week 3: christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/christology 2016 iii.pdfin the...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Week3:Christologyagainsthistory
• ‘Dialectical’theologywasmorethanjustaresponsetofrustrationaboutunsuccessfulhistoricalJesusresearch.• RejectionofhistoryasmajorpointofreferenceforChristology/soteriology.• OftenframedascausedandjustifiedbyWWI,butmustultimatelybejudgedbyitsanswers.
![Page 2: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1.Søren Abaye Kierkegaard(1831-1855)
![Page 3: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
KierkegaardReading
• PhilosophicalFragments(1844).Onlineat:http://sorenkierkegaard.org/texts/text7a.htm• ConcludingUnscientificPostscripttothePhilosophicalFragments(1846)• P.L.Gardiner,Kierkegaard,Oxford1988• A.Hannay (ed.),TheCambridgeCompaniontoKierkegaard,Cambridge1997• J.Howland,KierkegaardandSocrates.AStudyinPhilosophyandFaith,Cambridge2006.
![Page 4: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
KierkegaardII
• WholeheartedrejectionofHegeliansynthesis.• Dichotomyoffaithandknowledge.• Religioustruthisattainedassomethingalientohumans.→ Cannotbygainedby‘Socratic’method.• Ithastoacknowledgesin,theconsciousturningawayofhumansfromGod.• Thereforeitcanonlybetaughtbyateacherwhocanfirstchangethelearner→ Godhimself.
![Page 5: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
KierkegaardIII
• Godmustapproachthehumanbeingassomeonelikehim→Incarnation.• Thisisparadoxical,theAbsoluteParadox.• Causespolemicalresponse;onlyacceptedthrough‘leap’intofaith.• → Faithisalwaysmiracle.• Thereforenodifferencebetween‘first’and‘second’disciple.
![Page 6: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
KierkegaardIV
• Thefascinationofthis‘Christology’liesinitsfocusontheutterstrangenessoftheunionofdivineandhuman.• Also:no‘impartial’Christologypossible,onlyfaithwillgraspit(intimateconnectionwithexistentialistanthropology!)• NoconceptualisationoftheIncarnationassuch(it’saparadox!)
![Page 7: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
2.KarlBarth(1886-1968)
![Page 8: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
BarthReading
• K.Barth,TheEpistletotheRomans,1919,2nd ed.1921,ET:1933.• T.F.Torrance,KarlBarth.AnIntroductiontohisEarlyTheology,London1962.• B.McCormack,KarlBarth’sCriticallyRealisticDialecticalTheology.ItsGenesisandDevelopment1909-1936,Oxford1995.• R.E.Burnett,KarlBarth’sTheologicalExegesis.TheHermeneuticalPrinciplesoftheRömerbrief Period,Tübingen 2001.
![Page 9: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Barth– earlytheology
• InfluenceofKierkegaard,Kant,ReligiousSocialism(andindeedpoliticalsocialism).• From1911pastoratSafenwil(Switzerland)• Breakwiththeliberalismofhisacademicteachersandtheirforebears(esp.Schleiermacher)• Majorcriticismoftheologysince18th century:puthumanityatthecentreoftheology,ratherthanGod.
![Page 10: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
BarthIII
• MajordocumentofhisearlyperiodishiscommentaryonPaul’sEpistletotheRomans• Barthallbutignoreshistoricalscholarship.• ReadsStPaulundertheassumptionthathewasspeakingofGod–theproblemswiththatwouldbethesamethenandnow.• Centraltenet(withKierkegaard):dichotomyofGodandman.• Christsignifiestheintersectionoftwoplanes,aknownandanunknown.
![Page 11: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
BarthIV
• ‘Thepointonthelineofintersectionisnomoreextendedontotheknownplanethanistheunknownplaneofwhichitproclaimstheexistence.Theeffulgence,or,rather,thecratermadeatthepercussionpointofanexplodingshell,thevoidbywhichthepointonthelineofintersectionmakesitselfknownintheconcreteworldofhistory,isnot– eventhoughitbenamedthelifeofJesus– thatotherworldwhichtouchesourworldinHim.’(29)
![Page 12: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
BarthV
• CombinationoftwoelementsfromKierkegaard:infinitedifferencebetweenGodandhumanity&Incarnationasaparadox.• Consequently,Christologicalfocusontheresurrection:• TheResurrectionistherevelation:thedisclosingofJesusastheChrist,theappearingofGod,andtheapprehendingofGodinJesus.TheResurrectionistheemergenceofthenecessityofgivingglorytoGod:thereckoningwithwhatisunknownandunobservableinJesus,therecognitionofhimasParadox…IntheresurrectionthenewworldoftheHolySpirittouchestheoldworld…(30)
![Page 13: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
BarthVI
• AttheresurrectionJesusis‘proclaimed’SonofGod(cf.Rom1,4)–thisisallthatmatters:• ‘[This]isthesignificanceofJesus,and,apartfromthis,Jesushasnomoresignificanceorinsignificancethanmaybeattachedtoanymanorthingorperiodofhistoryinitself.’(30)• Thecrucialeventisnotthe‘mergingorfusion’ofGodandman,buttheunveilingofthecomingKingdomofGod.
![Page 14: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
BarthVII
• Relevanceofeschatology(cf.Schweitzer!)• Barth:thismeantanexpectationofsomethingentirelydifferentfromhistory,notsomedramaticendofhistory.• RejectsassumptionofearlyChristian‘crisis’becausetheParousia,the2nd comingofChrist,didnotoccur.• Eschatologyisasmuchamatterofhopenowasitwasthen:
![Page 15: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
BarthVIII
• ‘Butthatdayandthathournomanknoweth– noteventheangelsinheaven,neithertheSon,buttheFather (Mk13,32).Donotourearsburnwhenwehearthis?Willthereneverbeanendofallourceaselesstalkaboutthedelay oftheParousia?…TheendofwhichtheNewTestamentspeaksisnotemporalevent,nolegendary‘destruction’oftheworld;ithasnothingtodowithanyhistorical,or‘telluric’orcosmiccatastrophe.TheendofwhichtheNewTestamentspeaksisreallytheEnd;soutterlytheEnd,thatinthemeasuringofnearnessordistanceournineteenhundredyearsarenotmerelyoflittle,butofnoimportance’.(500)
![Page 16: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
BarthIX
• BarthmanagestobreakawayfrommajorChristologicalpatternsofthe19th century.• Theliabilitiesoftheearly20th centurydiscoveryofeschatologyarevirtuallyturnedintoanasset.• Theocentric,notChristocentrictheology.• NotionoftheIncarnationpracticallyvanishes:Jesusisanoccasionfortheresurrectiontooccur.
![Page 17: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
MoreBarthReading
• K.Barth,TheHumanityofGod, London1967• MacCormack,Barth’scriticallyrealisticdialecticalTheology,Oxford1996,partiv• J.Thompson,ChristinPerspective.ChristologicalPerspectivesinthetheologyofKarlBarth,Edinburgh1978.• G.Hunsingerin:Webster(ed.),CambridgeCompaniontoKarlBarth• T.Hart,‘WasGodinChrist’in:id.RegardingKarlBarth,Carlisle1999• R.Jenson,GodafterGod,Indianapolis1969.
![Page 18: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Barth’sLaterTheology
• Barth’sChurchDogmaticsisstrictlychristocentric.• ThereforeChristologycannotbelimitedtooneparticulartopic.• Howdoesitshapetheworkasawhole?• ChristocentricfocushasledBarthtonegativeandpositiveassertions.Thenegativeonesarebetterknown,thepositiveonesprobablymoreimportant.
![Page 19: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
LaterBarthII
• Majordecisionisrejectionof‘naturaltheology’.• AnyattempttospeaktheologicallyapartfromChrist(analogyofbeing;‘anthropological’theologyofliberalism)• Barthseesdangerofuniversalapproach→ Christianityisreducedtooneinstanceofamoregeneraltruth.• Instead,theologyoughttobeconcrete.
![Page 20: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
LaterBarthIII
• Revelationdoesnotmeanasetofpropositions,butbecomingawareofreality.• JesusistherevelationoftheWordofGodbecauseinhimoureyesareopenedtotherealityofGodandthehumanbeing.• Barththusisless‘orthodox’thanhasbeenclaimed.• Canbeseenasforerunnerof‘postmodernist’emphasisonspecificity(J.Derrida;cf.G.Ward,Barth,DerridaandtheLanguageofTheology).
![Page 21: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
LaterBarthIV
• FocusonJesusChristmeansthattheologyisbasedonthenotionofreconciliation.• Godrevealedhimselfasbeingalignedtohumanity.• Godrevealedthehumanbeingasexaltedtothedivineimage.• Theseareorthodoxcategories,butmodifiedwithinachristocentricsystem:• DoctrinesofGod,creationandFallcannotbearticulatedindependentlyoftheChristevent.
![Page 22: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
LaterBarthV
• TheconsequenceisthateverythingstandsunderthepropositionthattheworldhasbeenreconciledtoGod;sintrulyis‘nothingness’.• AlltheinitialnegationsoftheCDaremodifiedinlightofthisinsight:• InlightoffaiththeworldisfullofsignspointingtoGod.• InlightoftheChristeventthehistoryofreligionstakesonapositivesignificance.
![Page 23: Week 3: Christology against historyusers.ox.ac.uk/~trin1631/files/Christology 2016 III.pdfIn the resurrection the new world of the Holy Spirit touches the old world … (30) Barth](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022042313/5edd70a9ad6a402d666888fe/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
LaterBarthVI
• HasBarthturnedwhollyidealisticandlefthisdialecticalphasebehind?• No,becauseGod’srevelationisatthesametimehisconcealment.• Wedonotgrasphisbeing,butseehissalvificwill.• IncarnationandreconciliationarenotnecessaryconsequencesofGod’snature(asinHegel),butGod’sfreedecisiontoalignhimselfwithhumans.• Therefore,theologydoesnotturnintoametaphysicsofalovingGod.