yhn board non confidential pack 2 february 2016
DESCRIPTION
ÂTRANSCRIPT
Board Tuesday 2 February 2016 at 5.00pm
Meeting to be held at YHN House, Newcastle upon Tyne. Contact: Jill Davison (telephone: 0191 278 8624 email: [email protected])
AGENDA
Introduction items Timing Page No.
1 Reminder to switch off mobile phones 5.00
2 Apologies for absence
3 Declarations of Interest
Items for Decision / Discussion
4 Business Strategy 5.00 1
5 Digital by Choice 5.20 30
6 Board Learning and Development Plan 5.35 47
Items for approval
7 Minutes of 8 December 2015 5.50 59
Items for Information
8i Universal Credit update 63
8ii Stonewall 72
8iii Delegated Decisions 74
8iv Board Forward Plan 76
8v Committee minutes:
Service and Strategy Delivery Committee 1 December 2015
77
To exclude the press and public during discussion of agenda item 9-13 because of the likely disclosure of confidential information. The definitions of what is considered confidential are contained within Section 16 of the Company’s Standing Orders.
Protect not for publication
Items for approval
9 Confidential minutes 8 December 2015 5.50 82
10 Finance and Performance Quarter 3 5.55 86
11 Budget 2016/17 principles 6.15 104
12 Remuneration Committee report 6.35 Supplemental
report
Items for information
13 Byker Community Trust update 6.55 112
Date of next meeting 15 March 2016 5pm YHN House
Board 2 February 2016
YHN Business Strategy 2016-2020
Report by Director of Corporate Services
For Decision
1 Background
1.1
This report provides Board with the draft Business Strategy for YHN (2016-2020) which has been the subject of a Time Limited Committee (TLC). The Business Strategy is the foundation document for the annual Delivery Plan and for all key corporate strategies and financial plans. Its main audience is the Board and the YHN workforce, though of course it also needs to be meaningful to our shareholder, our service users, partners and the wider sector.
As there are multiple factors affecting our organisation, many of which are difficult to predict, the Business Strategy is designed to provide a steer to us whatever changes lie ahead. It is not intended to specify tightly all of our actions for its life, these will be contained in the annual Delivery Plans, but to be specific enough to help with decisions and courses of action when necessary.
1.2 In June, Board decided to set up a TLC to oversee the development of the strategy, it has met four times; firstly to take stock of where we are now, secondly to consider scenarios in the future to help define the ‘must haves’ or core business then later to look at the statement of purpose and more detail on the content of the strategy.
The committee explored YHN’s purpose and vision and along with a proposal around the development of service objectives (what we will do) and cross-cutting objectives (how we will do things or principles that will be applied to all of our activity).
1.3 Based on material presented to the committee, members concluded that:
A statement of purpose needs to be descriptive as well as aspirational, besides being more memorable than our current purpose.
Our vision needs to be set in the future and provide a clear steer at times when strategic decisions are needed. The notion of ‘making the money deliver’ should be retained.
4
Page 1 of 81
Being clear about service objectives would help all stakeholders, but staff in particular, understand their role and where priorities lie.
The development of cross-cutting objectives, which is something new for our strategy, has the potential to provide a framework for all of our activity, keeping the business viable and the services to the standard required by NCC.
A single page summary, preferably diagrammatic, would be an invaluable reference document.
1.4 Following work with the committee, in November 2015 Board agreed the purpose statement, vision, service objectives and cross cutting objectives presented. These form the basis of the Business Strategy (appendix one) and remain largely unchanged except the following:
Service objective three has been amended to reflect the Board feedback about improving the health and wellbeing of tenants, and
Two of the seven cross cutting objectives presented to Board in November (achieve efficiency at every level and direct resources) have been merged together.
2 Developing the Strategy
2.1 Since Board approved the purpose, vision and objectives, officers have worked via a series of workshops to develop the content, using a range of information, including:
Information about our operating environment and any changes expected
Known information about financial pressures we face
Expectations about performance from our landlords
Tenant priority areas for service delivery, and
Proposals about what we will need to do under the cross cutting objectives in order to deliver against the service objectives given the above.
2.2 When tenants were consulted about the purpose, vision and objectives the direction of travel was endorsed, however they stressed the need to ensure that we don’t understate the challenges we face over the next few years. We have tried to reflect this feedback in the draft presented.
2.3 Consultation on the draft strategy has been carried out with Heads of Service, the Chair, members of the Board TLC and NCC Directors.
As a result some things previously listed as achievements are now more appropriately referred to as measures. Where there are measures we have sought to be more precise about our aspiration for 2020. In addition the text on traded services has been amended to reflect Board member feedback. Other individual queries have been responded to on a one to one basis.
Page 2 of 81
2.4 Board is recommended to approve or amend the Business Strategy.
3 The Business Implications
3.1 Purpose and Strategic Objectives:
The Business Strategy is intended to place us in as strong a position as possible for the future. It sets out a new set of strategic objectives and the principles we will work to in order to ensure that strategic objectives continue to be delivered despite changing and challenging circumstances.
3.2 Value for Money/Efficiencies:
Achieve efficiency at every level and direct resources to where they are needed the most is a cross-cutting principle for the new Business Strategy.
3.3 Financial Implications:
The Business Strategy aims to give us a solid foundation to plan for and respond to the financial implications of our current environment. Following approval of the Business Strategy, a Finance Strategy will developed to support and underpin the Business Strategy.
3.4 Resources (financial, property, technological or human):
The focus of a number of the cross-cutting objectives is a recognition that we will need to deliver our contracts with fewer resources. This will mean an increased emphasis on technology in order to transform service delivery and the need to optimise resources through trade.
3.5 Impact on Services/Performance:
The Business Strategy is designed to protect performance despite pressure on finance and other changes to the environment.
3.6 Outcomes for Tenants/Leaseholders:
The proposed purpose and vision are designed to enshrine high quality levels of service.
3.7 Risk (reputation, relationship):
There is a risk that if we do not continue to deal with our challenges in a planned, robust and timely manner we will create greater problems in the medium and long term.
3.8 Environmental:
Improving the neighbourhoods we manage is integral to service objective one in the Strategy.
3.9 Legal:
The Business Strategy sets out a framework of principles that will guide our
4
Page 3 of 81
4 Conclusion and Recommendations
4.1 Board is recommended to Board is recommended to approve or amend the Business Strategy.
5 Implementation
5.1 The next steps include the following:
Produce a one page summary of the Business Strategy which will be circulated to Board before the end of March and published on the YHN website.
The Delivery Plan will be brought to the March meeting for decision. This is the annual plan to show whether or not the objectives of the Business Strategy are being met. This in turn will be monitored on a quarterly basis by Board.
Key strategies will be brought to Board for approval and their implementation will be monitored by Service and Strategy Delivery Committee.
A programme of training and awareness raisng amongst staff will be developed starting with a team brief which will be cascaded throughout the organisation.
Signpost key messages for tenants via Homes and People.
Contact Officer: If you have any questions about this report that you would like clarifying before the meeting, you can contact Louise Horsefield, Head of Business Strategy, telephone 0191 278 8720 or email [email protected]
business decisions over the next four years to ensure we continue to deliver contractual requirements for our landlords. It will also help us to work with our landlords to prepare for and respond to significant changes in housing and welfare legislation that are expected over the coming years.
3.10 Equality and Diversity and Community Cohesion:
The Business Strategy will support us to deliver equality of access to services for tenants. In particular, service objective three has been amended to reflect the Board feedback about improving the health and wellbeing of tenants and access to employment opportunities.
Page 4 of 81
1
YHN Business Strategy 2016-2020
4
Page 5 of 81
2
Our vision for 2020:
“We will be high performing, innovative and focussed on providing quality housing management and support services. We will make the money deliver across everything we do while continuing to create positive outcomes for our customers”
Our purpose “Delivering great services, enabling people to thrive in great communities, supporting a
great city”
YHN LIMITED
(Parent)
ASFALEIA LIMITED
(Subsidiary)
ABRI TRADING LIMITED
(Subsidiary)
Who are we? Your Homes Newcastle manages 30,000 tenancies – Council and Registered Providers – across the city. We help customers find and keep homes, improve the city’s housing stock and services and we enable our customers to sustain their tenancies by providing a range of specialist support services. In October 2015 we established a new group structure with two new subsidiaries, Asfaleia Limited charitable subsidiary and Abri Trading Limited which is our trading subsidiary. This new group structure enables us to operate in the most tax efficient way, make the best use of our financial resources and better reflects the breadth of activity we carry out. YHN Group structure:
What are we here to do?
In developing this strategy we have taken the opportunity to reflect on what our purpose is. Our ethos remains the same but our purpose has been re-defined:
Where do we want to get to by 2020?
Page 6 of 81
3
The road ahead The world we operate in has changed a lot since we were established in 2004. The economy is in recovery but the pressure to reduce public spending remains. Our parent organisation Newcastle City Council (NCC) has already lost £191 million as a result of government cuts and unfunded cost pressures like inflation and rising energy costs (£1,567 for every household in Newcastle). We anticipate that NCC will need to reduce costs by a further £100 million over the next three years. This pressure is compounded by the government requirement on social landlords to reduce social rents by 1% for each of the next four years. This will mean a reduction of income into the Housing Revenue Account (HRA) of £593m over the next 30 years. Welfare Reform and the introduction of Universal Credit pose a further threat to income from rent, and the Housing and Planning Act will bring significant changes to social housing. Planned changes include an extended Right to Buy, the end of lifetime tenancies and the sale of high value council housing. From April 2016 we have a new ten year management agreement with NCC. This enables us to plan for the future and gives us a great opportunity to continue to deliver NCC’s housing services. However, given the financial pressures NCC faces, the management fee we will receive has been reduced to reflect the reduced income into the HRA. This will mean we have to innovate and transform our organisation so we can continue to deliver our vision. More than ever before we will need to make sure the money delivers; spending money where the need is greatest and focusing on services where we know it will make the biggest difference. We must continue to build and strengthen our already excellent relationship with our key shareholder NCC, and work collaboratively with other partners to help the city achieve their key objectives in an incredibly challenging financial climate. We may need to make some difficult decisions along the way and be prepared to re-direct resources to ensure the best possible outcomes from the services that we provide on behalf of our landlords.
About this strategy The environment we operate in is constantly changing, so this strategy must be able to adapt to changes as they happen. It sets out where we want to be by 2020 based on what we know now. We will need to revisit our plans on a regular basis so they continue to reflect their environment. Every year we will publish an annual Delivery Plan which will set out how we plan to implement this strategy in the subsequent year.
Our 2016-2020 objectives
We have categorised these into service and cross cutting objectives.
4
Page 7 of 81
4
Our three service objectives are:
Keep the housing stock decent, and neighbourhoods clean and safe
Collect the rent and let properties efficiently
Promote health and wellbeing and support vulnerable people to enjoy independence
We will:
Use modern technology and innovation to challenge and redefine service delivery
Achieve efficiency at every level and direct resources to where they are needed most
Have high performing people who understand how to contribute to our purpose
Trade profitably to support core services
Work proactively with NCC and our other landlords
Maximise partnerships to improve services
What we need to do: our service objectives
This sets out what we need to do to ensure continued delivery of our core services and deliver our purpose. There is a particular focus on ensuring we are able to continue to comply with the conditions set out in the management agreements we hold with NCC, Leazes Homes and Byker Community Trust (BCT).
How we will work: our cross cutting objectives
We know we need to make some significant changes to the way we work. These six objectives will guide the way we do things over the next four years. They are fundamental to achieving our vision.
Page 8 of 81
5
We aim to be in the top quartile compared to our peers in the sector for the following:
Rent loss due to empty properties (voids) as a percentage of rent due
Amount spent on void reinstatement costs
Overall management cost per property managed
Rent collected as a percentage of rent due
Percentage of dwellings that are non-decent at the end of the year
Tenant satisfaction with overall housing services
Tenant satisfaction with neighbourhood as a place to live
We also aim to improve our performance in the following areas:
Year on year increase in the proportion of Your Homes Your Jobs placements and apprentices that progress into employment, education or training
Maintain current tenancy sustainment levels for vulnerable tenants receiving support
Growth in daily internet use among Council tenants above national trend every year
Year on year increase in the profit generated by Newcastle Furniture Services and Palatine Beds as reported to Abri Trading Limited Board
What our performance will look like in 2020 We have set out our ambition for each of our objectives in the following sections of this strategy. We want to improve our performance so we are one of the top performers in the sector across our key areas of business. We know that for some service areas achieving this ambition will be challenging. Here is a summary of our key performance measures for our Business Strategy. Our performance against these measures will be reported regularly to YHN Board.
4
Page 9 of 81
6
Housing stock and neighbourhoods will be well maintained, sustainable, desirable and continue to generate money for the HRA
Service Objective 1 - Keep the housing stock decent and the neighbourhoods clean and safe
We rely on the rent we collect to carry out repairs and maintenance and invest in the housing stock and maintain surrounding estates. Investment ensures stock is able to meet the needs of the population of Newcastle and is sustainable, desirable and can continue to generate money in the future. The 1% rent reduction represents a loss of income of £593m in the HRA over the next 30 years. This reduces the money available to develop new homes and to invest in maintaining and improving the properties and the estates that we manage. As well as our commitment to maintaining the Decent Homes Standard we need to ensure we continue to provide investment to meet our landlords’ statutory responsibilities, such as gas servicing, fire safety, lift refurbishment and other health and safety issues. We will need to continue to seek external funding to ensure we maximise the money which is available to invest in the stock. Tenants have told us that the condition and appearance of the estates surrounding their homes is very important to them. It plays a major role in creating sustainable and cohesive communities where people want to live. Tenants and prospective tenants, like all of us, want to live in clean and safe neighbourhoods.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
Repairs and Maintenance service delivered by NCC will continue beyond March 2016
Reducing fuel poverty will continue to be important to us
Land availability/contamination will mean fewer opportunities to build
Low demand for some property types, particularly high rise flats
Reduction in HRA budget (capital and revenue)
Lower rents will mean payback will be difficult on some new developments
Changing demand for stock
Potential increase in anti-social behaviour case-load due to current economic conditions
More limitations on Homes and Communities Agency (HCA) grant
Unknown impact of Housing and Planning Act changes (e.g. sale of high value voids)
Average SAP rating lower than other similar organisations
By 2020:
Page 10 of 81
7
We will achieve this by:
Implementing our Asset Management Plan
Using performance management, benchmarking and market testing to ensure that our repairs and maintenance service and estate services contracts, deliver quality customer focussed outcomes and value for money
Flexing our programme of planned works to respond to changing circumstances and priorities
Empowering residents to contribute to improving their local areas
Delivering a more streamlined and efficient response to dealing with anti-social behaviour
Recommending a capital programme to NCC on an annual basis. Outcomes we will achieve:
The homes we manage are maintained to decency standard
We will deliver against the priorities most important to tenants
We make it possible for people to enjoy where they live
The appearance and reputation of council housing is improved How we will measure success: We will work towards improving our performance so we are top quartile compared with similar organisations in the following areas:
Percentage of dwellings that are non-decent at the end of the year
Tenant satisfaction with their neighbourhood as a place to live
Average SAP rating of housing stock
4
Page 11 of 81
8
Service Objective 2 - Collect the rent and let properties efficiently
Welfare Reform represents the biggest shake up in welfare for over 60 years, changing the way in which benefits are allocated and administered. The introduction of a new ‘bedroom tax’ has already had a considerable impact. Many of the tenants who are under-occupying their homes have had to move to a smaller property or are waiting to do so because they can’t afford to stay. Universal Credit (UC) will bring further challenges. Unlike Housing Benefit, UC is paid directly to claimants who are then responsible for making their rent payments to their landlord. This is a huge change for us and tenants, as currently around 65% * of tenants have some or all of their rent paid directly through Housing Benefit. It is having a negative impact on rental collection from tenants that are now claiming UC, and is pushing more of them into financial hardship. It presents further challenges for many tenants who are financially excluded without access to bank accounts. We have taken sustained intensive action to counteract the impact of the changes but this will be more challenging as more tenants switch onto UC. Alongside this challenge, the housing needs of the local population are evolving and some of the stock is not sustainable or desirable in its current state. Demand for good quality family and older person’s accommodation is stable, but we will need to continue to seek creative and cost effective ways to align available stock with what people need and can afford. The housing market itself is complex in Newcastle due to the diverse nature of its stock and communities. Private sector housing in Newcastle accounts for approximately 69%* of all housing stock, this is made up of a combination of owner occupied, private rented, empty private sector housing and some specialist accommodation. With numbers of private rented properties in Newcastle higher than the national average there is a greater need for us to operate competitively to ensure social housing is a viable choice for renters. *Figures correct as of January 2016
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
The benefit cap will be lowered
UC will be introduced for other claimants
Discretionary Housing Payments will be used to support benefit cap cases
We will be successful in embedding a payment culture
We will continue to work as part of a regional partnership for letting homes
We will use data to understand markets, customer segments and
Backdated UC will be limited to one month
UC means rent will no longer be paid directly to landlords for the majority of working age claimants resulting in a substantial reduction in guaranteed income
High number of financially excluded tenants
Increased workloads as more intensive rent recovery work required
We will need new models for service delivery and may need to redirect
Page 12 of 81
9
By 2020: We will have sustained rent collection rates through the transition to Universal Credit and the majority of tenants will pay their rent in advance by direct debit. Through partnership working, the properties we manage will be sustainable and let quickly to customers who value the service we provide, leading to successful tenancies.
behaviours
We are already experiencing low demand issues with some property types in some parts of Newcastle
resources
Matching the housing stock with local demand
We currently perform worse than our peers in rent collection and letting homes
We will achieve this by:
Implementing our Income Management Strategy
Promoting financial inclusion through the implementation of our Income Management Strategy
Implementing a revised void end to end process, which should reduce the amount of time a property is not available to let
Working with NCC to revise their Allocations Policy to allow flexibility to increase demand for less popular homes
Improving our marketing of our landlords’ properties to increase the audience reach and attract new markets particularly for difficult to let properties
Expanding the Tyne and Wear Homes Partnership to include other parts of the North East which will increase the housing options available and customer base
Outcomes we will achieve:
Rent collection is optimised to enable service provision
Tenants’ debt levels are minimised
The negative impacts of empty properties are diminished How we will measure success: We will work towards improving our performance so we are top quartile compared with similar organisations in the following areas:
4
Page 13 of 81
10
Rent lost due to empty (void) properties as a percentage of rent due
Amount spent on reinstatement of void properties
Rent collected as a percentage of rent due
Average re-let time
Tenancy turnover rate
Page 14 of 81
11
Service Objective 3 - Promote health and wellbeing and support vulnerable people to enjoy independence
We support vulnerable young people with complex needs and provide housing and telecare support services to older people. Additionally we provide tailored advice and support to anyone who is struggling to sustain their tenancy for a variety of reasons. Going forward, supporting people to enjoy independence in their homes and sustain their tenancy continues to be a vital part of our service offer despite the reduction and eventual withdrawal of NCC funding. In October 2015 we created a new charitable subsidiary, Asfaleia Limited which reflects our on-going commitment to this valuable work and also helps us to make more efficient use of the limited resources that are available. Demand for these services is likely to increase, but the continuing impact of welfare reform and reducing public health and social care budgets within the local authority and health service means that those services will face significant cost pressures. The challenge will be how to continue to provide efficient and effective support to those who need help to sustain their tenancies. A reduced management fee means that it is likely that we will have to prioritise the clients who need our help the most rather than providing a universal service to everyone. Our Telecare service, Ostara, faces the specific challenge of operating without any NCC funding. Our first priority will be to convert the 2,800 existing NCC funded users of the Telecare service into paying customers. 1,600 other customers already pay for the service but if the majority of funded users opt out then the service will operate at a loss. This could not be sustained long term. Further challenges we face are high levels of poor health and wellbeing, closely linked with unemployment levels that over the years continue to be far higher than the national average. Unfortunately many tenants living in the homes we manage are affected which can lead to difficulties in sustaining tenancies. We have a vital role to play in promoting both health and wellbeing and employment and will need to continue to work closely with local partners to develop effective solutions.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
HRA to fund some Advice and Support/Young people Service activity
NCC to cease funding for Telecare (Ostara)
Less locally provided debt and benefit advice available to tenants
Newcastle continues to have lower levels of employment and educational achievement
Tenants experience inequality in health outcomes compared with other residents in Newcastle
Fuel poverty is an issue for some
Increase in termination of tenancies as tenants cannot sustain tenancy without support.
Decrease in take up of tenancies if support services not in place.
Fewer older people living independently without support services i.e. telecare.
Increase in levels of social isolation amongst older people
4
Page 15 of 81
12
By 2020: We will have improved the health and wellbeing of tenants and tenancy sustainment levels through the provision of efficient and cost effective support services for vulnerable people who need it the most.
tenants and this impacts on their physical and mental health
We will achieve this by
Implementing our new Telecare (Ostara) marketing plan to increase our client base
Developing a more streamlined support offer for vulnerable tenants, that uses technology to improve efficiency
Implementing the actions resulting from our Health and Housing support review
Continuing to strengthen our partnerships with Health, Social Care and Public Health as this enables us to provide a holistic service to customers who have additional health and wellbeing requirements
Considering support and care requirements as part of our pre-tenancy service offer
Working with our Tyne and Wear Homes partners to make better use of adapted and adaptable stock across the region
Collaborating with local health partners to produce a YHN Health and Wellbeing plan aimed at improving health outcomes for tenants
Expanding our employability programme to increase the number of employment and training opportunities we are able to offer tenants
Strengthening our organisational approach to safeguarding and domestic violence by improving our policies and processes and collaborating with other partners to ensure a holistic response
Improving tenant financial stability to enable people to stay in their homes and meet their rent obligations
Developing a programme of community action events to help reduce the impact of social isolation
Implementing actions required to achieve our ambition that all housing stock achieves an Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) rating of E or above by 2020
Outcomes we will achieve:
The health and well-being of individuals is enhanced
Page 16 of 81
13
Tenants are supported to become more self-sufficient
Support for the most vulnerable tenants is sustained
Unemployed tenants are more likely to secure and sustain employment How we will measure success:
Maintain current tenancy sustainment levels for vulnerable tenants receiving support
Revenue generated by Telecare (Ostara) service to be at least equal to expenditure by 2018
Year on year increase in the proportion of Your Homes Your Jobs placements and apprentices that move onto education, employment or training
Using HACT methodology to develop a baseline snapshot for health and wellbeing
4
Page 17 of 81
14
By 2020:
Our cross cutting objectives- the way we will do things
We will: use modern technology and innovation to challenge and redefine service delivery The importance of technology to YHN and NCC has grown significantly in recent years and plays an ever increasing role in the delivery of our customer services. The broad adoption of online services by the general public, together with greater availability and lower price of mobile devices and process automation solutions, present better opportunities to improve customer service whilst realising efficiencies at a time when we, like all public sector organisations, need to make significant financial savings. The move towards a “digital first” approach by Central Government (for example, requiring claims for Universal Credit to be made online) makes digital engagement a necessity for most of our customers. This presents us with a moral and practical need to support digitally excluded customers in acquiring the access and skills they need to survive and thrive in an increasingly digital world.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
Our work in this area will continue to be guided by Newcastle City Council’s “Digital By Choice” strategy
Wherever possible, we will work collaboratively with NCC in the design and delivery of digital services
We need to invest in modern technology in years one and two so that we realise efficiencies further down the line
A continued upward trend in the number of people accessing the internet
Council tenants in Newcastle are among the most digitally excluded people in the UK, so we will need to do more than most social housing providers to support tenants in getting affordable access to the internet and in developing the skills they will need to use digital services
There is growing demand within the business for new IT solutions to address a wide range of service delivery and process issues
We have reduced the digital inclusion gap between tenants and the rest of the UK.
Developed well-used digital service offerings for all common transactions with our customers
Made substantial savings by making better use of modern technology across YHN, while maintaining our focus on customer service
Page 18 of 81
15
We will achieve this by:
Implementing our ‘Digital by Choice’ Strategy
Providing more digital services, so customers can self-serve and face to face service provision becomes the exception and is targeted at those that need it the most
Providing affordable access to the internet for tenants and ensuring they know how to go online so more tenants access digital services
Reducing costs of delivering services by adapting new systems, such as mobile working and workforce scheduling, that transform how we work
Improving or replacing key IT systems to maximise productivity
Outcomes we will achieve:
More tenants are digitally included
Transactional and operational costs are reduced enabling greater productivity
Significant increase in the number of transactions completed online
Resources are freed up for those who still need personal contact and support
How we will measure success:
Growth in daily internet use among Council tenants above national trend every year
The proportion of transactions completed online more than trebled
Our technology-based service improvements deliver net savings within three years on average
4
Page 19 of 81
16
We will: achieve efficiency at every level and redirect resources to where they are needed the most
We have a vital role to play in ensuring that we make the money deliver. We need to make sure our house is in order to ensure maximum value for the Council and our other landlords. In particular:
We are now a service provider organisation to multiple clients;
Our main client (NCC) through the (HRA), is now self-financing and so needs to demonstrate financial sustainability;
There is a new relationship with NCC and increased scrutiny of our management fee;
Our clients and their tenants are coming under financial pressure from Welfare Reforms and cuts to Local Authority budgets; and
The HCA is exerting pressure on housing organisations to demonstrate Value for Money.
Due to the financial pressures our clients and their tenants face we will have to change the way we deliver our services. NCC has confirmed that our management fee will be reduced by 5% per year over the next three years. This means we need to save money on all areas of expenditure across the organisation. This will mean spending less on the things we need to run the organisation, be it paper, power or people. We have a good track record of finding the best price for things we buy and this will need to continue. Staffing is our biggest expenditure so we will need to transform our organisation in order to reduce our costs. Implementing new technology will lead to efficiencies as will process improvement. Some services will face resource pressures over the next four years as we try to balance demand for services with cost savings. An important part of our approach will be to anticipate and identify these resource pressures so that we can redirect our resources. Our annual business and financial planning process will be used to identify areas where resource pressures are expected and enable managers to highlight areas where directing resources might be required.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
Technology and process redesign will be key to achieving efficiencies. They may require upfront investment but will realise a cost saving by 2019
Year on year reduction in management fee. This equates to 15% reduction in the fee over the next three years
We will need to cut costs across all areas of expenditure
Services that are able to save more than 15% by 2019 will contribute those additional savings to help services with resource pressures
1% reduction in rent reducing resources for the Housing Revenue Account. This in turn impacts our management fee and resources we oversee including repairs and the housing investment programme
Impact of welfare reform on money into the HRA
Right sizing services across our business will bring uncertainty for staff
Page 20 of 81
17
By 2020:
We will have a more streamlined organisation led by a lean management structure. All of our teams will have eliminated wasted capacity, and are supported by fit for purpose systems and processes that drive the lowest cost per unit for our landlords.
We will achieve this by:
Implementing the Value for Money Strategy
Spending less on all of the things we buy
Reducing the cost of delivering services by adapting new systems, such as mobile working and workforce scheduling, that transform how we work
Eliminating waste and removing complexity through the use of improved, simplified processes
Restructuring across the organisation to right-size teams following system and/or process transformation
Considering if some services could be delivered more efficiently through partnership working, shared purchasing arrangements or outsourcing
Outcomes we will achieve:
Teams that are optimised to eliminate wasted capacity
A lean management structure
Fit for purpose systems and processes that drive the lowest cost per unit for our landlords
How we will measure success: We will work towards improving our performance so we are top quartile compared with similar organisations in the following areas:
Overall management cost per property managed
Tenant satisfaction with overall housing services provided by YHN
4
Page 21 of 81
18
By 2020: Our people will demonstrate our values in all that they do, they will have adapted well to organisational change and are motivated to succeed, this will be demonstrated through both individual and our organisational performance.
We will: have high performing people all contributing towards our organisational goals In a financially challenging and changing environment, high performing people all positively contributing towards our organisational goals will be the key to our ongoing success. This will not be an easy task, particularly as we will need to reduce in numbers and restructure over the life of this strategy. We know that motivation and morale will be affected as our people are faced with considerable change. We will have to work hard to manage this. Despite this each and every one of us has to be committed to maximising resources so that we can meet our contractual obligations and demonstrate exceptional value for money to our clients particularly as the wage bill remains our highest cost. To achieve this, high performing people will need the skills to balance conflicting priorities. We need to ensure that all of our staff are clear about the focus of our business and their role in delivering this Business Strategy. We also need flexibility to utilise the varied skills of our people and place them where their skills are needed to contribute to delivery of projects in other parts of our business. Maximising productivity through effective engagement, management of performance and absence will continue to be a key focus of our people management approach.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
There will be a learning and development budget but we will need to reduce costs
Operational HR and Organisational Development (OD) will continue to be provided by NCC
Achieving our vision with a reduced number of employees
Dealing with considerable change and managing any drop in motivation and morale and higher levels of anxiety resulting from restructures
Sickness absence is higher than in other similar organisations
We will achieve this by:
Implementing a new People Strategy to support us in managing the transformation of our organisation, supporting everyone to understand and deliver their role
Effective management of the HR and OD Service Contract with NCC to ensure we have provision that meets the needs of our business
Page 22 of 81
19
Developing new organisational values to reflect the new People Strategy and to help everyone understand the ‘YHN way’ of doing things
Sharing skills across the organisation better so that we can make more efficient use of the skills and knowledge of our staff
Developing and delivering a development programme for YHN managers to equip them for the future
Outcomes we will achieve:
YHN remains a great place to work
We attract and retain high performing staff and achieve high levels of staff engagement
People have been supported through a period of significant change by effective leaders
A new cultural ‘norm’ has been established following transformation work How we will measure success:
Increase in engagement levels
Levels of sickness absence comparable with top quartile performers in the sector
Reduction in number of employee relations cases reported and investigated
Tenant satisfaction with overall housing services is maintained in top quartile compared with similar organisations
4
Page 23 of 81
20
By 2020: We will have an efficient and thriving furniture service concentrated on higher profit margin business with major landlords and local authorities. It generates significant surpluses before gift aid to Asfaleia Limited. Our Palatine Beds business will continue to demonstrate clear social value by maintaining its levels of supported employment whilst breaking even after corporate overheads.
We will: trade profitably to support delivery of services to tenants
Trading profitably provides a material cross subsidy for our ALMO services. The income helps protect the services that benefit tenants. Our trading subsidiary, Abri Trading Limited, has two commercial services: Newcastle Furniture Service (NFS) and Palatine Beds. For NFS the trade within Abri is for any works carried out, that are outside of Newcastle City. NFS provides both sale of goods and furniture rental for landlords and local authorities. Palatine Beds is a supported employer, whereby more than 50% of staff have a disability. They manufacture and sell mattresses predominantly to other businesses but also have a retail outlet that sells to the public. In order to increase our trading activity we need to develop our commerciality and become much more business orientated. To do this we need to improve the commercial skills of our board, our senior management team and those involved in the direct day-to-day management of our trading businesses. By doing so we are confident that we will be better placed to expand our market share through the successful pursuit of new contracts and in turn increase our profits and investment back into services to tenants.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
Our trading activity will not put our core services and performance at risk and vice versa
Resources will be directed to profitable contracts which all meet an appropriate level of return
We will reduce costs through improved systems, processes and structures
We will maintain our current level of supported employment at 25 protected FTE positions
The growing reliance to increase profits to cross subsidise in the face of a reducing management fee.
The potential impact on the lower benefit cap on demand for furniture packs
The possible complete withdrawal of Work Choice funding for supported employment within Palatine from October 2017
Competitive market for retail (1907 brand)
We will achieve this by:
Implementing the business plan and meeting the identified growth targets for Abri
Trading Limited
Page 24 of 81
21
Ensuring we have a simple procurement route for interested purchasing
organisations
Avoiding contracts with small or poor profit margins
Increasing the rate at which we convert interest from organisations into contracts
Ensuring that our IT systems are fit for purpose and reducing manual intervention and reduce resource requirements
Outcomes we will achieve:
Income levels are optimised to enable service provision
Palatine Beds maintains number of supported employees How we will measure success:
Year on year increase in the profit generated by Newcastle Furniture Services and Palatine Beds as reported to Abri Trading Limited Board
Minimum number of supported employees equals 25 FTE’s.
4
Page 25 of 81
22
By 2020: We will demonstrate success across all our service areas with all clients and will have retained all current contracts. We will enjoy a productive and collaborative relationship with our key shareholder Newcastle City Council whereby our recommendations are agreed, based on earned trust.
We will: work pro-actively with Newcastle City Council and our other clients
NCC is our sole shareholder and the Management Agreement between NCC and YHN covers the vast majority of our activity. NCC is the strategic decision-maker with regard to the HRA. A successful relationship with NCC, one in which our contractual requirements are met or exceeded, not only means that we earn the management fee, but also sets us up to provide high quality housing services to their tenants. Our objectives help the City Council achieve theirs. We work pro-actively with NCC on the delivery of our management agreement for their homes. We do this through a framework of meetings and sharing of information about our performance. Openness and communication is vital. We also support NCC to deliver against their objectives through collaborative working across other service areas. Customer service in all its forms, but especially the move to Digital by Choice, will be an important focus for us over the next few years. We achieve more working together than we can separately, and efficiencies can be realised this way. Relationships with Leazes Homes and Byker Community Trust (BCT) are also extremely important to us. We have recently extended our Management Agreement with Leazes Homes to 2018, whilst 2016 will see a change to our working relationship with BCT, as by the end of the year we will be providing fewer services for the Trust. Services to their tenants also need to be delivered well to maintain these contracts and the respective income.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
Management Agreement with NCC until 2026
Management Agreement with Leazes Homes until 2018
Byker Community Trust continue to purchase some services from YHN
- NCC and Leazes Homes will continue
to be under extreme financial pressure for the lifetime of this strategy
We will achieve this by:
Aligning our Business Strategy and Business Plan with NCC objectives
Delivering against our contract key performance indicators (KPIs) for our landlord
Page 26 of 81
23
Producing timely and accurate reports on our performance for our landlords
Communicating with our landlords through an agreed framework of meetings
Working with NCC to deliver the Digital Newcastle programme to increase internet access and online service take up
Working with NCC to review customer service provision
Working with NCC to review service provision for financial inclusion
Develop a new approach to monitoring satisfaction with the services we provide
Outcomes we will achieve:
Tenants benefit from Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) being met
Our income source is secured through our performance levels
Problems are resolved without unnecessary cost or upheaval
Savings and improvements to services are delivered through joint working
How we will measure success:
Delivery of agreed KPIs for NCC, Leazes Homes and Byker Community Trust
Maintain landlord satisfaction with our performance against KPIs
4
Page 27 of 81
24
By 2020: We will be working differently with tenants and partners to make sure that service quality levels remain high despite challenging financial environments
We will: maximise partnerships to improve and maintain services We have a variety of partnerships at YHN across the majority of our services with a range of objectives and working arrangements, although we have not really used them as a tool to reduce costs and continue delivery of essential services. As resources become even tighter we will need to be far more proactive in seeking out opportunities to work with others if we are to ensure that services valued by tenants can continue. As a minimum we should improve our relationships within social housing and other sectors to learn from others and develop our understanding of what other organisations can offer. In putting the customer first, we need to be open to new working arrangements, shared projects, reciprocal service offers and seek to eradicate duplication and/or pool resources wherever possible.
It is also vital that we continue to work closely with tenants so that they can help us to improve services. As our customers they have the best insight into the services we deliver. Focusing on understanding their use and experience of our services can give us the insight we need to make our services better.
Assumptions we have made Challenges we face
Our colleagues in social housing and in other sectors will be experiencing similar financial challenges
Most of our services are not unique and exist in other organisations
Some of our services may be delivered to a better standard by other organisations
There is scope to transform some of our service delivery through partnership working
We have a culture of doing things ourselves rather than working with others
Our relationships with colleagues in social housing and in other sectors need to be improved
Ensuring we focus on realising as much value as possible from partnerships rather than monitoring the number of interactions with others
There are many definitions of partnerships
Engaging with a wider range of tenants and developing a deeper understanding of how they experience our services
We will achieve this by:
Developing a framework of networks that allow us to improve our relationships with colleagues in social housing and in other sectors. This framework will cover all tiers of the organisation
Page 28 of 81
25
Expanding the Tyne and Wear Homes Partnership to other parts of the region to increase economies of scale
Considering commissioning or working in partnership for new areas of work where expertise already exists elsewhere
Consider options for partnership, shared purchasing or outsourcing for delivery of non-core services as part of service reviews
Focusing on partnerships that are clearly aligned with our objectives
Revise our approach to tenant involvement to ensure that we focus on the issues most important to tenants and to ensure we constantly expand and refresh the tenants we engage with
Outcomes we will achieve:
Better relationships with other providers will provide opportunities which benefit service users
More efficient delivery models from making use of expertise rather than trying to do everything ourselves
Tenants are confident that their views have influenced decision making How we will measure success: We will work towards improving our performance so we are top quartile compared with similar organisations in the following areas:
Tenant satisfaction with overall housing services provided by YHN
Overall management cost per property managed
Tenant satisfaction that YHN listens to their views and acts on them
4
Page 29 of 81
Board 2 February 2016
Digital by Choice
Report by Director of Tenancy Services and Assistant Director: Customers, Culture and Skills, Newcastle City Council
For Decision
1. Background Information
1.1 In March 2015 Board received a report setting out our proposals for how YHN should deliver excellent customer service in the future. Board agreed four principles that YHN will adhere to, they are
1. A commitment to alignment with NCC’s Digital by Choice programme in the long term, recognising the way that people increasingly expect, and are expected to, access services, and the efficiency gains that may be achieved over time.
2. A recognition that the demographic of our customer base is such that the move towards digitally accessed services needs to be enabling and supportive.
3. A reassurance to all of our stakeholders that despite a shift to digital access, customer service remains key to the way we do business, no matter what role or function in the business, no matter who the customer is.
4. An acceptance that some people will always need face to face contact.
1.2 Board received a further report in June 2015 when the Digital by Choice programme for 2015/16 was developed.
That report provided Board with a summary of current actions, all of which are now complete:
Free Wi-Fi in public buildings
Free Wi-Fi in communal areas in sheltered schemes, YHN’s young people’s accommodation and some tower blocks
Skills training for Council and YHN front-line staff
Improvements in digital payments and removal of cashiering from 27 November
The removal of cashiering does not appear to have had any negative impact on rent collection - in fact, collection rates are better than this time last year. This follows a concerted campaign by YHN Income staff in advance of the change to provide information and increase the number of tenants paying by direct debit, which is the lowest cost and most stable payment option.
During September, October and November, take up increased by 837 to a
5
Page 30 of 81
total of 8,007 paying by direct debit. This represents 26% of customers who have something to pay – not far below the national average of 33%.
1.3 An earlier series of reports on Tenant Broadband had established an aspiration to provide “affordable (and ideally free) basic internet to all tenants”, and an accompanying action plan of which the provision of free communal Wi-Fi highlighted above was a medium-term deliverable.
The outstanding actions from the Tenant Broadband plan have been combined with those arising from the two more recent reports and appended to this report as Appendix A, along with a progress update, providing a holistic view of all planned work relating to Digital By Choice.
2. Digital Newcastle: Council priorities and joint working
2.1 The Council’s vision for Digital By Choice is to have “excellent digital services which are so easy to use that they are naturally the way people choose to engage with us”.
Key elements of the Council’s work in this area include:
2.2 Digital First
The Council has agreed its approach to strengthening its digital platform, and is building on its existing Customer Relations Management system (formally known as Lagan) to develop Council wide streamlined digital systems.
Known internally as ‘Digital First’, there is now a project team in place and a work programme is being developed using agile principles. The team, led by YHN and Council colleagues, is planning the delivery of its first project.
2.3 Go Digital Newcastle
The People’s Network (free public use PCs and internet access) has been refreshed across all libraries and Customer Service Centres. Free Wi-Fi has been installed in all public buildings (and communal areas in YHN managed blocks), and the free outdoor Wi-Fi service is on track for full completion in March 2016. WI-FI provision in the Civic centre has also been improved by ICT Newcastle.
2.4 Digital Payments
The cashiering service was removed from all centres on 27 November. There has been little negative reaction to this so far, although the December- January period is usually quieter in terms of related customer activity. The main issue has finding the most appropriate replacement method for the Council to make cash payments to vulnerable customers or their Appointees (a person approved to look after the finances of someone who is unable to do so for themselves).
2.5 Community Hubs
Another project in the Digital Newcastle programme is the development of Community Hubs. Originally arising from 2015/16 budget proposals, subsequent decisions about the future of face to face service provision; outcomes from the review of YHN by the Council; and a range of Council budget proposals for 2016/17 require us to consider again what we want from the concept, and how we drive it forward.
Community Hubs have the potential to be the key entry point to a
Page 31 of 81
coordinated, targeted and consistent information, advice and referral system cross the city. They could be the first point of help for people as the established ‘welfare state’ offer ceases to provide a universal safety net, and becomes a tightly targeted service.
Developing Community Hubs is not about trying to protect a reduced version of our existing face to face services (Customer services, YHN services, Library and Information services for example). We have instead to ensure that we provide targeted provision to those who most need it, in partnership with other agencies. Our universal offers will have to be based around self-service and digital offers. Digital by Choice is therefore key to delivering our community hubs offer and a new face to face offer.
3. Digital By Choice at YHN
3.1 Board has made a commitment to align to the Council’s “Digital By Choice” Programme “in the long term”. In order to make the most of the Council’s investment in digital technology, that will still mean YHN playing a full part in the development of online services.
YHN needs to build new online services at the same pace as the Council, while providing an enhanced level of support for longer to customers who need it. If we were to delay this work, the economies of scale to be gained from joint development would be lost.
YHN has therefore worked closely with the Council to align relevant work programmes, establishing joint teams and projects where applicable.
YHN has established a “Digital Services” team within ICT, which is responsible for leading on the delivery of all actions in this strategy.
3.2 Strategic Framework
This report aims to draw together new and existing workstreams to create a coherent “Digital By Choice” strategy, illustrated by the diagram below.
These five elements are described in more detail below, and the related actions and progress to date are set out in Appendix A.
3.3 Partnership
Our approach to Digital By Choice goes beyond co-operation, and seeks
5
Page 32 of 81
wherever possible jointly to develop shared services and processes which will provide customers with a joined-up experience when interacting online with the Council and YHN.
YHN is represented by the Head of IT on the Council’s Digital Delivery Group, and by appropriate staff in all relevant workstreams.
In addition to our work with the Council, both organisations are collaborating with Northumberland County Council on the development of online services. We are also maintaining our conversations with both universities in the city, and are funding a PhD at Northumbria University researching digital inclusion and focusing on our tenant internet access initiatives.
3.4 Services
Excellent services are at the heart of the Council’s vision, and they have committed significant resource to the development of improved services through the “Digital First” programme, which will start to deliver new internal and external processes this month and is funded for two years.
YHN and the Council will be using the same ICT platform to develop new services, reducing duplication and maximising sharing opportunities. Where appropriate, staff from both organisations will work as a single team.
Both the Council and YHN have adopted a flexible, agile approach to the development of these services which will allow the programme to respond quickly to emerging priorities and changes in customer behaviour and demands.
This work follows on from considerable progress already made in getting the Council’s “Top 25 transactions” and YHN’s “Top 7 themes” online.
Improvements for YHN customers that are complete, or should be done by the end of March include:
Better online payments
Online requesting of door entry fobs
Online home insurance applications and claims
Online reporting and monitoring of ASB cases
Bids for properties using the YHN App
General upgrade of the YHN App
YHN will also replace its current, dated website with a modern, mobile-friendly one by the end of March.
Services will need to be accessible to all, and assisted digital routes will be needed so no one is left behind. Offline assistance will continue to be available to those who need it.
3.5 Access
NCC tenants are among the most digitally excluded groups in the UK (in 2014, 30% of tenants had no access to the internet, compared to 15% of UK adults, and fewer than half were daily users, compared to two thirds of UK adults). Those without internet access are increasingly disadvantaged as central and local government join commercial organisations in focusing their service delivery efforts on the connected customer. This is a particular issue for people of working age, when job opportunities and access to benefits are
Page 33 of 81
both increasingly accessed principally online.
The government estimated in 2009 that a typical household can save £560 per year from shopping and paying bills online, and more recent research published by BT in 2014 ("Valuing digital inclusion") suggested that becoming digitally included is worth £1,064 per year to a new user. On that basis, closing the gap between council tenants and the rest of the country could be worth up to £4m a year to the affected families.
In addition, YHN’s ability to make a significant transition to online service delivery will be limited unless regular internet use among tenants grows substantially.
Finally, internet-connected properties will offer new opportunities for efficiencies and service offerings. For example, the use of sensor technologies to extend average boiler life by one year might generate annual savings of up to £1m.
For these reasons, YHN has an aspiration to provide affordable (and ideally free) basic internet access to all tenants, and we have already made a start through the provision of free Wi-Fi in the communal areas in sheltered accommodation, young people’s services and many of our tower blocks.
The draft capital programme due for consideration at Cabinet 27 January includes £2m (£500k per year for four years) to allow us to go much further towards meeting that aspiration over the next four years and hopefully to approach universal free access.
3.6 Capabilities and skills
We know that internet access is not the only reason for people not being online. Many people lack the skills and confidence needed.
Research shows that people in work who acquire digital skills achieve a rise in earnings of between 3% and 10%, and that having digital skills helps improve the likelihood of someone who is unemployed finding a new job. Only 27% of young people who are offline are in full-time employment.
YHN’s digital champions programme provides training for tenants so that they can in turn support other tenants in getting online. We are pooling resources with the Council so that we can retain a shared digital inclusion team to continue to develop the digital champions while running other digital skills programmes.
We have adopted a similar approach internally by creating a virtual “Digital Staff Network”, who provide feedback on digital initiatives and support to less confident colleagues.
3.7 Efficiencies
The Council is facing unprecedented funding cuts, and is looking to the “Digital By Choice” programme to help reduce the cost of customer contact.
As YHN tackles our own budget pressures, digital transformation will allow us to reduce the cost of routine transactions with those who are already digitally capable, while using some of those savings to help digitally excluded to gain the access and skills they need to use the new online services.
We are participating this year in a research project with nine other social housing providers, which will test a range of digital service approaches based on behavioural insights and choice architecture (also known as
5
Page 34 of 81
“nudge”) to produce rigorous evidence on those that generate genuine savings.
While this report concentrates primarily on digital engagement with customers, most of the savings we expect to generate from the “use of modern technology and innovation to challenge and redefine service delivery” highlighted in the draft Business Strategy will come from greater efficiencies in internal processes. Increased use of mobile technology and automated work scheduling is already improving staff utilisation in the Furniture Service and Concierge, and we expect to continue investing in technologies such as this where they will reduce our operating costs in the longer term.
The Council’s Digital First team will similarly be seeking to achieve digital transformation both in interactions with customers and in the way services are organised and delivered.
4. The Business Implications
4.1 Mission and Strategic Objectives:
The proposals in this report support the ambitions of the Digital by Choice vision and the existing YHN Business Strategy ICT Plan, which contribute to the YHN strategic objectives of “make the money deliver” and “work together to realise a brighter future” through the delivery of “Inclusive Digital Housing Services”.
The draft 2016-2020 business strategy makes explicit reference to Digital By Choice and the key elements of this report within the cross-cutting objective to “use modern technology and innovation to challenge and redefine service delivery”.
4.2 Value for money/efficiencies:
YHN’s approach to Digital By Choice recognises high levels of digital exclusion and so will provide higher levels of support to tenants for longer and preserve face-to-face provision. This will limit our ability to make efficiencies from digital interactions with customers, at least in the short term.
In the long term, existing research and evidence in the area of “choice architecture” suggest that big savings will be hard to realise unless we are prepared to be bold in the way we construct “default options”. For example, much greater savings can be made by asking customers to “opt in” to continue to receive paper rent statements, rather than trying to persuade them to “opt out”.
4.3 Financial Implications:
YHN’s Digital By Choice programme has been funded from existing budgets. Extension of the digital champions programme will require approximately £5k per cohort of twenty people for hardware and training. £2m over four years has been included in the draft capital programme to provide free internet access for tenants.
4.4 Resources (financial, property, technological or human):
A digital services team of three staff has been established within the YHN ICT service without growth to the establishment. YHN and the Council has pooled resources to create a shared digital inclusion team of two staff for two years to build on the success of the YHN Digital Champions programme and
Page 35 of 81
provide digital skills training and support.
4.5 Impact on services/performance:
The development of an integrated customer portal for Council and YHN services will significantly improve online services.
4.6 Outcomes for tenants/leaseholders:
The Digital By Choice programme will encourage and support more people to become online or to use the Council’s People’s Network to engage online. This will also introduce non-digitally active residents to a whole range of online activity, not just for Council and YHN transactions, but also email, online shopping, and other digital activities that most people take for granted.
All residents will have the opportunity to engage equally with digital communications and services, with mediated support from frontline staff for those who need it, in proportion to that need.
There is strong evidence that being digitally included has significant benefits for individuals and families – an estimated £1,064 saving per year to people becoming digitally engaged for the first time, as well as improved educational and employment outcomes.
4.7 Risk (reputation, relationship):
There is a risk that customers continue to prefer face to face contact – this will be mitigated by developing an excellent digital offer, positively promoting benefits, and where appropriate targeting provision;
There is a risk that the funding for free tenant internet access will receive negative coverage in the press, especially if it is not seen to be delivering significant benefits – this will be mitigated by delivering and evaluating the programme in small, discrete work packages.
4.8 Environmental:
Any move towards online services has a number of low-impact environmental impacts, including a reduction in paper and energy use and a reduction in transportation consumption.
4.9 Legal:
It may be necessary to take legal advice where the status of electronic communications is unclear in relevant legislation or regulatory requirements, e.g. for the provision of paper rent statements. State aid and procurement advice will be required in relation to the tenant internet access capital works.
4.10 Equality and Diversity and Community Cohesion:
Older people, along with those with disabilities, low educational attainment and low wages are most likely to be digitally excluded, so all of these groups will benefit where we are successful in getting them online.
Where we are unsuccessful, people in these same groups will experience a negative impact to the extent that any existing services are removed or downgraded.
4.11 Stakeholder Involvement/consultation:
There has been wide consultation on the Digital by Choice vision (some of
5
Page 36 of 81
which has been facilitated by YHN officers). Generally the vision has been endorsed by residents and stakeholders.
Internally, “Digital” was the main focus of “Team Brief” in December last year.
Further engagement with customers is planned throughout the development of online services.
5. Conclusion and Recommendations
5.1 YHN Board has already committed to be a partner in the Digital by Choice programme, accepting that there will always be some residents that need face to face support.
Good progress has already been made in many of the areas covered by this report, all of which are now being delivered under one Head of Service, with the Customer Service and Improvement function now reporting to the Head of IT.
As delivery of Digital By Choice will be a significant driver of the overall business strategy, it is recommended that Board continue to receive periodic updates on progress against the associated actions, with the next update scheduled in six months’ time.
5.2 YHN Board is invited to receive this update and approve the recommendation.
6. Implementation
6.1 The Digital by Choice Programme will continue to be progressed through:
joint work between YHN and the Council through the NCC Digital First team and the YHN Digital Services team to deliver improved online services
a rolling delivery plan for tenant internet access
a continuation of the digital champions programme for at least a further 12 months
Both YHN and the Council have adopted “agile” project delivery methods for this work, an approach widely adopted in government ICT delivery which aims to be more flexible and responsive to changing circumstances, and to deliver tangible outcomes more quickly.
Background Papers:
Digital by Choice (Board Report), June 2015
Digital by Choice (NCC Cabinet Report), June 2015
Customer Service (Board Report), March 2015
Tenant Broadband (Board Reports), January/July/December 2014
“Valuing Digital Inclusion”, Just Economics for BT, June 2014
“Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth and Happiness”, Sunsein & Thaler, 2009
“Digital Britain”, UK Government, 2009 Contact Officer: If you have any questions about this report that you would like clarifying before the meeting, you can contact:
Neil Scott, Director of Tenancy Services, 0191 2788711, [email protected]
Page 37 of 81
Tony Durcan, Assistant Director, NCC. 0191 211 5383, [email protected]
Geof Ellingham, Head of IT, YHN. 0191 2784392, [email protected]
5
Page 38 of 81
Ap
pe
nd
ix 1
Y
HN
Dig
ita
l B
y C
ho
ice
Str
ate
gy A
cti
on
Pla
n
Th
is a
ctio
n p
lan
in
clu
de
s u
pd
ate
s (
in ita
lics)
on
all
actio
ns a
gre
ed
by B
oa
rd in
ea
rlie
r re
po
rts o
n T
en
an
t B
roa
db
and
, to
ge
the
r w
ith
exis
tin
g a
nd
n
ew
actio
ns fo
r th
ose
ele
me
nts
of
the
str
ate
gy t
ha
t h
ave
be
en m
ore
re
ce
ntly in
co
rpo
rate
d.
S
ho
rt T
erm
: B
y D
ece
mb
er
201
5
Me
diu
m T
erm
: B
y J
une
201
6
Lo
ng T
erm
: B
y D
ecem
be
r 2
01
7
A1 – Free Wi-Fi in sheltered
accommodation
Pro
vid
e f
ree
Wi-F
i to
all
resid
en
ts in
at tw
o
sh
elte
red
acco
mm
od
atio
n s
che
me
s w
ith
in
co
mm
un
al a
rea
s u
sin
g c
om
me
rcia
l d
om
estic s
erv
ice
s.
Co
mp
lete
d:
fre
e W
i-F
i h
as b
een
in
sta
lled
in
Co
nis
ton
Co
urt
.
Pro
vid
e f
ree
Wi-F
i to
all
resid
en
ts in
sh
elte
red
acco
mm
od
atio
n w
ith
in
co
mm
un
al a
rea
s.
Imp
lem
en
tatio
n o
f fr
ee
Wi-
Fi in
all
rem
ain
ing
sh
elte
red
sch
em
es h
as b
een
c
om
ple
ted
.
Pro
vid
e lo
w-c
ost W
i-F
i to
re
sid
en
ts in
sh
elte
red
acco
mm
od
atio
n in
te
nan
ts’ o
wn
ro
om
s in
a s
ma
ll n
um
be
r o
r tr
ial site
s
wh
ere
de
ma
nd a
nd
an
ap
pro
pria
te
su
ppo
rt m
od
el ca
n b
e d
em
on
str
ate
d.
Th
is is e
xp
ecte
d t
o b
e a
n e
arly d
eliv
era
ble
in
th
e t
en
ant
inte
rne
t acce
ss e
lem
en
t of
the
ca
pita
l p
rog
ram
me
.
A2 – Free Wi-Fi in young
people’s accommodation
P
rovid
e f
ree
Wi-F
i to
all
resid
en
ts in
yo
un
g
pe
op
le’s
accom
mod
atio
n w
ith
in c
om
mu
na
l a
rea
s.
Imp
lem
en
tatio
n o
f fr
ee
Wi-F
i in
YP
S
sch
em
es,
Ju
bile
e C
ou
rt a
nd
the
ho
ste
l h
as b
ee
n c
om
ple
ted
.
Page 39 of 81
A3 – Free Wi-Fi in tower
blocks
P
rovid
e f
ree
Wi-F
i w
ith
in c
om
mu
na
l sp
ace
s in
a s
ma
ll n
um
be
r of
tow
er
blo
cks
wh
ere
th
ere
are
su
ita
ble
lo
ca
tio
ns a
nd
lo
ca
l re
sid
en
ts w
illin
g t
o s
upp
ort
oth
er
ten
an
ts.
Imp
lem
en
tatio
n o
f fr
ee
Wi-
Fi in
a
pp
rop
ria
te c
om
mu
nity s
pa
ce
s t
ha
t ha
ve
a
su
pp
ort
ed
te
nan
t fu
nctio
n h
as b
ee
n
co
mp
lete
d.
Ide
ntify
a t
ow
er
blo
ck w
he
re e
xis
tin
g
infr
astr
uctu
re w
ill a
llow
fre
e W
i-F
i to
be
p
rovid
ed
to
all
fla
ts a
t m
ode
st
co
st.
Th
is is e
xp
ecte
d t
o b
e a
n e
arly d
eliv
era
ble
in
th
e t
en
ant
inte
rne
t acce
ss e
lem
en
t of
the
ca
pita
l p
rog
ram
me
.
A4 – Free Wi-Fi in low-rise
accommodation
P
rovid
e f
ree
Wi-F
i w
ith
in c
om
mu
na
l sp
ace
s in
a s
ma
ll n
um
be
r of
low
-ris
e
acco
mm
od
atio
n b
locks.
Th
is w
ill b
e a
de
live
rable
in
the
te
nan
t in
tern
et a
cce
ss e
lem
en
t o
f th
e c
ap
ita
l p
rog
ram
me
.
5
Page 40 of 81
A5 – Internet-enabled tablets
for targeted use
Pro
vid
e f
ree
ta
ble
t com
pute
rs w
ith
a lo
w-
ba
nd
wid
th 3
G d
ata
con
tra
ct
to ta
rge
ted
cu
sto
me
rs s
ub
ject to
Un
ive
rsa
l C
red
it f
or
a 1
2 m
on
th p
erio
d.
Co
mp
lete
d:
a low
-co
st
(£7
0)
tab
let
ha
s
be
en
pro
vid
ed
to
pa
rtic
ipa
nts
in
the
Dig
ita
l C
ha
mp
ion
s p
ilot
to d
eliv
er
su
ppo
rt to
o
the
r te
na
nts
.
De
ve
lop
a s
tru
ctu
red
pro
gra
mm
e t
o
pro
vid
e t
ab
let
com
pu
ters
with
a lo
w-
ba
nd
wid
th 3
G d
ata
con
tra
ct
to ta
rge
ted
cu
sto
me
rs w
ith
in a
fra
me
wo
rk o
f in
ce
ntive
s a
nd
aff
ord
ab
le p
aym
en
ts.
C1 - Digital skills support for tenants
De
ve
lop
a d
igita
l skill
s s
up
po
rt m
od
el
inclu
din
g d
igita
l ch
am
pio
ns a
nd
fa
ce
-to
-fa
ce
skill
s s
upp
ort
, a
nd id
en
tify
ava
ilab
le
exte
rna
l fu
nd
ing.
Co
mp
lete
d:
Th
e d
igital ch
am
pio
ns
pro
gra
mm
e h
as b
ee
n e
sta
blis
he
d, a
nd
a
ran
ge
of d
igita
l skill
s s
up
po
rt h
as b
ee
n
de
ve
lop
ed in
clo
se
coop
era
tion
with
th
e
Co
un
cil.
Imp
lem
en
t th
e m
od
el to
pro
vid
e s
up
po
rt
for
the m
ed
ium
te
rm a
ctio
ns in
th
is p
lan
.
Co
mp
lete
d:
40
dig
ita
l ch
am
pio
ns h
ave
b
een
tra
ine
d, a
nd
ha
ve s
o f
ar
en
ga
ge
d
with
460
ten
ants
, fo
cu
sin
g s
pe
cific
ally
on
site
s w
he
re fre
e W
i-F
i h
as b
ee
n r
olle
d o
ut.
Wi-F
i la
un
ch p
art
ies h
ave
bee
n d
eliv
ere
d
at
13
ven
ue
s.
Dig
ita
l ch
am
pio
ns a
lso s
up
po
rt
Co
mm
un
ity O
pe
n D
ays,
one
to o
ne
a
ppo
intm
en
ts,
dro
p in
se
ssio
ns, g
roup
tr
ain
ing
se
ssio
ns a
nd a
pp
oin
tme
nt
se
ssio
ns in
Ho
usin
g O
ffic
es.
Pla
n a
nd
im
ple
men
t a
city-w
ide
ro
llou
t of
the
su
ppo
rt m
ode
l, w
ork
ing w
ith
th
e
Co
un
cil
and
oth
er
pa
rtn
ers
and
usin
g
evid
en
ce
to f
ocu
s in
ve
stm
en
t on
are
as o
f gre
ate
st
ne
ed.
Sh
are
d Y
HN
an
d C
ou
ncil
dig
ita
l in
clu
sio
n
ca
pa
city h
as b
een
esta
blis
he
d fo
r 2
ye
ars
to
sup
po
rt d
igita
l ch
am
pio
ns a
nd
co
ord
inate
th
e d
igita
l skill
s t
rain
ing
an
d
su
ppo
rt.
Page 41 of 81
C2 - Digital skills support for front-line staff A
gre
e t
he r
ole
of fr
ont-
line
sta
ff in
diffe
ren
t se
rvic
es in
su
pp
ort
ing te
nan
ts g
ett
ing
on
line
. U
nde
rsta
nd
the
skill
s g
ap
s f
or
sta
ff to
sup
po
rt c
usto
me
rs t
o u
se
dig
ita
l se
rvic
es.
Aw
are
ne
ss o
f th
e d
igita
l p
rog
ram
me
ha
s
be
en
ra
ise
d a
t te
am
me
eting
s a
nd
th
rou
gh
vid
eo
blo
gs, m
essa
ge
s o
n t
he
in
tra
ne
t a
nd
em
ails
sen
t to
ma
na
ge
rs fo
r d
isse
min
atio
n t
o s
taff.
A d
igita
l sta
ff n
etw
ork
ha
s b
ee
n s
et u
p,
ma
de
up
of
sta
ff w
ho
are
pa
ssio
na
te
ab
ou
t a
ll th
ing
s d
igita
l. G
rou
p m
em
be
rs
are
su
pp
ort
ing
co
llea
gu
es to
un
de
rsta
nd
the
ro
le o
f d
igita
l in
their w
ork
.
Pro
vid
e a
pp
rop
ria
te tra
inin
g,
su
ppo
rt a
nd
gu
ida
nce
to
fro
nt-
line
sta
ff in a
rea
s
aff
ecte
d b
y t
he
oth
er
sh
ort
te
rm a
ctio
ns in
th
is p
lan
.
NC
C a
re c
urr
en
tly w
ork
ing
on
an L
MS
m
od
ule
to
he
lp to
in
form
sta
ff a
bou
t a
ll th
ing
s d
igita
l a
nd t
he
ir r
ole
Re
vie
w t
he
im
pa
ct a
nd c
osts
of
the
in
vo
lve
me
nt of
fro
nt-
line
sta
ff in
su
ppo
rtin
g d
igita
l in
clu
sio
n w
ork
in
th
e
pilo
t a
rea
s,
agre
e a
n o
rga
nis
atio
n-w
ide
a
pp
roa
ch
an
d p
rovid
e tra
inin
g,
su
ppo
rt
an
d g
uid
an
ce a
s a
pp
rop
ria
te.
C3 – Communications
and awareness plan
De
ve
lop
an
d la
un
ch
dra
ft p
lan
.
De
vis
e a
pla
n to
en
coura
ge
cu
sto
me
rs to
a
cce
ss s
erv
ice
s o
nlin
e in
ste
ad
of fa
ce
to
fa
ce
or
via
th
e te
leph
on
e.
Co
mp
lete
d:
Initia
l co
mm
un
ica
tio
ns h
as
focu
sed
on
en
su
rin
g t
ha
t cu
sto
me
rs w
ere
a
wa
re o
f th
e w
ith
dra
wa
l o
f ca
sh
iers
fro
m
cu
sto
me
r se
rvic
e c
en
tre
s,
usin
g p
oste
rs
an
d a
uto
ma
ted
ph
one
ca
mp
aig
ns.
Vid
eo
blo
gs p
oste
d o
n F
ace
boo
k a
nd
Y
ou
Tub
e h
ave p
rovid
ed
add
itio
na
l in
form
atio
n a
bo
ut
ou
r d
igita
l p
lan
s.
De
vis
e a
pla
n to
re
co
gn
ise
ho
w w
e c
an
su
ppo
rt t
he
mo
st
vu
lnera
ble
cu
sto
me
rs t
o
acce
ss s
erv
ice
s in
the
dig
ita
l w
orld
.
5
Page 42 of 81
S1 – Accessible online services Id
entify
YH
N m
ost fr
equ
en
t in
tera
ctio
ns to
e
nsu
re th
at
we
ta
ckle
th
e s
witch
to
on
line
d
eliv
ery
in
th
e r
igh
t o
rde
r.
Co
mp
lete
d:
the
“T
op
7 t
he
me
s”
we
re
ide
ntified
an
d h
ave b
ee
n u
se
d to
de
live
r e
arly im
pro
ve
me
nts
.
Fo
r th
e T
op
7 t
hem
es, im
pro
ve
exis
tin
g
on
line
pro
ce
sse
s a
nd
im
ple
men
t ne
w
on
line
se
rvic
es w
he
re n
one
cu
rre
ntly
exis
t.
Pa
ym
en
t syste
ms h
ave
bee
n u
pg
rad
ed
.
Ho
me
Co
nte
nts
In
su
ran
ce
ap
plic
ation
s
an
d c
laim
s a
re a
va
ilab
le o
nlin
e.
Re
pla
ce
me
nt
do
or
en
try f
ob
s a
re o
rde
red
thro
ugh
an
on
line
-on
ly p
roce
ss.
S2 – Mobile services
Imp
rovin
g t
he
YH
N M
ob
ile A
pp
to d
eliv
er
mo
re tra
nsa
ctio
na
l se
rvic
es,
imp
rove
la
yo
ut
an
d f
un
ctio
na
lity,
and
bra
nd
th
e
ap
p a
s Y
HN
.
Co
mp
lete
: th
e a
pp
was r
eb
rand
ed
with
Y
HN
co
lou
rs a
nd
mo
re b
utto
ns w
ere
a
dde
d to
giv
e t
he
cu
sto
me
r q
uic
ke
r a
cce
ss f
rom
th
e fro
nt
scre
en
.
To in
cre
ase c
usto
me
r fu
nction
alit
y t
o u
se
the
ap
p f
or
se
rvic
e r
equ
ests
.
Co
mp
lete
: T
he a
pp
con
tin
ue
s t
o g
ive
cu
sto
me
rs a
cce
ss to
bid
din
g f
or
pro
pe
rtie
s
an
d r
ep
ort
ing
re
pa
irs.
Imp
rove
me
nts
ha
ve
b
een
ma
de
fo
r cu
sto
me
rs p
ayin
g t
he
ir
ren
t, r
ep
ort
ing a
nti-s
ocia
l b
eh
avio
ur
or
ma
kin
g a
co
mp
lain
t.
Th
e a
pp
now
als
o
allo
ws r
ep
ort
ing
en
viro
nm
en
tal is
su
es,
acce
ss to
jo
bs,
a lin
k to
YH
N’s
Fa
ce
bo
ok
new
sp
ag
e a
nd a
fe
ed
ba
ck b
utt
on
.
To lin
k t
he
ap
p d
eve
lop
men
t to
th
e
red
esig
n o
f th
e Y
HN
we
bsite
to
giv
e t
he
sa
me u
sab
ility
an
d fu
nctio
na
lity
irre
sp
ective
of
the
typ
e o
f de
vic
e t
he
cu
sto
me
rs u
se
(i.e
. sm
art
ph
on
e, ta
ble
t,
PC
).
We
an
ticip
ate
th
at th
e a
pp
will
be
dis
co
ntinu
ed o
nce
a f
ully
re
sp
on
siv
e
web
site
an
d c
usto
me
r p
ort
al a
re a
va
ilab
le.
Page 43 of 81
S3 – SMS (text
messaging)
Exte
nd
con
tra
ct
with
su
pp
lier
(De
ep
lake
) fo
r a
fu
rth
er
ye
ar,
de
ve
lop
ing a
nd
eva
lua
tin
g n
ew
use
s for
the
se
rvic
e
Co
mp
lete
: te
xt
me
ssa
gin
g is n
ow
be
ing
u
se
d s
ucce
ssfu
lly w
ith
in t
he
In
co
me
te
am
.
Ad
ditio
na
l u
se
s w
ill b
e id
en
tified
as n
ew
o
nlin
e s
erv
ice
s a
re d
eve
lop
ed
.
S4 – Social Media
Co
ntin
ue
to in
cre
ase
ou
r u
se
of
so
cia
l m
ed
ia a
s a
to
ol to
sha
re info
rma
tion
with
o
ur
follo
we
rs.
Co
mp
lete
: F
aceb
oo
k, T
witte
r a
nd
Yo
uT
ub
e a
re u
se
d to
sh
are
new
s s
torie
s
an
d in
form
atio
n.
Re
vie
w o
ptio
ns fo
r re
sp
ond
ing t
o
cu
sto
me
r en
qu
irie
s t
hat
are
re
ce
ive
d v
ia
so
cia
l m
ed
ia, in
clu
din
g c
on
sid
era
tio
n o
f h
ow
an
d w
he
n r
esp
onse
s s
hou
ld b
e
pro
vid
ed
outs
ide
tra
ditio
na
l w
ork
ing h
ou
rs.
5
Page 44 of 81
S5 – Website Redesign
Re
de
sig
n Y
HN
we
bsite
to
ma
ke
it
“re
sp
on
siv
e”
(i.e
. e
asily
usa
ble
on m
ob
ile
ph
on
es a
nd
ta
ble
ts),
su
ppo
rt g
rea
ter
cu
sto
me
rs in
tera
ction
an
d r
efle
ct
the
ch
an
ge
s m
ad
e to
th
e m
ob
ile a
pp
.
Th
e r
ep
lace
me
nt
site
will
use
a
co
mm
erc
ially
ava
ilab
le p
latfo
rm
(Wo
rdp
ress)
to m
inim
ise
co
sts
, w
hile
e
nsu
rin
g t
he
site
co
ntin
ue
s to
me
et
cu
sto
me
r e
xp
ecta
tio
ns f
or
fun
ctio
na
lity.
Th
e w
eb
site
will
be
desig
ne
d a
s a
“b
roch
ure
site
” w
ith
tra
nsa
ction
s t
akin
g
pla
ce
th
roug
h th
e s
ha
red
cu
sto
me
r p
ort
al
be
ing d
eve
lope
d w
ith th
e C
ou
ncil
by th
e
Dig
ita
l F
irst
tea
m.
S6 –Telephony
Dra
ft v
isio
n,
co
nsu
lta
tio
n w
ith
cu
sto
me
rs,
ap
pro
ve
vis
ion
, n
ext
ste
ps to
re
vie
w t
he
co
nta
ct
cen
tre
an
d e
nqu
iry c
en
tre
d
eliv
ery
.
Co
mp
lete
: th
e te
lep
hon
y v
isio
n h
as b
een
a
gre
ed
an
d is c
on
sis
ten
t w
ith
th
e D
igita
l V
isio
n t
o c
om
ple
me
nt
NC
C a
nd
YH
N t
o
su
ppo
rt c
usto
me
rs t
o m
ake
th
e m
ove
to
o
nlin
e s
erv
ice
s.
Page 45 of 81
E1 – Nudge Research
Pa
rtic
ipa
te in
th
e “
Nudge
Yo
ur
Wa
y T
o
Ch
an
ne
l S
hift”
re
se
arc
h p
roje
ct, r
un b
y
CA
PIT
A.
YH
N h
as a
gre
ed
to p
art
icip
ate
in
the
p
rog
ram
me
, jo
intly w
ith
the
Co
un
cil.
T
he
p
rog
ram
me
is d
ue
to
be
gin
in F
eb
rua
ry
20
16
.
5
Page 46 of 81
Board 2 February 2016
Governance Improvement Plan Update
Board Learning and Development Plan
Report by Company Secretary
For Decision
1. Background information
1.1 This report provides an update on the Governance Improvement Plan and sets out a Learning and Development Plan for Board members for 2016/17.
1.2 At the Board Away Day in April 2015, Board members received a presentation from Fiona Underwood of Altair outlining the Homes and Communities Agency (HCA) regulation reform, the responsibilities of Boards and highlights from the Cosmopolitan report. One key area from the HCA Governance regulation is; Registered providers shall ensure that they manage their affairs with an appropriate degree of skill, independence, diligence, effectiveness, prudence and foresight Board reviewed a self-assessment which had been completed against the HCA Regulatory Standards and highlighted the current compliance, gaps and governance issues and agreed a set of actions, the Governance Improvement Plan.
2. Progress to date
2.1 The updated Governance Improvement Plan is attached as appendix 1 and shows the progress which has been made by the officers and Board members in improving the governance of the organisation, to ensure our performance meets the standard.
2.2 A lot of the work has been completed over the last nine months in conjunction with the disaggregation project, especially around the structure of the Board, subsidiaries and committees as well as new documentation such as a Board member job description and the Group Governance Handbook.
6
Page 47 of 81
2.3 All actions completed to the target date have been marked as completed, with just two actions which had slight delays in the completion date.
2.4 The actions which are still outstanding are; - Benchmarking other ALMO agenda content and report templates - Amending Board report template and contents - Appraisal process to be reviewed - Governance review included in the Internal Audit Plan - Succession Plan of senior executives devised
These will be carried over into 2016.
3. Learning and Development Plan
3.1 In order to achieve our strategic objectives - the shape, skills and knowledge of YHN’s workforce needs to constantly develop and adapt within the context of some challenging and seemingly conflicting targets e.g. the need to make large cost savings whilst maintaining the quality of service for tenants. Integral to success is the provision of relevant and effective learning and development of all staff groups at every level within the organisation including the Board.
Devising a Learning and Development plan, linked to the Board member role description and specific Board member responsibilities, was highlighted in the Governance Improvement Plan as a medium priority action with a completion date of December 2015. This needed to include training on strengthening financial understanding and the ability to scrutinise reports and training linked to the new role description, in order to strengthen governance within the organisation.
With this brief, a range of learning and development areas were agreed by Board in September 2015. Appendix 2 sets these areas out in greater detail showing the delivery method and timescales.
3.2 The first development area which has been identified for all Board members is in relation to the legal role of the Board and directors duties. We have worked with a leading law practice, Anthony Collins, who specialise in training and have previously delivered events for YHN. The full day session will include the key areas relating to legislation, directors duties and liabilities, governance and equality and diversity legislation.
3.3 The rest of the learning and development plan is a mixture of delivery methods using in-house training with officers such as the Head of Finance, LMS e-learning and board briefing sessions.
3.4 Board members are requested to review, comment and approve the content of the Learning and Development Plan.
4. How success is measured
4.1 Attendance at the training sessions will be recorded and reported to the Board annually and individual members Learning and Development will form
Page 48 of 81
part of the Board members reviews with the Chair.
5. The Business Implications
5.1 Mission and Strategic Objectives:
The development of the Board contributes to all the strategic objectives of the organisation as the Board is the strategic leadership of the organisation and should be fit for purpose at all times.
5.2 Value for money/efficiencies:
We have sourced a range of internal and external training providers to ensure value for money.
5.3 Financial Implications:
The Board has a development budget of £5,000, these proposals are within budget.
5.4 Resources (financial, property, technological or human):
In most of the proposals in house training utilising the skills of current staff has been recommended, with external providers sourced for the legal aspects.
5.5 Impact on services/performance:
Learning and development will ensure the Board are equipped to discharge their responsibilities and perform effectively.
5.6 Outcomes for tenants/leaseholders:
A well informed Board will contribute to more informed strategic decisions being made for the benefit of the organisation and all tenants/leaseholders.
5.7 Risk (reputation, relationship):
The development of effective decision making and good governance within YHN ensures the organisation is well run and avoids any risks of reputational damage or governance failures.
5.8 Environmental: none
5.9 Legal: as discussed in the body of the report
5.10 Equality and Diversity and Community Cohesion: as discussed in the body of the report
5.11 Stakeholder Involvement/consultation: none
6. Conclusion and recommendations
6.1 Board is recommended to review, comment and approve the Learning and Development Plan.
6
Page 49 of 81
7. Implementation
7.1 The Company Secretary will ensure all learning and development is scheduled throughout the year, monitor and record attendance and report to the Board annually on the progress of the plan and member attendance.
Background Papers Board member role description Group Governance Handbook Contact Officer: If you have any questions about this report that you would like clarifying before the meeting, you can contact Jill Davison by telephone on 0191 278 8624 or email [email protected]
Page 50 of 81
Boa
rd L
earn
ing
an
d D
eve
lop
me
nt
Pla
n 2
01
6/1
7
Th
em
e
Wh
at
are
as
wil
l b
e c
ove
red
W
ho
re
qu
ire
s t
his
?
Ho
w i
t w
ill
be
de
live
red
T
ime
sc
ale
T
he
role
of
the
B
oa
rd a
nd its
m
em
be
rs
Fid
ucia
ry d
utie
s
Duties u
nd
er
the
Co
mp
an
ies A
ct 2
006
‘Oth
er’ d
utie
s –
sta
tuto
ry a
nd
co
mm
on
la
w in
clu
din
g r
egu
lato
ry,
the
Brib
ery
A
ct
and
Co
rpo
rate
Man
sla
ugh
ter
Lia
bili
ty o
f tr
uste
es
Dea
ling w
ith
co
nflic
ts o
f in
tere
st
Gu
idan
ce
an
d r
ea
ssu
ran
ce
Prin
cip
les o
f goo
d g
ove
rna
nce
Regu
lato
ry F
ram
ew
ork
exp
ecta
tion
s
Ris
k m
ana
ge
men
t a
nd r
isk f
low
Role
s –
of
the
Bo
ard
, th
e E
xe
cu
tive
, w
ith
sh
are
ho
lde
rs a
nd
su
bsid
iarie
s
Eff
ective
Boa
rd p
erf
orm
an
ce
Equ
alit
y le
gis
latio
n a
nd t
he
pro
tecte
d
ch
ara
cte
ristics
Exp
ecta
tio
ns o
n e
mp
loye
rs
How
to
ma
na
ge
alle
ga
tion
s o
f d
iscrim
ina
tion
etc
.
Ris
ks a
nd
lia
bili
ties
All
ne
w s
tart
ers
plu
s a
ny e
xis
ting
bo
ard
me
mb
ers
wh
o h
ave
a
sse
ssed
kn
ow
led
ge
as ‘lim
ite
d’ o
r ‘n
on
e’.
To e
nsu
re v
alu
e fo
r m
on
ey w
e
wo
uld
en
co
ura
ge
all
Bo
ard
m
em
be
rs to
att
en
d.
An
tho
ny C
olli
ns S
olic
ito
rs
Em
plo
ym
en
t a
nd
go
ve
rna
nce
pro
fessio
na
ls to
pro
vid
e
be
spo
ke
tra
inin
g c
ove
rin
g a
ll d
utie
s c
ove
red
by
legis
latio
n.
Full
da
y c
ou
rse h
eld
at Y
HN
Ho
use
to
in
clu
de t
hre
e
ele
me
nts
;
D
ire
cto
rs’
Du
ties
an
d L
iab
ilit
ies
Go
ve
rna
nce
E
qu
ali
ty a
nd
Div
ers
ity
Da
te to
be
agre
ed in
ea
rly 2
01
6
(Ap
ril)
Go
ve
rna
nce
at
YH
N
Gro
up
go
ve
rna
nce
ha
nd
boo
k
Sta
nd
ing o
rde
rs
Cod
e o
f con
du
ct
All
ne
w s
tart
ers
O
ne
to
on
e w
ith
Com
pa
ny S
ecre
tary
G
rou
p G
ove
rna
nce H
an
dbo
ok,
Cod
e o
f C
on
du
ct
W
ith
in o
ne
mo
nth
of
ap
po
intm
en
t
Fin
an
ce
le
ve
l o
ne
Ba
sic
defin
itio
ns
How
to
rea
d a
nd
und
ers
tan
d f
inan
cia
l in
form
atio
n
An
in
trod
uction
to
YH
N’s
fin
an
ce
s
All
bo
ard
mem
be
rs w
ith
ou
t a
cco
un
tan
cy q
ua
lific
atio
n
In h
ou
se t
rain
ing s
essio
n w
ith
He
ad
of
Fin
an
ce
eithe
r o
ne
to
on
e s
essio
n o
r sm
all
gro
up
se
ssio
ns
Qu
art
er
1
Fin
an
ce
le
ve
l tw
o
Va
lue
fo
r m
one
y
Net
pre
sen
t va
lue
C
ash
flo
w
Bu
sin
ess c
ase
s
Str
ess t
estin
g
Mo
re d
eta
iled
loo
k a
t Y
HN
’s f
inan
ce
s
All
bo
ard
mem
be
rs
In h
ou
se t
rain
ing s
essio
n w
ith
He
ad
of
Fin
an
ce
p
rogra
mm
ed
into
Bo
ard
fo
rwa
rd p
lan
to
be
com
ple
ted
a
t B
oa
rd m
ee
tin
g.
Qu
art
er
1
(10
May 2
01
6 B
oa
rd)
6
Page 51 of 81
Ris
k,
au
dit a
nd
brib
ery
le
ve
l o
ne
Lia
bili
ties a
nd
ba
sic
con
ce
pts
A
ll b
oa
rd m
em
be
rs –
an
nua
l re
fresh
er
E-L
ea
rnin
g L
MS
(L
ea
rnin
g M
an
age
me
nt S
yste
m)
Curr
en
t B
rib
ery
Mo
du
le t
o b
e r
efr
eshe
d to
in
clu
de
R
isk a
nd
Au
dit
Co
uld
be
de
live
red
as a
gro
up
se
ssio
n fo
r th
ose
wh
o
do
no
t e
nga
ge
with
E-L
ea
rnin
g.
Ne
w L
MS
la
un
ch
on
1st A
pril 20
16,
all
Bo
ard
m
em
be
rs to
be
issue
d w
ith
pa
ssw
ord
s,
brie
fing
se
ssio
n o
n L
MS
to
be
sch
edu
led
into
Bo
ard
me
etin
g.
Qu
art
er
2
Ris
k,
au
dit a
nd
brib
ery
le
ve
l tw
o
Mo
re d
eta
iled
le
ve
l of
the
sam
e c
on
ce
pts
A
ud
it C
om
mitte
e m
em
be
rs
Brie
fin
g s
essio
ns p
lann
ed
in
to G
rou
p A
ud
it m
eetin
gs:
Au
dit inte
rna
l &
exte
rna
l o
ve
rvie
w f
or
ne
w
mem
be
rs
Ris
k m
ana
ge
men
t
Fra
ud
, B
ribe
ry, W
his
tleb
low
ing
Th
rou
gh
ou
t 2
01
5/1
6
Equ
alit
ies a
nd
d
ive
rsity le
ve
l o
ne
The
le
ga
l fr
am
ew
ork
All
ne
w s
tart
ers
plu
s a
ny e
xis
ting
bo
ard
me
mb
ers
wh
o h
ave
a
sse
ssed
kn
ow
led
ge
as ‘lim
ite
d’ o
r ‘n
on
e’.
Equ
alit
y le
gis
latio
n s
essio
n p
rovid
ed
by A
nth
on
y
Colli
ns (
se
e s
ectio
n a
bo
ve
)
Da
te to
be
agre
ed in
ea
rly 2
01
6
(Ap
ril)
Equ
alit
ies a
nd
d
ive
rsity le
ve
l tw
o
Le
ga
l fr
am
ew
ork
A
wa
ren
ess r
ais
ing
Cha
ngin
g f
ace
of
div
ers
ity
E&
D a
t Y
HN
All
bo
ard
mem
be
rs –
an
nua
l re
fresh
er
Mix
ture
of
info
rma
tio
n r
ep
ort
s to
Bo
ard
mee
tings,
in-
ho
use
briefing s
essio
n a
nd
an
nu
al E
-Le
arn
ing
refr
esh
er.
Qu
art
er
2
Hea
lth
an
d
Safe
ty
The
le
ga
l fr
am
ew
ork
an
d B
oa
rd’s
lia
bili
ty
Hea
lth
an
d s
afe
ty a
t Y
HN
All
bo
ard
mem
be
rs –
an
nua
l re
fresh
er
Le
ga
l p
rofe
ssio
na
l to
de
live
r 2 h
ou
r sessio
n
Qu
art
er
4
Safe
gu
ard
ing
The
le
ga
l fr
am
ew
ork
an
d B
oa
rd’s
role
H
ow
we
ma
na
ge
safe
gu
ard
ing a
t Y
HN
All
bo
ard
mem
be
rs –
an
nua
l re
fresh
er
In h
ou
se -
fa
ce t
o fa
ce b
espo
ke
se
ssio
n d
eliv
ere
d b
y
Org
an
isation
al D
eve
lop
men
t.
Qu
art
er
3
Ge
ttin
g t
o k
no
w
ou
r serv
ices
The
wa
y s
erv
ices a
re d
eliv
ere
d
The
issu
es r
egu
larly f
ace
d
Ke
y s
ucce
sse
s a
nd c
ha
llen
ge
s
Op
tio
na
l fo
r th
ose
wh
o h
ave
id
en
tified
th
is a
s a
need
T
wic
e y
ea
rly e
sta
te to
urs
an
d te
am
vis
its –
to in
clu
de
na
rra
tio
n o
n s
erv
ice
s (
e.g
. A
SB
, sh
elte
red,
yo
un
g
pe
op
le,
op
tion
s)
as w
ell
as s
tock im
pro
ve
me
nt a
nd
rege
ne
ratio
n
Th
rou
gh
ou
t 2
01
6/1
7
Ge
ttin
g t
o k
no
w
ou
r custo
me
rs
Op
po
rtu
nitie
s to
mee
t a
nd
he
ar
fro
m
pe
op
le w
ho
use t
he
serv
ice
s
Op
tio
na
l fo
r th
ose
wh
o h
ave
id
en
tified
th
is a
s a
need
In
vita
tio
ns to
bo
ard
mem
be
rs to
eve
nts
(S
TA
R
aw
ard
s e
tc.)
and
fa
ce
to
fa
ce
info
rmatio
n b
ooth
s le
d
by C
usto
me
r In
vo
lve
me
nt T
eam
Th
rou
gh
ou
t 2
01
6/1
7
Le
ga
l u
pd
ate
s
Hou
sin
g P
olic
y
Va
rio
us a
sp
ects
of
law
an
d p
olic
y
rele
va
nt
to o
ur
serv
ices
Op
tio
na
l fo
r th
ose
wh
o h
ave
id
en
tified
th
is a
s a
need
Invita
tio
ns to
bo
ard
mem
be
rs to
se
min
ars
and
co
nfe
ren
ce
s a
s a
nd
wh
en
ava
ilab
le
Bo
ard
briefing s
essio
ns
Th
rou
gh
ou
t 2
01
6/1
7
Page 52 of 81
Te
ch
no
logy
To b
e b
ase
d o
n fu
rthe
r a
na
lysis
of
ne
ed
O
ptio
na
l fo
r th
ose
wh
o h
ave
id
en
tified
th
is a
s a
need
In h
ou
se t
rain
ing w
ith
IC
T T
rain
ing a
nd
Su
ppo
rt
Off
ice
r. T
rain
ing n
eeds a
na
lysis
fo
rms a
va
ilab
le t
o
ide
ntify
in
div
idu
al n
ee
ds.
Th
is in
clu
de
s P
C
Aw
are
ne
ss a
nd
Mic
rosoft
Off
ice
soft
wa
re.
Besp
oke
se
ssio
ns c
an
th
en b
e d
eliv
ere
d t
ailo
red
to
th
e g
rou
p
or
ind
ivid
ua
l n
ee
ds.
Th
rou
gh
ou
t 2
01
6/1
7
Em
plo
ym
en
t
Ba
sic
s o
f em
plo
ye
e r
ela
tio
ns
YH
N p
olic
ies a
nd
pro
ce
du
res
Tho
se
wh
o p
art
icip
ate
in
co
mp
an
y
ap
pe
al pa
ne
ls a
nd
mem
be
rs o
n
the
Jo
int
Con
su
ltative
Co
mm
itte
e
Op
era
tion
al H
R M
ana
ge
r fo
r Y
HN
to
de
live
r a
be
spo
ke
se
ssio
n.
When r
equ
ire
d
Com
me
rcia
l a
cu
me
n
Inn
ova
tio
ns
Be
st
pra
ctice
Retu
rn o
n in
ve
stm
en
t
Ab
ri B
oa
rd m
em
be
rs a
nd
op
tio
na
l fo
r th
ose
wh
o h
ave
id
en
tified
th
is
as a
ne
ed
Ad
ditio
na
l vis
its a
nd
/or
sp
ea
ke
rs t
o b
e d
ete
rmin
ed
by
Ab
ri B
oa
rd
When r
equ
ire
d
Cha
rita
ble
go
ve
rna
nce
C
ore
prin
cip
les
Tru
ste
es r
esp
on
sib
ilities
Asfa
leia
Bo
ard
mem
bers
an
d th
ose
w
ho
ha
ve
id
en
tified
th
is a
s a
nee
d
Half d
ay s
essio
n d
eliv
ere
d b
y C
ha
rity
Skill
s
On
ap
po
intm
en
t to
Asfa
leia
Cha
ir
Deve
lop
men
t D
eve
lop
ing t
he
role
of
the
ch
air
E
nco
ura
gin
g p
art
icip
atio
n
Bu
ildin
g R
ela
tion
sh
ips
Work
ing w
ith
off
ice
s a
nd
exe
cu
tive
s
Cha
ir,
Vic
e C
ha
irs a
nd C
om
mitte
e
Cha
irs
(tbc)
(tbc)
6
Page 53 of 81
GO
VE
RN
AN
CE
IM
PR
OV
EM
EN
T P
LA
N 2
015/1
6
RE
F
AC
TIO
NS
AG
RE
ED
AT
B
OA
RD
AW
AY
DA
Y
PR
IOR
ITY
A
CT
IVIT
Y P
RO
PO
SE
D
(in
clu
din
g
ad
ditio
na
l actio
ns p
rop
ose
d a
t a
wa
y d
ay)
TA
RG
ET
D
AT
E
PR
OG
RE
SS
H2 H
5
A15
Jo
b d
es
cri
pti
on
/Re
cru
itm
en
t R
ole
description w
hic
h inclu
des
responsib
ilities t
o b
e w
ritt
en for
chair/v
ice c
hair/b
oard
m
em
bers
/com
mitte
e c
hairs
“
Skill
s a
nd e
xperience r
eq
uired o
n
the B
oard
” develo
ped into
a P
ers
on
specific
ation w
hic
h inclu
des r
eq
uired
skill
s a
nd q
ualif
ications, in
clu
din
g
financia
l accounta
bili
ty.
S
kill
gaps identified s
hould
influence
targ
ete
d r
ecru
itm
ent fo
r th
e
independent
vacancy w
hic
h w
ill b
e
availa
ble
in 2
015.
B
enchm
ark
ing o
f th
e m
ake-u
p o
f B
oard
(siz
e a
nd s
kill
s)
and a
lso
recru
itm
ent pro
cess,
T
he leg
al and f
inancia
l skill
gap
id
entified s
hould
influence t
arg
ete
d
recru
itm
ent fo
r th
e independent
vacancy w
hic
h w
ill b
e a
vaila
ble
in
2015.
HIG
H
1.
Benchm
ark
ing o
ther
HA
/ALM
O’s
on B
oard
siz
e,
skill
s,
role
descriptions a
nd r
ecru
itm
ent
pro
cess
2.
Skill
s s
pecific
ation f
or
the b
oard
as a
whole
, S
kill
s M
atr
ix p
roposed
3.
Revis
ed J
ob d
escription for
Board
mem
bers
, in
clu
de N
ola
n p
rincip
les
4.
Skill
s h
ealth c
heck b
y indiv
idual board
m
em
bers
usin
g S
kill
s M
atr
ix
5.
Recru
itm
ent
of In
dependent
Board
mem
ber
to f
ill v
acancy o
f N
itin
Shukla
influenced b
y
gaps identified in s
kill
s h
ealth c
heck
LA
TE
R
Consid
era
tion o
f C
o-o
pte
es if
sig
nific
ant
skill
s
gap w
hic
h r
eq
uires im
media
te input
Revis
ed J
ob d
escription for
Chair, V
ice C
hair,
and C
om
mitte
e C
hairs I
nclu
ded in t
he G
roup
Govern
ance H
andbook
1.
1 J
une 2
015
2.
16 J
une 2
015
3.
16 J
une 2
015
4.
30 J
une 2
015
5.
22 S
ept 2015
H7
H9
Co
mm
itte
es
Revis
e t
he c
om
mitte
e r
em
it a
nd
schem
e o
f dele
gations f
ollo
win
g
dis
agg
reg
ation
.
Benchm
ark
with o
ther
ALM
O/R
P
com
mitte
e s
tructu
res a
nd t
erm
s o
f re
fere
nce
Board
appro
val of
a
com
pre
hensiv
e f
inancia
l fr
am
ew
ork
needs to b
e u
ndert
aken
inclu
din
g a
revie
w o
f th
e s
chem
e
HIG
H
1.
Benchm
ark
ing o
ther
RP
/ALM
O o
n c
om
mitte
e
str
uctu
res a
nd t
erm
s o
f re
fere
nce
2.
Pro
posed c
om
mitte
e s
tructu
re a
nd r
em
it r
eport
to
28 J
uly
Board
, in
clu
din
g o
utc
om
es r
eq
uired
and r
eport
ing
to B
oard
req
uirem
ents
3.
Annual cycle
of
busin
ess f
or
Board
to b
e
develo
ped a
nd r
eport
ed to 2
8 J
uly
Board
4.
Schem
e o
f dele
gations r
evis
ed
1.
30 J
une 2
015
2.
28 J
uly
2015
3.
28 J
uly
2015
4.
22 S
ept 2015
6
Page 54 of 81
of
dele
gations a
nd f
inancia
l re
gula
tions.
The c
urr
ent fo
rward
pla
n t
o b
e
adapte
d into
a s
trate
gic
annual
cycle
of
busin
ess for
the B
oard
and c
om
mitte
es w
hic
h c
an
inte
gra
te a
gendas a
nd e
nsure
a
focus o
n a
chie
vin
g o
utc
om
es.
5.
Fin
ancia
l re
gula
tions r
evis
ed
6.
Confirm
chang
es t
o g
overn
ance a
rrang
em
ents
and a
mended d
ocum
enta
tion, to
be a
ppro
ved
at
AG
M.
7.
Mem
bers
hip
of
com
mitte
es t
o b
e a
ppro
ved a
t A
GM
5.
Full
revie
w
req
uired d
ue
to s
enio
r m
anag
em
ent
chang
es
6.
22 S
ept 2015
7.
22 S
ept 2015
H5
H7
H8
A14
A15
Bo
ard
meeti
ng
eff
ecti
ven
ess
Chair t
o intr
oduce r
eport
s a
nd
sum
marise the s
ignific
ance o
f th
e
item
and a
ny p
revio
us
dis
cussio
n/s
cru
tiny t
o c
learly
info
rm B
oard
mem
bers
of th
e input
req
uired fro
m them
.
Board
mem
bers
to c
onta
ct
off
icers
w
ith r
eg
ard
to d
eta
il in
report
s p
rior
to B
oard
meeting
s
Fin
ancia
l and n
on-f
inancia
l perf
orm
ance r
eport
s to b
e b
roug
ht
tog
eth
er
at
Board
.
Benchm
ark
ag
enda c
onte
nt
and
report
tem
pla
tes
Cash f
low
report
ing t
o B
oard
fro
m
April 2015.
Manag
em
ent te
am
to look a
t str
ength
enin
g b
usin
esses c
ases
and e
xit s
trate
gie
s w
hen
pre
senting
pro
jects
to B
oard
.
Ong
oin
g m
onitoring
info
rmation o
f risk n
eeds t
o b
e p
rovid
ed t
o t
he
Board
by o
ffic
ers
.
ME
DIU
M
1.
Pro
vid
e C
hair w
ith s
um
mary
of
report
s,
sig
nific
ance o
f item
, any b
ackgro
und to t
he
item
i.e
. pre
vio
us d
iscussio
n/s
cru
tiny a
nd a
cle
ar
indic
ation o
f th
e input re
quired fro
m
Board
.
2.
Benchm
ark
ing o
ther
RP
/ALM
O’s
ag
enda
conte
nt and r
eport
tem
pla
tes
3.
Report
s t
o B
oard
am
ended t
o r
eflect
impro
vem
ents
req
uired i.e
. bring
ing
tog
eth
er
financia
l and n
on
-fin
ancia
l in
form
ation,
dashboard
of
indic
ato
rs, suite o
f financia
l covenants
, m
onitoring o
f risk info
rmation a
nd
str
ength
enin
g b
usin
ess c
ases a
nd e
xit
str
ate
gie
s w
hen p
resenting p
roje
cts
F
inancia
l and n
on-f
inancia
l in
form
ation n
ow
pre
sente
d t
o B
oard
, dashboard
in d
evelo
pm
ent
LA
TE
R
Develo
p a
nd p
ilot
a m
echanis
m for
Board
m
em
bers
to h
ave g
reate
r com
munic
ation
with o
ffic
ers
on d
eta
il of
item
s p
rior
to B
oard
m
eeting
.
1.
16 J
une 2
015
2.
22 S
ept 2015
3.
22 S
ept 2015
Outs
tandin
g
Outs
tandin
g
Page 55 of 81
H2
H5
H7
A14
Tra
inin
g
Tra
inin
g r
eq
uirem
ents
whic
h w
ould
str
ength
en u
nders
tandin
g o
f ro
le
and r
esponsib
ilities inclu
din
g
financia
l ele
ments
to b
e fed into
annual Learn
ing &
Develo
pm
ent
pla
n.
Tra
inin
g o
n r
ole
s a
nd
responsib
ilities lin
ked to p
ers
on
specific
ation to b
e c
om
ple
ted b
y a
ll B
oard
mem
bers
on a
ppoin
tment
and p
eriodic
ally
on r
e-
appoin
tment.
Rang
e o
f le
arn
ing a
nd
develo
pm
ent
options t
o b
e
pro
posed to B
oard
(tr
ain
ing,
exte
rnal fa
cili
tato
rs &
consultants
)
Str
eng
then the s
kill
s b
ase o
n
Fin
ance a
nd R
esourc
es
Com
mitte
e, so B
oard
assure
d
suff
icie
nt financia
l scru
tiny a
nd
challe
ng
e.
Identify
best
pra
ctice in o
ther
ALM
O/R
P t
o e
nhance learn
ing
ME
DIU
M
1.
Benchm
ark
ing w
ith o
ther
RP
/ALM
O’s
on t
he
train
ing a
nd e
nhanced learn
ing o
ffere
d t
o
board
mem
bers
2.
Tra
inin
g a
nd d
evelo
pm
ent
options p
resente
d
to B
oard
for
com
ment
3.
Update
annual le
arn
ing a
nd d
evelo
pm
ent
pla
n f
or
2015/2
016 t
o inclu
de t
rain
ing
on
str
ength
enin
g f
inancia
l unders
tandin
g a
nd
abili
ty t
o s
cru
tinis
e a
nd k
ey t
rain
ing lin
ked t
o
role
description
4.
Report
to B
oard
annually
on learn
ing
and
develo
pm
ent
undert
aken inclu
din
g
att
endance b
y b
oard
mem
bers
, fe
ed into
in
div
iduals
appra
isals
.
1.
28 J
uly
2015
2.
28 J
uly
2015
22 S
ept 2015
3.
22 S
ept 2015
2 F
eb 2
016
4.
Annually
H4
H5
Ap
pra
isal
A r
evis
ed B
oard
appra
isal and
develo
pm
ent
pro
gra
mm
e is
req
uired, w
hic
h w
ill b
e lin
ked t
o t
he
role
description a
nd p
ers
on
specific
ation.
Board
mem
bers
appra
isals
(lin
ked
to p
ers
on s
pecific
ation)
to f
eed into
th
e a
nnual le
arn
ing a
nd
develo
pm
ent
pla
n.
ME
DIU
M
1.
Appra
isal &
Develo
pm
ent
pro
cess r
evis
ed t
o
reflect jo
b d
escription a
nd s
kill
s m
atr
ix,
and
linked into
learn
ing
& d
evelo
pm
ent
pla
n
1.
31 D
ec 2
015
Outs
tandin
g
6
Page 56 of 81
H2
H3
H4
H13
As
sessm
en
t o
f g
overn
an
ce
Eff
ecti
ven
ess
Assessm
ent
arr
ang
em
ents
in
clu
ded in I
nte
rnal A
udit a
nnual
pla
n.
Directo
rs r
eport
to inclu
de a
sta
tem
ent of
com
plia
nce w
ith t
he
govern
ance d
ocum
ents
.
All
govern
ance d
ocum
ents
made
availa
ble
on t
he intr
anet
Exte
rnal in
dependent re
vie
w t
o b
e
schedule
d f
ollo
win
g A
GM
2016 t
o
assess h
ow
successfu
l th
e n
ew
arr
ang
em
ents
have b
een
imple
mente
d.
Com
ple
te g
overn
ance r
evie
w
annually
and/o
r m
ake s
tate
ment
in
annual re
port
.
ME
DIU
M
1.
Govern
ance r
evie
w inclu
ded in I
nte
rnal A
udit
2015/1
6 p
lan
Req
uest m
ade to b
e s
chedule
d into
2016/1
7
pla
n o
nce n
ew
str
uctu
re e
mbedded in.
2.
Annual re
port
to inclu
de s
tate
ment of
com
plia
nce
3.
Govern
ance p
ag
e o
n intr
anet re
freshed to
inclu
de a
ll g
overn
ance d
ocum
ents
LA
TE
R
Exte
rnal in
dependent re
vie
w t
o b
e s
chedule
d
follo
win
g A
GM
2016
Com
ple
te g
overn
ance r
evie
w a
nnually
1.
22 S
ept 2015
2.
22 S
ept 2015
3.
22 S
ept 2015
H5
Su
ccessio
n p
lan
nin
g
S
uccessio
n p
lannin
g o
f senio
r executives t
o b
e u
ndert
aken.
LO
W
1.
Successio
n p
lan o
f senio
r executives d
evis
ed
T
o b
e c
om
ple
ted in c
onju
nction w
ith
manag
em
ent re
vie
w
1.
31 D
ec 2
015
Outs
tandin
g
H9
Au
dit
A
nnual re
port
of th
e A
udit
Com
mitte
e C
hair t
o B
oard
to b
e
enhanced,
by p
resenting t
o t
he
Board
annually
to g
ive h
is
independent
vie
w o
f th
e
eff
ectiveness o
f th
e r
isk fra
mew
ork
and c
om
ment
on a
ny a
reas o
f str
ength
or
weaknesses o
r concern
s
on t
he f
utu
re d
irection.
LO
W
1.
Annual A
udit C
om
mitte
e r
eport
to the A
GM
to
inclu
de independent
vie
w o
f eff
ectiveness o
f risk fra
mew
ork
inclu
din
g s
trength
s/
weakness/ concern
s
1.
22 S
ept 2015
H11
Co
ntr
acts
C
om
pany S
ecre
tary
to log a
ll are
as
of
the b
usin
ess e
nte
ring
into
sale
s
contr
acts
and s
et
up a
centr
al
reg
iste
r w
ithin
the g
overn
ance
depart
ment.
LO
W
1.
Sale
s c
ontr
act re
gis
ter
esta
blis
hed
1.
1 O
ct
2015
Page 57 of 81
H1
Co
de o
f g
overn
an
ce
T
he C
om
pany S
ecre
tary
to c
ontinue
to m
onitor
code o
f g
overn
ance f
or
any f
utu
re c
onsultations o
r re
vis
ions
to the G
oo
d G
overn
an
ce S
tan
dard
fo
r P
ub
lic S
erv
ices,
and e
nsure
kept
up t
o d
ate
.
LO
W
1.
Ong
oin
g g
overn
ance c
om
plia
nce r
evie
w a
s
part
of
Com
pany S
ecre
tary
role
and
responsib
ilities.
1.
Ong
oin
g
6
Page 58 of 81
Board 8 December 2015 (5.00pm to 7.25pm)
Present: O Grant (Chair), P Dibbs, P Dutton, L Doherty, V Dunn, D Huddart, J Purvis, J McCarty, A Mirza (until 6.15), T Moore, M Page, J Reid, J Streather, L Stephenson, E Snaith (from 6.00), M Talbot, L Wilson.
In attendance:
J Davison Company Secretary
N Scott Senior Director & Director of Tenancy Services
S Breslin Assistant Chief Executive & Director of Corporate Services
D Langhorne Director of Property Services
L Forrest Head of Finance
D Creighton Executive Assistant to the Chief Executive
J Urwin Head of Housing Options
R Clark Care Services Manager
P Lumsden Health and Safety Manager
J Vinton Head of Assets and Regeneration
I Gallagher Head of Property Maintenance
B Elder Strategic HR Manager
A Senior Newcastle City Council (until 6.10)
430 WELCOME
The Chair welcomed everyone to the meeting.
431 APOLOGIES
Apologies were received from P Scope and D Slesenger.
432 DECLARATIONS OF INTERESTS
No interests were declared
433 MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT
Submitted: Report by the Director of Corporate Services (previously circulated, copy attached to Official Minutes).
Sheila Breslin introduced the report, explaining this was the third time the Management Agreement had been brought to Board, and additional sessions had been provided for those members who wanted to discuss the agreement in more detail.
Sheila Breslin informed the Board there had been minimal changes to the main
7
Page 59 of 81
section of the agreement since the last version was circulated, and the final proofing would be completed on the schedules. The main part of the agreement was the contractual part, and the appendices/schedules contained areas subject to annual review. The NCC capital programme was to be agreed at January cabinet, the fee would be agreed as part of NCC budget processes and the YHN Delivery Plan would be brought to the March Board meeting.
The Chair questioned what minor changes had been made to the agreement. Sheila Breslin responded that these had been proof read and changes were typically pagination, cross references, and plurals. Discussions with NCC had been around the agreement of how service charges would be paid, and all issues had been resolved.
RESOLVED, the Board agreed to;
The content of the main part of the management agreement and noted the next steps in section five of the report.
434 HEALTH AND SAFETY SIX MONTHLY REPORT
Submitted: Report by the Director of Corporate Services (previously circulated, copy attached to Official Minutes).
David Langhorne introduced the report which outlined Board members’ responsibilities and reported on Health and Safety (H&S) accidents and incidents.
David Langhorne also provided Board members with an update on recent major incidents.
Dean House suspected carbon monoxide incident – the work is underway to remove the drying cabinets from 10 multi storey blocks which affects 882 properties with only 200 outstanding. BCE have worked very quickly to ensure this programme of works is completed.
Iris Steadman House – Following the incident of a resident falling in her home which was undergoing refurbishment works, sadly the resident has passed away. David Langhorne explained this incident is under legal privilege as a claim is still outstanding with the sub-contractors, but assured the Board that YHN had complied with all H&S duties.
St Anne’s scaffolding collapse during high winds – the HSE had been informed and a report submitted by the contractors, measures were put in place and the HSE were happy for the site to re-open.
Craster Square – sink hole appeared adjacent to the garages which is suspected to be a mine air shaft. No further updates for Board at this time as the Coal Authority are still undertaking investigations.
Recent high winds have also damaged YHN properties, with a house in Warrington Road losing its roof and a garage block in Tumulus Avenue also losing part of the roof. Two residents have been decanted whilst the structure of the house is surveyed, and the garage block will most likely be demolished.
Section six of the report outlined new legislation regarding corporate manslaughter and David Langhorne assured the Board the implications of this would be included in the H&S training session for Board members.
Page 60 of 81
Questions/Comments
A Board member questioned when the next meeting of the H&S committee would be, and another Board member expressed interest in attending these meetings. Paul Lumsden to action.
A Board member questioned the statistics on incidents to employees and enquired what animal related incidents were. Paul Lumsden confirmed these were mainly dog related incidents.
Doreen Huddart declared an interest as she occupies one of the garages affected by wind damage.
A Board member referred to Board’s roles and responsibilities in section three, and asked whether this crossed over to tenants, with regard to contractors carrying out work in their homes, and what steps we made to promote H&S and draw to tenants attention the work being carried out. Paul Lumsden responded that the capital investment team complete a lot of tenant liaison work, talking to tenants and explaining the work being completed, if the work is major then tenants would be decanted to a safe property until complete. With regard to day to day repairs, the organisation relies on competent workers to inform tenants of the possible dangers.
A Board member questioned whether the new corporate manslaughter legislation would be included in the risk register. Neil Scott to action.
A Board member commented that in section 4.3 aggressive / threatening / intimidating behaviour and verbal abuse was the main area of concern and that racial discrimination should be reported under the business implications for equality and diversity. RESOLVED, the Board;
Received and commented on the report
435 MINUTES OF 3 NOVEMBER 2015
A Board member thanked the officers for including further information in the minutes with regard to the breakdown of why tenancies are terminated, commented that the biggest area was internal transfers and enquired how this is being addressed. Neil Scott responded that the Voids time limited committee would be investigating this area and their first meeting was on the 10 December. YHN were also jointly working with NCC to review the lettings policy. RESOLVED that the Board;
Considered the minutes of the meeting held on 3 NOVEMBER 2015 and approved them as a correct record.
436 ITEMS FOR INFORMATION
437 SAFEGUARDING REPORT
Neil Scott briefly outlined the report which included annual update for Board in relation to safeguarding alerts and safeguarding training across YHN.
7
Page 61 of 81
A Board member commented that they were pleased to see the learning and development being achieved in this area, and questioned section 3.2. It stated that YHN staff are involved in many more cases than just those which are recorded as YHN referrals, and the Board member queried could we refine the performance data and ensure these cases are recorded so it can be seen how many cases in total staff are working on. Neil Scott responded that we are working much more in partnership but could not record other agencies referrals just our own. Whilst the increase in referrals may look worrying, this is a positive indication that the system is working much better and the staff are more aware of safeguarding issues.
438 RESOLVED – That the following items be received for information:
8ii) Delegated Decisions
8iii) Board Forward Plan
8iv) Committee Minutes: Audit Committee 20 August 2015
439 EXCLUSION OF PRESS AND PUBLIC
RESOLVED – That in accordance with the organisation’s Access to Information provisions, the press and public were excluded from the meeting during the consideration of all further agenda items.
………………………………………..
Mrs O Grant
Chairman
2 February 2016
Page 62 of 81
Board 2 February 2016
Universal Credit
Report by Senior Director
For Information
1. Background
1.1 This report is to provide Board with an update on Universal Credit (UC) and a summary of key activity that has been on-going since the board report in November 2015. This details the progress the implementation project has made and learning from the initial roll out for single people on UC.
1.2 The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) key reform, Universal Credit, will replace six benefits with a single monthly payment. It is currently being rolled-out, largely for Job Seekers Allowance (JSA) claimants who are single, and three jobcentres are currently operating the digital service. The DWP expects UC to simplify the benefit system and make it less open to mistakes.
1.3 Housing Benefit (HB) will eventually be replaced by the housing element of UC and will be paid directly to the tenant. The housing element is likely to be a large component of a claimants monthly benefit income, so inaccuracies can cause challenges. If too little is paid, a claimant may be unable to meet their housing costs and may incur debt with their landlord. If too much is paid, then this money is deducted from subsequent payments, resulting in a lower amount each month until the overpayment is recovered.
2 Implementation
2.1 National Position
287,310 people had made a claim for universal credit up to 3 December 2015.
186,645 (12 November 2015), attended an initial interview, accepted their claimant commitment, and moved on to UC;
155,568 people were in receipt of UC as of 12 November 2015. Of these, 51,076 (or 33 per cent) were in employment and 104,490 (or 67 per cent) were not in employment.
8i
Page 63 of 81
2.2 Newcastle Position
As at 3 December 1,464 residents of Newcastle have claimed UC as shown in the table below.
Age Range Male Female
Newcastle City
16-24
365 165 25-49
50+
Newcastle West 16-24
421 186 25-49
Newcastle East 16-24
237 90 25-49
3. Progress of Universal Credit Delivery
3.1 National rollout of the UC live service started on the 16 February 2015. The DWP report that it is now available in almost 550 jobcentres; three quarters of the total national network. By April 2016, UC will have been rolled out to every jobcentre and local authority in Great Britain.
The government’s driver to accelerate other groups being moved onto UC is the digital service. The DWP began testing the full UC service in November 2014. The full service provides more online features, giving claimants greater control over their UC claim, with one on-line account for payments, reporting changes of circumstances, and receiving job alerts and work coach feedback.
3.2 The DWP have confirmed that from May 2016, they will be launching the full service. This means that where the full service is in place people will be unable to make new claims to benefits under the old system.
There will be a staggered approach and contrary to earlier claims by the DWP that this would only be a ‘make scalable’ pilot, it has since been confirmed that it will be the live service. In Newcastle, this means that the City Job Centre will be going live from the 23 May 2016.
For council tenants, this will mean that any new claims for Income related Employment Support allowance; Income Support and new claims for Housing benefit and tax credits will now be treated as Universal Credit claims and administered by the DWP.
We have requested anticipated numbers of those who may be affected and to date the DWP have been unable to provide this. YHN has received assurances from the Partnership Manager of the local job Centre Plus Office that they will endeavour to provide some anticipated numbers and we will provide board with an update as soon as we are able.
Currently, there has been no mention of how they plan to migrate existing UC claimants onto the live system.
Page 64 of 81
4. Spending Review and Autumn Statement 2015
The government announced at the summer budget the aspiration to move Britain into a higher wage, lower tax, and lower welfare society. At this time the government announced the introduction of the National Living Wage, an increase in the income tax personal allowance and welfare reform. The Spending Review and Autumn Statement sets out the next stage of these reforms.
4.1 Tax Credits and Universal Credit
The Working Tax Credit reductions in April 2016 as announced in the Summer Budget 2015 have been rescinded; however, the equivalent cuts to Universal Credit will go ahead in April 2016. Those transferred by DWP from Tax credits to Universal Credit will receive transitional protection.
From April 2016, the amount a tax credits income can increase in-year compared to their previous years income before their award is adjusted will be reduced to £2,500
There will be a two child limit and loss of the family premium in Child Tax Credit and equivalent in Universal Credit from April 2017
In UC, the minimum Income Floor for the self-employed will be in line with the National Living Wage instead of the National Minimum Wage.
4.2 Housing Benefit
The government stated that spending on Housing Benefit (HB) increased by 46% during 1999-2000 and 2010-2011 reaching £21.4 billion. Significant changes to HB were already announced in the Summer Budget and the spending review and autumn statement makes further reforms.
There will be a cap on the amount of rent that HB will cover in the social sector to the relevant Local Housing Allowance which the rate is paid to private renters on Housing Benefit. This will include the shared accommodation rate for single claimants under 35 who do not have dependent children. In Newcastle, the rate for this group is £60.00 per week. This will apply to tenancies signed after 1 April 2016, with HB entitlement changing from 1 April 2018 onwards.
There will be a limit on housing benefit and Pension Credit payments to four weeks for claimants who are outside of Great Britain from April 2016. (currently claimants can go abroad for up to 13 weeks while continuing to receive HB)
4.3 Employment Support
The government aim to do more to get people into work and make the system fairer. By 2020, Universal Credit will extend work support and conditionality to an extra 1.3 million claimants.
8i
Page 65 of 81
Jobseekers will be required to attend the jobcentre on a weekly basis for
the first three months of their claim and the Help to Work Programme
will be brought forward.
Increased funding to help people with disabilities and health conditions to get work and remain in work. For example, a new Work and Health Programme will be introduced when the current Work Programme and Work Choice contracts end, to provide specialist support for claimants with health conditions and those unemployed for two years.
From 2017, local areas, including the North East, “will work with the Department for Work and Pensions to co-design employment support for harder-to-help claimants”.
5. YHN Implementation Response
5.1 Universal Credit Implementation Project and Action Plan
YHN are aware of 201 tenants currently claiming UC, the rent collection rate for these tenants is currently 79.3%. The Income Recovery Officers who are acting as UC specialists are continuing to provide support to tenants to maximise rental income. Following the confirmation of the digital service being live in the City Job Centre, we will be working towards a planned, staggered approach to upskill other frontline staff in preparation for more people claiming UC.
5.2 Universal Credit Project Plan
5.2.1 In the last Board report members were advised that the UC Project Plan was being reconfigured. Board should be aware that the constant changes of timescales from the DWP for implementation and the changes following the autumn statement, planning can be difficult and we need to work flexibly in order to overcome this.
5.2.2 The revised action plan objectives are;
Income is maximised for our landlord clients and customers that have been affected by welfare reform changes, with rent loss minimised.
Our relationships with partners are developed, which means that duplication of effort is reduced. The knowledge of our staff is improved and they can give customers accurate advice or know where to refer them to.
For YHN services and budgets that support customers, a higher proportion of their resources are directed at customers that need support and present an immediate and financial risk.
Customers affected by welfare reform changes are supported to pay their rent and other obligations and are able to access services which meet their needs.
Board and Management teams have confidence in our approach, are aware of their current risks and opportunities, and learning from the process is captured and shared.
Page 66 of 81
6. Partnership Working
YHN continue to work in partnership with the Council and other partners to develop learning. Board will recall that as part of the Delivery Partnership agreement between the DWP and City Council YHN are delivering an element of personal budgeting support for council tenants.
YHN have continued to test the benefits of co-locating with the three job Centres in Newcastle. We are currently working on a joint report with the DWP and NCC to consider the benefits of extending this pilot for 2016/17.
The city council have established a welfare reform operational group to support and test the alignment of care and support services to respond to the integrated demands of welfare reform. The aim is to develop and deliver a longer term programme of work to respond to and mitigate the impact of welfare reform. YHN’s Head of Support and Care and UC Implementation Manager are both representatives from YHN on this group and once work is programmed board will be updated on activity.
6.1 Personal Budgeting Support
Under UC, most households will receive a single, monthly benefit payment, including where applicable, a housing element. The aim of the monthly payment is to replicate payment of wages and therefore ease the transition from benefits into work. It is however, a major change for many households used to dealing with a large number of smaller payments with HB paid directly to their landlord. Personal Budgeting Support (PBS) has two elements: Alternative Payment Arrangements (APA’s) and money advice.
Currently YHN officers have assisted 72 tenants with personal budgeting support as a result of making a claim for UC.
6.2 Alternative Payment Arrangements
Alternative Payment Arrangements (APA’s) are available in circumstances for claimants who are unable to manage their monthly payment. YHN have applied for 57 APA’s to receive the housing element as a ‘managed payment to landlord’.
All applications have been successful with one tenant improving their circumstances with support from the UC specialists. The APA has since been reviewed and cancelled with the tenant paying monthly by direct debit.
6.3 Universal Credit Trusted Partner Pilot
The UC trusted partner pilot builds on the DWP’s commitment to working with landlords to help those claimants who need support to manage their direct payment of rent as part of a UC claim. The pilot is a product of joint working between the DWP and social rented sector to develop an approach that ensures those tenants who need support receive it.
In March 2015 the DWP carried out an eight week proof of concept test with six North West social landlords. The test set out to establish if the trusted
8i
Page 67 of 81
partner concept created better opportunities for joined up working resulting in a better outcome for the claimant. As a result of the test the DWP have decided to progress to a larger pilot extending out of the North West to include other areas in England, Scotland and Wales.
6.3.1 The aim of the UC trusted Partner Pilot is to understand and assess the process whereby social landlords identify vulnerable tenants who may struggle to cope with paying rent direct to them, and make appropriate recommendations for a direct payment of housing costs known as an Alternative Payment Arrangement (APA). The pilot will test whether;
The end to end APA process provides a good experience for claimants and staff, and is suitable for national implementation
There are any gaps, for example, in the provision of support services locally
Support can be easily co-ordinated between trusted partners and DWP
Trusted partners are able to undertake APA reviews
The process is affordable in both resource and time for landlords and DWP
6.2.2 In November 2015, the DWP allowed landlords to express their interest in being part of the trusted partner pilot. Following the expression of interest, YHN have been selected to be one of twenty landlords nationally to take part in the trial.
An initial set up meeting has taken place with the DWP and the trial is expected to commence at the end of February 2016 lasting six months. This is a unique opportunity for YHN to influence policy and how the trusted status would work once rolled out nationally.
7. Policy in Practice (PiP)
7.1 As mentioned in previous board updates, YHN and NCC have worked with Policy in Practice to look at the cumulative impact of welfare reform for both Newcastle residents and tenants of council properties managed by YHN.
YHN have been working through via the UC project group and with NCC how we use this information to target support to households who are hardest hit by welfare reform. The project group has agreed to target those currently affected by the under occupation charge ‘bedroom tax’ and those who will be faced with the reduced benefit cap.
The objectives of this targeted work;
Using the information available ensure tenants understand the impact of future reforms
Support tenants with budgeting and maximising income both on their current circumstances and in the future depending on what further reforms they may face.
Ensure those that are masked by repeated Discretionary Housing Payment applications have support to improve their circumstances or understand their obligations to pay their rent.
Update demographic and household data on IT systems so
Page 68 of 81
information and support can be easily provided to them in the future
Reduce rent arrears
Improve their personal circumstances where available to ensure they do not pose a risk to rental income.
8. Internal Audit
8.1 We have commissioned Internal Audit to review the effectiveness of the arrangements in place for managing tenants in receipt of universal credit.
The audit will assess whether significant risks in relation to managing tenants in receipt of universal credit are adequately and effectively controlled through examination of the following system objectives:
There is a project plan covering implementation of universal credit and YHN’s response to this which is reviewed and updated in light of lessons learned as implementation progresses.
All tenancies affected by universal credit can be clearly identified and appropriate arrangements are in place to support tenants and minimise risks of non-payment of rent.
Where appropriate, Alternative Payment Arrangements (APA’s) have been agreed and relevant support is provided to address the underlying issues.
Appropriate, relevant performance management arrangements have been established and effective monitoring takes place.
Procedures are in place to achieve value for money and identify efficiency.
The current mechanisms used to predict future numbers of tenancies to be affected by universal credit to determine if it seems relevant and considers all relevant factors.
It is anticipated that the audit findings will be presented to Audit committee in May 2016.
As the audit progress board will be kept informed throughout UC updates.
9 Income Management Strategy
9.1 Progress is being made with the Income Management Strategy action plan.
Direct debit continues to be our preferred payment method and the number of rent direct debit payers has increased by 30% year to date to 8,006. We expect to achieve our target for rental income collection for this financial year.
The cashiering service was withdrawn at the end of November and the preparation work that was undertaken ensured a smooth transition to alternative payment method for tenants. We have encouraged tenants to pay by direct debit and the online payment service has now been upgraded to provide a more user friendly customer experience. For tenants who prefer to pay by cash they can do so at Pay Point outlets and post offices
8i
Page 69 of 81
across the city. We are able to print bar codes so that tenants now have an immediate way to pay rather than waiting for their swipe card to arrive.
10. Business Implications
10.1 Purpose and objectives
By taking an approach that maximises income collection whilst supporting tenants we will contribute to our strategic objectives of;
Make the money deliver
Work together to create a brighter future.
10.2 Value for money and efficiencies:
The implementation project includes actions that are intended to ensure we deliver efficient services that are value for money. As part of the revised project plan we are looking at how services work together in will look to calculate the impact UC has on current service delivery.
10.3 Financial Implications
YHN Board previously agreed to establish a reserve specifically for welfare reform related activity. This reserve is now managed by the council and we are currently drafting feedback to the city council on expenditure for 2015/16 and anticipated additional costs for 2016/17.
10.4 Impact on services / performance
The collection rate for tenants who have been transferred to Universal Credit is being monitored separately and as expected arrears for this group are above average with a collection rate of 79.3%. This figure is showing an improving weekly trend which is expected to continue. The overall collection rate for all tenants including UC claimants is currently on track at 99.26% which is ahead of the seasonally profiled target of 99.18%
10.5 Outcome for tenants/leaseholders
A large percentage of council tenants and leaseholders will be affected by Universal Credit. Currently over 65% of working age tenants are currently in receipt of Housing Benefit and will be responsible for managing a monthly payment and paying their rent directly to YHN.
10.6 Risk (reputation and relationship)
YHN and the City Council have developed a reputation for low evictions and reduced homelessness. The introduction of Universal Credit presents a risk of increased rent arrears which could ultimately lead to eviction. This may affect our relationship with statutory and voluntary sector partners. The trusted pilot does present a unique opportunity to build positive relationships with the DWP and influence how landlords can assist tenants and protect rental income.
Page 70 of 81
10.7 Environmental
There are no direct environmental impacts following the introduction of Universal Credit.
10.8 Legal
UC is a significant element of the Welfare Reform Act 2012 and its implementation is determined by further regulation and guidance. In terms of our implementation project there may be changes to tenancy agreements and further updates will be brought back to Board.
10.9 Equality and Diversity and Community Cohesion
The introduction of Universal Credit may increase tenancy turnover and homelessness which could impact on community cohesion and sustainability of estates.
10.10 Stakeholder Involvement/consultation:
We have been working with the council and other partners as part of the welfare reform strategy board. We have developed a communication plan as part of our UC implementation project that encompasses internal and external stakeholders.
11. Conclusion and recommendations
11.1 Board is recommended to
Note progress made on delivery of the Universal Credit Implementation Project.
12. Implementation
12.1 Reports will be brought back to Board on a quarterly basis during 2016.
Background Papers Universal Credit report to YHN Board February 2015 Universal Credit report to YHN Board May 2015 Universal Credit report to YHN Board July 2015 Universal Credit report to YHN Board November 2015 Contact Officer: If you have any questions about this report that you would like clarifying before the meeting, you can contact Neil Scott, by telephone on 0191 278 8711 or email [email protected]
8i
Page 71 of 81
Board 2 February 2016
Stonewall Workplace Equality Index 2016
Report by Director of Corporate Services
For information
1. Background information
1.1 The Stonewall Workplace Equality Index (WEI) is an evidence-based benchmarking tool used by employers to assess their achievements and progress on LGBT equality in the workplace.
It has been compiled by Stonewall, the national charity for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) rights, for the last 12 years and the 2016 index saw the highest response rate from employers.
415 organisations across the country took part, demonstrating their expertise in ten areas of policy and employment practice, including network groups, career development, training and community engagement.
2. YHN’s position in the index
2.1 YHN has taken part in the Stonewall Workplace Equality Index since 2008.
This year, we were placed at number 36 in the list, a jump of 62 places from 2015. We also know that our point score has increased by almost 20% from last year, rising from 110 to 149 points out of a possible 200.
We were one of only seven housing organisations to place in the list and came in the top five.
3. YHN’s performance within the index
3.1 Although we are yet to receive detailed feedback from Stonewall about our performance across the various parts of the WEI, in previous years YHN has consistently scored highly in the following areas:
8ii
Page 72 of 81
Employee policy;
Monitoring;
Network groups, and
Staff and community engagement.
Since receiving our feedback in 2015, officers have been working to implement actions to improve our performance across all areas of the index.
4. Further feedback
4.1 Stonewall assessors will be visiting YHN to provide further feedback on YHN’s performance in the index on Wednesday 24 February 2016. Any feedback on areas for improvement will be incorporated into the revised action plan for the Equality and Diversity Strategy for 2016-17.
Background Papers The full Stonewall Workplace Equality Index (also often referred to as “Top 100 Employers” is available on the Stonewall website at https://www.stonewall.org.uk/ Contact Officer: If you have any questions about this report that you would like clarifying before the meeting, you can contact Louise Horsefield by telephone on 0191 278 8720 or email [email protected]
Page 73 of 81
Bo
ard
2 F
eb
rua
ry 2
01
6
De
leg
ate
d D
ec
isio
ns
– S
ch
ed
ule
of
no
n-c
on
fid
en
tia
l D
ele
ga
ted
De
cis
ion
s t
ak
en
be
twe
en
17
N
ove
mb
er
20
15
an
d 6
Ja
nu
ary
20
16
No
. D
ire
cto
rate
/ D
ele
ga
ted
Off
ice
r S
ch
em
e
Co
st/
Bu
dg
et
pro
vis
ion
U
nit
s
Co
ntr
ac
tor
Wa
rds
1 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e M
ill H
ou
se C
om
mu
nal
A
rea
Ref
urb
ish
men
t £
426
,25
9.9
2 f
rom
Cap
ital
P
rogr
amm
e -
Co
mm
un
al w
ork
s
98
M
ears
C
on
stru
ctio
n
Win
gro
ve
2 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e IS
AR
bo
iler
rep
lace
men
t sc
hem
e
£2
,75
6,0
00
fro
m E
ner
gy
Effi
cien
cy/F
uel
Po
vert
y m
easu
res
24
00
Bu
ildin
g an
d
Co
mm
erci
al
Ente
rpri
se
Cit
ywid
e
3 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e
We
ster
ho
pe
Co
mm
un
ity
Cen
tre
Ro
of
wo
rks
£
11,0
32
.66
fro
m R
egen
erat
ion
-
No
n-h
ou
sin
g A
sset
s 1
Ho
dgs
on
Sa
yers
W
este
rho
pe
4 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e EX
T000
6 R
ydal
Ro
ad
Ver
tica
l Tile
s £
251
,020
.86
fro
m S
pen
d t
o s
ave
1
9
Mea
rs
East
Go
sfo
rth
5 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e w
ind
ow
hin
ges
/ re
stri
cto
rs
£11
6,5
08
.75
fro
m C
apit
al
Pro
gram
me
- H
ealt
h a
nd
Saf
ety
90
Bu
ildin
g an
d
Co
mm
erci
al
Ente
rpri
se
Wal
ker
8iii
Page 74 of 81
6 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e Is
ar B
oile
r R
epla
cem
ent
(NEP
)
£1
,28
7,9
00
fro
m E
ner
gy
Effi
cien
cy/F
uel
Po
vert
y m
easu
res
115
8
DEL
TA
Cit
ywid
e
7 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e Fe
rn A
ven
ue
Re
nd
er
Wo
rks
£2
9,6
74
.62
fro
m L
ease
ho
lder
C
on
trib
uti
on
s, n
o c
ost
to
HR
A
8 Tu
rner
Fac
iliti
es
Man
agem
ent
Faw
do
n
8 H
RA
-D
avid
La
ngh
orn
e In
terc
om
rep
airs
£
30
,00
0 fr
om
exi
stin
g R
&M
R
even
ue
Bu
dge
ts
N/A
O
pen
view
C
ityw
ide
9 YH
N -
Sh
eila
B
resl
in
NC
C T
elep
ho
ne
Stan
db
y Se
rvic
e £
37
,33
4 G
row
th t
o C
CA
S re
ven
ue
bu
dge
ts
N/A
N
ewca
stle
Cit
y C
ou
nci
l C
ityw
ide
10
YHN
- S
hei
la
Bre
slin
R
eAC
T A
SB c
ase
man
agem
ent
IT s
yste
m
£1
9,4
00
Gro
wth
to
HA
SBET
re
ven
ue
bu
dge
t N
/A
EBS
ReA
CT
IT
Cit
ywid
e
11
YHN
- S
hei
la
Bre
slin
Fu
nd
ed P
hD
- D
igit
al
Incl
usi
on
£
30,0
00
fro
m e
xist
ing
I.T
Rev
enu
e B
ud
gets
N
/A
No
rth
um
bri
a U
niv
ers
ity
Cit
ywid
e
12
HR
A -
Dav
id
Lan
gho
rne
Par
tici
pat
ory
Bu
dge
t –
pro
visi
on
of
par
kin
g sp
aces
, No
. 9 M
edb
urn
R
oad
£
27
,24
2 f
rom
Par
tici
pat
ory
b
ud
get
32
Ho
usi
ng
and
Lo
calis
ed
Serv
ices
Le
min
gto
n
All
pro
jects
we
re a
pp
rove
d a
s p
art
of
the
In
ve
stm
en
t D
eliv
ery
Pro
gra
mm
e c
on
tain
ed
with
in a
re
po
rt e
ntitle
d ’30
Yea
r H
RA
Fin
an
cia
l M
od
el an
d O
the
r F
ina
ncia
l Is
su
es’ w
hic
h w
as c
on
sid
ere
d b
y t
he
Board
on
11
De
ce
mb
er
201
2.
Page 75 of 81
Board 2 February 2016
Board Forward Plan
1 Board Forward Plan
1.1 This Board Forward Plan lists the reports known at the present time that will be presented at the Board meeting on 15 March 2016 (or amended date subject to confirmation):
Board Reports
Delivery Plan Non-confidential
Anti-Slavery & Human Trafficking Statement Non-confidential
Budget 2016/17 Non-confidential
Five Year Plan & Stress Testing Confidential
Contact Officer: If you have any questions about this report that you would like clarifying before the meeting, you can contact Jill Davison, Company Secretary by telephone on 0191 278 8624 or email [email protected]
8iv
Page 76 of 81
Service and Strategy Delivery Committee 1 December 2015 (5.00 pm - 6.45 pm) Present: P Dutton (In the Chair) E Snaith, M Page, V Dunn, J Streather, L Doherty In Attendance:
D Langhorne - Director of Property Services J Vinton - Head of Assets and Regeneration J Urwin - Head of Housing Options B Elder - Strategy HR Manager A Pearce - Assets and Programme Manager M Pearson - Regeneration Project Co-ordinator L Riley - Service Quality Officer C Patterson - Democratic Services Officer
1 WELCOME AND INTRODUCTIONS The Chair welcomed everyone to the meeting and introductions were provided.
2 APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE Apologies for absence were received from Julie Purvis and Jane Streather for lateness.
3 APPOINTMENT OF VICE CHAIR RESOLVED - That Lisa Doherty be appointed as Vice Chair of the committee for 2015/16.
4 DECLARATIONS OF INTERESTS During discussions on the Housing Investment Programme – progress update and impact of the future rent reduction (Agenda Item 8), Jane Streather and Veronica Dunn declared a personal interest being Cabinet members for Newcastle City Council.
5 PURPOSE OF THE COMMITTEE AND PROPOSED AREAS OF BUSINESS - PRESENTATION A presentation was delivered by Director of Property Services on the remit of the committee and the proposed areas of the business. D Langhorne circulated
8v
Page 77 of 81
additional information in the form of a diagram which highlighted responsibilities for the management team; YHN and the committee. During discussions the following main points were raised:
Clarification was provided around how the forward plan was drawn up and the process in which issues were added.
Concerns were expressed around the committee’s role, particularly around service reviews and strategies. It was reported that the committee would have a proactive role in both areas, particularly around setting improvements and monitoring progress. The committee was reminded that all business was reported through to Board, giving members a further opportunity to consider matters.
Reference was made to the terms of reference and purpose of the committee with comments raised around the wording not being implicit enough around the committee’s purpose and role. A request was made to seek some clarity about this and on whether this committee could influence the scope of reviews on service delivery and strategies. It was confirmed that in terms of the service review the committee had a definite direct role to influence. The scope of reviews would be presented to the committee for discussion prior to being commenced.
Jane Streather arrived at 5.15pm
Reference was made to update reports on reviews that were included the forward plan with queries raised around who had input into these reviews. It was explained that these two particular reviews were already underway prior to the restructuring. A request was then made to circulate a list of all the reviews underway and these that were to be planned. It was explained that this information was still in the planning stages but an early draft copy of the plan could be circulated. ACTION.
Queries were raised around the strategic oversight responsibility for measuring and assessing performance of YHN in relation to the management fee and how this all linked. It was explained that this was this committee’s responsibility. The list was not exhaustive. Low level key performance indicators were being developed including measures around ALMO business.
RESOLVED – That the presentation be received and information and the committee’s comments noted.
6 GOVERNANCE ARRANGEMENTS - TERMS OF REFERENCE AND MEETING DATES A report by the Company Secretary was considered on the terms of reference for the committee; the areas of responsibility and the schedule of meeting dates proposed for 2016. The Chair pointed out that paragraph 3.1 of the report stipulated meetings were every quarter but were in fact every six weeks. Further to earlier discussions, he explained that the terms of reference would be reworded to be more explicit around the committee’s purpose and that it would be resubmitted for approval at the next scheduled meeting. ACTION.
Page 78 of 81
RESOLVED – That (i) The terms of reference be received and reconsidered at the next scheduled
meeting as outlined above. (ii) The committee’s responsibilities be reviewed annually. (iii) The schedule of meetings for 2016 be noted.
7 FORWARD PLAN A copy of the work plan to November 2016 was presented for consideration. The Chair explained that the plan was a fluid document and welcomed ideas for the May 2016 bus tour. During the committee’s review of the work plan the following points were raised:
Reference was made to the Annual Letting Review Action Plan to be considered by the committee in April 2016. In response to queries on the Board’s agreement to set up a task and finish group, it was explained that the Board had agreed the task and finish group would consider the whole end to end process. The committee would report to the Board. The company secretary was overseeing where each item needed to be considered and how all the committees linked and worked with the Board
Reference was made to the lack of reference in the forward plan about the medium term financial planning. It was explained that this would be part of the information provided via the Finance Strategy presentation to be delivered to committee in May 2016; however, ratification would be provided that the medium term financial planning was to be considered by the Board and when it was programmed to be considered. ACTION
Reference was made to the fact there would only be two occasions when HR matters would be considered by the committee, which was a fraction of time that previously such matters were considered at Finance and Resources Committee. It was explained that HR issues may also be presented to the Board for consideration, giving the committee members other opportunities to have input. The Chair reiterated that the forward plan was a fluid document that could be changed throughout the year, if issues arose and it was deemed necessary to present to committee.
Following a comment being raised about having a clearer understanding about the actual content of each item to the considered by the committee during the year, it was agreed that a revised Forward Plan that provided more detailed information on the proposed content of each item would be circulated in advance of the next meeting. ACTION
Comments were made around the non- establishment of a Finance and Resources Committee and the reasons for this. It was suggested that clarification be circulated on the discussions held at the Away Day and the Board’s thinking and decision around this. ACTION
RESOLVED – That the work plan be received and comments noted.
8v
Page 79 of 81
8 HOUSING INVESTMENT PROGRAMME - PROGRESS UPDATE AND IMPACT OF THE FUTURE RENT REDUCTION. A report by Head of Assets and Regeneration, which provided information on the progress to date of the 2015-16 investment programme and the impact of the proposed rent reduction was submitted for consideration. D Langhorne explained that the report provided clarity around the sense of scale and impact that was being proposed, pointing out that further discussions with Newcastle City Council (NCC) was required. During discussions, the following main points were made:
Concerns expressed about the reputational effects and disruption for tenants when delivering an elemental approach. These points needed to be borne in mind when decisions were being made.
There was a need to have detailed consideration on the private finance lease back model option currently being explored by NCC.
Committee was informed that discussions with NCC were around achieving flexibility to support future year programmes.
Clarification was sought around who made the decision about future programmes. It was confirmed that the final decision would be with NCC; however, NCC would be taking in to account YHN’s views. Discussions have been ongoing throughout the review to try to mitigate against different views on priorities. The working relationship between YHN, NCC Finance Team and the Fairer Housing Unit had been good. There was a project recommended for removal from the programme, which was North Kenton new build project where further discussions were perhaps required.
In response to a query around possible resource implications, it was explained that if the programme dropped then there was a potential to review directorate structures but the programme remained sizeable for the first few years.
In response to concerns expressed around residents, it was explained that consultation would be on a year on year basis so residents were not aware of specific dates for future work. The approach was to continue to deliver programmes but at a slower pace to minimise the impact on tenants. There were some concerns around North Kenton new build project but YHN and NCC were looking at opportunities through the private finance lease back mode for new build.
Reference was made to the reserve levels and whether these could be used to support the programme.
Comments expressed about the impact of the reduction and the challenging times ahead in addition to welcoming the amount of work that had been progressed so far.
Reference was made to sheltered housing remodelling in the programme to eradicate bed sits with queries around whether this would still be a priority. It was explained that the Fairer Housing Unit had identified support for vulnerable tenants as a priority are but this would need to be considered in the wider programme review.
In response to a query on the timescales, it was confirmed that the final details were being worked through with NCC. It was hoped a decision would be provided to enable proposals to be presented to NCC Cabinet in January 2016.
Page 80 of 81
Reference was made to the Board’s earlier decision to earmark reserves with clarification being sought around the level agreed. D Langhorne indicated that he would provide information at the next Board Meeting about the agreed reduction in the reserve levels that was agreed to enable a discussion about the future use of reserves. ACTION.
At this point in the proceedings, Veronica Dunn and Jane Streather declared personal interests as cabinet members at NCC.
Comment were raised around the magnitude of the challenge and the impact of the rent reduction which extended far beyond £563m over 30 years of life cycle. Planning for future programmes was crucial.
Reference was also made to the importance of continuing to develop pipeline projects waiting for opportunities to arise. Hopefully the work done so far had not been done in vein and other forms of funding could be secured.
RESOLVED – That (i) The report be received and the progress to date on the 2015-16 investment
programme be noted. (ii) The comments on the proposed reductions to accommodate the financial
pressures on the investment programme over the next five years be noted. (iii) The committee agree to receive further information on the private finance
model once this had been explored and how this changed the proposed programme.
9 HEALTH AND HOUSING SERVICE REVIEW UPDATE
A report by Head of Housing Options was presented, which provided information on the health and housing service review, following the amalgamation in June 2014 of three service areas: health and welfare assessments, adaptations and relocation support. J Urwin introduced the item, summarising the main aspects. D Langhorne explained that the closure report was programmed for approval by the committee at the July 2016 scheduled meeting. A member suggested that case studies should also be included in the report to demonstrate the outcomes. In response, it was reported that as part of the closure report there would be opportunities to provide real examples of outcomes as suggested. Performance data, including information on time and financial benefits would be fed into the closure report to ensure the committee understood more fully the new service provision. RESOLVED – That the report be received and comments.
10 DATE AND TIME OF NEXT MEETING Tuesday 19 January 2016 at 5.00pm
8v
Page 81 of 81