water harvesting from roads in ethiopia: techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · water harvesting...

37
Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1 , Frank van Steenbergen 2 , Kebede Manjur 1 , Marta Agujetas Perez 2 , Taye Alemayehu 2 ( 1 Mekelle University, Ethiopia; 2 MetaMeta, The Netherlands) A Paper Presented at the International Conference on “Geology, Mining, Mineral and Groundwater Resources of the Sub-Saharan Africa: Opportunities and Challenges Ahead”; July 11-13, 2017; Livingstone, Zambia

Upload: others

Post on 14-Oct-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia:

Techniques and Approaches

1

By: Kifle Woldearegay1, Frank van Steenbergen2, Kebede Manjur1, Marta

Agujetas Perez2, Taye Alemayehu2

(1Mekelle University, Ethiopia; 2MetaMeta, The Netherlands)

A Paper Presented at the International Conference on “Geology, Mining, Mineral

and Groundwater Resources of the Sub-Saharan Africa: Opportunities and

Challenges Ahead”; July 11-13, 2017; Livingstone, Zambia

Page 2: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

1. Introduction

2. Road and Water: Interactions and Effects

3. Approaches and Techniques of Road

Water Harvesting (RWH)

4. Effects of RWH: Hydrological Monitoring

5. Design considerations for RWH

6. Concluding remarks

Outline 2

Page 3: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

3

Road development

changes the hydrology

(surface and

groundwater) leading to:

Concentrated surface

runoff, or

Altering groundwater

movement.

Concentrated water flow

is a resource, if

harvested/managed.

How could roads be

used to harvest/manage

water?

1. Introduction

Page 4: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

4

Why water harvesting from roads?

Road building is one of the

largest public investments.

Unmanaged water from

roads often lead to negative

effects including to the road

itself.

Water scarcity is a major

issue in many parts of

Ethiopia, and SSA.

Managing water from roads

has economic, social and

environmental benefit; an

opportunities to be tapped.

Page 5: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

5

(a) Increase in erosion of

local streams and

road side drainages

2. Road and Water:

Interactions and

Effects

Nigeria

Ethiopia

Ethiopia

Page 6: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

6 (b) Sedimentation:

reservoirs, farm

lands, roads, etc

Page 7: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

7

(c) Water logging/flooding

(Highland)

(Lowland)

Page 8: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

8

(d) Opening springs

Spring: road cuts in

mountainous area.

Spring: in flat areas

at soil-rock interface.

Page 9: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

9

Panoramic View of Waja bridge, Waja area, Tigray, Ethiopia

Typical Example of a bridge under annual

maintenance due to siltation problem

Waja town

Flood

protection

Upstream Downstream

Page 10: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

10

Landslides

Earth fissures

(e) Water-induced

hazards

Page 11: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

11 3.1 Approaches

Agricultural Offices: overall

lead.

Woreda Offices: coordinating the

implementation.

Communities: Implementing the

interventions.

Road contractors and

consultants: support the overall

activity.

Research consortium: capacity

building, evidence generation,

and sharing.

3. Approaches and Techniques: Water

Harvesting from roads in Ethiopia

Page 12: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

12

Culvert

Deep trenches

(a) Construction of Deep

trenches at

downstream side of

roads to recharge the

groundwater and

improve moisture

conditions of soils.

3.2 Techniques Used

Page 13: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

(b) Road side ponds/

pits to recharge

groundwater and

enhance in-situ

moisture in soils.

13

2016 2015

2014

Page 14: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

(c) Road side

runoff or water

from culverts

stored in ponds

for surface water

storage and

groundwater

recharge.

14

Page 15: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

15

Pond

(d) Water from

culverts channeled

into farmlands

(used for

groundwater

recharge and

improving soil

moisture.

Culvert Diversion

Page 16: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

16 (e) Road side runoff

is channeled into

farmlands (used

to improve soil

moisture and

reduce runoff to

downstream

areas).

Page 17: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Deep trenches

Culverts

Borrow pit

(f) Runoff from a town

(Freweign) is

managed through a

number of options:

Construction of deep

trenches to reduce

runoff and enhance

groundwater

recharge.

Diverting water from

culverts into a

borrow pit for

surface water

storage and

groundwater

recharge.

Communities which used to have been

affected by flooding are saved from flooding.

17

Page 18: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

(g) Water from

culvert is

channeled into

check-dams (for

surface water

storage and

groundwater

recharge.

Check-dam

Hand-dug well

Road

18

Gabion check-dam

Bridge

Page 19: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

19

Percolation pond

Road side drainage

Bridge

Deep trenches

Hand-dug well

(h) Water from a bridge

is spread into series of

deep trenches and

percolation ponds to

recharge groundwater.

Hand-dug well

which used to be

dry became

productive after the

intervention.

(i) Road side drainage

connected to

percolation pond for

groundwater

recharge.

Page 20: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

20

(j) Hand-dug wells at

upstream of Irish Bridge in

Megab area, Tigray, Ethiopia.

Hand-dug well

Irish Bridge with hand-

dug well at upstream. Hand-dug well upstream of

the Irish Bridge

Irish Bridge

Page 21: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

21

21

(k) A pond developed

for harvesting water

from culverts and

Bridges in Northern

Ethiopia:

To enhance water

availability during

the 2015/2016

droughts.

Culvert

Pond

Bridge

Pond

Page 22: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

22

(l) Roads as dam

embankments; used

for:

Surface water

storage,

Sediment/Sand

storage.

Groundwater

recharge.

Road

Road

Water

Water

Page 23: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

4. Effects of Road Water Harvesting:

Hydrological Monitoring 23

Positive effects:

Enhancing recharge to shallow

groundwater,

Enhancing soil moisture (in-situ),

Cessation of gully expansion,

Reduction in flooding,

Enhancing productivity as supplementary

irrigation,

Sources of water in drought periods.

Page 24: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Note: Borrow pit was used as water storage in the month of

July 2014.

Water from a

culvert and

road side

drainage

channeled

into a pond:

Enhanced

the shallow

groundwat

er

4.1 Effects on groundwater level

24

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8Gro

und

wa

ter

level belo

w s

urf

ace

(m

) Month

Groundwater level flactuation in Freweign area, Tigray, Ethiopia

2013

2014

2015

2016

Page 25: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Check-dam

Hand-dug well

Culvert 4.2 Effects of check-

dams

25

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Gro

un

dw

ate

r le

vel

bel

ow

surf

ace

(m

)

Month

2013

2014

2015

2016

Page 26: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

4.3 Effects on soil

moisture

26

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

W1 W2 W3 W4 W1 W2 W3 W4 W1 W2 W3 W4

Sept Oct Nov

In-s

itu

mo

istu

re (

%)

Month

In-situ moisture distribution in soils (Megab area, Tigray,

Ethiopia)

2013

2014

2015

2016

Page 27: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

4.4 Supplementary

irrigation

27

Diverting water from

culverts and roadsides

are important sources

of water for

supplementary

irrigation.

Productivity has

increased by 50% in

2014/2015 harvest

season.

Page 28: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Ponds are important

sources of water in dry

periods: as witnessed in

2015/2016 drought

periods.

4.5 Sources of water

in dry periods

28

April 2016

Sept. 2015

Page 29: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

29

Three options could be

considered:

Use existing roads to

harvest/manage water.

Design modifications to

existing roads.

Adapt and implement

new design approach:

integrate road water

harvesting options:

Guideline/standard.

5. Design considerations for RWH

5.1 Scenarios and approaches

Page 30: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

30

Road

Road development: based on landscape continuum

water management model.

Different techniques along the landscape: upstream,

integrated with roads, and downstream of roads.

In all the three options, a landscape continuum

approach is preferred:

Page 31: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

31

5.1.1 Techniques at Upstream/Upslope

Techniques that:

Enhance infiltration,

Reduce erosion,

flooding and

siltation,

Enhance soil

moisture and

groundwater

recharge. Example: Surface runoff has reduced by 80%

as a result of the upstream intervention.

Page 32: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

32

5.1.2 Techniques integrated with the roads

Roads: as water

storages and diversions.

River crossings: water

buffering.

Pond

Water

Road as dam

embankment

Roadside

runoff

diverted

into a pond

River crossing

Water and sand

at upstream of

crossings

Page 33: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

33

5.1.3 Techniques at Downslope/ Downstream

Promote technologies

that:

Storage surface water,

Enhance groundwater

recharge,

Control flooding,

Reduce negative

effects: erosion,

siltation, etc

Enhance sustainable/

productive use of water.

Culvert

Culvert Check-dam

Hand-dug well

Page 34: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

34

6. Concluding remark a. There is a great potential to turn

the negative effects (of water

from roads) to positive through

introduction of appropriate

technologies.

b. Road development is part of

land use planning: need for

collaboration among various

sectors.

c. Towards multi-functional and

climate resilient roads: adapt

landscape continuum based

water management.

d. Develop guidelines and

standard procedures for road

water management.

Culvert

Water

channeled

into farm

lands

Pond

Road

Page 35: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Funding organizations for the research:

NERC (UK): Part of the UPGro Catalyst grant.

NWO/WOTRO (The Netherlands)

GRP (Global Resilience Program)

Research Consortium Partners: MetaMeta (The

Netherlands), Mekelle University (Ethiopia), IDS (UK), IDS

(University of Utrecht, The Netherlands), and HESPI (The

Horn Economic and Social Policy Institute).

Collaborating institutions in Ethiopia: Tigray region

(TBoWR, TBoTRC, TBoARD, REST), Amhara region

(ABoARD, ABoWR, BoRT), Oromia region (OBoWME,

OBoWR, OBoRT), SNNP (BoWR, BoARD), Ethiopian Roads

Authority, Afar Region (BoWR, BoARD), Gambella Region

(BoWR, BoARD, BoRT).

Acknowledgement

35

Page 36: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

Support for this conference:

UPGro and SKAT foundation: for the financial,

and technical support to attend this conference as

well as for the continued effort to promote results

of the UPGro Catalyst grant.

Conference Organizers: for the invitations and

excellent organization.

Acknowledgement 36

Page 37: Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and … · 2017. 8. 4. · Water Harvesting from Roads in Ethiopia: Techniques and Approaches 1 By: Kifle Woldearegay 1, Frank

37

Let us be champions in promoting road

water management for resilience