women & guerrilla movements
DESCRIPTION
WOMEN & GUERRILLA MOVEMENTS. ILEANA RODRIGUEZ: CORRECTING THE ERASURE OF WOMEN AS ACTORS IN REVOLUTIONARY TRANSFORMATION. WOMAN AS “REVOLUTIONARY PUSSY” FEMINIZATION OF EPISTEMOLOGIES. 2. ELIZABETH BURGOS DEBRAY & RIGOBERTA MENCHU. CONSTITUTION OF WOMAN AS SUBJECT - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
1
WOMEN & GUERRILLA
MOVEMENTS
2
ILEANA RODRIGUEZ: CORRECTING THE
ERASURE OF WOMEN AS ACTORS IN
REVOLUTIONARY TRANSFORMATION
• WOMAN AS “REVOLUTIONARY PUSSY”• FEMINIZATION OF EPISTEMOLOGIES
2
3
ELIZABETH BURGOS DEBRAY & RIGOBERTA MENCHU
• CONSTITUTION OF WOMAN AS SUBJECT
• NARRATIVE OF RESISTANCE• HOW WELL DOES KAMPWIRTH DO
THIS?
3
4
THEORIES• ESCOBAR & ALVAREZ
– TRADITIONAL ACTORS, – Revolutionary Upheaval– MARXISM & FOCO STRATEGY
• FEMINIST CRITIQUE• NSM (NEW SOCIAL MOVEMENTS)
• ESCOBAR: CULTURAL & POLTICAL STRUGGLES– IDENTITY– STRATEGY– DEMOCRACY
• DORE, CHINCHILLA, STARN
4
5
SO WHAT HAS CHANGED?
• THEORISTS?• OLD / NEW ACTORS?• NEW KINDS OF MOVEMENTS?• HOW WOULD KAMPWIRTH RESPOND?• STRUCTURE, AGENCY, & COLLECTIVE
IDENTITIES
5
6
JOAN CAIVANO & THAYER HARDWICK
• NATURE, STRUCTURES, GOALS, & STRATEGIES
• GUERRILLAS, LEFTISTS, CONSERVATIVES
• 1970-80s GUERRILLAS OPPOSE DICTATORSHIPS– PINOCHET– WOMEN FILL VACUUM– REPRESSION CROSS-CUT CLASS LINES
6
7
PARADOX:• OPEN DEMOCRACIES – WOMEN LACK
EQUITY IN GENDER RIGHTS• CLOSED MILITARY DICTATORSHIP –
HI LEVELS OF FEMALE MOBILIZATION• OBJECTIVE OF ENDING
DICTATORSHIP OBSCURED FUNDAMENTAL DIFFERENCES
• INSTITUTIONALIZATION OF GENDER ROLES
7
8
CENTRAL AMERICA• WOMEN’S ORGANIZATIONS GREW
OUT OF GUERRILLA MOVEMENTS– RARELY ENTERED WITH FEMINIST
GOALS IN MIND
8
9
WHAT FACTORS RADICALIZED WOMEN TO
JOIN GUERRILLA MOVEMENTS?
• MASS MOBILIZATION STRATEGY– FSLN (30%) & FMLN (40%) VS. CUBA (5%)
• LIBERATION THEOLOGY– “PREFERENTIAL OPTION FOR THE POOR”– CEBs
9
10
NICARAGUA• SANDINISTAS (FSLN) VS. SOMOZA• AMPRONAC AMNLAE
– LOYALTY & MACHISMO– DAISY ZAMORA:
“IT’S ABSOLUTELY TRUE THAT THE REVOLUTION OPENED UP A NEW SPACE FOR WOMEN. WE FOUGHT ALONGSIDE OUR MALE COMRADES & THAT PRODUCED AN EXPLOSION OF NEW POSSIBILITIES. BY THE END OF THE WAR THE OLD ORDER HAD BEEN COMPLETELY DISRUPTED, AND ALL THE WOMEN WHO HAD TAKEN PART HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO HELP CONSTRUCT A MORE JUST SOCIETY. I THINK THE PROBLEM WAS THAT THIS NEW SPACE WASN’T ACCOMPANIED BY A NEW MENTALITY ON THE PART OF MOST OF THE MALE-DOMINATED LEADERSHIP”
10
11
AUTONOMY?
• DIVISION AMONG WOMEN:– SUPPORT OF FSLN VS. AUTONOMY– THE FATE OF AMNLAE
11
12
EL SALVADOR• CO-MADRES
– SIMILAR TO MOTHERS OF THE PLAZA DE MAYO
– KIDNAPPINGS, TORTURE, RAPES– MERGING OF FEMININE & FEMINIST
INTERESTS
12
13
DIGNAS• DIGNAS & THE FMLN
– STRUGGLE FOR DIVERSITY, AUTONOMY, PARTICIPATORY DEMOCRACY
– ENCUENTROS, COALITION BUILDING– AUTONOMOUS ORGANIZATION– CLASS DIFFERENCES
MULTIPLE DIMENSIONS OF WOMEN’S OPPRESSION
13
14
DOBLE MILITANCIA• SUPPORT REVOLUTION & PROMISE OF A
NEW SOCIETY?• WORK FOR FEMINIST CAUSES IN AN
AUTONOMOUS ORGANIZATION?• GUATEMALA & URNG• COMANDANTE LOLA:
“IT WASN’T THAT WE DIDN’T CONSIDER GENDER ISSUES IMPORTANT, BUT THAT OUR LIFE WAS VERY HARD, FULL OF ACTIVITY DIRECTLY RELATED TO COMBAT, TO THE RECRUITMENT OF MILITARY UNITS”
14
15
AUTONOMOUS WOMEN’S MOVEMENTS AND NGOS
• RETURN TO DEMOCRACY• CUTS IN SOCIAL SPENDING• NGOs
– SKILLS GAINED BY WOMEN IN REVOLUTIONARY MOVEMENTS
– STATE FAILURE TO PROVIDE BASIC SERVICES
– ENCUENTROS & REGIONAL SOLIDARITY MOVEMENTS
15
16
NGOS CONFRONT GOVERNMENTS ON GENDER
ISSUES• GUATEMALA: GOVT. VS. NGOs• NICARAGUA, EL SALVADOR,
GUATEMALA– WOMEN’S REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS
• YET AUTONOMY MAY MARGINALIZE WOMEN & DIMINISH INFLUENCE ON POLICY
• PLAYING “MALE POLITICS”?16
17
IRONY:
• UNLIKE POLITICAL PARTIES AND SINGLE-ISSUE NGOS, WHICH ARE ROOTED IN SELF-INTEREST POLITICS,
• WOMEN’S SOCIAL MOVEMENTS UNDER THE DICTATORSHIPS WERE CHARACTERIZED BY SOLIDARITY AND COLLABORATION
17