wpa educational programme on depressive disorders: depression in population groups part 5:...
TRANSCRIPT
WPA Educational Programme on Depressive Disorders: Depression in population groupsPart 5:
Prevention of Suicide; Issues for General PractitionersProf Danuta Wasserman
Dr Susanne Ringskog Vagnhammar
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association
Definitions of suicide
• Suicide is a deliberate, determined, self-inflicted and life-threatening act resulting in death
• Suicide attempt, or parasuicide, is a self-inflicted, self-destructive act with non-fatal outcome and which is aimed at realising changes which the subject desires
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 2
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 3
Classification of Suicide Behaviors: Steps in the Suicidal Process
• Suicidal ideas
• Suicidal gestures
• Medically less serious suicide attempts
• Medically serious suicide attempts
• Completed suicide
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 4
Increase in Suicides World-Wide
In the year 2000:
1 million people committed suicide
In the year 2020:
It is estimated that 1.53 million people will commit suicide
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 5
Suicide and Gender
• World-wide more men than women commit suicide
(with some exceptions, eg China)
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 6
Why do more men than women commit suicide?
• Men often use more violent suicide methods
• Depression in men often escape diagnosis and treatment (because of atypical symptoms)
• Men often have difficulties communicating and may not turn to medical care for help
• Men and women react differently to stress- men: ”fight-or-flight”, - women: ”tend-and-befriend”
• Difference in cultural values
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 7
The Stress Vulnerability Model (1)
• Suicidal behaviors:
Not an illness but a process that is influenced by many different risk factors
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 8
The Stress Vulnerability Model (2)
Suicidality is a function of several risk factors;
• Genetic predisposition• Mental ill-health• Somatic illness• Traumatic life events• Alcohol- or drug abuse• Difficult relationships• Socio-economic difficulties
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 9
The Stress Vulnerability Model (3)
The two most common risk factors for suicide:
• Loss of hope• Previous suicide attempt
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 10
Factors influencing the suicidal process
• Risk factors• Protective factors
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 11
Risk factors for suicide
• Loss of hope• Earlier suicide attempt• Mental disorders, especially depression• Alcohol/drug abuse• Genetic influence• Environmental (in its widest sense) influence• Violence, violation, Mental trauma ( bullying, neglect)• Losses, of all kinds (relationships, health, economy, culture/country etc)
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 12
Protective factors
• Family patterns; good relationships, experience of caring parents etc• Cognitive style and personality; confidence, readiness to seek help,
openness to others• Cultural and social factors; good social integration• Environmental factors; good diet, enough sleep and physical exercise
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 13
Strategies in Suicide Prevention
• Two perspectives:- Health care perspective- Public health perspective
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 14
Health Care Strategy
Aims:
Increasing and improving access and quality of health care
Suicide and attempted suicide can be prevented
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 15
Public Health Strategy
Focuses on influencing attitudes to increase the awareness about suicide and suicide prevention in certain targeted populations
Goal: increase identification of and support for
vulnerable individuals
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 16
Educational S-preventive Programmes
• D/ART; Depression/Awareness, Recognition and Treatment (USA, 1988)• The Defeat Depression Campaign (United Kingdom, 1992 – 1996)• Beyond Blue (Australia, 2004, 2005, 2008)• Choose Life (Scotland, 2006, 2007)• AFSPP; Air Force Suicide Prevention Programme; USA, 1995 – 1999• Nuremberg Alliance Against Depression, (2001-2002)• European Alliance Against Depression, 2004 –• Saving and Empowering Young Lives in Europé (SEYLE) 2009 – 2012
(BMC Public Health. 2010 Apr 13;10:192.)
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 17
Diagnostics (1)
People who commit suicide turn to their GP some time
before the fatal step
Diagnosis:
1. anamnestics, (case story)
2. rating scales (depression, anxiety, alcohol/drug abuse etc)
3. listening to the next-of-kin
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 18
Diagnostics (2)
• Depression• Anxiety Disorders• Alcohol and drug abuse• Psychotic disorders• Suicide and co-morbidity
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 19
Diagnostics: Depression (3)
1. Anamnestics (case story)
2. MADRS-S ( Montgomery Asberg Depression Rating Scale)
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 20
Diagnostics: Anxiety (4)
1. Anxiety is related to elevated risk for suicide attempts and suicide
2. Highest risk when both anxiety and affective disorders are present
3. HAD – Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 21
Diagnostics -Alcohol and drug abuse (5)
1. Mortality of people with alcohol dependence:
Four times that of the normal population
AUDIT – diagnostic interview alc. dependence
DUDIT – diagnostic interview drug dependence
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 22
Diagnostics – Psychotic Disorders (6)
10 percent of patients with schizophrenia die as a result of suicide
• Note: Schizophrenia is not uncommon – prevalence 1 percent all over the world
Diagnosis: crucial to listen to the family
Immediate referral to psychiatric clinic
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 23
Diagnostics: comorbidity (7)
• Highest suicide rates:
Depression comorbid with alcohol/drug abuse
Important:
Under reported; the connections of:
– Women/alcoholism/suicide– Elderly/ alcoholism/suicde
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 24
Diagnostics:Somatic disease and suicide (1)
Elevated risk for suicide:
• Neurological diseases (MS, spinal chord injuries, epilepsy, migraine, stroke, also mental retardation)
• Cancer (especially period around diagnosis)• Conditions involving severe and chronic pain• Tinnitus in elderly men• Crohn´s disease and ulcerous colitis
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 25
Somatic disease and suicide (2)
Please note:• Somatic illness in itself is not enough to elicit suicidal
behavior
• Usually a combination with feelings of - Loneliness- Being abandoned- Hopelessness- Psychological problems- Psychiatric disease
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 26
Special groups: Child and adolescent suicide (1)
• Suicide in children younger than 10 is rare (concept of death not adequate until the age of 10 – 12)
• Risk for children suicidality related to risk factors in parents
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 27
Special groups (2)Child and adolescent suicide
Adolescents 15 – 19 years of age:
• Suicide is the third highest cause of death
• Rising trend among young men (genetic factors + men less prone to seek help)
• Risk group: socially underprivileged children cared for by the welfare system
• Trauma: physical, sexual, etc.
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 28
Special groups (3)Suicide in the elderly
• Risk of dying from suicide increases with advancing age
• Risk factors for suicide in the elderly:- Widowhood- Impaired physical health- Having moved to home for elderly- Social isolation- Mental illness- High suicidal intent
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 29
Special groups (4)Suicide in prisons
• Suicide rate in prisons higher than in the male population in general
”Preventing Suicide: A Resource for Prison Officers” (WHO 2000) from:
www.who.int/mental_health/resources/suicide
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 30
Suicide Risk Assessment
• Suicide risk analysis
”Preventing suicide. A resource for general practitioners” (WHO, 2000) www.who.int/mental_health/resources/suicide
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 31
Checklist of risk factors for suicidality (1)
1. Psychiatric symptoms ?• Depression?• Strong anxiety?• Psychotic ideation?• Violent tendencies?• Alcohol/drug abuse?
2. Previous suicide attempt?
3. Suicidal model?
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 32
Checklist of risk factors for suicidality (2)
4. Severe somatic illness?
5. Social network ?
(Failing, missing or supportive)
6. Suicidal intention?• Hopelessness? Thoughts about death? Wishes for death? Suicide thoughts?
Suicide wishes/impulses? Suicide note? Suicide plan/method?
• Time fixed for putting plan into work? =(extremely high risk)
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 33
Suicidal communication
• Communication;
– Means there IS a part of the person open to persuasion to hang on to life
– Use that opening in persuading the person to go on with his life
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 34
Relationship between attempted suicide and suicide
• 11 583 patients were followed-up 15 years after their suicide attempt
• 300 had died from suicide
• Thus, the suicide risk in this sample was 66 times greater than in the general population
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 35
Ask for previous suicide attempt
• Always ask a suicidal patient if he has ever made a suicide attempt
• This considerably heightens the risk of completed suicide
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 36
Predictors of Completed Suicide
Higher risk of suicide when:
• Male sex• Age over 45 years • Separated, divorced or widowed• Unemployed or retired• Chronic somatic illness• Major psychiatric disorder, especially depression• Addiction to alcohol/other substances• Use of violent methods for suicide attempt• Having left a suicide note
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 37
Treatment
Pharmacological treatment of individuals who are suicidal• Treat the underlying psychiatric condition:
- Anti-depressants• Plus supportive therapy• Plus short period of anxiolytics • Should be relatively safe in overdose• Adherence and effectiveness dependent on the relationship between
patient and the GP – call the patient, follow-up
- Lithium (bipolar disorders, by psychiatric specialists)
- New antipsychotics (psychiatric specialists)
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 38
Suicide and antidepressant use
• 60 % of people who die from suicide suffer from depression
- but only 15 % received prescriptions for antidepressants
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 39
Undertreatment of depression – explanations:
• Only 70 % respond to antidepressant medication• Adherence to treatment depends ,mostly, on the doctor –
patient relationship• Many patients distrust medication, don’t even try it• Because of medication side effects, patients stop taking
the pharmocological treatment
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 40
Psychological treatment of suicidal people
• Psychotherapy:- A form of counselling that can help to develop problem-solving
strategies
• Evidence-based therapies- CBT, cognitive-based therapy- DBT, dialectical behavior therapy
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 41
CBT and DBT: view on suicidal behavior
• Suicidal behavior as a learned coping response that originates under conditions of extreme emotional pain and anxiety
• Goal of CBT and DBT: help suicidal individuals find alternative ways of solving their emotional problems
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 42
Importance of combining pharmacological and psychological treatments for suicidal patients
• Patients suffering from a very deep depression need to be treated with antidepressants first,before starting a psychotherapy
• During this initial treating phase, they need a frequent, supportive contact with their doctor
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 43
Reducing repetition of deliberate self-harm
1. Protect the patient against repeated suicide attempts (reduce suicidal possibilities)
2. Reduce feelings of hopelessness
3. Treat the patient with pharmacological and psychological methods, or refer to specialist
4. Improve the person´s subjective quality of life (network, societal resources and facilities)
5. Societal resources can help with housing and employment
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 44
Training and support
1. Training for general practitioners and their staff
2. Supporting healthcare staff
3. Traning GP:s in the treatment of depression and in suicide prevention strategies
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 45
1. Training for general practitioners and their staff
• The supportive contact between GP and patient is of decisive value
• It is the quality of this relationship that will decide what the patient gains from medication treatment
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 46
2. Supporting healthcare staff
• Staff should learn about, and practice, suicide preventing strategies
• Clinical supervision
• Continuous education
• GPs taking responsibilities also for the well-being of their staff
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 47
3. Training GP:s in the treatment of depression and suicide prevention strategies
• Educating GPs how to diagnose and treat depression and how to identify patients at risk for suicide
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 48
Finally: example of a Successful implementation of an intervention programme
1. level one: training of family doctors and staff
2. level two: public relations campaign, information about depression
3. level three:cooperation with community facilitators ( teachers, clergy, local media)
4. level four: support for self-help and high-risk groups
Copyright © 2012 World Psychiatric Association 49
Thank youwww.ki.se/suicide
Danuta Wasserman & Susanne Ringskog Vagnhammar