zoonotic disease in australia caused by a novel member of the

7
112 Zoonotic Disease in Australia Caused by a Novel Member of the Paramyxoviridae David L. Paterson, P. Keith Murray, and From the Infectious Disease Section, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; and the Commonwealth Scientific and Joseph G. McCormack Industrial Research Organization (CSIRO) Australian Animal Health Laboratory, Geelong, Victoria, and the Department of Infectious Diseases, Mater Misericordiae Hospital, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia Twenty-three horses and three humans in Queensland, Australia, were infected with a novel member of the Paramyxoviridae family of viruses in two geographically distinct outbreaks. Two of the humans died — one died of rapid-onset respiratory illness, and the other died of encephalitis. The third infected human developed an influenza-like illness and made a complete recovery. All infected humans had close contact with sick horses. Since the two outbreaks occurred at sites 1,000 km apart and no known contact between the two groups of humans and horses occurred, extensive testing of animals and birds common to the two areas was conducted. Fruit bats (Pteropus species) were found to carry a virus identical to that found in the infected humans and horses. Although there was no contact between the infected humans and the bats, some form of close contact between the horses and bats is the likely mode of infection. A new member of the virus family Paramyxoviridae, coined abrasions on his hands and arms. In all, 18 horses at the stables became ill, and 14 died. Three horses were subsequently found the equine morbillivirus, which has recently been described in to be seropositive for the virus but were asymptomatic. Australia [1–5, 5a], appears to truly qualify as a cause of an After 4 days of nonspecific symptoms (myalgia, lethargy, emerging infectious disease. It is an infection that has newly sore throat, and headaches), the horse trainer developed nausea, appeared in a population and thus fulfills one of the criteria vomiting, dyspnea, dry cough, and finally, respiratory compro- for an emerging infectious disease as described by Morse [6]. mise necessitating mechanical ventilation. Physical examina- The occurrence of this infectious disease demonstrates that the tion revealed that he was markedly hypoxemic, and there was zoonotic pool appears to be by no means exhausted [6]. The diffuse alveolar shadowing on a chest radiograph (figure 2). disease mysteriously appeared in the state of Queensland, Aus- Laboratory investigations revealed thrombocytopenia (platelet tralia (figure 1), in the latter half of 1994 and has been responsi- count, 46 1 10 9 /L), mild hepatitis (aspartate aminotransferase ble for the deaths of two humans and 16 horses. We describe level, 128 U/L [normal range, 2 – 40 U/L]; alanine aminotrans- the clinical presentation of human infection with this virus and ferase level, 61 U/L [normal range, 2 – 40 U/L]), and elevated the subsequent seroepidemiological studies that were con- levels of lactate dehydrogenase (672 U/L; normal range, 100 – ducted. Although our aim is to concentrate on the clinical 200 U/L) and creatine phosphokinase (2,227 U/L; normal aspects of this infection, new developments in the taxonomy range, 10 – 60 U/L). of the virus will be described briefly. The initial differential diagnosis included legionellosis, viral pneumonitis, pneumococcal pneumonia, melioidosis, glanders, Case Reports and paraquat poisoning. Empirical therapy with erythromycin and rifampin (for possible legionellosis), penicillin (for possible Patient 1. A previously healthy 49-year-old male horse pneumococcal pneumonia), and ceftazidime (for possible glan- trainer became ill in September 1994 [1 – 3]. A number of ders or melioidosis) was begun. Cultures of sputum, blood, horses in the stables at which he worked had recently become and bronchial washings, obtained before initiation of antibiotic ill, with loss of appetite, dyspnea, and a copious frothy nasal therapy, were negative for bacterial pathogens. Immunofluo- discharge. The horse trainer had had percutaneous exposure to rescence assays of bronchial washings and serum were negative nasal and oral secretions from the first sick horse via numerous for Legionella species. Despite antibiotic therapy and the addi- tion of methylprednisolone to the regimen, the patient’s respira- tory and renal function deteriorated. Arterial thrombosis devel- oped in his right leg. After 7 days of intensive therapy, and Received 20 August 1997; revised 19 February 1998. despite some improvement in respiratory function, he devel- Reprints or correspondence: Dr. David L. Paterson, Infectious Disease Sec- tion, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, University Drive C, Pittsburgh, Pennsyl- oped cardiac arrhythmias and died. vania 15240. Autopsy revealed congested, hemorrhagic lungs. Micro- Clinical Infectious Diseases 1998; 27:112 – 8 scopic examination of the lungs revealed foci of necrotizing q 1998 by the Infectious Diseases Society of America. All rights reserved. 1058–4838/98/2701 – 0023$03.00 alveolitis with giant cells, some syncytial formation, and viral / 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 November 2018

Upload: others

Post on 22-Feb-2022

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

112

Zoonotic Disease in Australia Caused by a Novel Member of theParamyxoviridae

David L. Paterson, P. Keith Murray, and From the Infectious Disease Section, Veterans Affairs Medical Center,Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; and the Commonwealth Scientific andJoseph G. McCormackIndustrial Research Organization (CSIRO) Australian Animal Health

Laboratory, Geelong, Victoria, and the Department ofInfectious Diseases, Mater Misericordiae Hospital, Brisbane,

Queensland, Australia

Twenty-three horses and three humans in Queensland, Australia, were infected with a novelmember of the Paramyxoviridae family of viruses in two geographically distinct outbreaks. Two ofthe humans died—one died of rapid-onset respiratory illness, and the other died of encephalitis.The third infected human developed an influenza-like illness and made a complete recovery.All infected humans had close contact with sick horses. Since the two outbreaks occurred at sites1,000 km apart and no known contact between the two groups of humans and horses occurred,extensive testing of animals and birds common to the two areas was conducted. Fruit bats (Pteropusspecies) were found to carry a virus identical to that found in the infected humans and horses.Although there was no contact between the infected humans and the bats, some form of closecontact between the horses and bats is the likely mode of infection.

A new member of the virus family Paramyxoviridae, coined abrasions on his hands and arms. In all, 18 horses at the stablesbecame ill, and 14 died. Three horses were subsequently foundthe equine morbillivirus, which has recently been described into be seropositive for the virus but were asymptomatic.Australia [1–5, 5a], appears to truly qualify as a cause of an

After 4 days of nonspecific symptoms (myalgia, lethargy,emerging infectious disease. It is an infection that has newlysore throat, and headaches), the horse trainer developed nausea,appeared in a population and thus fulfills one of the criteriavomiting, dyspnea, dry cough, and finally, respiratory compro-for an emerging infectious disease as described by Morse [6].mise necessitating mechanical ventilation. Physical examina-The occurrence of this infectious disease demonstrates that thetion revealed that he was markedly hypoxemic, and there waszoonotic pool appears to be by no means exhausted [6]. Thediffuse alveolar shadowing on a chest radiograph (figure 2).disease mysteriously appeared in the state of Queensland, Aus-Laboratory investigations revealed thrombocytopenia (platelettralia (figure 1), in the latter half of 1994 and has been responsi-count, 46 1 109/L), mild hepatitis (aspartate aminotransferaseble for the deaths of two humans and 16 horses. We describelevel, 128 U/L [normal range, 2–40 U/L]; alanine aminotrans-the clinical presentation of human infection with this virus andferase level, 61 U/L [normal range, 2–40 U/L]), and elevatedthe subsequent seroepidemiological studies that were con-levels of lactate dehydrogenase (672 U/L; normal range, 100–ducted. Although our aim is to concentrate on the clinical200 U/L) and creatine phosphokinase (2,227 U/L; normalaspects of this infection, new developments in the taxonomyrange, 10–60 U/L).of the virus will be described briefly.

The initial differential diagnosis included legionellosis, viralpneumonitis, pneumococcal pneumonia, melioidosis, glanders,

Case Reports and paraquat poisoning. Empirical therapy with erythromycinand rifampin (for possible legionellosis), penicillin (for possiblePatient 1. A previously healthy 49-year-old male horsepneumococcal pneumonia), and ceftazidime (for possible glan-trainer became ill in September 1994 [1–3]. A number ofders or melioidosis) was begun. Cultures of sputum, blood,horses in the stables at which he worked had recently becomeand bronchial washings, obtained before initiation of antibioticill, with loss of appetite, dyspnea, and a copious frothy nasaltherapy, were negative for bacterial pathogens. Immunofluo-discharge. The horse trainer had had percutaneous exposure torescence assays of bronchial washings and serum were negativenasal and oral secretions from the first sick horse via numerousfor Legionella species. Despite antibiotic therapy and the addi-tion of methylprednisolone to the regimen, the patient’s respira-tory and renal function deteriorated. Arterial thrombosis devel-oped in his right leg. After 7 days of intensive therapy, andReceived 20 August 1997; revised 19 February 1998.despite some improvement in respiratory function, he devel-Reprints or correspondence: Dr. David L. Paterson, Infectious Disease Sec-

tion, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, University Drive C, Pittsburgh, Pennsyl- oped cardiac arrhythmias and died.vania 15240.

Autopsy revealed congested, hemorrhagic lungs. Micro-Clinical Infectious Diseases 1998;27:112–8 scopic examination of the lungs revealed foci of necrotizingq 1998 by the Infectious Diseases Society of America. All rights reserved.1058–4838/98/2701–0023$03.00 alveolitis with giant cells, some syncytial formation, and viral

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018

113CID 1998;27 (July) New Virus in Australia

pest, like measles and canine distemper viruses, is a memberof the genus Morbillivirus, family Paramyxoviridae. Rinderpestvirus antisera gave a very weak reaction by western blot butdid not neutralize the virus [3]. However, on the basis of thisweak reaction, primer pairs were designed to amplify regionsfrom the matrix, fusion, or L proteins of morbilliviruses. Withuse of PCR, the matrix protein primer pair amplified a 400-bpproduct. This product was sequenced.

A pair of primers (5*-CATGTAGATGCCGGAGTCAT and5*-TTGTGTTCGGGTCCTCTGGC) was designed to be spe-cific for this amplified product. These primers gave a specificproduct of Ç200 bp when the equine viral RNA and the virusisolated from the kidney of the human case were used. Se-quence analysis revealed that PCR products from the virusesisolated from the horses and the patient were identical. Thissequence had Ç50% similarity with the matrix proteins ofmorbilliviruses. The sequence was quite different from that ofthe original Rinderpest virus used in the initial immunologictesting. Phylogenetic analyses of the matrix protein sequencesindicated that the newly discovered virus was distantly relatedto other known Paramyxoviridae.

Figure 1. Map of Australia and Papua New Guinea, showing the Serological testing with use of a serum neutralization test andlocations of the two outbreaks in Queensland (Brisbane and Mackay).

immunofluorescence was developed. Neutralizing antibodies toBats infected with the novel virus have been detected in Brisbanethe novel virus were detectable in the patient’s serum during hisand Mackay as well as Madang, Darwin (Northern Territory), and

Melbourne (Victoria).

inclusions (figure 3). Serology for a comprehensive range ofrespiratory viruses (including hantaviruses, arboviruses, andHIV) and for Leptospira species, Coxiella burnetti, and Burk-holderia pseudomallei was negative [1].

Lung, liver, kidney, and spleen samples obtained at autopsywere inoculated onto Vero, LLC-MK2 (rhesus monkey kidneycells), and MRC5 (human fetal lung cells) cell lines at theCentre for Public Health Sciences in Brisbane, Queensland,Australia. After 12 days, the MRC5 and LLC-MK2 cell linesinoculated with kidney material exhibited prominent syncytia.Virus had already been isolated from the tissues of the affectedhorses at the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial ResearchOrganization (CSIRO) Australian Animal Health Laboratory,Geelong, Victoria, Australia [2, 7]. Molecular, electron micro-scopic, and serological analyses of the human isolate showedit to be identical to the equine isolates. Electron microscopicexamination of the cultured virus revealed a pleomorphic, enve-loped virus, ranging in size from 38 nm to 600 nm. The enve-lope had a double-fringed appearance because of coverage with10-nm and 18-nm surface projections. Free-lying herringbone-shaped nucleocapsids, 18 nm wide with a periodicity of 5 nm,were seen [8].

As these observations were consistent with the appearanceof a member of the family Paramyxoviridae, the virus wastested against antisera to these viruses. With use of immuno- Figure 2. Chest radiograph of patient 1 at the time of his infectionfluorescence and protein immunoblot analyses, all antisera ex- with a new member of the Paramyxoviridae. Reprinted with permis-

sion from the Medical Journal of Australia [1].cept that to Rinderpest virus gave negative reactions. Rinder-

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018

114 Paterson, Murray, and McCormack CID 1998;27 (July)

and anxiety, he has remained well after ú2 years of follow-up. Examination of blood obtained in May 1996 showed that hecontinued to have significant levels of neutralizing antibodies inhis serum (titer, 1:160) but that there was no evidence of viralgenetic material by PCR.

Patient 3. A 36-year-old male developed aseptic meningi-tis in August 1994 [4, 5]. He was a sugar cane farmer wholived on a horse stud in Mackay, Queensland, Australia. Thiscity is Ç1,000 km (600 miles) north of Brisbane (figure 1).The man had cared for and assisted in the autopsies of twohorses that had become ill several weeks before he developedmeningitis. Like patient 1, he had several abrasions on hislimbs related to the physical nature of his occupation. Stored,formalin-fixed tissue specimens obtained from the horses wereretrospectively found to be infected with the novel member ofthe Paramyxoviridae [9]. Neither the horses nor this patient hadrecently been in Brisbane. There was no known link betweenpatients 1 and 2 and this patient, nor had his horses been incontact with the horses described in the first case.

The initial illness in August 1994 consisted of 12 days of sorethroat, malaise, headache, anorexia, and vomiting. Physicalexamination revealed a drowsy but rousable man with a stiffneck. A CT of the brain was normal. Two courses of oralantibiotics had been given during the initial course of his ill-ness. Examination of CSF, obtained by lumbar puncture duringoral antibiotic therapy, revealed a WBC count of 560 1

Figure 3. Postmortem lung tissue from patient 1 showing necrotiz- 106/L (82% polymorphonuclear cells). The CSF protein leveling alveolitis with giant cells, syncytia viral inclusions (A), and syncy- was elevated (1.82 g/L), but the glucose level was normal.tia (B). Reprinted with permission from the Medical Journal of Aus-

Bacterial and viral cultures of CSF were negative. A diagnosistralia [1].of partially treated bacterial meningitis was made, and the pa-tient was given intravenous ceftriaxone and benzylpenicillinfor 10 days. He made a full recovery.respiratory illness but not in stored serum obtained in May 1994.

It was determined that serum samples (from horses that had The patient had an exacerbation of long-standing low backpain after his meningitic illness, and in January 1995 he under-recovered from the infection), which were able to neutralize the

newly described virus, also neutralized virus isolated from the went an uncomplicated left lumbosacral laminectomy and nerveroot decompression, with relief of his symptoms. After thisfirst patient [2, 3]. Furthermore, immunoelectronmicroscopy re-

vealed that the virus from the patient reacted with serum from procedure, he had a mild nonproductive cough that persistedfor 3 months, but he was otherwise asymptomatic and returnedrecovered horses and the serum samples from the patient [8].

Homogenates of spleen and lung from the dead horses were to work. He became ill again in September 1995, when hereported a 2-week history of irritable mood and recurrent backused to determine if other horses could be infected [2]. Two

healthy horses, at a different geographic location, were given pain. He then had three focal motor seizures involving hisright arm, followed by his first generalized tonic-clonic seizure.intravenous or nebulized tissue homogenates. After a little over

1 week, they developed high fevers and respiratory illnesses. Findings on a CT of the brain were reportedly normal, andCSF obtained by lumbar puncture contained 440 1 106The virus was isolated from lungs, liver, kidneys, and lymph

nodes of these experimental horses. WBCs/L, 9% of which were polymorphonuclear cells.The CSF glucose level was normal, but the protein levelPatient 2. A previously well, 40-year-old male stablehand

became ill at the same time as the outbreak mentioned above was again elevated at 0.88 g/L. Bacterial and viral cultures werenegative. Serology for all viruses known to cause neurological[1–3]. He developed myalgia, sore throat, headaches, lethargy,

and vertigo. He had no cough, chest pain, or dyspnea. The illnesses in Australia, including Japanese encephalitis, Austra-lian encephalitis, Kunjin, Alfuy, Kokobera, Stratford, and Edgeresults of physical examination, chest radiography, a biochemi-

cal examination, and hematologic examination were normal. Hill viruses, was negative.Fevers, frequent focal motor seizures and generalized tonic-He did not require hospitalization and made a complete recov-

ery. Neutralizing antibodies were detected in his serum 10 and clonic seizures, and altered consciousness followed. There wereno respiratory symptoms or signs. Penicillin, ceftazidime, tri-20 days after the onset of his illness. Apart from some fatigue

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018

115CID 1998;27 (July) New Virus in Australia

methoprim-sulfamethoxazole, iv acyclovir (10 mg/kg every 8 was also positive. An ELISA, developed at the CSIRO Austra-lian Animal Health Laboratory by Dr. P. Selleck, was alsohours), and dexamethasone were given, without improvement

in the patient’s condition. An MRI study of the brain initially positive. A PCR assay of CSF from September 1995 revealeda product of identical molecular weight to that of the productrevealed subtle multifocal cortical changes, with marked deteri-

oration and progression of his illness (figure 4). He died 25 from the clinical specimens obtained from patient 1. Sequenc-ing of this product revealed it to be identical to the productdays after admission to the hospital.

CSF obtained during his initial illness in August 1994 was obtained from patient 1 and to that from the horses affected inthat outbreak [5].not available. Serum collected in August 1994 was positive for

neutralizing antibodies to the novel member of the Paramyxo- Autopsy revealed mild interstitial pneumonitis, with endo-thelial cell multinucleation in the liver, spleen, and lungs [5].viridae described in the first case report. Although the titer of

antibodies was low (1:4), it was quite specific, since screening Examination of the brain and meninges revealed lymphocyticleptomeningitis. Foci of necrosis were seen in the neocortex,of several hundred serum samples from individuals who had

had close contact with the infected horses or the patients pro- basal ganglia, brainstem, and cerebellum. Occasional multinu-cleated endothelial cells were seen in the brain. Immunohisto-vided completely negative results (titer, 1:2). A nested PCR

assay of this patient’s serum sample was also positive. Epide- chemistry of brain tissue with use of rabbit antiserum to thenovel member of the Paramyxoviridae was positive. Electronmiologically and microbiologically, therefore, it seems that he

acquired the infection from the two sick horses, which were microscopy also showed aggregates of nucleocapsids withinthe neurons, and these nucleocapsids reacted with serum fromalso positive. Evidently the virus had remained latent until his

second illness in September 1995. Serum samples obtained at the recovered horses, as visualized by immunoelectronmicros-copy [8].this time showed a marked rise in titer compared with those

obtained during the 1994 illness. Indirect immunofluorescence

Seroepidemiologic Studies

In view of the high attack rate among the horses describedin the first case report and the patient’s rapidly fatal illness,there was considerable concern about spread to the rest of thehuman population. This concern escalated with the death ofpatient 3. The results of serological testing of humans who havehad contact with horses has been presented by McCormack etal. [10]. Fifteen individuals who had had contact with the in-fected horses at postmortems were tested serologically andwere negative. Six others who had had close contact with thesick horses in Brisbane or Mackay and 113 individuals whohad had lesser contact with the horses were also seronegative.

Concern was also expressed that the virus could be transmit-ted to health care workers in the course of their duties. Onehundred fifty-nine health care workers who had had varyinglevels of contact with the patients in cases 1 and 3 were sero-negative [10].

Since it was speculated that the new virus might have anatural host in a native animal species, particularly one thatmight be capable of migrating between the two outbreak sitesor be present at both sites, widespread testing of animal popula-tions was performed. More than 2,000 horses were tested andwere negative. More than 5,000 serum samples from 46 otherspecies were tested and were also negative [11, 12]. However,subsequent investigations revealed that 20 of 224 serum sam-ples from four species of Australian bats (belonging to thesuborder Megachiroptera) were positive for neutralizing anti-bodies to the newly described member of the Paramyxoviridae[13, 13a]. In September 1996, a paramyxovirus was isolatedfrom a grey-headed flying fox (Pteropus poliocephalus), whichFigure 4. Axial T2-weighted MRI scan of the brain of patient 3 onwas closely related, if not identical, to the previously describedday 14 of his fatal encephalitic illness. Reprinted with permission

from Lancet [5]. virus [13]. As a result, concern was expressed that humans

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018

116 Paterson, Murray, and McCormack CID 1998;27 (July)

handling bats might be at risk of acquiring the virus [14]. At family, with the exception of the P gene, which is larger. Inaddition, the order of genes is identical (figure 6) [15]. On theleast 70% of bat handlers have reported being bitten by bats,

and 88% have reported being scratched, raising concern about other hand, the sequence of the genome is substantially differ-ent from that of the genomes of other members of the Paramyx-parenteral exposure to bat secretions. One hundred twenty-

eight bat handlers were tested for antibodies to the virus, and ovirinae [15].On the basis of these findings, it has been suggested thatall were negative [14]. As many of these people had cared for

sick bats, and many had cared for bats for a considerable time, this virus should be included as a new genus within the familyParamyxoviridae, subfamily Paramyxovirinae [5a]. It appearsit would seem that transmission of the virus between bats and

humans must be extremely rare, if it occurs at all. to occupy a taxonomic place between the morbillivirus andparamyxovirus genera. Since its genome is larger than thoseThe results of serologic studies of humans and animals are

summarized in table 1. of all other members of the Paramyxoviridae, one suggestionhas been to call the genus megamyxovirus and to term thevirus itself, Hendra virus, after the suburb of Brisbane in whichthe first outbreak occurred [6, 15].Taxonomy of the Virus

Although the virus was originally termed equine morbillivi-Discussionrus, it now appears that it is not a morbillivirus at all. Antisera

to known morbilliviruses do not neutralize the virus or react No other human infections with the virus have been diag-with infected cells in immunofluorescence tests [3]. The surface nosed since September 1995. It appears that all human andprojections of known morbilliviruses are Ç15 nm in length, equine cases became medically evident at around the samebut the new virus possesses surface projections of two distinct time (table 2). The two clusters of infection occurred Ç1,000lengths, 15 nm and 18 nm (figure 5) [8]. Although the genome km apart, and there was no contact between the horses andof the new virus (figure 6) has an overall structure identical to humans associated with the Brisbane outbreak and those associ-that of the morbilliviruses, sequence homology between the ated with the Mackay outbreak. However, it was always consid-new virus and the known morbilliviruses is limited [5a, 15]. ered that there was a potential wildlife reservoir that could beHowever, sequence analyses have shown that the virus is widely distributed. The isolation of a closely related virus inclearly a member of the Paramyxovirinae subfamily. Further- fruit bats raises the likelihood that this mobile species of nonter-more, morphologically, it is enveloped, pleomorphic, and cov- restrial mammal was the link between the two outbreaks. How-ered with surface projections and contains herringbone-shaped ever, it is not known how the virus crossed from bats intonucleocapsids, just like other Paramyxoviridae [3, 8]. Charac- horses. Horses may have grazed into bat-excrement-contami-terization of its proteins by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis nated areas under fruit trees or have been scratched or contami-show that its structural proteins resemble those of other Para- nated by an infected bat. The occurrence of outbreaks frommyxoviridae [5a]. August to October, which coincides with the birthing season

However, the size of the genome of the virus is significantly for fruit bats, together with the observation that the virus canlarger (ú18 kb) than that of other members of the Paramyxovir- be isolated from uterine fluids [13a], suggest that horses mayinae (ranging from 15 kb to 16.5 kb) [16]. This larger genome have been infected from contact with parturient bats. A novelis due to the significantly larger intergenic sequences seen in lyssavirus has recently been described in these bats [16]. There-the new virus. In contrast, the size of the genes of the new fore, another intriguing possibility is that a neurologically dam-virus is very similar to that of the genes of other viruses in the aged bat may have transmitted infection to the horses.

Transmission of the virus from horses to humans appearsmost likely to be through extensive contact with infectious

Table 1. Results of serological studies used to test for a new member respiratory secretions. Both patients who died had breaches inof the Paramyxoviridae in humans and animals. skin integrity that may have been portals of entry. The lack

of transmission to those conducting autopsies on the horsesSerum neutralizing antibodydescribed in the first case report or to the health care workers

Subjects No. (%) positive No. (%) negative involved in both cases argues against frank droplet transmis-sion. Standard precautions would appear to be sufficient to

Humans in close contact prevent transmission within health care facilities.with sick or dead horses 3 (2.2) 134 (97.8)

It is of interest that previously unrecognized Paramyxoviri-Humans in contact withdae that have affected marine mammals—phocine distemperother human cases 0 159 (100)

Humans in contact with bats 0 128 (100) virus, porpoise morbillivirus, and dolphin morbillivirus—haveHorses in Australia 23 (0.9) 2,400 (99.1) recently been described [17, 18]. No human infections havePteropus bats 39 (12.5) 273 (87.5) been recorded. These viruses have, however, shown an abilityOther animals in Australia 0 5,550 (100)

to appear in unexpected species, suggesting that their host range

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018

117CID 1998;27 (July) New Virus in Australia

Figure 5. Electron micrograph ofthe novel member of the Paramyxo-viridae. The nucleocapsid is appar-ent (arrowhead), as are the outerspikes (large arrow) and innerspikes (small arrow) (bar, 100 nm).Electron micrograph courtesy of A.Hyatt.

can often be wider than that observed in the first instance [18]. that of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE). Similaritiesbetween the two illnesses include their causes (a paramyxovi-For example, canine distemper virus has been transmitted from

jackals and wild dogs to lions, hyenas, leopards, and foxes in rus) and progressions (initial infection, followed later by neuro-Tanzania in recent years [19]. logical decline and death). We were unable to isolate virus

The clinical illnesses of the patients described above appear from the brain of the third patient, which raises an additionalquite different, although the findings at autopsy suggest that question that this virus was in a defective, cell-associated formboth patients with fatal cases had disseminated infection. There (as with SSPE). However, the time course and microscopicare several possible explanations for the third patient’s biphasic appearances of specimens in case 3 are quite different frompresentation. One is that the initial illness was akin to a sero- those of SSPE. Reinfection during the time between the twoconverting illness that was followed by a latent stage. Alterna- neurological illnesses seems unlikely, as the patient had notively, his illness could have had a pathogenesis similar to exposure to sick horses during this time.

Table 2. Time course of infections with a newly described memberof the Paramyxoviridae.

Date Event

August 1994 Two horses in Mackay, Queensland, Australia, becomeill and die

August 1994 Patient 3 develops aseptic meningitisSeptember 1994 Eighteen horses in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia,

Figure 6. Genome structure of the novel virus. The boxes indicate become ill, and 14 dieprotein coding regions, the numbers in parentheses after the protein September 1994 Patient 2 develops an influenza-like illnessname represent protein size in amino acid residues, while the sizes September 1994 Patient 1 develops a fatal respiratory illnessof noncoding intergenic regions are indicated by nucleotides (nt) with September 1995 Patient 3 develops fatal encephalitisa down-pointing open arrow. The vertical bar in between each gene September 1996 Virus is isolated in batsrepresents the position of intercistronic sequences. Data from [15].

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018

118 Paterson, Murray, and McCormack CID 1998;27 (July)

2. Murray K, Rogers R, Selvey L, et al. A novel morbillivirus pneumonia ofThe only antiviral treatment that has been used against thehorses and its transmission to humans. Emerg Infect Dis 1995;1:31–3.virus has been acyclovir (patient 3). This therapy appeared not

3. Murray K, Selleck P, Hooper P, et al. A morbillivirus that caused fatalto have any impact on the outcome of the infection. Ribavirin disease in horses and humans. Science 1995;268:94–7.has been used with some success against another member of 4. Anonymous. Another human case of equine morbillivirus disease in Aus-

tralia. Emerg Infect Dis 1996;2:71–2.the Paramyxoviridae (respiratory syncytial virus) [20], and its5. O’Sullivan JD, Allworth AM, Paterson DL, et al. Fatal encephalitis due touse intravenously should probably be attempted in future cases

novel paramyxovirus transmitted from horses. Lancet 1997;349:93–5.of the infection. Vitamin A has been used to decrease the5a. Murray K, Eaton B, Hooper P, Wang L, Williamson M, Young P. Flying

severity of measles [21] and could also be considered. Measles foxes, horses, and humans: a zoonosis caused by a new member ofvaccination is highly unlikely to be protective against the new the Paramyxovinidae. In: Scheld WM, Armstrong D, Hughes JM, eds.

Emerging infections 1. Washington DC: ASM Press, 1998:43–56.virus, as both patients 1 and 3 had IgG antibodies to measles6. Morse SS. Factors in the emergence of infectious diseases. Emerg Infectvirus at the time of the onset of illness.

Dis 1995;1:7–15.We do not know if subsequent cases of this viral infection7. Gould AR. Comparison of deduced matrix and fusion protein sequences

will appear, but as with most emerging infectious diseases, of equine morbillivirus with cognate genes of the Paramyxoviridae.the initial cases reported present many difficult questions for Virus Res 1996;43:17–31.

8. Hyatt AD, Selleck PW. Ultrastructure of equine morbillivirus. Virus Resclinicians and researchers. These cases have taught us that the1996;43:1–15.prompt isolation of a causative organism is a key not just to

9. Hooper PT, Gould AR, Mitchell G, et al. Retrospective diagnosis of asolving an individual diagnostic dilemma but also to under-second outbreak of equine morbillivirus disease. Aust Vet J 1996;74:

standing why a disease may emerge. Sufficient expertise and 244–5.financial and technical resources must be available to make 10. McCormack JG, Allworth AM, Selvey LA, Selleck PW. Transmission

from horses to humans of equine morbillivirus (EMV) infection [abstractnew diagnoses. In addition, the disparate presentations in casesno 273]. In: Program and abstracts of the Infectious Diseases Society1 and 3 remind us that the diagnostic net needs to be castof America 34th Annual Meeting (New Orleans). Alexandria, Virginia:widely in cases of severe life-threatening illness. New diseasesInfectious Diseases Society of America, 1996.

may present in a manner that has not been previously encoun- 11. Rogers RJ, Douglas IC, Baldock FC, et al. Investigation of a second focustered. of equine morbillivirus infection in coastal Queensland. Aust Vet J

1996;74:243–4.12. Ward MP, Black PF, Childs AJ, et al. Negative findings from serological

Addendum studies of equine morbillivirus in the Queensland horse population. AustVet J 1996;74:241–3.

Since our report was submitted, a new virus of the family 13. Young PL, Halpin K, Selleck PW, et al. Serologic evidence for the pres-Paramyxoviridae, distinct from the virus we described, has ence in Pteropus bats of a Paramyxovirus related to equine morbillivirus.

Emerg Infect Dis 1996;2:239–40.been isolated from pigs in New South Wales, Australia. Two13a. Halpin K, Young P, Field H. Identification of likely natural hosts forpatients with intense occupational exposure to pigs had an

equine morbillivirus. Communicable Diseases Intelligence 1996;20:476.influenza-like illness with rash and serological evaluation dem-

14. Selvey L, Taylor R, Arklay A, Gerrard J. Screening of bat carers foronstrated high convalescent-phase antibody titers to this new antibodies to equine morbillivirus. Communicable Diseases Intelligencevirus but not to the virus that affected horses and humans in 1996;20:477–8.

15. Wang L-F, Michalski WP, Yu M, et al. A novel P/V/C gene in a newQueensland, Australia [22, 23].Paramyxoviridae virus which causes lethal infection in humans, horsesand other animals. J Virol 1998;72:1482–90.

16. Allworth AM, Murray K, Morgan J. A human case of encephalitis due toAcknowledgmentsa lyssavirus recently identified in fruit bats. Communicable DiseasesIntelligence 1996;20:504.Numerous organizations and individuals have contributed to the

17. Osterhaus ADME, Groen J, Spijkers HEM, et al. Mass mortality in sealsvirological research and the care of patients infected with thiscaused by a newly discovered virus-like morbillivirus. Vet Microbiolnew member of the Paramyxoviridae. These have included Linda1990;23:343–50.

Selvey and John Sheridan (Communicable Diseases Branch,18. Taubenberger JK, Tsai M, Krafft AE, et al. Two morbilliviruses implicated

Queensland Health); Alex Hyatt, Paul Selleck, and Lawrie Gleeson in bottlenose dolphin epizootics. Emerg Infect Dis 1996;2:213–6.(the CSIRO Australian Animal Health Laboratory); Rachel Wells 19. Roelke-Parker ME, Munson L, Packer C, et al. A canine distemper virus(Centers for Disease Control and Prevention); Tony Allworth and epidemic in Serengeti lions (Panthera leo). Nature 1996;379:400–1.John O’Sullivan (Royal Brisbane Hospital); Lester Hiley (Centre 20. Hall CB, McBride JT, Walsh EE, et al. Aerosolized ribavirin treatment of

infants with respiratory syncytial virus infection: a randomized double-for Public Health Sciences, Brisbane); and Russell Rogers, Peterblind study. N Engl J Med 1983;308:1443–7.Young, Kim Halpin, and Hume Field (Queensland Department of

21. Hussey GD, Klein M. A randomized, controlled trial of vitamin A inPrimary Industries).children with severe measles. N Engl J Med 1990;323:160–4.

22. Philbey AW, Kirkland PD, Ross AD, et al. An apparently new virus(family Paramyxoviridae) infectious for pigs, humans and fruit bats.

ReferencesEmerg Infect Dis 1998;4:269–71.

1. Selvey LA, Wells RM, McCormack JG, et al. Infection of humans and 23. Chant K, Chan R, Smith M, et al. Probable human infection with a newlyhorses by a newly described morbillivirus. Med J Aust 1995;162: described virus in the family Paramyxoviridae. Emerg Infect Dis 1998;

4:273–5.642–5.

/ 9c51$$jy19 06-15-98 23:43:35 cida UC: CID

Dow

nloaded from https://academ

ic.oup.com/cid/article-abstract/27/1/112/359992 by guest on 23 N

ovember 2018