1

Ensuring a 'Flexible Use of Airspace'….Ensuring a 'Flexible Use of Airspace'….

Patrick DelmouzéeHead of ATM UnitDSS/CMEUROCONTROL

Moving towards an Integrated ASM/ATFCM/ATS Approach

EUROCONTROL HQ, 20-21 Sep 2012

Current ASM processCurrent ASM process

2

Flexible Use of Airspace (FUA) Concept

Flexible use of airspace is an airspace management concept described by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) and developed by the European Organisation for the Safety of Air Navigation (Eurocontrol), according to which airspace should not be designated as either purely civil or purely military airspace, but should rather be considered as one continuum in which all users’ requirements have to be accommodated to the maximum extent possible.

3

ASM process Network Manager

National AMC

Mili

tary

plan

ning

NEGOTIATION

Military UsersCivil Service Providers

Civil usersCivil demand

Network Consistency

NATIONAL PLAN

4

Enablers at Local, FAB and Network level

• Consistent Airspace Data

• National AMCs

• Sharing airspace demands at regular times(from snapshots to rolling airspace plans)

• Collaborative Decision Making (CDM)

• System support

5

Ensuring a 'Flexible Use of Airspace'….Ensuring a 'Flexible Use of Airspace'….

Current ASM/ATFCMCurrent ASM/ATFCM

ANDERS HALLGRENManager ASM proceduresDNM/COO/NOM/OPL/PROEUROCONTROL

Moving towards an Integrated ASM/ATFCM/ATS Approach

EUROCONTROL HQ, 20-21 Sep 2012

Processes and Interfaces

6

Click to edit Master title styleExploit airspace

availabilityConsistent

application of FUA

Safe, efficient and accurate

data flows

Rolling UUPProcedure 2&3EAWCDR network TRA/TSA clarification

FL publication CBA designationSupport StakeholdersCDR inconsistencies

B2BNOP portalCIAMASM Support Systems

ASM Improvements Initiative

7

Click to edit Master title styleDeliverables Achieved

8

Click to edit Master title styleImproved Processes and Procedures

Procedure 1: –At pre-tactical level assess impact by

expected airspace allocation

• Procedure 2: –Better exploitation of airspace

opportunities on the day of operation

9

Click to edit Master title styleImproved Processes and Procedures

Procedure 3– Enhanced flexibility on the day of operations

• ATCO: – Tactical rerouting Rerouting via IFPS reprocessing

= lower workload

• AO: – less overbooking on D-1 more capacity, – predictability, – less tactical actions by air crew

10

Click to edit Master title style2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

UUP 2

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

FPLsReact (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

CF

MU

EN

V

Database U

pdate

eAUP

Coo

rdin

ation

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

11

Click to edit Master title style2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

Coo

rdin

ation

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

UUP 2

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

FPLsReact (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

CF

MU

EN

V

Database U

pdate

eAUP

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

Network impact assessment

Coordination

12

Click to edit Master title style2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

FPLsC

FM

U E

NV

D

atabase U

pdate

eAUP

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

UUP 2

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

React (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

Coo

rdin

ation

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

CFMU ENV Database Update

eAUP

FPLs

13

Click to edit Master title style

UUP 2

2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

FPLsReact (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

CF

MU

EN

V

Database U

pdate

eAUP

Coo

rdin

ation

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

UUP 1 UUP 2

14

Click to edit Master title style2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

UUP 2

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

FPLsReact (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

CF

MU

EN

V

Database U

pdate

eAUP

Coo

rdin

ation

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

Notification Notification

15

Click to edit Master title style2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

UUP 2

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

FPLsReact (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

CF

MU

EN

V

Database U

pdate

eAUP

Coo

rdin

ation

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

Rerouting Proposals

to AOs

Rerouting Proposals

to AOs

16

Click to edit Master title style2012 ASM/ATFCM Process

Airspace

Users

AMCs

FMP

AO

Draft AUP

Time

Axis(Summer) 14.00 15.00

15.00-16.00

17.00 17.1512.00 09.00 09.15

Netw

ork im

pact

assessm

ent

NM

AUP

12.00-13.00

UUP 1

Notification

UUP 2

Notification

Earlier area

deactivation

Coordin. with other

Users

D-1 D

Final airspace Request

> 12.00

Earlier area

deactivation

>08.00

FPLsReact (CGH, CNL or

new FPL)

Rerouting Proposals to AOs

17.15> 09.15>

React (CGH, CNL

or new FPL)

Coordin. with AMC

CFMU ENV

UpdateRerouting Proposals to AOs

CFMU ENV

Update

Coordin. with other

Users

Coordin. with AMC

Final CDR

Request

CF

MU

EN

V

Database U

pdate

eAUP

Coo

rdin

ation

Draft UUP 1 N

etwo

rk an

d Lo

cal a

ssessm

en

ts

16.0016.00-17.00

Coordination w

ith Users

08.00

Draft UUP

2

08.00-09.00

Netw

ork a

nd

Loca

l asse

ssme

nts

Coordination w

ith Users

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Coordination w

ith A

MC

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

Requests fine-tuning

(D)

13.00-14.00

React (CHG, CNL

or new FPL)

React (CHG, CNL

or new FPL)

17

Click to edit Master title styleUUP PUBLICATION D-1

16.00 17.00 18.00 19.00 20.00 06.00

D-1 D-OPS

Winter time

18

Click to edit Master title styleUUP PUBLICATION D-OPS

07.00 08.00 09.00 10.00 11.00 12.00 20.00

D-OPS

Winter time

19

Click to edit Master title style

CDR number of segments

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

CDR2

CDR1/2

CDR1

CDR Network

20

Click to edit Master title styleUptake CDRs

CDR segments used

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

21

Click to edit Master title style

UUP vs. AUP CDR1 closure time reduction

-200

-175

-150

-125

-100

-75

-50

-25

0

25

Dec

-01

Dec

-02

Dec

-03

Dec

-04

Dec

-05

Dec

-06

Dec

-07

Dec

-08

Dec

-09

Dec

-10

Dec

-11

Dec

-12

Dec

-13

Dec

-14

Dec

-15

Dec

-16R

edu

ced

ho

urs

of

clo

sure

Rolling UUP

22

Click to edit Master title style

UUP vs. AUP CDR2 opening time increase

-2000

-1750

-1500

-1250

-1000

-750

-500

-250

0

250

Dec

-01

Dec

-02

Dec

-03

Dec

-04

Dec

-05

Dec

-06

Dec

-07

Dec

-08

Dec

-09

Dec

-10

Dec

-11

Dec

-12

Dec

-13

Dec

-14

Dec

-15

Dec

-16In

crea

sed

hour

s of

ope

ning

Rolling UUP

23

Click to edit Master title styleUUP Publication March 2012UUP Publication March 2012

Not Using CIAM

Using UUP

Not Using UUP

24

Click to edit Master title styleImproved Economies

166592

262342

233066

257104

278695

0

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

300000

Tons

fuel

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

CDR fuel savings

25

Click to edit Master title styleEnvironmental Benefits

524765

826058

734977

809875868657

0

100000

200000

300000

400000

500000

600000

700000

800000

900000

Tons

CO

2

2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

CDR CO2 emissions savings

26

Click to edit Master title styleEnsuring a 'Flexible Use of Airspace'….

Thank you for attention!