what we will cover… - shipman & goodwin llp forum faculty... · 2016-10-06 · infrequent...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
© Shipman & Goodwin LLP 2016. All rights reserved.
The Americans with Disabilities Act
at Higher Education Institutions:
Addressing ADA Issues with Faculty
and Staff
Linda L. Yoder
Peter J. Murphy
Friday, October 7, 2016
What we will cover…
• Statutory and regulatory framework
• Judicial treatment of statutory and regulatory
language
• Focus areas for Higher Education
![Page 2: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Focus Areas for Discussion
• Institutions of Higher Learning Under Specific Scrutiny: Are we and should we be held to a higher standard?
• Developments in technology mean that old case law should be treated with caution
• Addressing mental health concerns
• Faculty are different
• How to analyze a new type of request: service animals
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)• 1990: Passage of ADA
� Expanded protection against disability discrimination to most employers, state and local governmental programs and providers of public accommodations
� 1999 and 2002: U.S. Supreme Court narrowed protection
� Determination of coverage could account for mitigating measures
� Narrower definition of “major life activity”
• 2008: ADA Amendments Act of 2008
� Reversed U.S. Supreme Court rulings
• 2010: Amended ADA Regulations published
• 2016: ADA Amendments Act Final Rule published
� Effective on October 11, 2016
� Implements the requirements of ADA Amendments Act of 2008
![Page 3: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Covered Entity’s Obligations • Prohibit discrimination on the basis of disability
� Title I: Employment
� Applies to employers with 15 or more employees (inclusive of faculty, staff, and student employees)
� Title II: Public Entities
� Applies if you are a state-run entity (e.g., a public college or university)
� Title III: Public Accommodations
� Applies if you are a private entity that offers a public accommodation (e.g., a private college or university)
• Provide reasonable accommodations and auxiliary aids and services
• Reasonably modify policies, practices, and procedures
“MEETING THE DEFINITION”
![Page 4: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Definition of a Disability
• A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities - OR -
• Regarded as impaired – OR - record of such an impairment
� Must be otherwise qualified
� Able to carry out the essential functions of the program with or without accommodations
• “Definition of disability shall be construed broadly in favor of expansive coverage, to the maximum extent permitted by the terms of the ADA.”
� Does not apply to transitory and minor impairments
� Generally determined without regard to ameliorative effects of mitigating measures
Judicial Trends• Cases since 2010
� Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has a “disability”
� However, courts have looked into whether certain mental health conditions entitle someone to ADA protection
� Focus more on qualification of individual and documentation
� Whether an individual is “otherwise qualified”
� Whether the documentation provided justifies the requested accommodation
![Page 5: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
When Can/Should You Intervene?
• Professor Paul is a long-time, tenured faculty member. Very highly regarded.
• Students voice concerns about unrelated “stories” being told in class, with little instruction.
• Co-workers also have noticed changes in his formerly-impeccable appearance, his office becoming messier, and him snapping at co-workers and demonstrating inability to work with colleagues in the department.
• What steps, if any, can you take?
Potential Steps
• Discussion with dean or department chair?
• Refer to EAP?
• Provide FMLA paperwork?
• Determine if he has a disability?
• Send for IME?
![Page 6: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Mental Health and Anxiety Issues
• Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult Dave, a senior member of the department who mentors all junior faculty in the department.
• Abby complains about Dave’s mentoring and interpersonal skills, and ultimately informs you that it is giving her anxiety.
• Abby asks for you to move her to another mentor as an accommodation, and refuses to work until such a change is made.
• Should Abby be given another mentor?
Is Abby Disabled?• Higgins-Williams v. Sutter Medical Foundation, 237 Cal. App. 4th 78
(Ca. Ct. App. May 26, 2015).
� Undisputed facts show that employee’s anxiety related solely to her
supervisor’s oversight.
� An employee’s inability to work under a particular supervisor because
of anxiety and stress related to the supervisor’s standard oversight
does not constitute a mental disability under California law.
• Pack v. Illinois Dep't of Healthcare & Family Servs., 2015 WL 507555,
at *3 (N.D. Ill. Feb. 5, 2015):
� “Because Plaintiff asserts that she is capable of working, just not at
IDHFS where [her current supervisor] is, Plaintiff has not sufficiently
alleged that she is disabled under the ADA.”
![Page 7: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Is Short-Term Illness a Disability?
• Adjunct Professor Peter had heart surgery in April.
• Summer classes start in May, and his classes are reassigned because the school has not heard from him. Peter demands to return to full duty after that reassignment has occurred.
• Peter is then only assigned two classes for the Fall Semester, instead of his normal four.
• Peter claims disability discrimination. The school claims he is not disabled.
• Who is correct?
Silk v. Bd. of Trustees, 795 F.3d 698 (7th Cir. July
30, 2015)
• Short-term illnesses are not covered by ADA:
� Employer’s belief not enough, however.
� Need to show impairment actually was transitory and minor.
Employer did not do that in this case.
• Perceived disability claims can be difficult.
� Even if not disabled, employee can succeed if shown that
employer perceived him as disabled.
� Adjunct identified alleged statements suggesting that the
college perceived him as disabled when assigning classes for the
Fall Semester.
![Page 8: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Potential for an IME?
• ADA prohibits IME unless it is:
� Job related, and
� Consistent with business necessity.
• Employer can meet that standard by showing:
� Employee has requested an accommodation;
� Employee has impaired ability to perform essential
functions of position; or
� Employee poses a direct threat to himself or others.
Potential for IME
• Hawthorne v. Oakland Univ., 158 F.Supp.3d 586 (E.D.Mich. Jan. 27, 2016):
� Associate Professor sent for three medical evaluations after negative, hostile interactions with students created unsafe learning environment.
� Professor had no right to injunction against future evaluations.
• Ellis v. San Francisco State Univ.,136 F.Supp.3d 1140 (N.D.Cal. Dec. 22, 2015):
� Professor suspended and then terminated after refusing to submit to IME .
![Page 9: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
IS THE DOCUMENTATION
SUFFICIENT?
Documentation
• What is required?
• How recent?
• What professionals are qualified to provide documentation?
� What level of deference should be afforded to the evaluating professional?
• Who must pay for documentation?
• Must documentation demonstrate a connection between the disability and the requested accommodation?
![Page 10: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Documentation
• ADA Amendments Act of 2008
� Rejected heightened standard for demonstrating
disability
� Generally, there is no requirement that
documentation must be presented to obtain legal
protections guaranteed by ADA
Documentation
• Purpose:
� Establishing disability of faculty or staff member.
� Permissible sources: self-report, observations from
college staff and/or information from external parties
� Individualized process
� Understanding how the condition may affect the
employee.
� Make informed decision about what, if any,
accommodations are necessary.
![Page 11: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
Documentation Process
• Common-sense standard
• What would a reasonable person conclude?
• Requiring extensive medical or scientific evidence likely beyond reasonable.
• Non-burdensome process
� Does the process discourage, even if not the intent, employees with disabilities from seeking accommodations?
� How long is the process?
Smith v. UCONN, 794 F.3d 249 (2d Cir. July 22,
2015)
• Employee worked in dining hall.
• Walked off line after feeling ill, believing his
bronchitis was returning.
• Employee terminated per college policy.
• Employee’s lawsuit failed, as only illness
alleged in the complaint was bronchitis, which
is not a disability under the ADA.
![Page 12: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
IS THE EMPLOYEE OTHERWISE
QUALIFIED?
Otherwise Qualified
• Is the employee eligible to performance the essential functions of the job, either with or without reasonable accommodations?
• If incapable of performing the essential functions of the job, the employee is not a “qualified individual” under the ADA.
• Query: Is there a job description? How do you define the essential functions of faculty member? Does this differ by department and where can I find this information in writing?
![Page 13: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
Badwal v. Bd. of Trustees, 139 F.Supp.3d 295
(D.C.DC Sept. 28, 2015)
• Professor developed ailment that prevented the normal use of his arms for classroom duties (e.g. writing on the chalkboard).
• Professor went out on leave, and then retired.
• Professor later claimed that the college forced him to retire, and had failed to accommodate him.
• Court found Professor not a “qualified individual.”
� Allegations in the complaint showed he was physically incapable of performing his teaching duties.
Snowden v. Columbia Univ., 612 F.Appx 7 (2d
Cir. Apr. 6, 2015)
• Mail clerk at university was terminated because she could not do essential functions—e.g. bending, stooping, sorting, and filing.
• Because Plaintiff could not do these essential functions, she was not a qualified individual.
• Plaintiff also failed to identify any reasonable accommodation that would allow her to perform the job.
� Additional point: University did not engage in thorough interactive process. Court excused this error because there was no reasonable accommodation that could have been discussed with employee.
![Page 14: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Hypothetical
• Professor Brian informs you that his disability
is getting worse, and his psychological state
restricts him from face-to-face meetings.
• He requests to teach all classes on-line, and
never be asked to come to campus.
• Must the college make this accommodation?
Factors to Consider:
• What classes does he teach?
� Is there a reason that he must be present in-
person, such as interactive class discussion or
supervision of a laboratory?
• Does the school allow any on-line courses?
� How widely have you opened the door?
� Are their other reasons to come to campus?
� Departmental meetings, student meetings, etc.?
![Page 15: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
EEOC v. Ford Motor Co., 782 F.3d 753 (6th Cir.
Dec. 3, 2014)
• Courts will defer to employers on what constitutes an essential function of a job.
• “Common sense” dictates that in-person attendance and interaction with co-workers and consumers are essential functions of most jobs.
• Employee bears burden of proving accommodation is reasonable, and telecommuting can be reasonable.
• Employee’s request here is not reasonable because:
� No set schedule; wanted to pick days on no notice.
� Employee was refusing to come on site if needed.
Can Sleepy Sam Teach Remotely?
• Sleepy Sam served as a tenured professor and a coordinator of a community college's honors program.
• Sam has “severe problems falling asleep, sleeping undisturbed, and ... remaining awake when driving long distances.”
• Sam asked to “teach most of his course load and hold office hours remotely, via distance learning.”
• Was the request properly denied?
![Page 16: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Epstein v. Cty. of Suffolk, 2016 WL
4257349 (E.D.N.Y. Aug. 11, 2016)
• No. Plaintiff’s claim that he has trouble
sleeping is insufficient to establish disability.
• Court also concluded that work at the college
would not trigger his sleep disorders.
• Sleepy Sam could fall asleep at home or at
work.
ARE THE ACCOMMODATIONS
REASONABLE?
![Page 17: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
Accommodations
• Three categories
� Auxiliary aids and services—need not include devices or services of a personal nature
� Is the college/university financially responsible?
� Or could another agency such as state vocational rehabilitation program?
� Undue financial burden?
� Concerns: public backlash
� Modifications of policies, practices, and procedures
� Architectural/Design Features
Accommodations
• Burden on the institution (Not likely)
� Demonstrate that officials considered alternative means, feasibility, cost and effect on the program at issue and came to a rationally justifiable decision
� Including whether accommodation would either lower academic standards or require substantial program alternation
• Expectation that the institution AND employee engage in an interactive process when addressing accommodation requests
![Page 18: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
Accommodations
• Co-teacher: generally not required to pay two
people to do one job.
• Video Recording: no case law, but likely to be
considered a reasonable accommodation.
� How to handle professor who considered lectures
“intellectual property” and ban video/audio
recordings for students?
Accommodations
• Interpreters or transcription:
� Sign language interpreters are provided to students,
do they need to be provided to professors, too?
• Modification of tenure clock: courts are typically
deferential to educational institutions in
determining tenure requirements and timelines.
� If out on FMLA leave, does that stop the clock?
� Is there a section in the faculty handbook discussing
grounds to stop the tenure clock?
![Page 19: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Safety Concerns
• Even if an employee is disabled, he or she can still be terminated for misconduct even if it is connected to a disability.
• See Mayo v. PCC Structurals, 795 F.3d 941 (9th Cir. 2015)
� (“Put simply, the ADA does not require that an employee whose unacceptable behavior threatens the safety of others be retained, even if the behavior stems from a mental disability. Such an employee is not qualified.).
Prepare For/Avoid Retaliation Claims
• Many institutions of higher education have
loose supervision/performance review
procedures.
• Who makes decisions regarding class
assignments, courses taught, and is there a
clear mechanism for deciding disputes?
• Can you limit retaliation claims by limiting
knowledge of the disability/accommodation?
![Page 20: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
SERVICE AND COMFORT ANIMALS
Service Animals• Legal term under the ADA
� “A dog [or miniature horse] individually trained to work or
perform tasks…”
� Excludes comfort or emotional support animals
� No limit on breed or size
• Can accompany a person with a disability in all areas open to
the public
� Must be tethered unless device interferes with the animal’s
work
� May only be excluded if 1) the animal is out of control and the
handler does not take effective action to control or 2) the
animal is not housebroken
![Page 21: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Service Animals
• Only two questions may be asked:
� Is the dog (horse) a service animal required because of a disability?
� What work or task has the dog been trained to perform?
• Staff cannot ask about the person’s disability, require
documentation or special identification card, or ask that the
animal demonstrate its ability to perform the work or task
• ADA provides protection under Title II (public entities) and
Title III (public accommodations)
� Employment and housing context not addressed but would be part of
the interactive process and request for accommodation under Title I
or Section 504
Emotional Support Animals• No protection under ADA Title II or Title III
• Be careful in defining the term: does a comfort animal
perform a service to someone with PTSD or an anxiety
disorder?
• However, the protection possible under the Fair Housing Act
(“FHA”), which has a broad definition of eligible animals (not
limited to dogs) who may serve as “assistance animals”
� Do you have faculty housing?
� Has been found applicable to student housing facilities on
campus See U.S. v. Univ. of Nebraska, 940 F. Supp. 2d 974
(D. Neb. 2013)
![Page 22: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Emotional Support Animals• May be kept in a dwelling unit as a reasonable accommodation if:
� Person has a disability;
� Animal is necessary to afford an equal opportunity to use or
enjoy the dwelling; and
� An identifiable relation or nexus exist between the person's
disability and the assistance provided by the animal
• May be denied or removed if:
� Animal poses a direct threat to health and safety of others;
� Would cause substantial physical damage to the property of
others;
� Would pose an undue financial and administrative burden; or
� Would fundamentally alter the nature of the provider’s
operations
MOVING FORWARD
![Page 23: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Create a Culture That is Accepting of
Diversity
• Plan for an aging population as well as a more
diverse work force.
• Design policies and procedures for universal
access/disabilities before a specific request is
made
• Advertise acceptance of a diverse population
• Do not use an ADA request as the time to
address a performance issue
Educate Faculty Regarding Care for
Colleagues • Who has responsibility to consider the affect of
disability on junior faculty member?
• Notice to senior faculty is likely notice to the institution
• Enforce the culture: do not ignore inappropriate comments or failure to implement accommodations in good faith
• Try to make faculty understand that what they say (or do not say) or write (e-mails) can and will be used against them (and the university) in a court of law
![Page 24: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
Involve the Faculty In the Process
• It is imperative to confer with faculty/staff and
organizations when designing procedures that
will affect individuals with disabilities:
� Extension of tenure timeline
� How will a reduction in course load affect the
reappointment/tenure timeline?
� What is appropriate to ask of faculty/individual
department members with regard to
accommodating colleagues?
Involve Faculty/Staff when
Addressing Student Accommodations• Accommodations for students in general and
specific students/courses
• Will faculty accept video recording/remote participation?
• How will group projects affect the ability of students with intermittent health conditions to participate?
• It is imperative to inform faculty in a timely way of accommodations for students?
![Page 25: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
Consider Faculty/Community Impact
When Designing for Students
• The focus on making a campus more user
friendly for students should include faculty
and staff
• Policies and practices need to be adjusted to
account for benefits of emerging technology
Questions?
![Page 26: What we will cover… - Shipman & Goodwin LLP Forum Faculty... · 2016-10-06 · Infrequent evaluation of whether an individual has ... •Associate Professor Abby’s mentor is Difficult](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022050606/5fad7e4fb08dc028491f9ade/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
Visit our blog!
• Visit our blog site,
www.ctschoollaw.com, where
we post information about
current school law issues
affecting colleges and
universities
• Subscribe for automatic
email updates: www.ctschoollaw.com/subscribe