workshop & webcast 1:30 - 3:30 march 2, 2004 1. damian bassett stewardship ontario “examining...
TRANSCRIPT
TODAY’S AGENDA1:30 – 1:35 Welcome Damian Bassett – Stewardship Ontario
1:35 – 1:45 Examining 2004 & 2005 Steward Fees Derek Stephenson – Stewardship Ontario
1:45 – 2:40 Preliminary Fees for 2004 Guy Perry – Stewardship Ontario
• Cost Allocation Project Dan Lantz – MacViro
2:40 – 3:25 Question Period Derek Stephenson Guy Perry
3:25 – 3:30 Closing Remarks Damian Bassett 3
TODAY’S INSTRUCTIONS
• Remember: veterans and rookies alikein audience
• 2nd audience listening in on-line• Save questions for Q & A at the end – Guy will break
½-way for preliminary questions * with Dan Lantz• Those on-line:
download slides from our homepage within the Yahoo player, or “minimize” player, and download slides from our homepage through your web browser
e-mail Questions - from your regular email program - to: [email protected]
4
TODAY’S OBJECTIVES
• Focus on the setting of Steward fees for the second half of 2004 and the development of fees for 2005
• Examine the allocation of costs to each Blue Box material collected in the Ontario municipal waste system
• Webcast archived – 180 days
• Deadline to comment – March 10, 2004
5
• Introduction
• Review of Fee Setting Formula
• Cost Allocation
• Preliminary Fees for 2004
• Proposed Consultation
• Proposed Process for Setting 2005 Fees
EXAMINING FEES
7
• Blue Box Program Plan (BBPP) approved December 22,
2003
• Extension of BBPP for 6 months
• First year “2003” stewards fees extended to be effective
to end of June 2004
• Minister requires 2004 fees for July though December to
be submitted by March 31, 2004
EXAMINING FEES
8
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
• Information on some of the tables on these slides has
been aggregated for the purposes of presentation.
• Detailed tables summarizing the calculation of 2004
fees are available from the website
www.stewardshipontario.ca
• Background information may be found in the February
2003 Blue Box Program Plan (BBPP), particularly,
Section 9.10 - Setting Fees
Appendix XI – Pay In Model, and
Appendix IX - Cost Allocation Principles 10
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
INTRODUCTION
• Net cost of Blue Box Program represents ~82%
of fees
• Net cost negotiated to be higher in 2004: Net cost negotiated to be $62.5 million for first year
(2003), as per BBPP• gross cost of ~ $129.2 million; revenues of $66.7
million
Net cost negotiated to be $84 million for 2004 • Gross cost of ~ $150.5 million; revenues of
~ $66.5 million 11
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CONTEXT
• Negotiated gross cost is higher by ~16%, but in fact,
Actual costs have not increased significantly in system
Most of increase due to improved information on costs
Obtained through detailed financial survey of all
municipalities (2003 financial datacall)
2001 2002
Tonnes Recovered 699,255 727,007 27,751 4.0%
System Gross Cost $129.2 M $150.5 M $21.3M 16.5%
System Revenue $66.7 M $66.5 M ($0.2 M) -
System Net Cost $62.5 M $84 M $21.5M 34.4%
Net Cost / tonne $89.38 $115.54 $26.16 29.3%
Cost of Living - - ~ 2%
Change
12
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CONTEXT
• To set 2004 fees, first considered raising each material
cost by same proportion
However, it was recognized that we need to improve data &
to ensure there is a link between allocation & real system
material costs
• Recommended => 2004 fees should be based on updated
material-specific costs obtained from additional field study
of cost for managing materials in municipal programs
13
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
FUNDING MODEL - PRINCIPLES
Five key Principles:• Reflect the true costs to manage each designated Blue
Box material
• Consider the benefits to all stewards from high recycling rates achieved by some materials
• Encourage increased material recycling rates
• Minimize the total net costs to the members of Stewardship Ontario (SO), e.g., reflect positive revenue
• Encourage stewards to select materials that can be recycled at lower costs
14
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
BLUE BOX WASTE
Blue Box Waste is defined as:
• Printed materials and packaging that are made of paper, glass, metal, plastics, textiles or any combination of these materials that are used by consumers and households and that make their way into municipal waste management systems.
• A steward is required to report on all packaging and printed materials that are primarily destined for Ontario households and therefore managed by municipal waste management systems. This includes consumer packaging and printed material sold through all distribution channels that may subsequently find its way into the municipal waste stream such as from retail and take out food service.
• The materials within the Blue Box are addressed within the funding model in two streams: • All printed paper, and • All packaging
15
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
BASIS FOR FEE PAYMENTS
• The fees paid by stewards are based on: Blue Box Waste generation Blue Box recycling rates Gross costs for managing recyclables, and Revenue, primarily from sale of recyclables
• The model for calculating fees is comprised of 3 elements:1.Blue Box Waste generation and diversion
2.Net cost to manage (gross cost less revenue)
3.Funding formula 16
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
BASIS FOR FEE PAYMENTS
• Fees are to be updated annually February - June, 2004
=> 2003 fees based on 2001 system data
July – December, 2004
=> 2004 fees based on 2002 system data
2005 fees will be based on 2003 system data
• Fees are reported as annual figures, but • for the 1st 5 months of 2004 the 2003 fees will be used• for the later 6 months the 2004 fees will be used
17
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
WASTE GENERATION
• Generation based on waste audits in several municipalities• residential sector only - not sales into the marketplace• Updated for 2002 => incorporated additional audits
=> Also population growth (1.46%)
1,578,500 tonnes of Blue Box recyclables
generated in Ontario
households in 2002
Quantity %'age of Quantity %'age of Category Generated Generated Generated Generated
(tonnes) (tonnes)
PRINTED PAPERPrinted Paper Total 724,100 46.60% 732,000 46.37%
PACKAGINGPaper Packaging Total 325,400 20.94% 332,300 21.05%
Plastics Total 232,200 14.94% 238,700 15.12%Steel Total 67,900 4.37% 69,100 4.38%
Aluminum Total 28,100 1.81% 27,000 1.71%Glass Total 176,300 11.34% 179,400 11.37%
PACKAGING TOTAL 829,900 53.40% 846,500 53.63%
TOTALS 1,554,000 100.00% 1,578,500 100.00%
2001 2002
18
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
RECYCLED
• Source: annual datacall administered by WDO, MOE & SO• 727,006 tonnes diverted in 2002, up 27,750 tones or ~ 4% from 2001• The overall diversion rate for the Blue Box program in 2002 was 46%
Change in Change inQuantity Recovery Quantity Recovery Quantity Recovery
Category Recovered Rate Recovered Rate Recovered Rate(tonnes) (%) (tonnes) (%) (tonnes) (%)
PRINTED PAPERPrinted Paper Total 391,435 54.25% 409,754 55.98% 18,319 1.72%
PACKAGINGPaper Packaging Total 134,822 41.17% 134,980 40.62% 158 -0.55%
Plastics Total 26,989 11.47% 31,928 13.38% 4,939 1.91%Steel Total 32,582 47.91% 33,472 48.44% 890 0.53%
Aluminum Total 10,875 40.91% 10,776 39.91% (99) -0.99%Glass Total 102,552 58.00% 106,097 59.14% 3,545 1.14%
PACKAGING TOTAL 307,820 36.90% 317,253 37.48% 9,433 0.58%
TOTALS 699,255 44.95% 727,007 46.06% 27,752 1.11%
2001 2002
19
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
ALLOCATION OF COSTS
• Allocation of costs refers to attributing the cost of the Blue Box System to individual materials to set material fees
• Net costs (gross cost less revenue) represent ~82% of fees
• Although fees are expressed as $/tonne or ¢/kg, fees are NOT determined according to weight
20
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
ALLOCATION OF GROSS COSTS
• Fees are established by first determining the gross costs & revenues for management of each material
• Gross costs for managing each material are determined using “activity-based costing” (ABC)
Outlined in Blue Box Program Plan (BBPP), Appendix IX
• For 2003 fees => costs allocated using the best available data from studies using similar ABC approach
• MPAC recommended further allocation studies (field study of municipal programs) to establish 2004 material costs
21
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
ACTIVITY-BASED COSTING (ABC)
1. ABC assigns costs to the activities which incurred the costs, e.g. labour cost for sorting, cost of wire for baling, cost of fuel for collection, cost of hydro for running magnets, capital cost of conveyors
2. ABC then allocates these costs to individual materials based on what caused the cost, e.g. time spent sorting PET, quantity of wire used for newsprint bales, portion of fuel for collecting volume of cardboard, hydro for magnetic separation of steel cans, capital cost of eddy current separator for aluminum
Minimizes the allocation of costs on an arbitrary basis, i.e. costs assigned that are not related to how costs actually incurred
Covers all aspects of program, incl. capital, operating and administration
22
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
ACTIVITY-BASED COSTING (ABC)
• The detailed set of principles by which the costs are assigned to activities and then to specific materials is presented in Appendix IX of BBPP
• The principles were developed by a subcommittee of Materials Packaging Advisory Committee (MPAC) in the fall of 2002
starting with earlier work of a municipal and industry task group
23
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
COST ALLOCATION PROJECT• Five municipal programs were studied in 2003/4
Both collection & processing operations
represent a range of systems, size, cost structures
• Field study involved conducting detailed operational
measurements time-motion studies of complete collection routes &
processing facility operations,
Building & capital equipment layout,
capital equipment & all operational costs, and
production & residue rates
• ABC analysis to determine gross cost to manage each
material in each program 24
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
COST ALLOCATION PROJECT
• Extrapolate gross cost for each material province-wide assigned weighting factor to each program
represented the proportion of total tonnes marketed in the province
managed by that type of program
for each material => Sum of gross cost multiplied by weighting
factor from applicable program
• Report will be available results,
observations about operations,
possible recommendations on how to improve the approach, and
a set of guidelines on how to conduct such ABC studies 25
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
2002 COSTS
• 2002 material costs calibrated to negotiated gross system cost of $150.5 million
• Negotiated gross cost higher for 2002 than 2001
~ $21.5 million
• Higher gross cost for all materials, except
glass (due to operational changes), and
boxboard (due to improved allocation method)
26
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
2002 COSTSCategory Material
2001 Cost ($/tonne)
2002 Recovery (tonnes)
2002 Cost ($/tonne)
PRINTED PAPERNewsprint, Magazines & Catalogues 85.00$ 381,809 90.00$ Telephone Books 85.00$ 6,461 124.00$ Other Printed Paper 85.00$ 21,485 159.00$
Printed Paper Total 85.00$ 409,754 94.19$
PACKAGINGPaper Based Packaging Old Corrugated Containers 270.00$ 87,705 372.00$
Gabletop & Aseptic Containers 350.00$ 46,602 728.00$ Old Boxboard 400.00$ 45,585 340.00$
Paper Packaging Total 315.00$ 134,980 364.63$ Plastic Packaging PET bottles 700.00$ 15,898 930.00$
HDPE bottles 770.00$ 8,964 877.00$ Plastic Film 900.00$ 2,702 1,338.00$ Polystyrene 870.00$ 886 1,613.00$ Other Plastics 870.00$ 1,047 866.00$
Plastics Total 756.00$ 31,928 997.68$ Steel Total 230.00$ 33,472 240.00$
Aluminum Total 557.00$ 10,776 733.18$ Glass Flint 190.00$ 59,613 144.00$
Coloured 190.00$ 46,484 137.00$ Glass Total 190.00$ 106,097 140.58$
PACKAGING TOTAL 311.64$ 317,253 352.83$
TOTALS 184.77$ 727,007 207.05$ 27
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
2002 REVENUE• For total revenue,
WDO Cost Containment Committee agreed to use the 3-year average of municipally reported revenue ~$66.5 million
• Adjusted to account for municipalities not reporting 3 years of data
• For material specific revenue, The total municipally-reported revenue was
apportioned to individual materials based on the 3-year average of CSR price sheet
• a monthly survey of market prices This is consistent with approach used to establish
first year fees 28
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
COMPARISON OF SELECTED PRICES
Material2002 CSR
Price Sheet
Adjusted 3-yr average
using price sheet (2)
Mean (1) Min (1) Max (1)All Printed Paper 94$ 75$ 129$ 95$ 83$ OCC 114$ 97$ 148$ 106$ 77$ OBB 44$ 33$ 79$ 36$ 33$ All Paper Packaging 98$ 35$ 166$ 76$ 60$ PET 157$ 104$ 321$ 166$ 232$ HDPE 244$ 169$ 346$ 233$ 243$ Aluminum 1,650$ 1,052$ 2,068$ 1,709$ 1,559$ Steel 60$ 36$ 92$ 47$ 49$ Clear Glass 25$ 2$ 45$ 29$ 33$ Note:1. Reported revenue figures from programs managing more than 1,000 tonnes2. Prices after adjusting total municipally reported 3-year average revenues using 3-year average of price sheet
2002 Municipally - Reported Revenues
29
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
2002 REVENUE
• Lower for most materials, except ONP, polycoat, OBB & film
• Total 2002 revenue
~ $66.5 million
Total TotalMaterial Per Tonne Revenues Per Tonne Revenues
PRINTED PAPERONP/OMG/OTD 83.31$ 30,899,705$ 83.85$ 32,557,833$ Other Printed Paper 83.31$ 1,709,805$ 55.18$ 1,185,428$
Printed Paper Total 83.31$ 32,609,510$ 82.35$ 33,743,261$
PACKAGINGOld Corrugated Containers 81.46$ 7,156,834$ 68.24$ 5,984,761$ Polycoat & Aseptic 50.91$ 43,019$ 57.02$ 70,708$ Old Boxboard 37.95$ 1,733,081$ 44.16$ 2,012,888$
Paper Pack'g Total 66.26$ 8,932,934$ 59.77$ 8,068,357$ PET bottles 246.22$ 3,382,081$ 228.96$ 3,639,873$ HDPE bottles 259.18$ 2,064,103$ 241.24$ 2,162,354$ Plastic Film 6.48$ 8,942$ 7.02$ 18,960$ Polystyrene 115.71$ 59,010$ 88.60$ 78,542$ Other Plastics 3.70$ 10,178$ 1.75$ 1,837$
Plastics Total 204.69$ 5,524,314$ 184.84$ 5,901,566$ Steel Total 54.61$ 1,779,393$ 49.13$ 1,644,307$
Aluminum Total 1,605.06$ 17,455,025$ 1,552.70$ 16,732,651$ Flint 10.72$ 577,557$ 6.01$ 358,218$ Coloured (3.63)$ (176,614)$ -$ -$
Glass Total 3.91$ 400,943$ 3.38$ 358,218$
PACKAGING TOTAL 110.76$ 34,092,609$ 103.09$ 32,705,099$
TOTALS 95.39$ 66,702,120$ 91.40$ 66,448,360$
2002 Revenue2001 Revenue
30
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PROGRAM GROSS COSTS & REVENUES
• For 2001, the gross cost of the program negotiated to be
$129.2 million & revenue negotiated to be $66.7 million,
Net $62.5 million – limited survey
TotalMaterial Per Tonne Total Cost Per Tonne Revenues
PRINTED PAPERPrinted Paper Total 85.00$ 33,271,975$ 83.31$ 32,609,510$
PACKAGINGPaper Pack'g Total 315.07$ 42,478,120$ 66.26$ 8,932,934$
Plastics Total 756.47$ 20,416,310$ 204.69$ 5,524,314$ Steel Total 230.00$ 7,493,860$ 54.61$ 1,779,393$
Aluminum Total 557.00$ 6,057,375$ 1,605.06$ 17,455,025$ Glass Total 190.00$ 19,484,880$ 3.91$ 400,943$
PACKAGING TOTAL 311.64$ 95,930,545$ 110.76$ 34,092,609$
TOTALS 184.77$ 129,202,520$ 95.39$ 66,702,120$
Gross Cost 2001
Revenues 2001
31
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PROGRAM GROSS COSTS & REVENUES
• For 2002, the gross cost of the program negotiated to be
$150 million & revenue to be $66 million, net $84 million –
mostly due to better data
TotalMaterial Per Tonne Total Cost Per Tonne Revenues
PRINTED PAPERPrinted Paper Total 94.00$ 38,579,990$ 82.35$ 33,743,261$
PACKAGINGPaper Pack'g Total 364.00$ 49,180,832$ 59.77$ 8,068,357$
Plastics Total 998.00$ 31,851,083$ 184.84$ 5,901,566$ Steel Total 240.00$ 8,033,247$ 49.13$ 1,644,307$
Aluminum Total 733.00$ 7,899,153$ 1,552.70$ 16,732,651$ Glass Total 141.00$ 14,952,549$ 3.38$ 358,218$
PACKAGING TOTAL 353.00$ 111,916,864$ 103.09$ 32,705,099$
TOTALS 207.00$ 150,496,853$ 91.40$ 66,448,360$
Gross Cost 2002
Revenues 2002
32
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
2002 NET COSTS – Printed Paper
• Negotiated Total System Net costs ~ $21.5 million higher• Printed Paper net cost ~ $4.2 million higher
~ 6% of total system net cost ~ 20% of the “increase” in system net cost
Change in Net Cost
Per Total Per TotalMaterial Tonne Net Cost Tonne Net Cost
PRINTED PAPERNewsprint 1.69$ 592,910$ 6.15$ 2,254,068$ 1,661,157$
Magazines and Catalogues 1.69$ 24,374$ 6.15$ 92,661$ 68,288$
Telephone Books 1.69$ 10,446$ 40.15$ 259,388$ 248,942$
Other Printed Paper 1.69$ 34,735$ 103.82$ 2,230,612$ 2,195,877$
Printed Paper Total 1.69$ 662,465$ 11.80$ 4,836,729$ 4,174,264$
TOTALS 89.38$ 62,500,400$ 115.61$ 84,048,493$ 21,548,093$
Net Cost of Current System
Net Cost of 2001 System
33
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
2002 NET COSTS – Packaging
• Packaging net cost ~ $17.4 million higher ~ 94% of total system net cost ~ 80% of the “increase” in system net cost
Change in Net Cost
Per Total Per TotalMaterial of Total Tonne Net Cost Tonne Net Cost
PACKAGINGPaper Pack'g Total 248.81$ 33,545,186$ 304.58$ 41,112,475$ 7,567,289$
Plastics Total 551.78$ 14,891,996$ 812.75$ 25,949,517$ 11,057,520$
Steel Total 175.39$ 5,714,467$ 190.87$ 6,388,940$ 674,473$ Aluminum Total (1,048.06)$ (11,397,650)$ (819.70)$ (8,833,498)$ 2,564,152$
Glass Total 186.09$ 19,083,937$ 137.56$ 14,594,331$ (4,489,606)$
PACKAGING TOTAL 200.89$ 61,837,936$ 249.68$ 79,211,765$ 17,373,829$
TOTALS 89.38$ 62,500,400$ 115.61$ 84,048,493$ 21,548,093$
Net Cost of Current SystemNet Cost of 2001 System
34
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING MATERIAL LEVIES
• After setting material gross cost & revenues =>
net costs,
The Industry portion of total net system cost is
allocated to each material based on three
weighting factors:
1. Recovery Rate – 40% of total cost to industry
2. Net Cost – 40% of total cost to industry
3. Equalization Factor – 20% of total cost to industry
35
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING MATERIAL LEVIES– Recovery Factor
Recovery Rate Calculation – 40% of net cost Recovery rates are compared relative to one another
• by comparing each to the mean
Separate calculations for printed paper and packaging Net costs allocated so that levy ($/tonne) is:
• higher for materials with lower recovery rates• lower for materials with higher recovery rates, and• the same for materials with the same recovery rate
The total levy ($) will be proportional to tonnes generated
36
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING MATERIAL LEVIES – Net Cost Factor
Net Cost Calculation – 40% of net cost Levies are proportional to each material’s percentage
of the system current net cost
40% of the net system cost is allocated in proportion to the cost of managing each material in the Blue Box system
• E.g, if the net cost of managing a material represents 5% of the total net cost of the current Blue Box program, it is assigned 5% of $ allocated to the net cost levy (40%)
37
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING MATERIAL LEVIES – Equalization Factor
Equalization Calculation – 20% of net cost
A means of promoting fairness in sharing costs
• by accounting for different $/tonne to manage materials, and
• compensating for different current recycling rates,
• by assuming all materials are recycled at the same rate
Determine the net incremental cost to manage 75% recovery of each material
Incremental cost to manage 75% recovery calculated by:
1. multiplying 75% of the tonnes generated by the net cost per tonne to manage a given material, &
2. subtracting the current net cost 38
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING MATERIAL LEVIES – Equalization Factor
Equalization Calculation – 20% of net cost
Levies ($) are proportional to each material’s percentage of the incremental cost (over the current system) of the system in which all materials recycled at the same rate (75% recovery)
• E.g, if the cost to manage 75% recovery of a material represents 5% of the total incremental cost to manage 75% of all materials, it is assigned 5% of the $ allocated to Equalization (20%)
39
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING MATERIAL LEVIES – Base Levy
• Sum of each of three levies assigned to each material
Recovery Rate Factor levy + Net Cost Factor levy + Equalization Factor levy
• Changing the weightings (40%, 40% and 20%) will have an impact on the levies assigned to each material, currently
• weightings established through a series of sensitivity analyses to minimize variance of levies between material categories
40
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PRELIMINARY 2004 BASE FEES
Rec. Rate Net Cost Percentage Equalization Combined Base Fee100% minus Allocated Net Cost Allocated of Costs at Allocated Base Total
Recovery Fee/Tonne Fee/Tonne 75% Recovery Fee/Tonne Allocated Fee/TonneMaterial Rate Generated Generated Rate Generated Fees GeneratedWeight for Factor 40.0% 40.0% 20.0%
PRINTED PAPERPrinted Paper 44.02% 1.32$ 100.00% 1.32$ 100.00% 0.66$ 2,418,100$ 3.30$
PACKAGINGPaper Based Packaging 59.38% 17.52$ 51.90% 24.74$ 17.91% 4.27$ 15,462,745$ 46.53$ Plastics Packaging 86.62% 27.86$ 32.76% 21.74$ 78.73% 26.12$ 18,075,484$ 75.72$ Steel Packaging 51.56% 14.55$ 8.07% 18.49$ 1.59% 1.82$ 2,409,109$ 34.86$ Aluminum Packaging 60.05% 17.77$ -11.15% (65.49)$ 0.00% -$ (1,287,086)$ (47.72)$
Glass Packaging 40.86% 10.49$ 18.42% 16.27$ 1.77% 0.78$ 4,941,648$ 27.55$
Factor Allocation to Printed Paper 2,418,100$ Factor Allocation to Packaging 39,601,900$
Recovery Rate Factor (1)
Net Cost Factor Equalization Factor
41
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
OTHER COSTS
• Other program costs & WDO & SO Administration added to the base levy, e.g. Ensuring compliance Market development Effectiveness & Efficiency Fund Program audits – cost containment Start-up WDO & SO Admin, e.g. annual financial & tonnage
datacall
42
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
OTHER COSTS
Material
Annualized Mandated
Program Costs for 2003 Fees
(1)
2004 Budget (2)
Annualized Mandated
Program Costs for 2004 Fees
(3)
Market Development 3,000,000$ 2,453,500$ 2,407,000$ Feasibility Studies 500,000$ 508,300$ 600,000$ Glass Investment 2,500,000$ 1,945,200$ 1,807,000$
MOE & SO Compliance 400,000$ 301,700$ 270,000$ Other Programs 750,000$ 462,500$ 300,000$ SO Program Delivery & Administration 1,842,300$ 2,739,100$ 3,943,000$ Start-up 750,000$ 750,000$ 875,000$ WDO Administration -$ 710,000$ 1,420,000$ Total 6,742,300$ 7,416,800$ 9,215,000$ Notes1) Fees for 2003 cover 5 months but figures are annualized since they are set based on material generated annually2) Figures represent budget for 20043) Fees for 2004 cover 6 months but figures are annualized since they are set based on material generated annually
43
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CALCULATING FINAL LEVIES
• A factor to account for de minimis & projected Year 1 compliance rate is applied.
De minimis:
• small businesses are exempt from paying levies
• < $2,000,000 in annual Ontario sales, or
• < 15 tonnes of Blue Box material generated
Compliance:
• It will take time to “capture” all stewards
• Lower rates are assumed for first year as program is established
44
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PRELIMINARY 2004 FEES – Printed Paper
Material
($) (¢/kg) ($) (¢/kg) ($) (¢/kg) (%)PRINTED PAPER
Newsprint 135,186$ 0.028$ 135,186$ 0.026$ -$ (0.002)$ -6.2%
Magazines and Catalogues 72,890$ 0.081$ 189,124$ 0.310$ 116,234$ 0.23$ 281.1%
Telephone Books 11,783$ 0.081$ 101,695$ 0.687$ 89,912$ 0.61$ 750.7%
Other Printed Paper 327,395$ 0.251$ 1,771,779$ 1.318$ 1,444,384$ 1.07$ 425.3%
547,253$ 0.084$ 2,197,784$ 0.334$ 1,650,530$ 0.25$ 297.3%
2003 Fee 2004 Fee ($) Change in Fee
• Figures represent total fees for printed paper including, Base Fee, Other programs, Program Delivery, Administration & Start-up
adjusted to account for compliance & de minimis factors
• Figures for Newsprint are after the deduction for in-kind contribution of $1.3million
45
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CNA/OCNA IN-KIND CONTRIBUTION• The in-kind contribution ($1.3 million) is deducted from the fees of CNA/OCNA stewards (excluding the SO & WDO administration & start-up
costs).
• Deduction should not apply to fees for non-CNA/OCNA generated newsprint
• Calculation not presented in this way in BBPP & in information on 2004 fees
a reliable figure for the quantity of non-CNA/OCNA material will not be available until stewards have filed their sales figures
• Therefore, it is proposed that once data are filed, the fees will be adjusted accordingly.
• Preliminary audit data suggest that up to 20% to 30% of the newsprint could be generated by stewards who are not part of CNA/OCNA. Given
this, Preliminary 2004 fee for non-CNA/OCNA stewards could be ~ 0.241¢/kg
Part of the administration fee currently allocated to CNA/OCNA members will be distributed to non CNA/OCNA members, maintaining the per-kg levy for
CNA/OCNA members
46
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PRELIMINARY 2004 FEES – Packaging
• Figures represent total fees for packaging including, Base Fee, Other programs, Program Delivery, Administration &
Start-up, • adjusted to account for compliance & de minimis factors
Material
($) (¢/kg) ($) (¢/kg) ($) (¢/kg) (%)PACKAGING
Paper Packaging Total 15,384,507$ 4.728$ 19,894,872$ 5.987$ 4,510,365$ 1.26$ 26.6%
Plastics Total 15,538,623$ 6.692$ 22,940,760$ 9.611$ 7,402,137$ 2.92$ 43.6%
Steel Total 2,466,921$ 3.633$ 3,033,899$ 4.391$ 566,978$ 0.76$ 20.8%
Aluminum Total (1,895,764)$ (5.465)$ (862,833)$ (3.199)$ 1,032,931$ 2.27$ 41.5%Non-LCBO - Flint 2,740,229$ 3.723$ 2,728,602$ 3.682$ (11,627)$ (0.04)$ -1.1%Non-LCBO - Coloured 819,356$ 4.016$ 802,775$ 3.916$ (16,581)$ (0.10)$ -2.5%LCBO Glass 4,750,000$ -$ 4,750,000$ -$ -$ -$ -
Glass Total 8,309,585$ -$ 8,281,376$ -$ (28,208)$ -$ -
2003 Fee 2004 Fee ($) Change in Fee
47
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PRELIMINARY 2004 FEES – Selected Paper Items
Packaging Type
Product Packaging ExampleUnit
Weight (Grams)
Cents/kgEstimated
Fee Cents/Unit
Cents/kgEstimated
Fee Cents/Unit
Printed Paper Daily Newspaper 249 0.03 0.0069 0.03 0.0065
Magazine - large 820 0.08 0.07 0.31 0.25
Magazine - small monthly 251 0.08 0.02 0.31 0.08
Catalogue - large 1450 0.08 0.12 0.31 0.45
Paper Paperboard box - 525 g cereal 104 4.73 0.49 5.99 0.62
Packaging Paperboard box - 312 g waffles 40 4.73 0.19 5.99 0.24
Egg Carton 53 4.73 0.25 5.99 0.32
Corrugated case 210 4.73 0.99 5.99 1.26
Kraft bag - 4 kg of pet food 82 4.73 0.39 5.99 0.49
Polycoat 2 litre milk carton 63 4.73 0.30 5.99 0.38
1 litre milk carton 41 4.73 0.19 5.99 0.25
250 ml drinking box 10 4.73 0.05 5.99 0.06
2003 Fees 2004 Fees
48
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PRELIMINARY 2004 FEES – Selected Packaging
Packaging Type
Product Packaging ExampleUnit
Weight (Grams)
Cents/kgEstimated
Fee Cents/Unit
Cents/kgEstimated
Fee Cents/Unit
Ferrous 1.36 litre juice can 153 3.63 0.56 4.39 0.67
Aluminum 355 ml soft drink can 15 -5.46 -0.08 -3.20 -0.05
Glass 473 ml juice bottle 228 3.72 0.85 3.68 0.84
Plastics 2 Litre PET bottle 58 6.69 0.39 9.61 0.56
HDPE - 2. 6 L dishwashing soap 149 6.69 1.00 9.61 1.43
PP - yogurt cup (no lid) 6 6.69 0.04 9.61 0.06
HDPE - carry out bag (large) 13 6.69 0.09 9.61 0.12
LDPE - outer milk bag 8 6.69 0.05 9.61 0.08
PS - half pint blueberries 10 6.69 0.07 9.61 0.10
Laminant Pasta bag 5 6.69 0.03 9.61 0.05
Frozen concentrated juice can 29 4.73 0.14 5.99 0.17
Multiple Frozen Entrée - Paper 28 4.73 0.13 5.99 0.17
Packaging Frozen Entrée - Plastic 25 6.69 0.17 9.61 0.24
2003 Fees 2004 Fees
49
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
CONSULTATION 0N 2004 FEES• Need to submit 2004 fees to Minister by March 31, 2004
Consulting on: Preliminary 2004 Fees Process for Setting 2005 Fees
Proposed Timeline: MPAC & Stewards Initial Review February 17 Stewardship Ontario Board February 20 Seminar & Webcast for Stewards & Stakeholders March 2 Last Date for Comments March 10 Report to Stewardship Ontario Board March 10 SO Board Approval of Recommended Fees March 15 Report to WDO Board March 16 WDO Board Approval of Recommended Fees March 23
50
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PROPOSED PROCESS TO SET 2005 FEES
• Blue Box Program Plan says submit preliminary 2005 fees to Stewards by August 15, 2004
• Plan says establish final 2005 fees by November 1, 2004
Issues:
Completion of 2003 data verification & set total net system cost
Revisit Funding Formula => 40:40:20 allocation of net cost
Additional cost allocation study
51
Draft for CONSULTATION – Preliminary Material Levies for Obligated Stewards for 2004
PROPOSED PROCESS TO SET 2005 FEESProposed Timeline:
Task or Milestone
2003 Datacall Submission Deadline
Data verification
Set 2003 Total Net System Cost
Possible Additional Cost Allocation Analysis
Consultation on Pay-in Formula
Finalize Pay-in Formula (Board Approval)
x
Market Development Strategies
Submit Preliminary 2005 Fees x
Consultation on Preliminary 2005 Fees
Recommend Final 2005 Fees x
Final 2005 Fees x
May June July Aug. Dec.Sept. Oct. Nov.
52
DATES TO REMEMBER
• Blue Box Plan Approved• December 22, 2003
• Steward Obligations Effective• February 1, 2004
• Steward Pre-Registration• Began on January 21, 2004
• www.stewardshipontario.ca
• Deadline to Register & Pay Fees• April 20, 2004
54
ADDITIONAL CONSULTATION
• Week of March 8, 2004
Public Consultation
• see www.stewardshipontario.ca
• webcast 1:00 pm, March 11
Municipal Consultation
• see www.wdo.ca
• webcast 9:30 am, March 11
55
KEY NEXT STEPS
• Steward Deadline for Comment• Wednesday, March 10
• Write to: [email protected]
• Stewardship Board• Monday, March 15
• WDO Board• Tuesday, March 23
• Minister of the Environment• Wednesday, March 31
56
ADDITIONAL SUPPORT
• Stewardship Ontario Membership Services www.stewardshipontario.ca
1-888-288-3360
Stewardship Ontario26 Wellington Street East, Suite 601Toronto, Ontario M5E 1S2
57