woodlawn avenue underpass clearance improvement · introduction woodlawn avenue underpass clearance...

48
WOODLAWN AVENUE WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS UNDERPASS CLEARANCE CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT IMPROVEMENT Presented by: Presented by: Andrew Avery, P.E., City of Elmira Andrew Avery, P.E., City of Elmira Mark Mark Horschel Horschel , P.E. Bergmann Associates , P.E. Bergmann Associates Bergmann Associates Presented to: Presented to: 10 10 th th Statewide Conference Statewide Conference on Local Bridges on Local Bridges

Upload: others

Post on 11-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

WOODLAWN AVENUE WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASSUNDERPASSCLEARANCE CLEARANCE

IMPROVEMENTIMPROVEMENT

Presented by:Presented by:Andrew Avery, P.E., City of ElmiraAndrew Avery, P.E., City of ElmiraMark Mark HorschelHorschel, P.E. Bergmann Associates, P.E. Bergmann Associates

Bergmann Associates

Presented to:Presented to:1010thth Statewide Conference Statewide Conference on Local Bridgeson Local Bridges

Page 2: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Presentation Overview

Andy Avery:IntroductionCoordination

NYSDOTRailroad

Page 3: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Presentation Overview

Test Pits Foundation ReportFoundation AlternativesStructural PlansConstruction Photos

Mark Horschel:Development of Plans

Page 4: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Introduction

Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project

Background Information:City Owned Street (AADT 7000)Urban Minor ArterialAdded to MPO LRP 19941996 Truck Route Study Recommended as Secondary Truck Route2002 – Signed as NYSDOT Route 14

Page 5: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Project SpecificsIncreased Vertical Clearance at Bridge

(12.3 ft. to 14.0 ft.) without Alterations to Superstructure

Improved Sight Distance and Geometry

Page 6: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Project SpecificsMade Sidewalk Continuous Through Project

on Both Sides of Road.

BEFORE

AFTER

Page 7: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Project Specifics

Upgraded / Replaced Underground UtilitiesImproved Roadway Drainage

BEFORE

AFTER

Page 8: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Project SpecificsNew Aesthetic Retaining Wall

BEFORE

AFTER

Page 9: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Project SpecificsSeparate the Combined Sewer SystemAdded Pump Station for New Storm SewerBuilt Underground Detention Vault (55,000 gal)

Page 10: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Project Specifics

Length of Project Approx: ½ MileConstruction Cost: $2.25 Million

Page 11: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Coordination NYSDOT Region 6

Programmed in MPO TIP 1997Locally Administered Federal Aid ProjectDOT Region 6 Agreed to Let City Negotiate with

Norfolk Southern.

Page 12: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Coordination - Railroad

Norfolk Southern Railroad

2001 Notification of Superstructure Deficiencies2002 Notification of Substructure Deficiencies50/50 Sharing for Substructure Cost with NSPlan Review/Approval by RailroadTotal Time (Substructure Notification Through

Construction Approx. 5 Mos.

Page 13: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Information

Original Plan 18993 Simple Spans (11.5’ – 32.5’ – 11.5’)Riveted Steel ConstructionNo SkewStone Masonry Abutments

Page 14: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Information

Carries 3 Tracks (2 Mainline, 1 Yard)10 Trains/Day for Each Mainline Track50-100 Cars per TrainBridge Narrowed Circa 1936Bridge Raised at Later Date

Page 15: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Investigation

Plans – Lower Roadway to Increase Vertical Clearance

Page 16: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Investigation

Movement of Steel Pier Columns NoticedTest Pit Dug at Each Pier Column

Page 17: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Investigation

Page 18: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Investigation

Page 19: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Investigation

Page 20: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Bridge Investigation

Page 21: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Foundation Report

Weak Soils, Allow Bearing Capacity 5 ksf

Minipiles, Est. Cost $470K

Spread Footing, Est. Cost $190K SELECTED

Page 22: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Railroad Requirements

Plan Review and Approval Required

All Tracks Must Remain Open

Allowed Train Slow Down

Live Load Cooper E-80

Railroad Flagman During Entire Construction

Page 23: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

DesignPier Section

Page 24: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

DesignPier Plan

Page 25: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Jacking Systems Investigated

Timber Cribbing

Combination of Timber Cribbing & Steel Jacking Beams SELECTED

Page 26: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

DesignStaging – Phase I

Page 27: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

DesignStaging Phase 2

Page 28: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Jacking SystemCribbing from New Footing

Page 29: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Jacking SystemBeam Details - 1

Page 30: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Jacking SystemBeam Details - 2

Page 31: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

CONSTRUCTION

PHOTOS

Page 32: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 33: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 34: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 35: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 36: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 37: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 38: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 39: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 40: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 41: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 42: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 43: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 44: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 45: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 46: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban
Page 47: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

Summary

Total Duration of Work for RR Piers - 5 Mos.(Test Pits Through Construction)

Norfolk Southern Shared Cost of Piers 50/50

Project Completed on Schedule

Added Construction Cost - $190K

Page 48: WOODLAWN AVENUE UNDERPASS CLEARANCE IMPROVEMENT · Introduction Woodlawn Avenue Underpass Clearance Improvement Project Background Information: 9City Owned Street (AADT 7000) 9Urban

THANK YOU!

QUESTIONS ?