washeq 2011 ppt morning session 2011

140
PLATINUM SPONSORS SILVER SPONSORS BRONZE SPONSORS MEDIA PARTNERS

Upload: korkor-agbettor

Post on 06-May-2015

632 views

Category:

Business


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Inaugural WASHEQ 2011 presentations

TRANSCRIPT

Page 2: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

WASHEQ – Ghana - 23rd September, 2011.

By Joe – Steve Annan M.Sc. Quality, Safety & Environment; University of Magdeburg – Germany B.Sc. Chemical Engineering; KNUST – Ghana. P.G.Cert . Industrial Hygiene; University of UTAH – USA IGC. NEBOSH Occupational Health & Safety; British Safety Council. International Member- American Industrial Hygienist Association. Specialist-International Institute of Risk & Safety Management.

A Critical Look At Legal Requirement For Occupational Safety & Health In Ghana

Contact: P. O. Box 388, Sekondi, Ghana. Call: 00233244182337, Mail: [email protected]

Page 3: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Areas of Occupational Safety and Health Application In Ghana

•Construction •Mining •Refinery •Insurance and Finance •Agriculture •Shops and Warehouses

•Manufacturing •Processing •Oil & Gas •Laboratory •Transportation •Artisans (Carpentry, etc.) •Energy (VRA, etc.)

Has the nation got laws to ensure the OH&S implementation in all the areas?

Page 4: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Potential Accident Scenario A ship offloads lime at a Port in

a manner that makes it airborne, and hence, everyone nearby get exposed. Operator of a reversing truck visually impaired by the airborne lime runs into a nearby fixed tank containing hydrocarbon and spills it. A nearby running generator ignites the spilled hydrocarbon and the fire engulfs three nearby men to death. 10 workers were later diagnosed of silicosis as a result of over exposure to the lime.

Page 5: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 6: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Iso tanks

Fluidized transfer

Layout

Location

Design

Consequence 1 Port

Fire / Property Damage

Consequence 1 Injury / Fatality / Illness

Consequence 1 Emissions / Spillage /

Contamination

Recovery Measure

Inappropriate Discharging

Lime

Truck Operator Failure

Running Generator At Unbunded

Area.

Emergency Response

Emergency Response

Emergency Response

Monitoring

Competence PPE’s and Medicals

Truck-Tank crash to

fire

BARRIERS:

Prevent MAE from occurring

RECOVERY MEASURES:

Prevent or reduce the consequence of MAE

INHERENT DESIGN FEATURES + SAFETY CRITICAL ELEMENTS

(Layout, Structural Integrity) (Procedures, Tasks, Emergency Response)

Port Operations

Simplified BOWTIE – Potential Port Lime Discharge Related Accident

Page 7: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 8: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 9: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Fire destroys Tema Oil Refinery - Ghana

Page 10: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Fire At Foreign Ministry - Ghana

Page 11: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

1. Using concrete breaker without ear plugs and proper workplace isolation (Cape Coast - Ghana). 2. Fabricating a bill board at height without fall protection / arrest system (Tema - Ghana).

Page 12: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Are We Legally Required To Prevent These Acts & Conditions In Ghana?

• How?

• What can we do?

• Which legal instruments support us?

• Who is responsible for what?

Do we actually have the legal framework for Occupational Safety and Health in Ghana?

• What are they?

• Where are they?

• How are they implemented?

Page 13: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Institutional Legal Backing In Implementing Components of OH&S In Ghana.

• Inspectorate Division of Minerals Commission – Monitor and control OH&S activities in the mining industry.

– Backed by LI 665.

• Environmental Protection Agency – Monitoring of implementation of EMS.

– Backed by EPA Act 1994 (Act 490)

• Ghana Labour Commission – Industrial relations and employee wellbeing at workplace.

– Labour Act 2003, Act 651

– Workman’s Compensation Law 1987

Page 14: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Institutional Legal Backing In Implementing Components of OH&S In Ghana.(Continued).

• Radiation Protection Board of GAEC – Control of importation, use and disposal of radiation sources.

– Backed by LI 1559, 1993 and Act 204 of 1963.

• Department of Factory Inspectorate – Control of OS&H in shops, offices, and factories.

– Backed by Act 328, 1970.

• Ghana Standards Board – Setting of standards, promotion of QMS, inspection of high risk goods

– Backed by Standards Decree, 1973.

Page 15: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Institutional Legal Backing In Implementing Components of OH&S In Ghana.(Continued).

• Ghana Food and Drugs Board. – Food and drug production, storage, use and importation safety.

– Supported by Food and Drugs Act 523, 1996.

• National Road Safety Commission. – Road and pedestrian safety.

– NRSC Act 1999, Act 567.

• Ghana National Fire Service. – Prevention and management of undesired fires.

– GNFS Act of 1997, Act 537.

• The Employee. – Labour Act 2003, Act 651

– Workman’s Compensation Law 1987

Page 16: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Gaps In The Nations Control of The Implementation of OH&S Under Respective

Jurisdictions. • OH&S legal requirements are fragmented under

different jurisdictions. • Lack of national policy in OH&S. • No ratification of the ILO Convention 155. • No national “body” responsible for developing

and implementing OH&S standards and guidelines across all industries.

• Unknown national targets and objectives to guide across all Ghanaian Industry.

• Lack of accredited academic programs in OH&S

Page 17: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Recommended OH&S Model In Ghana

National Occupational Safety & Health Policy – Scope, Aim, Expected KPI’s

Organization – Commitment, Communication, Cooperation, Competence, Control, Roles

& Responsibilities.

Planning & Implementation – Standards, Guidelines, Management Systems and Procedures.

Monitoring and Evaluation – Inspections, Internal & External Audits, Quality Assurance & Control.

Action for Improvement – Corrective Actions, Preventive Actions, Sanctioning

Auditing must be conducted for each section above.

Page 18: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Thank you.

By

Joe – Steve Annan M.Sc. Quality, Safety & Environment; University of Magdeburg – Germany

B.Sc. Chemical Engineering; KNUST – Ghana.

P.G.Cert . Industrial Hygiene; University of UTAH – USA

IGC. NEBOSH Occupational Health & Safety; British Safety Council.

International Member- American Industrial Hygienist Association.

Specialist-International Institute of Risk & Safety Management.

Any question please?

Contact. E-mail: [email protected] Phone: 0244182337

Page 20: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Leadership and HSE Management in Kosmos

WASHEQ Conference

23 September 2011

Page 21: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

21 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Consider this Accident……

Page 22: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

22 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Why do Injuries Happen?

Injury Triangle

Energy

Person

Object

HSE MS •Policies/Procedures •Risk Assessments •Audits/Inspections •Training/Competency

LEADERSHIP

Page 23: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

23 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Leadership in HSE Involves motivating others within your own sphere of influence to eliminate at-risk behaviors or conditions which allow the Injury Triangle to exist 1. Be aware and seize the moments of

high influence with workers

2. Management by walking around and visibly demonstrate HSE leadership

3. Be ready to deal with unsafe behaviors immediately when they are observed

4. When a problem persist, be prepared to have a discussion of accountability with the involved person(s)

Page 24: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

24 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Moments of High Influence At the beginning of work shifts New employees added to a team or work group Beginning of an unfamiliar task

Immediately after an incident

Role model safe behaviors

Immediate feedback for both positive and at-risk behaviors

Award or recognition for good behaviors in front of peers

Page 25: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

25 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Management by Walking Around

• Pick out people and places where you want to be seen – and see what’s going on (i.e. critical work activities, problem areas, areas of complacency, etc.).

• Announce your visit so it is not a surprise.

• Show up knowing something about what you want to accomplish – brush up on applicable procedures if necessary.

• Time your visit for effect (i.e. not at lunch, break, or quitting time)

• Analyze what you are seeing by perceiving both what is going on and be able to understand the reason why.

Page 26: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

26 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Dealing with Unsafe Behavior

“SORRY” Method

Step 1: State your reason for making the observation.

Step 2: Describe the behavior you Observed.

Step 3: State the Requirement.

Step 4: Ask for the Reasons why the rule isn’t being followed.

Step 5: Tell them “What can happen to You if you don’t follow the rules.”

Page 27: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

27 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

Discussion of Accountability

FIVE “S’s” METHOD Start with the situation that led you to look into the causes

of the problem. Explain the significance of the situation and why it is worth

the discussion. Tell the individual the specifics of what you’ve found as

you’ve looked into the problem. Ask the individual for his/her side of the story – how does

he/she see the situation? Determine the steps that need to be taken to prevent the

problem from happening again.

Page 28: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

28 WASHEQ Conference 23 Sept 2011 23 October 2013

What HSE Culture Do You Want?

Definition of Culture:

“The totality of socially transmitted behavior patterns, beliefs, institutions, and all other products of human work and thought characteristic of a community or population.”

“THE WAY THINGS ARE”

(Good or Bad)

Your example as a LEADER

will establish the HSE CULTURE

Page 30: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Leadership role in managing hazards and risks in the mining industry – the case of AngloGold Ashanti, Ghana.

Alfred Chinbuah

Divisional Safety Manager 23 September 2011

Page 31: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Introduction

Mining has been carried out over centuries ago providing wealth, prosperity and employment to generality of Ghanaians.

Even with improved state-of the-art technology and Innovations and comprehensive procedures, mining still presents a substantial risk to employees. We must understand that these risks are similar to driving on the road or playing sports, so we need to manage all the possible hazards involved likely to result in significant risks to our employees and the operations.

Safety is Our First Value

Page 32: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Type of Hazards

32 Or, a combination of these hazards

HAZARDS

Electrical Hazards caused by the use of electrical

energy

Hazards causing a deterioration in

individual health or mental well-being

Hazards generated by materials and

substances

Hazards generated by the environment

Hazards caused by the mechanical movement

of machinery

Hazards directly generating potential for physical injury

Mechanical Chemical

Physical

Psychosocial

Environmental

Page 33: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Risk Management

33

Baseline risk assessment – base risks sorted using AGA matrix and residual risks prioritized and determined controls established and monitored to completion. Periodic audits conducted to ascertain the effectiveness of these controls by corporate office.

Issues based risk assessment – issues emanating from risks are dealt with before task commences from the following; a new equipment or machine introduced into the mine a system of work is changed or operations alter after an incident has occurred as new knowledge comes to light and information is received which may influence the level of risks to employees e.g. changes in the toxicity levels of a known substance

Continuous risk assessment – risk based planned inspections of plant and equipment, simplified risk assessment, job safety analysis (to be instituted)

Business risk assessment completed by insurance company which is compiled into a risk register and managed by the risk champions

Page 34: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Advanced Incident Investigation Process

.

Page 35: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards - Fall of ground - Gravity

35

Page 36: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards - Fall of ground - Induced by removal of “Key Block”

Page 37: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards - Fall of ground - Induced by removal of “Key Block”

MINE DESIGN

The emphasis is on avoiding seismic and ground control problems through state-of-the-art mine design based on the best available information and knowledge.

This would involve mining method, layout and sequencing.

Page 38: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards - Fall of ground – Control measures

SUPPORT DESIGN

1. Support a. Primary support

Split set Grouted gewi bar Weld mesh

b. Secondary support Cable bolting Shotcrete Welded/link mesh

2. Scaling 3. Ground examination 4. Skills Training 5. Planned task observation 6. Jumbo spray which is operated from a safe distance in the cab of an equipment (yet to be installed)

Page 39: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards - Fall of ground – Control measures

MANAGERIAL

This involves training, communication, planning and implementation.

MONITORING

This involves monitoring the rock mass response to mining, monitoring of support performance and monitoring of adherence to standards, as well as the implementation of strategies and recommendations.

Page 40: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards – Conveyor belts

CONTROL MESAURES Planned maintenance schedules Policies and standards for working around conveyors Implementation of safe system of work including JSA

Page 41: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards – Slope Failure

CONTROL METHODS Slope wall monitoring using prism and radar equipment to detect movement Training in standards and procedures Training and simulation drills in emergency plans

Page 42: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards – Mobile equipment

CONTROL MEASURES Competency Operator training and licensing. Equipment maintenance Job observation Separation of equipment, LV and personnel Operating procedures Training and simulation drills in emergency response plans

Page 43: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards – Confined Space

Control Methods Competency training in permit Risk assessment prior to starting work

Testing of atmospheric gases Permit - issuance and cancellation process Training for supervisors, members of the rescue teams, attendants and people likely to work in confined space Maintenance of equipment such as BA sets, life-lines

Emergency arrangements

Page 44: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards – Fire and Explosion

CONTROL MEASURES. Fire risk assessment to identify all fire sources. Provision and maintenance of passive and active fire protection equipment. Regular training of employees in the use of these equipment Fire teams establishment and training Regular inspection of the workplace Regular removal and safe disposal of refuse

Page 45: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards

45

CHEMICAL

Gases Liquids Fumes Vapour Aerosol Smoke Mist

CONTROL METHODS

Chemical survey to identify all chemicals used on site with respect to storage, use handling, transportation, MSDS, health effects. Training Emergency response plans and training Measurement and monitoring of exposures for both employee and workplace Medical surveillance

Page 46: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Types of Hazards – Manual Handling

46

CONTROLS Risk assessment to be completed before undertaken the task which focuses on the task, load, individual capability and the working environment Training in manual handling techniques Purchase of mechanical handling aids Training in the use of these equipment

Page 47: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Occupational hygiene

47

Exposure to dust, harmful fumes, vapours etc lighting and Heat stress

Hygiene lab established for the two mines with competent personnel Gravimetric dust sampling conducted periodically. Analysis done for inhalable and respirable dust as well as for welding fumes. Spot samples are also completed Employees are educated on the harmful effects of dust Regular monitoring of atmospheric contaminants Periodic review of MSDS Periodic survey of chemicals and substances using COSHHH guidelines Medical surveillance Dust suppression in the plant Use of water bowsers to suppress dust on the mine and access roads

Measurement of lightning conditions and dealing with issues Measurement to determine the WBGT of the working areas

Page 48: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Occupational hygiene

48

Exposure to excessive noise

Vibration monitoring

Noise surveys completed for plant and equipment leading to noise zone demarcation of the working areas Hearing conservation programme instituted Personal monitoring and measurement Spot measurements Signage Underground mobile equipment fitted with silencers working at critical areas Evaluation and measurement of effectiveness of ventilation system Medical surveillance

Whole-body vibration and Hand-arm vibration measurements being done

Page 49: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Governance

49

Leadership comes from actions not words, and one of the greatest risks to leadership integrity arises from "Do as I say, not as I do". –

Judith Hackitt CBE, HSE Chair

The safety, Health and Environment board meets every quarter to review the performance of the company and in particular how these risks are being managed There are risk management standards which have developed by corporate and these tend to give the process Senior management on the mines are also deeply involved in the implementation of the safety management system particularly in the area of reviewing hazards and risks through Visible FELT Leadership

F – Frequent interactions of the executive safety role of line management E – Engage workforce through involvement of all and openness of communication L – Live the behaviours by obeying safety rules that have been set T – Tell the people you care by demonstration of care and concern for all those affected by the business

Page 50: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Governance

50

Leadership comes from actions not words, and one of the greatest risks to leadership integrity arises from "Do as I say, not as I do". –

Judith Hackitt CBE, HSE Chair

CHANGE MANAGEMENT

Where changes in working arrangements have significant implications for health and safety, these are managed through change management process Identifying the changes

Identifying areas of the operations likely to be affected by the change

Completing risk assessment

Executing the change

Communicating the change

Reviewing the change to see if the desired results have been achieved.

Page 51: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 53: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

HOW LEADERSHIP INFLUENCES SAFETY CULTURE IN DIAGEO

By

Jerry Ekow Nyan (Grad IOSH) (PG Dip EH&SM, PG Cert. OH&SM, Dip MEE, OHSMS/OHSAS 18001 Lead Auditor)

West Africa Regional Health & Safety Manager, Diageo Plc

Page 54: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is Safety Leadership There are many different definitions of what leadership is.

These include motivating and inspiring others, leading by example, the ability to adapt and be flexible, being a role model, having a vision and the ability to implement it, and providing guidance, a sense of integrity and building trust. A common idea is that a leader is someone who is effective in influencing others to achieve objectives and goals in such a way that people want to accomplish them. A safety leader is someone who believes in and values the importance of safety and uses their leadership qualities to influence others to do the same.

Page 55: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is Safety Leadership cont…

Whilst the senior management of a company provides leadership with executives who develop the procedures and systems to promote safety, everyone in an organization is responsible for safety and can be safety leaders too. What employees think about safety, the attitudes they have towards procedures and rules, whether they believe that they are important or not, all influence the safety culture of a workplace. Leaders create cultures by what they systematically pay attention to (“Safety, Culture and Risk”, Andrew Hopkins, 2005 citing “Organizational Culture & Leadership”, E Schein, 1992)

Page 56: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What does World-Class Safety leadership Look Like?

• Would you know good safety leadership if you saw it? • How do your Leaders communicate “safety” to their employees? • How do they look for hazards in the workplace? How do they

prevent unsafe acts? • How do they motivate employees to “want” to be safe? • Can they coach employees to maintain essential fitness to perform

their job assignment? • Are they part of the daily safety activity at your facility, or do they

leave safety to the safety department?

Page 57: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Diageo’s vision is “Zero Harm”

Meaning- • Everyone goes home safe, everyday, everywhere. • Diageo’s vision is Zero Injuries, Zero Fatalities, Zero Harm. • Valuing Each Other starts with every Diageo employee being passionate

about keeping each other safe – no one ever walks by • We are all obsessively committed to preventing every single injury • When an injury occurs we are ruthlessly focused on ensuring the person

is supported in treatment and return to work, we understand the root cause and know it is our responsibility to share learnings across Diageo

• We always recognise the benefits of safe behaviours and celebrate our safety successes

“Our aim is to create a proactive safety culture in which all Diageo employees believe that all injuries and illness are foreseeable and preventable and act in a manner that demonstrates their personal

commitment to this aim.”

Page 58: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

How is Safety Leadership demonstrated in Diageo?

Page 59: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

1. Frequently stating Safety is our No. 1 Priority

We show commitment to OH&S by frequently stating and articulating that “Safety is our No. 1 Priority”.

How to demonstrate this? This is done by stating and explaining the principle in every day conversation and by making decisions that show we do what we say without exception. Some leaders find it useful to adopt a catch phrase or slogan to articulate the point, e.g. ‘Safety above all else’, ‘Nothing is so important that it cannot be done safely, ‘An accident is one too many’.

Why stating as your No.1? his area? There are a number of competing priorities in every business decision e.g. cost, quality & yield. When we state that safety is our number one priority we are creating the possibility for safety to be the most important priority for any given business decision. Your life is your most important asset.

Page 60: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

2. As Safety Ambassadors

We act as visible ambassadors for safety by behaving in a safe manner at all times and always visibly challenging the behaviour of others if it threatens safety.

Why taking the lead? This is leading by example. Leaders should take action that will prove that the organization is actually being serious about safety. By failing to challenge unsafe behaviour we tacitly reinforce the notion that it is acceptable. To be credible, we must be authentic – our decisions and actions must match our words.

How to demonstrate this? Ask about the safety rules in advance of visiting a particular area especially what PPE is required. Show it is important for you by acquiring it in advance. You should also attend site H&S inductions when on site for the first time. Leaders should seek ways to challenge the unsafe behaviour of others in a timely manner to demonstrate that unsafe behaviours are unacceptable. Start by asking the leading question ‘‘What could we do to make this machine or process safer?”

Page 61: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

3. Great Safety Performance through incident prevention

Commitment to great safety performance by being the first to be contacted when a safety incident has occurred and by reviewing the outcome of incident investigations What does this expect of you?

Respond to incidents in a positive, learning way. Lead teams to properly investigate accidents, identify root causes, and implement corrective actions that address both immediate and obvious hazards (e.g. unguarded machinery) as well underlying hazards (e.g. failure to train employees in machinery safety). As a minimum senior site Managers/leaders are immediately informed when a Global LTA occurs in their area.

Why? Leaders can demonstrate their commitment to improving safety and reducing accidents by being the first to be informed when an incident occurs. Sending a strong message that knowing about anything that goes wrong is key to creating the conditions necessary to successfully eliminate the next injury. This sends a clear message that we view safety performance as being as important as other business KPIs. It also reinforces that safety performance is being monitored.

Page 62: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Why include Safety? By including safety in employees’ Objectives and targets, leaders ensure that the commitments enshrined in the OHS policy are brought to life and their teams constantly deliver great performance.

What is expected of you? Use this document to identify key areas for safety leadership development for your direct reports. In addition to specific accident rate reduction targets consider also specifying any of the following items in the objectives and targets document: attendance at safety training, completion of risk assessments, conducting safety audits or developing safety procedures.

4. Include Safety in Employees Objectives & Targets

Supportive by ensuring that safety is included on all my direct reports objectives and targets.

Page 63: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is expected of you? Holding or chairing of regular safety committee meetings is one way of promoting participation. When leaders attend or chair safety meetings this ensures that good attendance at these meetings is maintained and actions are progressed on schedule. Focus on creating a team environment where everyone feels comfortable about raising safety concerns.

Why regular Safety meetings? Development of an effective safety culture requires a participative approach. Constantly growing your awareness and knowledge of key safety issues related to your area will motivates our employees to participate.

5. Regular Health & Safety Meetings

Demonstrate commitment by holding regular health & safety only meetings

Page 64: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is expected of you? Ensure meeting agenda are revised to include safety as the first item. Use the time to share examples of proactive activities that have taken place to improve OHS performance. Update each other of activities that are underway to address gaps e.g. accident findings, audit reports or regulatory compliance. Ask open questions to stimulate debate and get the discussion going.

Why start with safety? By placing safety as the first agenda item in meetings creates the possibility for others to think, decide and act appropriately. Safety can often be left to the end of meetings where it may not receive the attention it deserves. This leads to the perception that safety is an after thought as opposed to being an essential component of our way of working. This is a very tangible way to demonstrate that you make and support safety over production decisions.

6. Start all meetings with Safety

We are committed by starting all meetings with safety. Safety is first on the agenda for every business meeting.

Page 65: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is expected of you? Contact your local Health & Safety Manager and arrange regular walkabouts in your diary to cover all areas. When conducting the walkabout leaders should engage direct reports or other staff in conversations in which they feel confident enough to raise concerns regarding safety in their work area. They should elicit their complaints, their differences of opinion, their doubts and ideas about how zero harm can be achieved.

Why Safety walkabout? Safety management system performance are reviewed by conducting regular safety walkabouts as part of an overall site audit programme. By being involved in this programme leaders demonstrate authentic commitment and become personally aware of the prevailing safety conditions in their area. Auditing presents an excellent opportunity for leaders to meet their employees in their work areas and to have proactive discussions about safety.

7. Safety walkabouts

We increase visibility around health and safety by personally conducting safety walkabouts

Page 66: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Why? By promoting the prioritisation of H&S related projects leaders will demonstrate their support for improving safety and will ensure that these projects receive adequate resources for completion. Completion of these projects increases trust amongst the workforce and reinforces the message that we value the opportunity to make improvements arising from hazard and near miss reporting. Safety culture can be eroded when employees perceive that safety improvement projects are impeded by financial constraints or red tape

What is expected of you? By speaking with your management teams you can become aware of safety related improvement projects that are planned for your area. Challenge the progress of these improvements to ensure they are implemented and signed off in a timely fashion. Ensure you adequately budget for the safety needs of your area. Maintain trust by providing frequent feedback to employees on the progress of improvements in an open and transparent manner.

8. Review Safety Improvement Projects

Supportive by ensuring safety related improvement projects are reviewed & tracked with priority and appropriate pace relative to other projects.

Page 67: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is expected of you? At your next team meeting recognize a member of the team for their safety efforts by simply praising their proactive efforts or awarding them with a safety related item. When making awards leaders should be specific, clear and visible. Emphasize their meaning to you personally and their value to people.

Why? Leaders should constantly deliver and recognise great safety performance. They should also recognise the endeavours of employees who improve safety on site. There is always an opportunity to recognise those who voluntarily contribute to safety e.g. Safety Representatives.

9. Recognise Safety achievements

Supportive by providing recognition for safety achievements in the same way that other business achievements are recognised.

Page 68: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

What is expected of you? Before conducting an interview add some safety related probing questions to your interview prompt notes e.g. how would you complete a thorough accident investigation? How would you go about improving safety culture? How would you demonstrate that safety is a core value for you?

Why recruit safety inclined people? When recruiting / promoting employees, question about safety, this type of communication reinforces your commitment to safety and safety performance is enhanced by hiring people with good safety attitudes and values. This is a sustainable approach to continually delivering great safety performance.

10. Recruit people with good safety attitudes and values

Demonstrate the importance of safety by recruiting and promoting people with good safety attitude and values.

Page 69: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

In organizational safety performance, everyone has a role to play. These roles are all aimed at the same objective. However, they differ by level and job function. While most leaders would agree that a "hands-off" approach is not appropriate, many well-intentioned leaders err on the side of "taking over" roles that really belong to others. Role confusion can become a prolonged problem because it often provides positive short-term consequences: satisfaction, results and even climate change. However, it also takes a toll on organizational culture: failing to develop role competency in others, blurring the leader's true role, and avoiding the underlying causes that led the leader to take over in the first place.

Knowing How (And How Not) To Influence?

Page 70: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

As an example, consider just one manager's effect on his organization's culture. The site's incident investigations are handled at the front-line supervisor level with support from the safety staff and some wage-roll employees. The new manager finds the investigations inadequate. He reviews the reports, sending them back with notes in red, but with little other guidance. When little improvement is seen, the manager decides to conduct the investigations himself. The reasoning is that he wants to demonstrate and role model how a "good" incident investigation should be handled and demonstrate caring for the injured employee. These are honourable motives. However, in taking over this role, the manager has inadvertently undermined any hope of lasting change. Rather than try to discover and improve the circumstances that prevented good investigations in the first place, he has implicitly told these employees that they are incompetent, lessening the likelihood that they will participate in future safety activities. In addition, he has neglected fulfilling some of his own roles and responsibilities in the process, creating further mistrust and resentment.

Knowing How (And How Not) To Influence?

Page 71: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Steps to better influence & Conclusion

Page 72: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

When leaders make missteps in safety it is rarely out of bad intent. More often the culprit is the leader's lack of understanding about what he or she can and should be doing to influence safety. Below are some of the steps we have found to be critical in establishing an effective and appropriate leadership presence in safety.

1. Develop and articulate your own safety vision. 2. Monitor the most critical elements of the safety system. 3. Ensure the effectiveness and use of sustaining mechanisms. 4. Establish a context for safety actions. 5. Align organizational consequences with values and beliefs. 6. Apply the right solution to the problem. 7. Focus on culture.

Page 73: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Thank you!!!!

For further clarifications and questions, please contact: [email protected]; or

[email protected] ?

Page 75: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

WASHEQ - 23rd September 2011 Tayo Adedeji

Regional Environmental Manage, CARES Ltd

Establishing Environmental Management Systems – the Importance of Sustainable Development

Page 76: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Introduction

This presentation provides a broad overview of environmental management systems as a means of contributing to sustainable development, and covers: What is sustainability? Components of a good EMS. Industry specific considerations. How we can help you.

Page 77: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Sustainable Development

Sustainable development is means of effecting change that “meets the needs of the present

without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs”.

- United Nations. 1987. Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development. General Assembly Resolution 42/187, 11 December 1987.

Page 78: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Sustainability

For a policy to be sustainable, it must respect five principles, which rely on: a sustainable economic approach; good governance; and sound science.

Page 79: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 80: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Sustainable Development Indicators

Environmental

– Carbon – Waste – Materials – Water – Ecology

Social – Transport – Culture and heritage – Health and happiness – Equity, fair trade and food

Economic – Whole Life Value

Page 81: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Environmental Considerations

The point at which environmental factors are considered greatly influence the measures to be taken. Design phase All elements of the projects can be considered, many of which will relate to design features and material use during project cycle.

Construction and operational phase This will largely relate to resource use and release control (waste and incident management) and remediation related to accidental releases. Decommissioning/closed phase At this stage, remedial works will be the only relevant factor…

Page 82: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Environmental Management Systems

An EMS is a management tool enabling an organization of any size or type to: identify and control the environmental impact

of its activities, products or services; implement a systematic approach to setting

environmental objectives and targets, to achieving these and to demonstrating achievement; and

improve its environmental performance.

Page 83: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

EMS in Practice

The underlying philosophy is that whatever the organization's activity, the requirements of an effective EMS are the same.

Page 84: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

EMS and the ISO14001 Standard

An EMS which considers the ‘Plan-Do-Check-Act’ cycle is, in broad terms meeting the requirements of ISO 14001:2004, in conjunction with: a commitment to compliance with applicable environmental legislation and regulations; and a commitment to continual improvement

Page 85: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Environmental Aspects

Identifying the environmental aspectsassociated with all operating conditions andsituations. These relate to a review of: normal and abnormal operating conditions; accidents / disasters; and emergency situations.

Page 86: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Legal Compliance

Clarify the legal and other requirements that apply to your organisation: Legislative standards Regulatory guidelines International conventions Best practice guidelines…

Page 87: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Steps for Implementation

Examine your organization’s current environmental management policies, procedures, and practices- or put something in place.

This usually involves considering your organisations operating, purchasing and contracting policies, procedures, and practices.

Page 88: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Define the EMS Scope

Establish a boundary: the entire organization? a specific operating unit or facility? Once defined, all activities, products, andservices that fall within this boundary should comply with the ISO 14001 standard.

Page 89: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Oil and Gas Exploration and the Environment

Spills and releases Chemical usage and

storage Gas flaring Operation-related

travel Product

transportation

Page 90: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Mining and the environment

Ecological impacts

Extraction material management (cyanide)

Social impacts 'Galamsey’ Transportation

Page 91: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Ports and the environment

Ecological impacts Waste

management Hazardous

material movement Fuel use, storage

and containment Biofouling and

invasive species

Page 92: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Manufacturing and the environment

Handling of raw materials;

By-products of manufacturing – solid, liquid and

gaseous Waste management Transportation of

goods manufactured

Page 93: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

How we can help…

CARES is a multi-disciplinary environmental and engineering consultancy company that

brings together a team of highly experienced individuals, a number of whom have over 30

years experience in their chosen fields.

Page 94: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Environmental management and assessment

EMS development and associated training

Environmental auditing Legislation compliance

and future planning Environmental, Social

and Human Health Impact Assessment (EIA, ESIA, HSE, etc.) management, delivery and training

Public consultation, social impact assessments and environmental PR input

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) reporting

Page 95: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Environmental investigation and interpretation

Pollution assessments and management including development of contingency

Environmental monitoring

Hydrology, hydrogeology and water quality assessment,

Environmental due diligence, risk and

liability management Contaminated land

management including remediation

Planning and permitting support

Expert witness service

Page 96: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Sustainability and climate change

Sustainability appraisals Resource management including renewable

energy appraisal Carbon management including carbon

footprinting Climate change risk evaluation and weather

planning

Page 97: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Thank you!

Tayo Adedeji

Regional Environment Manager CARES Ltd

[email protected]

Page 99: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 100: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Supremacy ?? Superiority ?? Excellence ?? Distinction ??

Page 101: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

A product of a high standard as in comparison to a similar product

A product of good worth, well made and perfect for the purpose it was produced

A product that has superior attributes as in comparison to a similar product

A product or service which responds to a customers needs and requirements

A product that is ranked as top of the line

Page 102: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Gives the Company a Competitive Advantage Encourages Return Customers Reduces cost in savings on after sales

problems Helps improve efficiency Provides customer with information Builds consumer confidence in the brand

Page 103: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Total Customer Satisfaction Supplying High Quality products that meet

International Standards and Customer specifications

To achieve, sustain and improve quality economically

To ensure every member of staff is aware of the goals and objectives of the Company

Page 104: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

QUALITY PRODUCTS

AND SERVICES

A CUSTOMER FOCUSED COMPANY

A STRONG ORGANIZATIONAL

STUCTURE

IINVOLVEMENT OF ALL STAKE

HOLDERS STAFF, SUPPLIERS & CUSTOMERS

ENSURING A PROCESS

APPROACH

A SYSTEMATIC APPROACH TO MANAGEMENT

A FACTUAL APPROACH TO

DECISION MAKING

MUTUALLY BENEFICIAL SUPPLIER

RELATIONS

CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT

Page 105: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

1 Customer Focused Organization

Organizations depend on their customers and therefore should understand current and future customer needs, should meet customer requirements and strive to exceed customer expectations.

2 Leadership Leaders establish unity of purpose and direction. They should create and maintain the internal environment in which people can become fully involved in achieving the organization’s objectives.

3 Involvement of People People at all levels are the essence of an organization and their full involvement enables their abilities to be used for the organizations benefit.

4 Process Approach A desired result is achieved more efficiently when activities and related resources are managed as a process

5 System Approach to Management

Identifying, understanding and managing a system of interrelated processes as a system contributes to the organization’s effectiveness and efficiency in achieving its objectives

6 Continual Improvement Continual improvement of the organization’s overall performance should be a permanent objective of the organization

7 Factual approach to decision making

Effective decisions are based on the analysis of data and information

8 Mutually beneficial supplier relationships

An organization and its suppliers are interdependent and a mutually beneficial relationship enhances the ability of both to create v

Page 106: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Is the focus on my customer in this process? Do the following show up in this process: Leadership Guiding policies Measurable objectives An environment that motivates staff to achieve said

objectives? Have people at all levels been included in the design

of the process and decision making? Has the measurement, monitoring and improvement

of the products and services been included n this process?

Has the applicable process been applied to attaining Company’s objective in this process?

Page 107: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Has a systems approach to management of the processes that interact with each other been applied to maximize performance and eliminate bottlenecks?

Have the facts collected been transmitted to decision maker in this process?

Can continual improvement in performance, efficiency, and effectiveness be measured in this process?

Is this process creating a mutually beneficial relationship with suppliers?

Page 108: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

•Improved Stakeholder Relationships between staff, customers and suppliers

Customer Satisfaction through the delivery of products which

that consistently meet customers requirements

•Proven Business Credentials through Independent verification against recognized standards. •Ability to win More business particularly where procurement

specifications require certification as condition to supply.

Reduced Operating Costs-Continued improvement of

processes resulting in operational efficiency

•Improved Risk Management through greater consistency and traceability of products & services

Legal Compliance- Understanding how regulatory requirements impact on your

organization and your customers

Page 109: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011
Page 110: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Determine what parameter is to be controlled Establish whether you need to control before,

during or after Produce plans for control which tell us how to

achieve our objective through detection and removal

Organize resources to implement the plans for quality control

Install a sensor at an appropriate point in the process to sense variance from specification

Page 111: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Collect and transmit data to a place for analysis

Verify results and diagnose the cause of variance

Propose remedies and decide on the action needed to restore the status quo

Take the agreed action and check that the variance has been corrected

Page 112: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

Helps the Company to prevent or greatly reduce defects

Improves the quality of the product through rigorous testing procedures

Measuring is Knowing MEASURE=KNOWLEDGE= CHANGE Helps maintain a healthy relationship with our

suppliers along all our processing stages Ensures products and services are designed and

produced to meet or exceed customer requirements

Guarantees that only products of the highest standard reach the customer

Page 113: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

QUALITY IS:

SUPREMACY ?- YES!! SUPERIORITY?- YES!! EXCELLENCE ?- YES!! DISTINCTION?-YES!!

In other words YOU ARE THE BEST IN BUSINESS !!

Page 115: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

THE NIGERIAN NATIONAL POLICY ON

OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH : QUO VADIS?

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011 11

Page 116: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

OUTLINE

• Introduction

• Background

• The Policy in general

• The Basis of the policy

• The 11 different sections of the Policy in details

• Prospects & Challenges

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 117: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

NIGERIAN POPULATION 45% Muslims 54% Christians 1% Traditionalists

History, geography and economy The most populous in Africa and 10th most populous country in the entire world!!! Population of 140,431,790 (NPC 2006) 1 in 4 Africans Population > 50% of West Africa Population growth rate of 3.2% pa

374 identifiable ethnic groups 774 local government areas 36 states and the FCT 6 geo-political zones 923,768 square kilometres

Page 118: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

BACKGROUND

• The first of its kind in Nigeria

• Signed by the Hon Minister of Labour ( Dr Hassan Mohammed Lawal) on 22-11-2006

• Due for review at 3-year intervals

• A product of collaboration and contributions from various stakeholders

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 119: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

RELEVANT STAKEHOLDERS • NISCN 1964 National Industrial Safety Council of Nigeria

• NISP 1980 Nigerian Institute of Safety Professionals

• NIOHS 2011 Nigerian Institute of Occupational Health and Safety • NPC 1961 National Population Commission

• ESN 2006 Ergonomics Society of Nigeria

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

OTHER STAKEHOLDERS GOVERNMENTS @ all levels EMPLOYERS of labour (public & private)

EMPLOYEES in various workers unions/NLC TRADE UNIONS including artisans MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC

Page 120: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

GENERAL

• The policy has 11 sections in 19 pages • Policy anchored by the Federal Ministry of Labour and

Productivity

•Provides the way forward for the elimination or effective control of occupational hazards and the protection of workers against work-related illness, injury and disease

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 121: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

BASIS

Section 17.3C of the Nigerian Constitution:

the state shall divert its policy towards ensuring that the

health, safety and welfare of all persons in employment is

safeguarded and not endangered or abused

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Nigeria is also obliged to domesticate ILO Convention 155

on Occupational Safety and Health and the Working

Environment which Nigeria ratified in 1994

Page 122: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 1 : INTRODUCTION

………is government approach for achieving, inter alia, a national development philosophy of building a united, self-reliant and egalitarian economy through minimizing, so far as is reasonably practicable, the causes and effects of hazards inherent in the working environment

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 123: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 2 : GOAL OF THE POLICY

• Facilitate improvement of OSH performance by providing the framework for participative OSH protection of workers

• Ensure harmonisation of rights protection and regulating various provisions for securing safety, health and welfare of workers in Nigerian workplaces

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 124: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 3 : OBJECTIVES OF THE POLICY

• To create a general framework for the improvement of working conditions and the working environments

• To prevent accidents and departures from health arising out of or in the course of work

• To ensure the provision of OSH services to workers in all sectors of economic activity

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 125: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 4 : SCOPE

The OSH policy applies to all Nigerian workplaces including formal and informal sector workplaces

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 126: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.1 : DUTIES OF STATUTORY AUTHORITY

To give effect to this policy, the statutory authority shall be the Federal Ministry of Labour and Productivity

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 127: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.2 : DUTIES OF THE FEDERAL MINISTRY OF HEALTH

Collaborate with the Federal Ministry of Labour and Productivity on occupational accidents, injuries and diseases by providing relevant information on all such cases in medical facilities nationwide

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 128: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.3 : DUTIES OF EMPLOYERS

It is the duty of every employer to ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the safety, health and welfare of all workers including provision, at no cost to the worker, PPE appropriate for the nature of the job

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 129: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.4 : DUTIES OF WORKERS

It is the duty of every worker in the formal and informal sector, to

• Co-operate with government and employers on safety, health and welfare matters

• To take reasonable care for his health and safety and of other persons around

• To use provided PPE correctly and consistently

• To report any hazardous situations to his supervisor and if need be, to the Inspector of Factories, closest to the workplace

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 130: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.5 : DUTIES OF MANUFACTURERS

It is the duty of any person or

organisation who designs,

manufactures, imports or supplies

any equipment, article or

substance for use at work to

ensure the product is safe

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 131: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.6 : DUTIES OF TRANSPORTERS

It is the duty of transport owners to ensure that hazardous workplace materials are transported safely with due regards to the safety and health of workers mode of transportation notwithstanding

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 132: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.7 : DUTIES OF SAFETY & HEALTH COMMITTEES

The employer shall establish a Safety and Health Committee to facilitate the implementation of safety and health programmes

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 133: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 5.8 : ROLE OF THE MEDIA

The support of media shall be enlisted in the advancement of safety, health and welfare of the nation’s workforce especially in the creation of awareness, dissemination of information on knowledge of accident prevention and safe systems of work

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 134: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 6 : STRATEGIES FOR IMPLEMENTATION

• Appropriate training and education on the policy provisions and policy implementation

• Promoting the WORLD DAY FOR SAFETY AND HEALTH AT WORK to be commemorated annually 28th April

• Inclusion of occupational safety, health and welfare training in educational curricula from primary to tertiary levels

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 135: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

SECTION 7 : COLLABORATION

The Federal Ministry of Labour and Productivity shall collaborate with the most representative of employers’ and workers’ organisations and all government agencies with a role in occupational safety and health

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 136: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

OTHER SECTIONS

• Section 8 Monitoring and Evaluation

• Section 9 Research and Development

• Section 10 Policy Review

• Section 11 Definitions of terms used in the policy

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011 13

Page 137: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

PROSPECTS and CHALLENGES

PROSPECTS • Starting somewhere • Political will • Awareness creation • CSO and HRO

interests • Demand for good

governance

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

CHALLENGES •Public sector-driven • Lack of legal teeth • Cultural barrier • Low level of industrialization • Gross underemployment

Page 138: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

RECAP

• Introduction

• Background

• The Policy in general

• The Basis of the policy

• The 11 different sections of the Policy in details

• Prospects & Challenges

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011

Page 139: WASHEQ  2011 ppt Morning session 2011

THANK YOU ALL

23/09/2011 WASHEQ 2011