yes! i am proud to be a homoeopath. - final may not be used, if pgs of issue exceed limit of ......

Nat aI ofTHY

Vol .9 94th Issue IuIy 2007 Rs.45

Repertory 2

i

National Journal of HOMOEOPATHYJULY 2007 - REPERTORY 2

1

Repertory 2 Contents July 2007

EDITORIAL

5 The FIRST EVER Student Edi-tion: Repertory-Student. . . .Dr C H Asrani

GENERAL SECTION

10 Yes! I am proud to be aHomoeopath...Dr Krutik Shah

13 An Introduction to repertoryDr Krutik Shah

14 Details of some lesser known RepertoriesDr Ardeshir T Jagose

18 Utility of understanding relationshipof RemediesDr Parimal K Parmar

21 Steps to RepertorizationDr Shashi Kant Tiwari

23 Funny Game of Rubrics DiscriminationDr Satish P Kanojia

29 Towards EnlightenmentDr Amrapali Merchant

REPORT

30 A Workshop on Repertory - A ReportDr Kurain P J

Q & A

31 Queries and SolutionsProf Dr Kasim Chimthanawala

Printed, Published & Owned byDr (Mrs) Vishpala ParthasarathyPrinted at Impressions Dynamic, 203, Mahavirdeep,167, Vidyanagari Marg, Mumbai - 98. Tel. 26528157Published at Milan Clinic, 71-B Saraswati Road, Near GokulIce Cream, Santacruz (W), Mumbai 400 054. Tel: 26492762Editor: Dr (Mrs) Vishpala Parthasarathy

Phototypeset by: Impressions DynamicProof Reading by: NJH TeamCover Design: Dr C H AsraniIssue Editor : Dr C H Asrani

8 CALENDER

28 ADVERTISEMENT INDEX

1. Original Articles – Unpublished2. Exclusively for NJH**3. Articles to Highlight Homoeo Aspects4. Articles to preferably pertain to Announced Topics. Others may not be used, if pgs of issue exceed limit of

76 pages.5. Submit TYPED copies in Duplicate +email: [email protected] + [email protected]. Send Photos: Passport size in Black and White or Colour ** Articles sent to us, must not be sent to other

journals at same time.Please state so in your covering Letter to NJH. (This is not being followed).* On receipt of your articles you will be sent a post card acknowledging receipt. Not Accepted articles will bereturned.REMEMBER !!!Enhance your reputation Join NJH Author Bank. Write three articles, in a year. Get a free subscription nextyear.Any author entitled to receiving 2007, (must write in with details of his 3 articles - issue and page no.)

Guidelines for Students


2

Messages

MESSAGE

Dear Dr Vishpala,

Every new activity of NJH excites me and I am very glad to know that NJH is bringing out a Student Edition.

It is a very praiseworthy decision. Being in constant touch with the students, I can say that today’s studentsare more hungry for knowledge and willing to learn skills to succeed. They not only have a quest for learningbut also an open mind.

I trust that NJH would cater to the needs of the students in providing academic material consistent with theviews of great masters Hahnemann. Boenninghausen, Boger and Kent.

I have just received the regular Repertory issue of the NJH. And I must say it is very, very good. I know thisnew venture will be of equally high standard.

My best wishes to the NJH team. Dr D P RastogiEx-Director Central Council of Homoeopathy

Dr D P RastogiE1/G7, Alaknanda Shopping Complex,

Alaknanda, N Delhi 110019Email: [email protected]

Dr Ajit KulkarniDirector, Homoeopathic Research Institute, Satara

38, Bhawani Peth, Satara (MS), IndiaPhone-02162-234842 Email:

[email protected] Vishpala

Your announcement to bring out a student edition, in addition to the regular publication of NJH, is appre-ciable. It amply demonstrates that imparting classical homoeopathy is an integral part of NJH.

Continuing regularity in publishing of a medical journal, especially in the homoeopathic field, requires in-tegrity, persistence and perseverance. NJH - the editor and the team, has proved this through their zeal andefforts. Homoeopathy is at the cross-roads today and the onus of spreading right kind of homoeopathy fallson both senior and junior practitioners as well as the teachers. NJH has recognized this need of the hour andventured into motivation of students, our budding homoeopaths.

With this move of NJH, student community should feel free to exchange their ideas, problems, experiencesetc. Let this student edition of NJH be a bridge to further the cause of homoeopathy.

Wishing NJH and also the students, the grand cerebral tranquility through showering of knowledge, and notonly information, and assuring of our humble long-lasting cooperation.

Yours sincerely

Dr Ajit Kulkarni

RNI No. 71004/98. Vol. 9 No. 4 July 2007 (NJH 94th Issue) MastheadIndexed with Cumulative Index to Nursing & Allied Health Literature ® print index / CINAHL ® database. Cinahl Info Systems,

Publications Dept, 1509 Wilson Terrace, Glendale CA 91206

EDITORIAL BOARDHONORARY ADVISORS:Dr KASIM CHIMTHANAWALA MBBS, LTMH DDV DMS

HOM (CAL) FNAH

TEL: 0712-2532008, 2522563 (R): 2766286Dr N L TIWARI, LCEH

(C): 23863479 (R): 24224010 Mo: 9819672835*Dr D P RASTOGI MA, DMS, MD (HOM)TEL: 011-26446067

EDITOR

Dr (MRS) VISHPALA PARTHASARATHY LCEH

TEL: (C) 26492762 (R) 24382131e-mail: [email protected]

ASSOCIATE EDITORS

Dr C H ASRANI DNB.Tel: (C) 26652348. email: [email protected] (Mrs) RASHMI NAGAR LCEH.Tel: (C) 26129849. email: [email protected] (Mrs) RAJNI GWALANI

TEL: 25291527. email: [email protected]

ASSISTANT EDITORS

Dr SUSHMA JAISWAL. Mob: 9821224553.Dr BHAVINI MEHTA. Mob: 9819269034.Dr SATISH KANOJIA. Mob: 9821009605.

SUB EDITORS: STUDENT EDITION

Dr ARDESHIR JAGOSE

Dr VAISHALI BHAGAT

Dr KRUTIK SHAH

Please contact following office staff for:Manager NJH : Ms. Shilpa ShahOffice Assistant, NJH : Mr Nilesh Sandimemail : [email protected] : Dr Bhavini MehtaSure-shot Section : Dr Sushma JaiswalNJH Book Club : Dr Vibha Shah

Please quote your subscription number in allcorrespondence, NJH c/o Milan Clinic, 71 B, Saraswatiroad, Santacruz (W), Mumbai - 54 (India).Tel: 2-6492762 / 2-6042749 Fax: 2-4332131Website: www.njhonline.com

TO SUBSCRIBE OR RENEW FOR NJH BY ELECTRONIC TRANSFER:India: PNB Bank Ac No. 1281000100060357(Add Bank Charges Rs 70/-)

Overseas Subscribers can directly pay to njhonline.com- paymentgateway-Paypal account or at

ANZ Standard Chartered Ac No.: 23705004540

AhmedabadDr KETAN SHAH

Happy Homoeopathic Store, 109, Shreyas Complex,Opp Jain Temple, Navrangpura, Ahmedabad-380009.Tel: 079-26430135 Mob: 09328212112e-mail : [email protected]

AhmednagarDr PRASHANT GANGWAL

Rameshwar Chambers, Shivaji Road,Mahavir Pain, A/P Shrirampur– Ahmednagar.Tel: (02422) 22390(C) 43454(R). Mob: 9850521129

AnandDr KRUTIK SHAH

Holistic Homoeo Care, B-1, 1st Floor, Pioneer ShoppingCentre, Bhalej Road, Anand-388001, GujaratMob: 9825891948.email: [email protected]

AurangabadDr PRADEEP GARGE BHMS

Near Nutan Colony, Bus Stop, AurangabadTel: 02589-23541. 0240-2-332434/2-352444 (R)Mob: 9422202501. email: [email protected]

BarodaDr JAISWAL G D DHMS

Dr Mital Jaiswal G D (SUB EDITOR)Samarpan Society, Nr Raneshwar Mahadev TempleVasna Road, Baroda 390020Tel: 0265 – 2632086/2301408 (C). Mob: 9824237282

BangaloreDr MANJUNATH B SVijaya Clinic, 4th Cross, Hanumanth Nagar,Bangalore-560019Tel: 080 –6603336/6523123. Mob: 9886457477e-mail: [email protected] SUMIT CHATTERJEE

P 109/1 New Raipur Road, Post garia,Calcutta 700 084Tel: 033-4629482. Fax: 033-4129151

ChennaiDr RAMA HARIHARAN

Swasthyam, Kumud Apartment 4 (Old No. 5),Laxmipuram, Royaptha, Chennai 600014Tel:044-28116494. Mob: 09444019748Email: [email protected]

DelhiDr CHANDA SETH LCEH

B2/11, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi 110070Tel: 011-6147791 / 30943642. Mob: 011-31067432Email: [email protected]

HyderabadDr S PARVEEN KUMAR DHMS, MBS (H), MD (HOM)102, K M Residency, St No 8, Ashok Nagar,Hyderabad-20Tel: 040–27664146 / 040-27668898 (R)Mob: 9849054632.Email:[email protected]

*SUB EDITOR:Dr MAHESH CHEVVA

Sathya Diagnostic, Himayatnagar, Hyderabad-29.Tel: 040-23210566. Mob: 09949472271e-mail: [email protected]

JaipurDr DARYANI J DC VI-101, Kamal Apt –2, Bani Park, Jaipur 302 006Tel: 0141-2202071. Mob: 9414074574e-mail: [email protected]

Other State Representatives: Associate & Sub Editors (Exclusive for NJH) [* NEW]

JharkhandDr VIJAY KUMAR SHARMA

Naya Toli Chowk, P.O. PathalKudwa–Ranchi,Jharkhand – 834 001Tel: 0651-253 1578. Mob: 9431325100

MalegaonDr SOHAIL ANSARI

749, Nayapura, East Iqbal Road,Nr. Sulemani Masjid, Malegaon-423203Tel: 95255-237465 (C) 95255- 233965 (R)M: 9890434365e-mail : [email protected]

Navi Mumbai / KhargarDr ARDESHIR JAGOSE

Meherzin Co-op Hsg Society Ltd, C/43-44, 4th Floor,109/A, Wodehouse Road, Colaba, Mumbai-400005Tel: 022-22153873. Mob: 9820291108

NagpurDr ADIL CHIMTHANAWALAThe National Academy of Homoeopathy, India, ShaadHospital Complex & Research Centre, Near Itwari RlyStation, Nagpur. TEL: 0712-2766286 / 2532008

PuneDr VAISHALI A BHAGAT

Pratik Nagar, 3rd Building, Flat 27, Paud Road,Kothrud, Pune-29Tel: 20-25466344. Mob: 09860062626

SataraDr AJIT KULKARNI

38, Bhavani Peth, Opp. Rajwada Bus Stop, Satara-415002Tel: 952162-236e-mail: [email protected]

SuratDr AKSHAY BANKER LCEH

102, Gokul Apts, 1st Flr, Pani-ni-Bhint,Sonifalia, Surat 395003Tel: 0261-5553922 / 2235203 (C) 0261-2237855 (R)Mob: 9426857525. e-mail: [email protected]

SangamnerDr PRASAD RASAL

Sai Swami Homoeo Clinic, Indira Ngr. Gali No. 1, Dist.Ahmednagar, Sangamner-422605Tel: 02425-223913 (C) 02425-226872 (R)Mob: 9890168872e-mail: [email protected]

ThiruvnanthapuramDr SHAJI KUTTY

Chiriyankandathil House, Near Malaysian Tower, EastNada, Guruvayoor, Thrisssur-680101, Keralae-mail: [email protected]: 0471-2481998 / 2480134 (R). Mob: 9447080834

ThaneDr NAVEEN R MAURYA

Usha Homoeo Pharmacy, B-13, Sahyog Apt, AnandNagar, Nr Vartak School, Vasai (W), Mumbai-401202.Tel: 2337072. Mobile: 09422483130

FOREIGN AustraliaDr ANN TACEY

80 Essendon Road, Anstead, QLD 4070, AustraliaTel.: 617 3202 6517. Fax: 617 3202 661e-mail: [email protected]

DenmarkDr FLEMING BORREGAARD OLSEN (REP ELECT)Vangede Bygade 78, 2, tv, 2820, GentofteTel: 0045-46373411. Mob: 00945-26253611Email: [email protected]

3

2007 1) ADHD 10/4/2007 2) Noble Metals 20/5/07 3) Repertory 25/7/074) Repertory- Stu 16/8/07 5) Constitutional 6) Practical Application of Organon- Stu7) Interview Techniques 8) Homoeopaths to Allopaths?- Stu 9) Dementia

3 Types of Mailing: 1) Direct Mailing by post. We have reverted to Indian Posts in 2007, as couriers have become unreliable. 2) Through courier to somerepresentatives in bulk and they locally courier it to you. From 2007: Issues will come out beginning of next month and then mailed. If not received by 20th

of next month ie if you miss an issue, write to NJH office, enclosing stamp of Rs 9/- or collect from local Rep or Nodal. Foreign post to UK, USA and Dubaietc are sent by individual registered post. Australia is couried to Ann Tacey who posts it locally. Issues reach Foreign Land in 4 Days.


5The FIRST EVER Student Edition: Repertory-Stu. . . .Dr Vishpala Parthasarathy

Editorial

DR C H ASRANI

Our Guest Editor for this first issue, himself a mature student when he didhis DNB (Family Medicine) at the ripe age of 43: Dr C H Asrani:It is said ‘when it rains, it pours’. For the students of Homoeopathy (un-dergraduate, post graduate, MD students and practitioners alike) this say-ing is more than true!After being told for last decade, that NJH must have a student section –not that NJH team did not try! Another popular saying delayed it- ‘who’llbell the cat?’ We had people with noble intentions – that of helping thestudents – but no one to take charge of the students’ section. We alreadyhad our hands (and mouths) so full, begging for articles for NJH that wecould not have dedicated a (b*****g) team for students section. So it re-mained, another of our unfulfilled dreams.And so passed 14 years; years full of suggestions; ideas; brilliant ideas;promises; more promises but little action.Then Vishpala had a brain wave – why not become a student again? Thebest way to feel like a student, understand the needs, gather tips to study,already struggling to cope with the practice and still study! …and sheenrolled in an external MD course from Aurangabad. 2 years of living her

busy life to the fullest and continue studying; writing a 271 page thesis and preparing for her exams! Nowthat period of worship is about to be over - she is busy preparing for her finals – NJH proves ‘when itrains, it pours!’NJH launches this bi-monthly student - edition! Yes, an entire edition dedicated to students will be pub-lished every other month.Who are the torch bearers? Dr Ardeshir Jagose, Dr Vaishali Bhagat and Dr Krutik Shah. At last Vishpalahas her three musketeers – these three have promised to deliver, have taken the mantle of providingstudent-friendly information – academic info as well as tips on how to study? Tips on starting a newpractice; which software to buy; smart borrowing if one needs money for projects etc etc.The inaugural edition has blessings from none other than Dr Rastogi and Dr Ajit Kulkarni; The articlestoo are more to do with academics than usual, for example Dr Shashi Kant Tiwari’s very detailed articleon Repertory and its various types and the comparisons of all the Repertories, including the new onestoo.Dr Krutik says Homoeopathy is my life and then goes ahead and proves it. He has poured his heart outand talked about the best he would like to do for students, and how they should work towards multifaceted development; with Dr Parimal Parmar he takes us through an actual repertory working, solvinga case. He then roped in his aunt, a PhD in Philosophy/ religion, to give her thoughts on what constitutesthe qualities of a good doctor and how he should evolve! A multi-pronged approach, indeed.Dr Jagose, the 2nd team member of the Tripartite, has taken us through the evolution of the Repertory, andnoted the differences and compared all. But then he got stumped on particular Qs.

The FIRST EVER Student Edition: Repertory-Student. . . .Another NJH first.


6The FIRST EVER Student Edition: Repertory-Stu. . . .

Dr Vishpala Parthasarathy

Editorial

And then we have been taken on a lovely spot on the chair, so let us remember how this chair cameabout and how we have to take it forward. The most interesting on this Repertory ship, he takes herand asks to freedom. This is effectively done by Dr Kanojia where he has taken the mental rubrics andkind of given meaning in cross reference types. Interesting!So it is a holistic approach on the Repertory and coming close on the heels of the Regular Repertoryissue, which itself was remarkable, it kind of complements and completes the study of the Repertory -the most exhaustive one ever.This issue NJH acknowledges the contributions of Dr Sushma Jaiswal, Dr Satish Kanojia & Dr BhaviniMehta and appoints them as Assistant Editor(s).Last but not the least, a final call to ALL those who can give ONE tip for practice; ONE tip for learningand remembering; ANY tip to help others…And a call for all of you to question, demand and ask advice on any sphere of Homoeopathy and Life.Finally, let each one of us strive to apply Erma Bombeck’s quote in our life…“When I stand before God at the end of my life, I would hope that I would not have a single bit of talentleft, and could say, “I used everything you gave me.” AmenDr Vaishali Bhagat’s article missed the deadline. She sends a message with a promise of more contentnext issue onwards. Editor

☯ ☯ ☯

MESSAGE FOR STUDENT EDITION - FROM EDITOR - STUIn this 21st century at a click of computers, we are exposed to an ocean of information from SCIENCE TOART. Students of this generation are curious, zealous, intelligent WITH an unquenchable thirst for knowl-edge. They are exploring the world of Homoeopathy. Needless to say our journal, “National Journal ofHomoeopathy” enlightens them in all aspects at the current era.Being a teacher for almost twelve years, I see a dynamic spirit in my young students. They are in searchto know homoeopathy and require a space to share their understanding to fulfill their quest.Team NJH with the guidance of Dr Mrs Vishpala Parthasarathy has decided to give our buddinghomoeopaths their space to write and read articles of assorted interest in our Student Edition (6 per year)which will satisfy their intelligent minds.I hope this issue on Repertory-Stu gives all my students pleasure reading & knowing Homoeopathy.Dear student readers please give us your valuable feedback to enhance our effort in fulfilling your desireof quality reading. Also ask questions to your heart’s content and get clarified.Look forward to your support in all above ways.All the best!

Dr VAISHALI BHAGAT, MD (Hom)Student Edition TeamPune

☯


7The FIRST EVER Student Edition: Repertory-Stu. . . .Dr Vishpala Parthasarathy

Editorial

NJH goes MONTHLY!with this first Repertory - Student issue

Current subscribers get 6 more issues/year(3 in’07) at the SAME subscription rate

...& if you thought that is ALL?Another NEVER BEFORE offer!!

Now NJH subscribers can register for

Dr RAJAN SANKARAN’S NOV SEMINAR

& get an added, assured GIFT (of knowledge) from NJH.

Register before 25th Aug 07, send the cheque favouring‘Bombay Workshop 2007‘

To NJH office and select 1 of the Six titles worth Rs 100,especially earmarked for this and still more

WEEP AND DANCE CME: 2ND SERIES FROM SEPT

2007 TILL FEB 2008 FOR ONLY RS 600/-To sign up, call SHILPA at NJH Office 26492762

(read the 1st Series on www.njhonline.com/forums)

Check In: Seminar details in NJH calendar/ www.njhonline.come-mail: [email protected]


8Calender

Calender

DATE

6 September2007TillMarch 2008

15 - 16 September2007

4 November 2007

23 to 25November 2007

EVENT

‘SAHYA’ (School of Artistic Hom for all Young and Adults)Advanced training on classical Hom. Practical Training on Homsoftware. Empowering professional challenges of the new age.HRD training by renowned trainers.CONTACT: Dr Sarath Chandran, 9447206157Mr Prakash Babu, 9249707867.The Hom Multi Speciality Hospital, Changanacherry – 1,Kerala 0481 – 2412233E Mail: [email protected] site: www.drbijuonline.com

WEEP AND DANCE, SECOND SERIESThe Interactive NJH CME: A 6-month De-sensitizationseries, from Sept 07-Feb 08FEES: Rs 600/- for 6 mths.Team NJH and Life Members: Rs 50 per session.CONTACT: NJH Office: 2649 2762

KENT MEMORIAL LECTURES 2007National Homoeopathic ConferenceORGANISER: South Delhi Hom AssociationCONTACT: I-67, Lajpat Nagar-I, N Delhi-24Phones: 41720991, 26960906, 09810130436,01202456530,09811163169THEMES PROPOSED: Neurological Disorders. Depression, SomeRare Medicines Their Impacts (Research Oriented)SPEAKERS: Dr M S Oberoi, Dr Vishpala Parthasarathy, Dr R PPatel, Dr Parimal Banerjee, Dr Diwan HarishChand, Dr D PRastogi, Dr Prof S Haque, Dr Prof V K Gupta, Dr R S PareekFEES: Delegates Rs. 900/- Members Rs 800/-. LM Rs 700/-.Internees and PGs Rs 600/-.

Dr Parmeshwar Nath Memorial Lecturer Series AllahabadSPEAKERS: Dr Kate Birch, Dr Sharad Shangloo, etcTOPICS: Vaccine injury, Renal stone, Uterine fibroid, Ovarian.Consultation for patients also arranged by Dr Kate Brich on15-17th November 2007CONTACT: Dr Sharad ShangalooEmail: [email protected] • Mob: 094152534

Dr RAJAN SANKARAN SEMINAR:”Sensations in Homeopathy: New methods and practicalutility”TIME: 9:00 am to 5:00 pm.FEES (Till 25th Aug, 2007): Rs 850/- Doctors. Rs 550/- Students.After 25th Aug 2007: Rs.1200 Doctors and Rs.800 for Students.Any Non Indian Passport Holder. Fees 250 US $.Payment: Send To: Bombay Workshop 2007, F/2, SaraswatColony, Saraswati Road Ext, Anusuya Road, Off Niwas Path,

VENUE

Atmata KendramNear Railway StationChanganacherry

Smruti BuildingFlat No 4Pherozshah StreetSantacruz WestMumbai 400 054

PHD HouseOpp Siri Fort StadiumNew Delhi

Meera ShangalooHomeopathic ResearchCentreEl-chico Civil linesAllahabad

Birla Matushri SabhagarNear Bombay HospitalMumbai 400 020.


9Calender

Calender

Lane Opp To HDFC Bank, Linking Road, Santacruz(W),Mumbai-400054. Tel-26605776, 26605680. Fax-26045637.For details: [email protected] or NJH

“Dr Kasim Chimthanawala’s 16th Homoeopathic Postgradu-ate Residential Winter School” in “The Principles andPractice of Homoeopathy (PGNAHI)”FEES: Rs 3500/- Graduates and Internees and Rs 3000/- NAHFellows and Students.ITENARY: Applied Philosophy, Live MM, Theraps, Live CaseDemos, Clinical Analysis, Practical Repertorisation, Drug/Potency Selection, Lectures on Hom Cardiology, etc.DIRECTOR: Prof Dr Kasim ChimthanawalaTRAINERS: NJH TeamCONTACT: Dr Adil Chimthanawala

THE HOMOEOPATHIC MEDICAL ASSOCIATION OFINDIA“Swastha Bharat Samarth Bharat”: Health for All by 2020.ORGANIZER: HMAI Gujarat State Branch, Host: HMAI RajkotUnit.TOPICS: 1. Homeopathy and Community Medicine 2. DrugProving 3. Auto-immune diseases etc, Scientific Papers invitedto present in the seminar.LAST DATE for submission of papers: 20th Aug 2007.CONTACT: Dr Kalpit Sanghvi, Panchratna, Nr Raiya RoadRailway Crossing, Rajkot, Gujarat. 360007. Phone: 02812459181.Email: [email protected]: www.hmaiseminar.info

13TH SARLA SONAWALA MEMORIAL SEMINARTHEME: Puls - Silicea - Flouric - acidSPEAKERS: NJH TEAMFEES NJH LM NJH Subs/Students Others

PrinciplesTill Sept 2007 Rs 50/- Rs 200/- 250/-Till Nov 2007 Rs 250/- Rs 300/- 350/-Till Dec 2007 Rs 250/- Rs 350/- 400/-After Jan 2007 +Spot Rs 250/- Rs 450/- 500/-CONTACT: SHILPA, NJH Office, C/O Milan Clinic, SaraswatiRoad, Santacruz (West), Mumbai 400054.Tel: 26492762. email: [email protected]

21 to 30December 2007

21 to 23December 2007

24 Feb 2008

Shaad Hospital Complexand Research CentreNear Itwari RailwayStationNagpur- 440-002.Phones: (0712) 27662862522563, 25320089822240648

Hemu Gadhvi AuditoriumTagore RoadRajkot (Gujarat) 360002.

Ravindra Natya MandirPrabhadeviMumbai 400 025

For complete details and other eventsCheck: www.njhonline.com/forums, email: [email protected]

The Comprehensive Homoeopathic Event CalenderPlease quote NJH while applying to any seminar.


10

General Section

Yes! I am proud to be a Homoeopath...“HOMOEOPATHY IS MY LIFE”.

ABSTRACT: Here, I am going to share with you my deepest feelings of Homoeopathy. When DrVishpala Madam (Editor,NJH) came up with an idea of “Student NJH” – I got very excited asI got an opportunity to share something which has been absolutely unexpressed till date.I have moulded this article in my feelings in such a way, that it can be easily understood bythe neophytes of Homoeopathy, because I wanted to get best out of me.

Dr KRUTIK SHAH BHMS, D-IACH (Greece)Holistic Homeo Care, B/1 1st Floor, Pioneer Shopping Center, B/h Pioneer High School, Bhalej Road. Anand – 388001.Mobile: 09825891948 E-mail: [email protected].

HOMOEOPATHY IS A COMPLETE SCIENCE

Hippocrates – Father of Modern Medicine, WilliamHarvey – Father of Circulation, Robert Koch – Dis-coverer of Tuberculi bacilli (Thus Tuberculosis isalso called Koch’s lesion) etc and many other sci-entists have seen the objectivity of nature and thuscreated the science called Allopathy. Thence we sayAllopathy is primarily Objective science. Hahnemannas an allopath, had seen the objectivity of nature,and later with an attempt to understand nature heperceived its subjectivity and invented a new sci-ence called Homoeopathy.According to Hippocrates – A MEDICAL SCIENCE isbased on FACTS and LAWS. The facts in Homoeopathyare Proving of drugs and the laws in Homoeopathy areSimilia Similibus Curentur, Cardinal principles, Nature’sLaw of Cure (Aph: 26) andHahnemann had the idea that PROVING on animalswill allow a lot of subjective information lost; so hechanged the idea and proved it on healthy humanbeings. Thus Hahnemann has given more impor-tance to subjectivity while proving of drugs, as thesubjectivity differs from person to person; henceHahnemann has advised us to treat the sick personnot the disease, which finally leads to the conceptof Individualization (Aph:82).We can proudly say that Homoeopathy is a COM-PLETE science as it has full and detailed record ofthe symptoms ie subjective and objective, withmodalities, causative factors etc. Our medicines are

proved on healthy human beings (unlike Allopa-thy). These various types of information are usedfor our prescription.HOMOEOPATHY IS A HOLISTIC SCIENCE

Homoeopathy is a holistic science; a human science.We always have to consider an element of human-ity. Our Homoeopathic medicines have the powerto bring back health without any manual interven-tion even in deeply deranged cases. This is amiracle!!!A person comes to you with ten problems and you aretreating him with only one medicine without even touch-ing him! To the best of my knowledge –Homoeopathy is the only science which has a ca-pacity to do this in this 21st century. What you needto do is just get the RIGHT simillimum according toeasily comprehensible principles (Aph: 2) and restwill be done by medicine as it acts unconditionally(Aph:32). Just requires dedication and sincerity andlove for patients.HOMOEOPATHY IS A (W)HOLISTIC SCIENCE

Homoeopathy does not treat disease but it treatsDiseased Individuals (Aph: 81 foot note). Hahne-mann was a vitalist who was studying life. He hadthe idea that a symptom or pathology is not onlyrelated to one parts of the body; it can be related tomany part of the body. As body is made up fromone cell – whatever symptoms appear even thoughin different parts of the body, they are scientificallyinterconnected.

Yes! I am proud to be a Homoeopath...Dr KRUTIK SHAH


11

General Section

You need to understand the patient as a whole.Body is an indivisible whole in their sensations andfunctions (Aph: 189). No single disturbance strictlyconfines to the single organ or tissue (Aph: 185, 191),as symptoms are known as outwardly reflected pic-ture of the internal essence of disease; an affectionof the vital force (Aph:7). the tunnel or focal allo-pathic vision (like cardiologist, dermatologist,nephrologist etc) is not allowed. This is the proofthat whatever Hahnemann has advised stands trueeven after 250 years!!This is the best advantage of Homoeopathy aswhether the cause is known or unknown – it willbe destroyed; which Dr Hahnemann has said it asan “INVISIBLE HIDDEN INTERIOR (CAUSAMORBI)” (Aph: 6 Foot note). This is the reason whypeople say that Homoeopathy treats permanently(Aph: 25, 26, 109 Foot note, 190).NO RESISTANCE OF HOMOEOPATHIC MEDICINE

At the time of Hahnemann – they were treatingcases of eczema, scabies’ and other relatively su-perficial disease and now almost after 250 years af-ter – you can see the cases of deep neurological,psychiatric, neuromuscular disorders like muscu-lar dystrophies, multiple sclerosis, AIDS etc whichwere not there in their time. So you can see that ahuman health is so much deteriorated over a pe-riod of 250 years!! But still you can see that at thetime of Hahnemann – single medicine was enoughto cure and even now that single medicine is equallyeffective.So these 250 years of observation suggests thatHomoeopathy is able to work throughout, eventhough the human health has been so much dete-riorated probably with so much abusive drugs andvitiated environment!!WHAT DOES THIS MEAN?In Modern Medicine – the first antibiotic inventedwas Penicillin, then bacteria developed resistanceto it and then next generation antibiotic and so on,where today they are using cefixime, ceftrioxoneand still more broad spectrum and yet they developresistance to it.

HAVE YOU EVER HEARD THE WORD RESISTANCE OF AHOMOEOPATHIC REMEDY? Never!! Almost never. Eventhe medicines prepared 250 years ago are still work-ing without any expiry date!! This suggests thatHomoeopathy is not against nature. It is a part andparcel of nature; it will stop working only if thenature changes (Aph: 26, Aph: 119 foot note, Aph:145 foot note).HOMOEOPATHY IS THE FASTEST SCIENCE:Homoeopathy is the fastest science in the world andyou can see it in your day to day practice, if youapply it correctly ie if you get simillimum rightly.These miracles won’t be seen in those Homoeopathswho practice Homoeopathy Allo-pathically. A com-mon tendency of a Homoeopath - to prescribe veryhastily without following principles. DrHahnemann has called them “Mongrel Sect” (Aph:149 foot note).But with proper knowledge (Aph: 3), proper casetaking (Aph: 84 – 99), getting totality of symptoms(Aph: 7 and 18) and forming a portrait of disease(Aph: 6) and making a proper individualization(Aph: 82, 119 foot note) - miraculous results are atyour doorstep (Aph: 24, 68, 145). This stands truein acute disease (Aph: 149) as well as in chronicdisease (Aph: 148).This is purely subjective and it’s application variesfrom person to person. I would suggest that “AHomoeopath should have Patience, Positive atti-tude and Perseverance to be on the path of success”.“Homoeopathy is complete but the Homoeopathis incomplete.” Books can give you a basic frame-work but its application is totally practical. Thus, Iwould recommend to all neophytes of our frater-nity to sit with a Hahnemannian Homoeopath tolearn the application of principles into practice.People have a belief that Homoeopathy takes longtime to act; it is a wrong belief. ‘Homoeopathy is not ascience of action; it is a science of reaction’. Nobodycan predict the response from the organism. It is aclearing mechanism, where vital force is throwing thetoxins out which should be allowed after the admin-istration of a correct Homoeopathic remedy.



12

General Section

Homoeopath tries to hide his mistakes by putting hisblame on Homoeopathy (Aph: 149 foot note). Thiswrong belief about the slow action of Homoeopathic medi-cine is created by none other than the half heartedlypracticing Homoeopaths only!!HOMEPATHY IS THE CHEAPEST SCIENCE

People have been exhausted taking AllopathicMedications (Aph: 74), A specific line of treatment(Aph: 104 footnote), never cures (Aph: 149) and onthe contrary they deteriorate human health morebadly (Aph: 149 footnote).This will never, I say, never happen withHomoeopathy as you are curing a person perma-nently from his one or ten diseases with just threeor four drops of similimum and from then on hewill enjoy his highest level of health!!! This is justamazing and beyond human imagination.What I feel is that the cure we are effecting is abso-lutely immaterial and we are comparing it with thematerial amount, which I feel is an insult toHomoeopathy. Money is equally important; so oneshould charge fairly, but I feel that “Acceptance ofHomoeopathy in masses will surely increase na-tional economy.”MANY AREAS OF RESEARCH

I urge all my colleagues, enthusiastic Homoeopathsto contribute something to the fraternity ofHomoeopathy. There are many areas of researchlike Remedy relationship, Posology, Proving onlower animals to get maximum objective symptoms,authenticity of Homoeopathic medicines, Patho-logical Prescribing etc.“Such Researches may show a new world ofHomoeopathy beyond horizon!!”My friends, Homoeopathy HAS A LOT OF MONEY onlyif you apply principles of Homoeopathy correctly

in your practice, as three to four drops ofsimillimum will cost nothing while you can chargeanything.If you apply your principles properly, then you canbecome a quality-oriented Homoeopath rather thanquantity-oriented. Each case is a new world to en-ter; every case is a new challenge; it is very toughtask to perform. I feel that “There is only one bigdifficulty with Homoeopathy ie it is very difficultto master”.Hahnemann was an allopath and thus he became asuccessful Homoeopath. So the importance of di-agnosis and investigation is equally important. Al-lopathy is the oldest science. Not a single science iscomplete, but knowledge of all the sciences willenable us to guide the patient in a proper direction.If we start working whole-heartedly and if we cor-rect our pitfalls, then the time is not far whenHomoeopathy will be considered equal or evensuperior than Allopathy because where Allopathyworks, Homoeopathy equally works but whereAllopathy ends, Homoeopathy still works.“Opportunities are many but the occasions arefew.” We need to serve our science with the help ofthe fanatic lovers of Homoeopathy whose heart isbeating for Homoeopathy.Thus, I must recommend all the buddingHomoeopaths to read last paragraph of the prefaceof 1st edition of Organon by Dr Hahnemann.LET US BOW DOWN INTO THE LOTUS FEET OFOUR FATHER AS 2ND JULY IS THE 164th DEATHANIVERSARY OF THE MOST SCIENTIFIC GE-NIUS EVER LIVED!!! ☯☯☯☯☯

What stubbing, plowing, digging, and harrowing is to land, that thinking, reflecting, examining isto the mind. Each has its proper culture; and as the land that is suffered to lie waste and wild for along time will be overspread with brushwood, brambles, and thorns, which will not fail to sproutup in a neglected, uncultivated mind, a great number of prejudices and absurd opinions, which owetheir origin partly to those seeds which chance to be scattered in it by every wind of doctrine whichthe cunning of statesmen, the singularity of pedants, and the superstition of fools shall raise. -Ber-keley.



13

General Section

The “scientific method” is the mechanical method; tak-ing all the symptoms and writing out all associatedremedies with grading, making a summary withgrades marked at the end. There is an “artistic method”that omits the mechanical and is better, but all are notprepared to use it. The artistic method demands thatjudgment should be passed on all the symptoms, afterthe case is most carefully taken. The symptoms mustbe judged as to their value as characteristics, in rela-tion to the patient; they must be reviewed by rationalmind to determine those which are strange, rare andpeculiar.The artistic prescriber sees much in proving that can-not be retained in the repertory, where everything mustbe sacrificed for the alphabetical system. The artisticprescriber must study Materia Medica earnestly, to en-able him to fix sick images in his mind which, whenneeded, will infill the sick personalities of human be-ings.No such things as infallibility in prescribing will everbe attained, but he who uses his repertory faithfullyand intelligently and no one can do that without equalfruitfulness and intelligence in his study of MateriaMedica – will inevitably reap his rewards in resultsand in that peace of mind that comes with an approv-ing conscience.Homeopathy is, from the beginning to end an “Art ofIndividualization” (Aph 82). We have to individualizeour remedies as well as our patients. As there are nosurrogates (Aph 119 Foot Note). It must be kept in mindthat to allow our conception of remedies to be limitedby nosological terms will hinder us from utilizing rem-edies to the fullest. To get the greatest good from theMateria Medica – we must recognize our remedies aspowerful curative agents ready to serve us in any case,no matter what the name of the disease or what thelaboratory findings are. The use of the repertory is one

of the higher branches of our art and before it can bemastered. The laws governing the homeopathic treat-ment and cure of the diseases given in Organon of Medi-cine and Chronic Disease by Hahnemann must be mas-tered. I firmly believe that if homoeopathy is to sur-vive in this age of therapeutic nihilism, when so manyill practices are being fostered as Homeopathic, its sur-vival will come from a comprehensive study of the Or-ganon.Samuel Hahnemann in Aphorism 153 Footnote hasvery much appreciated repertorial work of Dr VonBoenning-hausen especially in Intermittent Fever inAphorism 235 Foot Note.What I feel is that “Every Homoeopath should be hisown Materia Medica maker”. I think you will be am-ply repaid for the time given to a careful study of thisanalysis, not only for the usable knowledge of the rem-edies that you will have acquired, but also and per-haps, of the greatest importance – the help it will be toyou in enlarging and compiling your own MateriaMedica.The repertory was not discovered to replace MateriaMedica. We cannot stress enough that the repertorycan never replace our constant study and use of thepathogenesis of our remedies. It should be used as anindex to lighten the task of memory in storing that vastsymptomatology of our remedies.Repertory, Organon and Materia Medica are the pil-lars of Homoeopathy and are deeply interconnected.“Nobody can be successful ignoring basics”. Sourcebooks are the tools and need to be studied thoroughlyin order to become true, Hahnemannian Homoeopath.One must remember that even the stalwarts have be-come popular and successful only by reading thesource books.All the very best to all you budding homeopaths!Jay Hahnemann. Jay Homeopathy!. ☯ ☯ ☯ ☯ ☯

An Introduction to repertoryABSTRACT: Repertory is our chief instrument of precision. True, some men do some goodwork without repertory, but they also do poor work, more then they would do with it. Aself-made artisan may be a very useful man although ignorant of the theory and mostadvanced methods obtaining in his line of work, but he can never measure up to the manwhom education and thoroughness of method has made an expert.

Dr KRUTIK H SHAH BHMS, D-IACH (Greece)“Holistic Homeo Care”, B/1 1st Floor, Pioneer Shopping Center, B/H Pioneer High School, Bhalej Road, Anand – 388001. Gujarat.Mobile: 09825891948 Email: [email protected], [email protected]

An Introduction to repertoryDr KRUTIK SHAH


14

General Section

Details of some lesser known RepertoriesABSTRACT: The totality of symptoms in contrast to pathology plays the key role in under-standing a drug or patient in Homoeopathy. The selection of similimum from the vastsymptomatology of Material Medica always demands a way of differentiating/sortingsimilar looking drugs. Repertorisation is one such comprehensive, scientific and error-less way of doing this exercise.

Dr ARDESHIR T JAGOSE MD (HOM)Meherzin Co-op Hsg Society Ltd., C/43-44, 4th Floor, 109/A Wodehouse Road, Colaba, Mumbai - 400 005.Tel.: 022-22153873, Mobile: 9820291108

The roots of Repertory can be seen as early as 1816in the preamble of Materia Medica Pura byHahnemann himself: “For the convenience of treat-ment, we require merely to jot down after eachsymptom all the medicines which can produce sucha symptom with tolerable accuracy, expressingthem by a few letters (Abbreviations), and also tobear in mind the circumstances under which theyoccur; they have a determining influence on ourchoice. Proceed in the same way with all the othersymptoms, noting what medicine each excite; fromthe list so prepared we shall be able to perceivewhich among the medicines homeopathically cov-ers most of the symptoms present, especially themost peculiar and characteristic ones and for whichthis remedy is sought”. This laid the foundation ofthe present day repertories.From the first repertory Fragmenta De ViribusMedica Mentorum Positivis published in 1805 byHahnemann himself, the profession has seen a largenumber of repertories and the search for an idealand complete repertory will go unabated in future.The credit for publishing the first repertory goes toVon Boenninghausen, who published the Reper-tory of Antipsorics in 1832 with a preface by theMaster (2nd Ed in 1833). This repertory was used byHahnemann himself.In 1835, came Boenninghausen’s Repertory of medi-cines which are not antipsorics and in 1836 camean attempt at showing the relative kinship ofHomoeopathic medicines. All these publicationswere combined to form his masterpiece. Therapeu-

tic Pocket Book was published in 1846 in German.This became the standard reference work used bymost American Homoeopaths including StuartClose, Carroll Dunham, H N Guernsey and T FAllen. In 1900 Cyrus Maxwell Boger made a newtranslation of the Antipsorics remedies into English.It contained 232 pages. Dr Boger continued to en-hance it until his death in 1935. He made so manyadditions and new rubrics that its final size was1040 pages - an almost five fold increase which latergrew into The Boger-Boenninghausen’s Charac-teristics and Repertory(BBCR) in 1905.1) KNERR REPERTORY

It is an index to Hering’s Guiding Symptoms pre-pared by Dr Calvin B Knerr.The arrangement or classification, followed in thecompilation of the repertory is the one inauguratedby Hahnemann, developed, perfected and used byHering through his entire Materia-Medica work ieanatomical or regional division into 48 chapters.LIST OF CHAPTERS

Mind and disposition (91), Sensorium (2), Innerhead (3), Outer Head (4), Eyes (5), Ears (6), Nose(7), Upper Face (8), Lower Face (9), Teeth and Gums(10), Taste and Tongue (11), Inner Mouth (12),Throat (13), Desires, Aversions Appetite, Thirst (14),Eating and drinking (15), Hiccough, Belching, nau-sea and Vomiting (16), Scrobiculum and Stomach(17), Hypochondria (18), Abdomen (19), Stool andRectum (20), Urinary organs (21), Male sexual Or-gans (22), Female Sexual Organs (23), Pregnancy,Parturition, Location (24), Voice Larynx, Trachea

Details of some lesser known RepertoriesDr ARDESHIR T JAGOSE


15

General Section

and Bronchi (25), Respiration (26), Cough and Ex-pectoration (27), Inner Chest and Lungs (28), HeartPulse and Circulation (29), Outer Chest (30), Neckand Back (31), Upper limbs (32), Lower Limbs (33),Limbs in general (34), Rest, Position, Motion (35),Nerves (36), Sleep (37), Time (38), Temperature andWeather (39), Fever (5\40), Attacks, Periodicity (41),Locality and Direction (42), sensation in general(43), Tissues (44), Touch, Passive Motion, Injuries(45), Skin (46), Stages of Life and Constitution (47),Drug Relationships (48), Index.Each chapter is alphabetically divided into sectionsand rubrics without destroying consistency as awhole. The basic difference of this repertory fromAllen’s symptoms register is that it contains symp-toms and remedies from provings and confirma-tions.To represent it, different grades have been used.

I. The lowest, a single light line, designatingoccasionally confirmed symptoms.

II. A double light line designates symptomsmore frequently confirmed or if but onceconfirmed, strictly in character with the ge-nius of the remedy.

III. A single heavy line, a symptom verified bycures.

IV. A double heavy line, symptom repeatedlyverified.

These degree marks tally with the four styles of typeused by Boenninghausen.∏∏∏∏∏ represents symptoms observed on the sick ie onlyrepresents toxicological symptoms.This concordance repertory is one of the few reper-tories where symptoms have been placed unbro-ken by preserving the original words/expressions,so that they retain the most delicate shades of mean-ing to maintain individuality, which is very vitalin the selection of similimum. Generalization hasthe drawback of destroying the fine delicacy ofsymptoms as has been with Boenninghausen Rep-ertories and to some extent with Kent’s Repertory.Let us take some example of mental symptoms:Forgetful: Knerr has listed first all the remedieswhich have forgetfulness in general, followed by

smaller rubrics which have special association witha particular circumstance or condition or are relatedto a specific time frame in an alphabetical order.This arrangement though systematic and good, isimpractical in the repertorisation process. There-fore, this repertory, though useful has rarely beenused by professionals.Rubric placing is more appropriate in Knerr’s Rep-ertory as compared to Kent. Eg Jaundice has beenplaced under section Liver and Gall stones is a sepa-rate rubric.2) THEMATIC REPERTORY BY JA MIRRILI

The author opines that it is very difficult to under-stand homoeopathic knowledge from hithertoavailable Clinical and Pure Materia Medica andRepertories. He tried to express the thematic phi-losophy of the study of homoeopathic symptomsby organizing the symptoms of Pure MateriaMedica and repertory by themes. He says that Rep-ertories were the main attempt to classify thehomoeopathic symptoms so that they could be usedin the clinic for fast medical advice, but they haveseveral limitations. Eg: In repertory, symptoms aresevered and classified in alphabetical order withno connections, loosing their dynamic expression.Thus similar symptoms are placed in different chap-ters and remain unrelated.Secondly, the symptoms described in Pure MateriaMedica are not totally represented in the reporto-rial rubrics. In this new thematic repertory, authorhas tried to overcome weaknesses of repertories.Eg: In the thematic repertory, at the forsaken theme,we have lots of symptoms with the sense of for-saken but they do not present the word forsaken.This thematic repertory incorporates the collectivemood and 12,500 symptoms from the Pure MateriaMedica of Hahnemann, Hering, T F Allen, H CAllen, Jeremy Sherr and Complete Repertory byRoger van Zandvoort.These are arranged carefully under nearly 300themes like Ambition, Forsaken, Death, Helpless-ness, Money, Religious, Travel, Yielding etc. In thisway, all unrelated symptoms present under the



16

General Section

same theme and the limitation of the Kentian rep-ertories, where similar symptoms with differentspelling are found to be listed far away of eachother, is overcome.3) ROBIN MURPHY’S REPERTORY

It is a reorganized and expanded version of Kent’sRepertory with Kent and Knerr format. The bookis compact, practical and easy to carry like KentRepertory. It has 67 different chapters arranged al-phabetically as compared to 37 in Kent’s. Rubricsand sub rubrics within each chapter are in alpha-betical format, similar to those of Materia Medicaleaving out Kent’s plan of site, time, modalities, ex-tensions etc. There is complete reorganization of theinformation with smaller anatomical and functionalsubdivisions in alphabetical order. It contains 39,000new rubrics and reliable 20,000 new additions andupdates, still retaining a small lightweight size forconvenience. The grading of drugs is similar toKent’s three grades ie Bold, Bold italics and plaintype.Dr Murphy has updated the language of the reper-tory in many places, for which many new genera-tions of homoeopathic students will thank him. Eg:“Boredom” replaces “Ennui”, “Crying” replaces“Weeping” and “Humiliation” replaces “Mortifi-cation” though the original terms are cross refer-enced to the terms in updated language.There is a bold reorganization and expansion ofrepertorial information with many practical divi-sions: Children, Pregnancy, Emergencies, Environ-ment, Dreams and Delusions, plus use of moderndiagnostic terminology as Alzheimer’s syndrome,Polycystic Ovaries etc.He has created sections which make it easier to lo-cate an experience such as symptoms related tomusic. Besides the separate sections which havemusic as a modality, he has a music section in theMind chapter which includes many of the othermental symptoms which relate to music.There are plenty of cross references and a very use-ful word index in the back of the book to locate dif-ficult symptoms.

DRAWBACKS

It lacks the superscript code reference of the authorswho have contributed towards addition to Kent.Therefore it is very difficult to know the source ofthe concerned data as well as remedy.If we compare three rubrics of Murphy with that ofComplete repertory in Mac Repertory: “Deceitful”,“Defiant” and “Ailments from Reproaches”. In“Deceitful “Lycopodium2, Opium3, and Thuja3 appearin Murphy’s Repertory same as in the CompleteRepertory except Morphinum is added. But becauseof absence of references one does not know thesource of these additions/upgrades.In “Defiant”, Cham2 and Medo1 are added and Tubis upgraded (3) where again the same commentsare applicable.In “Ailments from reproaches”, he has added Anac1,Cham1, Lyc3 and Nat-mur2and upgraded Carc2, Coloc2

and Staph3.There are some rubrics which have been combinedfrom the original Kent Repertory, An example iscombination of “Egotistical” and “Haughty” intoone rubric entitled as “Egotistical haughty.” Thetwo words describe two distinct characteristics, asoriginally perceived by Kent, and belong to twoseparate rubrics.4) COMPLETE REPERTORY BY ROGER VAN ZANDVOORT

IRRHIS Publishers, Leidschendam, the Nether-lands, July 21, 1996This is the largest, most complete, and most accuraterepertory in the history of homoeopathy. It comes inthree volumes Mind, Vertigo through speech andVoice and Respiration through Generalities and anall-in-one volume (2,830 pages). Using Kent’s Reper-tory as the core, Van Zandvoort poured in the con-tents of every reliable repertory he could put his handson, including the unique personal repertories of PierreSchmidt and Von Boenninghausen.SOURCES OF COMPLETE REPERTORY

First, Third, and Sixth American editions of KentsRepertory, Homoeopathic journals, Schmidt’s andChand’s Final general repertory, Kunzli’sRepertorium Generale, Sivaramans’ Additions and



17

General Section

Corrections to Kent’s Repertory, Boger’s Additionsto Kent’s Repertory, CCRH’s Corrections toBoenninghausen’s Repertory.Information and cross references have been addedfrom Pierre Schmidt, Kent Repertories andBoenninghausen’s Repertory. Boericke’s Repertoryand the most useful part of Phatakas Repertory havebeen completely incorporated, using Referenceworks for cross checking the material with theirsource.DESCRIPTION OF COMPLETE REPERTORY -CRThere are about 515,000 confirmed additions in theCR along with a number of new remedies: Ozone,Bambusa, Marble, Limestone, Sequoia-sempervirens,Lac-humanum, Hydrophis (snake venom) and manyadditions for Sacharum-officianalis, Carcinosin andBowel-nosodes, Granite and Bothrops-atrox. Each andevery rubric has been traced to its origin mentionedin superscript coded number giving the page num-ber of the original text for each rubric for precisionreference. This is the greatest advantage of this rep-ertory, as each new information has a reference codeby which one can judge its value or worth.There has been a lot of planning in the organiza-tion of the repertory. The mind symptoms havebeen systematically classified and indexed so thatthe right rubric or remedy can be found easily.Noises in several sections have been brought to-gether under the main rubric “Noise” (like in ab-domen, grumbling, quacking etc)He has changed previously confusing abbreviationsto more easily understood versions mostly in themineral and acid remedies.Many occurrences of symptoms have been simpli-fied using the most common word for their spe-cific meaning. Most important word in many ru-brics has been moved to be read first; ie during uri-nation is changed to urination, during. The termi-nology in some cases has been modernized andclarified eg Miscarriage has been replaced withAbortion and Micturition by Urination.SOME IMPORTANT CHANGES

One example of a rubric in Mind section: Emotionspredominated by intellect (as it appears in Syn-

thetic) has been changed after confirmation fromtext to : Emotions -Controlled by intellect, need tobe. This phrasing of the rubric gives it exactly theopposite meaning. Whereas the first one indicatesthat the intellect is so strong that it overwhelms andcontrols the emotions, the actual meaning indicatesthat Emotions are so strong that they have to becontrolled by intellect. The latter makes sense be-cause the drug enlisted against the rubric (Caler andViol-o) both are known to be highly emotional andhysterical drugs and not intellectual ones as de-picted earlier.The latest edition of Complete Repertory also addsanother rubric:Emotions, too strong – which also has the samedrugs. This confirms the corrections.Some of the new rubrics are; Ability increased,Achieve things desire to, Animal consciousness,Borrows trouble, Blaming, Charitable, Constructive,Daydreaming, Delicacy feeling of, Dignity, House-keeping inept for, Independent, Enthusiasm, Teas-ing, Telepathy, Intellectual.A NUMBER OF SUB RUBRICS HAVE BEEN ADDED

Precocity – Religious, Sexual, School, but does notperform to capacityEmbraces – Trees wants to embrace: OzoneExtravagance – Economy for want of, sometimesmiserly, works hardConsolation refuses for one’s own – Nitric-acidContemptuous – Opponent for, relations for, society.DISADVANTAGES

1. Lot of unreliable additions has been madeboth in terms of drugs and rubrics; egAndroctonus and Chocolate are two drugswhich are put in almost all rubrics.

2. Lot of cross reference, which turn out to befutile

3. Many small rubrics with single drugs leadthe prescriber go astray if given too muchimportance

4. It weighs almost 10 gm making it difficultto carry.



18

General Section

5) SYNTHESIS: REPERTORIUM HOMOEOPATHICUM

SYNTHETICUM BY FREDERIK SCHROYENS

This Repertory is linked to the Radar project. It isbased on the Sixth American Edition of Kent’s Rep-ertory and contains all its rubrics and remedies.Since 1987, Synthesis has been used as a databasefor the Radar program in the daily practice of lead-ing homoeopaths. It has been commented upon andthereby improved over and over again, which givesit an outstanding label of quality. This repertory isthe best example of expanded version of Kent’sRepertory from 1916 till date. It retains the Kent’shierarchical structure, therefore there is no need to

learn a new format. It incorporates vast number ofcorrections and adaptations caused by textual er-rors, illogical symptoms locations and ambiguouswording found in original eg Breast is replaced byMammae or Chest when appropriate, there areabout 235,000 additions from highly respectedhomoeopathic texts, giving priority to the classicalauthors – Kent, Hahnemann, Hering, Allen, Clarke,Boericke, Knerr etc.

Utility of understanding relationship of RemediesABSTRACT: This article especially attempts to explain the last section of Boenninghasuen’sTherapeutic Pocket Book (TPB) which deals with “Concordance”. It is interesting toknow that in the earlier editions it was named ‘Enigma’ meaning puzzle. For betterunderstanding and solution (for whom it is indeed a puzzle), the author has furtherexplained method of using relationship section with the help of a case from TPB.Ed: I think the deo is wonderful givinig re-sight into TPB and its usefulness.

Dr PARIMAL K PARMAR BHMS, MD (REPERTORY)36/ Ravi Park Soc, Opp Sainath Park Soc, Vasna Road, Vadodara, Mobile No: 9426410136.

Concordance means, “The state of being similar to”or “Consistent with something else”, used espe-cially for the action of the medicine. This section isthe least understood and used because of the ne-glect on the part of us, the physicians.Boenninghausen’s own experience and study ofremedies has helped him to compile this section,which in reality should render an important ser-vice to the Homoeopathic System of Medicine.It is arranged in alphabetical order by devoting onesection to each remedy and then subdivided intodifferent rubrics, which are generalized symptomgroups, arranged in the same order as the previoussections in the Repertory.FOR EXAMPLE: Mind, Localities, Sensations, Glands,Bones, Skin, Sleep and Dreams, Blood, Circulationand Fever, Aggravation: Time and Circumstances,

Other remedies, Inimical and Antidotes.Homoeopaths sparingly use this section. It canbring out therapeutics programme of acute rem-edies, constitutional remedy, complementary rem-edy, second prescription, intercurrent remedies andother like remedies.METHOD OF USING RELATIONSHIP SECTION WITH THE

HELP OF A CASE

A 65 years, elderly lady, complained of pain: beganas soreness in epigastrium and right hypochondria;ameliorated by sitting, belching and aggravated bylying on back, markedly by lying on right and onmotion especially on turning over in bed. There wasa constant sensation of pulling in the right hypochon-dria, aggravated on right side. The pain is associatedby sweating, as if repeated blows in the region of rightscapula. The mouth is exceedingly dry. Great aver-

Utility of understanding relationship of RemediesDr PARIMAL K PARMAR


19

General Section

sion to water, strong odors including food, causesnausea. She vomits as soon as water becomes warmin the stomach. There is no thirst. Flatus++, soonpasses.URINE: Offensive.CBC: WBC was 19000/ Cu mm.REPERTORY ANALYSIS

LOCATION: Epigastrium (Pg 79), Hypochondrium,right (82)SENSATION: Pulling (175), Hammering (160), Sorepain, internally (181)MODALITIES: < Lying on back (290);on Rt side(290),<Motion of affected part (292), < Turning over in bed(304), < Strong odor (293), > Sitting (319), > Belch-ing (313)CONCOMITANTS: Sweat with associated symptoms(256), Thirst less (66), Mouth in general (62), Dry-ness internally (of part usually moist) (156), Incar-cerated flatus (85), Urine offensive (95).The case was repertorised with the 18 symptomsnoted above with following results: Sulphur 71/18;Phosphorus 68/18; Nux-vom 71/16; Bryonia 58/15;Pulsatilla 63/16.Now TPB has no rubric for vomiting as soon aswater becomes warm in stomach, Phosphorus wasadministered with the knowledge of MateriaMedica, which improved the patient.

The 1st prescription was Phosphorus, with whichpatient was relieved.To complete the cure, we need to prescribe the 2nd

remedy with help of concordance.For that one needs to draw 12 vertical lines of equaldistances except the first and the last, which shouldbe broader. On the top of the first broader columnrecord the term ‘medicines’ and the last broader col-umn record the term ‘total’ the rest 10 columns arefor sections: Mind, Location, Sensations, Glands,Bones, Skin, Sleep and Dream, Blood circulation andfever, Aggravations, Other remedies.The base of the first prescription should be takenas Eliminating Rubric, as in the case eliminating ru-bric is location.Now consider the medicines from Remedy Phospho-rus, which was first prescribed. Particularly of the 1st,2nd, 3rd grades ie with mark values 5, 4, and 3 of therubric in the column space for the ‘Medicines’ in thefirst vertical column one below the other. When re-cording is complete sum them up the total matchingand the total grades and record on the Rt hand broadercolumns specified for total by oblique lines to demar-cate them. Pick up 2 or 3 medicines as per highestmatching and highest grade in total and compare wellwith the section values of medicines then finally cometo a condition of similimum by totality.

MEDICINES L M S G B S S B T O TOTALO I E L O K L L I TC N N A N I E O M HA D S N E N E O E ET A D S P D A RI T S G RO I D F G EN O R E M

N E V EA E DM R Y

APIS 5 4 4 - - 3 2 2 2 5 27/08ARG-N 5 - 5 5 - - 3 1 3 5 27/07BELL 5 4 4 5 2 3 3 4 3 4 37/10CALC-C 5 3 4 2 3 3 4 3 4 4 35/10GELS 5 4 4 - - - - 4 2 5 24/06

FIRST PRESCRIPTION: Phosphorus

Utility of understanding relationship of RemediesDr PARIMAL K PARMAR


20

General Section

ABSTRACT: Repertoriztion is not only a mechanical process of counting rubrics and totaling marks ob-tained by a medicine. It also includes the logical steps to reach the proper repertory and finallydifferentiating the remedies with the help of Material Medica.

KALI-BI 5 - 5 - - 1 - - 3 4 18/05PULS 5 5 5 3 2 4 5 4 5 5 43/10SANG 5 - 5 - - - - 3 3 4 20/05SEPIA 5 3 4 - - 3 5 3 5 4 32/08SULPH 5 3 5 4 4 5 4 3 2 5 40/10Aesculus 4 - 3 - - - - - 1 3 11/04Aloe 4 2 3 - - - 1 1 2 4 17/07Ars 4 - 2 2 - 4 2 4 3 3 24/08Bapt 4 3 3 - - - 2 2 2 4 20/07China 4 - 4 - - - 2 3 3 3 19/06Lyco 4 2 4 3 2 4 - 5 4 4 32/09Merc 4 2 4 4 2 3 3 4 3 4 33/10Nux-vom 4 4 5 - - - 4 4 5 4 30/07Podo 4 - 2 - - - 2 2 2 4 16/06Aconite 3 4 3 - - 3 2 4 2 3 24/08Allum-c 3 - 1 - - - - - 1 2 07/04Arnica 3 - 3 2 - 3 - 2 2 2 17/07Berb 3 - 4 - - - - 2 - 2 11/04Bryonia 3 2 4 2 - 3 4 5 4 4 31/10Carbo-veg 3 3 - 2 - 2 - - 2 3 15/06

RESULT OF REPERTORIZATION: Puls 43/10, Sulp 40/10,Bell 37/10, Calc-carb 35/10.Puls covers the maximum marks and is present ineach section so is the second prescription.

Second remedy chosen should have either ‘Comple-mentary’ relation or ‘Follow well’ otherwise the casemay spoil. ☯ ☯ ☯ ☯ ☯

Steps to Repertorization

Dr SHASHI KANT TIWARIPrincipal, Father Muller Homoeopathic Medical College & Hospital University Road, Deralakatte, Mangalore – 574160

Repertory follows the logic of induction and deduc-tion. The steps to repertorization start from casetaking and end by finding out the simillimum. Theyare:

1. Case taking2. Recording and interpretation3. Defining the problem4. Classification and evaluation of symptoms

(analysis)5. Erecting totality6. Selection of a proper repertory7. Repertorial result8. Analysis of repertorial result and prescrip-

tionCASE TAKING: It is the first step, and the outcome oftreatment entirely depends upon its success. Any

Steps to RepertorizationDr SHASHI KANT TIWARI


21

General Section

mistake committed here certainly interferes in theselection of the remedy and planning of the treat-ment.RECORDING AND INTERPRETATION: For effectiverepertorization, precise recording is very crucial forproceeding further with the subsequent steps. Re-cording is not done independent of interpretation;so both should be done simultaneously. Care shouldbe taken to record the intensity of each symptomand interpreting them without being prejudiced.DEFINING THE PROBLEM: Once the case is taken well,interpreted and recorded properly, the physicianshould be in a position to define the problem pre-cisely. The record should guide him to understandthe person and his disease. The sickness of the per-son expresses itself at various levels, and to bringall such expressions together to get a whole pic-ture, requires a clear understanding of whatHahnnemann stated: “What is to be cured in a dis-ease, that is to say in every individual case of dis-ease”. To define a problem means, to define the in-dividual who is facing a problem. The individualis fully revealed to a physician from the effects ofdifferent events associated with him as well as fromthe related data collected from various sources.Diagnosis of the disease, which is of crucial impor-tance, would segregate the peculiar characteristicsexpression from the common ones. The problemdefinition includes, knowing the patient’s predis-position, disposition, diathesis and disease. Thusonly by precisely defining the problem, a physicianwould be in a position to go ahead in the right di-rection.CLASSIFICATION AND EVALUATION OF SYMPTOMS

(ANALYSIS): It is a well known fact that all the symp-toms in a case are not equally important. After tak-ing the case, a physician faces quite a big numberof symptoms, which are required to be analyzed,classified and evaluated in order to arrange themhierarchically. Analysis and classification give anidea about the case in respect of its nature and thetype of symptoms, and therefore, evaluation can bedone by different methods. The three standardmethods of classification and evaluation pro-pounded by Boenninghausen, Kent and Boger are

of practical use in repertorization. The best way ofdoing analysis of a given case is to classify all theexpressions and symptoms of the case into com-mon and uncommon symptoms. This classificationwill give the idea about the suitability of the Rep-ertory as well as the method of working out a case.ERECTING TOTALITY (SYNTHESIS): Totality is not thesum total of symptoms but it is a logical combina-tion of symptoms, which characterise the personas well as individualise the problem. Thus, all thesymptoms which are classified and evaluated, donot form a working totality of the case.From classification and evaluation, the hierarchyof symptoms is known, but which to select to formthe totality ie which can logically represent thewhole picture and get a correspondence? This logi-cal arrangement must follow a definite principle. Ifthe case has got more Generals and a few Particu-lars with rare Modalities, it would follow a differ-ent arrangement than that of a case, which hasvague Modalities and striking Concomitants, or aPathological General.SELECTION OF THE REPERTORY AND REPERTORIZATION

After the totality has been erected, the case becomesclear to the physician. He should look for one ofthe following points in the case:GENERALS: MENTAL/ PHYSICALS. PARTICULARS.LOCATION. SENSATION. MODALITIES. CONCOMITANTS

PATHOLOGICAL GENERALS.If a case were full of Generals, Kent’s Repertorywould be the best. If it has got Pathological Gener-als, Boger’s Repertory must be selected. If the casehas got Particulars, with Location, Sensation, Mo-dalities and Concomitants with a few mentals,Therapeutic Pocket Book is preferable; however,Boger’s Repertory can also be used.Synthetic Repertory can be used for the Kent methodto refer more Generals. It has also many Pathologi-cal Generals, but no Particulars. Synthesis, CompleteRepertory and Homoeopathic Medical Repertory can beused where Generals are more prominent. More-over, these recent repertories can also be utilisedfor working out all types of cases. RepertoriumUniversale is suitably designed to repertorise all



22

General Section

types of cases by using different methods ofrepertorization.Once the repertory is selected, a major part of theanalysis and synthesis of the case is done. The nextstep is to rearrange the totality according to the rep-ertory selected. Rearrangement of totality in terms ofthe Repertory selected is called “Repertorial totality’.Thus, a well arranged totality is worked out.Next convert the symptoms into rubrics, which re-quires an acquaintance with the repertory. Thesymptoms obtained from the patient may not befound in the repertory in the same form; so the phy-sician must know the construction and arrangementof each repertory.Rubrics should be arranged according to hierarchy,reason and page number. The final outcome is writ-ten as follows:

Symptom Rubrics Reason Page No1 x y z2 x y z3 x y z

Now, at this stage, the case is referred to repertory,worked out, and a group of medicines with mark-ings is arrived at.REPERTORIAL RESULT: A group of close running medi-cines should be noted down according to the symp-toms covered and marks obtained. For example, if

Lyc covers seven rubrics and 18 marks, it should bewritten 18/7. A few medicines, which are nearer tothe first also, find a place in the repertorial result.ANALYSIS OF REPERTORIAL RESULT AND PRESCRIPTION:The remedy, which gets the highest mark, is notnecessarily the final remedy in all cases. Repertorialresults should be finally referred in the court ofMaterial Medica. Marks are important, but thesedo not constitute the final verdict. Further, thegroup has to be compared to the picture of the pa-tient and with the help of Materia Medica, it shouldbe differentiated. Sounding a note of caution,Boenninghausen writes, “…… for this purpose, heshould not content himself with repertories thathave been prepared, a very frequent carelessness, forthese books contain only slight hints as to one or theother remedy that might be selected but can nevertake the place of the careful reading up of the foun-tain sources” (The field, which differentiates medi-cines, is called potential differential field). Repertorythus narrows down the groups of medicines, andwith the help of source books, a final remedy canbe found out. The remedy so selected must finallypass through certain criteria such susceptibility,sensitivity, suppression (if any), the level of simi-larity, functional and structural changes, vitalityand miasm, to arrive at the right potency and doseschedule.

☯☯☯☯☯

The love of study, a passion which derives great vigor from enjoyment, supplies each day, each

hour, with a perpetual round of independent and raional pleasure.

- Gibbon

☯ ☯

The more we study the more we discoveer our ignorance.

- Shelley



23Funny Game of Rubrics DiscriminationDr SATISH P KANOJIA

General Section

Funny Game of Rubrics DiscriminationABSTRACT: Though a tedious one yet, it was fun discriminating the rubrics on mentalchapter. The article deals with the rubrics and their corresponding cross referencesfound in the Kent’s Repertory. The language used is not entirely Repertorial.

Dr SATISH P KANOJIA 1, Mangela Wadi, Juhu Tara Rd, Santacruz (W), Mumbai-400 049Tel: 26607867 (C) 9821009605.

1. Abandoned 01a) Delusion she is alone in the

world 20b) Forsaken feeling 49c) Delusion lost affection of

friend 20d) Deserted 35e) Delusion friendless 26f) Delusion that he is neglected

30g) Isolation sensation of 60h) Delusion has lost affections of friends 20i) Delusions she is always alone

20j) Delusion his friends have lost

22 confidence in him.2. Abrupt 01a) Answers abruptly 03b) Impulsive 54c) Rashness 71d) Insolent 573. Absent Minded 01a) Absorbed, buried in thoughts

01b) Abstraction of mind 01c) Thoughts persistent 87d) Pre-occupied 69e) Reveries 75f) Meditation 64g) Sits, wrapped in deep, sad

thoughts as if and noticesnothing 81

4. Abusive 01a) Cursing 17

b) Insolent 57c) Rudeness 75d) Swearing 86e) Contemptuous 16f) Scorn 78g) Slander 81h) Despises 365. Activity desires 01a) Industrious 56b) Occupation ameliorates 69c) Busy 10d) Anxiety, motion amel 07e) Delirium busy 186. Acuteness 01a) Memory active 64b) Concentration active 137. Admonition agg 01a) Repnaches ailments form 71b) Weeps from admonition 93c) Weeps from reproaches 94d) Weeps when remonstrated

with 948. Affectionate 01a) Benevolence 09b) Love, with one of her own

sex 639. Agitation 01a) Excitement 4010. Air Castles 01a) Theorizing 87b) Plans making many 69c) Deeds, feels as if he could do

great 1711. Ambition loss of 01a) Indolence 55

b) Dullness 37c) Listless 62d) Comprehension different 1212. Amorous 2a) Lasciviousness 61b) Lewdness 62c) Shameless 79d) Nymphomania 68e) Increased desire 716f) Indifference exposure of her

person 55g) Sexual passion violent 711h) Sexual passion increased 711i) Naked wants to be 68j) Obscene 6913. Amusement, averse to 2a) Going out averse to 50b) Indifference to pleasure 55c) Indisposition to play in

children 6914. Anger 2a) Irritability 57b) Quarrelsome 7015. Anger caressing from 2a) Anger when touched 216. Antagonism with herself 4a) Delusion divided into two

parts 24b) Thoughts two trains of

thought 8817. Anthrophobia 4a) Fear of people 46b) Fear of men 46c) Men dread of 65


24Funny Game of Rubrics Discrimination

Dr SATISH P KANOJIA

General Section

18. Antics 4a) Grimaces 51b) Foolish behaviors 48c) Childish behaviour 11d) Silly 80e) Idiocy 53f) Buffoonery 10g) Gestures, viticulture’s or

foolish 50h) Play full, play with bottom of

his clothes 6919. Anxiety, conscience of (as if

guilty of crime) 6a) Delusion that he is a criminal

23b) Delusion that he has ne-

glected his duty 30c) Remorse 7120. Anxiety dark in 6a) Fear dark 43b) Darkness agg 17c) Delusion sees image in the

dark 30d) Delusion sees specters ghost

spirits 3221. Anxiety cruelties after

hearing 6a) Horrible thing and sad

stories affect her profoundly52

b) Fear of hearing bad news 43c) Report of cruelties excite fear

4322. Anxiety fits with 6a) Anxiety paroxysms 7b) Anxiety sudden 823. Anxiety about future 7a) Fear destination of being

unable to reach his 4424. Anxiety as if pursned when

walking 7b) Delusion pursued thought he

was 31c) Delusion pursecuted that he

is 3025. Anxiety salvation about 8a) Religious affections 71b) Despair religion 36c) Doubtful about the welfare of

his soul 3726. Anxiety riding while 7a) Fear of riding in carriage 47b) Riding in a carriage averse to

7527. Anxiety storm, during a

thunder 8a) Thunderstorm during 88b) Storm approach of 140328. Anxiety strangers in the

presence of 8a) Company presence of strang-

ers agg 12b) Stranger presence of agg 84c) Child coughs of the sight of

stranger 806d) Perspiration in the presence

of stranger 130229. Anxiety time is set if a 8a) Hurry for the appointed time

to arrive 54b) Time passes too quickly 8830. Anxity in warm bed yet,

limbs cold if uncovered 9a) Anxiety in bed 5b) Anxiety in evening 431. Apathy 9a) Indifference 54b) Listless 6232. Audacity 9a) Courageous 17b) Insolent 57c) Boldness 1033. Avarices 9a) Fear of poverty 64b) Selfishness 78c) Covetous 17d) Desires more than she needs

35

e) Delusion thinks he is poor 31f) Delusion he is poor 31g) Delusions family will starve 33h) Fear of financial vain 47i) Fear of starving 4734. Aversion approached to

being 9a) Aversion to answer 3b) Aversion to be spoken to 82c) Aversion to be touched 89d) Fear of others approaching

him 4335. Aversion to friend 9a) Company aversion to friend

of intimate 1236. Aversion to certain persons

9a) Sensitive to certain persons

7837. Aversion to strangers 9a) Company aversion to pres-

ence of strangers 1238. Bad news ailments from 9a) Excitement after bad news 40b) Sadness after bad news 76c) Trembling in ear after sad

news 319d) Sinking in the stomach from

bad news 526e) Sensitiveness in stomach

from bad news 526f) Diarrhoea after bad news 611g) Trembling hands after

unpleasant news 1212h) Sleepiness after sad news

1251i) Chilliness after sad new 1270j) Perspiration from unpleasant

news 1298k) Organs of blood from dis-

agreeable news 137739. Bashful 9a) a) Timidity 88b) Cowardice 17



General Section

c) Cautious 10d) Startled easily 83e) Reserved 72f) Frighted easily 49g) Embarrassed 39h) Gentleness 50i) Repulsive 71j) Low minded 63k) Secretive 78l) Mildness 6540. Bed aversion to 9a) Timidity going about to bed

89b) Fear to go to sleep 47c) Fear of the bed 43d) All waking on of something

under the bed 4741. Bemoaning 9a) a) Lamenting 61b) Complaining 12c) Weeping 92d) Whining 9542. Benumbed 09a) a) Stupefaction 84b) Cloudiness 12c) Confusion 13d) Confounding 13e) Bewildered 09f) Drunken seems as if 3743. Break things desire to 10a) Destructiveness 3644. Brooding 10a) b) Anxiety 04c) Sadness 75d) Gloomy 50e) Despondency 36f) Grief 50g) Gnawing 51h) Melancholy 64i) Despair 35j) Dejection 18k) Moaning 67l) Howling 5245. Businesses averse to 10

a) Indifferences to businessafter 54

46. Busy - Refer to no 547. Calmness 10a) a) Tranquility 89b) Quite disposition 70c) Talk indisposed to 8648. Calumniate - Refer to no 449. Capriciousness 10a) a) Persists in nothing 69b) Impulsive 54c) Rashness 71d) Inconstancy 54e) Mood alternating 67f) Mood changeable, variable

68g) Refuses thing asked for 71h) Fickle 48i) Irresolute 57j) Fitful 48k) Frivolous 50l) Appetite capricious 476m) Longing for things which are

rejected when offered 63n) Whimsical 9550. Carelessness 10a) Heedless 51b) Rashness 7151. Cares full of 10a) Anxiety 452. Carphologia 10a. Gestures picks at bed clothes

5053. Censorious 17a) Faultfinding 42b) Reproaches others 71c) Quarrelsome 70d) Critical 1754. Chagrin 10a) Mortification 6855. Chaotic 10a. Confounding 13b. Confusion 13c. Cloudiness 12

56. Cheerfulness 10a) Mirth 65b) Gaiety 50c) Vivacious 91d) Lively 62e) Jesting 60f) Humorous 52g) Joyous 60h) Contended 16i) Laughing 61j) Hilarity 51k) Exhilaration 4157. Circumspection lack of 11a) Indiscretion 5558. Clairvoyance 11a) Prophesying 69b) Dreams clairvoyant 1237c) Dreams of event not yet

taken place 1239d) Dreams prophetic 1242e) Dreams visionary 124459 Company aversion for 12a) Wants to walk alone 1260. Company desire for 12a) Anxiety when alone 561. Confidence want of self 13a) Delusion fails thing will 25b) Delusion does nothing right

31c) Delusion reproach, has

neglected duty and deserves31

d) Delusion that he does everything wrong and will notsucceed 33

e) Fears losing self control 47f) Fears undertaking anything

47g) Undertaken nothing lost he

will fail 9162. Confusion beer from 14a) Confusion spirit ion by near

from 1563. Confusion cold bath amel 14



Dr SATISH P KANOJIA

General Section

a) Confusion washing face amel16

64. Confusion identity as to his15

a) Delusion density errors ofpersonal 27

b) Forgetful name his own 4965. Confusion interruption

from 15a) Thoughts vanishing when

interrupted 8866. Contradict disposition to –

refer No 5267. Contrary 16a) Obstinate 69b) Irrittable 57c) Positiveness 69d) Defiant 17e) Disobedience 3768. Conversation agg 16a) Calking of others agg 86b) Confusion agg by confusion

1469. Cosmopolitan 17a) Travel desire to 8970. Crazy 17a) Insanity 56b) Delusion 2072. Cruelty 17a) Moral feeling want of 68b) Malicious 63c) Hard hearted 51d) Misanthropy 66e) Hatred 51f) Vindictive 91g) Resentment 71h) Revengeful 75i) Unfeeling 9172. Darkness agg 17a) Fear dark 4374. Death desire to 17a) Loathing of life 61b) Killed denser to be 61c) Weary of life 92

d) Ennui 39e) Disgustful 37f) Irksome 5775. Deceitful 17a) Duplicity 3676. Despair recovery of 36a) Doubtful recovery of 37b) Hopeless 52c) Sadness 7577. Dictatorial 36a) Domineering 37b) Stubborn 84c) Obstinate 69d) Dramatic 3778. Discontented 36a) Displaced 37b) Dissatisfied 3779. Dread 37a) Fear 4280. Dream as if in a 37a) Confusion 14b) Fancies absorbed in 41c) Unconsciousness, dream as

in 9080. Earnestness 39a) Serious 7981. Egotism 39a) a) Haughty 51b) Imperious 54c) Pride 6982. Eat refuses to 39a) Aversion to food 48183. Embraces comparison 39a) Kisses everyone 6184. Entertainment 39a) Amusement desire of 2b) Excitement 40c) Occupation 6985. Envy 39a) Jealous 6086. Escape, attempts to 39a) Runs about 75b) Impulse to run 5487. Estranged, family from her

39a) Escapes from her family 39b) Aversion to husband 9c) Indifferences to loved ones 55d) Flies from her own children

39e) Forsakes his own children 4988. Excitement conversation

from 40a) Talking excited 86b) Excitement debate during 40c) Excitement anticipating

events 4089. Exclamation 41a) Shrieking 7990. Exercise, mental symptoms

> by physical 41a) Exertion amel 135891. Fanaticism 41a) Religious fanaticism 7192. Fastidious 42a) Rest cannot when thing are

not in proper place 7293. Fear, disaster of 44a) Fear of impending danger 43b) Fear evil of 44c) Fear something will happen

45d) Fear misfortune of 4694. Fear of impending disease

44a) Fear of pneumonia 46b) Fear of cancer 43c) Fears consumption of 43d) Fear body will putrefy 4795. Fixed notions 48a) Delusions 2096. Flattery desires 48a) Longing for good opinion 6397. Fidgety 48a) Restlessness 7298. Fight, wants to 48a) Quarrelsome 7099. Forgetful 48



General Section

a) Memory weakness of 64b) Mistakes 66100. Forgetful well known street

49a) Forgetful which side of the

streat his house was on 49b) Recognize does not well

streets 71c) Confusion loosen his way in

well known streets 15d) Mistakes localities 66101. Forebodings 48a) Fear 42b) Anxiety 4c) Sadness 75102. Frantic 49a) Rage 70b) Fury 50103. Frown disposed to 50a) Wrinkled forehead 396104. Gestures hands motion

involuntary 5a) Motion hand 1034105. Gestures grasping genitals

at, during spasms 50a) Handles genitals 17106. Gestures usual vocation of

his 50a) Counting continually 17107. Grimaces 51a) Expression pinched 374108. Growling like a dog 51a) Barking 9109. Hastiness 51a. Hurry 52b. Impatience 53c. Impetuous 54d. Quick to act 70110. Hide, child thinks all

visitors laugh at and hidesbehind furniture 51

a) Fear of people in children 46111. High place agg 51a) Fear of high place 45

112. Home desire to go 51a) Home sickness 51113. Humour, effects of

wounded 52a) Indignation bed effect

following 55b) Mortification to 79114. Horror 52a) Anxiety 4b) Fear 42115. Ideas abundant clearness of

mind 52a) Thoughts puissant 87116. Indifference 54a) Listless 62b) Joyless 60c) Phlegmatic 69117. Impertinence 54a) Insolent 57b) Rudeness 75118. Indifference while in

company 54a) Indifference relation to 55b) Indifference society in 55119. Insanity 56a) Mania 63b) Rage 70c) Delirium 18d) Frantic 41e) Fury 50120. Irritability questioned

when 59a) Irritability spoken to when 59121. Irrability 57a) Irascibility 57b) Anger 2c) Quarrelsome 70d) Fight wants to 48e) Petulant 69122. Kill desire to the person

who contradicts her 60a) Contradiction, has to restrain

himself to keep from violence16

123. Kneeling and praying 61a) Religious affection 71124. Loquacity 63b) Speech wandering 82c) Talk denre to 86d) Talkative 86e) Loquacity sleep during 63125. Mental effort inability to

sustain 65a) Prostration of mind 70b) Senses dullness of 65126. Mesmerised 65a) Magnetised desires to be 63127. Mischievous 66a) Rage mischievous 71b) Wicked disposition 95c) Insanity malignant 57d) Joy at misfortune of other 60128. Mistakes speeches 66a) Forgetful word of while

speaking 49129. Muttering 68a) Delirium matting 19130. Narrating her symptoms

agg 68a) Conversation agg 16b) Talking agg 86c) Weeping when talking of her

sickness 94131. Offended easily 69a) Sensitive 78b) Oversensitive 69132. Refuses to take medicine 71a) Fear of taking too much

medicine 46b) Well says when he is sick 95c) Irritability sends the doctor

home 59133. Reproaches himself 71a) Anger over his mistakes 2b) Delusion neglected his duty

30c) Delusion does nothing right

31



Dr SATISH P KANOJIA

General Section

d) Delusion fancies he has donewrong 35

134. Ridiculous mania 75a) Jesting 60b) Mocking 61c) Unfriendly humors 91135. Reverence lack of 75a) Rudeness 75136. Sadness cloudy whether 76a) Sadness darkness 76137. Sensitive to fight 78a) Shuns light 62b) Photophobia 261138. Sensitive to music 78a) Delusion, music, fancies he

hears 29b) Excitement music form 41c) Fear music form 46d) Hysteria music amel 52e) Indifference music which he

love to 55f) Irritability music during 59g) Restlesseness music form 74h) Sadness music from, sad

music amel 77i) Thoughts persistent, music

about in evening 87j) Unconscious music from 90k) Weeping music form 94l) Weeping music bells of 94m) Weeping music piano 94139. Sexual excess mental

symptoms from 79

a) Thoughts intrude sexual 87140. Shining objects agg 79a) Rage shining object from 71141. Sighing respiration 80a) Desire to breath deep 766b) Sighing respiration‘775142. Sits quiet still and break

pins 81a) Insanity break pins, she will

sit and 56143. Size incorrect judge of 81a) Delusion being double 24b) Delusion small thing appear

32c) Smaller, things appear 81d) Vision, small object seem 283144. Smiling sardonic 81a) Laughing sardonic 283145. Speech monosyllabic 82a) Answers monosyllabic 3b) ‘No’ to all questions 3146. Starting electric as if 83a) Electric current sensation of

985147. Talks with dead people 87a) Delusion converses with

absent person 30b) Delusion talking with dead

people 33148. Unconscious blood sight of

90a) Faintness blood sight of 1359

149. Unconscious convulsionafter 90

a) Unconscious epilepsy after 90150. Unreal everything seems 91a) Delusion everything is

strange 33151. Weeping consolation agg

93a) Consolation agg 16b) Weeping pitied if he believes

he is 94152. Well, says he when very

sick 95a) Cheerful with all pains 11b) Hopeful 52153. Work aversion to mental 95a) Thinking aversion to 87Source: the following books were

taken help of:a) Repertory of the

homoeopathic MateriaMedica with word index – DrJ T Kent

b) Kent’s Comparative Reper-tory of the Hom MateriaMedica – Dr Koklenberg andDr Dockx

c) Encyclopedia of reporto-rial – Dr J Benedict Castro

NOTE: The number in font of therubric demonstrates the pagenumber of which it is fond inKent’s repertory

ADVERTISMENT INDEX

J k cement Back Cover

R M Bhutler Inside Back Cover

Hiranandani Inside Front Cover


29

Philosophy

Towards EnlightenmentABSTRACT: India has provided “The Man of the Millennium” and now it is the duty of theNation to promote and prepare another Man of the Millennium. I am sure that peopleof India will continue the tradition. India has great heritage of philosophy and due tothis it is possible to prepare good human beings.

Dr AMRAPALI MERCHANT MA LLB PHDAwarded: Dr Radhakrishanan National Award for Higher Education”,.“Gyandeep Puraskar” International Award by YashvantraoChavhan Maharashtra Open University, Nasik, Award for Women Services by Young Men’s Gandhian Association. Ahmedabad,Gujarat. Has Penned 21 Books.Professor and Head, Dept of Sociology, Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar. Gujarat.Mail: [email protected]. Mobile: 9909254550

Editor: Why is this topic relevant for our First StudentEdition NJH? Good human beings make best doctors.So our aim should be to travel that path right from ourinception in Homoeopathic field. We requested DrAmrapali, a renowed spiritual teacher to write a briefword on how a Homoeopath should conduct and de-velop himself.The Human life is “Amulya (invaluable)”. A Medi-cal doctor is considered as second to God. Home-opathy is the godly way of treatment and you allare also second to God for your patients. You arethe future of India and the world. Homeopathicmedicines are a blessing for humanity-being af-fordable, effective and curing the patient in theshortest time. I believe that if Homoeopaths takeefforts to spread awareness, Homeopathy will bethe most preferred choice of treatment.Let us think, what is life? From where we come?Where do we go? I consider that life is gifted byGOD to achieve ENLIGHTENMENT. The philoso-phy of the India says that human life is just toachieve Moksha (to be free from all attachments).The era of 21st century is “knowledge” based. Knowl-edge has stages and man can conquer those stagesone by one and reach to the highest stage. The free-dom from “Janam (birth)” is the wish of every Hindu.Hindu culture has stated four objectives of life:Dharm, Arth, Kam, and Moksha. Jainism is the an-cient religion of India which has Moksha as the high-est Goal of life. To achieve Moksha, one has to passthrough various stages of knowledge. Man has towalk through following stages:

1 Information 2 Understanding3 Analysis 4 Synthesis5 Creativity 6 Innovation7 Empowerment 8 Enlightenment9 Towards Moksha

Do we learn this in our life? Is it through educativesystem or through any systematic way? If not,Where we have lost our ancient wisdom? Let usdiscuss these stages in detail how one can achieveall the stages in a short life.Actual life of a human being is just about 25 years.If man lives 70 years, first ten years are just investedin playing and at the end of life about 5 years withDoctor, so 70 -15 = 55 years. We sleep for 27.5 years,and we invest at least 5 years in eating and doingpersonal work. Now if we are going to live onlyabout 27 years than we have to live carefully. Mydear friends, this is not just philosophy but it istruth. Let us think that if life is so small than everyOne has to plan it carefully.1. MAN STARTS LEARNING WITH INFORMATION- the fac-tual meaning of the visual thing. Information helpsman to understand the physical world and theworldly matters. Man learns about physical, socialand emotional world. Information teaches use,making and processing things.2. UNDERSTANDING: Gives the real meaning the in-ner meaning of worldly things and its analysis. Per-son always thinks with his own perception, sur-rounding and reference. Analysis helps person tosynthesis and understand the situation.

Towards EnlightenmentDr AMRAPALI MERCHANT


30

Report

3. CREATIVITY: Only after full understanding in totothan creativity starts. This step is very important.. Cre-ativity is better known as innovation -the person’sIDENTITY, a reflection of his personality.4. EMPOWERMENT: Comes out of hard work, excel-lence, brightness, smartness and achievement. Thisstage leads to the Goal of life and towards Enlight-enment.5. ENLIGHTENMENT: The highest stage of humanbeing. “Realized SOUL”. Enlightenment will eas-ily take the human to ULTIMATE GOAL of life- toachieve God.,to travel to Moksha. To walk on thispath, one has to develop eight dimensions givenbelow:1) Development of Health2) Mental Development3) Social Development4) Economic Development5) Civic Development6) Cultural Developments7) Ethical Development8) Spiritual Development

a. Self directedb. Self managedc. Self motivatedd. Self controlled

The main isDEVELOPMENT OF HEALTH: To perform optimally, Manneeds balanced health-both physical and mental,needs to develop a habit to take care of him/her health,so vital for his growth. Well being of body is consid-ered as first happiness. Well being is based on goodfood habits, lifestyle.and Yoga. Here is where the im-portance of Homoeopathy as a preventive medicalscience play an important role.This along with development of all other 7 devel-opments will allow us to travel towards Excellency.Now we can see the importance of Health and itsmanagement in our overall development.Doctors are the best human being in the world be-cause they treat patients. When patients visit you,they are unhappy, but when you treat them, theygo with happiness. It is a short journey for doctorstowards enlightenment which will take doctors to-wards excellence. ☯

REPORTED BY

Dr KURAIN P J POST GRADUATE STUDENT (REPERTORY)Fr Muller Homoeopathic Medical College. Deralakatte.

A Workshop on Repertory - A Report

A workshop on Repertory for PG student was heldon June 8th and 9th 2007 at Fr Muller HomoeopathicMedical College, Deralakatte. The workshop, firstof its kind in South India was conducted by Deptof Repertory of Fr Muller’s, attended by 70 delegatesfrom various institutions.The workshop was inaugurated by Director Rev FrDr Baptist Menazes followed by a brief introduc-tion, of PG syllabus for Repertory.THE FIRST DAY SPEAKER- Prof Dr S K TIWARI: Dis-cussed the Basic Repertories by Boenninghausen,Boger and Kent.THE SECOND DAY

1. Prof Dr VALAMATHY R FERNANDEZ discussed Syn-thesis 9. 1.

2. Significant features of latest edition of Murphy’sRepertory were elaborated by Prof Dr RITA

CHAKRABORTHY

3. Computer Software Programmes in Repertoryby Dr KURIAN P J.

4. Elaborate exposition of Modern Repertories byProf Dr S K TIWARI.

5. An active discussion followed.6. At the end of the sessions, the representatives

of each institution expressed their views andalso expressed gratitude for the stinulation ses-sions. All the delegates were awarded partici-pation certificates by Rev Fr Stany Tauro in ashort valedictory function. ☯

A Workshop on Repertory - A ReportDr KURAIN P J


31

Q & A

PROF DR KASIM CHIMTHANAWALA MBBS, LTMANDH, DDV, DMS, FPT, FNAHI, PGNAHIPresident: The National Academy Of Homoeopathy, IndiaDirector: Postgraduate Advanced School Of HomoeopathyShaad Hospital Complex And Research Centre, Near Itwari Railway Station, Nagpur -2Ph: 0712-2766286, 2522563, 2532008, 9822240648 Email: [email protected]

Queries and Solutions

Q1: Have there been any clinical trials of comparingAllopathy and Homoeopathy in any area of medicine?

Dr AMIT NIMBHORKAR, AMRAVATI.ANS: There have been a few authentic studies publishedin journals on a comparative study of homoeopathywith conventional system of medicine. Some of themare- International Journal of Clinical PharmacologicalTherapy in 1997, (35:296-301) reported a study doneby Drs K Friese, F Kruse, R Ludtke and Moller on “Thehomoeopathic treatment of Otitis Media in children –comparisons with conventional therapy.” Anotherstudy is reported by Dr Trichard, Dr Chaufferin andDr Nicoloyannis in the 2005 issue of Homoeopathy (94:3-9) entitled “Pharmacoeconomic comparison betweenhomoeopathic and antibiotic treatment strategies in re-current Rhinopharyngitis in children.” A good articlewas reported in a journal “Wien Klin Wochenschr”2005 (117:256-268) by Hamre et al on “Anthroposophicversus conventional therapy of acute respiratory andear infections: a prospective outcomes study.”The jour-nal of Alternative Complementary Medicine publishedan article in 2001 (7:149-159) entitled “Homoeopathyand Conventional medicine – an outcome study com-paring effectiveness in a primary care setting” by DrsRiley Day and Fischer. The journal, Clinical Experi-ences in Rheumatology also reported an in-depth studydone by Professor G S Breuer and Dr Orbach in 2005(23: 693-696), on “perceived efficacy among patientsof various methods of complementary alternativemedicine for rheumatologic diseases.” Another Ger-man study carried out by Drs Bensoussan, Jovenin andteam on “Complementary and Alternative Medicineuse by patients with Inflammatory Bowel Disease: re-sults from a postal survey.”It was reported in the Jour-nal of Gastrointestinal Clinical biology -2006 (30: 14-23). Lancet in 2005 (366: 726-732) itself reported an ar-ticle on “Are the clinical effects of homoeopathy pla-cebo effects? Comparative study of placebo–controlledtrials of homoeopathy and allopathy.” Many morecomparative studies are still going on the globe over.

Q2: “An apple a day, keeps the doctor away!” Can youjustify this statement?

Dr SHILPA GULHANE, NAGPUR.ANS: Well, I think when this idiom was coined, it musthave been presumed that an Apple contained all thenutrients and vitamins required for a healthy living.Unfortunately nowadays all fruits / foods are hybridand have lost their original nutrient value at the ex-pense of high yield. As far as apple is concerned, itcomes in all shades of red, green and yellow. Applesare free of fat, sodium and cholesterol. Theycontain flavenoids in high proportions that have anti-cancer properties. 25% apple’s volume is air, 25% wa-ter - hence they may combat Obesity as well. The Ironcontent is high, useful for anaemic patients. Eating awhole apple is more nutritious than drinking applejuice. The apple peel contains high amount of fibre,vitamins and minerals. They are “Nature’s Tooth-brush” help clean the teeth and massage the gums. Itwas the falling of an apple that prompted Newton toenunciate the Law of Gravity. And finally mankindstarted when Adam and Eve sinned by eating the for-bidden apple in the Garden of Eden.Q3: Sir, What do you think about the use of ComputerProgrammes for repertorizing new cases?

Dr SANJAY CHANDRAKAR, RAIPUR.ANS: Most computer programs available today aremere compilations of rubrics from different reperto-ries and literatures. One fact is overlooked that everyauthor has his or her own conceptions regarding theterms used as rubrics. For example, in Boericke’s Rep-ertory, “worry” and “restlessness” are synonymous.Where as in Kent’s Repertory, “anxiety” connotesworry and “nervousness” and restlessness are same.More-over, at number of places, the same rubric hasdifferent drugs in different grades. Hence my opinionis to adapt yourself with book repertorization in ini-tial period of practice and keep the computer programsfor later as they are benefecial for keynote prescrip-tions, rare symptoms, etc. ☯

Queries and SolutionsPROF DR KASIM CHIMTHANAWALA


32

Date ___________________ S U B S C R I P T I O N F O R M

New SubscriptionRenewal of Subscription Quote Subscription No. __________Name: First Father’s /Husband’s Surname__________________________________________________________

Address: ___________________________________________________City: ____________ State: ________________ Pin: _______________Telephone: _______ Fax: ________ E-mail: ______________________Qualifications: _________________ Mobile No.: __________________Year began practice: ___________________ Signature: ______Cash/MO/DD or Postal Order (PO) No ___________ For Rs / $_______

(Favouring National Journal of Homoeopathy;DATED __________ DRAWN ON __________________________________

India: PNB Bank Ac No. 1281000100060357 (Add Bank Charges Rs 30/- extra) Foreign: ANZ Standard Chartered Ac No.: 23705004540 (Add Bank Charges at your end)

Oustation cheques addRs 75/- bank charges)

Mail to: NJH C/o Milan Polyclinic, 71/B, Saraswati Road, Santacruz (W), Mumbai 400 054, Tel:26042749/26492762 Fax: 24332131

Subsciption FormDETAILS OF ISSUES

SUBSCRIPTION RATES

CCCCCURRENTURRENTURRENTURRENTURRENT I I I I ISSUESSSUESSSUESSSUESSSUES OOOOOLDLDLDLDLD ISSUESISSUESISSUESISSUESISSUES

1 Yr 3 yrs PER 1Yr EACH10 Yrs

06/07 07-09 96/97/98 1999-04 1996-2006! ! ! ! !

INDIA (Rs.) 275/- 750 150 225 1900*FOREIGN US $+ 30 80 25 30 260Australia A$ 41.5+10# 125+30# 35+10# 35+10# 390+00#

SAARC US$ 25 70 25 225SINGLE Xerox Issue US$ 6 / Rs 80/- eachLIFE SUBSCRIPTION:(Allows 40% rebate on NJH Bks etc)Rs. 6000/- $ 550 / A$ 775Rs. 4000/- $ 375 (students & above 65 years)* Postage in India of Rs 350/- Extra+Includes Registered post to USA#Local posting charges. We courier direct to Dr Ann Tacey

BoundVols

1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 19981. *The Mind *Dreams *Schizophrenia *Asthma Hypertension Depression *Behavioural Disorders2. *Paediatric Mind *Leucoderma * Warts *Neurosis Epilepsy Magnesium Eye3. *GI Tract *Liver * Kidney *Cancer Ear Teeth Diabetes4. *Ophidia Group *Spider * Fish *Psoriasis Impotence PMS Precious Metals5. *Ooh Aaah Ouch * Emergency *Malaria *Acid Group Ferrum Group Rheumatology DUB6. *When is old, old * Rare Remedies *Menopause *Hair & Nails An approach Repertory Keynote Prescribing

to a case

* Issues exhausted Only Xerox copies at Rs 80/$ 6 each B Vol Rs 150/- $25/yr

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 20061. Anxiety *Acid *Potency II *Ferrum Mercury Medorr Psycho-Sexual Case Recieving2. Athritis *OCN *Kali Group *Stress Male Infertility IBS Sycotic Miasm Carcinosin3. Pregnancy *Tuberculosis-I *Jaundice *Tub Miasm Mixed Bag ENT Investigations Carcinosin II4. Natrum Group *Colo-rectal dis *Anaemia *IHD Degenerative Jt Dis ENT II Backache Hering’s Law5. Respiratory Allergies *Tuberculosis-II *HIV/AIDS *Trauma I Diseases of Veins Fevers Plant Kingdom Common EyeDisorders

6. Philosophy: Aph 1+2 *Potency *Uterine Tumours *Trauma II Diseases of Brain Allergy Mixed Pool Coma

Bound Vol Rs 200/- $ 25/year Bound Vol Rs 225/- $30/year Bound Vol Rs 275/- $30/ year Single issue Rs. 45/- $6 each* Xerox copies for Rs 60/ $6 each

1996/97/98/99/00/01/02/03/04/05/06 Bound volumes: All 11 yrs for Rs 1900/- only. (+Postage Extra 400/) 1996/97/98/99/00/01/02/03/04/05/06 Bound volumes: All 11 yrs for US $ 260 only. (including postage)

NJH Issues so far...

Issues for 2007 Issue Editor LAST DATE FOR ARTICLES DATE OF RELEASE(1 MONTH BEFORE DATE OF RELEASE)

Feb’07 ADHD Dr Bhavini Mehta 10.04.2007Apr’07 Noble Metals Dr Vishpala Parthasarathy 20.05.2007Jun’07 Repertory Dr Sushma Jaiswal 25.07.2007July 07 Repertory Stu Dr Krutik Shah 16.08.2007Aug’07 Constitutional Prescribing Dr Rashmi Nagar 15.09.2007Sept 07 Practical Application of Organon Stu Dr Jagose 15.10.2007Oct’07 Interview Techniques1 Dr Satish Kanojia 15.11.2007Nov 07 Homoeopaths to Allopaths? Stu Dr Vaishali Bhagat 15.12.2007Dec’07 Dementia Dr C H Asrani 25.01.2008

yes! i am proud to be a homoeopath. - final may not be used, if pgs of issue exceed limit of ......

Documents