washington irving’s romantic vision of spain in the ...alhambra, granada and spain in general as...

34
FACULTAD de FILOSOFÍA Y LETRAS DEPARTAMENTO de FILOLOGÍA INGLESA Grado en Estudios Ingleses TRABAJO DE FIN DE GRADO Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The Student of Salamanca: Life Experience or Erudition? Farah Ahmed Baba Dih Vº Bº del tutor y fecha Tutor: Berta Cano Echevarría 2013-2014

Upload: others

Post on 17-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

FACULTAD de FILOSOFÍA Y LETRAS DEPARTAMENTO de FILOLOGÍA INGLESA

Grado en Estudios Ingleses

TRABAJO DE FIN DE GRADO

Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The Student of Salamanca: Life Experience or Erudition?

Farah Ahmed Baba Dih

Vº Bº del tutor y fecha

Tutor: Berta Cano Echevarría

2013-2014

Page 2: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction
Page 3: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

ABSTRACT

The present research project is going to deal with the specific image of Spain

(particularly Granada and the Alhambra) depicted by Washington Irving in his short

story The Student of Salamanca (1822) (generally translated into Spanish as El

Alquimista de Granada), and how his works –as well as his particular interest in the

Iberian Peninsula– largely contributed to a paradigm shift in the way Spain was seen

beyond its borders. In order to do so, in this essay I will try to answer the following two

questions: (1) did Washington Irving write The Student of Salamanca having evidential

facts that confirmed his assertions about Spanish history, culture and environments?

And, (2) did he portray a romantic and orientalist image of Spain in his short story due

to the fact that he was a romantic writer, or this was just a strategy to mislead the

reader?

KEYWORDS: image, Spain, Granada, Alhambra, Spanish Orientalism, romantic.

El presente trabajo de investigación versará sobre la imagen específica de España

(particularmente Granada y la Alhambra) retratada por Washington Irving en su historia

corta The Student of Salamanca (1822) (traducida generalmente como El Alquimista de

Granada), y como sus obras –así como su interés particular por la Península Ibérica–

contribuyeron en gran medida a un cambio de paradigma en la forma en la que se veía

España más allá de sus fronteras. Con este fin, en este ensayo trataré de responder a las

siguientes dos preguntas: (1) ¿Escribió Washington Irving El Alquimista de Granada

basándose en hechos probatorios que confirmaran sus aseveraciones acerca de la

historia, la cultura y el ambiente de España? Y (2) ¿retrató una imagen romántica y

orientalista de España en su historia corta debido al hecho de que era un escritor

romántico, o fue simplemente una estrategia para confundir al lector?

PALABRAS CLAVE: imagen, España, Granada, Alhambra, Orientalismo español,

romántico.

Page 4: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Washington Irving (picture by Stuart Newton, 1820)

Page 5: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Index

1. Introduction…………………………….............................................6

2. Spanish Orientalism…………………………………........................8

3. Washington Irving and Spain:

Biographical Aspects…….……………………………………….11

4.Overview and Analysis of The Student of Salamanca

4.1 Plot Overview…………..............................................................17

4.2 Analysis………………………………………………….……..18

5. Conclusion……………………………………….............................26

Annex: Illustrations.………………………..………………………....28

Bibliography.………………………….…………………….……….. 30

Page 6: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

1. Introduction

The present work will examine the particular depiction of Spain portrayed by

Washington Irving in his short story The Student of Salamanca. The specific vision of

the American author about Spain pictured in this tale is particularly interesting, since he

describes with great skill the customs and manners of Spanish society before even

having been at the Peninsula. Thence, it is especially fascinating the way in which an

outstanding author as Washington Irving could have been so interested in a country

whose image was rather seen as cruel and primitive in the period he wrote about it

(early 19th century). In fact, from the 16th and 17th centuries to the late 19th century (or

rather beginnings of the 20th century) Spain was seen as a ruthless and a savage country

as a consequence of the human rights abuses committed by the Spaniards during the

American Conquest. Later, this negative image –motivated above all by the Spanish

settlers– derived into a more general criticism against the Spanish Empire; these

judgments toward the Peninsula are what we now know as the Black Legend, defined by

Herrera-Sobek in Celebrating Latino Folklore: An Encyclopedia of Cultural Traditions

as follows:

“The Black Legend as a term was coined in 1914 by Julián Juderías as a way of explaining the

antipathy toward Spain that originated with colonial settlement in the sixteenth century. English

and Dutch writers and thinkers classified the Spanish as morally inferior through their use of the

Black Legend. By the early eighteenth century, the Black Legend was widely known and

disseminated. Popular lore held that the Spanish colonists were crueler to natives than were their

English and Dutch counterparts.” (Herrera-Sobek 117)

Accordingly, it is difficult to understand how Washington Irving could have

transformed this negative image of the country –particularly in the United States and

England– into another one that not only promoted the costumes and behavior of Spanish

society but, also, the vision of the Peninsula as an exotic and an unexplored country

who everyone should visit. Nonetheless, the American writer kept that negative image

of the Spanish Catholic Church in the Student of Salamanca (as it is going to be seen in

the analysis of the story), but his particular idealization of the Spanish landscapes and

people gave the peninsular country a chance to recover from the negative image

promoted by the Black Legend.

Page 7: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Nevertheless, even if he used some romantic techniques and devices to describe and

define his personal points of view about Spanish themes and issues, as we will see later,

we cannot state that Washington Irving was a defined romantic writer as later American

authors such as Edgar Allan Poe or Nathaniel Hawthorne; although he was one of their

main influencers. One of the main reasons of this is that many of his works are

dominated by sarcasm and irony, and these are features that distanced him from being a

Romantic writer.

Hence, in order to answer the two questions previously stated in the abstract and to

remark the aforesaid change of paradigm, the present work will be organized into the

following main sections: (1) clarification of the term “Spanish Orientalism” (in order to

understand the term, and consequently, Irving’s fascination about Spain); (2)

Washington Irving’s life, works and interest on the Peninsula; (3) overview and analysis

of the main elements of The Student of Salamanca; and (4) conclusion (where I will try

to give an answer to the above-mentioned questions).

Finally, it is important to make clear that in order to be more accurate and

academically correct in the information that is going to be given, the present essay is

going to be based on quotations, paraphrasing and extraction of excerpt from The

Student of Salamanca and other writings and works (as to analyze and comment the

relevant information that is going to be dealt with). On the other hand, it is also

important to clarify that as the present work is going to deal with Irving’s particular

vision of Spain in The Student of Salamanca, the narrator’s voice may be understood in

some cases to be expressing Irving’s own opinions.

Page 8: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

2. Spanish Orientalism “Spain and the Spanish past are topics of long standing in the Western canon”

(Steven 24). Indeed, Spain and its past are themes that have attracted and charmed

foreign writers along history as a result of an orientalist conception of the Peninsula.

The term Orientalism is defined by the literary critic and theorist Said (2006: 2) as “a

style of thought based upon an ontological and epistemological distinction made

between “the Orient” and (most of the time) “the Occident.”’ In other words, a style that

has its roots in the image of the “social descriptions, and political accounts concerning

the Orient, its people, customs, “mind,” destiny, and so on” (Said, 2006: 2,3) portrayed

by travel writers in Europe in the first three decades of the 19th Century. Specifically,

those travel writings, in which Spanish Orientalism can be detected, use to describe the

Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent

places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction of Spain is only from the economic point of

view since, in literature, it was portrayed as an exotic, an unexplored and a fascinating

country. Thus, stereotypes like gypsies, flamenco, bullfighting or the lax character of

the Spanish people were seductive and, therefore, recurrent themes in foreign writings.

In such a way, this attraction was induced by the rise of the Romantic movement that

started at the beginning of the period and, also, as a consequence of Thomas Rodd’s

translation of Genes Pérez de Hit’s writings: The Civil Wars of Granada (1801) and

Ballads from the Civil Wars of Granada and the Twelve Peers of France (1803), both

based on the original Historias de los Bandos de Cegríes y Abencerrajes and Guerras

Civiles de Granada (1595/1604). Moreover, to these literary innovations that created an

exotic image of the peninsula all over the world, it was added the historical knowledge

of Spain’s Moorish past through books such as: A Concise History of the Moors in

Spain (1811) by Thomas Bourke; The History of Empire of the Mussulmans in Spain

and Portugal (1815) by George Power; or The Arabian Antiques of Spain (1815) by

James Cavanah Murphy (Steven 24; Buchanan 269; Colmeiro 127; Kagan 9-11; Said 2,

3; Hilton 38).

As a result, Spain –particularly its southern part– became the focus of interest in

literature; it was represented as a place where past and present cultures were mingled.

Furthermore, the city of Granada, and concretely the Alhambra, was seen as the last

remaining piece of the glorious past of the Moors in Spain; its last essence. Hence, in

Page 9: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

the academic field, the expulsion of the Arabs from the peninsula was and is still

frowned upon; scholars criticize this fact and write nostalgically about it. For example,

the Spanish Philologist and Arabic language and culture’s specialist Julián Ribera–

answering Miguel Asín Palacios’ speech on Dante and Islam– states:

I repeat (and I will repeat until satiety, since justice requires it) that the Muslims of the Peninsula

were Spaniards: Spaniards in race, Spaniards in tongue, Spaniards in character, taste, tendencies

and genius… And we should consider the merits of the Spanish Muslims to be our own national,

Spanish wealth; by means of their civil virtues, they made southern Spain the best run country,

the most powerful, the richest and most cultured of the first half of the Middle Ages, and by

means of its natural gifts of genius they excelled to such an extent in the deeds of the spirit that

they created a peculiarly Spanish scientific, literary and artistic culture, absolutely unique and

without equal in any of the previous periods in the history of Spain. Julián Ribera (in Mallette

57)

Thus, the mysteriousness, exoticism, primitivism and backwardness in which Spain was

portrayed in literary and historical books, created a Romantic image of the country

outside its borders. Particularly, in the United States this new image about the Peninsula

started at the beginning of the 19th century coinciding with the birth of the American

Romantic Movement:

Literary historians have traditionally recognized the decades before the American Civil War (the

1820s through the 1860s) as “the Romantic period in American literature,” which occurred about

a generation after the Romantic Movement in European literature […] Romanticism differs

significantly from Classicism, the period Romanticism rejected. Hence, Romantic literature

rebelled against the formalism of eighteenth-century reason, being more concerned with emotion

than rationality. It generally values the individual over society, nature over the city. (Pakditawan

6)

In addition, Iván Jaksic in The Hispanic World and American Intellectual Life, 1820-

1880 claims that:

Romanticism served as the vehicle for building national traditions, even where few were to be

found. Americans by and large […] did not seek to anchor national traditions in the Native

American past. They went elsewhere, to a Pan-European spectrum of sources […]. They focused

on Spain. (Iván Jaksic 2012:4)

Page 10: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Indeed, American writers (specially) in the 19th century tried to borrow and adapt many

of the European themes, motifs and style of writing in order to establish their own

tradition. Spanish issues were very seductive to many of them, but the first one who

introduced this interest on the Peninsula was Washington Irving (1783-1859); one of the

greatest American authors and short story writer. He adapted and used many of the

European themes and literary techniques (many of them Spanish) in his works. What is

more, he introduced many romantic elements before any other American Romantic

writer in the period; therefore, we can consider him as one of the initiators of the

movement in the United States. Nonetheless, and as it has been anticipated in the

introduction of the present work, he was not a clear romantic writer since he tried to

break with the possible romantic images he described in his works by introducing

elements of humor, sarcasm or irony (Gieseler 3-5; Ladd et al. 23, 24; Kagan 49-51;

Iván Jaksic 4).

Page 11: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

3. Washington Irving and Spain:

Biographical Aspects

Washington Irving was born in 1783 in New York as one of the sons of a

wealthy English family. His parents were great admirers of General Washington;

therefore, they decided to name him like the former. Since his youth, he presented a

great attraction towards reading and writing, and even if he felt a particular tendency

towards literature, he decided to study law. However, he never let aside his interest in

literature and worked in several magazines, editorials and journals. Between 1804 and

1806, the American author traveled for the first time to Europe residing chiefly in Italy

and France and returning to the United States very influenced and seduced by the

European culture. Thus, he started writing between 1805 and 1815 portraying this

admiration towards Europe; among his works stand out A History of New-York from the

Beginning of the World to the End of the Dutch Dynasty, by Diedrich Knickerbocker

(1809), which is a humorous work published under the pseudonym of Diedrich

Knickerbocker –it achieved a great success in his country–. Hence, he became the first

American professional writer who was paid author’s royalties both in the United States

and later, in Europe. Moreover, he is considered by some scholars as one of ‘the

founders of the American literary tradition’ (Kidder and Oppenheim 27; Hilton 1-61;

Burt 198,199; Scotfield 10; Irving, 1998: 11-35).

As a consequence of his delight about Europe, in 1815 Irving decided to go back to the

old country with the intention to return to his native one in a few years. Nonetheless, he

remained in Europe until 1832, ‘he was forty-nine years old, and when he arrived […]

he had been absent from his native country for the past seventeen years’ (Irving, 1956:

14). Although, he became a very important figure in the United States during his

absence, his writings did not deal with American themes, landscape or manners, quite

the contrary, “he had become thoroughly Europeanized, and he had written mainly of

England, Germany, and most recently, of Spain and the Alhambra” (ibid). Therefore, he

tried to compensate this lack of knowledge about his own nation exploring the scenes

and sketches of the plains of the ‘far west’ of America in the book A Tour on the

Prairies, published in 1932. In the introduction of the former, he stated:

Page 12: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

As I saw the last blue line of my native land fade away, like a cloud in the horizon, it seemed as

if I had closed one volume of the world and its concerns, and had time for meditation, before I

opened another. That land, too, now vanishing from my view, which contained all that was most

dear to me in life; what vicissitudes might occur in it–what changes might take place in me,

before I visit it again! Who can tell, when he sets forth to wander, whither he may be driven by

the uncertain currents of existence; or when he may return; or whether it may ever be his lot to

revisit scenes of his childhood!

Such were the dubious thoughts that passed like a shade across my mind many years since, as I

lost sight of my native land, on my voyage to Europe. Yet, I had every reason for bright

anticipations. I was buoyant with health, had enough of the “world’s geer” for all my wants, was

on my way to visit the fairest scenes of Europe, with the prospect of returning home in a couple

of years, stored with recollections for the remainder of my life. (Irving, 1956: 3)

In these fragments we can observe his first feelings about leaving his beloved country

and how his intentions of returning turned into a “lost (of) sight of my native land, on

my voyage to Europe.” Certainly, Europe came to be his home. He had been idealizing

the country and learning about it since his youth. Furthermore, and as we have seen, in

the case of Spain thanks to his fascination about reading and writing from a very young

age, he became to be a great connoisseur of the Spanish literature and culture before

even visiting the peninsula; Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra and Ginés Pérez de Hita

were two of the most important influences on his forehand knowledge about the

European country. Besides, after being several times to Spain and knowing its reality,

he became the most important American and English Hispanophile1 and Hispanist2

(above all, because of ‘The Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus’ (1828) and

‘Chronicles of the Conquest of Granada’ (1829)); something that Rolena Adorno (in

1 “A Hispanophile may express a particular love or passion for Spain and its culture but does not

necessarily write about Spanish (or Hispanic) subjects. To be sure, many Hispanophiles […] are also

Hispanists, but the two words are not necessarily synonymous” (Kagan 2).

“Spain’s ‘Diccionario de la literatura española’ defines hispanismo, or Hispanism, as “the study of

language, literature, and history of Spain by foreigners.” More broadly, Hispanism is a twentieth-century

neologism that has yet to appear in many English-language dictionaries. Nineteenth-century scholars used

the term ‘Hispaneolized’ to refer to individuals immersed in Spanish culture […] but there were no

Hispanists per se. Nor are Hispanists to be confused with Hispanophiles, the modern term for someone

who is Hispaneolized” (Kagan 2).

Page 13: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Kagan 49) clearly states in the following quotation:

Any consideration of the origins of Anglo-North American Hispanism must take into account the

United States’ first man of letters, Washington Irving (1783-1859). Irving’s lifelong interest in

Spanish culture can be summed up by the literary production of his long stay in Spain: A History

of the Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus (1828), The Conquest of Granada (1829), and

the always-in-print Alhambra (1832), better known today as the Legends of Alhambra. Whether

working in the private library of the U.S. consul and bibliophile Obadiah Rich in Madrid, living

in apartments of the Alhambra in Granada, or recalling his Alhambra days while carrying out

diplomatic chores in London, Washington Irving represented a triangulation of interests and

influences that embraced Spain, England, and the United States. Born of English parents and

ever grateful, he said, to have been born on the banks of the Hudson River, Irving had a love

affair with Spain that extended from the time of his boyhood readings through the end of his life.

(Kagan 49)

During Irving’s second sojourn in Europe, he wrote a collection of short stories signed

under the pseudonym of Geoffrey Crayon. Thence, he published them in installments in

Philadelphia and New York during 1819 and 1820, and in 1820, as a book in London

under the name of The Sketch Book of Geoffrey Crayon, Gentleman. Such a

compilation, consists of thirty short stories among which there are two of Irving’s most

famous tales: Rip Van Winkle and The Legend of Sleepy Hollow. Both stories mingle

fantasy and terror with European customs and manners. Furthermore, they were the first

greatest contributions of Washington Irving to the development of the American short

story tradition3 (Scotfield 1-14; Hilton 36-38).

In 1822, he published an extension of this volume under the name of Bracebridge Hall;

a book composed of European tales containing the short story that occupies the present

work: The Student of Salamanca. As it has been said, Irving was greatly influenced by

Spanish writers like Pérez de Hita or Cervantes; and we can observe a clear

“The short story in America has for almost two centuries held a prominent, even pre-eminent place in the American literary tradition. […] It could be argued, indeed, that around the 1820s and 1830s the Americans virtually invented what has come to be called ‘the short story,’ in its modern literary sense (although one should of course note the parallel European tradition in, for instance, the development of the Russian short story from Gogol in the 1830s). Certainly the short story found its first theorist in one of its major early practitioners, Edgar Allan Poe; and the short story was for Poe his most successful and influential literary form. A number of other American writers in both the nineteenth and the twentieth centuries have, arguably, done their best work in that medium” (Scotfield 1).

Page 14: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

intertextuality in his works referring to the previous ones. Particularly, Hita’s

descriptions of the landscape and settings in Historia de Las Guerras Civiles de

Granada (1595/1604) were essential for Irving to write about Granada in The Student of

Salamanca; a place he had never seen when he wrote about it. Thereby, in order to

illustrate the impact that the former book caused in Irving, we could consider the

following quotation from Pérez de Hita:

Entre el Albaicin y el Alhambra pasa por lo hondo el rio Darro, hacienda una ribera de árboles

agradables. A esta fundación no la llamaron los moradores de ella Iliberia como la otra, sino

Granata, respecto á que en una cueva junto á Darro fué hallada una hermosa doncella que se

decia Granata, y por eso se llamó la ciudad así; y despues de corrompido el vocablo se llamó

Granada. Otros dicen que por la muchedumbre de las casas, y la espesura que habia en ellas que

estaban juntas como los granos de la Granada, y la nombraron así. Hízose esta ciudad famosa,

rica y populosa, hasta el infeliz tiempo en que el rey don Rodrigo perdió á España, lo cual no se

declara por no ser á propósito de nuestra historia: solo diremos como, despues de perdida España

hasta las Asturias y confines de Vizcaya, siendo toda ella ocupada de moros, traidos por aquellos

dos bravos caudillos y generales, el uno llamado el Tarif, y el otro Muza, asímismo quedó la

famosa Granada ocupada de moros, y llena de gente de Africa. (Pérez de Hita 2)

As it can be observed, Pérez de Hita explains with great detail why the Andalusian city

was named Granada and, how King Rodrigo could not defend Spain from the Moorish

invasion. In this manner, the American Hispanophile took ideas and descriptions like

the former in order to set The Student of Salamanca in the Peninsula and portray

Spanish customs and manners before visiting the country.

On the other hand, one of the main sources of the use of the technique of metafiction (a

very important strategy in this particular writing) by Irving in his works is found in

Cervantes’ Don Quixote (1605/1615). As Cervantes already did in his work, in The

Student of Salamanca, Irving employed the technique of metafiction to begin the story.

However, he went further than the Spanish writer and made it more complex; while

Cervantes makes the reader believe that the story derives from some documents of

someone called Cide Hamete Benengeli, Irving did not only play with the fact that the

story is said to be written by Charles Lightly (one of the character’s friend who wrote

the story and died in battle) but also with the fact that the whole book –The Sketch Book

of Geoffrey Crayon– is written by Geoffrey Crayon; presumably the author and

compiler (Barrio and Allué 319-325; Pere 52; Cassuto 34; Mancing 111,112).

Page 15: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

In 1826, Washington Irving received a letter from Alexander Hill Everett –the United

States Ambassador at Spain then– urging him to come to Madrid in order to investigate

about the country and the conquest of America. Consequently, he could enjoy an open

access to the main library of the American Embassy, which contained a large number of

books on Spanish themes and issues. As a result, in his first visit to Spain, he wrote ‘The

Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus’ (1828) and ‘Chronicles of the Conquest of

Granada’ (1829); both works awarded him with the tittle of “The Hispanist”. His

writings on Columbus are a mixture history –based on his studies on Spanish archives–

and the fictional elements that he introduced on purpose in order to add fluency and

eloquence to the narration. On the other hand, in 1829, the American author left Spain

after having been appointed the Embassy Prime Secretary of the United States in

London. Nevertheless, he did not forget about the country and continued writing and

publishing on peninsular issues. Thus, in 1831 he published Voyages and Discoveries of

the Companions of Columbus, and in 1832 he finished and published (both in England

and in the United States) one of his greatest works: The Alhambra Tales. This was a

selection of short stories set in the Muslim Andalusia that he started writing during his

stay in Granada in 1829. In this manner, it can be said that if Irving paid tribute to Spain

in many of his previous writings, in The Alhambra Tales his special homage to the

peninsula achieved its highest magnificence (Hilton 16-19; Wallhead and Burnham

274).

Thereby, and having reached this point, it is important to clarify why is Washington

Irving associated with a romantic vision of Spain in the present assignment. First, and as

it has been pointed out, from a very young age the American author had a clear interest

and tendency towards the peninsula, and in particular, towards its Arabic past because

of his education. Moreover, he had a special concern with the glorious Moorish past in

the southern region of Granada and its Alhambra. All of this passion about the history

of the Nasrid kingdom of Granada, together with his obsession with reading Spanish

works like the aforementioned, did nothing but to increase Irving’s idealization of

Spain. Nonetheless, the ‘romantic’ perspective of the author regarding Spain reached its

highest level with The Alhambra Tales; despite the disappointing feeling he suffered

after his first visit to the Iberian Peninsula. Thus, there is a clear contrast between

Irving’s Spain in The Student of Salamanca –where it is presented the way in which the

Page 16: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

author saw the nation (its landscape, people and architecture) before having been at the

country–, and the image he portrayed in The Alhambra Tales after having lived and

traveled through the country for three years (one of these trips was only through

Andalusia, in 1829). That being so, Irving felt somehow disappointed at his arrival to

Spain since he realized that many of the preconceived ideas he had (many of which

were acquired by reading Ginés Pérez de Hita’s works –written in the 16th and 17th

centuries–) did not coincide with the reality that he discovered. This impact, lead to a

change in his style of writing making the descriptions and reflections of The Alhambra

Tales the most mature and plausible narrations and thoughts about the reality of Spain.

Notwithstanding this, in this particular moment is when Irving reached the most

‘romantic’ vision of his literature, offering the rest of the world a different perspective

about the Peninsula; a country represented as an exotic and an enigmatic orient full of

mysteries, beauty and tradition. In such a way, many intellectuals consider the

American author as the driving force behind the positive change of the Spanish image

out of its borders from the 19th century onwards (above all in the United States and

England). Therefore, he was the main influential writer on other contemporary and

younger American authors who also promoted a positive image of Spain abroad;

Irving’s main followers were H. W. Longfellow, W. C. Bryant, Culeb and Caroline

Cushing, Severn T. Wallis, John E. Warren, Bayard Taylor and Charles W. March

(Jaksic 186; Vilar et al. 35; Killick 58-61; Hilton 38,60).

In 1832, the American author decided to return to his native country after having been

in Europe for seventeen years. Here, he started to participate more actively in the field

of politics and in 1842 (ten years later) he returned to Spain for a period of three years

as the American Ambassador in the Peninsula. However, as a consequence of the

instability of the country at the time, he went back permanently to the United States.

Since my return, in 1846, from my diplomatic mission to Spain, I have been leading a quiet life

in a little rural retreat I had previously established on the banks of the Hudson, which, in fact,

has been my home for twenty years past. I am in a beautiful part of the country, in an agreeable

neighborhood, am on the best of terms with my neighbors, and have a house full of nieces.

(Irving, 1864: 219)

Page 17: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

4. Overview and analysis of Washington Irving’s ‘The Student of

Salamanca’ contained in the book Bracebridge Hall (1822)

4.1 Plot Overview

As it has been said, The Student of Salamanca is a short story included in the book

Bracebridge Hall (published in 1822), which is a compilation of tales that deal with

European themes and concerns. Hence, the story line in this narration deals with a

young student of Salamanca, Antonio de Castros, who decides to go to Granada in order

to increase his knowledge and to investigate about the city’s Moorish past. In this

manner, during his sessions of research in the college’s library, Antonio became aware

of the presence of an old man who spent the days absorbed in reading odd and ancient

Arabic manuscripts. Attracted by this strange man, the young student decided to enquire

about him and to try to talk with him, as they both were interested in the same topics.

Nevertheless, the old man refused to strike up a friendly conversation with him and, as a

consequence of his curiosity Antonio determined to follow him.

There was something like adventure in the thing, which charmed his romantic disposition. He

followed the stranger […] They passed along the skirts of the mountain, and then by the shady

banks of the Darro. They pursued their way, for some distance from Grenada, along a lonely

road leading among the hills. The gloom of evening was gathering, and it was quite dark when

the stranger stopped at the portal of a solitary mansion. (Irving, 1822: 70)

While following the old man, he admired the exotic landscape and surroundings of

Granada until the stranger stopped at his home; a dark and ruinous mansion. When the

unknown man was going to enter the house, Antonio could see that he lived with an old

servant and a young and beautiful girl that he verified was his daughter. From that

moment on, he started frequenting the mansion almost daily, and soon, he attained his

purposes of finding out about the man and knowing more about the lady that obsessed

him from the very first time he saw her. Hence, he discovered that Felix de Vasques

(the old man) was an alchemist who was trying to find the philosopher’s stone, and his

daughter, Inez, was a descendant of a Moorish family; something that he found even

more interesting and attractive. Thereby, the student started collaborating with Felix in

Page 18: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

his research of the philosopher’s stone both, because he was very interested in the

investigation and, also, as a way of being near Inez.

With all his zeal, however, for the discovery of the golden art, the feelings of the student had not

cooled as to the object that first drew him to this ruinous mansion. […] he had frequent

opportunities of being near the daughter; and every day made him more sensible to her charms.

There was a pure simplicity, and an almost passive gentleness in her manners; yet with all this

was mingled something, whether mere maiden shyness, or a consciousness of high descent, or a

dash of Castilian pride, or perhaps all united, that prevented undue familiarity, and made her

difficult of approach. (Irving, 1822: 82)

Later, Antonio became aware of the fact that his beloved, Inez, was in grave danger

because Don Ambrosio (a rich man who was obsessed with her) was harassing her; and

as a result of her fair, she presented a distant and cold attitude towards him at the

beginning. Consequently, the alchemist’s learner proposed that they should move to

Valencia in order to be safe and continue their investigations about the philosopher’s

stone there. However, they could not move because Antonio, suddenly, disappeared.

Furthermore, the Spanish Inquisition accused Felix de Vasques of witchcraft and Don

Ambrosio kidnapped Inez. Nonetheless, after days of struggle, the old man’s daughter

could scape from Ambrosio’s mansion with the help of an old girlfriend of the former

and, Antonio arrived just in time to save Felix from the hands of the Inquisition and

marry Inez. At the end of the story, the narrator explains the strange disappearance of

Antonio, and how he could save the Spanish family from the inquisition:

It appeared that the lover [Antonio], who had sought her affections in the lowly guise of a

student, was only son and heir of a powerful grandee of Valencia. He had been placed at the

university of Salamanca; but a lively curiosity, and an eagerness for adventure, had induced him

to abandon the university, without his father’s consent […] Trusty emissaries had been

dispatched to seize upon him by main force, and convey him without delay to the paternal home.

[…] The father, […] a very reasonable man, as appears by his consenting that his son should

return to Grenada, and conduct Inez, as his affianced bride, to Valencia. (Irving, 1822: 119)

4.2 Analysis of Washington Irving’s The Student of Salamanca (1822)

Once made a brief summary of the argument and set the cornerstones of the story,

we are going to examine those aspects, which from a literary and a cultural perspective

are the most relevant for the present research project. It is important though –having

Page 19: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

reached this point– to clarify that Irving did not set the central story in a particular

period of the Spanish history. In addition, we can guess that due to his reading of

Spanish works (many of them corresponding to the 16th and 17th centuries), he had a

mixture of preconceived ideas about the Iberian Peninsula that he tried to describe in the

story (many of these conceptions do not correspond with the reality of the Peninsula in

the 19th century). Having made this clear, we are going to start analyzing the main

elements that make up the tale.

First, we are going to examine one of the main stratagems that Irving used in several

of his writings –and especially in this particular one–, which make of them some of his

most creative works: the technique of metafiction. As it has already been anticipated in

previous sections, in this short story the author –with great skill and technical

complexity– begins the tale using the literary technique of metafiction (a method that he

probably borrowed inspired by its use in Cervantes’ Don Quixote). In this manner, he

presents a situation in which a group of people are gathering at Julia’s home; a young

girl who has had a recent accident. Thus, in order to entertain her and the rest of the

people, a man –in the narration referred to as the Captain– begins reading a story, which

he assures that ‘is one of the scribblings […] of my poor friend, Charles Lightly, of the

dragoons. […] Poor fellow! He was shot down close by me at Waterloo4. […] And,

indeed, he died a few minutes afterwards.’ Hence, the Captain continued telling the

listeners how did the scroll that contained the tale came into his possession and adding

that the story he was ‘going to read is a tale which he [Charles Lightly] said he wrote in

Spain, during the time that he lay ill of a wound received at Salamanca.’ After this

metafictional introduction of the story, the narrator of The Student of Salamanca

clarifies that he had obtained a copy of the narration and therefore, he was able to make

us (the readers) know about it. In such a way, we are facing a narration (the beginning

of the story in which the narrator talks about Julia and the people around her) that is

within another narration (the subsequent story that the Captain talks about), which is

contained in another story (the one that the actual narrator is telling; he claims that he

4 As we know thanks to his education Irving was a great connoisseur of the European history and culture. Thus, in this part of the story he made a reference to the Napoleonic Wars; “a series of wars between 1792 and 1815 that ranged France against shifting alliances of other European powers and that produced a brief French hegemony over most of Europe. The revolutionary wars, which may for convenience be held to have been concluded by 1801, were originally undertaken to defend and then to spread the effects of the French Revolution.” (Definition taken from: “Napoleonic Wars (European History).” Encyclopedia Britannica. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 July 2014).

Page 20: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

had obtained a copy of the tale), and this last one is as well included in another one (the

real narration we are reading; the story as a whole). Furthermore, Irving’s use of the

technique of metafiction goes even further –the complexity of authorship in the story is

even greater– given that he signed Bracebridge Hall under the pseudonym of Geoffrey

Crayon.

Second, even if there might be scholars who classify The Student of Salamanca as a

simple story, actually, we are dealing with a romance tale with hints of verisimilitude

throughout the writing. In other words, this narrative has all the elements of a romance

novel with the only difference that it is not a novel, but a short story. Thus, we can

define it as ‘a work of prose fiction that tells the story of the courtship and betrothal of

one or more heroines’ (Regis, 2003: 19). Moreover, the short story we are dealing with

contains the same elements that define a romance novel; this argument can be supported

by the enumeration of the main elements that make up this last style written in A

Natural History of the Romance:

All romance novels contain eight narrative elements: a definition of society, always corrupt, that

the romance novel will reform; the meeting between the heroine and hero; and an account of

their attraction for each other; the barrier between them; the point of ritual death; the recognition

that feels the barrier; the declaration of heroine and hero that they love each other; and their

betrothal. (Regis 14)

Hence, The Student of Salamanca is a romance tale, in which Irving introduced many

romantic elements. In order to second this idea, we are going to use the previous ‘eight

narrative elements’ with the aim to analyze Irving’s particular romantic vision of Spain

portrayed in the story.

On the one hand, Irving’s short story has many romantic and idealized descriptions

of the Spanish landscape, buildings and people. Specifically, the narrator’s descriptions

of the Alhambra and the Vega of Granada are some of the main elements that represent

this idealization and passion for the Peninsula. During the narration, through a little

light setting, the storyteller describes the Vega and Granada’s surroundings as an

‘earthly paradise’. A place full of caves dug in the ground where it can be found

treasures and ancient Arabic manuscripts banned by the Pope. Furthermore, the Vega is

described as an ideal place for all those with a strong intellectual curiosity. Thus, we are

Page 21: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

provided with an idealization of the Spanish landscape and history that can be only seen

throughout the narrator’s own words:

He had directed his steps one evening to the sacred mount which overlooks the beautiful valley

watered by the Darro, the fertile plains of the Vega and all that rich diversity of vale and

mountain which surrounds Grenada with an earthly Paradise. It was twilight when he found

himself at the place where, at the present day, are situated the chapels known by the name of the

Sacred Furnaces. They are so called from grottos, in which some of the primitive saints are said

to have been burnt. At the time of Antonio’s visit the place was an object of much curiosity. In

an excavation of these grottos, several manuscripts had recently been discovered, engraved on

plates of lead. They were written in the Arabian Language, excepting one, which was in

unknown characters. The Pope had issued a bull forbidding any one, under pain of

excommunication, to speak of these manuscripts. The prohibition had only excited the greater

curiosity.” (Irving, 1822: 70)

Another item –that especially stands out from the descriptions of the Peninsula

(particularly, the representation of Spanish society)– is the reference to the Roma

ethnicity and their relationship with the superstitions and the dark arts. Interestingly, the

narrator uses the Castilian term 'gitanas' rather than the Anglo-Saxon word 'gypsy':

He found a group of Gitanas, a vagabond gypsy race, which at that time abounded in Spain, and

lived in hovels and caves of the hills about the neighborhood of Grenada. […] Antonio

endeavored to obtain some information of them concerning the old building and its inhabitants.

[…] “Some of the country people, who work in the vineyards among the hills, believe the old

man deals in the black art, and they are not over-fond of passing near the tower at night. But for

our parts, we Gitanas are not a people to trouble ourselves with fears of that kind.” (Irving, 1822:

71)

Moreover, Irving goes a step further on the idealization of the Spanish society when he

describes two of the main clichés of the Peninsula: the Castilian pride and the beauty of

the Spanish women; tanned and with black eyes. These descriptions are summarized in

the following two excerpts extracted from the text:

A female head looked out: it might have served as a model for one of Raphael’s saints […] a pair

of fine black eyes darted a look of surprise […] there was something in this sudden gleam of

beauty that wonderfully struck the imagination of the student. It was like a brilliant flashing from

its dark casket […] this appearance of being shut up and kept apart gave her the value of a

Page 22: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

treasured gem […] She was attentive in her devotion; her eyes were never taken from the altar or

the priest; and on returning home, her countenance was almost entirely concealed by her mantilla

[…] But then the Spanish females were so prone to love and intrigue; and music and moonlight

were so seductive, and Inez had such a tender soul languishing in every look. (Irving, 1822: 71,

72, 73, 83)

Felix de Vasques, the alchemist, was a native of Castile, and of an ancient and honorable line.

Early in life he had married a beautiful female, a descendant from one of the Moorish families.

The marriage displeased his father, who considered the pure Spanish blood contaminated by this

foreign mixture […] There were a pure simplicity, and an almost passive gentleness in her

[Inez] manners; yet with all this was mingled something, whether mere maiden shyness, or a

consciousness of high descent, or a dash of Castilian pride, or perhaps all united, that prevented

undue familiarity, and made her difficult of approach. (Irving, 1822: 78, 82)

On the other hand, Irving did not only project a positive, exotic and romantic image

of the Peninsula in the Student of Salamanca, as we have anticipated in the introduction,

he also portrayed two main negative elements that contrast this idealized vision of Spain

in the story: the past expulsion of the Moors (described as something sad and unwise);

and, the idea that Spanish society is corrupted by religion (Inquisition).

From one side, the period in which the Moors dominated Spain is depicted in the story

as a glorious epoch, in which the narrator saw the Peninsula (concretely Granada and

the Alhambra) as an “earthly paradise”:

The Generaliffe, the palace of pleasure, in the days of Moorish dominion, but now a gloomy

convent of capuchins […] The palace is full of the sad story of past times […] The whole garden

has a look of ruin and neglect […] The convent bell flings its sullen sound, or the drowsy vesper

hymn floats along these solitudes, which once resounded with the song, and the dance, and the

lover’s serenade. Well may the Moors lament over the loss of this earthly paradise; […] well

may their ambassadors smite their breasts when they behold these monuments of their race, and

sit down and weep among the fading glories of Grenada! (Irving, 1822: 94)

Thereby, he laments the Moorish expulsion from a cultural point of view (their

expulsion seen as a loss of culture and architectural beauty), and also from a historical

perspective; this can be observed in the following quotation:

Page 23: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Felix de Vasques, the alchemist, was a native of Castile, and of an ancient and honorable line.

Early in life he had married a beautiful female, a descendant from one of the Moorish families.

The marriage displeased his father, who considered the pure Spanish blood contaminated by this

foreign mixture. It is true, the lady traced her descent from one of the Abencerrages, the most

gallant of Moorish cavaliers, who had embraced the Christian faith on being exiled from the

walls of Grenada […] When the dance was ended, two of the parties approached Antonio and

Inez; one of them began a Moorish ballad, accompanied by the other on the lute. It alluded to the

story of the garden, the wrongs of the fair queen of Grenada, and the misfortunes of the

Abencerrages. It was one of those old ballads that abound in this part of Spain, and live, like

echoes, about the ruins of Moorish greatness. (Irving 1822: 78, 95)

From another side, as an addition to the negative view of the Moorish expulsion, Irving

criticized heavily the behavior of the Spanish Inquisition throughout the story.

Furthermore, he was so concerned with this subject that, as it can be observe in the tale,

he attached great importance to its criticism; it occupies much of the story lines. Hence,

Irving referred to the miseries and tortures that prisoners suffered on account of the

Inquisition and, made a detailed description of many of the inquisitorial processes.

Moreover, he described the image of San Benito and the procedure of Autos da Fé and

how they had become a social event to which everyone attended as if it were something

to celebrate; “for such is the horrible curiosity of human nature, that this cruel sacrifice

was attended with more eagerness than a theater, or even a bullfeat” (Irving, 1822:

114). In addition, he made clear his position to this unfair ‘justice’ in the story by

criticizing the Spanish Catholic Church saying:

One would have thought it some scene of elegant festivity, instead of an exhibition of human

agony and death. But what a difference spectacle and ceremony was this from those which

Grenada exhibited in the days of her Moorish splendor […] It is an awful thing –a voiceless,

noiseless multitude! The hushed and gazing stillness of the surroundings thousands, heaped on

walls, and gates, and roofs, and hanging, as it were, in clusters, heightened the effect of the

pageant that moved drearily on […] The faces of the prisoners were ghastly and disconsolate.

Even those who had been pardoned, and were the Sanbenito, or pernitential garnment, bore

traces of the horrors they had undergone. (Irving, 1822: 115)

Besides, the American author went beyond the criticism against the Inquisition by

showing his opposition to the way in which the Catholic Church torture and murdered

intellectual such as Raimond Lully or Pietro d’Albano –to whom he compared the

character of Felix de Vasques–; probably, Irving was trying to say that intellectuals

Page 24: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

represented a challenge to society and therefore, the Inquisition tried to put them all

aside. For this reason, he reserved a section in the story to indicate his indignation:

For what would be the effect of this length of days, and this abundant wealth, but to enable the

possessor to go on from art to art, from science to science, with energies unimpaired by sickness,

uninterrupted by death? For this have sages and philosophers shut themselves up in cells and

solitudes; buried themselves in caves and dens of the earth; turning from the joys of life, and the

pleasance of the world […] For this was Raymond Lully stoned to death in Mauritania. For this

did the immortal Pietro d’Albano suffer persecution at Padua, and when he escaped from his

oppressors by death, was despitefully burnt in effigy. (Irving, 1822: 104)

Thus, Irving’s descriptions about the Inquisition are –even if raw and harsh– somehow

burlesque and ironical, what probably made of The Student of Salamanca one of his

most critical and satirical works about Spain and Spanish society. Hence, as a final

remark about this section, it is important to highlight two brief quotations that represent

this ironical (although severe) depictions and comments about the Spanish Inquisition:

And as the increase of wisdom is the increase of virtue, how may he become the benefactor of

his fellow-men; dispensing with liberal, but cautious and discriminating hand, that inexhaustible

wealth which is at his disposal; banishing poverty, which is the cause of so much sorrow and

wickedness; encouraging the art; promoting discoveries, and enlarging all the means of virtuous

enjoyment! […] “Señor,” said he (the inquisitor), “this is all rambling, visionary talk. You are

charged with sorcery, and in defence you give us a rhapsody about alchemy” […] His trial

continued for a long time with cruel mockery of justice, for no witnesses were ever, in this court,

and the latter had continually to defend himself in the dark. (Irving, 1822:104)

She (Inez) was too ignorant of the nature of the inquisition to know that even innocence was not

always a protection from its cruelty; and she confided too surely in the virtue of her father to

believe that any accusation could prevail against him. (Irving, 1822: 110)

Finally, the Student of Salamanca deals with one final –but basic– element that is the

central part of all romance novels (in this case, the central part of a romance tale), and

in this particular story it gives rise to introduce many of the romantic descriptions and

ideas that compose the story: the love affair between the protagonists Antonio and Inez.

Page 25: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Hence, on the one hand, the story deals with all the aforesaid love elements about the

‘heroine and hero’ between Inez and Antonio defined in A Natural History of the

Romance Tale by Regis:

The meeting between the heroine and hero; and an account of their attraction for each other; the

barrier between them; the point of ritual death; the recognition that feels the barrier; the

declaration of heroine and hero that they love each other; and their betrothal. (Regis 14)

In such a way, in the tale there are two lovers who fall in love almost at the beginning of

the story and show their attraction to each other. Then, several incidents (the sudden

disappearance of Antonio, Inez kidnapping by Don Ambrossio and the imprison of

Felix de Vasques condemned by the Inquisition for sorcery) made a barrier between

them. Furthermore, all of these obstacles made their love seem almost impossible;

according to Regis (2003: 35) this moment is called ‘the point of ritual death,’ what she

defines as “the moment in the narrative when the union between heroine and hero, the

hoped-for resolution, seems absolutely impossible, when it seems that the barrier will

remain, more substantial than ever.” Nonetheless, the lovers finally get over all the

hindrances they had to face and, get engaged.

On the other hand, this love affair between the two protagonists framed the story and

made possible, as we have seen, Irving’s particular ‘romantic vision’ and description of

the Spanish landscape and society.

Page 26: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

5. Conclusion

At this point, we are going to give answer to the two questions that compose the

present research proposal: (1) did Washington Irving write The Student of Salamanca

having evidential facts that confirmed his assertions about Spanish history, culture and

environments? And, (2) did he portray a romantic image of Spain in the short story due

to the fact that he was a romantic writer, or this was just a strategy to mislead the short

story readers?

On the one hand, a careful reading of The Student of Salamanca is enough to see the

fascination and admiration that Washington Irving felt about Granada and Spain during

his life. Nevertheless, and as it is clearly stated along the present paper, this esteem

about the Peninsula was a mere erudition. Moreover, and as we have seen, Irving was a

great connoisseur of the Spanish culture, literature and history thanks to the reading of

Spanish works as Ginés Pérez de Hita’s Guerras Civiles de Granada (1595/1604),

which motivated him to write about Peninsular issues. Whence, he extracted the

elements he considered the ones that described Spanish society, costumes and manners

and, hence, he created a story full of preconceptions and topical ideas about the country.

It should be recalled the fact that the American author published Bracebridge Hall

between 1819 and 1822, six years before going to Spain for the first time. In this

manner, what we really have in The Student of Salamanca are fragments of

preconceptions and stereotypes –taken from other writings and authors– mixed with the

author’s own imagination.

On the other hand, we can somehow assert that the protagonist of the short story,

Antonio de Castros, is a mouthpiece of certain beliefs and assumptions held by Irving

himself in the way in which, he idealizes the vision of the Alhambra and recreates in his

own fantasies about its aspect in the years of its maximum splendor. Furthermore, the

romantic vision of Irving about the Alhambra and Granada is also projected by way of

the narrator’s descriptions and ideas; the following passage is particularly telling:

His mind soon became occupied by other objects. He passed several days wandering among the

mouldering piles of Moorish architecture, those melancholy monuments of an elegant and

voluptuous people. He paced the deserted halls of the Alhambra, the paradise of the Moorish

Page 27: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

kings. He visited the great court of the lions, famous for the perfidious massacre of the gallant

Abencerrages. He gazed with admiration at its Mosaic cupolas, gorgeously painted in gold and

azure; its basins of marble, its alabaster vase, supported by lions, and storied with inscriptions.

His imagination kindled as he wandered among these scenes. They were calculated to awaken all

the enthusiasm of a youthful mind. Most of the halls have anciently been beautified by fountains.

The fine taste of the Arabs delighted in the sparkling purity and reviving freshness of water, and

they erected, as it were, altars on every side, to that delicate element. Poetry mingles with

architecture in the Alhambra. It breathes along the very walls. Wherever Antonio turned his eye,

he beheld inscriptions in Arabic, wherein the perpetuity of Moorish power and splendor within

these walls was confidently predicted. Alas! How has the prophecy been falsified! Many of the

basins, where the fountains had once thrown up their sparkling showers, were dry and dusty.

Some of the palaces were turned into gloomy convents, and the barefoot monk paced through

those courts which had once glittered with the array and echoed to the music of Moorish

chivalry.” (Irving, 1822: 69)

Nevertheless, and as we have anticipated several times, even though we cannot assure

that Irving in his works in general was a pure romantic writer, since he introduced some

elements of humor and irony that distanced him from being a romantic author, in this

specific tale he had a remarked tendency towards romanticism. In any event, thanks to

Irving’s The Student of Salamanca (and his subsequent work The Alhambra Tales), the

American author made possible a change of paradigm contributing to the change of a

widely known negative image of the Peninsula, to an almost ‘earthly paradise’ image.

This new vision of Spain was also motivated by the cultural elite of the time who,

impelled by Irving’s works, propagated an exotic and mysterious image of the

Peninsula in their writings; they depicted a country full of tradition and magical stories.

Some of the most important American authors who helped actively to promulgate this

new vision of the Peninsula were: H.W. Longfellow, W.C. Bryant, W.G. Prescott and

G. Ticknor.

Finally, it is important to remark that Washington Irving’s particular vision of Spain

in the Student of Salamanca should not only be seen as one of the main contributions to

the change of the Spanish image abroad in the 19th century, but to be also taken

(nowadays) as the origin and main inspiration of Hispanist and Hispanophile’s writings

all over the world. In other words, such a relevant contribution to the American tradition

should be remembered and taken as the basis of all literary works that promote and

emphasize Spanish culture and history

Page 28: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Annex: Illustrations

Washington Irving by John Wesley Jarvis, 1809

“The gate of Justice, The Alhambra” (1881) by Gustave Doré

Page 29: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

“Ladies of Granada, Listening to Itinerant Dwarf Musicians” (1881) by Gustave Doré

“Crusade Against the Moors of Granada” (late 19th century) by Gustave Doré

Page 30: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Bibliography

Adams, Charles. Memoir of Washington Irving: With Selections from His Works, and

Criticisms. New York: Carlton & Lanahan, 1870. Print.

Barrio, José Manuel, and María José Crespo Allué. La huella de Cervantes y del

Quijote en la cultura anglosajona. Valladolid: Universidad de Valladolid,

Secretariado de Publicaciones e Intercambio Editorial, 2007. Print.

Bryant, William Cullen. Poetical Works: With Griswold’s Memoir. London: G.

Routledge & Company, 1861. Print.

Buchanan, M. A. “Alhambraism.” Hispanic Review 3.4 (1935): 269. Web. 22 June

2014.

Burstein, Andrew. The Original Knickerbocker: The Life of Washington Irving. New

York: Basic Books, 2008. Print.

Burt, Daniel S. The Biography Book: A Reader’s Guide to Nonfiction, Fictional, and

Film Biographies of More Than 500 of the Most Fascinating Individuals of All

Time. Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group, 2001. Print.

Cahoon, Herbert, Thomas V. Lange, and Charles Ryskamp. American Literary

Autographs, from Washington Irving to Henry James. New York: Courier Dover

Publications, 1977. Print.

Cassuto, Leonard. The Cambridge History of the American Novel. Cambridge:

Cambridge University Press, 2011. Print.

Colmeiro, J. F. “Exorcising Exoticism: Carmen and the Construction of Oriental

Spain.” Comparative Literature 54.2 (2002): 127–144. Web. 22 June 2014.

Page 31: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

Doré, Gustave. Doré’s Illustrations of the Crusades. Philadelphia: Courier Dover

Publications, 2013. Print.

Fernández-Corugedo, Patricia Shaw, and Santiago González. Studia Patriciae Shaw

Oblata. Oviedo: Universidad de Oviedo, 1991. Print.

Frantz, Sarah S. G., and Eric Murphy Selinger. New Approaches to Popular Romance

Fiction: Critical Essays. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland and company,

2012. Print.

Gale, Robert L. A Henry Wadsworth Longfellow Companion. Westport, CT:

Greenwood Publishing Group, 2003. Print.

Gieseler, Christina. Romantic Elements in Washington Irving’s Rip Van Winkle.

Norderstedt: GRIN Verlag, 2010. Print.

Gifra-Adroher, Pere. Between History and Romance: Travel Writing on Spain in the

Early Nineteenth-century United States. Cranbury, Mississauga and London:

Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 2000. Print.

Hartmann, Katja. Washington Irving: The Alhambra His Inspiration to Write the Tales.

n.p. GRIN Verlag, 2002. Print.

Herrera-Sobek, María. Celebrating Latino Folklore: An Encyclopedia of Cultural

Traditions. Santa Barbara, California: ABC-CLIO, 2012. Print.

Hilton, Sylvia L. Washington Irving: un romántico entre Europa y América :

introducción y bibliografía general. Madrid: CSIC - CSIC Press, 1986. Print.

Imhof, Rüdiger. Contemporary Metafiction: a Poetological Study of Metafiction in

English Since 1939. Heidelberg: Winter, 1986. Print.

Irving, Pierre Munroe. The Life and Letters of Washington Irving. New York: G.P.

Putnam, 1864. Print.

Irving, Washington. A Tour on the Prairies. Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press,

Page 32: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

1956. Print.

Irving, Washington. The Complete Tales of Washington Irving. New York: Da Capo

Press, 1998. Print.

Irving, Washington. The Washington Irving Anthology: The Complete Fiction and

Collected Non-Fiction. n.p. Bybliotech, 2014. Print.

Irving, Washington. Works of Washington Irving: Life and Letters. Philadelphia: J. B.

Lippincott & Company, 1870. Print.

Irving, Washington. Tales of the Alhambra. Paris: Baudry’s European Library, 1832.

Print.

Irving, Washington, and Pierre Munroe Irving. Irving’s Works: Alhambra. n.p. G.P.

Putnam’s Sons. Print.

Jaksic, Ivan. The Hispanic World and American Intellectual Life, 1820-1880. New

York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2012. Print.

Jones, Brian Jay. Washington Irving: The Definitive Biography of America’s First

Bestselling Author. n.p. Skyhorse Publishing, Inc., 2013. Print.

Kagan, Richard L. Spain in America: The Origins of Hispanism in the United States.

Illinois:University of Illinois Press, 2002. Print.

Kidder, David S., and Noah D. Oppenheim. The Intellectual Devotional: American

History: Revive Your Mind, Complete Your Education, and Converse

Confidently About Our Nation’s Past. New York: Rodale, 2007. Print.

Killick, Dr Tim. British Short Fiction in the Early Nineteenth Century: The Rise of the

Tale. Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2013. Print.

Ladd, Andrew et al. Romanticism and Transcendentalism: 1800-1860. New York:

Infobase Publishing, 2010. Print.

Page 33: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

MacDonald, Scott. The Garden in the Machine: A Field Guide to Independent Films

About Place. London and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2001.

Print.

Mallette, Karla. European Modernity and the Arab Mediterranean: Toward a New

Philology and a Counter-Orientalism. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: University of

Pennsylvania Press, 2011. Print.

Mancing, Howard. Don Quixote: A Reference Guide. Wesport, CT: Greenwood

Publishing Group, 2006. Print.

“Napoleonic Wars (European History).” Encyclopedia Britannica. N.p., n.d. Web. 11

July 2014.

Pakditawan, Sirinya. Aspects of American Romanticism in Short Stories by Edgar Allan

Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne. BoD – Books on Demand, 2007. Print.

Hita, Ginés Pérez de. Historia de las guerras civiles de Granada: historia de los

Vandos de los Zegris y abencerrages, cavalleros Moros de Granada. Paris:

Jacques Cotinet, 1660. Print.

Ragussis, Michael. Figures of Conversion: “The Jewish Question” & English National

Identity. Duke: Duke University Press, 1995. Print.

Regis, Pamela. A Natural History of the Romance Novel. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania:

University of Pennsylvania Press, 2003. Print.

Rennison, Nick, and Ed Wood. 100 Must-Read American Novels: Discover Your Next

Great Read... London: A&C Black, 2010. Print.

S. Stevens, Michael. Spanish Orientalism: Washington Irving and the Romance of the

Moors. Georgia: Georgia State University, 2007.

Said, Edward W. Orientalism. New Delhi: Penguin Books India, 2006. Print.

Schueller, Malini Johar. U.S. Orientalisms: Race, Nation, and Gender in Literature,

Page 34: Washington Irving’s Romantic Vision of Spain in The ...Alhambra, Granada and Spain in general as primitive, undeveloped and decadent places. Nonetheless, this negative depiction

1790-1890. Michigan: University of Michigan Press, 2001. Print.

Scofield, Martin. The Cambridge Introduction to the American Short Story. Cambridge:

Cambridge University Press, 2006. Print.

The American Whig Review. New York: G. H. Colton, 1852. Print.

Títulos completos, A-L. Centro Estudios Cervantinos, 2008. Print.

Vilar, Mar. La prensa en los orígenes de la enseñanza del español en los Estados

Unidos (1823-1833). Murcia: Universidad de Murcia, 1996. Print.

Wallhead, Celia M., and Walter Dean Burnham. Voting in American Elections: The

Shaping of the American Political Universe Since 1788. Palo Alto, CA:

Academica Press, LLC, 2010. Print.