what are chords - george brodbeck

120
7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 1/120

Upload: mauriohernandez

Post on 20-Feb-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 1/120

Page 2: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 2/120

WHAT ARE CHORDS

Learn the inside secrets of chords

What they are and how to create them.

Easy and clear stepwise formatFrom simple 3-note shapes to

8-note “monsters”.

by

George Brodbeck

Copyright © 2015 by George Brodbeck

 All tuition images and audio tracks

Page 3: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 3/120

Table of Contents

MUSIC THEORY ONLINE

About The Author 

1. FOURWORD

2. REQUIRED KNOWLEDGE

2.1. Music Notation

2.2. Major scales

2.3. Elementary intervals

2.4. The Circle of Fifths

3. HOW TO ACCESS AND PLAY THE AUDIO TRACKS

4. WHAT ARE CHORDS

5. CHORDS ORIGINATING FROM THE MAJOR SCALE

5.1. 2-NOTE CHORDS (Really?)

5.1.1. Do 2-Note Chords Exist?

5.1.2. Notation of 2-Note Chord Symbols

5.2. 3-NOTE CHORDS or TRIADS

5.2.1. How to Create Triads

5.2.2. Notation of 3-Note Chord Symbols

5.2.3. Inver sion of Triads

5.2.4. The Major Scale Triad Chord Diagram

5.3. 4-NOTE CHORDS

5.3.1. How to Create 4-Note Chords

5.3.2. Notation of 4-Note Chord Symbols

5.3.3. Inversion of 4-Note Harmony

5.3.4. The 3 Chord Groups of the Major Scale

5.3.5. The Major Scale 4-Note Chord Diagram

5.3.6. A Rebellious Look At The Circle of Fifths

5.4. 5-, 6- and 7-NOTE CHORDS

5.4.1. How to Create 5-, 6- & 7-Note Chords

5.4.2. Notation of Chords with Added Tensions

Page 4: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 4/120

5.4.3. Inversion of Large Harmony

5.4.4. The Major Scale 5-Note+ Chord Diagram

6. CHORDS ORIGINATING FROM THE WHOLE TONE SCALE

6.1. About The Whole Tone Scale

6.2. How To Build Whole Tone Scale Chords

6.3. Notation of Chords From The WT Scale

6.4. The Whole Tone Scale Chord Diagram

7. CHORDS DERIVED FROM THE MELODIC MINOR SCALE

7.1. About The Melodic Minor Scale

7.2. How To Build Melodic Minor Scale Chords

7.3. Notation of Chords From The MM Scale

7.4. The Melodic Minor Scale Chord Diagram

8. THE CHORDS OF THE DIMINISHED BLUES SCALE

8.1. Insight into The Diminished Blues Scale

8.2. How To Build Dim Blues Scale Chords

8.2.1. The Whole Tone-Half Tone Way

8.2.2. The Half Tone-Whole Tone Road

8.3. Notation of Dim Blues Scale Chords

8.3.1. Diminished Chord Symbols

8.3.2. Dominant 7 Chord Symbols

8.4. The HT-WT Scale Chord Diagram

8.5. The WT-HT Scale Chord Diagram

8.6. More Digging into the Cycle of Fifths

9. SUS4 & SUS2 CHORDS

9.1. About sus4 Chords

9.2. About sus2 Chords

9.3. Major sus4 and sus2 Chords

9.4. Dominant sus4 Chords

9.5. Minor sus4 Chords

9.6. Diminished or Half-Diminished sus4 Chords?

10. THE MODES BETWEEN THE MODES

Page 5: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 5/120

10.1. What Are The Modes Between The Modes

10.2. How To Create The In-Between Modes

10.3. In-Between Major & Dominant Modes

10.4. In-Between Diminished Modes

11. DOMINANT VERSIONS OF II, III & VI CHORDS11.1. How To Handle II7, III7 & VI7 Chords

12. CHORD TREES

12.1. About My Chord Trees

12.2. Major Chords

12.3. Minor 7th Chords

12.4. Minor 6th Chords

12.5. Dominant Chords

12.6. Diminished Chords

12.7. Half Diminished Chords

13. CODA

Page 6: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 6/120

About The Author 

When I hear a melody in my head, I always hear chords along with it. That’s greatyou might say but it’s both very convenient and annoying at the same time. It

really would be nice to hear a melodic line by itself once in a while but that’s near 

impossible for me. Of course it doesn’t mean that I’m stuck with what comes out

of my thoughts and I do have the freedom to experiment and change my

harmonies if I so desire.

This has been going on ever since I started dabbling in music through my

childhood and learning to play the trombone in the local brass band back in

Switzerland.

Intrusive musical thoughts interrupted the focus on my first job as a computer 

programmer on a regular basis and this trend continued after my emigration to

 Australia where sketches of tunes were shuffled quickly under pages of IBM code

ust before getting caught by the boss entering my office.

Eventually music won the battle when I discovered my flair for writing music

arrangements.

To this day I’m self-taught except for a summer term at Berklee College inBoston. My first love is jazz but I soon discovered that to earn a living I had to

broaden my knowledge of musical styles. This then led to becoming a staff 

arranger at Channel 9 Sydney for almost 20 years and teaching trombone and

arranging at the Jazz Department of the Conservatorium in Sydney for the same

length of time. Among my students I had the privilege of teaching James Morrison

and Adrian Mears.

Good ears for harmonic development was an integral part in being offered the

arranging job for all 3 stage productions of “The Boy From OZ”, other musicals,

advertising commercials and films.

The same ears served me well playing in the trombone section of many local

and visiting artists. Among those were Frank Sinatra, Sammy Davis, Natalie Cole,

Page 7: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 7/120

Liza Minelli, Tom Jones, Shirley Bassey and many more.

I’m thankful for a fulfilling musical life made easy by the ability to listen even

though still now, chords tag along with those ever-present tunes in my head.

Retirement? No way! It’s time to give back. This e-book is the start of a

sequence of publications aiming to make it easier for YOU to understand the

secrets of music.My self-taught-edness should provide you with an insight born from 40+ years

of experience as a music professional. It may not be “by the book” but certainly

“From The Heart” 

Page 8: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 8/120

1. FOURWORD

Here is hoping that you will be as passionate about chords as I am. From the

simplest two or three note structure to complex orchestral harmonies that lift a

film to greater heights, chords are truly amazing.

Even the most memorable of melodies loses a little of it’s sheen without the

enhancing backdrop that harmony provides. YOU must get to that stage where

changing or adding or omitting one note out of a chord becomes the artistic

detective work that drives your completeness as a composer.

The only student of music who might get away with NOT knowing about chords

is a single note instrumentalist content with sitting in a band or orchestra (or 

playing solo) reading the notes and never bothering to look “behind the curtain” of 

the music he/she is performing.

 A person like that may not even realize that they are, in a different way,sounding chords regularly when playing arpeggios.

Everybody else either HAS to know what chords are (keyboard, guitar, banjo

and other multi-stringed instrument players, students of jazz/improvisation) or 

SHOULD acquire basic chord knowledge to complete their music education.

The good news is that despite the daunting multitude of chord types, learning

about them is actually quite easy.

 As one of the universal truths states: “Everything is connected”.

Page 9: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 9/120

This applies also very much to music. If you had no musical knowledge and were

starting from scratch it would be an uphill battle to jump straight into studyingchords. It would be like trying to learn to paint without knowing about brushes,

paint, technique or subject.

In music “everything is connected” means that if you follow the dots in the right

sequence, step by step, my lessons on chords with images and audios will make

complete sense. Please follow the suggestions in the next chapter about the dots

you should connect before you start painting your chord-portrait.

My approach to teaching harmony is more on the practical side and less by the

rulebook. Nearly 50 years of pro music making is at the basis of this publication

and I’m sure you’ll find my look at the workings of chords and harmony at bit less

stuffy than normal (I hope!).

And, by the way, the spelling of the title of this chapter is on purpose and a bit

silly. The reason being that the number 4 has such a multitude of meanings in

music so I thought why not.

Page 10: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 10/120

2. REQUIRED KNOWLEDGE

To understand and absorb the content of “What Are Chords” easily you need to be

familiar with:

2.1. Music Notation

2.2. Major scales

Just knowing the basic ins and outs of 1 major scale is a good start.

2.3. Elementary intervals

 All the basic interval possibilities in each major scale

Page 11: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 11/120

2.4. The Circle of Fifths

You will find much more valuable and surprising info about the cycle of fifths inchapters 5.3.6. and 5.4.5.

Page 12: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 12/120

3. HOW TO ACCESS AND PLAY THE AUDIO

TRACKS

Since at this point in time it is not possible to embed audio files directly into

Kindle e-Books I’m forced to “park” them elsewhere.

So I have built a website to hold all 49 tracks and also a blog about chords.

You can access the music files in 2 ways:

1. Clicking on the link below takes you to the audio page where you can navigate

to each track manually from the sidebar.

2. Use the link of each audio example as you come to it in the text. This will take

you to the corresponding page/track on the website. If you prefer, you can keep

the first link-page open and navigate from there using the “NEXT” or “PREV”buttons.

 Above each track is also a slightly enlarged score image of the music you’re

hearing.

WhatAreChords.com

The audios are marked with this logo:

Please Note:

Not all treble-bass clef grand staff parts in the many musical illustrations are

“piano-friendly”. They are simply examples of chord voicing

Page 13: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 13/120

4. WHAT ARE CHORDS

The basic definition of a chord is:

3 or more musical tones (of different pitch) played simultaneously by a chordal

instrument like a keyboard or a guitar or voiced for horns, strings or singers.

Track01-4.1 Chord Examples

What kind of chords to use, and when, is very much dependent on the style of 

music that is being created and the melody line.

 As a very general rule we can say that:

3-note chords: are used in rock, country and folk music, classical music 

4-note chords: (consisting of 4 notes of different pitch) swing & trad jazz, pop music,

classical music, musicals

5 and more-note chords: (consisting of 5 or more notes of different pitch) jazz, some

classical & pop music, movie scores, special effects

Of course this ver y basic subdivision constantly gets shot to pieces by

exceptions.

NOTE: When I say 3-note, 4-note and 5 and more note chords I mean 3, 4 or 5+

different notes without doubling any of them up or down 1 or more octaves. It is o

course possible to turn any chord into a 10 or more note sound by doubling all the

chord tones multiple times higher and lower.

The vast majority of chords are extracted from and belong to a scale or mode.

The only exceptions are unusual, incomplete, un-namable or very complicated

dissonant chords used in special circumstances.

Track02-4.2 Chord Dissonance

So:

Let’s get in harmony with chords and have a closer look!

Page 14: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 14/120

5. CHORDS ORIGINATING FROM THE MAJOR

SCALE

5.1. 2-NOTE CHORDS (Really?)

5.1.1. Do 2-Note Chords Exist?

Officially no, they don’t exist, but in my humble opinion the sound of 2 notes, for

instance C and E or C and Eb, create a C Major and C minor chord respectively

that is beyond any doubt.

Track03-5.1.1 2-Note Chords

Also there are umpteen rock-type songs that survive by just playing the tonic and

the fifth in the rhythm section while the third used in the melody gives the

impression of a complete C triad.

Track04-5.1.1 2-Note Rock

5.1.2. Notation of 2-Note Chord Symbols

To use these types of 2-note sounds the chord symbols need to be adjusted

Page 15: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 15/120

accordingly:

C and E = C (no 5th)

C and Eb = Cm (no 5th)

C and G = C (no 3rd)

The next chapter includes a much closer look at chord symbols

You can make your own mind up whether 2-note chords are of any use to you.

Depending on what style of music you’re creating you may never use them or find

them very handy regularly.

5.2. 3-NOTE CHORDS or TRIADS

5.2.1. How to Create Triads

As I mentioned earlier, the traditional definition of the smallest chord has 3 notes

and is called a triad.

The recipe to create a triad is:

a) Take a C Major scale (or anyone of the other 14 major scales)

b) Let’s change the look of this scale (just this first time) to make it visually

clearer 

Page 16: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 16/120

c) Extract the first, third and fifth note (Tonic, 3rd & 5th) and place them on

top of each other

d) You just created a C-Major triad. Let’s hear it!

Track05-5.2.1 C-Major TriadHow do we know that this is a Major scale & chord?

Because the distance between the first note (tonic) and the third note (third) in the

scale is 4 semi-tones or 2 whole tones.

 At this point I would understand if you said, “OK, I know how to make a Major 3-

note chord, let’s carry on to the big, exciting stuff”.

But you would be very hasty and miss out on some fundamental information

hidden inside every major scale.

Each one of them is the “front” for 6 other scales (also called modes) and

triads. Here is our C-Major scale again:

Page 17: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 17/120

On the surface this scale contains 7 notes (+ octave C), 8 basic intervals

and, if we stretch the examination, some more complicated intervals.

But, in fact, this scale and all other Major Scales include all of the above plus:

7 Modes (other related scales)

31 Chords (7 triads + 24 chords made up of 4 and more notes)

 All The Chord Tones (for triads & 4-note sounds)

Guide Tones (the backbone of each chord)

Tension Notes (possible additions to the harmony)

 Avoid Notes (notes best left out of the chord structure)

56 intervals

Here is the C-Major scale expanded, showing what is behind the façade in basic

triad form:

Page 18: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 18/120

 All we have done is to use each note of the C-Major scale as the starting point of 

its own scale. This creates a total of 7 scales or modes, each with it’s own name

and personality.

Please note that the modes are traditionally counted in Roman numerals (I II III

Page 19: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 19/120

IV V VI VII) and have Greek names. There is no need to learn the names of each

mode unless you have to. Just be aware that:

C to C = Major scale and chord 

D to D = Minor scale and chord 

E to E = Minor scale and chord F to F = Major scale and chord (sub-dominant)

G to G = Dominant scale and chord (*)

 A to A = Minor scale and chord 

B to B = Half-Diminished scale and chord (**)

IMPORTANT:

(*) Because our focus is just on triads at this point, the chord of the 5th scale (G to G / Mixolydian) is just a

Major triad (G – B – D) but will turn into its proper Dominant purpose in the chapter on 4-note chords.

(**) The same applies to the chord of the 7th scale (B to B / Locrian). As a 3-note sound (B - D - F) it is

correctly called a diminished triad but as you’ll see later, it really represents the first 3 notes of a Half-

Diminished chord.

Let’s hear each triad with its scale played over the top:

Track06-5.2.1 C-Major Triad Modes

5.2.2. Notation of 3-Note Chord Symbols

To notate major, minor and (half-) diminished triads we use chord symbols.

They consist of:

1. The symbol or name

2. The chord quality sometimes called suffix

To notate Major Triads:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. C or F. This symbol

on it’s own always signifies the whole major triad like:

Page 20: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 20/120

Sometimes (for extra clarity) the capital letter M or Maj can be added after the

symbol:

To notate Minor Triads:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. D or E or A plus the

letter m or min or (now mostly avoided) a hyphen:

To notate Diminished Triads:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. B plus the

abbreviation dim or °:

TIP:  Chord symbols are an essential part of popular music and jazz. As a

composer/song writer it is important that you write them clearly and without any 

doubts, especially when added notes and alterations come into play.

Page 21: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 21/120

5.2.3. Inversion of Triads

You may have noticed that so far all the triads have been notated and heard in

their basic build: 1 - 3 - 5. This is called Root Position.

I treat each triad as a SOUND that can be used in many different forms and I

encourage you to think the same way.

In strict music theory tuition there are rules about inverting chords (not having the

tonic at the bottom).

★ Third at the bottom (3 - 5 - 1) is called 1st inversion

★ Fifth at the bottom (5 - 1 - 3) is called 2nd inversion

Of course if you invert again you get back to the root position one octave higher.

Track07-5.2.3 C-Major Triad Inversions

But, like I said, if you treat each triad as a sound, it is much easier to be moreadventurous about how you use your 3-note chords.

You can use them in many different ways. Here are some suggestions:

1. Just as 3-note chords in close position, using the 3 inversions as above. (Not

sure about chord symbols? We’ll talk about them after these examples)

Page 22: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 22/120

Track08-5.2.3 Simplicity 1 (Triads)

2. Turn them into 4-note chords by doubling the bottom note one octave higher or 

the top note one octave lower.

Track09-5.2.3 Simplicity 2 (Triads + Oct)

3. 3 or 4 note versions in more open positions.

Page 23: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 23/120

Track10-5.2.3 Simplicity 3 (Open triads)

4. 5+ note versions orchestrated in countless different ways

IMPORTANT:

When using more open triads in 1st or 2nd inversion, the chord symbol must (or should) be adjusted to reflect

that the bass note is not the tonic, like this:

C/E or C/G (use a slash between chord name and bass note - meaning C chord over E bass or G bass).

Page 24: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 24/120

Track11-5.2.3 Simplicity 4 (orchestral)

TIP: Get used to the slight variation in sound between major and minor triads in

root position and 1st and 2nd inversion. It is a very distinctive small difference.

Play them repeatedly till your ear/mind can recognize them easily.

 ALL THE INFO ABOVE

 ABOUT TRIADS IN C-MAJOR

SHOULD BE APPLIED

TO ALL OTHER 14 KEYS!

Look how far you’ve come already:

Page 25: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 25/120

Each scale that you know provides 7 triads multiplied by 3 inversions = 21

different 3-note chords!

That means, if you can play and understand all the major scales there are (15)

you already know 315 triads (15 x 21).

I think a pat on the back is in order!

 At this point you may well ask: “Is that all there is to triads? 315 major and minor ones?” The answer is no. There are other 3-note chord types with alterations, but

to keep our chord-evolution journey in “everything-is-connected” order, we’ll talk

about those at the appropriate moment.

REMINDER:

Please be clear that at this point we’re only looking at chords that are connected to the 15 major scales and 

their associated modes.

You’ll be surprised to find that just this relatively restricted slice of the chord pie offers a choice of 465+harmonies and all of them without having to write a single accidental (strictly speaking and if all your key 

signatures are correct).

5.2.4. The Major Scale Triad Chord Diagram

Even those readers who, like me, found or are still finding it hard to stay awake

during school classes that dealt with numbers, you must by now realize that there

is a very clear mathematical relationship between many parts of music learning.

The next diagram is for those who like to see things in a more abstract,schematic way:

PLEASE NOTE:

If you’re unsure about the distance between each root note and the other 2 chord-tones above it (the

numbers next to the chord tones), remember this:

To work out those intervals, you must always “pretend” that each scale is a MAJOR scale. Then you relate

each chord tone to the root note of that scale. For instance:

Pretend D-Dorian is D-Major → the 3rd of D-Major is F♯ but our note is F therefore the interval betweenD and F = ♭3. That part should be pretty obvious.

Let’s do the same exercise with the B-Locrian scale: Pretend it is a B-Major scale → the 3rd would be D♯

and the 5th F♯, but our notes are D♮ & F♮ so the intervals have to ♭3 & ♭5.

This whole little “rave” of mine will make more sense when you get to the next 2 diagrams showing 4-note

and 5-note-plus chords.

PS: All following diagrams are linked to larger versions on the website. Just click

on the images to see them.

Page 26: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 26/120

Page 27: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 27/120

OK, time to get into the bigger stuff.

Triads are the building blocks of harmony but lots of times we need that extra

chord tone (or two) to enhance our sound palette with some extra color.

5.3. 4-NOTE CHORDS

5.3.1. How to Create 4-Note Chords4-note chords are simply triads plus the seventh note of the scale added.

The formula now reads:

Tonic + Third + Fifth + Seventh (1 - 3 - 5 - 7).

Page 28: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 28/120

Note how the naturally occurring 4-note sequence in all keys is:

For all Major chords 1 - 3 - 5 - 7

For all Minor chords 1 - ♭3 - 5 - ♭7

Page 29: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 29/120

For Dominant chords 1 - 3 - 5 - ♭7

For Half-Diminished chords 1 - ♭3 - ♭5 - ♭7

Given the right key signature, this formula holds true in each of the 15 keys

naturally without having to add any accidentals!

5.3.2. Notation of 4-Note Chord Symbols

 As with triads, the notation of 4-note chords consists of:

1. The symbol or name2. The chord quality sometimes called suffix

To notate Major 4-note chords:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. C and add the

presence of the 4th note, which is the Major 7th.

This is abbreviated using the letter M or Maj or very commonly a triangle:

To notate Minor 4-note chords:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. D or E or A and add

the presence of the 4th note, which is the Minor 7th.

 Abbreviation: the letter m or min or (now mostly avoided) a hyphen plus the letter 

7:

Page 30: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 30/120

To notate Dominant 4-note chords:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. G and add the

presence of the 4th note, which is the Minor 7th.

 Abbreviation: the number 7:

To notate Half-Diminished (or minor 7th flat 5) 4-note chords:

Use the root note of the scale/mode the chord belongs to i.e. B plus the other 3notes in “shorthand” m7(♭5) or a circle with a diagonal line through it (∅):

PLEASE NOTE:

Remember when we discussed triads I mentioned that the 7th step of each major 

scale (B to B in the key of C) is usually named a diminished triad (Bdim or B°, B-

D-F). It now becomes clear why that is misleading even though it is correct. When

we add the 4th note to the chord, which in the key of C is the note A, we finish up

with a Bm7 ♭5 chord (B-D-F-A or  1-♭3-♭5-♭7 ) and not a B°7 which would need the

note to be A♭.Diminished 4- and more note chords are, due to their even minor 3rd interval 

build between notes, a special group and not attached to any of the 7 modes but 

an 8-note scale called the diminished blues scale or whole tone - half tone scale.

(More on that later).

This is a good time to mention a small but important detail about the major

modes (I-Ionian & IV-Lydian) in every key:

Their 4th chord tone, the Maj 7th can be interchanged with the 6th note,

depending on melody note and sometimes style.

While the 2 chord versions sound slightly different, they’re on par as far as

how they can be used.

Page 31: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 31/120

So C - E - G - B (1 - 3 - 5 - 7) can be interchanged with C - E - G - A (1 - 3 - 5 -

6). The same applies to F (F-A-C-E can be F-A-C-D).

This does not apply to the other 5 modes, where the 6th note is either a

tension or an avoid note.

Here are the C-Major Modes once more with the chord symbols added:

Page 32: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 32/120

Let’s play each 4-note chord with its scale played over the top:

Page 33: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 33/120

Track12-5.3.2 C-Major 4-Note Modes

5.3.3. Inversion of 4-Note Harmony 

Inverting 4-note chords follows exactly the same principle as triads. The only

difference is that we have 4 notes, therefore 4 inversions.

1. Tonic at the bottom (1-3-5-7) = Root Position2. Third at the bottom (3-5-7-1) = 1st inversion

3. Fifth at the bottom (5-7-1-3) = 2nd inversion

4. Seventh at the bottom (7-1-3-5) = 3rd inversion

 And, if you invert again, you’re back to the root position one octave higher.

The following image shows the 4 inversions of all 7 chords in the key of C.

Page 34: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 34/120

Track13-5.3.3 C-Major 4-Note Inversions

 As a careful reader and listener you will have noticed (and heard) that some of the

4-note inversions create clashes (tension) between adjacent notes. This will

Page 35: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 35/120

happen more and more as the harmonies contain more notes.

My attitude towards inversions is: “Forget about them”! Chords however 

complicated they may get are a sound to be molded into the right shape by the

requirements of your composition. What determines the inversion you use is, in

most cases, not which note is at the bottom of the chord but which sits at the top.

 As a general rule we can say that semi-tone clashes at the top of the chord arequestionable because the important sound of the top or lead note has its clarity

masked by the closeness of the one below it. As a passing clashing-effect done

on purpose, it can of course be very effective.

Track14-5.3.3 4-Note Inversion Clashes

5.3.4. The 3 Chord Groups of the Major Scale

If you examine the note content of each of the 7 chords in each key, you’ll find that

some contain the same notes and create a similar sound.Therefore we can sort the 7 chords into 3 groups:

1. Tonic Group contains I + III + VI (CMaj7 - Em7 - Am7)

2. Sub-Dominant Group contains II + IV (Dm7 - FMaj7)

3. Dominant Group contains V + VII (G7 - Bm7♭5)

This grouping will become even clearer once we start adding tensions to chords.

Page 36: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 36/120

 As you can see, the notes in C6 and Am7 (and therefore the sound to the

listeners ear) are the same. The only thing that differentiates these 2 harmonies in

sound quality and chord symbol notation is the bass note (or tonic). The same

applies to F6 and Dm7.

Track15-5.3.4 4-Note 3 Chord Groups

We’ll come back to this briefly later when the remaining group connections make

more sense.

In the meantime keep remembering what I said earlier:

Learn to hear the difference between major, minor, dominant & diminished / 

half-diminished harmonies.

Be open to the possibility that each sound can have variations but remain

the same in its basic purpose. (Ex. CMaj7 and C6)

Become attuned to the most fundamental role the root note or tonic or bass

note plays in creating subtle variations in quality of the same or similar 

groups of notes.

The note content of the melody dictates which chord variations and quality 

are most suitable.

 Again:

Page 37: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 37/120

 ALL THE INFO ABOVE

 ABOUT 4-NOTE CHORDS IN C-MAJOR

SHOULD BE APPLIED

TO ALL OTHER 14 KEYS!

Congratulations:You’ve reached another milestone in your “What Are Chords” journey. I’m sure by

now the process of extracting harmony from scales is becoming a bit of a light

bulb event.

The volume of your chord knowledge is growing steadily. Think about it: 15

major scales x 7 triads x 7 4-note chords (not counting inversions) = 735

harmonies to chose from.

I know, keeping score like that is a bit “greedy” but it gives you an idea how

much knowledge is contained in just all the major scales.

 And we’re not done yet!

5.3.5. The Major Scale 4-Note Chord Diagram

Here is the 2nd version of my chord diagram, this time enlarged to show 4-note

harmony.

Note the inclusion in brackets of the 6th as an alternative to the 7th in the 2

major modes.Also, very importantly, the triad diagram listed the 5th mode as a major chord

and the 7th mode as diminished which was correct.

But now, with the 4th note added, mode 5 turns into its true quality of

dominant 7th (G7) shown with a separate color and similarly mode 7 has

morphed into its real function of Half-Diminished (B∅).

Page 38: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 38/120

Page 39: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 39/120

5.3.6. A Rebellious Look At The Circle of Fifths

As I mentioned in chapter “2. Required Knowledge”, the greatest assistant to

absorbing this introduction to chords and have lights go on all over the place, is

a basic understanding of the circle or cycle of fifths or fourths. It naturally

completes and clarifies the picture of major scale chords we are painting here.

For this circle to be of real help when discussing chords it is much more

convenient to have it laid out flat:

I know, this is very small. It’s difficult to fit 15 keys and key signatures into 1 line,

so just for display we’ll cut this in half and show flats and sharps separately and

larger:

The one thing that has always bothered me about this traditional version of the

cycle is that the sharp keys are on the right and the flat ones on the left.

I’m going to turn this around and switch sides by putting sharps on the left and

flats on the right like this:

Page 40: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 40/120

Here is why:

Music on paper flows left to right  and almost every composition that has ever 

been written includes chord sequences like II-V-I (Dm7-G7-CMaj7) and similar 

right to left  around-or-along-the-cycle type movements.

If you are a chord-novice you may not understand this reasoning at this point but I

promise you it will make total sense soon enough.

Let’s take a very common III - VI - II - V - I harmonic flow in the key of C and

show it on the traditional cycle:

Page 41: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 41/120

The flow of this sequence from right to left goes against the grain visually.

Let’s see the same set of harmonies on my amended cycle:

Track16-5.3.6 The Rebel Turn Around

The cycle flows with the music. I rest my case!

If you are in the dark or unsure about the cycle of 5ths, please take the time to

watch the first 2 of my 5 very informative free videos.

Don’t worry if some of the content is hard to grasp at first, it will soon make

sense and we’ll re-visit the cycle once more at the end of the next chapter.Video 1:

( A detailed look at the basics of the circle of 5ths, keys, key signatures, circle or cycle, 4ths or 5ths.)

Page 42: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 42/120

Page 43: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 43/120

 As you can see the chord choices in each mode are numerous and it is important

at this point to realize that the style of your music and personal harmonic

preferences should dictate how far you go with this.

Just adding the 9th in many instances is a step towards a jazzy sound. Mind

you, many pop artists like Stevie Wonder, Sting, Steely Dan, Michael Jackson and

many more use this kind of harmony in their songs all the time. So it’s decision-

making time. You can have a triad or a 7-note chord if it is appropriate to your 

composition.

Page 44: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 44/120

The best way to go forward if you haven’t used 5+-note chords before is to

listen to the sound of each one. You’ll soon feel what’s right and what’s too thick

or tense or jazzy.

Here is each chord from the last image played in sequence. Be aware that they

are all in root position and there are many more other ways to use them:

Track17-5.4.1 C-Mode 5+Note Chords

 A few comments about the chords of each mode:

IONIAN:

3-6 notes. All chords if voiced properly sound very nice and are very common.

DORIAN:

3-6 (7) notes. Strictly speaking the addition of the 13th (Dm13), even though it is a

reasonably common jazz chord, is a no-no because the note B goes against the

basic purpose of the II-chord.

PHRYGIAN:

3-5 notes. This mode has the least choices of all if used cleanly because it has 2 

avoid-notes. But rules are there to be broken! 

LYDIAN:

3-7 notes. The 4th mode is the only one without avoid-notes therefore it gives you

the most harmonic choices of all. Care must be taken when and how to use the B

(♯11) or messy sounds will be the outcome.

MIXOLYDIAN:

3-6 notes. All versions are very common but remember, the triad just sounds like

a major chord. The V chord has the most potential for alterations and other 

versions, as you’ll see later.

 AEOLIAN: (Also called the NATURAL minor)

3-6 notes. As the relative minor it is very common even with 9th and 11th added 

and nicely voiced (spread). This scale is also the foundation from which the

harmonic and melodic minor scales are built.

LOCRIAN:

3-6 notes. The triad is just a diminished sound and the 4th note is needed to make

it m7( ♭5). 5 and 6-note versions are more rare and mostly used in jazz.

Page 45: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 45/120

5.4.2. Notation of Chords with Added Tensions

The more involved harmony gets, the more important it is to notate it very clearly.

Badly written or questionable chord symbols can lead to mistakes in interpretation

(of course) but also unnecessarily lost time in any recording situation where time

is money.

Unfortunately there are also a variety of opinions out there about how certain

tensions should be notated. But I’m confident after almost half a century of 

messing about with harmony, that my way of chord symbol notation is clear and to

the point.

If you’re composing music for your own band you can get away with a certain

amount of simplification because anything questionable or incomplete can be

explained.

But in any other situation where your arrangement gets sold or the

performance of it is out of your control, you can go 2 ways:

1. If your music is for professional jazz players you can assume that they knowthe secrets of modes and chords, which allows you a certain tolerance. For 

instance there is no need to write complicated chord symbols as the

performers will know “what goes” with added tensions and so on. If you write

for jazz students I’d think a bit more carefully about including slightly more

detail.

2. For all other music that routinely includes chord symbols I would be specific

about added tensions within reason. That means ridiculously complicated

symbols often do more damage than good and are frequently unnecessary.

Plus they are almost impossible to sight-read for many players.

Here are some of the 5+-note chord & symbol possibilities again per mode, this

time notated on a grand staff in a variety of ways:

MODE I:

Note: I always use the triangle for Maj7 & 9; it is very common and international. Use 6/9 when adding the 9th

to the 6th chord, sometimes notated with a slash between 6 and 9. The full 6 note symbols (ex. 5 & 6) I hardly

ever use. Just because the orchestra plays a full 6-note chord doesn’t mean that piano & guitar also have to

play the full thick sound, it is often overkill. But if necessary, by all means use the last 2 symbols.

Page 46: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 46/120

MODE II:

Note: Minor chords with extra tensions are used all the time and are basically simple to notate. I never use

the hyphen for minor because it is too easily missed. Keep in mind that m11 includes the 9th and m13 the 9th

& 11th. If you want special versions like m7 + 11 only it should be made clear like this: m7(add 11), see mode

III.

MODE III:

Note: This minor harmony when used strictly as the III of the key only allows the 11th as a tension. Therefore

we only get one symbol to use. “add 11” should be in brackets.

Page 47: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 47/120

MODE IV:

Note: The most versatile of the 7 modes due to the availability of the ♯11. Treat the symbol notation exactly

like the I-chord until you add the tri-tone (♯11) then be sure to put it in brackets. The full 7-note chord sounds

quite thick and it is often best to omit the natural 5 to lessen the tension.

MODE V:

Note: The V chord has the most potential for added tensions and alterations, as you’ll see later. But here the

2 possible additions are the 9th and/or the 13th. To avoid confusion with the sus4 harmony it is best to be

clear by saying G7, G9 or G9(13). If you want to use the 13th without the 9th notate G7(13). I don’t use G13

because it leaves a question mark whether it is a proper dominant or a sus4.

Important: In dominant 7th chords, the 6th is always called a 13th, whether it is placed above the ♭7 (in the

13th spot, ex. 3 & 4) or right next to it (ex. 5).

Page 48: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 48/120

MODE VI:

Note: Treat this like the II-mode except the 13th is not available.

MODE VII:

Note: The symbol ∅ should only be used for the 4-note-chord. If you need to write the 2 larger versions use

m11(♭5) for the 5-note harmony and m11(♭5♭13) for the 6 notes. The last symbol is complicated looking and

I hardly ever use it.

Page 49: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 49/120

The musical examples given above are of course only a minimal cross section of 

what is possible and many more versions of all these harmonies, especially withomitted notes and other varieties, are possible.

That is where you can work towards your personal style by being selective in

what goes in a chord and what stays out.

5.4.3. Inversion of Large Harmony 

In the last chapter on inversions I said to “forget about them”. This is even more

accurate for larger chords.

Think about it. Chords that have 5 or 6 or 7 different notes in them need a

minimum of 5 or 6 or 7 horn or string players or singers. They can be played by a

piano but a guitar is restricted to 5 notes.

Your choice of lead note of each chord becomes more and more crucial. Pick

the “wrong” note on top and certain voicings/inversions become awkward. Of 

course there is no such thing as a wrong lead note, all 5 or 6 or 7 are valid but

some are definitively better than others.

Depending on your music style, instrumentation etc. you will be frequentlyfaced with the need to omit notes without jeopardizing the sound or purpose of the

harmony. The most common 2 notes to be left out are the tonic & the 5th. The

tonic can easily be omitted if there is a bass player, and the 5th is not absolutely

necessary to retain the character of the chord. But the 2 guide tones must stay for 

a complete harmony.

Here is a variety of inversions/voicings for a mixture of musical situations and

instrumentations, some with doubled notes, some with notes left out:

Page 50: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 50/120

Page 51: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 51/120

Listen to each example played slowly with a brief gap between them (piano,

guitar, brass, strings and voices).

Track18-5.4.3 5+Note Chord Inversions

If you’re unsure about guide tones and the many interesting things about them,

feel free to watch my 4 videos that explain it all.

Video 1:

(What are guide tones?)

Video 2:

(How to use guide tones?)

Video 3:

(A detailed look at the close relationship between guide tones and the circle of 5ths.)

Video 4:

(A note by note analysis of single and double guide tone lines written for a 32 measure orchestral piece.)

5.4.4. The Major Scale 5-Note+ Chord Diagram

Here is the 3rd version of the chord diagram this time including all the possibleadditions (tensions) to the 4-note chord.

Page 52: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 52/120

Page 53: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 53/120

Page 54: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 54/120

6. CHORDS ORIGINATING FROM THE WHOLE

TONE SCALE

6.1. About The Whole Tone Scale

My chapters will be slightly shorter and to the point from now because 1) I’m

hoping that you understand the basics of chord creation and 2) the rules for 

building harmonies from scales don’t change even for the upcoming more left-field

sounds:

1-3-5 = Triad

1-3-5-7 = 4-Note Chord

2-4-6 = Available Tensions/Avoid Notes (plus a few surprises)This 6-NOTE scale is one of a kind, built on a series of whole tone (WT) steps and

therefore unusual but also very symmetrical.

(I’ve included the enharmonic pitches because, depending on where or how this scale or chord is used, either 

of the 2 notes with the same pitch are applicable)

Up to chapter 6 you had to translate all the info given into 14 other keys, which

admittedly is quite a time consuming but necessary task.

The good news is that with the WT Scale there are only 2. C and C♯. When

you get to D, you’re back into the C-WT scale starting from the 2nd note. Yippee!

Similar to the diminished chord, the harmonies from the WT scale have an

easily recognizable sound to them. They always sound like a question mark to my

ear, unresolved, restless, slightly troubled, needing to go somewhere.

Let’s see what chords come out of the WT scale.

6.2. How To Build Whole Tone Scale Chords

The formula for creating harmonies from the WT scale is a little different due the

scale being restricted to 6 notes.

Here is the scale image again with all the additions:

Page 55: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 55/120

This picture tells us that there are no avoid notes and that the harmonic

possibilities from the WT scale are:

TRIADS:

C major with a ♭5 or C major with ♯5

4-NOTE CHORDS

C7 with ♯5 or ♭5

5- or 6-NOTE CHORDS

C9 with either ♯5 or ♭5 or both.

♯5 is also called augmented  and sometimes indicated with a + sign.

Remember the above applies exactly the same to D (D7♯5 or ♭5) E, F♯/G♭, G♯/A♭

and A♯/B♭.

Take the whole scenario up a semi tone and it turns into C♯/D♭, D♯/E♭, F, G, Aand B.

So, we have 2 WT scales with a potential total of 84 different triads and 4-, 5-

and 6-note chords.

NOTE:

Take care when creating the larger WT harmonies because a bunch of notes a

tone apart can sound thick and ugly. Therefore: Be smart with your voicings! 

6.3. Notation of Chords From The WT Scale

The more often used chords from the Whole Tone Scale are the augmented ones.

Many composers, arrangers and songwriters use the plus sign (+) to notate thembut I find it can be confusing to read just like the hyphen for minor. It is much safer 

and clearer to use (♯5) instead.

Page 56: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 56/120

Flat 5 harmonies are a little less common (outside of jazz anyway) and should

be written (♭5).

Here is a bunch of chord sounds taken from the WT scale, from triads to 6-note

chords in root position and 4 others in a more open shape:

Listen to them played in sequence, each line from left to right.

Track19-6.3. Whole Tone Scale Chords

Like I said, they all sound like they need to resolve to some kind of F chord.

Inversion of these chords works the same as the mode-chords.

Page 57: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 57/120

Triads can be in root position or 1st & 2nd inversion plus the 3rd inversion for 

4-note chords.

 Again, be aware of the regular whole tone space between notes, which can

lead to awkward voicings.

6.4. The Whole Tone Scale Chord Diagram

Page 58: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 58/120

Holy smoke, if you’re reading this, you’re still hanging in and finding out about

“What Are Chords”.

Congratulations  and believe me this journey will be seriously worthwhile to

your understanding of music in general.

Next we’re diving into a similar tonal center to the Major Modes but this time

with a minor sound and 7 really cool new chords.

Page 59: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 59/120

7. CHORDS DERIVED FROM THE MELODIC

MINOR SCALE

7.1. About The Melodic Minor Scale

 A little while back I mentioned that the Aeolian mode (or natural or relative minor 

scale) is the basis for building the Melodic Minor scale. While this is true in classic

music theory I want you to forget about it.

To have a scale that sharpens 2 notes of the natural minor on the way up and

then flattens them again for downward melodies only makes sense if you’re into

strict classical composition.

If you’re writing a pop song and decide to use a Cm6 chord in measure 5 then

that  sound and scale remain the same whether the notes of your tune go up or down.

The simple truth about the melodic minor (MM) scale is that it’s a  MAJOR 

SCALE WITH A MINOR THIRD! 

So, if you know your major scales, just make 1 small change and flatten the

3rd note. Simple!

In my mad practice days many years ago I always repeated whatever exercise I

was playing in a major key also in melodic minor straight after.Here is an example:

This is (or should be) a very simple thing to do and it opens up such a

smorgasbord of harmonies to become comfortable with. You get your 7 Major 

modes with all their harmonic variations and another 7 from the MM scale with its

cool chords in one practice session.

If you’re studying and learning to compose classical music this may not be the

way to go!

So let’s have a look at the MM modes.

7.2. How To Build Melodic Minor Scale Chords

Page 60: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 60/120

Since you’re familiar with the detailed examination we made of the major modes

in triad form and moving to ever-larger chords and their symbols, I’m going to

push you into the deep end again and present you with the whole MM mode &

basic chord picture straight away.

Before you look at the image below, let me point out a few interesting details:

1. Be amazed at how much difference the simple change of flattening 1 note,the 3rd from E in C-major to E ♭ makes and how it opens up a whole new 

 Aladdin’s cave of harmonic treasures.

2. Compared to the major scale modes where only the 4th mode has no avoid-

notes, in this scale there are 4 modes where all the notes are valid chord 

tones. That makes for more harmonic variations to chose from.

3. Out of the 7 modes 1 is not used very often, 4 are suitable for general use

and 2 are mostly jazz chords.

4. If you think that these harmonies are too complicated for your personal taste,remember that you don’t have to use the 5-, 6- or 7-note sounds. The 4-note

chords are fine because the scale that goes on behind them makes the

difference.

Here’s the “deep-end”:

Page 61: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 61/120

Let’s zoom-in on each one:

I - MELODIC MINOR

Many minor flavored tunes use this as the resting place, the “coming home”

sound. In other words, use it like the Ionian mode in a major key composition. Lots

Page 62: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 62/120

of possible variations as all 7 notes are available.

Listen to the scale then each chord from left to right with snippets of scale played

over the top:

Track20-7.2. Melodic Minor Scale Chords

II - DORIAN ♭2

This minor mode is not used very often. Personally I’ve never used it in any of my

work because I don’t particularly like a m7 harmony with the sound of a ♭9 (E♭) in

the scale. But I’ve seen it used so don’t completely chuck it in the bin just yet.

You be the judge when you hear it:

Track21-7.2. Dorian ♭2 Scale Chords

III - LYDIAN AUGMENTED

This is a special sound that you find quite a lot in more modern jazz tunes. But it

also has a place in middle of the road music as a replacement or substitution of the Ionian major chord. You could make | Fm7 | B♭7 | E♭Maj7 more interesting by

doing this instead | Fm7 | B♭7 | E♭Maj7(♯5) E♭Maj7 (if the melody allows).

Lend your ear please:

Track22-7.2. Lydian Aug Scale ChordsIV - LYDIAN DOMINANT

 A very common version of the dominant 7 harmony, that turns the normally avoid

4th in the basic Mixolydian into a usable note (♯4-♭5-♯11 = Lydian). Hip players of 

the Blues love the Lydian Dominant.

Please listen:

Track23-7.2. Lydian Dom Scale Chords

Page 63: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 63/120

V - MIXOLYDIAN ♭13

 Another version of the dominant 7 harmony, this time with a ♭13 or ♯5. Can be

played instead of the whole-tone scale. Very often seen before resolving to a I-

minor.

Go to audio:

Track24-7.2. Mixolydian ♭13 Scale Chords

VI - LOCRIAN ♯2

The “bug” about the normal Locrian mode is that it doesn’t have a usable 9th. This

scale solves that problem but is otherwise the same as mode VII of the major 

scale. The added note gives the option of resolving to a major chord. Ex. The

main purpose of the normal Locrian in B♭  is usually to be part of the II-V-to the

relative minor: Am7(♭5) - D7(♯5) - Gm7 or Gm6. But with the Locrian ♯2 you could

go: Am9(♭5) - D13(♭9) - GMaj7. Different, but very effective.

Hear these 2 examples with their corresponding modes in the melody:

Track25-7.2. Locrian ♯2 Scale Chords

VII - ALTERED

This is one the most extreme version of the dominant 7 chord, but also one the

most interesting and versatile. The 9th and 5th are altered both ways (♭9 / ♯9 & ♭5

/ ♯5). This gives lots of harmonic options from reasonably simple to all in.

Note: Since all notes are available as chord tones, I’ve added the ♯5 as the 5th of 

the chord in this example but it could have been the ♭5 instead. Also, the 3rd of Bshould be D♯ but as part of this mode, E♭ will have to do.

Please listen, but be aware that the true magic of this harmony does not begin to

shine till some of the other tensions (or even all) are added - in the next chapter:

Track26-7.2. Altered Scale Chords

 As you can see, the basic procedure of chord extraction from a scale remains the

same as the one I detailed in the Major Scale Modes.

Page 64: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 64/120

But the notation of these new chord symbols are bit more involved due to all

the possible added notes. Let’s have a look at that now.

7.3. Notation of Chords From The MM Scale

When chord symbols get more complicated as some do here, it becomes crucial

to be totally clear about what is going on. As I’ve said before, depending on who

you write music for,

their content can vary quite a bit. You only need to write the “extreme” symbols

when you want to make sure that no liberties are taken with what notes are

included in the sound. For jazz players a basic symbol is enough, as they should

know what notes are allowed as additions if they choose to use them.

So here again is each MM-mode with a complete set of possible symbols and a

frequently used voicing underneath plus a short playback:

I - MELODIC MINOR

Track27-7.3. Melodic Minor Chord Symbols

II - DORIAN b2

Page 65: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 65/120

Track28-7.3. Dorian ♭2 Chord Symbols

III - LYDIAN AUGMENTED

Track29-7.3. Lydian Aug Chord Symbols

IV - LYDIAN DOMINANT

Page 66: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 66/120

Track30-7.3. Lydian Dom Chord Symbols

 As you can see and hear, it is ok if required to have ♮5 and ♭5/♯11 in the same chord. But for a cleaner 

sound I prefer to leave the ♮5 out.

V - MIXOLYDIAN b13

Page 67: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 67/120

Track31-7.3. Mixolydian ♭13 Chord Symbols

What I said a minute ago about ♮5 and ♭5 in the same harmony goes a bit more against the grain if you try it

with ♮5 and ♯5/♭13. Personally I’m not a big fan. (Replay the last chord of the above audio sample). To

keep “in tune” with the C-Melodic Minor scale, the ♯5 is displayed as E♭ instead of 

D♯.

VI - LOCRIAN #2

Track32-7.3. Locrian #2 Chord Symbols

VII - ALTERED

Page 68: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 68/120

Track33-7.3. Altered Chord Symbols

 Again, apologies for notating the 3rd of B as E♭ instead of D♯.

Remember:

Chord symbols are not a unified and set in stone subject. Many musicians have

different ways of writing them. But the ones you’ve just looked at have not given

me any problems or complaints in over 40 years of writing arrangements.  Above

all: Be clear!

7.4. The Melodic Minor Scale Chord Diagram

Page 69: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 69/120

Page 70: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 70/120

Only kidding! The altered mode should not be any more difficult than the others

because it’s still just the MM-scale starting on the 7th note. Right? Don’t let all

those serious looking symbols scare you.

The good news is: You’ve arrived at another milestone. We’ve covered almost all

the chord varieties you’ll ever need to know.

If you understand the content so far and it makes sense, you should be smiling

with pride.

The remaining 2 chapters cover what is left of the chord pie, the diminishedscale and then how to treat outside chords when they arise inside a major tonal

center.

Page 71: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 71/120

8. THE CHORDS OF THE DIMINISHED BLUES

SCALE

8.1. Insight into The Diminished Blues Scale

The Diminished Blues Scale is daunting to some, overused by others and not fully

understood by many.

Here are some important facts why this is the case:

1. It is an 8-note scale

2. It has multiple names

3. It only exists in 3 keys then it repeats

4. It is 2 scales in one

Let’s put each of those points under the microscope:

1. 8-Note Scale

8 scale tones without avoid notes, which opens the door for a large variety of 

harmonies, up to 8 notes if you “dare”.

2. Multiple Names

The other 2 names of this scale are:Whole Tone-Half Tone (WT-HT) or Half Tone-Whole Tone (HT-WT) scale

depending on the starting note:

3. Only 3 Keys

Page 72: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 72/120

Similar to the whole-tone scale where we found that it really only exists in 2 keys

before you start repeating, the Dim Blues has a regular interval pattern of 3 semi-

tones between chord tones. This means that there are only 3 different keys (C, C♯

and D) before we get back to the C-version starting on E♭.

4. 2 Scales In One

This is the most important point. You can look at this scale in 2 different ways:

a. Half Tone-Whole Tone is the basis of a Dominant 7(♭9) chord (1-3-5-♭7)

and 3 others exactly the same starting on notes 3, 5 and 7.

b. Whole Tone-Half Tone is the mode behind a Diminished 7th chord (1-♭3-

♭5-♭♭7) and also 3 others from notes 3, 5 and 7.

(I know that 3 of the D♭ diminished chord tones are enharmonically incorrect but I left them the same as the

top scale for this demo.)

Page 73: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 73/120

Hear both scales with the 4-note harmony behind them:

Track34-8.1. C-HT and D♭-WT

If you’re still a bit confused about this mode, don’t worry. It took me a fair amount

of time and practice before the fog cleared. The next chapters will provide more

insight and chord samples.

8.2. How To Build Dim Blues Scale Chords

Since each one of the 24 possible harmonies (3 scales x 4 dim + 3 scales x 4 b9)

has no avoid notes, it is possible to build chords anywhere from 3 to 8 notes. Thisis a huge soundscape of simple triads (probably not often chosen in this scale,

but then, why not), to 4-note chords with either 1, 2, 3 or even 4 added tension.

Let’s have a closer look, separately for WT-HT and HT-WT.

8.2.1. The Whole Tone-Half Tone Way 

Allow me to nail this down once more: Each of the 3 WT-HT modes is the

backdrop for 4 diminished 7th chords containing 4 basic chord tones and 4

possible tensions.Standard 4-note dim chords have a reputation for sounding a bit passé, especially

when used for any length of time (like 1 measure) and not just as passing chords

for instrument voicings where they might move at 8th note speed. So, the addition

Page 74: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 74/120

of 1 or 2 of the available tensions has the potential to bring the old-fashioned into

the now. Which 2 out of the 4, or whether any of them are suitable, is always

determined by melody notes and style.

NOTE:

The rows of note names at the bottom of the image are valid for all 3 scales.

Enharmonically correct spelling of each chord tone is near impossible and

depends a lot on what key you are in and whether you are using say C♯ or D♭, F♯

or G♭ etc. diminished.

Here are the same 3 scales in a different format displaying the chords & tensions:

Page 75: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 75/120

NOTE:

 Accidentals in the 2nd  measure carry right through from the first chord and its

tensions.

 Again: Enharmonic spelling of the dim chords has been kept the same as in

measure 1 for convenience.

You must have noticed that each WT-HT scale consists of 2 intertwined diminished chords, 1 starting on the root note and the other a whole tone above.

8.2.2. The Half Tone-Whole Tone Road 

It is tempting (and possible) to subdivide the HT-WT mode like we just did in the

last chapter and superimpose 2 diminished chords on top of each other like so:

But this image, while technically correct, leads to confusion and does not address

the true purpose of a HT-WT scale, which is to be the backdrop for a dominant 7th

chord with 4 possible added tensions as you saw in chapter 8.1.

Page 76: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 76/120

Now we’re cooking and able to expand the info like we did for the WT-HT mode.

Despite the difference in looking at this scale, it still holds 3 other dominant 7th

chords.

To display this though in one image like I did with the WT-HT is not possible

because the sequence of chord tones and tensions is not even any more.

Here are the 4 dominant 7th  chords “hidden” inside the C HT-WT: (enharmonic

spelling errors of some chord tones admitted and on purpose!)

Page 77: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 77/120

Page 78: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 78/120

additions. Adding all or some of those to the basic 4-note symbol is pretty straight

ahead for the dominant 7th ones (HT-WT) but gets a bit trickier for the diminished

group (WT-HT).

Let’s check it out!

8.3.1. Diminished Chord Symbols

 As I mentioned earlier you may want to spice up the basic dim7 chord with an

extra note or two. And that is about as far as I would go unless you’re aiming to

create a pretty strained sound. If you add more than 2 tensions, expressing all 3

or 4 added notes clearly in the symbol becomes more and more difficult. You

could follow the normal path and name the 4 extra notes as intervals from the root

note something crazy like this:

But I have never written dim chords in such a way or seen them in anybody else’s

music.

The most common tension added to the diminished harmony is the ▵7 closely

followed by the 9th. In a Cdim7 that is the notes B & D, resulting in the reasonably

often used symbols C°(▵7) or C°(▵9).

In these situations the note(s) immediately below the added tension(s) in the scale

is/are frequently omitted resulting in a less clustered but just as effective sound.

See and hear the following examples:

Track35-8.3. Cdim(▵7)and(▵9)

Page 79: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 79/120

To accommodate the other 2 tensions or include 3 or even 4 (if you must) I have

always either written the voicing out or used a symbol that is not necessarily all-

inclusive but quite enough to give chord players the message. If you really want to

convey that you want 4 chord tones + 4 tensions, the easiest way is to write B°7

over C°7. The “over” part is a horizontal slash (or underscore) with the B°7 above

it and the C°7 below. This is easy to understand and write.

Here are some examples:

You can see that the above methods allow you to write just about any combination of the 8 notes.

Track36-8.3. Cdim + up to 4 tensions

Remember to always notate dim chords by their root note. So if a C is on the

bottom it’s a C°, if it is E♭ or G♭ or A call them E♭, G♭ or A diminished.

8.3.2. Dominant 7 Chord Symbols

You’ll be glad to know that notating this section of the diminished blues scale is abit more straight ahead.

You start with 1-3-5-♭7 and have the choice of adding any or all of these: ♭9,

♯9, ♭5/♯11 and 13.

The most common and still pleasant sounding 7-note symbol is C13(♭9/♯11).

The same harmony with ♯9 in it is quite tense and used less. If you must go “all

the way”, you could use the chord over chord technique and say E♭° over C7(♭9),

but I have never needed to go that far.

Important: Whenever the 9th is altered in either direction, the natural 9 is NOT 

available.

Here are a few examples of C7 voicings with a variety of the 4 tensions added:

Page 80: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 80/120

Track37-8.3. C7♭9 + up to 4 tensions

The only chord that has a note omitted is the 4th chord in the lower row. The ♮5 is

missing resulting in a clearer sound.

Notice how the root position examples at the beginning of each measure are

more edgy than the open voicings where clashing notes are separated. There are

many more ways to use these harmonies. You can try any combination and also

leave notes out as long as you keep the root note and the 2 guide tones (3rd and

♭7) in place. When using ♮5 and ♭5 it is best to have the ♮5 BELOW the ♭5 unless

you brake the rules and have them next to each other or reversed to create a

special tense sound.

8.4. The HT-WT Scale Chord Diagram

Page 81: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 81/120

Page 82: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 82/120

8.5. The WT-HT Scale Chord Diagram

Page 83: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 83/120

Page 84: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 84/120

8.6. More Digging into the Cycle of Fifths

In the last burst of circle of fifths info way back in chapter 5.3.6 the main points of

discussion were the 15 keys and their key signatures plus the need to reverse

the order of sharps and flats to make along-the-cycle harmony flow in the same

direction as music on paper, left to right. I trust this makes sense to you.

This time I’d like to draw your attention to a wider look at the cycle, the

peripheral vision part if you like.

The great thing about this tool is its multi-purpose qualities. Sure you can use

it to remember how many sharps and flats keys have and in what order they are

added or subtracted. But for me the more juicy info is that each station on the

cycle can be anything with that name! For instance let’s take D and forget the 2

sharps for a moment and let’s pretend that D can be any chord not just D major,

for instance Dm7 or D7 or any D chord as complicated as you like and any scale

that goes with each of those harmonies. That really opens up this gadgetsusefulness.

Now a “tame” inside the key turn-around like III-VI-II-V-I (Em7-Am7-Dm7-G7-

CMaj7) can be as complicated as E7(♯5♭9) Altered Scale - A7(♭9) Half Tone-

Whole Tone Scale - D9(13) G Major Scale - G9(♯11) Lydian Dominant Scale -

C6/9.

If this extra dimensional view of the humble circle is to your liking, you can

watch parts 3, 4 & 5 of my free videos on the cycle of 5ths. They cover all thatstuff and more:

VIDEO 3:

(Watch & hear how chord progressions behave on the cycle of 5ths diagram in detail. Learn about the “turn-

around” and analyze the harmonic details of a 16-measure song step by step.)

VIDEO 4:

(10 easy steps to perfect music transcription using the cycle of fifths. A hands-on look at a short song and

how to transcribe each instrument from the bass up. Learn how to hear and adjust chords using the melody.)

VIDEO 5:

(How To Transpose Music Instantly With The Cycle Of Fifths. Watch a step-by-step demo using a short song.)

Page 85: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 85/120

Page 86: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 86/120

Let’s look at the sus chord groups separately.

9.3. Major sus4 and sus2 Chords

In the major chord group the sus4 version is most often applied to the triad. So C

(C-E-G) becomes Csus4 (C-F-G). Inversions follow the same principles as

discussed in the major modes.

Track38-9.3. Csus4 + Inversions

If you extend this to larger chords it can get confusing both in sound and symbol

notation. But despite that they exist.

For instance:

C▵7(sus4) = C-F-G-B or C▵9(sus4) = C-F-G-B-D which is the same as

G7/C, easier to write and interpret.

C6(sus4) = C-F-G-A and C6/9(sus4) = C-F-G-A-D. Both of those are a bit

clustery in root position and need careful voicing. The second one can be

notated as Dm/C

You can see that having an F in a C-major harmony can form little triadic or 4-note

structures over a C-bass.

Page 87: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 87/120

Track39-9.3. CMaj7 + C6 (sus4)

The sus2 version of major chords has been used to great effect in some famous

themes.

It is mostly applied to the triad and, similarly to above, larger sus2 chords can

easily be written in other ways:

C(sus2) = D-E-G (still with a C in the bass, also called C2)

C▵7(sus2) = D-E-G-B is really the same as a different voicing of C▵9 or 

Em7/C.

If you enlarge further to include the 9th, the exercise becomes pointless because

the 9th in C is the D and symbol-wise we can use C▵9 or C6/9.

The variety of harmonic possibilities just in this sus department is maybe not

endless but large. I would suggest this:

Use C(sus2) or C2 or C(add2) when you want the D played inside the triad 

and not above it in the ninth spot. For those you can say C(add9) or C ▵9 etc.

Track40-9.3. C(sus2) examples

9.4. Dominant sus4 Chords

If you’ve been around any of today’s music even a little bit you would have

encountered dominant 7th(sus4) chords. They are everywhere. Not just to resolve

to the non-sus harmony but by themselves covering whole sections of songs.

 Any Dominant/Mixolydian scale that contains a 4th as an “avoid” note can be

hijacked and turned into a sus4 by promoting the 4th to chord-tone status and

barring the 3rd to the wasteland of the untouchables.

Page 88: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 88/120

Be clear that the Lydian Dominant and HT-WT scales are not candidates for sus4-

ing because they don’t have a 4th to sus but a ♯4/♭5/♯11 instead.Let’s look at a few examples of G7(sus4) and how quite often any V(sus4) can

also be a disguised II-chord (Dorian) with the V already in the bass.

Note: The 4 notes of the Dm7 are the same as F6 and Dm9 is the same as F▵7. The Dm (II) is better if 

resolving to G7 but the F (IV) could also be used in other harmonic circumstances

Track41-9.4. G7(sus4) examples

IMPORTANT:

Listening to pop music of any style I hear harmonic passages on a regular basis

that have used the sus4 AND the 3rd in the same chord . That sounds cool andeffective if it is done on purpose and with care. But quite often it is obviously a

mistake that has occurred when overdubbing or through sheer ignorance. Be

clear in your mind that the main purpose of the sus4 is the resolution to the 3rd.

Page 89: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 89/120

Page 90: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 90/120

Diminished harmonies are not sus4-able because the 4th note in the WT-HT

scale is ♯4, therefore unavailable.

The 1/2-diminshed chord family is also not a good candidate for sus 4ths because

the 5th note is a ♭5, a half tone away from the 4th or T11.

So, as we discovered in the Locrian and Locrian ♯2 modes, the T11 is an

available note to be used as a tension above the 4 base notes, but were you to tryand create a B∅(sus4) you’d get B-E-F-A. That is actually a cool sound, but it

could also be named G9(13)/B or Dm6/9/B.

In all my umpteen years of “peddling” chords I’ve never come across the

∅(sus4) symbol. Of course that doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist somewhere in a

dark corner of chord-land. Actually, in hindsight, I rather like it.

Page 91: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 91/120

10. THE MODES BETWEEN THE MODES

10.1. What Are The Modes Between The Modes

Back in Chapter 5 we looked at the 7 Major Modes and all the examples in the

key of C.

Imagine for a moment that you’re composing or working on a tune in C. It is

very likely that amongst its chord sequence you will find C, Dm, Em, F, G7, Am &

B∅. Maybe not all 7 but at least some of them.

The truth is though that most songs don’t just contain all or some of those

inside harmonies but possibly any other chord there is. That’s why we need to

look at our C-scale with a chromatic eye. The places in the scale where there is

room for in-between or outside harmony are:

C♯/D♭ (♯I or ♭II),

D♯/E♭ (♯II or ♭III),

F♯/G♭ (♯IV or ♭V),

G♯/A♭ (♯V or ♭VI) and

 A♯/B♭ (♯VI or ♭VII).

 All of those outside chords could potentially be any chord type: Major, Minor,Dominant, Diminished, even 1/2-Diminished. The ones that we’re going to look at

are the most common: Major, Dominant and Diminished.

It is important to point out that the appearance of those in-between harmonies

be “out-of-the-blue” (in the case of major chords NOT preceded by II - V).

Page 92: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 92/120

Track43-10.1. In-Between Modes (out-of-the-blue)

When one of the outside major chords has a II - V in front of it, like Fm7 - B♭7 -

E♭6, it presents a different situation. From the moment of the Fm7 to whenever thesong goes back to C (via Dm7 - G7) you are in the key of E♭.

So, for the “out-of-the-blue” outside cases to contain as much of a “C-sound”

(inside) as possible we need to find a way to integrate the chord and its scale into

our C-song. That easy technique is the topic of the next chapter.

10.2. How To Create The In-Between Modes

To keep a tune close to it’s tonal center or key when dealing with “outside” or in-between chords is relatively easy. The choice whether you want to do this is of 

course totally up to you. But if your composition is aimed at the general listening

market it makes sense to avoid the appearance of unnecessary notes with

accidentals where possible.

Here is what I mean:

Your tune is in C and in measure 3 you have 4 beats of E♭7. You’d be quite

correct if during measure 3 in your melody you would choose the E♭-Mixolydian

scale with the note A♭ as the 4th. This note is not wrong and you could insist thatit is what you want. But A♭ is not part of the C-major scale and therefore “outside”.

So how do we keep those major and dominant harmonic situations as inside as

possible?

Page 93: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 93/120

Simple:

1. Create the appropriate 4-note chord and 

2. Fill the gaps with notes from the key/scale the tune is written in.

For the E♭7 chord we mentioned above, the 2 steps would be:

1. E♭7 = E♭ - G - B♭ - D♭

2. E♭ - F - G - A (not A♭) - B♭ - C - D♭ (bold = C scale notes) result: E♭ Lydian

Dominant.

Hear the subtle difference between using a Lydian Dominant scale (inside) versus

an Eb Mixolydian (outside).Tune is in the key of C, first with the Eb-Lydian Dominant melody in measure 3:

Page 94: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 94/120

Track44-10.2. E♭ Lydian Dominant Ex.

Now with the Mixolydian, meaning the A’s become A♭’s in measure 3:

Page 95: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 95/120

Track45-10.2. E♭ Mixolydian Ex.

Don’t know about you but I definitively prefer V1 with the inside melody. The E♭chord seems to be less invasive.

10.3. In-Between Major & Dominant Modes

 Assuming again that we are working with a tune in C-major, let’s test the theory

Page 96: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 96/120

from the last chapter on the five in-between spots D♭, E♭, G♭, A♭  and B♭  (the

enharmonic alternatives are, apart from F♯, not “valid” scales) and see what

scales and chords we come up with for major and dominant chords.

Please be aware that not all chord possibilities have been notated:

1. D♭ Major and D♭ Dominant

2. E♭ Major and E♭ Dominant

3. G♭ Major and G♭ Dominant

Page 97: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 97/120

4. A♭ Major and A♭ Dominant

5. B♭ Major and B♭ Dominant

 As you can see, all of those scales & harmonies require a natural T9 (a wholetone up from the tonic). For some (E♭ & B♭) that happens to be a C-major scale

note but for the others that 9th is a non-C-note. The same applies to the 6th/T13.

Page 98: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 98/120

 As it turns out, all the major in-between scales become Lydian and the

dominant ones Lydian Dominant. Easy to remember!

10.4. In-Between Diminished Modes

 As I said before, Diminished chords in general are less common in todays music.

But if you like jazz standards and similar styles of music you will stumble across

the dim7 chord symbol quite often. If you’re a composer of that type of musicyou’ll most likely hear and use them.

The temptation will be to just use the Whole Tone-Half Tone scale. That will

work of course but many of the in-between notes will be more “outside” your key

center than necessary.

So, the procedure to arrive at a more “inside” and less disruptive sound is the

same as outlined in the major/dominant chapter you just read with 1 modification

and 2 how-to rules.

The modification is simply that these dim7 scales are 8 notes long. The 2 rules

we’ll get to in a minute.

In-between diminished harmony occurs most commonly as link-up or connecting

chords between these major scale modes:

1. Going up from I-major to II-minor → ♯I-dim7

2. Going up from II-minor to III-minor → ♯II-dim7

3. Coming down from III-minor to II-minor → ♭III-dim7

4. Going up from IV-major to V-dominant → ♯IV-dim7

5. Going up from V-dominant to VI-minor → ♯V-dim7

When creating the 5 modes you will also note the close connection between dim

and dom7(♭9) we talked about earlier (WH-HT & HT-WT scale) in 4 of them.

The 2 rules are designed to help you decide whether the in-between scale

notes are labeled T (tension) or A (avoid).

Rule 1: Scale tones that are a 1/2 step below a chord tone become Tensions.

Rule 2: Scale tones that are a whole step below a chord tone become  Avoid .

Once again, the following examples all assume that we are dealing with a

composition in the key of C.

Remember the routine: Create the 4-note dim chord, and then fill the gaps with C-

scale notes! 

Page 99: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 99/120

 A few comments about these 5 scales and their chords:

1. Notice the restriction to only 2 or 3 tensions available. If you used the WT-HT

scale on all of those 5 chords you’d have the choice of 4 notes to add (if you

wanted to) but also many more accidentals and therefore outside of C

sounds.

2. In ♭III and ♯IV dim (3 tensions each) the chord symbols are not complete but Itrust you understand that all 3 added notes are available and could be

included in the symbol.

3. Other in-between diminished’s are possible like ♭VIIdim7 (B♭°7) and would be

Page 100: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 100/120

treated in the same way.

Here is my 8-bar tune (“Link Up”). First using all five dim7 chords and a simple

improvised melody:

Page 101: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 101/120

Page 102: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 102/120

Track46-10.4. “Link Up” (Dim7)

Let’s hear it once more, this time all diminished chords except E♭dim have beenreplaced with dom7(♭9) harmonies which creates a V to I movement into each

next measure. All I’ve changed are the chord symbols and the bass line.

Page 103: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 103/120

Page 104: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 104/120

Track47-10.4. “Link Up” (Dom7)

Despite all the added accidentals, both versions in harmony & melody still have a

sense of belonging to the key of C. This would not (or much less) be the case if 

you were to change the tune to include WT-HT scale tensions. Try it!

Page 105: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 105/120

11. DOMINANT VERSIONS OF II, III & VI CHORDS

11.1. How To Handle II7, III7 & VI7 Chords

In any major key, the II, III and VI chords are minor. In the key of C that means:

II = Dm7 (Dorian),

III = Em7 (Phrygian),

VI = Am7 (Aeolian)

But you will find either in your own composition or analyzing or orchestrating other 

people’s music that those 3 places have been replaced by some version of a

dominant chord. It happens all the time and knowing how to handle this change of 

sound becomes important.

With all that you’ve absorbed so far about the chameleon quality of the

dominant 7th chord, the solution is actually quite easy. ANYTHING GOES

depending on the harmonic circumstances you find yourself in.

The last chapter on the dom7th variation of the in-between harmonies should

give you a hint. If necessary, look at and replay the last track of “Link Up” and be

aware that D7 (measure 5) is the dominant version of the II-chord, E7 (measure 6)

and A7 (measure 1) are the dom7th replacement of the III and VI respectively.

The choice of the quality of those 3 chords is up to you and what you like best.

One deciding factor may be that you want their sound to be as “inside” as

possible. We’ve discussed how to handle this scenario in the last chapter. If you

need a reminder:

Create the 4-note chord and fill the gaps with notes from the scale your tune is

written in.

Like this in the key of C:

Page 106: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 106/120

But that is only the inside way. Potentially any quality of dom7 chord can be used.

It depends where II7, III7, VI7 lead to. The resolution can be to Minor, Dominant or 

Major and each of those can require a different sound, from simple Mixolydian to

outlandish Altered. YOU decide!

Here is a variety of turn-arounds (a repetitive chord sequence) using our 3

chords III - VI - II - V from totally inside to the other extreme.

Page 107: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 107/120

Page 108: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 108/120

Track48-11.1. C Major Turn-Arounds

The final choice of which version of II7, III7 or VI7 is best will be dictated by the

notes of the melody and the style of the music.

There are hundreds of songs out there (some very famous) that explore those

3 chords in a multitude of ways. Check them out and experiment.

Page 109: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 109/120

12. CHORD TREES

12.1. About My Chord Trees

I’m a bit of a diagram/graphic nerd. Schematic representations offer a different

look at a topic and for some people they may just shed a new light on a problemand lead to an “AHA” moment.

 Armed with my very limited graphic skills I’m attempting to show the 5 chord

families in a different form.

Each of the following chapters displays each chord family as a tree that

includes all  possible chord tones. They are color coded so the brown tree trunk

contains the root note, guide tones and the basic 4-note chord while the green

leaves are representing any available tensions.

In keeping with the practice followed so far, each tree is in the key of C.

To change to any other key, you would just need to slide the keyboard on the left up or down till the root

note shows the name of the new key. The placing of all the notes inside each tree would be in exactly the

same position but of course the note names would change with each “slide”. Unfortunately I haven’t quite

figured out how to make this possible on a web page yet, but I’m working on it.

If the device you are reading this on does not display a clear or big enough

image, you can view a larger version on the website by clicking on each tree.

12.2. Major Chords

Please take your time to look this over, it may be confusing at first but all the info about major chord varieties

are included.

Follow the red chord type numbers (a to d) and text to the right. It contains chord tones (1/3/5) and chord

symbols. I have not  included all symbols due to lack of space. After your chord-journey so far you should be

able to follow the content easily.

Page 110: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 110/120

Page 111: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 111/120

12.4. Minor 6th Chords

This is pretty straight ahead. Think of it like a C-Major chord with a ♭3. It has a 6th, ▵7, 9th and all the

combinations thereof. The 11th allows the extension to a 7-note harmony.

Page 112: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 112/120

12.5. Dominant Chords

It was impossible to fit all the dominant chord varieties into 1 tree and make it look readable. So I split them

into 3 parts. This first one contains Mixolydian, Lydian Dom & Whole Tone. Note how the Lydian Dom & WTkind of overlap depending on what scale is being used.

Page 113: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 113/120

Part II shows the dom7th(♭9) chords from the Half Tone - Whole Tone (Dim Blues) scale. Again, lack of space

prevents the inclusion of all possible symbols.

Page 114: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 114/120

 And finally in part III you can see the harmonies from the Altered scale. The top 2 notes in the tree (A♭ & F♯)

are really a non-event because were you to use those 2 extensions you’d be implying that there is a  ♮5th

available which is not the case.

Page 115: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 115/120

12.6. Diminished Chords

Notating WT-HT diminished symbols with added tensions can get out of hand (as touched on before). 1 or 2

added notes is manageable but when it gets to 3 & 4 a compromise is in order. I suggest either write them outor try the B°7 over C°7 method. The “over” part must be a horizontal line not a slash.

Page 116: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 116/120

For the following representation of the “inside” diminished chords we have to assume that C-dim can be ♯I

(in the key of B), ♯II or  ♭III (key A), ♯IV (key F♯) or ♯VI (key D). As you remember, these 5 inside versions of 

dim harmony will blend into any of the 5 keys better by not giving access to 4 tensions like the WT-HT scale

ust shown, but a selection of avoid notes and tensions.

Page 117: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 117/120

12.7. Half Diminished Chords

Last but certainly not least let’s take a look at the 1/2-dim tree. The difference

between Locrian and Locrian ♯2 is only that the latter contains a usable tension 9,therefore providing 1 more layer of symbol/sound. For most musical situations the

basic symbol (a2) is enough but by all means use the others if necessary.

Page 118: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 118/120

Page 119: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 119/120

13. CODA

Getting to the Coda in nearly all music means that you have read through most of 

your part and you’re near the end of the tune.

Well, this “song” about what chords are is no different; you’re very close to the

“Fine” .

If you are reading this you have displayed remarkable tenacity and patience to

get this far. I take my hat off in admiration.

If your head is buzzing with too much information please remember that a lot of 

the material in this book becomes really clear and user-friendly with repetition and

translation into other keys.

Once you GET IT in one key, the others are a snack.

My 10 suggestions for easy chord learning are:

1. Become inside out (that is completely) comfortable with your favorite Major 

key.

2. Practice and understand the 7 modes of that key.

3. Become inside out (that is completely) at ease with the Melodic Minor version

of your favorite Major key by flattening the third by a semi tone.

4. Practice and understand the 7 modes of that Melodic Minor.

5. Become totally cozy with the Diminished Blues scale starting on the root note

of your favorite Major scale.

6.  Apply and get the concept of the WT-HT and HT-WT part of this scale.

7. Repeat 1-6 in as many other keys as possible

8. Learn the 3 Whole Tone scales and understand their content.

9. Extend your Major, Dominant and Minor chord/scale knowledge to include

sus4 and sus2 harmony.

10. Internalize the meaning and content of the Modes Between The Modes

Now you’re well equipped to develop your personal harmonic style. This is crucialto successful composition and chord choice.

If you need help with how to apply all this wonderful chord knowledge you’ve

acquired you may be interested in the sequel to “What Are Chords”.

Page 120: What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

7/24/2019 What Are Chords - George Brodbeck

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/what-are-chords-george-brodbeck 120/120

It will cover such topics as: “How To Use Chords”, “Song Writing Tips”, “Chord

Patterns”, “How To Write Chord Progressions” and much more.

If you want to be notified about the release date (mid 2016) and any future

publications, please use the opt-in form on the homepage of WhatAreChords.com

.

Here are few measures of choral harmony as an example of what kind of chords

buzz around my head: