Upload File

1 m&v cx working group report new york city - m&v summit steve dunnivant - chair this...

  • Home
  • Documents
  • 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will
16
1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair

Upload: cornelia-stone

Post on 21-Jan-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

Report

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

1

M&V Cx Working Group Report

New York City - M&V Summit

Steve Dunnivant - Chair

Page 2: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

2

Objectives of Working Group

Mainstream Use of Commissioning into DOE SuperESPC Projects

Modify IDIQ Contract to address Commissioning Requirements

Expected Completion - 4th Quarter 2004

Page 3: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

3

Final Deliverable

Commissioning content recommendations to be incorporated into revision of IDIQ contracts.

Page 4: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

4

Current Status

Commissioning DO Guidance currently in use on selected projects to identify potential project impacts and improvements

Recent reviews show that ESCOs are participating in Cx

Page 5: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

5

NORESCO/GSA Project DES

Cx Plan Outline & Approach in Section III Site Mgt. approach

Plan Outline– Overview– Approach– Procedures– Documentation

Page 6: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

6

NORESCO/GSA Project DES

Commissioning Specification– Introduction– General Requirements– Electrical– Pneumatic– Programming and Software– Mechanical & Physical

Page 7: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

7

Alliant/Cogenex SSA (IP)

Retro-Cx Plan (DES Phase)– Systems (Cooling, Heating, Lighting) &

Outline of Project Steps– Cx Plan Requirements & Calibration &

Maintenance Checks– Monitoring & Testing (Analyze Data) &

Functional Testing– Final Commissioning Report (Contents)– Recommended Measures in DES Proposal– Roles & Responsibilities

Page 8: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

8

Sempra/FDA-GSA White Oak

Cx Provisions in DO-RFP (for base scope)

Cx only to central utility plant FDA-GSA added Cx scope

– Substation Failure req’d substation upgrade

– Life Sciences Building (awarded)– CEDR Offices (award pending)

• Expanded EMS tie-ins to Cx & M&V

Page 9: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

9

Accomplishments to Date

Adopted Cx Provisions for DO-RFP Cx Provisions in use for selected

projectsProject Management Plan (PMP) updated

(Fall ‘02)PMP Updated for Agency Witness (Spr

‘03)Cx Workshop for PF’s/ESCO’s (Spr ‘03)Project Mgt. Plan Updated ( Spr ‘03)

Page 10: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

10

Planned Actions

Review Draft ESPC Cx Guidelines - 1st Qtr FY04

Select Cx Pilot Project - 1st Qtr FY04Standardize Cx Report Requirements

2rd Qtr FY04Training of PF’s/ESCO’s - 3rd Qtr FY04Provide IDIQ contract input (4th Qtr

2003)

Page 11: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

11

Cx Workgroup Thursday Breakout AgendaReview & Discussion of Farnsworth

Task 5 (Doug D)Results of Meetings & Discussions

with ESCO’s (Farnsworth)Draft Guidelines - Outline of Cx

Guidelines & Key Points (Farnsworth)

Pilot Projects Discussion (Team)

Page 12: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

12

Team Members - Thanks!!

Agency - Labs - ESCO’s - SubsSylvia Berry-Lewis HoneywellCynthia Brockey APSESMichael Cross HQ Air ForceJerry Culbert Select EnergyCharles Culp Texas A&M Doug Dahle NREL

Page 13: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

13

Team Members - Cont...

Chad Dorgan FarnsworthChuck Dorgan FarnsworthJohn Evarts NorescoKristin Heinemeier Texas A&MMax Hogan NFESCMarc Jeanson Johnson ControlsJohn Johnson ConEd SolutionsRoger Johnson Farnsworth

Page 14: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

14

Team Members - Cont..

Scott Judson NORESCOVenkat Kumar Johnson

ControlsWill Lintner DOE-HQDarryl Matsui NFESCJay McCarroll APSESRobert McMillin SiemensWilson Reynolds EME

Page 15: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

15

Team Members - Cont..

Balaji Santhanakrishnan Texas A&M

Dale Sartor LBNLMargaret Selig Herlihy CorpTerry Sharp ORNLGary Snead TrigenMark Stetz Nexant, Inc.Dave Underwood USA CERL

Page 16: 1 M&V Cx Working Group Report New York City - M&V Summit Steve Dunnivant - Chair This presentation will probably involve audience discussion, which will

16

Team Members - Cont..

Mark Vilchuck Chevron Energy Solutions

Phil Voss NRELLia Webster Nexant, Inc.Yes - That’s 31! - Well actually 32

counting me...


Machine Learning for Health Informatics · 01/07/2019  · . 10 201 M 01 M 201 m M x m m M . B b ( :m. . 11 201 M 01 “v v v : :.bXb66Q128m54

Classical Mechanics Lecture 12 - Simon Fraser University · 2013-02-26 · Mechanics((Lecture(12,(Slide(13 + = CM m 1 m 2 v *m 2 1, f v 2, f m 1 v CM + + x m 1 m 2 v* 1,i v* 2,i =

2. V A & V A M

IR analysis for HBr,E0,V(m+4),V(m+5)

Hawkins v. Clayton Ors: Where There'sA Will There'sA Way · Hawkins v. Clayton & Ors: Where There'sA Will There'sA Way Karen M. Hogg* ... High Court'swillingness to allow recovery

COLLISIONS We use the Conservation of Momentum Law for Collisions: m 1 v 1i + m 2 v 2i = m 1 v 1f + m 2 v 2f

A.B. Maritime Aegean Cargo M/V Pollux (CS) M/V Sirius (CS) · PDF fileBoduroglu Kum Cakil Insaat M/V Bodyer (DC) Boeing M/V Boeing SBX-1 (DC) Boluda Grupo M/V Vero B (RoRo) Boluda

M-learning v/s M-Teaching

C[ · _r 7 $ 7 - -v1ubr| 7 t ;u 7 " = ; 0;;m 7; ; torbm] 1 v|ol om|;m| -m-];l;m| " v|;lv 7 m tbm; " u ; v -m7 m tbm; "|ou;v =ou lou; |_;m |;m ;-uv :

The Great War 1914- 1918 m/watch?v=i2CgUIrBHoo m/watch?v=i2CgUIrBHoo m/watch?v=i2CgUIrBHoo

M V s ç - Sendai...M V s ç A

15 - sitashri.com · ‘w§~B©, ewH«dma, 10 OyZ 2016 U 7 _of … _ m Z { g H V m U V U m d O m U { d Ê ` m M r e Š ` V m a m h V o. n yd ©{ Z ` m o{ O V à d m g m V H m h r

M 'v*f,m '- J

BACK LANE - Vancouver · hhhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhhhh hhhhhhhh h hhhhhhh hhhhh hhhh hh h h m m m m m m m m m m m m V V VV V V V V V VVVVV VV V V V V V V V V V V VVV VVV VV V VV V V V V

M&V Part 3: FEMP M&V Methods. 3-2 FEMP M&V Methods Ø Definition of Savings Ø FEMP M&V Guidelines Ø Examples & Applications

FR:POLOSATOV M V TO:SIEVERTS E · Title: FR:POLOSATOV M V TO:SIEVERTS E Subject: FR:POLOSATOV M V TO:SIEVERTS E Keywords

PBFT: The Setup A Byzantine Renaissance › ~lorenzo › corsi › cs380d › ...1,v,n) (m 2,v,n) (m,v,n) m m v n 2f (m,v,n) n m v P-certificates are not enough A P-certificate proves

V T V TV TV Sk1 2,5 m Sk1 3,5 m V Sk1 3,5 m TV...Sk1 3,5 m Sk1 3,5 m Sk1 6 m Sk1 6 m Sk1 3,5m Sk7 V 1 V 1 V 1 T 1, T 2 V 1 V 1 V 1 V i 1, T 1, T 2 T 1, T 2 T 1, T 2 T 1, T 2 Sk7 Sk7

M&V Part 4: M&V Plan Review. 4-2 M&V Plan Review Ø FEMP Documents F M&V Overview Checklist (Phase 2) F Final M&V Plan Checklist (Phase 3) Ø Risk & Responsibility

ý !)½v V 1 r Í · 2014-08-19 · r % ± 1+ a ± ý !)½v V 1 M ¹ %)½v V 1 þ )½v V 1 )(M a ± }v a ± y(M)½v V 1 *µ a ±)½v Ý >%1 % r º m ! M ¹ % V 1 æ Í y ± ¼ Æ

Rdia v-m-v

ý`M V M®, ¯p Ô w V M !QoMVhM

E an T E M T L O V M V U M DV - Greenlee

STELLATE GANGLION BLOCK - PatientPopStellate Ganglion Block t Z Z v µ ] v P v ] v i } v M A local anesthetic will be used to numb your skin. The doctor will then insert a thin needle

R r vv r m R r v v v v r r v m V v r v v r v Oblique FAUST Clustering P R = P (X dot d)a D m R m V = oblique vector. d=D/|D| midpoints of means (mom)

V W WslSlsllvvlul m m Si- INDEPENDENT · L-i r I--HE 1 1 v 3rWli t ii L V v HI W WslSlsllvvlul m m tm lL9 k--B Vol XV H 17 r Tho Fino Pnsaongor Steamers of This Lino Will Arrive and

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT VASILEV, V. - VASILEVA, M. · Title: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT VASILEV, V. - VASILEVA, M. Subject: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT VASILEV, V. - VASILEVA, M. Keywords: VASILEV V

A -~ (V~~~&m%) V

M V s ç - Sendai · M V s ç ° A [ !!!!!"""""#####!"#$% &'($%)*+($%,-./ 01+

M V s ç...M V s ç A [

OCA RESULTS BOOKS...M SIHARATH Kitsada 19 MAY 1992 v M SOUVANNAMETHY Bounpathom 22 JUN 1989 v v M VANNASOUK Paseuthsack 5 SEP 1985 v v v MAS - Malaysia M ABDUL WAHAB Mohd Faizal 2

Communication - Dinabandhu Andrews College · A V c v m V c V m sin Z m t V c mV c sin Z m t V c (1 msin Z m t) where, c m V V m is called the modulation index. The instantaneous

M v. M H. W

G = ( (u 1,n) r e u 1,n M n,..., (u L,n) r e u L,n M n,..., (v,m 1 ) r e v,m 1 U v,..., v,m L R e (v,m L ) U v ) d/dt( (U u +tG u )(M m

D L M M J V S D L M M J V S D L M M J V S