wp3 ict support - vtt · wp3 ict support d3.1 ict ... managing notes and comments associated with...

29
Dissemination level PU Public X RE Restricted to a group specified by the consortium CO Confidential, only for members of the consortium WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT services requirements specification Revision: Final Due date: 2014-05-31 Actual release date: 2014-12-18 Lead contractor: CSTB

Upload: hoangthuy

Post on 03-Apr-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

Dissemination level

PU Public X RE Restricted to a group specified by the consortium CO Confidential, only for members of the consortium

WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT services requirements

specification

Revision: Final

Due date: 2014-05-31

Actual release date: 2014-12-18

Lead contractor: CSTB

Page 2: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 2 of 29

Deliverable Administration & Summary ecobim WPX Eco-Innovera

No & name D3.1 ICT services requirements specification

Status <Draft / Working / Released> Due m17 Date 2014-05-31

Author(s) Eric Lebègue (CSTB), Wolfram Trinius (TRIN)

Editor CSTB

Description This document presents the ICT services specifications proposed by the ecobim framework.

Comments

Document workflow

Released CSTB Date 2014-12-17

Accepted VTT Date 2014-12-18

Page 3: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 3 of 29

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Executive summary........................................................................................................ 5

1. Recall of the ecobim framework ................................................................................. 6

2. Recall of the ecobim ICT framework ............................................................................ 8

3. ICT services requirements specification ..................................................................... 10

3.1 BIM checker and assessment ..................................................................................... 10

3.2 Product Life Management (PLM) ................................................................................ 10

3.3 Detailed process ....................................................................................................... 11

3.4 BIM objects on the PLM ............................................................................................ 12

3.5 Life Cycle Analysis and calculation of eco-indicators ..................................................... 17

3.6 Loading BIM quantity take off into Excel ..................................................................... 20

4. Conclusions and recommendations ........................................................................... 22

Annexes ...................................................................................................................... 23

Annex 1. Excel macro sample .......................................................................................... 23

Page 4: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 4 of 29

Table of figures

Figure 1: ecobim framework…………………………………………………………………………………………………6

Figure 2: Partial view of the template for ecobim case studies……………………………….…………..6

Figure 3: Business opportinities for eco-innovation………………………………………………………..……7

Figure 4: The ecobim ICT framework…………………………………………………………………………………….8

Figure 5: eveBIM checking tool……………………………………………………………………………………………10

Figure 6: BIM Edition general process…………………………………………………………………………………11

Figure 7: BIM-PLM-LCA process………………………………………………………………………………………….12

Figure 8. Process to build the XML………………………………….…………………………………………………..15

Figure 9: The export option in the file menu…………………………………….……………………………..….15

Figure 10: Proxy model used to display a project………………………………………………………………..16

Figure 11: View of system model…………………………………………………………………………………………16

Figure 12: IFC loaded model…………………………………………………………………………………….………….17

Figure 13: Life Cycle Analysis and production of eco-indicators………………………………………….18

Figure 14: XML BIM loading macro within Excel………………………………………………….……………..21

Figure 15: Example of an automatically filled sheet…………………………………………….……………..21

Page 5: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 5 of 29

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

This document presents the ICT services specifications proposed by the ecobim framework described in ecobim D1.2 “ecobim project framework”. Eco-innovative services can be created with the support of new processes and ICTs. Service by service, this report explains the functionalities but also the processes required for achieving the service.

It proposes solutions based on the combination of BIM CAD Tools (eg. Revit, ArchiCAD…), the eveBIM viewer of CSTB, the Lascom AEC PLM platform and a mechanism based on XML and Excel spreadsheets for Life Cycle Analysis. One of the main questions raised is how to generalize the findings so that they become applicable in other contexts, e.g. in other countries or in different regions within the same country, or even in different thematic contexts.

Page 6: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 6 of 29

1. RECALL OF THE ECOBIM FRAMEWORK

The ecobim framework is based on paradigm change and eco-innovations supported by new ICTs and new processes. They result in new services and also in new business models, especially for SMEs.

Figure 1: ecobim framework.

The achieved impacts can be assessed in increased environmental, economic and social or cultural sustainability. A template covering these aspects has been defined to be applied in the Finnish, French and German D4.1 Case studies.

Figure 2: Partial view of the template for ecobim case studies.

ecobim

market impact

new ict

new process

new service

value driven life cycle based sustainable business models

environmental impact

easy-to-use guidelines based on indicators for

sustainable eco-innovative construction business

models +

recommendations for policy makers

new revenuemodel/ other

social/cultural impact

easy-to-understand common reference,better quality of life for citizens

paradigm change to eco-innovation minimizing impacts of building activities using LC approach

new business opportunities for construction SMEs

actorsVTT FinlandCSTB FranceSME FinlandSME France

SME Germany

a roadmap for new business models for sustainable construction procurement in direct collaboration with SMEs through

flexible life-cycle assessment tools based on indicators and linked to BIMs

BIM checkers and assessmentProduct Life Management (PLM)

Life Cycle Analysis and Production of Eco-indicatorsMonitoring of buildings

Other BIM based business opportunities

Value drivenlife cycle based

processes re-engineered

Paradigm change relatedeco-innovative services,

especially for SMEs

Sustainable business modelsbased on eco-innovations

and new earning logics

main results

Page 7: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 7 of 29

The ecobim project has already identified a number of opportunities for eco-innovation within the construction sector and is working on the following: BIM checkers and assessment, Product Life Management (PLM), Life Cycle Analysis and Production of Eco-Indicators, Monitoring of Buildings and other business opportunities not necessarily related to BIMs and ICTs. Opportunities related to BIM, PLM, LCA and Monitoring are being developed through real case studies in Finland, France and Germany. However, other opportunities not related to BIMs and ICTs are being explored through co-creation workshops with different stakeholder groups supported by ecobim networking platform.

Figure 3: Business opportunities for eco-innovation.

ecobimvalue driven life cycle based sustainable business models

OtherBIM basedbusiness

opportunities

Otherbusiness

opportunities

Other business opportunitiesNew ICTNew ProcessNew ServiceNew Revenue ModelOtherecobim scope is not limited to the BIM based business solutions described so far. Other potential candidates may be identified during the project’s life time e.g. with the help of the ecobim online networking platform, exploiting Building Information Modeling or not. The key objective is to relate them to eco-innovation and special concern is to look for opportunities to SMEs

BIM checkers and assessmentwith better tools, it is possible to

superpose different pieces of BIM, e.g. workpackages or specific views of the different actors for synthesis or clash

detections.

Product Life Management(PLM)

PLM ensures collaborative work around the BIM to manage e.g. different actors

of the construction project with their roles, hierarchies, workflows and

commissioning data.

Life Cycle Analysis and Productionof Eco-indicators

life cycle assessment for different phases, disciplines or processes provides new

business opportunities so that the BIM Manager role can become an ECO BIM

Manager.

Monitoring of buildingsremote monitoring of buildings can

reproduce its behaviour within the BIM, enabling to perform simulations and propose corrections to improve the

building performance.

Page 8: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 8 of 29

2. RECALL OF THE ECOBIM ICT FRAMEWORK

The ecobim D1.1 deliverable has presented some business opportunities for eco-innovation thanks to the combined usage of BIM, Product Life Management (PLM) and potential other technologies (Web, indicators sharing, XML…).

These business opportunities are presented in detail in the following chapters, after a presentation of the general ecobim ICT framework, which can provide a coherent approach for these different opportunities.

The following schema presents the general ecobim ICT framework. This schema takes advantages of the tandem BIM + PLM for supporting different eco-innovation business opportunities with different processes that are described later in this document.

Figure 4: The ecobim ICT framework.

The elements of the ecobim framework are:

the different actors related to the building lifecycle use specific tools dedicated to their specific disciplines and roles in e.g. building design, construction or building maintenance & operation. Depending on their tasks and roles, they may generate or apply data that ideally can be fed into and read from an IFC formatted BIM model, established for collating technical building information;

a BIM Viewer, Checker and Synthesizer tool is used for :

providing a common technical view of the building all along its lifecycle;

checking that the IFC data are correctly defined and provided, depending on the lifecycle phase;

establishing the links between the objects of the building and its different associated requirements, annotations, documents, ecobim indicators (analysis results dedicated to eco-performance) and monitoring data;

Page 9: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 9 of 29

ecobim Web Services for offering a data connection (for data transfer with access rights managed by the PLM) between the different actor tools and the ecobim PLM;

ecobim PLM Engine for :

establishing the links between the different elements of the building technical data;

managing the actors' roles and collaborative access rights to these elements;

the ecobim Data Server for sharing and archiving the different files of the building.

In the scope of the ecobim project framework, eveBIM from CSTB will be extended to play the role of the BIM Viewer, Checker and Synthesizer and the Lascom AEC platform of Lascom will be extended and parameterized for playing the role of the ecobim WEB Services and PLM engine.

Page 10: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 10 of 29

3. ICT SERVICES REQUIREMENTS SPECIFICATION

3.1 BIM checker and assessment

The BIM checker is a tool that can be used for checking a BIM IFC model, before sharing with other actors and applications.

Its functions are as follows:

1. Checking that the IFC Syntax is OK 2. Checking that original BIM model structure, hierarchy and relations between objects

are preserved 3. Checking that the object types, GUID and properties are preserved 4. Checking that the quantities of the object are present 5. Checking that object location and orientation are preserved 6. Checking that the objects geometry envelop (BREP) is OK 7. Checking the materials 8. Notifying objects for raising potential issues (BCF – BIM Collaboration Format)

Figure 5: eveBIM checking tool.

3.2 Product Life Management (PLM)

The PLM provides a platform for managing the project data all along the life cycle of the project.

NB: Project Life Cycle means the management of the building data all along its project life, from initial programming, to design, construction and exploitation.

The functions for BIM and PLM coupling are as follows:

Page 11: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 11 of 29

1. Defining roles and access rights of the different actors 2. Defining the general organization: phases, disciplines, types of buildings, zones, levels 3. Managing documents and BIM parts coding naming system based on the

organization 4. Storing documents and BIM parts and providing upload and download mechanisms

(WEB Services) 5. Managing the versioning of the documents and the BIM Parts 6. Managing notes and comments associated with documents, BIM parts and BIM

objects 7. Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish,

validate, upgrade 8. Providing mechanisms for linking documents stored in the PLM with the BIM objects 9. Providing email notification mechanisms

The ecobim result is the Lascom AEC BIM Edition product:

Figure 6: BIM Edition general process. (Phases refer to the French process)

The Lascom AEC BIM Edition solution, is based on the coupling of eveBIM for Viewer Checker for BIM/IFC exported models viewing and checking and the Lascom AEC PLM platform.

3.3 Detailed process

The detailed process from BIM to PLM and Life Cycle Analysis is presented below in Figure 7.

Page 12: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 12 of 29

Figure 7: BIM – PLM – LCA process.

The process is the following:

1. BIM Cad tools (ex: Revit, ArchiCAD, Allplan...) can be used for creating BIM models and producing IFC files

2. eveBIM can be used for verifying the IFC model (checker), uploading to the PLM and also producing an XML model

3. The XML BIM contains the hierarchy of the objects with types, GUID, quantities and properties. This XML can be used by Excel for LCA analysis. It can also be used for creation of BIM Objects within the PLM platform.

4. Drawings, produced with the CAD tools but also technical or administrative documents can be uploaded to the PLM.

5. Some links can be established automatically (thanks to naming or identification mechanisms) or manually between the BIM Objects and the documents and drawings.

3.4 BIM objects on the PLM

It should be possible to create BIM Objects on the PLM.

They could be created manually automatically by using the PLM or importing an XML built from the IFC model.

The main objects can be the following:

Sites (IfcSite)

Buildings (IfcBuilding)

Storeys (IfcStorey)

Spaces (IfcSpace)

Objects Types (Object Type), built from Revit

Page 13: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 13 of 29

Here is a possible organization of BIM objects on the PLM:

Project

Site

1..n Building

1..n Etage

1..n Reference (~ Revit family)

1..n Instance

1.. n Space (IfcSpace)

1..n System (ex: Structure, architecture, electricity…)

1..n sub-system (ex: courants forts, courants faibles…)

1..n Reference

1..n Instance

When exported using XML, the structure can be as followed:

- root

OwnerHistories

o 1..n : OwnerHistory

Id : string

User : string

Organisation : string

Application : string

BuildingElements

o 0..n : BuildingElement

Id : string

GUID : string

IfcType : string

Name : string

Description : string

OwnerId : string

ObjectType : string

0..n : Material

Name : string

Properties

0..n : Propertyset

o Name : String

o 0..n : PropertyType

Name : String

Value : (depending of IfcValue)

Page 14: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 14 of 29

Structure

o Id : string

o Name : string

o 0..n : System or Group

0..n : Node

Name : string

Id : string

0..n : Node

o Name : string

o Id : string

o 0..n : Node (Site)

Id : string

Name : string

0..n Node (Building)

Id : string

Name : string

0..n : Node (Storey)

o Id : string

o Name : string

o 0..n : Node (BuildingElements)

Id : string

Name : string

o Node (Space)

Id : string

Name : string

Below is an example.

Page 15: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 15 of 29

The process to build this XML is presented in Figure 8.

Figure 8: Process to build the XML.

“Main app” in Figure 8 means the main application. In our case, it is the eveBIM-Edition. The

export option could be found in the file menu | export | export XML.

Figure 9: The export option in the file menu.

Page 16: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 16 of 29

The proxy model is a structure created for storing all the data in a tree. It is also used for

displaying a project, see Figure 10.

Figure 10: Proxy model used to display a project.

The system model is optional and only concerns models with groups, see Figure 11.

Figure 11: View of system model.

Page 17: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 17 of 29

The model is the IFC loaded.

Figure 12: IFC loaded model.

3.5 Life Cycle Analysis and calculation of eco-indicators

Life Cycle Analysis can be done using a spreadsheet computed from the BIM Functions:

1. Producing bill of quantities in a spreadsheet from a list of selected objects in the BIM (quantities take off).

2. Providing Excel macro that can be adapted for linking BIM objects and recorded materials with external LCA database of materials and product data.

NB: by default, the ecobim Excel spreadsheet is provided with macros that can load an XML file exported from the BIM into excel sheets. These macros can be modified by the users for the connection to specific database or tools.

3. Calculating indicator results for selected environmental performance indicators.

Page 18: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 18 of 29

Figure 13: Life Cycle Analysis and calculation of eco-indicators.

IFC provides the following quantities for main objects that can be used for LCA quantities calculation:

Ifc Entity Base Quantities Description

IfcWall NominalLength Total nominal (or average) length of the wall along the wall path. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NominalWidth Total nominal (or average) width (or thickness) of the wall perpendicular to the wall path. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NominalHeight Total nominal (or average) height of the wall along the wall path. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossFootprintArea Area of the wall as viewed by a ground floor view, not taking any wall modifications (like recesses) into account. It is also referred to as the foot print of the wall. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetFootprintArea Area of the wall as viewed by a ground floor view, taking all wall modifications (like recesses) into account. It is also referred to as the foot print of the wall. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossSideArea Area of the wall as viewed by an elevation view of the middle plane of the wall. It does not take into account any wall modifications (such as openings). The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetSideArea Area of the wall as viewed by an elevation view of the middle plane. It does take into account all wall modifications (such as openings). The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossSideAreaLeft Area of the wall as viewed by an elevation view of the left side (when viewed along the wall path orientation). It does not take into account any wall modifications (such as openings). The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetSideAreaLeft Area of the wall as viewed by an elevation view of the left side (when viewed along the wall path orientation). It does take into account all wall modifications (such as openings). The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossSideAreaRight Area of the wall as viewed by an elevation view of the right side (when viewed along the wall path orientation). It does not take into account any wall modifications (such as openings). The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetSideAreaRight Area of the wall as viewed by an elevation view of the right side (when viewed along the wall path orientation). It does take into account all wall modifications (such as openings). The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

Page 19: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 19 of 29

GrossVolume Volume of the wall, without taking into account the openings and the connection geometry. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetVolume Volume of the wall, after subtracting the openings and after considering the connection geometry. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

IfcSlab NominalWidth Total nominal (or average) width (or thickness) of the slab. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

Perimeter Perimeter measured along the outer boundaries of the slab. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossArea Total area of the extruded area of the slab. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetArea Total area of the extruded area of the slab, taking into account possible slab openings. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossVolume Total gross volume of the slab, not taking into account possible openings and recesses. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetVolume Total net volume of the slab, taking into account possible openings and recesses. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossWeight Total gross weight of the slab, not taking into account possible openings and recesses or projections. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetWeight Total net weight of the slab, taking into account possible openings and recesses or projections. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

IfcBeam NominalLength Total nominal length of the beam, not taking into account any cut-out's or other processing features.

CrossSectionArea Total area of the cross section (or profile) of the beam. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

OuterSurfaceArea Total area of the extruded surfaces of the beam (not taking into account the end cap areas), normally generated as perimeter * length.

TotalSurfaceArea Total area of the beam, normally generated as perimeter * length + 2 * cross section area.

GrossVolume Total gross volume of the beam, not taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetVolume Total net volume of the beam, taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossWeight Total gross weight of the beam without add-on parts, not taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses.

NetWeight Total net weight of the beam without add-on parts, taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses.

IfcColumn NominalLength Total nominal length of the column, not taking into account any cut-out's or other processing features.

CrossSectionArea Total area of the cross section (or profile) of the column. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

OuterSurfaceArea Total area of the extruded surfaces of the column (not taking into account the end cap areas), normally generated as perimeter * length.

TotalSurfaceArea Total area of the column, normally generated as perimeter * length + 2 * cross section area.

GrossVolume Total gross volume of the column, not taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

NetVolume Total net volume of the column, taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses. The exact definition and calculation rules depend on the method of measurement used.

GrossWeight Total gross weight of the column without add-on parts, not taking into account possible

Page 20: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 20 of 29

processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses.

NetWeight Total net weight of the column without add-on parts, taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses.

IfcDoor Width Total outer width of the door lining. It should only be provided, if it is a rectangular door

Height Total outer height of the door lining. It should only be provided, if it is a rectangular door.

Perimeter Total perimeter of the outer lining of the door.

Area Total area of the outer lining of the door

IfcWindow Width Total outer width of the window lining. It should only be provided, if it is a rectangular window.

Height Total outer height of the window lining. It should only be provided, if it is a rectangular window

Perimeter Total perimeter of the outer lining of the window

Area Total area of the outer lining of the window

IfcPlate Width Nominal width (or thickness) of the plate. Only given, if the plate is prismatic (constant thickness).

Perimeter Perimeter measured along the outer boundaries of the plate. Only given, if the plate is prismatic (constant thickness).

GrossArea Total area of the extruded area of the plate. Openings, recesses and projections are not taken into account. Only given, if the plate is prismatic.

NetArea Total area of the extruded area of the plate. Openings and recesses are taken into account by subtraction, projections by addition. Only given, if the plate is prismatic.

GrossVolume Total gross volume of the plate. Openings, recesses, and projections are not taken into account.

NetVolume Total net volume of the plate. Openings and recesses are taken into account by subtraction, projections by addition.

GrossWeight Total gross weight of the plate without add-on parts, not taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses.

NetWeight Total net weight of the plate without add-on parts, taking into account possible processing features (cut-out's, etc.) or openings and recesses.

3.6 Loading BIM quantity take off into Excel

An Excel macro is provided for loading the XML BIM into Excel and filling automatically sheets with the BIM objects and quantities, see Figure 14 and 15.

Page 21: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 21 of 29

Figure 14: XML BIM loading macro within Excel.

Figure 15: Example of an automatically filled sheet. This filling can be customised by modifying the Excel

macros (see Annex 1).

Page 22: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 22 of 29

4. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Besides displaying the results of predefined ecobim indicators of the building, analysis and tracing of the origins with the aim of redesign and improvement may also be considered, to make the purpose of LCA manifold. For the later, a more detailed level of information (granularity) is required, enabling overall building indicators, distribution to life cycle stages, distribution to building elements, contribution of selected materials, etc. Ultimately the goal of the application of the results, the "message and interpretation" defines the requested level of details. This also applies to export interfaces to external calculation or evaluation tools. The intended application of the information defines the scope and details of the information - if demand and supply do not match, the desired analysis and interpretation may be disabled.

Typically, we need to quantify the masses or volumes (kg or m3) of materials in a highly disaggregated level. For the sake of interpretation, not only the total amounts for the building are required, but information about all building elements, including 3D geometric information (thickness of layers), as well as physical material information like material density. The information should originate from the BIM model, or else it would need to be complemented manually. Typically, the architectural model will contain only the main materials (e.g. carpet) but not the glue. Consequently, in most cases, the generated list of materials would need to be verified and completed. Further, specified materials like reinforced concrete may themselves consist of combinations of different materials. For the LCA, an indication of the reinforcement (kg/m3 resulting reinforced concrete) is required. Depending on how such information is provided (percentage or kg), the calculations need to respond accordingly. Especially for stud-walls, frame-construction, suspended ceilings and elevated floors, there are also ”punctual“ or ”linear“ elements that would not be ”visible“ in a section. C-c-distances between studs and beams, or average metrics per reference unit (e.g. 7 studs per m2 elevated floor, or 2,5 kg profile per m2 drywall) would be necessary complementary information.

It is essential that the information can be re-organized according to the following steps and structures of data-application. Often, several routes of calculation are possible, flexibility in provided data and structure allows to adapt provided information and to clearly identify lacking information than needs to be complemented from other sources. For each building element (walls, ceilings, etc.) or (groups of) materials (minerals, metals, concrete, carpet, etc.) partial results or contributions to the overall building indicators can be presented and analysed. Such sorting and filtering will need to be adaptable to the purpose of the interpretation, possibly decision making or comparison of options. Last but not least, some elements of information may be applied also for life cycle cost calculation, especially service life information. There is a link also to construction cost planning, while recognising that cost information is more related to building elements or components rather than to single materials or products.

From an application perspective, there are two possible routes: (1) to include a vast amount of additional information into the BIM datasets; (2) to specify links to further sources of complementary information. Regional validity or applicability currently indicates a vague preference for (2). Management of such data will become a crucial success factor.

Page 23: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 23 of 29

ANNEXES

Annex 1. Excel macro sample

This annex presents the Excel macro example for filling sheets from the XML.

Option Explicit

'Type storey : used for keeping one storey data

Type Storey

name As String

GUID As String

id As String

End Type

_________________________________________________________________________________________

'Type structure : used to keep all the storey

Type structure

tab_storey() As Storey

last_elem As Long

End Type

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Function getLastEmptyLine()

'return the last empty line of the worksheet

Dim result As Long

Dim found As Boolean

found = False

result = 1

While Not found

If Cells(result, 1).Value = "" Then

found = True

Else

result = result + 1

End If

Wend

getLastEmptyLine = result

End Function

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub checkWallBaseQuantities(node As IXMLDOMNode, line As Long)

Dim i As Long

Dim j As Long

Dim current As IXMLDOMNode

Page 24: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 24 of 29

For i = 0 To node.ChildNodes.Length - 1

If node.ChildNodes.Item(i).nodeName = "PropertySet" Then

If node.ChildNodes.Item(i).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "BaseQuantities" Then

Set current = node.ChildNodes.Item(i)

For j = 0 To current.ChildNodes.Length - 1

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "Width" Then Cells(line, 8).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "Height" Then Cells(line, 9).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "Length" Then Cells(line, 7).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "GrossSideArea" Then Cells(line, 12).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "NetSideArea" Then Cells(line, 13).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "GrossVolume" Then Cells(line, 14).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "NetVolume" Then Cells(line, 15).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "GrossFootprintArea" Then Cells(line, 10).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

If current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Attributes.getNamedItem("name").Text = "NetFootprintArea" Then Cells(line, 11).Value = current.ChildNodes.Item(j).Text

Next

End If

End If

Next

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub redimtable(table() As Storey, newsize As Long)

'subfunction to resize a table without loosing data. change the dimension if needed

Dim i As Long

Dim tab_temp() As Storey

ReDim tab_temp(UBound(table()))

For i = 0 To UBound(table()) - 1

tab_temp(i) = table(i)

Next

ReDim table(newsize)

For i = 0 To UBound(tab_temp()) - 1

table(i) = tab_temp(i)

Next

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Page 25: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 25 of 29

Sub CheckIfcType(ByRef node As IXMLDOMNode, struct As structure)

Dim line As Long

Dim i As Long

Dim j As Long

If Left(node.Attributes.getNamedItem("IfcType").Text, 7) Like "IfcWall" Then

'adding the element in the IfcWall worksheet

Sheets("IfcWall").Activate

line = getLastEmptyLine

Cells(line, 1).Value = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("GUID").Text

Cells(line, 2).Value = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("Name").Text

If Not node.Attributes.getNamedItem("ObjectType") Is Nothing Then

Cells(line, 6).Value = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("ObjectType").Text

Else

Cells(line, 6).Value = "no data"

End If

Cells(line, 3).Value = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("Id").Text

For i = 0 To node.ChildNodes.Length - 1

If node.ChildNodes.Item(i).NodeType <> 3 Then

If node.ChildNodes.Item(i).nodeName = "Material" Then Cells(line, 5).Value = node.ChildNodes.Item(i).Attributes.getNamedItem("Name").Text

If node.ChildNodes.Item(i).nodeName = "Properties" Then checkWallBaseQuantities node.ChildNodes.Item(i), line

End If

Next

End If

If node.Attributes.getNamedItem("IfcType").Text = "IfcBuildingStorey" Then

'saving the storey datas for later

If struct.last_elem > 0 Then

redimtable struct.tab_storey, struct.last_elem + 1

Else

ReDim struct.tab_storey(1)

End If

struct.tab_storey(struct.last_elem).GUID = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("GUID").Text

struct.tab_storey(struct.last_elem).id = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("Id").Text

struct.tab_storey(struct.last_elem).name = node.Attributes.getNamedItem("Name").Text

struct.last_elem = struct.last_elem + 1

End If

End Sub

Page 26: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 26 of 29

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Function checkwalls(id As Long, storeyElem As Storey)

Dim eof As Boolean

Dim line As Long

Dim result As Boolean

result = False

eof = False

line = 2

Sheets("IfcWall").Activate

While Not eof

If Cells(line, 3).Value = "" Then eof = True

If Cells(line, 3).Value = id Then

Cells(line, 3).Value = storeyElem.GUID

Cells(line, 4).Value = storeyElem.name

result = True

eof = True

Else

line = line + 1

End If

Wend

checkwalls = result

End Function

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub fillAllStorey(node As IXMLDOMNode, storeyElem As Storey)

Dim found As Boolean

Dim i As Long

For i = 0 To node.ChildNodes.Length - 1

fillAllStorey node.ChildNodes.Item(i), storeyElem

found = False

If Not node.ChildNodes.Item(i).Attributes.getNamedItem("id") Is Nothing Then

'retriving the element in the whole document

If Not found Then found = checkwalls(node.ChildNodes.Item(i).Attributes.getNamedItem("Id").Text, storeyElem)

End If

Next

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub get_Storey(node As IXMLDOMNode, struct As structure)

Dim i As Long

Dim j As Long

For i = 0 To node.ChildNodes.Length - 1

Page 27: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 27 of 29

For j = 0 To struct.last_elem

If Not node.ChildNodes.Item(i).Attributes.getNamedItem("Id") Is Nothing Then

If node.ChildNodes.Item(i).Attributes.getNamedItem("Id").Text = struct.tab_storey(j).id Then

fillAllStorey node.ChildNodes.Item(i), struct.tab_storey(j)

Else

get_Storey node.ChildNodes.Item(i), struct

End If

End If

Next

Next

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub BrowseChildNodes(root_node As IXMLDOMNode, struct As structure)

'browse all the nodes from the xml

Dim i As Long

Dim currentNode As IXMLDOMNode

For i = 0 To root_node.ChildNodes.Length - 1

If root_node.ChildNodes.Item(i).NodeType <> 3 Then

Set currentNode = root_node.ChildNodes.Item(i)

If currentNode.nodeName = "IFCElement" Then CheckIfcType currentNode, struct

'retrieving the storey data from the structure

If currentNode.nodeName = "Structure" Then get_Storey currentNode, struct

BrowseChildNodes root_node.ChildNodes(i), struct

End If

Next

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub BrowseXMLDocument(ByVal filename As String)

'

' BrowseXMLDocument Macro

' get all the IFC building elements and their properties from a XML file

'

' declarations

Dim xmlDoc As DOMDocument

Dim root As IXMLDOMElement

Dim name As String

Dim n As IXMLDOMElement

Dim struct As structure

Page 28: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 28 of 29

' initialisation

Set xmlDoc = New DOMDocument

xmlDoc.async = False

If xmlDoc.Load(filename) Then

Set root = xmlDoc.DocumentElement

Else

MsgBox "Unable to load the file", vbCritical, "Attention"

Exit Sub

End If

' starting extracting datas

If Not root Is Nothing Then

struct.last_elem = 0

BrowseChildNodes root, struct

End If

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub clearAllSheet()

'clear and rebuild the sheets

Sheets(Array("IfcWall")).Select

Cells.Select

Selection.ClearContents

Cells(1, 1).Value = "GUID"

Cells(1, 2).Value = "Name"

Cells(1, 3).Value = "Storey (GUID)"

Cells(1, 4).Value = "Storey name"

Cells(1, 5).Value = "IFC Material"

Cells(1, 6).Value = "Type"

Cells(1, 7).Value = "NominalLength"

Cells(1, 8).Value = "NominalWidth"

Cells(1, 9).Value = "NominalHeight"

Cells(1, 10).Value = "GrossFootprintArea"

Cells(1, 11).Value = "NetFootprintArea"

Cells(1, 12).Value = "GrossSideArea"

Cells(1, 13).Value = "NetSideArea"

Cells(1, 14).Value = "GrossVolume"

Cells(1, 15).Value = "NetVolume"

Sheets(Array("IfcDoor")).Select

Page 29: WP3 ICT support - VTT · WP3 ICT support D3.1 ICT ... Managing notes and comments associated with ... Managing the workflow of the documents and the BIM Parts: upload, publish, validate

D3.1 ICT Services requirements specification 2014-12-18

Page 29 of 29

End Sub

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Sub XMLReader()

Dim filename As String

filename = Application.GetOpenFilename

'MsgBox filename, vbCritical, "Attention"

If (Dir(filename) = "") Then

Exit Sub

End If

clearAllSheet

BrowseXMLDocument (filename)

Sheets("Accueil").Activate

Debug.Print filename

End Sub