what we are learning - lumina foundation · to build commitment with stakeholders 4) to set and...

26
What We are Learning Lumina Foundation’s Community Partnership for Attainment

Upload: others

Post on 19-Aug-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

What We are Learning

Lumina Foundation’s

Community Partnership for Attainment

Page 2: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

CPA Overview

75 U.S. Cities | 3 Cohorts

Catalytic Funding

Robust Technical Support

Page 3: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Evaluation Overview

Page 4: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Evaluation Framework

Policy Changes

and Practice

Postsecondary Outcomes at

Scale

Commitment

Building

Partnership

Data & Equity

Data

& E

quity

Social, Political, Economic Context

Data & Equity

Page 5: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Evaluation Methods

Broad Approach across 75 communities:

• Site lead interviews

• Document analysis of charters and site materials

• “Deeper” interaction through site visits

• Policy & Practice questionnaire

Page 6: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Partnership

Page 7: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

3 Types of Partnerships

Long-standing partnerships focused on postsecondary success

Established partnerships “stretching” into the post-secondary side of the cradle-to-career continuum

Emerging partnerships focused on postsecondary success

Page 8: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Partners spent time and effort early on establishing the structures to help move the work forward

Embedded structures: MOUs, Data-Sharing Agreements, In-

kind Support

Role clarity

Mission Alignment/Common Vision

Trust

“Our partnership works because we use each other well and unapologetically in mission-centered ways. Working inside your mission is absolutely essential for creating change at scale.”

Page 9: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Ensure diversity of partnership members and

decision-making

Executive/Leadership

Operational Core

Action GroupAction GroupAction Group

Diversity in decision-making

SectorOrganizational TypeOrganizational Role

Race/EthnicityGender

Community Standing

Page 10: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Commitment Building

Page 11: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Align the message, the messenger, and the audience

Page 12: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Leverage strong relationships to build connections and expand networks

Low-hanging fruit

Page 13: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Policy and Practice

Page 14: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Where would you say your partnership is spending the most time/effort working in?

1) Readiness

2) Enrollment

3) Persistence

4) Attainment

Page 15: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Emphasis on readiness, enrollment, and a connection to

career/workforce development

Student supports/wrap around advising or mentoring

Cohort advising/supportRemedial education

Boot camps/bridgesDevelopmental education redesign

College application workshops

Employer-based tuition benefitsDual enrollment

Curricula alignmentSummer melt texting campaigns Career/education

pathways

Readiness Enrollment Persistence Attainment

Page 16: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Policy and Practice

Partnerships:• Higher ed-K-12• Higher ed-CBO• K-12-CBO• Higher ed-Business• K-12-Business

Page 17: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Data

Page 18: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Webinar Survey

In which of the following ways do you use data?

a) To identify policy and practice changes/intervention points

b) To monitor partnership functions (work groups, committees, etc.) and implementation

c) To build commitment with stakeholders

d) To set and monitor progress toward attainment goals

Page 19: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

How is data considered and incorporated into Partnerships’ work?

1)To identify policy & practice changes/intervention points

2)To monitor partnership functions (work groups, committees, etc.) and implementation

3)To build commitment with stakeholders

4)To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals

“We could move the needle [on FAFSA

completion]. We wanted something we

could track. We had experts who could

educate… students and faculty. This is

our goal – let’s go attack it.”

Page 20: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Data disaggregation can help focus partnership efforts

Page 21: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

User-friendly data is key to prompting action

“[The backbone] makes our work better.

They create materials than can be used

by all of us, but that none of us could

produce on our own.”

Page 22: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Factors influencing site progress

Page 23: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Factors: Webinar Survey

Which of some factors which are influencing your work?

Page 24: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]

Factors

Moving from planning to

implementation and piloting to

scale

Alignment with other initiatives

Authentically engaging diverse

voices

Local, State, and National

Context: social, economic, political

Other Factors

Other Factors

Page 25: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]
Page 26: What We are Learning - Lumina Foundation · To build commitment with stakeholders 4) To set and monitor progress toward partnership goals “We could move the needle [on FAFSA completion]