w ou - national bureau of economic research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ......

43
U0flC 12 IAU 0 JJC 20flWQ bibp urnA pc dnotq tiqipoiu cxbpc bci.wou bLoAJqQq rijj cLq ucjnqpJ © © ThÔ P 1CLCU G 1U VII 14JU2 Lc2LAcq 211014 2GCPOIJ2 0 )C U0 ID XQQ MO QxbLcacq IJJO2C 0j JJC fl0L uq UO IJ02C O 41jJ0UJ 11LGf1 0 ECOUOUJ!C J2GLcp I1 WBEL JJJJ2 bbcL !2 bn.j O 1BEL2 LC29LCJJ bLourw !' C0th0Lfl jiuuc uA obuiou KthJ01& JçICJC jçr1pcje Axq 2cpm2icnrF"!' UJC2 miq acu1!ut bujcbnu j1utq iuq LQJ1J tOL W C0UJUJIU2 vuq 2fl C2110112 0 op QCLPJQV H'4 BU H0IWP0W FOfl!2 2ciucc bonuqoIr JJflflItC2 ID fff1LCCu OD0UJJ 0L pcjb u bLcbn.!u wun2c1.!bV j UJ .LI1!2 LC2CL 2 2nbbol4cq PX J/ILL2 IIUCW!OU91 L!IJUC!J KCQ9LCP CQUIDL uq W M!O1JI N w ou JOO 22CJJfl2CU2 yicunQ MVJJOMVr' Bf1!EVfl OE ECOMONIC BE2EVBCH J0LjUU bCL 40 JO J 1QLCWX c COKbOBVLE IE2OfIKCE2 V11D IHE CONbEILLIOM EOJ itLEicwvr cviuvr NVJKEJ2 I4BEK iiAOIcIUMG bVbEK 2EffIE2

Upload: others

Post on 14-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

U0flC 12 IAU 0 JJC 20flWQ

bibp urnA pc dnotq tiqipoiu cxbpc bci.wou bLoAJqQq rijj cLq ucjnqpJ ©© ThÔ P 1CLCU G 1U VII 14JU2 Lc2LAcq 211014 2GCPOIJ2 0 )C U0 ID XQQ MO

QxbLcacq IJJO2C 0j JJC fl0L uq UO IJ02C O 41jJ0UJ 11LGf10 ECOUOUJ!C J2GLcpI1 WBEL JJJJ2 bbcL !2 bn.j O 1BEL2 LC29LCJJ bLourw !' C0th0Lfl jiuuc uA obuiouKthJ01& JçICJC jçr1pcje Axq 2cpm2icnrF"!'UJC2 miq acu1!ut bujcbnu j1utq iuqLQJ1J tOL W C0UJUJIU2 vuq 2fl C2110112 0 op QCLPJQV H'4 BU H0IWP0W FOfl!22ciucc bonuqoIr JJflflItC2 ID fff1LCCu OD0UJJ 0L pcjb u bLcbn.!u wun2c1.!bV j UJ.LI1!2 LC2CL 2 2nbbol4cq PX J/ILL2 IIUCW!OU91 L!IJUC!J KCQ9LCP CQUIDL uq W M!O1JI

N w ouJOO 22CJJfl2CU2 yicunQMVJJOMVr' Bf1!EVfl OE ECOMONIC BE2EVBCH

J0LjUU bCL 40 JO J

1QLCWX c

COKbOBVLE IE2OfIKCE2V11D IHE CONbEILLIOM EOJ

itLEicwvr cviuvr NVJ�KEJ2

I4BEK iiAOIcIUMG bVbEK 2EffIE2

Page 2: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

1OI iqiq nbhoW 5IHHM QQI 'M

T3X5IAM JATNAD JAM5IThI SlOq i4OflTFNMOD HHT UfrIA

D$ITJO251 TAMOI51OD

TDAMTflA

01 ioi XLB r1b3oIIB iii 1tu$upbsñ is1oq1oo lo 1oi r1i nfrru$x iqnq irIT

1oirioz &f irtsupbrf ibriI !nsd n IiInU .ihsm Is3iq3 thrriini its ni 1oiq fi13qmo3

th -- nD!3iq-1nniw" fiX fl3 01 3VI1n3fI1 IL1 bits rrioilius r1i ilioci ii vi Isiti 1rIh

jill ni do[ boo s niob vfi .i±ons 03 ijoiq ,no motI thnuI ni11irt Ivi3o 10 3ii3ntq

fLi rliiw qir1noi1s1t nwo 1i nrfw nv u1.sv 33st3 ff53 ttisupbsr1 ,noin3mth nbbiq-tnniw

xsIi 01 HE fl qIrL lorln.s3 io1ii1i ii bris 2rnIdoiq ngs riliw 1rtui1 i ihsm Izliq& 3bi1uo

!sfrI1f1i isfil i tr1 bqo1v3b 1bom rIi lo noita3ilqmi nO .a3nisiino3 iibt3 biw-rrrff1 Hinvo

buoo1 \1viiEI5I oocb iflsqmo3 nrfw lini3i11 iom noil3nul 'Qm i!inm IEflqs3

nii .D mtit 1ncnsnsM lo Ioort32 nso1 8N'- so1onñoT lo 3iuflinI iiud3E22sM

3vh0 IshornM O V41-MO AM ,bhdrrisD

SIHflT4 bits

Page 3: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

flOii3lJbOliflI .1

or iuoi I3nrIBfI3 2i3)hsm !.ariqso Is(rf3ini (I3iffW d 33O1 rIr sIns iqsq irfT

i 31r11 4iH :siuis1 A owi asH rfoirfw !sbom £ qo1v3b I .nqmoa E 8bini u ini11ib

r1b513 3is31.s ns a3s1 213tIupbs3rt 33sIoq1o3 , ..i--ebnu1 lo (ii3lB3 biw-nEqmo3 £

i 213rIs1Jpb3li bno .iio1q Vfl4-3vi1ioq ifs nEnfl 01 3!ds 3d ion 'sm bnfi InLEi1nOO

wolldas3 3d1 31qrnx3 ioI .ai3oiq zaoios zbnul 331E3E 328th nh1S3Ot(S31 Iii b3 113 'I3V!13B

.noiaivib dioaE iii in3m1vni no lnsq2 bns nAEi sd sm iiivi1cs noizivib 3fl0 d b3iI3n

t I&1I gni3nEnft 321Z1 q1311 ol 15131z11o3 as bu 3d sm ai3azs znoiaivib no 'viisrrI31th tO

di nsdi fli3flEfIfl lzloi azL vioi ab3joiq moa wriT .noiaivib 3rbo rIi 01 b1i3vib 113111

laum a1irnq Isubivibni iuq 1qmi .3lom vii aitho 3liuiw riiiia 3rIols-bnsla £ 111 bluow

airil ni at3aoI baa anniw 3111 Aoiq 01 ai dot iiisupbad bris abnu1 isoa 8th ioI 3i3qmoO

nowi3qmoo

laiiqso Isrn3ini 115 lo noiiqh3ab (VQI) 2noamsiIIiW 10 thiqa 3f11 23Th1q53 I3bOm 8rfT

lud aiuoa iiri1 01 b31rw131 1Ls3i1smoius Ion 515 rrnil miol-M rfi iii awofl ffas3..." :13)hsm

awofl iia& lo iri3mniaas airli iq281 vjism nI. .noilii3qmoo 1srrl8ini as 01 bsaoqx3 is bsiani

(.8M-V1I .qq) "...32i-Iqrn3 miol-M dr 10 3iudhfls Ialn8rnsbnul iaom 3111 al au b!3i rlid or

qol 233ior13 Is3jno iaorn 311T" :athw oHw 8QI) noablsnoU d b3bdu,oa 21 mrLi islimia A

in3mia3vni 3i3Irfl2 nJ3qmo3 noms 2331uo251 31530115 15111 320(11 315 28)ISm ifl3m3gSfISm

(Q .a) ".a8iiinlmoqqo

isHi ai w3iv (48QI) noabtsnoU bns (VQI) noamsilliW sill lo i3sqas 1iii3i3ifli 13V 3110

isdi ai3so1q insmiesvrn bslslsinu 13i3!qmo3 saiwlsdlo noms s3nsbnsqsblsirn fiB aiasua ii

I

Page 4: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

fb!IIW 03 1fl33x3 3f11 ilR3f1i33q2 .nsqrno3 rnsa 8r11 10 Iooi I3 l3bnu b3i&o! d 03 n3qqBrf 12uL

'i33o1q lEfli rio 1no ion bnq3b iliw ihsm [siiqs3 IsrrI3ini ns iii b3bnuI ioiq n3vig 'flE

llzivo nqmoo 3r11 ni zioo1q irfio ol 3v13E151 th3m 3i no ozis lud th3m 3iulo2ds fiwo

fli brw fl bns A noiivib b31s!31nu owl znwo nsqmoa Ii 1qmEx3 101 urIT •OilObioq

in3m3avni isdi 1qmi 01 m bhiow tn3mugls fli !n3bbu H flu nui23vni lo Is3qqs

I3nnEf1o 13nsupbs3d is-1oq-io3 s--nigrsm fli is V1T4-3viikoq zi liii n3v3--3nu1ob bluow A ni

.H 2blswoi 31ijo1 33l3 ii lo tom 'I3viiE131

initIJ 21SflSffl won iliiw 3dil ol Irustz33 w3iv 33n3bn3q3bl3lni-in3miasvni 2icfT

.QQI lo sM ni bonuonns AsboN n3nfW .noiis3ith 10 iiInid bits 2io3 n1i lo rno iuods

2nizud nfio owl bits iinu irib qoiduntiW nu113i ii 1sz iol qu niuiuq sw ii isnil

3(13 bonisIqx 13rf2iI 1o3O nsmiisito (un3v31 lo I3ismixo1qqs lo Isioi nrn3231q91)

3w.. .fl1)ij 03 in3miimmo3 Isloi 116111 2231 nin11on o1 21[ 31u3tñ 51sbo)I" :nuisi2 d 3VOffl

02 3w w used 2in3mivni llsrn2 (1sm 03) 23innuiloqqo nsm 001 qu ni22sq 313W

-110112 3vsrI bluow w nismi bits (1115311 ilioci nisi3l 01 b3iqm3iis 3w 11 iol b3qqzzi2

(PQQ1 sM jsmuo1 i3U IIsW) ".diod bnsn13

10 noilon &Ii iol tloqqu2 13iInuI 2sbivolq (QQ1) inomsJ d *iow !s3hiqm3 11183351

3ibiupi1 nsqmo3-s1ini" b3m183 3d iiiim isdw 2insmu3ob inom&1 .on3bn8q3b13ini ifl3mi23Vfli

&Ii d iiti-bisnl 313W 2wofldaso 'esinsqmo3 ho iojsm n3rIw :iiaubni ho 2.U 3(13 flj "213v011iq2

113(13 uI in3fni23vni nibuI3ni bisod 3(13 o13s ln3mi23vni 1u3 3flJ 8Q1 10 3n1h33b riq ho

21631m3f1301i8q 3fIi nI b5rIuo3o 2iu3 ssdi lo ',nsm hnb!hi2 i2oM .2noi2ivib b33s131-lio-non

niivni lo 15qqs 8± 3ws33d r1i1ow31on hs1u3ii1Eq 21 zidT .23insqmo3 ho r11 lo 2noi2ivib

floIl3lJbO1q 3(13 (Ii liJqni iotsm 5 2i ho 25 lls1 233flq ho (1811W Ji bluorl2 21E3im3u13o1i3q iii

Page 5: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

ho flflw b3isilffth ion orIi ,

..i) 2mlfl im3thxnl3q 3noIs-bn1 bbni bnA .283OIq

.boh3q 3m Ii vo in3mizvni ini Iin3flini bib (insqmo3

Isubivibni 01 ni3nsnfl 3iolls 2i3*Ism Isiiqs3 Isrn3ini Ii 2Ji bnuo2 ii e3lim idi 1o hA

isth sw 3r11 moi1 in5I11ib IIsin3msbnu1 i ISIfI EW £ ff1 ffoi2wib 10 2333(,olq

Ansd 3Ink s nisrni hias 1153 no 3hqmsx3 ioI .13rnoiw3 113111 01 1ib513 3isolls 213b1131

d3urn 22 ii i bnA .ai33uboiq 1sümrbo1i3q bus al3oubolq ho shq-iuq thod ol nibn3h

zii 11311w 2l33ubolq !soim3k)oli3q 3111 01 nibn31 1u3 !qmi12 bluow Ansd S f13u2 isili '13)hih 2231

bn3hl3bnlJ v3r1i 11 t13V3 isrli 2i23u2 a!nsd iuods rioiihjini 3125d mO .is bsd £ bsrf 21fl3ih3 ho

b33&01th 21 flb313 $Ismthn3d 3*ism-1siiqso-ih3q 123d-321fl £ 03 bsisqmo3 2s 3S13vs no

iO .th3m 8v115131 3113 ol nib1o33s z1 bus ipiq lo th3m 33u1o2d5 di ol nibiooos 3iom

15303 r13 n!2s313r1i luods 3mm 3d 01 m bluow nthisd lo a23niwd uf1 hin3111ib bise

.wosr lo bog b3xit £ gu nibivib luods 2231 bus 33jo1q vjltiow 01 3IdSlisvS nibnu1

lnscJ £ r1w 2bnuo1 [83i131o3r11 no auoivdo 131sib3mrni ion 21 Ii 3fnii 311152 311316 13Y

ISi3IlsnhI lo miol £ in3231q31 iiiod hishD .31131311ib 02 3d bluorl2 1Aism hsiiqs3 hsrn3ini as bus

2m3Idoiq noiismioIni io vns 3viiimhq mse rii lo iuo ns tfiod 1dsuiA .noiicib3ml3ith

h133iib 23v132m311i 3311511fl 01 2i3o1q in3mi23vni lo 2qi 11151133 iol iluoiulib ii 1sm rl3iulw

323(11 lsth noiiqmuaslq 32 1 313(11 232S3 rhiod ui bnA .13*15111 tsiiqE3 rIigrr3I 2'fIflS 3(11 111

d3i3f1i a133o1q 3(11 luods noiisrniolni nniJJp3s iol 3k)lrI3v 1113131113 as 315 a3rrsib3ml3ini

220136 i3vOIhiq2 lo 3513b 311102 21 513113 313(1W 231qm5x3 1o )lflifIi (ISO 3110 32iU03 10' 315123 11351 211 no 232201 31s1 213111J2 Ansd bi1siiqso hiooq £ II .2in3iIo lnsd 1n813111b

211 01 2231 bn3l 3101313(11 bus 2rioi1shusi Isliqso d bsnisli2noo 3moO3d 'sm ii oibo1iioq bhuow 2i3vohliq2 323(11 i3v3woH (.IQQI nwoi bris Ansnifl .21113113 b11i 316123

111 nrnuooo 320th 115(11 5buhinsm th b3onuoffoiq 2231 bns nommoo 2231 doum 3d 01 isqqs iol 2(10255! mh3bnu 3111 3ioIqx3 01 21 iqsq airll lo 1so ismhq A .233)hsm Lstiqso LSffl3ifIi

.33n313111b insrsqqs elili

Page 6: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

.ifl3fni23vrti in3i3flh ni1siiIi3th bits noiJ3h1 3qi-noiism1o1ni\3ngs nitsiv1Is

Ansci n&ii IJni3Thb oz Aiow i!ism 1s11q53 lsrn3ini its sly fll3flsfIi1 ob dw o (4QQI) ni3i bits nija1isd 13ntt3D d *tow ini wollol I iqsq if1i it! Vnibn1

lo rnio1 owi 3(11 (111w b31si3o2as thfh Ioijnoo in5r3Ttib rfi no 2uaol bits D 11fl0h3fl3f1

2idi1 Isubiz3l si1 2i3tIsupbsd 3isloqTo3 13)hsm LBflqso IsrrI3ini ifs Ri 1S1U3i11Lq nI .33fl5f111

3111 l3vo--(OQQ!) 3looM bits fisH bits (8QI) fisH bits nLm2aolD 10 321182 3111 nl--lOTIflO3 lo

inEtIoqrni owl asri aith Isril 31311 ugis I .ion a3ob ibn3I Ansd s 3IirIw a&nsnfl ii 2l33o1q

)Insd £ nsili 1hodius iom bits 3viinnk iom thod esii a 1-Isupbs3fl 81510q103 :23)fl3Up32f1o3

.13(110115 01 i38o1q no moil abnul nii1ir1a lo 33isIq 311 i "nb13iq-18nniw" ni 3SfI3 01

as ni 2ir1ri 10111103 fIsupbs311 no eiasfIqm3 3111 220 driw aisrla iqsq iiii 311(1W

al3tIsupbs3rt j8bom 220 3111 it! .sw Isin3rnsbnul v no ni aifIib ii 18)hsm L1iqs3 151rI31(Ii

isrIl auaai 3111 IsdI z3iIqmi aiftT .3IdsILsvs 2331110231 Lci3nsnfl b8iirnulnu 3v511 01 bemIJaac 25W

nhr1sqmo33s 11i bits 2bnu1 lo Iooq b3xft £ lo noiis3oIIs 8th--31811 cr1831103 15111133 lo 31B

iqsq 21(11 ni 1eslino3 it! &.I3born 220 di ni 321-is 183fl bIuo3--nb13iq-13nniw 10 non3mon3lfq

2181-isupbs3d 13vo5IoM .nwo au lo 111153w ni2ix3-81q on 3vsd 01 b3muaas ai 2131Isupbs9rI

3111 bits 113211 nw13d rn3ldoiq 'ngs as lo iuo 12uonobn3 325 lsrli a1111s1121103 1ib513 aos1

3ludnfls r1uoat-b3xfl 3(11 ivi1b a3iujtht owl 323111 13r11oi R3AST .13*iEm Isiiqs3 3bi2iuo

.rn)13iq-13nniw luods nb1nh1i iol Jrlioq nI11E12 522338fl £ 21 IscIl

:rrriol 3m811x3 its 31s1 111w al3tIsupbs3rI nios1 ins1iano3 1ib313 3(11 232B3 31(102 it!

nii3a s iii 2233olq noils3olls Lciiqso lsfrI3lni 8th I3bom oats (4QQ1) vivs$I bits ainsH thu io 220 1311113 ni 8AiInU .ainisliano3 Isionsnfl on a3s1 aI8rIsupbs3Ii 220 (Ii 2S 5I3f1w

-flsH\(8Q1)tisH-nsmaacn0 8th uI aidri lolino3 aaiia ion ob vivsM bits einsH I8v3wod iqsq .321132 (OQQ!) 3100M

Page 7: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

aioiq Isubivibni 3(11 nsth ls3ci 01 gnibnul laioi om ns rthd oi 3lds 3d ion Iliw al3llsupbE3fI

vl3ftsupbs3rl as 3m31ix8 aith iii fl3V3 13Y .a3noLs-bnsia as niisiqo 32161 bluo3 298213V0 ii

510ffl ebnul lo inuorns rnsa 3th gniis3olls d 1*isrn lsiiqs3 lsrn3lni RE ni 3ulsv bbs hue 1163

Ansd s (111w iasiino3 3(11 aA.sm ii brts mio1 1251uq 21i ni nD131q-I3fIniw 21 2iffT .lifl3i3fft3

gnD131q-I3nn1w ni 3ER3 01 3lds 2231 21 Ansd £ 33n12 isdi wol3d 3ugls I :*isia 1Lsiq29 l3bnol

.233115(111 ii 2i33o1q 3111 iol 3ffI3VE no 21(116112(103 11b313 232S3 ii 223111u sulsv 316313 13v3fl (153 ii

ihsrn Lsiiqs3 lsrri3ini RE bns )lnsd £ nwisd noii3nilaib 128q1s1i2 8th arrrI3i 153 1351q III

al3bom bisbns1 .aonsnfl rba isfil aijoiq to 8qi bris l3dmun 3(11 ifliw ob 01 asrl 1dsdoiq

3g151 ol bn3l bluotia a)lnsd isth ia3ua (8QI) bnornsiU as 113u2 noiisib3rnl3ini 1513(15(111 10

b3isl3lduJ lo i3nEv s ni 3d ol ir1uo al3wol-iod 323(11 1ls3bi isril bns a13wO11Od to 2I3dmUfI

W113f151111 311(1W 3U1SV 315513115313*151(1 laliqE3 1611131(11115 13bom ffl (Ii i25hino3 nI .28223f1i2Ud

(IS lo (10113(1111 nD13Iq-13nniw 3(11 232S3 31(102 (1! 13V0510M .aioiq lo l3dmun llama £ lno

lo 3isIi2 b32U301 5 28200(13 f1EfflO3 3111 113(1w 13113d 2*10W 1lSu13s 13)hsm LSiiqs3 LsfrI3jni

.ai33o1q in3rnia3vni b3iEl3lnu rtsrli 13(1151 b3is131 13eol3 ni3flSf1fl

ni isth noiisvl3acJo 8th mo,1 1iiib awofl s31s1ia b3au3ol s lo iovsl (II in3mugLs MIT

lo looq b3xfl £ gnilsoohls iii bv1ovni lnsmhq Ci zl3nEupbssrI i3)1lsrfl Isliqso lEm3ini its

31121vr1s131 113112 niob n3rlW .aiasd 3v11s151 s no ai3o1q nb1nsi Ri 33(13(1 bits aiuoa lo airI8m 8111 nhi5U1sv3 111 210113 3111102(15 23)lsm al3tIsupbs3fI Ii l3flsm ion a3ob ii gnb1nsi

£.ai3ejolq 8(11 22013S b31513T1o3 316 210118 828111 as no1 as ai33o1q

no 31UiS18ii1 3(11 nih3bnu 15(11 bits 3io1 aidi n33w13d olsns 32013 £ 21 313f1T1

3Aoi bns nsiO (I81) (132051 bns 153.x&1 , ..3 a-- noliiisqmo3 A3i1abis 10 Zifl8msfflU01 ifl3ib51fli lsi3lrIo 8(11 23253 rfiod iii .(8Q1) 13113h11 bits (E8QI) iilii bits 11ud31SM (8QI)

.a18snsm\2138o1q 220135 b3iSl3TI03 315 isth 210113 lo 33fl8i2iX3 8th 21 (Ioi2 3111 RI

Page 8: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

giziie bu3o1 B aiqobs ruiqmo s z8rfw noiisuii2 s 13b12no3 1qmsxs 31513no3 s 2A

31fl02 i-il .oi 33ubolq ritod isili noi2ivib owl nwi3d nuoi qu nibivib 113211 2bnul bns

di ,

..3--noizivib oi 1dii3 ni nui3vni1o ih3m 3iuIo2ds 3111 3gbuim Iliw 213tIsupbsrI 232E3

.no2s32 ni11 2smithfD ifi nhub bnsm3b oj lo 3ls1 11i luods aii2imiiqo h3vo 3d irfim

ion ob 23Asi2im lo 21102 &fi b3xiI is bsnimmo3 3d 01 315 isdI 3iUo1 Lsioi 311111 iuH

13113d if1 3ubo1q noi2ivib 113111w 223225 'th)511o3 2l3tIBlJpbSSfI isrli i 21911sm isili hA .13115m

ir1im ii jloiiSofli2l3vib b3isl3lnu 10 3is1i2 £320011301 313W nsqmo 3111 Ii 12H1ifl03 iii .2Oi

.noi2ivib o1onib3ioid &io bits noi2ivib oi no sa nswi3d 2331U0231 qu nibivib 113231 bnfl

.oi iol bnsm3b 3111 bb1Jj2im ii Ii iuoi 31so1Lim bbni bluow ii 9253 2ifli nI

-io1q 3Iqmi2 s iiio s1 II noiio .2wohIoI 2S bsinsio zi iqsq 3111 1 l3bnsm3l 3dT

11311W ifl3ffIi2SVflfl8bflU bris ninoiisi 1ib313 ot b631 nso Ii wod wor12 bits ms1doiq 3fl3S 13V31

Isiiqso 1s1r131x3 f1in31 mis 3d) it! 23no[s-bnsi2 s ni3flSf1fl aisi 01 lqm3liS 2ioo1q Isubivibni

n3dw b3isiv3lls 1hsii-isq 3d fl63 enoiltoizib in3mia3vni 32811) wod wode III noi33 .i3*tSm

ni3s el3rIsupbs3rl 31s-IoçIo3 rliiw ((iiin3 31610cp03 13ls1 s 3bi2fl! b33s301 315 2133 O1 3IqiiItJm

3111 2315IieiJIhi (1011332 culT .13*rsm Isrn3iX3 3111 bits ei33o1q 9th n33w13d '1sibem13irIi its

3d) dign3I 3(1102 is 2322u321b oels bits i3)hsm Isiiqs3 16(1133(11 its lo 3101 gIlDl3iq-l3flfliW 3iasd

lo fiOlie3up 3111 ee3lbbs 01 bsi1si3n Ci I3bom 3111 VI noii33 nI .213bfl31 )hfIsd 1111w iesflno3

b31s513 8IJIRV 3111 nisimixSm io1 3is1i2 13313d 3113 ci flOtlBOfliZl3Vib b315131n11 10 2U301 13111311W

.23bu13n03 V noiio .i3115m 1siiqs3 Ism3lni as

Page 9: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

12 fO 1UJC 0 1G SLW2 JGU}J WSLJCGI JU 1p12 2GCIJOU 52 LCbLG2U1!1J IPG pouq W9LJCGV11 12 qicnJ1 OL qicw 10 CUSG IJ SUA 2014 0j W0UUOUU SC1/qA jJ1t12 S IJSUILSJ !UIthLGWfl0U

A 5UJJ2 JGU1JJ I UJU 10 2flC21 IPSI pGL SLG S JSC U11UJCL O q!jp2c !UAC210L2 20

hflL1PGLW0LC i 12 S22flWG 11151 < A < A5 < U OflJGL M0L2 FLOW IJJC bCL2bCCIIAG o 1C

lpc onuqL suq 1C Uu9ucicL2 jJ9AC iio qjjcr1J1A GWU IpCIL p9uq2 Oil J€2C C921J110M2

1uAc21cq JJJC CS2JJOM2 A' suq A3 sic sriwcq o pc co211c22JA Ac JJC .Lp2 !mbI!c2 IPSI

s 9IJJOJ1UI oj CS2PUOM A' i su swonu j MS2 !1JAC21cq suq 1.clflLIJ2 A i su swonui M92

!UAc2lwGuf qcbcuq2 ou 1C 2151G o pc MoLq ftjJGIJ pC 2151C 12 B (oL 4jsq,) c bLolccl Lcu1u12

jJJG SWOIIUI 0 !UAc21WC111 Il IJIC bLolccI C9U PC C!IPCL J OL 3 JJJC LCUIW Oil 1JJ12

12 2C1 10 CL0 52 12 IJIC LC2CLA9fIOU MSC 0 1JJC WS1JSGL

UUSUCIGL2 OL MSG2 fO IJJC 1JJSUSCL EOL 2!Wbf!C!1A IJJC LSIG0 LGIflUJ LGcIflILCq pA qic uusucIcL2

nic cxbccicq bLocccq2 IJISI pc onuqci. qcuAc2 L0W p12 iqcs uc o suA bsAwcul2 10 IIJC

L0nb o UUSuCJCL2 jjn.onpon pc bsbcL I S22flWC IPSI lpC O CJ1AC JflJJCIJOU 2 10 UJ9XWC

o s pop bLoC22iouffJ uJ9uSCL--MpO Sj20 p92 U0 MC9J1P 0 P! OMU--52 MCJJ 52 f1uqiU L0W S

qoc2 pe psc suA wsuscusj Sp!J!1A jpi2 iwbjca IIJSI Ipe bLolccl MijJ sJ2o LcdniLc 1C 2CLAICC2

csbiisj iuAC2IWCUV flLqoL1fru51CJA 521qC ow ipc bS1Cu1 ipe onuqcL 52 uo OIJICL mc5jfp IJOL

iu oLqcL OL Ipc bLolccl 10 UJ0AC OLMsi IJIC iqcs 111(121 pG cowpiucq MIII urnuscus1 JSOL suq

1OL Mp!cp IpcI.c urnA pG Wcs'UJUIJTJ COUILOJ UP121 OUC CSU flJIUJC 0 !I 92 LCbLC2culcq pA s bsicur

COWC2 L0W S jonuqcr j0 1AG IP!2 !qcs S COUCLCfG CW0q1WGUI 52 911 522G1 1115112 AsjrIspJc suq

bLolccl 1P91 2 IJUSUCCq !U IJIC 9LUJ2 jCIiIJJ CXIGUJSJ W5LJG1 JJJG 0LJ!IJffJ OL tpc bLoiccI

i pciu pA qccupiu 1G 1ccpuo1oA suq !1J0LWS110U 2IIJICIflLC 0L s 2iujc IUAG2IWGUI

V V22flWb1!0U2

II• JJJC B921C bL0GCt-rCACI VGUCA bLOP!CIJJ MJIp EXICWS1 JiU9UCi1J

Page 10: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

I iu i 8 81si2 iii inmi23vni 10 1vI Ismiiqo ti ibnuo1

.3vil3ubolq iom i in3rnivni ("boog" io1) 0 ai bhow Ii lo isie 3di ntfW

won 31B I niivni mrnI 2b3o1q rfi isth oa , I < ioiasl £ 'd b32i1 21 iuqiuo IIS3ii33q

isiii oa , I < ( - isth b3muas 2k ii . won is ni1vni moil 2b3o1q i1i bn ,'

2! 0 31i2 ru in9mivni lo 13v3I [smiiqo r1i 13bnuo1 3111 to 3v1133q213q 3111 mcnl

3101513111 8 31E12 lo 1iIidfido1q 3r11 ;q 2k ninuo 0 tt2 lo iI1dsdoiq 31ns X3 311T

21313116(111 3111 bilE lsbnuoI ft iud I1siib bhow 3111 lo 3ti2 1i 3rn2do 213flr1Bm i331o11 .q-1

b3mlotninu 3111 ol 1t31 miimo2 111w I n3mm2s nolismiolni 2i111 to 1r1iI nI .ion ob

ol daiw iojvnj 3bi2jIJo Ii hsI3 "ioavnj 3bi2iuo" as I8vth)3I1o3 eiansnfl bns l3bnuol

.m3rll 01 31612 3(11 i-ioq3l 01 216(16111 no 'I31 1211m 3r1i 3isia 3(11 no innuino3 1n31n123Vn! Asrn

3vrib d1 32usd 2r1oq5u 3itaimiJqol3vo im 01 (on3bn3i £ 3vsfl 111w 2i6flEffl 13v3woH

.1011(103 113(11 l3brw 23311J0231 lo ifliJofflE 3(11 tlflw 326313(11 isilI 21113fl3d 3lsvhq

3111U226 I sw 3Iqm!2 s ni lrI3mie3vnn3vo biswoi fl0116f1113fl1 2'1(13ffl3sftBm I3bom oT

.Jn3mivni moil 2b3rnq wofldas3 3(11 01 Lsnoinoqoiq Ii31ib 516 21113fl,cJ 336V'flq 3adi 16111

bits I lo 213v31 1n3mivnk iol a bns SIB 21113n3d 3lEvflq 3111 8 21 31612 3(11 Ii 2LJIIT

316 21113f13d 3isvhq 3111 0 2k 31612 3111 Ii ,'Iis1imi .1(1512(103 b3X11 £ 2! 2 51311w I8Vi133q231

b3mhJazB 316 21113fl3d 3isvhq 32311T .13viioqz31 bns 110 213v31 tn3ffli23vfli iol 2 bnB

3d lonruso 1i isrli 321132 cr11 nk ,

"3lsvnq" m3th 23)IBm Isrlw 21 21(11 ;3IdskIrI3vnu 3d 01

.210123V111 3bi2iuo ol b3ni2zs IIsu1o.siinoo

n&1W .m3ldolq gnion&ufl 1o 3qi 3Idiauslq bits oiasd 13 £ 31u1q53 2floiiqmU2Zs 3231ff

113(11 3151213V0 01 3n3bn31 £ 3v511 111w 213RflBffl n!3f1Snfl 101 21o123vn1 3biaiuo fuif13So1qqE

sm 21o123vn1 3b121u0 3111 2ifft gniwonA .nom iom 3aisl 01 l3blo lii 2133q2o1q in3mi23vni

8

Page 11: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

-S

3111 iol nionsnñ lo Jinu I nscli 3iom m3iil nivi 13V3 imm 01 2bnuI noilsi 01 bio1 3d

i bhow 3111 lo 31E12 31r11 3111 113(1w 1n3rn1vnhov0 niin3v5Iq lo 1118f18d 3(11 2Sf! 2111T .bo1q

.0 21 31s1 oiril 1i 11311w in3mivnh8bnu niws lo 1203 8111 asrl oals 11 lud H

noilsmiolni 10 110i1s!3v51 on ai 313111 (13(1w nir1oiJEI 3ib3lD .a

noial3v31 on 318(1w 3253 8th 18b12n03 121fl w 131 1U0 ir1im ninoiisi woif oT

not813v51 rbiJ2 (1311w worlz 111w I) .noitsmiolni 8lsvnq 21n3ff!3g6f1Sm 113113 01 b32u 318 23(118(132

3bsm 3d lonriso in3ml2ovni 32S3 2ith nI (.1hsir13rnom luo b3IlrI 1wonobn3 818 28(1181132

iinu I 3bivolq zsw1s (I 13thi3 nso 213!onsnfl 8th i isilT .bhow 3(1110 31612 3(11 (10 1113flhinO3

.ru3nsnit lo 2flnu 3bivolq zsw1s ( io nionsnfl 10

no (lnsmiz3vni 1iiini 8(11 lo 13(1 ,

.3.1) 2woIIii2zo 1311 b31oqx3 8111 0flSfI332 18(11101 3111 iii

21 (ii1n61Jp 21111 2r1oIJqmu22S 1311183 1110 lo 3IJIIIV H .1 - 1((q-I) + q) 318 1ooiq 3111

nionnfl 1o iiniJ I 32161 01 3Idi2aOq 3d 2'SW1S Iliw ii 16111 21163ff! 2iflT .8Vi112Oq 3d ol b1n81su

1OI .21313(15(111 3(11 01 21fl8fl3d wofl11253 8111 lo nothoq 1!IJ0ft3 81E1 8 flu11i2ZE (1L8U13811fl03 d 1d3b £ 21 bhI li1 e3ob ifir!1--3fio 1no 3111 21153111 on d duor1i--1osi1rioo 31qm12 3110 3!qff1SX8

31832 3(11 lo 2231b1S31 b33iV132 3d 1183 1361J11o3 ii1T .1 Io 1n3ff16q31 b32imolq s (111w iozilnoo

l3v8iEflw niqA l3brwol 3(11 1111w fl3V3 1sid ol Sl3ionEnfl 8111 2wolts will bnE bIiow 3(11 1o

.13V0 1131 2i

518 2W0fl112S3 bn b3133qx3 3111 231612 us (11 21 in3ml23vni ir1w 0flEfi832 131151 3111 nI

3(11 Ii 3VL1E3n 3d 111w 1i1rtsup 21(11 2norJqmua2s 1311163 1UO n3viE) . - ((q-I) + q)

lsth 8fflU225 111w I trio inioq 21(11 mo1I .llsrn2 11r!3i3fl1u2 21 flIJ33O 0 31612 10 q ii1idsdoiq

3c11--ni3nsnfl lo 211(111 32181 01 21336116m iol 81d12531n1 2111 IsrIl 28ilqrni 2ifIT .3253 8(11 2! 21111

Page 12: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

ni3nsnfl ii iuini sth woii l3flsm on 213i3nEnfl 3(11 sq5I llu1 ol 3zimoIq 1dib313 ionnEo

.3gsl3vE no 2woflrI2so 11uon3 3Js13n3 ton ob 1qmi2 'f1i usd in3ffl3flST1S

ro m3ldotq 3n3\noiism1o1ni 3(11 inr1o r1oi1s!3v3 flioriliw isril i 3ni! rnoliod dT

.0 81S12 ni wol I1fl3i3lTt3fli i 1nrnivni 3i3rIw bns b3r1oiiE1 i iibio 313(1w noiisuii2 ol bI

m8r132 npi3EI3v5r lo 211m11 34T .D

Ion ai noilfimlolni 3isvhq 13nrn 1s3d 2i1ue1 8vods b3dhoe3b 3f13i3fl13fli 3(IT

b nOil23up 3r11 isi 2irIT .31E12 3(11 riO b3noiiibnoo Ion 33(13(1 21 IrI3mI23vni bns b3iio1qx8

bn,s noiImioIni 2e13EflEffl 113113 ol 3m3(132 3v11r13311i fiB 321J ol 31dB 3d Ir1im 3(10 18(113(1W

.223112o3 Ion lud 31di2aoq zi airil 1I3n nI .2noi2ib In3mi23vrn 13fl3d Asm d313r1i

.oe ob ol 3Idsli23b 3d Ion sm 10 'Bf1I Ii noiiEm1o1ni 3111 113113 01 2! ii 'Ii2o3 won no nibn3q3U

its 3)Ism 01 b3Aas 315 213EflBffl IsrlI 3fflU22B I ion1a 1d li3nIl 23rn31132 noiisL3v3l vi oT

2i111 diod Isdi bits 33s1q 23)151 ln3mi23vni 31o13d nioilsrniolni 3jsvhq li3rII lo In3m33fIuofInB

nsm 2jf1T .b3jth3v 1223II2o3 3d riso 3151a 3111 lo noilssils3i 31sm111u 3111 bits in3m33nuonns

313(1w (is)w rn-iol 311110 In3nrP(sq 3vi1n33fl! its aigsnsrn vi ol 31d!2s&t 'llB1J13HI1flO3 2111 IsrfI

O � (s)w isill 21 jnjsi12o3 1no 311T .31532 bi1si r1I 21 1 bns 1n3rn33nuOnfls 113111 21 B

.1111w fli3d 01 (IWO 113(11 lo (11153w 0(1 3VS(t 213SffBffl 33(112

3d laum 13S1tSffl B I211I .b&1211B2 3d i2urn Isill 21(115112(103 3Vi1fI33f1i Owl 315 313111'

:3253 3(11 2! 21(11 (13(1w 8 21 31512 3f11 isdi nuonns 01 nu11iw

(I) + (fl0)w � + (aa)w

01

Page 13: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

IJ

C9IJ jcq 10 CLGqII LP0IJ1U 9uq !UGWC!GU( IIJAC2(WCU( HOMGACL (jIG UJ9U OCfl2 O (JIG bsbGL

BIG 91191A212 OAC JJJfl2(L1C2 JIOM !UOLWOU 911q GUCA bLopJcw2 HI GX(GW9J UU91JCC

V V221WD(10U2 1pOn( JJCgdrIffl4GL2, f1(JJOiJ(A !UCCU(!AG2 91Jq W0U!(OUU cbpJJi(IG2

1W BIG KOIC 01. COthOL11C cqdnm(GL2 Hi 911 JU(GUJ9J Cb!(Sl j9G(

01 !''WJ'J1 12 9JM9A2 J' LG9LqJC22 O (jIG 2W1G

.LP'2 LG((1W2 fl2 (0 (JIG i1JOLWOUJC22 201fl(!OU q12cfl22cq pOAG' MJJGLC (JIG JGAGj

LGUJ91IJGL O (JiG b9bGL 0Cfl2 niA S((GU(!OU 011 2IICJJ C72c2' MJICLG LGAGJPOU 2CJJGIJJG2 91G U0( rt2Gq

LGJ11ACJA 211J8JJ OL 2 12 LGJ(iAGjA J9LC Ju OLGL (0 2iWbjiA (JIG GXb021(!OU' I MIJJ OL (JIG

moqi b(%(A1 - A') - j) BI!2 iwbJ!C2 1P(!( MllJ UO( pc MOL(JJ ft2HJ LGAGJ(!OU 2CPGIJJG b 12

(J-b)2(A3 - A) BIG PGUCW2 9LC (JI( OIJG C91J UOM HJAC2( 3 111 2W(C 0 1u2(Cq Oj)f12( J BI!2 12

BI112 111 911 CX 9U(C 2GU2G (JIG C02(2 0I CIJCWU 11JOLWflOU 14L0W (JIG 1JJ91GL LG

O2G( (JIG qqcq buA(C PCUGW2 (JJ( JIG bnC2 rib pA qoiu 20

jOL Aojnu(914jA CPO02!U (0 IUAG2( oujA j 1U2(C O 3 1l 2WIG B 9i1 (p12 OUI12 JJ2 (0 GXSC(JA

= e(A3 - A') JjI!2 JI2 911 UW1(jAG IIJ(GthLCW(joLJ (JIG UJ91IGL JJS2 (0 pc 1AGU 0UI12

MA Oj (JIG G0112(LSjlJ(2 2 (0 2C( M(O'a) = M(oB) = M(B'G) = 0' tcuq (0 2G(

II !2 C92A (0 2CC (J( O (JJG2C (MO COIJ2(WjIl(2' oiijA (i) MJJJ C p1uqflI BIG JOMC2(-C02(

M(CJ'Q) + 2A 5 M(B'Q) + 2A' ()

c2C:

ccouq' (JIG IJJ91GL Wf12( G M!jju 10 UUOriUCG (Ji( (jIG 2((G 12 0 NJCU (p12 12 (JIG

Page 14: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

I&n3ini n thy 2i33oIq nionsnfl d b3ithv3lls I1sthq 3d (1E3 2cnsfdrnq 3rfi 131119(1w A2s 01 21

zbnul 92th1 13no1 on aisn&n ioiq Isubivibni ihsm 1511qs3 lsrrI3lni ifs ru .13)hsm IRuiqS3

"213nslJpbs9rl 91sIoçzo3" 13msn ;n33w18d-0 £21513111 ii11s$I .21o123vn1 3b121uo rnotI I1ostib

2bnul 1i no1s 23E mm ni isrli bits 11ism 3bi2luo 11 diiw 2tsb lsrll 213J1supbsd WOfi 2111

.2133o1q Isubivibiti 01 zzisi ii

asd 313(1 3izsr1qm3 I Isili i3thsm Lsliqso Ism3lni its lo ai33qas 3111 1o 3110 O niwo11oI

b3wobn3 21 213tisupbsr1 i3*[smn 1511q53 Ismn3lni its itt 11s3fli33q .eir1ri 1011(103 (111w ob 01

3looM bris tisH bits (ô8Q1) tisH bits rlsma2oli) lo 32(132 3111 ni) IolJno3 10 21(IgrI L6ubi23i illiw

3253 3(11 iIiiw 212s11no3 2111T .213225 to1q 1n3up82du2 ns bits in3isq Lcilini 3(11 13V0 ((OQQI)

.21r1n 1011(103 1111w b3wobn3 StE 2l3gSuISffl lo3tolq 31311W 11i3f1Sflfl 1sfl131X3 to

libsI3 lo 3s11 I3131qmo3 113211 2SW 213t1511pb53(1 31510(p03 Isili b3(flU22S 0216 3W iii

og I 313H .rloii23up Ri z133otq 3111 itt lz3vni 01 2bnul b3limilnu bsrl 2SWI6 Ii .3.i--21f1L6112fl03

wilT .RWO alt lo 23311J0231 On 2511113211 213115Upb53f1 Isrtl 3111U225 I .3m311x3 isloq if11o 3111 01

L81311511fl 3bi2flJO 3(11 mnrnl 123vrn 01 231121w Ii abnul ns 32L61 01 asml 11 1n3m3sn5m 133 joIq 3)111

--2rn3ldolq ns 01 138Ldu2 oals ai 1n3m3smism l33tolq 3)111 a13nsupbs3d 13V03l0M .13*ism

3d 111w orlw 01 25 noiai38b Isilini its nb1sm as l3bnlJoI 3(11 lo )1riirll 1153 3(10 23253 iilod nI 3310113 isdI 3)1sm 111w l3brwol 3(11' .13SnSm lo3loiq ei11 io a13tisupbs3f1--a1rfI 1o11no3 b3ni22s

15(11 nimuas ins I (1i3i1qmi2 ioI .awoflrlaso (3IdsiIri3v) 1311 b3133qx3 a3simixsm 1131(1w

15(11 niugis d bsi1snoi1zi 3d 1i1im aiifT .l3brwol 3111 moil lonlleib 13131qmo3 ai al3tIsUpbs3Ii

ill 3Sfi3 01 .3.1--dOl a13tisupbs3l1 ob 01 b3b33n 211th 9111 3V511 loft 230b l3bnuol 3(11

2l3tisIJpbS3(1 15111 rumua2s oats rris I .15no12281o1q 3bi21u0 its 3Efl3 laurn auth bns--nno1inom ni1jri ms I nifl9a 133o1q-81qi11um s ni aui1T .ai3snsm 133o1q Lsubivibni 3111 ff011 13(1112kb 21

111w i 133joTq lo 135ifEff 8111 52 1st11 1i1idiaaoq 3n13mnm'as (nu129i31ni 1tsI1n310q) 3111 luo 3111 1111w 1sb 01 b3l3woqm3 3d 3101513111 bits

, 13eoiq bits I 139o1q rllod lo lo11noo fl3Vi 3d

Isili niurs d b3siIsnollsl 3d 1rlim airli nisA .21ootq owl 311110 11sd3d no 13*Ism 9bi2luo

01 3Idsnu 3d bluow 1i isrll 11u1 02 abnsrl 113111 3v511 a133oiq Isubivibni lo 213SitBff .2139o1q 131110 lOliflOffl 12U03fl5i1Uffli2

Page 15: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

3vs11 oaLR 111w 213risupbslf is1u3thsq it! .i*ism 3biajuo &h lo saodi moil 8gl9vib aia3l8ini au

.loljno3 au l3bnu aiuoai 3rIi rriimixsm iol 33rx313131q 5

3101 1u132u s flio 31Ln bluow znoiiqmuaas lo atioa 3adu usili isqqs idim ii, ilauld laifi IA

01 332 bluow 13*tsm lsiiqso Isrn8ini its siv 133 oiq £ ni3r1sr1iI .ai3AlEm 1Su!qS3 ISrn3iIli ioI

auoivdo 'ens luodliw (a131isupbsr1 ,

.3.1) 3ns lo iss1 bnooa s lo rloiJs3t3 sill v1ovni

3(11 ff1 losrioD ai oio1 aith 1i-is1nsmom ssa 111w sw as bssbni bnA .alllsrisd nIJS2n3qm03

2i33oiq sigiulum isvo Io11noo ft3V1 21 tisiisupbssd nsilw isvswoH .sas soiq-s1gnia

.sulsv bbs anoilsujia 31(102 lii fIS3 lsAism 1Eiiqs3 Lsrnsini its IauosnsiIumia

zi3so1q sill lolinom 01 ii1ida sill asri als11supbssrI iaiiq .awollol 25 315 aoiui3eqa silT

aisltsupbssrl 25VI ii bits i33o1q isq 310 laoo llsma £ asvlovrn nhoiinoM .iol sldiaflOqa5I 2f ii

aisrisupbssrf wolls a1ilh 1011(103 all bnos .bhow sill lo sisia sth lo lsngia (aion 1diaaoq) £

.ffisnsd sisvnq sill lo I > ftOii3Sll 5 ifl3ffl35f1Effl u33o1q (11011 susnqolqqs 13V!i35113 01

a SIR alilsnsd slsvnq Isiot bits 515 awoflhia.s3 sldsflrtsv \13i1duq Ii s1qrnsxs ioI aur1T

.lnsrnsgsitstn u3soiq iol a(i-I) 1no nivss1 qss)1 01 alSg WOn alSlIBlJpb.89f1

15111 bsuis SW sisdT .2O lii SbEm 3(10 ol Isaijnsbi 11silnsaas ai noilqrnuaas islisi airfi'

sifts X3 iid1 s3ubsI oats bluow aisiisupbssd 2ins1 iaoq X5 2135(15ff1 l33rnq ni3ubsi 'd

313(1 idl 31u1q53 oT .iuqiuo lnsrnlasvni 33tJb31 mlii tii urlgtm uilT .110113 rIliol luq 01 2SViifls3fIi

ils 213rts1Jpbs3fl d (133213V0 21 i3501q 5 (1311W Isill 8ff1U22S I sw mioI-b&)ubsl slqmia s iii

31512 3(11 uisrlw WIlT .10111103 isgsrisrn lo 3253 3(11 01 sviislsi I > A 101351 s d Itsi awofldas3

aistisupbssd A sis 2w0fl11253 sldsilrtsv bsv1ovrn a! aisrisupbssd bits 1 ai lrisrniasvrn H 21

.,Aa(-I) lo lifsnsd sisvhq s a1s issnsm i3sio1q sill bits 1a 1o iflsiisd susvrlq s a1s

sldsflrtsv b,v1ovni ai aisrisupbssd bits 1 21 insmiasvni D 21 sisia 3(11 113(1W hs1imi

Page 16: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

in&n bo1q 3111 bnB ,

lo ifl3n3d 3lsvhq B 21 e13tisupbsr1 s)! 518 2woflr123

(11kw 21 13v31 1n3m123vni 3111 n3rfw 23iIqqE noilBion 2uOoIsr1A .1Ae(-I) lo 1fl3n3d 3ISVflq . d 31 1w'13v3 b33B1q31

21ollno3 21311supb.s3r1 31311w S3 3f11 ni i1no lnBv3I8l 21 3bsm 3d 01 f!oilqfflu2aS Isrifl 3ffT

thothuE 9111 213llEiJpbf1 vi ir1h 10111103 1i Isrit 3f1J22S I aso 21111 nI .z133o1q 3IqiJIIJm

ii 1o11noo 11si1ini 213tiEupbsr1 Ii wIlT .1oiq Isubivibni iol nibnu1 lo 13v31 3(11 3200113 01

lo 2linu it isi ol "Lc13351103" 2s in1sq 3i1l u 01 bI$nsm woIi3moz asd bits aln33Sq

a13o1q 3(11 lo r13s3 3vi ns Ii :23310113 lo l3dmun £ asri Ii 13*Isrn 3bialuo rl3 moit nionsnfl

nibnu1 on m11 lo at 13(130115 aiinu msrli lo fn 3V1 (153 Ii 10 fli3f1BfIi1 10 linhi I (I13BX3

ns qu 3bivib rts a13r1supbs1i abiow 131110 nI .linu I m3lii to (mi-n) bits 13v3021Sf1w

.23200113 02 liii a1o1q 3111 220135 '1n3V3nu 32i61 ol 31dB nd asrl Ii 2331U0231

mail al3llBIJpbB3fl 23112i1JfluJ2ib ai33O1q 220135 23311J0231 3flJdrIlaibsI 03 3nort3us 3dT

nivi qu bniw sm al3flsupbs3fl ni1udi11zib31 8 .Ansd £ 25 113112 '(lsib3ml3irn i311w0-fl0n s

2I9IlsiJpbS3fI 31qmsx3 ioI .23fl01E-b11532 as nisido bIuo3 3111 115111 ni3nsnfl 2231 213301q 31(102

01 flO abitul 323111 aasq 113th 1id abnu1 nisldo 01 i inisq to 31J[SV [613361103 9th no wsib sm

aid3 ob 10111153 Ansd A .ob 01 nidlon 111kw 1 133o1q lo 13BfIEffl 3111 nivs31 133o1q 131110115

3113 gnhlBi moit 13SflSat 333o1q fl3vi ns 1n3v31q 03 lr1h 3111 3vsli ion a3ob ?InBd £ 3211533d

nI .1sb 31dsIovsI stom s )1332 01 13*ism 3b!aluo 3113 01 nio bits 210111103 311 IBIII ln3lsq

atilt lo 1iviau13x3 320ffl1 01 Ii 31(15113 air1h 10111103 a13J1supbs3r1 15(11 f1ifflU22S ats I 1azi3n03

3100M bits risH lo thiqa 9th 111 ri3um (I3V a! noitqmuaas wIT ô.al3gBftsm 133 joiq no 1102

fiB Ilk '1iviau1ox3 113112 10 33flS3i1if1i2 3111 flO 3v1333q213q 11131311kb s iol (8QI) 19n113[) 83 .i3Alsm Isflqs3 1srn3ini

II

Page 17: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

01 ii1ids 2i11 i is its Io inwo r1i d b3eaoq irIsh 31o2 th..." :isth 3thw oriw (OQQ1)

(11 I .q) ".ias isdi 10 au 3rti moil 2l3rIio 3bu13x3

:13tIsupbsd 3isloq1o3 iuods 3bsrn ni3d 2noiqmus iftstioqmi iuol 515 st3fh jnua Ii!

31(15 X3 '2bjoiq iuods noiisrniohni 31UJ35 flRZ) ii bno3 .nwo all lo 23311J231 on asil ii iaii1

b3izoaas aiiI3n3cI 3isvhq di lo 315(1 2 £ 31u1qs3 01 ii wolls aiu1h Ioiunoo all b1h1T .2133q20Iq

aisnsm ioiq niiuIib lo iao 3(11 15 amo zirli ,l3v3woff 233213VO ii i33o1q RB illiW

.2ia3o1q 220135 2331U0251 3iUdfliaib3l 0111 wolls ozls aicIri 1011(103 aft rlrrnol briA .28v1f133fli

nuiia ioig-3no s iii ihsm lsiigso 1srrl3uni its lo viithmiigo-dua 3dT .I

3(11 or iohmni a'swIs ai ihsm tsnqs3 1srn3hni its Isili 15313 ai ii anoiiqmuaas 3(11 nviD

23v11n33ni aisgsnsm io1q lo noiiulib rfi 1Ls lo iaiiT .griiiia i33o1q-3no Liii 33±iEm 15m3ix3

d b33ubsi 3d 111w iuqiuo ifl3(fli23vni lo 13v31 fl3v! fis iol isili ans3m 13*151(1 lsrrI3uni (15 itt

bits nnorinom ml rnainsrb3m s as beau 3d wodsmoa bIuo3 2l3tIsupbs8rI Ii wo14 .)L 101351 s

aqsrh9q aJnizfl2no3 iib3i nies d318rfi bits ihsm 3bieilJo 3(1101 noiismiolni 11ii53irnJfnmo3

3is3inumrno3 ol bnibni siom Ofi 3d iliw 2l3tIsupbs3d 13v3woH .132110 3d bluo3 1203 airfi

.aI8snsm 13v31-138(olq 111w nsrll 13*1.sm sbiaiuo sdi diiw 11u1r11ini

b3v2do asd bits 1203 nnoiinom 3r11 Anua asri al3flsupbs8Ii 15(11 rIIUaaS air1i a oT

un3m3gsnLm i3o1q 3)111 32i1sd is12 3111 tIoqsl 1iano11 ion Iliw ii .H 21 31512 3LJ1I 3113 isrii

01 iit3mla3vrn smm 213131q asw1s ii 33(1311 bits iuqiiio 01 Isnoirioqoiq 315 21i13f13d 3isvnq all

21(115112(103 1ib313 10 iioa 311152 3111 1i35X3 3351 Iliw al8llsupbS3Il isdi ai 8(111 rnoiiod 3dT .2231

3d 13V3fl Iliw al3ilsUpbL3fI--13*isffl 3f11 1111w 1jiib ils8b 3d Ii bluow gsrism i38o1q 3(11 isili

Page 18: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

V3151 31r11 3ffi 10 21b1s31 rn3nEnit 3b121uo lo iirw I nsth atom i131 01 3Ids

3)IIJ .ftOiiBIb3fffl3ifli Lsionsftfl 10 2ia'1sns (48QI) 'bnomsiU lo 1n3321nim51 21 11u231 2IrIT

1aiiqso &Ii n33w13d 'lsib3m'13ini ns ni2oq13in1 isril losI Hj 2l3bizno3 1iioiIqx3 bnomsiU ob I

ms 3(11 ol mid 2bs1 21ff!' .3n3g 10 is1 bno £ 23is13 2lo1q Isubivibni bits ihsm

.333o1q 31m2 s e33nsnfl Ino ii 11311w b3lsrtimob s1i3 12 21 V1s1b3m13if1i (IS 15(1l--fl0i2tJ13n03

iil 320(11 moil 1n313111b VI3v 315 31311 Zno!21J13no3 r1i isiil duodi b3ion 3d bluoil2 II

1I33 3uIsv bbs 233ns12mu31i3 'nsm ni bluo3 33*tSm Lsliqs3 1.Brn3ini its iqsq lsiIi flI .220

b3mua2s w 220 ni 3ausd iisq gis1 111 21 aii11 riisA .l33rnq 31f1i2 s '1no b33ftsnfl ii 11311w

8.213tISupb5311 3lslopo3 lo 13v31 3111 is 21n 51121103 iibi3 ssws

21311111w nbbig :1uo231 b3xfl bits 2io1g 3IgiiIum thiw 21tisupbs3r1 lo 3101 311T .D

(21oI flD13Ii2 bits)

ii Mow9msiI in5rnJ3 Ii iii 9111sv ns 3vstf 01 13*ism L6iiqso Isirl3ini its iol l3blo nI

01 Iu132u 2111 hs1o izom io1 rll oT .a1oq 3IqiiIum ni3ffsnfl 111 bv1ovni 3d izum

(13111w lo d3s ,

j bits I 2i33o1q owl 12u1 315 313111 isth aoqqu .3253 3Iqffli2 S(13V £ (Iliw 11512

15111 21 2133 joiq owl 3111 n33wi3d 3311313111b Ino 3(IT .3vods noii3 lii b9dh329b 25 '113EX9 21

Ill 23m3r132 fI0iis13V31 101 1Siin3lOq 3(11 biS312ib 01 231rn 11103 3110 25 sf101 02 3U11 21 2iflTv

3ismIiIu bits 2no12133b irr3mi23vni 113(11110 bsd 219Sfl5 01 3bsrn 315 23fl95 3v11n33111 dairIw (Ii 3sinsvbs its 3VsrI '(Sm zl3ttsIJpbs3rI 113111 tnsv3131 315 29m3r132 f13u2 1! .2w0flf1253 b3i1s31 lo 110113511 £ 23Vi3331 '(1110 213115Upb5311 32u533d 21 2iflT .fIifl32 133t01q-3f10 S (Ii 1Ii2tE1-bflIJ1

fiB 321v3b 01 '(13203 2231 3d 111w ii will ;ln3mi23wth9vo iiiiw b3351302a6 21113113(1 3iSvflq 3(11

3U221 21(11 310ni I .2133q2o1q 211 gnhlsi2l3vo moil al3rIsupbs3rt 23g511Jo32ib isth 3m3r132 3ViifI33fli .2W01101 lsdw ni

ai Ii lniziiano3 11b313 oft 23351 2l3flsupbs3fi 313(1W ,QQI) vivs$I bits zmsH ni hsLimi28 .nui132 133o1q-3no £ 11! I13V3 3101 8ldEUlSV s '(slq 01 31ds

Page 19: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

13i3!qmo3 ls owl ii bbnI .b31s!31-1o3 li113q ion 8Th A3od2 'iivL13ubo1q ii1i

&ndw 10 8Ib1s31 q i 0 3ii lii ni8d i ioiq lo ii1idEdrnq 3111 isrli oa in8bn3q3bni

eijo1q owl 3111 lo 13diii 2loiinom el3flBupbs3d n3dw 11sni1 .213v 331V bnB fli 2i j i33OTq

.1133113q 81E12 3(11 3'fI3ado n il

no bnu 13d3oi a133o1q owl 8111 riifluq 31311w 32S3 £ l3bi2no3 I nid 3m11 8(11 io1

21oIino3 Ii 21n81sq owl 3111 flO bsd ai isdT .2inisii2no3 1ib313 ILSi3vo 32S3 ion ob Iooi

ii lo 21b1s3i 1*ism 3biailJo 3111 moil nibnu1 lo 2linu lix3 232 'HI E'Sw1R 213l1Supb3r1

3(11 (l3ViO .323 3v11S'fl32fl03 3d 21111 11-ior12 is13 siom 3mod 111w 2A .noiismiolni

01 no b3i131 3d n.s 2sw1J 2iol23vni 3biaiIJo j3bom 3111 RI gi&n isdi loivEd3d mUfldIliUp3

Ri 23311Si2f111J3113 3(1102 3d 1zi3n ii 11 1w 31&11 I3vcrnoM .nibnij1 lo 2iinu ias3I is 3bivo1q

b!uo3 21oiq Isubivibni 3dl isdw lo rnua rfi risth iom 3215101 31ds 3d Iliw 213ttsupbslf (13111w

110 1S301L6 [531q53 1sm3ini 01 1113n3d in £ ln3mu3ob nso no ii i3v3woH .nwo li3lii no 32L8I

l3woI 3vifluini bns 31qm12 £ sbivoiq Iliw airli 31dshisvs o31uo1 llsivo (Ii 8nS(b £ luoiiliw

sin rnm 3111 (II enirfi 3voiqmi tiso 13*LSm 1siiqs3 Ls1r131111 its (1311(11 won ioI bnuod

EW 1no 3111 n1iiw *10W 01 23311J0231 31O 3v511 Ion ob ihsm Isrri3ini ns isril n8V10

3Iqrnsx3 iol wr1T .'1in3i3ifl3 310(11 23311J0231 323113 233530115 ii Ii zt 2r11111 3volqml riso Ii isrll

bns ,i ni 2iirw 123vn1 1r1im 2l3tIsupb53f1 31512 111 21 i33rnq bns 0 31532 (11 2i I i33o1q Ii

310m £ 1351 lii 21 21111 15(11 31(111225 izum I nhi2313i11I 3d 01 rn3ldoiq 3111 iol 13b10 nI . ni nir1ion

tsniism 3111 biow 13(110 nI .2io3o1q illod ni inuoms I511p3 its nil23vni rtsrll (10115301151(13131113

1mm 12111 3(11 110 fnui3l 1sniism 3113 nsrli 13is5I 3d 12mm 1 iii b3i23vni 1mm bnoo32 3(11 no niu131

. < ( - io j iii b3i23vni

1203 3(13 )lnu2 2511 ii 33(10 11iw 2l3tIslJpbs3d lsrfi iuo ennui ii b3i12iise ci noiiibno3 thfi II

Vt

Page 20: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

lr1n 3111 01 2331110251 b3xfl 211 51so1Is 01 e8vilnsoni iqoiq 3111 3v511 bbni nholinom lo

01 Isnoihoqolq '1j351ib SIS 21113n3d 3lsvhq '213t1supbsr1 32nsd 1qmi2 21 2ifIT .2ijo1q

0218 111w 213115upbs311 lflsr18d 3lsvhq 21i 3S1rn1Xifl 01 aiiqm311s iii urfT .2woflhias3 133o1q

.3111Sv wofld2s 8ldsilh3v 23ximixsIn 15(11 jn3mj23vrti 10 xim 3111 A31q

1203 nho1inom i1i Ani2 01 3bib bbrii 111w 2l3risupbs3ii Isill 1h3v 01 2f115ffl51 n3(I1 II

15111 21fl3n3d 3lsvhq ni 3as313n1 3111 01 3viisI3l ll.5m2 2i 1203 21111 Ii 13v3woH .l33O1q 13 3 lo

iol Ismilqo 113n12 3d 111w ii 2noiaib ic1h 8th gnblsm molt 213tIsupbsd 01 23111335

jEdi 02 noiiibnoo lo 1102 21(11 23fl21152 3 isrIi 3ffl11225 I f1t10133f13H .loiinom 01 2l3ttEUpbE3Il

.nho1inom iii 23Ef!3 2sW1s zl3nslipbs3d

El3tlSIJpbE3fI 311(1W :233m3 fliioq 1s13n3 £ b3i1(12 13m511x8 21 l3bom 3111 f1uodl1A

1ibi3 33s1 01 3V511 111w 3311311 bns--2ioiq 211 1o 116 111 3I3VE no 123vnh3v0 01 insw 111w

nsido 23ob ii 2bnlJl 3(11 1311115(13 01 3Viifl33fli 3moa 2511 11il ii--13*Ism 8biaflJO 3(11 molt 2111151121103

(go1on1m13i 9111 rlliw lulsts3 lid S 3d bIuorl2 3110) .tI21o1I molt sws bits "21311111w" 2blswoi

1o linu I 28V!3331 Ii n3flw VTT4 3Vin2Oq 21 i33o1q 8-31i2 "13201" 8(11 113V3 331112 5I3(1

21 135f1Sffl 133io1q Isubivibni its brts 213t15upb.6311 n33w13d noil3nui2ib 18131113 3(IT (.ln3ml23vni

IE13y32 molt 21fl3113d 315vng 8vr13b 01 ii 2wolls 10111103 lo rtsg l3bSOld 21811EupbS311 lsth

31n12 s molt aiiI3nsd slsvnq 3vrI3b 1no riso 13SflBffl 138j,olq 5 811(1W 12U08fl511Umi2 2i33o1g

s molt sws 2bnul 3)151 01 ni11iw 3d 23mil3mo2 111w 213t1511pb5311 15111 Z3iIqmi 211IT .13o1q

133o1q 13)153W 3111 lo 135nSffl 3111 31111w 3fl0 13gn0112 5 01 srnm 8Vi 01 13b10 111 i3o1q 13)153W

.02 ob 13V311 blijow

(3vthq213q 213bnu01 £ molt) nis 31115 X3 3111 3151113153 01 b1svno11f1is1J2 21 II

Isrn3ini liZ 01 13*lsm IEtri3ix3 115 111 gni3ftaniI l33jolq Isubivibni molt nivom iliiw b815i3o22s

81

Page 21: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

in biqx Isioi 1i i*tsm 1Brri3ix fiR nI .218tIsupbsd d ivo b3bi25tq iAism IRuiqE3

:d nvi i M3 d b3iori8b io1q owl 3rfi moil njqtuo

() (I - ((q-I) + q)1) = M3

2swL6 2i3o1q owl 3f11 10 113R3 i3*Iflrn Isrr1ix3 ns ni iEfi 1361 &fr aifli () noiisup3

d b3ion3b iuqflJo 13n b3iqx3 16101 fli isAisrn Iflrnini n ni iz13no3 nI .1 '1i3SX3 2i2Vfl!

:d nvi 21 MI

(4) -

A(q-1)q + 1Aq + 1A(q-i) = MI

A iolosl noiiulib-floIl3 9th 21 i3f1i lIi1 :w owl ni (F) mrnl 213Thb () noilsupa

--293612 1n813111b ni is 2io1q owl 3111 n11w bno3 .MEI n&li s1 MI 3)lsm ol ebn3i 113111W

lb 2.iinu 23vi3331 0 33612 Iii 21 fI3ifIW 133jrnq 3f1i--(q-1)q ii1idBdrnq 1111w zrl9qqsd (131(1w

noiJs3ollfl b3vrnqmi 2irfT .Hs ii 1n3m129vn1 on vi3i H 31612 fl i3oiq 3111 311(1w 1fl3mJ29vni

noii2 1ifl3i3fl1hJ2 21 133113 131161 11i n3uIW .M3 risth is MI 1sm ol 2bn31 smoi 10

ni3nsnfl lb 3bom b5rrn1Iq r1i 3d 1163 2i3r!Bupb63ff 'd b31312ir!imbs 13*IEm IEuiqB3 16(1131(11(16

b9i6l3n floilRfIrIoIni 3(11 no 136 oi 28v11f133fl1 ir1n 3(11 26(1 2131-IsupbE3rI ud 21 21111 fIISA

516 isth 2io3o1q 2blswol 2bnuI 13n116f13 01 323131n1 3lEvhq '2l3tIsupb63rI (Ii 2111 .nrIoiinom d 9113 lsffi 320(11 moil sw bits 21311n1w

133116 ion 230b ii 92u633d 21 2111T .() ni isqqs ion 2sob 3 1203 nhoiinom di 1&Ii 910W '(Iqmi2 21111 H61rt3m313ni 232fl n3dW .l3bnuoI 9(11 01 31d611flvS 2WOfll1263 31d61th3V 191! 8111

.213116Upb6311 'd b8Otfl3 23(191 9th 01(11 2163

Q1

Page 22: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

21fl3n3d 3isvnq 13r1supbr! niArn cI Sliw3mo gnirfi b3n 3vSfI I 32WO3 10

2331UO231 lo ffiuorn bexif iol irfs iIqmi iiiT .2woffdaso Sjoiq OS Lnothoqoiq Iiib ai2sd 3!T .noiisimixEm 3uIsv thiw 13oEx3 3bi3nio3 111w aiI3ini fli'fl32-1I3 13flJwpbd

:31u1s13111 V3fl3 311110 ff311111 ni iioilqrni i isrti noilon s 31u1qs3 OS i noiSqfnuZ2S aidS 1o oqinq 3rf1 aS33oIq nb1risi n3rfw e313th3nort Sud ivrrh3vo 01 on3bn3S Lsi3n3 £ 3vsrf isrtsm

(48Q1) nozblsnoQ lsiiw 3d os rnz 2irlT .z3no VqM-l3woI 01 ano V1T4-13r1iff 13151q OS bn3i

i Si bnA °'."rIiIs3w 3SsioqIo3" 3ximixsm OS 2)1332 2igcnsm isrtS 2311315 3(1 n3ffw bnim iii asri

LsrrI3Sni IuIiin3Iq isdi 311315 05 ai3dio bns (F'.QQI) R32fl bol asrl Isfil 3aim3lq 10 hoz 3111 \1i3SX3

2523135n1 l3bIod3IEda bn.s Ish3gsnsm 1133w13d 83n3gi3vib s 315313 05 '(13)11 siom ai woflrlz53

'.a3ilifwtloqqo Sn3mia3vni 3vii3siiis w31 13vi1s131 3vsfI a3insqmo3 n3flw

yliasx3 315 awoflr1as 3Idsilil3v bus aSfl3n3cI sisvnq isiil noiiq(nu225 3(11 S(1lE31D

1om a3nirii 3)15(11 01 bow 1no ai bus 3d OS 2b33n ii risiii 3rn311x3 3lom i Isnoitioqoiq

fiB (Iflo 21 513(11 31311W 3253 3(11 13b12fl03 OS I3bom 3115 31I.613ff33 \Ii2S3 (153 3(10 .inszsqansii

b15w1o15113is1i2 alt! .awoflrlaso 3Idsith3v bus aii13n9d 3isvrlq n33wS9d 3an9bnOqa3TIO3 533113qmi

d3uothls 113w as aso aith ui 3uIsv bbs a3mil3moa ([53 13)115111 1511q63 lRffl3Sfli us Isdi worfa OS

31dsIovsl iol b3533132 ai 1joiq lsfu3irIsq £ 113(1w 23(1115 3d Iliw 513(11 won :2231 abb.s 'lls3iq'(i Ii

iloirfw 13V0 (15153w isrfr ai iiS1sw 3SsloqIoD" :awollol as at floiiiflfl3b anoab1snoU iol xfls3I1in3ia all bns lnioq aia1i lo noilslodsI3 RE iol ".

. .10111103 3V1i33113 asri ifl3m33sflEffl

.(QQ1) a13M oals 332 311i13uIi2 1551qs3 Ismisqo

.211u231 islimia os abs3I 15111 noiishimiol 3vIisrn3iIs 115 b3i2ua asfi wolqsA aiuoJ' wofidas3 dj nsrfi 1311151 b3523vn1 lrnioms 3(11 03 IsllolflOqolq 31S 231133d 3isvhq 35113 320qqu

lo 31532 3(11 Suods 131Uq 3153 21335115111 3flO1S 25ft3f13d 3SsvFIq no b32sd lsffS 02 b33IJbO1q

lnuoms Ilsrria £ 233Ub0fl11i 311011 n3flT .VqT4 all OS as lnsI3lIibni 13i31qmo3 sis bus Sn3mS23vni VqM-13r13i11 iovsl aisnsm 1sm OS bn3i Iliw aith noilsan3qmo3 3v11n33111 b3asd-)13o12 lo

3111 isnimi! 01 d3uon3 Son ai noilsan3qmoo 3viin33ni r1S Ii fl3V3 23110 VqM-13W01 13V0 2133 jolq .Sn3mia3vnh8vo abiswoi asid 15131133

o

Page 23: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

—S

2i3'ulo ii 321JE33d 1qmi2 irI1 thsm ion ob 2wofl112s3 211 11311w 113V3 2u1S12 nibrnit

.213nIupbB3d ol 2ifl3n3d 3iBvhq c1ir1 13isnoii1oqo1qaib

fl0i22U32iU .U

Vlubw i2om 3d 213*tBrn Isiiga3 11fl3irn 111w 11311W .1

IsfrI3lni T3bnu 2ninu3li3 1i iuods anoiisi1qmi b1swiobf1isii2 ar1 I3bom 311T

tsrrI3ix3 11,11W .inm3nzns tthorisnfl lo tIo2 ,vifl i2om 3111 d oi bn,i 111w 21,)hsm 1stiqs

nid ern1doiq 'ng bn noiismioIni lo sns 11i ni--t1bqo1vbnu" '(I3viisI5l 5'S 213)hsm

3lom 3d 111w ii nibnid 'cI3V 3101313(11 315 2inlgiieno3 flb313 brLB--b33nuonoiq hE1U31tLSq

.2133o1q 220135 b,isollssi '1irI3i3ffl3 d nso 2bnIJ't b,fimiI ,rIl isdi insuloqmi

110111211511 3(11 fllASffl 121J1 2i Isril '(lifluJO3 ns3qO1U cr131253 11510 )1nid1 223f13i313fl03 io9

3vi1mflq flup 11112 21 o1oncb,1 ni1ibus bns nuinuo33S 3(11 II .mono b325d-13*ism 5

bluow 2 1313m515q 3111 ,

.3.i--21fl3rr3d 3isvnq 110 norfqi2 01 213E11Effl iol 2S3 ii ,lsm idim 21(11

01 2io1q tcubivibni iol btsrf ii ,)lsm bluow cnui tic girfl' .2i33o1q 120(11 iol 1i(I II5I3fl3 d bluo3 213)hsm 1511q53 Isrii1ni 2sons12rnu31i3 1131J2 nI .gni3nEnuI 'to 1v1 123d-121fl rfi izs'iis

.3101 1dsu1sv \(13V £ s1q 11si1ti3ioq

brüI 1riim 13*ism IsfrI3inf ns3qolu3 cr131253 115 111 el3ilSupbS3d f3lqrnsx3 3110 ,1s1 oT

2f1o113!b3lq 31S13n3 if(im ii 25 1r1ri flWO 21i (Ii rni2318ifli d bluo3 noi1sii1sin £ 113LJ' 2wolls ,rioli 1Is3fliq .88213v0 ol 213r1s1ipbad 101 2io1q 'to oiloThoq 1smiiqo ,rIi iuods

3(11 d binsiqi 25) "oIond331 noiisrtqoiqqs 3fl3119d isvnq" 3111 isdi y)iIidi22oq rfi iol 8213 ils isdi i23ue bluow 21(11 2,n12IJbnt lo al33jolq 220135 11R3iiSm3i22 231SV (2 1813mS1Sq

'to 132 S 01 113211 21ri125I 2lstIsupbs3rl cic1w 1irI3i3fl't3 iom b3is3olls d Iliw 233Th0231 Isiip 116 olni b3qolsv8b 3d 1,1smi11u bluo3 nin02S31 10 1102 2111T .2 10 281J15V 1511ffl12 ftliw 2133o1q

15(11 oi (Lsin3m3lqrno3 lud moi1 13n1121b 21 isdI 23ig315132 31510q103 b32U301 iol 1113mUg15

.wo1d VI no i38 cli b81118231q

Page 24: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

1dign&t aa& as 113w as inslq "A3sia3Ioma" blo tsL i to nibnu1 3111 (1133213VO 113211

blo rIi Isril 3d sm Ii woi4 .aiooq in3mqo13vb VLT4-13r1giff bits 3vilsvonni siom Hid

aiasd 3no1s-bnsia s no isth 3ulsv 1s181s11o3 bits woflrks3 in3TIu3 1113131T1u2 asri lnslq A3sJa3Aoma

lo fl3Is3a 11513v0 3111 n3vi 3fnii 352 3111 Is 1u8 .11siinsiaduz 123Vfli31 01 3U11i1fl03 bluo3 ii

2133o1q in3mqol8v3b 3vilsvonni stout &Ii 03 gnibrwl airli fl3vib at 13fl8d 3d ir1im ii 2331UO231

easO s ai airlT .a8noIs-bnsla as 3131 Ii 23v1am5th r1uori niaisi i1u3i11ib 9vsd bluow 113111w

.1u182u F1s1u3iflsq 3d ir1im nD13iq-T3nrnw in 3Sfl3 ol 1i1ids 'al3tiBupbs3rI 51311w

qol3v3b aihsm Lsiiqs3 1.61r131x3 as isdi ai ninoasst lo 3nhl 21± ol 'ts11rno3 £ 321iJO3 10

3f11--b33Ub51 13Vii38113 ai a 1313mz15q 3111 bns a3voiqmi so1oncb3i ni1ibus 3111 , .3.i--3m11 13V0

ol (8qoil io) iqx bluorla no bits b8bo13 3d Iliw at3Alsm Ism3ifli lo 3gRinsvbS 3VliSlsqfflO3

.amifl noizivib-iiIum 3g151 lo qu nb1ssnd 3ffl02 332

al3voIIiga vlibiupil rtsamo3-sI3rtI . 3111 2! 31311 b3qol3v3b (to3r11 3111 iol noitsviiom 8no noii3ubo1inI 3111 ni bion aA

ho 3111 tI al3vohhiqa 1ibiupi1 rnsqmo3-s1ini aln3muoob o11w (4QQ1) lnornsJ lo *tow Is3hiqm3

1I31J2 luods anoii3ibsiq 13v113b lls131i1 ion a3ob 3vods b311311a I3bom 3111 13v3woH .iizubni

01 3IcIsllsvs 23311J0231 ils l3bOm bOrl3q-3fl0 3111 1o 1x3111o3 3113 flI 321J533d ai airlT .al3volliqa

s as iibiupi1 Lsntini iol 3O32 on ai 813111 bits snsnfl Ism3iX3 wn moil 311103 2l3tlsupbS3fl

.bnu1 lo iuoa

grn3d 25 I3bOffl 3111 1o Anidi 01 nOiJsistql3irnst ionim (I3V 5 1no asnupsI ii 131snutIo1

211 is 3V511 111w al3tIsupbs3d nifl32 boh3q-iiIum s nI .al3voIliqa iibiupi1 rnsqmoo-siini luods

as llw as ;a133o1q 10 oilolrnoq all ianiss 82151 1153 ii abnul 1sfll3IX3 W3fl 'ens (1 :rliod Isaoqaib

Page 25: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

Ion aii isrii bns b3Is13n bsiIs 3vBrI ijoiq 3adI isrfi woflhf2s3 (31di1n3v) Isrn3ini flB ( gf1imu2A ios1ino3 Ith3nsiIit ti lo mii fi l3bclu ioiivni 3biiuo th 01 iuo bisq nd i3 b3is13n !Lsm3ini 01 iq2i ibiw sthothus noiiBoolls3i 3m 8th 2Sf! 21311s1Jpbsd isth

Iliw nolis3ilqmi rI3vo1Iiq2-(Iibiupi1 8th e2brnñ bsisi llsirI3ix3 (1iiw 2sob ii isufi 2woflri2so

.wo!IoI

flo2 3r11 10 al3voIliq2 iibiupi1 ns 1bom 3r11 10 noimv Ia3Iqfni2 8th 01 griiblo33A

no Ii 13v3woH .rlion n3-3rl3i3flh3 2S b3i3lqi3ini 3d bluow (1Q!) inomsJ d b3ln3muaob

01 1snoiiioqoiq Ii3rIi2 2sw1.s ion is isril 23113n8d 3isvrlq io1 wolls 01 I3bom 8th a3xiIm3n3g

nsqmo3-s1ini ioI Islin3ioq 3111 31115 x8 :8vri3 1231 81 3d bluow noiiSi3lql3ifIi 8(11 2Woflf12S3

131211511 £ thu2 aso 3fliq2 ns ni iud gsivs no 3ldsuthv 2s n d bhiow 2131211ff11 'iibiupi1

.io3jolq 18cJ £ 3Sib!2dU2 01 31ib 213ttsupbs&1 ifl31 1qmi2 o2L8 ir1im

n lo 31s32 Lsmiicro rfi bits einisituroa $1b813 15fl133x3 lo r10135x6181 311T .E

i(ism 1siigs lsnl8ini

thiol 1om on asri 213rIEupbsr1 isrli bmus asw ii noii3 8vods 8111 lo 2i21sfrs 3(11 iii

23no15-brIsi2 s b33nsnfl 3i3w th Ii bluow 21oiq lsubivibrii 8th n.sth illiw *10w 01 233Th0231

dot lsiied s niob d 3uIsV bbs 11112 1153 2l3risupbs8li 1insiioqmi bnA .1*ism 1SW13IX3 8(11 111

zlstIsupbs3rI Ii 21 Aas ol noi1up IX3n Lsiuisn A .2331110231 lo inuOmfi b3Xfl 8th nuis3olls lo

moil 2331tJ0231 Isiol 810m 32151 01 3Ids 3d 3fl3i3flu3 3V1IS3OIIS 18iS31 2ii lo 3IJI1IV d irigim

3LdsiIn3v wolls llsmiiqo 21o123vn1 3bieiuo 31311W 231qm5x3 331r112n03 01 '(253 2i iI 111w abnul 328th isrli i3ib5lq nso 210i23vn1 3b121u0 II .b3323vni31 bns b3n1s131 3d ol 2wofl11253

3d 01 2bnuI 3(11 niwo11s 3vn33q213q 113111 moil VT4-8viii2oq 21 Isth 'sw £ ni 8W 01 iuq 8(1

.I3bom 3(11 111 3isb Isilini 8th is nionsnfl IsrrI8ix3 W311 nionsvbs 01 3irlcpomo2i 21 11)31115131

Page 26: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

.zisnsm 1o3oiq Lsubivibni rLi bluow nsr(i ihEm 3biaHio ftj

nv jii1 d jdim noiiiip 21111 01 13WZflE 8111 rfw nosi b3is1i Owl 51B 513(IT

1si ns 2l3nslJpbs8li rkMrIw ioI u1sv l3i3mBisq mo 31B 313111 iooiq Owl 12U1 13vo liii

2ifti 13viflulnI .113.63 3(10 321.61 12111(1.63 2133 jolq thubivibrii 3111 n3rfw r13v3 nibnu1 lo 2iirn.J 351111

01 23viinsonI irfgn 3111 asH ii 1.6th n3vii) .a3mo3fllo b3o1q lo n3bn3q3bth 11i lo 32uod 21

thod nsdw 2iinu sir1i illiw ivnh3vo 1no 111w 2l3tIEupb.6&1 213o1q zois 2bnul 31S3o11S

3111 (11 1as-i1no3 nI .(q-1) 1i1idsdoiq 111kw iuo aiiiT .12uo3n.611umi2 8 31.612 (Ii 81.6 2i33O1q

2111330 jn8mj23vnn3vo 133joiq iq ni3rLEnfl 1o rinu &io nsdi siom 21 513(1111 nil132 3noLs-bnsl2

.(q-1) ii1idsdoiq rtliw

£ r1uoic11 b3xs13i 3d 31qi31 q iii bluoo 2inis1ieno3 lib3lo 11.si3n3 iom bns bnO33

513(1w 3lqmsx3 3m311x3 its l3bi2no3 wo(1 a oT .noi1si1i213vib 3Ls32-gis1 lo 3i10q

nI .000! z ar33o1q in3bn3q3bni 11 ii2ii.612 lo l3dmun is1 iv £ 3213V0 2l3Dtsupb.63f1

2i33o1q q000! 1r1uoi niv&1 no lnuo3 nso w 1.6111 21J a111 2l3dmun is1 1o wsl 3(13 32.S3 ziift

lo 2iinu (q+ 1)0001 3V 21 213tuupb(1 Ii wilT .8 ni ai33o1q (q-1)000! ba D 31.612 fil

linu I brui i) 31a12 ni 316 1&Ii 2133ioIq 3111 01 113.63 2iiflhJ 31.63011.6 111w Ii thiw )hOW 01 f113f1Bf1fl

no inuoo (1.63 210328vn1 8b123uo 3.6111 z3ilqrnl miii ni zulT .8 33.612 lii 31.6 Isili 21330lq 3(11 01 113.63

51o13131i1 111w 1n3m123vn1 .0001 I2IJL nEth i3(1tsl (q+ 1)0001 323vn1 r1i Ii I3V3 bthq3l ni3d

.nibnid d ino1 on Iliw 21(11.6112(103 iibsio bns j3v31 123d-i2liI 3(11 01 313VflO3

ni isth or 16limia noil3nul £ 2ffnoh3q nollsofli2l8vib 31532-3g1E1 31qmEx3 2ifIi nI

fljod.6 1f11StI33 133113q 3V.6ff 01 210123Vfl1 3bialJJo 2woll.6 ii--lnsd s 1o l3bom (48Q1) 2bnomsiU

31qmsx3 2irii lii 13v31 123d-121fl 8th 03 1sup3 3d 111w in3mi23vni lo Inuorns 3111 i1uo(1i1A' .)1 1313fflfi16q noitulib-tiolI3 3(1110 3211.63311 13wo1 3d 111w uuquuo

Page 27: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

r1i lo isi 3(11 luods gniifion woml r1i Ii 113V3 iuqiuo in3mivni lo noiiudniib 81 31gg5 3(11

.5Iom ivni 01 ni11iw is 'sr11 iniStI3 Joh3q 21(11 n3viE) .2ioiq Isubivibni

--2io1q iau thiw--isl wiii b3qol3v3b as !3bom 3113 15111 2i23U2 ifl3mu1S 108th! 2i1IT

1511131111 115 to 31532 lsmiiqo 8111 nwob niq of b3liup5I 21 irr3ib3ini l8rIionA .b311i33q2 !1ii1 ion 21

llsbi bliioik miii di isth noiisoilqmi Isui3sh8inuo3 3111 biovs of 21115w 811011 i8)hEm !siiqso

.bis31 21111 111 28i1i1idioq to l3dmun s 8is 31311T .8g151 1hsiiidis 3bsrn 3d

isili 3b81worD13s of 3d bluow Isborn 11i zo1z of sw 1oiib bns 81qm12 120(11 8th 2qSth3

3110 21f11 as f13u2 131)0111 £ ru .2i33o1q 3IqrJIum r1i33213VO iol (i13sqs3 b3iimil 25(1 Ei3iiSIJpbfl3l1

32013 3flup nhc113mo2 10 ifl3S 31fl12 £ 25 2l3tIflhJpbS3ft lo flOiiorl 3111 i(12iJ0fl32 'hts1 3)1St 01 2511

1s3n3to8fIi nih3bnu (15 b 33(132dB 3111 fli--8fflu225 121J1 of 3iBrlqolqqBni 3d bluow II .31 of

18(1113 iuothiw 2i38o1q 1o l3dmun b3iimilrw (18 321'n8qu2 (ISO 21811511pb58f1 isth--noiisoflui2ul

1IJ3 12111 3b1r13 '(13V 5 as wriT .23V1Jfl3311i all nn8iLs 10 1i1ids gnnoiinom 211 m2imo1qmoa

flOtl3fIIJI X3V1103 11i2S313fli (15 2i 3 1203 flflo1ifl0ffl 133o1q-13q 3113 15(11 iieoq !qmi2 iflgim 3110

25W 15111 3253 138i01q- 3111 fli1i32 21(11 frI .213t15Upb5311 d fl332i3V0 2i3301q lo i3dmlJfl 3111 lo

ono 1iaoo \(13V a3moo3d fsth o1ontii rtho1inom s of bnoqa3lloo bluow 8VOds b8IsnE

'.2i33o1q lo 3Iquo3 s bno3d b81Iauq

(183 ei3risupbs3r! isth 1i1idiaaoq 8th iol wolls of 3d bluow rlosoiqqs b3isoiiairlqoa 3101(1 A' 111313111b nnoiinom lo Aasi 3111 of b8is13b al3dm3rn usia 11131311ib thiw 11s3a 13g151 s bbs

of 3vsrI bluow 3110 1iioias1ai1sa aufi I3bom of 321Uo3 10 .aiojo1q etmifl 3111 lo ai8adua

.ifl3fflfloliVfl3 ([B tbua ni 32n5 15111 zm8Idoiq ns lo 213s1 b3bbs 8th 1o iflU0335 3)151 1noi1qx3

SW 3vflsrn8ils (IA .* tow 1r1im I3bom £ 113u2 wofi lo noiaauoaib lsfthIJi £ iol V flo1i33 33 lo 21102 8th of Ls8qqs of 3d blijow 13h5m Lsnqso 18(1131111 11510 31532 lsmrlqo 8th 3ifl80bfl8 01

.(QQI) 13no1s bits 13dm3io5I bns (QQ1) atI3do5I bits moi1iM 183M d 811am 2ifI3rf1JJlS

as ibua i3flWO (is iol olism3ldoiq 3d (Sffl Ii r1w 21102531 fuo tmOq ziqsq 328th lo thofl 11011 38 fli 11513b 310ffl 111 b322U321b 815 3(11 flOiiS3fli2i3Vib 31S32-3151 (Ii 3S(13 01 213115UpbB81i

.W013d U.VI

Page 28: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

13b1131 !nsd s bits Itsijpbsr1 nwi3d noii3nuiaib 3111' •.1

baisi asw isril noiia3up 3111 9looal8bnu I3bom (481) a'briornsiU 01 aio[sr1s auorisv 91ff

luods ii ai isiIW :Iuoi1iioid1 oshua 3111 ths3n3d nbhu1 nd asd isrli bits noil3uboliril 3111 iii

V233o1q (1011530115 Isliqs3 1s(rI3ini 3111 luods 11sfli30qa ii aAsm 15113 i3qsq airll lo l3bom 3111

ni3d as "213J1supbsf1 31stoq1o3" 13dB! I isdw 131q131n1 3(10 l'nbluoo 11n9191uib bisa iO

s mloIl3q 15111 23 £1b3m131n1 31E rliod 11s 1331A cl3bn3I Ansd 3biaiuo its 01 ln3tsviup3

bluow Ii ilsill 1n3i31113 310(11 jn3mje3vni 1sm 01 qI3li 1di2n3iao isili bits nOii3nuI nhoiiriom

.13)hsm IGrri3lx3 111gn31 arrns 3(13 1i b3oIIsnuI 313W 2io3o1q Ii 3d

as b31512 sd 1153 13bn31 !nsd s bits al3rIsupbs3rI n33w13d noil3nuiaib 3111 2m13J bsoid iii

nsrtt 1s3d 01 nibnu1 (13q53113 ias3I Is io) iom rthd 01 ai 1nsd £ lo 3101 '(ismnq 3dT :awolloI

Ansd s 115 ai airli nuii32 abriornsiU iii bbnI .nwo li3rIi rio 321St bluo3 213o1q Isubivibrii 3(11

Its bits ts3iln3bi 31115 X3 515 aI33o1q--13v3oaIsrtw noiiDnul grIbl3iq-l3nrliw OR 21 313111' .aob

01 21 al3tIsupbs3rf lo noi1nii1 nisrn 3111 j3born 'm ni 12s1ino3 nI .nibnii1 lo !3v31 352 3111

01 3Ids 3d oats sm al3tIsIJpbs3H .ai,aol bits 213nniW noms zbnul lo !ooq b3xfl 5 31s3011531

(1E22333fl ils Is Ion 21 airli Ansd s 1111w 1i1nu hid b3isliauILi 1w1 zsw as 21nisT12no3 hibsi3 3258

.3U1SV 815313 03 ii iol

--rbiilw ni 21101111603 (Is1b3m13hni 1sionsrnl b I3bom £ 1n3231q (ô8Q1) 11o3231q bn b'ofl 310ffi 01 nibs31 2110 IsuLsv3 13119(1(111w 31ns X3 b315u1sv3 aI3oo1q--(48Q1) bnomsiU iii 3)hlnu

138o1q ifs hsrli noiiqmuaes 8(11 'd 3ldiaaoq ,bsm ai noijs3olIs3l airlb j3bom 113(11 iii .nibnu1 2noflslJI5v3 3(11 lo 211u231 3111 31013(1 233511(103 nibnid oini 193(13 1153 flOiiiISO3 3(13 fli 213M1Sffl

315 a11uzt 3111 331112 2i1ua81 323111 no b3rloihibno3 3d 11E3 213511(103 3(11 15111 bits riwom1 315 -boa 9111 sw airli iii rnJ3s11r1o3 3b3lqmoo iol wolls 3di 321J533H .31dBflfl3v 1313Lqm03

2111 audi bits a1r1gh qidal3nwo i33o1q lo noliasup 3(13 01 As3qa 11s31 Ion ob alluast ilooa31q 10 13)11Bm LSflqs3 1511133(11 (16 )IftBd S ILJO(JS fl13d 25 b3331q131rn 18333d 515 (3f!1 isilis11w 15313111J

.in3rn3r1sT1s [ISiiOilUflIani 131110 3(1102

Page 29: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

213rIsupb13d isril nb13iq-13rrniw 10 nba 3(13 111 Sfl3 30111153 1qmia lnsd s aiuoa 10

b3xft riliW .01 thof11us 3111 vsr1 tori aob ii vods b3ion as ausd bbom sm ni z3ob

al3aoI gnD1Sm--t1nD131i2-132O1" b3m1i 3d vsm isriw ai r1D131q-13nn1w lo 8bi2 qifl 3(11 2331UO231

ns iio1ns 03 31(15 rii3d z1iupi rriui 111 airiT .23no15-bns1a as bluo3 8f11 nsrfi 2231 1avni

ln3231q ion 313w 31111531 (iiviau13x3 21(11 li io1 .213201 3113 (111w In3ff13(IBT1S fli3flfiflh1 3V12U13X3

2111 lo a1nia 3(13 n1Wom1 i ion brts) 8 3ila iii ai d t&11 nivi3ado 13gSnEm 333101q rw

13viqm3-31q a1i13r13d 3lsvhq aid iioiq 03 noTl3 its iii bluow (anoiaivib 131110 (Ii 231JB3iIo3

.3m81132 fli3fI5flh1-1fl!0t 3111 moil 3b3332

'llsu1os al3flsupb53d isth 11OS3-i 310(1w 3111 oa ob 01 s1hothus 3113 fl3Vi l3vo3loM

oats aidh Ioiirto3 all isth al anoiaib noi1solls ir1h 3(11 23)Ism n3111 bits lolinom 03 23200(13

13bn31 insd sli 113V3 .02 riiob riliw b315130225 ailI3n3d 3isvilq 3111 lo moa 3llJiqS3 01 Ii 31d5fl3

131B3W 3V511 bluow ii noiI53o1[si 331110231 lii 35fl3 03 ihothus 3(11 3vs11 worlemoa bib

iol auc1T .21113n3d 3isvhq ns 31u1q53 ion bIno3 ii 32irnd 2133 joiq 1rth 3(13 13iq 01 23vi1f133111

3(13 diiw b3wobn8 lnsd s iL6ma i1sivh1 3bsm 313W 3 21203 rthoiinom 3113 Ii 113V3 3IqmSX3

".1o1inom 01 ion 3200113 1auon3obn3 bluow al3ilsupbE3fI as o1ond33i ftflOii1iOrfi 3mS2

3v338q231 113113 diiw ob 03 asd 231108(11 owl 3(13 n33w13d noijonilaib 1a3F1Si2 3113 eqsrhs

rliiw ieiiI .çiEib3rnl3ini 3111 d bl3rl 3d 03 "oiioThoq" lo 3q'i !smiiqo 3111 ioI anoiisoilqmi

8111J3E 01 3Viin33ni 13i531 £ it 3V1 air1ri 10111103 alOflBIJpbS3fl isrli 11013011 8I1T 3113 nI .(.tQQI) 3io1iT bits noidA iii bris 2D ni qu ewoda oats 13bn31 lnsd s nsiii noiismiolni

luods nbllsi a'swLs 815 3W isuli 13dm3m31 01 insfloqmi aili i3bom ln3Tluo 3(13 lo lx3inoo 11353 1 10 133O1q 0-31532 £ ItI 13(1313 323Vflj .3.i--23i8jSTi2 Ifl3ffIi23Vfli owl n38W13C1 iiood

.ewoflulaso 8ldsflh8v lo 2(11131 111 VM-3viii2oq LIIQJ 315 d3ir1w--t33o1q 8-31512 s bits 0-31s12 £ (ii

11132(15 r1w 21 aiclT .23)15(11 ii 3310(13 isrfw l3flsm on nom 32o1 Ion billow 13bn81 )1risd s wriT bits 3n3m123vn1 lo xim 13fl3d 3(11 )loiq 03 a3vflrI3oni 13)153W 3V511 bluow Ansd £ aiil3n3d 3lBVflq

.flOIiSiJI5v3 i38o1q (10 2331110231 I15 bn3qx3 01 rii11iwnu 3d bluow

Page 30: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

Ansd s isrIi noii&iIqmi 1s313 3111 211(1 !3born 3I12-bnomsiU oi!obioq 1i b 3s12 3(11 01 bisi 1i1ids 21i 01 1s11n33 02 21 n011113fl1213v1b 32iJ3d aiworiod lo l3dmun is1 11 01 bn3I 01 ii1uo

3(11 no 131o2 gnucI ion 23ob zl8tIEupbs3rl 3isloqlo3 10 3IJLSv 81(3 ,121111no3 flu .8u1Sv 31S31) 01

3blvolq ol nu1!iw 810ffl alola8vni 3biaiuo 1m isrIl 21I13 noiisoi1iI3vib 8LS32-3lB1 lo tIO2

nevs 81o1 Iu182u s s1q bLuo3 213*113(11 1stiqs3 lsrri3ini IsrIl i3eqx3 ir1im rio 2udT .ni3flSnfl

x11!31 ol d3um ob ion ob r1i n3rlw 33r13r1 bns noi2ivib 33s111q32 w31 £ '(!f10 33(111(111 3f1i fl3fiW

.2ins112no3 iib3io llsl3vo

111313 (13v £ niss 21 813(11 oi1oThoq 3111 lo noili2oqmo3 sf11 oi bisi rIliw bnoos

.2l3woTIod bSjEISinu 01 bnsl 01 )(332 bluorl2 virfi 31dieth1 i s rl3um zs :aAnsd iol noi3ib5lq

lo 33flSflEV 120q X3 8111 soiibsi 01 'EW i2sd 3111 21 2ifIi--flOtlS3iIi2l8Vib lo sno 21 3igoI sf11 n1sgA

23ffl031U0

isrlwsmo2 3111 norii2oqmo3 oiloThoq iol 2110 153 qrni 3(11 i3*1srn LsiiqS3 Ism3ini ifs ru

(15 21 313(11 2)1f1Sd 1111w s brisil 3fl0 di nO .*uow is sis 31o1 ni2oqqo Isisrus nI .131idu2

£ iovsl 01 abn3l i113 2irIT .3vods bsdri32sb iioa 3(11 lo 133113 "1f1JLZ112fl03 111)313 3(11 3253"

2bIorl sno Ii brisrl 13(110 3111 nO .223n12ud 10 snu1 bsisI3lnu ni nu1vni 2131isJJpb53rl lo v3izui2

SlOffl 2331110231 lo inuoms nsvi s 315301111 01 81i28b i1i bxfl ifflS132n03 11b513 to 3313b 3(11

f1i rl3irIw (11 2313113112 b32IJ3O1 3200(1301 a3irusqmo3 bssl llsu1s 2821138(1102 (11(153 1ifl3i3ft18

.2231112Ud 1o 23(111 1)3111131 (11 le3vfli

31s10q103 iol 32(132 310(11 s)1sm ir1im 23i31sii2 b32u3o1 'dw bnsial3brw 01 l3blo nI

.ixsfi qu (13)1111 21 )!211i 2!fIT .isflwsmo2 Isbom 3(11 3SiIS18fl3 01 (is2E333fl 21 ii 213fl511pb53d

1ii3!1qx3 30 (1311W 113V3 sldsulsv sd n83 215)hsm IBiiqS3 Lsmsini 2blow 13(110 Ju1

lo 2lsdmun 31.S1 fli38213vO (11011 213n13upb113r1 insv5Iq sm 1i3Eqs3 b31imil isdi 23ino331 .12uo3nsu1um12 2i33o1q

Page 31: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

iiEti 3i1oqIoD s noiiofliai3viU b3iBL3lnU .v 2LJ301 .VI

DJII noi1 ni b3bi2no3 3&63 &fi no 2u3ó1 111w I 1qmi2 2i2'1snB Isrrnol 341 qA oT

lo 2iinu izul s(1 wI 213iisupbsfI 31(1w brtE j bn 1 z1oiq iHi 5I(1w 3vods

11b313 r1i sass" ris inoil sws niiosiiads sd 111w I ,niob oa nI .sldslisvs nibniñ lsioi

d isrfisdw al noilasup ninismst 1no silT .noiisoiliaisvib rliiw bsisiooaas 2133113 "iflLGliaflOO

nL)13iq-13nn1w siuq sill ni dol isnsd £ ob ass srisupbssii siSIi2 bsau3Ol B fl!2OOff3

noiansfnib

asfflo3iIJo i33rng bsisIsrlo3nu :noiisoftiatsvib lo iovsl rti insmuis 1sivhi A .A

noasst isrllons ai sisdi ,bsxfl aisflsupbssd 01 slds svs 2331U0231 Isioi sill f11q33)1 fl3V3

01 1hrli1a bsiIB1sns al Isbom sill saoqqu .sansa sAsm irlim sisii2 noiissiliaisvib s r1w

isdi nollqmuaas 3111 ninLgjnism 311(1W b3iS13TIO3 iSfIWsffloa sd ol asmo3iuo i3sj.rnq wolls

as noiJs3flialsvib lo aAitirli sno Ii nsilT .iOris tuorliiw 2sfflo3iIJO sasill 131b51q ass aistisupbssrl

isth 1sisibsrnmi awollol Ii b3lsL5rIo3 aasl asmo3iuo 1sjoiq 3rlbIsrn asili siom nii1ion niob

.noils3flivib lb ssisb sill lo nothnift niassi3ni as al i3)hsm Isflqs3 Isrrisirii as lb sulsv 3(11

sisdw "2u301 ioshsq" lb sass nilimi1 sill nhsbi2no3 d nssa 1iass iaorn 21 noiliulni silT

bits 11sw as 0 sIsia lii asw1s ai ,0 sista ni ai i Ii isill oa ,bsisIsno3 1J331I5q 315 2133[olq sill

risrit isflsd 1SVS11 21 i33oiq 3110 32us33d ,sldiaaoqmi 21 nD13iq-13fIrnW 32S3 audi nI .5213v-531V

ishsm Ismsixs sill d bsisriimob sd asw1s 111w l3)hsm Isinsini as lifl3Up52flOD .isilio sill

sill 233ub31 atiool wilT .3110 nsrli aasl 3d 01 asunljno3 1 lsismslsq noiiulib-iioIIs sill as no1 02

.18)115(11 lsliqs3 Lsirisirii (IS lb sUISV

at Ii tn.svs1s1 21 lsilw lo tiBq swlqs3 'sm bns ,sansa Ls3io1 as)1sm ln3muls aurtt sliilW

Page 32: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

1ni1 3i1211qm12 iEIIw3moa 3111 IIOii23LJp ir1im 3110 4z1iI .211o2B31 owl 101 LBi3ftI3qu2 lid £ '11313

2noilsuji2 nimi nO .21J3o1 lo noiion 3111 bits noiisI3no3 1oiq n33wi3d nwsib 2! isth

31311w i3' 31B1i2 bwool £ 11s3 1dsnosi bluow bodns lsdw aiqobs nsqmo £ 113111w 111

£ l3bieno3 31qfnsx3 ioI .2i33O1q 220135 33nsbn3q3bni lo L63b boos £ 2S51 313(11

31i1 2bnuo2 aidT .inb wn 111313111b ivs iol UZ51 ni aivrri isrli insqmoo 18311u335m1J31fq

nI .2in3rloqmo3 3IiE13fP20ibi is1 3vsrI 13)1i1 23mo3iuo 3111 i3 3iE1i2 b32IJ3o1 '13VIiS151 £

.nb13iq-13nniw 111 01 213itsupbs3r1 iol morn 3lqms 3d 11112 111w 313111 zs aiill

311102 03 23115111 isili 21 flOIIB3IIi2l3Vlb lo iovsI 111 in3mugIS auII lo 223(1)153W bnoa A

11332 3d 111w 2A .lon3 iuorliiw b8i3ibstq 3d 11B3 23mooiuo 133 jpiq isili noilqmu22s 3(11 (10 351g3b

.b32l3Vst 3d (153 11012u13fl03 3111 b3Xs131 21 noiIqmu22s 2i11i 113(1W W013d

2IOTI3 noi1su1sv3-i33p1p 1)315131103 :auo1 Ip iovsl (II 3n3mu1s 313dU2 310ffl A .H

iflim s3isfl bu3ot £ '11w idl noiiiuifIi 312sd 3111 11oi13Ubo11fII 3111 111 b3dn323b zA

lsth in31X3 3111 oT .b1svno1ir1i.sl12 21 110L153i1i213Vib b3isl3mu rtsili 321132 510111 3)Ism

111w misrl on 21o3rnq lo aln3m 3lulo2ds nsrli ithsi 3Vii5131 3111 223225 01 21 dot 213i1BUpbS311

bnA .2133o1q 3111 220135 b3lsL3TIo3 StE 210113 323111 25 gnol 02 1n3m3gbu fI 210113 moil moo

-i33o1q b3lslsrIo3 3vlovrn ol 13)li1 310111 21 315112 bu3o1 s wo13d 11513b 310m 111 31J15 I 2S

.fl01i53i1i213Vib b31s15111u lo 31S1i2 £ rtsril 210113 flOIIsulEV3

315 31311T .1if1gi12 l3bOm 3(11 3i1513n3 011)3311 I 11srnio1 noiinuini 21111 3luiqs3 oT

--3i511J335 '1J33h3q 13fl01 on 315 a1sniz '2l3ttsupbE3li (1 :b3bbs 3d i2um isrIl 231u15&t (3)1 351(11

323111 ( ;23mo31u0 i33o1q 12s331o1 01 nhiqm3iis 11311w 32115 IsrIl 210113 floli3ib3lq 315 313111 , .3.1

3111 S3i5h12 3111 b82U301 310111 3111 ( bits ;2133jo1q 220135 b31s1311o3 3d 1153 210113 noLt3lb8lq

Page 33: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

G9fflL6 O fIG GLIU uJoqGj O Cp9q2fGU 9uq 2GIJ (ro)b'.cqicnou GLLOL2--i2 9J20 9 U6C6229LA LJLGqCIJi 111 O11LIJ9U1GUi-2iAJG wOqcja U 12 9J2O JCGA

jV2 WGUU0UG 111 j0OIJOG 3 9p0AG qJ!2 20L 0 !U0LW910U 2LflC1nLG--MIfp COLLGJSIGq

JIJCGJX O 9120 2POM rib iU i2 922G22WGU O fIG OflJGL b'.o1cci EOL GX9UJbJG !u fiG q'.ri-

MO cJo2GJA LGJSIGq bLo1cc2 Mp9GAGL p19262 0'. WJ2inqWcIu2 !1 W9JC62 sponl OUG bLo1Gc 916

JJJG L9110U9IG pcpluq ?ITCJJ 911 IUIGLbLGWpOU !2 92 IOJJ0M2 JJJGU pG9qdff9l4GL2 UJOUUOL2

O ocfl2--fIC IJJOLG OCfl2G !2 fIG 2PSGA fiG LC9tGL 2 c

HG'.G 12 b9LSWGGL GMG6U 0 9U J fI I MoJq JIJCG 0 JUIGthLGI 92 9 UJGS2fILG O fIG qc'.cc

b'.op(r', \Q) = (j-d) \fUSJO0fl2jA b'.opQ-j, \ B!eThH) = (j-d)(j +) > bLop(H! \B.) = (j-d)

I!ICGIA 10 G1 9 9J26 JOM (pip) 2IUSJ 92 Md11 1pn2: b'.op(r, \ o,or'i) = (j-d)Q +) >

csbt'.c flh12 I 9Z2fIWG fJJ91 MGU bLo1Gc) G2 9 9J26I JOM (piji) 2iU9J bw1cc i 12 WOLG

V2 2riG2G 9poAG1 9 c'.ncwj IULcqicIu !2 b'.cqtcpou GLLOL2 916 cOLLG!916q jO

1 JJIG J9LGL 1? cP fIG WOLG !U0LW9f AG 12 fiG 2!U9J

922flWG bLop(H. \ C.) = bLop(j', \ B.) = cP MU T\3 < d < j 9u9JoOn2jA to'. bLO)GC

2JU9J OL C!fIGL b'.oiccr fIG 2IU9T C9U pc C!fliGL H (to'. ,1jnp41) oi. j-' (to'. 1jom11) u 12

qdn914cL2 110 J0UGL O2GLAG2 fiG bLo1cc OtIltOWG2 qLccflA pm Iu2c9q G12 9 U012A

916 MIUUGL2 9uq 20W6 flJ91 916 JO2GLV

GX9WbJG 9OAG 9W 92211WIU fJ91 GAGU MIf$J 9 0Cfl2G 2IL9GA fJJGLG 916 20W6 bLo1cc2 fJ9f

coupunc o pojq LG9LJG22 0 fIG GLG6 o 0Cn2--!u IJJG 2b!uf o IpG bp91w9ccnpc9J cowb9uA

oncowc2 COUU11G o pe iuqcbcuqcu 2o b'.op(, \ = b 9J2o jJ112 nJqGbcuqGuCG MIJJ

bLop9piJuA oi GfJGL bLokcf 0'. b'.o1cc pGiu 111 2WG 3 '.611191112 b J2o 92 pcJoLG b'.o1cc

1116 2bGCIIJC2 0 fIG 1UOLW9IJOIJ 2ILJ1CII1LG 916 9? j0JJ0M IIL2I fIG nucouqifJou9J

WOLG pipjA coLLcjsGq 916 fIG blcqicfou 611012'

Page 34: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

Js13n ni irib no i11ud ooi 3d 1qmt sm i31siJpbsd vodE b3d3iA2 32B3 ifI3fnqoI3v3b

ii 233nq 3di no f1OiiE1IJ31 31B3-thIB3rf ni anBrfo iuiiñ lo 2i33113 8th a3lsmila3l3bnu Ii susd 11i1 e1 113um ei Ii b31s13inu rIoiiBl3biano3 l3brw 2io1q 3111 1i 1asflno3 nI .isrb

2i 2I3flBlJpbB3l1 Ii aunT .ai33o1q owl 3111 22013S 3bBm 3d 11kw 1n3mbuakm m'a 3111 18111

1102831 0(1 2i 313(11 nOi13ubo1q 1311183 ff81311610 U51 ginb 01 ebnut f1ii6301I.6 (133w13d fli2OOd3

lElimia B d b3rI3lsm 3d 111w ainb iol ai30qaolq i11 no rnairnulqrn3vo i11 3v3i13d 01

.2i30q2oiq 131163 1iiiB lo 1n9mbuam

3d 01 abn lsth 1i1id6doIq 31om 3110 Ilila 21 813(11 31u13trrt2 noijEmlomni srIl n3viD

n11 23a831311i L 133o1q no 1sni (din1) wol 32L61 £ 16th b3muaaS 3VSI1 I 3IifIW .b3iIi30qa

(Hiif) wol 32181 8 (131J2 18th 3U22E ion ob I i 133olq no Lsnia (dii1) wol 32181 810 s1i1idsdo1q

.i 133o1q no 1snia (r1ir1) wol 1331103 10 abbo 3r11 2326513n1 133o1q no Ini Isnil 'IaiiooIsns bns p = (a\ U)doiq = (iJlØ \ J)doiq lsnIl 3muaas I 2i lsrIT

3283 ol lauL ak noilsoiuilqmia last aith 10 saocpuq Out' .p = ('D\ 'H)doiq = (LHE) \ 'H)dolq

.a11u251 3i28d 3111 flfl31I& luothiw Ii X515! (183 3fl0 13111J13 1snoxi1on 3(11

3d WOfl 1153 aoililidsdoiq Lsntoiiibno3 2IJO11EV 3(11 us 3381q (Ii anoilqmuzas 323111 (111W

.3110 01 mua a3IiilidEclolq (161133 IsnIl alnomoiiupoi 3(11 'd io 311n a3Ea d iorf1i nwob b3nniq

bns 2noiizIuftno3 823(11 231613fflU113 I 3tdET .2noiiIuflno3 oldiaaoq 1 lo [S1o1 8 318 313IiT

JoAism IBITI3IXO ns dliw YIosq b315i30225 3(11 ( ;nmu33o ii 10 ii1idsdo1q 3(11 (1 :21211 (1353 iol

13)hsm 18(113111! 116 illiw Tfosq b31513o225 3111 (F bns ;alaoolq 220138 abnul 3183011831 10(11163 16(11

3263 3(11 01 213131 HHDD nOi151ui1flO3 3(11 noils1on 3111 v1hs13 oT .abnul 3153011831 j 15(11

1i3i1qm12 1oI .(i1ii1) H 313W z1sfli rllod bris 23m031UO (boos) 0 3V511 a133o1q nliod 313(1W

I oldsT 111 3110 01132 ai A 1313m51sq noklulib-11o113 srIl

Page 35: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

bjscc JJJ12 12 Mph 1,OCfl2 W9UCL2 WOLC MJJCU d 12 JOMCL--92 d 9bbLo9cpc2 ouc ipc 2ru9J2

01, COfl12C 9JJ 1p12 OUJA 1119ffCL2 fO IJJC CXICIU 1JJ91 2iU9J2 fcuq fO pc W121jCCU 1U IJJG U13f

W!2SJjOCf10U 01, LC2OflLCC2

cwU qqjcuu 2ru9J2 MJJCIJ fC bLolccf2 Sic cdnsjjh sfpscjmc--92 lu eRHr-- jcq o s

C9CP LCCCJAC OUC (1 Wf 01, 1,fl1Jq1U' MJJICP J2 IJIC COLLCCf 9JJOC10U 01, LC2OI1LCC2 P1 COUfL21

fMO UJ12JC9q!u 21u9J2 2IWflJf9UCOfl2JA--92 !U pBH--qoC2 9p2OJnfCJA UO pSLur BOIP bLo)ccf2

JJJC LC9201J f9f 1p12 2p1Ij1u Si0fW 01, bLop9pIJIlA MCJJJl2 9qq2 A9J(IC 12 pCCSfI2G cwu

cdn&11A 9UL9CfJAC

pccA fO pC U OITICOWC JIyC BBH1T MCLC IpC 21U9'j2 SiC qi1,1,c1.Cuf pill 141C bLOlCCf2 Sic SClfJllA

OCCflL2 WOLC 1,LCdflCUfjh 92 CX 12 L912CCJ JuG U!) 2JqC 01, fy12 J2 191 MJI WOLC 1,0Cff2 1CLG !2 JC22

12 911 Cxs'uibjc 01, IJJ!2--BBHH J2 9 2CGU9LJO MCLC poqi 2JUS'j2 SiC wi2jc9qnJJA bO21f!AC suq JI

OIJC bLo1Ccf if 12 WOLC JJICGJh fO 9120 C W!2W1CG11 1,OL 01CL bL0lCCc JJJC coUU1.Sf!OU BBHH

OIJC p9uq fpi2 1WbJJG2 fIf MpcIJ 1CLC 12 P1P (JCLCG 01, 1,OCfI2 suq qiG 2!IJ9J 12 U112191CGU 140L

29WG 1JWC ! J0MCL2 1G bL0PffP!J!fh MC!P1 011 C0UUflL91T0U2 111Cc OOHF "1 BBHr 0U Ipe

IUCL2JU 1,OCfI2 W12C2 fpc bLop9pJJJIh MCJP1 OU COUfrL91J0U2 111CC (3OHH 911q BBHH jf

jJJC IUfflifJOU pcpiuq 1C bLobo2!lou J2 9bbSiCuf 1,L0W 911 JU2bCCIJ0IJ 01, 1C 191)JG

MJJGU pcSqdnSiicL2, 21USJ2 SiC JC22 9CCUL9fC

fC 1,OCfl2 bSIswcfcL CX JC b02111AC C1,1,CCI 01, CX 12 WOLC bLouonuccq MCU d 12 2U19JJCL--1C

W0b0211!ou: J.pc A9JnC CLC9fC ph 911 JUICWSJ C9bJrJ W9LJCGI J2 911 IucL2Iu 1,flUCIJOU 01,

QIACIJ IJJG IU1,OLW9IJOU lu 1C 19JG JI J2 21L9J11,0LMSi 10 qCUJOU2IISIC

Page 36: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

23mo33d ion floil3ib3Iq b31s15r1o3 lo 3ui 5111119 3111 bm3 3iS1u33E 11oh3q 3mod

wo1 10 sib Lsmilgo r1i :13f1iol Ii ni11uq .D

owl 315 313(11 isili 3u2 anoii2du2 owl euoiv3lq 3111 ni 2in3muglB 111 i3dlot n3AST

3111 2325313111 1hsmhq 2u3o1 (i lsth 1n31x3 111 01 bnsr1 3(10 r1i nO .*iow Is 233101 ni2oqqo

311111 13v1is181 ifiiw b3i3ib3lq 3d 1163 23mozxiuo aift (ii bits ;a3mooiuo i33o1g lo noiisI3Tlo3

3(11 nO .3ldsulsv a31 13*IEm LBiiqso 1snl3ini ns 1sm 01 bn3l 111w V31ST12 b32u3o1 5 (13111 1OTI3

2113o1 (ii bits ;2iLo1q ni iori s 913111 (i 15111 1n31x3 3111 01 1n31x3 9th ol bnsd itho

as Ism 01 brl3i 11kw isti2 b32u3oI £ ff3111 ,Elo•r13 323(11 10 (10135131103 3111 2325313(11 1hsmhq

.19113d *1ow 13)hsm lstiqso Isfn3ini

noii63fli2l9vib b3isI3lnu .v 2u3o1 no *10w 13(110 .U

s noilsofli2l3vib b3Islsrnu .2v 2il3o1 lo 23 3v115151 9th no 31u1513111 3151 £ 2i si&IT

no 113hd d31J01 111w I 13ths5I .51311 33i121J1 11 ob 01 Iqrn3ns Ion 111w I bns 23i3iS1i2 31510q103

253b1 3113 1no1l 1631J31031i1 3111 nO .iasv3Isi hs1u3ii1sq m332 isili 2noiiudhino3 1n3331 W31 B 12U1

bns moi1iM 138M bns (j1) noIti bits gi9dm3ioM ni 92oth 01 b316131 315 iqsq airli iii

*Iow3ms11 r11J3E1ino3 3l3lqmo3ni ff5 ff1132 0215 316 213S 13(110323(11 lo dioa .(Q!) 2319(1051

.231g315112 b32U301 lo iovsl iii 1nmug1s as b3au 3d ff63 isth abbom bliud oats diod bits

2*10W 2IJOflSV 3111 220135 iS(lw3mOa 13111b ol ame 'u3o1" c1 ins3m 21 Isrlw ,13V3w0H

13no1 on 111w ii Isth 31d5113111u 02 516 a1sniz 3111 wo1 QQI 23m033d p11 isili 13v3wof1 3iOi4° .m3rfi no b32sd 2noi2ib noiis3oll.s 331U0231 9Asm 01 33)hsm lstiqso lSrrI3ifli 116 101 lsmiiqo 3d

£ ni 23!lqqs 11ssi 1no noiiiaoqolq 3111 ni 01 bsrx3l9l p no 31u231 233512 3vislaqmo3 9(11 aurfT .3351q 12111 3(11 ff1 3IdBiV nb13iq-131tniw 3)lsm 01 r1ir1 \1in3i3flbJ2 21 p 818(1w no131

Page 37: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

3cJ ns ii isdi Hs31 ai inioq flthm 3111 (QI) i3noIs bits 13dm8io5I ni 1qmsx ioI

"enwonsn" lls th isiiw 01 niJiimmo H .3ni2ud b &ti1 19w31 iii d ol miii s iol i3i13d

313!qmo3fti 115 (Ii 231i1v1135 3viisvonni 3IJ211J 01 233o!qm3 au 3isviiom 13fl3d ns miii £ rloua

rfliw ob 01 2231 asil 3vods b3qol3v3b au3cñ lo floiloir 3(11 i25iin03 nI .ifI3fflfiOiiVfl3 I11i3sIiflO3

01 ii1id a13rIsupbsd a3xiasflqm3 Ii 1i1us$I .a iq itI 21 rrnil £ aa3niaud lo 231111 vnam won

.a3a2enieud lo l3dmun f13Vi flS lo al3oqaolq 3vi15131 3(11 aaaas '!3iHIU33S

in3mu1s its iom 1[s31 oals 21 (QQ1) Is 13 13M (1QI) i&iots bits gt3drn3lo$I 3A1J

iol 3IdffIia3b 3d nso ii 1Ehi3itI6q nI .aa3niaud lo ani1 iwl iii b3vlovni grri3d '(nEqmO3 S ioI

3Iom 13dio mon rlaso nithzib al linu isdI 11311w iinu gnimioh3q hooq £ ia3vib 01 r1sqmo3 S

21 3110 21111 01 qlflanoDs!31 iii i3qsq 113111 luods nui23131ni iaom 2i isrfW .anoitst&jo sldsifloiq

01 iiIids a131isupbs3rf 10 bia hsb 3111 as lo ifIti0ffi 3d ir1im isifw 3i2sf1qrrl3 3u11 isifi

2135flfiffi ioiq bs31 sm anoiisoolls5I Ii3ua iol 1611n31oq 3111 is(11 3US r1T .abruñ 3153011E51

3izEd msa 3111 no iliud zi lobom 113111 311(1w aunT .a3iiivii3B 33113uflni luI3lasw (Ii 3Sfl3 01

ii wolls isili ai(1h 1011(103 3111 asii ai3nsupbs3d isnli 53b1 3111--l3qsq 21(11 (11 3110 3111 25 32im31q

lsm3ini lo A3sdwsib £ as 31111531 ahili 1253 3di--13d1ons 01 i33oiq 3110 mon 233111025! lIinIa 01

.3sinsvbs LsiurI8uOq £ 25 11 u2s3 3vsli I 81111w 213)hsm Isflqs3

iom £ 3blvolq 01 al3bom owl 3(11 lo aic1iani 3(11 31lidmo3 bluo3 3(10 31qi3nnq nI

.U.III noi138 ru .i3Awn 1811q53 Ism3im (15 10 3032 Ismiiqo 3(11 10 noliqnoa8b 3i3Iqrno3

01 b3iohia3i 3d Ithmi1qo 1r1im 18)hsm Lsuiqso IslrI3ini ifs rfw (102531 3Iqmia 3(10 3VS I r3VOdS

31ff .l3dmufl 3lsI £ lolinom 13vi133u13 Jonfiso 2191tsIJpbs3rl :a133o1q 10 l3drrwn lisma £ Ino

zi33o1q srnm 3111 :xia miii no 1fliSt12nO3 L611310q 13(110(15 2i23ua 3io1 (QQ1) Is 13 13'3M

Iul3lasw iol Isiun3ioq 8(11 13is31 3(11 bits a101ifl03 ii 2331110231 310ffl 3111 233213V0 al3llsupbs3nl

Page 38: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

bLouonuceq MCU tpc wntibjc 2CWCU12 sc u qujccut -q!t Ic coqcql2conut oi LonpA j LCSftAG o 2!UJG-2GwGUt UUJJ2 JALOLGOAGL 1p12 qI2COflUf 12 UJOLC

EOL cxswbjc BCLGL suq ocjc (J) cwstc s ps wrtJfJ-2Gwcuf UUJJ2 sqc St

TuAoJAJu wnjtibjc (1u1f2 lu tpc 2SWC 01. 211111191. j1uG2 o pn2!uc22 qo uoi sbbcsi to qo 92 psqjA

nuLcJ91cq qrAeL2!cstiou 9LG St G21 pip1A 2fl2bCcf f 1JJG 291MG tWG IJJOLG Ocn2cq 2fL9fG1G2

OAGL9II fpc WG229G tJJ91 GwGLG2 LOW t1J12 MOLJC !2 11151 lUG A9JIIG cou2GdflGUcC2 o

qiAc2t nuLGSt€q 9? obbo2cq to cstcq flUt2 IpSI MGI.e opiucq fLOfl buoL gcdrn2itIou?

2CPGLGL (jg,) suq KSbI9u 9uq ffiGI2pSCp (j) sjj uq tpst ULW2 sG wfrcJJ WOLG i!JCCIA to

tpst IUCLCS2G2 JU OCfl2 pSAG pecu 2GGIJ 92 ooq UGM2 E11J911A bOLtGL (Jg) 1�sAcu2cLsl4t suq

psic pccu fLC5tG pA we 2IOCJ w9LKGI 92 p9q UGM2 MIJ!IG cowwcut suq 1sucjj (j) qocnwcut

pi S LGJ9fG Ac!U 0LCJ( 2pJG!GL 9uq A12PUA (iao) 2OM pSt nuejsteq Scdn!2ifJou2

PCVACGU qJAGL21Cs1iOu suq jOp!U2 d31

(jggY r'u suq nj (j) suq GLGL suq oc (j) sJj qocnweui S uG5tLAG LcJst!ou?pth

2IOCJC urnqcct UJCS2flLG2 to csbInLc !UAG2IOL2, bCLCCbt!OU2 o A9jnc MCL1JGUGJ1 suq Nou1owcLA

lccpuidne2 n2eq (ee jitGJJGL OL s enucA) GAGLSJ WOLC LGCCUf bSbGL2 JJSAG cujbjoAeq

OAGL 11we JJJG LC2flJt2 PGLC 2GGW to pe 2OWGM5t 2GIJ2IIIAG to tpc 2swbJc bcuoq suq Ipe couiioj

OC(12G coflufcth9142 OWG 0 tIM? MOLJC JOOJC2 Sf 9CCOflhJtiU-ps2cq WG92IILG2 0f bGI4oLw9lJcc

52JC2 Ju ouc MSA 01. 9'uofpeL MJJGIJJGL qiAcL2Iljcq jJLUJ2 bGLOLW pefteL 01. MOL2G tpsu tpca WOLG

ou tpc ewbiucsj LOU1 tJJGLG 12 5 J9LG poqA o M0LJC peiuuw Mifp J�'nwcJf (ro) tpt

!UUffGUCG C02f2

Js1c (bcipsb GCSfl2G tpGLc 2 9 pp qcec o OCfl2 swou tpc bLocct2) S2 to cxcecq tpc

LG2tLICI 112 2CObG fO S LGJStJAGJA 2UJSJJ 2GI bLOlGCf2 MIJGLC tile MiuUGL-b1CJcI1J PGUGUI? 9LC 20

iujjrieuce scpAJtie2 JjJfl2 Su obtiwsj psj9'ucc wsA !UAOIAc p5Aiu su iufcurnj cSbJtsT UJ91J(Gt

Page 39: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

thiq 3111 1111w in3iirlo3 1bEo1d 31S nibrtfl 323111 izi qmrk i 3iuiii2no3 1btsii 'r1i rfuothiA

.3vodE b3rioi3Aa (iOi2 L63115103f11 3f11 10

2nOIWI3nOD .V

ilBq 3111 no 1oivr13d 3q'1 nibIiud-51iqm3 b31 i3ini-113 isrfi 21 iqq eirfi lo 3m3111 3(10

1011(103 lo riS2 3111 no riibn3q3U .nirij bd '13i31qmo3 £ eswIs loll 21 213SflEffl 31S10q10310

3bEm bris b3223rnEd 3d 23m113mo2 risri 2313n3bn31 b3i3ini-11 323111 fl3vi 31B 213SflEff1 isrIi

.noiisimixsfn 3U18v l3bIod5lsfl2 lo zi33q 3mo2 illiw qu 3(111 2231 10 3101(1 01

3fl 3(11 nO .inioq 21111 lo 91qmBx3 ns 21 13*lBIn IsnqE3 lsfn3ini ns flu 31o1 '213tiEupb8H

nLs3b n3rIw 2inthil2no3 1ib313 ol abssl ivnh3vo ol noiii2oq2ib 1g13n 1311Bupbr1 bnsii

V13 3d ion sm 2i1Eupbr1 vIsib3rrrI3ini ns E (1332 wriT .i3*rsm Lsfrl3ix3 3111 1111w

bns(1 1311103(11 nO .2io1q [subivibni 01 1dlisvs nibnu1 iom ribLsm lo 2r1r131 flu 1u122333lJ2

-1132 nwo 211 lo iiu2luq 3111 ni--sm 2l3tisupbs9rI nibnu1 3Idslisvs 1o inuoms n3vi s io1

nothilo2 lSthEq £ 21J(IT .ai33rnq 220135 2331110231 nu1so11si lo dol 31d5fl02531 £ ob--i3131ni

3vi bris m3rll moil 1011(103 8)151 01 21 213EriSffl i33o1q rtib1iud-31iqin3 lo m3ldolq von8g 3111 01

.2123131rn Isirboisq 31 asH odw lud 3ldon iom on 21 orlw 1o2ifl3q1J2 nib1iud-3iiqrn3 ifs 0111

5 01 b3ilqqs 11uI3w 3d irIim bns 3flO 1ffI3n3 £ 21 3Iqi3nrTq 3125d 21(11 15(11 21(1332 II

n33d 10(1 2511 isrIi 311221 3(10 ,3lqmsx3 ioI .fli23b Lnouisxinsio flu 2nd1112311p 13(110 lo l3dmun

oT .1131st8i11 no 1530115 1snqso 18v31-iiIurn £ lo 31u131r112 Ismiiqo 3113 21 13E 21(11 111 b32isl

ii isrli 2i33o1q iuol 2511 miii £ 82oqq112 b32z31bbs 3d ii'1im 15111 2n0i123up lo 21102 8111 31511211111

31111311112 13(s1-owi 3lqmuz £ 3W 01 3d bluow 21111 iuods O 01 5W 3110 .01 2bnul 31530115 iaum

bluow orlw ("2l3iisupb53r1") lo2ivI3que 31n12 £ 3d bluow 313113 ,

.3.i--3VOdS b8ibui2 1102 3111 lo

Page 40: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

b!uo3 3no I3viisrr!flA .13gsnrn 1otq iuol cft 2ZO13 331uoE31 cnifl 3111 lo Its 31&o11.s

nwi3d a3uiuo1 miii 3111 iiIq iifl E13i1supbsr1 IEIII o fbl13u1 3f11 oi 13v31 id1ons bb

J3o1q mol Hi lo owl fl3v1 i niul lii 13snsm 3lbbirn r1i lo 113s3 "insm 3lbbim" owl

.111 a r1 as lo1q ffl nom ln3mJolls nwo ir1 3bivib nj bn ivo ol

rii iovs1 1l3n1 01 m bliiow iqq 21111 ni b3i3biano3 31o1 3111 bnBr1 3f10 3111 nO

l2orn 3rfj noizib noils3olls r11 nbIsm tiq 3111 ni23b 2iffT .nizb isI-owi 13rrnO1

213110 5101513(11 bnE 13f1130i 2133oiq 3(11 ils 'c1 b3iB13n3 21113(13(1 3isvnq 3111 01 223338 iostib

Irigim no brisiI l3tho 3111 nO .2noi2bb ln8ml23vni boos nLiLsn13ini tol Isiln3ioq i23ls31 3(11

31niz ns idi sbi 3111 r!oili3bi2no3 olni nb1si 1li3i1qx3 d 11obzii gnii23l3lni fIB 31Bt3f13

3(11 111kw i11 3Idi2uEIq 2ffl3 ii i 11T .a3iiiIidBqso noiii2iup3B noiismtolni b3iirnil 2811 1f13B

ni 118(11 2133oIq -iuol dj luods Islol iii iom rrrsI ns3 213srism 3lbbim owl Ii ni23b 131181

tol z3ugts rfidw) noilsmiolrii b 1iIsup nw13c1 noRn3l B i 513111 2ufIT .10iv13q1J2 3IgfliZ B

3uis rI3iclw) rn2iIsirI3olsq biovs ol 31123b £ bns (2233otq noil&olls IsliqBo 3(11 ill 213J$1 310m

.(2i3otq fi moil 1isiib 21i13n3d 3isvhq qsi ns oriw toirnqu in3loqinmo 31fUa £ 101

t3r11tu1 tol 3un3vs nh123131ni its 3bivotq 1r1im Ilosbiril lo itoe aifli 10 31u1sn 3111 nho1qxd

.)hOW

Page 41: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

233fl5131351

ni*iow ",2noiJxin1O ni thorfiuA Iss5I bnB thririoT' ,sIoiiT riss1 bni sqqi!irI ,noidA ..tQQI isqsq

I!3nniI 10 Ismuol ,sLJIV rrniL no i11a 2'nozis3fl!2lsviQ" As1O i13 bits qiIi#I isis8 2ô-QC ,QQI ,V ,&imonooa

imono no aisqs I1D1OO1 "d3nIrID jibsiD sdT ,nwoj .2 ztsD bits .2 nsa sAnsmsa ,IQQI iIVLtOA

lo Isirtuot " noiiiIsoD-tsibsmisjnI 1si3nsmI" ,flOzs.zcI .D biswba bits .H adot ,boa ,8QI vtosdT imono

lo Isinuot "rnuis$I 13o12 bits 2u3oI sisiopoD" .A ggsiE) jlsnst bits lisdo$I insmmoD .V8-V Q1 imono3 Isi3nSniI

3imonooEI 1o wsivs$I ",nhojinoM bsissIsU bits noilsibsrnislnl tsi3nsniT' ,zsIuoU bnomsiU 18QI ,sibu12

.18QI *ioY wsi4 a1sd2i1duq 133q ,rIiIsW siztoqioD nigsnsM ,nobioD ,no2btsnoU

bns ai3slinoD svRuI3xH :2noii3sznsiT ls*isM IstiqsD lo noiisirtsgiO silT" ,.H tisdo5l ,isnlisD .8QI isqsq nbhow TIM ",noiisrrnôlnl 3hlsmmA isbnu noilsislnI Is3iflsV

LsiiqsD 1srnslxd iJ215v Isirisini" ,nisj2 .D msist bits ni312115r132 .2 bivsU .H flsdo5l lsrthsO .OCI-11I ,.tQ! QOI ,imono 10 Isrnuot hstisuO "2l3*isM

1p Isirtuot "sjnoD bits lnsmsrrtuoT lo no2nsqmoD A" sAol2 nsM bits vnst nssiO ,8QI IQ ,vmono33 I&niilo

10 iosrtT A :qiifrisnwO 10 iflsnsH bits eleoD silT" risH isvi!O bits biolns2 nsmazoiD .1V-Iô ô8QI 4Q ,mpno Iilpg lo lsrriuot "itoilsislnI Isisl&I bits Is3iflsV

rnsleswrltio'4 "noiisrrno1nI bits asvijnsotil gnilsbua IsiiqsD" ,vivs$I iutiA bits nolliM ,einsH .QI isqsq nthow iieisviitU

Is3tlilpq lo [srrtuot ",miil sill lo siulsi4 sill bits eirli5I tisqoi" ,siooM miot bits isvi!O ,flsH .8-III OQI 8Q ,mono

loilnoD isirisini Ia siulthl sill bits iixH ,noiiulovs$I !shieubnl insboM silT" !ssil3iM ,nsenst .O8-I8 ,QI ,8 ,s3nsni lo Isrrwot "emsles2

mail sonsbiv3 :eitoiiieiup3A 1o ee333u2 silT" ,rl3sdeisW .2 IssthiM bits .V1 nsvsl2 jislqs)I .8E!-VO1 ,QQ1 sonsniI lo lsmuo "esiuiilesviU

Page 42: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

TIM "13thM IciiqfiD Lsiri3inI moil n3biv3 :inmievnI bns woR rfaD" n3wO inom&1 ..QQ1 iqsq rtbhow

miiI briE noiisflizi3viQ iirioqioD e'nidoT" xIui n3$I bris .'I.H ris.J ri&i .O8-81 1QI OI mono Jiiilo lo Isrrwo1 "oasm1o1i3q

"aioa-iRioD iod&I thrnulqO s 2in3msrrIuoT 13biO-1nEW n3ao5I nivrni briE biswb3 iE&I .4ô-I48 j8Q1 Q8 mono !i1iloq lo lErrujot

bs 3vnU viijdO IshEnEM oU" nrt2iV .W tido$I briE l9Iishf 2 13ibnA ILsbnE5I AoioM .81-1 OQQ1 naniI 10 Isrriuot "V2noiii2iup3A

iudD boow1BH iiM bna .noiJi1iiviU .rtiwoiO :noi3iopoD dT .D airrnsQ i11uM .V8Q! bnsh3siiw2

zi2oD 3Qn3uflnI aiqoi InoiIEiru1O" ti3doM nrIo1 bns moi1iM Ius ils1EM .&Q QQ1

, I jzTi2 3ri3mEnEM briE 2aimono33 lo L&nuo1 "rirfD qirf13nwO bris

bilggA lo Isrnuot "1u13Ini2 lEiiqsD IsmiiqO ioI niff3IE32 !11i2" ilEw3t2 13M .114 QQ1 ô risnR 3iEloçIoD

10 io,dT 1irin3D E thiswoT :23viirinI briE h1" sii1ii2 rkpaot briE 11ud31sM .€1-1 C8Q1 M 3imono 10 Ismuol L1 "noiii1qmoD briE noiis2n3qmoD

niwa blEvisH "isii2 3zioq1oD oi 3srnsvbA 3vifli3qrnoD moiT' .E1 I3ErI3iM 10q V8Q1

______ (ynii113 3imonO33 bns .211o-H2 .i3M I5!3d2 .M 3i13b31l bris .TL bivsU fls1n3vs5I

.V8QI jijiiinI nbooia DU j1oinirI2sW

rlsQn3mA "i3is1i2 23fI1UH woiisl4 1o aifln" 13no1s2 rinsO bns oiIul gxdmio$1 .Q4-O&1 1QQ1 48 wiv$I 3frnono33

1q ii13viflU bisvisH rIsm1oh3q 3imorIo bris 1ui3uT12 .v3isii2 ,

•q bisiioil 11mu$I .1VQI AM bhdmsD

nsori3mA "Inmta3vnI bns loivsrI3a bH" niJ2 .D rnrn1 bris .2 bivsU f1i3i11Rd32 .QV-4 OQQ1 O8 w3iv51 3imono3

8Q1 ô1 31mono3 lo Isrnuol. bris$I "noiiii3qmoD !3iiblsY lo viodT A" i31bnA 131i31ff 2

iii 2u3o1 lo 3orisrloqml fIi bris 2nidoT" i3mo1noM .A sithrnD bns l3giiH 11&h3rrI,W .1-ô1 88Q1 8V w&v51 3imono3 ns3i1mA "ansmiohq rrniI

3iI!oD noi1si1gmI lwiiiinA bits i1snA :irt31sI3iH bits iAiaM , .3 ivi1O nomsi11iW

*xoY w*1 ,

.nI 213rIildu (tBII!m3sM

Page 43: w ou - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2004. 8. 19. · 03 .i±ons vfi niob s boo do ... 3iom nibiooos ol di 33u1o2d5 th3m lo ipiq bus z1 nib1o33s ol 3113 8v115131 .th3m iO

(j-b)5(d5+c(j-d)5) 5A'

i BerT' (j-b)bcl(j-d) A'(r+) A'(j+)

rr err b(j-b)Q-d)d A'(j+)

n eerr A'

J5 BBFH (j-b)5(d(j-d)-(j-cJ)3)

IF BOITH (j-b)bd5

10 OBF'H A'(j+)

eerii b5(d(j-d)-c(j-d)3)

BBHI' (j-b)5(d(j-d)-c(j-d)3) A'

BOHF (j-b)b(j-d)3 A'(j+) A3

OBHI' b(j-b)d3 A'Q +)

eeiir b3(d(j-d)-c(j-d)3) A'

'ct. BBHH (j-b)3(j-d)3(j+) A'

BOHH (-b)bQ-c1)d A'(j+)

OJ3HH bQ-b)dQ-d) A'(j-.j)

OOHH A1

bLOPPJWA EXfGWJ LJ(G IUW LJ(GOnCOW\2!U91 bAoU:

EflUCUOU O C DGLG O EOCI12..LJJG ATIflG O I1UCUJ9I Cb!WI LJ(G

JflJG I