what is ailing the indian higher education

20
WHAT IS AILING THE INDIAN HIGHER EDUCATION SYSTEM ANUP K SINGH, PHD

Upload: anup-singh

Post on 22-Nov-2014

272 views

Category:

Education


1 download

DESCRIPTION

This presentation analyses the problems of higher education system in India as regards regulation, financing, governance, privatisation and commercialisation.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What  is ailing the indian higher education

WHAT IS AILING THE INDIAN HIGHER

EDUCATION SYSTEM ANUP K SINGH, PHD

Page 2: What  is ailing the indian higher education

ROILING ISSUES

• Complex and confusing regulation of higher education institutions

• Policy hung between State control and market forces

• UGC’s inability to regulate a huge educational system

• Lack of quality framework; accreditation is given just lip service

• Poor Graduate Enrolment Ratio (18%) compared to developed and BRICS countries

• Lower government (Both central and state) spending on higher education

• Exponential growth of higher education in last one and a half decade, resulting in numerous quality issues

• Sudden growth of private higher education, mostly for profit purpose

• Lack of scholarship, research and innovation on the campus

• Lack of qualified and well-trained faculty

• Education and employability link is weak

Page 3: What  is ailing the indian higher education

COMPLEX AND CONFUSING REGULATION (GOVERNMENT)

• Education is in the concurrent list of the Constitution

• Several central professional bodies controlling education

• States differ in their control of higher education institutions

• Several educational bills hang fire in the Parliament

• Ambiguity about the treatment of education as any other service

• Foreign HEIs are hardly welcome in India

• Lack of modern, coherent and consistent education policy

Page 4: What  is ailing the indian higher education

COND…

• UGC and AICTE are two main regulatory bodies, often working in isolation and sometimes causing confusion through contradictory directions

• Then there are a host of professional bodies regulating professional education. Some of these are: BCI, PCI, CoA, etc. These professional bodies are sometimes at cross purpose with the UGC and AICTE. There are conflicting norms and standards between the two types of institutions

• Once in a while, there are conflicts between norms and standards of state government and professional bodies

• Professional bodies sometimes may have dated curricula and educational standards

• There are allegations of corruption in professional bodies in the regulation of professional education. Some examples are: MCI and DCI

• Weak interaction between professionals and academics in professional bodies

Page 5: What  is ailing the indian higher education

FINANCING HIGHER EDUCATION SYSTEM

• Central government as the major provider of funds for education and research through the MHRD, DST, DBT, UGC, AICTE, etc.

• State governments also provide funds for education and research

• Central governments help students through scholarships, loans and other facilities

• In government HEIs, the main source of funding is financial assistance (Indirect payment)

• Private entrepreneurs and trusts start the HEIs

• They also provide scholarships and other supporting facilities

• However, their main source of funding is fees (Direct payment)

• Few private HEIs operate for philanthropic purpose. Mostly they operate for profit purpose. Hence, government institutions are quite wary of the private HEIs

• Innovative models of financing higher education system are the need of the hour

Page 6: What  is ailing the indian higher education

POLITICIZATION OF HIGHER EDUCATION: GRANT-IN-AID INSTITUTIONS• Political leaders and social activists established a host of HEIs to protest against the British raj, such as Gujarat

Vidyapeeth, AMU, BHU, DAV Colleges, etc.

• Even during the British Raj, the grant in aid system to private system was initiated

• This system continued after independence

• Controlling colleges provide prestige, power and pelf to politicians

• The political masters also control land and treasury of the HEI

• These politicians command high prestige among their constituencies due to their governing roles

• Politicians can influence selection of faculty and staff

• Then they can also make money through such selections

• They also influence admissions in the HEIs, favouring students close to them

• Such students, faculty and staff also promote the political interests of their patrons

Page 7: What  is ailing the indian higher education

TRADITIONAL STATE UNIVERSITIES

• A large number of state universities are traditional universities. In principle, these universities are governed by senate

• A senate consists of ex-officio, elected and nominated members

• A senate is a large body. It can have 100 to 200 members

• It is a highly political body. The members jockey for power to attain their political objectives than to contribute to institutional excellence

• The political chaos and uncertainty of Indian society is reflected in the senate

• The executive body of a traditional university is Syndicate that is the smaller version of the senate. It also has elected, nominated and ex-officio members

• Unfortunately, academic and support staff members are also divided along political lines

• The university functionaries waste a lot of energy in managing political dynamics

Page 8: What  is ailing the indian higher education

SELECTION OF VICE CHANCELLOR

• Vice Chancellor is the chief academic and chief administrative officer of the university

• The Vice Chancellor is often appointed by the governor, on the advice of the state government

• In some universities, the governor has free hand to appoint the Vice Chancellor

• In both cases, political factors affect the selection of the incumbent

• In a large number of cases, Vice Chancellor is selected on the basis of his political ideology than on the basis of academic excellence

• Once a politically committed VC is selected, he promotes and protects political ideology on the campus

• In addition, he selects and promotes faculty and staff who are closer to his political inclination

• Hence, meritocracy goes for a toss

Page 9: What  is ailing the indian higher education

CONTD…

• Even if the Vice Chancellor is not politically committed, his financial dependence on the government, thus ruling party and bureaucracy is quite high

• State universities have a few ways through which they generate financial resources; even a small increase in fees creates uproar and strong protest from different stakeholders

• Hence the university system, including him, is deprived of autonomy. Sometimes academic autonomy is also restricted

• A case in point is the Vice Chancellor of Delhi University, who was forced to roll back four year liberal arts bachelors programmes

• The duration of a Vice Chancellor is short. It is only 3 years. He takes six months to understand the academic and administrative issues. He can hardly work for 2 years. In the last six months, he just withdraws and looks for another opportunity

• On the other hand, his counterparts in IITs and IIMs have a duration of five years

Page 10: What  is ailing the indian higher education

STUDENT UNION

• The university is a microcosm of the society. It is also considered as the place where students learn about the polity and participate in the political process

• Historically, student politics and activism were prevalent; several student organisations were formed in the British Raj

• All major political parties have their student wings

• There is a student union in most government universities. It is supposed to protect student interest and is treated as an important stakeholder in the management of a university

• There are several student political groups in a university. They represent national level political parties

• National parties want to rule student union so that they can influence the electorate

• The student leaders are more interested in making their future political careers than in promoting academic excellence

• They take advantage of administrative inefficiencies of the university and help the students to get certain benefits that anyway they should have got

• Elected student union leaders influence the functioning of a university

• More often than not many student organisations adversely affect the normal functioning of the university on petty issues

Page 11: What  is ailing the indian higher education

QUALITY AND ACCREDITATION

• The whole education system suffers from quality problems; the supply of quality students in the higher education system itself is poor

• There exist a few quality HEIs; the rest suffer from mediocrity and poor quality

• The government HEIs are more interested in expansion and access, while private ones are more concerned about money making

• Although the UGC recommends that accreditation is a must for colleges and universities; there are only two accreditation agencies – NAAC and NBA

• Accreditation bill is pending in the Parliament

• The quality and standards of accreditation agencies are questioned by many

Page 12: What  is ailing the indian higher education

CONDT…

• India has been accorded signatory status of Washington Accord in the meeting of International Engineering Alliance held on 13th June 2014 in Wellington, New Zealand. The other signatories are Australia, Canada, Chinese Taipei, Hong Kong China, Ireland, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, New Zealand, Russia, Singapore, South Africa, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States

• NAAC has been established in the year 1994 is headquartered at Bangalore

• It is an autonomous body of the UGC

• NAAC’s working is governed by the General Council (GC) and the Executive Committee (EC) on which University Grants Commission (UGC), All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE), Universities and other professional institutions are represented

• The National Board of Accreditation (NBA) was established by All India Council of Technical Education) as an autonomous body under section 10(u) of AICTE act, 1987

Page 13: What  is ailing the indian higher education

ECO-SYSTEM OF ACCREDITATION

• Accreditation of HEIs in any society, especially a large society with rich diversity of institutions like, requires a robust and dynamic eco-system

• On the top to the pyramid, there is national accreditation body, responsible for framing accreditation regulations and monitoring the functioning of different accreditation body. It is also responsible for the accreditation of different accreditation bodies

• Below that, there are general purpose accreditation bodies that are involved in the overall accreditation of universities and colleges, especially multidisciplinary colleges. These accreditation bodies can be national level agencies. There number can be anywhere between 6 to 12

• At the bottom of the pyramid, there are equally important discipline-based accreditation bodies, specialising in accreditation of professional colleges, such as medicine, law, engineering, management, etc. It is also desirable that for each professional discipline, there should be at least two accreditation bodies

• Further, international accreditation bodies can also be allowed to accredit professional institutions to help them achieve their goals of globalisation

Page 14: What  is ailing the indian higher education

INTEGRITY AND PROFESSIONALISM IN ACCREDITATION• It is a common knowledge that corruption is rampant in the Indian society

• The educational sector is equally infected by the disease of corruption

• Therefore, there is high likelihood that corruption may vitiate the accreditation system

• It is highly desirable that proper checks and balances are created in the accreditation system and processes from the very beginning so that quality is not certified through unfair means

• All efforts therefore should be made to increase transparency. The names of accreditation peer team should be made public after accreditation, the SSR should be uploaded on the website of concerned institution and the accreditation body, the accreditation report should also be made public

• The size of accreditation team should be at least 5 so that there is sufficient diversity in the team. It is difficult to corrupt a diverse group

• The peer team members should be highly trained. In addition, there should be periodic training. A code of conduct for different role holders should be evolved

• The guidelines for peer team members should be highly elaborate. They should also be required to write their reasons for rating. Scope for subjective rating should be reduced

• The accreditation should be a peer supported process rather than an inspection based process

• Each accreditation body should have an integrity committee to examine the cases of dishonesty, corruption and unprofessional practice

Page 15: What  is ailing the indian higher education

EDUCATION AND EMPLOYABILITY LINK

• The purpose of an HEI is not only knowledge dissemination but also enhancing the employability of students

• The HEIs are generally inward-oriented and are less driven by the industry demands

• Lesser involvement of industry professionals in curriculum design, development and delivery

• Less project learning and internship in the curricula

• Most faculty members have scant industry exposure

• Industries also do not take pains to connect with the academe

• Competency-based curricula are not ubiquitous

Page 16: What  is ailing the indian higher education

LACK OF QUALIFIED AND WELL-TRAINED FACULTY

• Exponential growth of educational institutions, creating a huge demand of faculty, while the supply side is poor

• Central HEIs that were supposed to be research-oriented did not work hard to promote PhD programmes

• Academe pays lesser than the industry and professions. Therefore, it is unable to attract talent

• When faculty join an institution, they are pushed into teaching straightaway. Faculty development is not given due importance

• UGC and professional regulatory bodies differ in their norms for faculty sufficiency and productivity

• Performance management system (Appraisal, rewards, training, penalty) is weak in the HEIs

Page 17: What  is ailing the indian higher education

LACK OF FACILITIES

• Apparently it seems that most institutions, especially new ones, have high quality facilities. But the truth is otherwise

• They do not have sufficient space in the classroom. Reading areas are hardly there

• Library are poor. Low quality, low cost books are produced. In addition, many issues of the same book is procured to show large number of books in the library

• Quality journals are not bought

• Databases are temporally subscribed for inspection purpose. Then they are discontinued

• Library hours are short

• Laboratories do not have required equipment. Often consumables are not available. Modernisation is not done from time to time

• sufficient technical staff is not available

Page 18: What  is ailing the indian higher education

LACK OF SCHOLARSHIP, RESEARCH AND INNOVATION

• Most institutions lack funding, skills and motivation for scholarship, research and innovation

• Higher education has become elevated school education

• As UGC has stressed the importance of PhD in the selection and promotion of faculty, a host of institutions have started PhD programmes that allow low quality doctoral work

• As institutions vie for ranking and prestige through publications, many faculty indulge in plagiarism and academic dishonesty

• Most institutions do not value research and remain a teaching institution

• Research project management skills are unavailable in the institutions

• Office of Research is not constituted in the institutions

Page 19: What  is ailing the indian higher education

PRIVATE HIGHER EDUCATION SECTOR

• Most private HEIs entered higher education for investment and profitability

• There is corporatization of private HEIs

• They charge more fees, pay less to the staff and cut costs on library and research

• Unfortunately, good private HEIs are treated at par with profit making HEIs and are not allowed to excel

• Only 5 per cent private HEIs can excel. Therefore, one should not be too optimistic

• The state is ineffective in controlling errant HEIs; therefore, market forces should be allowed to control them

• A strong regulatory body is needed that does not differentiate between government and private institutions on quality dimensions. More than the UGC and AICTE, the sector needs a power accreditation framework

Page 20: What  is ailing the indian higher education

COMMERCIALISATION

• The Constitution of India allows people to impart education through trust and society. Later, non-profit company was added to this category

• The Constitution and several Supreme Court judgements have clearly proscribe profit-making through an educational venture in any form, such as exorbitant fees, capitation fees, bribery, etc.

• However, the Supreme Court has allowed private institution to generate reasonable surplus for their future growth and development

• Most de jure non-profit educational institutions are de factor for-profit educational institution

• They find out innovative methods of siphoning out surplus from the institution

• Even if the government decide to fix their fees, they first feed the promoters then others things are done