7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

1/13DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav =$ 6>>1 >1

Oau}

^vay`jq}dp ua oxvjhqmah pjq xj xba DDOA Fdje/ Ua bj~a xblx pjq lva i`oh`oe xb`} fdlue bad~iqd xj caa~ q~ u`xb kakfav oau} loh jxbav

`xak} ji `oxava}x hqv`oe xba hvp }~add} faxuaao `}}qa} ji xba DDOA Oau}/

@i pjq lva }mvlxmb`oe pjqv balh lx xba xavk Fdlue$ x } gq}x l xavk mj`oah xj ha}mv`fa l daeld fdje loh l fdje } gq}x l uaf}`xa xblx } xp~`i`ah

fp iva|qaox ~j}x}$ q}qlddp `o mbvjojdje`mld jvhav$ jixao x`ka} mjoxl`o`oe d`oc} xj `xak} ji `oxava}x ijqoh jo xba uaf/ Ijv arlk~da$ jo

Jmxjfav 68xb jo xba DDOA Fdje$ ua ~j}xah oijvklx`jo lfjqx xba q~mjk`oe ]OADDL ildd kaax`oe u`xb d`oc} xj xba ]OADDL uaf}`xa loh

~vjevlk vae`}xvlx`jo/

@i pjq ulox xj ar~loh pjqv fdlue mjo}qk~x`jo fapjoh xba DDOA fdje$ xbava lva djx} ji evalx djmld joa} ~j~~`oe q~ ldd xba x`ka/ Xba

ijddju`oe `} l d`}x ji }jka xblx blya mlqebx jqv apa vamaoxdp$ ijmq}ah kl`odp jo fdlue} `o xba Oau Aoedloh lval u`xb l mjq~da ji kjva

va}jqvma} ivjk iqvxbav li adh/ @i pjq coju ji lop jxbav evalx fdlue}$ ~dal}a akl`d ka jv$ faxxav pax$ ~j}x x ijv eaoavld mjo}qk~x`jo jo xba

DDOA Fdje/ Pjq mlo ~j}x fp ej`oe xj uuu/fdjeeav/mjk/ Xba q}avolka `}7 ddoaq}av3 loh xba ~l}}ujvh }7 ddoa~l}}/

Oau Aoedloh Fdlue}Dlu ]mbjjd Fdje}

D`dd`lo Ejdhklo Dlu D`fvlvp Plda Dlu ]mbjjd

Plda Dlu D`fvlvp} mqvvaox loojqomakaox ~lea mjoxl`o} `oijvklx`jo lfjqx d`fvlvp bjqv}$ vamaox lm|q`}`x`jo}$ loh }jka `oxava}x`oe

~j`oxav}$ d`ca xj xba ]lhhlk Bq}}a`o Xv`ld Fdje "`i pjq lva oxava}xah/

Oau Aoedloh Dlu D`fvlvp Vaiavaoma Fdje

Xb`} joa bl} va}alvmb x`~}$ }qmb l} bju xj mq}xjk`wa jo Ua}xdlu q}`oe xlf}$ vamjkkaohah valh`oe}$ loh d`oc} xj jxbav daeld fdje} ji`oxava}x/

^`avma Dlu @^ Oau} Fdje

@oxava}x`oe kqdx`+lqxbjv fdje hayjxah xj oau} jo `oxaddamxqld ~vj~avxp$ mjkkavma$ loh xambojdjep/

]qiijdc Dlu D`fvlvp Fdje

Xb`} fdje bl} aoxv`a} jo xba d`fvlvp bjd`hlp bjqv}$ d`fvlvp+}~jo}jvah mdl}}a}$ oau lm|q`}`x`jo}$ va}alvmb x`~}$ loh daeld oau}/

Yavkjox Dlu D`fvlvp

Yavkjox `} q}`oe l fdje+xp~a `oxavilma jo `x} bjka ~lea/ Mbamc jqx xba arxao}`ya lvmb`ya} ijv l xl}xa ji ublx xb`} }`xa bl} xj jiiav/

Xba Fdlue} ji Oau Aoedloh loh FapjohFp ]q}lo Ylqebo

Vaiavaoma D`fvlv`lo ]qiijdc Dlu D`fvlvp

mjox`oqah jo ~lea 9

http://llne.blogspot.com/mailto:svaughn@suffolk.eduhttp://www.law.yale.edu/outside/scr/library/news/index.asphttp://www.law.case.edu/saddamtrial/http://neslreference.blogspot.com/http://ipnewsblog.com/http://suffolklawlibrary.blogspot.com/http://www.vermontlaw.edu/library/index.cfmhttp://suffolklawlibrary.blogspot.com/http://www.vermontlaw.edu/library/index.cfmhttp://ipnewsblog.com/http://neslreference.blogspot.com/http://www.law.case.edu/saddamtrial/http://www.law.yale.edu/outside/scr/library/news/index.aspmailto:svaughn@suffolk.eduhttp://llne.blogspot.com/

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

2/136 DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav = $ 6>>1

Ijvulvh Kakfav}b`~ Oau} `xak} xjxba Ah`xjv jv xj xba ijddju`oe7

Mjooamx`mqxBlvxijvh*Ojvxbavo Mjooamx`mqx]q}lo ]ayavjQo`yav}`xp ji Mjooamx`mqx]mbjjd ji Dlu D`fvlvp=0 Ad`wlfaxb ]x/Blvxijvh$ MX >91+66 15>+18}}ayavjNdlu/qmjoo/ahq

Plda*Oau BlyaoK`mbadda ]qdd`yloPlda Dlu D`fvlvp916>"6>= 8=6+988=3 ilr7 "6>= 8=6+0906k`mbadda/}qdd`yloNplda/ahq

Kl`oaDpoo VlohlddDlu ) Dae`}dlx`ya Vaiavaoma D`fvlvp]xlxa Bjq}a ]xlx`joLqeq}xl$ KA >8==="6>5625+>3 ilr7"6>5625+6895Dpoo/VlohlddNdae`}dlxqva/kl`oa/ejy

Kl}}lmbq}axx}Al}xavoClv`o XbqvkloMjkkjoualdxb ji Kl}}lmbq}axx}Jii`ma ji Lxxjvoap Eaoavld D`fvlvp6>xb Idjjv$ Joa L}bfqvxjo dlmaFj}xjo$ KL >62+2 589+0522

Oau Blk~}b`vaClxbp IdaxmbavOau Blk~}b`va Dlu D`fvlvp]q~vaka Mjqvx Fq`dh`oeJoa Ojfda Hv`yaMjomjvh$ OB >==>6 59=+2=>= r68823 ilr7 "2>6 59=+58ilr "9

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

3/13DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav =$ 6>>1 =

DDOAOau}Oau}daxxav ji xba Dlu D`fvlv`lo} ji Oau Aoedloh

Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav =$ 6>>1

MJ+AH@XJV] OJXA

Pjqv Mj+Ah`xjv}

Dlpjqx Ah`xjv

C`k Hqd`o

L}}jm`lxa D`fvlv`lo ijv

Va}alvmb ]avy`ma}

Blvylvh Dlu ]mbjjd D`fvlvp

Lvaahl Bldd 169

68

}ilvlejN}jm`ldlu/mjk

Ah`xjv}+`o+Mb`ai

Gjbo ah`o`

H`vamxjv ji Kah`l ]avy`ma}

]jm`ld Dlu D`fvlvp

> Mjqvx Bjq}a

Fj}xjo$ KL >62

"9>62

"9 Bqox`oexjo Lyaoqa

Fj}xjo$ KL >6

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

4/138 DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav = $ 6>>1

^va}`haox}Ka}}lea

L} ua }axxda hjuo `oxj xba djoe u`oxav kjoxb} bava `o Oau

Aoedloh$ @ iaad ulvkah fp xbjqebx} ji DDOAijoh kakjv`a} ji

xba ~l}x$ l} uadd l} bj~aiqd mjoxak~dlx`jo} ji xba iqxqva/ Dlxadp$

`o oalvdp ayavp }axx`oe$ @ }aa ~aj~da vaidamx`oe jo xba ~l}x loh

lhl~x`oe xj xba oay`xlfda mbloea} `o jqv ~vjia}}`jo loh }jm`axp/

@o xba q~mjk`oe palv$ @ djjc ijvulvh xj dalvo`oe ivjk jqv v`mb

jvelo`wlx`jold b`}xjvp$ xb`oc`oe lfjqx bju ua mlo mlvvp jo jqv

}qf}xlox`ya xvlh`x`jo} l} ua akfvlma xba arm`xakaox "loh

qomavxl`oxp ji xba iqxqva/

@ aogjpah }aa`oe klop ji pjq lx jqv Ildd Kaax`oe lx xba Fv`}xjd

Blvfjv @oo o Fv`}xjd$ Vbjha @}dloh/ Dlu$ Olxqva loh E`ix} ivjk

xba ]al ~vjyah xj fa l d`yadp loh aoele`oe ~vjevlk$ `x}adi lo

`oxava}x`oe gjqvoap u`xb vaidamx`jo} jo xba ~l}x loh

mjoxak~dlx`jo} ji xba iqxqva/ Xbloc pjq xj Vjeav U`dd`lk}

Qo`yav}`xp ]mbjjd ji Dlu D`fvlvp ijv l ilfqdjq} ~vjevlk/ Ojx

jodp ul} xba ~vjevlk `x}adi evalx$ fqx xba ualxbav xblx hlp ul}

~aviamx,

@o lhh`x`jo xj xba o}xlddlx`jo ji oau jii`mav} o Gqdp$ xba Aramqx`ya

Fjlvh bl} qohavejoa }jka jxbav mbloea}/ @ u`}b xj xbloc

mjkk`xxaa mbl`v} ubj blya daix xba Fjlvh ijv xba`v jqx}xloh`oe

}avy`ma loh uadmjka xbj}a ubj vamaoxdp gj`oah/ Jqv Ejyavokaox

Vadlx`jo} mbl`v$ Ah Blvx "ijvkavdp ji Oau Aoedloh ]mbjjd ji Dlu

vamaoxdp vadjmlxah xj xba Qo`yav}`xp ji Idjv`hl/ Mbv`}x`oa Ba~dav

"Qo`yav}`xp ji Kl`oa ]mbjjd ji Dlu } jqv oau mbl`v/ Mbv`}x`oa

`} djjc`oe ijv va~va}aoxlx`ya} ivjk ayavp }xlxa$ }j ~dal}a mjoxlmx

bav jv kp}adi`i pjq lva `oxava}xah `o }avy`oe jo xba mjkk`xxaa/

Hqv`oe xba}a x`ka}$ `x `} ~lvx`mqdlvdp `k~jvxlox xblx ua fa lulva

ji fjxb }xlxa loh iahavld dae`}dlx`jo `k~lmx`oe xba `oijvklx`jo

~vjia}}`jo/ Xba Fjlvh ld}j f`h} lh`aq xj jqv ]avy`ma Mjkk`xxaa

mj+mbl`v} ^lx Oaumjkfa loh Flvflvl Ua}x "fjxb ji Ua}xavo

Oau Aoedloh ]mbjjd ji Dlu/ @ vamaoxdp l~~j`oxah Gaoo`iav

Ca}}dav "Ejjhu`o ^vjmxav loh Lohval Vl}kq}}ao "Ahulvh}

Loeadd ^ldkav ) Hjhea l} xba oau mj+mbl`v}/ ^dal}a mjoxlmx

xbak `i pjq lva `oxava}xah `o ~lvx`m`~lx`oe `o ]avy`ma Mjkk`xxaa

ayaox} jv blya ~vjgamx `hal}/

Hqv`oe xba vamaox Ildd Aramqx`ya Fjlvh kaax`oe$ xba Fjlvh vay`auah

ejld} loh lmx y`x`a} ijv xba q~mjk`oe kjoxb}/ Joa yavp `k~jvxlox

`xak jo xba leaohl } l madafvlx`jo ji jqv b`}xjvp, Xba palv 6>>9

u`dd fa l f`e palv ijv Oau Aoedloh lval dlu d`fvlv`lo} l} ua

madafvlxa xba 9>xb loo`yav}lvp ji DDOA$ l} uadd l} xba LLDD

Maoxaoo`ld/ Lvmb`ya}*B`}xjvp Mbl`v K`mblad Bqeba} bl} faao

ej`oe xbvjqeb jqv lvmb`yld klxav`ld} `o jvhav xj jvelo`wa xbak

loh mqdd jqx klxav`ld} ijv h`}~dlp} loh ~vjkjx`jo} l} ua vak`o`}ma

lfjqx jqv DDOA b`}xjvp/ Ua u`dd fa jo xba djjcjqx ijv klxav`ld}

xj i`dd o }jka ji jqv el~}$ }j fa valhp ijv }jka }~v`oe "jv u`oxav

mdalo`oe, @i pjq blya lop `hal} lfjqx bju ua mlo madafvlxa jqv

loo`yav}lvp$ ~dal}a mjoxlmx K`mblad/ Ua u`dd ld}j }jjo fa

qoya`d`oe jqv oau DDOA djej ha}`eoah fp l djmld evl~b`m lvx`}x

Ua xb`oc xblx `x ml~xqva} xba a}}aoma ji DDOA$ mjkf`o`oe xba

b`}xjv`mld xvlh`x`jo ji xba jvelo`wlx`jo u`xb xba kjhavo mbloea}

`k~lmx`oe dlu d`fvlv`lo}b`~/

^l}x+^va}`haox loh Mjkkqo`mlx`jo} Mjkk`xxaa Mbl`v Vl|qaJvx`w "Fj}xjo Qo`yav}`xp ]mbjjd ji Dlu D`fvlvp bl} va~jvxah

xblx jqv DDOA fdje ul} lulvhah l ^va}`haox`ld Mavx`i`mlxa ji

L~~vam`lx`jo fp LLDD/ Mjoevlxqdlx`jo} xj oau}daxxav ah`xjv}

]q}lo Ylqebo loh ]blvjo ^av}jo} ijv xba`v blvh ujvc jo xba

~vjgamx, Ua ujqdh d`ca xj aomjqvlea DDOA kakfav} xj q}a xba

fdje ijv }blv`oe loojqomakaox}$ va}alvmb x`~}$ axm/ ^dal}a mjoxlm

]blvjo jv ]q}lo ijv xba q}avolka loh ~l}}ujvh ijv ~j}x`oe xj

xba fdje/ @i pjq lva oxava}xah o famjk`oe l vaeqdlv mjoxv`fqxjv

~dal}a }aoh l ka}}lea xj q} ijv lo `oy`xlx`jo/ Ua bj~a xbl

kakfav} u`dd xlca lhyloxlea ji xba fdje xj mjkkqo`mlxa xb`oe}

`o l x`kadp il}b`jo jv xj valmb l fvjlhav lqh`aoma fapjoh }xv`mxdp

DDOA kakfav} l} xba fdje } j~ao xj xba ~qfd`m/ U`xb xba d`}x}avy

xba uaf}`xa loh xba fdje$ xbava lva klop ulp} ijv q} xj

mjkkqo`mlxa u`xb joa lojxbav loh xba ujvdh lx dlvea/

Jo l }a~lvlxa$ pax }jkaublx vadlxah ojxa ji mbloea

mjoevlxqdlx`jo} xj Vl|qad ubj bl} faao }adamxah l} LLDDoa

Mjjvh`olxjv ijv LLDD/ @ coju xblx }ba } lor`jq} xj balv pjqv

xbjqebx} lfjqx ublx pjq ujqdh d`ca xj }aa jo LLDDoax "l} uad

l} xba DDOA uaf}`xa$ }j klca }qva xblx pjq }blva pjqv xbjqebx}

u`xb bav/

@o djjc`oe xj xba iqxqva ji jqv ahqmlx`jo ~vjevlkk`oe$ DDOA

Ahqmlx`jo H`vamxjv Adl`oa L~j}xjdl vamaoxdp ~lvx`m`~lxah `o xba

LLDD Ahqmlx`jo ]qkk`x ubava mbl~xav loh ]@] va~va}aoxlx`ya}

kax xj h`}mq}} bju LLDD mjqdh ilm`d`xlxa xba mjox`oq`oe

ahqmlx`jo ji `x} kakfav} fapjoh xba Looqld Kaax`oe/ L va~jv

ivjk xba ayaox } lyl`dlfda jo LLDDoax/ Bj~aiqddp$ DDOA mlo

ld}j dalvo ivjk xba }qkk`x loh djjc ijv ulp} `o ub`mb ua mlo

mjddlfjvlxa u`xb jxbav} loh q}a xambojdjep xj aobloma xba

ahqmlx`jold j~~jvxqo`x`a} ijv jqv kakfav}/

@o Kakfav}b`~ Hayadj~kaox oau}$ lva pjq l oau DDOA kakfav

ubj ujqdh d`ca xba faoai`x ji dalvo`oe ivjk l kjva ar~av`aomah

kakfav d`fvlv`lo: Lva pjq l djoe}xloh`oe DDOA kakfav ubj

ujqdh fa `oxava}xah `o ij}xav`oe l vadlx`jo}b`~ u`xb l ~av}jo

oauav xj xba ~vjia}}`jo: DDOA `} `oxava}xah `o hayadj~`oe l

kaoxjv`oe ~vjevlk/ @i pjq lva oxava}xah o ~lvx`m`~lx`oe$ ~dal}a

mjoxlmx Kakfav}b`~ Hayadj~kaox Mjkk`xxaa Mbl`v Mlxbp Fvaao

]j joulvh xj ublx u`dd bj~aiqddp fa lo arm`x`oe palv ji djjc`oe

ijvulvh loh flmculvh ijv DDOA/ Ua djjc ijvulvh xj jqv ]~v`oe

Kaax`oe$ L~v`d 6

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

5/13DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav =$ 6>>1 1

DDOA ARAMQX@YA MJKK@XXAA

6>>1+6>>9

^va}`haox

K`mbadda ^alv}a

Y`ma+^va}`haox*^va}`haox Adamx

Hly`h Xqvcldj

^l}x ^va}`haox

Vl|qad K/ Jvx`w

]amvaxlvp

Looa M/^axav}

Xval}qvav

Clxbdaao H/ Idaxmbav

Ahqmlx`jold H`vamxjv}

Adl`oa L~j}xjdl

Vafamml Fldhu`o Aoe}fave

B` e b

Xa m bB` o x }

Fp ]q}lo Ylqebo

@ ul} dqmcp aojqeb xj lxxaoh lo ]DL xldc e`yao fp Bj~a X`ddklo$

H`vamxjv ji D`fvlv`a}$ Flf}jo Mjddaea$ jo Ojyakfav =vh

/ Xbaxj~`m ul} Evalx Elheax} `o D`fvlv`a}7 Caa~`oe q~ u`xb Mqvvaox

Xambojdjep/ Ijv ldd pjq xamb`a} "jv l}~`v`oe xamb`a}$ @ lk gq}x

ej`oe xj e`ya l |q`mc }poj~}`} ji }jka ji xba elheax} loh d`fvlvp

l~~d`mlx`jo} xblx }ba kaox`joah$ ub`mb @ ijqoh ~lvx`mqdlvdp

`oxv`eq`oe/ Ijv xbj}a ji pjq `oxava}xah `o kjva$ Bj~a}

~va}aoxlx`jo mlo fa ijqoh `o ~hi jv ^juav~j`ox ijvklx}/

Fdlmcfjlvh Flmc~lmc

Ijv xbj}a lmlhak`m o}x`xqx`jo} q}`oe Fdlmcfjlvh$ xbava } l oau

~vjhqmx mlddah Fdlmcfjlvh Flmc~lmc/ Flmc~lmc lddju} }xqhaox}

loh ~vjia}}jv} xj lmma}} fdlmcfjlvh klxav`ld} loh ujvc u`xb xba

klxav`ld} jiid`oa$ j~avlx`oe d`ca l y~o }p}xak/ Ijv kjva joFdlmcfjlvh Flmc~lmc$ }aa x} uaf}`xa/

^jmcax ]mlooav} "Valh`oe ^ao

Xb`} `} l ~ao }bl~ah hay`ma xblx mlo }mlo$ }xjva$ loh }aoh

`oijvklx`jo/ @x mlo valh ojxa} ldjqh$ mlo falk `oijvklx`jo xj

jxbav hay`ma}$ loh ld}j bl} l h`mx`jolvp/ Ujqdhox xb`} fa evalx

ijv lo A]D }xqhaox jv klpfa l d`fvlvp q}av u`xb l y`}qld

`k~l`vkaox: L }lk~da ji xb`} hay`ma mlo fa ijqoh lx x} uaf}`xa/

K^= dlpav}*^jhml}x`oe

]aak} d`ca ayavpubava pjq djjc$ ayao "a}~am`lddp o xba d`fvlvp$

ayavpjoa bl} joa$ fa `x xba jb+}j+xvaohp `^jh$ V`yav$ Wao$

]lk}qoe$ jv ]jop/ ]j bju lva d`fvlv`a} valmb`oe jqx xj q}av} ji

xb`} xambojdjep: Bj~a elya }jka evalx arlk~da}/ Kj}x ji pjq

blya ~vjflfdp balvh ji xba Hqca `^jh ~vjgamx fqx blya pjq }aao

xba dlxa}x d`}x ji mdl}}a} q}`oe xb`} xambojdjep loh h`h pjq coju

xblx Hqca D`fvlvp `} ar~loh`oe `x} h`e`xld mjddamx`jo} `o jvhav xj

}q~~jvx xb`} ~vjevlk: Mjjd$ bqb:

Blohbadh*]klvx ^bjoa L~~d`mlx`jo}

Lx ]qiijdc ua lva dqmcp aojqeb xj blya l @@@ mlxldje loh l eval

}p}xak} d`fvlv`lo$ ]lvlb Fjd`oe$ }j ua uava alvdp lhj~xav} ji l

~hl lmma}}`fda yav}`jo ji jqv mlxldje/ Bj~a elya q} ~j`oxav} xj

}ayavld jxbav mjjd l~~d`mlx`jo} fqx bava lva l mjq~da pjq k`eb

ulox xj mbamc jqx7 OPQ D`fvlv`a} HL lmma}}`fda va}jqvma ~lea

loh Daeld Mjoxaox lx Oau Pjvc Dlu ]mbjjd/

@ xb`oc pjq mlo elqea bju }qmma}}iqd l ~va}aoxlx`jo `} fp bju

klop `hal} pjq dalya u`xb/ Fp xb`} }xlohlvh Evalx Elheax} ul

l bjka vqo/ @ djya xj }aa ublx }klvx$ `oojylx`ya d`fvlv`lo} lva

hj`oe loh i`oh `x mblddaoe`oe/ @ bj~a pjq hj xjj/

http://www.hopetillman.com/presentations/bcsla2005.pdfhttp://www.hopetillman.com/presentations/bcsla2005.ppthttp://www.hopetillman.com/presentations/bcsla2005.pdfhttp://www.hopetillman.com/presentations/bcsla2005.ppthttp://www.blackboard.com/extend/backpack/http://www.wizcomtech.com/http://library.nyu.edu/mobile/#infohttp://library.nyu.edu/mobile/#infohttp://www.nyls.edu/pages/420.asphttp://www.nyls.edu/pages/420.asphttp://library.nyu.edu/mobile/#infohttp://www.wizcomtech.com/http://www.blackboard.com/extend/backpack/http://www.hopetillman.com/presentations/bcsla2005.ppthttp://www.hopetillman.com/presentations/bcsla2005.pdf

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

6/139 DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav = $ 6>>1

Dlu ]xqhaox Fdje}

Lkav`mlo Mjo}x`xqx`jo ]jm`axp ji Oau Aoedloh ]mbjjd ji Dlu

Xb`} fdje mjoxl`o}$ oau}$ `oijvklx`jo loh h`}mq}}`jo ji

`oxava}x xj xba LM] ji OA]D$ jxbav LM] kakfav}$ loh xj

lopjoa u`xb l ~vjeva}}`ya y`}`jo ji xba Mjo}x`xqx`jo$ xba dlu

loh xba mjqvx}/

Oau Aoedloh ]mbjjd ji Dlu JQXDlu}

Oau} loh `oijvklx`jo ji `oxava}x ijv xba Oau Aoedloh ]mbjjd

ji Dlu JQXDlu}$ loh jxbav kakfav} loh }q~~jvxav} ji xba

EDFX dlu }mbjjd mjkkqo`xp lx dlvea/

Mjqvx Fdje}

Kl}}lmbq}axx} Dlu Fdje

Xba Kl}}lmbq}axx} Xv`ld Mjqvx D`fvlv`a} bl} mbloeah xba

ijvklx ji xba ublx} oau ~lea xj l fdje$ xj lddju

`omjv~jvlx`jo ji kjva daeld loh d`fvlvp oau} l} uadd l} fl}`m

`oijvklx`jo lfjqx uaf}`xa q~hlxa}/ Hai`o`xadp fjjcklvc xb`}

~lea jv lhh `x xj pjqv V]] Valhav/

I`vk jv Lxxjvoap Fdje}

Xba Mjooamx`mqx Dlu Fdje

]`xa bl} evalx ~j`oxav} xj daeld bl~~ao`oe} `o Mjooamx`mqx/

Dlu D`oc} t Baldxb D`oc}

Mjooamx`oe daeld$ baldxb$ loh klvcax`oe va}jqvma} u`xb l Oau

Aoedloh ijmq}/ @ lk ojx }qva ubj `} lqxbjv`oe xb`} fdje fqx `x

bl} }jka ejjh ~j`oxav} xj `oxava}x`oe djmld daeld oau}/

Fdlue}$ Mjox`oqah ivjk ~lea >= m/2/ L oh bava o `} xba mvqr ji xba ~vjfdak/] jka ji kp mjddaleqa} fad `aya xblx xba mj~plffvay`lxjo }bjqdh fa m$ }jka mjoxaoh xblx x }bjqdhfa mj~$ loh }jka "el}~) `o}`}x xblx xba mj~p fa}~addah jqx/ ^ dal}a }axxda x joma loh ijv ld d fp xadd `oe

`x d`ca `x `}/U b`mb U b`mb } U b`mb o M lxldje`l/Halv =UM$

Uadd$ uadd$ uadd$ dax ka va}~joh o xba kkjvxld ujvh} ji U`dd`lk

]blxoav7 Pjq coju$ faijva @ lo}uav lop kjva |qa}x`jo}

xbava} }jkaxb`oe @ uloxah xj }lp/ Bly`oe vama`yah ldd pjqv

daxxav} jyav xba palv}$ loh @ya }~jcao xj klop ji pjq$ loh

}jka ji pjq blya xvlyadah/// pcoju/// bqohvah} ji k`da} xj fa

bava$ @h gq}x d`ca xj }lp/// EAX L D@IA$ u`dd pjq ~aj~da: K`}}

Ojkav mjogamxqva} xblx pjq blya ld}j mjo}qdxah u`xb xbj}a

o`x~`mc`oe evlkklv`lo} ubj l}c lfjqx ~dlmakaox ji mjkkl}

loh |qjxlx`jo klvc}/

K `}} O jkav

H alv K `}} O jkav7B A D ^ , @ lk lx kp u x} aoh/ K p l}}}xlox

mjddaleqa$ loh @ q}a xba xavk djj}adp$ u d d ojx d alya kaldjoa ijv joa k`oqxa/ B a } ldulp} lixav ka xj l}c kalfjqx ayavp }`oeda haxl d ji b`} gjf loh bju ba }bjqdhhj x/ X b`} gad dpi` }b u`d d ojx }xloh jo b`} juo xuj iaaxu`xbjqx }xa~~ oe jo k`oa/ U blx }bjqdh @ hj: @

blya xv`ah ayavpxb`oe xblx @ mlo xb`oc ji q~ xj oju/

U `xda}} o U `mb`xlD lu D `fvlvp H `vamxjv O jad E lvoav

Halv Djoa Vloeav$ i @ klp mldd pjq xblx$ lva pjq bly`oe xvjqfda

u`xb pjqv Xjoxj: Blya pjq ayav uldcah `o b`} }bja}: Blya

pjq xv`ah xvlyad`oe jqx ji xba fq`dh`oe l} kqmb l} ~j}}`fda xj

bad~ fq`dh b`} mjoi`haoma: Blya pjq xlcao ldd pjqv ylmlx`jo

x`ka: K`}} Ojkav bl} klop jxbav |qa}x`jo} }`oma pjq h`h ojx

~vjy`ha aojqeb ijhhav lfjqx pjqv `oxavlmx`jo} u`xb b`k/ Ijv

`o}xloma$ K`}} Ojkav ujohav} `i ba dj}x b`} }~`oa `o hald`oeu`xb l xbjvop `}}qa ubao pjq uava jxbavu`}a aoeleah loh ojx

lyl`dlfda ijv eq`hloma/ Ba klp fa livl`h xj eax flmc jo xba

bjv}a lixav l ~lvx`mqdlvdp qoijvxqolxa ayaox/ Ldd xblx }l`h$ ublx

pjqv }`hac`mc klp oaah } l c`mc o xba }`ha ivjk pjq/ Loh `i

ba caa~} }xa~~`oe jo pjqv xja}$ klca mavxl`o xblx ba bl}

~daoxp ji }bja ~jd`}b xj caa~ ~jd`}b`oe q~ xj pjq ubao ba xl`d}

ldjoe ijv xba v`ha/

K `}} O jkav

http://snltranscripts.jt.org/86/86hgetalife.phtmlhttp://snltranscripts.jt.org/86/86hgetalife.phtml

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

8/132 DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav = $ 6>>1

Dlu$ Olxqva ) E`ix} ivjk xba ]al ul} xba xbaka ji xba Dlu

D`fvlv`lo} ji Oau Aoedloh Ildd 6>>1 Kaax`oe bj}xah fp xba }xlii

ji xba Vjeav U`dd`lk} Qo`yav}`xp ]mbjjd ji Dlu D`fvlvp/ Xba

djmlx`jo ji xba kaax`oe ul} xba Fv`}xjd Blvfjv @oo `o Fv`}xjd$

Vbjha @}dloh/ Lixav xba kaax`oe$ d`fvlv`lo} xjqvah xba b`}xjv`m

klo}`jo D`ohao ^dlma loh xba Dlu D`fvlvp/ Xba xjqv ji D`ohao

^dlma ul} eaoavjq}dp }~jo}jvah fp U`dd`lk ]/ Ba`o ) Mj/$ @om/

Xba arb`f`xjv} omdqhah LFM+MD@J3 FOL$ @om/3 Dar`}Oar`}3 ]jm`ld

Dlu D`fvlvp3 Xbjk}jo*Ua}x3 loh U`dd`lk ]/ Ba`o ) Mj/$ @om/

Lxxaohaa} aogjpah l d`yadp$ `oijvklx`ya ~load h`}mq}}`jo ji xba

ylv`jq} `}}qa} `oyjdyah `o }`x`oe DOE "D`|q`i`ah Olxqvld El}

vama`y`oe xavk`old} o Oau Aoedloh$ kjva }~am`i`mlddp xba DOE

vama`y`oe xavk`old ~vj~j}ah fp Ualyav} Mjya Aoavep ijv Ildd

V`yav$ Kl}}lmbq}axx}/ Kakfav} ji xba ~load uava Ejvhjo ]balvav$Mbv`}xj~bav HJy`h`j$ loh ^lqd Vjfavx`/ Kv/ ]balvav `} ^va}`haox

loh MAJ ji Ba}} DOE loh MAJ ji Ualyav} Mjya Aoavep/ Kv/

HJy`h`j `} }xlii lxxjvoap ijv xba Mjo}avylx`jo Dlu Ijqohlx`jo}

Vbjha @}dloh Lhyjmlmp Maoxav loh lo lhgqomx ~vjia}}jv lx xba

dlu }mbjjd/ Kv/ Vjfavx` `} l Vbjha @}dloh L}}`}xlox Lxxjvoap

Eaoavld/ Ba `} xba ^qfd`m Qx`d`x`a} Vaeqdlxjvp Qo`x Mb`ai/ Xba

~load h`}mq}}`jo ul} kjhavlxah fp El`d U`o}jo$ H`vamxjv ji xba

Dlu D`fvlvp loh L}}jm`lxa vjia}}jv ji Dlu/

L }qkklvp ji xba ~load`}x} vaklvc} ijddju}/

Kv/ ]balvav faelo b`} ~va}aoxlx`jo fp }bju`oe l mblvx

`ddq}xvlx`oe edjfld olxqvld el} hakloh yav}q} va}avya} ijv 6>>8/Xba mblvx oh`mlxah xblx Ojvxb Lkav`ml bl} xba b`eba}x ~avmaoxlea

ji hakloh loh xba djua}x ~avmaoxlea ji va}avya} loh xbavaijva

oaah} xj `k~jvx olxqvld el}/ Ba kaox`joah xblx xbava `} l

mjo}ao}q} lkjoe ylv`jq} `ohq}xvp loh ejyavokaox aox`x`a} jo

xba oaah ijv DOE/ Bjuayav$ xbava `} oj mjo}ao}q} jo }`x`oe DOE

xavk`old}/ Lmmjvh`oe xj Kv/ ]balvav$ xbava bl} faao hakjo`wlx`jo

loh }mlvakjoeav`oe ji DOE ha}~`xa xba `ohq}xvp} }q~avf }liaxp

vamjvh hqv`oe xba ~l}x ijvxp palv}/ Ba vaklvcah xblx xbava lva oj

~aviamx }`xa} loh xblx xba DOE xavk`old} u`dd ej ubava xba klvcax

oaah} xbak/ Ba ~j`oxah jqx xblx jii}bjva }`x`oe klp ojx fa xba

}jdqx`jo hqa xj mj}x}$ aoy`vjokaox$ loh bqvv`mloa} "ojx`oe xba

hayl}xlx`oe aiiamx} ji xb`} palv} bqvv`mloa} Clxv`ol loh V`xl/

Ba h`}~dlpah l mblvx }bju`oe xba djmlx`jo ji ar`}x`oe loh

~vj~j}ah Ojvxb Lkav`mlo DOE xavk`old}$ kj}x ji ub`mb lva

djmlxah jo xba Mld`ijvo`l mjl}x$ xba Eqdi ji Kar`mj$ loh xba Lxdlox m

mjl}x/

Oarx$ Kv/ ]balvav h`}mq}}ah }jka vaeqdlx`jo} ~avxl`o`oe xj DOE

}`x`oe/ Xba Iahavld Aoavep Vaeqdlxjvp Mjkk`}}`jo } xba dalh

leaomp ijv }`x`oe jo}bjva xavk`old} ub`da xba Q/]/ Mjl}x Eqlvh*

Klv`x`ka Lhk`o`}xvlx`jo mjoxvjd} jii}bjva xavk`old} qohav xba

~vjy`}`jo} ji xba Haa~ Ulxav jvx Lmx/ Ylv`jq} iahavld loh }xlxa

leaom`a} ld}j blya }jka vjda `o DOE xavk`old }`x`oe/ ]xlxa} vaxl`o

Mjl}xld Wjoa Kloleakaox Lmx "MWKL$ Mdalo L`v Lmx "MLL

loh Mdalo Ulxav Lmx "MUL jyav}`ebx/ Kv/ ]balvav xldcah lfjq

xba DOE ~vjy`}`jo} ji xba Aoavep Lmx ji 6>>1 ub`mb omdqha xba

ijddju`oe7 xba Iahavld Aoavep Vaeqdlxjvp Mjkk`}}`jo `} xba dalh

leaomp loh mlo }ax l x`kaxlfda ijv ldd leaomp lmx`jo}3 }xlxa}

vaxl`o MWKL$ MLL$ loh MUL jyav}`ebx3 xbava `} l klohlxjvp

~va+i`d`oe ~vjma}} xblx `} `oxaevlxah u`xb xba Qo`xah ]xlxa} Mjl}

Eqlvh3 xbava } l mjkkjo vamjvh ijv leaom`a} loh l~~ald}3 MWKL

l~~ald} u`dd fa }xvalkd`oah3 ldd l~~ald} lva xj xba H/M/ M`vmq`

u`xb ar~ah`xah xvalxkaox3 loh }xlxa} blya }liaxp `o}~amx`jo v`ebx}

Kv/ ]balvav uaox jo xj }~alc lfjqx ylv`jq} }liaxp vaeqdlx`jo}

Xbava lva vaeqdlx`jo} mvalx`oe armdq}`jo wjoa} }`oma xba ~vjr`k`xp

ji DOE xavk`old} vl`}a} ~qfd`m }liaxp mjomavo}/ Xba Ha~lvxkao

ji Xvlo}~jvxlx`jo} ^`~ad`oa loh Blwlvhjq} Klxav`ld} ]liaxpLhk`o`}xvlx`jo ~vjkqdelxa} }liaxp loh }amqv`xp vaeqdlx`jo}/ Xba

Iahavld Aoavep Vaeqdlxjvp Mjkk`}}`jo ~avijvk} ~va+ loh ~j}x

mavx`i`mlxa vay`au} ji DOE xavk`old} u`xb f`aoo`ld vay`au}

mjox`oq`oe ijv xba d`ia ji xba xavk`old/ Xba Ha~lvxkaox j

Xvlo}~jvxlx`jo vaxl`o} lo `o}~amx`jo vjda/ Xba Qo`xah ]xlxa}

Mjl}x Eqlvh aoijvma} jii}bjva }b`~ }liaxp loh }amqv`xp/

I`olddp$ Kv/ ]balvav }qkklv`wah xba mv`x`mld vjda ji DOE `o xba

Oau Aoedloh klvcax/ Ijva`eo DOE }b`~kaox} }q~~dakao

hu`ohd`oe hjka}x`m }q~~d`a} xj xba kaax xba vae`jo} evju`oe

hakloh/ DOE had`yavah h`vamxdp xj xba vae`jo vahqma} xba oaah

ijv mj}xdp oau ~`~ad`oa ml~lm`xp/ DOE `} xba kj}x mj}x+aiiamx ya

ulp xj `omval}a lyl`dlfda }xjvlea `o xba vae`jo/ Oau Aoedlohbl} l dlvea oaxujvc ji DOE ~alc`oe ~dlox}$ lmmjqox`oe ijv 8>!

ji ~alc hlp }q~~dp/

]aa kjva haxl`d} lfjqx Ualyav} Mjya Aoavep ~vj~j}ah DOE

vama`y`oe xavk`old ijv Ildd V`yav/

Kv/ HJy`h`j lvx`mqdlxah xba Mjo}avylx`jo Dlu Ijqohlx`jo}

"MDI ~j}`x`jo jo }`x`oe DOE xavk`old}/ MDI `} ojx j~~j}ah xj

olxqvld el} l} lo aoavep }jqvma l} `x `} da}} blvkiqd xj xba

aoy`vjokaox xblo fqvo`oe ij}}`d iqad}/ MDI kl`oxl`o} xblx xbava

`} oaah ijv lx dal}x joa jv xuj kjva DOE vama`y`oe xavk`old} o xba

Ojvxbal}x/ Xba mqvvaox }`xqlx`jo `} xblx xbava lva }ayavl

~vj~j}ld} ijv DOE vama`y`oe xavk`old} xj fa }`xah `o Oau Aoedlohloh `o Al}xavo Mlolhl/ Xb`} }`xqlx`jo bl} va}qdxah `o h`}mjvh

lkjoe va}`haox} ji xbj}a mjkkqo`x`a} l} xbap haflxa xba faoai`x

loh h`}lhyloxlea} ji bly`oe lo DOE vama`y`oe xavk`old }`xah `o

xba`v mjkkqo xp/ Xba Mjo}avylx`jo Dlu Ijqohlx`jo lhyjmlxa

xblx xba Iahavld Aoavep Vaeqdlxjvp Mjkk`}}`jo ldjoe u`xb

iahavld$ }xlxa loh djmld ~jd`mp klcav} mjohqmx l }xvlxae`m vae`jol

ldxavolx`ya} loldp}`} l} l }jdqx`jo xj xba i`v}x+mjka$ i`v}x+}avya

fl}`} ji evlox`oe ~avk`x} xj aoavep mjk~lo`a} xj fq`dh lo DOE

vama`y`oe xavk`old/ Kv/ HJy`h`j mjkkaoxah jo xba Ualyav}

Mjya Aoavep ~vj~j}ah DOE vama`y`oe xavk`old/ Ba }l`h xbl

DDOA Ildd 6>>1 Kaax`oe7 Dlu$ Olxqva ) E`ix} ivjk xba ]alfp Olo Fldd`jx$ Valhav ]avy`ma} D`fvlv`lo

Vjeav U`dd`lk} Qo`yav}`xp ]mbjjd ji Dlu D`fvlvp

http://www.weaverscove.com/http://www.weaverscove.com/

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

9/13DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav =$ 6>>1 0

xbava }bjqdh blya faao l ~vjevlkklx`m Aoy`vjokaoxld @k~lmx

]xlxakaox "`/a/ }xvlxae`m vae`jold ldxavolx`ya loldp}`}3 xblx xbava

ul} `olha|qlxa ldxavolx`ya} loldp}`} l} va|q`vah fp xba Olx`jold

Aoy`vjokaoxld jd`mp Lmx3 xblx xbava ul} oj mjo}`havlx`jo ji xba

U`dh loh ]mao`m V`yav} Lmx loh jxbav aoy`vjokaoxld `k~lmx}3

loh xblx xbava ul} oj }bju`oe xblx xba ~vj~j}ld } `o xba ~qfd`m}

fa}x oxava}x/ ]aa kjva oijvklx`jo lfjqx xba Mjo}avylx`jo Dlu

Ijqohlx`jo} ~j}`x`jo jo xba }`x`oe ji DOE vama`y`oe xavk`old} `o

Oau Aoedloh/

Kv/ Vjfavx` ar~dl`oah xblx xba Vbjha @}dloh Ha~lvxkaox ji xba

Lxxjvoap Eaoavld j~~j}a} Cap]~lo} ~vj~j}ah DOE ar~lo}`jo

`o vjy`haoma loh xba Ualyav} Mjya Aoavep DOE }`x`oe o Ildd

V`yav/ Ba }l`h xblx xba Ha~lvxkaox ji xba Lxxjvoap Eaoavld `} l

va~va}aoxlx`ya ji xba ]xlxa} `oxava}x loh xblx DOE ar~lo}`jo `o

^vjy`haoma loh DOE }`x`oe o Ildd V`yav lva ojx o xba fa}x oxava}x

ji Vbjha @}dloh m`x`wao}/ Ba ha}mv`fah xba `k~lmx ji iahavld

~vaak~x`jo l} x vadlxa} xj xba }`x`oe ji DOE xavk`old}/ Ba }~jca

jo xba d`k`x} ji iahavld ~vaak~x`jo l} `x vadlxa} xj xba }jyava`eo

v`ebx} ji xba ]xlxa/

Oarx$ Kv/ Vjfavx` xldcah lfjqx xba xbvalx xj xba ~qfd`m }liaxp loh

xba `olf`d`xp ji aox`x`a} xj ~vayaox l had`favlxa lxxlmc jo DOE

xlocav} jv xavk`old}$ ojx`oe xblx xba Olyld Ulv Mjddaea ujqdh fa

lo lxxvlmx`ya xlveax ijv xavvjv`}x} `o xba ~j}x 0* ~avmaox

ji xba }ldyleah ejdh loh lulvhah xba vakl`o`oe xao " ~avmaox

xj xba `o}qvloma mjk~lo`a} "0>>/ Lel`o$ xba

`o}qvloma mjk~lo`a} l~~aldah xj xba Ijqvxb M`vmq`x Mjqvx j

L~~ald} ubava xba Mjqvx q~badh Gqhea Caddlk} lulvh "19 I/ =h

119$

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

10/13 DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav = $ 6>>1

`oxava}xah `o mjo}avy`oe klv`oa dloh}/ Xba ~vjhqmx va}qdx`oe

ivjk xb`} ~vjgamx `} xba va~jvx$ Xjulvh} Mjo}avylx`jo ji

]qfkaveah Dloh}7 Xba Dlu loh jd`mp ji Mjo}avylx`jo Dal}`oe/

K}/ Idaxmbav `} l mj+ah`xjv ji xba va~jvx/ Xba ~qv~j}a ji xba

va~jvx `} xj `oijvk loh xj `o}~`va `oojylx`ya xb`oc`oe lfjqx xba

vjda ji xba ~qfd`m `o mjo}avy`oe }qfkaveah dloh} `o xba Qo`xah

]xlxa}/

@x `} jodp vamaoxdp xblx Xba Olxqva Mjo}avylomp loh `x} ~lvxoav}

blya faao hayadj~`oe ~vjgamx} ijv dal}`oe jv ~qvmbl}`oe

}qfkaveah dloh} ijv ~qv~j}a} ji mjo}avylx`jo loh va}xjvlx`jo/

]ba h`}mq}}ah }ayavld daeld `}}qa} ~avxl`o`oe xj xba dal}`oe ji

}qfkaveah dloh}/ Xba}a `omdqhah xba ~vjhqmx`ya q}a va|q`vakaox$

hqvlx`jo*armdq}`y`xp ji xba dal}a$ iaa}$ loh ~vj~joaox ml~lm`xp/

Joa `}}qa `} ubaxbav mjo}avylx`jo }lx`}i`a} xba ~vjhqmx`ya q}a

va|q`vakaox/ Lojxbav `}}qa `} ubaxbav Xba Olxqva Mjo}avylomp

}bjqdh ~lp iaa} xj }xlxa ejyavokaox} ijv va}xjv`oe haevlhah

klv`oa dloh} ubao xba }xlxa} }bjqdh fa }~aoh`oe kjo`a} xj hj

}j/ Ld}j lx `}}qa `} xba ml~lm`xp ji lo aox`xp d`ca Xba Olxqva

Mjo}avylomp xj klolea l dal}a$ va}xjva jv kjo`xjv l }`xa$ loh

mdj}a jqx xba dal}a ubao l~~vj~v`lxa/

]ba }qkklv`wah }jka ji xba va~jvx} i`oh`oe}/ Xba}a i`oh`oe}

`omdqha xba ijddju`oe7 >6 loh `} mjk~dax`oe b`} mjqv}aujvc ijv xba Kl}xav

ji D`fvlvp ]m`aoma lx ]`kkjo} Mjddaea Evlhqlxa ]mbjjd ji D`fvlvp

loh @oijvklx`jo ]m`aoma/ Cpda kj}x vamaoxdp ujvcah l} xba@oxavd`fvlvp Djlo*Ilmqdxp Va}alvmb loh @oijvklx`jo Had`yavp

L}}`}xlox lx Blvylvh Dlu ]mbjjd D`fvlvp/ "Ba l}cah ka xj xad

pjq ldd xblx ba `} lua}jka/ H`h @ kaox`jo xblx ba bl} l eval

}ao}a ji bqkjv:

DDOA Kakfav qfd`mlx`jo}

Ah Flohav$ DDOA Kakfav$ ^vjia}}jv Akav`xq} lx ]qi ijdc

Qo`yav}`xp Dlu D`fvlvp$ loh Ah`xjv Akav`xq}$ F`kjoxbdp Vay`au

ji Dlu Fjjc}$ u`xb mj+lqxbjv} Ivloc ]/ Fla$ Ivlom`} V/ Hjpda

Gjad I`}bklo$ loh lqd V`mbavx bl} ~qfd`}bah ]alvmb`oe xba Dlu

=vh ah/$ Xvlo}olx`jold qfd`mlx`jo}$ 6>>1/ Xba ^qfd`}bav ~vjy`ha

xba ijddju`oe oijvklx`jo jo xb`} fjjc7

L oau q~hlxah ah`x`jo ji xba ~j~qdlv daeld

va}alvmb xjjd q}ah fp klop daeld va}alvmbav}

ivjk dlu }xqhaox} loh dlu ~vjia}}jv} xj dlu

d`fvlv`lo}$ ~lvldaeld}$ loh ~vlmx`x`joav} u`dd fa

~qfd`}bah `o }~v`oe 6>>1/ Ubao l dlu }xqhaox

`} ilmah u`xb ublx fjjc }jqvma} lva lyl`dlfda

ijv l daeld xj~`m jv ayao ublx va}alvmb xjjd} xj

q}a$ xb`} fjjc e`ya} l ejjh }xlvx/ Ijv xba dlu

~vjia}}jv ubj `} uv`x`oe loh oaah} xj coju

}jka ji xba }jqvma} `o lo qoilk`d`lv lval xj

mjo}qdx$ xb`} xarx e`ya} klop ejjh dalh}/ Fq}pdlu d`fvlv`lo} l}cah xj }q~~jvx l oau ~vlmx`ma

lval jv lo}uav l va}alvmb |qa}x`jo `o lo

qoilk`d`lv lval ji dlu u`dd eax l ylv`axp ji ejjh

x`~} bava/ Xba ~lvldaeld xblx bl} l va}alvmb

l}}`eokaox u`dd fa da}} ivq}xvlxah i xbap mjo}qdx

xba oau ah`x`jo ijv cap }jqvma}/ L ~vlmx`x`joav

ubj xlca} jo l ml}a o lo qoilk`d`lv lval ji dlu

u`dd }~aoh da}} x`ka djjc`oe ijv q}aiqd klxav`ld

`i xbap q}a ]alvmb`oe xba Dlu$ =h Ah`x`jo/

Dlu }mbjjd mjqv}a ha}mv`~x`jo} loh }mj~a

ojxa} lva `omdqhah$ xj bad~ xba va}alvmbav

haxavk`oa i xba`v ~lvx`mqdlv }qfgamx } mjyavahfp l }~am`i`m xj~`m/

Vaiavaoma} xj daeld aompmdj~ah`l}$ xba Ua}x

H`ea}x ]p}xak$ Dar`} ]alvmb Lhy`}jv$ loh

Ua}xdlu Cap]alvmb lva `omdqhah qohav almb

xj~`m `o xba xb`vh ah`x`jo/

DDOA Kakfav Oau}

http://nature.org/initiatives/marine/files/tncrwu_leasing_policy_report.pdfhttp://nature.org/initiatives/marine/files/tncrwu_leasing_policy_report.pdfhttp://nature.org/initiatives/marine/files/tncrwu_leasing_policy_report.pdfhttp://nature.org/initiatives/marine/files/tncrwu_leasing_policy_report.pdf

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

11/13DDOA Oau}$ Yjdqka 61$ Oqkfav =$ 6>>1

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

12/13>1

H@VAMXJVP JI JII@MAV] LOH MBL@V] 6>>1+6>>9

JII@MAV]

^va}`haox

K`mbadda ^alv}a

F`fd`jevl~bav ijv Loedj+Lkav`mlo

Dlu

Blvylvh Dlu ]mbjjd D`fvlvp

662

"950

ilr "962

"9= 662+2 29>+

ilr "1>2 506

al~j}xjdlNkjhd/mjk

Vafamml Fldhu`o Aoe}fave

Vaiavaoma*Xambo`mld ]avy`ma}

D`fvlv`lo

\q`oo`~`lm Qo`yav}`xp ]mbjjd ji DluD`fvlvp

1 Kjqox Mlvkad Lya/

Blkhao$ MX >91= 126+==91= 126+==665 52>+80

7/30/2019 Volume 25, Issue 3, 2005

13/13

@oxavoax ]qfmjkk`xxaa

Vl|qad K/ Jvx`w

Balh ji Vaiavaoma ]avy`ma}Fj}xjo Qo`yav}`xp ^l~~l} Dlu

D`fvlvp

591 Mjkkjoualdxb Lya/

Fj}xjo$ KL >6666

"9

Joa ^akfavxjo ]|qlva

Fj}xjo$ KL >62

"92

ilr "9>1+6>>9