;I t&S defjyif;pGmjzif h qlnH pGmarmif;ESif0ifa&mufcJ ha=umif;/ bkwvifòrd @wGif òrd @e,f tifeft,fvf'D &k H;qd kif;bkwfwifyG JjyKvkyf+yD;'DyJ,if;bufok d @qufxGufa=umif;/ 'DyJ,if; ra&mufrD qd kif;jyif&Gmud k0ifa&muf+yD; n (7)em&DausmfrS ,mOf(9)pD;/
qd kifu,ftpD; (40)cef @ESif htwl 'DyJ,if;òrd @bufud k qufxGufa=umif;/ 'DyJ,if; ra&mufrD ESpfrd kifcef @tuGmòrd @t0ifwGif a':pk=unftm; uef @uGufqENjy&efapmif haeonf @ vltiftm;(5000)cef @&S donf @ vlpkvla0;ESif hóuHawG @cJ h& a=umif;//
a':pk=unf.,mOfwef;wGifvd kufygvmonf @ armfawmf,mOfrsm;onf vltkyftwGif;rS twif;wd k;xGufwd kufcd kufarmif;ESif&mrS tpjyK+yD; wpfzufESif hwpfzufyÉdyuQjzpfyGm;cJ h=ua=umif;/ n(8)em&Dcef @rS n(11)em&Dcef @txd &kef;&if;qefcwfjzpfay:+yD; tajctae&_yfaxG;cJ ha=umif;/ armfawmf,mOfwpfpD;rSm vrf;ab;opfyifud kt&S defjzif h 0ifaqmif hrdonf[kod&a=umif;/ ,mOfwef;rSmygonf @armfawmf,mOfwpD;rSm vrf;ab;ud kxd k;us+yD;/ rSefrsm;uG Ja=umif; od&a=umif;/ a':pk=unfud kqef @usifonf @vlrsm; pD;eif;vmonf @ armfawmf,mOfwpD;ud krl tifeft,fvf'DygwD0ifrsm;u rD;&_ d @zsufqD;I ysufpD;cJ ha=umif;od&a=umif;/ TjzpfpOfwGif armfawmf,mOfwd kufcd kufr_ ,mOfxdcd kufr_
rsm;a=umif h vl(4)OD; aoqk H;a=umif;ESif h tjyeftvSef&k dufESufr_rsm;a}umif h ESpfzufpvk H; vl(50)cef @ '%f&m&a=umif;od&a=umif;/ armfawmf,mOf(8)pD;ysufpD;+yD; qd kifu,f(9)pD;ysufpD;oGm;a=umif;od&a=umif;/ tqd kygjzpfaeonf @
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 175/208
175
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tajctaeud k owif;&v#if&csif; ppfud kif;wk dif;at;csrf;om ,ma&;ESif hzG @Hòzd;a&;aumifpDtwGif;a&;rª; OD;pD;+yD;&JwyfzG J @0ifrsm;yg0ifaom vk HjcKHa&;wyfzG J @ESif h tcif;jzpfonf @ae&mud koGm;a&mufxdef;odrf;cJ ha=umif;/n(12)em&Dcef @wGif tajctaetm;vk H;ud k xdef;odrf;Ed kifcJ ha=umif;/ '%f&m&olrsm;ud kvnf; aq;&k Hod k @yd k @aqmifI aq;0g;ukor_rsm;
aqmif&Gufay;vsuf&S da=umif;/ tajctaet&yf&yfud kw&m;Oya'ESif htnD ud kifwG,fajz&Sif;ay;vsuf&S d+yD; e,fajrat;csrf;a&;ud k aqmif&Gufvsuf&S da=umif;/ nbufwGifrk H&Gmòrd @xJY pd kufxlxm;onf @ jynfol @oabmxm;qd kif;bkwftcsKd @ud k tifeft,fvf'DygwD0ifrsm;uvltkyfpkzG J @+yD; vd kufvHzsufqD;r_tcsKd @&S dcJ ha=umif;/ vk HjcKHa&;tzG J @rsm;xdef;odrf;&efa&mufvmonf @tcgvlpkcG JI xGufajy;oGm;}u a=umif; ,ckrk H&Gmòrd @ay:rSmat;csrf;wnf+idrfpGm&S daea=umif;//
,ckjzpfpOfwGifa':pk=unfudkqef@usifqENjyolrsm;uvrf;ab;0J/ ,mESifhvrf;ay:rStcsKd@qENjyonfudkat;csrf; pGmajz&Sif;Ijzwfoef;oGm;v#if Tod k @aomjzpfpOfjzpf&yfjzpfrnf[krxifa=umif;/ a':pk=unfESif h vd kufygvmonf @,mOfwef;rS qd kifu,frsm;ESif hum;rsm;u vlpkvla0;ud k twif;wd kufcd kufjzwfoef;armif;ESifonfrS tpjyK I yÉdyuQrsm;jzpfay:cJ h&a=umif; od&S d&a=umif;/ ,cktxd yÉdyuQjzpfoGm;&onf @@ ta=umif ;&if;rSm rdrdwd k @ESif hrlvESpf
zufn‡ dE_ dif;oabmwlnDxm;onf @tcsufrsm;ud k azmufzsuf+yD; xdyfwk duf&ifqd kifr_rsm;jyKvkyf&mrS vlpkvla0;rsm;xdef;rEk difodrf;r&I jzpfay:vm&jcif;jzpfa=umif;/ rdrdud kaxmufcHaomvltkyfpk/ qd kifu,ftkyfpkrsm;ud kyifEd kifatmifrxdef;Ed kifaomtajctaejzpfcJ h&a=umif;/ c&D;pOfwGifjzpfay:aeaomtajctae t&yf&yfESif hajymqd kr_rsm;ud k rdrdwd k @taejzif hrjzpfoif hwmrjzpf&atmif tifeft,fvf'DrSwm0ef&S dol vl}uD;rsm;ud kqufoG,fI xdef;xdef;odrf;odrf;jyK vkyf&ef r=umc% owday;ajym=um;cJ ha=umif;/ od k @&mwGifowday;ajym=um;csufrsm;ud k vufcHjcif;r&S dbJ wrift&G J @wd kuf I ygwD0ifrsm;ud k tok H;csumvlpkvla0;jzif h xdyfwk duf&ifqd kifr_jzpfatmif zefwD;onf @twGufa}umif h,ckuJ hod k @ jyomemjzpfay:&jcif;jzpfonf[kxifa=umif;/ &efukefuoGm;onf @a':pk=unf OD;wifOD;tygt0if tifeft,fvf'DtzG J @0ifrsm;ud k oufqd kif&mvk HjcKHa&;tzG J @rsm;u aumif;rGefpGmapmif ha&Smufxm;a=umif; today; wifjytyfa=umif;//
rdrdwk d @jrefrmEd kifiHonfvGwfvyfa&;+yD; umvtwGif;rSmolrsm;Ed kifiHrsm;enf;wl rdrdEd kifiHacwfrD zG H @òzd;wd k;wufa&;ud kaZmufcs+yD; at;at;csrf;csrf;vkyfEd kifcJ honf @tajctaersm; r&S dcJ hbl;qd kwm tm;vk H;todyJjzpfa=umif; jynfwGif;vufeufudkif qlylaomif;usef;r_rsm;/ EdkifiHa&;oabmxm;uG Jv$ Jr_rsm;/ jynfwGif;qlylqENjyr_rsm;/ jynfyya,m*yl;uyfaeonf @trsKd;om;opPmazmufrsm;. jynfwGif;ajcxk d;r_rsm; tp&S donf @jy\emrsm;ajz&Sif;aeonfESif htcsdefukef+yD; Ed kifiHawmfwd k;wufa&;ud k at;csrf;pGm rvkyfEd kifcJ ha=umif; ,ae@tajctaeonftqd kyg tajctaeqk d;rsm; &mcd kifE_ef; tawmfawmfrsm;rsm;ud kz,f&Sm;Ed kifcJ h+yD; tajctaeaumif;rsm;ud k zefwD;Ed kifonf @tcsdefumvjzpfa=umif;/ Ed kifiHawmfzG H @òzd;wd k;wufa&;twGuftajctaeaumif;rsm; vrf;cif;+yD;vnf;jzpfa=umif;/ Ed kifiHawmfzG H@òzd;wd k;wufa&;twGufTtajctaeaumif;rsm;ud k ajcukyf,l+yD; wd k;wufatmifaqmif&GufoGm;oif h
a=umif;/ xd k @a=umif hvnf; ,ae@ajym ajymae=uonf @ trsKd;om;&if=um;apha&; [kyJ ac:ac: trsKd;om;jyefvnfoif hjrwfa&;[kyJ ajymajym/ trsKd;om;jyefvnfpnf;vk H;nDnGwfa&;[kyJ owfrSwfowfrSwf wd kif;&if;om;pnf;vk k H;nDn$wfa&;ud k em;vnfr_&S d&S dwnfaqmuf+yD; jynfaxmifpkjrefrmEd kifiHawmf}uD;wd k;wuf&mwd k;wufa=umif;enf;vrf;aumif;ud k &SmazGazmfxkwftaumiftxnfazmfonf @tvkyfud kyJtm;vk H;em;vnfr_ &S d&S dyl;aygif;vkyfaqmif&rnf @tcsdefjzpfa=umif;/ ,ckuJ hod k @ jy\emzefwD;r_rsm;ESif hpGyfpG Jajymqk dr_rsm;ud k ajz&Sif;ae&onf @tvkyfonf txufrSmazmfjycJhonf@wdkif;&if;om;jyefvnfpnf;vkH;nDn$wfa&;vkyfief;udk taxmuft ulrjyK[kajym=um;vd ka=umif;/ rdrdwd k @taejzif h Ed kifiHawmfzG H @òzd;wd k;wufa&;twGuf at;csrf;om,ma&;ESif h w&m;Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;ud k pepfwusaqmif&GufoGm;rSmjzpfa=umif; today;ajym}um;tyfyga=umif; &Sif;vif;ajym}um;onf//
xd k @aemufowif;pmq&mrsm;. ar;jref;csufrsm;ud kumuG,fa&;0ef}uD;XmerS Xmerª;}uD; Ad kvfrª;csKyfoef;xGef;u jyefvnf&Sif;vif;ajz}um;+yD;owif;pm&Sif;vif;yG Jud k nae (4)em&D (45)rdepfwGif &kyfodrf;vd k kufonf//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 176/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
176
'Drd kua&pDrqefaom pnf;&k H;v+yf&S m;r+rsm;
a':pk}unfacgif;aqmifaom tifeft,fvf'DtzGJŒu jyKvkyfcJ hjcif;
a':atmifqef;pk}unf OD;aqmifaom OD;wifOD;tygt0if tifeft,fvf'D tzG J @0if aemufygwpkonf(29-5-2003)&ufae@ eHeufydkif;wGif/ rE Wav;òrd@rS um;ckESpfpD;/ qdkifu,ftpD;(20)/ vltiftm;(100)ausmfjzifhrk H&Gmòrd @bufod k @ c&D;xGufcJ honf// ppfud kif;òrd @wGif tifeft,fvf'D ygwD0ifrsm; xyfrHvd kufygI um;(14)pD;/ qd kifu,f
tpD;(20)jzif h/ qufvufxGufcGmcJ h+yD;/ acsmif;OD;òrd @ok d @a&muf&S dpOf um;(16)pD;/ qd k kifu,ftpD;(70)/ vltiftm;(150)cef @jzif h/ rk H&Gmòrd @od k @ xGufcGmcJ hojzif h/ rlvu c&D;oGm;onf htzG J @wGif/ um;ok H;pD;ESif h vl(18)a,mufyg&S d+yD;/usef tpD;rsm;rSm ta¹cGt&Hrsm;ESif h/ a':pk=unf. vk HjcKHa&;tzG J @rsm;jzpfonf[k=um;od&onf//
acsmif;OD;òrd @e,f/ a&bd kprf;&Gmta&mufwGif/ a':pk=unftm;qef @usifolrsm;u/ vrf;ab;0J,mrS at;csrf;pGmqENjycJ haomfvnf;/ a':pk=unfESif hvd kufygvmolrsm;u cJrsm;ESif hypfaygufojzif h/ e,fajrcHjynfol ESpfOD; cJxdrSef'%f&m&&S dcJ honf// xd k @tjyif a':pk=unfESif h tifeft,fvf'D tkyfpkrSm/ rk H&Gmòrd @od k @oGm;a&muf&mwGif/ qd kifu,ftpD;(100)cef @jzif h/ jynfolvlxktok H;jyKvsuf&S daom ta0;ajy;vrf;r}uD;ud k Oya'rJ h ydwfqd k @armif;ESifcJ hojzif h/
ta0;ajy;vrf;r}uD;wGif/ vrf;ydwfqd k @r_ESif h,mOfwd kufcd kufr_rsm;tygt0if/ c&D;oGm;jynfolrsm;ud krsm;pGm taESmif ht,SufjzpfapcJ honf//
rk H&Gmòrd @wGif;od k @ 0ifa&muf&mwGifvnf; um;(16)pD;/ qd kifu,ftpD;(150)cef @xdyif rsm;jym;cJ hojzif h/ òrd @wGif;wGiftkwfatmfaomif;wif;jzpfyGm;cJ honf// òrd @wGif;Y xd kjrifuGif;ESif hjzpfpOfud k pdwf0ifwpm; =unf @&_&if; "mwfyk H&k dufaeolwOD;tm;/ ,mOfwef;ESif htwlygvmaom tifeft,fvf'D tzG J @0ifrsm;u 0d kif;0ef;&k dufESuf&m acgif;uG JoGm;onf[kod&S d&onf// tqd kygt&k dufcH&olrSm rk H&Gmòrd @ae armifrsKd;jrif hqd kol "mwfyk Hq&mwOD;jzpfonf[kod&S d&onf// òrd @cHjynfolrsm;u/ oufqd kif&m&Jpcef;ok d @ tifeft,fvf'D ygwD0ifrsm; u t}urf;zuf 0d kif;0ef;&k dufES dufcJ ha}umif;/ xk d @tjyife,fajrtwGif;wnfjidrfr_ESif h at;csrf;om,mr_ud k/ aESmif h,Sufysufjym; ap&efjyKvkyfusif h}uHcJ ha}umif;/ owif;yd k @wd kifwef;xm; onf[kowif;&&S donf//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 177/208
177
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
a':pk}unfOD;aqmifonf htifeft,fvf'DtzG J @onf/ qufvufI xd kae@nae(6)em&Dcef @wGif/ rk H&GmjrdK@ t0if*dwfod k @jzwfoef;a&muf&S dcJ honf// xd ktzG J @onf jrdK@t0ifwGifapmif hqd kif;aeaom/ tifeft,fvf'DygwD0ifrsm;ESif htwl/armfawmfqd kifu,frsm;ESif hyl;aygif;jcH&Hv#uf/ rk H&GmjrdK@twGif;Y ok H;em&Dcef @vSnf hvnfcJ honf// xd kod k @ +rd K@wGif;Y vSnf @vnfpOf/ a':pk}unf.,mOfwef; ygarmfawmf,mOf (16)pD;ud k/ armfawmfqd kifu,ftpD;(150)rS jcH&Hum rE Wav;/ppfud kif;/ jrif;rl/ acsmif;OD;jrdK@rsm;rS a':pk}unf ESif htwlygvmaomygwD0ifrsm;u/ xyfrH 0d kif;0ef;aygif;pyfI pDwef;
vSnf hvnfcJ h}uojzif h/ jrdK@wGif;Y vrf;rsm;ydwfqd k @r_rsm;jzpfay:cJ h+yD;/ &kwf&kwfoJoJjzpfum/ +rdK@wGif;aejynfolrsm;txdwfwvef @jzpfcJ h&a}umif; owif;&&S donf//
oufqdkif&mtpd k;&wm0ef&S dolrsm;u/ tifeft,fvf'DygwDtm; ,ckuJ hod k@+rdK@e,ftvd kufpnf;&k H;a&; oGm;a&mufonf hc&D;pOfrsm;wGif/ e,fajrcHjynfolvlxkud ka}umuf&$ H @xdwfvef @aponf h jyKrlv_yf&Sm;rlrsm;ud k a&Smif&Sm;&efESif h jynfolrsm;tay:em;vnfr_&S d&S d/ oabmxm;}uD;}uD;xm;&S dI/ pnf;&k H;a&;aqmif&Gufoif ha}umif; tifeft,fvf'DOD;vGifrSwqif h/ today;ta}umif;}um;cJ ha}umif;owif;&&S donf//
tifeft,fvf'D a':atmifqef;pk-unfESif htzG JŒwd kŒ ,cifuvnf; 'Drd kua&pD rqefaom jzpfpOfjzpf&yfrsm;jyKvkyfcJ hjcif;
'Drd kua&pDpepfud kpwiftul;tajymif;wGif/ Ed kifiHa&;ygwDrsm;taejzif h/ jynfolvlxk tay: em;vnfr_ &S d&S djzif h/pnf;&k H;v_yf&Sm;Ed kif&eftxl;vd ktyfvsuf&S donf//
a':pk}unfESif htzG J @onf ppfud kif;wk dif;/ ucsifjynfe,fESif h rE Wav;wk d kif;twGif;/ ygwDjyefvnfzG J @pnf;a&;/ ygwDwGif;pnf;&k H;a&;oGm;a&mufcJ h&m/ olrtm;raxmufcHaom vlxktiftm;pkrsm;u rvk dvm;a}umif;/jidrf;csrf;pGmaºuG;a}umfr_jyKvkyfcJ h}uonf//xd kjzpfpOfrsm;ESif hywfoufI tifeft,fvf'Duolr.,mOfwef;tm; vufeufjzif h[ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufonf[k pGyfpG Jajymqd kaomfvnf;/ trSefwu,f jzpf&yfrSma':pk=unf. ,mOfwef;wGifygaomvli,frsm;u/ pwift}urf;zuf&k dufES dufcJ honf htwGuf/ atmufygtwd kif; '%f&mrsm; &&S dcJ h}uonf[k owif;&&S dcJ honf//
10-5-2003 &ufae@ n (9)em&Dausmf/ tif;awmfjrdK@od k @a&muf&S dpOf/ vrf;,mbufjcrf;rS jynfolvlxk(70)cef @u/“a':pk}unftm;raxmufcHa}umif;”pmwef;ygqd kif;bkwfrsm;jidrf;csrf;pGmud kifxm;onfud k/ a':pk=unf,mOfwef;ESif h/ ,mOfwef;tm;}udKqd kaomygwD0if (200) cef @uatmf[pf&_wfcscJ hjyD;aemuf/ tjyeftvSef atmf[pfcJ h=ua}umif;/ tifeft,fvf'Dud k raxmufcH/ rvd kvm;olrsm;(70)cef @u/ jyefvnfxGufcGmoGm;pOf/ tifeft,fvf'DygwD0ifrsm;u qJqd kjyD;/ cJrsm;jzif hypfaygufonf htwGuf/ t&yfom;ig;OD;'%f&m&&S dcJ ha=umif;/ ‚if;wd k @rSm aX;vGif(c)bd kvGif/ jrpfap;aus;&Gm/ awmifomukef; aus;&Gmtkyfpk/ Aef;armufjrdK@e,f/ (OD;acgif;ayguf/ av;csufcsKyf'%f&m&&S d)/
odef;Ek/ crd k k;aus;&Gm/ Aef;armufjrdK@e,f/ (ausmyGef;yJ h/ twGif;a=u'%f&m&&S d)/ oef;OD;/ rGwfodrfaus;&Gm/ Aef;armufòrd @e,f/ (,m rsufpdzl;a&mif/ aygufjyJ'%f&m&&S d)/ pd k;jrif hOD;/ ebm;aus;&Gm/ tif;awmfòrd @e,f/ (nmajcaxmufESif h
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 178/208
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 179/208
179
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
atmufyg tifwmAsL;wGifajz}um;olrS m
trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJŒcsKyf/ rEWav;wkdif; vli,fwm0efcH uk daZmfaZmfatmifjzpfygonf?
-opaws;vsEd kifiH&S d trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG JŒcsKyf. tifwmeufpmrsufESmrSwqifh
ul;,lazmfjyxm;ygonf?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? cifAsm;u ppfuk dif;wk dif; 'DyJ,if;/ usnf&GmrSmjzpfwJ ha':atmif fqef;pk=unfwd k @um;wef;ud k t=urf;zufwJ h tJ'DtxJrSmygoGm;+yD;awmh/ jyef+yD;awmh tJ'DtxJuae aouHraysmuf jyefvGwfvmwJ h vlaygh? bkwvifuae+yD;awmh'DyJ,if;ud koGm;wm bkwvifuaejyD;awmh b,fESpfem&Davmuf xGufvmovJcifAsm?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? bkwvifuae+yD;awmh (4)em&DcG J (5)em&D 0ef;usifavmufawmh &S dr,fxifw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? (5)em&D0ef;usifavmuf xGufvmw,fqd kawmhusnf&Gmqk dwJ h &Gmud k b,fESpfem&Davmufa&mufovJ?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? usaemfwk d @ n(8)em&D0ef;usifavmuf (a&mufygw,f)
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? n (8) em&D0ef;usifqd kawmh vrf;rSm a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k óudqd kwJ hvlawGa&m &S dovm;?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? [kwfuJ h&S dygw,f? tJ'DrSmvnf; usaemfwd k @ jynfolvlxkud k E_wfqufwm bmnmeJ @ enf;enf;yg;yg;=umygw,f?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 180/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
180
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'DrSma&m a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k qef @usif+yD;awmh qENjywJ h atmf[pfae=uwJ htoHawG =um;cJ h& ovm;?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? usaemf r=um;&bl;?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? usnf&Gma&mufawmh n (8)em&Daemf? jynfolawGu xGufóudae=uwm b,favmufavmuf&S drvJ?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? jynfolawGxGuf}udKwm usaemfxifwmu cef @rSef;ajc (3000)ausmfausmf 4/ 5 axmifavmuf&S dr,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? &Gm}uD;aygh?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? [kwfuJ h &Gm}uD;yg//
ar;ar;ar;ar;ar;? usnf&Gm [k dbuf'DbufrSm awmawG bmawG&S dvm;?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? v,fuGif;awG?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'D&GmxJu ckexGufóudwJ h jynfolvlxkawGxJua&m a':atmifqef;pk=unf qENjywJ h/ tvk dr&S da=umif;qENjywJ h toHawGa&m =um;cJ h&ygovm;?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? tJ'gawmh r=um;&bl;?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? 'grSr[kwf yd kpwmawG bmawG axmifxm;wma&m?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? r&S dygbl;?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh a':atmifqef;pk=unfu quf+yD;awmh jynfolawGuk d E_wfcGef;qufpum;ajymw,f? ajym+yD;awmh b,favmufavmuf=umovJ? tcsdefu æ
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? (10)rdepf 0ef;usifavmufyg//
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'DuaejyD;awmh wcg qufxGufwmaygh?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? qufxGufawmh a&S @em; uk dufw&mausmf (200)ausmf 0ef;usifa&mufwJ htxdrSm/ odyfra0;ao;wJ h
tcsdefrSm&Gmom;awGeJ @ enf;enf;av;yJ uGmygao;w,f? aemufum;wef;awGawmifrS rrD h wrD &S dyg
ao;w,f? &Gmom;awGvnf;jrifw,f? &Gm;om;awGvnf; rjyef=uao;bl;aygh? tJ'DrSm bkef;}uD;ESpfyg;eJ @vl(3)a,muf avmuf&S dr,fxifw,f? olwk d @uae+yD;awmh a':pkum;ud k wm;ygw,f? wm;+yD; a':pkud kw&m;a[m+yD;rS 'DuaexGufcGmzk d @ajymygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? 'DbufrSmvnf; y&dowfawGeJ @ &S daewkef;u rvmyJeJ @?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? olwk d @vmr,fqk d&if vmvk d @&w,fcifAsm? 'gayr,f h olwk d @u a&S @uyJ apmif haew,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? &yfapmih fae+yD;awmh wcgwnf; 0ifa[mck dif;wmaygh?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? xGufjyD; a[mck dif;wmaygh? w&m;a[mcd kif;ygw,f? a[mcd kif;awmh tcsdefuvnf; rd k;csKyfae+yD;/ a&S @rSm
vnf; usaemfwk d @ 'DyJ,if;0if&OD;r,f h tcsdefuvnf;&S dawmh tJ'DrSm a':pkum;rSmygwJ h teft,f'Dwm0efcHwa,mufuqif;+yD;awmh “t&Sifbk&m; wynf hawmfwk d @ rd k;csKyfaeyg+yD/ tcsdefr&vd k @ygbk&m;/ wynf hawmf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 181/208
181
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
wd k @ cGif hjyKyg ”vd k @ajymvnf; bkef;}uD;u rjyefao;bl;? aemufud k vSnf h=unf h vSnf=unf heJ @ xyf +yD;ajymwmbmajymvnf;qd kawmh“igvlawG tvm;um;yJ” u|efawmfwd k @vnf; atmufuae a':pkum;uk d tJ'DtcsdefrSm vH kòcHa&;t&qif;+yD;awmhab;rSm umay;wmayghaemf? tJ'DtcsdefrSm tJvd kajymwmu “aemuf
rSm ighvlawG vmr,f? igbkef;}uD;pum; ud kem;axmifyg? olwk d @ud k }udKpm;jyD; a[may;yg”ajym+yD; olwd k @uxGufcGif h ray;bl;? tJ'DxGufcGif hray;wh JtcsdefrSm u|efawmfwd k @ vli,fwm0efcH tJ'D a':pkum;rSmygwJ hvlu xGuf&zd k @ awmif;yefygw,f? tJvd kawmif;yefwJ htcsdefrSm [d kuvnf; rxGufeJ @ 'Duvnf;xGufyg&ap awmif;yefaewJ htcsdefrSm aemufuaejyD;awmh rD;awGxd k;jyD;awmh tJ'Dum;awGa&mufvmygw,f?um;awG a&mufvmygw,f? tenf;qH k; (7)ESpfpD;avmufawmh&S dw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? bmum;awGvJ?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? um;uawmh tpH kyJ? tpH kyJqk dwmu ukefum;}uD;a&m ajr}uD;o,fwJ hum;ayghAsm? 'd kifemum;awGvnf;
awG @w,fAsm? awG @wJ htcsdefrSm olwd k @a&mufvm+yD;awmh bmrajym nmrajymeJ @ &Gm;om;awGud k qif;&k duf w,f? &k dufwJ htcsdefrSm vSrf;=unf hawmh rD;uxd k;xm;awmh jrifae&wmayghAsm?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dum;ay:rSm ygvmwJ hvlu qif;+yD;awmh &Gm;om;awGud k &k dufwmvm;?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? [kwfuJ h? olwd k @u qif ;&k dufwm? qif;&k dufawmh u|efawmfwk d @u 'Du vSrf;jrifaew,f/ olwk d @u rD ;xd k;
ae=uwmav/ olwd k @um;awGu ta0;}uD;uae+yD;awmh jrif&atmifqd k+yD;awmh? &k dufwmu bkef;}uD;awGawmhawmfawmfrsm;w,fAsm? vlawGuvnf; awmfawmfav;ud k rsm;w,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? bkef;}uD;awGvnf;ygw,faygh tJ'Dum;rSm?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? &Gmom;awG&k dufawmh &Gmom;awGu a=umuftm;vef @tm;eJ @ atmf[pf+yD;awmh ajy;oGm;=uw,f?ajy;awmhtJ'D&Gm;om;awGaemufud k 'DaumifawGu vk dufoGm;=uw,f? 'Dbufu tJ'DusefwJ hvlawGu'Dbufuk dvm+yD;awmhu|efawmfwk d @tzG @Jum;wef;ud k vm+yD;awmh tukef;vH k;wef;pD+yD; bmrajym nmrajymbJeJ @&k dufygw,f? tJ'DtcsdefrSma&mufcgeD;rSm usaemfwd k @vSrf;=unf hwJ htcsdefrSm bkef;}uD;awGrSmvufywftjzL awGud k nmbufvufrSm pnf;xm;yg w,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? bkef;}uD;awGu olwd k @ubmac:vnf; oauFwawGaygh [kwfvm;?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? olwd k @tcsif;csif; rSwfom;+yD;xm;xmwm olwd k @tcsif;csif; rSwfom;+yD;xm;w,fqk dwmu ra&m,Suf
atmifab;bkef;}uD;awGeJ @ rwlnDwJ hyH kpHrsdK;uk d owfrSwfxm;wmjzpfygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? 'Dbkef;}uD;awGu tppfawGwk d @ ,lqvk d @&ovm;?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? bkef;}uD;tppfawmh rjzpfavmufbl;xifwmyJ? bmvd k @qk d olwk d @ &Gmom;awGa&m/ usaemfwk d @tzG J @u
vlawGa&m +idrf;+idrf;csrf;csrf;eJ @ aewmud k vd kufjyD;awmh&k dufwm? tckqd k&if 'D[m usaemfwd k @=um;ae&wmusaemfwk d @a&S hjrifae&wm/ aoaewJ hvlawGawmif ygygw,f? aoaewJ hvlawGygwJ htwGuf tjypfrJ hvlawGud kaoatmif&k dufavmufbl;xifygw,f? bkef;}uD;tppfqk d&ifawmh?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh &Gmom;awGud k vd kuf&k duf+yD;awmh &Gmom;eJ @ teft,f'DtzG J @0ifawGud k uef @ypfvd kufwmayghaemf?
uef @vk duf+yD;awmhrS 'Dbufuteft,f'DtzG J @0ifawGud k &k dufw,fqd kygawmh?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? [kwfygw,f? teft,f'DtzG J @0ifawGuk d &k dufygw,f? &Gmom;awGvnf; ajy;wJ htcsdefrSm tJ'D&Gmom;awG
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 182/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
182
ajy;wJ h[mawGeJ @ awG @+yD;awmh qH k+yD;uswJ hyH kvnf;jzpfwwfygw,f? usaemfwk d @tiftm;u enf;enf;av;yg? usaemfwk d @tiftm;u enf;enf;av;qd kayr,f h tiftm;uenf;enf;rsm;rsm; usaemfwd k @rSm bmvufeufrS rygygbl;?usaemfwk d @ acgif;aqmifawGuvnf; wzufu &efrl jyKrlvm&ifawmifrS jyefvnf+yD;
ckcHzk d @/ jyefvnfwH k @jyefzd k @ vH k;0cGif hrjyKxm;ygbl;? aemufqH k; pum;ukefrSmxm;wmuawmh olwd k @&k dufawmifrS }udwf+yD; cHay; &r,fvd k @ usaemfwk d @acgif;aqmifawGu rSmay;xm;ygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh olwk d @u teft,f'DuygvmwJ h um;wef;ay:u &JabmftukefvH k;ud k rn‡mrwm &k dufaeawmhwmaygh?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? taotaus rn‡mrwm&k dufwm[m b,favmufxd&k dufovJqk d&if usaemfwd k @ud kAsm &d kufwJ h tcsdefrSmusaemfwk d @um;ud k vm&k dufwJ htcsdefrSm v_yfaewJ holawG @&if 'Daumif raobl; &k duf&k dufqd k+yD; 0k dif;&k dufae=uwm? &k duf+yD;awmh/ wkwfwacsmif;awmifr[kwfbl;/ wkwfawGu ESpfacsmif;oH k;acsmif; vltkyf=um;xJu jzwf&k dufoGm;wJ hvl&S dw,f? raoao;vd k @ &k dufaewJ hyH kpHrsdK;? tJ'DrSmwif nnf;nL+yD;awmh a=umufygw,f/ vef @ygw,fvd k @ajymvk d @&S d&if a=umufyg+yDAs? awmfygawmfAsm bmnmajym&if [m 'DaumiftoHxGufw,f raoao;bl; &k duf &k duf &k duf/ &k dufw,f? tJ'DtcsdefrSm usaemfwk d @uvnf; usaemfwk d @&J haor,f h ta&;yJawG;+yD; a=umufvef @aewm? usaemfwk d @em;rSm atmf[pfaewmawG=um;ae&w,f?usaemfwd k @ rv_yfawmhbl;? tm;vH k;urv_yfawmhbl;/ aowJ hvleJ @/ ajy;wJ hvleJ @/ wcsd K@vnf; v_yfaewJ hvlud k&d kufwkef; vrf;av#muf &if&k dufvd k @ 'Dtwk dif;yJ+idrfaewJ hvlawGayghAsm? tJ'DrSmwif bmajymvnf;qd kawmhrif;wk d @ igwk d @vrf;awGazmufw,f/ wHwm;awGaqmufaewm rif;wd k @xnf hrajymbl;/ rif;wd k @ atmifqef;pk=unfu Ek difiHtwGuf bmawGvkyfay;vd k @vJ? rif;wk d @ ukvm;r,m;=oZmcHawG qk d+yD;awmh/ tJ'Drv_yfwJ h[mawGud k xyf+yD;awmh &k d fufoGm;w,f? tJ'Dvk d ajym+yD;xyf&k dufygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJvd kqd kawmh a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kvk dufyd k @wJ hum;ay:rSm trsdK;orD;awGvnf; ygw,fvd k @=um;& w,f? olwd k @=uawmha&m
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? olwk d @yg ygw,f cifAs? trsdK;orD;awG ygygw,f? tJ'Dvk dygwJ htcsdefrSm trsdK;orD;awGud k yifeD0wfxm;wJ h[mawGayghAsm/ trsdK;om;awGa&m tukefvH k; yifeDrjrifcsifbl;qd kjyD; tukefvH k;c|wfck dif;ygw,f? c|wfcd kif;awmh wcsdK@uowdvpfaewJ hvlawG aoaewJ htyH kxJu &S dwJ hvlawGrSmusawmh jzKwf,lw,f? [d kxJrSmxJu yifeDawG qG Jc|wfwJ hvlawGa&m/ um;ay:uae u|wfygwmawGvnf;&S dw,f? rdef;uav;awGud kvnf;qG Jc|wfw,fAsm? twif;ygyJ? rc|wfygeJ @vd k @awmif;yefawmh olwk d @uvufrcHbl;? vufrcHbJeJ @ olwd k @qG J
c|wfw,f/ tusôawGud k tJ'DrSmwifqG Jc|wfjyD; qG Jóud;ygc|wf,loGm;w,f? qG J}udK;c|wfaewm usaemfwd k @rsufjrifygyJ? aemufwcg qG J}udK;jzKwf &H kwifrubl; tdyfawGwcsdK@ud kvnf; ,loGm;w,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? olwdk @u tJ'DrSm vlawGud kvnf;&k dufw,f? trsdK;orD;awGud kvnf; um,dajENysufatmif atmufcHtusôawG qG Jc|wfw,fqk dwJ h oabmayghaemf? a,muF sm;av;awGuawm wd kufyH ktusôqd kawmh jy\emr&S dygbl;? uav;rawGusawmh &ifzH k;tusôqd kwJ htcgusawmh c|wfvd kufawmh 'g ÁajENysufatmifvkyfwJ h oabmaygh? qG J}udK;awGbmawGvnf;
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? qG J}udK;awG c|wf,loGm;w,f? yd kufqHtdyfygoGm;&if yd kufqHtdyfyg,lw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dvd k &d kufESufaewm b,favmufavmuf=umvnf; cifAsm?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? cef @rSef;acs (2)em&D xufawm hravsmhbl;? (2) em&DtausmfyJ &S dw,f? olwd k @u &k duf+yD;awmh rv_yfwmud k
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 183/208
183
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tJ'Dem;rSm um;/ ,mOfem;rSm tukef;vH k;ywfcsmoGm;vm+yD;awmh '%f&m&wJ hvlawGud k apmif h=unf haewJ hvlawG v_yfaewJ h vlawG toHxGufaewJ hvlemawGuk d æ
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh a':aatmifqef;pk=unf um;ua&m?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? tJ'Dawmh a':pkum;u tJ'Dvd k pjzpf+yD;awmh r=umbl; olwk d @um;u a':pkwk d @um;ayghAsm um;(5)pD;ua&S @uk dxGufoGm;w,f// bbOD;wifOD;wd k @ um;vnf ;ygw,f/ a':pkuum;vnf;ygw,f/ usaemfwk d @ vli,fvH kòcHa&;um;vnf;ygw,f? usaemfwk d @ +rdK@e,fuum;awGav?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? qd kawmh usnf&GmuaevGef+yD;awmh vGwfoGm;w,faygh? qk dawmh cifAsm;wk d @tJ'DrSmusefcJ hw,f? usefcJ hwJ htcgusawmh (2)em&Dausmfavmuf &d kufwJ hoabmaygh?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? (2)em&Dawmh tausmfyJ&S dygr,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? [kwfuJ h? tJ'Dvd k&d kufwJ htay:rSm cef @rSef;ajcaygh '%f&m&r,f od k @r[kwf rajymEd kifbl;aygh aoausoGm;Ek difwJ hvlawG b,favmufavmuf&S dr,f xifvJ?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? (20) ausmfavmuf&S dr,f? usaemfwd k @ usnf&GmrSmjzpfwJ h[mud kajymwm? 'Da&S hrSm jzpfcJ hwJ h[musawmhusaemfwk d @cef @rSef;=uwm æ
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @um;[m ygoGm;w,faygh/ a&S @ 'DyJ,if;bufrSm wcg xyfjzpfao;w,fqdkwJ hoabmaygh?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? jzpfygw,f? bmvd k @ jzpfygovnf;qd kawmh tJ'Dbufuajy;vmwJ hvli,fawGu usaemfe@JawG @&w,f?
[d krSmvnf; wkwfawG/ 0g;c|efawG/ opfvH k;awGayghaemf? tJ'g oHwkwfawGvk d @ ,lq&wJ h[mawGeJ @ 0k dif;&k dufygw,f? ausmif;om;av;awGa&m/ qd kifu,fawGzrf;jyD; vufjyefóud;awGwkwf+yD; ac:oGm;wmud kvnf;olwd k @uawG @cJ h& ygw,f? ol @qd kifu,fu ol @ta&S @rSmwif tJ'DrSmtzrf;cH&jyD; olujyefvGwfvmwmjzpfygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dta&S @rSm usaemfwd k @=um;&wmu aoewfawGbmawGeJ @ypfw,f tJ'Dvd k=um;w,f?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? aoewfoH=um;&w,f? usaemfwd k @=um;&w,fqk dwmu =um;&w,fqk dwJ hae&mrSm tcsdefud kajymr,f
qd k&ifusaemfwk d @ (12;00)em&D avmuf&S dyg+yD/ (12;00)em&D (1;00)em&DeJ @wlw,f? usaemfwd k @ pd k;&drfwmu
b,fvd kpd k;&drfovJqk dawmh usaemfwd k @ae&mrSm aoewfrygbJeJ @ (20)ausmfavmuf '%f&mjyif;xefeJ @aowJ h vlawGvnf; &S d=uvdrf hr,f? a&S @rSm aoewfoH=um;wJ htwGufa=umif h usaemfwd k @ txifawmhyd k+yD;awmh usaemfwd k @ tefwDpkwk d @ bbOD;wifOD;wk d @twGuf touftE W&m,fud k usaemfwd k @ awmfawmfav;pd k;&drfygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh 'D &d kufwJ htzG J @awG[m a&S @ud k qufvd kufoGm;vm;/ jyefoGm;vm;?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? olwd k @u [d k[mayghAsm uef @owfxm;wJ hyH kpH&S dygw,f? aemufjyef vSnf h+yD;awmh jyefoGm;=uygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'g b,ftcsdefavmufvJ cifAsm?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? (10) em&Dausmfavmufjzpfygw,f?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 184/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
184
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh cifAsm;u tJ'Duae b,fvd krsdK;vGwfvmygovJ?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? usaemf b,fvd krsdK; vGwfvmovJqd kawmh usaemfu uHaumif;w,fayghAsm? usaemfwk d @tzG J @awGxJu
uHqd k;wJ hvlawGxJrSmawmhuHaumif;w,faygh? b,fvd kuHaumif;vnf;qd kawmhusaemfwd k @ vlawGxJrSm
'%f&m r&bJeJ @ usaemfu jyefvGwfvmwmayghAsm? vGwfvmawmh v,fuGif;awGxJuae jzwf+yD;awmhrH k&Gma&mufatmif usaemf jyefajy;vmwmayghAsm?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'DrSm cifAsm; tJ'Dae&muae a&Smifvd kufwJ htcsdefrSm bmawGrsm;qufvkyf=uao;vJ 'D=uH hzG H @awGu/=uH hzG @HawGjyefoGm;+yD; txJrSm b,frSmqufjzpfao;vJ?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? bmqufjzpfao;vJqd kawmh usaemfwd k @ rjyefcifaygh/ usaemftJ'DrSm '%f&mr&ayr,f h vlu Ek H;csnf h+yD;awmhud k,f hvlawGeJ @xdjyD;awmh usaemfvnf;pdwfraumif;jzpf+yD;awmh tJ'Dem;rSm vlu '%f&momr&w,f? vrf;av#mufwmawmh ,d kifwd,d kifwd kifayh gAsm? tJ'DtcsdefrSm (10;30)avmufrSm qd kifu,fwpD;eJ @ vlwa,muf a&mufvmw,f? a&mufvm+yD;awmh usaemfwd k @ 'DjzpfpOfud k vm=unf hoGm;wJ hyH kpHrsdK;/ vlawGvJaewmud k vm=unf hoGm;wJ hyH kpHrsdK;/ tJ'DrSm awmfawmfav;&yf+yD;awmh =um=um=unf hoGm;w,f? vlaotavmif;awG =unf h+yD;awmh csufcsif;yJjyefvSnf hoGm;w,fcifAsm? tJ'DrSm (12;45)rdepfavmufrSm [D;Ed k;um; c&D;onfwifum;ayghAsm (3)pD;a&mufvmw,f? c&D;onfaw Gryg ygbl;?'gayr,f h tJ'DusrS tJ'DaoaewJ h[mawGjrif+yD;awmh vlawGvJaewmjrif/ aoaewmawGjrif '%f&m& aewmawGjrif/ um;wef;awGjrifjyD;awmh olwk d @jyefvSnf hoGm;=uw,f? tJ'D um;(3)pD;vk H; wyfacguf+yD;awmh jyefvSnf h oGm;=uw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? 'gjzif h vJaewJ hvlemawG od k @r[kwf aoa=uwJ hvlawGvnf; 'Dtwd kif;yJ&S daewmaygh?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? 'Dtwd kif;yJ &S daeygw,f? wcsdK@uvm+yD;awmh um;ay:wifoGm;ygw,f? tJ'gawmh awG @&w,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? tJ'Dawmh tJ'gawG aemufqH k;ydwf b,fvd kqufvuf+yD;=um;vJ?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? usaemfwk d @u tJ'DrSm ,d kif,d kifeJ @oGm;aewmayghAsm? usaemf apmif h=unf haewmyg? apmif h=unf h&if; (12;45)
rdepfrSm bma=umif hvnf; usaemftcsdefeJ @ajymEd kifwmuvnf; usaemfwk d @rSm em&Dygw,f? (12;45)rdepfrSm &JawGa&m/ rD;owfawGa&m jidrf0yfawGa&mayghAsm olwd k @ [d k'if;bufuxifygw,f/ a'otm%myd kifawG bufuvm+yD;awmhusaemfwk d @ 'D[mawGuk d tavmif;awG vlemawGud k um;awGay: wifay;ygw,f? aemuf+yD; awmhwckusaemfth H=owmu bmtH h=ovnf;qk dawmh usaemfwd k @taemufbuf 'DyJ
,if;bufvSnf hxm;wJ h usaemfwk d @&yfxm;wJ hum;ud k taemufbufvSnf hxm;wJ hum;uk d 'Dawmifbufcsufcsif;vSnf h+yD;awmh vrf;ab; qifajcav#mayghAsmtJ'DtxJ csvd kufw,fAsm? um;wpD;ud kvnf;aemufuae wGef;cs vd kufw,fAsm? tJ'D (2)pD;ud k ususee zefwD;xm;w,fAsm? usaemh frsufpda&S @wifjrif&wm?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? um;csif;wk duf+yD;awmh wckckjzpfw,fqk dwJ h oabmaygh?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? tJ'DyH kpHrsdK; olwd k @ zefwD;xm;wmyg? tJ'DrSmusaemfvnf; awmfawmfav; ud k,f hrsufpdud k r,H kbl; jzpfaeyg
w,f? tcsdefeJ @ usaemfwd k @ ususeerSwfxm;ygw,f? tJ'DrSm vlemawG wifwJ hvlawGuk dwif+yD;awmh'DyJ,if;bufud k um;awGuwcsdK@xGufw,f? wcsdK@u aemufjyef+yD;awmh xGufoGm;=uw,f? xGufoGm;
+yD;awmh vl(30)avmuf usefcJ hw,f? vl(30)avmufu &JawGvm;/ pGrf;tm;&Sifvm;vd k @ usaemfwd k @oJoJuG JuG J rodbl;? bmvd k @rodwmvnf; qd kawmh ,leDazmif;wlaew,fav? tJ'D (30)avmufuae+yD;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 185/208
185
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
awmh um;awGuk d wGef;oGm;w,fav? a&OD; bufwGef;oGm;wm usaemfwd k @awG @&ygw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? teft,f'DtzG J @0ifawG pD;vmwJ hum;ud k æajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? [kwfuJ h usaemfwd k @ teft,f'D tzG @J0ifawGpD;vmwJ hum;uk d wGef;oGm;ygw,f? wGef;oGm;jyD;awmh oHawG
ud kcGmaewJ h toHawG usaemfwd k @ =um&ygw,f? tJ'DrSmjzpfcJ hwJ h usaemf hrsufjrifayghAsm? ydef;yifawG=um;
xJrSm tJ'g æ
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? 'gu usnf&GmrSmjzpfcJ hwJ hudpPayghaemf? a&S @vGefoGm;wJ h 'DyJ,if;bufrSmjzpfwmud k cifAsm; rodbl;ayghaemf?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? usaemf rod&bl;Asm? tJ'DbufrSm æ
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? apmapmuajymwmu tJ'Djy\emjzpf&mu vGefoGm;wJ hum;awGqDuae aoewfoHawG =um;&w,f?wcsdK@uvnf; rajymbl;? wcsdK@uvnf; jrifcJ hwmajymjyw,f? tJ'Dawmh a&S @rSmwzG J @ apmif haewJ h oabm&S dwmaygh?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? a&S @rSmwzG J @ aocsmaygufapmif hae=uw,f? bmjzpfvd k @aocsmaygufapmif haevnf;qk dawmhaoewfoHvnf;=um;&w,f? usaemfwk d @ awG @cJ hwJ hvlawGuvnf; ajymjyw,f?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? [kwfuJh 'Davmufod&wm aus;Zl;wifygw,f?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? [kwfuJ h 'guvnf ; usaemfwd k @ od&oavmufayghaemf? ypfw,fqd k&if aowJ hvl rsm;rvm; usaemfwd k @
pd k;&drfygw,f? bmvd k @vnf;qd kawmh 'gu usaemfwd k @od&wJ h enf;enf;yJ&S dygao;w,f? a&S @jzpfcJ hwJ h[muyd k+yD; qd k;avmufygw,f? bmvd k @ qd k;avmufovJqk dawmh aoewfoHawG=um;wJ htwGuf?
ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;?ar;? a&S @rSm tzG J @yd k=urf;w,faygh?
ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz?ajz? tzG J @yd k=urf;wJ h jzpfwJ h[mawG trsm;}uD;awG @&ygw,f?Ð
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 186/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
186
'DyJ,if;vlowfyGJukd rsufjrifóuHawGŒ cJ haom
q,fbD;ukefwifum; py,ff,mwOD;rS &ifzGifhoH
usaemf hemrnfu ausmfvGifyg/ touf (30)ESpf &S dyg+yD/ usaemftck eDqef;,l'D NISSAN-UD um;trSwf 2 c§1962 rSm pyg,f,mvkyfygw,f// ,mOfarmif;uuk dndKyg//
usaemf hum;yd kif&Sifuawmh OD;pHjrif h-a':rmvm&Dyg// wu,f hum;yd kif&Sifuawmha&póud axmuf vSrf;a&;uvd k @ odxm;ygw,f//
usaemfwd k @um;u &efukefbk&if haemif-ca&vrf;rSm&S dwJ h armifjrif h*dwfrSm *dwf
xd k;ygw,f// *dwfzH k;eH ygwfu &efukef 68 1229 yg// usaemfwd k @um;u &efukef-rH k&Gm ukefpnfyd k @aqmifa&;ud k t"duvkyfygw,f//
arvukefyd kif;u usaemfwd k @um; rH k&Gmud k ukefawGoGm;yd k @ygw,f// 28-5-03&ufae@ avmufu p+yD;awmh rH k&GmrSm acsmqG JcH&ygw,f// erc u qG Jwmyg// tm;vH k;q,fbD;um; (10) pD;yg// um;tm;vH k; erc 0if;xJrSmae&ygw,f//
arv (30) &ufae@rSmawmh æerc 0if;xJuae Ad kvf}uD;qd kwJ holu a&S @cef;rSmxd kifygw,f// olu t&yf0wfeJ @
yg? um;ay:rSm quf oG,fa&;pufawGvJwifvmwmawG @&ygw,f// aemufcef;rSmawmh oCFef;0wf/ vl0wf tm;vH k; ta,muf(50)avmuf wufygw,f// um;ud kwmvywftrd k;eJ @zH k;um+yD;rS pxGufcd kif;ygw,f//
n (7;00)em&DausmfavmufrSm erc 0if;xJuae pxGufwmyg// 'DyJ,if; /a&OD;bufud k armif;cd kif;yg w,f//
'DyJ,if; ra&mufcif (2) rd kif/ (3) rd kiftvd kavmufrSm vlawG &kef;&if;qefcwfeJ @&d kufyG J}uD;wckud k awG @&ygw,f// tJ'Dae&ma&mufawmh (8)em&DcG J/ (9)em&Davmufxifygw,f//
a&S @cef;u Ad kvf}uD;qd kolu um;rD;eJ @xd k;cd kif;xm;+yD;/ aemufcef;uvlawGud kqif;cd kif;+yD; tJ'DvltkyfxJ 0if&d kufcd kif;ygw,f//
um;ay:rSmawmh usaemf&,f/ ud kndK&,f/ Ad kvf}uD;qd kol&,f oH k;a,mufyJ usefcJ hygw,f//
jrif&wmuawmh tjyif;txeft+iKd;w}uD;eJ@&d kufaewmrsdK; jrifawG @ae&ygw,f// awmfawmfajcmufjcm;zd k @ aumif ;ygw,f// 'grsdK; rawG @bl;/ róuHzl;ygbl;// wzufowf&d kufaeyH kygbJ//
t&d kufcH&wJ hvlawGvJ vJwJ holvJ/ ajy;wJ holajy;/ atmfwJ holuatmfeJ @aoG;&l;
aoG;wef;jzpfae=uwm awG @&ygw,f//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 187/208
187
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
vJaewJ holwcsdK@ud k r xkwfvm+yD; usaemfwd k @um;em;rSm vmyH kxm;ygw,f//r vmwJ holawGud k b,fol b,f0gawmh rodygbl;// usaemf hum;ay: ygvmwJ h olawGyJ xifygw,f//
um;acgif;cef;xJuAd kvf}uD;qd kwJ holuawmh “[kwfuJ h Ad kvfcsKyf/ [kwfuJ h/ [kwfuJ h” qd k+yD; zkef;wvH k;eJ @ ajymaewmawG @&ygw,f//
c%aeawmh um;ab;uvlaoyH kud k um;ay:wifzk d @ usaemf hud kcd kif;ygw,f// a&S @
rSm&d kufaewJ h vltkyfxJud kvnf; ajcmufvH k;jyL;eJ @ (3/ 4) csuf vSrf;ypfvd kufao;w,f?vlaoawGvm;/ arharsmae=uovm;awm hrodbl;/ tm;vH k;uawmh aoG;awG&$ JepfaewmygyJ// usaemfud k,fwd kif xr;fwif&wmyg// um;aemufcef;xJud kaygh//tm;vH k; (17) a,mufwdwdbJ//
wifvd k @vJ+yD;a&m um;ud kaemufa=umif;jyefvSnf h armif;cd kif;ygw,f// um;ay: uoCFef;0wfawG/ vl0wf awGawmh jyefyg rvmygbl;//
aemufrSm bmawGqufjzpfaevJawmhusaemfrodygbl;//
wjcm;acsmqGJcHxm;&wJ h q,fbD;um;awGvJ 'D&dkufyGJ}uD;udkvmwmawG@&
ygw,f// olwd k @ bmvkyf& ovJawmh rodygbl;//usaemfwd k@vJ um;armif;vmvdkufwm tvHk&Gma&mufwmhum;&yfcdkif;+yD;/
aemufcef;u tavmif; (17) avmif;ud k atmufcs+yD; vrf;ab;rSm yH kcd kif;ygw,f?Ad kvf}uD;qd kwJ holucd kif;wmyg// +yD;awmhum;ud k erc 0if;xJ jyefarmif;cd kif;ygw,f//
0if;xJrSm pg;yG JaomufyG JawGtqifoif hjyifxm;+yD;/ usaemfwd k @ud k 0ifpm;cd kif;ygw,f// usaemfwd k @vJ pm;yG JwckrSm 0ifpm;=uygw,f// t&ufvJygwmaygh// +yD;awmhwa,mufud k aiG (30000)usyfpDay;ygw,f?
usaemfwd k @pm;aomufaewkef; usaemfwd k @um;ud k wjcm;vlwa,muf armif;oGm;wmawG @&ygw,f? Ad kvf}uD;qd kwJ holu “'Dem;wifyg pdwfrylygeJ @” vd k @ajymygw,f//
um;u aemufae@arv (31)&uf naeavmufrSjyefa&mufvmygw,f//
um;uk d ZGefv (1)&ufae@reufusrS a&aq;+yD;qGrf;uyf&ygw,f// tvH kvrf;ab; csxm;cJ hwJ h tavmif;(17)avmif;ud k bmvkyfovJawmh rodygbl;// ajymoH=um;wmawmh rD;±_ d @ypfw,fqd kvm;yJ?
tck *dwfjyefxd k;+yD; vd kif;jyefqG Jaeygw,f//
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 188/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
188
rEWav;wd kif; trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJŒ0iftrsKd;orD;wOD;ESifh
jynfyowif;Xme awGŒqH kar;jref;cef;wGif
xkwfazmfajymqd kcsufrsm;ud kazmfjyvd kufygonf?
usrwd k @ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;eJ @ wd kif;¶H k;uae+yD;awmh (29/ 5/ 2003)&ufae@ reuf(10)em&DrSm rSmpxGufygw,f? usrwd k @um;wef;&J @ taemufrSm b§8090 Van rD;cd k;a&mifeJ @ axmufvSrf;a&;um; ygvmygw,f?tJ'DaemufrSm qd kifu,f ppfpdrf;a&mif ,§50531/ qd kifu,fpdrf; ,§51176/ qd kifu,f 1,§68549/ 'DwD1,§78953/ um; tdyfcsfZl;Zl;2c§2472/ *spfum; 7138/ ppfud kif; wHwm;ud ka&mufwJ htcgrSm jynfytm;ud k;ykqdef¶d k; qd kwJ h pmwef;awGud kud kif+yD;awmh &yfae=uygw,f f/ wcsdK@qd kvd k @&S d&if tJ h'Dpm&Guf}uD;awG ud kifxm;&muaetaxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;ud kvnf;jrifa&m vuftkyfcsD=uygw,f? usrwd k @"gwfyHkawGvnf; ¶d kufxm;ygw,f&Sifh?
tJ h'Duae c&D;qufxGufwJ htcgrSm jrif;rl¶H k;ud k (11)em&D(15)rdepfrSm a&mufygw,f? a&mufwJ htcgrSm òrd @e,fvli,fawGud k zG J @pnf;/ òrd @e,fqd kif;bkwfawGud k wif+yD;awmh (2)em&D (45)rdepfrSm p xGufygw,f? usrwd k @&J @um;aemufrSm qefeDtjzLa&mif 4u§5799 axmufvSrf;a&;bufrS um;wpD; xyfygvmygw,f&Sif?
tJ'Duae a&yd k;pm;uefud ka&muf&S dwJ htcgrSm um;wwef;vH k;ud k ae&mtvGwf r&S dbl;/ vlawGtjynf h t=uyfeJ @um;wef;awGuvnf;tukefvH k; olwd k @AsL[mrª;ac:&rvm;/ &Jrª; tJ'Dum;awGuvnf;tjynf h csHKcdk+yD;ae=uygw,f? ae+yD;awmh tJ h'Dtay:rSmyJ pm&GufawGud kif+yD;awmh toHawG xGuf+yD;awmhqd kygw,f&Sif? usrwd k @tzG J @uEd kifiHawmfoDcsif;eJ @yJ wkef @jyefoDqd kcJ hygw,f? tJ h'Duaep+yD;awmh usrwd k @ud kóudwJ h qd kifu,ftpD;aygif; (2000)cef @&S dygw,f? tJ h'Duae quf+yD;xGufvmwJ htcgrSm rH k&Gmòrd @t0ifud k nae (3)em&D (15)rdepfrSm a&muf&S dygw,f?tJ'DrSm wvSrf;csif;/ wvSrf;csif;av; vS drf h+yD;awmh nud k;em&DcG JrS usrwd k @ rH k&Gm¶H k;csKyfud k a&mufygw,f? rH k&Gm¶H k;csKyfud ka&mufwJ htcgrSm òrd @e,ftzG J @pnf;awG zG J @pnf;+yD;awmh òrd @e,f¶H k;rSmyJquf+yD;awmh usrwd k @ vli,fawGzG J @pnf;ygw,f? aemufwae@ (30)&ufreuf (10)em&D (20)rdepfrSm rH k&Gm ‘pdrfr#m;’pwd k;uae+yD;awmh pxGufygw,f?tJ'DrSm [d kif;vwf "§9458 olwd k @axmufvSrf;a&;um;yJ xyf+yD;awmhygvmygw,f? usrwd k @ *g&0ðyzd k @ ‘aZmwdubkef;}uD;ausmif;’ud k (10)em&D(50)rdepfrSm a&mufygw,f taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;eJ @ OuUÏ}uD;yJ0if+yD;awmh q&mawmfud k ouFef;rsm;qufuyfygw,f? tJ'Duae quf+yD;xGufwJ htcgrSm ‘OuU H awm&ausmif;’ud k usrwd k @r0ifawmhygbl;&Sif? tJ'Daemuf usrwd k @qufwd kufygvmwmayghav? q§4103 um;? (11) em&D(15)rdepfrSm‘tvH kòrd @’ud ka&muf&S d+yD;awmh qufvuf+yD;xGufwJ htcgrSm‘bkwvifòrd @’ud k (1)em&D(5)rdepfrSm a&mufygw,f?bkwvifrSm òrd @e,fvli,fzG J @pnf;+yD;awmh (5)em&D(15)rdepfrSm pxGuf+yD; (6)em&D(15)rdepfrSm ‘pd kifjyif’ud k a&mufyg
w,f? pd kifjyif}uD;rSm usrwd k @ (1)em&Dem;ygw,f&Sif? em;+yD;awmh a':pku vlxkud kem&D0ufcef @ pum;ajym+yD;awmhpd kifjyifuae (7)em&DrSm pxGufygw,f? (7)em&DcG J usnf&Gmud ka&mufwJ htcgrSmawmh jynfolrsm;pGmu usrwd k @ud kóudaeygw,f? (7)em&DcG Jqd kawmh arSmif&DysdK;p tcsdefud ka&muf&S daeyg+yD&Sif? tJ h'DtcsdefrSm jynfolawGaemufu um;wef;}uD;u um;rD;awGxd k;+yD;awmh wòydifeufxJ v#yfwjyufqd kovd k a&muf&S dvm+yD;awmh usrwd k @um;wef;awGay:ud krD;armif;awGxd k;+yD;awmh usnf&GmujynfolawGud k p ¶d kufygw,f&Sif? ¶d kufwJ htcgrSm usrwd k @tzG J @acgif;aqmifawGuae+yD;awmh “bmjzpfwmvJ/ b,fvd kvJ/ trsdK;orD;awGtm;vH k; um;ay:u rqif;ygeJ @ tm;vH k;=unf h=uyg?jynfolawGud k¶d kufaewm wm0ef&S dw,f?ajz&Sif;&rSmaygh”qd k+yD; usrwd k @vl}uD;awGuae qif;+yD;awmh vkyfwJ h tcgrSmqufwd kufqufwd kufqd kovd k um;wef;awGa&S @ud k oGm;wJ hvluoGm;/ aemufqH k;rSm usrwd k @ um;wef;awGu usef
tJvk djzpf+yD;awmhusrwd k @ p +yD ;awmh¶d kufwm olwd k @u óudwif,lvmwJ h[myg&Sif?ausmufcJawGqd k tdwfvd kufawGeJ @/usrwd k @ tJ'Dem;av;u v,fuGif;jyif}uD;yg&Sif? v,fuGif;jyif}uD;rSm bmausmufcJrS r&S dygbl;? tJ'DrSm ausmufcJ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 189/208
189
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
awGeJ @ 0d kif;ayguf/ wkwfawG/ oHwkwfawG/ rma=umwJ hwkwf&mawGeJ @ tJ'DrSm bkef;}uD;wkawGjzpfygw,f? vufrSmvnf; tyfcsnftjzLóud;av;awG csnfxm;ygw,f&Sif? vlawGuvnf; rJrJjywfjywf ykykeJ @ pum;ajymuvnf;&kef @&if;=urf;wrf;wJ h z¶k\0gpm pum;awGeJ @ usrwd k @tzG J @awGud k ajymygw,f? ajym+yD;awmh qufwd kuf ¶d kufvd kuf
wm usrwd k @trsdK;orD;awGqd k tukef0yf/ um;ay:rSm ud k,f htoufud k,f vnfpif;ay;ovd k qufwd kuf usrwd k @cH&ygw,f? usrwd k @tzG J @rSm vufeufqd kvd k @ tyfwd k wacsmif;awmif rygcJ hygbl;? tJ'D[m oufouf jrefrmjynfoltcsif;csif;ud k usrwd k @ t¶d kufcH&ygw,f? tJ'DrSm acgif;ud kt"duxm;+yD;awmh taooabmrsdK;ud k ¶d kufwmjzpfygw,f? um;wpif;vH k;ud kv_yf+yD;awmh “rqif;bl;vm;/ qif;rSmvm;/ rqif;&if rD;¶_ d @ypfr,f”qd k+yD;awmh usrwd k @tzG J @awGud k tukefqif;cd kif;ygw,f? qif;wJ htcgrSmvnf;yJ trsdK;om;awGud k ucsifvH kcsnf/ tuô s tjzLawGud k ZGwfc|wfcd kif;ygw,f? usrwd k @ trsd K;orD;awGud kvnf; yifeDtuô sawGud k c|wfcd kif;ygw,f? c|wfcd kif;wJ htcgrSm usrwd k @ &ifvsm;+yD;awmhqif;&ygw,f? tJ'Dtqif;rSm wa,mufwcsuf acgif;awGcsnf;yJ t¶d kufcH&wm rsm;ygw,f? usrqd kvd k @&S d&ifowdud k renf;xdef;+yD; usr arhoGm;ygw,f? csmvnf¶d kuf+yD;awmh rl;aeayr,f h usr owdud kt+rJxdef;+yD;awmhapmif;vd kufawmh usrwud k,fvH k;rSm aoG;awG&Jaeawmh tukefvH k; usrud k ao+yDqd k+yD;awmh vSnf hr=unf hbJeJ @usrwd k @um;ay:rSmygwJ h tefwD}uD;wa,mufu vl}uD;qd kawmh olu x=unf hw,f/ ol @ud kvJ awmfawmfav;oJoJrJrJ a,muf sm;rsm;enf;wl t¶d kufcH&ygw,f? ausm/ &if/ wifyg;/ acgif;/ acgif;qd kwm b,fESpfcsufrSef;awmifrodygbl;? wcsufwnf; t¶d kufcH&wm b,folrS r&S dygbl;/ tukefvH k; q,fcsuf/ ig;csuf/ oH k;csuf? usrqd k&ifig;csuf txdcH&ygw,f? xdyf ESpfcsuf/ tv,f wpfcsuf/wcsufqd k&if usrtcktcsdefxd aq;ukae&wkef;yg? bk}uD;jzpfae+yD; "gwfrSef ¶d kuf&w,f/ tcktcsdefxd tJ'Dbk}uD;u ta&mif ravsmhao;ygbl;?
tJ'Dvd k olwd k @tao;pdyf¶d kufoGm;+yD;awmh um;awGud kolwd k @ v,fuGif;xJud ktukefqG Jcs+yD;awmh ‘vm a[hb,folawGusefao;wkef;’qd k+yD;awmh olwd k @tzG J @u um;t&Snf}uD;eJ @ acsmif;OD;-rH k&Gm bufud koGm;wm awG @vk duf&ygw,f? tJ'DrSm usrwd k @ud k ygvmwJ hqG Jóud;awGaum tukefc|wfygw,f&Sif h? yd kufqHawG/ tdwfawG/ t0wfpm;awG
tukefqG J+yD;awmh,lwm usrwd k @ zdeyfawmif rusefygbl;&Sif h? trsdK;om;wa,mufqd kvd k @&S d&if tdwf wjcrf;u=um;xJrSmnyfaevd k @/ wjcrf ;rSm uifr&m/ yd kufqHig;aomif;? yd kufqHuvJwa,mufud k ryg˜ygbl; qd k&if ig;aomif;/ajcmufaomif;? um;wpD;/wpD;ud k yd kufqHu av;ig;odef;avmufyg˜ygw,f? aemufyd kif;u usrwd k @trsdK;orD;ajcmufa,mufu qG Jóud;ajcmufuH k;/ em&DawG tc|wfcH&ygw,f?
tusôqG Jc|wf&if;eJ @ usrwd k @qG Jóud;awGud k c|wf,loGm;wmyg&Sif// ,loGm;+yD;awmh tdyfawG/ zdeyf awG tukefvk H;ygoGm;+yD; usrwd k @ wppD arhwJ hvluarh/ vJwJ hvluvJ / '%f&m&wJ hvlu & / nnf;wJ h vlunnf;? x r=unf heJ @aemf/x=unf hwJ hvlrSefor# taoyJ vd k @ajymqd k+yD;awmh olwd k @ um;wef;}uD;awGeJ @ um;t&Snf}uD;awGok H;+yD; rH k&Gmbufud k oGm;ygw,f? q&mawmfrsm;pD;+yD;vm wJ h 'd kifemum;tjzLud kvnf; ‘tifeft,fvf'D u&_ d d @wmuG’vd k @ajymqd k+yD;
rD;&_ d @oGm;wmyg// aemufqk H;usefwJ h a&OD;-wef @qnf um;tjzLav;ud k rD;&_ d @cJ hygw,f// olwd k @jyefoGm;+yD;awmh usrwd k @wawGu jyef+yD; owd&wJ hvlu & / usrwd k @ trsKdorD; ajcmufa,mufpvk H;owd&+yD; ckeutdwfwjcrf;usefcJ hwJ htrsdK;om;qd k&ifwjcrf;u"mwfyk H/ rSwfwrf;uwfjym;/uifr&mawG/ yd kufqHawG tukefvk H;,loGm;+yD; usefcJ hwJ h&Syftusôok H;av;xnfud k usrwk d @ trsK;dorD;awGud k 0wfcd kif;ygw,f// 0wf+yD;awmh a&wd kufwJ hvlu a&vd kcsif&if a&wd kuf/usru '%f&m&wJ hvlawGud k w¶kwfoGm;wd kufaq;Al;eJ @odyfay;/ tJ h'DrSm w¶kwfoGm;wd kufaq;Al; wAl;/ a&oef @Al;ESpfAl; ukefygw,f? tJ h'Duae+yD; usrwd k @a&SmifaerSjzpfrSm awmf=umjyefvm+yD;¶d kufae&if b,f hES,fvkyfrwkef; qd k+yD;awmh tJ h'DrSm&S dor#vlemawGud k um;ay:wifwm wif/ wG J+yD;awmh rS Dwefwm rS D vkyf+yD;awmh usrwd k @ v,fuGif;xJa&mufoGm;ygw,f? usrwd k @tzG J @awG uG Jukefygw,f? usrwd k @v,fuGif;xJaeawmh (11)em&DavmufrSm olwd k @awGjyefa&mufvmygw,f? olwd k @ud k,folwd k @awmh a=umufygw,f&Sif? 'd kif;awGaum/ aoewfawGaum,lvmygw,f?,lvm+yD;awmh usrwd k @tzG J @awGud kajymwJ hpum;awG[m t&rf;ud k &kef @&if;=urf;wrf;ygw,f? “a[haumifawG/rxbl;vm;/ xrSmvm;”qd k+yD;awmh rxEd kifwJ hvlawGud k ajcaxmufeJ @uefyH k&ygw,f? rxEd kifvd k @ygcifAsvd k @ usrwd k @
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 190/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
190
tzG J @awGuajymwmud k ZGwfuk dxcd kif;+yD;awmh um;ay:ud kwifoGm;ygw,f?tJ'g(11)em&DavmufrSmyg um;csif;wd kufwJ hyH kpHawGvkyf/ opfyifawGckwfcd kif;+yD; um;ay:ydwJ h yH kpHawG/ um;awG opfyif0ifaqmif hwJ hyH kpHawGvkyf+yD; "gwfyH kawG wzsyfzsyf¶d kufoGm;wmud k usrwd k @vSrf;jrif&ygw,f?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? tpfrwd k @tapmu aq;ukor_vkyfay;aewJ htcsdef[m oufoufrJ hv$wfay;xm;wmayghaemf?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? [kwfuJ h/ tJ h'DtcsdefrSm b,folrSrvmao;ygbl;&Sif h? ¶d kufoGm;+yD;awmh b,folrSjyefrvmao;ygbl;?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? 'gqd kolwd k @¶d kuf+yD;awmh yxrwcg xGufajy;oGm;wmayghaemf?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? [kwfuJ h/ ¶d k kuf+yD;awmh olwd k @um;wef;}uD;awGeJ @xGufajy;oGm;wmyg&Sif h? tJ'g usrwd k @um;wef;&J @
tv,fa=umrSm jzpfwmyg? aemufyd kif;rSmvnf; ¶d kufyG JawGjzpfw,fvd k @=um;ygw,f? usrwd k @jzpfwmuum;wef; tv,fa=umayghaemf?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? [kwfuJ h/ quf+yD;ajymygcifAs/ tpfr bmawG qufjrifcJ h&ao;vJ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? tJ'DtcsdefrSm olwd k @"gwfyH kawG wzsyfzsyfeJ @¶d kufygw,f? aemuf+yD; 'DyJ,if;bufuvnf; aoewfoHawG
=um;&ygw,f? usrwd k @tzG J @awGxJu rxEd kifwJ holawGud k vmac:wif+yD;awmh 'DyJ,if;bufud k xGufoGm;ygw,f&Sifh?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? tcktrwd k @ t¶d kufcH&wJ haeud k b,fae&mavmuf owfrSwf&rvJ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? usnf&GmeJ @ 'DyJ,if;=um; rd kifwd kif 175 tay:u 4/ tJ h'DrSwfwd kifem;av;rSm&Sif h?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? a=omf[kwfuJ h/ a':pkum;eJ @awmh trwd k @eJ @u rqH krdbl;ayghaemf?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? a0;wmayghaemf/ olwd k @um;ua&S @rSma':pkwd k @u usrwd k @uaemufqH k;rSm? usrwd k @um;awGu tao
twG,fcH&wmayghaemf? tJ h'DrSm usra&S @wifaowm (3)OD;awG @&ygw,f? &Spfem&DavmuftcsdefrSm æ
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? b,folawGvnf; qd kwm trodvm;?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? odygw,f&Sif/ odef;wd k;at;&,f/ ud kpef;jrif h&,f/ ud kwifarmifOD;uawmh aovm;&Sifvm; usr rodygbl;
awmfawmfawmhqd k;ygw,f?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? [kwfuJ hqufajymygOD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @owif;awGaum qufr=um;&bl;vm;/trwd k @tajcae awG b,fvd kqufjzpfvJ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? usrwd k @wawGu b,fol @ b,fol @ud krSud k r=unf hEd kifatmif olwd k @u ¶d kuf/¶d kuf qd kwJ htoHawGeJ @
qufwd kufud k¶d kufygw,f? bmwckrSud k emvefrxlEd kifatmif cJawGeJ @ypf/ wkwfawGeJ @¶d kuf wpD;eJ @wpD;ud kjyef+yD; r=unf hEd kifatmifud kusrwd k @t¶d kufcH&ygw,f? olwd k @¶d kuf+yD;awmh jyefxGufwJ htcgrSm um;awGay:u vlawGud katmufud kqG Jcsygw,f? um;awGud kv,fuGif;xJud kwGef;csygw,f// olwd k @jyefoGm;+yD;wJ htcgrSm usrwd k @owd&+yD;awmh tapmuajymovd k '%f&m&wJ holawG wwfEd kifoavmufðypk+yD;awmhjyefvm&ifb,fvd kvkyfrvJ/ axmfvm*sDvnf; iSm;vd k @r&eJ @// tJ h'DtcsdefrSm &Gmom;awG wa,muf/ ESpfa,mufavmufawmhvufES dyf"mwfrD;awGeJ @ vm=unf hygw,f// ypPnf;,lcsifvd k @yJvm;/ olwd k @bufu
vlvm;awmhrodbl;ayghav? vm=unf h+yD; jyefoGm;=uygw,f? wa,mufrSud k toHr=um;&awmhyJeJ @tJ'Dvd kjzpfaewJ htcsdefrSm usrwd k @u a&Smif&if;/ a&Smif&if;eJ @ tkyfpkvd kuf}uD; v,fuGif;awGxJud ka&mufoGm;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 191/208
191
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
ygw,f// (11)em&DavmufrSm tapmuajymovd k "gwfyH kawG¶d kuf/ vl emawGwif+yD;awmh 'DyJ,if;bufud kxGufoGm;ygw,f? 'DyJ,if;bufu aoewfoHawG[m tJ'Dtcsdefuwnf;u p+yD; =um;ae&ygw,f?reufav;em&D/ ig;em&Davmuftxd aoewfoHawG[m qufwd kufqd kovd k =um;ae&ygw,f&Sif h? reuf
vif;wJ htcsdefrSm usrwd k @um;awGud kxGufwm;ayr,f h usrwd k @&J @ '%f&mawGud k=unf h+yD;awmh b,fum;rS usrwd k @ud k &yf ray;ygbl;&Sif h? &yfray;awmh usrwd k @ud k q&mawmfwyg;u vmac:oGm;+yD;awmhtJ'D bkef;}uD; ausmif; rSmyJ usrwd k @wnf;cd k&ygw,f? tJ'Dbkef;}uD;ausmif;rSmyJ usrwd k @aq;uk?olwd k @bufutiftm;u qd kifu,fqd k&if tpD;ig;&mavmuf&S dr,f/ tJ h'Dbkef;}uD;wkawGu yg;pyfrSm t0ga&mifawGpnf;xm;+yD;awmh vufrSmutjzLóud;awGpnf;+yD;awmh olwd k @bufuvd kufvmwJ holawGqd k&ifcef @rSef;rdoavmufawmh (3000)ausmfavmuf&S dr,f/ vltkyf}uD;u awmfawmhud krsm;ygw,f? usrwd k @bufu rE Wav;wd kif;u (120)ygvmw,fqd kawmh 'Dbufuqd k&if usrwd k @tkyfpku cef @rSef; &cufw,f?bmvd k @vJqd kawmh ab;uaeóud óud+yD;awmhvk dufvmwJ h ausmif;om;av;awGwd k @/ bmwd k @qd k&if awmf
awmf ud k rsm;w,f?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? [kwfuJ h tJ h'DrSm tukefvH k; tenf;eJ @trsm; '%f&m&=uw,faygh?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? tukef'%f&m&=uw,f? tJ'DrSm usrwd k @eJ @twl ausmif;om;av;awGaumygvm+yD;awmh ausmif;
awGrSm wnf;=u/ cd k=uygw,f? olwd k @u um;awGud k ESpf&ufydwfxm;ygw,f? ydwfxm;ayr,f h olwk d @uusrwd k @tzG J @awGud k ywfwD;tazG;om;awGeJ @ rH k&Gmbufud ko,foGm;wJ hum;awGud kvnf; usrwd k @ vSrf;jrifae&ygw,f? tJ'DrSm 'DyJ,if;eJ @rk H&Gmud k tyd k @tóudvkyfwJ h olwd k @acsmum;awGuvG J&if b,fum;rS rxGuf&ygbl;? usrwd k @ um;awGud kawmh u&def;awGeJ @r˜+yD;awmh (e²r²c)xJrSm xm;w,fvd k @ od&ygw,f&Sif h?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? [kwfuJ h/ trwd k @'%f&mawGeJ @ b,fvd kvkyf+yD; bkef;}uD;ausmif;a&mufoGm;w,fqd kwm qufajymay;ygOD;?
ajz ? ?jz ? ?jz ? ?jz ? ?jz ? ? [kwfuJ h/ usrwd k @'%f&mawGeJ @ qd kifu,fawGypf+yD;ajy;vmwJ @ ausmif;om;vli,fav;awGud kyg q&mawmfuvmac:+yD;awmh tukefvH k;ud kaq;awGukoay;ygw,f? usrwd k @u t0wfwxnf ud k,fwckyJav/ zdeyfawmifrS rygwm q&mawmfbk&m;u vd kavao;r&S d vkyfay;+yD;awmh bkef;}uD;ausmif;rSmESpf&ufavmuf aecJ h&ygw,f? aemufw&uf um;xGufwJ htcg=uawmh q&mawmfbk&m;u usrwd k @ud krH k&Gmbufud k um;wifay;vd kufawmh usrwd k @ rH k&Gmud ka&mufcJ hygw,f&Sif? [kwfuJ h/ usrwd k @rSmygvmwJ h
uifr&mawG/ yd kufqH/ qG Jóud;/ em&D / t0wftpm;tdwf tukefvH k;ud k "g;jywd kufovd k ,lwmyg&Sif?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? 'gqd k trwd k @ a&S @yd kif;u um;awGuawmh jywfoGm;wmayghaemf?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? [kwfuJ h/ tefwDwd k @um;u a&S @u tjrefE_ef;armif;ajy;awmh tefwD hud kvnf; um;rSefwcsyfuG J+yD;awmh
tefwD h&J @ nmbufeJ @acgif;rSmvnf; '%f&m&w,fvd k @od&ygw,f? aemuf usrwd k @ vGwfvmwJ holawGeJ @awG @qH k wJ htcgusawmh olwd k @ud k ppfa=uma&;rSm orefwvif;ay:rSm wifyv†ifacGxd kifcd kif;+yD;awmhvlrqefpGmppfw,f vd k @od&ygw,f?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? trwd k @&J @ tckavmavmq,f tajctaeav;ud kvnf; ajymjyygtH k;?
ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? tckavmavmq,frSmawmh usrwd k @ a&Smifae&ygw,f? ta&;tcif;+yD;wJ haemufyd kif; usrwd k @tdrfawGud k ra,mifrvnfeJ @ apmif h=unf haew,fvd k @ tdrfu usrqDud k ta=umif;=um;ygw,f?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 192/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
192
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? aemufwcku trwd k @ 'DyJ,if;udpPxJrSm yg0ifwJ holawGtukefvH k; ckcsdefxda&Smifae&wkef;yJvm;?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? [kwfuJ h/ ckcsdefxda&Smifae&wkef;ygyJ? wa,mufrS tdrfrjyef&Jao;ygbl;?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? aemufqufwG JawGaum trwd k @ bmawG=um;ao;vJ//ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? tckavmavmq,fawmh usr bmrS r=um;rdao;ygbl;?
ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ?ar;? ? 'DudpPud k trwd k @aeeJ @ óudwif}uHpnfxm;w,fvd k @jrifvm;/ óudwif}uHpnfw,fqd k&iftrwd k @ bma=umif hajymEd kifvJ?
ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ?ajz ? ? óudwif}uHpnfwmaygh&Sif? 'g[m vkyf}uHr_}uD; wckyg? jynfolawGrSm bmvkyfyd kifcGif h&S dvd k @vJ? usrwd k @rE Wav;u pxGufuwnf;u a&yd k;pm;rSm olwd k @pDpOfae=uw,fqd kwm usrwd k @owif;=um;ygw,f?olwd k @ud k óudwif}uHpnfw,fvd k @ bma=umif hajymEd kifvJqd kvd k @&S d&if ¶d kufwJ htcgrSm olwd k @yg;pyfu ajymwmu tapmu usrajymzd k @usefoGm;w,f? “aumifrawG/ tar&dueftm;ud k;wJ h aumifrawG vdrfz,fvdrfz,feJ @ Ed kifiHawmfoDcsif;ud k yifeDav;0wfum/ 0wfumeJ @ qd k=uw,f”qd kawmh Ed kifiHawmf oDcsif;qd kwm[musrwd k @a&yd k;pm;uefrSm jzpfygw,f? olwd k @u usrwd k @rsufESmem;ud kvm+yD;awmh vuf!d ‡K;awGeJ @xd k;+yD;awmh ajymwm? a':pku usrwd k @ud k ajymxm;wmu olwd k @bmyJvkyfvkyf ud k,fu ud k,fxdvufa&mufjyefrvkyfzd k @ ajymxm;ygw,f? ajymxm;awmh usrwd k @u ud k,f hEd kifiHawmfoDcsif;yJ qd kwm? ¶d kufwJ holawG
usrwd k @ud kajymwmu Ed kifiHawmfoDcsif;awGqd kvd k @ “eifwd k @ cspfwmxufawmifrS igwd k @ucspfao;w,f/aumifrawG”tJ'Dvd kawGaygh&Sif? z¶k\0gpm =urf;wrf;wJ hpum;awGeJ @ usrwk d @ud k ajymygw,f? tJawmh'DvlawG[m a&yd k;pm;rSmuefrSm tuGufcsw,f// r&bl;/ bmvd k @vJqd kawmh tJ'DrSm q&mawmfrsm;a&m/qd kifu,fawG/ um;awGeJ @awmfawmfrsm;rsm;óud=uygw,f&Sif/ tiftm;rsm;wJ htay:rSm rlwnf+yD; olwd k @qufvd kufvm+yD;awmh// wcsdK@ usr =um;&wmayghaemf/ usrwd k @oGm;wJ h vrf;u r[kwfbJeJ @ wjcm;jzwfvrf;awGuae um;}uD;awGeJ @oGm;+yD; bk&m;pk/ usnf&GmbufrSm olwd k @aocsmud k tuGufcs pDpOfxm;wmygwJ h/ bmvd k @vJqd kawmh rH k&Gmòrd @rSm wu,f hemrnf}uD; q&mawmfbk&m;rsm;ud k yif hzdwf+yD;awmh olwd k @(e²r²c) xJu ‘xaemif;&dyf’rSm qGrf;au|;ygw,f/ au|;+yD;awmhq&mawmfrsm;ud k usrwd k @jzpfysufwJ h*dwfaygufem;rSm bmrS r[kwfyJeJ @ um;wef;}uD;awGeJ @ olwd k @u xm;ygw,fwJ h? usrwd k @ ud k;uG,fwJ hq&mawmfrsm;u jyefajymjywmayghav? tJ'DrSm xm;+yD;awmh wnvH k;wJ h/ rsufpdatmufwifjzpf+yD;awmhreufusrS jyefyd k @w,fwJ h? olwd k @oabmu 'Dq&mawmfawGvnf; 'Dtjzpftysufud k odygw,fqd kwJ hvkyf}uHZwfrsdK; vkyfzd k @eJ @wlygw,f&Sif/ olwd k @ tuGufcs+yD;awmhvkyfaqmifoGm;wmyg// tck'DrSm jzpfysufaewmuawmh uav;0 bufoGm;wJ harmfawmfawGud k olwd k @ ppfaq;a&;awGupufawGeJ @awmif ppfw,fvd k @ =um;ygw,f? [d k&Gm 'D&Gm oGm;wmawmifrS rSwfyH kwifawG bmawGeJ @ 'Dbufe,fwa=umrSmawmhtawmfud k tvkyf¶_yf ae=uw,fvd k @ owif;awG=um;ygw,f?usrtaeeJ @aemufqH k;ajymcsifwmuawmh 'DudpPud k tr_rSefay:aygufa&;twGuf 0d kif;0ef;aqmif&Gufay;=uygvd k @ awmif;qd kvd kufygw,f?
ÐÐÐÐ
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 193/208
193
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
urm&Gwfòrd Œe,f trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzGJŒcsKyf tzGJŒ0if ud kpd k;oef;ESihf awGŒqH kar;jref;csuf
trnf - ud kpd k;oef;(c)atmifpd k;oef;arG;ouU&mZf - 1971 ckESpf/ Zefe0g&Dv (1)&ufrdbtrnf - OD;pdefeuf/ a':at;&Dynmt&nftcsif; - qXrwef;tvkyftud kif - v,f,mpd kufysdK;a&;
ae&yfvdyfpm - ausmufwGif;aus;&Gm/ wGif;rtkyfpk/ jrdKifjrdK@e,f/ rauG;wd kif;/Ed kifiHom;rSwfyH kwiftrSwf - 8§rreEd kif 032913
usaemfarmifpd k;oef;(c)atmifpd k;oef; (Ed kifiHom;pDppfa&;u'f 8§rreEd kif 032913 ud kifaqmifol)onf zcifjzpfol OD;pdefeufESif h rdcifjzpfol a':at;&Dwd k @rS 1971 ckESpf/ Zefe0g&Dv(1)&ufae@wGifarG;zGm;cJ hygonf? tajccHynm
tv,fwef;txdoif,ljyD;aemuf v,f,mpd kufysdK;a&;vkyfief;jzif h toufarG;0rf;ausmif;jyKum ausmufwGif;aus;&Gm/ wGif;rtkyfpk/ jrdKifjrdK@e,f/ rauG;wd kif;wGifaexd kifch Jonf? 1995wGif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfod k @ 0ifa&mufjyD;/ urm&GwfjrdK@e,f/ qufoG,fa&;vli,fwm0efcH(1)tjzpf tzG J @csKyfwGifwm0ef,lvkyfud kifcJ honf? 1998ckESpf/ =o*kwfv(24)&ufae@wGifzrf;qD;cH&jyD; atmufwd kbmv(20)&ufae@wGif tif;pdefaxmiftwGif;&S d txl;w&m;&H k;trSwf(1)rS ta&;ay:pDrHr_tufOya'yk'fr(5) (n)jzif h axmif(7)ESpfjypf'%fcsrSwfjcif;cHcJ h&onf? 2000jynf hESpf/ Zefe0g&Dv(22)&ufae@wGif rdrdtygt0if (47)OD;ud k tif;pdefaxmifrS om,m0wDaxmifod k @ajymif;a&$ @cJ hygonf? 2002 ckESpf/ pufwifbm(23)&ufae@wGif om,m0wDaxmifrSac:aqmifvmjyD; (25)&ufae@wGif&Gmod k @jyefvnfvd kufyd k @ygonf? jypfr_qd kif&musif hxH k;Oya'yk'fr 401(1)t& cH0efcsufjzif hjyefvnfvGwfay;cJ honf? axmifr
SvGwfajrmufvmjyD;aemuf trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf/ urm&GwfjrdK@e,fwGifqufvufwm0efxrf;aqmifcJ honf?
rdrdonf urm&GwfjrdK@e,f/ qufoG,fa&;vli,fwm0efcHtjzpf wm0efxrf;aqmifpOfumvtwGif; etzESif ha':atmifqef;pk=unfxdyfwd kuf&ifqd kif=uHKawG @&onf htjzpftysufrsm;rSm ² ² ²
1? 1996ckESpfEd k0ifbm(3)&ufae@ *GwWvpfvrf;qH kwGif a':atmifqef;pk=unf.rdef @cGef;ud k em;axmif&efvma&mufcJ honf h jynfolvlxktm; óudwif=uHpnf&d kufESufr_//
2? 1996 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(9)&ufae@ vlxktm;rdef @cGef;ajym&efxGufcGmvmonf h a':atmifqef;pk=unf/OD;wifOD;ESif hOD;=unfarmifwd k @.,mOfrsm;tm; óudwif=uHpOfqD;óudwk dufcd kufr_?
3? 199& ckESpf/ atmufwd kbmv(28)&ufae@ &efukefwd kif;r&ef;ukef;òrd @@e,f/ vli,fvkyfief;tzG J @ zG J @pnf;a&;tm;aESmif h,Sufr_?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 194/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
194
4? 1998 ckESpf/ ZGefv(24)&ufae@pmzwf0d k fif;/5? {&m0wDwd kif;/ yxrc&D;pOf/ 1998 ckESpf/ Zlvd kifv(21)&ufae@rS(29 )txd?6? {&m0wDwd kif;/ 'kwd,c&D;pO/f =o*kwfv(12)&ufrS(24)&ufae@txd/
a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k etzu (1996) ckESpfuwnf;u vkyf}uHzd k @=udK;pm;cJ honf hudpPESif h ywfoufI ² ²²
etz. &xm;yd k @aqmifa&;0ef=uD;/ =uH @zG @Htoif;twGif;a&;r_;OD;0if;pdefu tif;awmfòrd @e,f/ v,fjyifaus;&Gm/rlvwef;ausmif;twGif;rSmjyKvkyfwJ h &GmvH k;u|wf=uH @zG H @toif;0iftqd kjyKv$may;tyfyG Jtcrf;tem;rSm “a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kokwfoif&Sif;vif;ypfoif hw,fqd kwmudk em;vnf&J @vm;/ okwfoif&Sif;vif;ypfoifhw,fqdkwmowfypf&r,fvd k @ajymwm/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kowfoif hovm;/ owfoif hovm;”[k 0ef=uD;OD;0if;pdefuwufa&mufvmonf h=uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;tm; t}udrf}udrftcgcg ar;ch Jygonf? wufa&mufvmwJ h =uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;xJu rnfolur# jyefrajzonf htwGuf &xm;yd k @aqmifa&;0ef}uD;OD;0if;pdefud k,fwd kifu “a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k owfypfoif hw,f”[k xd ktcrf;tem;rSmajymonf hrdef @cGef;xJwGif xnf hoGif;ajymqd kcJ hygonf?
xd kod k @ajymqd kjyD;aemuf òrd @e,faygif;pH k}uH hzG @Hrsm;ud k vufa&G;pifa&G;cs,fap+yD;/ a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h Ed kifiHa&;tzG J @tpnf;rsm;ud k wd kufcd kufES drfeif;&ef oifwef;rsm;ay;cJ hygonf? 1996 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(1)&ufae@rS pwifjyD;jynfxJa&;Xme¶H k;csKyfESif h rsufapmif;xd k;wGif&S donf h/ or0g,rukefpnfjyyG Jcef;r aemufzuf&S dwk dufopf}uD;xJwGif}uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k txl;oifwef;rsm;ay;ygonf? um;wpD;xGufvmvsif rnfod k @¶d kuf&rnfqd konfrsm;utpoif=um;ay;xm;onf[kod&ygonf// vufa&G;piftjzpfa&G;cs,fac:,l xm;onf h}uH hzG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ud k w&ufv#ifxrif;au|;+yD;/ wOD;vsifusyf(200)pDay;xm;onf[kvnf; od&S d&ygonf? 1996 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(3)&ufae@wGif
a':atmifqef;pk=unf. tywfpOfa[majymyG Jtm; vma&mufem;axmif=urnf hjynfolvlxkud k etzu *GwWvpfvrf;qHkY vrf;ydwfjyD;[ef @wm;xm;onf htwGuf xd kae&mwGifvlrsm;pka0;ae=u&ygonf? ajrmufOuUvmESifhurB mat; bk&m;zufrSvm=uolrsm;vnf; qD'd k;em;[k dw,fteD;&S drD;yd GKif hY ydwfqd k @[ef @wm;xm;jcif;ud k cH&onf htwGuf xd kae&mwGifompka0;ae=u&onf? awmifOuUvm/ oCFef;u|ef;ESif hwmarGzufrSvmolrsm;vnf; [mrpfwpfrD;yG dKif hY ydwfrdae=uygonf?
a':atmifqef;pk=unf.tywfpOfa[majymyG Jod k @ vmolrsm;uk d txl;oifwef;ay;xm;olrsm;u *GwWvpfrSpwif&d kufESuf=uygonf? ¶d kufyHk¶d kufenf; rnfr#txdpepfwus&Sdonfudkajym&vsif (3)&ufae@naeydkif;wGif
um;ay:rS }uH hzG H @rsm;qif;vm+yD; a&S @qH k;rSaeI (5)a,mufwwef;ESif h (15)wef;cef @wef;pD+yD; jynfolvlxktwGif;od k @pepfwus0ifa&mvd kuf=uonfud k awG @&ygonf? a[majymyG Jvmolrsm;u pepfwusaeaomfvnf; aemufqH k;wGifa':atmifqef;pk=unfrvma&mufEd kifap&ef t0ifvrf;rsm;ud kydwfqd k @xm;vd kufonf htwGuf jynfolvlxk}uD;rSmjyefIvnf; r& b,frSvnf; oGm;r&awmhyg// xk dok d @jzpfaepOf rdrdrSm qD'd k;em;[k dw,fa&S @wGif vlxkESif htwl &S daecJ hygonf?
usaemfwd k @vnf; vlpkruG Jap&ef pka0;+yD;ae=u&on/f/ nae(6)em&D vrf;rD;rsm;vmonh ftcsdefwGif *GwWvpfbuf&S dvltkyfESif h oGm;a&mufyl;aygif;rSjzpfrnf[kqH k;jzwfjyD; qD'd k;em;[d kw,fESif h &efuif;aps;vrf;xdyfrSaeI pufr_(1)vrf;r}uD;twd kif; pkaygif;jyD;vrf;av#mufoGm;=uygonf? xd kod k @vrf;avsmufoGm;onf h htcsdefwGif =uH hzG H @rsm;u
vnf; vrf;av#mufaeonf hvlrsm;=um;rSa&m+yD; vd kufygvm=uonfud kjrifawG @&ygonf? vH kxdef;rsm;uvnf;vrf;ydwfxm;onf hae&mrSpI vltkyf}uD;aemufod k @vd kufvmjyD; enf;trsdK;rsdK;jzif h 'kuQay;onfuk d jrifawG @ae&
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 195/208
195
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
ygonf?
xd kod k @vrf;av#mufoGm;aepOfrSmyif vltkyfwGif;Y&S daeaom=uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;u ‘ajy;-ajy;’[k atmfvd kufyg
onf? vlawGuvnf; &kwfw&uf bma=umif hajy;cd kif;rSef;rodjzpfae+yD;/ patmf+yD;ajy;olrsm;ud k =unf hvd kufonf htcg vG,ftdwfrsm;/ ykqd k;pvG,fod kif;rsm;ESif h }uH hzG H @rsm;jzpfaeonfuk dawG @&ygonf? xd kolrsm;uyif‘ajy;-ajy;’[katmf+yD; vlxkud kaoG;vSef @vd kufonf htwGuf vltkyf}uD;uxGufajy;=uygonf? xd kod k @xGufajy;olrsm;ud k k vH kxdef;rsm;u vd kuf¶d kufygonf? t&d kufcH&olrsm;u vufjzif hum=uonf/ xd kod k @ vufjzif humolrsm;ud k ,cifuyifvltkyf=um;wGif&S daeonf h}uH hzG H @rsm;u ‚if ;wd k @.vG,ftdwfrsm;/ ykqd k;pvG,fod kif;rsm;xJrS toif h,laqmifvmonf hwkwfrsm;/ av;cGrsm;jzif h jynfolvlxkud kxyfrH¶d kufESuf=uygonf? vlxku }uH hzG @HESif hvH kxdef;rsm; ESpfzuf!SyfI¶d kufESufonfud kcH=u&ygonf? pepfwusoifwef;ay;xm;onf htwGuf jynfolvlxkrSmyH kpHwus ¶d kufESufjcif;ud k cHcJ h&ygonf? vlxk}uD; upOf huvsm;jzpfoGm;onf htcsdefwGif acgif;uG JoGm;olrsm;ESif h/ tcsdK@vJvH kxdef;rsm;.
zrf;qD;jcif;ud k cH=u&ygonf?
‚if;wd k @uenf;rsdK;pH koH k;I a':atmifqef;pk=unf.a[majymyG Jud k xd kod k @ydwfyifcJ haomfvnf; Ed k0ifbm(9)&ufae@paeae@a&mufonf htcg vlxkua':pkrdef @cGef;ud kem;axmifzd k @ vm=uygonf? vlxkud k Ed Srfeif;Ir&onf htcga':atmifqef;pk=unftygt0if trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfacgif;aqmifrsm;tm; vkyf}uHowfjzwf&eftwGufjyifqifr_rsm;vkyfvmonfud k awG @&ygonf? (9)&ufae@naeyd kif;wGif wuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;r}uD;ud k tif;vsm;vrf; rD;yd GKif hrSpI wuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;opf *GwWvpfvrf;qH krD;yd GKif hxd/ wuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;wav#mufvH k;ud kydwfxm;vd kufygonf? urB mat;vrf;r}uD;ud kvnf; pufr_(1)vrf;xdyf pD'd k;em;a[mfw,faxmif hrS pwifI [mrpfwpftxd urB mat;bk&m;vrf;r}uD;ud k ydwfxm;vd kufygonf? xd kod k @ydwfxm;onf hvrf;xJod k @ a[majymyG Jvmaom jynfolvlxkud k0ifcGif hray;bJ ‚if;wd k @.}uH hzG @Hrsm;ud k &yfuGuftwGif;aexd kifolrsm;uJ hod k @ óudwifae&mcsxm;ygonf? pD'd k;em;axmif hwGif ajrmufOuUvmòrd @e,frS}uH hzG @Hrsm;ud k ae&mcsxm;onfud k usaemfwd k @awG @cJ h&ygonf?xd kod k @csxm;cH&olrsm;u wcsdK@rSm jcif;cwfae/ wcsdK@rSm usm;xd k;ae=uygonf? abmvH k;uefae=uolrsm;vJ&S dygonf?aemuf ykqd k; pvG,fod kif;ESif hvlrsm;u yvufazmif;rsm;ay:wGifukefxrf;orm;yk HpH&kyfzsuf+yD; wef;pDIxd kifae=uygonf? ‚if;wd k @ud k trsm;u &yfuGufol&yfuGufom;rsm;[kxifap&ef pepfwusjyifqifjyD;ae&mcsay;xm;ygonf?
naeyd kif;wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif hOD;wifOD;wd k @aetdrfrSxGufvmygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;.a&S @wGif vH kòcHa&;vli,ftzG J @. um;tjyma&mif yg&S dygonf? ‚if;aemufwGifa':atmifqef;pk=unf.um; jzpfyg
onf? xd kum;.aemufrS OD;wifOD;um;/ xd kum;rsm;.aemufwGif axmufvSrf;a&;um; ygvmygonf? OD;=unfarmif.tdrfud k 0ifac:ygonf? jyeftxGufwGif vrf;uusOf;aoma=umif h um;jyefvSnfh&efcufonfhtwGuf‚if;wd k @.axmufvSrf;a&;um;rSm a&S @qH k;ujzpfoGm;ygonf? jyefxGufvmaomtcg urB mat;bk&m;vrf;r}uD;ESif h OD;cspfarmifvrf;xdyf&S d eH&Hausmif;[kac:aom A[ef;t²x²u(2)a&S @ yvufazmif;ay:rS toif hxd kifapmif haeolrsm;u ‚if;wd k @ykqd k;pvG,fod kif;rsm;xJwGif 0SufI,laqmifvmonf h wkwfrsm;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @. um;wef;ud k pwif0d kif;¶d kuf=uygonf? ‚if;wd k @ p¶d kuf=uonf htcsdefrSmyif jcif;cwfae/ usm;xd k;ae/ abmvH k;uefae=uonf h }uH hzG H @rsm;uvnf; ‘¶d kufa[h-¶d kufa[h’[k nmoHawGay;+yD; a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @um;rsm;&S d&mod k @atmfajy;vm+yD; wqufwnf;rSmyif av;cGrsm;ESif h 0d kif;xk=u+yD; óuH&mcJrsm;ESif hvnf;xk=uygonf? a':pk.um;
ywfywfvnfwGif pufbD;ukef;&mrsm;ESif h um;rSefrsm;vnf; tm;vk H;uG Jukefygonf? rSefrsm;u pwpfum uyfxm;aoma=umif h aºuGusroGm;bJ tukefa=uukefygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 196/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
196
OD;wifOD;um;vnf; rSefawGuG J+yD; OD;wifOD;yg;rSm um;rSefuG Jp xdoGm;ygonf? OD;=unfarmifum;qd kvsif rSefuG J+yD;um;xJud k vS HESif hvSrf;xd k;ygonf/ OD;=unfarmifu xd kifcH krS D+yD; aemufud kyufvufvSefI xd kifcsvd kufygonf? xd k @a=umif h OD;=unfarmif.rsufESmud k vS HESif h rxd k;rdjcif;jzpfygonf? xd kr#omru ‚if;wd k @ cG Jvd kufonf hrSefuG Jrsm; acgif;
xJ0ifaeI cgvd kufonf htcg rSefuG Jrsm;&S+yD; OD;=unfarmifrSm uwH k;wH k;vd kuf&ygonf? OD;=unfarmifrSmvnf;cufcufcJcJ wdrf;a&Smif&jcif;jzpfonf? xd ktjzpftysufrsm;ud k=unf hjcif;jzif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h tjcm;aomacgif;aqmifrsm;tm; ‚if;wdk@u taoowfjcif;[kajymEdkifygonf? xd kpOfua':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;udkarmif;onf h ud karmf}uD;.u|rf;usifr_a=umif h a':pk.touf raoqk H;cJ h&jcif;jzpfygonf// ‚if;wd k @u }uH hzG H @rsm;tm;rd kufrd kuf¶d kif;¶d kif;oifwef;rsm;ud k pepfwusoifay;+yD; t¶d kufcd kif;jcif;jzpfonf? ,ckajymaomta=umif;t&mrsm;rSm1996 ckESpf/ Ed k0ifbmv(9)&ufae@wGif a':atmifqef;pk=unftygt0if OD;wifOD;ESif hOD;=unfarmifwd k @tm; ‚if;wd k @uvkyf}uHowfjzwf&ef vkyfaqmifvd kufjcif;jzpfonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfESif h OD;wifOD;wd k @tm; yxrqH k;t}udrfvkyf}uHr_[k ajymEk difygonf? xd kpOfuvnf; tvGefuHaumif;Iom usaemfwk d @.acgif;aqmifrsm;toufraoqk H;bJ vlxkxHod k @ jyefa&mufvmEd kifcJ hjcif;jzpfygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unf/ OD;wifOD;ESif h OD;=unfarmifwd k @u urB mat;bk&m;vrf; eH&Hausmif;zufrSazmufxGufvm+yD; a&$*H kwd kifrD;yd GKif hod k @a&mufvmum xd krSwqif h wmarGav;rD;yd GKif h/xd krSwqif h *GwWvpfxd jzwfxGufvmEd kifcJ h=uonf? *GwWvpfa&mufaomtcgwGifrS jynfolvlxkud krdef @cGef;ajym+yD;pufr_(1)vrf;rbufrSaeI urB mat;bk&m;vrf;twd kif; auG @ywf+yD;jyefaoma=umif h at;at;aq;aq;ESif h tdrfjyefa&mufoGm;cJ hjcif;jzpfonf?
1997 ckESpf/ atmufwk dbmv(28)&ufae@wGif r&rf;uk kef;òrd @e,f tJeft,fvf'D vli,fvkyfief;zG J @pnf;a&;twGufvmaom a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k }uH hzG @Hrsm;/ vH kxdef;rsm;u urB mat;bk&m;vrf;ESif h *E<rmvrf;xdyfrSydwfqd k @wm;qD;+yD; trsdK;rsdK;aESmif h,Sufygonf? OD;=unfarmifESif htwl vl(50)cef @qd kvsif um;jzif hwifoGm;+yD; a&$waumocsõ Kif;od k @ tyd k @cHcJ h&onf? usaemfwd k @vl(70)eD;yg;qd kvsifvnf; arSmfbDtxd tyd k @cHvd kuf&onf? usef
tJeft,fvf'D tzG J @0ifrsm;ud kvnf; &efukefòrd @jyif&S d ae&mtoD;oD;o@d k um;rsm;jzif hwifac:oGm;+yD; ‚if;wd k @xm;vd konf hae&mwGifcsxm;cJ hygonf? vGwfawmfud k,fpm;vS,frsm;jzpfaom a':pef;pef;/ a'gufwmoef;ndrf;/ a':ar0if;jrif hESif h vli,fvkyfief;tzG J @ud kOD;aqmifcJ h=uonf h ud kcifarmifjrif h (uav;axmifwGifaoqH k;)/ r0if;0if;aX;(c)ryd k/omauwòrd @e,fOuUXOD;pd k;jrif h/ r&rf;ukef;òrd @e,f trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf&H k;(tdrf&S Sifjzpfol OD;Om%faomif;)tygt0if (*)OD; zrf;qD;cHcJ h&ygonf?
aemufw}udrf a':atmifqef;pk=unfud kaoapEd kifonftxd vkyf}uHonfrSm 1998 ckESpf/ ZGefv (24)&ufae@wGifjzpfygonf? usaemfwd k @ trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. vli,fpmzwf0d kif;wGif (a': )a&$ularESif; bmomjyefonf h tar&dueftpd k;&pmtkyfud kaqG;aEG;&eftwGuf pmzwf0d kif;ud kvm=uonf h aqG;aEG;yG Jvmolrsm;ud k e²0²w
axmufvSrf;a&;rsm;u ‘jynf h0’pm;aomufqd kifa&S @ *dwfrSae+yD; pmzwf0d kif; r&S douJ hod k @vnf;aumif;/ pm&if;ra&mufouJ hod k @vnf;aumif; enf;rsdK;pk HESif h trsdK;rsdK;ajymI vrf;ydwfxm;ygonf?pmzwf0d kif;od k @vmrnf holrsm;.pm&if;ud k usaemfwd k @uk d,fwd kif OD;wifOD;xHay;xm;+yD;jzpfonf? OD;wifOD;rSwqif h
a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; ay;onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfu ‚if;wd k @axmufvSrf;a&;rsm;ud k xd kpm&if;rsm;tm;ay;xm;+yD;jzpfonf? od k @aomf ‚if;wd k @u xd kpm&if; ray;oa,mif OD;wifOD;uyif vdrfoa,mifajym+yD; pmzwf0d kif;ud kvmonf h NLD vli,frsm;ud k vk H;0 0ifcGif hray;bJydwfxm;ygonf? xd kuJ hod k @ydwfxm;onf htwGuf usaemfwd k @u&k H;csKyf&S d OD;wifOD;ud koGm;ac:+yD; rdrdwd k @vli,frsm;ud k e0wu a':pkjcHxJod k @ 0ifcGif hray;yJydwfxm;a=umif;&Sif;jyygonf?OD;wifOD;a&mufvm+yD;aemuf a':pkud k oGm;ta=umif;=um;vd kufonf htwGuf a':pkESif h OD;wifOD;wd k @ um;jzif h xGufvm+yD; apmif haeaomvli,frsm;ud k “txJ0if—pmzwf0d kif;&S dw,f”[k a':pkuajymygonf?
rdrdwd k @acgif;aqmifu 0if [kajymonf htwGuf rdrdwd k @u txJod k @0if=uygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfum;uusaemfwd k @.aemufrSuyfygvm+yD; um;xJwGifOD;wifOD;vnf;ygvmygonf? xd ktcsdefrSmyif wm0efusaeonf h
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 197/208
197
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
axmufvSrf;a&; Ad kvfrª;pnfolu ‘ydwf-ydwftm;vk H;ydwf wa,mufrS t0ifrcHeJ @’[kajym+yD; vrf;ud k qD;ydwfvd kufygonf? wuUod kvf&dyfomvrf;wavsmufwGif axmufvSrf;a&;/ ppfwyfESif h vk Hxd def; ponf hok H;zG J @aygif;+yD;csxm;ygonf? =uH hzG @HtzG J @0ifrsm;ud kvnf; xd kvrf;wav#muf tvSnf huswm0efcsxm;onfud kawG @&ygonf? rdrd
wk d @u ‘usaemfwd k @acgif;aqmifu 0ifcd kif;xm;+yD;+yD a':atmifqef;pk=unf tdrfud k oGm;rSmjzpfw,f’[k ajymonf htcg ‘b,ftdrfoGm; oGm;--tJ acgif;aqmifaum/ bmaum rvd kcsifbl; tukefydwf’[kqd k+yD; ‚if;u trdef @ay;ygonf? usaemfwk d @uvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unf 0ifcd kif;xm;jcif;jzpfonf htwGuf usaemftygt0if A[ef;uud krkef;Ed kif/ Ad kvfwaxmifu ud katmifxl;/ {&m0wDwd kif;u ud kjynf hpk H/ &efuif;u ud kat;xGef;/ usaemfwk d @ (5)a,mufu a&S @qk H;uae wd k;onf htcg usaemfwd k @aemufrS rdef;cav;rsm;ESif hwcsKd @a,musmf;av;rsm; vk dufwd k;vm=uygonf?ud kwifat;wd k @ ud krsKd;rif;Ed kifwk d @qd kv#if a':atmifqef;pk=unf.um;ud k 0d kif;um+yD;awmh vk dufvm=uygonf? um;.aemufrS (100)cef @&S donf h tzG J @ 0ifrsm;vd kufygvmygonf?
vl(100)cef @u wd k;onf hvlu wd k;/ a':pkum;ud kumonf hvlu um/ um;aemufrSvd kufonf hvl vd kufESif h0ifvm=uonfrSm rnfonf hae&mtxd a&mufoGm;onfqd kygvsif ,d k;',m; ppfaumifppf0ef.aetdrfud kausmf+yD;a':pktdrfacgif;&if;Y&S daom rlvwef;ausmif;a&S @txdyif rdrdwd k @vli,f(5)a,muf a&muf&S doGm;ygonf? usaemfwd k @ESif h aemufuvltkyfrSm (10)aycef @uGmoGm;ygonf? usaemfwd k @u pmoifausmif;a&S @u ref;usnf;yiftxda&mufoGm;+yD; aemufuvd kufvmonf hvltkyfu ,d k;',m;aumifppf0ef&k H;ESif h pmoifausmif;t=um;u jcHpnf;&k d;cef @wGif a&mufaeonf?
xd ktcsdefrSmyif Ad kvfrSL;pnfolu ‘&d kuf-&d kuf-tukefvk H;ud k&k duf-wa,mufrSrcsefeJ @’[k trdef @ay;vd kufonfud kusaemf=um;&ygonf? ppfom;rsm;/ axmufvSrf;a&;rsm;ESif h vH kxdef;rsm; aygif;(70)cef @u usaemfwk d @(5)a,mufuk dyxrOD;qk H; pwif&k dufESufygonf? a':pku um;ay:rSqif;ajy;vm+yD; “uav;awGuk d r&k dufeJ @ usruk d &k duf”[kqk d+yD;&k dufESufaeonf hae&muk d 0ifvmygonf? usaemfwk d @uvnf; a':pkud k ‘rvmeJ @’[k vSrf;atmf=uygonf? usaemf
wk d @uk d,fwk difrSmvnf; t&k dufcHae&onf htwGuf a':pk=um;Ed kifap&efóud;pm;+yD; vSrf;atmf=uaomfvnf; a':pkuk d,fwk difu twif;ajy;vm+yD;/ rdrdwd k @ud k “uav;awG jyefrvkyfeJ @/ t&k dufcH t&k dufcH”[kajym+yD; olr. t=urf;rzufa&;vrf;pOftwd kif; vd kufemapygonf? a':pku “vk H;0 t&k dufcH/ olwk d @ &k dufcsif&d kufyavhap”[k ajymaepOfrSmyif a':pk.vk H+cKHa&;uk dwm0ef,lxm;onf h Ak dvf}uD;aZmfxl;atmifu ‘trygw,f/ trygw,f’[k vSrf;atmfaeygonf? od k @aomf Ak dvfrS l;pnfol qk dolrSm vk H;0 ajymIr&yg/ ‚if;u Ad kvf}uD;aZmfxl;atmifxuf &mxl;yk d}uD;oljzpf&m‚if;u‘traom bmaom em;rvnfbl;/ wa,mufrS rcsefeJ @/ tukef&k duf’[kqk d+yD;&d kufck dif;ygonf? ,leDazmif;tjynhf0wfqifxm;olrsm;u eHywfwkwfawG/ ausmif;+cHpnf;&k d;rsm;ud kum&Hxm;onf h ESpfwvufrwkwfawG/aemuf+yD; ukud UKyifay:uusKd;usaeonf h ukuU dKom;tajcmufawG pojzif h óuH&mwkwfawGESif h aumuf&k duf=u
onf htjyif ‚if;wk d @aqmif;xm;onf hoHcarmufawGESif hyg &d kufESufygonf? t&yf fom;rsm;uJ hod k @[efaqmifxm;olrsm;uvnf; óuH&mwkwfawGud kqJ Gvm+yD; &k dufESuf=uygonf? &yfuGufxJ&efjzpfonf htcg vlawGuk daoatmif&k dufouJ hod k @ 0&kef;okef;um;&k dufjcif;jzpf+yD;/ uk dat;xGef;qk dv#if acgif;uJ GoGm;ygonf? rat;rm qk dvsifvnf; OD;acgif;.aemufyd kif;uk d t&k dufcH&onf htwGuf rl;arh+yD;vJusoGm;ygonf? ajrmufOuUvmòrd @e,frS a'gufwmoef;0if;(jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f)qk dv#if 0wfxm;onf hyifeDtusôud k qJ G+zJ+yD; vrf;ray:uk dypfvS JcHvk duf&onf htwGuf uwW&mvrf;ay:wGif yk HvsufvJusoGm;ygonf?
xd kod k @ t&d kufcHae&oonf htcsdefwGif OD;wifOD;u a':pktm;&k dufonf hwkwfrsm;uk d xD;t}uD;}uD;ESif h vd kufIumay;ygonf? OD;wifOD;rSm ol @uk d,fol rumuG,fbJ a':pkud komvd kufIumuG,fay;ygonf// OD;wifOD;rSmwyfrawmft&m&dSa[mif;}uD;jzpfonf htavsmuf vkH+cKHa&;t&tumtuG,fay;onf htcg rdrdwkd @vli,frsm;
xufyifoGufvufI touft&G,fESif hrr# vsifjrefjzwfvwf+yD; usGrf;usifpGmjzif ha':pkuk d twif;vk duf tumtuG,fay;ygonf? xd k @a=umif h xD;vnf; pkwfjywfoGm;+yD; OD;wifOD;.wud k,fvk H;ud kvnf; t&k dufcH&ygawmhonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 198/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
198
xd kpOfu t&d kufcH&onf htwGuf '%f&mawGusefcJ hygonf? usaemfqk dv#if vuf uyfoGm;ygonf? nmbufvufrSm ,cktcsdefxd v_yf&Sm;Iraumif;ao;yg? usaemfwk d @uk d&k dufonf hwkwfrsm;/ a':pkuk d&k dufonf h wkwfrsm; ponf htm;vk H;ud k vufjzif hom um=uonf htwGuf vufud k k t"du xdcd kufrd=uygonf?
uk dat;xGef;uk d&k dufonf h wkwfusKd;+yD;/ ajrmufwufoGm;&mu a':pk ykck H;ay:uk djyefusonf htwGuf a':pk.b,fbufykck H;aygufoGm;ygonf? OD;wifOD;uvnf; ol.tawG @t}uKHt&“aumifrav;awG rif;wk d @ a':pkuk d zufxm;/ zufxm;”[katmf[pfowday;ygonf? xd ktcg rdef;uav;rsm;ua':pkuk d vSrf;zufvk duf=uygonf// rdrdwk d @rSm'%f&mawG&ae=uonf htwGuf a':pkud k rumuG,fEk difawmhyg// xd kod k @0k dif;zuf=u&mwGif a':pku t&yfjrif honf htwGufrdef;uav;rsm;u olrukdvS J+yD; 0d kif;zufxm;onfud k rdrdwdk @a,muFsm;av;rsm;u vufcsif;csdwfumausmrd k;+yD; olwk d @tm;vk H;uk d aemufwxyf um&Hxm;vk dufygonf? rdrdwk d @ausmrsm;qk dv#if ylavmifae+yD; rnfod k @jzpfrSef;uk d vk H;0rodawmhyg? (2)em&D(15)rdepf (a':pk)+cHxJod k @wk d;0ifuwnf;upI pdwf&d Svuf&d S&k dufaeonfrSm(10)rdepfausmfausmfce@f &k dufaeygonf? xd ktcsdefrSmyif a':pktygt0if usaemfwk d @a&S @qk H;uwk d;olrsm;/ a':pkum;uk d 0k dif;ay;xm;olrsm;ESif h um;a&S @uvlrsm;tm;vk H;aygif; ta,muf(30)cef @xd kt&k dufcH&onf hae&mrSmyif t0k dif;cHvk duf&onf?
um;aemufuvlrsm;uk dvnf; wjcm;axmufvSrf;a&;awG/ vk Hxdef;awGu0d kif;&k duf+yD; ukuU dKif;rD;yG dKih fbufod k @&d kufESufarmif;xkwfvk dufygonf? xd kod k @ (10)rdepfausmfcef @&k duf+yD;aemuf ‚if;wk d @u &yfrdef @ay;vk dufygonf? xd k @aemuf usaemfwk d @uk d vk Hxdef;rsm;u0k dif;xm;ygonf? xd kvk Hxdef;rsm;tjyif ppfwyfuyg0k dif;xm;ygonf? xd kppfwyf.aemufrS oHql;óud;rsm;jzif h0k dif;xm;onf? xd kod k @txyfxyf0k dif;xm;+yD; xd kvrf;xJod k @ 40§41 bwfpfum;}uD;rsm;(7)pD;cef @armif;0ifvm+yD; ukud UKif;rD;yG dKih frSvSrf;=unh fvsif usaemfwk d @uk d rjrifEd kifap&ef xd kum;}uD;rsm;ud k ab;csif;,SOf+yD; um;vrf;r}uD;uk dumI ydwfxm;vk dufonf? xd kae@u wae@vk H;rd k;&Gmae+yD; a':pkykck H;rSmvnf; aoG;pk d @oGm;onf? uwW&mvrf;ay:wGif ajcz0g;jrKyfonftxd rd k;a&pD;aeygonf? xd kod k @ um;}uD;rsm;ud kpD+yD;csdefwGif
xd kbwfpfum;rsm;.aemufod k @ vk Hxdef;awGud kyk d @vk duf+yD;/ xd kvk Hxdef;rsm;.aemufwGif oHql;}udK;wm;I usaemfwd k @ud k ydwfxm;vd kufygonf? xd kod k @ydwf&mwGif a':pktdrfESif h (t-r-u)ausmif;a&S @wGifoHql;}udK;wv$m/ (t-r-u)ausmif;ESif h ,k d;',m;aumifppf0ef&k H;=um;wGif oHql;}udK;wv$m/ xd kod k @oHql;}udK;ESpfv$mwm;+yD; usaemfwk d @uk dydwfxm;vd kufjcif;jzpfonf?
xd kod k @ydwfxm;+yD; Ak dvfrSL;ol&(c)aepd k;u‘tr jyefcsifjyefyg// uav;awGuk d tdrfjyefvGwfyg/ 0ifcGih f rjyKygeJ @’[k a':pkud k vmajymygonf// xd ktcg a':pku“uk dol&/ &Sif usrta=umif;odw,faemf/ tm;vk H; 0ifvk d @&&if 0ifr,f/ tm;vk H;0ifvk d @r&&if r0ifbl;”[k jywfjywfom;om;jyefajymvd kufygonf// xd ktcg ‚if;wk d @ jyefoGm;+yD; &k H;csKyfay: wGif aqG;aEG;ae=uygonf// rdrdwk d @vnf; xd kae&mwGif nae(2)em&D(15)rdepfupI tydwfcHvk duf&onfrSm wn
vk H;yifjzpfygonf?usaemfwk d @ESif htwl a':pkESif hOD;wifOD;yg xd kuwW&mvrf;ay:urk d;a&awGxJrSmyif wnvk H;xd kifaech J&ygonf//nbufa&mufonf htcg tar&dueftpk d;&qk donf h pmtkyfta=umif;ud kaqG;aEG;rnf h pmzwf0k dif;tm; e-0-wu tb,f ha=umih fydwfyif&onfud k a':pku usaemfwd k @ud kteD;pyfqk H;&Sif;jyygonf? “pmtkyfygta=umif;t&mawGu tar&dueftpk d;&&J @ zJ G @pnf;yk HOya'yg orw&J @vkyfyk difcGih fawG/ w&m;a&;csKyfvkyfyk difcGih f/ v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,f&J@ vkyfykdifcGihf/ jynfolvlxk&J@tcGihfta&;awG 'gawGukd wu,f'Drkdua&pDpepfusus tao;pdyfa&;om;xm;wmawGyga=umif;/ ‚if;wk d @u ,ckolwk d @a&;qJ Gaeonf h zJ G @pnf;yk HtajccHOya'rl=urf;ESif h 'Dtar&duefuzJ G @pnf;yk H t&rf;uGm[aoma=umif h wu,h f'Drk dua&pDpepfaumif;aumif;uk d jynfolvlxk rodapcsifonf htjyif/usaemfwk d @ tifeft,fvf'Dvli,fawG 'gawGodjrifoGm;rSmuk d olwk d @taeeJ @ rvk dvm;wh Joabm/ &Sif;&Sif;ajym&&if
awmh olwk d @u 'Drk dua&pDuk d rvk dvm;vk d @ jynfolawGrodatmif ydwfyifwh Joabm”[k a':pku tJ'Dpmtkyfta=umif;uk daqG;aEG;jyygonf? OD;wifOD;uvnf; Ak dvfcsKyfausmfaZmork dif;uk d aemufcHa&;xm;onf h wk d @wk dif;XmeD
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 199/208
199
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
qk daom pmtkyfta=umif;uk daqG;aEG;ygonf? aemuf+yD; ol. ppfork dif;tawG @tóuHrsm;ud kvnf;ajymjyygonf?xd k @aemuf usaemfwk d @tm;vk H; Ek difiHa&;oDcsif;rsm; ud kwnvH k;oDqk d=uygonf?
nOf @eufvmonf htcg OD;wifOD;u a,musfm;av;awGud k ikwfwkwfxd kifrS D+yD; vrf;ay:wGiftd dyfygonf? a':pk
uvnf; rdef;uav;awGud krS D+yD; wvSnf hpDtdyf=uygonf? aemufwae@eHeuf(10)em&D(45)rdepf&S donf htcgwGifrSa':pk+cHxJuk d‘tm;vk H; 0ifvk d @&+yD’[k Ak dvfrSL;ol&u vmajymonf// (a':pk)+cHxJuk da&mufonf htcg tm;vk H;a&csKd;+yD;a'gufwmwifrsKd;0if;a&mufvmum '%f&m&oltm;vk H;uk d aq;ukay;ygonf// c%em;ae+yD; (11)em&DcJ G (12)em&Dcef @wGif ck H&Snf}uD;rsm;quf+yD; tm;vk H;a':pkESif hxrif;vufqk Hpm;=uygonf? a':pkESif h usaemf xd kwcgxrif;vufqk Hpm;zl;jcif;jzpfonf? xd ktjzpftysufrSm a':pkuk d 'kwd,t}udrfvkyf=uH jcif;jzpfonf? txl;ojzih f OD;wifOD;ud k,fwk diftawG @tóuHt& tumtuG,fay;xm;ch Jonf htwGuf a':pk toufraoch Jjcif;jzpfygonf?
aemuf (21-&-98)rS (29-7-1998)ckESpf tnmpkaus;&GmteD;/ ck H;wHwm;av;Y ( 98 ckESpfwGif jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,frsm;uk d e0w ppftpk d;&u ta=umif;rh J tus,fcsKyftjzpfzrf;qD;xm;+yD; ck d;/ qk d;/ Ed _ufawGuk dwyfonf h Oya'yk'fr(54)wyf+yD;/ ajccsKyfESif hcH0ef tufOya'yk'fr (5)(1)(p)(q)ponf hyk'frrsm;ESif h tjypfrh Jolrsm;tm; zrf;qD;xdef;odrf;jcif;rsm;ud k jrefrmjynfw0Srf;vk H;wGifðyvkyfcJ hygonf? xd kpOfu OD;wifOD;rS Oya'oabmw&m;t& 'D Oya'[m jynfolvlxktwGuftrSefwu,fpk d;&drf&a=umif;/ jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,fawGqk donfrSm vlxkuae ,k H=unftm;xm;I rJay;a&G;cs,fcef @xm;olrsm;jzpfa=umif;/ xk dyk*~ dKvf}uD;rsm;uk d/ jynfolvlxku &G Hrkef;onf h ck d;qk d;Ed _ufawGuk dwyfaomOya'ESif h wu,fuk d rvkyfoih frvkyfxk dufonfuk d vkyfxm;onfqk d+yD;OD;wifOD;u ‚if;wk d @uk d Oya'a=umif;t&ta&;qk dxm;ygonf? a':pkESif h OD;wifOD;u trwfawGud k xdef;odrf;xm;onf[kajymonf? trSefwu,f xdef;odrf;xm;aomfvnf; (Ek difiHjcm;a&;0ef}uD;)OD;0if;atmifu Ek difiHwumud k rzrf;xm;ygbl l;[k vdrfvnf ajym=um;onf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfajymonf htwd kif; r[kwfyg[kjiif;onf?a':pku trwfawGud k zrf;qD;xm;jcif;aocsma=umif; oufaojyonf htaeESif h rif;vSòrd @e,frS a':vSvSrd k;.
usef;rma&;tajctaeraumif;vd k @ t&ifqk H;oGm;awG @onf? xd k rif;vSc&D;pOfwGifvnf; a':pkud karSmfbDvk Hxdef;wyf&if; trSwf(5)a&S @rS qufroGm;Ed kifap&efydwfxm;jyD; aemufwae@a&mufrS a':vSvSrd k;ud kac:vm+yD; awG @ay;vk dufaoma=umif h a':pk jyefvmcJ h&onf//
'kwd,tacgufrSm {&m0wDwd kif;/ anmifwkef;c&D;pOfjzpfonf? {&m0wDwd kif;u trwfawGqDod k @ a':pkoGm;jcif;jzpfonf? eHeuf(9)em&DcG Jcef @rSm &efukefu p xGufvmjyD; v_ difom,mòrd @txGuf vH kxdef;wyf&if;trSwf(9)a&S @Ya':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @. um;ud k pwifydwfqd k @jcif;óuHawG @&ygonf? vd _ifom,m òrd @xJuum;awG/ vlawGoGm;vmr&jzpfvmonf htcgwGifrS &efukefESif hanmifwkef;oGm;aomum;vrf;ud k (10)em&Dausmfcef @wGif jyefzGih fay;vk dufygonf? v_ difom,mòrd @uxGufvm+yD; xef;wyifòrd @e,fwmqk H vrf;cJ GrSm a':pkwd k @.um;ud k acwWxyfrH
ydwfqd k @+yD; r=umcifrSmyJ vrf;zGih fay;vk dufygonf? xd kod k @ydwfqd k @xm;csdefrSmyif xef;wyifòrd @e,f tnmpkaus;&GmtwGif;u &Gmom;rsm;ud kacsmqG JI oJtdwfawGxrf;cd kif;+yD; tnmpkwHwm;xdyf wzufwcsufwGif xd koJtdwfrsm;ud k pD+yD;xyfxm;cd kif;onf? wHwm;.taemufbufxJY ppfwyfwwyf&S donf? xd kwyfxJu &,f'Drdwf oHql;óud;rsm;ud ko,f,lcd kif;+yD; vrf;ay:rSm um;ESpfpD;omvsifarmif;ESifEd kif&ef vrf;ud kzGif hxm;onf? vrf;ab;tpyfawGrSm oJtdwfrsm;ud k oHql;óud;awGESif hpDxm;onf? xd k @aemuf tJ,m;uGef; c&D;onfwifbwf(pf)um;}uD;awGud kpepfwusjyifqif+yD; tqifoif h&yfwef @xm;onf// a':pkum;a&mufvmonf htcg tnmpk wHwm;xdyfu oJtdwfawG/ oHql;}udK;awG r&d Sonf hae&mrSm tJ,m;uGef;bwfpfum;}uD;(2)pD;u vrf;uk duef @vef @jzwfxk d;I ydwfvk dufygonf? um;vrf;}uD;wckvk H; um;ESpfpD; ,SOfydwfxm;aoma=umif hvnf;aumif;/ oJtdwfawG oHql;}udK;awGumxm;aoma=umif hvnf;aumif;/ a':pk.um;rSm rnfod k @r# oGm;r&awmhyg/ t&d SefESif harmif;vmonf hum;uk d
‚if;wk d @u bwfpfum;}uD;rsm;ESif h xk d;ydwfvk dufonf htwGuf um;csif;0ifwk dufvkjzpfoGm;ygonf? um;armif;onf huk dxGef;jrih fu um;uk d *i,fauG @ auG @+yD; bD;uk daxmifoGm;vkeD;yg; vSnf hypfvd kuf&ygonf? uk dxGef;jrih f. um;armif;
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 200/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
200
u|rf;usifr_a=umih fom um;rwk dufrd fjcif;jzpfonf? um;u auG @+yD;&yfxm;onf htcsdefrSmyif ‚if;wk d @u pepfwus
óudwifjyifqifxm;jcif;jzpfonf htwGuf vk Hxdef;awGcsufcsif;a&mufvm=uygonf? vk Hxdef;t&m&d Su a':pkuk d‘&efukef jyefyg/ 'Dbufuk d qufroGm;ygeJ @’[kajymygonf// a':pku “usr&J @ jynfol @v$wfawmfuk d,fpm;vS,fawGusef;rma&;tajctaet& olwk d @eJ @awG @qk Hzk d @twGuf usr vlr_a&;t&vmw,f jyefzk d @vmwm r[kwfbl;/ vrf;ud kbma=umih fydwfwmvJ”[kjyefar;ygonf? ‘tJ'gawGolwk d @ ajymcGih fr&d Sbl;/ &efukefuk domjyefyg/’[k ‚if;u qufajymonf htcg a':pku“vk H;0 rjyefbl;/ jyefzk d @vmwm r[kwfbl;/ aemufwacguf xyfrajymeJ @”[k a':pku jywfjywfom;om;ajymvk dufygonf// a':pkuk dajymI r&onf htwGuf vk Hxdef;awGutiftm;ESif h0k dif;+yD; a':pk.um;uk d ronf htcg um;ay:wGifa':pk/ OD;vSaz/ um;armif;onf huk dxGef;jrih fESif h t&HpufjyifwOD; xd kav;a,mufrSm um;ay: Y ykcufpD;ouJ hod k @ ygoGm;ygonf? ‚if;wk d @u um;ud k vrf;r}uD;.ab;&S d wHwm;av;ay:od k @ r oGm;+yD;wifxm;vd kufyg onf? a&ajrmif;av;ay:&S d xd kwHwm;rSm a':pkum;wpD;omv#if wifI&onf?xk dod k @wifxm;+yD;rS a':pkuk d
‘&efukefjyefr,fqk d&if jyefvk d @&w,f/ 'Dbufud k oGm;cGih frjyKbl;’[kajymygonf// &efukef-anmifwkef;vrf;r}uD;ud krlbmrS rjzpf ouJ hod k @ jyefzGih fay;vk duf=uonf? xd kod k @jyefzGih fay;onf htcsdefrSmyif a':pkum;u armif;xGuf&efjyifqifygonf? xd ktcg teD;rSm&yfxm;onf h oJum;u csufjcif;yif um;vrf;ud kxk d;ydwfvd kufygonf? vk Hxdef;awGua':pkum;uk daemufw}udrf r +yD; wHwm;ay: jyefwifygonf? ,ckwcgwGif ‚if;wk d @u vltrsm; rjrifEd kifap&eftxl;jyKvkyfxm;aom uef @vwfjzwfn‡yfb&dwfESif h um;bD;tm;vk H;uk dbD;atmufuae n‡yfxm;+yD; rarmif;Ed kifap&ef ðyvkyfxm;vd kufygonf? (&kyfjrifoH=um;)pavmif;rS =unh fonf htcg um;av;u ol @[mol &yfonf hyk Hjzpfaeygonf// Ek difiHwumuk d zk H;uG,fvdrfnmEd kifap&ef pepfwuszefwD;vkyfaqmifxm;jcif; jzpfonf? a':pkum;uk dwHwm;ay:rSm n‡yfb&dwfrsm;ESif hn‡yfIwifxm;+yD; a':pkwd k @ud kxrif;vnf; rau|;/ a&vnf; rwk dufbJ/ ‚if;wk d @u
a':pkuk d ‚if;wk d @owfI r[kwfbJ/ ol @[mol aoonf[kajymcsifonf hoabm jzpfonf?a':pkwk d @rSm rk d;&Gmaomtcg olwk d @rSmygoGm;onf hxD;ESif h rd k;a&cHI rk d;a&aomuf+yD; touf&Sif=u&ygonf?
xd kod k @aecJ h&onfrSm (8)&ufwk difwk dif=umjrif hygonf? a'gufwmwifrsdK;0if;u a':pk.rdom;pk q&m0efwa,muftaejzif h usef;rma&;tajctaeud kodvd konf htwGuf awG @cGih fawmif;onf htcg a':pkESif hawG @qk HcGih f&cJ honf? a':pkrSm xd ktcGih fta&;wckomvsif &&Smonf? (8)&ufajrmufae@rSm a'gufwmwifrsKd;0if;uk d,fwk dif a':atmifqef;pk=unfrSm pdwfaqmifonf htoufomvsif&d Sygawmhonf? ommref vlwa,mufqk dvsif ol[m aoaeyg+yDqk d+yD;a=unmcsufwapmifxkwfjyefvk dufygonf// xd ktcgusrS Ek difiHwumuvnf; a':atmifqef;pk=unfuk d v$wfay;&ef 0k dif;+yD;ajymvm=uygonf?
xd k@a=umif h ‚if;wk d @taejzifh rvJ $omIom n(10)em&Dausmfce@frSm Akdvfrª;ol& OD;aqmif+yD; a':pkwk d@uk dtwif;t"rRcsKyfaESmifI ac:aqmifvmygonf// Ak dvfrª;ol&qk dolu rk dufrk duf&k dif;&k dif; aemufrS a':pkuk dok dif;csKyfxm;+yD; &Jar(2)a,muftm; a':pkajcaxmufawGuk d um;aemufcef;rScsKyfck dif;xm;onf? &Jrª;wa,mufu um;armif;onf? tpmjywfa&jywfESif h tiftm;csdenf haeoluk d ‚if;wk d @av;a,mufucsKyf+yD; &efukefod k @jyefac:vm=uygonf?a':atmifqef;pk=unf tdrfuk djyefa&mufvm+yD;aemuf a':pkESif htwlygoGm;onf h OD;vSaz/ uk dxGef;jrih fwk d @u "gwfyk HawGESif htwl owif;pm&Sif;vif;yJ Gvkyfygonf? a'gufwmwifrsKd;0if;uvnf; olay;ch Jonf haq;0g;rsm;jzif h a':pk.toufuk d rnfod k @u,fwifcJ h&yk Hpojzif h tao;pdyf ol}udK;pm;xm;&onf hta=umif;awGud k owif;pm&Sif;vif;yJ Gvkyfay;ygonf? e0w u a& rwk duf tpm rau|;/ um;uk dvnf; n‡yfb&dwfawGvkyfxm;onf hta=umif;usaemfwk d @tm;vk H;uk d &Sif;jyygonf? ‚if;tjzpftysufrSm wwd,t}udrfa':pkuk d ‚if;wk d @vkyf=uHjcif;jzpfygonf?
xd kw}udrfwGifvnf; rdrdwk d @.acgif;aqmifrSm wk dif;jynftay: olr.pdwfapwemrSefuefr_a=umih fvnf;aumif;/olr.bkef;uHa=umih fvnf;aumif; Tr#txd olr touf&Snfae&a=umif; usaemf,k H=unfcH,lcJ hygonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 201/208
201
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
1998 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (12)rS(24)txd a'gufwmwifrif;xGÉfESif hawG @qk H&ef {&m0wDwk dif;od k @ 'kwd,t}udrf
a':pkxyfrHoGm;a&mufcJ hygonf? xd kt}udrfwGifvnf; ,cift=udrfu wm;qD;cH&onf h ck H;ausmfwHwm;av;Yyif/vk Hxdef;awGu vltiftm;ok H;I um;ud k r wifxm;onf// xd ktacgufrSm a':pkuk d (13)&uf=umydwfxm;onf?xd kwacgufwGifvnf; tpmvnf; ray;/ a&vnf; rwk dufyg? od k @aomf a':pkwk d @u ‚if;wk d @.aumufuspfr_uk dod+yD;jzpfI a&oef @Al;rsm;,loGm;=uygonf? tpmcHonf h ajryJ,k duJ hod k @ tpm;tpmrsm;ud kvnf;xnh foGm;=uygonf?xd k @a=umif h 'kwd,tacgufrSm yxrtacgufuJ hod k @ a':pk.usef;rma&;tajctaerSm pk d;&drf&onf htajctaeod k @ra&mufcJ hyg? ‚if;wk d @url a':pkuk d tpmraºuG;bJxm;jcif;jzpfonf// xd kt}udrfrSm a':pkuk d pwkwWt}udrfvkyf}uHjcif;jzpfygonf?
tqd kygc&D;pOfwGif rSwfwrf;rsm;,laeonf h rdrdESif htwlygol(4)OD;ud k =o*kwfv(21)&ufae@wGif e0w rS
vd kufvHzrf;qD;ojzif h &H k;csKyfod k @jyefvmcJ h&ygonf? 1998 ckESpf/ =o*kwfv (24)&ufae@wGif usaemf tzrf;cH&ygonf// axmifxJrSmvnf; usaemf hudk &kdufESufn‡Of;yrf;jcif;rsm;pGmðyvkyfygonf? axmifrSvGwfvm+yD;aemuftrsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfwGif qufvufwm0ef,lcJ h&m 2003 ckESpf/ a':atmifqef;pk=unf. txufjrefrmEd kifiHpnf;&H k;a&; c&D;pOfwGif csif;jynfe,fc&D;pOfwGifvd kufygcGif h&cJ hygonf? a':pk.csif;jynfe,fc&D;pOfwGif *ef @a*g+rKd @e,fc,u OuUX OD;aX;OD;qk doluk d,fwk difu *ef @a*gòrd @rSm a':pka[majymyJ Gvmolrsm;uk d 0g;vk H;ESif hvk duf&k dufygonf?òrd @rvrf;xdyfrSae+yD; vk duf&k dufonfud k usaemfwk d @uk d,fwk difjrifawG @&ygonf? rD;owftzJ G @uvnf; rD;owf0wfpk Hrsm;0wf+yD; rD;owfum;}uD;ESif h a':pka[majymonf hae&muk da&mufvm+yD; rD;ab;a&Smif ravmifcifwm; qk daomoDcsif;uk d us,favmifpGmzGih fI aESmif h,Sufr_ðyvkyfygonf? axmufvSrf;a&;(20)rS Ak dvf}uD;vif;aZmfuHqk d kolu‚if;uk d,fwk dif a[majymyJ GxJod k @0ifvm+yD; uufqufESif htoHzrf;jcif;rsm;ðyvkyfygonf? xd k @aemuf ta&S @*ef @a*gESif htaemuf*ef @a*g=um;wGif&d Saomóud;wHwm;uk dvnf; vlxk ul;rvmEk difap&efydwfxm;ygonf? xd k @aemuf uav;-a&rsufeDajy;qJ Gonf h rD;&xm;uk dvnf; xd kae@rSmyifydwfvk dufygonf? *ef @a*gwGifvlrsm;+yD; a':pkud k óudqd k=urnfud k pk d;&drfonf? vlxkESif ha':pkawG @qk H=urnfud kvnf; vGefpGmpk d;&drfonf? vlxku a':pkuk daxmufcHr_ rnfr#}uD;rm;a=umif; ‚if;wk d @uk d,fwk dif od&S dae+yDjzpfonf?
xd k @aemuf *ef @a*grStjyef awmvrf;c&D;wav#mufwGif opfwk H;}uD;rsm;ud k vrf;ray:csxm;onf? xd kopfvk H;rsm;rSm tpd k;&opfawm}udK;0k dif;rS opfrsm;jzpfI tpk d;uomv#if o,f,lyd k @aqmifEd kifonf? jynfolrsm;uo,f,lv#if ‚if;wd k @uzrf;+yD;axmifcsrnfjzpfonf? xd kopfwk H;}uD;rsm;ud k vlr&d Sonf hum;vrf;r}uD;ay:rSm rnfonf htwGufvmcsxm;&oenf;? usaemfwk d @ xd kopfvk H;rsm;ud kz,f+yD; c&D;qufch J&onf? ‚if;wk d @u vGwfvyfpGmoGm;vm
cGih fjyKygonf[k ajymaomfvnf; a':pkwk d @rSm xd kod k @aomaESmif h,Sufr_trsKd;rsKd;uk d jzwfoef;oGm;vmch J&ygonf?txufygtjzpftysufrsm;onf usaemfud k,fwd kifyg0ifcJ h+yD; &ifqd kif=uHKawG @cJ h&aom tjzpftysuftrSefrsm;
jzpfygonf? a':atmifqef;pk=unfud k vkyf}uHowfjzwf&ef [d k,cifuwnf;u pepfwus óudwif=uHpnfcJ hjcif;jzpfa=umif;ud k jynfolrsm;od&S dEd kifap&eftwGuf ,ckuJ hod k @ zGif hajymjy&jcif;jzpfygonf? 'DyJ,if; vkyf=uHr_}uD;rSmrlrnfod k @r# zH k;uG,fIr&Ed kifawmhbJ jynfoltrsm;uod&S dcGif h&vd kufjcif;jzpfygonf?
armifpd k;oef;(c)atmifpd k;oef;armifpdk;oef;(c)atmifpd k;oef;armifpd k;oef;(c)atmifpd k;oef;armifpdk;oef;(c)atmifpd k;oef;armifpd k;oef;(c)atmifpdk;oef;
2003 ckESpf/=o*kwfv (27)&uf2003 ckESpf/=o*kwfv (27)&uf2003 ckESpf/=o*kwfv (27)&uf2003 ckESpf/=o*kwfv (27)&uf2003 ckESpf/=o*kwfv (27)&uf
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 202/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
202
2003 ckESpf/ Ekd0ifbmv (18)&ufaeŒwGif usif;yaom
( 58 ) }udrfajrmuf ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcHrS
jrefrmEkdifiH. vlŒtcGif hta&;tajctaeESif hpyfvsOf;I csrSwfaom qk H;jzwfcsufrsm;
urB mhukvor*~yÉdnmOfpmwrf;/ tjynfjynfqk dif&mvl @tcGif hta&;a=unmpmwrf;/ vl @tcGif hta&;qk dif&mEk difiHwum yÉd mOfpmcsKyfrsm;ESif h tjcm;vl @tcGif hta&;pmcsKyfpmwrf;rsm;t&vnf;aumif;?
ukvor*~tzG J @0ifEk difiHtm;vH k;onf vl @tcGif hta&;ESif h tajccHvGwfvyfcGif hrsm;ud k umuG,fjr‡if hwifay;&rnf h0wW&m;&d SonfESif htnD/ tzGJ @0ifEd kifiHtm;vH k;rsm;taejzifh vufawG @aqmif&Gufr_e,fy,fY txufygtrsKd;rsKd;tpm;tpm;aom Ek difiHwumpmcsKyfpmwrf;rsm;t& ‚if;wk d @.wm0ef0wW&m;rsm;ud k jznf hqnf;ay;&rnf h wm0ef&d Sonf[k xyfrH twnfðycsuft&vnf;aumif;?
jrefrmEd kifiHonf uav;oli,ftcGif hta&;qk dif&moabmwlpmcsKyf/ trsKd;orD;rsm;tm;yk HpHrsKd;pk Hjzif h cG Jjcm;zdESdyfqufqHjcif;rsm; y,fzsufa&;oabmwlpmcsKyf/ vlrsKd;wH k;owfjzwfonfh&mZ0wfr_tm; umuG,fjcif;ESif hjypf'%fay;jcif;qd kif&m oabmwlpmcsKyf/ ppf'%foif holrsm;ud kumuG,fapmif ha&Smufa&;qk dif&m 1949 ckESpf =o*kwfv (12)&uf *sDeDAmoabmwlpmcsKyf/ twif; t=uyftvkyfapck dif;jcif;ESif h t"rRvkyftm;ay;apr_qk d dif&m 1930
ckESpf oabmwlpmcsKyf( pmcsKyftrSwf 292 )ESif h Ek difiHwumtvkyform;tzG J @csKyf( td kift,ftd k ). vGwfvyfpGmtoif;tyif;zG J @pnf;v_yf&Sm;cGif hESif h vGwfvyfpGmpnf;&H k;cGif hwk d @tm; tumtuG,fay;onf h 1948 ckESpf oabmwlpmcsKyf ( pmcsKyftrSwf 87 )wd k @. tzG J @0ifEd kifiHjzpfonfud k owdðyr_t&vnf;aumif;?
uav;rsm;ta&;ESif hvufeufud kifyËdyuQta&;tay: taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;. vH k+cHKa&;aumifpDqH k;jzwfcsuf 1460 (2003)ud k ESvH k;oGif;Ivnf;aumif;?
,cifucsrSwfcJ haomqH k;jzwfcsufrsm; ( r=umao;rDu csrSwfcJ honf h 2002 ckESpf 'DZifbmv(18)&uf.qH k;jzwfcsuf trSwf 57§231/ 2003 ckESpf {+yDv (16)&ufae@ qH k;jzwfcJ haom vl @tcGif hta&;aumfr&Sif. qH k;jzwfcsuftrSwf 2003§12 ESif h jrefrmEd kifiHtwGif; twif;t=uyftvkyfapck dif;jcif;ESif h t"rRvkyftm;ay;apr_wk d @ESif hywfoufI 2000 ckESpf ZGefv (14)&ufae@wGifðyvkyfonf h (88)}udrfajrmuf Ed kifiHwumtvkyform;nDvmcHwGif
Ed kifiHwumtvkyform;tzG J @csKyf( td kift,fvftd k )u jyÏmef;onf hqH k;jzwfcsuf )ud k jyefvnfazmfaqmifIvnf;aumif;?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 203/208
203
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
tpd k;&tcGif htm%m. rlvtajccHonf jynfolrsm;.qENoabmxm;jzpfonfESif htnD/ 1990jynf hESpfwGif&Sif;vif;pGm xkwfazmfjyocJ honf h jrefrmjynfolrsm;. qENoabmxm;ud k twnfðyIvnf;aumif;?
jrefrmEd kifiHwGif ppfrSefonf h'Drd kua&pDtpd k;&w&yfwnfaxmifjcif;onf vl @tcGif hta&;rsm;ESif h tajccHvGwf
vyfcGif hrsm;ud k em;vnfoabmaygufjznf hqnf;ay;&eftwGuf r&d Srjzpfvk dtyfonfuk d twnfðyIvnf;aumif;?aumif;rGefonf htkyfcsLyfa&;/ 'Drd kua&pDa&;/ w&m;Oya'pd k;rd k;a&;ESif h vl @tcGif hta&;rsm;tm; av;pm;vd kufemjcif;onfom wd kif;jynf. pD;yGm;a&;ESif hzG @H+zdK;wd k;wufa&;wd k @twGuf t"duusonfud k todtrSwfjyKvsuf &S donfud kvnf;aumif;?
jrefrmEk difiHtwGif; bdef;xkwfvkyfr_ud k wk dufzsuf&efvd ktyfa=umif; tpd k;&uyk drk dI em;vnfvufcHvmjcif;tm;rSwfwrf;wifjcif;tm;jzif hvnf;aumif;?
2003 ckESpf =o*kwfv 30 &ufae@wGif jrefrmEd kifiH0ef}uD;csKyfrS xkwfjyefa=unmcJ haom 'D drd kua&pDtoGiful;ajymif;a&; Ed kifiHa&;vrf;jyajryH kud k rSwfwrf;wifjcif;tm;jzif hvnf;aumif;?
(1)atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k óudqd ktyfonf?(1)atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k óudqd ktyfonf?(1)atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k óudqd ktyfonf?(1)atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k óudqd ktyfonf?(1)atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k óudqdktyfonf?
(u) +yD; cJ honf hESpftwGif; urB mhukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyf. txl;oHwreftm; jrefrmEk difiHok d @vnfywfEd kif&ef cGif hjyKcJ hjcif;tm;vnf;aumif;/ ukvor*~ vl @tcGif hta&;aumfr&SifrScef @tyfxm;aom vl @tcGif hta&;ud k,fpm;vS,ftm; vl @tcGif @a&;tajctaersm;ESif hywfowfI pk Hprf;Ed kif&ef cGif hjyKcJ h+cif;tm;vnf;aumif;?
(c) jrefrmtpd k;&tm; trsKd;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;/ awG @qk HaqG;aEG;a&;vrf;a=umif;ay:od k @a&muf&efwGef;tm;ay;aom Ek difiHwumtod kif;t0d ki;f. óud;yrf;r_rsm; / txl;ojzif @ a'oqd kif&mEk difiHrsm;.óud;yrf;r_/ 2003
ckESpf ZGefv (18)&ufae@pG J jzif @ (10)}udrfajrmuf ASEAN xdyfoD; aqG;aEG;yG JrSazmfjyxm;aom a'oqd kif&mvk HðcHa&;twGuf t "duaomhcsufonf 'Drd kua&pDazmfaqmifa&;jzpfonf[laomtcsufud k vd kufemtodtrSwfðy&efqd kaom tcsuftm;vnf;aumif;?
(*) ukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;ta&;r_;csKyf. jrefrmEk difiHESif hywfowfaom tpD&ifcHpm tm;vnf;aumif;?(C) ukvor*~ vl htcGif hta&;ud k,fpm;vS,f. jrefrmEk difiHvl @tcGif @ta&;tajctaeta=umif; tpD&ifcHpm
tm;vnf;aumif;?(i) vwfwavm t"rRvkyftm;ay;r_ESif @ywfoufI taumiftxnfazmfEk difonf @tajctae r&S dao;aomf
vnf;/ t"rRvkyftm;ay;ck dif;apcH&jcif;a=umif @ twd'kuQa&mufolrsm;tm;ulnDay;&ef vGwfvyfonf htultnD
ay;a&;tzG J @ wnfaxmifa&; oabmwlnDcsufyg0ifon@f jrefrmtpk d;&ESif @ Ek difiHwumtvkyform;tzG J @csKyfwd k @.arv (27)&uf 2003ae@ &efukefðrd @wGif oabmwlnDcJ @onf h yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufr_vkyfief;pOftm;vnf;aumif;?(p) Ek difiHwum =uufa+ceDaumfrwD ( td kifpDtmpD )ESif @@ qufvufI yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufaejcif;tm; vnf;
aumif;?
(2) atmufygtcsufrsm;udk tvGeftrif;pd k;&drfa=umif; azmfjyonf ?(2) atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k tvGeftrif;pd k;&drfa=umif; azmfjyonf ?(2) atmufygtcsufrsm;udk tvGeftrif;pd k;&drfa=umif; azmfjyonf ?(2) atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k tvGeftrif;pd k;&drfa=umif; azmfjyonf ?(2) atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k tvGeftrif;pdk;&drfa=umif; azmfjyonf ?
(u) arv (30)&uf 2003 &ufae@wGif jzpfyGm;cJ haom t=urf;zufr_=uD;wGif e t z vufud kifwkwf =uH @zG H @tzG J @}uD;. ajAmifusus yg0ifywfoufaer_ESif @ jrefrmEk difiHtwGif; tqd k;&Gm;qk H; vl @tcGif hta&;csLd;azgufr_rsm; qufvuf
jzpfay:aejcif;?(c) a':atmifqef;pk=unftm; tus,fcsKyftjzpf qufvufxdrf;odrf;xm;jcif;ESif @ vGwfvyfpGmoGm;vmEk dif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 204/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
204
aom olr. tajccHvl @tcGif hta&;rsm;ud k jiif;qefaejcif;tjyif trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf. xdyfwef;acgif;aqmifrsm;tm; qufvufxdef;odrf;xm;jcif;?
(*) wEk difiHvk H;&d S trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csLyf&k H;rsm;tm; ydwfyifxm;r_/ trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0if
rsm;/ tjcm;Ek difiHa&;ygwD0ifrsm;ESif @ axmufcHolrsm;tm; teD;uyfapmif @=unf hr_rsm;ESif @ axmifoGif;tusOf;csaejcif;rsm;/ xd k @tjyif Ek difiHa&; tusOf;om;rsm;tm; axmifoufaphajrmufaomfvnf; qufvufzrf;qD;xm;jcif;?(C) trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csLyf tzJ G @0ifrsm;tm; }uH @zG @HtzG J @rS pEkpfwus aESmif h,Suf+cdrf;ajcmufaejcif;?(i) ukvor*~ vl @tcGif @ta&;aumfr&SifrScef @tyfxm;aom txl;pk Hprf;a&;uk d,fpm;vS,fESif @ yl;aygif;aqmif
&Gufr_ tm;enf;jcif;/Oyrm - vl @tcGif @a&;txl;uk d,fpm;vS,fwifjyxm;aom vl @tcGif @a&;csKd;azmufr_qd k;&Gm;aeaom wd kif;&if;
om;vlrsdK;pka'orsm;od k @ oGm;a&mufI vGwfvyfaom pH kprf;ppfaq;r_rsm;ðyvkyf&ef ppftpd k;&rS cGif @rðyao;jcif;?
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) tvGeftrif; pd k; &drf yl yefr_ rsm; ud k atmuf yg tcsuf rsm; jzif @xyfrH azmf jyonf?tvGeftrif; pd k; &drf yl yefr_ rsm; ud k atmuf yg tcsuf rsm; jzif @xyfrH azmf jyonf?tvGeftrif; pd k; &drf yl yefr_ rsm; ud k atmuf yg tcsuf rsm; jzif @xyfrH azmf jyonf?tvGeftrif; pd k; &drf yl yefr_ rsm; ud k atmuf yg tcsuf rsm; jzif @xyfrH azmf jyonf?tvGeftrif; pd k; &drf yl yefr_ rsm; ud k atmuf yg tcsuf rsm; jzif@xyfrH azmf jyonf?
(u) jrefrmjynfolrsm;. Ek difiHom;tcGif hta&; / Ek difiHa&;/ pD;yGm;a&;/ vlr_a&;ESif f @ ,Ofaus;r_tcGif @ta&;rsm;tygt0if vl @tcGif @ ta&;rsm;ud k jrefrmtpd k;&rS pepfwus tpDtpOf&S d&S d csdL;azgufaer_rsm;?
(1)Oya'rJ @oufjzwfjcif;/ ppfom;rsm;vufeufozG,f tok H;ðyavh&S daomn‡Of;yrf;ES dyfpufr_/ rk'def;r_rsm;ESif @tjcm;vdifqd kif&mt=urf;zufr_rsm; / pdwfysufzG,fqd k;&Gm;edrf @usvSaom xdef;odrf;a&;pcef;rsm;.tajctae/ t"rRae&majymif;a&$ @r_rsm;/ uav;rsm;tm; vkyfom;tjzpf t"rRapcd kif;aer_tygt0if / t"rRvkyftm;apck dif;r_/ ppfwyfrS jynfolrsm;. toufarG;0rf;a=umif;vkyfief;rsm;ud k zsufqD;r_rsm;ESif @ twif;t=uyfajrae&modrf;yd kufr_rsm;/tpm;taomuf/ usef;rma&;ESif h ynma&;tp&d Saom vlaer_tqif @twef;qd kif&m tcGif @ta&;rsm;tm; csdK;
azmufr_?(11) owif;vGwfvyfcGif @/ vGwfvyfpGmtoif;tyif;zG J @pnf;cGif @/ vGwfvyfpGmv_yf&Sm;oGm;vmcGif @ tygt0if
vGwfvyfpGm xkwfazmfajymqd kcGif @rsm;tm; ppftpd k;&rS jiif;y,faejcif;?(111) wd kif;&if;om;vlenf;pkrsm;/ trsKd;orD;rsm;ESif huav;rsm;tm; rwlnDonf hbmoma&; (od k @r[kwf)
vlrsKd;a&;ud ktajccHI cJ G+cm;qufqHrlrsm;ESif h n‡Of;yrf;Ed Syfpufr_rsm;?
(c) Ek difiHwGif; td k;rJ htdrfrJ @a&$ @ajymif;ykef;cd kae&ol ta&twGufyd krd krsm;jym;vmjcif;ESif @ tdrfeD;csif;Ek difiHrsm;od k @pD;0ifa&muf&S doGm;=uaom rsm;jym;vSonf h'kuQonfrsm;.tajctaeESif h Ttajctaersm;ud k ajz&Sif;&ef Ek difiH
wumOya't& jrefrmtpd k;&. wm0ef&S dr_ud k owdðyrdjcif;?
(4) atmufygtcsufrsm;tm; jrefrmtpd k;&od k @ awmif;qk donf?(4) atmufygtcsufrsm;tm; jrefrmtpdk;&od k@ awmif;qk donf?(4) atmufygtcsufrsm;tm; jrefrmtpd k;&od k @ awmif;qk donf?(4) atmufygtcsufrsm;tm; jrefrmtpdk;&od k@ awmif;qk donf?(4) atmufygtcsufrsm;tm; jrefrmtpd k;&od k @ awmif;qk donf?
(u) arv(30)&uf 2003 ckESpfY jzpfyGm;cJ @aom 'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfESif hpyfvsOf;I Ek difiHwumESif h yl;aygif;umvGwfvyfaom pk Hprf;ppfaq;r_rsm;uk d jynf hpk HpGm jyKvkyfoGm;&ef/
(c) &Srf;jynfe,fESif @ tjcm;jynfe,frsm;wGif ppfom;rsm;usK;vGefcJ @=uonf @t"rRðyusif @r_rsm;ESif @tjcm;aomrw&m;zdES dyfr_rsm;ud k pkk Hprf;ppfaq;&eftwGuf ukvor*~vl@tcGif @ta&;txl;uk d,fpm;vS,f.tqdkjycsufudkjrefrmtpd k;&taejzif h csufcsif;taumiftxnfazmf aqmif&Guf&ef/ xd k @tjyif txl;uk d,fpm;vS,foGm;vk donf @
rnfonf @a'o rqd k oGm;a&mufEk dif&efESif @ txl;uk d,fpm;vS,ftm;yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufolrsm;. vk HòcHa&;uk d tmrcH&ef?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 205/208
205
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
(*) ukvor*~ESif h Ek difiHwumvlom;csif;pmemaomtzJ G @tpnf;rsm;taejzif h vlom;csif;pmemaom ulnDaxmufyH @r_rsm; ay;tyfEk difa&;ESif h taxmuftyH hypPnfrsm;tm; tvd ktyfqk H;olrsm;xHod k @ trSefwu,f a&muf&d SEk dif&eftwGuf jrefrmEk difiH ae&ma'otm;vk H;od k @ [efwm;aESmif h,Sufr_uif;pGmESif @ vk HðcHr_&d SpGm oGm;vm pk Hprf;Ek difa&;
wd k @ud k tmrcHcsuftjrefay;&ef?(C) typftcwf&yfpJjcif; rjyKvkyf&ao;onf h wd kif;&if;om;vlrsKd;pkrsm;eSif h jzpfyGm;aeonf hyÉdyuQrsm;ud k
tqk H;owfEk difa&;twGuf +idrf;csrf;pGm awG @qH kaqG;aEG;tajz&Smonf henf;vrf;ud ktoH k;jyK&ef/ typftcwf&yfpJxm;onf h wd kif;&if;om;vlrsdK;pka'orsm;&S d vl @tcGif hta&;tajctaersm; wd k;wufaumif;rGefvmap&efESif h a'ozG H @òzd;a&;tpDtpOfrsm;ud k wd k;jr‡if haqmif&Guf&ef?
(i) jrefrmEk difiHwGif; twif;t=uyftvkyfcd kif;apjcif; (od k @) t"rRtvkyfapcd kif;jcif;ESif hywfoufI pH kprf;ppfaq;Ek dif&ef Ek difiHwumtvkyform;tzG J @(td kift,fvftd k). 1930 (nDvmcHtrSwf 29)t& zG J @pnf;xm;onf h pH kprf;ppfaq;a&;aumfr&Sif.t}uHjyKcsufrsm;ud k tjynf ht0taumiftxnfazmfEk dif&eftvd k @iS g Ek difiHwumtvkyform;tzG J @ESif h yl;aygif;aqmif&GufEk difrnf h vd ktyfaomtajctaersm;ESif h tajccHvkyfaqmifr_rsm;tm;vH k;ud kaqmif&Guf&ef/jrefrmEk difiHtwGif; twif;t=uyf vkyftm;ck dif;apaer_rsm;twGufjrefrmtpk d;&ESif h Ek difiHwumtvkyform;tzG J @yl;aygif;aqmif&Gufa&;vkyfief; tpDtpOfESif hpyfqk difonf h 0ef;usifw&yfwnfaqmuf&efESif h txl;tm;jzif h yHyk d;aqmif&Gufay;rnf htpDtpOfrsm;uk d wnfaqmufxm;&efESif h ,k H=unfpdwfcsavmufaom taumiftxnfazmfaqmif&Gufr_rsm;uk d vkyfaqmif&ef?
(5) jrefrmtpd k;&od k @ atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k tjyif;txefwdkufwGef;onf?(5) jrefrmtpd k;&od k@ atmufygtcsufrsm;udk tjyif;txefwd kufwGef;onf?(5) jrefrmtpd k;&od k @ atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k tjyif;txefwdkufwGef;onf?(5) jrefrmtpd k;&od k@ atmufygtcsufrsm;udk tjyif;txefwd kufwGef;onf?(5) jrefrmtpd k;&od k @ atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k tjyif;txefwd kufwGef;onf?
(u) vl @tcGif hta&;csKd;azmufr_rsm;tm; tpDtpOf&S d&S d pepfwusvkyfaqmifaer_rsm;uk d &yfqk dif;&efESif h vl @tcGif h
ta&;ESif h tajccHvGwfvyfcGif hrsm;tm;vH k;ud k tjynf ht0 av;pm;vd kufem&ef?(c) arv (30) &ufESif h (30)&ufae@aemufyd kif; zrf;qD;xm;onf h trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tzG J @0ifrsm;/
acgif;aqmifrsm;ESif h a':atmifqef;pk=unfwd k @tm; c|if;csufr&S d v$wfay;&efESif h/ 'Drk dua&pDtoGifulajymif;a&;umvtpDtpOfrsm;/ trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;udpP&yfrsm;wGif ‚if;wk d @tm; tjynf ht0yg0ifaqmif&GufcGif hjyK&ef?
(*) Ek difiHa&;tusOf;om;tm;vH k;ud k ¹cGif;csufr&S d csufcsif;v$wfay;&ef?(C) ar (30) jzpf&yfaemufyk dif; ,m,Dxkwfjyefxm;aom trdef @rsm;/ Oya'rsm;ud k csufjcif;¶kyfodrf;&efESif h
Ek difiHt0Srf;&S d trsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf ¶k H;rsm;tm;vH k;ud k csufjcif;jyefzGif h&ef?
(i) +idrf;csrf;aom Ek difiHa&;v_yf&Sm;aqmif&Gufr_rsm; rjyKvkyfEk dif&ef &nf&G,fcsrSwfxm;aom wm;qD;uef @owfcsufrSefor# tm; tjrefqk H;y,fzsufay;&ef/ owif;vGwfvyfcGif htygt0if vGwfvyfpGmtoif;tyif;zG J @pnf;cGif hESif hvGwfvyfpGm oabmxm;xkwfazmfcGif hrsm;ud k tmrcHcsufay;&ef?
(p) vl @tcGif hta&;tm; pepfwuscsKd;azmufr_rsm;ESif h rw&m;zdES dyfr_rsm; tqH k;owfapa&;twGuf vl @tcGif hta&;ud k csKf d;azmufae=uonf h ppfom;rsm;/ }uH @zG H @tzG J @0ifrsm;ESif h tjcm;aomtpd k;&0efxrf;rsm;tm; rnfonf htajctaersdK;wGif rqd k pH kprf;ppfaq;&efESif h ¶k H;wifw&m;pG Jqd k&ef?
(q) 2003 ckESpf/ ar (30)aemufyd kif; jrefrmEk difiHtwGif;jzpfysufaeaomtajctaerSefrsm;ud k tuJjzwfEk dif&eftwGuf yxr tqif htaejzif h jrefrmtpd k;&onf ukvor*~taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyf. txl;oHwrefESif hukvor*~ vl @tcGif hta&;aumfr&SifrScef @tyfxm;aom vl @tcGif hta&;txl;uk d,fpm;vS,fwd k @ESif h ,ckxufyd krd kIt&S deft[kefjr‡if hyl;aygif;aqmif&Guf&ef/ t&yfom;tkyfcsKyfa&;pepfqDuk dOD;wnfaom toGiful;ajymif;a&;umvqDok d @ wd kif;jynfud ka&S @aqmif&ef/ ukvor*~ taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyf. txl;oHwrefESif h vl @tcGif hta&;aumfr&Sif
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 206/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
206
. txl;uk d,fpm;vS,fwd k @tm; jrefrmEk difiHtwGif; vGwfvyfpGmoGm;vmpH kprf;Ek d kifcGif h tjynf ht0&&S dapa&;ud k tmrcH
&ef/ ukvor*~taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyf. txl;oHwrefESif h vl @tcGif hta&;aumfr&Sif. txl;uk d,fpm;vS,fwd k @tm; yl;aygif;aqmif&Guf=uolrsm;uk d +cdrf;ajcmufr_/ [ef @wm;aESmif h,Sufr_ (od k @r[kwf) yH kpHwpfrsKd;rsKd;jzif h ta&;,lrcH&apa&;twGuf tmrcHcsufay;&ef ESif h ‚if;wd k @ jrefrmEk difiHY&S daepOftwGif; trsdK;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyf tygt0if Ek difiHa&;ygwDtoD;oD;rStzG J @0ifrsm;/ acgif;aqmifrsm;ESif h wef;wl&nfwlawG @qH kEk difatmif aqmif&Gufay;&ef?
(Z) 'Drk dua&pDpepf jyefvnfazmfaqmifa&;ESif h 1990 a&G;aumufyG J&v'frsm;ud k taumiftxnfazmfEk dif&ef'Drd kua&pDpepfod k @ ul;ajymif;a&;ESif h trsKd;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;wd k @twGuf a':atmifqef;pk=unftygt0iftrsKd;om;'Drd kua&pDtzG J @csKyfrS acgif;aqmifrsm;ESif h xda&mufIpepfusaom awG @qH kaqG;aEG;yG Jud k csufcsif; pwif&ef/xd k @tjyif tjcm;Ek difiHa&;acgif;aqmifrsm;ESif h wd kif;&if;om;ud k,fpm;vS,frsm;uf d kvnf; xd kawG @qH kaqG;aEG;yG Jrsm;wGif
apmv#ifpGm xnf hoGif;&ef?(ps) 'Drd kua&pD toGiful;ajymif;a&;twGuf a&;qG Jxm;aom vuf&S dEk difiHa&;vrf;jyajryH kwGif t"duvk dtyfaomtcsufrsm; ryg&S day? Oyrm - rnfonf htcsdefwGif pwifrnf/ rnfonf htcsdefY +yD;qH k;rnf ponf h wdusaomtcsdefumvvnf; owfrSwfxm;jcif;r&S day? xd k @tjyif Ek difiHa&;tiftm;pkrsm; tm;vH k;yg0ifEk difrnf h/ wd kif;&if;om;vlrsdK;pkrsm;tm;vH k; yg0ifEk difrnf h pDrHcsufrsm;vnf; ryg&S day? od k @twGuf 'Drd kua&pDtoGiful;ajymif;a&;twGufEk difiHa&;vrf;jyajryH kY yg0ifaomvkyfief;pOfrsm;tm; trsm;u ,H k=unfvufcHEk difavmufaom/ Ek difiHa&;tiftm;pktm;vH k;/ wd kif;&if;om;vlrsdK;pkrsm;tm;vH k; yg0ifEk difaom Ek difiHa&;vrf;jyajryH k jzpfvmEk difa&;twGuf taotcsmjyefvnfqef;ppf&ef?
(6)(6)(6)(6)(6) (18)'DZifbm 2002 taxGaxGnDvmcHqH k;jzwfcsuf 57§23 t&vnf;aumif;/ (16){+yDv 2003(18)'DZifbm 2002 taxGaxGnDvmcHqH k;jzwfcsuf 57§23 t&vnf;aumif;/ (16){+yDv 2003(18)'DZifbm 2002 taxGaxGnDvmcHqH k;jzwfcsuf 57§23 t&vnf;aumif;/ (16){+yDv 2003(18)'DZifbm 2002 taxGaxGnDvmcHqH k;jzwfcsuf 57§23 t&vnf;aumif;/ (16){+yDv 2003(18)'DZifbm 2002 taxGaxGnDvmcHqHk;jzwfcsuf 57§23 t&vnf;aumif;/ (16){+yDv 2003vl @tcGif h ta&;aumfr&Sif qH k;jzwfcsuf 2003§12 t&vnf;aumif;/ xyfrHI jrefrmtpdk;&tm; atmufygvl @tcGif h ta&;aumfr&Sif qH k;jzwfcsuf 2003§12 t&vnf;aumif;/ xyfrHI jrefrmtpd k;&tm; atmufygvl @tcGif h ta&;aumfr&Sif qH k;jzwfcsuf 2003§12 t&vnf;aumif;/ xyfrHI jrefrmtpdk;&tm; atmufygvl @tcGif h ta&;aumfr&Sif qH k;jzwfcsuf 2003§12 t&vnf;aumif;/ xyfrHI jrefrmtpd k;&tm; atmufygvl@tcGifh ta&;aumfr&Sif qHk;jzwfcsuf 2003§12 t&vnf;aumif;/ xyfrHI jrefrmtpd k;&tm; atmufygtcsufrsm;ud k jyif;xefpGmwd kufwGef;tyfonf?tcsufrsm;ud k jyif;xefpGmwd kufwGef;tyfonf?tcsufrsm;ud k jyif;xefpGmwd kufwGef;tyfonf?tcsufrsm;ud k jyif;xefpGmwd kufwGef;tyfonf?tcsufrsm;udk jyif;xefpGmwd kufwGef;tyfonf?
(u)vGwfvyfonf hw&m;pD&ifa&;/ Oya'vkyfxk H;vkyfenf;rsm;ESif htnDaqmif&GufEd kifapa&;wd k @twGuf tmrcH&ef?
(c) vufrSwfa&;xd k;jcif; rðy&ao;aom Ek difiHwumvl @tcGif hta&;pmcsKyfpmwrf;rsm;tm; oabmwlvufrSwfa&;xd k;a&; OD;pm;ay;pOf;pm;&efESif h Ek difiHwumvl @tcGif hta&;pHcsdefpH!$ef;rsm;twd kif; vkyfaqmif&ef f?
(*) jrefrmppfwyftwGif;ESif h tcsdK@aom wd kif;&if;om;vufeufud kiftiftm;pkrsm;twGif; uav;ppfom;rsm;yg0ifaer_ESif h uav;ppfom;opf pkaqmif;aer_rsm;tm; csufjcif;&yfqk dif;ypf&ef/vufeufzsufodrf;a&;/ ppfr_xrf;tjzpfrS E_wfxGufcGif hjyKa&;/ wef;wl&nfwl jyefvnfaygif;pnf;a&;wd k @ud ktmrcH&ef/&nf&G,fcsuf&S d&S d t"rRae&ma&$ @ajymif;r_rsm;tm; tqH k;owf&ef/Ek difiHtwGif; xGufajy;wdrf;a&Smif ykef;cd kae&olrsm;ta&; tqH k;owf&efESif h tumtuG,fay;&ef/'kuQonfrsm; ae&yfod k @ rdrdoabmqENtavsmuf *k%foduQm&S dpGmESif h vH k+cHKpGmjyefvmEk difa&;twGufcGif hjyK&ef/
ud k,fcHtm;usqif;r_Ad kif;&yfpfyd k;ESif h ud k,fcHtm;usqif;r_a&m*g(HIV/AIDS)
wd kufzsufa&;wGufvk dtyfaomvkyfief;pOf rsm; csrSwftaumiftxnfazmf&ef?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 207/208
207
'kwd,t}udrf y%mrtpD&ifcHpm
(7) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfod k@ yef=um;csuf(7) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfod k @ yef=um;csuf(7) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfod k@ yef=um;csuf(7) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfod k @ yef=um;csuf(7) taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfodk @ yef=um;csuf
(u) trsdK;om;jyefvnf&if=um;apha&;wGifyg0ifywfoufaeaom tzG J @tpnf;rsm;ESif haomfvnf;aumif;/jrefrmjynfolrsm;ESif haomfvnf;aumif;/tpd k;&ESif haomfvnf;aumif;/'Drd kua&pDjyefvnfazmfaqmifa&;ESif h vl @tcGif h ta&;tajctaersm;ta=umif; qufvufaqG;aEG;vkyfaqmifoGm;yg&efESif h taxGaxG
twGif;a&;rª;csKyf. pGrf; aqmifEk difr_rsm;ESif h aqmif&Gufyk difcGif hrsm;ud k qufvuftoH k;jyKay;yg&ef?(c) ,ck qH k;jzwfcsufrsm;ESif hywfoufI taumiftxnfazmfaqmif&GufEk difonf hwd k;wufr_rsm;tm; t}udrf
(60)ajrmuf vl @ tcGif hta&;aumfr&Sif nDvmcHESif h (59)}udrfajrmuf taxGaxGnDvmcHod k @ tpD&ifcHpmwifjyay;yg&ef?
(*) ukvor*~taxGaxGtwGif;a&;rª;csKyfrS cef @tyfxm;aom txl;oHwref.yH hyd k;aqmif&Gufr_tcef;u¾Y‚if;.vkyfief;wm0efrsm; atmifjrifpGm tjynf ht0taumiftxnfazmfaqmif&GufEk dif&ef vd ktyfaomtultnDrsm; ay;yg&ef?
(C) vl @tcGif hta&;aumfr&Sif. txl;uk d,fpm;vS,ftm; ‚if;tm; tyfESif;xm;aom vkyfief;wm0efrsm; atmifjrifpGm tjynf ht0 taumiftxnfazmfvkyfaqmifEk dif&ef vd ktyfaomtultnDrsm;ay;yg&ef?
(8)(8)(8)(8)(8) jrefrmEd kifiHta&;udpPrsm;ESif h ywfoufI (59)}udrfajrmuf taxGaxGnDvmcH}uD;wGif xyfrHaq;GaEG;&efjrefrmEd kifiHta&;udpPrsm;ESif h ywfoufI (59)}udrfajrmuf taxGaxGnDvmcH}uD;wGif xyfrHaq;GaEG;&efjrefrmEd kifiHta&;udpPrsm;ESif h ywfoufI (59)}udrfajrmuf taxGaxGnDvmcH}uD;wGif xyfrHaq;GaEG;&efjrefrmEd kifiHta&;udpPrsm;ESif h ywfoufI (59)}udrfajrmuf taxGaxGnDvmcH}uD;wGif xyfrHaq;GaEG;&efjrefrmEd kifiHta&;udpPrsm;ESif h ywfoufI (59)}udrfajrmuf taxGaxGnDvmcH}uD;wGif xyfrHaq;GaEG;&efqHk;jzwfonf?qH k;jzwfonf?qHk;jzwfonf?qH k;jzwfonf?qH k;jzwfonf?
tar&duefEd kifiH e,l;a,mh(cf)òrd @Y usif;yaom ukvor*~taxGaxGnDvmcH}uD;rS2003 ckESpf 'DZifbmv 1 &ufaehwGif tzG J @0ifEk difiHrsm;tm;vk H;. oabmwlnDcsufjzif h qk H;jzwfonf?
8/14/2019 2004 Second Preliminary Report (Bur.)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/2004-second-preliminary-report-bur 208/208
'DyJ,if;vkyf}uHr+ ta&;,laqmif±Gufa&;aumfr&Sif
arv(30)&uf 2003 ckESpfY jzpfyG m;cJŒ aom'DyJ,if;jzpf&yfESif hpyfvsOf;I Ek difiHwumESif hyl;aygif;um
vGwfvyfaompk Hprf;ppfaq;r+rsm;uk d jynf hpk HpG m jyKvkyfoG m;&ef
To initiate a full and independent inquiry,
with international cooperation, into the Depayin
incident of 30 May 2003.
U it d N ti G l A bl