what really happened in turkey on july 15, 2016? · fethullah gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
WhatReallyHappenedinTurkey
onJuly15,2016?
AnAlternativetotheTurkishGovernmentNarrative
ByAllianceforSharedValuesNewYork,NY
20July2017
![Page 2: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
AbouttheAllianceforSharedValuesInspiredbytheworkofMr.FethullahGulen,theAllianceforSharedValuesisanumbrellanon-profitorganizationservingasavoiceforcivic,cultureandserviceorganizationsaroundtheU.Sdedicatedtopromotingcommunityservice,educationandinterfaithdialogue.TheAlliance’smemberorganizationsarefoundedbyindividualswhoareparticipantsintheHizmetsocialinitiative.TheAllianceworkswithpeopleandorganizationsofallbackgroundsandfaithstopromotegreaterunderstanding,cooperateonmeaningfulprojects,andbuildstrongerbonds.AboutHizmetBeginningasagrassrootscommunityinTurkeyinthe1970s,Hizmettodayisatransnationalsocialinitiativethatadvocatesfortheidealsofhumanrights,equalopportunity,democracy,non-violenceandtheemphaticacceptanceofreligiousandculturaldiversity.Hizmet’sculturallyandreligiouslydiversesupportersareinspiredbythelifeandworksofFethullahGulen,oneoftheworld’smostimportantMuslimfiguresforhisdecades-longcommitmenttointerfaithtoleranceandaltruism.Hizmetparticipantsbringstolifetheseidealsbypromotingphilanthropyandcommunityservice,investingineducationforcultivatingvirtuousindividuals,andpromotinginterculturalandinterfaithdialogueforpeacefulcoexistence.Thispaperwillbeupdatedasnewinformationbecomesavailable.AnearlierversionfromJuly18,2017,underthetitle“WasJuly15Erdogan’sReichstagFire?”includedmaterialfrominappropriatepoliticalsourcesthathavebeenremoved.TheAllianceforSharedValuesregretstheerror.
![Page 3: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
ToplineTakeawaysOnJuly15,2016,Turkeyexperiencedahorrificevent.TheTurkishparliamentwasbombedandhundredsofsoldiersandcivilianslosttheirlives.Thiscoupattemptappearedtohavebeenplannedandexecutedwithremarkableincompetenceandwascrushedquickly.Ayearlater,thefailedcouphasbeenusedasapretexttolaunchanunprecedentedcrackdownonPresidentRecepTayyipErdogan’spoliticalopponentsandthefreepress,clearingthewayforthepresidenttoconsolidatepowerandensurehisplaceasTurkey’sleaderforyearstocome.Attheone-yearanniversaryofthisincident,manyquestionsremainunansweredwhileastateofemergencyremainsinplaceandthegovernment’sviciouspersecutionofpoliticaloppositionandthemediarageson.Thisdocumentwillexamine:
• TheErdogangovernment’songoingpurgesandcrackdowninTurkey,whichwereinitiatedwithsurprisingspeedandefficiency,andhavethusfarledtothearrestsofmorethan50,000peopleandthedismissalofnearly140,000others.Additionally,some234journalistshavebeenarrestedand149mediaoutletshavebeenshutteredbygovernmentdecree.ThestateofemergencyinitiallydeclaredbyPresidentErdoganhasbeenextendedseveraltimesandremainsinplaceoneyearafterthefailedcoup.
• TheErdogangovernment’srushtoblamethecouponFethullahGulen,despiteofferingnocredibleevidencetosupportthisclaim.WhileMr.Gulenhasdeniedanyinvolvementwiththecoup,andhaspubliclycondemneditanditsparticipants,theTurkishgovernmenthaslaunchedacoordinatedandconcertedefforttodefameGulenandholdhimresponsible.Meanwhile,severalreportsfromintelligenceagencieswithintheEuropeanUnionhavedebunkedtheallegationthatMr.Gulenorchestratedtheattemptedputsch.Inaddition,severalleadingUSintelligenceofficialshavepubliclychallengedtheideathatGulenwasbehindtheattempt.
• ThegrowingnumberofinconsistenciesinthenarrativeputforwardbyErdoganandseniorTurkishofficialsinthegovernment,militaryandintelligenceapparatus.Publicly,Erdoganhasofferedconflictingexplanationsaboutwhenandhowhebecameawareofthecoupattempt.What’smore,questionsaboundaboutwho,whenandhowofficialswithinthegovernmentweretippedoffabouttheputsch.
• Conflictingevidenceandtestimonyregardinghowordersfrommilitaryofficersweredeliveredandwhichindividualsmayhavehadforeknowledgethatacoupattemptwasintheworks.
• AlternativenarrativesthatmightexplainwhatreallyhappenedonJuly15.
![Page 4: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
IntroductionOnJuly15,2016,Turkeyexperiencedahorrific,unsuccessfulcoupattempt.TheTurkishparliamentwasbombedandhundredsofsoldiersandcivilianslosttheirlives.Thecoupattemptappearedtohavebeenplannedwithremarkableincompetenceandwascrushedquickly.PresidentRecepTayyipErdoganwasnotharmedthankstothe1starmyinIstanbulwhosecommanderremainedloyaltohim.Inthedaysfollowingtheincident,theErdogangovernmentdeclaredastateofemergencyandbeganamassivepurgeofallegedsympathizersoftheIslamicscholarandpreacherFethullahGulen.ItquicklybecameclearthatthearrestsofthebulkofmilitaryofficerswereunrelatedtowhethertheyparticipatedintheeventsofJuly15.Thearrestedcommandershadcollectively200,000membersoftheTurkisharmyundertheircommand.Thearrestedairbasecommandershadmorethan200fighterjetsundertheircommand.Iftheytrulyintendedit,thesecommanderscouldhaveexecutedaneffectivemilitarycoup.Butthepurgesandarrestswentfarbeyondthemembersofthemilitary.AccordingtoTurkeyPurge.com,asitethattracksthevictimsofthepurge,atlastcount138,148peopleweresacked,including8,271academics.Ofjudgesandprosecutors,4,424weredismissedandaround3,000werearrested,and2,745oftheseweredismissedonJuly16,2016.TheattackonTurkey’smediaincluded149mediaoutletsshutdownand234journalistsarrested1.Intotal,108,258peopleweredetained,ofwhom53,668werearrestedasofthiswriting.LiterallyallHizmet-affiliatedinstitutionswereshutdown.ThecategoriesandnumbersofinstitutionsshutdownbyErdogangivesagoodsummaryoftheareasinwhichtheHizmetmovementhasbeenactiveduringthefivedecadespriorto2016:2,099educationalinstitutionswereshutdown,includinghundredsofprivateK-12schoolsand15universities.Theseclosuresforced128,000studentstorelocatetootherschools,sometimesfacingbullyingandotherformsofabusesintheirnewschools.ManyoftheHizmet-affiliatedschoolsknownfortheirsecularcurriculumandsuccessinscienceeducationwereconvertedintoreligiousschools.Thirty-fivehospitalswereshutdown,resultinginhundredsofdoctorsandnurseslosingtheirjobsandpatientshavingtobetransferredtootherhospitals.ThehumanitarianrelieforganizationKimseYokMu,whichhelpedthevictimsofeverymajordisasteraroundtheworld,withanannualbudgetofaround$50million,wasalsoshutdown.IntellectualorganizationssuchastheFoundationofJournalistsandWriters,apioneeronrekindlingthespiritofinterfaithdialogueandrespectinthemid-1990swasclosed.Professionalorganizationswiththousandsofmembersfromamongphysicians,healthcareprofessionals,teachers,andengineerswerenotonlyshutdown,butmembershipintheseassociationswerelaterusedincourtsasevidenceof“membershipinaterroristorganization.”AmongthetargetsofthepurgesweretheorganizersoftheInternationalFestivalofLanguageandCulture2whichbroughttogetherstudentsfrommorethan150countriesineventsdedicatedtothecelebrationoflinguisticandartisticdiversityintheworldandtothepromotionofglobalhumansolidarity.HavingbeenbannedinTurkey,theorganizationrelocatedtotheUnitedStatesandhasbeenorganizingsmaller-scaleeventsinseveralcountriessincethen3.AmnestyInternational4,HumanRightsWatch5andtheUnitedNations’SpecialRapporteuronTorture6reportedstrongevidenceofsystematicandwidespreadtortureindetentioncentersandprisons.
![Page 5: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
HumanRightsWatchreportedthatthestateofemergencythatwasauthorizedonJuly20resultedindenialsofdueprocessrightstodetaineesandencouragedbothwrongfuldetentionsandinhumanetreatmentofdetainees7.TheNewYorkTimesreportedthatduetoitsscaleandcruelty,analystscomparedErdogan’scrackdownwith“JosephMcCarthy’sAnti-Communistwitch-huntinthe1950sAmerica,theStalinistpurgesofthe1930sandtheCulturalRevolutioninChinainthe1960sand’70s”8.SomeanalystsconsideredthepurgesasanunravelingofErdogan’s“innerStalin”9.ThevariouscategoriesofhumanrightsabusescommittedunderthestateofemergencyaresummarizedinExhibitA.ThefailedcoupattemptprovidedErdoganwithanexcellentexcusetoconsolidatehispower.Inadditiontopurgingmorethan6,000membersoftheTurkishmilitary,Erdoganalsochangedthemilitary’srecruitment,reportingandeducationstructures.Initswake,hereignitedtheideaofanexecutivepresidency,andhesecuredanarrowvictoryinaconstitutionalreferenduminApril2017—despitemanyreportedelectoralirregularities—toopenhispathtobecomingtheexecutivepresidentofTurkeyin2019.Erdogan’sGovernment’sNarrativeandtheResponsesbyWesternGovernmentsPresidentErdogan,speakingonnationalTVaroundmidnightthatfatefulday,immediatelyblamedFethullahGulen,aretiredpreacherandavocalErdogancriticwhohasbeenlivinginPennsylvaniasince1999,tobethemastermindoftheJuly15incident.Gulencondemnedtheattemptwhileitwasinprogress10andrepeatedlydeniedanyinvolvement11(ExhibitB).HechallengedtheErdogangovernmenttoallowforaninternationalinvestigationintotheevent12(ExhibitC).Gulenpledgedtoabidebyitsruling,andiffoundguilty—evenbasedonfalsetestimony—promisedtobuyhisowntickettoTurkey.Erdogandidnotrespondtothiscall.TheErdogangovernment’sunprovennarrativeaboutwhathappenedonJuly15thisthefollowing:Gulen-affiliatedofficersintheTurkishmilitarywerealarmedbythenewsofanimpendingpurgeattheAugustmeetingoftheMilitary’sSupremeCouncil.Inordertopre-emptsuchamoveandtotakeovertheTurkishstate,theyplannedacouptostartat3aminthemorningofJuly16th.However,theirplanwasdiscoveredandtheyhadtostartearlyintheeveningofJuly15th,whichledtoitbeinghastilyarrangedandultimatelyfailing.Westerngovernments,intelligenceservicesandobserversdidnotacceptErdogan’snarrativeofJuly1513.Inparticular:
1. Then-U.S.SecretaryofStateJohnKerryMr.KerrysaidtheTurkishgovernment,aspartoftheextraditionprocess,mustprovideevidencelinkingGulentotheincidentthatwithstandsscrutinyinanAmericancourt14.Asofthiswriting,approximatelyoneyearaftertheincident,thereisnoconfirmationfromtheU.S.DepartmentofJusticethattheTurkishgovernmenthassubmittedevidencethatmeetsthiscriteria.
2. JamesClapper,then-directorofU.S.NationalIntelligence,whenhewasaskedwhethertheTurkishgovernment’sallegationsthatclericFethullahGulenwasbehindtheattemptpassedthe“smelltest”ofcredibility:“No.Nottome.”AsreportedbyTheWashingtonPost,ClapperalsosaidthatSecretaryKerrywasrighttopresstheTurkishgovernmenttobackupitsextraditionrequestwithevidenceofGulen’sinvolvement.Clapperadded,“Wehaven’tseenityet.Wecertainlyhaven’tseenitinintel.”15
![Page 6: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
3. WhenaskedbyDerSpiegel,whetherGulenwasbehindthecoupasclaimedbyErdogan,BrunoKahl,HeadofGermany’sBDNForeignIntelligenceAgencyresponded,"Turkeyhastriedtoconvinceusofthatateverylevelbutsofarithasnotsucceeded"16.
4. TheEuropeanUnionIntelligenceCenter(INTCEN)reportontheincidentcontradictedtheTurkishgovernment’sclaimthatGülenwasbehindtheplottooverthrowtheTurkishgovernment.ThereportconcludedthatthecoupwasmountedbyarangeofopponentstoErdoganandhisrulingAKParty.ThereportfounditunlikelythatGulenhimselfplayedaroleintheattempt,accordingtotheTimesofLondon,andErdogan’spurgeswereplannedwellbeforetheincident17.
5. AreportbytheForeignAffairsCommitteeoftheBritishParliamentonU.K.-Turkishrelationsstatedthatthe“U.K.governmentdoesnothaveanyevidencethatU.S.-basedclericFethullahGulenorganizedTurkey'sJulycoupattempt.”1819(PleaseseeAppendixCfortherelevantexcerptfromthereport.)
WhytheTurkishGovernmentNarrativewasnotFoundCrediblebytheWestObserversnotedthattherewasabiggapbetweentheperspectivesoftheWesterngovernmentsandtheTurkishgovernmentnarrativeofJuly1520.Theprimaryreasons:
1. First,thegovernmentbeganpurgingthousandsofmembersofthemilitaryandthejudiciaryonJuly16.WesternobserversnotedthatitwouldbeimpossiblefortheTurkishgovernmenttoidentifythoseresponsiblefortheincidentonsuchshortnotice.Itwasclearthatthepurgelistswerepreparedwellinadvance21.AfailedcoupattemptthatallowedErdogantoeliminateperceivedcriticsenmasseappearedtooconvenientforErdogantobetrue22.
2. ThesecondreasonwastheTurkishgovernment’sfailuretoprovideconcreteevidencelinkingGulentotheincident23.Thefewtestimoniesextractedfromofficerswho“confessed”theirlinkstotheHizmetmovementwerenotfoundcrediblebecause,ironically,pro-governmentmediachannelsairedphotosofthosesameofficersshowingclearsignsofhavingbeentortured(ExhibitD).Moreimportantly,noneoftheofficersclaimedtohavereceivedordersfromacivilianoranybodyotherthantheircommandersortheGeneralStaffHeadquarters.
3. Finally,Erdogan’sownnarrativehadself-contradictions.ErdoganclaimedthatneitherhenorhisintelligenceserviceknewanythingaboutthecoupattemptupuntilthedayofJuly1524.Westernobserversfounditinconceivablethataneventofthismagnitude,whichwouldrequireweeks—ifnotmonths—ofpreparation,couldbeorchestratedfromanothercontinentandnotbediscoveredbyTurkishIntelligenceandahostofotherintelligenceagencies.Erdoganclaimedtohavelearnedabouttheeventnotfromhisintelligenceservicebutfromhisbrother-in-law,givingthreedifferenttimesastowhenthathappened(ExhibitE).Yet,hedidnotdismisstheDirectorofNationalIntelligence(MIT)HakanFidanwho,perhisownstory,failedtoinformorprotecthimafterreceivingatipfromaninformantontheafternoonofJuly1525.Similarly,thechiefofgeneralstaffwasnotdismisseddespitehavingfailedtostoptheincident,orprotecthisoffice,afterbeingalertedtoitseveralhoursbeforehand.
SomeobserversofferedthefollowingtworeasonsforwhyGulencouldnothaveorganizedthecoupattempt:
• First,startingintheearly1990s,Hizmetmovementparticipantshavesetupschools,hospitals,medicalclinics,andothercivicinstitutionsaroundtheworld.Itisestimatedthattherearemorethan500schoolcampusesaloneinmorethan150countries.Acoupattemptorchestratedby
![Page 7: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
Gulen,ifsuccessful,wouldsendanalarmingmessagetoworldleadersandspelltheendofthemovementaroundtheworld.AllothergovernmentswouldbegintoseeGulen-sympathizersasathreatandquicklyshutdowntheirinstitutionsandexpeltheirpersonnel.Itdoesn’tmakesensetosacrificehundredsofinstitutions,collectivelyworthmillionsofdollars,andreputationsbuiltthroughdecadesofworkforthesakeofpoliticalpowerinTurkey26.
• Second,thetopbrassofTurkishmilitaryconsistofsympathizersoftheideologyofthefounder
ofTurkishRepublicMustafaKemalAtaturk,knownasKemalists.TherehasneverbeenacredibleallegationthatthetopcommandershadanyGulen-sympathizersamongthem27.Infact,none,includingthechiefofgeneralstaff,secondchief,forcecommandersorarmycorpscommandershasbeenaccusedofbeingaGulensympathizer.Inaninformationage,itisimpossibleformid-levelofficerstostageacoupwithouttheknowledgeandapprovalofthetopcommanders.Iftheydid,therewouldbestrongreactionfromwithinthemilitaryitself.Onthenightofthecoup,therewasverylittlereactionfromwithinthemilitaryitself.MostoftheresistancetotheattemptwasbythepoliceandtheTurkishpeople.
AddingtothesuspicionsaboutthegovernmentnarrativewastheErdogangovernment’sapparentunwillingnesstofullyinvestigatetheincident.TheparliamentaryinvestigatorycommissionwasdelayedbecausetherulingAKPpartywasslowtoappointmemberstothecommission.Onceformed,thecommission28,dominatedbyAKPmembers,refusedtocallkeywitnessesfortestimony29,suchasthechiefofnationalintelligenceandthemilitary’schiefofgeneralstaff30.MithatSancar,anoppositionmemberofthecommissionsaidthefollowing:
TherulingAKPdidnotformthiscommissiontoilluminatethecoupattempt.Theyconstructedacoupnarrative.TherulingAKPhasanarrativeaboutthecoupattempt.Theywereexpecting(thiscommissiontoproduce)aworkthatwouldsupportthisnarrative….
Onlyinformationorrumorsthatsupportthegovernmentnarrativehavebeendisseminated,andallotherinformationthatpointstootherscenarioshasbeencensoredbygovernmentauthoritiesandacompliantmedia.Scoresoflawyershavebeenarrested,andattorney-clientprivilegehasbeenrevokedunderastateofemergency,leavingtheaccusedindividualsunabletodefendthemselvesthroughdueprocess.Belowweprovideanarrativebasedontheinformationavailablefrompublicsourcesandreceivedinpersonalcommunicationswiththelawyers,relativesorfriendsofindividualsaccusedbytheTurkishgovernment.TheaimofthisdocumentisnottomakeadefiniteclaimaboutwhathappenedonJuly15,2016,buttoraisequestionsaboutthegovernmentnarrativeandprovideanalternativethatdeservestobeconsideredaspartofanindependentinvestigation.OtherNarrativesaboutJuly15SeveralnarrativeshavebeenproposedbyTurkeyobserversaboutwhathappenedonJuly15,2016,insteadoftheErdogangovernment’snarrative.ExcerptsfromanumberofcommentatorsofdiversepoliticalorientationsquestioningthegovernmentnarrativeandsometimessuggestinganalternativeareprovidedinAppendixB.Wewilldiscusstwosuchnarratives,the“BroadCoalitionNarrative”becauseitistheprevalentviewamongindependentTurkeyexpertsandthe“CollusionNarrative”becauseithasthemostexplanatorypower,aswillbedetailedbelow.
![Page 8: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
BroadCoalitionNarrativeTheprevalentviewamongTurkeyobserversinEuropeandtheUnitedStatesisthefollowing31:Abroad-basedcoalitionofofficersinthemilitaryhasbeendiscussinganinterventionagainsttheErdogangovernment.TheybelievedErdoganunderminedtheTurkishstate’sdemocraticinstitutionsandsecularism.Thiscoalitionincluded,butwasnotlimitedto,militaryofficerswhofearedbeingpurgedattheAugustmeetingoftheMilitarySupremeCouncil.TheyplannedacoupwiththeintentionofremovingErdoganandrestoringTurkishdemocracyandsecularism.AninformantalertedTurkishIntelligencetotheplanduringtheafternoonofJuly15,forcingsomeofficerstostarttheactionearly.However,manyofficersgaveupandrefrainedfromparticipating,andhencetheeffortfailed.PartoftheevidenceforthebroadcoalitionnarrativeisthefactthatamongtheofficersarrestedafterJuly15,thereweremanyknownasKemalists.Ironically,theemergingdeclarationsbypro-ErdoganpoliticalcommentatorsandAKPmembersalsosupportedthebroadcoalitionnarrative.Forexample,JusticeMinisterBekirBozdag32andpro-ErdogancommentatorsCemKucukandRasimOzanKutahyali,amongothers,suggestedthattherewerenon-Gulen-affiliatedgroupswithintheTurkishmilitarythatweresupportiveofamilitaryinterventionagainsttheErdogangovernment33.ThebroadcoalitionnarrativeprovidesvaluableinsightsintotheeventsofJuly15andhelpsexplainsomeofthequestions,suchastheapparentambivalenceandconfusionofcommanderswhoareknowntobeKemalistsatthenewsofamilitarycoupaswellasthelackofasignificantresponsefromwithinthemilitaryagainsttheattempt.However,thebroadcoalitionnarrativedoesnotsufficientlyanswermanyotherquestionsaswillbedetailedbelow.CollusionNarrativeAbroad-basedcoalitionofmilitaryofficerswereErdogandetractors.TheybelievedErdoganunderminedtheTurkishstate’sdemocraticinstitutions.Theyhavebeendiscussingapotentialmilitarycoupformonths.TurkishNationalIntelligenceService(MIT)andErdoganwereawareofthesediscussions.Anultra-nationalist,orneo-nationalist(ulusalciinTurkish),factionamongthemilitaryassociatedwiththeEurasian-orientedHomelandpartycolludedwithErdoganandtheIntelligenceServicetostageapre-emptivecouponJuly15.ThecollusionnarrativesuggeststhattheincidentonJuly15wasamobilizationofaverysmallportionofthemilitary,aweakandcompromisedactiondesignedtofailbybeingcrushedbythepoliceforceandangrycrowds.Accordingtothisnarrative,July15thwas—borrowingthelanguageofapoliticalcommentatorwhodoesnotnecessarilyendorsethisview—agenuineplanthatwascompromisedandweakened,andallowedbyPresidentErdogantoplayoutinordertocrushitandachievehisstrategicgoals34.
WhathappenedonJuly15,2016,doesnotmatchthepatternofacoupplannedbythemilitary,butratheroneplannedbytheintelligenceservicewheremilitaryofficersunwittinglyplayedcrucialroles.BelowwewillgiveamoredetailedaccountoftheCollusionNarrative.
![Page 9: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
The“CollusionNarrative”ofJuly15thStartinginthefallof2015,abroadbaseoftop-levelandmiddle-levelcommandersintheTurkishmilitaryallegedlyheldmeetingsdiscussingamilitaryinterventioninordertostopErdoganfrombecominganelectedautocrat,andtohelpreviveTurkishdemocracy.Duringthelastfewmonthsof2015andthroughoutthespringof2016,therewerewidespreadrumors,numerousarticlesandclaimsinthedomesticandforeignmediaofanimpendingmilitarycoup.TherumorsofabrewingcoupreachedsuchalevelthattheTurkishgeneralstafffeltcompelledtoissueanunprecedentedstatementonMarch31,2016,refutingtheallegations35.InDecember2015,adelegationofpro-EurasianHomelandParty(VatanPartyinTurkish),formerlyknownasWorkersParty,headedbyMr.DoguPerincekvisitedMoscow36.TheHomelandPartymembersinthisdelegationwereret.Gen.IsmailHakkiPekin,formerdirectorofMilitaryIntelligence,ret.Adm.SonerPolatandret.Gen.BeyazitKaratas.TheHomelandPartydelegationmet,amongothers,withAlexanderDugin,aRussianultra-nationalistknownforhisEurasianistviewsandKonstantinMalofeev,“amultimillionairewithtiestotheRussianOrthodoxChurch”whoisalsounderEuropeanUnionandU.S.sanctionsforfinancingillegalmilitarygroupsinEasternUkraine3738.Thedelegationexpressedconcernsaboutaloomingpro-Americancoup39andencouragedRussianleadershiptorepairtheirrelationshipwithErdogan.StatementsbyAlexanderDuginandKonstantinMalofeevaboutthisvisitareavailableonYouTube40.PerincekhasbeenavocalcriticofErdoganforyears,andhewasimprisonedaspartoftheErgenekontrial.Perincek’sHomelandpartyhasaMarxist-MaoistideologythatisdiametricallyopposedtothereligiousleaningsofErdogan’sAKP.However,followingthe2013corruptionprobe,ErdogandecidedtobringthejudiciaryunderhiscontrolandreplaceallGulen-sympathizerswithinthejudiciary.LackingsignificantnumberofqualifiedsupporterstoreplacetheallegedGulen-sympathizers,ErdoganmadeapactwithPerincek.InOctober2014,intheelectionstotheSupremeCouncilofJudgesandProsecutors,bothleaderssupportedagroupcalled“UnityinJudiciaryPlatform”41.WhenthecandidatesofthisgroupwonthemajorityoftheseatsintheCouncil,bothleaderswerejoyous.ThisallianceandvictorygaveErdoganthepowertoinfluencethejudgeandprosecutorappointments,turningtheTurkishjudiciaryintoapoliticalinstrumentfortargetinghiscritics.Aftertheestablishmentofthealliance,Perincekwasnolongertargetedbyprosecutors,andhesurprisedeverybodybyspeakingoftheneedtokeepErdoganinpowersothatTurkeycanresisttheUnitedStates.42ThelossofjudicialindependenceinTurkeyhasbeennotedbytheU.S.DepartmentofState’sannualHumanRightsReport43,HumanRightsWatch44,AmnestyInternational45,theEuropeanUnion’sprogressreportfornegotiationswithTurkey46andtheInternationalCommissionofJurists47,amongothers.Gen.IsmailHakkiPekinlaterbecameoneoftheintervieweesofavideodocumentarytopromotetheErdogangovernment’snarrativeaboutGulenintheUnitedStates.48TheprojectwaspartofanagreementbetweenformerMichaelFlynn—laterPresidentDonaldTrump’sshort-livednationalsecurityadvisor—andEkimAlptekin,aTurkishbusinessmanwithtiestoErdogangovernment.Alptekin’sfamilyalsohastieswithPerincek’sHomelandParty49.Accordingtonewsreports,AlptekinarrangedforameetingbetweenTurkishForeignMinisterMevlutCavusogluandEnergyMinisterBeratAlbayrak—whoisalsoErdogan’sson-in-law—withFlynninwhichtheTurkishsidewantedtodiscussthepossibilityofremovingGulenfromtheUnitedStatesandtakinghimtoTurkey50.
![Page 10: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Erdoganwasawareoftheserumorsandtheallegeddiscussionsofacoup.Itis,ofcourse,inconceivablethatwhentherumorsaboutaloomingcoupreachedevenpoliticians,Erdoganwouldnotbecomeawareandnothaveitinvestigatedbyhisintelligenceservice.Moreconcretely,aftertheirvisittoMoscow,theHomelandPartyarrangedavisitbyAlexanderDuginalongwithaRussiandelegationtoTurkeyinMarch2016,duringwhichtheymetwithAKPofficialsandErdogan’srelatives.ItisreasonabletoassumethatinadditiontodiscussionsaboutrepairingtherelationshipwithRussia,theydiscussedmeasuresagainsttheimpendingcoup,whichtheyclaimedwouldbe“pro-American.”ItisnotclearwhethertherewereothervisitsbyAlexanderDugin,butonJuly15,2016,hewasinAnkara51.
Figure1AlexanderDuginmeetingwithDoguPerincek,headofHomelandPartyandmembersincludingret.Gen.IsmailHakkiPekin,formerheadofMilitaryIntelligenceinTurkey.
ItisanopensecretthattheHomelandPartyhassignificantpresenceinthestate’ssecurityandintelligenceservices52.Theso-called“Eurasianistclique”withintheTurkishmilitary53wasdescribedina2003leakedcablebyU.S.EmbassyinAnkaraaspursuingEurasianismasanalternativetotheU.S.“withoutunderstandingtheRussia-dominatednatureofthe‘Eurasia’concept”.In2003,thepro-U.S.andpro-NATOgroupcalledthe“Atlanticists”wereseenaslosinginfluencewithintheTurkishGeneralStaff.Perincek’sHomelandPartyisfavoriteamongretiredhigh-rankingmilitaryofficers.Perincek’sdeputyisretiredCol.HasanAtillaUgur.PartyleaderPerinceksaidonanumberofoccasionsthatthepartyis“stronginthemilitary,inthejudiciary”.Otherex-militarymembersofthepartyincluderet.Gen.HasanKundakciandtheaforementionedret.Gen.IsmailHakkiPekin,theformerheadofTurkishMilitaryIntelligence.PerincekissuedthefollowingmessageuponthedeathofAdmiralAzizCemCakmakwho
![Page 11: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
wastriedforparticipationintheSledgehammercoupplot:“WearesendingAdmiralCemCakmak,ourcomradeduringtheSledgehammerandErgenekontrials,tohisfinaljourney54.Inanaudiorecordingdatingto2012andattributedtoAdm.Cakmak,heclaimedthatthankstoanagreementmadebetweentheirsideandErdogan,Gulensympathizerswouldsoonhavetoleavethecountryandwouldnotevenfindwatertodrink55.TheHomelandPartyisalsoknownforitsanti-Americanviews56andoppositiontoTurkey’smembershipinNATO,whichtheylabelasaninstrumentofU.S.imperialism57.AfterJuly15,halfoftheTurkishNATOofficersoftheTurkishmilitarywerepurgedandreplaced.WhenGen.JosephVotel,theheadofU.S.CentralCommandexpressedhisconcernsovertheimpactofthepurgesontherelationshipwiththeirTurkishmilitary,PresidentErdoganscoldedVotelbysaying,“It’snotuptoyoutomakethatdecision.Whoareyou?Knowyourplace!Youaretakingthesideofcoupplottersinsteadofthankingthisstatefordefeatingthecoupattempt.”58Reutersreportedthat149militaryenvoyspostedtothealliance'sheadquartersandcommandcentersinGermany,Belgium,theNetherlandsandBritainwereorderedtoreturntoTurkeywithinthreedaysbasedonaclassifiedmilitarydispatchseenbytheagency59.ItwasclearthatthereasonfortherecallandtheprospectiveindictmentoftheseofficerswasnotparticipationintheincidentofJuly1560.AsanothersignofErdogan’sawarenessofthecoupdiscussions,anarticlepublishedinaPro-ErdoganoutletTurkiyeonApril21,2016,pennedbyFuatUgurthreatenedGulen-sympathizersinthemilitarywiththefollowinglanguage:“Doyouthinkthatourgovernmentisnotawareofyou?Theyarejustwaitingforyoutoact,andtheywillsummarilyexecuteyou.”6162OnthenightofJuly14,2016,NationalIntelligenceChiefFidan,whoisacloseconfidantofErdogan,heldmeetingswithSpecialForcesCommanderAksakalliandChiefofGeneralStaffAkar.Asofthiswriting,thecontentsofthesetwocrucialmeetingsthenightbeforethefailedcoupattempthavenotbeenrevealed.NeitherAkarnorFidanwerecalledtoanswerquestionsbeforetheparliamentaryinvestigationcommittee,andintheirwrittenresponsestothequestionsbythecommittee,neitherofthemreferredtothesemeetings.July15doesnotMatchthePatternofPreviousMilitaryInterventionsinTurkeyMilitaryexpertssuggestthatthepatternofactionsonthenightofJuly15thdonotfitthepatternofamilitarycoupbutratheracoup-likeactionthatisdesignedbyanintelligenceservice.TheJuly15eventlackedcrucialactionsofamilitarycoupandincludedcounterproductiveactionsthatdidnotmakesenseinthatcontext.Crucialmissingpiecesofamilitarycoupincludedpreparingthepublicopinion,startingtheactionaftermidnightduringtheearlyhoursoftheday,securingkeypoliticiansfirst,thensecuringcontrolofmediaoutletsandcommunicationscentersandtheparticipationoflandforces.Inthiscase,theactionsthatactuallyhappeneddon’tmakesenseinamilitarycoup,includingstartingthemobilizationatrushhour,closingabusybridgetotraffic63,bombingtheparliament,bombingpoliceheadquartersandtargetingcivilians.
![Page 12: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
PreviousInterventions July15,2016
Publicopinionwaspreparedforanintervention.
Publicopinionwasnotprepared.
Actionstartedaftermidnight,duringtheearlyhoursoftheday.
Actionstartedduringrushhourat9:30pm.
Theleader(s)oftheinterventionwereclearandtheymadepublicdeclarations.
Theleader(s)oftheinterventionwasnotclear.Nopersonmadeapublicdeclaration.Adeclarationbythe“PeaceatHomeCommittee”wasairedonTRTwithoutdisclosingthemembersofthecommittee.
Communicationscentersweresecured. Communicationscenterswerenotsecured.
RadioandTVstationsweresecured. WiththeexceptionofahandfulofsoldierssenttoTRTandCNN-Turk,pro-ErdoganTVchannelswerenotsecured.
LeadpoliticianssuchasPrimeMinisterandInteriorMinisterweredetained.
PresidentErdogan,PMBinaliYildirimandtheInteriorMinisterwerenotdetained.
Themilitarywascarefultoavoidciviliancasualties.
Hundredsofcivilianswerekilled.
Themilitarydidnottargettheparliamentorthepolice.
Parliamentandpoliceheadquarterswerebombed.
WhoMobilizedMilitaryUnitsonJuly15?Inthissection,wewilldiscusswhen,howandbywhommilitaryunitsweremobilizedduringtheeveningofJuly15.ThisisimportantbecausethegovernmentnarrativeclaimsthatofficersassociatedwithGulenstagedthecoupwithdirectivesfromciviliansaffiliatedwithGulen.However,thereisnota
May27,1960
Sep12,1980
July15,2016
![Page 13: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
singleofficerwhostatesinhistestimonythatheactedonthenightofJuly15bythedirectivesofacivilian.Activationofmilitaryunitscanbetracedtooneofthethreeprimarysources:
1. OfficeofGen.YasarGuler,theSecondChiefofGeneralStaff.2. OfficeofGen.ZekaiAksakalli,CommanderofSpecialForces.3. Gen.MehmetDisli,DirectorofStrategicTransformation.
Secondarysourcesofmobilization,suchasColonelCemilTurhan,Gen.MehmetPartigocandGen.IlhanTalu,whowereondutyattheheadquartersofthegeneralstaffthatnightclaimedthattheysimplyfollowedtheorderstheyreceivedfromtheprimarysources,and/orwerethreatenedbythepro-coupofficers.Inadditiontothemilitaryunitsmobilizedtoperformtheirdutiesundermartiallaw,manyunitsweremobilizedunderthepretenseofoneofthefollowing64:
• Participationinaregularexercise• Participationinaneducationalexercise• Participationinan“unconventionalexercise”• Participationinanoperationtoprotectgeneralstaffheadquarters• Protectionofamilitaryorciviliancompoundfromaterroristattack
SpecialForcesUnitsWereOrderedtoParticipateinan“UnconventionalExercise”DuringthedaysleadingtoJuly15,agroupofofficersfromspecialforcesweregivenorderstoparticipateinan“unconventionalexercise.”Thegoalofthisexercisewasdescribedasprotectingthegeneralstaffheadquartersagainstaterroristattack.However,theunitswhofulfilledtheirordersonthenightofJuly15werelaterarrestedascoupplotters.Col.FiratAlakus,onethespecialforcescommandersarrestedasacoupplotter,saidinhistestimonythathereceivedhisordersfromGen.ZekaiAksakalli,thetopcommanderofthespecialforces.Otherofficersclaimedthataplanecarryingtheallegedpro-coupcommanderGen.SemihTerziwasallowedtoflydespitethegeneralbanonmilitaryflightsbyAksakalli’scloseaideCol.UmitTatan,commanderofEtiMesgutSpecialForcesAirCommand.Col.UmitBakofspecialforcesstatedthatGen.AksakallitoldhimtoallowonlyGen.SemihTerzitospecialforcesheadquartersthatnight65.Terziwaskilledbyalowerrankingofficeronceinsidethespecialforcesheadquartersthatnight.Aksakallideniedtheclaimsagainsthimandwasnevercharged.Instead,hewasgiventhetaskofcommandingtheTurkishMilitaryunitsthatstagedtheFiratShieldOperation.Theordersforspecialforcesunitstoparticipateinan“UnconventionalExercise”wereissuedstartingonJuly11byCol.Bak,whoclaimedthathereceivedhisordersfromGen.Aksakalli,thecommanderofspecialforces.Gen.Aksakalliclaimedtheorderswereissuedwithouthisknowledgeorapproval.IfCol.BakissuedorderswithoutAksakalli’sapproval,duringthefourdaysfromJuly11toJuly15anofficerwhoreceivedtheorderscouldeasilyhavebroughtitupinameetingwithGen.Aksakalli.Inthatcase,ColonelBakwouldfacecourtmartial.Aspreviouslynoted,onJuly14,aconfidentialmeetingwasheldatspecialforcesheadquartersbyGen.HulusiAkar,thechiefofgeneralstaff,HakanFidan,directorofNationalIntelligenceOrganization(MIT)andGen.Aksakalli,commanderofthespecialforces.Aftertheconclusionofthismeeting,Gen.Aksakalli
![Page 14: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
andintelligencechiefFidanheldaseparatemeeting.Thecontentsofthesemeetingshaveneverbeenrevealed.OrdersWereIssuedfromtheOfficeofGen.YasarGuler,SecondChiefofGeneralStaffAnothergroupofofficersweremobilizedonJuly15byordersfromtheofficeofSecondChiefofGeneralStaffGen.YasarGuler.Theorderswereissuedbyhisaidedecamp,CaptainMehmetAkkurt,whowaskilledbyanotherofficerthatnight.Gen.Gulerclaimedthathisaidedecampissuedtheseorderswithouthisknowledgeorapproval.IfGuler’sclaimistrue,itisnotclearwhetheranaidedecampatthelevelofcaptaincouldtakesuchanactionwithouttheapprovalofanothersuperiorofficer.TheonlyothertwoofficerswhocouldgivehimsuchanassuranceareGen.HulusiAkar,thechiefofgeneralstaff,andGen.MehmetDisli,whowasknowntobeaclosefriendofGen.HulusiAkar.Certainmilitaryunitsweresentdirectivestomobilizebyofficersondutyatthegeneralstaffheadquarters,suchasGen.MehmetPartigoc,commanderoftheOfficeofGeneralStaffPersonnel,Gen.IlhanTalu,andCol.CemilTurhan.Theseofficersclaimedthattheyfollowedordersfromtheofficeofthesecondchiefofgeneralstafforwerethreatenedbytheputschists.Gen.Gulerclaimedthatafterdiscussingpreventivemeasuresagainstapotentialmilitarycoupwiththechiefofgeneralstaffandintelligencechief,hereturnedtohisdesktocontinue“routinework.”Thequestionremainsunansweredastowhyhewouldreturntoroutineworkagainstthethreatofamilitarycoupinsteadofworkingwiththechiefofgeneralstaffandforcecommandersaroundacrisisdeskuntilthethreatiscompletelyeliminated.Maj.Gen.MehmetDisli,HeadofStrategicTransformationDepartment,MobilizedOfficersManyofficerswhoactedonJuly15wereledbyGen.MehmetDisli,commanderofstrategictransformation66.Gen.DisliisthebrotherofAKPViceChairmanSabanDisli,whoisaclosefriendofErdogan.TheDislifamilyisknowntohaveclosetiestotheErdoganfamilydatingbackdecades.Accordingtoobservers,thisofficewasspeciallycreatedforGen.Disli.OnthenightofJuly15,manyAKPdeputiescalledGen.Dislitofindoutwhatwasgoingon,showingthedegreeoftrustthatexistedbetweenthepartyofficialsandGen.Disli.DisliwaslaterimplicatedbyGen.Akarasacoupplotterandwasarresteddespitedenyingchargesagainsthim.PilotsMisledandThreatenedPilotswhowerenotondutyandweresimplyspendingtimewiththeirfamiliesweresummonedtotheirairbasestoostensiblydefendagainstamajorterroristattack67.Pilotswerethreatenedatgunpointandwiththreatstotheirfamiliestodropbombsattheparliamentandthepoliceheadquarters.Thegovernment’sexplanationforthebombingoftheparliamenthasamajorself-contradiction:TheputschistsweresoangryatthegovernmentthattheybombedtheparliamentbuildingbutsomehowmissedErdogan’smassivepresidentialpalacedespitethestateoftheartmilitaryaircraftandprecisionbombsundertheirdisposal.StudentsofAirWarCollegeStudentsfromAirWarCollegewereputonbusesandcarriedtotheIstanbulbridgesonthenightofJuly15.Thesestudentswerelaterarrestedforparticipationinacoup.
![Page 15: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
ImportantQuestionsAbouttheJuly15IncidentDespiteayearpassingsincetheincident,someaspectsofJuly15havenotbeenexplained,evenwiththeongoingtrialsofallegedpro-coupofficers.ShuttingDownBridgeTrafficShuttingdownIstanbul’sbusyBosphorusbridgetotrafficwasnotonlysenselessasacouptactic,itwascounterproductive.Thisactiondidnothelpachieveanymilitaryobjectiveinanywayandinsteadmadethepublicangry.Themilitaryunitssenttoshutdownthebridgetrafficwereabandonedonthebridgeandfacedlynchingbyangrymobsinthemorning.Gen.UmitDundar,thecommanderofthe1stArmyinIstanbulwhopledgedallegiancetoErdogan,didnotintervenetoremovethemilitaryunitthatoccupiedthebridge.Thatledtociviliansattackingthemilitaryunit,receivingfireandultimatelyseverelybeatingandkillingsomesoldiers.OnthenightofJuly15,asniperallegedlyshotatandkilledciviliansfromatoponeofbridge’spoles.ThesniperhimselfwasshotandkilledbypolicesnipersandthecasewasneverfullyinvestigatedbythegovernmentdespitetheuseofciviliandeathsonthebridgeasanelementofthemediacampaignagainstGulen68.AmongtheciviliansallegedlykilledonthebridgewasErolOlcak,aformerpollsterandcommunicationsconsultantofErdogan,whotweeteddaysbeforetheincidentthatErdoganwaspreparingforahistorictransformationoftheTurkishmilitary69.CivilianDeathsDeliberatelytargetingciviliansduringacoupisunprecedentedinthehistoryofmilitarycoupsinTurkey.Videofootageofthenightrevealsthatsomeofficersandsoldiersweredistressedbythefactthattheywereabandonedbytheircommandersandangrycrowdswereapproachingthem,possiblytolynchthem.Itappearsthatsomeoftheciviliandeathsarearesultoftheactionsofpanickedsoldiers.Itisalsoallegedbyeyewitnessesthatparamilitaryunits,possiblybelongingtotheSADATinternationaldefenseconsultingorganizationstartedbyErdogan,wereresponsibleforsomeoftheciviliandeaths70.Twowitnessesreportedthatindividualsshootingfromblackvansorcarsshotatcivilians71.Anindividualwhoappearslikearadicalreligiousfigurecanbeseeninavideoclaimingthatheisreadytoplayhisrolewithhisweapon72.
MuteberAyabak,motherofayoungmankilledonthenightofJuly15,claimshersonwasshotfrombehindbyindividualsshootingfromablackFordTransitvan.
Witnessclaimingthatcivilianswereshotbyindividuals(possiblypolice)shootingfromablackMiniCooperontheBosphorusbridge.
Dr.NevzatTarhan,psychologicalcounselorforErdogan’sparamilitarySADATforce,statingthatformermembersofmilitaryaffiliatedwithASDER,wereactiveonthenightofJuly15.
AnErdogansupporterwithaguninthemorningofJuly16statingthattheyhaveabattletofight.
![Page 16: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
Whileusingtheciviliandeathsasacrucialcomponentoftheirmessagingaroundtheattempt,theErdogangovernmentmadelittleefforttoactuallyilluminatethespecificsofthosedeaths.Ironically,itwastheaccusedmilitaryofficerswhoaskedforforensicexaminationofthefirearmsandbulletsusedbythesoldiersundertheircommandalongwiththeautopsiesofthekilledcivilians.Theserequestswerenotwelcomebytheplaintiffsorjudges73.Thegovernment’srefusaltoinvestigatethesniperontheBosphorusbridge,whoallegedlyshotcivilians,wasalsosuspicious,astheregularunitsthatweresenttothebridgethatnightnormallydonotincludeasniper74.AerialBombingoftheParliamentandPoliceHeadquartersThedamagethattheparliamentbuildingsustainedallegedlyduetoaerialbombingwasoneoftheprimaryelementsofthegovernment’smediacampaigntojustifythesubsequentpurges.IntheearlymorninghoursofJuly16,militaryjetsdroppedbombsatthegardenandanunoccupiedcorneroftheparliamentbuilding,andatthefrontyardofthepresidentialpalace.Althoughtheparliamentbuildingwasdamaged,therewerenocasualtiesandtherewasnoharmdonetoErdogan’spresidentialpalace.BombingtheparliamentisunprecedentedinTurkey’shistoryofcoups.Itisalsonotclearwhythepilots,iftheyweretrulyactingaspartofacoup,mighthavemissedErdogan’senormouspalace.Oneofthepilotswhowereaccusedofbombingtheparliamentbuildingclaimedthathewascalledfromhishomeunderthepretenseofdefendingagainstaterroristattack.Whenhefoundoutthathisbombingtargetwastheparliament,heinitiallyattemptedtoevadetheorderbyjammingthefighterjet’smechanism,buthewascoercedtocarryouttheorder75.Thereareotherproblemswiththegovernment’snarrativeaboutthebombingoftheparliament.Governmentofficialsclaimedthattheparliamentbuildingwasbytwo-stagepenetratingbombsdroppedfromF-16s.Observers,whoclaimtobepurgedNATOofficers,disputedthisclaimandpointedoutthatthevideoimagesandtheimpactoftheexplosionsattheparliamentbuildingmatchthepatternofaninternally-placedbombratherthanapenetratingbombdroppedfromafighterjet76(EXHIBITF).Whencombinedwiththepilots’testimoniesthattheywerethreatenedtobombtheparliament,itispossiblethattheinternallyplacedbombsweredetonatedtoensurethatthebuildingwouldbesufficientlydamagedincasethepilotsrefusedtodirectlytargettheparliament77.TheCrewofaSearch-and-RescueHelicopterWhoSoughtAsyluminGreeceTheeight-personcrewofasearch-and-rescuehelicopter,fromanairbaseinIstanbul,soughtasyluminGreecethemorningofJuly16.Intheirasylumapplication,theofficerssaidtheywerepartofanarmysearch-and-rescueunitwiththreehelicoptersandweretoldbytheircommanderstopickupcasualtiesonthenightofJuly15.However,whentheyapproachedthedesignatedlocationsofthecasualties,theirhelicopter,alongwithtwoothers,receivedfirefromtheground.Theyreturnedtoanearbyarmybasebuttheycouldnotreachtheircommandersasthepolicebrokeintothebaseandstartedshootingatsoldiers.Thecrewofthethreehelicoptersdecidedtore-groupandflytogetherinonehelicoptertoseekasyluminGreecebecausetheythoughttheywouldbechargedwithparticipationinthecoupattemptandwouldnotreceiveafairtrialinTurkey78.Thereareotherreportsofcommandersorderingofficers—insomecasesafterbeingrecalledfromtheirvacation—toperformactionsapparentlyunrelatedtoacouponlytobeabandonedbythesamecommandersandchargedthenextdaywithparticipationintheattempt.
![Page 17: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
ContradictionsoftheErdoganCampThestatementsbyPresidentErdoganandhisallies,includingHakanFidan,thedirectorofNationalIntelligenceService(MIT),andthechiefofgeneralstaff,includemanycontradictionsandleavemanyimportantquestionsunanswered.Belowwewillgivesomeexamples.PresidentErdoganPresidentErdoganreportedfourdifferenttimesforwhenhelearnedaboutthecoup.BeforedawnonJuly16,heheldapressconferenceattheIstanbulairport,79wherehesaid,“Asitisknown,therewasactivityinthemilitaryintheafternoon”80.InaninterviewtoCNNonJuly18,hesaidhelearnedabouttheattemptfromhisbrother-in-lawaround8pm81.InaninterviewwithReutersonJuly21,hesaidthetimeofthecallfromhisbrother-in-lawwasbetween4and4:30pm.InaninterviewtoTurkishA-HaberonJuly30,hesaidthathemisrememberedearlierandthecorrecttimewasaround9:30pm(ExhibitE).Inaneventlikeamilitarycoup,Erdoganwouldbetheprimarytargetandhislifewouldbeindanger.Itisdifficulttobelievethathedidnotrememberexactlywhenhefirstlearnedabouttheincident.AlsoapuzzleisErdogan’srefusaltofire,oreveninvestigate,hisintelligencechiefandmilitarychiefdespitetheirfailuretoinformorprotecthim.InaninterviewwithFrance24,whenpressedbythehosttoexplainwhyhedidnotseektheresignationofhisintelligencechief,ErdoganarguedthatthereweresecuritylapsesinotherplacesasinthecaseoftheParisterrorattacks,completelyignoringthefactthataterroristattackbyafewindividualsandamilitarycouparecompletelydifferentevents82.Erdogan’sclaimthathewasfirstinformedabouttheeventbyhisbrother-in-lawaround9:30pmandthathecouldnotreachIntelligenceChiefFidanwascontradictedbyChiefofGeneralStaffAkar.Inhiswrittenstatementtotheparliamentaryinvestigationcommittee,AkarsaidthatIntelligenceChiefFidancalledandspokewiththeheadofErdogan’ssecurityguardduringtheirmeetingbefore8:30pm.InorderforErdogan’saccounttobetrue,wehavetoassumethattheheadofErdogan’ssecurityguarddidnotinformhimdespitebeingaskedabouttheirpreparationsforapossibleattack.QuestionssuchaswhyFidandidnotasktospeakwithErdogan,whyhedidnotspecifythenatureofthethreattotheheadofsecurity,andwhyErdoganclaimedthathecouldnotreachFidanuntil10pmwereneveranswered.Erdoganclaimedthathisairplanewasassaultedbypro-coupfighterjetsbutprotectedbypro-governmentjets.TheGreekAirForcerefutedErdogan’sclaimsthatnosuchairfightoccurred83.ItisalsoinconceivablethatifloadedF-16stargetedErdoganasheclaimed,whywouldtheynotbeabletoshootdownhisplaneorforceittoland?Erdoganclaimedthatpro-coupforcesassaultedhisvacationresidence15minutesafterheleftthelocation,around1or1:30am.However,specialforcesunitsaimingtoarrestErdoganarrivedathisvacationresortaround3-3:30am.ThisbringsupthequestionofwhethertherewasasecondaryassaultatErdogan’svacationresorttwohoursbeforethespecialforcesarrivedthere.PresidentErdogan’sfailuretorespondtoGulen’scallforaninternationalinvestigation,accompaniedbyhispledgetoabidebyitsruling,isalsonoteworthy.AssumingErdoganwassincereabouthisclaim,therewouldbenoreasonfromhisperspectivenottoacceptthischallenge.IfGulenweretobefoundguiltyandfulfilledhispledge,thenthecasewouldbeover.IfGulenweretobefoundguiltybutbackedoutfromhispledge,thenhewouldincriminatehimselfinbothdomesticandworldpublicopinionandjustifysomeofErdogan’spurges.Ofcourse,thecommitteecouldalsodeterminethatGulenwasfalsely
![Page 18: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
accused.Furthermore,thecommitteecouldalsowanttoinvestigateotheraspectsoftheJuly15incidentbesidesErdogan’saccusationagainstGulen.WerethesethereasonswhyErdoganrefusedtoacceptGulen’schallenge?Wemightneverknow.HakanFidan,DirectorofNationalIntelligenceOrganization(MIT)IntheafternoonofJuly15,acaptainreferredtoasO.K.informedtheNationalIntelligenceOrganization(MIT)headquartersthatanattackonthebuildingwasplannedtocapturetheMITchief.Thisofficerwasneveridentifiedpublicly,ostensiblytoprotecthim,andlaterdischargedfromthemilitary,ratherthanbeinggivenamedalofhonor.Hewaslaterre-admittedtothemilitaryandwasgivenapositionwithMIT.MITChiefFidansenthisdeputytotheofficeofgeneralstaffat4pmandlaterhimselfmetwiththemilitarychief,Akar,at6pm.AccordingtotheaccountsofPresidentErdoganandPrimeMinisterBinaliYildirim,theintelligencechiefdidnotinformorprotecteitherthepresidentortheprimeminister.Infact,theyclaimedtheycouldnotcommunicatewiththeintelligencechiefuntil10pm.Fidan’saccountoftheeventsofthenightisfullofpuzzlesandcontradictions.AccordingtoGen.Akar’stestimony,FidancalledErdogan’sguardsandaskedthemiftheywerepreparedagainstanattack,withoutspecifyingthenatureorthescaleoftheattackandwithoutaskingtospeakwithErdogan.InsteadofstayingwithGen.Akartoinvestigateandtakeprecautionsagainstapossiblecoup,Fidanleftthegeneralstaffheadquarterstoattendtopre-arrangedmeetings.Gen.UmitDundar,commanderof1starmyinIstanbulGen.UmitDundarpledgedalligeancetoErdoganduringtheearlyhoursoftheattempt,accordingtoBeratAlbayrak,Erdogan’sson-in-law84.Asearlyas12:52am,Dundarconfidentlydeclaredtheattempttobetheworkofasmallfactionwithinthemilitaryandhencedoomedtofail85.HewaslaterdeclaredtheactingchiefofgeneralstaffasthewhereaboutsofGen.Akarwerenotknown.However,duringtheearlyhoursoftheincident,FatihTezcan,afamouspro-Erdoganpoliticalcommentator,labeledUmitDundarasaputschist86.MilitaryexpertsnotethatitisverydifficulttostageacoupinTurkeywithouttheparticipationofthe1starmy.Indeed,thefamousSledgehammermilitarycoupplot,whichresultedinthetrialsofmanyofficers,wasdiscussedattheheadquartersofthe1starmyinIstanbulin2003.Itisunlikelythatamilitaryleadershipwouldconsidercommittingtoacoupwithouttheparticipationofthecommanderofthe1starmy.Itispossible,thereforethatDundarearliergavetheimpressionthathewasinfavorofacoupandmisledsomeofficerswhileintendingtosidewithErdogan.MilitaryunitsinIstanbulclosedaccesstotheBosphorusbridgearound8pmandthenthebridgetrafficinonedirectionaround9:30pm.Itislaterrevealedthattheseunitswereundertheimpressionthattheywereparticipatinginanexercise87.Thisactiondidnothelpthecoupinanyway,butsimplyexacerbatedpublicreactiontoit.Thecommanderof1starmy,UmitDundar,whopledgedallegiancetoErdoganearlyon,didnothingtostopthebridgeclosuredespitethebridgebeinginthe1starmy’sareaofresponsibility.Asthehourspassed,officersandunitsunderthefalseimpressionthatthemilitarywasstagingacoupwiththefullchainofcommandrealizedthattheywerebeingabandoned88.
![Page 19: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Gen.YasarGuler,the2ndChiefofGeneralStaffDirectiveswereissuedfromGen.Guler’sofficeandweresenttomilitaryunitsaroundthecountryforthemtotakeactionsthatwerelatercharacterizedasparticipationinthecoupattempt.Hisaidedecamp,CaptainMehmetAkkurt,allegedlyissuedtheseorders.Gulerhimselfdeniedanyinvolvement.Aswasmentionedabove,itisinconceivabletothinkthathisaidedecamp,whoisacaptain,wouldissueadeclarationofmartiallawwithouttheapprovalofGen.Gulerhimself,orGen.AkarorGen.Disli,whoisknownasaclosefriendofGen.Akar.OnthenightofJuly15,specialforcesunitsenteredgeneralstaffheadquartersrelativelyeasily.ThecommanderofthegeneralstaffheadquartersguardunitreportstoGen.Guler.Gen.HulusiAkar,ChiefofGeneralStaffGen.Akardidnotgoalongwiththedemandsofthepro-coupofficers.However,someofhisactionsraisequestions.Couldtop-levelcommandersholdmeetingsaboutamilitarycoupplanwithouthisknowledgeandapproval?WashethreatenedbyErdogantoplayalongwithhisplan?WhydidhenotprotecthimselforthegeneralstaffheadquartersorinformErdogan?Whydidhenottakemoreeffectiveactionsbetween4pm,whenhewasfirstinformedbytheintelligencechief,and9pm,whenhewasreportedlytakenhostage?Gen.Akarwasalsocriticizedfornotrecallingforcecommanders—whowereattendingweddingceremonies—toreturntotheirheadquartersandresumecommandofthetheirforces.Despitetheearlyinformationthesecommandersdidnottakeprecautionstoprotectthemselvesandwerelatertakenhostage.Theirself-reportedactionstotrytostopthecoupattemptweremeagerandraisemanyquestions89.Observersnotedtheabsenceoftheleaderfortheattempt,whichisunprecedentedinthehistoryofmilitarycoupsinTurkey.ThegovernmentaccusedGen.AkinOzturk,theformercommanderoftheAirForce,ofbeingthemilitaryleaderofthecoup.However,theOfficeoftheChiefoftheGeneralStaffpostedamessageonitswebsitedescribinghimasaherowhotriedtostopthepro-coupofficersandpreventbloodshed90.Nevertheless,Ozturkwascharged,arrestedandjailed.ThemessageonthewebsiteoftheOfficeofChiefoftheGeneralStaffwaslaterremoved,butacopyisavailableonothersites91(ExhibitG).ForceCommandersManyofthetopcommandersoftheTurkishMilitary,includingthreeoftheforcecommanders,wereattendingweddingceremoniesonthenightofJuly15.TheywereeventuallydetainedandtakentoAkinciairbase,theallegedheadquartersofthecoupattempt.NoneofthesecommandersischargedwithbeingaGulen-sympathizerandtheyhaveretainedtheirpositionsaftertheincident.Theirfailuretoactintimetostopallegedpro-coupofficers,andtheirtestimoniesregardingtheirresponsestothenewsofamilitarycoupattempt,leavesmanyquestionsunanswered.
![Page 20: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
ExplanatoryPoweroftheCollusionNarrativeBelowwesummarizehowthecollusionnarrativehelpsansweralltheimportantquestionsabouttheJuly15incidentthatremainunansweredwithinthegovernment’snarrative.Question Responsebasedon
GovernmentNarrative
WhytheGovernmentResponseisnotconvincing
AnsweraccordingtotheCollusionNarrative
WhydidthemilitaryunitsshutdownbusyBosphorusBridgeduringrushhourtraffic?
Asashowofforce. Innopreviouscoupdidthepublicorthepoliceputupanyresistancetothemilitary.Untilthewhereaboutsofthechiefofgeneralstaffwasrevealed,therewasnopoliticalcommentaryinthemediaoutoffearoftheattemptsucceeding.Sothis“showofforce”wascompletelyunnecessaryfromamilitarystrategicviewpoint.
Tomakethepublicangryandhelpantagonizethemtoattacksoldiers
WhywastheParliamentbuildingbombed?
Themilitarywantedashowofforce.
Theparliamentincludesdelegatesfromallparties.EventhoughmembersofthemilitarymaybeangryatErdogan’sAKP,membersoftheoppositionpartiesarealsointheparliament.
Toantagonizethepublicandgivethemessagethatthe“pro-coup”officersareagainstthe“people’swill”
WhydidthepilotsmissErdogan’shugepalace?
Noresponse. Erdogan’spalaceisamassivebuilding,impossibletomissbyfighterjetsequippedwithguidedmissilesandbombs.
PilotswerethreatenedatgunpointtodropbombsattheparliamentandpoliceheadquartersbyErdogan’scolluders.Erdogandidnotwanthispalacedamaged.
WhywereahandfulofsoldierssenttoErdogan’spalace,whichwouldbewell-guarded?
Incompetenceofthecoupplotters.
AnymilitaryofficerwouldknowthatErdogan’spalacewouldbewell-protected.Itdoesn’tmakesensetosendahandfulofsoldierstoattempttotakeoverthepalace.
The“attack”atErdogan’spalacewassimplyashowtodepictErdoganasavictim.
Whywerepoliceheadquartersbombed?
Themilitarywasagainstthepolice.
Thepolicedidnotresistthemilitarycoupsinthepast.Therewasnoindication
Toantagonizethepoliceandhelpthemattackthemilitary
![Page 21: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
thattherewouldbeastrongresistancethistimeeither.Ifanything,bombingpoliceheadquartersamplifiedthepoliceresponse.
unitsactivethatnight.
WhydidPresidentErdoganreportfourdifferenttimesastowhenhelearnedabouttheattempt?
Forgetfulness. ItishardtobelievethatErdoganwouldnotremembertheprecisemomentwhenhelearnedaboutthispotentiallylife-threateningevent.
Heisnottellingthetruth.Itisimpossibleforhimtoforgetthetimehelearnedaboutaneventthatthreatenedhislife.
Whydidn’ttheintelligencedirectorinformorprotectErdogan?
IntelligencedirectorcalledheadofErdogan’sguard.
IntelligencedirectordidnotasktospeakwithErdogan,hedidnotspecifythenatureofthethreatanddidnotattempttofortifyprotectionaroundErdogan.
Hedidn’tneedto,becauseErdoganalreadyknewandhislifewasnotindanger.
Whydidn’tthechiefofgeneralstaffinformErdoganorrecallforcecommanderstotheircommandsandprotectheadquartersofofficeofgeneralstaff?
Chiefofgeneralstaffmadecallstohaltflightsofmilitaryaircraftandmovementofarmedvehicles.
Actionstakenbythechiefofgeneralstaffweretooweaktostoparealmilitarycoupattempt.Thechiefhimselfwasallegedlytakenhostageseveralhoursafterbeinginformed.
Hewasinformedbeforehandthatthiswouldnotbearealcoup.HewasalliedwithErdogan.
Whydidthepro-coupunitsfailtooccupy/controlcommunicationscenters,TVstationsotherthanTRTandCNN-Turk?
Astheywereforcedtostartthecoupearlierthantheyplannedtheystumbled.
OnlyahandfulofsoldiersweresenttoTRTandCNN-Turkandtheywereeasilysubduedbypoliceandcivilians.NomilitaryunitsweresenttootherTVstations,includingpro-ErdoganTVchannelswhosestudioswerewalkingdistancefromthefewpositionsthesoldiers“occupied.”
Ifthisattemptweregenuine,evenifthemilitarywereforcedtostartearly,thiswouldbeacrucialstep.Themilitarydidnotplanthisattempt.Itwasplannedbytheintelligenceservice.Therefore,thecrucialpiecesofamilitarycoupweremissing.
Government’s“Evidence”againstGulenandResponsesTheErdogangovernmentofferedalleged“evidence”implicatingGulenandhissympathizerstothecoup92.Hereweexplorethoseclaimsandofferresponses.ThecaseofAdilOksuz,theallegedcivilianleaderofthecoup,isdiscussedinmoredetailinAppendixA.
![Page 22: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Claim1:ThreepoliceofficersallegedlyaffiliatedwithGulenwereamongtheputschistsoldiers.Response:ThesethreeofficerswerenotamongthethousandsofpoliceofficerspurgedbeforeJuly15bytheErdogangovernment.IfErdogan’sclaimsofGulenhavingthousandsofsympathizerswithinthepoliceforceweretrue,itwouldnotmakesensethatonlythreewouldparticipateintheattempt.Claim2:LeventTurkkan,aidedecampofChiefofGeneralStaff,“confessed”tobeingaGulenaffiliate.Response:Turkkanshowedclearsignsoftorturewhenhefirstemergedfromdetention.Histestimonyisunreliable.Athiscourthearing,Turkkanstatedthathegavehisinitialtestimonyunderduress.Claim3:ConfessionofBrigadierGeneralSagirResponse:SimilartoCol.Turkkan,Gen.Sagirshowedsignsoftorturewhenheemergedfromdetention.Histestimony,therefore,isnotreliable.Claim4:TaskListRecoveredonPutschistGeneralResponse:Theallegedtasklistisfullofcontradictions.Manyimportantcivilianpoststhataresupposedtobefilledbymilitaryofficersaremissing.Theallocationofmilitaryofficerstothepostsonthelistdoesnotlineup.Gen.AkinOzturk,forinstance,isassignedapostthatisinferiortotheposthehadpriortoJuly15.ThecaptainwhoinformedtheIntelligenceServiceofanimpendingcoupisalsoincludedinthislist.Inanycase,therelativelyeasyrecoveryofsuchalistissimplytooconvenienttobetrue.Claim5:OffertoPutChiefofGeneralStaffAkaronaPhoneLinewithGulenResponse:BothGulenandGen.HakanUnver,whoallegedlymadetheoffertoAkar,deniedthisclaim.Akarwasnotcalledtogivetestimonytotheparliamentarycommissionaboutthisorotherallegationsagainsthim.Hedidnotaddressthisissueinhiswrittenresponsestothecommission.Claim6:AdilOksuzwasthecivilianmastermindofthecoup.Response:ThegovernmentclaimedthatAdilOksuz,whoisaprofessorofTheologyatSakaryaUniversity,wastheorganizeroftheairforceofficersaffiliatedwithGulen.Besidesthefactthatitisimpossibletostageamilitarycoupwiththeairforcealone,thisallegationraisesmanyquestions.ThegovernmentclaimedthatOksuzwasarrestedneartheAkinciAirBase,theallegedheadquartersoftheattempt.AccordingtoaninterviewbyOksuz’sfamilytoaTurkishTVstation,whenhemetwiththembeforehisdisappearance,OksuzclaimedthathewasbroughtneartheAkinciAirBaseagainsthiswillbythepoliceafterbeingdetainedatacheckpoint.DespitereportedlyhavinganIntelligenceServicefileonhim,OksuzwasletfreebytwojudgesonJuly16andatamandatoryreportstopatthecourthouseonJuly18.HethentraveledonacommercialflighttoIstanbulgoingthroughairportsecuritycheckpointswithhisownIDandthendisappearedaftermeetinghisfamily.ItappearsthegovernmentwantedOksuztodisappearsothattheclaimsagainsthimandtheallegedlinktoGulencouldbecirculatedwithoutchallenge.AmoredetaileddiscussionofthiscaseisgiveninAppendixA.Claim7:OtherciviliansfoundatAkinciAirBase,TRTandTURKSAT.Response:TherearemanyproblemswiththeargumentsmadebytheErdogangovernmentagainsttheHizmetmovementregardingtheaccusedciviliansallegedlyfoundatkeylocationsonthenightofJuly15includingtheAkinciairbase,TRTbroadcastingcenterandTURKSATsatellitecenter:First,thereliabilityofthe“confessions”oftheseindividualsisquestionableduetotheoverwhelmingatmosphereofblameandindicatorsoftorturewhileindetention.Exacerbatingthisarereportsofatleastsomeoftheaccusedhavingbeenbroughttothoselocationsagainsttheirwill,includingthenow-famousAdil
![Page 23: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
Oksuz.SomecivilianswithtechnicalskillswereclaimedtohavebeenbroughttoTRTbytheputschiststostopitsbroadcast93.However,itwasnotclearwhytheputschistswouldwanttostoptheTRTbroadcastratherthanoccupyit.Finally,whatevertheintentionsandactionsoftheciviliansallegedlyinvolvedintheeventsofJuly15,thereappearstobenomilitaryactionthatcanbetracedtothemaccordingtoofficers’testimonies.AllmilitaryofficersreportreceivingorderstomobilizefromtheirsuperiorsorthroughmessagesissuedwithinthemilitarycommunicationssystemoriginatingfromtheOfficeofGeneralStaff.Theoneindividual,Capt.MehmetAkkurt,theaidedecampoftheSecondChiefofStaffYasarGuler,whoischargedwithissuingordersformartiallawisunabletodefendhimselfsincehewaskilledonthenightofJuly15.Claim8:SocialmediapostsandmediainterviewshintatanimpendingcoupbyindividualsallegedlyconnectedwithGulen.Response:Whileitistruethatcertainsocialmediapostsbycertainindividualshintatanimpendingcoup,thatdoesnotofferevidencetoimplicateGulenorHizmetparticipantsforthreereasons:First,priortoJuly15,therumorsofanimpendingcoupweresowidespreadandbyindividualsofallorientations,includingErdogansympathizers.Second,thenatureoftherelationshipbetweentheaccusedindividualsandGulenishighlydebatable.ItispossibletofindpostsbyHizmetsympathizersthatarehighlycriticaloftheaforementionedpostsandthataccusethoseindividualsofbeingmolesplantedbytheTurkishIntelligenceService.Inanycase,therehavebeennostatementsbycredibleaffiliatesofGulenthatconfirmtheaffiliationofthoseindividualswithhim.Finally,someofthosepostsandmediainterviewshavebeeneditedanddisseminatedoutofcontext.Forinstance,avideointerviewsegmentbyDr.OsmanOzsoy,ahistoryprofessor,authorandTVprogramhost,hasbeencirculatedbypro-ErdoganmediaasevidenceofGulensympathizers’involvementintheJuly15attempt.Inthesegment,OzsoysaysthathewouldbeabletoservehiscountrymuchbetterasacolonelinTurkisharmyratherthaninhiscurrentroleasanacademicandcommentator.WhatiseditedoutofthissegmentisthepartwhereOzsoyexplainswhathemeans.Accordingtohisexplanation,manyoftheTurkishmilitaryanti-terroroperationsarecommandedbycolonels.HeisexpressinghiswishthatasacolonelhecouldbepartofcounterterrorismoperationsthattheTurkisharmyhasbeenconductingforyears.Claim9:Gulen-sympathizersused“ByLock,”anencryptedcommunicationprogram.Response:The“ByLock”softwarewascommerciallyavailableonApple’sAppStoreandGooglePlay.ThemainserverfortheByLocksoftwarewasbroughtdownseveralmonthsbeforeJuly15,accordingtoitsauthor,makingitunusable94.Intheirbriefingtoforeignreporters,membersoftheTurkishIntelligenceServicestatedthatnoneoftheByLockmessagesthattheyinterceptedreferencedacoupplot95.Nevertheless,theuseoftheByLocksoftwarehasbeenusedbyTurkishcourtstoestablish“guiltbyassociation”96andincriminatethousandsofTurkishcitizensincludingacademics97,businesspeople98andhousewives99.StrategicGoalsAchievedbyErdoganThankstotheJuly15IncidentTheJuly15incidentgaveErdogananexcellentexcusetopursuehisgoalofconsolidatingpower.Inparticular:
1. Massivepurgesandarreststargetedmembersofthebureaucracyandthecivilsociety.Inthemorningofthecoup,abigpurgestartedwiththedismissalandlaterarrestsof2,745members
![Page 24: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
ofthejudiciary.Duringtheremainingmonths,morethan120,000governmentemployeesweresacked.Purgescontinuedtounprecedentedproportions,andtensofthousandsofcivilians,includinghousewivesandmothersofinfants100weretargeted.
2. Erdogan’sbidforexecutivepresidencygainedmomentum.PriortotheJuly15coupattempt,opinionpollsconsistentlyshowedthatthemajorityoftheTurkishelectoratewasopposedtotheexecutivepresidentialsystemproposedbyErdogan101.Intheaftermathoftheincident,Erdoganbeganpushingforthechange.InaconstitutionalreferenduminApril2017,hesecuredbyanarrowmarginthepathtoa2019executivepresidency.
3. Purgingandrestructuringthemilitarybecamemucheasier.Inthemorningofthecoup,abigpurgestarted,withmorethan2,700membersofthejudiciaryand8,000militaryofficerssacked,including150NATOofficers(halfoftheNATOstaffintheTurkishmilitary).ErdoganstartedacompleteoverhauloftheTurkishmilitary’ssystemofeducation,recruitment,reportingandpromotion.
4. TurkisharmyenteredSyria.ItwaswellknownthatErdoganwantedtheTurkishmilitarytointerveneinNorthernSyriatosupporttheFreeSyrianArmyagainstthegroupknownasthe“SyrianDemocraticForcesledbyKurdishYPGforces.Thatdesire,however,wasmetwithresistancebysomecommandersoftheTurkishmilitary.Gen.AdemHuduti,commanderoftheSecondArmy,andGen.ErdalOzturk,commanderofthe3rdArmyCorps,bothknownasKemalist/Secularistcommanders,werearrestedafterJuly15.WhileGen.HudutiwasathiscommandonthenightofJuly15,Gen.OzturkwasonvacationataMediterraneanresort.Thecommonattributeofthesecommanders,alongwithGen.SemihTerzi,commanderofSpecialForces’1stBrigade,whowaskilledbyaninferiorofficerthatnight,isthattheywereknowntohavestronglyopposedTurkishMilitary’sincursionintoSyria.TurkishMilitarystartedanincursionintoSyriainAugust2016102.
ConcludingRemarksOnJuly15,2016,ahorrificandanunprecedentedtragedyoccurredinTurkey.Anactionthatlookedlikeamilitarycoup,onethatcostthelivesofhundredsofsoldiersandcivilians,wascrushedprimarilybythepoliceforceandTurkishcitizens.ManyaspectsoftheincidentbaffledobserversandquestionspersisttothisdaysuchasPresidentErdogan’shavingreportedfourdifferenttimesastowhenhelearnedaboutit,theIntelligenceChiefsnotinformingorprotectingErdogan,themilitaryChiefofGeneralStaff’snotcommunicatingwithErdoganorprotectinghimself,thesoldiers’failuretotakePresidentErdoganorPMBinaliYildirimintocustody,thelackofanyattempttocontrol100plusmediaoutletsfriendlytoErdogan,thestartingoftheactionatrushhour,theshuttingdownofIstanbul’sverybusyBosphorustraffic,andthebombingoftheparliamentbuildingandpoliceheadquarters.Theseactionsdon'tmakesenseinamilitarycoup,whichTurkeyfacedmultipletimesbefore,andimportantquestionsremainaboutthegovernment’snarrative.However,thereisanalternativenarrativeunderwhichalloftheseactionsmakesense.Thealternativenarrative,whichisreferredtoasthe“CollusionNarrative”here,isthatagroupofultra-nationalistofficers,incollusionwithErdoganandhisIntelligenceService,startedaweakandcompromisedmilitaryactiononlytocrushitwiththehelpofthepoliceforceandangrycrowds.Themovewasdesignedtolackessentialcomponentsofamilitarycoup,andhencewasguaranteedtofail.Accordingtothisnarrative,PresidentErdoganreportedfourdifferenttimesastowhenhelearnedabouttheincidentbecausehewasnottellingthetruth.TheIntelligenceDirectordidnotinformorprotectErdoganbecauseErdogandidnotneedtobeinformedorprotected.ThemilitaryactionwassetuptofailandtherewasnorealthreattoErdogan’slife.Theactionbeganduringrushhourandthe
![Page 25: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
parliamentbuildingwasbombedtoaggravatethepublic.Policespecialoperationsheadquarterswasbombedbeforepolicetookanyactionagainstthemilitary,inordertoaggravateandemboldenthepolice.Atthispoint,thereisnotenoughevidencetoclaimthatthecollusionnarrativeiswhatactuallyhappenedonJuly15.Andthisdiscussionisnotintendedtoserveasadefinitiveassertionoraccusation,butratherasacallforanindependentinvestigationcomprisedofaninternationalcommitteeofexperts.Forsuchaninvestigationtosucceed,theTurkishgovernmentmustalsoguaranteethesafetyoftheaccusedmilitaryofficersandtheirfamiliessotheycantestifywithoutfearofreprisalbythegovernment.Ironically,theclarificationofwhatreallyhappenedonJuly15isinthehandsoftheErdogangovernment,whichsofarhasshownlittleinterestinferretingoutthefacts.
![Page 26: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
EXHIBITA:CategoriesofHumanRightsAbusesunderErdogan’sStateofEmergency
![Page 27: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
EXHIBITB:Gulen’sMessageCondemningtheAttemptandDenyingAnyInvolvementThefollowingmessagewasapprovedbyF.Gulenforpublicationaround1:48AMTurkishtimewhilethecoupattemptwasinprogress.
EXHIBITC:Gulen’sOpEdChallengingErdoganOnLeMonde(11August2016)GulenchallengedTurkishGovernmenttoallowforaninternationalinvestigationintotheeventandpledgedtoprovidefullcooperation.
![Page 28: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
EXHIBITD:PhotosofOfficersShowingSignsofTorture
ColonelLeventTurkkan,aidedecampofChiefofGeneralStaff,allegedly“confessed”toparticipatinginthecoupattheurgingofGulenaffiliates.
Soldierspileduplikefishduringdetention.
Gen.AkinOzturk,formercommanderoftheairforce,showingsignsofilltreatmentandpotentiallytorture.OzturkwasaccusedbythegovernmenttobethemilitarymastermindofthecoupdespitebeingexoneratedbytheChiefofGeneralStaffAkar.Akarlaterretractedhisexoneratingstatementfromthewebsiteofhisoffice.
ColonelFiratAlakusofSpecialForcesshowingsignsofilltreatmentandpotentiallytorture.Alakuswasaccusedofparticipatinginthecoup.HedeniedtheaccusationandsaidthathesimplyfollowedhisorderstoprotecttheofficeoftheChiefofGeneralStaffissuedbytheSpecialForcesCommanderGen.Aksakalli.Aksalliwasnevercharged.
![Page 29: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
EXHIBITE:Erdogan’sContradictoryReportsofWhenHeLearnedAbouttheJuly15Attempt
July16:ErdoganatIstanbulAtaturkairport,around4:20am,statingthat“asitisknowntherewasmobilizationwithinthemilitaryin
theafternoonhours”.
July18:ErdogantellingCNNthathelearnedabouttheeventfromhisbrotherinlawaround
8pm.
July21:ErdogantellingReutersthathelearnedabouttheattemptaround4:30pm.
July30:ErdogantellingTurkishnewschannelA-Haberthathelearnedabouttheattempt
around9:30pm.
![Page 30: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
EXHIBITF:VisualsofDamagetotheParliamentBuilding
Parliamentroomallegedlydamagedbyaerialbombing.Observersnotethatthedoorshingesshownosignofexplosiondamage.
Parliamentroomallegedlydamagedbyaerialbombing.ObserversnotethattheHDTVonthewellshowsnosignofexplosiondamageincontrastwiththefurniture.
Ex-militaryobserversnotingavisualpatterninconsistentwithapenetratingtwo-stagebombdamage.
AsitedevotedtoanalyzinggovernmentclaimsaboutJuly15contraststhevisualpatternoftheallegedaerialbombingoftheparliamentwiththevideofootageofarealaerialbombingwiththeammunitionclaimedtohavebeenused.
![Page 31: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
EXHIBITG:PressReleasebytheChiefofTurkishGeneralStaffonJuly21ExoneratingGen.AkinOzturk(Item5),praisinghisefforttotrytostoptheattempt.ThepressreleasewaslaterremovedfromtheChiefofGeneralStaff’swebsiteunderpressurebyErdogan.
![Page 32: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
APPENDIXA:AdilOksuz:TheAllegedCivilianLeaderoftheAttemptTurkishgovernmenthasclaimedthatDr.AdilOksuz,aprofessoroftheologyatSakaryaUniversitywasthecivilianorganizerbehindtheJuly15thincident.ThegovernmentclaimedthathetraveledtotheUnitedStates,allegedlytomeetwithGulenandgethisapprovalforacoupattempt.OksuzwasdetainedonthenightofJuly15thnearAkinciairbaseinAnkara,theallegedheadquartersoftheattempt.Theinformationthatsurfacedabouthim,however,raisesseveralquestionsaboutthegovernment’sstory.Let’sexaminetheevidenceagainsthim:
1. AphotographofOksuzattheAkinciairbase,datedJuly16th,togetherwithdetainedofficers.[VISUAL]
2. AvideoofOksuz,enteringandexitingSincancourthouseinthemorningofJuly18th.TworelatedvideorecordingsshowOksuzatAnkara’sEsenbogaairportandIstanbul’sSabihaGokcenairportaround9amthemorningofJuly18th.[VISUAL]
3. Testimoniesbytwosecretwitnesses,namedSapka(Hat)andKuzgun(Raven),thatOksuztraveledtotheU.S.togetGulen’sapprovalforthecoupandwasactivelyorganizingofficersthenightpriortothecoup.
OksuzwascapturednearAkinciairbaseonthenightofJuly15.Thegovernmentallegedthathewastheretotouchbasewiththemilitaryofficers.HewasarrestedandkeptattheairbaseandphotographedtherebeforebeingtakentoSincancourthousealongwith99militaryofficers.Whilealltheofficerswerearrested,OksuzwasreleasedbyjudgeKoksalCelikduetolackofevidencewiththeconditionsthathereporttothecourthousetwodayslaterandwithabanonforeigntravel.ProsecutorMehmetYilmazappealedthereleasedecisiontoahighercourt(AsliyeCeza).Thistime,judgeCetinSonmezdeniedtheprosecutor’sappealonthebasisthattherewasnoevidencetojustifyanarrest.Pro-governmentmediaallegedthatthejudgeswereGulen-sympathizers.However,itwasrevealedlaterthatoneofthejudgesissuedasupervisor/trustee(“kayyim”inTurkish)toaHizmet-sympatheticcompanyaspartofErdogan’scrackdownonHizmet.Twodayslater,Oksuzreportedtothecourt,spending21minutesatthecourthouseandthentookaflighttoIstanbulfromAnkara’sEsenbogaairport.OksuzwaswelcomedattheIstanbulairportbyhisbrother-in-lawandtakentohishouse.HespentthedayathishouseandthenheadedtoSakarya,hisworkplaceandwherehisin-lawswereliving.HespentthenightofJuly19intheirhome,toldhisstory,andleftinthemorning,presumablyforwork,nevertobeseensince.Whileathisin-laws’home,OksuztoldthemthathewasdetainedagainsthiswillbythepoliceinAnkaraanddroppedatahighwayneartheAkinciairbase.Hewasimmediatelyarrestedthereandtakentothebase.Hewasinterrogatedandreleasedlater.ThecaseofAdilOksuzraisesmanyquestionsforthegovernmentnarrative.IfOksuzindeedplayedaroleinthepreparationofJuly15andhadpreviousrelationshipswithmilitaryofficers,thenitisinconceivablethatTurkishIntelligenceServiceMITdidnothaveafileonhim.While99soldierswhowerebroughttothecourtwerearrested,Oksuzwasreleasedbytwoseparatejudges.Inthevideoofhisreturningtothecourthouseforreporting,asaskedbythejudge,heappearscomfortableandreadyfortravelwithasuitcaseinhishand.Heentersandexitsthecourthousewiththesuitcase.WhenheiswelcomebyhisbrotherinlawinIstanbul,thelattermakesavisualcall,presumablytoOksuz’family,andOksuzwaveshishand.Oksuz’generalappearanceatthecourthouseonthemorningofJuly18,histakingaflighttoIstanbulbyshowinghisphotoID,fullyawareofsecuritycamerasrecordinghisactions,spendingJuly18athisownresidenceandthenspendingthenextnightathisin-laws’residencedonotreflectthepsychologyandexpectedbehaviorpatternofamaninvolvedin
![Page 33: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
orchestratingamilitarycoupandbeingluckyenoughtobereleasedbymistake.AKPgovernmentpurged2745membersofthejudiciarythedayafterthecoupattemptandmorethan2000ofthemwerealsoarrestedandimprisoned.ThetwojudgeswhoreleasedOksuz,however,werenotdismissedorimprisoned.Theyweresimplysubjectedtoaninquiry,anincomparablyfavorabletreatmentincontrasttothethousandsofjudgesandprosecutorswhowerefirstdismissedandthenarrestedstartingonJuly16.APPENDIXB:ExcerptsfromIndependentCommentaryontheAlternativeNarrativesGermanintelligenceexpertandauthorErichSchmidt-Eenboom,speakingonaGermanpublicbroadcasterZDF103:
“According to CIA analyses, the so-called coup attempt was staged by Erdoğan to prevent a real coup. The BND, CIA and other Western intelligence services do not see the slightest evidence showing Gülen instigating the coup attempt.”
VeteranTurkishJournalistCengizÇandaronAlMonitor,PostedJuly17,2016104
While the Turkish coup was underway, The New York Times was asking me whether I was surprised, expecting my answer to be, “Of course I am.” I bluntly wanted to respond “No” and remind New York Times correspondent Sabrina Tavernise that only two weeks ago, in our lengthy chat in Istanbul, I had told her of the “Faustian bargain President [Recep Tayyip] Erdogan made with the military, which therefore, in my opinion, opened the way for a coup or a coup attempt to take place in Turkey within the upcoming two years.” But I conceded and told her, “Yes, I’m surprised. I did not expect that to happen in two weeks.”
KemalKilicdaroglu,chairmanofmainoppositionpartyCHP:
“The real coup was done on July 20, after the controlled coup of July 15th was over. Nobody should forget July 20th. This is the date when the executive branch got the approval for the state of emergency from the parliament. Now, the real putschists of July 20 want to constitutionalize the current situation. That is why they brought this constitutional amendment to the parliament.”105(Translationandemphasisbyauthors)106
GermanFocusmagazinereportedthefollowingintheirJuly2016issue:
British signals intelligence agency GCHQ intercepted communication between top Erdogan brass about half an hour after shooting started that the coup would be blamed on Gulen and purges would start the next day107108.
HDPleaderSelahattinDemirtasinaspeechatTurkishparliament:
“I heard it from my brother-in-law.” He says. Lie! He knew about it before you, me, MIT (Turkish Intelligence Service). You knew about the coup, took your precautions, and just to consolidate your power you let all those people die. We are facing one of the biggest setups in the history of Turkey109.“
DemirtaswasarrestedinFebruary2017underterrorismcharges110.AykanErdemir,formerTurkishparliamentarianandseniorfellowatWashington-basedFoundationforDefenseofDemocraciesquestionedtherelativespeedinwhichthecoupattemptwasfoiled:
PresidentRecepTayyipErdogan’sallegationsaboutexiledclericFethullahGülen’sinvolvementintheJuly15coupd’etatbidinTurkeyisnotbeingtakenseriouslybymanyanalystsbasedinvariousworld
![Page 34: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
capitals.However,governmentsaremaintainingsilenceonthematterindeferencetothe‘legitimatedemocraticgovernment’inAnkara.MostanalystsareindeedquestioningthewaytheTurkeycoupwasfoiledbeforeitactuallygotimplementedontheground.Wastheplotsetupforaguaranteedfailure?WasitaimedtostrengthenErdogan’srulewhilehisgraspoverhiselectoratewaslooseningthankstofailureinSyria,economiclossesduetoRussiansanctionsimposedforshootingdownitsplaneandmistrustvis-à-visIran?111
JoeLauria,aveteranforeign-affairsjournalistwrote:
Because Erdogan knew of the coup hours before, there is a stronger possibility that he let it happen to smoke out disloyal officers, confident his handpicked brass would crush it. They may have played along with the coup and then double-crossed the coup leaders once it was underway. It would be a seriously amateurish attempt to go ahead without the consent of the top military leadership112.
MithatSancar,memberoftheParliamentaryCommissionInvestigatingtheJuly15thIncidentrepresentingoppositionHDP113:
“Many individuals, who would have provided valuable information to illuminate the coup attempt were not called to testify at the parliamentary investigation commission. The ruling AKP did not form this commission to illuminate the coup attempt. They produced a coup narrative. The ruling AKP has a narrative about the coup attempt. They were expecting a work that would support this narrative…. In our opinion, AKP leadership and the President knew about the coup plan a while ago. The president and his team knew about it. Instead of stopping it, they allowed it to start. Their purpose was to capture the coup plotters on the night of the attempt. Not only that. When the President called the coup attempt “a gift from God”, he was publicizing his plan for the aftermath of the attempt. They used the coup attempt as an opportunity and implemented a counter coup.”114(Translationbyauthors)
APPENDIXC:ExcerptfromReportbyU.K.HouseofCommonsonU.K.TurkishRelations115
“Given the brutality of the events of 15 July, the severity of the charges made against the Gülenists, and the scale of the purges of perceived Gülenists that has been justi ed on this basis, there is a relative lack of hard, publicly–available evidence to prove that the Gülenists as an organisation were responsible for the coup attempt in Turkey. While there is evidence to indicate that some individual Gülenists were involved, it is mostly anecdotal or circumstantial, sometimes premised on information from confessions or informants, and is—so far—inconclusive in relation to the organisation as a whole or its leadership. As we publish this report, nine months after the coup attempt, neither the UK nor Turkish governments can point us to one person who has been found guilty by a court of involvement in the coup attempt, let alone anyone being found guilty with evidence of involvement with Gülenist motives. We also note that, despite Turkey purportedly submitting 80 boxes of ‘evidence’ to the US to achieve the extradition of Fethullah Gülen on the basis that he masterminded the coup attempt, the US judiciary has not yet moved to deport him.”
![Page 35: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
ENDNOTES1https://turkeypurge.comnumbersreportedasof23June2017.2http://www.intflc.org3http://internationalfestival.us4https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2016/07/turkey-independent-monitors-must-be-allowed-to-access-detainees-amid-torture-allegations/5https://www.hrw.org/news/2016/10/25/turkey-emergency-decrees-facilitate-torture6http://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=209777https://www.hrw.org/report/2016/10/24/blank-check/turkeys-post-coup-suspension-safeguards-against-torture8https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/17/world/europe/turkey-erdogan-gulen-purge.html9http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-l-phillips/erdogans-inner-stalin_b_11101118.html10http://hizmetnews.com/18205/fethullah-gulen-condemns-coup-attempt-turkey/11http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/26/opinion/fethullah-gulen-i-condemn-all-threats-to-turkeys-democracy.html12http://www.huffingtonpost.com/emre-celik/fethullah-guelen-i-call-f_b_11480974.html13http://www.theglobepost.com/2017/03/25/after-8-months-turkish-govt-still-unable-to-sell-coup-narrative-to-allies/14https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/20/world/europe/fethullah-gulen-erdogan-extradition.html15https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/a-reality-check-on-the-middle-east-from-americas-spy-chief/2016/07/21/a221a1aa-4f86-11e6-aa14-e0c1087f7583_story.html?utm_term=.aa0efff4f74a16http://www.reuters.com/article/us-turkey-security-germany-idUSKBN16P0LQ17http://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/erdogan-plotted-purge-before-coup-say-brussels-spies-2hh8mgx6h18https://www.alaraby.co.uk/english/indepth/2017/2/1/UK-No-evidence-Gulen-involved-in-Turkey-coup-attempt19https://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201617/cmselect/cmfaff/615/615.pdf20https://washingtonhattius.com/2017/06/15/western-diplomatic-sources-western-govts-not-believe-gulen-behind-coup/21Amemberofthejudiciarywhowasonthepurgelistdiedmonthsbeforetheincident.22http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2016/07/why_the_failed_turkish_coup_will_empower_erdogan.html23https://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201617/cmselect/cmfaff/615/615.pdf24https://www.turkishminute.com/2017/05/21/testimony-shows-major-informed-mit-about-coup-7-hours-beforehand/25https://www.turkishminute.com/2016/12/04/chp-deputy-implies-july-15-coup-attempt-staged/26https://www.turkeyanalyst.org/publications/turkey-analyst-articles/item/562-post-putsch-narratives-and-turkeys-curious-coup.html27http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-skeptics/why-erdo%C4%9Fan-shouldnt-double-down-dictatorship-after-the-coup-1701728TurkishparliamenttookthedecisiontoformthecommissiononJuly26th.However,byprovidingthenamesofAKPdelegatestothecommissionjustbeforetheparliamentwentonvacation,AKPdelayedthestartofthecommission’sworkuntilOctober4th.29http://www.gazeteduvar.com.tr/yazarlar/2017/01/10/akpye-ragmen-bu-karanlik-darbenin-sirlari-ortaya-cikacak/
![Page 36: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
30ThecommissiondidnotevenaskforanaffidavitfromMr.Guleninresponsetotheaccusationsagainsthim.31http://www.silkroadstudies.org/publications/joint-center-publications/item/13209-a-botched-coup-and-turkeys-descent-into-madness.html32http://www.cumhuriyet.com.tr/haber/siyaset/775047/Bekir_Bozdag__Darbe_olmus_Basbakanlik_musavirisiniz_gidip_konusuyorsunuz_siz_kimsiniz_.html33http://www.sabah.com.tr/yazarlar/kutahyali/2017/03/07/15-temmuz-ve-ataturkcu-subaylar34http://www.globalresearch.ca/why-the-failed-turkish-coup-attempt-wasnt-a-false-flag-power-grab-by-erdogan/553634135http://www.atimes.com/article/turkish-military-denies-coup-attempt-against-erdogan-what-next/36http://vatanpartisi.org.tr/genel-merkez/gundeme-dair/rus-yetkili-bizi-vatan-partisi-ikna-etti-2026437https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_sanctioned_during_the_Ukrainian_crisis38http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/11038730/French-politician-defends-plan-for-Crimean-theme-park.html39http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-dugin-trump-putin-turkey-20170203-story.html40https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWkHihbiYDw41http://bipartisanpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/BPC-President-Erdogan-Turkey.pdf42http://www.tgrthaber.com.tr/politika/perincek-erdogan-olmazsa-abdye-karsi-koyamayiz-17524843http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/humanrightsreport/44https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2015/country-chapters/turkey45https://www.amnesty.org/en/countries/europe-and-central-asia/turkey/report-turkey/46http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/10/turkey-criticised-over-media-freedoms-and-judicial-independence-in-eu-report47https://www.icj.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Turkey-Judiciary-in-Peril-Publications-Reports-Fact-Findings-Mission-Reports-2016-ENG.pdf48https://www.wsj.com/articles/mike-flynns-pro-turkey-work-an-unfinished-documentary-to-boost-countrys-image-149618327649http://dailycaller.com/2017/06/01/the-landscape-surrounding-michael-flynns-enigmatic-client/50https://www.wsj.com/articles/ex-cia-director-mike-flynn-and-turkish-officials-discussed-removal-of-erdogan-foe-from-u-s-149038042651http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-dugin-trump-putin-turkey-20170203-story.html52http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2016/10/turkey-power-struggle-between-islamists-and-secularists.html53http://foreignpolicy.com/2017/07/13/turkeys-post-coup-purge-and-erdogans-private-army-sadat-perincek-gulen/54http://www.palo.com.tr/a/özgürlüğümün-bir-tümörle-gelmesi-ne-acı-demişti-28775355https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pHoGhGbc_a456http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/07/12/turkeys-deep-state-has-a-secret-backchannel-to-assad/57http://vatanpartisi.org.tr/english/dosyalar/the-turkish-left-and-the-pkk-1109458http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/07/29/erdogan-and-u-s-general-in-post-coup-war-of-words/59http://www.reuters.com/article/us-turkey-nato-exclusive-idUSKCN12C16Q60http://iswresearch.blogspot.com/2016/07/partial-assessment-of-turkeys-post-coup.html
![Page 37: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
37
61http://www.turkiyegazetesi.com.tr/yazarlar/fuat-ugur/591124.aspx62Bukonuşma7ŞubatMİTdarbesindensonra,17-25Aralıkdarbegirişimindendeöncedir.ÜmitAkdemirovakitşöyleyanıtlıyoronları:“BakMuratbey.Emniyet’teörneğinkaçmüdürlükvar.Diyelimki500.Amabirdüşünün.O500hizmetelemanınıorayayerleştirirkensenenaz2000adayıküstürmüşsün.Sizsanıyormusunuzkiemniyetsadecebizden.Buyargıdada,bürokrasidedeböyle.Sanıyormusunuzkidevletuyuyor.Hepsinitakipediyor.Emiryukarıdangeldiğindehareketegeçenleraynızamandakendilerinideifşaetmişolurlar.Devletdeonlarınzatenhizalanmasınıbeklemektedirvebüyüktemizliğebaşlar.Anadolu’dabirlafvardır,TavukTAR’dasayılır.Sizdolaşır,çalışırsınız.Sanırsınızkidevletinhiçbirşeydenhaberiyok.EmirkomutaileTar’ın,yaniodununüzerinesıralanıphizalandığınızdaöylekolaysayılırveavlanırsınızkineyeuğradığınızışaşırırsınız.Devletbazıhareketlerinizigöremeyebiliramaortayaçıktığınızanhepiniziavlar.”63http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2016/07/why_the_failed_turkish_coup_will_empower_erdogan.html64http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2016/07/turkey-kamikaze-coup-attempt-fails.html65http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/darbe-girisiminden-yargilanan-binbasi-aksakal-4035773366https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jul/18/military-coup-was-well-planned-and-very-nearly-succeeded-say-turkish-officials67http://www.posta.com.tr/tbmm-yi-bombalayan-darbeci-pilot-terorle-mucadele-harekati-sandim-haberi-128277168http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/pro-coup-sniper-on-istanbuls-bosphorus-bridge-tower-shot-dead-during-coup-attempt--.aspx?pageID=238&nID=101904&NewsCatID=34169https://www.wsj.com/articles/erdogan-ally-died-in-bosporus-bridge-confrontation-146894927670AlawyerwhoescapedfromTurkeyaftertheincidentsharedthestoryofaresidentofCengelkoydistrictinIstanbul.Accordingtothisresidentcivilianswerekilledintheirdistrictbybearded,armedmenonmotorcycles.ThisdescriptionfitsthedescriptionofmembersofSADAT,whatisineffectPresidentErdogan’spersonalarmy.71http://www.shaber3.com/adam-kacirilan-siyah-transporterlar-15-temmuzda-da-sahnedeymis-haberi/1286295/72http://www.sozcu.com.tr/2016/gundem/silahli-sivillerin-sokakta-ne-isi-var-1317315/73http://www.milliyet.com.tr/turksat-davasinda-ikinci-ara-karar-gundem-2458915/74http://www.aei.org/publication/did-erdogan-stage-the-coup/75https://stockholmcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/15_July_Erdogans_Coup_13.07.2017.pdf76https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VHr3MdZn8G877https://purgednato.files.wordpress.com/2017/05/a-search-for-truth1.pdfp.4878http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3694232/Eight-coup-supporters-fled-Greece-Blackhawk-helicopter-fight-Turkish-demands-sent-home-face-retribution.html79http://www.cnbc.com/2016/07/15/gunfire-heard-jets-seen-flying-in-turkish-capital-of-ankara.html80https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1GtZaYQ9JQ81https://stockholmcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/15_July_Erdogans_Coup_13.07.2017.pdf82https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZtuHW-fFIY83http://www.keeptalkinggreece.com/2016/07/21/greeces-air-force-erdogans-aircraft-at-no-point-harassed-by-rebel-f-16s-on-coup-night/84https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CcO84VubmU885http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2016/07/turkey-kamikaze-coup-attempt-fails.html
![Page 38: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
38
86http://haber.sol.org.tr/toplum/yandas-fatih-tezcanin-darbeci-dedigi-isim-genelkurmay-baskani-yapildi-16219987http://www.yeniasya.com.tr/gundem/koprudeki-askerler-darbe-girisimi-gecesi-yasadiklarini-anlatti_40607888http://www.gazetevatan.com/darbeci-askerlerden-sasirtan-ifadeler-1039748-gundem/89https://stockholmcf.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/15_July_Erdogans_Coup_13.07.2017.pdf90http://www.bbc.com/turkce/3685860191http://www.emekliasubaylar.org/images/haberler/darbe/genkur-basin-21-temmuz.jpg92https://www.hizmetstudies.org/commentary/questions-we-dare-not-ask-gulen-and-the-coup/93http://www.sabah.com.tr/gundem/2016/08/23/trtyi-basan-sivil-ismin-kimligi-ortaya-cikti94http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/bylock-use-is-an-evidence-of-gulen-network-links-owner.aspx?PageID=238&NID=105284&NewsCatID=50995https://www.wsj.com/articles/turkeys-powerful-spy-network-never-saw-coup-coming-146982306296http://www.latimes.com/world/europe/la-fg-turkey-purge-crackdown-snap-story.html97https://turkeypurge.com/22-itu-academics-jailed-over-bylock-use98https://turkeypurge.com/40-businessmen-public-servants-detained-over-bylock-use99https://turkeypurge.com/33-housewives-teachers-detained-in-kayseri-over-bylock-use100http://www.turkeypurge.com101http://www.newsweek.com/turkey-coup-erdogan-can-now-consolidate-power-483951102ItisinterestingtonotethatHomelandPartymemberformerGen.PekinandotherretiredseniorTurkishofficersRearAdm.SonerPolatandMaj.Gen.BeyazitKaratas,visitedDamascusinJanuary,April,andMay2015andmetwith“severalofthemostinfluentialsecuritychiefs,diplomats,andpoliticalofficialsintheSyriangovernment”inordertofacilitateanormalizationofrelationswithTurkey.http://foreignpolicy.com/2016/07/12/turkeys-deep-state-has-a-secret-backchannel-to-assad/103http://citifmonline.com/2017/04/05/erdogan-was-behind-failed-coup-based-on-cia-bnd-reports-german-intel-expert/104http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/en/originals/2016/07/turkey-military-coup-attempt-more-questions-than-answers.html105http://www.diken.com.tr/kilicdaroglu-ohali-tanimladi-gercek-darbe-20-temmuzda-yapildi/106http://presstv.ir/Detail/2017/04/03/516596/Turkey-AKP-CHP-Kemal-Kilicdaroglu-Erdogan-coup-FETO-Gulen107.http://beforeitsnews.com/alternative/2016/07/report-british-intel-proves-erdogan-staged-the-turkey-coup-will-blame-gulens-hizmet-sack-millions-3390262.html108http://www.thedailysheeple.com/report-british-intel-proves-erdogan-staged-the-turkey-coup-will-blame-gulens-hizmet-sack-millions_072016109https://www.hdp.org.tr/en/en/news/from-hdp/demirtas-erdogan-knew-about-the-coup-before-it-happened/9047110http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2017/02/turkey-kurdish-politicians-face-up-143-years-jail.html111http://www.defenddemocracy.org/media-hit/dr-aykan-erdemir-turkish-coup-staged-by-erdogan/ 112http://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/08/04/mystery-turkeys-failed-coup113http://www.gazeteduvar.com.tr/yazarlar/2017/01/10/akpye-ragmen-bu-karanlik-darbenin-sirlari-ortaya-cikacak/
![Page 39: What Really Happened in Turkey on July 15, 2016? · Fethullah Gulen, a retired preacher and a vocal Erdogan critic who has been living in Pennsylvania since 1999, to be the mastermind](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022062609/60f980a564c2be3b0c721786/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
114Original:“Dinlenmelerihalindedarbeyleilgilipekçoknoktayıaçığaçıkartacakkişilerçağrılmadı.AKPbukomisyonubellikidarbeyiaçığaçıkarmakgibibiramaçlakurdurmamıştı.Birtürdarbehikayesikurguladılar.BiranlatısıvardıAKP’nindarbeyeilişkin.Buanlatıyıdestekleyecekçalışmabekliyorlardı.Neydibuanlatı;15TemmuzdarbesiGülencemaatinemensupsubaylartarafındanorganizeedilmiş,hayatageçirilmiştir.Bütünsorumluluk,bütünplanlarGülencemaatineaittir…Darbeyekalkışanlarınsiyasibağlantıları,Gülencilerinsayısı,cemaatdışındannekadarkişininkatıldığıgibisorularhiçbirşekildetartışılmadı.AKP’ninanlatısı,darbesonrasınailişkinsiyasistretejisibusorularımümkünolduğuncasordurmamaktı.Böylebirstratejinindoğalsonucuolarakdarbedekimlerinrolaldığının,siyasiayağınınveamacınınneolduğununortayaçıkmasınıistemediler.AKPkendianlatısınauygunbirçalışmaiçinkomisyonuaraçsallaştırdı.”“BizegöreAKPyönetimi,baştaCumhurbaşkanıdarbegirişimindenbellibirsüreöncehaberdarolmuşlardı.Cumhurbaşkanıveekibinindarbedenhaberivardı.Darbegirişiminiöncedenengellemekyerineyolverdilerdarbecilere.Onlarındarbegirişiminebaşlamasınaizinverdiler,imkantanıdılar.Darbegecesidarbecilerikıskıvrakyakalamaktıamaçları.Sadecebundandaibaretdeğil.Cumhurbaşkanı‘BubizeAllahınbirlütfu’derkendarbegecesisonrasınailişkinstratejisininetbirbiçimdeaçığavuruyordu.Darbeyifırsatolarakkullandılarvekarşıdarbegerçekleştirdiler.”115https://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201617/cmselect/cmfaff/615/615.pdf