wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

10
1 Comparison of EDTA Chelation, Angioplasty and Bypass Surgery

Upload: bhalchandra-1946

Post on 14-Jul-2015

50 views

Category:

Healthcare


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

1

Comparison of EDTA Chelation,Angioplasty and Bypass Surgery

Page 2: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

2

Cardiologists and cardiac surgeons invariably recommend either angioplasty or bypass surgery to patients suffering from coronary artery disease. Almost all diabetologists do not attempt to save the gangrenous leg. They give heinous advise of leg amputation.

As said earlier the objective of most of the so called experts trained in modern medicine is to push up the profit of hospitals and pharmaceutical companies and manufacturers of medical instruments through rampant recommendations of surgical procedures. As EDTA chelation therapy does not achieve any of these objectives they do not recommend it even if it is the best treatment to reverse the disease.

The truth behind this becomes apparent from the comparison of death and adverse events in these treatments presented in the forthcoming slides. The conclusions of the recently concluded TACT, a 10 year long research project, is that chelation therapy is very safe and unbelievably effective.

Page 3: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

3

Chelation therapy is a boon to diabetic patients suffering from coronary artery disease. Of course, organizations like American Medical Association and American Heart Association endeavor best efforts to ensure that such information does not reach public.

These organization made herculean efforts in hiding the results of TACT by opposing their publication in JAMA, AHJ etc.

The information about angioplasty and bypass surgery given in the comparison presented in the forthcoming slides, is taken from following two books published by Wiley in the year 2003.

"So, You Are Having Heart Cath and Angioplasty" by Magnus Ohman - a cardiologist and

“So, You Are Having Heart Bypass Surgery” by Bret Sheldon a cardiac surgeon.

Information about chelation therapy has been taken from many different sources.

Page 4: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

4

Likelihood of following occurrences Bypass Surgery

Angio-plasty

Chelation Therapy

Death in low risk patients 1 - 3.0% 0.5 -1.4% Near NilIncidence of heart attack 3 - 5% 1 - 3% Near NilIncidence of stroke 1 - 2% 0.5% Near NilWorsening of kidney disease 16% 10 -20% Near NilStart of kidney impairment 1% 1 - 5% Near NilStart of arrhythmia 20 - 30% 1 - 2% 0.005%Need for blood transfusion >10% 0.5% Near NilSerious blood hemorrhage 0.5% 0.05% Near NilAllergy to the drugs infused in body 0.01% 0.5% 0.001%Permanantly high blood pressure 20 - 30% Near Nil Near NilAbdominal ulcers or gastritis 0.5 -3% 0.1% 0.05%Fluid accumulation in heart/lungs 3 - 4% Near Nil Near NilInfection in chest wounds <1% <0.1% <0.01% Other types of infection 4 -6% Near Nil Near NilUlcers within arteries by catheter Near Nil 0.4% Near NilNeed to revert to other treatment Near Nil 0.2 -3% Near NilAlzheimer dementia in three years 1 - 25% Near Nil CuresRecurrence of angina in one year 4 -8% 15 -30% 10 -15%

Page 5: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

5

The comparison presented in this slide proves EDTA chelation therapy to be superior to other two modalities.

It is superior to angioplasty on 15 out of 18 criteria. Only on three criteria angioplasty is equally good as EDTA chelation therapy.

It is superior to bypass surgery on 16 out of 18 criteria. On one criteria both are equally good.

Only on criteria, viz."Recurrence of angina in one year" bypass surgery is found to be superior to chelation therapy and far superior to angioplasty.

The reason for this fact can be explained as under.

When signals of angina are generated in the heart they are felt only when they get transmitted through nerves up to the brain. All such nerves pass through pericardium. In bypass surgery pericardium has to be heavily cut in order to reach heart. Naturally, nerves also get cut and pain vanishes.

Page 6: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

6

Even though pericardium is stitched back at the end of surgery, the nerves remain in discontinuity and pain remains vanished.

This means bypass surgery creates pseudo effect. Actually it is not very effective to the extent it is believed to be.Likelihood of following occurrences Bypass

SurgeryAngio-plasty

Chelation Therapy

More useful than other two therapies 6 - 10% 3 - 5% 85 - 91%Need for medicines due to minor side effects

High Very High

Nearly Nil

Approximate expenses for the treatment in Rs.

About 500000

About 300000

About 85000

Treatment repitition after how many years?

5 years 3 years 5 years

Yearly expenses for medicines in Rs 8000 12000 18000Total yearly expenses 108000 112000 35000Does it treat the cause of coronary artery disease?

No No Certainly

Does it reverses other degenerative diseases present in the body?

No No Many diseases

Page 7: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

7

The table in the previous slide compares the three modalities on some more criteria.

On these criteria also EDTA chelation therapy proves superior.

With the towering high costs of medical treatments, particularly surgeries, one has to think of yearly cost for the treatment alternative chosen. On this criteria EDTA chelation therapy proves far superior because its cost is only about one third than the other two alternatives.

Other two important criteria of comparison are, Does the therapy treat the cause of coronary artery disease? and Does it reverses other degenerative diseases present in the body?

Bypass surgery or angioplasty do neither of these two things but chelation therapy effectively does both these things.

I recommend chelation therapy to all the patients because it works curatively and preventatively.

Page 8: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

8

In the year 2005, R. Blaha, T. Born and T. Chappell made a 3 year follow up of the health condition of 220 patients who underwent chelation therapy during year 1992 to 2001. Later they compared the data with the condition of about equal number of patients who had similar diagnosis before the treatment but had chosen either to remain only on medicines or underwent bypass surgery or underwent angioplasty.

The data obtained is presented in the following table.

Occurrence of Incidence in 3 years Only medicines

Angio-plasty

Bypass Surgery

Chelation Therapy

Heart attack or similar incidences 1.3% 7.3% 7.6% 0.0%Death caused by heart disease 1.3% 3.2% 4.0% 0.0%Need for angioplasty due to futility of the therapy

16.0% 22.3% 5.5% 0.9%

Need for bypass surgery due to futility of the therapy

4.4% 11.6% 1.2% 2.1%

Success rate =100-(R2+R3+R4) 77% 55.6% 81.7% 97%

Page 9: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

9

The data indicates,

1 Likelihood of heart attack greatly increases after angioplasty as well as bypass surgery in comparison to remaining only on medicines.

2 The only apparent blemish to EDTA chelation therapy is that turning to bypass surgery after it is little higher than that in case of bypass surgery. This happens because a surgeon usually does not recommend second bypass surgery within three years. However, a cardiologist is too eager to recommend bypass surgery or angioplasty after EDTA chelation therapy.

3 Even though much importance is not given to death caused by heart disease the success rates of chelation therapy is extensively high as compared to the other treatment modalities.

Thus from all the angles of comparison EDTA chelation therapy is far superior to either remaining on conventional medicines or undergoing angioplasty or undergoing bypass surgery.

Page 10: Wv8 2 comparison of edta ct, cabg, ptca (10)cvfp

9

The data indicates,

1 Likelihood of heart attack greatly increases after angioplasty as well as bypass surgery in comparison to remaining only on medicines.

2 The only apparent blemish to EDTA chelation therapy is that turning to bypass surgery after it is little higher than that in case of bypass surgery. This happens because a surgeon usually does not recommend second bypass surgery within three years. However, a cardiologist is too eager to recommend bypass surgery or angioplasty after EDTA chelation therapy.

3 Even though much importance is not given to death caused by heart disease the success rates of chelation therapy is extensively high as compared to the other treatment modalities.

Thus from all the angles of comparison EDTA chelation therapy is far superior to either remaining on conventional medicines or undergoing angioplasty or undergoing bypass surgery.