yala swamp complex, kenya - birdlife | partnership for ... · web viewthis study was done at yala...

YALA SWAMP COMPLEX, KENYALEONARD AKWANY, ECOFINDER KENYA REVIEWED BY : JENNY MERRIMAN , ROSIE TREVELYAN

PRELIMINARY WORK

This study was done at Yala wetland in Kenya, located on the north-eastern shoreline of Lake Victoria (between 00° 02’S and 34° 1E, 34° 7S) and an altitude of 1150m above sea level. Yala wetland covers 17,500 ha and is comprised of three freshwater satellite lakes (Kanyaboli, Sare and Namboyo). Lake Kanyaboli was gazetted on September 2010 as a national reserve and covers an area of 41.42 Km2. There are also a small park, a private farm and scattered homesteads in the area. The land tenure system is a combination of trust land and private land.

Figure 1. Yala wetland location, Source: Ecofinder Kenya (2014)

Suggested citation: Akwany, L. (2015) YALA SWAMP COMPLEX, KENYA. Accepted TESSA case study. Available at [http://www.birdlife.org/worldwide/science/assessing-ecosystem-services-tessa]

Figure 2. Yala wetland land context, Source: Ecofinder Kenya (2014)

The habitat in the area includes papyrus plants in the swamp, planted and cultivated goods, three freshwater lakes, and a mixture of settlements and vegetation.


Figure 3. Yala wetland habitat, Source: Ecofinder Kenya (2014)


RAPID APPRAISAL

The rapid appraisal assisted in the identification of key ecosystem services relevant to the current state and also helped to identify Lake Kanyaboli National Reserve as representative of the alternative state. The stakeholders consulted included representatives from the local community, county government and national government officials, members from NGOs, CSOs and research institutions. The Yala wetland is an Important Bird and Biodiversity Area and supports the livelihoods of many people who directly or indirectly depend on the ecosystem services provided in this area. The ecosystem services provided by the wetland are global climate regulation, water-related services, harvested wild goods, cultivated goods, nature-based recreation. Other ecosystem services that were identified by the rapid appraisal that TESSA could not measure were ceremonial and spiritual services, cultural and Indigenous Knowledge services, and flooding control services.

IDENTIFYING PLAUSIBLE ALTERNATIVE STATE

The alternative state was a vision of a better managed Yala wetland, with the Lake Kanyaboli National Reserve selected as the comparison site to provide representative data. Lake Kanyaboli provides important ecosystem services such as water provision, crop production, fish harvesting, wild goods, fire wood, recreational services and global climate regulation (carbon storage). The direct beneficiaries from these services are the local community - farmers, fish traders, papyrus harvesters and tour guides. The local government benefits from the revenue collection from tourism and trade. The Kenya Wildlife Service in collaboration with the Siaya and Busia county governments are currently working on enhancing the sustainable use of resources in the area in order to improve conservation practices while also looking after the socio-economic well-being of the local community.


Figure 4. Lake Kanyaboli National Reserve, Kenya. Source: Leonard Akwany, Ecofinder (2014)

The main challenge of identifying the alternative state was the establishment of boundaries because the comparison site was located within the Yala Wetland Complex. The two sites were under different management regimes; one of commercial agriculture and one of conservation and local smallholder farming. However, determining the boundaries of the commercial agriculture section was not clear and we had to rely on our observations to conduct the assessment.

METHODS SELECTION

The services assessed were harvested wild goods and cultivated goods through surveys that were distributed in sixteen villages within the area of study. Three hundred questionnaires were distributed and two hundred and sixty-nine were collected and used for analysis.

ANALYSIS AND COMMUNICATION

Wild goods are harvested to clear land for crop production. Harvesters use the fodder and papyrus collected to make mats, thatch their homes and make furniture. Thus, harvesting of wild goods (fodder and papyrus) is higher in the current state than the alternative state. Satellite studies of papyrus land cover in the region have shown that the coverage of natural papyrus has reduced by over 50% (Owino & Ryan, 2007)1, which suggests that the rate of harvest under the current state is unsustainable.

a. Harvested wild goods

1 Owino, A.O. & Ryan, P.G. (2007) Recent papyrus swamp habitat loss and conservation implications in western Kenya Wetlands Ecology and Management 15 (1), 1-12


Fodder Papyrus Fodder Papyrus0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

current state alternative state

Figure 5. Average wild goods harvested per day per household (in kg)

It was interesting to find that the costs of labour for harvesting wild goods are higher than the actual revenue from these goods. The net value of wild harvested goods is negative as show on figure 6 below. This finding could be partly explained by cultural reasons - this is a traditional activity that people have always done, or perhaps there are no other alternatives.


Fodder Papyrus Fodder Papyrus

-5000

-4500

-4000

-3500

-3000

-2500

-2000

-1500

-1000

-500

0current state alternative state

Figure 6. Annual net value of harvested wild goods per household (in KSh)

There is higher net value in the current state for cultivated goods (figure 7). However, there are negative values in the current state that relate to the high costs of hiring labour to uproot the papyrus reeds, clear the land and guard farms from wild animals. There would be negative values in the alternative state as well, which would be related to the high labour and transport costs, and the low returns from cultivated goods (figure 8). The Yala wetland region is a fertile ground for crop production. However, the area needs to be better managed to enable sustainable food production.


Maize Millet BeansVegetables Maize Millet Beans0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

current state alternative state

Figure 7. Annual average quantity of cultivated crops per household (in kg)

Maize Millet Beans Vegetables Maize Millet Beans

-2000

-1000

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

Alternative State Current State

Figure 8. Annual net value of cultivated goods per household (in Ksh) Suggested citation: Akwany, L. (2015) YALA SWAMP COMPLEX, KENYA. Accepted TESSA case study. Available at [http://www.birdlife.org/worldwide/science/assessing-ecosystem-services-tessa]

The results from the assessment were shared with stakeholders in the programme launch, at forums and workshops. We also organised drama and puppetry presentations for grass-root communities and local user groups, and we are planning to share our final report in our website (www.ecofinderkenya.org). The target public included the local community (fish traders and farmers), county government representatives, national government representatives, NGOs and CSOs representatives, and member of staff from private companies.

TESSA facilitated the engagement of a variety of organizations on the issues facing the swamp and the ecosystem services provided. Advocacy messages were also developed to include Yala wetland complex in local development planning and budget allocation. We tapped on thematic issues generated from the assessment and successfully fundraised for two projects to be funded by PREPARED (USAID project) and the MACARTHUR Foundation. We also tapped on nature-based recreation services by training naturalists as tourist guides to provide lessons on basic swamp ecology and history.

USEFUL ADVICE FOR NEW TESSA USERS

Effective engagement of stakeholders is paramount for the work to be useful Familiarize yourself with the toolkit through preliminary training and field

testing Use community service and volunteers to reduce the costs of implementing

the toolkit


yala swamp complex, kenya - birdlife | partnership for ... · web viewthis study was done at yala...

Documents